Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutUrgency Ord 1357 - Temp Moratorium Issuance of STR PermitsORDINANCE NO. 1357 MEETING DATE: PREPARED BY: REQUEST: STAFF REPORT CITY OF PALM DESERT COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT September 10, 2020 Ryan Stendell, Director of Community Development Consideration for approval an interim urgency ordinance establishing a temporary moratorium on the issuance of short-term rental permits within all Planned Residential zoning districts, unless the owner can provide an affirmative response from an HOA that short-term rentals are lawful. Recommendation 1. Waive further reading and adopt Interim Urgency Ordinance No. 1357 establishing a temporary moratorium on the issuance of short-term rental (STR) Permits within all Planned Residential (PR) zoning districts, unless the owner can provide written approval from an Homeowners Association (HOA) that short term rentals are permitted within the HOA. 2. By Minute Motion, direct the existing City Council STR subcommittee (Kelly and Nestande) to review and provide a recommendation to the City Council. Executive Summary Approval of staff's recommendation will approve an interim urgency ordinance that will place a 45-day moratorium on issuing new STR permits within all PR zoning districts unless approved by the governing HOA. The moratorium allows existing permitted STR properties within the affected zoning district to continue operating, including permit renewals. Given that this is an urgency ordinance intended to take effect immediately, it requires a 4/5 vote to pass. Background Analysis At its regular meeting of August 27, 2020, Councilmember Jonathan requested that staff review a known zoning irregularity within PR zoning districts that do not have a governing HOA as it relates to STR use. Councilmember Kelly added her concurrence to that effort, however she expressed the need to bring forward an interim urgency ordinance, placing a moratorium on the issuance of STR permits within Planned Residential zoning districts unless approved by the HOA. Councilmember Jonathan concurred that both are important. September 10, 2020 - Staff Report Interim Urgency Ordinance — STR PR Zoning Districts Page 2of2 Discussion Staff, at the direction of the City Council, has been monitoring STR permits in PR zoning districts since the updated STR ordinance was approved in late 2017. The PR zone provides maximum flexibility in development, ranging from large planned communities to developments that function the same as R1 or R2 single family zoning districts. Areas such as the Hovley Lane West, Shepherd Lane, and ungated developments along Deep Canyon Road are good examples of neighborhoods that are zoned PR, but share many commonalities with the R1 or R2 zoning districts. Staff has prepared the language to include all PR zone properties subject to proof of HOA approval because we are aware of at least one PR zoned development (The Grove) that has an HOA that is not currently active. There could be additional locations where this exists, which is why staff is proposing the Interim Urgency Ordinance in this way. Memo to City Council Dated July 24, 2020: Staff prepared the most recent update to the City Council in late July of this year; it is attached to this staff report. At that time, staff noted there had been a fairly significant increase in complaints from surrounding residents. As was learned in 2016, resident input is one of the biggest indicators of a mounting STR concern. Consistent with the memo, staff's recommendation remains the same: Refer this to the STR subcommittee whose members are uniquely qualified to develop a strategy to be submitted to the entire City Council for consideration. Fiscal Analysis Staff believes that the impact on Transient Occupancy Tax revenue of this moratorium while short-term rentals are studied would be relatively insignificant. LEGAL REVIEW DEPT. REVIEW FINANCIAL REVIEW ASSISTANT CITY MANAGER Robert W. Hargreaves City Attorney R4J tz.. z. crtexdC LL Ryan Stendell Dir. of Community Development 2a", t 1'f. 14loo1 Janet Moore Director of Finance .Andy Firestine Andy Firestine Assistant City Manager City Manager, Lauri Aylaian: ATTACHMENT: Draft Interim Urgency Ordinance Map of affected areas Memo dated July 24, 2020 related to STRs in PR zones Recent correspondence from residents INTERIM URGENCY ORDINANCE NO. 1357 AN INTERIM URGENCY ORDINANCE ESTABLISHING A TEMPORARY MORATORIUM ON THE ISSUANCE OF SHORT-TERM RENTAL (STR) PERMITS WITHIN ALL PLANNED RESIDENTIAL (PR) ZONING DISTRICTS, UNLESS THE OWNER CAN PROVIDE A WRITTEN APPROVAL FROM AN HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATIONS (HOA) THAT SHORT TERM RENTALS ARE PERMITTED WITHIN THE HOA. WHEREAS, the Palm Desert Municipal Code permits short-term residential rentals within certain zoning districts, subject to the requirements of Palm Desert Municipal Code Chapter 5.10, which includes a requirement for a short-term rental permit, as well as operational requirements and standards; and WHEREAS, in recent years, notwithstanding steadily increasing short-term rentals in Planned Residential zoned districts, the City has not experienced significant public nuisance complaints associated with properties used as short-term residential rentals because the City has maintained a rigorous short -term -rental enforcement program; and WHEREAS, other Coachella Valley communities have experienced significant public nuisance complaints as the density and frequency of short-term rentals has grown, and have recently taken actions to ban or curtail short-term rentals; and WHEREAS, there is concern that the density and frequency of short-term rentals in Palm Desert will increase in response to limitations imposed elsewhere, which may result in unwanted changes in the character of residential neighborhoods within the City; and WHEREAS, based on the foregoing, the City Council finds that issuing additional short-term rental permits in Planned Residential zoning districts prior to the City's study and evaluation of the potential impacts of such short-term residential rentals would pose a current and immediate threat to the public health, safety, and welfare, and that a temporary moratorium on the issuance of such permits is thus necessary; NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, DOES ORDAIN AS FOLLOWS: SECTION 1. Imposition of Moratorium and Findings. A. In accordance with the authority granted to the City of Palm Desert under Government Code Section 65858, from and after the date of this Ordinance, no new short-term rental permit shall be approved or issued for a short-term residential rental for a period of forty-five (45) days in PR zones, unless with written approval of the homeowner association having jurisdiction over the property, except as provided below: (1) Annual renewals of existing permits shall be permitted under Section 5.10; 72500.00896\33239117.1 INTERIM URGENCY ORDINANCE NO. 1357 B. This Ordinance is an interim urgency ordinance adopted pursuant to the authority granted to the City of Palm Desert by Government Code Section 65858, and is for the immediate preservation of the public health, safety, and welfare. The facts constituting the urgency are: (1) as the density and frequency of short-term rentals have grown, neighboring Coachella Valley cities have received an increasing number of public nuisance complaints emanating from short-term residential rentals and have recently taken actions to ban or limit such rentals; (2) excessive density and frequency of short-term rentals in Planned Residential zoning districts may threaten the character of existing residential neighborhoods; (3) the density and frequency of short-term rentals within Planned Residential zoning districts has gradually grown over the last several years; recent limits placed elsewhere in the Coachella Valley may cause a significant increase in applications for short-term rental permits in the City; (4) the City needs time to study and evaluate the potential impacts of short-term rentals in Planned Residential zoning districts to determine the necessary regulatory requirements to ensure that short-term rentals do not fundamentally alter the character of existing residential neighborhoods. C. This moratorium shall not apply to existing short-term rental permits. D. The City finds and declares that this moratorium is a reasonable and necessary measure designed to protect the important public purpose of the preservation of the public health, safety, and welfare. SECTION 2. Compliance with California Environmental Quality Act. The City Council finds that this Ordinance is not subject to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to Sections 15060(c)(2) (the activity will not result in a direct or reasonably foreseeable indirect physical change in the environment) and 15060(c)(3) (the activity is not a project as defined in Section 15378) of the CEQA Guidelines, California Code of Regulations, Title 14, Chapter 3, because it has no potential for resulting in physical change to the environment, directly or indirectly; it prevents changes in the environment pending the completion of the contemplated study of impacts. SECTION 3. Severability. If any sentence, clause, or phrase of this Ordinance, or any part thereof is for any reason held to be unconstitutional, such decision shall not affect the validity of the remaining portion of this Ordinance or any part thereof. The City Council hereby declares that it would have passed each sentence, clause, or phrase thereof, irrespective of the fact that any one or more sentence, clause, or phrase be declared unconstitutional. 2 72500.00896\33239117.1 INTERIM URGENCY ORDINANCE NO. 1357 SECTION 4. Effective Date. This Ordinance shall become effective immediately upon adoption if adopted by at a least four -fifths (4/5) vote of the City Council and shall be in effect for forty-five (45) days from the date of adoption unless extended by the City Council as provided for in the Government Code. SECTION 5. Notice of Adoption. The City Clerk shall certify to the adoption of this Ordinance and cause it, or a summary of it, to be published once in a newspaper of general circulation printed and published within the City of Palm Desert. SECTION 6. Report. City staff is instructed to prepare the report required by Government Code Section 65858 (d) describing the measures taken to alleviate the condition that led to this Ordinance's adoption for presentation to the City Council no later than ten days prior to the expiration of this Ordinance. PASSED, APPROVED and ADOPTED this 10th day of September 2020, by the City Council of the City of Palm Desert, California by the following vote, to wit: AYES: NOES: ABSENT: ABSTAIN: GINA NESTANDE, MAYOR ATTEST: GRACE ROCHA, ACTING CITY CLERK CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA 3 72500.00896\33239117.1 INTERIM URGENCY ORDINANCE NO. 1357 STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF RIVERSIDE ) ss. CITY OF PALM DESERT ) CERTIFICATION FOR INTERIM URGENCY ORDINANCE NO. 1357 I, Grace L Rocha, Acting City Clerk for the City of Palm Desert, California, DO HEREBY CERTIFY that Interim Urgency Ordinance No. 1357, the reading in full thereof unanimously waived, was duly passed and adopted at a regular meeting of the City Council held on the 10th day of September 2020, and said Ordinance was passed and adopted by the following stated vote, to wit: AYES: NOES: ABSENT: ABSTAIN: and was thereafter on said day signed by the Mayor of the City of Palm Desert. ATTEST: APPROVED AS TO FORM: GRACE ROCHA, ACTING CITY CLERK ROBERT W. HARGREAVES CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA CITY ATTORNEY 4 72500.00896\33239117. 1 VIA TUSCANY DEL PELLEGRINO --.24r-ori_ray -Timmy ovir2" woman. inimmtmormnimtfam 7,� HOVLEY LN W -.ALTERRAZA DR TERRAZA VENETO _ ! 4 O'_ r 4 Q " W I.. ZQ. -1. Zcai c1- , laiL >m 4 CC r erflocriAMS. Ez "IPP CORDOBAWAY. - Hovley Lane West VIA TUSCANY WILLOW LAKE DR SIERRA'MADRE N WILLOW LA VICINITY MAP I?�I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1/ 1111111111111 ( FORD GERAL-D-FORD-DR GERA DL DR o' D' 0cc S SC-HOLAR—/ LN W —\ x\ SCHOLAR LN E 0 n� I = ti 1 A -WINDFLOWER-CT f m O J m 0 O. JULIE ) COLLEGE JERI'LN—i \ENCORE-LN L-N -DR COSMOPOLITANS LLANASTACIA LN / LN--_,& PORTOLA ACADEMY L-N"E1 11111/4 POINT-L-N� 1.J IMPERIAL—/ \- MPERIALJI COURTW _ _1 cc COURT:E KINGSTON/ COURT — w a =.—COURT w KINGSTON E�f C\ PETUNIA--/ \--PETUNIAf1 PLACE W—\ ' PLACE E ti , � ,` C C HINOOK CIR CHINO_OK CIR E T1 Q 1[1I JI I I I 10 -Al11 WOOD ARD R — w •= Q K KOKOPELLIJ CIR KOKOPELO CIRE H- CC (--Z--- 0 � 0 N Mr J 0 ,J U p Z. -I-w J a w w m vi' w O WOCOLLEGE_VIEWJ COLLEGE VIEW /V.. /. cc O n N - O CIR W CIRE O U w o -2 Z 7-- WIMPALPINE JAMESON WILLINGTON LN—' � UNIVERSITY RD RD w w - POINTE I I C I I HEATHERWOOD DR *AIISYI-Lill N pEl E-PL ( ), ) (I I I I FF {. I I I I LJ I I_ I� �!�� 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 I1rP,C<Q� Shepherd Lane VICINITY MAP CORAL BELLS_CIR DAYLILY CIR MOSS ROSE DR VIA DULCINEA LAVENDER WAY ROCIO-j CT ORQUIDIA' CT 1 SAN CRISTOVAL SAN CRISTOVAL I 1 ILCIRSil I\ WARING.CT�� FRED'WARINGDR North Deep Canyon VICINITY MAP MARIGOLD DR ASTER DR FREDIWARING DR GOLETA AVE GOLETA AVE iz] SANTA ROSA CIR H LL_I gSPL,C8r USZCI- CitJ�l�'1 uno UM �esuxawavMa VALItaiu Zz kz>c) - off° �!z z a o.0 r-Z Z N r. Z z ROYAL CANYON L DEEP-CANYO EL-CORTEZ WAY DE ANZA WAY a =SAN 0 SAN MARINO WAY f! r� I I ALESSANDRO DR PALM DESERT -DR S ALLEY EL CORT, 9 S7wIrfr ii\*,t%i 11111M111470 111111111 o. 0 ALESSANDRO DR a, _,,,, ,L,�i PALM DESERT DR N 1 HWY14, PALM DESERT DR S r -POR -H .PA --11 ..: The Grove VICINITY MAP CITY OF PALM DESERT DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT INTEROFFICE MEMORANDUM To: Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council From: Ryan Stendell, Director of Community Development Date: July 24, 2020 Subject: Update on Short-term Rentals in Non -gated Homeowners' Associations in Planned Residential Zones Background Information At its November 14, 2019, City Council meeting, staff presented an update regarding the four non -gated Planned Residential (PR) neighborhoods. Below is the information staff presented during the meeting for each of the four non -gated PR neighborhoods and associated complaint history: • Shepherd Lane: The neighborhood is mostly off Shepherd Lane, north of Frank Sinatra Drive, west of Portola Avenue, and south of Gerald Ford Drive. Total Short-term Rental (STR) Permits as of November 14, 2019: 29 2018 — Three Complaints 2019 — Five Complaints • Hovley Lane West: The neighborhood is east of Monterey Avenue and west of Portola Avenue. Total STR Permits as of November 14, 2019): 23 2018 — Zero Complaints 2019 — Zero Complaints • The Grove: The neighborhood is west of Deep Canyon Road, south of Fred Waring Drive, and north of Highway 111. Total STR Permits as of November 14, 2019: 3 2018 — Zero Complaints 2019 — 30 Complaints. The City has received letters from all 30 residents who would like to see their neighbor rezoned to R1. STR Update in Homeowners' Associations July 24, 2020 Page 2 • North Deep Canyon (Lavender Way, Columbine Drive, Coral Bells Circle. Strawflower Circle. Davlily Circle, Waterlily Circle, Amaryllis Way, and Moss Rose Drive): The neighborhood is east of Deep Canyon Road, west of Palm Desert High School, north of Fred Waring Drive, and south of the Whitewater Storm Channel. Total STR Permits as of November 14, 2019: 6 2018 — Two Complaints 2019 — Five Complaints At the conclusion of the November 2019, City Council meeting, the Council directed staff to monitor the areas mentioned above, and prepare a request for action if any reason exists to do so. Discussion Over the last two months, staff has received numerous STR complaints from residents primarily along Hovley Lane West. While this memo focuses heavily on compliance activities on Hovley Lane West, staff continues to monitor all of the ungated PR zones as directed by the City Council. Listed below is permit activity: Neighborhoods Total STR Permits (as of 11/14/2019) Total STR Permits (current) Shepherd Lane 29 34 (+5) Hovley Lane West 23 26 (+3) The Grove 3 3 (+0) North Deep Canyon 6 9 (+3) Many residents within the Hovley Lane West area are concerned that STRS are overrunning their neighborhoods. Because the majority of these neighborhoods are ungated and do not have HOAs, they are requesting that the City Council rezone their neighborhoods to R1, which does not permit STRs. City staff is responding to each complaint and has been in contact with most residents regarding the process for rezoning. Below is a matrix prepared by City staff outlining the various compliance efforts throughout the region of Hovley Lane West. 2 STR Update in Homeowners' Associations July 24, 2020 Page 3 STRs Hovley Lane Complaints West 2020 Case Number(s) Citations STR Permit Address: 40620 Glenwood Lane 3 20-0678 (active code case) 2 40640 Clover Lane 0 40613 Clover Lane 0 40641 Clover Lane 0 40780 Avenida Califia 0 40588 Meadow Lane 1 20-0435 0 40751 Meadow Lane 0 40500 Meadow Lane 4 20-430; 20-0445; 20-0563; 20-0572 0 40613 Meadow Lane 0 40765 Avenida Estrada _ 4 20-0438; 20-0553; 20- 0714; 20-0787 0 40557 Diamondback Drive 0 40640 Diamondback Drive 0 40641 Diamondback Drive 36 20-0183; 20-0259; 20- 0402, 20-0618; 20-640; 20-0677; 20-0693 (active) 2 40505 Palm Court 0 40750 Centennial Circle 3 20-0425; 20-0739; 20- 0763 0 40935 Centennial Circle 0 40755 Centennial Circle 0 40561 Terraza Drive 0 40713 Baranda Court 0 40600 Via Fonda 3 20-0762 0 40603 Via Fonda 8 20-0418; 20-0442; 20- 0555; 20-0598; 20-0646; 20-0709 0 40399 Corte Placitas 0 40893 Avenida Solana 0 40785 Avenida Rosario 0 40941 Sandpiper Court 0 40906 Sandpiper Court 0 _ Staff has prepared this interoffice memorandum for the City Council's review and consideration regarding STRs in the PR zone since the volume of complaints has significantly increased, especially in the region of Hovley Lane West. Staff was directed to monitor STR use in ungated, PR zones, and report to the City Council if there are any alarming trends. While staff is not seeing an alarming increase in permits 3 STR Update in Homeowners' Associations July 24, 2020 Page 4 issued, we are concerned about the increase in calls for operational issues. Staff recommends that any next steps should be directed as a "request for action" at a future Council meeting, which may include reconvening the existing City Council sub -committee on STRs to review and to present more specific actions for Council consideration. If you have any questions or need additional information, please contact me. Ryan Stendell, Director of Community Development Attachments: Correspondence from Property Owners Redacted Case History Reports cc: Lauri Aylaian, City Manager Robert Hargreaves, City Attorney Andy Firestine, Assistant City Manager Pedro Rodriquez, Code Compliance Supervisor Kevin Swartz, Associate Planner 4 si oIN IaelPIIN 0 aa a ro m S 0 A o z, m 9 13. 0 aSS * ry a 2 N 7c.02 � p t ;go oa r . in O1 O. rma°° ro -c o a m . 0 is: = o o � —M 3 -° n ro a c O 0. rn y 3 n ° `O Pa 3 VD -9c 99. `a ro ppmyy Z rwi O A d OS A as g . • Lain RI a ° y m d g' to a o °* e n a ; ai o a0. Z �S0 ID X d C d 3 a O mDI!'ro m O O a d n r� LArt m n o gZ 0. - m �°'n•`mrI a110 0. m 3 m w r, a 0 ° Sin ID ro o. m ID 7 3 '' < m 1 d W ro _ c n — m m rz ro m v. 7 O H • 313 0 VD 0. a, Z rscCLw VPm .. 0. 34 0 NOI 3DNVIldINOa NON sl.uoI 4 g3 I V 0 N 10 N aOL73dSN m m to crt IQ c o v O a rroo m a �i 8i hi t i 8i m4. * 3� o 3 ,� a o p m et ro .4— o 7=•c- an Pig o a N n N N r _ 3 F+ 6Vn t m O fig, *, , P v @ J r° 74 (D w a T Fr m r7 rb rri O m. +°7.asmN at gZas No 4.44 d o la =g 7 rY '0A 4.— rN° met 3� ��x a'T °FOP � Di D n C N Ttri N 0 al ID _ m 7 W 011 D Fr, m N oa is d 0 cr c a ro° N roro el ro no 7 = 3 0 w st O to= nti O °as z- w C r D G m AI a g a — ro a III va g x 0 x ill d aS m O m 2. c L FL O. S ro m D u1 3 m z SS006ZZZ9:11391A111N 13011Vd " Z m m " lox+ 20 39 P.1 I— m Z m C d r w C n. 9-19 1i 8L90-OZ 2139Wf1N 3SV3 .UOd3a AUOISIH 3SV3 m Y 0 z c Q z 0 sl�aW Iae4DIW :ON uO14e7 3 troGmrtro 2 A 3 .0 7C -0 O NnisdA Cr a Ns o a<- 13 O 7 03' A CitQ+rt 1 0 Q O N 0 O w F. VC 07 c o.,., o. oa O. RI n to o Co 3 a 3{_. ro VI 3 A on z ID ID W 2I. NI •. a.0 A W ro "•0.A 0r in n A g33CL Ve rt OQ n ,0.. @ S A A N o, = rt N N A W ' ro G IA rt A W r � n 0— =- N C a..� �a$ d 2- z, a O Q N 7 rt O A C 3 W 3 I w y^ d 41 W. O 0. 03 r3r • N = ; a, no w $ 7 -O o, Di C a A et n �ry(1� 01 11. N3 O T N ..?roan 3 N a n O v a+ m et a 3 o CI a 3et ��PC b'� 0 Q '�°c3oa 4' a O. n. 3 Q O 'n .rt.0 0 n no A7 0. .. O III f7 w ro A 3 0 o 5. 0 '0 ro °: 4• w3 w a 00. 7 O- 7 0. 7 0 F. 0 1 z0f1 a, S VI cro N it m O c NJ 0 D o ro 7 d 33 X. 3 as z` NOLLV113 NIWQV su d v a 13ID A mso o 0w C 0 pi 3 3 6 1111 o. V. o o ag 0 0 3 7 A 0. F. et DJ A o, a 0. ro a uNi O O a . 6 w 6i o. o OD 3 a 3 3 N ro n rt A 0 V 0 3. A Respond to: Lorena Ritchey HISTORY: SCHEDULED ACTION STATUS 6/22/2020 SHORTTERM RENTAL CEASE AND COMPLETED DESIST LETTER 131 23 N O g o 0 m x al 0 N N N 0 N 0 3AI1VH15INIWOV 33IOANI 03131dV OD Aay u1 3 m 23 stJJOIAI IaepIW NOLLVLD NIWOV 23 3 Z 01 72 Fm + N C N ter,, N o 0 SIJJOW lee4PIW 0 in H ro m 09ZZ6 bra `1ZI3S30 V lVd SS006ZZZ9 :a391N11N 133»Vd ADDRESS: 40620 GLENWOOD LN n -o -4 rn 23 o v c z 23 m O S m -I 0 a* -, 0 w m Z m .0-1. r o. 2m. m la > i m m 73 K 8L90-OZ U3>3Wf1N 3SV) . JIOd3a Aao.SIH 3SV 0 v 0 P E m a3131c ,�aLp I euaaoi Al a0173dSNI o E m 1 51-u01 1 Iae9'I114 C 0 0 Z m 3 O a a a O A A 0 0 1 Q 3 a E pp _ N = Q _ in 0 ^ D0. N N N 3 N in ni fa 0 G. ro A En - ell a C 7 t o ro ooN o ..�co 00 a. as ra 0•odo n G. 7 —? N j m m 53� Ai IA ,p OD 0 o o. . ya °: a v 7D �� D 0. �� � W fp N o a 'CI 0a S 3 n . 7 j G Q O 2p ry V K7 .+ fp rn la 3 r,� -a �. W II .10 n 4...• o m m N rna w I -0.,3B s �N Q N fp to Q.N !b y 7 tp 0 7 a N M v No a au m m 0 co d pai �^ o n „ U N N c x2;aO 0= 0 = mo o, a IT n3 A 2. — O S N w DO • ..4 = O Ofrt .�• a d 0 m N 3fp o72 . 0 N Q .y 7 O fiau r. S K :T S .9.r m a.f to — C h 0 N y P N ? O N K a C m ro =' a 0 0.. ,y m quoin) lae 09ZZ6 d] '183530 10111Vd N N n m n m m .-c� °XI ccm " av CO MM '• 0 0 N C 0 1 m 0 Vf N S 6 1 O tP S f'1 Sflld 201NDD 11VD :032mf32i 8L90-0Z 13361N11N 3SVD 7 1HOd311 A1101SIH 3SV SIJJOIN IOPL PM A C v aO.D3dSNI m O SWOW Iae PM Z r .. o a C n 7 Z d O 0 a3 m c ° 10�� Maj. N'aa •°i NOI1.D3dSNI an MO1IOd 3JNVIldWOD NON swDIry laeplyy x 1 2 0 2 O 1 WIN N Iae4PI01 N A 0 �Oy 0a Oi O1 Oi 0p : C w aL�! O C 5 .. too Q. G. n a ter VI y 3 µ W n rD m m ririrrad _ o a v ID o3� 3�D�•"aZ »vt N'e raav' o rt igD m N Q Q Z p N O O 0 Fr+ V on c j 0 ra 7 5 C ci D_ (0 N N G, @ N 12- '' Cl w N * N 7 7 72 W OD 0' p' 0 rroo f0 0Al, 1 0 a a 0 a: a a' N C 3 0 m A. N Trn .► � n n it 3 �� m a N 0. D M 1> w A �3� Es 0 m0 4 .. R ^ 0 0 .-. m aa3 0 Dr to I s .. m w ro 1,1 a m r, m C3 9 N_ .{ ID F. D g w c a 0 3 0 N ? n ry co c 0. 0 o N 3 0. D N IA o- n. S5OO6ZZZ9 :1139141f1N 13311Vd ° m Z a in zMmm 72mg OJ rn ,c m �� C O -D r of ra C N o CL n In 01 09ZZ6 to 11i13S30 LAMM 8L90-0Z 2i380111N 3SV0 1114d311 A IOJSIH 3SV3 SluoIN Iaega!W smog S•S :awllnlen le701 5SO06ZZZ9 :SWAIM 13DUVd 1IVJU3d 1V1N3/1 W113111J0HS ON :3041911S 3510 1VJN3HI WH1311HOH5 :3dA13SV3 O'°ZD z,mg 73m m Z Q O n r. ti. A � m � Q Z � m� c '3 a w C 0 in m O a n 3 Ill 09ZZ6 V3 '1113S30 1N1Vd N1 1300MN319 0Z9017:5531100V :31V0 SfLLVJS mm 0> „� -o m ao my M N 72 N � O n r� O w v� m O n t r_ Z m 8L90-0Z H LNfN 3SV7 fltOd38 AUO.LSIH 3Sd3 a GI m to SWay� 10e43!01 may T :arming; Ielo1 NO1133dSNI dll MOTIOJ 33NV 5w1 a3Vta31 ■ § :3ALLVaUVN a A. aRI °im fE dkk a■ �§ £7, 22to79 1 2■togi�» 0. o N ■ 0 M.-$% 2 3"§ 0. m p z, [ ■a 2 r K 1 §• ID8 " c tu0 1 = - @ƒ Nk �0E m o ■G@ oF L�§=- Ln IkIE KE&] fp I�raE , EkI; �- in ¢/0'V R. §.. o §fM.I¢§0f��,E k �J f =?i¥�■, Kr 0 , 0. 0" § m -_�.Q ; di; -'; aE -� 4§ 0 00 E2 § s!JJI RP states property Is being rented out through 1d1N311 I,01311VOHS :3d1LL 3SV 11118 0109 :3 WyN 113NM0 ■ / \ d o u9 m n" >0 d m 0 P OZo OD 4 g q k E 22 § o m in 0 to -0 z m SEtO-OZ 21321Nf1N 3S1 .111Od311 A2HOJSIH 3SVD k 1 s!JJoyy Iae'PM shay T :awl.I. NEIs lelol Property is listed as a owner occupied STR. I will keep an eye on the property to insure compliance. O3131d1A107 9.1.10yy Iae43lMN p m NOI133dSNl 1VWNI 37NVIldlN07 s!JJoyy laeyalw a :3A11VWWIVN submitted email complaint with Kevin Swartz about a possible short term rental. 33NII:Id )IHVW A31NV1S:31AIVN a3NMO 09ZZ6 VD'1113S3a W1Vd aG r in 03 co rn 700 OiNI N NJ IG mp 8-1 m m 1V1N3ZI V J H311HOHS :3dA.1.3SV n-a O 3. E vo • NI -1 O ri O W m c O a+ a z n m DE O-OZ 21381/4f1N 35113 .0 Od3a AHOISIH 3SVD n G1 a Z ▪ y U m. Nin 17 o Cr 1i1 po C Cr r 0 o T .O A pi 3v Zg in rr9 aaSQ 6v. 31 z a A m N N m Z. ao 30. 10 3 m .- * A W ' m N i'i' ' RI n . it 2• 0 in Z 3 N a o e 8 cis $ d M n 0 v 'r-43 8 2 (.2 <a+rii3 z _n a d A . m .. 3 N N Of r O g 7-7 • al m a 3 0 0 A 3. N o Ul m Please see email from Carrie McLeod email complaint dated 04/24/2020 about short term rental properties N 0 a]lna3l Ds a m C N 0 Amply euaJo1 HHO.D3dSNI e1 mopeaw pue ietuua;uao She states they own two STR rental properties, one on 3AILVIiUVN 3DNIUd *NW )31NVLS:31AtlN H3NMO Sflld H31143311% :03111133311 ZI3H1O :3dA18f1 0 0 -oNn 1f1 O To m O vNJ tO o� ozo 1tl1N31N W1131111OHS ad/J. 3510 035010 3SVD :Sf11tl15 a m 1111014 £ :aulL1.11e4S leiol 73 tra p0 m o C C .O N 22 3 1411 fa fa z NOILJ3d5NI dfl MOT103 3DNVIld WOD swovI lae11p1141 z in in m z 1 See attachedDENIAL STR COVID19 from Planning Department 32 ;e m Idt rn 30 m v O 3 m A s' tro Crm 0 ell C y nr roa a 4 B e to S N N a ro 41 A 0 s ro a 0 ro A si V O O a a ro Q1. Q k. 3 -13 m 0 o1 ea 0 071 O. 0 O 03i31dINOD o in 3 m 1 1 z 1 C N n ro � a !� = :— = Q -yam ro 7 roYl d a c c c N C 7 � O W�o rho ma 2 -- m — ^_ A 5. S a ro a w DDrroro 1 ro to j701 o �a 0 N a. a N ro a ro x O n 7 ro Q o.a °1 w 5 m 19 S. N N AI. .15 N A g? S C ro d w e a ro 3' 5ow�0.5 =0.Ll 7 .c 01 44 n Cl. - • 0 0 ti r0 m n A m 2 to c ON ro n 0 c z � ro ro a C_ p Q o ' w c 3 4 o 3 p cro tro 3 f'f r1 0 ~ 8c G m n. ^ `O 0. m Ft z ro 33NIad NIIWW A31NVIS:3WV/N 113NMO PtOO6ZZZ9:11391A111N 1331Nd Sflld 1131ND 11VJ :03t1l13A311 n • mO m 0b G m xi 4 m y O M S N v 0 X -I mma 73 73 -I D 0 w z m rn LID > oin r E 17 z n m v za m m rn m m = 73 .. > -I m or ha xi 6. CP m o N t p 20 N 0 0 a GI 7 0 O o c9„m fD N 93 om 3 -ry 3 R p� • a3 m et _ `" o N gI O O v NI n 0 m 4 m 7 d R a d > 3 d av 22:4 d O LT C a C r Z $ m O 7 4 �- , 1 d a°a 3FLt0S'a mri,IP 3 0 0 .. d 7 0 - z ea fD T N d - V .. d X- in ID a 0 � c 3 = o 4 fD 7 0 4 .'i 7 cm0'mmo mO•LI ovo O m R a m m rV S g 7 V C fD O a .n N n 0 0 0 7 C O v Eames * o. m a m eD d N d et O d 0.I 73 O. 14F. of Swav�o St 5 a3aNnOJNn Stu, m [saga swoyy laeyPlN a0!]3dSNI z z EP ID c 3 a O 7 le 1'r O Droq fD N 0 O d iD 2- • o. d 3 3 O m 7 1. n 0 rn ra u' tn d m 0 8 a w CI. m C 0 0 7 ro n m 0 d tIOO6ZZZ9113914f1N 13Z»Vd 30NIad NUM A31NV1S:3INVN a3NMO 09ZZ6 V `1a3S30 W1Vd S9NIa3H1V9 Snld i131N3011VJ :031111313H cNV S311)Nd anOI A1naNn :3dA19fS 3SV3 1V1N3a INU3118OHS =3dAU. 3SV0 cn g 23n 4 17. n = � m 11' Lri N O '" O N O E9S0-0Z 1139W f N 3SV3 111Od311 AUOJSIH 3510 GI m 1 o slaw Iae PM smog T :awliyelsIeloi trIOO6ZZZ9:H3801111N 13311Vd DNIlld )ElIdW A31NVIS :3INVN H3NMO S9NRi3H1V9 Sflld 1131ND 11VJ:03211133311 v _i4 ui Win±!, m c • m r tri o izz c z o o Z o 0 E950-OZ 2138INf1N 3SV3 1UOd]H AHOJSIH 3S1r3 s!JJoW petpm :o; puodsati s.inoq 540 :awls nen ielol On 06-21-20, I conducted an inspection of the property. No SIR violations observed. Case closed. 0 :3AlltltilNN • = N T 7 0 m.i ▪ 01 v 2 • 3 z 3 ro 3 DJ a 0 ro 0 x- m y' 3 C 7 ro tr1 cri 1 m hiI 111 NO1133dSNI1VIWINI 33NVI1dINO3 Sla.loyy laey�u HHO.D3dSNI 0 in 3 rn 09ZZ6 VD'11;i3S3a INlbd tT006ZZZ9 :u39 WfN 13321Vd N1 Moav3W oOsoti :S53aaay 035010 3SVD :sn1V.Ls ZLSO-QZ 1139Wf N 3SV 1UOd3H AaO.S1H 3513 m I g sul$PV Iaey3I1A1 unotl TO :aus1}}elS Ie3o1 Unfounded. Owners were at home and reminded them of the Orders 3DNVIldV1OD 5, :3ALLVHIHVN Operating a short term rental during COVID19 OZOOEEZZ9 :113e1MIN 133HVd n 0 0 MI M XI nen co C N m Z 0 H pzi v m C H C N N Z NI n al 0 n 0 0y sEbO-OZ i138Wf1N 3SV3 IUOd311 Aa1OISIH 3SV3 n GI 0 3 0 0 a 3 N a 0 o aN ea CI CD N Q en 0 IF1 0 m as a a m a a N 0 0 O 1 ro 8 ro z D 0 d O 0 m ro a 0 e s la NOIL' 3dSNI di MOTIOJ 33NVIldW03 1.11 a 0 CI slualry Iae43lV11 101 M m 0 C 0 0 v 0 O = vn 0 ti 3 0 ' esar ID ri re gdw W z0 7 a 0 e s� i° n n_d z? o O C a ea Nea _ w a. da � 0 N d R 7 a :1 Vs A ni ao 0 ^ 0 0 3 -gyp en 0 0 0 m ^ ro e IA 'a 0 S a r �cr K N01l33c 0. 03l3 Swi rin 2m 2z vGI 4 m C W m �= -3 S om O D as z 0 O m Z a N z m m m m 2 0 O a Q p nn D v 73 o � C 0 v v' o rn v 0 .a tcri n> a m G z — m g. ny m Cn- >0o >000 09U6 n `.La3S3fl W1dd ogi rn c v"' 0 -I 0 O ? 12 M N 0D z m EMIR 1I3801f1N 3511 1UIOd311 AtIOISIH 3SV3 I zanalapab oapad smoy z :MU Reis Iewo . Z 1 n n, y 0 Qm o N ro 'S0 Z 3 3' c 'O 1-2^ ro DO 3-. N ro 0 o..%.agd1rQe0 o fD 3 0 °.m .. . clrr • c a - Tr ~ '0 3 'Q 3 0 0.a a v s c 0 N^o ..0 OI ems* d 5 E % g• 4. g o 1.1 n 0 it 4 3 j fA 01 o d o w a m n m., c o 3 0 f 0. CI ro o X' = 0 a. c a- ct co • a a ra + 0 av m m ro 3 x 3 { S ro OJ 0• 0 O rL ro a 03pom��3 Of.< In gro x o 51 0 3"�g0 c0. 3 3 TM F.. .rK S "0 y -^ O a CI RID 0roa fp c .. 0 3 .. m �m rec. gQ 3 N 3 i ro a3 m 0 e.m YI „0roro1 ^svi fp zo.• .<c 3 ro ID cc ro ° m 0. c -� -. 7 y VD 0 [3p o1 pi .4 flq 3 0.` 0. 0 3 S r, d X 0 C 111 N 0 0 `� 20 0 3B. - m Si rn 67. c o it, - < fG N a n o. 7 3 ° a N TTC 4s m c S a . TO ro O. 11 N A aa; oot anoge a NOI173dSNI 1VWNI 37NNI1dWO7 zan2upog wpad z a a? c 3 m 11v: 031 11O.L 3dSNl a d I called RP back and provided case number and answer to some STR questions he had. 11V3 3NOHd 03131dINO7 a Ca 3:1 N ID c N m O o 0 0 m 1 8 zanbseA xaly z 1 1 just got off the phone with 24hr contact Carlos at 2:01pm. He will be addressing the noise violation now. 11V3 3NOHd 03131dW07 aaE n a IT/ m en=C� Xi Z Z w m D m 1.0 O m z a Z = m m na a 39n� m x = m " m c I N N N NJ 09ZZ6 VD '1a3S30 Wldd 0 0 m N sn a 0 tie c �, a m a C nm rri N m (. yoo nos? b1LO-OZ U3014111ly 3SVD lUOd3U A11O1S1H 351/3 a m W 1 zana1poHcupad smog s•o :aw jjjeis lelo1 zanSupog cupad 22 RP: Anonymous. RP stats the car is obstructing the sidewalk. City source 985195. Submitted a color picture :3IAIVN 113NMO 09ZZ6 VO 11113S3Q 1/1Vd O100EEZZ9 :1f39Wf1N 13D111fd rrs 171 11 v0 fp N vs o-x O m C 72 •• ri as NIN N 0 VavaiS3 VaIN3AV S9/00 :SS3 iaaV m 0 1 m o m m-d m gm m j O A 9 (F—, •• m N y a Q g 1 N m pe fae, rso tra' o C= a re n 3 0 m re ID 3 0 g$ a c a-4 a (ro " g.Zan7C ro C Tf° Pm m �'nZ " ro a^ S N d 0. n d a n a Q o .. 0 3 p a 0 CI N re ex CO Oa F!. IANm 00 d hNN wO;- O A. cm J bOi RCo ro >> fD S? a IA w 0 C re, w D. ~ N G n s 000'in co rw M 0_ "" ^. o 0 Ifi G n m • rho ►~+ c a . o -w ro c G1nn iago z K A m x- m 3 t. c 0 m a y N SO .0. m 041 0• PP O Ie a 12 in inc' .- = - 3 m cm, D12 O .'.�� ID ID m o N C 9 m ra 7. 3 ro N w s c na 0 w 7 In x 51. re m m O rt d 3 N II ea sIJo1N IaeLPIyN swoyy IaeypM op: Z o ▪ m N% o M m n m m v MI to c o fyM j ag• tan 12 S m ro a 3 A N 09ZZ6 V `1113S30 W1Vd 0 03501D 3SVD :S[1J.d1S E8iO-OZ 1J381Nf1N 3SV3 1110d3H Aa01SIH 35113 swoW P' M smog Z :awl,I WAS Ieloi NOUJ dSNI an MO110d 3ONV ld[NO3 siJoW P IPIW P. N N 0 NOI133dSNI 1VWN1 3DNVI1dINOD NON S JJOW Iae43Iyy 03111a3H3S 0 Z sgioIN iaeyPIW Z3nOSYA ONWJUV :31NVN I3NMO 09ZZ5 VD'flI3s3O wlvd Q v m N 0 rn n 0 z Q a* n 0 035010 3SVO:SniVIS ESUO-OZ a391AnN 35V0 121Od3k1 AHOlSIH 3SV slnoq ST :aus1}}e151elo1 § ij ez12 6 I. §�°Z 0'- _ I a_■■ 1 c . CL D. 222 %� ; « £ g n § , 0 . 0. --r2EJ Q4kEKI E£E, •EE-�� co72§Cv 22 ; 0 E E ƒ - CIQ.vs i a <.§ fDfp(OT§�(i7fir P. i • k n « me in la $ «■ OSo /0§ E-/ 4 0 • • - _20 m o ] ph ro = ■ ETg v ro & § 2 g § £s0 r �72 ro �/J � - �K:4' 2 7 NOIi73d5N 33NVI 511. § Z31113SVA ONVWatl :31/1IVN 113NMO 09ZZ6 V3'1113S30WlVd S90O6ZZZ9 :a391A 1N 133UVd 3Danos AiI7 : 3111133311 0 0 vs . /\ � a � » 2 m to 2 0 03s010 3SVD :91111V15 65Z0-OZ 2U38INfN MD 12IOd311 AMIOlSIH 3SVJ k sJnoy i :aw1ge351e3n1 ■ NOLL73d5N1 dfl M Efrt k in § suPlPV laeRDMW 3 § z f § S ij NO1173d5NI 1VWNI 37NVI1dINOD NON 5, _ k C K0UZI u ni %EA &°� /12 �2 0 - vs -0 •&d § 72 7 I mm m ZWD cdgi mmQ q m MT cn m z 5 2 k k ZOVO-OZ 213OIPdf1N 3SV3 .UOd311 AUOISIH 3913 0 z a+ u' m co •• O Q rn i N ro A g o m f o rho a rro - m gi d m 6 ' OF m 9 d d m m Fir N c n c= e —ay a Fir,xi Z en c 3 ..,-2 i'.a 2 !4 ro ntu � N is or O - Rri, •; N a it ti t.r N 03 - m N to a li t N r5 0 K n N N O d m 7 ru c, - Z 7 1 m p a s. m or ra or •[ n 0 f0 C= n O .3 I6D d a g S n e g a c as .. _.0 a 0.c.5 c •oz -- --- n Q'aa s Er z n0 �: m S a N a a O. 0. 3 C C a N 9 ro Lei 13 dl9 d C C .,r 7 a .� o o ro ^a9' 3 �o� PS MI N °' a an3 E. C n. I G w a ta '" 00„i:IQ wA aaOw0 N r]F 6 m s.. ro P ro w r r]p ro ~+ m o� c '�o Nr'yr m� W 3 V F. o m I..dm ro °N' a ma g ro o a �� E Kro o ro 'Sn �- OP owo . tti a'i W n. 1 co n m i° 3 m 3 r 3 W" 3 m.. I. ` r3r N ry K N N m e ..... v ro 3 3 ro d a 0ro m 7 C 3 S ro CIO g m to Na = pNg � m N D O N Ch 4 N 10 i w 0 m x w .A en ro ro a orsa o 3 u Ln O O N W 0 7 ro ZtZOS6=Planss!od m m T N 0 en NJ 0 C O A O swoN Iae PM 110J]3dSNI :3ALLVid8VN On 06-05-20, I received multiple complaints reference loud pool party. S9006ZZZ9 41391Af1N 133UVd S9Nli13 H1V9 cNV S311i8Vd anal A1flHNf=3d4LL9fl53SV3 1V.N3H1 VJ H 11UGHS :3dA13SVD z 411 a N Z m m m33 m 22 rn y' LIS m Cn C � O m o N N 0 09ZZ6 V] '1U13S30 W1Vd 133SO1D 3SVD :Sf11V.IS 8Z90-0Z 2U391Nf1N 3SV3 11IOd3a AHOISIH 3SVJ P ISO �" O r C rroo v 0 S' ooi ro m m O 0 �+ a m v oQi nQi m A m m i c In C = c_ .. a D •+ Q 1' = c N... a .. 2 d 40 al n 7 N C ID f7 c n N n Oo C C (O ''* fp C j 0 0 C s 10 m in x n 'a n H 0 '0 oRT - m•• m x n v -, ea w St °i o C= n rxo n 3 '^ a -i A .... C n' 2 f5 3 'C" w m --I ro A m a a a aiopc'o�ca°Z�C'�aIcovlu,�co °�aa�alur n�a� 0 3 a '" a IA c a o�' c` c` n K o o gv ;a a s a? c` c` +� m m m o v o '° K. u' 0 m• 0_ a a 0 N °=co �F pc a 7 Q o L. v 11 uu � m.N0,9 v nN G"N IA QM ® in 41 N 7 C10reADvN01GIjCI0 W aP4 IA Di in � a and vpac000 sd eD 0 a N m = o, xo o a3 coJ—m Q u'0-•J, 0_ in .0 y a 1a w w 17 Of co o ro _ no vx 3 0. o 01 V at 5 c A. O -0 =@ 3 al ID 3 w a vto n A m .-0.d. 'CI W .fir C C. I.0 n A 'K N 3 LP c m aA 01 m; 3 o ID IAD t0 Q. N 3 w a ci ID ID C ID PA in d WI I^P N f'1 3 N .' IC Q" h, 2 c 02 ff. DI L vi O, a tO S. C. n O is N S ID IO O 7 Q. d ilT O•d N a J E. • @ % ID '001 '+ j , x, Ip DO N ro m 3 0. a 'a II II 0 N ni 0 ro 12 -a A m —I s G �1 33 ID nN 3 Nw a d • d m n 4 co 0 to m m o 7 V O O co — _ = a i:, a,, A o 0a 93W m 0 a N 3 oa m n ra ra m al J V r n 0 In IID Ia ioo n C m •'° z C N C N w -c gC UI D a Z v C 23 m E. a Z mITS n m ^� 72 73 EaFg N I m C co mt rn O N N w 0 O v m m m K Z Q a>' m to n ON1 Q N Q 70 O 1VIN3H1 Wa3.L.LaOHS :3d1LL 3SV 03SO10 3SVD :SflldjS 8190-0Z U3911011N 35V3 12IOd311 AZIOISIH 3SV 0 72 SCHEDULED ACTION 6/6/2020 EMAIL s!Loyy Paeya!yy O m a sluoW iaey?M a0 a 3 c 'am oa4 0a 0 „ °o' z z � r � Is •00 d m 0 m 0. C a '°a ora m m 0 0 f0 'G r- _ o 3 St 111 n 0 3 N N O o 0 0 o an ra 61 aso a or N NOLLD3d5 03J.3 spJJ1 4 in m swop,/ fag'PM 12 r1 72 72 N a 'rp 0 A 3 3 1' a al d 0i e m ro d000 r�]1am��ov =°?—g i C. G it .4or n Zj 3 w 09 a n N R. .��i A G d N or o o c f° Ln m N O1 . a a '° Po m a s rn A 0 C G� N f07 r�i E In 0 ems► pID 7cc -07 0 n'0 0 7 d1 m01 zu 3 b R d 3 n S 11 m 0 N a G a co el '► = f1 Gwo to 3 °' p n m P, ro 3 m d N an ea '° co i a 0 y 3 7 3. Elr 0 x 1 m 0 VI 61 � S9006ZZZ9 :2139Wl1N 133iIVd :3WVN H3NMO 09ZZ6 VD '1213S3a W1Vd m C GI LA m c z O c 1a z 3721f10S AID :a321213A3u n Q N 0 0 0 z 0 07 n 0 1ViN311 W 21311MOHS :3dA13SV3 m m F Ova x m C ND NJ H N 0 n tn tC rn 0 0 a3SO1D 3SVD=Sl1V.S n -12 32, v o in T.1 0 n O D N m o O • r a z n m 8190-0Z 21391Nf1N 3SV7 .Zaod]a AIOISIH 3SVO t 5liIN N IaetPM smog z :aqua JJe751e3o1 .► G O G A 3 d Q °+ Ga a 3:- 3�cR o • o3q '� a c o ::a.;g•c d o m d a$ao?. 2� 54*? Qm n =faaw e o » 0 it w o ?aQ n~i D r. m I ca w iDe RPr —V o DI A "c„.I 3c c' O d `{ Ip o- a 0 m c O d n d O. 17. Io �. arc �- n r 4 o j a,c m O ro rt c51 a'0.c n� E co tr,c N ID s m f+ 4 4 a a m a a3 n m 7° 2 a co 3 m m o c oo 3 . 0 x rt I s d— m.• m o. xc 0- " •1 N O — coz co m a Id—q Q'7 O it 0m < ro O �n m to 3 m p .. 3 • D `dC qi D- O m n IA =• m Q c cc r. r.3 3 o a ". j .D n y 7 a m d -'• 0.-1 3 9 01 6 A 3 S 03. D • 00 3 - D a v a ^ $ m « a 3 _ 01 0 0 NOIL33dSNI di M01103 a3aNflOdNf1 SNJOW Iae4pIW 4 0 aa a3V1amns 0 z 1 c swop,' Iae43IW = mcD° N O ea fop N A 9 q0i d fAC n 7 m o c 0 w m a ro c r. 2 c m 'R .[ S gl •• ro •• n a Q v n H m c N 3 m C 3 ° m o. a s n,s 0 G m rT 3 N fl m a> z .. .. •• H d.mr Cr' +SD •O m_da7 an c c n.. a a H a qy R. 3= o. v O d 3 tp f4 01 31 al It y'a fb n m p 2 K. :° N N m ID ro d 0 �n O W o a' o o.w A f° Wp o00 d O .an on V ,4.--- IA R fp ij feD UP N 0 0 N N O F 3 N N a 1-+ fr m m_F r r "3 m o :+'3 .At41^m. w ro "'" G I O a a N m 7 ID S 3 N a., s n ix in 1 rx< m 3 IAe d a 10 Am m �o gd v 0 Ca in IA aD , IA 3 to m en c O m 0 anN N _ ID LT m T c 3 in m ID `CCL CD i". m to D m d hiro 3 — d (A 5 N asC a O_ O d In o G m to O in ro G c n N F 3 D �a m d tu w 7 CD o S9006ZZZ9 :1138WIIN 133HVd :3WVN N3NMO 09ZZ6 V] `1H3S30 WTdd SJN1U3H1VD 33>:IfIOS A110 :Q3k1U3d3t1 aNV 5311111fd af101 AlilUNfl :3dA18f15 3SV3 1V.N]H WH311HOHS :3dA13SV3 Q3S013 3SVD :SfijVJS A •v oa 0 o 73 NJ n N m 0 O 1 z m 8Z90-OZ 7338Wf1N 3SV3 .UJOd311 AUOlSIH 3SVJ GI sNJ°VJ Iae43 IN sang i :awajlelS 1e701 am o f c rvo `�"}2> m gm m m 1 C 7 C .�-' . b �'+ a» d 2 13 0A�d�dd -eDc�nrmO.0R R- Q. O @C. -O . .- d d El ri 0. 01 ' CO , su a a 0 7 °' � , 3 0 m" r r ro ro m n a o N p Y Y m LO O. O-ro 19 N my to NJ 00a ai m° coa .i O0i a 0 e� m O N w CO �� 0 w 0„� H w o r.i C co N w W LnLnR cl rn 1r, d -0 'D c w, 7r a m� 33ro :tiro m in a < ID ID m A n� ro R N A -0 y 0 an c 3 ea c v N v. tO N C f� ro D 0. N xm Di N �.a M ii) @ x O `V 0 O c c ro a- n 3 Z r m Q w 3 0 0 25 N s!JJOW Iae4PIW NOI1.13dSNI 1VWNI 33Ntll1dINO3 sluoW laegagn O Ln On 06-11-20, I received CitySourced Service Request ID# 955413, in reference to a vehicle parked blocking a sidewalk. O9ZZ6 VD `11:139a wldd 03SO10 3S10 =Sn1VIS 1 a SIA M laetpM smog 5•0 :awu.yea51e4O1 NOIL13dSN 33 SW a i" 3 m :3A11V8UVN On 06-11-20. I received a citizen complaint reference to a vehicle parked blocking the sidewalk. -31/11VN 213NMO 091Z6 V3'12l3S30 Wldd 1NIV1d1NO3 N3Z1113:03212133321 v v 73 O • n 49, VI � a O m z 0 m • N 0 N o 0590-OZ 21391Nf1N 3SVD 1aOd311 AHOISIH 3SV x 2 m o c o m 73 In m C O 1 sivayp Iaey3!W 4 $ 0 oo Z •0 O c R. m IT Iri 4 c Fr r o +i-i r0 1 CO rt o m d r O m am o w g g g 0 E m tico o p A m - p G g H on m y rn N R goacr° mm{j�a �c"sd n� a. aD , N L. 0. n n s—' ro Y^ a N g o c. m= F. O d 6 7 A N m a i '0 III 0oNI 0N °rom DJ Lh10 { NA *612- 00M TQ2 d rod0. o.a. co 3m *ax .... „ g in r� rro m m r10 m m� rn a = m .> p d F+ m ^ N V 3 �o n 0. m N CCD O �y m A - Z0 gN co ro ° ,A ro e � o10 LI `'• °nr w A on G � A nn'3 S d d 1 - Aus ro = I-. in co i. ° . c C m IV 1-- w d er R OCh N Q O 7 co I ro •ry .c w ro 1, n t;n ra O = no — 3 = a, m ° i° 3 ro rp v Pr O 7 0. 0 a 04 el = h 0 ro a a- a ro r. aro - 59006ZZZ9 413OVNf1N 13321i/d :MANN i13NMO Q O 10 v VI m F. Q C m -4" o n N wcn r. N O Oin °1 Q N m 0 73 0 0 LL90-OZ U381Nf1N 3SV 1 121Od3a AaOlSIH 3SV3 m s!JJOIAI IaeLMIN smog Z :awO,jje35Ip7a1 =spo c rro q1 .0 c W ivgp� N1 0 303 o `xan "6" ..' 0 s ° . S rL el R CD a.i -a TA to LA- m0 R Q F " au-00 to .O I AT c j 0 CD a d N �. ro m . n 3 _ ro T O 0 - C a o 4 as ro d oo o ID 0. 0 0 0 0_ P.7 O ro m 3 m m n 0 g w 4 Q = =. a - m an _ _. NOLLD dSNI dfl MO11Od a3aNflOdNfl sluoyy IaepM ions E m 0 m NC 0 v sWI" S0 ^ obi 7.' O N - C 1 S ' pi 0 0 ro P. E. Q.aw 0. 3 0..+ 00rn re o dl c "b E DO CD 0 5 ro C g� n ro D S It G0 ro ro ry d - '1D N 0. IA r N i° 03 . 0 S ro 0 3 T eti ro O ... rmo En .K ro w m c• R s s 0_ 1 is OD 4 o m d m ro 0 co O aar 3 0.0 ro s� m NOI1J3d5NI 1VLUNI 33NVI1dINO3 NON sl.tloIN Iae4PIW 2 o m SIuOIA lae4PM114 tri S g co, gn r' ro O f�0 N N R 'II d A ro In w v n N oa e c a 0^ ro = ...1 -. ro ,.. m. O_ 7 u, ,fin n C r7 ro 7 9 ro �1 9 ro = D. 77 'x• 0 Q. 3731 R . O ro mm ro aa4�'" ,NaO- oaA,cem- mnO ro9m ro C -..ss d 0gN N Il0 a ro 0T(4 0CAD N N- al 7'.A NO ON inw an N ro Er P1 to W ra , N 7 n N 41 I� (� (� G no S R y. N O 0 o 41 crop O .7y C 1y W N ' 3 Oo 0a n 7T cu •ro C 0 0 0 C et dro M 7 b CO 'O ro O co 23 O_ 47 0 E K N 0 ro v, 0 3 w ael MI G 0 d (D -a ID ntn �{ c ap p' in m a ro ro m la ci H c. N fA Q H ro ID 'iluni Al Q ID d ro y1 0 4- 0 0 n 0 0 A m ro m 0'0. 0. 3ET pi is ' C = 5- E,'," < aaro ao 7 O.00 O N n x Oo 0 iro (012. o ro CO r`o -- ro :31,11VN IMNMO 09ZZ6 tl] '1a3S3a Wfdd IC 4 Z -co in CD m " 0 rrn tPG) 0 73 rn N vsZ -+a 70 r m 'm°a 91 In mO=�1 a C r f _ m Z;v mal 130 -I -tn. N O n_ -0 r 'o m E N tan mCP 73 0 ri O m N ri O to a m LL9O-OZ a381NI1N 3SV3 121Od3a AUOISIH 3SV3 GI m A A x m 0 C 0 0 a 0 Z rn 0 37NVnd1103 NON O m a 1 Aagaila eualoi �ro m n a azr to ro rr9 O w 3 Iv a 3 ra N 01 Of A N ea QPr CI. 0 co eo eo co 0 N Aagmy euatoi UO133dSNI 1 0 AmpIlg euaio-1 Z 1 01 0 O 23 a3,na3fns N mm fe �� > a c. F O rn Co to n 0 _• n O1 c rrn 0. N 0. n P. A m vic n < v a na LI '• co °I 0 N fp ac CLP p GO 3 R. 0 0 rorag S m ro 70 a ro ID to to UO.L 3d5NI O N m suPIPV lae4aliN NOI133dSNI dfl MO11Od a a suPIPV laePMW P 3 m aint via City Source 966503 about cars parked on the street. Also added the violation of trash cans in public view. 2nd Complaint via City Source 966221 about cars parked on the street. RP: mg luleldwo3 a panlaaai aauelldwo3lsoH RP states guest parking in the street 59006ZZZ9 4138 W f1N 13DHVd m m C 4 02 O m Z ouo z m70m 70g� 2 .p. mG a et 00 Epza n m mrct'o 0 m am. 0 pa rD r- N O N CU CU a fl! 7 a. a m N si.UoW IaetPM m V. rn C N 0 o in m ION uoge a O 0 NOLLVJ s!Joyy peq iyj 73 a3ina31Ds IOJ.D3dSNI P m m Aay�;�a euaJoi f1 0 co ° 0 n re re 4 7 7 0 ° 3 a �^ m m vo ?„ C 3 sz O a r s ° m 7al .-r n iD N O. C re C D z tn m 0 73 a in 31 m, '° W n T la (0 FV f• N A rn A ear N .�► •X fo .Z 111 0 0. in Ili 7 74 Z d a O Q� 0 = N ; •W fp s •< S L 5. 10 W? n 03 N -0 d 0 = q 0. N 7 d • ° N +D p ° '° i .61 rim IV O� y am ..0 w o00 =" 3= 2 a T 3 Fr G)m124 IR I Pr < a * co 0 n < � `�� =. -s1 c. m z IC 411 < S re to N O i .2ID n Or A S m o0. Ncr;;@o0P<S _,= iniT 9 I o" f on ' <. , E I. ,„7,- i ro �1 ac a 3• 7 nSa 7 of 2. C 7 (p p0 S a m 06 71 O.io o� O O O n a C O. P 3 S C O 0a°a3•cso_gID a 7 „re � ° � V' 0-0 C d c d a ili 0:°° IDDOS 'roo0C°' p1 DO ID C . G ZI .n .°.. ID W fa G on C 7 S 1,1 iSL ; <n RI ri S ° O N , C N O..-•. vy @ S 7 eg Dp — 00 • m m i-+0 1 ro $m R I n°` c a 30 0. I9 D o 0.3 a 5u cr ° m'� e v m in 2. Q n '-, .< C S Gl z S9006ZZZ9:H39WfN 137IIVd —ARILS NO 9NIE8Vd :3 aQ 0 -I M c XJ —I 0 0 A m M N n 0 14 N r 3 r a 2 m oxiz-nm co 0 Z m m 3 � r m m Q O m n a zi C N C y � 6] m a0 o]V9aNOWVIa Tb90b:SS311gQV :311/(] Sf11V1S 3ALLDV :SnlVIS E690-OZ H38Wf1N 3510 11IOd3Z1 A IO.SIH 3SV7 a m c G 2 0 = x 0 0 i 2 0, a 2 m ti o o= m� IV C 0 C 0 0 0 0 o 4snz a 0 •_ ' aa r mN O .: • x C1.3Q O et, 0 m 2 a a o 2 2. n, Z 0 m? m a �3 .� n 0 c i 3 m 3 o c c z 0 coA 0 Q. C fb IC j -1 ry S d Du 00 m ° n 7 as R O I 3 in'O A to o c$ $ a l ID m afD 4 c ° • P -n o 3 w 3 7 n o a N Ea 0 3 a o — c O r.0 m G at Imo 0 a o, 02 m N N d 0- N m w o m i G 0. O^ C y 4 0 E p 0 a 0 ., 0 IT E 7 w a y tip o ro v o 0 'm m v -ro , 0 a w o 0 s o O n n o o a „o s o Ln 3 m fD NO1133d5NI dfl 3DtsAir swim Iae pm 1O.L 3d5NI 3 m 72 1 g s!Low Iae43Iw . m -w m v ro _ c.o-s nr-02 P a .17S NQh �� � CO a 7.n_ O O O artm iiii . o O N R I^ N a a= p N 7 .c aed o g°�— m m' CE N v L- y 1 7 m C I 7 7 ~ :� 1° 0 F d wd t0 s. 0 N 2m oN s 0a �� 19 m m w Q CI 72 7 0 I 3 3 5 a0 4 ro IA ra 0)' N x _'f 0 m 3-6 -0 p1 to t to o. 0 e a Et 0 0 7 7-to O 0 S9OO6 9 :mown N 133a1/c1 m GI 03 N +23 M n m 3.3a ILI ro S R+ a j r� ro g S s r z`tb 4. 3 F z 3 E. rt ID C a Q a ra tri O '33 ET ro IA E a O / < m N m N v R N = 'A 0 C 0 m 0 v a31na3H3S mAm F'` N o 1- N 0 0 a 0 in E a 1 zanappOa Olpad NOLL73dSNI dfl MOIIOE 33NVIldV OD NON zanappoa (Wad 0 in II N C Z N rn m a 0 hayaala BU JO1 w 0 ro V 0 m 09ZZ6 VJ'la3S3a INlVd S9006ZZZ9 :a39 W [1N '13 »IVd iia )IJtl9aNOWVI0 Yb90b:SS38QQt/ n m m m -a fe 1 °Is 4 b° i On�N O 0 3 G A O s • Z m M N ,,a o� r- E I — xi z m :31tl0 SCLLtl1S 3Ah1J '=snivis A 1 s zanbsef xalV tn m N v 11V3 3N0Hd 03131dV OD u, a01]3dSNI •Mou puodsai amid co a O 2 m 2 a m in 0 0 0) .¢ m 0. S9006ZZZ9 :21391Af1N 13»aVd Sflld 1131ND 11VJ :a38113A3a 3AIJJV :Sn1VIS E690-0Z a38Wf1N 3SVI .1110d3H Aao1SIIH 3SV m SI110104 Iaeyam 33 IA trn C wC m a P w A m on c e E a la d, d 73 m Z ff m H n 00 C C m^ m C m g 5- � la x a. x^ g sz. m -1 y eR-^2:i oam .*ra O Z' m aa mn rit aaZ IA mz a n-- c` n m mauc n n a ... . IV HJ a C ft n a mgN NIN m 10 -c-o p u. 0. W to C 5 V p d•p .aDo W O COO V a.,tmo'm 41N ��'rno0 H w 3 n 3 �c G =8. p W M a f1 Po, 33c °. p m n 00 n R m V a �raca �; am m ,m m 1.1 9 m N 0 C C n a cn m ^' 01 o c N ¢ m X NI ,IQ a N ro O. C 3 z w N V m m a sluow la swoyy pe4?!W inn c a n C 0< a 12 '0 d'i a s 2 rt D) O. -_1 O m 7 =�= D p n C C m .3 ,C ( iD x O umi +D th= ov Cantu ` Z N a a Sao in m 3 en 3 a° @. 5 g a. rn o a a C a C p� O �<�g Z Li R � y E. a a a a n c c c .�v. o n�_3pB Al Nm:k m Re 3 710 a w A N N -.. V ro w m ,,, o+ !+� c o a 0 V a ,. D 01 C w +� m op 0 3 n w a V CV 0 n c Q N 3 c N p n I-. O W R mIC 33C � ID w w Ku fp n p V n ea M G Y O w 3 wos Ti m .. N o 0 I - 3 A Cr�n C)W A 3 n N IIDD Ca .r N < N .p . c m m Z a 10 H = ea NI I e a O c Sa 3 `" co 7-F. X 01 aR c R A m 0 1.0 1. N V j p A 0 A CO cG N Ta in o 0 . m rD 1V1N31;1 W21311IIOHS :3dJLL 3SV7 O m Z a 44 in z; M m ZDO> 3 nr-nx .�, m m m rn C 0 E O :L Ll 0 09ZZ6 VD'1MMs3a WlVd ua )IJV9aNOWVIO V179017:SS3110OV 3ALLTY :snjVls n m 91 70 C 5 -1 en 10 -1 O O A m N 0 N z m E690-OZ 2i381Nf1N 3SV3 1UOd311 Ma01SI11 3SV3 sluoIN Iae4PIW :ON 11013e3l3 lunoury cull a 0 i 2 v No c No m 71 -1 O an S v n a e a O N co Z 111 N ro N 4. a c m cr 11 ° Rre O CD g 1 o 3 Er a NOLEV. C o cr 2 0 a1 tu a w " 0 d S. 0 0 .0i " a ln c 0 ID o n •0 w m a o o o to O SWOW IaetP W 110133dSNI 031111531E 1 31Jo1A1 Iaey3IW en no a d N o5 d a a M. a n a re 23 d e 2- ... o, I a N N F E R o G1 1^ d o G. .'". � a a� S p a o 1 •• o E 71 IC , o -' ° ° DO N N C .Z .a N 8 0 '� o O d It •O N Q. o P. o z N N o 0 00 10d• 7 4 g a tn v >> o d o CD O. 41 N UJ UI M 73 se* 7 N COW = y a 7'^ 2m •0w o;ad 3 ° O. -0 f0� �� �NR L., ^ tD A Pt N p T W cr + MI .. rt 1D CD. y = an i x�61 a a~ A a 3 a a o a o f at10 * c 0 c .. m 4r, ° d hi 7 • ° S 7 f0 a o Fir C a m x a m g o = -c O .. 7 = P ro m O 1n C c = a 0. en m zCo c�.. •70n—I oz n E a Z m Z � r O'*+Z0 Z m m m 73 xi E " r 0 m a. 'O 7 A C 0 � O d "0 61 a 09U6 VD'.Lu353a 011Vd va )IDVS NOINVIU Zf:90fi:553aac1/ 3AILJV :SlnjVIS F690-OZ 1138Wf1N 3SV) lHOd311 AHOISIH 3SV 03111031 u SWOW Iaetpwq 0 w M m s!Uoyy Iae4)IW v X co- -.i C 0 to 0 13 S+m m m m o �0.. m R d 9i -I EL a 0 a - e o N N m 0 0 3 0 0 0 Nf0'� f3D AV 1 V 0i ^ 3 X to 5I1JoIN IaelpIyy 1101]3dSNI 0 E m cgNm3QAmaooel=°:�0 Ni. 10 OCa N ro 3 C C N Q. p- 4. O0 d o D x a A ei,3 Goa n Yt D V E. V J DO ..* G -w H IV V -a .. M 33°inroad_- �o°a0VDi7@o 0. o- .-0- S3 3 w to „D. �'=n CD 3 A fn ? D = rn ..JID . - c a3 m n O1 v H_ 7 IN. �rnmd�_ .* Lroi ti w rn ru ~ fY D '* rn? .+ 7~ 7 as V 1 b Cu 4 A 01 -1 R^ rrnr 7 1im lc m a- p ,� 0. H 7, D a0. ±n nO C P w 0 p �, rn • Qs0c�N3�a2�iro;m D rn 0.a3 a9 m N eavi a � g N d 37..... o a 3 m3 Qa rn D 3 �' CO 3 '� t'' +ND p ti 3o.rnamo:33:'= 7. 2 00 n D 0 " m 3 in: . . N rn a rn ro Qa rb �m1 -- D wi . @ pv aNID no 3 cm N OC� ' VD' IS. a 7 •••f in - H 0 p? rn :.f. f4D 3 c a y c••• 3 fat m 3 a+'Drn�m f0710 2mN°o ? S y p p ain_- 7 0 m p d -v. fb-, a . m C a g 3 f ea IT 0. a c o . rn O. m in A el i >^ x°''p - V'3aDI - o. 3 Oh °. S l0 01 rn O '�° -..0 S :r1 p3 n3 a$ f0 . Sf0 rn rn7._ m p oT0 � C Kr: .7102 -. 0 4 d a CD 1 ryrn nLi rn ^ fl w rn o a a* p 3 in n DI Z 0 3, `[ ro at m • rn @ V n o a04 warn m rn if -. w +D f0D Q. a 0 m c 01 m ro 1 o paueap uaaq S90O6ZZZ9 : J38wnN 137a11d n_ 12 m 72 m _ 5. N fl D O z-1 CTI0 -1 0 c}E o Z Z M N -a oN m 1- 3 c a z n m O m Z r zm o m ry rn a MI 22 a x . CLit 0 S 4 07 m 3 a 09ZZ6 tD 11UI390 W1tld 2i0 )IDV80NCVNI© Lb90b=SS32IOOtl E690-0Z ZI39WnN 3S1d3 111Od311 A)OISIH 3SVD GI 03 z 0 Z V 0 `sus N "Cl m RIIIIAo ro 3 a 8i d, �i bi �i N m o . 1 A A A N Z 3 0 •.. vI m or 00 ° !^ a ro ro Lli A ;a n Ci a m a Cr m o = m m a= c � I �� g crZ O S O0 no p G W a7 w Ol C V m Z A O A °ill w a ymLai$ .-o Nn 0 a .S °; as - _ = m w aa) a v w ID u,,- a Inn A aA C N _ � o ID3 F. 5 7 N n ro_ n a 2n a a = m a d _ F' 3 s mrt m In m m 1D o. a' .0. 0 gm on Iao0 c a g a 3 a 0 3 a I ro aV XI IA ? W N 16 0 r Q N ro 3 C m ro c 7. Tr 7 ro 04 0 a C n = 3 Q 0 - co SluOW Iae43IW VOl33dSNI O en m S!.UoW lae4plvi ro H O a �+ . ID T Si.- d IC ID an o IA C 7 C ing^ 2 2 a -1 an c a :° m•"• a -3. ° m 3o •'--o O n" RI n Y a d~ w Q= fP .. e o 4 a a m o.az yNu+wma7'0�a _ •• woa 0 CId n DJ NI m to 3 M N § . p 0 0 O A 0 hio° c ZIT +tieg n" • nc a ro W N a ,. 3 fi Vi n I+ a fl DJ N 3 1�1 to a if tnJ ui 141 i.:, o_o o 1'3 coal,-•$ 3 ro '"',� K3c„ ro a o Ft v. a us al n 0 w ,r ID rt a V O 7 m r' A i M WI IA 3 7 N 0 C N a co la N 5 ro a I.1 = g d a x w V. c ro a V A 0 N 01 S9006ZZZ9 :1139Wf1N 1331Nd E 1.14 2 m m xi 23 E n m � n r T n o m as 12 r- cro m O. 09ZZ6 VJ 'lil3S30 W1Vd HC] NJb80NOW'd10 T179017 :SS3HGOV .1.33111S NO DNlNUYd :3dJLL911S 3SV3 :31VO Sf11V15 1V.N 3lI INH311HOHS :3dAL 3SV3 311Il.Jb' :5f11V15 E690-OZ 11381AlflN 35V3 111Od32I MIOISIH 3SV0 m to E606L6=P!anss!Lxdse•I!eaapanss!/sanss!sa8ed/woxpa 0 N N m 1O 0 O 0 N N ID rn 1 v m f 3303 31 m C N m O "' 3 4 M 0 3 < —. - n - Si .F .'^. Q �' N ^ a n a n m A �_ o�-C LI " C L _1 p, n 3 IV aae PP.e --! b � �p a m R n' 5 A °4 a a� cm r x ,m-o�aa5a�Ccn^ v=o v N 5 0 m N a to IA' o- O ca a N N = N O N a LaN N Al -. e A 7Jj/ en=T ?ag 000 0 rr N IY No W O P.' _CQ1 R G m o "3 o0a.�i'^ ro "' F' 0 a n N m rD 91 a 3 3 to o n co n A m 0 Q, 3 n V CIeam fg v I-.0 w m N 0 re tri 1.1 3 (D N 0 C N VI re re 4 S re c. MN 0)N = /Am 01 W N N CI to -13 N g X 0 N 0 N ro a II to g V 2 CO a m d in 3 sWoW IaeIP!W 09ZZ6 '1a3S30 W1Vd S9006ZZZ9:H381Nf1N 133UVd a0 N3V9ONOWVIO T179017:SS3110aV 13381S NO 9N1)IUVd :3dAlans 3SV3 a u, 1V1N31:1 W113118OHS:3d,J 3SV3 3AI.1.3V:S111ViS A_ 4rn 0 a �M g ij N -1 0 0? rs 0 N Z m E690-OZ a381Alf1N 3SV3 la0d3a A iO1SIH 3SV3 s 0 oN tut t7 C 3 T c ZSt 53 O DJ ro m n d d o 0 xo0_ 0 sz 0. N 3 Cl. 0 C DI a. r zu fmro, o cr co-., 0-ft m v =cr=DIao.- ro Q. 7 S = iii •+ m O ID a fD in ro°i(0-g^m a a ti a wto pp A 7 3 ro.4 a r?D ^ 3 3 .. 3 ID O A Di �'az 'O H o I al r0 a -n-c 3 ro o a m C o -0 m ogl ro 3 c 5-PI o 0ti A _ O. vi ro IDa m r n G ri ro a H 2. OA II 0 ro c a = -In 61 2 3 DI m :� � d a tu m �3aodc CD 7 O uro a i C p .C.v. 0. K- O f S Di = sj o @ ro m , to c. * a. * E c -a -c . o f+ ifr NOLL 3dSNI 33NVIldVW sIIIJOyy 10e4211411 ti0133dSNI = _ 0 0 K a x M V T .. N C CIv a. �° S ro ro a d d a '�`° fa ro n R. w a p N naC N CDs a 3 OV A R 2a , , . 2 1 al atz=» g aof -Iro r a mw -ro g .res. 0ac ^ g:: nrn m 1p O O O so c Z. i�•$ ro aae� z a c Z+ d N al 3 a n A 0 0 :: m oit ro, v w °a to 19„ V m a V fD W'00 n N aVOID 2 w r 1-.3 a c_ qnNW0 CD m 0v%+ ..1. -'�� pia'^ m o Q- � y c I• 0 W 0 m III z ero D+ �� psa 3Mc?, n�o 0 W 0- f0 ° V1 .- w o co f A m f�D 3 8 -i O a 3 V O m m a n _� O j 1' 3 C w N 3 en el c. ° a ro 3 ;_a V � era P 7r.7,N rIo ID O 7_ Q O ui (D Iv n t N 00. C O N m 7 f0 o. up �+ a m G'y m N A a3a so ���1e ro K 0 ch .Nr C lA ai ei 0 • N d O r ' a x o a m o ^� -%m c o3 d 0. v cc � 3d. a 5. a Dl ttn ei Ye F tl M 3 vi mt.1...m = N m '{ O �'n O N a E ° mcr N li 04 3. 3 n a 3 ro N NOLL 3dSNI 03L swoyy Iae4Dlyy HO133dSNI o 3 T 1 a sl.uoyy Iae4p14V 59006ZZZ9 :11381AlfIN 13»IIVd a0 N3V90NOWVIO I179017:SS31J0OV EE Vb 02 ill 02 m 0 mg rn 7O r m 3ALLZ V:SflIVIS E690-0Z a38INfIN 35V3 121Od3H AHOI SIH 3Sto N C m 3 d 101 ..•° n b rn > O m TO b O W N j r7, 0, N 0 ri Z 0 �c o 4 3 In 0 m Z0 I o ao o- �IZ S 7 ° 0 3. - r N y , pi, n T 03 z=g o Its m o, p, T N d ~ 0.. h L K L, 44 7• O W G, a 7 ro00-9-a 0 o. 0 w n 27 In a a c a IA O m ..--��R. C E:'i 0. 0 m H v m sue'' w o_,‘0 - n Q. N 0 g z V V M 0 o OmN C Aaty„la eualol fl3L 0 0 swop.' lae .P!IN 0 in a0133d5N1 031111S311 Amp ;l11 eualo, Mailed US Certified/Regular an invoice of $1000.00 for PDMC 5,10,090(L) mailed to the property owner 03131dW03 a NOLL73dSN1 dfl A a -.. 0 V 77 A ...1 .'9 01 C m c 0 r o p N NJ o 0 v 0 v 0 6 0. 0 1 In O m - d rye m y, o n O 7• i7 3. p 70 'C OP EL Sp o in 3 m a MIRAN lae43j01 0 0 d A n g,L,ns o 2 3 a I-I0 . O Z f 7 0 N 0 ••' V N a V 30 3 3 3-3 0 A0m 5. 0- o ,D A Q. a m p n2N 0. ID a NOLLJ3dSNI do A 030N I, O O 23 ro A N O r O M a,0 0 0 C O. 0 • L tn • d m o 7 O 7. A g 0 a Sp i sumo' !ammo' S9006EZZ9 ;+`l3gW11N 1338Vd O T Z G nn m P3 m vs T m O 4 z = a v al C in rrp,�vC+ co O C7ras m -( m ton Q 6 72 in' Z0 m 0 , w73 rD r ,.., D.,-I g LA D. N LI a ni C. i10 NJVBONOWVIO Tb9017:sS3aacV :31V0 SfLLV.LS 3AI17V :VULVAS a • m o m Fn Er ro 0 0 �+ m rho `�' m m a a0, g 0 m I 7 C 16 rr Q 9 6, n •+ 2 N 7 C N .�i .r .N. ,. 2 0m!4rcal o�NXran�(D aoro'm"w CmQ.m m3 C> a. A f1 m INn d co —1 A O C .o ...I R n 3 'm' P4.1 m n a c m o m o. a c. r�o c m° m c m ma o. ro c r x 4 c v. • vaiaaa3+0.nc e o — m13 -Tida7 00. .0. c n; ▪ 9 El m 0 h. ; a 0 ,�j N o a — a r... I-. 7' t7 F. N m .1 7 rd m tit N en 7L n LI a �n N m to m fa rim A 7 02 W zb Q 0 0 O~ 7 a ▪ a 0 0 N.1 NJ 9 r... An • C c tVir A G 0 n tea h O c V Chi O O N ttOO i, r w l.+ � �J A N n m ra W F. tans ro �r .2. M0 u0i rC++a n a_0, aF.,a0iF. O Um g Li] ro ea 0 w01 wwq m C Y� G N a y, m a C �+ 0 Ar•.. 7 0 n �' 7 a s re = c. Fa 0- 33ro 0 7 ma a� TsT�"m as n CO n n w m N :O o3 m� 3 c s �� m n a o ▪ ~� Dais VI tuo A C gi m °1 y • ti° ' al Q • N c p = 3 m N 0 m ro YI 0 C 1mi1 C y m m as N N Y N c. t0 ,go a ip CD NJ I▪ J tot • 0 0_a M ▪ 5 x c w o N 0 • 0 3 0 La la la IDa m 11O. a c LO z 1.0 CA111 ,0 m . 1-S ' O 7i sivayy a e 0 e ij Aatmu euaaai cot O o 3 m 1 0 haysmt eualoi 09ZZ6 VD'IH]S30 WIVd S9006ZZZ9 :1138 W f 1N 13D21Vd 2f0 NDVB0NOINVIO tt90V:SS32uuu' E m m c4 co tn rp 77 7C m 61 E Orr' zz ."- m 72 pp eA o a �' �r obi �, A. m o d m rho m o o �i �i ai ai �i m e 0 c 0 v v fa ID m E u, c %- o o v ty m fp fo i^IA C A R N Q to N N° 3 3 A ° f0 fa -f, Q N �. Q a fA fl a 'x. f>4 to O. 2 n d N ST ° m a S d A 00 a ID 4- 4 'A d 3.1 a ° C' a 3 Z .0 N N 01 °1 f0 d f0 so S. Uf N 6� CD u" . �p d 7i o a a w N D 4+ ui !� 7� a n 0 d is ° .' = ro a c a 7 nr yg A- laf9 a-iI d c„ ID CD F+ 00 °;.c A DJ th JD d .r Q fro r, 7 o Q v O. - a 0�-1 m= -0 C .di a :° cr rcr a. aa a', 3'° C o r: a 3 c x 5 al m irsa d N% d H W N �^„ O fl A 0 v= a Q f0 3 v 5 5. a ,°a. ~ T Q d V S d y V n m. c 1= a n R N a' b Na N i7 = A y o1 w lff d < d r d '� ^i 3 I N 0. ^ N a N A 0 > d f07:1 3 I> d 4 47, Aau `° m RI C d {' C — �{ Va d d� O ro = fA d ° H S G m 43 a fa m 3 0 0 d 0 c CD I a - et = 5 0 At 3 m o a a4 a 73 o 5 5 P d a ra •* P - 0 ra 0 c ra C C N S f0 re a 170 n. 7 ra fa 0 2 n m h 0 0 Al ci 0. S9006ZZZ9:t139WfiN 133UVVd Sflld a31N3D 11V0 :03232133321 1331I1S NO DNINHVd :3dJLL8f1S 3SV :31tla SnU.tl1S 1ViN3Z1 W H311HIOHS :UAL 3SH3 3A113V :Sf1.Ld1S n_ 12 72 oa m IAo r 3� O 0N RI 0 Xi - O A N O A D N m A w O N r z m GI A zanNppou awed :03 puodsail N0U 3dSNI dfl MO1103 33NVIld1NQD NON zanBIJpoa olpad a N 2 a31na3 161 • m a • 2 m • I s co to to 3 • m ,o v c ro M w = 23 t^ C 0 • N j u O 0 G in re re '. ro Aa4paly euaJal Ampzw euajol a4p]ig euaJol a3lna31OS 11O133dSNI a311n531! SWOW Iaey3IW 73 K a31na3H3S m0+W 0D o i+ y c O Q. rN N om2�020 Z in „ IDo- at 1 co 3 T a m IQ to vo n ro et to 7 - G - W H go, CL IL 03 O C 00 �IJ 0O. 51 n ac3vr =Ng>n ro a _ 2 m n n O ro a E N ▪ L O R T r y� ro-a t.ri.c c • o;12 m 0 ▪ to 3 o C .Z O W d 7 7 oi . 7 a 2, R N N a r=e • ' O Fir 'p F+ rye * V 'b a N M m Al C ▪ n _ Q. C CI r Z g G v 0 0 a 'r c C n N 3 VaQ ID NO1133dSNI dfl swoyy Ias4DIyy UO133dSNI O 3 m spioyy Iae43m 09Zz6 VD'1H]S3a 10111'dd aO )1OV9ONOWVIO TV90V :5921aaV :31Va Sf11ViS 3AI.L]V :5111V15 €690-OZ nawnN 35V3 1)JOd311 AHOISIH 3S1/3 m G 0311103H3S CO C 00' siJopy lae4DM 80173dSNI O us A m 1 sluoyy laegplW 0 V 0 0 a x 0 72 a1lna]Hns 1 AJ M AI 0 C 0 c IA o rroo rn 9_'0 d d c A m n iD R. 5 N. t ti R i I 2 ID nZipriT ••(b ti^1cLeg,n' n� a C Z m 3 ro p on d a d 4 2 C z z �r",rfo 4az�:- ro^ r^ rya 'o d Q. D_ 5 a n c c pn 'rY y a, d N c C N h '•µi m e A 4 ro a '0 m m 0 roa m w oo3,°' -1.oto a N rya a f0 C in Oi y O 0 0 O 1 ro y x e -p y tp w O.Zc OOP Cro nd77 ^ H aro .' 7, - iw,,m m,+Lo3 °c. A 3ro rya aD ZC.O.ro ro A p 3 }"',^ ro _-0 3'0. nab c p C I. 7 3 y O d 0. N F+ I. iri fp O .r S 0 to �• 5.5.m ... {/� a 7n Di 11 �IJ -roi tP O n V n fna m .i d a C W A O 0 13 V 77 In 3 �'� 3 R^, a o as o o N r n a F. G w ro w ro �+ m oni m zi a m N p n N N I� e C & w d W. O ptr. N Q p 0 v w 3 c s p to 67 i- o n m of N O CO A C r 0 I.J. 10 C .� A c N �»� wa MKm v O. ro ro R Cl. m 3 3 m o r, • n W n N 7 In O 00 . N Pi c S z3 uri p 0 d ro ....o w n y co ro NI C V r0 fm W d z F m 01 Al 7a r a N 9 Cr N �,° OAl c N NAl c � oo N N co [fi d x N LT ttoo rya O N ry 0 0 =I 0 0 a LA, ro 1 fD C C_ C d a to (n aNi N M z H Fs' in co d mo V m m N toW M a cr K 1p C i p A on Oon 70 co _ C O ; = m y .c 4 II a DJ to co oo . 1 1 N 3 I. N F. m1 jt 1 i 1 1 59006?U9 :2139WF1N 1331Nd m � zrn ,Z7 .< M m W ta a m m NOLL 3d5NI dfl MO 1O3 ME N 13 stq o 73 N C m a o Ni"„, • o C 0 c 3 n Fv o in >o omit,' 0- cNcsc„a29CO,mmA m .'CD c a m a . 3 o'i ai� R m N X n� 2 0t rIt 3 0 0-0 C a 0.0. m 0 n p via ao m_aQ- c a c o'4 y O* 3 0 m. V V -n 3 n 0 a :�: �i CO {D 7 3 a 3 a w g o o IC O. V c "m m o g1 :40 0oa m °.aa.." f WN wr ��m op n N N d O C 1 O W W ^ A ',, O N 1-+ H m O m 33m o V Cian ro T 4/1 .Jo.3 mn r� m ram. m IA . N o c 0 0 88LLI36=manswydsevlapanssysanssl/saSed/wor Uo N N O O in 3 m g o m �cn 2i g0ro ro N C 3 c �+ a a m .+ e� m n �1 m rnoO N A a n. g N ro a a az - 3 w w w -I e = o c 0 A n a A c •A N ,� N F, in 4 a 0 m C c 0 .-" on�3o romn►+'-'ma C O . V V 0- 3 n ,n 00 $1 rri m to m r. m m w A 0 0 0 o '3'ro CN wr-+ ergm M 00 Er 171 �' N w G o 4 n o 10 em w oa a inth•*A a c I 0 M W m N c. W 0 33+co tow n it V n A ro m x 3 5I r m Ku N g = 3 c 7 w d m A la g A rx 3 A IA n La m N a! N 0. N o m v o_ C w_ C (tea A 0. a DD W CO V N V ID m 0 0 A 09ZZ6 V3 `11:13S30 W1Vd 59006ZZZ9 .H381NIlN 133HVd Sf11d )331N3311VD :03H11333H HO )OV9ONOWVIO 1b90b :SS3H0UV RE nm -422 m m m La ?I a v m a p mm O 0,8 m K nO ? Z m m" 1> ON n r 3 ,- a Z m m 3AIlDV/:Sf1xVIS E690-0Z MINIM 3SV3 i110d3H AUOJ SIH 3SVD NOIL73dSNI dfl M0110d x 1 swami !amplify 1 a c �. a 3 m swoop lae4plW C 0 en en o m 1 0 NOLD3dSNI dfl M0110d 031316,403 os 0 N O NJ 5 0 0 s!JJoW PCLP lry H m o i" E m 1 0 sluaW 1ae4PIW z 1 3 c N 0. IV 0 0 0 A ° ro s 0 m D ° or 3 m N 3 0 - o go a S d o. ono A go S m V A c 7-7M rot CO C m v o day o 0 d 7 � Sp x 1 3 'fl 9 0 3 uc+ °- ° 3 c in v x 0 'C n -a rim V 0 t ill y Of O ILV m m a a N cs •c �. �c v o v w ° 0m 4 O W y H 9 A 3 o m..! .. m m n10 0 a m a'aroag ?6+ °m'Dro °°om-4;a6°cw oo = 3- GO 9 3 or 3- 8 N G N° `� w O Z Q 4. ? a 3 s n °- 3 C O fC y 3 'p v 3 N A 0ND W d 12 0� �3y .. .. ry 7 - al d W N f m'' d m z Ai d grn • W. Of o 3 c 3 C 9 N ° - C r0 pD ep .> ° d fL n n' U1 a �► 7 N r. - r�i N n O ° r°. a o o. == a 3 H C .0 .. 0. �i " ..i m N a a 3 aei � co cn c° Nsg�maam�c.aa� n a aM ° . a3 10 R� I° a DQ. ^ N �c,�° mm20o° 1d as°°oA E~ ° i a - 09ZZ6 VD 1l1:13S30 1N1Vd S9006ZZZ9 :a39Wf1N 13aUdd uo NDV94NOW11I0 Ib900:SS390ad E m R7 2 to 0 C � rro P3 m b m w 1 m 0 N smog bZ :awlj Jp s 1e3o1 09ZZ6 V3'.wJS30 Wltld S9006ZZZ 9 :2138 W f 2 N 13321Vd 13a N V90NOINVIQ Tti9017:SS3U00tl £690-0Z U38WfN 3SV3 111Od3 I AIOISIH 3S113 rn vs rn m 0 n T N m O C 0 ▪ v sv. rov < z a o. 0 EJ a. zd o • a o Oi os vfro Y0 fl v. O 0 to ra a ra 0 a y� N o'� O ▪ fri • o v co m 7 C m c a • 0 m 0 NOI133d9 33NY SUPIF Complaint via Amy Lawrence. RP: Refused. Group of men staying in the dwelling. NVINO JV9 13VHDIW M311YVN Z13NMO 09ZZ6 VD `.1113S30 IN1Vd TO000£ZZ9 :1136INInN 130t1Vd .NIb'1dINO0 N3Z11I0:a3H113d3lI E E 3rn m m1 C-<I r• XP CO 4 m a O a T S N P. o = -1 m o m m M N M MP -I o 3 0 A, z m C1 > 0-J r S ✓ n z m 035ODD 3SVJ :Sfi1VJS SZPO-OZ 11381A1f1N 3SVD .UIOd3H AaO1SIH 3SVD � E su!IPV Iae4'iW E�ff $ -J &.CDf nkkfn CU in ro � }§ 2 § 2 Please let me know if you have any questions. The address is 40750 Centennial Circle. 3 5 8 � u .._ °}� 3/ ± E2 == ■ c§/k §0. i fp fpCDI DI2 ii &l; -D- § I; ƒc.� 25 -� ) Emn= = CAE.=-0�20.• • 3\■� a--, ;i� \_& IZ,= ƒE ��as} §/ LI I 0 i 0 B , § E § \==Froc2Fa�g al& o7' P�Gg g_2_ 0i7 �. ;I= �_ §a1 -E ;0' o-' 22§ }q ��� m/ _mw . ;,■ - k E£ ,m VI"CD-n � k\a § §0.. ]oE oE 0 n ƒ 41)�a o - — // ro N/ y. /E 2 ln ro on 1 think you handled this one a few weeks ago. Can you look into it. n 2 09ZZ6 V3 '183S30 Wltld Z0000EZZ9 :113flWAN 133HVd tll] 1VINN31N37 OSLOt:SS31100V 035O13 3SVD =SAMV1S 33NVI1dINO3 30O31113530 W1Vd 10 AID PREPARED: 7/20/202014:06:27 k U0000EZZ9 :2138141f1N 13311trd smog i :JWILHen ieloi SZVO-OZ U39 W fl N 3SY laod3a MIOISIH 3SVD n a to a &Jnoy t :awl1}1e351eio1 3 9 d 3 m a. Z 3 2 ° d o * vs v ID d 0 pp aa8 y 7 .� P 0 d c c to co a 53 CD O. 3 m S N m 011 3 0 G 0 0 z 0 7 0 .e n C fD lit* I d Oi y d d N ro c 0 o 3 c own s 00 3 to NO1133» 3JNVfldVJOZ NON C7 0 O siLolN PCLP IN 0 in C 0 Z . m• 0 m xVA o C 0 c 7 m n a v Ede m o fp 'z_i+a'o63 iy "d ' a_ 3 0 a) Q m nm mTa r Z Z' Q¢r0 to C gig -0 Of aet. a Mr, C C on- 3 n 3 a m m A A m a E. 8O AII iii ^1 0 In l0 al N a W O 0 0 0 V K P A N 0 m 0 n P4 NI co 00 3 A NJ 3 N KJ N rr A D. c ito'0"0N rn c to m- 3 to o 0. w m 000 m a 0 Ngo in 3 R C LI ID OD 3 rn DJ fD ID a y 0 c 4 IJJ la N 9 O N R N * m o ��TT11 .0 0, D A Vi N 0 r % N 'tit O N N N a i. V in V y m c q 0 51.1.1001 0 3 rn z 1 On 07-04-20, I received a message from CitySourced, Service Request ID# 974738. in reference to loud music. L0000£ZZ9 :H381Af1N 1331IVd :31NVN 113NMO 09ZZ6 VD 1.L113S30 W1Vd S9NI213HJV9 301If1OS AlI3:03t111333H ONV S3I111Vd anal A1flUNfl :3dA18f1S 3SV3 1VIN321 11JOHS :3dA13SV3 zn .fl m vri a n Y m co G g - M to o 0 6ELO-OZ 1139INflN 3SV3 .LUOd38 A)O.LSIH 3SV3 guppy iaeypiW :as puoc savoy = :Duni-PIS Ill 0 m re IA 4 •o N ▪ m 4 C 0 �n v NOI1D3dSN11VI11N1 03131dW03 N N 0 0 SILoW Iae' RAJ 73 C v z m 0 a zo N m 0 c *1 ty m }nn o erlps - ^ A •o a_�i I: +73 Nn N C 7 S n.r7 a .�: r*-2 3. • _ N PI art. G C `� 0.211. C g m a 'C R N a 0 ot G3 O It., . A r0 > g 2 3 N m y a_ o'—••S°i0Zc.a�I= r-2 N �a19 m a� n."'. N r� y m aQ-� aac c o c °'A-3v� ro �NIeit po m la A-0 7 in a ry A 0 0 j OD m a O Z c V V 0 0 A 1,1 ,n •r 0 6i f. N O 0-9 V 0- n NI r,,r 3 CI A Q. ram', rna V V 7 o. in rn fp C ro ro Ol coliai H ▪ a ar_ g• g13 p rL ▪ 3re `a▪ te 3 • m R m d m rn �. rn rw CIO 0,in G a = A C to Dr InIA 0 •. 0 C O CD C L▪ I g CI.N Yy 3 ry ta N IA0 SIT 0 m g n h, a v.x G N 3 c cr O 1° �. tip ry CO $ r N N 'C V 0 0 si.uoW Iaeyam 80133dSN1 0311ns38 o in 3 m On 07-12-20, I received CitySourced, Service Request IDOI 981127, in reference to a loud noise complaint. I0000EZZ91119W IN 7DHVd :3WVN 1I3NMO 09ZZ6 VD `1213S3O W1Vd S9NIU3H.V9 37af1OS A117 :3321113d3H ONV S311UVd anal AlflHNfl-3dA18f1S 3SV 1VIN31I Wait 1l1OHS :3dAi 3SV3 0 0 m ▪ Vi 0 a O � � N nac z- 9 • 111 Z 1-' m N fl ✓ r? m 53 0 'v oa m as r. v0 rn 0 n rA A m 0 0 E9L0-OZ 2138Wf1N 3SV3 1DIOd3!! A21OISIH 3SV3 SfJJOIN IaelpM smog T :awl,l,jels Km NOUL73dSNI IVWNI Q3131d1N0 sluoyy lae43iw 110J.33dSNI 0 m 0 c D 33NVIldV1OZ Amply euaJol a a 9AIiV13UVN Z3UVnS AIM :3WVN 213NMO 09ZZ6 V3 at13530 1$111Vd 0T000£ZZ9 :a38W11N 1332IVd id30 A.LIJ 01Oa3 Q3a333321:032I213332i 0 m 'Da wcri m m er z� --.. r N n 7a o 039010 35V3 :SfliViS Z960-0Z 2138W11N 3SV3 1aOd32i AUOISIH 3W3 a m 5111O1N IaeLPlN =» ro sco NOI1D3dSli 031 slaaoyy Iae PM tIOJ]3dSNI o� in 3 :3ALLVUUVN Kevin Swartz. Planning approved COVIDI9 STR exemption application from May 28-31, 2020 for Matthew Nordgren MINN :3WVN 113NMO OT000£ZZ9:838141111N 1331.1Vd 113HIO :3dA18fIS 3SVD 1111N3a W a3111IO HS :3dA13S133 1v oa m� 12 m 0 III 73 -i0 n F+ O uI 1 rn z rn z °tea ccn -nT m 73 m T m m f6 0 G Q {n O m -n {!7 N n 0 c w ui m n o NJ 4 Q m 1 09ZZ6 VJ'1a3S30 WlVd 03SO10 3SV3:91111f1S a 5 h 5111°I 1 IaeyaMMN a a 0 Sl1JOIA1 !amply,' T m m 7 S ad C 0,1 • pp 'C m m a B- o C .0 a m 4, CD 0 0 A 0. 0 m ID x a a a ggggg 4i I Z' p 0 7= g h w m a Y N m ID 0-R. o cr 3 sy teb D_ O m ra r▪ 1 O Q 0 0 y 0 0 C. I...b = • r 0 • 3 n o 0 m. c ill f Iri N 0 Lei 0 rmr D O m 0 oa 5' c p. a pa au ,mom EL - -. 03 N� 00 g3 N g. N Fa {r In c3 m ga =fp am el a o+ 0 - 3 c X N x n{Is vi AV ,.N-~. yn A fD m la my ma � m��= Z. in IN a N 0 1/1 Li a au Z 0 0 m m y a re 0 0. 1P R 51111 CD o g m n 0 M w d 0,o- c -3AILVl38VN 0 V N 4 0 a ID N d CO In 00 R 0 0 3 0 0 0 tv N v m f 0 U1 m Cr a OI r C. CO R7 f19 R Cy O a T£OTZ£ZZ9:11391AIfN 13311Vd :3WtlN a3NMO 09ZZ6 VD'183S30 WlVd Sf1ld 831N3J 11Vfo :a311113339 VONO3 VIA 0090b:SS3aaad Z9LO-OZ V3131NIIN 3SVJ 1ZIOd3U1 A)OISIH 3SV GI m G 3= 0 w= 0 LNa (I)3 C m S O O= a 7 a p "4 OJ •'• •7 ~ T o Z y w 3 „, 0. O- r 7 .. _ 7 a, 7• N N . .a m m0 or "4 0SN a: ro 7I-m 0 Sm mC isl S n ma m a7. s m C .4. 7 d w O O 7' n.4 sc.g A. • 1 m m 1 0. m O* o f° a •C 7 D FD-c n f PI c GJ m*-u 01.0 n FA 7 * N a0 * 0 0 an 3 o e 3 • „ 2, m 7 3 10 j 3' m 3 a6 N 0 ea 3 3 0 7 3 a m m m .+ m N a O of 7' Cf ti Q, ty 7 m AI N MI a * g r.-4 "' a r o g 0 3 ra p• a 0 7 O . N O m, O n o O 0 C_ O ,,, n 3 O_ L.N C a- to 0.. O3 . _ � 3 � man ^ ZN • C„ r0 n VI ay ma O. 7' sA N m 7 m m a 3 fa 3 ♦3 Q 03 o m 3 bi N .- -.. m m 'c m fa 3 NO11?3dSNI dfl 37NVfldWl su 0 w m m S!IOW lap4?!W NOIL73d 03131dWOD 5u-10114 lae'PM 8OD3dSNI 0en z m stump laeiminj Z O ro P m a ogggggI ocQim .. fn F. hp n O -Im m -L -ID,. 7 y Fro O G7'4'N ,C m�g,„0anprn m•wc.n )oI-' oaN, N 0.il m 7 �O W 0 d O 0.m r� Ir 1-1 OdN 7IDO 2 si c 5 >fnj co m 7 o, In a IA a 0 0 3 ff0 0 ^ 7 17➢ Fe s M ID fa 7 m -0 N h ip �n O. � g m a °'i 0 m m a T * c O m of ... C O 0 '07 m _ 4' S m n S N 0 a, { m m ': 3 o A 7 ID 01 d = 0 P au { a c m o 0. C 0. S m ONV S311/IVd 1V. Z9L0-OZ 2138Wf1N 3S1/3 J.UOd3H AUO.LSIH 35V m sluoi : lae4p101 Ita 0 NOI1J3dSNI dll M01103 c s 031f1Q]H3S a G 0 c 3 m 1 0 sJJoyy laeplyq m F. m fo n D V N .. ?aw C o 0 00 m 00 ° in m n v o• o m R° c. rn d rn tr - R. fa yro am, = N ^Q m ,I3 A mo 3 23 f33 a» Pi 13 O�f0 7@ N 3 ,- fA r 2 N C ty 3 N no fa ob C u, p 7 c at to n ° a 3 .r w at N co g.7 m in a N ,fp moo, ? o^D 3 c g O 2 y N. A ro 3 CM <�'o of N O a ;" j N fa 0 C , 7 r A N xJ m gici c a �O 3 C o o ISn 3 g fNi 6 p Z fa N V r N n r=a S= 0 N Q fva . v5 T v g d ID IIDD f0�c�� *sv "��2 d T E. ? 0 0 ro N 0 a 0� ; N 2 er g� �� � a. - • Pi c C 2. C o o o 01 s. A DIt p. v n fo $,m mEf s=m a ro aI_, c m N y N H N• g D p, a 7 a C C n Dt C e�� 7 C Ori, N L. rt C1 m p is ,, O x 3 s x p W L. O O jrn CI Wag* in.g 3 d.o DO ir9p oo° O re 3 S a 0^ A N W 0 •d rn •V 3 n a , to n N C !l Q. w T w i.'s ^' fq m m c` m 0 o 1 m NOLD3dSNI dfl MO1103 031.31dW03 siioyV Iae4P1W C 0 Z m 72 o m. su.toyyl'aeplW T£OTZ£ZZ9:1i99WnN 13DUVd =3INVN 113NM0 09ZZ6 VD `1k13S90 W1Vd tn i A m y m m • M LA C m XI Sflld mina) T1VD :03aa3d311 VONOJ VIA 0090V :SS3a0OV Z9L0-0Z a38Wf1N 3SVD 11IOd311 AHOJ SIH 3SVD G) Et w smog S•E :mull nen le1o1 na� naa .0 iprn m7c-( °mu CO !Ti N m O Cli XI Z - � o NI 23 IV N.)C rsi —i O Id -Cr. n N a w C m w '"' v n Ki - • > 3 Ln - 1 "' z n 11 0 m :31,11tlN 213NM0 09ZZ6 VD 11l13S30 Wltld Sflld )131N3011V] :03aa3d3t1 VQNOd VIA 0090V :SS3 JQQ'd a in xi Om IA m m = Fi noC F. S m XP • (Q N xP I" mO N• N N -I O N 0 n m •pasop ase3'auo8 an sdeq usu.!. NOLL]3d5NI df1 MO110E O31na; sulkpV IaeIpm NOLL 3dSNI1VI11NI 3DNVI1dINO3 NON sul1PV IaepW 13. C rn n n 0 < ID z 80133d5NI w dead» 'auk!. oI}15e A 0 = -a 2. co m o= ID m n O C c ; ri , 5 O y C J N 51 in 6h zn ma 8-o o N A v aO N inA= b 3 CP M^ A .3zNvtA , ro n o- @ 3 5a a y , F Z Aaea m Ip g m O to C 1.01 rom Q=ID re d N O. 2 co 2 - c_o 7 7 7' on f9 A rD 7- 7. o in C G =v d m = on O on ,i in in O c .► , rr S—f .7.-o- 3 n T 0 o n m 9i S A m = m et.-, rt. Q N I- m O al Oro N o al wcr ,C f9 S H g a MOa 0 I ty N 3 n 0 n. 7' n -! N ro O. „7 IA :L A 7 m 'e 7 3930VN :3WVN }13NMO 09ZZ6 VD `J.113S30 WIVd v v crt 4 336 VI CD .p N O m C ,p a en) z0 >0 ld 035010 3SV0:MINIS 8Tb0-OZ a38Wf1N 3SV la0d3)J Aa01SIH 3SV3 n co 7 N savoy S•i :aluLlnelS Ie101 OIOQVO 3930VN :341VN H3NMO 09ZZ6 V3 111:13530 IN1Vd 90OZZEZZ9 :1138141f1N l3]11tld slid 1131N3011VD :d311113d311 035010 3SVD:51111115 m 23 0 Q N O • ? Q FL m O 0 1 r a x m SIVO-OZ U381Nf1N 3SV 12IOd3V AZIOISIH 35V7 � 1 E sIuoiN Iae4PIW smog s•o :awl1lie7S lewoi ij / Erig. - =z tn c ..E�R ;�§&�O �.q#am- 0 A. K7 8a&i11X 2�}m=n - ID-, 2 E = . a §tso i cr ft ■7a; o•aa_n ■Q�.2.0 zV..r■F Me�2■ ; Ea&■ © *417•2 &•O/7g 5 E. 4. 8 E co i . r—0 : 0 g 03 o. § en 0• '9 0' � ZI E(�2 IHHH 0J§. ' E_�,; � 2EQa fi ea �/lu§R CD ,�@ = Om k17». o ,,n, ■�E§- .7}%�7 » 03V103HDS N 031i SIJA tn :3ALLV1111VN On 04-24-20, I received a message from CaII Center Plus, BCN - 20173, in reference to STR COVID19 noise complaint. 0100110 3930VN :3INVN )J3NMO 09ZZ6 VD'1ll3S30 WlVd Sflld k131N301111J :a321113d3u1 03SO1n 3SVD :SfI1tl1S ZVVO-OZ 71381Nf1N 3St10 lUOd3a AaO1SIH 3SV SWOw iaegalw s moq 1 :awLL}nen leeo1 s K Z C 0 3 O O a v' G raj CI 711 m, p 2 mo. • as g ro 0fD N n FL Q. m O. d O f1 1� 3 a E ro 0 0 LIS ro 8 r^ 01 C 0 N z 0 0 { 0 nu O � N N ro o Co 0. 0 A ro NOI133dSN1 an 33NV 51.1.11 in z o � m swLow laegPM 174 O nO m m ays z 35 o•c'.. Y 0 m m o. 3 O M. N C fD 3 Q. ro a N 7' d -, 1 O. ro ?am + c 9 0 air+ att n� o u, ri ID O a rgr 5 S. 61 ro � ro 7 N CL 63 M Jr toK o. m o 3 '° cr m ID ID 4. 0 s a K NOI133dSNI 1VW NI 33NVIld1103 NON LIT a N C g 0 0 swoIN leeg3iw a0133dSNI On 05-15-20, I received a CitySourced OneView Console Request ID# 932528, in reference to a noise complaint. 900ZZ£ZZ9: I]9 gI1N 13DUVd 3930VN :3WVN ZI3NMO n 0 Q 0 09ZZ6 V `l?13530 WlVd S9NIN3HIV9 33anOS A.EI3 :a3l1a3d311 n 'a m 5 7, t..o.� a© -a m al ns r NI o - nj-& r O 4. C Z In ul n as r3.1I 2 V m 03SO10 3SVD :Sn1VIS SSSO-OZ U38W=N 3SV3 11Od3N AIOLS1H 3SV3 frel 0 0 SIJJOW Iae' P!W x a0133dSNI a317nsaa 73 D sWoW Ide4pi1A1 m ryehmggng D N 4 E Oas O m A p 0 3c =•c v00p ` lir�Q1YO n fa e n 2uN n —r,, A N n. N n n O Q. 7 E „�0 c aD tz Oa o �ro M y A m rr I o ;;'0 s ' y r 1 mm co 00 Ou =° III ; R N N C N n "0r ro = al 3 Oi ' go N ., m f l 7 o a. •0 K a a• °N' °: -I rm 3 * m z G o+ 7 to Cto pi o _� ra am c 7in 0 . a a 'I, 01 m m 3 m m L. rno = m AP T3 or m m N Q ii n N �a 5Yto 0 Oa m O ,�� r0 O F. at N n Gat siuoW Iae4�IW 0 110133d5NI a3iln53a x x 0 D 1 w w z VI K N G N o 0to m I to 0 0 0 ; 0 +�i z 0 .► 0 A O O * m 30 C A0. 1 n 313 3 a.- o.to a r Z� Vi .0 C C ^P G r z to y a. N = C V � � a-0 CO o 00 ;= t s o O OCR 0 n•Z$c 5. o rso m OR N El Q. =a 0 a' at t 7 ai ... z a 7 a °' 5 n a CL 01co * N Tr. -.c LN Jr I. a G T R. rt 3 v.Qt1D NOI1.13d5N 33NVIldW1 z On 05-29-20, I received two messages from Host Compliance in reference to a loud noise and music from a pool party. 900ZZEZZ9 :H38Wf1N 1332WVd :3WVN 2H3NMO 09ZZ6 VD 11a3S3G WfVd S9NI83HIV9 $650-OZ H 9LI lfN 3SV3 .1.11Od3a AUO1SIH 3SV3 G1 m � \ 5ILO1A1 Iae'PIIN small l :awl }1EIS 1E401 ■ § in A 0 0 § 0 § NOI173dSNI d!1 M01104 37NYI1dWO3 sumo/ laetPM § § 0 § 0 tee m m 1 ea } o_ra� �20 1t ▪ '''E3, i gvD tn II§ ID 01 ✓ ; �• 7 \■ a §® E� io 0� g IA £ 41 co 0 a 0. B ea 0 .to.j _ / _ 4. co 0 fb 0 ID -c 0 3- m MI @ § § - ro k -n xi 3 E 2 m ▪ m§%o crt ez I 23 KJ 2 2 N ▪ r o 4. 8 mIAcn p t E / ' z n M31NVN 1l3NMO 09ZZ5 V]'1113930 V fVd Sflld MIND Tin :0311113d38 0NV 531111Vd ld 039017 3SV7 :Sf11V1S m 8650-OZ UI391NP1N 3SV:J .HOd3a A IO1SIM 3SV3 .P o. sluoW laeLIMIN smog I :aw0, U S le3o1 NOIL13dSN 03131dWO7 s1JJOW laeip J a c 0 A(0 O O 0s rt N -. O 3 o 0 0 al la Z� Gov 2 11 f yoio [1 co 0 ocr to N n o. a N v 2 3 M p N ro ro ro N O °ta W Si ',Og Q 0 m a Iv q >> ri 0 PI u2i C*•co O ro N re a 2 a N F+ O r° .DO o it 7 a - A I NC 4a C e m Z 7 N a �' 0 0 w OQ1 °O Pr O FIT o O Z w 7 7 N 2 O ro VI ro O1 W N n M O1 In MI 07 R M 7A n 0 Z 1p O MO O OI O d 10 a 0 a '0 I °: a w dm oa MSN0 V N 0 LA 3 m m » a, to w ~ 0- m m `rb n f0 — n a re r _ Y3 m 0 N y y n— m Vf rod, 1 d4 0 7 = 7 O to ro C n H " c m °1 O. = 0 0 IV co = A 0 i�i m N I- v. w y N v 0 m N m 5 0 m _ m E x to Sta m O 7 F1 a o o 0 0. crei 0- 0 ro IT' :3I/J N U3NMO S9NIa3H1119 Sflld /131ND 11VJ :031A3:13/E E m m c4 ta mCA O Z -I c m MI r � D m cz _1 > r m N Z m m O 9 1 N n x m mcli 3o 1 O hJ v a1 a m a �•vN•1ca rr -I m 42. 02 IA C o1 a m tn z o > o 0 91790-0Z MINIM 3SV3 .UIOd3}I AVOISIH 3SV3 sployy 'avow] r your consideration on this matter. ma ra N. ro el z 2 2 C g av ro 2ax'oa"'� o a 3 K pap n 5 7 5f9 s ^ N . f° N a a N N Or 091 N O• N C .... Gp C 7 d CD Q , 4 IP S N 'C s a* A m e m II �cp 3 13 0 0 U 49 i 4. m U a pa �-g ^ 7 5 n@ p C rn al G 2 p7p 3. A C t O~ Z 3 A O s C w �n N 3 o a 3 g 4 2 w ri= rsp 3 H az 7 ro 4. Q,a31 a �wRp7"s cf 0 0 ry G �3p ' 8 R° 33 3 ^^ o ui rp :t ^ a d 0 ey ID S 3 3 N � 3 3 gu li-, N -, - j 0 0 4,04 n ' o O in o ff.d Li mS E. �=F3 a.4 o m to S CI SPr L9IHdyxtaA/aw'quge//:sduy I'm filing a complaint against this property. 40603 Via Fonda, Palm Desert 92260, m39. m rn 0 swim [amplify HOID3d5NI o 3 m S0 A N c^ n Cr CD 0 - 2 C 7 C 2 a ro .71 3 9 d 3 900ZZEZZ9 :H391NfN 137aVd :3INVN H3NMO 09ZZ6 VD `11435301111Vd c) m c Z c Z c 5 c v n Z 1IV101-3 :O3a1134311 VONOW VIA £090b:SS3a00V 1VIN311 Wa311VOHS ad/J. 3S1/3 n m on �73 • n9 E 0 O CD 1 O 0 A m rn oUp a Z m 60L0-0Z 1:1391N11N 3SV3 111Od3d A}OISIH 3SVD 8 02 G C o MBE o to m a,g n 2'° rzv ro et m n 01 m La 3 �i �, obi to o 7 o 0 0 v m ro ro ry, OP m R A .. W .i ui z 3 G, .7r N 0.1 N G ro 0 .. o. � rmi � ^ � ro ro m _ N in o °° c C H o o E fD co w - 0 0. j r° 0� 7 !�* ICD r7r 7 n G F+ O 0. * Et '42 p m Si A- O� a -a S 3 Np [a rri a. C hV+ .9. C -a O ro G ro c$ 0 0 '' � 7 o LiJ °;7 al 0 d a a g CO m m" O z m v, c • = a0. a O O. a N a h n N N N is O mal WI m N 0 �ro ,5.4 � g(an 2_ d ro Q R = d 7 A O ry 2 Ni h 0. a a g �a a o o to r'o to 7 3 m n O Div Or O O N D 7 w 0 O. w N rnCU = 0 o y 0, TO 7 a3 1co a' a OJ; a 01 0. ° S o re P qv, g c gm = N d N Q. YI H agi 0 900ZZEZZ9 :HI39INf1N 1331IVd :31N1N }I3NMO 09ZZ6 V3 '183930 INIVd S9NIa3H1V9 lIVW1 :038t13d31:1 WNW VIA E09017:SS311JQV UNV S311HVd anoi AlfltINf :3dA18f15 3SV3 1V1N3H INH311ZIOHS :3dA1.35V7 60LO-OZ U39Wf1N 3SV3 111Od321 AJOJSIH 3SVD c m N 03.13141103 P 3 m 0.0 0..* 0 m=oo= 0 . m pi, �+ p 8 ae+ g o o 2 O,r, m 0 a N a m -= 0 to 2 „'-° °, ti O d m K a. o ra c n a Cq"1Coamm a'm 0 c c p O c -h•*L. -o o $ i.obi .o O to ': d 0 m N c. ar R 0 aaO 2; 0" rz° re g' m 0 m d 3 0 3' .. m — m ?,v m op -v 5 0 ha M m c y co C— y m N C h zu, m p O rar. roC ID 0. m c rra m m o.g9 m 0. a a7 0 0 c re 0 ,r, 0 7 re 7i. h T ° 0 0 3 0 a 3 H 0 o.a =04 N C m 3 NOI173dSNI dl1 33NVI1dI d10133d5NI sl.uoyJ Regain a o m: m :0.-1r :4° `"z3m%: aao a o+ m v1 m 0 $ N >ri M v, 6h1 0 c. m LHJU �' o Val' `ni f o r. C h m 0- S C N m ,.. Q a I F N 0 .@v 'O m a m a .0 g 0 00 0^ m 0 0 O . N �' rya 9 ; a N oa 0.. m o 3 m y m 5 5 ID ��7. 10 fa s v 3 '" m h n m b C. 0 1 M al y am1 n se Q' 0 in113 PP h .0r. 5 di in oa O. p 5 a1 m .'r d › 0 C S 3 ey1 0 �N aa1 riT _ a • n y G 0 0 cc w 0 0. pi, 7.. N 7, • 0 o X. t S " O 0 Y1 0 N C 0 a o m R alal :2. _. a m .... m o fa Er m m a o 0 0 7 4A S Gi 0 c 0 a .. a1 a7 7 N 0 aA 4 0 I• K0 w 0 0 0. y, 0 -02-s = n m s m sr,a�s 0. o ma m 0 z 1 900ZZEZZ9 :11391A111N 13DHVd :31#11VN 2I3NMO 09ZZ6 VD `1a3530 WIVd S9NI83HJ.V9 lIVIN-3 :03Ht1333a VONOJ VIA £090b:SS3a00V ONV 53111:1Vd anal A1flHN C C •• m m 60L0-OZ a38 W f N 3SV3 I11Od311 AUIOISIH 3SVD GI m w I i E SWOW laey31141 may g :awm 33e351 e;o1 NOLLD dSNI df1 M011od § o m 900ZZEZZ9 :1138WflN 73DHVd :3WVN U3NMO S9NIa3H1V9 l lYW-3 :0311113J3H1 3AWW :sf ivls ■ / July 23, 2020 To The Palm Desert City Council Residents in the Hovely Lane West neighborhood are experiencing Short Term Rental deja vu 2017. The resident STR complaints and operator arguments are the same today as they were in 2017. The city council banned STRs in R1 & R2 zones in 2017 after considering the same types of testimony. The purpose of this letter is to advise the council about what our neighborhood group wants the council to do regarding STRs in the HLW neighborhood. We have expressed our unhappiness about STR operations in our neighborhood in other messages to the council and city staff. We are living in a STR perfect storm. The Governor has issued a stay at home order. STRs are a lucrative business and very popular as a safe way to vacation. And the city code compliance department is short two officers on the day shift. We are asking the city council to change the HLW neighborhood to the R1 zoning standard. We are not asking to change the STR ordinance in any way. The city has acknowledged that our neighborhood functions the same as R1. We want to enjoy the same protections from STRs as the R1 and R2 residents. There are no new wheels to be invented. The city has a model from 2017 for including single family home residents in the R1 standard. The model starts with an initiation of a new permit moratorium. Move the administrative process forward to the formal hearings to change the HLW neighborhood zone to R1. We expect there to be a sunset period for the active STRs to move their operations outside of the HLW neighborhood. In 2017 the council provided a two year sunset period. Since our request is a much smaller scale, we are asking for the sunset period to be less than one year. The Homeowner Application For Short -Term Rental Permit includes the following language: By applying for and accepting a Short Term Rental permit, Applicant acknowledges that the City of Palm Desert is conducting, on an ongoing basis, a comprehensive review of regulations of Short Term Rentals (STR) within the City. Any changes to City's regulation of STRs will likely apply to this permit. Applicant acknowledges that the City has decided to largely eliminate STR activity in R1 and R2 zones by January, 2020 and may likely decide to extend that ban to other residential areas not governed by a functioning homeowners association, and permits issued in those areas after January 16, 2018, may be terminated. The City may decide to further severely limit or eliminate STR activity, and may decide not to renew STR permits on an annual basis. Applicant acknowledges that a STR permit does not authorize activity when property restrictions imposed by CCRs or similar property restrictions prohibit such activity and that any STR permit is subject to revocation if the City determines that the permitted property is subject to any such restrictions. July 23, 2020 The city had the foresight to anticipate the need for additional restrictions and put applicants on notice that their permit may need to be discontinued. Can this language be applied to our zone change request and streamline the administrative process? The city uses the number of STR permits, complaints and citations to measure the impact of STRs. We think the number of residents nearby each STR should be included in this analysis. In 2017 the city improved the enforcement process and resources. Our experience with complaint enforcement gives us little confidence that irresponsible STR operators and renters will be cited to a level that will return our neighborhood to the peace and quiet we once enjoyed. Prohibiting STRs is the only option that will give us day to day confidence that we will not have our lives disrupted by short term renters. STRs are a business. Businesses of all types must constantly adapt and adjust to new requirements. Prohibiting STRs in our neighborhood will require them to sell the property and relocate to another location. Renting the property seasonally or longterm is another option. Assuming there will be a sunset period they will have time to make these adjustments. The TOT revenue from the current 26 STRs in our neighborhood is about 2% based on the total number of STRs in Palm Desert. Home sales and prices are increasing in Palm Desert. It is reasonable to expect that many of the STRs will relocate and restart their operations. The paragraph below is taken from the STR home page on the city web site: The City recognizes that despite the new ordinance, short-term rentals will continue to impact our community in ways both good and bad. We are committed to doing what we can to reduce negative impacts while respecting the rights of home and property owners and preserving the neighborhoods that help make up the fabric of our community. Please restore and preserve our neighborhood. Thank you for considering our request, James and Senoleen Bantley 73540 Terraza Dr Bobby & Becky Gray 73548 Terraza Dr Bill and Cheryl Bester 73554 Terraza Drive July 23, 2020 Steve and Tiffany Matheson 40590 Glenwood Ln Richard Kluth and Tim Landherr 40750 Clover Ln Jim & Gladys Bersamin 40585 Meadow Lane Diana and Bob McGinity 40501 Meadow Lane John and Carlie Stanley 40528 Meadow Lane Rebecca Flanagan 40613 Diamondback Dr Mike and Sandy McGraff 40612 Diamondback Dr Richard Feldman 40640 Diamondback Dr Nancy Nowak and William Choplin 40669 Diamondback Dr Robyn and Steve Nagle 40697 Diamondback Dr Mark Bayer, M.D, Carol Bayer, MFT 40712 Via Fonda Barbara Norman and Alan Franks 40632 Via Fonda Scott and Courtney Halterlein 40580 Via Fonda Nicholas M. Latkovic 40629 Via Fonda Robert and Carol Klatskin 40625 Cabana Ct July 23, 2020 Larry & Susan Megorden 40688 Cabana Court Mark and Susan Wasson 40620 Baranda Ct Brenda Berman 40840 Avenida Calafia Cliff Sanforth 40783 Sandpiper Ct Swartz, Kevin From: Information Mail Sent: Wednesday, July 08, 2020 1:58 PM To: Code Hotline; Swartz, Kevin; Ortega, Niamh Cc: Hermann, David Subject: Fw: Residents Short Term Rental Distress Good Afternoon, We have received the following message regarding short term rentals through the City's informational e-mail. The message was also e-mailed directly to the individual members of the City Council. Thank You, Brianne From: William Choplin <wchoplin@icloud.com> Sent: Wednesday, July 8, 2020 1:07 PM To: Nestande, Gina; Kelly, Kathleen; Information Mail; Jonathan, Sabby; Harnik, Jan; Weber, Susan Marie Subject: Residents Short Term Rental Distress Dear City Council Members, We have been residents of Palm Desert since 2015. When we moved here we had no Short Term Rentals (STR) on our street and now we have 4 with permits and 4 more with permits on the street immediately to the west. The street immediately to our east has 1 with a permit and 2 other STRs in operation but we don't know their permit status. We are very concerned about the growth of STRs in our neighborhood. We become anxious every time a house goes up for sale. We've noticed the advertisements for some houses for sale include "great property for Short Term Rental". We were part of the 2017 effort to remove STRs from R1/R2 zones and mistakenly believed our neighborhood was included. In talking to Kevin Swartz in zoning, we understand that Council Members realize that we function as R1. We believe our neighborhood should be included under the R-1 standard. 1n February the house next door to us began renting and our life has become a daily torment. Every weekend is a party weekend. Every day we live with the fear and uncertainty of who will be in that house, how much noise we will have to endure, cars parked on the street and trash on the property. Along with many of our neighbors we are calling in our complaints to the the STR hotline and the Palm Desert Service App. We are getting no satisfaction especially in regards to noise. Our feeling is that the process we are trying to navigate is inconsistent, subjective and we receive no feedback on the outcome of any investigation unless we follow up. Pedro Rodriguez advised us that they use the measure "not common in a neighborhood setting" to determine if renters are violating regulations. He gave a family playing in the pool as an example of noise common to a neighborhood. We agree. But it is not common to have a pool party every day of the week. And most of the noise is not families playing in the pool. Our quality of life is now terrible. Instead of enjoying the beauty of Palm Desert and our lovely neighborhood we are bombarded with noise and strangers and trash. We are over 65 and because we are high risk for COVID we are home all day and all night except for essential shopping. We are being exposed to strangers and their outrageous behavior on a daily basis. 1 We are reaching out to you for support and help in the following areas: 1. Make enforcement effective. It leans toward favoring the STR not your residents. Residents have to make a huge effort to get any results. We understand code compliance is short staffed. If they do not have the staff to effectively enforce STR regulations, the city should close STRs until staffing is adequate. STRs should also be closed due the high number of cases of Covid-19 in Riverside County. 2. Inaccurate records. We have received reports on complaints from Keven Swartz and appreciate his willingness to work with us. We have shared these reports with neighbors and we know the numbers are not accurate as they have called with complaints that are not included in these reports. 3. Deal with the party house next door (40641 Diamondback Dr). We and our neighbors have made numerous complaints about noise. The efforts of code compliance are ineffective based on the standards they use. We feel helpless and avoid engaging in the complaint reporting process because it takes our time and increases our blood pressure for no relief. We are imploring you to help us and deal with this party house. No one should be expected to live like this on an ongoing basis in a normally quiet neighborhood. 4. Include Hovely Lane West under the R-1 standard for STRs. Make our beautiful neighborhood a stable, welcoming place to live in again. Let us know know when it would be best to talk with you. Due to COVID we are glad to do a Zoom meeting and include other angry and frustrated neighbors to work with you to solve these problems. Nancy Nowak and William Choplin 40669 Diamondback Dr 801.597.9764 Rebecca Flanagan 40613 Diamondback Dr Mike and Sandy McGraff 40612 Diamondback Dr Richard Feldman 40640 Diamondback Dr 2 Swartz, Kevin From: Information Mail Sent: Wednesday, July 22, 2020 11:01 AM To: Swartz, Kevin; Ortega, Niamh Cc: Hermann, David Subject: Fw: Request for Action Good Morning, We have received another e-mail from a Hovely Lane resident regarding STR zoning. Thank You, Brianne From: Cliff <diamond@socal.rr.com> Sent: Wednesday, July 22, 2020 10:30 AM To: Information Mail Subject: Request for Action We join our neighbors in their REQUEST FOR ACTION to change the streets along Hovely Lane West with single family homes to the R1 standard and stop short term rentals in our neighborhood. I fail to see why you didn't include our neighborhood when you banned str's in 2017. Since moving here in 2015 several homes have sold on our small street and become str's changing the nature of our neighborhood. Even now homes advertised for sale include the information that str's are permitted. With other cities banning them we are going to get even more. Not fair to this family oriented neighborhood. Help us please. Sincerely, Clifford Sanforth 40783 Sandpiper Ct., Palm Desert, CA 92260 1 To: Palm Desert City Council Members Subject: Open a Request for Action Dear Palm Desert City Council Members: My wife and I have been residents of Palm Desert since January of 2012. Following a 32 year active duty Army career and a follow-on 8 year career in academia engaged with educating the next generation of military physicians and graduate level nurses, we decided to relocate to Palm Desert to be close to our two children who live in Temecula and San Diego. During my 32 years on active duty, I had 17 different assignments that took me to places around the world and throughout the United States. Our dream for post -retirement was to settle in a community and a neighborhood where we knew our neighbors, respected each other's ownership and order and would Iook out for each other's well-being and needs. We found that neighborhood off of West Hovley Lane and settled into a very enjoyable setting. Then a few years ago, a house three doors from us sold to an out of town owner to be used as a short term rental. Two years later, the house directly across the street from us and directly across the street from the other short term rental sold to another owner as a short term rental. Our enjoyable, safe and quiet neighborhood has never been the same since. We now have a continual and steady turnover of large short term rental groups that regularly have loud parties, loud music and fill our quiet street with a multitude of cars. One weekend at just one of the rentals, 17 cars were parked on the street supporting the huge party being hosted in the backyard of the short term rental. This is not the neighborhood we bought into and certainly not the living environment we were hoping for at this point in our lives. It is our understanding that the Palm Desert City Council banned short term rentals in 2017 but "excluded" Hovley Lane West neighborhoods. Why our City Council would exclude our neighborhoods in favor of supporting those out of town owners who buy up houses for short term rental purposes eludes us. We are VERY hopeful that you will correct this unfortunate decision made back in 2017. We are requesting that the Palm Desert City Council open a Request For Action to correct this omission and change the streets in our neighborhoods with single family homes to the R1 standard. We love Palm Desert and the many opportunities it offers. However, short term rentals have made our lives in these quiet neighborhoods a living hell. My wife and I are requesting that you do the right thing and support us in this request so we can live in environments that drove us to select these wonderful neighborhoods in the first place. Thank you for considering our sincere request and thank you also for your service to our community. William T. Bester Brigadier General (Ret) U.S. Army Swartz, Kevin From: Information Mail Sent: Tuesday, July 21, 2020 7:21 AM To: Swartz, Kevin; Ortega, Niamh Cc: Hermann, David Subject: Fw: Short Term Rental Issues Good Morning, We have received the following message regarding STR through the City's informational e-mail. It was also sent to the City Council. Thank You, Brianne From: KW TC <kwmytc@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, July 20, 2020 5:15 PM To: Harnik, Jan; Nestande, Gina; Jonathan, Sabby; Weber, Susan Marie; Kelly, Kathleen; Information Mail Subject: Short Term Rental Issues Dear City Council Members - My wife and I purchased a home on Glenwood Lane last Fall, and have been greatly shocked and saddened at the level of noise, trash and traffic that has been generated from the short term rentals around us as of late. There seem to be no less than 4 STRs in the homes immediately surrounding us, which is an excessive amount of rentals for such a small area of a residential neighborhood, and at least two of them have become a real problem. The worst one is right next door to us, as the owner has rented it out almost every night of the week to parties of seemingly 10 people or more, who congregate in the back yard in the evening to play very loud music, scream and laugh loudly (often including profanity), and in many cases smoke pot into the night, all of which is a concern not only because it devastates the quiet enjoyment of our home and keeps us awake at night, but it disturbs my two young children who are forced to be a part of the sounds and smells emanating nightly from the property. They have also packed our street with vehicles, and have even used our trash cans several times in an attempt to deal with the debris from their parties. All of this is unacceptable! I have had to call the police several times, until learning about the STR hotline which we then began to employ, and have had great success with that but we are definitely concerned about this ongoing problem, as are many of our neighbors. We have no desire to continue calling the police on a weekly basis and wasting their valuable time, and much less do we feel we should have to continue putting up with this level of disturbance. I have spoken to several of our neighbors and they are also very concerned, one of them mentioning to me the other day that he has nowhere to go in his own home to get away from all of the constant noise. Please let us know that this email has been received, and if you need any further information from us in order to take the appropriate actions. Thank you so much, we love Palm Desert and are so thankful that you all care so much about our beautiful city and its residents. Steve Swartz, Kevin From: Nestande, Gina Sent: Monday, July 20, 2020 7:20 PM To: Bridget Zappia; Swartz, Kevin Subject: Re: Short Term Rentals in our neighborhood Hello Bridget, Mr. Kevin Swartz from our staff team should be contacting you regarding the code violations. Gina Nestande Mayor Ph: 760.346.0611 Direct: 760.776.6312 gnestande@cityofpalmdesert.org From: Bridget Zappia <mrsbzappia@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, July 20, 2020 2:41 PM To: Nestande, Gina Subject: Short Term Rentals in our neighborhood Hello Council Member Nestande: am writing to you for direction on the matter of short term rentals in my neighborhood on Hovley Lane West. This is a neighborhood that runs between Portola and Monterey. HELP! On our short block alone there are two "party" houses. Ugh! Living in neighborhoods with people you see on a daily basis, one can have a secure feeling of safety in a home. However, with strangers renting houses on the block for the weekend, makes one feel insecure. Makes a "neighborhood watch program" difficult to run when one often sees unfamiliar faces and cars. These homes have renters who are in party mode, and do not think twice about the neighbors that live here year round. Music is blasting, conversations are loud and the pot smoke is wafting over the fences. Their guests leave their trash (i.e. empty beverage cups, fast food packaging) in the street beside their parked cars and then just drive away. Would you like to live in a neighborhood like this? I find it to be a hard selling point. People say to call the city's compliance code hotline to leave a message, but I fear retaliation from the owners of these properties since they are running a business in the neighborhood. 1 come to you to gain direction. Is my neighborhood not worthy to be called a residential neighborhood (R1/R2)? What can be done? I appreciate your time and consideration of this matter. Sincerely, Mrs. Zappia 1 July 19, 2020 To: Palm Desert City Council Members: Gina Nestande, Jan Harnik, Kathleen Kelly, Sabby Jonathan, Susan Weber From: Larry Megorden, 40688 Cabana Court, Palm Desert, 92260 (760) 610-5024, Imegorden@vahoo.com Re: Hovely Lane West — Short term rentals Cc: banstrsalonghlw@icloud.com We moved full-time to Palm Desert on 10/10/10 from Seattle. We searched carefully for a neighborhood and a home where we could live safely and comfortably as we grow old (we are in our mid -seventies). In the 1990's we owned a second home in Palm Valley CC, that experience helped in our decision to seek a regular neighborhood without guard gates and with full-time residents. We live on a quiet cul-de-sac that has twelve homes; all home are occupied by full-time residents. We have two doctors, a golf professional (Big Horn CC) and a number of retired couples. We know all of our neighbors and could not be happier with our beautiful street and wonderful neighbors. Our corner neighbor is moving to Seattle and we are very concerned that their house will be sold to a STR investor. I understand that our neighborhood was missed when The Palm Desert City Council banned Short Term Rentals in 2017; some kind of zoning error. We are asking the City Council to please open a Request for Action regarding this issue, to correct the omission and change the streets with single family homes to the R1 standard. Our immediate neighborhood has really been hurt by allowing STR's. We have two homes close to us that have dramatically changed our neighborhood. These homes are being used for parties, filled with party -goers, cars parked everywhere, loud music, rude loud people and followed by piles of trash that sits alongside of the houses for days (our CCR's don't allow trash cans to be seen from the street). Our hearts are sick for our dear neighbors who, for no fault of their own, find themselves living next door to an STR. It should be easy for anyone to see that the Hovely Lane West community should have been included in the 2017 decision to ban short term rentals. The two homes are located on Via Fonda (40600 & 40603). We are respectfully asking (begging) for your help. There is absolutely no way to change the behavior of the renters, they pay big money to rent big houses to throw big parties. They are not concerned about the neighbors nor should they be; they came for a few days of fun and they could care less about the neighbors. The only hope we have is to prevent investors from purchasing homes and converting them to short term rentals. We must also find a way to reverse the decision to allow the current homes from renting short term. Please, please help. Swartz, Kevin From: James & Gladys<sandtreasuresandmore@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, July 20, 2020 11:50 AM To: Swartz, Kevin Cc: banstrsalonghlw@icloud.com Subject: 40697 Meadow Lane Attachments: IMG_20200720_105154 jpg; IMG_20200720_105148jpg Kevin please check property 40697 Meadow Lane. https:llwww.airbnb.com/rooms! 18207753?location=Palm%20Springs%20Desert&source impression id=p3 1 595269840 2n0t1AapudFOc%2FiX&guests=1 &adults=1 This is a hidden property we believe being operated by a Airbnb super host from 40588. This woman is very sneaky. The photos of front of house is not shown but the photos provided are from redfin or Zillow. ALSO REFERANCE THE ABOVE AIRBNB LINK. The owner is not there and we have seen several different cars parked over the last couple of months. This is very irritating. Also 40588 host is also allowing her guests to secretly park there cars in front of other homes down the street mainly between house 40669 and 40641. The home owners of 40669 are good friends with the superhost from 40588. Carole is a really sneaky lady and we had several confrontations over the years she has yelled at us from time to time when I questioned her actions. FYI THERE IS A VEHICLE WE BELIEVE IS ASSOCIATED WITH 40588 DOWN THE STREET. SHE IS ALSO NOT DOING THE 24 HOUR WAIT PERIOD. THIS WOMAN NEEDS TO BE STOPPED SHE ALSO SOMETIMES PARKS HER CARS ALSO AT 40613 IN DRIVEWAY WHEN PEOPLE ARE NOT HOME. WHY IS THIS BEING ALLOWED ?? JIM & GLADYS 1 Swartz, Kevin From: Ortega, Niamh Sent: Monday, July 20, 2020 10:32 AM Cc: Code Hotline; Swartz, Kevin Subject: FW: Hovely Lane West Rezone to R1 Attachments: 20200717_220201_1 (1).mp4; 20200717_220052_1 (1) (2).mp4 From: Rebecca Flanagan [mailto:cvtaflanagan@gmail.com] Sent: Monday, July 20, 2020 9:55 AM To: CityhallMail <Cityhall@cityofpalmdesert.org> Subject: Hovely Lane West Rezone to R1 To Whom This Concerns: I am a resident in the Hovely West Area and I'm writing to implore you to rezone our neighborhood to an R1. The houses in this area are not in a HOA and therefore are not protected against the influx of short term rentals. It has become a continuous flow of dozens of people, parties all week long and throughout the entire weekend. These are not just families having company over. These are places people rent strategically to have lots of people, play loud music, drink lots of alcohol (we know because they yell about how drunk they are)and get raucous in the pool. It is unfair to the other neighbors who work, have to get up in the morning and would like to enjoy their houses without listening to a loud party not just on the weekend but all -week long. This short term rental always has more than the allotted cars because it doesn't allow use of the garage. Almost every time it is rented, we see many cars parking off the site at the Temple and other streets like Palm Ct. With all the closures, this rental is very busy with at least 3 different groups of people from week to week and barely one day between rentals. We are tired of calling and making reports to Code Compliance only to be told we don't have valid complaints because the officer can't hear the music from inside his truck and more than150 feet away. We are tired of hearing that WE are the problem when this issue came to light several years ago when STRs were banned in Residential neighborhoods. We are tired of loud screaming people, music and unruly people that come to this house for one reason, to vacation and party. Two weeks ago, I sent a letter, slide show and evidence of the noise, overflowing trash and parking violations to Mr. Rodriguez, but he never replied! This past weekend was extremely bad again with parties that started at 11 AM and went until 3 AM! Their idea of quiet is to blast music from inside their house and that seems to be fine with Code Enforcement while we hear the bass inside our own houses. We have to document the noise for your officers and even then, sometimes they decide not to go and ask loud guests to be quiet. The 55 limit decibel stated in the City's code is never enforced objectively because the officers sit on the other side of the street when the noise is in my backyard and house. They also argue about what type of noise can exceed the limit, like screaming teenagers. It seems short-term rental people have more rights to party than I do to live in my house. I am in fear every Tuesday and Friday as to what mayhem we will have to endure when the new renters come. We moved to Diamondback Drive in 2014 and had a very quiet, peaceful neighborhood except for a couple of rentals on our street a few years back.(we made complaints but I guess they were erased) 1 When the house next door sold to people from out of state, they immediately started renting it and it is now an utter nightmare to live in my house. There has not been one weekend since the beginning of June, that we have been able to enjoy the serenity of our own home without being subjected to a loud raucous party and rude guests who play music louder and yell "f@#k the neighbors," when they are asked to be respectful. My neighbors and I are begging you to stop this detriment to our health and well being. This constant gathering of different people is sure to add to the spread of COVID and moreover, deeply affects the people who live, work, and pay taxes in this neighborhood. It is hard to understand why these rentals are allowed to operate when the rest of the Palm Desert businesses including City Hall, have been shut down. This is maddening and so I beg you to please immediately stop this rental from operating and rezone our Hovely Lane West area to an R1 and include us in the Short - Term Rental Ban. I have attached videos of lewd language, evidence of inebriation and the nightmare we live through now. If you need any more evidence of this blight, let me know -I have a redundancy of the same issues documented. Sincerely, Rebecca Flanagan Below are the City Codes that are violated REPEATEDLY and the ad where there is NO MENTION of any city ordinances in the ad listed online. I attached two videos of after 10 pm when we had to call the city again and these renters ignored the quiet hours completely. Why do we have to resort to calling the police who have more important things to do because the city is not maintaining its own ordinances? REPEATEDLY VIOLATED City Ordinances The following shall be clearly identified in any advertisement: (1) the maximum overnight occupancy of the short-term rental unit; (2) requirements for compliance with the city's noise standards and regulations; and (3) a statement that the short-term rental unit occupants shall respect the neighbors' privacy and enjoyment of their property. D. The operator shall use reasonably prudent business practices to ensure that the occupants and/or guests of the short-term rental unit do not create unreasonable noise in violation of Palm Desert Municipal Code (PDMC) Chapter 9.24, Noise Control or disturbances, engage in disorderly conduct, or violate any applicable law, rule or regulation pertaining to the use and occupancy of the subject short-term rental unit . E. Occupants of the short-term rental unit shall comply with all standards and regulations of the PDMC, including and especially Chapter 9.24, Noise Control, and Chapter 9.25, Multiple Responses to Loud or Unruly Parties, Gatherings or Other Similar Events. J. All parking associated with a short-term rental unit shall be entirely onsite, in the garage, carport, and driveway or otherwise off of the public street. G. Public Nuisance. It shall be a public nuisance for any person to commit, cause or maintain a violation of this chapter, which shall be subject to the provisions of Chapter 9.24, Noise Control, and Chapter 9.25, Multiple Responses to Loud or Unruly Parties, Gatherings or Other Similar Events. (Ord. 1345 § 5, 2019; Ord. 1332 § 2, 2017) (https://www.citvofpalmdesert.orq/home/showdocument?id=27242) Here is the AD for the rental on Diamondback which mentions NO ORDINANCES including noise or parking.! 2 Stylish desert home w/ private outdoor pool & .spa - close to golf' The Palm Desert Serenity Palms Retreat is an exquisite property with something for everyone. Much care and comfort have been put into this immaculate home with plenty of living space that gives it a .sprawling feel. The friendly design is clean and fresh while the finest materials keep it warm, cozy and classy. The furnishings give comfort to both the sophisticated and the laid-back visitors, making the home suitable for the most sophisticated, chic traveler, the most desert seeking vacationer or the average family. Musicians, actors, award -winning writers, families, couples and artists have vacationed here in the Desert and have fallen in love with the surroundings. This is desert living in every sense - with flowing open spaces, indoor/outdoor living, patios and a pool/spa. What's Nearby: Palm Desert is rich with golf clubs, and this home sits only a mile away from its closest resort, Monterey Country Club, so be sure to pack your golf clubs! For a learning experience of the local culture, you can drive about three miles south to Palm Springs Art Museum in Palm Desert. To get an urban taste of the local botany and wildlife, visit The Living Desert Zoo and Gardens just five and a half miles south of the home. The canyons and national park surrounding the city has a plethora of hiking trails for those wanting to experience the desert scene more authentically. Things to know: Free WiFi Full kitchen (with dishwasher) Private pool/spa Central AC * Please note that the pool or spa can be heated (not both) for an additional fee of $90 per day plus tax; 24 hours advance notice and a three -night minimum stay are required for this service You must be 21 years or older to rent this property. Property permit ID: STR2020-0023 Rebecca Flanagan 3 Swartz, Kevin From: Information Mail Sent: Monday, July 20, 2020 8:15 AM To: Swartz, Kevin; Ortega, Niamh Cc: Hermann, David Subject: Fw: STRs — HLW Neighborhoods — R1 Zoning Importance: High Good Morning, We have received the following message regarding STR zoning through the City's informational e-mail. Thank You, Brianne From: MWoulfe <bagmdiva@gmail.com> Sent: Saturday, July 18, 2020 10:53 AM To: Nestande, Gina; Harnik, Jan; Kelly, Kathleen; Jonathan, Sabby; Weber, Susan Marie; Information Mail Subject: STRs ' HLW Neighborhoods ^' R1 Zoning Dear City Council Members of Palm Desert _ We are property owners on Corte Placitas and have been permanent residents for over 101/2 years in the Hovley Lane West neighborhood. We URGE YOU (City Council Members of Palm Desert) TO OPEN A REQUEST FOR ACTION TO CHANGE THE STREET5 WITH SINGLE FAMILY HOMES TO THE R1 STANDARD IN THE HOVLEY LANE WEST NEIGHBORHOOD!. Thank You Thomas & May Woulfe Corte Placitas Palm Desert CA 92260 1 Swartz, Kevin From: Information Mail Sent: Monday, July 20, 2020 8:10 AM To: Ortega, Niamh; Swartz, Kevin Cc: Hermann, David Subject: Fw: R1 standard for HLW neighborhood Good Morning, The following message was received through the City's informational e-mail. It looks like they also sent it to the City Council's individual e-mail addresses. Thank You, Brianne From: Tootie Killingsworth <jemark2@aol.com> Sent: Sunday, July 19, 2020 3:58 PM To: gnestande@cityof palmdesert.org; jharnik@cityof palmdesert.org; Kelly, Kathleen; sjonathan@cityof palmdesert.org; sweber@cityof palmdesert.org; info@cityof palmdesert.org Cc: Tootie Killingsworth Subject: R1 standard for HLW neighborhood July 19, 2020 To: Palm Desert City Council Members: Gina Nestande, Jan Harnik, Kathleen Kelly, Sabby Jonathan, Susan Weber and City Information office From: Tootle (Mary) Killingsworth 40595 Cabana Court, Palm Desert, 92260 (760) 340-0524 jemark2@aol.com Re: Hovely Lane West — Short term rentals It has been loudly and very disruptively brought to my attention of the Short Term Rentals that are popping up in my neighborhood. It is my understanding that our neighborhood was missed when The Palm Desert City Council banned Short Term Rentals in 2017; some kind of zoning error. We are asking the City Council to please open a Request for Action regarding this issue, to correct the omission and change the streets with single family homes to the R1 standard. I am requesting that the HLW neighborhoods be included in the R1 zoning standard. It is also my understanding that the Palm Desert Council is meeting in two weeks and this issue could be brought to the floor and corrected. Our immediate neighborhood most certainly has been hurt by allowing STR's. There are two homes Tess than a block from me that have dramatically changed our neighborhood. These homes are used for parties, filled with party -goers, cars parked everywhere, loud music, rude loud people and followed by piles of trash. The noise level is high enough to be heard inside our house. I would appreciate your action with the R1 zoning and to respond to my email. TK Swartz, Kevin From: chrismillsap@remax.net <remaxchelan@gmaii.com> Sent: Tuesday, July 14, 2020 11:12 AM To: Stendell, Ryan; Rodriguez, Pedro; Swartz, Kevin; codehotline@cityofpaalmdesert.org Subject: 40641 Diamondback Drive, Palm Desert, STR This message contains suspicious characteristics and has originated from outside your organization To whom it may concern, My husband and I are the owners of the home at 40641 Diamondback Dr, Palm Desert CA. We purchased the home as a second home to enjoy the winters with a little spring and fall thrown in. We have spent a substantial amount of money furnishing it beautifully for ourselves. We have spent around $40,000 more in adding solar to the home so that we could have more of a worry free home that we could enjoy. When purchasing the home we verified that it was in an area where it is zoned to allow for Short Term Vacation Rentals. Our intent was never to actually use the home as a vacation rental but wanted the option if there was a need and also for resale value. Again, our intent was not to rent out the home, but as you know, life has changed in the last few months and this is a necessity for us. We live in the community of Lake Chelan, in Washington, a vacation destination where there are Short Term Rentals everywhere. We totally understand that sometimes renters can be bad and non caring of the neighbors or the property itself. We get it. There are times when we have to call on the renters, but it is a rare event. You and I both know that a STR get a few calls but not a lot. And as you know, when guests are told to tone it down, they usually do. It is my understanding that our neighbors are relentless and are harassing us and our tenants. We are trying very hard to stay within the laws/rules set forth by the City of Palm Desert. Not only do you get phone calls at all hours, but so are we and on top of that we are getting emails from one neighbor specifically William ChopIin that are just plain hateful and rude. I have given Mr. Choplin my phone number (mistake) and my email address (2nd mistake) so that we can get in the middle if there is a problem. Some quotes from Mr Choplin's emails: We are quite dismayed that you opened a small business next to us. Your small business has turned into our daily torment. It's just wrong we have to suffer this way and I don't see you doing anything about it. We have not been impressed with the code enforcement officer responding to the hotline calls. I did receive an email from Vacasa and this is what it says: I had a great conversation with the code compliance officer. He has been on duty since this whole thing started and is on duty every Thursday through Sunday. On this call he admitted that not one time have the guests been out of compliance- besides the parking issue which was resolved immediately on site. Every other call, the Guest was found to be in complete compliance with all rules. The officer stated that the reason he has not contacted us was because no rules have been broken and we have nothing to worry about. He suggested that if the guests are continuously harassed by the neighbors by taking matters into their own hands (knocking on doors at 11 at night, yelling at guests and their children from behind the fence, etc...) We contact the Palm Desert police department and file for harassment. Also, your neighbor called me today stating that guests were in compliance with noise ordinance times, However they don't agree that the time should be as late as it is. He essentially asked that we make our own rules to enforce by making quiet times earlier than 7 PM. I told him that this is not something we would be able to do, however we would reiterate to our guests that it is a residential area and to please be respectful. My guess i is that he will continue to call the hotline even while the guests are in compliance (like he did tonight), however we have nothing to worry about as the compliance officer agrees that no rules have been broken so there is nothing to enforce. I hope that brings some clarity to the issues. So what I would like to know is what can I do to stop the harassment of the neighbors to Me, Vacasa, The City of Palm Desert and the STRenters? I have rights as well as a taxpayer in this beautiful city. In the end we would love a peaceful resolution to this matter, but I am certainly not opposed to legal action if that is what it takes. I will not be bullied by the neighbors. We will be installing cameras around the home to create a safe environment for us and our guests. It is sad, the neighbors on both sides and across the street seemed so nice until we mentioned we may be renting out our home for a while. Your immediate response is requested. The harassment has to stop. 1�1 CHAIRMAN'S Chris Millsap, Owner/Designated Broker CRS, ABR, SFR, CDPE, CSSN RFJMAX Advantage Lake Chelan 11rff Mobile: 509) 860-7863 Fax: (866) 204-1163 Email: chrismillsap@rcmax.net HAMONK LL •IE 2 Swartz, Kevin From: Information Mail Sent: Monday, July 20, 2020 8:16 AM To: Swartz, Kevin; Ortega, Niamh Cc: Hermann, David Subject: Fw: STR's off Hovley Lane Good Morning, The following is another message regarding STR that was also sent to the City Council. Thank You, Brianne From: Mary Suarez <maryesuarez@yahoo.com> Sent: Friday, July 17, 2020 8:59 PM To: Nestande, Gina; Harnik, Jan; Kelly, Kathleen; Jonathan, Sabby; Weber, Susan Marie; Information Mail Subject: STR's off Hovley Lane Hello City Council Members, My name is Mary Suarez and my husband and I are RESIDENTS of Palm Desert and we LIVE ON Corte Placitas, right off Hovley Lane. I received a pink flyer this evening at my door telling neighbors to call Hotlines and complain about STR's in the neighborhood. We also OWN (2) Short Term Rentals off Hovley Lane, one on Meadow and one on Centennial Circle. We bought Centennial back in 2016, lived there for almost 2 years then began to Short Term Rent it and we've NEVER HAD ONE ISSUE, EVER with our home at 40935 Centennial Circle. When we bought our home on Meadow Lane, (40500) it was going to be our permanent residence, however after fixing it up it was too small for us so we decided to buy another house on Corte Placitas and make that house our residence and we would just STR Meadow lane. Well, ever since that decision, we've had neighbors who decided that they didn't want a STR so they did nothing but create problems. My husband and I have been STR our homes out for over 14 years and we've literally never had an issue, until Meadow Lane and the people who have nothing better to do than to create problems simply because they do NOT WANT ANY STR's on their street! Our guests follow ALL RULES set by the City and by US! We're VERY STRICT and extremely clean and conscientious of EVERYTHING GOING on at both our STR's. We walk every morning past both homes and make sure guests are following ALL rules and regulations. I called Pedro (code enforcement supervisor) and I've talked with Kevin regarding this issue, letting them know that we (my husband and I) are willing to help in any way we can...to make sure the STR's in our neighborhood are ALL following the rules and regulations set forth by the City. The beautiful families who rent our homes are gracious, caring, kind, CONSIDERATE and EXTREMELY RESPECTFUL, UNLIKE some of our 'actual' neighbors, who park cars (more than 4) on the street each night, don't take care of their property, moan and complain about other neighbors... THAT'S crazy to me! We had 'anonymous' people calling in about our house on Meadow, FOR LITERALLY NO REASON! Mike the officer who showed up twice, met with us there and he was even baffled! I think one of the very first things that needs to happen is NO MORE ANONYMOUS CALLERS! If you TRULY have a complaint, CALL YOUR NEIGHBOR, but if they're too cowardly to do that, then they at least should HAVE TO STATE WHO THEY ARE when calling the city! That seems only fair.... anonymous callers should not be taken serious - ANONYMOUS CALLS SHOULD NOT EVEN BE TAKEN! I think THAT ALONE could save so much time and we can start to see who's complaining just to get rid of STR's off Hovley. These people just DON'T WANT STR's period, there is NO valid reasoning! I'm sorry, but that is crazy.. We first started coming to this valley over 30 years ago and about 20 years ago, we started renting STR'S.... it's what brought us here full time! I've had 3 families who've made PALM DESERT their permanent residence, BECAUSE THEY rented from us first! STR's are part of this valley and with responsible owners, such as ourselves, we enhance the city, bringing in revenue and making the Coachella Valley a highly desirable destination location! Our homes are some of the cleanest, tightist, most efficiently run homes off Hovley Lane. We are GREAT neighbors and we LOVE LIVING OFF OF HOVLEY LANE AS RESIDENCE.... there is never any issues we see or hear, but if there were, WE'D LOCATE THE OWENRS and talk to them. There are a few of us (STR OWNERS) that would love a private meeting with you guys to discuss this issue. Please let me know if and when that would be possible. We LIVE OFF OF HOVLEY and we love our neighborhood and our neighbors. We want to be part of the solution.... there's too much segregation and disharmony in our world, especially now. Lets work together to live IN harmony and fix any 'real' 1 issues that might be going on and put a STOP to any pseudo made up creations people want 10 manufacturer just because they don't want a STR on their street! I appreciate you reading this and taking time to analyze it. Thank you and I look forward to hearing back from each and every one of you. Thank you, Mary Suarez 40525 Corte Placitas Palm Desert, CA 92260 805-490-7088 2 Swartz, Kevin From: Mike startire <startire@pacbell.net> Sent: Tuesday, July 21, 2020 12:18 PM To: Swartz, Kevin Subject: STR's off Hovley Lane Hello Mayor, City Council and Staff, My name Michael Baronian, me and my wife have been renting our homes off of Hovley Lane for years, It was brought to my attention that some residents want this to stop. Yes, every once and while we do run across some guests who are a little loud as we all tend to be on vacation. Very rare because I have strict rules posted at the houses. Both my immediate neighbors have no problem with my STR's. as a matter of fact, when they see something out of the ordinary, they call me and I call the guest and take care of the problem. On the other hand across the street of one house, the elderly lady will call hot line if she sees a napkin on my lawn. My wife was at one house a couple weeks ago and city officer showed up. He didn't even know why. My wife was inside doing laundry. I understand there is 26 STR's in the Hovley area, We bring travelers from other Countries, States and Cities. They spend money at our restaurants, golf courses, Tennis clubs, El Paseo, living desert, 111 shopping, designer boutiques etc. I'm not gonna ramble on but here's my thoughts. No more additional STR permits, $ penalties for multiple legitimate complaints and not phony calls. I hope we come to an agreement as this is my bread and butter for my family. Best regards; Michael Baronian, President Star Tire Center, Inc. Complete Auto Repair 3475 Peck rd, El Monte, Ca 91731 P (626)442-3180 F 626-442-8343 12130 Washington Blvd, Whittier, Ca 90606 P (562)646-3240 Email (startire@pacbell.net) Website (startirecenter.com) 1 THE FOLLOWING ATTACHED EMAILS WERE READ INTO THE RECORD AT THE CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF AUGUST 27, 2020, UNDER ORAL COMMUNICATIONS. Sanchez, Gloria From: joan sugino <jlsugino©gmail.com> Sent: Wednesday, August 26, 2020 7:07 PM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: Please read at the meeting Aug 27, 2020 : Request for Action for R1 Classification and No New Permits'in our Palm Desert neighborhoods I live on Lavender Way, zoned residential, in Palm Desert since 2005. The last several years for me have become an AIRBB nightmare. There are currently 2 of the 5 houses on my block rented out to large groups every weekend, with one of which I share a boundary.The rentals were built as 3 bedroom homes like mine and but are.advertised to sleep groups of 14-16 people. Living next to blasting music- rap, mariachi, Justin Beiber on a loop, screaming kids and pool play from Thursday afternoon until Sunday afternoon disrupts what since was a peaceful yard and house. And yes, with windows and doors closed , air conditioners on, I can still hear the noise day and night. Cars line the streets, trash overflow weekly. I don't understand the rationale of our exclusion but we need the same protection in our neighborhood that the rest of Palm Desert enjoys, no STRs. AND now with the pandemic, it is insane that large parties from LA and Orange county have move to our valley for the weekend, a fence away from me, sheltered in place and working from home. I look forward to the council re visiting this issue and protecting the rest of us. Thank you, Joan Sugino 74590 Lavender Way Palm Desert, Ca 92260 1 Sanchez, Gloria From: diana leal <dclgirl@yahoo.com> Sent: Wednesday, August 26, 2020 5:03 PM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: 8/27/20 Council Meeting - Banning Short Term Rentals Hello, my name is Miguel Leal and I Iive at 74537 Lavender Way in Palm Desert. I would like to request that my comments below be read to Council during Oral Communication time at the City Council meeting of 8/27/20. Honorable Council of the City of Palm Desert: I live next door to a short term rental home. I would like to have short term rentals banned in our neighborhood as there have been parties where the renter has rented large blow up slides and placed them in the front yard of the home. Renters park their car in front of the mailbox blocking the mail from being delivered and trash from being picked up. I contacted the homeowner about the trash issue, he suggested that I move the trash cans to the street. Nearby homeowners should not have to accommodate airbnb guests. People have gone to our house by mistake and have tried to open our door thinking it is the short term rental. There have continuous noise disturbances such as loud music and partying after the 10:00 p.m cutoff. We have complained to City of Palm Desert. We have had to pick up trash that renters have tossed over the fence into our yard. We have had traffic problems. Having interchangeable disrespectful guests breaks the sense of community in our neighborhood. We have worked very hard to accomplish homeownership. It is our hope to return to a peaceful, close-knit family -oriented neighborhood. . We are asking for two things from the council during this meeting; initiate a Request for Action to start the formal process of changing our neighborhoods to R1 and place a moratorium on any new permits for our neighborhoods. Thank you for your time. Respectfully, Miguel Leal 1 Sanchez, Gloria From: James & Gladys <sandtreasuresandmore@gmail.com> Sent: Thursday, August 27, 2020 12:48 PM To: CouncilMeeting Comments; Sanchez, Gloria Subject: Re: Distribute and HAVE READ today's meeting regarding Short Term Rental R1 Zoning Please have read today On Thu, Aug 27, 2020, 12:37 PM James & Gladys <sandtreasuresandmore@gmail.com> wrote: Hello please distribute to all council members on the August 27th, 2020 meeting We are Jim & Gladys Bersamin 40585 Meadow Lane of Palm Desert. We are part of a growing group of home homeowners 'facing a delima. PLEASE CHANGE ZONING TO RI and stop (discontinue) the SHORT TERM RENTALS NOW and stop issuing SHORT TERM RENTAL PERMITS NOW. We are are seeing a growing problem that seems to be getting worse and will continue to be worse unless the city changes what they should have resolved a couple of years ago. WE ARE NOT A HOA AND WE WANT THE SAME FREEDOM, SECURITY AND SAFETY AS OTHER NEIGHBORHOODS ARE ENJOYING. WE WANT OUR NEIGHBORHOODS BACK. Our neighborhoods are not tourist destinations and we should not be forced into accepting this. These homes are meant to be a peaceful and comfort for people who work and who are retired that actually make Palm Desert there full time residence. Please help. JIM & GLADYS BERSAMIN 40585 MEADOW LANE PALM DESERT, CA 92260 On Mon, Aug 24, 2020, 9:24 AM James & GIadys <sandtreasuresandmore@gmail.com> wrote: Hello please distribute to all council members on the August 27th:2020 meeting We are Jim & Gladys Bersamin 40585 Meadow Lane of Palm Desert. We are part of a growing group of home homeowners facing a delima. PLEASE CHANGE ZONING TO RI and stop (discontinue) the SHORT TERM RENTALS NOW and stop issuing SHORT TERM RENTAL PERMITS NOW. We are are seeing a growing problem that seems to be getting worse and will continue to be worse unless the city changes what they should have resolved a couple of years ago. WE ARE NOT A HOA AND WE WANT THE SAME FREEDOM, SECURITY AND SAFETY AS OTHER NEIGHBORHOODS ARE ENJOYING. WE WANT OUR NEIGHBORHOODS BACK. Our neighborhoods are not tourist destinations and we should not be forced into accepting this. These homes are meant to be a peaceful and comfort for people who work and who are retired that actually make Palm Desert there full time residence. Please help. JIM & GLADYS BERSAMIN 40585 MEADOW LANE PALM DESERT, CA 92260 i Sanchez, Gloria From: James & Gladys <sandtreasuresandmore@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, August 24, 2020 9:25 AM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: Short Term Rental R1 Zoning Hello please distribute to all council members on the August 27th, 2020 meeting We are Jim & Gladys Bersamin 40585 Meadow Lane of Palm Desert. We are part of a growing group of home homeowners facing a delima. PLEASE CHANGE ZONING TO R1 and stop (discontinue) the SHORT TERM RENTALS NOW and stop issuing SHORT TERM RENTAL PERMITS NOW. We are are seeing a growing problem that seems to be getting worse and will continue to be worse unless the city changes what they should have resolved a couple of years ago. WE ARE NOT A HOA AND WE WANT THE SAME FREEDOM, SECURITY AND SAFETY AS OTHER NEIGHBORHOODS ARE ENJOYING. WE WANT OUR NEIGHBORHOODS BACK. Our neighborhoods are not tourist destinations and we should not be forced into accepting this. These homes are meant to be a peaceful and comfort for people who work and who are retired that actually make Palm Desert there full time residence. Please help. JIM & GLADYS BERSAMIN 40585 MEADOW LANE PALM DESERT, CA 92260 T 1 Sanchez, Gloria From: Diana McGinity <dianamcginity@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, August 25, 2020 3:16 PM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: Request to be read at the city council meeting Aug 27, 2020 Regarding STRs in the Hovley Lane West neighborhood To all Palm Desert City Council members, Please consider some main points concerning short term rentals (STRs): 1. Hovley Lane West is a residential neighborhood composed of SINGLE FAMILY homes. Frequently, MULTIPLE FAMILIES rent these houses at the same time. 2. Residents have purchased their homes with the expectation of the peaceful enjoyment of their properties and being surrounded by neighbors. Renters are NOT neighbors, they are transient strangers, which compromises the stability and security of the neighborhood. 3. Residents should not have to be constantly alert to noise and mischief from renters. This is an invasion of their privacy. 4. Residents should not have to MONITOR, DOCUMENT, RECORD, OR FILM the abuses of renters in order to get help from city authorities. 5. Residents should not have to negotiate with law enforcement for protection. Rights of residents should take precedence over renters. 6. STRs undermine the residential character of a neighborhood, because they turn SINGLE FAMILY homes into MOTELS. 7. Since STRs are lucrative commercial enterprises, they DO NOT belong in a residential neighborhood! Therefore, we request an immediate moratorium on STR permits and a return to R1 zoning status for the Hovley Lane West neighborhood to restore peace and tranquility to our community. Thank you for your consideration. Respectfully, Diana and Bob McGinity 40501 Meadow Lane 1 Sanchez, Gloria From: Rebecca Flanagan <cvtaflanagan@gmail.com> Sent: Sunday, August 23, 2020 7:17 PM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: August 27 City Council Meeting Hello, Please read the following letter into the record for tonight's meeting: Dear Honorable Members of the City Council: I am writing this letter to ask the City Council to rezone our neighborhood to an R1 zoning area. As the City Planner acknowledged, we function as an R1, but we do not have that distinction, so we continue to suffer needlessly from the short-term rental nightmare that has become our life. In 2017, 1 was involved in the movement to ban STR's in Palm Desert only to find out that our Hovely Lane West neighborhood was not included. None of the streets off Hovely Lane West ever formed an HOA as was assumed. After finding out we were a PR, we also made several complaints about the STR's on our street during 2018 and 2019. Unfortunately, they are not recorded with the City even though Code Compliance came out many times. This year we gained another short-term rental on the other side of us which is causing considerable problems. Not only do we have footage of an expensive package being delivered there that was not returned, this property management company and/or their guests have also trespassed on our property leaving us forced to file two police reports and post no trespassing signs on our property. Had these people been neighbors, we would have gotten our package returned as we do with our other neighbors. These violations are in addition to the countless parking, trash and almost always, "unfounded" by Code Compliance, noise complaints. We are tired of having to argue about what is the 50 ft. 55-decibel limit, when the person on duty does not agree because he is 150 feet away and has made claims like "hearing the bass from music is not hearing music" when that music is inside their house, three times the distance away and with all the doors closed. Our backyard is within 50 feet away and the constant party penetrates our backyard and can be heard inside our bedroom which is in the back of the house. We cannot escape it. i There is no amount of enforcement that will be able to stop these constant loud gatherings that plague our house. The parties and loud raucous behavior of transient people who specifically come to short-term rentals to party will ultimately drive out everyone who wants to live in a neighborhood setting. We now refer to our street as "hotel row" and find we must constantly report violations instead of tenants who comply with the rules. The City's reactionary approach is not working and last week we even witnessed tenants get evicted for so many violations. Two days later, a new loud group of revelers arrived. This is a serious problem. - The anxiety of what will happen each time a new large group of people arrives and the noise they create thereafter, continues to have a detrimental impact on our health and well-being. If people need to profit from this neighborhood instead of living in it, then they should either stay on site and monitor their own unruly guests or have rentals for 30 days or more. Therefore, please include our neighborhood to the R1 zoning standard so we may be able to enjoy our home and the neighbors who live, work, and vote here. Thank you for your time and immediate attention to this matter, Rebecca Flanagan 1 2 Sanchez, Gloria From: Rita Westlie <zritagol@dc.rr.com> Sent: Sunday, August 23, 2020 2:36 PM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: Please read this email at the meeting on the 27th Short Term Rentals Please read my email below at the meeting on August 27th. Thank you much! We have owned our home almost ten years on Chinook Cir E. off Shepherd Ln in Palm Desert. We take.great pride in our home, neighborhood and our yards. We moved here from Hoyley Ct to 'get away' from the State run medical homes that surrounded us there. There was always noise and vehicles coming and going at all hours. Now...Short Term Rentals surround us now in this home!! We have a Short Term Rental next door and another a house away AND another lining up to the back of our house too on Petunia. I have called the Complaint Hot Line and the Sheriff's dept. several times over the years because of STR's. One time, the party was SO loud they could not hear me knocking on the door. The partys go on until all hours of the night. The music and the screaming in the pool areas is so loud we can hear it from down the street. Even bouncing balls on their roof went on for hours. Calling the complaint hot line did not help. This includes daytime pool parties and night time parties. Strangers near our home is not a comfortable feeling! We want some peace and quiet in our home and in our own pool area. Something we have worked for all our lives!! STR's don't take care of their front yards the way the other home owners do. The noise is SO irrating so we can't leave our sliders open for fresh air when it's nice outside. We have had booze bottles put in our garbage cans on the street. We have had beach towels thrown over to our side of the retaining 6ft wall! One time, after 1 am in the morning I asked the renters in the pool next door to please quiet down and they told me NO twice! Trying to reason with them myself didn't work so I called the Sheriff to get some peace and quiet. Recently, one evening the music was so loud at one house away from us, I knocked on the door and a very young woman answered. Over ten young people having a VERY loud party. Vehicles come and go at all hours and line the street. Calling the hotline and never works to quiet them down. We ask you to PLEASE include our Shepherd Ln area in the R1 STANDARD zoning and NO more STR permits! It seems quite unfair! Would you like your neighbors to be booming bass music so loud the whole block can hear it? Why is our home is less worthy of being R1 standard than any other home in the City? Hope something is done soon! ' r s Rita and Todd Westlie Zritagol@dc.rr.com i Sanchez, Gloria From: Cliff <diamond@socal.rr.com> Sent: Sunday, August 23, 2020 10:30 AM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: Please read this email during Agenda Oral Communications IXB Council Meeting on August 27, 2020 We join our neighbors in their Request for Action to start the formal process of changing our neighborhoods to R1 and place a moratorium on any new permits for STRs for our neighborhoods, Hovely Lane West in particular. Our neighborhood should have been included when you banned STRs in 2017. We live in Palm Desert and it was unfair that you exempted our neighborhood and three others to the protections afforded all other residential neighborhoods by banning Short Term Rentals. We should enjoy the same protections as all other covered Palm Desert neighborhoods. Those exceptions have made our neighborhoods targets for STRs banned not only in the rest of Palm Desert, but in many other cities in the Valley. Hovely Lane West is made up of many cul-de-sacs and just a few STRs on any street changes the nature of the street from one of families knowing your neighbors to one of strangers, parties, noise and parking issues. Since moving here in 2015 several homes have sold on our small street and become str's changing the nature of our neighborhood. Even now homes advertised for sale include the information that str's are permitted. With other cities banning them we are going to get even more. Not fair to this family oriented neighborhood. Help us please. Sincerely, Clifford Sanforth 40783 Sandpiper Ct., Palm Desert, CA 92260 } I Sanchez, Gloria From: William Chaplin <wchoplin@icloud.com> Sent: Monday, August 24, 2020 3:11 PM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: August 27th City Council Meeting - Oral Communication Comments Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Flagged Please read this message to the Palm Desert City Council Members during Oral Communication at the August 27th City Council meeting. Please acknowledge receipt of this message. Thank you, William Choplin Nancy Nowak and William Chaplin 40669 Diamondback Dr, Palm Desert City Council Members, We want to thank all the city staff who have been very helpful and responsive answering questions and providing information about Short Term Rentals. In 20I7 we actively supported the ban on Short Term Rentals in the R1 and R2 zones. At the time we and our neighbors mistakenly thought our non - gated neighborhood of single family homes along Hovely Lane West was included in the ban. We are now joining with our neighbors to ask the City Council to include our neighborhood in the RI standard. The city has acknowledged that our neighborhood functions the same as RI. We want to enjoy the same. protections from STRs as the R1 and R2 residents were given in 2017. As Council Members Kelly and Jonathan pointed out in November 2017, enforcement doesn't work. We are here to validate their opinions. We are completely frustrated by the current enforcement process. It does not serve residents. In 20I7 the Council created a sub -committee to study and make recommendations about STRs. We see no value, only delay, in creating a sub -committee to study our request. There is nothing new to learn. The arguments for pro STR and pro Residents are the same. If the Council decides to add our neighborhood to the R1 standard and a sunset period is provided, it should be much shorter. We have already endured the two year sunset provided in 2017. The Homeowner Application For STR Permits includes this language: "Applicant acknowledges that the City has decided to largely eliminate STR activity in R1 and R2 zones by January, 2020 and may likely decide to extend that ban to other residential areas not governed by a functioning homeowners association, and permits issued in those areas after January 16, 2018, may be terminated. The City may decide to further severely limit or eliminate STR activity, and may decide not to renew STR permits on an annual basis." We are asking the Council to invoke this language to remove STRs from our neighborhood and streamline the process to do so. Today we are asking the Council to initiate a Request for Action to start the process and impose a new permit moratorium to stop the bleeding. Thank you. 1 Sanchez, Gloria From: William Glover <billglover@twc.com> Sent: Monday, August 24, 2020 11:59 AM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: Ban STRs along Hovley West Good afternoon ^' I would like to first state that as I am unable to attend this meeting I would like for my letter to be read to those in attendance. My name is William Glover and my family and I reside at 40657 Glenwood Lane, here in Palm Desert. Before purchasing our home in 2011, I spent hours of research finding the most desirable location to live with a Awesome School District for my children to attend. After much consideration, we purchased our home on Glenwood Lane. Most of our neighbors on our 16 home Cul-de-sac, are retired. Just recently we had another family with school aged children move into our neighborhood. Shortly after moving into our home, I went to our local Palm Desert Sheriffs Department inquiring as to how I could start a neighborhood watch program on our street. Once I got the program started, our neighbors joined together to build a community where we look out for each other and our property. Most recently we found that one of our neighbors and sold her home at 40620 Glenwood Lane, as her husband had passed away and it was time to down size. Little did we know that the New Owners were purchasing the home to be a Short Term Rental and was advertising it on AirBNB. Just like the home located behind this residence located on Clover Lane. Now our quite neighborhood that we knew and loved has become a "Swinging Door" for anyone who want to invade our neighborhood for a day, weekend or whenever. Being the father of 4 children, obviously I have greater concerns than just the noise and traffic that these homes bring to our neighborhood. We are very particular and cautious about our children being out, even in our own front yard, with people across the street who pose a threat to our neighborhood. This is not what we signed up for when we bought our home on Glenwood Lane in Palm Desert. On behalf of all the neighbors on Glenwood Lane, Palm Desert, we would like our voice to be heard and let in be known that we do not want STRs on our Cul-de-sac or on Hovley West Neighborhoods. We are a community of families who loved our quiet neighborhood before it became a "Swinging Door". Let get back to the basics and bring our community back to what we knew and loved. Ban STRs along Hovley West. Respectfully yours, William R. Glover and Family President, Glenwood Lane Neighborhood Watch Sent from my iPhone 1 Sanchez, Gloria From: Richard Feldman <ricfe113@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, August 24, 2020 7:28 PM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: 40641 Diamondback Dr I did not purchase my home on Diamondback to have a business across the street for STR's. The daily cars of renters or cleaners, the trash left against curb, cars parked on the street or blocking the sidewalk. There have been over 38 complaints on this property. The last major one had the STR people evicted. That should have been the 3rd major complaint to terminate the owners from any future'STR's. But they continue to arrive all week. Previously all of the extra 2-5 cars from the renters parked at Temple Sinai. After telling the temple of the situation they immediately had "Private Property/No Parking" signs installed. Now the renters park their cars in the Albertson's parking lot. I pay over $6500 every year in taxes and my taxes are helping to support STR's in our neighborhood. Richard Feldman 40640 Diamondback Dr 3 I Sanchez, Gloria From: William Bester <wllmbester@yahoo.com> Sent: Sunday, August 23, 2020 7:47 PM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Cc: Nicholas Marcus Latkovic Subject: Comments To Be Read at City Council Meeting Attachments: We sent you safe versions of your files; Palm Desert City Council (Word).docx Mimecast Attachment Protection has deemed this file to be safe, but always exercise caution when opening files. Dear Palm Desert City Council: I am requesting that this letter be read at the August 27th Palm Desert City Council Meeting. It is less than the three minute max established for reading of comments. Thank you for including this item in your agenda and please let me know if you need any additional information from us. Many thanks. Bill and Cheryl Bester. 1 Sanchez, Gloria From: valetvideo@aol.com Sent: Friday, August 14, 2020 8:02 AM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: Fwd: Short Term Rental issues Attachments: 20200725_090321 jpg Can you please read this at the next council meeting. Thank you Mark & Susan Wasson Mark Wasson 40620 Baranda Court Palm Desert, CA 92260 July 26, 2020 Dear Council Members & Code Enforcement Personnel: I am writing to you as a concerned resident of Palm Desert. I am a I5-year resident of Palm Desert off of Hovley Lane West. Over the last several years I have noticed an increasing number of short-term rentals in the neighborhood. I take early morning walks at around 4:00 a.m. most mornings and have noticed on several occasions up to 9 vehicles parked in front of a short-term rental on Via Fonda. This number does not even include the 2-3 vehicles that are oftentimes parked in the driveway. In addition, I have personally picked up water bottles, beer bottles and other trash that has been discarded in the vicinity of this short-term rental property. On more than one occasion, on my early morning walks, I have heard people talking loudly in the backyard of this property. Although this does not affect me directly, I am certain that the residents directly adjacent to the property are affected by this noise disturbance. The owners of these short-term rentals have no regard for our neighborhood 'and are motivated by profit only. My wife and I did have a short-term rental next door to us several years ago. It is fortunately now a Tong -term rental, as we were awakened one morning at 2:00 a.m. by our doorbell ringing only to look out the window to find an inebriated 20-something male standing at our door in his underwear trying to get into our home. I recognized the young man as one of the occupants and guided him back to the correct home. He did apologize the next day, but needless to say it was a very unsettling experience. I must also mention that after reading the City Council Staff Report from November 14, 2019, with regards to the number of complaints (page 2) for HovIey-Lane West that there were "Zero Complaints" in 2018 and 2019, which is without a doubt incorrect. I personally called and left messages during this time period. At the time, I spoke with Jane Stanley and she was kind enough to transfer me to the proper extension where I did leave a message. Your consideration regarding this matter is appreciated. If you have any questions, I can be reached at (760) 567-1534. Respectfully, Mark Wasson PS, The attached picture is at 40603 Via Fonda and was taken on 7-25-2020 1 Sanchez, Gloria From: William Bester <wllmbester@yahoo.com> Sent: Sunday, August 23, 2020 7:47 PM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Cc: Nicholas Marcus Latkovic Subject: Comments To Be Read at City Council Meeting Attachments: We sent you safe versions of your files; Palm Desert City Council (Word).docx Mimecast Attachment Protection has deemed this file to be safe, but always exercise caution when opening files. Dear Palm Desert City Council: (am requesting that this letter be read at the August 27th Palm Desert City Council Meeting. It is Tess than the three minute max established for reading of comments. Thank you for including this item in your agenda and please let me know if you need any additional informationfrom us. Many thanks. Bill and Cheryl Bester. 1 To: Palm Desert City Council Members Subject: Open a Request for Action Dear Palm Desert City Council Members: My wife and I have been residents of Palm Desert since January of 2012. Following a 32 year active duty Army career and a follow-on 8 year career in academia engaged with educating the next generation of military physicians and graduate level nurses, we decided to relocate to Palm Desert to be close to our two children who live in Temecula and San Diego. During my 32 years on active duty, I had 17 different assignments that took me to places around the world and throughout the United States. Our dream for post -retirement was to settle in a community and a neighborhood where we knew our neighbors, respected each other's ownership and order and would look out for each other's well-being and needs. We found that neighborhood off of West Hovley Lane and settled into a very enjoyable setting. Then a few years ago, a house three doors from us sold to an out of town owner to be used as a short term rental. Two years later, the house directly across the street from us and directly across the street from the other short term rental sold to another owner as a short term rental. Our enjoyable, safe and quiet neighborhood has never been the same since. We now have a continual and steady turnover of large short term rental groups that regularly have loud parties, loud music and fill our quiet street with a multitude of cars. One weekend at just one of the rentals, 17 cars were parked on the street supporting the huge party being hosted in the backyard of the short term rental. This is not the neighborhood we bought into and certainly not the living environment we were hoping for at this point in our lives. It is our understanding that the Palm Desert City Council banned short term rentals in 2017 but "excluded" Hovley Lane West neighborhoods. Why our City Council would exclude our neighborhoods in favor of supporting those out of town owners who buy up houses for short term rental purposes eludes us. We are VERY hopeful that you will correct this unfortunate decision made back in 2017. We are requesting that the Palm Desert City Council open a Request For Action to correct this omission and change the streets in our neighborhoods with single family homes to the R1 standard. We love Palm Desert and the many opportunities it offers. However, short term rentals have made our lives in these quiet neighborhoods a living hell. My wife and I are requesting that you do the right thing and support us in this request so we can live in environments that drove us to select these wonderful neighborhoods in the first place. Thank you for considering our sincere request and thank you also for your service to our community. William T. Bester Brigadier General (Ret) U.S. Army Sanchez, Gloria From: robert greer <greercor@msn.com> Sent: Monday, August 10, 2020 3:58 PM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: Opposed to SHORT TERM RENTALS Hello City Clerk: At the appropriate time, please have the following read aloud to the City Council during their August 27, 2020 City Council meeting, if this subject matter is postponed to a future date then at that time it should be read to the City Council. Robert & Hedeliza Greer Homeowners 40641 Meadow lane Palm Desert Hello City Clerk: Please distribute this email to each City Council member before the next City Council meeting. We are requesting that the Palm Desert City Council change zoning to R1 Standard for Meadow Lane, Diamondback Drive, Palm Court, and Clover Lane and direct the City Manager and City Attorney to take immediate action to stop existing short term rentals and prohibit future short term rentals. Short term rentals take away the sense of community and turn neighborhoods into commercial enterprises, tourists coming and going. We all seek a sense of community in our lives, the neighborhood is one of the few places we feel safe, enjoying our homes and seeing our neighbors create a sense of wellbeing, a basic human need, we recognize those that live in our neighborhood and sometimes even wave and even talk to one another. It's not complicated, the neighborhood is where we live, not a tourist destination. Robert & Hedeliza Greer, Homeowners 40641 Meadow Lane Palm Desert 760 346-4429 greercor@msn.com 1 Sanchez, Gloria From: ace kidd <histokid@hotmail.com> Sent: Monday, August 10, 2020 1:15 PM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: Request for my comments to be read at the August 27, 20220 counsel meeting To whom it may concern, I ask that my comments below be read by a city staff member during the August 27, 2020 meeting. Thank you kindly, Arn Good afternoon, My name is Arn and I reside on College View Circle East in Palm Desert off of Shepard Lane. I have occupied my residence for over 20 years and I truly respect my neighbors and our wonderful city. I am writing to you today to voice my frustration with the ongoing short term rental issues my neighbors and I face on a regular basis. Approximately the last 6 years, my neighbors and I have had to put up with short term rental problems. Several of us have contacted the short term rental hotline on numerous occasions and at times have even had to contact the sheriff's department. Over the years we have faced so many disturbances from various occupants of at least one short term rental 74140 College View Circle East. Some examples of problems we have encountered and continue to deal with are; illegal fireworks being set off and landing in our pools, cars speeding up and down the street, extremely loud music throughout the day and into the evening, occupants up late at night outside talking loudly and at times hollering, trash piled high and in plain view from the street, large parties and numerous vehicles (as many as 16 at times) parked on the street and blocking the sidewalk. In fact the Wi-Fi connection for this property is titled the party house. This residence is a four bedroom home listed on Airbnb as Sleeps 12 persons with additional beds available upon request. I am a supporter of Palm Desert and I ask that you please consider our efforts to ban Short Term Rentals in our area as you have other areas of Palm Desert. Sincerely, Arn i Sanchez, Gloria From: Ortega, Niamh Sent: Tuesday, August 25, 2020 1:18 PM To: Sanchez, Gloria Subject: FW: Code Compliance Case #2735 Attachments: Code Compliance #2735.pdf; ATT00001.htm; We sent you safe versions of your files guess they do want it to be read. Niamh Ortega Secretary to the City Council Ph: 760.346.0611 Direct: 760.776.6315 nortega@cityofpalmdesert.org From: Comcast [mailto:5evans8778@comcastnet] Sent: Tuesday, August 25, 2020 1:15 PM To: CityhallMail <Cityhall@cityofpalmdesert.org> Subject: Fwd: Code Compliance Case #2735 Mimecast Attachment Protection has deemed this file to be safe, but always exercise caution when opening files. Dear Mr. Sabby Jonathan I am having a difficult time with Code Compliance (Mike Morris, Alex,and Pedro Rodriguez) to enforce Light Tresspassing in my neighborhood. If we do not make our community comply to city municipal code chapter 24 per ordinance 1272, then we should shut -down Code -Compliance, sell trucks and provide Palm Desert Sheriffs department with protective vest. I have submitted this to courtcilmeetingcomments@cityifpalmdesert.org. Unfortunately I did not include that I would like it to be read at the meeting on 8/27/20. I am requesting that it be read at the meeting thank you. Best Shannon Evans Sent from my iPad Begin forwarded message: From: Comcast <Sevans8778@comcast.net> Date: August 24, 2020 at 6:24:59 PM PDT To: CouncilMeetingComments@cityofpalmdesert.org Subject: Code Compliance Case #2735 Thank You for your time. Best Shannon Evans Begin forwarded message: i C i August 23, 2020 City of Palm Desert 73510 Fred Waring Drive Palm Desert, CA. 92260 RE: Case #2735 ORIGINAL MAILED 8-24-20 Ordinance#1272 (Obtained from City of Palm Desert App IOS) City Municipal Code 24.16.04 Light Trespassing l have submitted an original complaint #2735 early July 2020 regarding 43810 Carmel Circle, Palm Desert. Code Compliance has not enforced violation per City of Palm Desert Municipal Code Chapter 24.16.04. Why are we using our Tax Dollars for this department, Code Compliance? The City could sell off the 15 trucks in the parking lot not being used. I find this frustrating and a waste of time (for everyone). It's a simple solution to have the owners change the light setting to sensor orthey must be shielded per Ordinance No.1272 2416-3, current lighting is unacceptable. I look forward to a speedy response. Since this current violation is over 30 day. Please contact me with resolution 760-404-0227 or 858-774-1090. 1 would prefer to resolve this without Legal Counsel. There is a reason we don't have street lights: • 1. Light Pollution • 2.Light Trespassing I look forward to hearing from you soon. Sincerely, Shannon Evans CC: Mike Morris, Code Compliance Ryan Spendell, Director Community Development Gina Nestande, Mayor enc: Ordinance #1272 Exhibit A Sanchez, Gloria From: Comcast <Sevans8778@comcast.net> Sent: Monday, August 24, 2020 6:25 PM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: Code Compliance Case #2735 Attachments: We sent you safe versions of your files; Code Compliance #2735.pdf; ATT00001.txt Mimecast Attachment Protection has deemed this file to be safe, but always exercise caution when opening files. Thank You for your time. Best Shannon Evans Begin forwarded message: 1 Sanchez, Gloria From: Courtney Halterrein <courtneyhalterlein@me.com> Sent: Wednesday; August 26, 2020 10:47 AM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: Short Term Rental Comments I am requesting this letter be read aloud during the oral comments on Thursday 8/27/20. Oral Communications - B, XI, page 3 This is in regards to the Request For Action to ban short term rentals. Found under -Mayor and Council Members Reports and Remarks, XVIII, F., page 14. To Whom It May Concern, When we bought our home in 2017, we had every intention of making it our family's "forever home". Since then, our home has become surrounded by short term rentals. We live on Via Fonda, a street with 12 homes & 2 of them are short term rentals, one next door to us and one across the street, and likely more to come as properties continue to sell. We no longer feel safe letting our kids ride their bikes or play outside on weekends when short term renters are here, due to the amount of cars and intoxicated people coming and going on our small street. We also now avoid our own backyard most of the time due to the loud screaming and music that is playing day and night. Our bedroom is adjacent to the backyard of the rental house next door and again, the music, screaming and partying literally 20 feet from where we are sleeping is unbearable to deal with. We do not have any desire to continue living this way, as our quality of life has declined severely, but moving is not financially possible for our family of 5. We sometimes truly can't believe this is happening, that we saved for years to buy our family home in what we believed to be a quiet, safe area & these are the people we get for "neighbors". Based on my family's experience over the past 3.5 years, we do not believe there is any amount of "policing" or enforcement the city can provide that would properly or effectively manage rentals of this nature Short term rentals are already banned in single family residential neighborhoods, what you refer to as Zone R-1. We are living off Hovely Lane West in exactly what I just described, a single family residential neighborhood. No gates, no guards, no HOA. We want short term rentals banned in "PR zoned" neighborhoods like Hovley Ln West in order to make this an equitable situation for ALL the residents in the City of Palm Desert. You already banned them in R-1, now finish the job, make it right and make it FAIR to all your residents, the homeowners in the Hovely West area included. Thank you. Scott and Courtney Halterlein i Sanchez, Gloria From: Nicholas Marcus Latkovic <n.m.latkovic@gmail.com> Sent: Wednesday, August 19, 2020 10:38 AM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: STR's - Hovley West Please delete my previous email request sent in error - apologies. I would like to be included in the ORAL COMMENTS SECTION for August 27, 2020 Council Meeting. Topic — STR's Hovley Wes 1. Thank the Code Enforcement Tea or qui response times to my calls and patrolling daily — nice work on their part, 2. What is the cost of enforcement vs. re ue to the city — I know this is an intangible number based on what STR occupants spend in the city and abo TO ncome — discussion point only. Realize the city budget shortfall is $10.1 million. Perhaps plan a STR . velopme for revenue on city land at Frank Sinatra and Portola. 3. Have had 3 new purchases with R purposes b into Via Fonda / Terraza in addition to the existing. Would like the city to implement a Mo atorium on new 5 ' permits on Hovley West until parameters or new zoning determ ined. 4. We (neighbors) are now hav g to monitor STR's with a sent owners— who are many hours away and told by the owners "Why didn't yo call me sooner" or "call me • xt time — don't call the city". We have constant rentals with random goo•, bad guests turning over in 4 hou in a day during occupant change. 5. Have not had to call on a eighbor in 40+ years of home own rship until recently. Have now called 10 times + in the last 4 months. STR's are currently not working in Hovley West. Nick Latkovic 40629 Via Fonda Palm Desert, CA 92260 760-455-9727 DY,'; i Sanchez, Gloria From: Devin Kasprick <devin.kasprick@gmail.com> Sent: Thursday, August 27, 2020 4:43 PM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: RE: Please Read Email : For Short Term Rentals My name is Devin Kasprick , Pm a new resident of Palm Desert and recently took possession of a single family home. I am in my early 30s and moved to Palm Desert from Silicon Valley in Northern California, this home is my primary residence. I have been following the short term rental situation both in Palm Desert and surrounding areas. I urge the council and other residents of Palm Desert to be more forward thinking and not impose any additional measures to ban short term rentals that were not included previously. I have been a SuperHost with Airbnb now for over 4 years and allowing the flexibility of renting out my residence while I am away from home is a source of income and joy I have of sharing my unique home. I have many family members and friends who only book Airbnbs especially now to book unique homes and stay out of public hotels especially during the pandemic. In these uncertain times restricting revenue both to the city as well as to residents should be done with care as the last thing we do for all of us is to lose another`source of revenue during these difficult times. I'see the city as being a hub for technology now and in the future, Airbnb is going public this year and willing to work with us to cut down on disturbances/partying as one of their mandates of now becoming a public entity. Existing measures are already in place from these short term rentals such as banning any mentions of partying, not allowing guests under 25 to book property and more. I know myself I leverage technology to help resolve disturbances such as having multiple cameras, can broadcast a voice message throughout the interior and devices that measure noise levels in a property are used to keep them under control. Rather than imposing cold bans on rentals we need to do some more research on how these bans are impacting long term home prices , revenue for the city and overall economy. I can tell you right now partying right now at Airbnbs isn't an issue just for Palm Desert or not even in California it's an international issue. Due to the pandemic and covid it has been worse as more locals are using party homes as a vacation rather than being able to travel due to the pandemic. I am experiencing this same issue in Canada with my rental there of local residents booking to use as a party home and have had to deny a lot of bookings,I can tell you right now it's an issue everywhere not just in our city. I'm confident we can find a resolution to these issues and be more forward thinking for the future of our city rather than a straight ban on all short term rentals. Uber Airbnb and many other technologies have growing pains and we may need to make some changes to what is allowed rather than just a ban. i ORDINANCE NO. 1357 STAFF REPORT CITY OF PALM DESERT COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT MEETING DATE: September 10, 2020 PREPARED BY: Ryan Stendell, Director of Community Development REQUEST: Consideration for approval an interim urgency ordinance establishing a temporary moratorium on the issuance of short-term rental permits within all Planned Residential zoning districts, unless the owner can provide a written approval from a Homeowners Association (HOA) that Short Term rentals are permitted within the HOA. Recommendation Waive further reading and adopt Interim Urgency Ordinance No. 1357' establishing a temporary moratorium on the issuance of short-term rental (STR) Permits within all Planned Residential (PR) zoning districts, unless the owner can provide written approval from an Homeowners Association (HOA) that short term rentals are permitted within the HOA. 2. By Minute Motion, direct the existing City Council STR subcommittee (Kelly and Nestande) to review and provide a recommendation to the City Council. Executive Summary Approval of staff's recommendation will approve an interim urgency ordinance that will place a 45-day moratorium on issuing new STR permits within all PR zoning districts unless approved by the governing HOA. The moratorium allows existing permitted STR properties within the affected zoning district to continue operating, including permit renewals. Given that this is an urgency ordinance intended to take effect immediately, it requires a 4/5 vote to pass. Background Analvsis At its regular meeting of August 27, 2020, Councilmember Jonathan requested that staff review a known zoning irregularity within PR zoning districts that do not have a governing HOA as it relates to STR use. Councilmember Kelly added her concurrence to that effort, however she expressed the need to bring forward an interim urgency ordinance, placing a moratorium on the issuance of STR permits within Planned Residential zoning districts unless approved by the HOA. Councilmember Jonathan concurred that both are important. September 10, 2020 - Staff Report Interim Urgency Ordinance — STR PR Zoning Districts Page 2 of 2 Discussion Staff, at the direction of the City Council, has been monitoring STR permits in PR zoning districts since the updated STR ordinance was approved in late 2017. The PR zone provides maximum flexibility in development, ranging from large planned communities to developments that function the same as R1 or R2 single family zoning districts. Areas such as the Hovley Lane West, Shepherd Lane, and ungated developments along Deep Canyon Road are good examples of neighborhoods that are zoned PR, but share many commonalities with the R1 or R2 zoning districts. Staff has prepared the language to include all PR zone properties subject to proof of HOA approval because we are aware of at least one PR zoned development (The Grove) that has an HOA that is not currently active. There could be additional locations where this exists, which is why staff is proposing the Interim Urgency Ordinance in this way. Memo to City Council Dated July 24, 2020: Staff prepared the most recent update to the City Council in late July of this year; it is attached to this staff report. At that time, staff noted there had been alfairly significant increase in complaints from surrounding residents. As was learned in 20116, resident input is one of the biggest indicators of a mounting STR concern. Consistent with the memo, staff's recommendation remains the same: Refer this to the STR subcommittee whose members are uniquely qualified to develop a strategy to be submitted to the entire City Council for consideration. Fiscal Analvsis Staff believes that the impact on Transient Occupancy Tax revenue of this moratorium while short-term rentals are studied would be relatively insignificant. LEGAL REVIEW Robert W. Hargreaves City Attorney DEPT. REVIEW FINANCIAL ASSISTANT CITY REVIEW MANAGER "-*CL#L C "oo2u Andy Firestine Ryan Stendell Dir. of Communitv Development 1_ City Manager, Lauri Aylaian: Janet Moore Andy Firestine Director of Finance Assistant City Manager ATTACHMENT: Draft Interim Urgency Ordinance Map of affected areas Memo dated July 24, 2020 related to STRs in PR zones Recent correspondence from residents Sanchez, Gloria From: Richard Feldman <ricfel13@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, September 7, 2020 1:28 PM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: STR's It is one thing if a STR is a bedroom when the owners are present. When the owners are absent for the entire year and running a business out of their house .... that is a business on my street with cars and people arriving throughout the week and every weekend. House cleaners arriving a few times a week. I did not buy my house for cash to have a business run opposite my house on Diamondback Dr. Richard Feldman 40640 Diamondback Dr PD ac Sanchez, Gloria From: Mike McCrea <mbp.star@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, September 7, 2020 6:32 PM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: SEPT 10th Meeting regarding STR Issues I live in Palm desert and 1 have a rental property in a PR5 zone. I've been renting out properties using technology for over 10 years. I am going to make this short and to the point. My rental property is my primary source of income for my entire family. In addition my cleaner and maintenance crews would have to be laid off if a ban would pass.. There's a simple solution here for the problem. Change the minimum stay for STR to 7 days. This will eliminate the problem renters parties and will bring in more of a neighborhood experience. 1 and 2 night stays are huge problems at most of these party properties. I hope you seriously take this into consideration. A change in fine schedules is not the solution. It is about the length of stay. Thank You, Michael McCrea Sanchez, Gloria From: STEPHEN AUSTIN <smjaustin@hotmail.com> Sent: Monday, September 7, 2020 7:15 PM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: My management Dear council members, I was not planning on writing an email until I read something from one of my neighbors where he is disputing and wanting short term rentals banned throughout Palm Desert. I cannot believe the lies that continually happened throughout the neighborhood. Whether it's an email or online this is all a bully tactic. Some of these residents are straight up liars. After reading my neighbors letter I just can't believe it. I personally run a small management company for approximately 12 Airbnb rentals(2in palm desert). 74614 Strawflower Circle and 74529 Lavender I consider myself to be very good management for homeowners. I continually manage the houses, guests and cameras in the best interests for all entities. I have never received a City fine from any city. In fact I have only received a few phone calls from the city of which were false complaints or inaccurate complaints. Nothing like what my neighbor is explaining. This management company is my full-time job and 100% of my income. Without it I would be jobless. One of my neighbors next to the strawflower house is quite happy with my rental that he purchased and invested $650,000 to start his own Airbnb rental 2 houses away. I do believe that the city of Palm Desert and all surrounding cities are having their issues with short term rentals but the answer would be to fix the problem. Not illuminate all rentals. Why not increase the minimum rental days from two days to three days or even possibly four days. Possibly require every rental to have camera systems on the front or the back of the house to monitor noise levels like I do. Thanks STEPHEN AUSTIN Sent from my iPhone Sanchez, Gloria From: Jonathan Lee <lee jonathan.888@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, September 8, 2020 11:15 AM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: Sept 10 Meeting on STR Issue Dear City Council, After hearing about the potential changes and impact on short term rentals, I wanted to share my take on this issue which I hope you take into consideration. I have a house in which I was residing in. However, I was laid off due to COVID-19 and I'm now having to rent out my house while I live with my parents until I can land my feet. Fortunately, I've been able to support myself and my family and cover my mortgage and living expenses with the rental income. But I'm deeply concerned that new restrictions could negatively affect my livelihood. As a result, I propose another way to resolve the problems we may be experiencing. I suggest that... 1. we require noise monitors 2. only allow small bluetooth speakers in the backyard 3. talk to nearby neighbors about doing the right thing if there's any problem 4. have actual renters and not property owners are charged with fees if they violate noise rules. I believe this type of approach would get rid of unrespectable renters from our city, eliminate partying, preserve and maintain quiet neighborhoods, and enable me to depend on my rental income. This might be one-sided from my perspective but there are bigger implications if I lose my house. For example, I won't be able to pay my cleaning lady, pool, and maintenance guy who are living off of their jobs. Also, worst come to worst, I may have no choice and put my house into foreclosure which could have a negative economic impact on Palm Desert. Please think through all these possibilities and let's find a better way to resolve short term rental issues and care for our local residents and neighborhoods. Thank you, Jonathan Lee Sanchez, Gloria From: ace kidd <histokid@hotmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, September 8, 2020 12:43 PM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: 9/08/2020 Request to have comments read at next city council meeting regarding STR's To all city council members, I want to take this extremely important opportunity, to reiterate my personal request to ban STR's in our non- HOA residential neighborhood. For far too many years we have been plagued with STR's directly across and next to us. We have had to put up with all sorts of ruckus on a regular routine basis. The sheriff's department has been out several times, as well as code enforcement on many occasions. Renters routinely play load music, which can be heard from across the street and even when we are indoors. The STIR located at 74-140 College View Circle East, is essentially a party house as noted by their Wi-FI name "The Party House". On a regular basis there are no less than 4-5 vehicles parked at this residence and I have counted as many as 14 at times. Vehicles are regularly parked up and down the street and often blocking the sidewalk. This is a 3- bedroom home with an additional converted bedroom. The property is listed on VRBO as sleeps 12 with additional beds available upon request and "Parties Allowed". I have lived in this once peaceful Neiborhood since it was first developed and have witnessed the negative impacts from STR's. I recently told one of my young children, it is unfair we should have to contemplate moving out of the neighborhood to give way to those only motivated by profit. My neighbors and I selected to live in a residential neighborhood, not a business type neighborhood who's only focus is self-interest and profit. In speaking with a couple of my immediate neighbors, they too are contemplating moving. Our final opportunity to regain our peace and remain in the neighborhood rests with your decision to do the right thing by banning STR's as you did in other parts of Palm Desert. Please have my comments read and included in the upcoming city council meeting. Sincerely, Arn Sanchez, Gloria From: Richard Feldman <ricfell3@gmail.com> Sent: Wednesday, September 9, 2020 7:33 AM To: Sanchez, Gloria Subject: 40641 Diamondback Dr I live across the street from this property and have had to witness the constant arrivals of cars during the weekend and throughout the week, along with the cleaners who arrive after the renters leave. This property has had two fines levied by code enforcement. A few weeks ago renters had loud music, loud noise in the evening and daytime. Code enforcement came by in the morning, investigated and the STR's were told to leave. The vacasa agent even came by and spoke with me. ENLIGHTEN me why this was not the 3rd infraction for this STR? This should have been the 3rd major fine. But they continue to rent. There have been over 37 complaints for this property. Who is responsible for the incompetence? Why are complaints lost when submitted to code enforcement? Other communities in the area have banned STR's. Why do the city counselors continue to support them? Do you have friends or family who own STR's? They are NOT welcome in this community! Sanchez, Gloria From: Nicole Zambon <nicole@itrip.net> Sent: Thursday, September 10, 2020 11:46 AM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: Potential Moratorium off of Hovely Lane - Comments for the City Council Meeting Hi there, I am in support of maintaining STRs in the current PR zone off of Hovely and also in favor of keeping the zone PR. I manage a property on Meadow Lane. We are very communicative with our guests, and they are aware of the neighborhood; that it is a quiet neighborhood, and they comply with the codes. I have never had a code compliance officer come out to this home. I recommend that if there are true problematic homes, then the City should consider renewing those STR permits on a case by case basis. There's no need to punish innocent and compliant citizens again, like the R 1 and R2 zones that were all punished from just a few bad apples who killed the whole orchard. Furthermore, perhaps cranky citizens who repeatedly cry wolf and waste the time and money of our city by sending out code compliance for no good reason should be fined for disturbing the quiet enjoyment of others. Best Regards, Nicole Zambon Sanchez, Gloria From: jhnkalish@aol.com Sent: Thursday, September 10, 2020 12:24 PM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: Approve Interim Ordinance: Temp. Moratorium Short -Term Rental Permits To the Palm Desert City Council: Please approve the Interim Ordinance Establishing a Temp. Moratorium on Short -Term Rental Permits at the September 10, 2020 City Council Meeting. We have lived in the Hovley West Area at 40580 Posada Court, Palm Desert, CA 92260 since 2004. As evidenced by a quick search of one on-line site, Vrbo.com, there has been a tremendous proliferation of short -tern rentals in our neighborhood. Short-term rentals are absolutely inappropriate in a single family neighborhood. Noise, disruption, and safety issues all contribute to this being inappropriate and incompatible. Please pass the moratorium and issue no new permits. Thank you, John and Lisa Kalish 40580 Posada Ct. Palm Desert, CA 92260 Sanchez, Gloria From: lahooiel@gmail.com Sent: Thursday, September 10, 2020 1:44 PM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: Potential Moratorium off of Hovely Lane - Comments for the City Council Meeting September 10, 2020 Mayor Weber and Council of Palm Desert, I am in support of maintaining STRs in the current PR zone off of Hovley and also in favor of keeping the zone PR. We own a STR on Meadow Lane in the Hovley West area. We have had this as a STR for several years now with absolutely no complaints from neighbors. We hired a very reputable property management company to manage this property for us. The reason we did this is to make sure that careful screening is done on any STR applicants to avoid any kind of issue due to noise, groups, parties etc. We have never had code compliance have to come out and we feel that if a few people with STR homes in the neighborhood are not as careful as we are with our rental, then the City should deal with them individually and not blanket us in with the problem ones and put a moratorium on our rental. For us, having the ability to have a STR gives us the opportunity to be able to keep our home there in Palm Desert so that we as owners, can use and enjoy our home periodically throughout the year. Without the ability to have part year income, we would have to sell the home. Please consider STR's on a case by case basis based on the track record of each rental to avoid punishing the owners who truly make sure that there are no issues. Respectfully submitted, Linda L. Charette 40751 Meadow Ln. Palm Desert, CA 92260 lahooiel@gmail.com Sanchez, Gloria From: Jim Schmid <jimschmid@gmail.com> Sent: Thursday, September 10, 2020 324 PM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: Fwd: short term rental moratorium Dear Council members, I support the proposed moratorium on new short term rental permits in PR developments. I live in a neighborhood zoned PR which is ungated and not part of an HOA. Several new strs have popped up recently to the detriment of the neighborhood. Trash piled at the end of the driveway, noise, and numerous different cars parked up and down the street on a regular basis. Our PR neighborhood is functionally equivalent to areas zoned R-1 and R-2, and should be included in the STR ban that includes these areas. I support the moratorium, and I would like to see the city find a way to ban STRs in my neighborhood whether through re-zoning or other appropriate measures. Thank You, Jim Schmid 74535 Daylily Cir, Palm Desert, CA 92260 Sanchez, Gloria From: Richard de Sam Lazaro (ELCA) <rilazaro@expediagroup.com> Sent: Thursday, September 10, 2020 4:11 PM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: Comments re: Proposed Short-Term Rental Moratorium Attachments: We sent you safe versions of your files; 091020 Expedia Group re Palm Desert STR.pdf Mimecast Attachment Protection has deemed this file to be safe, but always exercise caution when opening files. Good afternoon, Thank you for your full consideration of the attached comments regarding the proposed moratorium on short-term rental licenses in Palm Desert. We look forward to working closely with you to address Palm Desert's community concerns with sustainable, balanced regulations. Please do not hesitate to reach out with any questions. Richard Richard de Sam �azaro Senior Manager, Government and Community T +l 206 660 8227 Email: riiazcrro:�exr�e��ia:7r-.:�u�,.c{�n� expediagroup.com He/Him/His �xp�dia group� September 10, 2020 By Electronic Mail Dear Mayor Nestande and Members of the City Council, On behalf of Expedia Group — a family of travel brands including vacation rental leader Vrbo — I am writing to urge you to vote against the urgency ordinance establishing a temporary moratorium on STR permits within Planned Residential (PR) zones. While we would welcome the opportunity to discuss ways to address nuisance and public safety issues facing Palm Desert communities, a moratorium is a blunt instrument that will not adequately address these needs. A more sustainable response would involve increased enforcement efforts targeting the handful of homes generating repeated nuisances. Applying the moratorium to all PR zones affects thousands of other homeowners miles away from the Hovley Lane neighborhood, where most complaints have been concentrated. If the Council concludes that a moratorium is the right step, we recommend a less wide-ranging moratorium that focuses specifically on the neighborhoods in question. This could be achieved by applying the moratorium only to homes on a list of streets corresponding to the neighborhoods in question. In any case, we encourage you to work with us to discuss regulatory best practices and compliance tools that can help make a longer term regulatory strategy most effective. Expedia Group believes that short-term rentals can thrive alongside long-term residences in every neighborhood. The effectiveness of STR policies is determined not by the existence of HOAs or neighborhood entry gates, but by imposing rigorous operational requirements backed by a robust City enforcement team. We have developed several regulatory tools we can employ on our platforms to enhance the effectiveness of City enforcement efforts. For example, we can work directly with City staff to require all listings on our platforms to contain a valid permit number. We can also connect our listing platforms with City databases to automatically remove any listing bearing an invalid or revoked permit number. This process of noncompliant listing removal would help the City eliminate any loopholes or workarounds for property owners who have their permits suspended or revoked, driving a high rate of compliance with the City's regulations. Enacting these requirements in statute would ensure consistency across platforms. Enhancing and re-focusing the City's enforcement tools will yield far better results than a moratorium on new permits. Thank you for the opportunity to share our perspective. Please do not hesitate to contact me to discuss the details of how we can work with you to ensure the City's policies are as fair and effective as possible. Sincerely, Richard de Sam Lazaro Senior Manager, Government and Community Expedia Group � 1111 Expedia Group Way West � Seattle WA 981 19 � United States Sanchez, Gloria From: Ann Morales <ann.morales012@icloud.com> Sent: Thursday, September 10, 2020 5:31 PM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: STR I am a resident on Lavender Way and am requesting that you approve adding our neighborhood to the R1 zoning standard which bans STRs. I have STR next to our home and behind our home. The noise and parties has escalated. Kareoke, loud music and fighting at 2:30 am are among the challenges the STR have created. Please consider my request. Ann Morales Sent from my iPhone Sanchez, Gloria From: Rebecca Flanagan <cvtaflanagan@gmail.com> Sent: Thursday, September 10, 2020 10:48 AM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: STR permit moratorium ordinance discussion-please read Dear Members of the City Council, Thank you in advance for voting on the STR permit moratorium ordinance and for listening to our very serious concerns about the invasive short term vacation rentals in our planned residential neighborhoods. It has become very clear over time that no amount of regulation or enforcement will be able to stop the transient, party culture of the people who rent these houses. There are villas and hotels widely available in Palm Desert that welcome such party-goers and this type of behavior. Working people, families and retirees however, deserve to live in a neighborhood where they have neighbors and not a constant flow of overnight strangers who don't care about anything but getting inebriated. I know you have already heard many stories about how this affects the entire culture of a neighborhood . My neighbors and I are requesting that you initiate the process to change our neighborhoods from planned residential to R 1 at the September 24th meeting. There is no other solution to this matter and allowing short term rentals to keep operating in neighborhoods without HOAs is affecting the overall health and well being of so many. Just one rental affects at least three to four other residences-there is never a"quiet" short term rental and each new arrival brings more mayhem. Now that the bars are closed, people rent a house for just two short days, invite all their friends and pack them in for a bash on our streets. If we were an R 1 residential neighborhood and someone wanted to profit off their home, they would have to be there on site to deal with their guests. This would solve the issue of loud parties because a homeowner would not allow such horrible behavior. Because they are never here, they don't know how bad it really is. Please take swift action to correct the zoning error of these neighborhoods and have a sunset period of no longer than six months to stop this madness. We have had to put up with this nightmare long enough already. As said many many times, no amount of regulation or enforcement will be able to stop this blight on our streets and it will only get warse now that other cities in the desert are taking action to remove them from their neighborhoods. Thank you again for your consideration in this matter, Rebecca Flanagan 40613 Diamondback Drive Sanchez, Gloria From: James & Gladys <sandtreasuresandmore@gmail.com> Sent: Thursday, September 10, 2020 9:20 AM To: CouncilMeeting Comments; Sanchez, Gloria Subject: Re: PLEASE HAVE READ SEPT 10th MEETING Regarding Short Term Rentals On Thu, Sep 10, 2020, 9:09 AM James & Gladys <�����trLa���resan��c�c���� �'�����il.cc�r��> wrote: The city of Palm Desert needs to stop the Issuing of permits and operation of short term rentals immediately. The agenda and purpose of others involved including the short term rental owners is to profit, create havoc, take advantage, and has been shown to clearly ignore the homeowners that have complained without and recourses proven. The permit request are being given without consideration and respect to the residents that choose to live here full time. We want what the city has given to other homeowners that have a peaceful lifestyle from the short term rental hiatus in regards to the ban from short term rentals in 2017. The creation of the zoning map from the city of Palm Desert proves that this is not taken seriously and is unnecessary. We are in a R1 zone. Give us the right to have our neighborhood back and fix this now. Before it becomes a short term rental pandemic. Bring back the commitment to sustain and improve the quality of life and open space residents love and enjoy," As elected City Councils of Palm Desert and appointed city officials all must do everything in your power to safeguard residents against those whose only goal is to profit off our wonderful City of Palm Desert. This is a public safety issue. It always has been and it always will be. Jim & Gladys Bersamin 40585 Meadow Lane Palm Desert, Sanchez, Gloria From: Cliff <diamond@socal.rr.com> Sent: Wednesday, September 9, 2020 4:12 PM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: STR Moratorium Please read at the September 10, 2020 meeting regarding STR Moratorium: Members of the Council: I stated my reasons for wanting the council to rezone our neighborhood to R1 at your August 27th meeting so I won't repeat myself here. That said, I urge you to approve the motion for a STR Moratorium until you have had time to more fully consider our request for re-zoning. The real estate market in our neighborhood has been very active and we should put potential buyers on notice that a short term rental ban is under consideration and until a decision has been rendered they will not be permitted. With Cathedral City moving in that direction it will make our little neighborhood even more vulnerable. So even if you think you may not vote for the zoning change, please, please vote for the moratorium until the final decision has been made. Thank you for your consideration. Respectfully, Cliff Sanforth 40783 Sandpiper Ct., Palm Desert, Hovely West neighborhood Sanchez, Gloria From: Sent: To: Subject: Attachments: valetvideo@aol.com Wednesday, September 9, 2020 3:15 PM CouncilMeeting Comments Fwd: 40744 Via Fonda 20200906_110828jpg Please read at meeting. This is a new STR that closed escrow in July and we are already having issues of cars parking on sidewalk. A short time after this photo was taken the white SUV was parked even more on the sidewalk. I did not have my phone to take a new picture. I have lived here in Palm Desert for many years and was involved with the great "Set To Save" energy efficiency program and take great pride to say that I live in Palm Desert, but these STR issues are having a very negative impact on the town I call home. Please do something about this problem before it gets out of hand. Yes the city may make a few dollars from the STR program but how much is it costing in man hours, aggravation and stress? What happens when we have another economic downturn and the city has to lay off staff, can the council guarantee the the Code Compliance office and the dedicated STR officer will not be terminated? Then who will follow up on the complaints then? Please do the right thing and follow your constituents wishes. These are our homes not a business Thank you Mark wasson -----Original Message----- From: valetvideo@aol.com To: kswartz@cityofpalmdesert.org <kswartz@cityofpalmdesert.org>; Iritchey@cityofpalmdesert.org <Iritchey@cityofpalmdesert.org>; prodriguez@cityofpalmdesert.org <prodriguez@cityofpalmdesert.org> Sent: Sun, Sep 6, 2020 12:19 pm Subject: 40744 Via Fonda 40744 Via Fonda has several cars parked on street and blocking driveway and sidewalk & , a �r� � k � � � I i �i, � �, � a �� � � � � � �� <� r � Sanchez, Gloria From: Diana McGinity <dianamcginity@gmail.com> Sent: Wednesday, September 9, 2020 12:46 PM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: STR Moratorium Request to be read at the city council meeting on Sept. 10, 2020 Dear City Council Members, We plead with each of you to personally place yourselves in our Hovley Lane West neighborhood and try to imagine what this community will look like in a short period of time without a moratorium on STRs. Because rental operators invite the paying public into a private residential area, conditions are deteriorating rapidly. Neighbors have had enough noise, garbage, multiple vehicles parked everywhere, foul language, and drunkenness. We are at a breaking point with many residents threatening to leave. Then what? More STRs will gain a foothold as operators will buy up vacated homes and the situation becomes beyond horrific! We are at a critical point. All of us need your help now to SAVE HOVLEY LANE WEST! We want to preserve the residential quality of our area and enjoy the peacefulness of a secure neighborhood. To each of you, we implore you to support the STR moratorium; it is our only protection. Thank you, Diana and Bob McGinity 40501 Meadow Lane Sanchez, Gloria From: William Choplin <wchoplin@icloud.com> Sent: Wednesday, September 9, 2020 12:04 PM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: Short Term Rental Item on 9/10 City Council Agenda Please read during the city council meeting on 9/10 at the appropriate time for the STR Urgency Ordinance. Please acknowledge receipt of this message. Thank you, William Choplin Nancy Nowak and William Choplin 40669 Diamondback Dr Thank you Council Members for considering the urgency ordinance to place a moratorium on new STR permits in our neighborhoods. Yesterday we noticed a house go up for sale on our street. We immediately became concerned that the house will be sold to a STR operator and increase the disruption to our day to day lives already caused by other STRs on our street. With Cathedral City moving to ban STRs in their R1 neighborhoods, we fully expect the homes in our neighborhoods to be prime targets for STR owners needing to relocate their operations and our homes will be picked off one by one. We are sitting ducks. The city made an honest oversight in 2017 when the planned residential neighborhoods with single family homes were not included in the R1 and R2 STR ban. The city anticipated the need for banning STRs in our neighborhoods when language was added to the STR permit application warning applicants that the city would likely impose more restrictions. We don't see the issue as complicated. The arguments for and against STRs in single family neighborhoods are the same now as they were in 2017. No one is disputing that our neighborhoods function like R1 neighborhoods. We understand that the city must go through a standard administrative process to include us in R1. We're are asking Council Members to begin that process today by passing the urgency ordinance and moving the process along quickly. Thank you. Sanchez, Gloria From: Maria R <anselita56@yahoo.com> Sent: Wednesday, September 9, 2020 10:10 AM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: Fw: Council Meeting comments on STRs Good Morning , Please read during the STR Permit Moratorium Ordinance discussion . Respectfully requesting :� 1.- Pass the temporary moratorium Ordinance 2.- The STR Subcommittee recommendations should be presented at the 09/24/2020 City Council meeting and include a Ban on STRs, in non HOA Planned Residential neighborhoods and if a sunset is provided for current STRs, it should be no longer than 6 months. We are Maria A and Jorge Rodriguez , Palm Desert residents in a Non HOA Planned Residential Neighborhood. For the past 15 years have lived next to a STR house and for all these years we've enduring multiples issues for which, I've been complaining through the hotline and the Code Enforcement Officer. Lately we had a Zoom meeting with Officer Rodriguez to explain our problems. Back in 2015 Officer Shawn Kirkpatrick took the complains and helped with the situation, things got better for a while. But for the past year things have gotten much worse because was a change of ownership. Under the new ownership , the house is listed for Events and for up to 12 people per stay, which brings large groups, people that exhibit a total disregard for the permanent residents of this quiet neighborhood. During this Pandemia this STR never stopped to receive customers, has been booked continuously. Main issues are : - Very loud music ,loud conversations and activities in backyard at any time day or night, multiple times we've been awaken at 2, 3, 4 and 5 in the morning by this noise. Sanchez, Gloria From: diana leal <dclgirl@yahoo.com> Sent: Tuesday, September 8, 2020 8:44 PM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: Short Term Rental Ban Please read at September 10, 2020 Council meeting during short term rental permit moratorium ordinance discussion: Honorable Mayor and Members of the Palm Desert City Council: My name is Miguel Leal. I live at 74537 Lavender Way in Palm Desert. Due to a short term rental (STR) next door, we have experienced loud noise, large gatherings, trash issues and mail obstruction. In the last 5 months, there have been at least 5 more STRs operating on our street. This has caused more traffic and unknown individuals in our neighborhood. Because of STRs, Palm Desert hotels are losing customers. Hotel employees are losing their jobs due to less occupancy. Some STRs are letting more occupants stay (up to 5 families). More occupants than what is allowed. It is basically living next door to a hotel. Three to four times a week people come and go. Our quality of life has diminished greatly. We feel less safe and fear that the value of our home will decrease. I would like to ask the City Council to: 1) Please consider the passing of a temporary moratorium ordinance for new STR permits. 2) Ask the short term rental subcommittee to study and present recommendations at the September 24th City Council meeting and include a ban on STRs in non-HOA planned residential neighborhoods. And, 3) If a sunset is provided for current STRs, request that the sunset be no longer than 6 months. Council's time and consideration is greatly appreciated. Thank you. Sincerely, Miguel Leal Dear Members of the Palm Desert City Council: We are respectfully requesting that you support passing the temporary moratorium ordinance on STR Permits. Over the past two plus years our neighborhood has changed from being a quiet, friendly and orderly one to a neighborhood of raucous parties, loud music and a continual flow of cars and people into an otherwise quiet, family oriented setting. Each of us purchased our homes in our West Hovely neighborhood because of the peaceful, orderly and supportive nature that it provided. It has now become an unruly and noisy neighborhood occupied by STR visitors who have shown no respect for our order, privacy and cleanliness that we work so hard to maintain with our permanent residents. We are also requesting that the STR Subcommittee recommendations be presented at the September 24th City Council Meeting and include a ban on STR's in non-HOA Planned Residential neighborhoods. We also request that if a"sunset" is provided for current STR's, that it be no longer than six months. We would greatly appreciate your support in our attempts to recoup the neighborhood environment that drew us all to this beautiful neighborhood originally. We hope you will positively represent and support us, your constituents, over the money-making wishes of out of town owners. Thank your for your consideration of support in this critical issue to so many of us Hovely West residents. Sincerely, Bill and Cheryl Bester Palm Desert and West Hovely Residents since 2011. Sanchez, Gloria From: ace kidd <histokid@hotmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, September 8, 2020 12:43 PM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: 9/08/2020 Request to have comments read at next city council meeting regarding STR's To all city council members, I want to take this extremely important opportunity, to reiterate my personal request to ban STR's in our non- HOA residential neighborhood. For far too many years we have been plagued with STR's directly across and next to us. We have had to put up with all sorts of ruckus on a regular routine basis. The sheriff's department has been out several times, as well as code enforcement on many occasions. Renters routinely play load music, which can be heard from across the street and even when we are indoors. The STR located at 74-140 College View Circle East, is essentially a party house as noted by their Wi-FI name "The Party House". On a regular basis there are no less than 4-5 vehicles parked at this residence and I have counted as many as 14 at times. Vehicles are regularly parked up and down the street and often blocking the sidewalk. This is a 3- bedroom home with an additional converted bedroom. The property is listed on VRBO as sleeps 12 with additional beds available upon request and "Parties Allowed". I have lived in this once peaceful Neiborhood since it was first developed and have witnessed the negative impacts from STR's. I recently told one of my young children, it is unfair we should have to contemplate moving out of the neighborhood to give way to those only motivated by profit. My neighbors and I selected to live in a residential neighborhood, not a business type neighborhood who's only focus is self-interest and profit. In speaking with a couple of my immediate neighbors, they too are contemplating moving. Our final opportunity to regain our peace and remain in the neighborhood rests with your decision to do the right thing by banning STR's as you did in other parts of Palm Desert. Please have my comments read and included in the upcoming city council meeting. Sincerely, Arn 760-773-2013 Sanchez, Gloria From: Courtney Halterlein <courtneyhalterlein@me.com> Sent: Tuesday, September 8, 2020 12:30 PM To: CouncilMeeting Comments Subject: Short Term Rental letter 9/10 We are requesting this letter be read aloud during the city council meeting on 9/10 during the time when short term rentals are being discussed. Please confirm receipt. City Council Members, Since our previous letter to you, at the last city council meeting, it's come to our attention that there is another new Short Term Rental on our street, Via Fonda. This is the 3rd short term rental to arrive on this street of only 12 homes. Which makes that 25% of the homes on our street currently operating as short term rentals. We asking for short term rentals banned as soon as possible, to put a stop to this. It has become completely unmanageable, and the fact that all of the "policing" of these rentals falls on the neighbors and homeowners is no longer acceptable. We don't want to be woken up by the constant noise coming from next door and across the street and be responsible for dealing with this, calling the rental hotline or being redirected to the sherriffs' non emergency line when it's after hours for the city code officers. The common thread in all of this is that no matter where short term rentals are located, NO ONE wants to be the one who lives next to them. The same thing happened in 2017 when you voted to ban them in R-1 and R-2. We are having the same experience due to the fact that the situation has not changed. Please stop the new permits and permanently ban short term rentals in PR zones so that we can enjoy the same quality of life as the residents of R-1 zones. Thank you, Scott and Courtney Halterlein