HomeMy WebLinkAboutInformational Update - Aestjetic Features for Council Chamber RnvtnSTAFF REPORT
CITY OF PALM DESERT
DEPARTMENT
MEETING DATE: November 14, 2019
PREPARED BY: Emily Roethler, Project Manager
REQUEST: Receive and file an informational update and appoint two (2) Council
Members to serve on the sub -committee and provide input regarding
aesthetic features for proposed Council Chamber renovations,
including the selection of paint color schemes and the finish materials
of furniture and other fixtures
Recommendation
By Minute Motion:
1. Receive and file informational update
2. Appoint two (2) Council Members to serve on the sub -committee and
provide input regarding aesthetic features for proposed Council Chamber
renovations, including the selection of paint color schemes and the finish
materials of furniture and other fixtures.
Strateqic Plan Obiectives
This action has no impact on the Strategic Plan.
Backaround Analvsis
The City Council Chamber was originally constructed in 1983 and was remodeled in
2000-2001. The remodel removed walls and doors, replaced carpeting, improved
council/director seating areas, and updated various audio visual (AV) components. During
this project, the original public seating in the Chamber was reinstalled over the new
carpeting.
The original seating that dates back to 1983 has degraded due to heavy use and age and
is no longer comfortable for the residents and staff who attend Council and Commission
meetings, sometimes for extended hours. The existing 35-year old seating no longer
provides adequate space for compliance with Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA)
mandated seating areas. The condition of the seating, along with the lack of appropriate
accommodations for ADA use, requires that the seating be replaced and upgraded to
current standards. Additionally, the City Council Chamber is no longer in compliance with
November 14, 2019 - Staff Report
Informational Update and Council Member Appointment for Council Chamber Interior
Design (Project No. 765-19)
Page 2 of 3
current ADA codes and standards for access. For example, the slope of the ramp leading
from the lobby to the public seating area exceeds the maximum allowed slope of 8%, the
handrails are non -compliant, and the texture of the wall behind the existing handrails
creates an architectural barrier for those who need to use them.
Recently, there has been an increased awareness surrounding the Council Chamber and
the need to update many of the interior features. During Council break in Summer 2019,
various IT/AV upgrades to enhance the usability and accessibility for Council, City staff,
and the public were implemented according to the IT Master Plan for the City. Additionally,
in April 2019, City Council appropriated $90,000 for design and compilation of
construction documents for the interior of the Council Chamber. Monies have been
included in the Capital Improvement Program (CIP) for Fiscal Year 2020/2021 for the
construction of this design.
The conceptual design work for Council Chamber Interior Improvements is approximately
65% complete. The preliminary design work has included the production of architectural
renderings showing the replacement of the built-in seating and carpet in the Council
Chamber, updating the podium to meet the needs of the public, updating existing
improvements to current ADA standards (access doors, ramp, handrails, and paths of
travel), redesigning the restrooms to current ADA standards, and creating a new access
door for the relocated control room. The construction of this phase of work is preliminarily
estimated to cost $1.7 million. Pending approval by City Council, including the
appropriation of sufficient budget for the remodel, the advertising and construction award
is anticipated Spring 2020 with construction over the July/August break in 2020.
Staff notes that the nature of this project and the highly visible location of it make it likely
that interested persons will suggest any number of enhancements and upgrades to the
project scope. While such additions to the project are always possible, they could quickly
grow to eclipse the original intent, which is to improve accessibility for persons with
disabilities, replace aged and uncomfortable seating, upgrade the general aesthetics of
the Chamber, and provide floor coverings that will enhance acoustics by minimizing
noises that currently disturb City Council meetings and interrupt the conduct of business.
At this time, the appointment of two (2) Council Members is being requested to aid in the
decision making for the overall aesthetics, including the selection of paint color schemes
and finish materials of furniture and other fixtures, so as to more effectively plan and
appropriately budget for it.
Fiscal Analvsis
Construction funds are being requested for Fiscal Year 2020-2021. The total project cost
cannot be accurately estimated until the scope of work, including ADA requirements and
other aesthetic features are further identified and narrowed. However, a preliminary
scope anticipated a $1.7 million total construction budget.
November 14, 2019 - Staff Report
Informational Update and Council Member Appointment for Council Chamber Interior
Design (Project No. 765-19)
Page 3of3
LEGAL REVIEW DEPT. REVIEW
FINANCIAL
REVIEW
Robert W. Hargreaves Tom Garcia, P.E. et M. Moore
City Attorney Director of Public Works Director of Finance
City Mana , �urierlin:
ASSISTANT
CITY MANAgER
I /
Andy Firest' e
Assistant Cit Manager