HomeMy WebLinkAboutMinutes - Parks and Recreation Commission 09/03/2019*Dl- H - -:�-
CITY OF PALM DESERT
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
INTEROFFICE MEMORANDUM
TO: Rachelle D. Klassen, City Clerk
FROM: Angie Marron, Office Specialist II
DATE: November 5, 2019
SUBJECT: Submission of Minutes for the Parks and Recreation
Commission
Attached for your records are the approved minutes of the Parks and Recreation
Commission Meeting of Tuesday, September 03, 2019.
Please let me know if you have any questions or need additional information. Thank you.
Attachment (as noted)
CITY OF PALM DESERT
MINUTES
PARKS AND RECREATION COMMISSION
REGULAR MEETING
TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 03, 2019 — 8:30 a.m.
Administrative Conference Room — Palm Desert Civic Center
73-510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert, California 92260
CALL TO ORDER
Chair Van G. Tanner convened the meeting at 8:30 a.m.
II. ROLL CALL
Present:
Chair Van G. Tanner
Vice Chair Mary Helen Kelly
Commissioner Randy Guyer
Commissioner Lynn Bixen
Commissioner Gerald Dawson
Commissioner Paul Murphy
Absent
Commissioner Kim Housken
Commissioner Mike Hardin
Rob Ballew, YMCA of the Desert
Ex-Officio Members:
Kevin Kalman, Desert Recreation District
Also Present:
Ryan Stendell, Director of Community Development
Eric Ceja, Principal Planner
Jennifer Nelson, Management Analyst
Randy Chavez, Landscape Supervisor
Sabby Jonathan, Council Liaison
Angie Marron, Recording Secretary
Guests:
David Keyes, YMCA of the Desert / Aquatic Center
Brenda Nutcher, Desert Recreation District
Laura McGalliard, Desert Recreation District
Tammy Martin, Friends of the Desert Mountains
John Luff, Desert Wave Ventures
Jason Miknuk, Wing Solutions
PARKS AND RECREATION COMMISSION
MINUTES SEPTEMBER 03, 2019
III. ORAL COMMUNICATIONS
NONE
IV. CONSENT CALENDAR
A. MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF TUESDAY, JUNE 04, 2019
Rec: Approve as presented
Upon a motion by Commissioner Murphy, second by Commissioner Bixen, carried
by a 6-0-2 vote of the Commission, (AYES: Guyer, Dawson, Bixen, Tanner, Murphy,
Kelly; NOES: None; ABSENT: Housken, Hardin) the Consent Calendar was approved as
presented
V. NEW BUSINESS
A. WAVE PARK UPDATE
- Presentation by Eric Ceja, Principal Planner
Principal Planner, Eric Ceja, and John Luff from Desert Wave Ventures
gave a presentation. Mr. Ceja stated that the Planning Department received
an application to develop a surf park from Desert Wave Ventures in
December of 2018. It is a masterplan that will involve hotel space, an event
center as well as villa units. The presentation included a proposal for a five
and half acre lagoon with surf technology designed to create consistent
waves and attract surfers to the desert. A specific and precise plan
application has been submitted. The Planning Department will also be
working on an environmental analysis for this proposal along with an
environmental impact report.
Mr. Luff, stated that this is a unique destination resort anchored by a surf
lagoon. It's the first of its type in the world. The first of its kind technology
will be utilized for this five and half acre surf lagoon to replicate ocean
waves. The idea is to create a surf lagoon with a controlled crowd and
controlled condition that will provide a premium experience. From a
recreational aspect, it changes the entire vibe in the water. He believes a
lot of people are looking for this type of experience, and will come to the
desert to escape the beach crowds and experience this high end resort with
the whole family. It is becoming increasingly rare throughout the world. Surf
in a lagoon is much safer than an actual body of water like the ocean
because of the fear of the unknown. They are able to produce waves that
are actually safer and feasible for everyone. Wave Garden is a company
that Desert Wave Ventures works with. A video of another concept located
in Spain was played for the Commission. It was very vibrant and engaging.
2
PARKS AND RECREATION COMMISSION
MINUTES SEPTEMBER 03,E 2019
Commissioner Bixen asked if there will be contests since she has seen
them on television. Mr. Luff stated that from a competition division, and
training events standpoint, the lagoon and surf pools are ideal for
competitive purposes. It's something that a lot of the broadcast companies
are particularly interested in because it can actually be planned and
programmed. In response to Commissioner Murphy's question, Mr. Luff
stated this is the first time he has taken on this kind of project. Mr. Luff
worked for the current developers and consulted internationally, and
domestically for these types of projects. Commissioner Guyer asked what
the time frame is for the project. The lagoon itself will take 14 to 18 months
to complete leaving the entire project to be, about 18 to 24 months. There
are two operator partners for the hotel brand. Desert Wave is also hoping
for night surf and integrating lights in this project that are sensitive to dark
skies at night. It is a unique approach. They went to the International Dark
Sky Association and worked with them and a company called Musco Sports
Lighting Design to come up with a lighting design that effectively meets the
International Dark Sky Association standards for a dark sky friendly lighting
system.
Chair Tanner asked what kind of international contests can be brought to
the desert. Pro Forma does not bank on having any large formal
international contests. Desert Wave Ventures has a great relationship with
The International Surf Association and its president. The capabilities are
high with surf lagoons. It opens the doors to many people with different
disabilities, and the U.S. Olympics are conceivable. The Commission asked
if there will be parking issues, water temperature controlled in the winter,
and if season passes will be offered for residents. The water may have a
solar thermal component to supplement the water with heat. We may not
be able to bring up the temperature to 82 degrees during winter. Mr.
Stendell explained the entire parking situation and its adequacy. There will
be overflow parking, shuttles, and underground parking. The City is being
guided as to what is appropriate for the area. Sabby Jonathan mentioned
that the underground parking will be public not just Desert Wave specific.
They are also contemplating programs for people that would like to come a
couple times a week not just throughout the year. Sabby Jonathan stated
that they have encouraged the developer to integrate discounts for locals,
residents, YMCA members, and the colleges.
It is important to build a relationship with the community. Surf camps would
be a great envision. It would also bring jobs to the area. Commissioner
Guyer is concerned with the lack of the recreational aspect. Vice Chair Kelly
believes this project would be a great financial help for the City of Palm
Desert. There has never been anything like it, and City staff has done a
great job researching this proposed project. City Council would appreciate
feedback from the Commission in regards to this project.
91
PARKS AND RECREATION COMMISSION
MINUTES SEPTEMBER 03, 2019
Upon a motion by Commissioner Murphy, second by Vice Chair Kelly, carried by
a 6-0-2 vote of the Commission, (AYES: Guyer, Dawson, Bixen, Tanner, Murphy, Kelly;
NOES: None; ABSENT: Housken, Hardin) the Commission motions to move forward with
this project and present to City Council for approval.
B. DRD MASTER PLAN SURVEY RESULTS UPDATE
Kevin Kalman utilized a PowerPoint presentation to update the Commission
on survey results. The DRD has been working on using a different
approach from 2013. They have invested time to determine different
statistics as a whole. The goal was to gather feedback. Mr. Kalman worked
with City staff, not just district but everyone in the valley. They want to
ensure and reflect the needs of each community. The survey was done
online, by phone and intercept surveys as well between March and May of
2019. All methods were combined to achieve results. The Riverside
County areas were divided as east and west. In total there were over three
thousand involved with the survey. All survey methods included Spanish,
to make sure everyone had the ability to participate, and Census data was
also used; each participating municipality overall provided consistent
representation to the communities.
There was a high percentage of permanent residents, the average age is
older in Palm Desert. The top three barriers in participation is consistent
with 2013. Palm Desert resulted with having no time or other personal
issues as a top reason, and not aware of programs of facilities was another.
The overall result was higher about needs not being met. Both valley wide
and Palm Desert, walking trails and paths have been number one for
activity. Items to be added or to be improved are pedestrian and bike paths
as a top priority. Parks and playgrounds were high needs for residents.
Communication is essential to getting through and reaching out to the
community. Sixty-two percent of Palm Desert residents surveyed, utilize
the Community Center. Mr. Kalman offered to have the complete survey
sent to all Commissioners.
VI. CONTINUED BUSINESS
None
VII. OLD BUSINESS
A. BIKE REPAIR INSTALL
Randy Chavez stated that the bike repair station was installed about a
month ago. It's a nice big orange mechanism; a guinea pig for future
installations. The reason that color was chosen is because they reached
out to CV Link and their color scheme was orange, so it was decided to
keep the themes linked. This is also a tentative install for all Palm Desert
4
PARKS AND RECREATION COMMISSION
MINUTES SEPTEMBER 03. 2019
parks. Mr. Chavez did confirm that the bike repair does get plenty of
utilization
Vill. PRESENTATIONS AND UPDATES
A. PARK USE REPORT
- Civic Center
Randy Chavez stated the Civic Center has been taking a holistic approach
for the last twenty years. The last two years they have had to rebuild two
ponds. The overpopulation of turtles is causing issues with the pumps.
Fortunately, Wing Solutions reached out to the City and helped out with the
over population of ducks; so far it has been working. Jason Miknuk was
present to introduce one of his furry friends. They work at night when the
ducks are less active. With two herding dogs and a hawk, this creates a
hostile environment for the ducks and they leave the area They are working
on pushing them more towards the east end of the valley. They have
reduced the animal population by 65% since they started. They work with
the evasive species as well. Commissioners seem very pleased with this
approach. Mr. Chavez stated that we have to be very cautious and
conscientious and try to be as humane as possible. The red ear slider
turtles are problematic as well. Traps will be set in lagoons to humanely
catch turtles, remove them and send them to a sanctuary in the San Diego
area. The contractor will decide where to re -locate the turtles. Closure of
dog parks will begin the week of September 23rd for over seeding.
B. PALM DESERT AQUATIC CENTER
David Keyes stated they had a great summer, no major emergencies this
year, and the numbers jumped up substantially from last year. More non-
residents are attending. Swim lessons were great, 1,195 group and private
in total. Now they have a bit of space issues, however nothing major. Mr.
Keyes and staff are coming up with creative ways to use the shallow end of
the pool. Events coming up, Palm Desert Swim Club, Oct. 11-13; April &
October of 2020. Diving competitions, Veterans weekend November 9-11.
Programming, fall lessons start today, with 70 people, and will typically get
well over 100. It seems that some Palm Springs residents are coming to
the PDAC because of better pricing. Staffing was great this year. No issues
with the pool being too hot.
C. FAMILY YMCA OF THE DESERT
None
PARKS AND RECREATION COMMISSION
MINUTES SEPTEMBER 03, 2019
D. DESERT RECREATION DISTRICT
Brenda Nutcher stated that summer was very busy. DRD averaged about
80 kids in camp, youth basketball had 324 kids participate, music program
continues with drums and guitar lessons. Salsa/aerobics was canceled.
Fourth day was added during the week specifically for pickleball.
First Tee — wrapping up construction this week. Next session is set to start
October 15.
E. FRIENDS OF THE DESERT MOUNTAINS
Tammy Martin stated that crews will be out evaluating all trails. They are
working on signage near the cross, and has a volunteer who would like to
do yoga on the trails, and would like the Commission to be on board with
the proposed project. Ryan Stendell stated they would have to run a
facilities use permit, and go through some options. Mr. Stendell stated he
will touch base with Ms. Martin, Jennifer Nelson and update the
Commission on the yoga proposal.
IX. COMMISSIONER, COUNCIL -LIAISON, AND STAFF COMMENTS
Vice Chair Kelly was glad to meet again and see everyone. Ryan Stendell
introduced Jennifer Nelson, who will be replacing Johnny Terfehr and will be the
operation arms for Parks and Recreation. Ms. Nelson was previously with the city
of Palm Springs, and city of Newport Beach as Assistant City Clerk. Ryan Stendell
is excited to be back to full staff in Community Development and encourages
everyone to support the Vision San Pablo Project.
Randy Chavez stated that the pickleball project starts construction soon.
X. ADJOURNMENT
With unanimous consent of the Commission, the meeting was adjourned at 10:22
a.m.
Qie Ma n cording Secretary
0