HomeMy WebLinkAboutRES 2022-093RESOLUTION NO. 2022-93
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT,
CALIFORNIA, TO ADOPT A MITIGATED NEGATIVE DECLARATION IN
ACCORDANCE WITH THE CALIFORNIA ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY ACT
(CEQA) AND APPROVE THE REFUGE SPECIFIC PLAN LOCATED ON
106.4 ACRES AT THE SOUTHWEST CORNER OF GERALD FORD DRIVE
AND REMBRANDT PARKWAY
CASE NOS. SP/EA22-0001
WHEREAS, Refuge Palm Desert, LLC ("Applicant"), submitted a Specific Plan
application for the Refuge Palm Desert Project to facilitate the development of 7 49 to 969
residential units, circulation, and infrastructure improvements on a vacant 106.4-acre site
located at the southwest corner of Gerald Ford Drive and extension of improvements
("Project"); and
WHEREAS, the Project site has a land use designation of Town Center Neighborhood
(TCN) in the General Plan adopted November 10, 2016, and a zoning designation of Planning
Residential (PR-20); and
WHEREAS, under Section 21067 of the Public Resources Code, Section 15367 of the
State CEQA Guidelines (Cal. Code Regs., tit. 14, § 15000 et seq.), and the City of Palm
Desert's ("City's") Local CEQA Guidelines, the City is the lead agency for the Project; and
WHEREAS, in accordance with State CEQA Guidelines Section 15063, the City
conducted an Initial Study to determine if the Project may have a significant effect on the
environment and to evaluate whether an Environmental Impact Report (EIR) was required;
and
WHEREAS, pursuant to the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act
(CEQA), the State Guidelines for Implementation of CEQA (State CEQA Guidelines), and the
City of Palm Desert CEQA Implementation Requirements, a Mitigated Negative Declaration
(MND), SCH# 2022100013 (EA 22-0001) and an accompanying Mitigation Monitoring and
Reporting Program (MMRP) attached as Exhibit "A" to this resolution, were prepared for the
Project; and
WHEREAS, the Project will designate the site as the Refuge Specific Plan and
establish design guidelines, development standards, and plans for the distribution, location
and extent of the uses of land, including open space, and residential within the area covered
by the plan. The full text of the Specific Plan dated October 2022, is attached as Exhibit "B"
to this resolution; and
WHEREAS, the Project is consistent with the development density and use
characteristics considered by the General Plan EIR in the TCN land use designation; and
WHEREAS, on September 29, 2022, the City Council of the City of Palm Desert
adopted the 2021-2029 Housing Element for the 6th Cycle, which allocates that the Project
site provides a minimum of 269 units for affordable housing; and
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 2
WHEREAS, the Refuge Specific Plan ("Specific Plan") has been prepared pursuant to the
California Government Code §65451 and is compliant with state law; and
WHEREAS, the Planning Commission of the City of Palm Desert, California, did on
the 18 th day of October 2022, hold a duly noticed public hearing to consider the request by
the Applicant and adopted Planning Commission Resolution No. 2820 recommending that
the City Council approve the above-noted Project subject to findings of approval; and
WHEREAS, all other legal prerequisites to the adoption of this Resolution have
occurred; and
WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Palm Desert, did on the 17th day of
November 2022, hold a duly noticed public hearing, the City Council opened the public
hearing, the City Council considered the request by the Applicant for the development of the
Specific Plan and Environmental Assessment; and
WHEREAS, at the said public hearing, upon hearing and considering all testimony and
arguments, if any, of all interested persons desiring to be heard, the City Council did find the
following facts and reasons, which are outlined in the staff report, exist to justify approval of
said request.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Palm Desert,
California, as follows:
SECTION 1. Recitals. The City Council hereby finds that the foregoing recitals are
true and correct and are incorporated herein as substantive findings of this Resolution.
SECTION 2. Specific Plan Statutory Requirements. Pursuant to Government Code
§65451, a specific plan must contain the minimum required information to be considered
legally adequate. The Specific Plan provides the following items compliant with state law:
§65451 (a) A specific plan shall include a text and a diagram or diagrams which specify all of
the following in detail:
1) The distribution, location, and extent of the uses of land, including open space, within
the area covered by the plan.
The Specific Plan provides exhibits throughout Chapter 1 and Chapter 2 identifying
the extent and location of land uses and open space covered by the plan. Exhibits are
provided, which depict the location of the five (5) planning areas, land uses, and
residential densities within each Planning Area. Table 2.1 -Land Use Summary found
in section 2.1 Land Use Plan of the Specific Plan identifies the acreage and allowable
residential density range for Planning Areas within the plan area. Chapter 2.2, found
in the Specific Plan, provides a description of the land use for each respective planning
area. Figure 2.1 -Conceptual Land Use Plan found on the Specific Plan provides a
diagram illustrating the location of Planning Areas throughout the plan area.
2
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 3
2) The distribution, location, and extent and intensity of major components of public and
private transportation, sewage, water, drainage, solid waste disposal, energy, and
other essential facilities to be located within the area covered by the plan and needed
to support the land uses described in the plan.
The Specific Plan contains an infrastructure plan for essential major components of
public and private transportation, sewage, water, drainage, solid waste disposal,
vehicle entry, and other essential facilities. The plan identifies necessary
improvements for the development, including descriptive text and illustrative diagrams
under Chapters 2.3 through 2.6 of the Specific Plan. The Specific Plan includes
diagrams and exhibits depicting planned infrastructure improvements necessary to
facilitate the planned land use. The improvements will include water and sewer (see
Chapter 2.5), grading and drainage (Chapter 2.6) as well as a plan for phasing of the
improvements over the planned buildout. The Project will be connecting to the existing
respective 12-inch water and sewer mains located on Gerald Ford Drive and Julie
Drive, which are provided by the Coachella Valley Water District (CVWD). The Project
prepared a Water Supply Verification/Water Supply Assessment, which has been
approved by CVWD and indicates that there are adequate water supplies for the
Project.
3) Standards and criteria by which development will proceed, and standards for the
conservation, development, and utilization of natural resources, where applicable.
The Specific Plan contains standards and criteria by which development will proceed,
and standards for the conservation, development, and utilization of natural resources.
Development of the land under land use change consideration will need to comply
with these requirements. Chapter 3 of the Specific Plan establishes the general
development standards for each of the five (5) PAs. Chapter 3.2 outlines the allowable
uses for all Planning Areas and generally allow residential uses within Planning Areas
(PA) 1 through 3 and space areas within PAs 4 and 5. Chapter 3.3 outlines the
development standards for each of the five (5) Planning Areas. General design
guidelines for all Planning Areas are provided under Chapter 4 of the Specific Plan.
4) A program of implementation measures, including regulations, programs, public works
projects, and financing measures necessary to carry out paragraphs (1 ), (2), and (3).
The Specific Plan Development of the land use change will require implementation
measures, including regulation, programs, public works projects, and financing
measures necessary to carry out the provisions contained in paragraphs (1 ), (2), and
(3) above. Chapter 2 and Chapter 5 identify the measures including private financing
measures and improvements needed to carry out the Specific Plan.
§65451 (b) The Specific Plan shall include a statement of the relationship of the Specific Plan
to the General Plan.
The Specific Plan provides a statement of the relationship of the Specific Plan to the
applicable goals, policies, and objectives of the Palm Desert General Plan (Chapter 6).
These statements are provided under Chapter 6 and elaborated on the Specific Plan's
consistency with applicable Palm Desert General Plan objectives, goals, and policies
included in the Land Use element, Mobility (Circulation) element, Health and Wellness
3
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 4
element, Environmental Resource (Open Space), Noise element, Safety element, Public
Utilities and Services Policy.
SECTION 3. Findings of Specific Plan. In approving this Project, the City Council, shall
make the following findings in accordance with the Palm Desert Municipal Code (PDMC):
1. Consistent with the General Plan. The Specific Plan or amendment is consistent with
the goals, objectives, and policies of the General Plan.
The Specific Plan is consistent with the Palm Desert General Plan goals and policies
of the Land Use Element. The Project site is designated Town Center Neighborhood
(TCN) by the Palm Desert General Plan Land Use Element (see page 30 of the
General Plan). The TCN designation is intended to provide moderate to higher
intensity neighborhood development that features a variety of housing choices,
walkable streets, and mixed uses with an allowable density range of seven (7) to 40
dwelling units per acre. The Project falls within the allowable density range established
for the TCN land use designation by providing an overall Project density of 7.0 to 9.1
dwelling units per acre. Additionally, the Project implements the goals, policies, and
objectives of the General Plan with respect to the intended built form and character
established for the TCN designation, which allows a variety of residential housing
types, including single-family detached, attached, condominiums, attached multi-
family and detached multi-family organized around connected pedestrian circulation,
open space, and walkable streetscapes.
2. Public Welfare. The Specific Plan or amendment will not create conditions materially
detrimental to the public health, safety, and general welfare.
The Specific Plan will not create conditions materially detrimental to the public health,
safety, and general welfare or cause serious health problems. The Project is not
located within a hazardous area that would be subject to flooding, liquefaction,
landslide, fault zones, or other natural hazards. The Project does not generate adverse
effects that would cause public health problems. Ground disturbing activities are
conditioned to prepare plans to control fugitive dust. The access locations to the
subdivision have been evaluated in accordance with a traffic impact analysis.
3. Land Use Compatibility. The Specific Plan or amendment is compatible with zoning
on adjacent properties and ensures development of desirable character that will be
harmonious with surrounding properties.
The Specific Plan will establish five (5) Planning Areas that will support the
development of a variety of residential housing types including multi-family
apartments, attached and detached multi-family garden-style apartments, alley-
loaded townhouses, and detached single-family residential. The Specific Plan will
establish standards to ensure that new development is compatible with surrounding
existing residential single-family development in terms of scale, density, and height.
To achieve this, the Specific Plan will limit all future housing adjacent to the existing
single-family residential to the east and southern edges of the property to a single
story in height. In addition, the Specific Plan will establish a planning area that consists
of a 45'-0" to 50'-0" wide landscaped walking trail to create a buffer. The residential
development is designed to accommodate a high degree of pedestrian walkability by
establishing amenity areas that are in close proximity to residential areas.
4
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 5
4. Property Suitability. The Specific Plan or amendment is suitable and appropriate for
the location, access, and topography for the development of the subject property.
The site is physically suitable for the density of development. The allowable density
for the site has been evaluated by the General Plan. The Applicant has prepared the
appropriate technical studies to assess that the site is physically suitable to develop
and will not result detrimental environmental impacts.
5. CEQA. The Specific Plan or amendment has been reviewed in compliance with the
provisions of the CEQA.
The Specific Plan has been reviewed in compliance with the provisions of the CEQA.
Under the CEQA and the State CEQA Guidelines, an Initial Study has been prepared
to analyze the environmental impacts of the Project. The documents have been
completed in compliance with CEQA, the State CEQA Guidelines, and City of Palm
Desert local CEQA guidelines. All environmental impacts of the Project are either
insignificant or can be mitigated to a less than significant level pursuant to the
mitigation measures outlined in the MND, Initial Study, and the Mitigation Monitoring
and Reporting Program (MMRP). The MMRP is attached to this resolution as "Exhibit
A."
SECTION 4. Project Approval. The City Council hereby approves Case No. SP/EA22-
0001, subject to the findings and conditions of approval.
SECTION 5. Custodian of Records. The documents and materials that constitute the
record of proceedings on which these findings are based are located at the City's office at
73510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert, CA 92260. Anthony J. Mejia, MMC, the City Clerk of
the City of Palm Desert is the custodian of the record of proceedings.
SECTION 5. Execution of Resolution. The Mayor signs this Resolution and the City
Clerk shall attest and certify to the passage and adoption thereof.
ADOPTED ON November 17, 2022.
ATTEST:
ANTHONY J. MEJIA
CITY CLERK
5
JAN C. HARNIK
MAYOR
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 6
I, Anthony J. Mejia, City Clerk of the City of Palm Desert, hereby certify that
Resolution No. 2022-93 is a full, true, and correct copy, and was duly adopted at a regular
meeting of the City Council of the City of Palm Desert on November 17, 2022, by the
following vote:
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
ABSTAIN:
RECUSED:
JONATHAN, KELLY, NESTANDE, QUINTANILLA, AND HARNIK
NONE
NONE
NONE
NONE
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and affixed the official seal of the
City of Palm Desert, California, on _N_ov_2_8_, _20_2_2 ____ _
6
ANTHONY J. MEJIA
CITY CLERK
Resolution No. 2022-93
EXHIBIT A
CITY OF PALM DESERT
REFUGE SPECIFIC PLAN
MITIGATION AND MONITORING PROGRAM
Mitigation Measure
BIOLOGICAL RESOURCES
BIO.1 Burrowing Owl Surveys
To mitigate potential impacts to burrowing owl, two pre-construction
surveys shall be conducted in accordance with CDFW protocol. The
first survey shall occur between 14 and 30 days prior to ground
disturbance, and the second shall occur within 24 hours of the initiation
of ground disturbance activities for any phase of development on the
Project site.
•If no owls are detected during those surveys, ground disturbance
may proceed without further consideration of this species,
assuming there is no lapse between the surveys and construction,
because the protocol states "time lapses between Project activities
trigger subsequent take avoidance surveys including but not limited
to a final survey conducted within 24 hours prior to ground
disturbance."
•If burrowing owls are detected during the surveys, avoidance and
minimization measures shall be required. Avoidance and
minimization measures may include establishing a buffer zone,
installing a visual barrier, implementing burrow exclusion and/or
closure techniques, in conformance with CDFW protocol.
BIO.2 Migratory Bird Treaty Act
If ground disturbance or tree or plant removal is proposed between
February 1st and August 31st, a qualified biologist shall conduct a
nesting bird survey within 7 to 10 days of initiation of grading onsite,
focusing on MBT A covered species. If active nests are reported, then
species-specific measures shall be prepared. At a minimum, grading in
the vicinity of a nest shall be postponed until the young birds have
fledged. For construction that occurs between September 1st and
January 31st, no pre-removal nesting bird survey is required.
•In the event active nests are found, exclusionary fencing shall
be placed around the nests until such time as nestlings have
fledged. Avoidance buffers shall be 100 to 300 feet from the
nests of unlisted songbirds, and 500 feet from the nests of
birds-of-prey and listed species.
7
Responsible
Party
Planning &
Engineering
Depts,
Developer
City,
Developer
Timing/Phase
Prior to
ground
disturbance.
Prior to
ground
disturbance.
Page 7
Action to Be Taken to Comply
Study submitted prior to issuance of grading
permits or other site-disturbing
authorizations.
Study submitted prior to issuance of grading
permits or other site-disturbing
authorizations.
Resolution No. 2022-93
d. Shrinkage and Subsidence. The following estimates of
shrinkage and subsidence are intended as an aid for project
planners in determining the earthwork quantities and should be
used with some caution since they are not absolute values. An
average shrinkage on the order of about 20 to 22 percent may
occur when excavated onsite soils are replaced (removed and
recompacted) as properly compacted fill. A subsidence
estimated between 0.2 and 0.22 feet may also be expected
when exposed bottom surfaces in removal areas are scarified
and re-compacted as recommended herein.
Additional recommendations on post-grading considerations,
foundations, footings and slabs on-grade design and construction,
retaining walls, masonry block walls, exterior concrete flatwork,
swimming pool and spa, and preliminary pavement sections should
also be followed in the Project design and construction.
TRAFFIC AND CIRCULATION
TRA.1 The Project proponent shall construct the following
improvements:
3. Construct Traffic signal at the intersection of Gerald Ford Drive and
Street A/Rembrandt Parkway prior to the occupancy of the first
residential units in Planning Area 1.
4. Construct westbound left turn lane with 150 feet of storage on
Gerald Ford Drive at Street A/Rembrandt Parkway prior to the
occupancy of the first residential units in Planning Area 1.
5. Construct eastbound right turn lane with 150 of storage on Gerald
Ford Drive at Street A/Rembrandt Parkway prior to the occupancy
of the first residential units in Planning Area 1.
6. Construct Street A as a collector roadway with a 44-foot curb to
curb width, with one travel lane southbound, one shared
left/through lane, and one right turn lane with 125 feet of storage
northbound on Street A at Gerald Ford Drive.
7. Connect to Julie Drive as a collector roadway with a 52-foot curb to
curb width prior to occupancy of the first residential units in
Planning Areas 2 through 6.
9
Page 9
Project Gerald Ford: Installation of improvements.
Engineer, Prior to
City occupancy of
Engineer, PA 1.
Project Julie Drive:
Proponent Prior to
occupancy of
any unit in PA
2 through 6.
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 8
CULTURAL AND TRIBAL RESOURCES
CUL.1 Archaeological and Tribal Monitoring Planning During any Monitoring Agreement to City prior to
Earth-moving activities, including grading, grubbing, trenching, or Department, site grading permits.
excavations at the site shall be monitored by a qualified archaeologist Engineering, disturbance. Report of findings 30 days after end of
and a Native American monitor. Project grading.
Archaeologist
If any cultural materials more than 50 years of age are discovered, they
shall be recorded and evaluated in the field. The monitors shall be
prepared to recover artifacts quickly to avoid construction delays but
must have the power to temporarily halt or divert construction
equipment to allow for controlled archaeological recovery if a
substantial cultural deposit is encountered. The monitors shall
determine when excavations have reached sufficient depth to preclude
the occurrence of cultural resources, and when monitoring should
conclude.
If artifacts are discovered, these shall be processed, catalogued,
analyzed, and prepared for permanent curation in a repository with
permanent retrievable storage that would allow for additional research
in the future.
GEOLOGY AND SOILS
GEO.1 Geotechnical Report Recommendations Project Prior to Submit geotechnical report with final grading
The Project design and construction should incorporate the following Engineer, approval of plan.
components based on each phase of development's site-specific City Engineer grading
geotechnical analysis during the preparation of precise grading plans: permit.
a. Earthwork Specifications. All earthwork and grading should be
performed in accordance with the applicable requirements of
City of Palm Desert, in compliance with all applicable
provisions of the 2019 California Building Code (CBC) and in
accordance with the recommendations in the Project
geotechnical report.
b. Site Clearing. Clearing operations should include the removal
of all vegetation and any structural features when found. Large
shrubs, when removed, should be grubbed out to include their
stumps and major root systems.
C.Ground Preparation. All unsuitable surficial materials should be
removed down to competent native dune sand deposits. The
exposed bottom surface should be scarified to a depth of at
least 6 inches, watered as necessary to achieve slightly above
optimum moisture conditions, and then recompacted in-place
to a minimum relative compaction of 90 percent.
8
Resolution No. 2022-93
EXHIBIT B
Refuge Specific Plan dated October 2022
(See following page)
10
Page 10
Prepared For:
City of Palm Desert
Applicant:
Refuge Palm Desert, LLC.
Prepared By:
MSA Consulting, Inc.
REFUGE SPECIFIC PLAN
OCTOBER 2022
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 11
REFUGE SPECIFIC PLAN TABLE OF CONTENTS
i
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION & SETTING
1.1 Executive Summary ......................................................................................... 1
1.2 Purpose & Intent ............................................................................................. 2
1.3 Project Location and Site Characteristics ........................................................ 2
1.4 Background & History ...................................................................................... 7
1.5 Development Concept & Vision ...................................................................... 7
1.6 Project Objectives ............................................................................................ 7
1.7 Existing General Plan & Zoning ........................................................................ 8
1.8 Utility & Service Providers ............................................................................. 11
1.9 Environmental Review ................................................................................... 12
1.10 Entitlement Process ....................................................................................... 12
CHAPTER 2: MASTER PLAN & INFRASTRUCTURE
2.1 Land Use Plan ................................................................................................ 13
2.2 Planning Area Descriptions ............................................................................ 13
2.3 Circulation ...................................................................................................... 16
2.4 Open Space .................................................................................................... 20
2.5 Water & Sewer .............................................................................................. 20
2.6 Grading & Drainage ....................................................................................... 20
2.7 Phasing & Financing ....................................................................................... 24
CHAPTER 3: DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS
3.1 Overview ........................................................................................................ 26
3.2 Permitted Uses .............................................................................................. 26
3.3 Development Standards ................................................................................ 27
CHAPTER 4: DESIGN GUIDELINES
4.1 Overview ........................................................................................................ 34
4.2 Design Guidelines .......................................................................................... 34
4.3 Landscape Design Guidelines ........................................................................ 44
CHAPTER 5: PLAN ADMINISTRATION
5.1 Overview ........................................................................................................ 47
5.2 Implementation ............................................................................................. 47
5.3 Administration ............................................................................................... 47
5.4 Interpretation ................................................................................................ 48
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 12
REFUGE SPECIFIC PLAN TABLE OF CONTENTS
ii
5.5 Enforcement .................................................................................................. 48
CHAPTER 6: GENERAL PLAN CONSISTENCY ANALYSIS
6.1 Land Use Policy Consistency .......................................................................... 51
6.2 Mobility Policy Consistency ........................................................................... 54
6.3 Health & Wellness Policy Consistency ........................................................... 55
6.4 Environmental Resources Policy Consistency ............................................... 55
6.5 Noise Policy Consistency ............................................................................... 56
6.6 Safety Policy Consistency .............................................................................. 57
6.7 Public Utilities & Services Policy Consistency ................................................ 57
FIGURES
1.1 Regional Location Map .................................................................................... 4
1.2 Vicinity Map ..................................................................................................... 5
1.3 Aerial Photograph/Existing Site Conditions ..................................................... 6
1.4 General Plan & Zoning Map .......................................................................... 10
2.1 Conceptual Land Use Map ............................................................................. 15
2.2 Vehicular Circulation ...................................................................................... 17
2.3 Typical Roadway Classifications ..................................................................... 18
2.4 Pedestrian Connectivity ................................................................................. 19
2.5 Conceptual Water Plan ................................................................................. 21
2.6 Conceptual Sewer Plan .................................................................................. 22
2.7 Conceptual Grading and Drainage Plan ........................................................ 23
2.8 Phasing Plan .................................................................................................. 25
2.9 Maintenance Plan ......................................................................................... 50
TABLES
1.1 Existing & Surrounding Uses ........................................................................... 3
1.2 Utility & Services Providers ............................................................................ 11
2.1 Land Use Summary ......................................................................................... 13
3.1 Permitted Uses .............................................................................................. 26
3.2 Development Standards PA-1 ........................................................................ 27
3.3 Development Standards PA-2 ....................................................................... 29
3.4 Development Standards PA-3 ........................................................................ 30
3.5 Development Standards PA-4 ........................................................................ 32
3.6 Development Standards PA-5 ........................................................................ 33
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 13
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
1
CHAPTER I: INTRODUCTION & SETTING
1.1 Executive Summary
The Refuge Specific Plan (“Specific Plan”) is a 106.4-acre planned development site within the
city of Palm Desert. The Specific Plan sets forth a comprehensive vision for a residential
community south of Gerald Ford Drive within the corporate limits of Palm Desert, California. This
Specific Plan is made in pursuant to California Government Code Section 65451 which requires
as follows: (a) A specific plan shall include a text and a diagram or diagrams which specify all of
the following in detail:
(1) The distribution, location, and extent of the uses of land, including open space, within the area
covered by the plan.
(2) The proposed distribution, location, and extent and intensity of major components of public
and private transportation, sewage, water, drainage, solid waste disposal, energy, and other
essential facilities proposed to be located within the area covered by the plan and needed to
support the land uses described in the plan.
(3) Standards and criteria by which development will proceed, and standards for the
conservation, development, and utilization of natural resources, where applicable.
(4) A program of implementation measures including regulations, programs, public works projects,
and financing measures necessary to carry out paragraphs (1), (2), and (3). (b) The specific plan
shall include a statement of the relationship of the specific plan to the general plan.
In addition to following all applicable California State regulations, this specific plan also abides by
Palm Desert Municipal Code (PDMC) Section 25.78.080 regarding the process for preparation and
processing of Specific Plans.
This Specific Plan will establish site-specific development standards, land use regulations, design
guidelines, and programs to guide the development of the property in a manner that is consistent
with the Palm Desert General Plan while also maintaining flexibility to respond to changing market
conditions that influence project development. The Specific Plan presents a comprehensive land
use plan for the property along with supporting infrastructure plans that address circulation, water,
sewer, grading and drainage systems. The Specific Plan is organized in five chapters, as described
below:
Chapter 1, Introduction & Setting: This section provides an overview of the document, the project
setting and history, legislative authority for the Specific Plan, entitlement process and other
contextual information.
Chapter 2, Master Plan and Infrastructure: This section describes the primary master plan
components required for further development of the property. These include land use, circulation,
open space and recreation, water and sewer, and grading and drainage.
Chapter 3, Development Standards: This section establishes the allowable uses and development
standards applicable within the Specific Plan area.
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 14
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
2
Chapter 4, Design Guidelines: This section establishes the design guidelines applicable within the
Specific Plan area.
Chapter 5, Plan Administration: This section describes the various processes and procedures used
to administer and implement the adopted Specific Plan.
1.2 Purpose and Intent
This Specific Plan is intended to provide a comprehensive development plan for vacant properties
previously owned by the City Redevelopment Agency and guide future development within the
Specific Plan area. This will include the establishment of site-specific development standards and
regulations and is intended to ensure quality development consistent with the goals, objectives,
and policies of the Palm Desert General Plan, as more fully described in Chapter 6. This Specific
Plan includes comprehensive development standards and implementation and financing
measures to ensure the creation of a vibrant, livable community with readily accessible amenities
and attractive streetscapes.
This Specific Plan defines the location, type and amount of development allowed within the
project area consistent with State Planning Law and Section 25.78 of the Palm Desert Municipal
Code (PDMC) which establishes the process for preparing, processing, and adopting Specific
Plans. Customized development standards will guide development while also allowing flexibility to
adjust residential products to market demand.
This document has been prepared pursuant to California Government Code Section 65450, which
grants local governments the authority to prepare Specific plans as a systematic means of
implementing their General Plan. California Government Code Sections 65450 through 65454
establishes the authority to adopt a Specific Plan, identifies the required contents of a Specific
Plan, and mandates consistency with the General Plan.
1.3 Project Location & Site Characteristics
As shown on Figure 1.1 (see page 4), Regional Location Map, the Specific Plan is located in the
central portion of the Coachella Valley within the corporate limits of the City of Palm Desert south
of Gerald Ford Drive, east of Monterey Avenue, and west of Portola Road. The Specific Plan area
is comprised of three (3) parcels totaling approximately 106.4 acres (APNs 694-310-002, 003 and
006.) This site location shall be referred to as “The Site” henceforth. Figure 1.2, Local Vicinity Map,
displays the physical setting of the property. Surrounding land uses are listed below in Table 1.1.
As depicted in Figure 1.3, Aerial Photograph the Site is surrounded by development on all sides,
and is an island of undeveloped vacant infill land with scattered vegetation and blow sand. The
subject property is in the central part of the Coachella Valley, a low-lying and relatively flat desert
valley surrounded by the San Bernardino, Little San Bernardino, San Jacinto, and Santa Rosa
Mountains. The mountains rise significantly above the valley floor with peak elevations up to 11,503
feet above sea level. The mountains are of high aesthetic value across the Coachella Valley,
including the City of Palm Desert.
Topographically, the site is mounded in the central portions (elevations ranging from 300-323
mean sea level (msl)). From this high point, the site slopes north toward Gerald Ford Drive
(elevation 275 msl) and south toward the southern property boundary (elevation 295 msl).
Gerald Ford Drive to the north of the Site is designated as a Balanced Arterial Roadway in the
Palm Desert General Plan. It is currently built with four paved travel lanes, curb and gutter, a raised
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 15
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
3
center median, and improved with a Class 2 bicycle/golf cart lanes. Portola Road to the east is a
General Plan Balanced Arterial currently built with six paved travel lanes, curb and gutter and a
raised center median. Sidewalks have been built on both sides of Gerald Ford Drive and Portola
Avenue, except where adjacent to undeveloped parcels. Rembrandt Parkway is fully improved
as a 2-lane road accessing The Gallery neighborhood north of the Project site. Julie Drive is a 2-
lane street with a sidewalk on the south side but is not improved adjacent to undeveloped parcels
on the north.
SunLine Transit Agency provides bus transit services to the Coachella Valley, including Palm Desert.
Currently, there are no transit routes or facilities in the immediate Project vicinity. The nearest bus
stop is on Dinah Shore Drive at Shoppers Lane (Route 4), approximately 1¼ miles northwest of the
Project site. Another stop at Cook Street and Berger Drive (Route 5) is approximately 1½ miles to
the southeast and can be accessed by bike from the Project site via existing bike lanes.
TABLE 1.1
EXISTING AND SURROUNDING USES
Jurisdiction General Plan/Zoning Existing Use
Site Palm Desert
Town Center
Neighborhood/PR Planned
Residential 20 Dwelling Units
per acre
Vacant Infill Land
North Palm Desert
Conventional Suburban
Neighborhood/PR: Planned
Residential 5
The Gallery Single
Family Residences
South Palm Desert
Conventional Suburban
Neighborhood/PR:
Planned Residential - 5
Single family
Residences
East Palm Desert
Conventional Suburban
Neighborhood & /PR
Planned Residential - 5
Single Family
Residences
West Palm Desert
Resort &
Entertainment/PR
Planned Residential
Marriott’s Shadow Ridge
Villas and Golf Club
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 16
Exhibit Date: October 11, 2022SPECIFIC PLANREFUGE:MSACivil Engineering Land Surveying Landscape ArchitecturePlanning Environmental Services Dry Utility Coordination GISMSAConsultinginc.comCONSULTING, INC.N.T.S.NORTH
REGIONAL LOCATION MAPFIGURE 1.1PAGE 4Source: MSA Consulting, Inc.Resolution No. 2022-93Page 17
Project
Site
ProjectCity of
Monterey AvenuePortola AvenueGerald Ford Drive
Dinah Shore Drive
GatewayV
a
r
n
e
r
R
o
a
dDrive
Dr.
Frank Sinatra Drive
SiteRancho
Mirage
City of
Palm Desert
County of
Riverside
In
t
e
r
s
t
a
t
e
1
0
Dick Kelly
Cook StreetExhibit Date: October 11, 2022
SPECIFIC PLANREFUGE:
MSA
Civil Engineering Land Surveying Landscape ArchitecturePlanning Environmental Services Dry Utility Coordination GIS
MSAConsultinginc.com
CONSULTING, INC.
VICINITY MAP
FIGURE 1.2
PAGE 5
N.T.S.
Legend:
Project Site
Source: City of Palm Desert
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 18
Gerald Ford Drive
PROJECT Portola Avenue3
0
0 2802
8
5
2
9
0
295300
30
5
305
3003053103
1
5
32032031531532031030530
5
295295295300
3
0
0
295 29529
5
Woodward Drive Shepherd LaneJulie Drive
275
2
9
5290285 2
8
0
Riverside County
Sheriff's Station
Marriott
Shadow Ridge
Golf Club
295
305
SITE
310323
Exhibit Date: October 11, 2022
SPECIFIC PLANREFUGE:
MSA
Civil Engineering Land Surveying Landscape ArchitecturePlanning Environmental Services Dry Utility Coordination GIS
MSAConsultinginc.com
CONSULTING, INC.
AERIAL PHOTOGRAPH / EXISTING SITE CONDITIONS
FIGURE 1.3
PAGE 6
N.T.S.
Source: City of Palm Desert
Legend:
310
Project Boundary
Existing Index Contours
323
275
Existing Project High Point
Existing Project Low Point
Direction of Existing Drainage
Existing Ridgeline
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 19
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
7
1.4 Background and History
The properties that comprise the Refuge Specific Plan were formerly owned by the City of Palm
Desert Redevelopment Agency (RDA). The RDA was terminated by the State of California in
February of 2012 with the passage of Assembly Bill X1 26. From there, the properties were
transferred to the Successor Agency to the Palm Desert RDA (SARDA) for disposal via sale to
private entities. Of the original land under RDA ownership, 23.4 acres adjoining Portola Avenue
was sold to GHA Montage and entitled for 63 single family residential lots under TTM 37993. The
106.4-acre balance constitutes the land within the Specific Plan boundary.
Of this 106.4-acre balance, the northern 11.9-acres adjoining Gerald Ford Drive was entitled with
a 269-unit affordable housing development known as Vitalia (PP/CUP 21-0004) on August 26, 2021.
The Specific Plan incorporates this project as approved. The approximately 94.5-acre balance of
the Specific Plan is vacant and will be developed according to the provisions of this Specific Plan.
As part of the development of the Project concept and vision, and in accordance with Palm
Desert Municipal Code Section 25.60.160 “Community Engagement”, a focused engagement
process with community stakeholders and adjacent property owners was conducted to seek their
input and feedback.
1.5 Development Concept & Vision
The Refuge Specific Plan will facilitate the coordinated development of a planned residential
community on approximately 106.4 acres with a variety of housing products and densities in a
walkable setting.
This Specific Plan will allow for the development of up to 969 residential units. The Project would
also incorporate open space, recreational, and outdoor gathering spaces as unifying project
design features. Pedestrian access and integration between the uses is a unifying element of the
Specific Plan. Chapter 4 provides guidelines and standards to ensure a quality project design that
is compatible with the surrounding built environment and consistent with the Goals and Policies of
the City of Palm Desert General Plan.
This Specific Plan intends to provide a degree of flexibility for future developers to design projects
that respond to market demand. The Refuge Specific Plan will supersede the development
guidelines and regulations of the Palm Desert zoning code to allow for a fresh, contemporary
development strategy for the 106.4 acres.
1.6 Project Objectives
Various issues were considered and evaluated during the preparation of this Specific Plan.
Engineering feasibility, water efficiency, General Plan goals and policies, compatibility with
surrounding land uses, and technical solutions to drainage constraints were considered during the
planning process. In order to ensure the functional integrity, economic viability, environmental
sensitivity, and positive aesthetic contribution of this development, unique project objectives were
established as follows:
Develop a thoughtfully planned and walkable residential community with a variety of
housing types organized around a central recreational amenity.
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 20
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
8
Provide a comprehensive land use plan that establishes development standards, land
use regulations, and programs to guide the orderly transition/development of the
property.
Grade the development in a way that accommodates the unique topographic
constraints of this land that ensures all stormflow being retained on site as shown on
the Tentative Tract Map Exhibit.
Provide surrounding property owners with a 45-50ft landscaped buffer to create a
positive community aesthetic along the project edge.
Accommodate phasing that allows for multi-year project development in an orderly
and efficient manner.
Provide flexible development regulations that allow future projects to be entitled
quickly and easily in response to market demand and evolving design needs.
Establish design guidelines, development regulations, use standards and procedures
that result in cohesive and attractive landscape and architectural treatments.
Provide a safe and efficient circulation system;
Provide water and sewer, systems to adequately service the project;
Promote quality development consistent with the goals and policies of the Palm Desert
General Plan.
1.7 Existing General Plan and Zoning
The Palm Desert General Plan, adopted in late 2016, establishes the City's policy relative to the
planned future pattern, intensity, density, and relationships of land uses in the City and the various
infrastructure systems needed to effectively support those land uses. The Specific Plan implements
the Palm Desert General Plan by bringing detailed policies and regulations together into a
focused development plan for the Specific Plan area. It serves as a link between the Palm Desert
General Plan and subsequent development proposals within the Specific Plan area. This Specific
Plan is a regulatory document which, when adopted by the Palm Desert City Council, will govern
all facets of project development including the distribution of land uses, location and sizing of
supporting infrastructure, as well as development standards and regulations.
Figure 1.4, General Plan and Zoning Map, displays the existing General Plan Land Use Map, which
designates this site as Town Center Neighborhood which is intended to provide moderate to
higher intensity neighborhood development that features a variety of housing choices, walkable
streets, and mixed uses. The project site is zoned Planned Residential (PR-20): 20 Dwelling Units Per
Acre. This zoning designation is designed to provide for flexibility in residential development, by
encouraging creative and imaginative design, and the development of parcels of land as
coordinated projects involving a mixture of residential densities up to 20 per acre, mixed housing
types, and community facilities. The district is characterized as providing for the optimum
integration of urban and natural amenities within developments and is organized around formal,
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 21
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
9
walkable, and highly connected streetscapes. The intention is to build out the site with a total of
969 dwelling units ranging in size, density, and housing type. This will include changing the zoning
designation of the affected area from PR-20 to Specific Plan.
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 22
Portola AvenueGerald Ford Drive
Shepherd LaneFrank Sinatra Drive
Woodward Drive Portola AvenueGerald Ford Drive
Shepherd LaneFrank Sinatra Drive
Woodward Drive
Exhibit Date: October 11, 2022
SPECIFIC PLANREFUGE:
MSA
Civil Engineering Land Surveying Landscape ArchitecturePlanning Environmental Services Dry Utility Coordination GIS
MSAConsultinginc.com
CONSULTING, INC.
EXISTING GENERAL PLAN / ZONING
FIGURE 1.4
PAGE 10
N.T.S.
Source: City of Palm Desert
Town Center Neighborhood
Conventional Suburban Neighborhood
Golf Course & Resort Neighborhood
Existing General Plan
Public Facility / Institutional
Legend:
SP Boundary
Existing Zoning
General Plan
Zoning
Planned ResidentialP.R.
PublicP
Resort & Entertainment
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 23
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
11
1.8 Utility & Service Providers
The Refuge project is within the service area of the utility and service providers as listed in Table
1.2.
1 TABLE 1.2 UTILITY & SERVICE PROVIDERS
2
Utility/Service Agency Address Phone
Sewer Coachella Valley Water
District (CVWD)
75-525 Hovley Lane
Palm Desert, CA. 92211 760.398.2651
Water CVWD
75-525 Hovley Lane
Palm Desert, CA.
92211
760.398.2651
Natural Gas Southern California Gas
(SCG)
P.O. Box 3150
San Dimas, CA. 91773 877.238.0092
Electric Southern California
Edison (SCE)
P.O. Box 800,
Rosemead, Ca 91770
800.655.4555
Electric Imperial Irrigation District 81600 Avenue 58
La Quinta, CA 92253 760.398.5811
Cable TV Spectrum
44-425 Town Center
Way Ste H
Palm Desert CA 92211
760.340.2225
Police Riverside Couty Sheriff
73-705 Gerald Ford
Dr.,
Palm Desert, Ca 92211
760-863-8990
Fire Riverside County Fire
Department
71-751 Gerald Ford Dr.
Palm Desert, Ca 92270 760.869.8886
Solid Waste Burrtec 41575 Eclectic Street
Palm Desert, CA.
760.340.2113
Schools Palm Springs Unified
School District (PSUSD)
150 District Center
Drive Palm Springs, CA
92264
760.883.2700
Public Transit Sunline Transit Agency
32505 Harry Oliver Trail
Thousand Palms, CA
92276 760.343.3451
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 24
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
12
1.9 Environmental Review
The project is subject to the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA).
Pursuant to the CEQA Guidelines (Title 14, Division 6, Chapter 3 of the California Code of
Regulations), an Initial Study has been prepared for the Specific Plan to analyze the environmental
impacts of the project. The Project area is urbanized, and the subject property is surrounded by
residential, golf course, and institutional (sheriff station) development.
No adverse impacts were identified that could not be mitigated to a level of less than significant.
Therefore, the City will prepare a Mitigated Negative Declaration (MND) containing an evaluation
of potential environmental impacts associated with the project and appropriate mitigation
measures for each potential impact. All mitigation measures identified in the Mitigated Negative
Declaration shall be identified in a Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program (MMRP) to ensure
that implementation occurs.
The MND will apply to all subsequent implementing entitlements proposed within the Specific Plan
boundary. All future development projects for the project site will be reviewed with the Specific
Plan and the MND to determine whether additional environmental documentation must be
prepared pursuant to CEQA Guidelines.
1.10 Entitlement Process
Approval of the following entitlements will implement this project:
Specific Plan (SP) – The Specific Plan will cover approximately 106.4 acres to provide
comprehensive development guidelines, allowable uses, and development standards.
Tentative Tract Map (TTM) – TTMs are intended to implement the project and subdivide the
property into smaller parcels/lots for sale. A phasing plan shall be incorporated.
Zone Change (ZC) – A Zone change is intended to cover the entire specified boundaries of the
property to accommodate higher densities than are currently allowed under the PR-20 zone.
See Section 5.2 of this Specific Plan for more detailed information on the administrative and public
hearing processes related to these implementing approvals.
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 25
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
13
CHAPTER 2: MASTER PLAN & INFRASTRUCTURE
2.1 Land Use Plan
The Specific Plan would facilitate construction of up to 969 residential units on approximately 106.4
acres with densities for individual projects expected to range from 4.7-22.6 du/ac. The Specific
Plan proposes five distinct Planning Areas as defined in Figure 2.1 Conceptual Land Use Plan and
Table 2.1, Land Use Summary. Implementing entitlement approvals may define the size, location
and configuration in greater detail as outlined in Section 1.10. Chapter 3A provides a detailed
discussion of permitted uses and relevant development standards for each Planning Area.
Table 2.1 Land Use Summary
Planning Area Area
(acres)
Density Range
(du/ac) Unit Range
PA 1 11.9 Up to 22.6 Up to 269
PA 2 16.4 10.0 – 18.3 165 – 302
PA 3 66.3 4.7 – 6.0 (average) 315 – 398
PA 4 3.9 - -
PA 5 7.9 - -
Total 106.4 7.0 - 9.1 749 - 969
2.2 Planning Area Descriptions
The Specific Plan is broken into five Planning Areas, each with common characteristics and
development standards.
Planning Area 1 - Residential
PA 1 is the northernmost planning area and covers the Vitalia project that was approved by the
City Council on August 26, 2021(PP/CUP 21-0004). It will be developed as approved; no changes
are proposed. It is approved for 269 affordable apartment units in 14 two- and three-story buildings
with one-, two-, and three-bedroom units. Onsite amenities include a swimming pool, playground,
dog park, clubhouse with fitness and childcare facilities, surface parking lot, and stormwater
retention basins that can also serve as passive open space. It will be accessed from two driveways
on (future) Vitalia Way. It consists of approximately 11.9 acres of land and will allow for residential
housing at an average density of up to 22.6 du/ac.
Planning Area 2– Residential
PA 2 consists of approximately 16.4 acres of land and will allow for up to 302 dwelling units at a
density range of 10.0 to 18.3 du/ac. It includes two retention basins and is accessed by a driveway
on Vitalia Way and a roundabout connecting to Planning Area 3. A variety of housing products
are permitted by right and with a Conditional Use Permit (CUP).
Planning Area 3 - Residential
PA-3 consists of approximately 66.3 acres of land in the central part of the Specific Plan area and
can accommodate up to 398 dwelling units at an average density ranging from 4.7 to 6.0 du/ac.
Permitted uses allow detached single-family, attached townhomes, duplexes, typical single story,
and up to two stories where appropriate, arranged in a walkable manner. It includes three
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 26
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
14
retention basins and is accessed by a roundabout connecting to Julie Drive (extended) and
Planning Area 2. A variety of housing products are permitted by right and with a CUP.
Planning Area 4 – Recreation Amenity
PA-4 consists of approximately 3.9 acres and will consist of a community amenity center offering
residents access to common recreation facilities such as pools, spas, club houses, management
offices, barbecues and other facilities as appropriate.
Planning Area 5 - Open Space/Buffer
PA-5 consists of approximately 7.9 acres of land containing a landscaped open space buffer to
provide a vegetative separation from adjoining single-family neighborhoods to the east and
south. In addition, the northern portion of PA5 includes the project’s main entry road Vitalia Way
providing vehicular and pedestrian connection to all Planning Areas. Pedestrian routes are
described in Section 2.3 under Pedestrian Circulation. Community trails are intended for residents
and will not be accessible to the public. These paths are not considered multi-modal and are
intended for pedestrians only.
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 27
NOPARKINGNOPARKING
NOPARKING NOPARKING
NOPARKING
COMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARGerald Ford Drive
Woodward Drive Portola AvenuePA 5
PA 1
PA 2
PA 3
PA 4
Shepherd LaneJulie Drive
Exhibit Date: October 11, 2022
SPECIFIC PLANREFUGE:
MSA
Civil Engineering Land Surveying Landscape ArchitecturePlanning Environmental Services Dry Utility Coordination GIS
MSAConsultinginc.com
CONSULTING, INC.
CONCEPTUAL LAND USE PLAN
FIGURE 2.1
PAGE 15
N.T.S.
Source: MSA Consulting, Inc.
Legend:
Project Boundary
Planning Area Boundary
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 28
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
16
2.3 Circulation
Vehicular and pedestrian circulation systems are a central element of every development project.
The Refuge community will have an interconnected network of vehicular streets and pedestrian
walkways and sidewalks to facilitate multiple forms of transportation. The circulation system is
illustrated in Figure 2.2 Vehicle Circulation, 2.3 Typical Roadway Classifications, and Figure 2.4
Pedestrian Connectivity. Key aspects of the circulation system include:
Project Entries – The project’s primary point of access is taken from Gerald Ford Drive to the north
with a secondary point of access to Portola Drive on the east. Both intersections will be signalized.
These access roads converge at a roundabout that will direct traffic along the project periphery
and into the project area. Entries off this main circulation route will provide a point of arrival into
each individual neighborhood grouping. Primary entries will be designed to provide a sense of
identity through the application of landscaping and monument signage. Additional information
on entries will be providing with each implementing entitlement application with identity theming
and landscaping remaining consistent throughout.
Vehicular Circulation – The vehicular circulation system will consist of local residential streets
providing convenient access to individual homes. Garages/carports for single family residences
may be traditionally located at the front of the home or, utilizing alleys, at the rear.
Pedestrian Circulation – The project will be designed to create a highly walkable environment as
desired by Palm Desert General Plan Policies 3.1-3.4 in Chapter 4. All single-family homes and multi-
family residences will be located within a quarter mile walk of a central recreational amenity
providing for quick and convenient pedestrian access. Pedestrian access signage around the
amenity area will be incorporated. Pedestrian routes will include an interconnected network of
paseos, greenways and sidewalks. Each street will provide sidewalks on one or both sides and,
due to their low traffic volumes, speeds, and short length, will encourage walkability. A pedestrian
access plan will be developed to accommodate expected foot traffic. Trees will be present for
shade on all sidewalks with curb adjacent placement being the preferred option wherever
possible. Connection between onsite uses and the regional trail/bikeway system will occur via
sidewalks that connect with Gerald Ford Drive and Portola Drive.
Parking – Sufficient off-street parking will be provided to serve each use as outlined in Table 3.2
Development Standards. The project may utilize a mix of on surface parking, carports, and
garages to adequately serve resident needs. Surface parking spaces will generally be used in
higher density areas with parking in enclosed garages and driveway aprons generally serving
detached dwellings.
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 29
NOPARKINGNOPARKING
NOPARKING NOPAR
KI
NG
NOPARKING
COMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARGerald Ford Drive
Woodward Drive Portola AvenueShepherd LaneJulie Drive
Exhibit Date: October 11, 2022
SPECIFIC PLANREFUGE:
MSA
Civil Engineering Land Surveying Landscape ArchitecturePlanning Environmental Services Dry Utility Coordination GIS
MSAConsultinginc.com
CONSULTING, INC.
VEHICULAR CIRCULATION PLAN
FIGURE 2.2
PAGE 17
N.T.S.
Source: City of Palm Desert / MSA Consulting, Inc.
Existing Traffic Signal
Alley
Local Road
Local Collector
Entry Road
Parkway
Legend:
Project Boundary
Note: Street network shown is conceptual and may be
reconfigured with future tentative tract maps using similar street
classifications and functional hierarchy subject to City approval.
Proposed Traffic Signal
Representative Circulation Elements
Access Connections
Proposed Roundabout
PA Entries
Proposed Roundabout & PA Entry
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 30
LOCAL COLLECTOR(PUBLIC ROAD)22'60'22'30'30'8'8'CL72'36'36'10'10'12'20'20'25'12.5'12.5'18'56'18'28'28'10'10'15'43.5'9'15.5'28'10'9'19'6'N.T.S.CLPROP.CLCLCLPARALLELPARKINGAMENITY CENTER PARKINGR/WPROP. R/WPROP. R/WPROP. R/WPROP. R/WPROP. R/WPROP. R/WPROP. R/WPROP. R/W6'6'3'P.U.E.PROP.PROP.R/WPROP.3'P.U.E.PROP.6'6'6'6'PROP. SIDEWALKPROP. SIDEWALKPROP. SIDEWALKPROP. SIDEWALKPROP. CURB & GUTTERPROP. CURB & GUTTERRAISED MEDIANPROP. SIDEWALKPROP. SIDEWALKPROP. CURB & GUTTERPROP. CURB & GUTTERPROP. SIDEWALKPROP. CURB & GUTTERPROP. CURB & GUTTERENTRY ROAD(PUBLIC ROAD)N.T.S.LOCAL ROAD(PUBLIC ROAD)N.T.S.PARKWAY(PUBLIC ROAD)N.T.S.ALLEY(PRIVATE ROAD)N.T.S.PROP. CURB & GUTTERPROP. CURB & GUTTERPROP. LANDSCAPE AREAPROP. LANDSCAPE AREAPROP. LANDSCAPE AREAPROP. LANDSCAPE AREAPROP. LANDSCAPE AREAPROP. LANDSCAPE AREAPROP. LANDSCAPE AREAExhibit Date: October 11, 2022SPECIFIC PLANREFUGE:MSACivil Engineering Land Surveying Landscape ArchitecturePlanning Environmental Services Dry Utility Coordination GISMSAConsultinginc.comCONSULTING, INC.N.T.S.NORTH
TYPICAL ROADWAY CLASSIFICATIONSFIGURE 2.3PAGE 18Source: MSA Consulting, Inc.Resolution No. 2022-93Page 31
NOPARKINGNOPARKING
NOPARKING NOPAR
KI
NG
NOPARKING
COMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARGerald Ford Drive
Woodward Drive Portola AvenueShepherd LaneJulie Drive
Exhibit Date: October 11, 2022
SPECIFIC PLANREFUGE:
MSA
Civil Engineering Land Surveying Landscape ArchitecturePlanning Environmental Services Dry Utility Coordination GIS
MSAConsultinginc.com
CONSULTING, INC.
PEDESTRIAN CONNECTIVITY PLAN
FIGURE 2.4
PAGE 19
N.T.S.
Source: City of Palm Desert / MSA Consulting, Inc.
Primary Pedestrian Connector
Legend:
Project Boundary
Recreation Amenity
Boundary of Project Level Pedestrian Area
Utilizing Sidewalks Alleys & Walkways
Streets with Sidewalks
Alleys
Paseos
Note: These elements or others may be used in any combination to
create a walkable community.
Representative Project-LevelPedestrian Elements
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 32
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
20
2.4 Open Space
Open Space is an important aspect of a livable development. It provides areas where desert
appropriate plant materials can be introduced to soften and shade urban hardscapes. They also
provide prime opportunities. Key open space elements include:
Landscaped Buffer – A 50-foot-wide open space buffer is provided along the east and south
project boundaries to create an attractive vegetative corridor separating the project from
adjoining residences. The buffer will incorporate a walking trail to form loops of varying distances
to encourage walking and bicycle use within the project.
Central Recreation Amenity – The project is designed around a central 3.9- acre recreational
amenity that will contain common recreation facilities such as pools, spas, club houses,
management offices, barbecues and other facilities as appropriate for the community.
Paseos - Linear paseos provide opportunities to interconnect sidewalks with the perimeter buffer
and with the central Recreational Amenity to encourage residents to walk or bike to take
advantage of these amenities.
2.5 Water & Sewer
The Specific Plan is provided with domestic water and sanitary sewer service by the Coachella
Valley Water District (CVWD). As shown in Figure 2.5 Conceptual Water Plan, the project will
connect to existing 12” public water mains in Gerald Ford Drive and Julie Drive These will be
connected by a new 12” water main with 8” lines extending south to serve each unit. CVWD also
provides sanitary sewer service to the site. As shown in Figure 2.6 Conceptual Sewer Plan, the
property will be designed to gravity sewer from north connecting to the existing 12” main in Gerald
Ford Drive.
2.6 Grading & Drainage
Because grading and drainage are closely interrelated, they are addressed jointly in this section.
Topographically, the site is mounded through the center (elevations ranging from 300-323). From
this high point, the site slopes northeast toward Gerald Ford Drive (elevation 275) and southeast
toward the southern property boundary (elevation 295). Because the southern half of the site is
surrounded on three sides by existing development without a pre-planned outlet, a sump
condition exists there. There is also very little cross-fall from south to north, limiting surface drainage
options. These physical constraints have been fully considered and are solved by the grading and
drainage design proposed for this project.
As shown on Figure 2.7, Conceptual Grading & Drainage Plan, the grading design will create
buildable pads, street corridors on site with balanced earthwork to avoid soil export of export.
Grading will achieve positive surface flows and protect all structures and physical improvements
from the 100-year storm through surface runoff into retention basins either above or below the
finished surfaces. Soil erosion and water quality will be protected both during and after
construction is completed. The incremental increase in storm water runoff from an existing
condition to the new developed condition created by impervious surfaces (roofs, pavement) will
be retained on site.
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 33
NOPARKINGNOPARKING
NOPARKING NOPAR
KI
NG
NOPARKING
COMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARGerald Ford Drive
Woodward Drive Portola AvenueShepherd LaneJulie Drive
PA 5
PA 1
PA 2
PA 3
PA 4
Connect
to Existing
12" Water Main
Per TTM 37993
Connect to
Existing 12" Water Main
Exhibit Date: October 11, 2022
SPECIFIC PLANREFUGE:
MSA
Civil Engineering Land Surveying Landscape ArchitecturePlanning Environmental Services Dry Utility Coordination GIS
MSAConsultinginc.com
CONSULTING, INC.
CONCEPTUAL WATER PLAN
FIGURE 2.5
PAGE 21
N.T.S.
Source: City of Palm Desert / MSA Consulting, Inc.
Legend:
Project Boundary
Existing Water Main
Proposed 8" Water Main
Proposed 12" Water Main12S
8W
Note: Design is conceptual and may be
reconfigured with implementing entitlements as
approved by the City Public Works Director.
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 34
NOPARKINGNOPARKING
NOPARKING NOPAR
KI
NG
NOPARKING
COMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARWoodward Drive Portola AvenueShepherd LaneJulie Drive
PA 5
PA 1
PA 2
PA 3
PA 4
Gerald Ford Drive
Connect to Existing 12" Sewer Main
Exhibit Date: October 11, 2022
SPECIFIC PLANREFUGE:
MSA
Civil Engineering Land Surveying Landscape ArchitecturePlanning Environmental Services Dry Utility Coordination GIS
MSAConsultinginc.com
CONSULTING, INC.
CONCEPTUAL SEWER PLAN
FIGURE 2.6
PAGE 22
N.T.S.
Source: City of Palm Desert / MSA Consulting, Inc.
Legend:
Project Boundary
Existing Sewer Main
Proposed 8" PVC Sewer Main8S
Note: Design is conceptual and may be
reconfigured with implementing entitlements
as approved by the City Public Works Director.
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 35
NOPARKINGNOPARKING
NOPARKING NOPAR
KI
NG
NOPARKING
COMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARWoodward Drive Portola AvenueShepherd LaneJulie Drive
Gerald Ford Drive
280
280285
290
285
295
295
295300305310315300300300
300300300280 295PA 5
PA 1
PA 2
PA 3
PA 4
Exhibit Date: October 11, 2022
SPECIFIC PLANREFUGE:
MSA
Civil Engineering Land Surveying Landscape ArchitecturePlanning Environmental Services Dry Utility Coordination GIS
MSAConsultinginc.com
CONSULTING, INC.
CONCEPTUAL GRADING & DRAINAGE
FIGURE 2.7
PAGE 23
N.T.S.
Source: City of Palm Desert / MSA Consulting, Inc.
Legend:
Project Boundary
Proposed Index Contours
Proposed Drainage Direction
Proposed Retention
300
Note: Design is conceptual and may be reconfigured
with implementing entitlements as approved by the
City Public Works Director.
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 36
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
24
As shown in Figure 2.7, Conceptual Grading & Drainage Plan, “developed condition” surface
drainage will be conveyed north and east toward retention basins at the eastern end of the
property. The stormwater drainage system depicts the general flow of surface drainage and
retention facilities which will be adapted and detailed with future development proposals.
Adjustments may include the number, location, configuration and depth of drainage pipes and
basins as well as the specific flow path through the site. The retention basins and storm drains will
be appropriately sized for each phase of the project using standard engineering modelling
methods as approved by the Engineering Services Division. If temporary facilities must be
constructed, they will be provided with each phase.
2.7 Phasing and Financing
Development of the Refuge Specific Plan is planned in seven (7) primary development phases
with anticipated build out to occur over approximately 6 years. Each phase may be broken into
subphases in response to market conditions and consumer demand. Construction of the first
phase is expected to begin in 2023 with full buildout by 2029. Figure 2.8 Conceptual Phasing Plan
reflects the anticipated development sequence at this time. This phasing sequence is conceptual
and subject to refinement and/or reordering with final engineering design and market conditions.
Each of these phases will have the required access and utilities deemed necessary by the city
engineer
The project financing will generally be private. A variety of financing options are available to both
the owners and the City to fund specific infrastructure requirements. These options may be utilized
by the owner as needed throughout the construction period. .
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 37
NOPARKINGNOPARKING
NOPARKING NOPAR
KI
NG
NOPARKING
COMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARGerald Ford Drive
Woodward Drive Portola AvenuePH. A
PH. 1
PH. 3PH. 2
PH. 4 PH.PH. 5
PH. 6 PH. 7
8
Development
timing as per
PP/CUP 21-0004
Shepherd LaneJulie Drive
Exhibit Date: October 11, 2022
SPECIFIC PLANREFUGE:
MSA
Civil Engineering Land Surveying Landscape ArchitecturePlanning Environmental Services Dry Utility Coordination GIS
MSAConsultinginc.com
CONSULTING, INC.
PHASING PLAN
FIGURE 2.8
PAGE 25
N.T.S.
Source: City of Palm Desert / MSA Consulting, Inc.
Legend:
Phase Boundary
Phase "A"
Phase 2
Phase 3
Phase 4
Phase 1
Project Boundary
Phase 5
Phase 6
Phase 7
Phase 8
Note:
1. Exhibit shows expected sequence of development, but may change
in response to market conditions.
2. Phase "A" will be constructed with the first phase of development
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 38
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
26
CHAPTER 3: DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS
3.1 Overview
This chapter identifies the development standards applicable to the Refuge Specific Plan area.
The establishment of the site-specific development standards set forth in this chapter are intended
to guide orderly development within the Specific Plan area, while also maintaining some flexibility
to respond to changing conditions which may be a factor in any long-term development.
3.2 Permitted Uses
Development standards for the Refuge Specific Plan area are shown in Table 3.1
Permitted Uses.
Table 3.1 Permitted Uses
Allowable Uses1 PA 1 PA 2 PA 3 PA 4 PA 5
P=Permitted; C=Conditional Use Permit; N=Not Permitted
Residential
Assisted living N N N N N
Accessory dwelling
unit P P P N N
Condominium C P P N N
Dwelling Duplex P P P N N
Dwelling Multifamily P P P N N
Dwelling Second P P P N N
Dwelling Single
Family N P P N N
Guest Dwelling N N P N N
Home- based
business P P P N N
Junior accessory
dwelling unit P P P N N
PUD - Residential C C C N N
Transitional/Support
ive housing 2 P P P N N
Open Space P P P P P
Community space P P P P
P
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 39
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
27
Foot Notes:
1. Review authority (Planning Commission, City Council, etc.) for the subject permits above shall be as outlined in
Section 25.60.110 of the Palm Desert Municipal Code.
2. Transitional and supportive housing shall be subject to only those restrictions that apply to other residential uses
of the same type in the Specific Plan.
3. Accessory Dwelling Unit definitions and regulations defined in Section 25.34.030 in the Palm Desert Municipal
Code
4. Guest Dwelling refers to units that cannot be separately rented out
5. Multifamily residential standards for PA-2 will apply to PA-3 if multifamily uses are chosen for this Planning Area
3.3 Development Standards
The following development standards apply to each planning area as described below.
Table 3.2 Development Standards PA-1
Standard
Product Type Vitalia 1
Density -
Lot Dimensions
Min Lot size -
Min Lot width -
Min Lot depth -
Yard Setbacks (Min)
Front - Street
to building or garage 8 -
Side – Interior 9 -
Side – Street 10 -
Side – Alley 8, 11 -
Rear - Traditional -
Rear - Alley to building 8
or garage 10 -
Rear-Building to PA-2
Boundary -
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 40
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
28
Patio Covers (Side &
Rear) -
Accessory Structures -
Lot Coverage
Max Coverage -
Parking
Spaces Required -
Building Measurements
Min separation between
buildings -
Max height -
Max stories -
Max height per story -
1. All development standards apply per Approved PP/CUP 21-0004 in accordance with Planned Residential District of
the PDMC.
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 41
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
29
Table 3.3 Development Standards PA-21
Standard
Product Type Detached 2 Attached 3
Density 10 – 18.3 du/ac
Lot Dimensions
Min Lot size 1,800 4 -
Min Lot width - -
Min Lot depth - -
Yard Setbacks (Min)
Front - Street
to building or garage 5
8 ft/18 ft 8 ft/18 ft
Side – Interior 6 5 ft -
Side – Street 7 7 ft 10 ft
Side – Alley 5, 8 5 ft 5 ft
Rear - Traditional 5 ft -
Rear - Alley to building 5
or garage 7
N/A 5 ft/3ft
Rear-Building to PA-2
Boundary
10ft 10ft
Patio Covers (Side &
Rear)
Per PDMC Section 25.40.030 (Projections
into Required Setbacks)
-
Accessory Structures
Per PDMC Section 25.40.050 (Accessory
Buildings and Structures)
-
Lot Coverage 9
Max Coverage 70% 70%
Parking
Spaces Required
One Bedroom: 1.25 spaces per unit
Two Bedroom+: 2 spaces per unit
Building Measurements
Min separation between
buildings 10 ft Per CBC/CRC
Max height 10 30 ft 35 ft
Max stories 2 3
1. Up to 70 units (10% of combined PA maximum) may be transferred between PA 2 & 3.
2. Including Small-Lot Detached Clusters, Bungalow-Style Detached Units.
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 42
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
30
3. Including Attached Townhomes, Garden-Style Attached Apartments.
4. Minimum lot size applies to single family attached or detached lots (not condo mapped development).
5. Measured from back of curb or sidewalk, if present, whichever creates a greater setback.
6. Including lots that adjoin common area landscape lots.
7. Measured from back of curb.
8. 0 ft side yard in paired or zero lot line condition.
9. The percentage of a lot covered by the total square footage of the main building, garage, and/or any
accessory buildings that are larger than 150 square feet.
10. Buildings along perimeter streets shall be no greater than 2 stories (25’-0”).
Table 3.4 Development Standards PA-31
Standard
Product Type SFD 2 SFD – Alley 3
Density 4.7-6 du/ac 4
Lot Dimensions
Min Lot size 3,000 sf 3,000 sf
Min Lot width 40 ft 40 ft
Min Lot depth - -
Yard Setbacks (Min)
Front - Street
to building or garage 5 10 ft/18ft N/A
Side – Interior 9 5 ft 5 ft
Side – Interior 6 7 ft 5 ft
Side – Street 7 - 5 ft
Side – Alley 5, 8 15 ft N/A
Rear - Traditional N/A 3 ft/3 ft
Rear - Alley to building 5
or garage 7
- -
Patio Covers (Side &
Rear)
Per PDMC Section 25.40.030 (Projections
into Required Setbacks)
Per PDMC Section 25.40.030
(Projections into Required
Setbacks)
Accessory Structures
Per PDMC Section 25.40.050 (Accessory Buildings and Structures)
-
Lot Coverage 9
Max Coverage 60% 65%
Parking
Spaces Required One Bedroom: 1.25 spaces per unit
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 43
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
31
Two Bedroom+: 2 spaces per unit
Building Measurements
Min separation between
buildings 10 ft 8 ft
Max height 30 ft 30 ft
Max stories 2 10 2 10
1. Up to 70 units (10% of combined PA maximum) may be transferred between PA 2 & 3.
2. Measured from back of curb or sidewalk, if present
3. Including lots that adjoin common area landscape lots.
4. The average density of PA-3 will fall within the range provided. Density range is just an average and may
include some lot configurations that will have densities outside the stated range.
5. Measured from back of curb or sidewalk, if present and whichever creates a greater setback.
6. Including lots that adjoin common area landscape lots.
7. Measured from back of curb.
8. 0 ft side yard in paired or zero lot line condition.
9. The percentage of a lot covered by the total square footage of the main building, garage, and/or any
accessory buildings that are larger than 150 square feet.
10. Limited to 1-story, and 18 feet in height, when adjacent to, or within 50 feet of, Planning Area 5.
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 44
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
32
Table 3.5 Development Standards PA-4
Standard
Product Type OS/Rec
Density -
Lot Dimensions
Min Lot size 3 Acres
Min Lot width -
Min Lot depth -
Yard Setbacks (Min)
Front - Street
to building or garage
20ft
Side – Interior -
Side – Street -
Side – Alley -
Rear - Traditional 20ft
Rear - Alley to building
or garage -
Rear-Building to PA-2
Boundary -
Patio Covers (Side &
Rear) -
Accessory Structures Per PDMC Section 25.40.050 (Accessory Buildings and Structures)
Lot Coverage
Max Coverage -
Parking
Spaces Required -
Building Measurements
Min separation between
buildings -
Max height -
Max stories -
Max height per story -
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 45
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
33
Table 3.6 Development Standards PA-5
Standard
Product Type OS
Density -
Lot Dimensions
Min Lot size -
Min Lot width -
Min Lot depth -
Yard Setbacks (Min)
Front - Street
to building or garage -
Side – Interior -
Side – Street -
Side – Alley -
Rear - Traditional -
Rear - Alley to building or
garage -
Rear-Building to PA-2
Boundary -
Patio Covers (Side &
Rear) -
Accessory Structures -
Lot Coverage
Max Coverage -
Parking
Spaces Required -
Building Measurements
Min separation between
buildings -
Max height -
Max stories -
Max height per story -
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 46
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
34
CHAPTER 4: DESIGN GUIDELINES
4.1 Overview
The Refuge is envisioned to be a cohesive residential community featuring right-sized recreation
and open space amenities integrated throughout the project. To accommodate a wide variety
of lifestyles, the Refuge allows for a range of lot sizes and housing types from conventionally
loaded single family detached homes to stacked flat multi-family living. The different product
types provide better livability through greater housing options and enhanced aesthetic interest
through diversity. The architecture and landscape should be designed to provide a thematic
character visually connecting the community.
The Specific Plan areas should be developed in a cohesive and integrated manner such that they
function as and are recognizable as a single destination. Structures, hardscape, and landscape
are all elements that should be considered in order to develop a pleasing and compatible visual
identity.
The Design Guidelines in this section are intended to serve as the guiding design principles for
future neighborhood development at the Refuge. These guidelines provide a flexible set of
fundamental principles that will assure an integrated, attractive, and high-quality living
environment, and are meant to promote development that is pedestrian-oriented,
interconnected, and visually engaging to residents. They are intended to ensure a high level of
design quality while providing the flexibility to accommodate changes in consumer preferences,
economic conditions, community designs, and the marketplace. As such, the use of “should”
equates to strongly encouraged and the use of “shall” means mandatory.
4.2 Design Guidelines
There are four planning areas within the Refuge Specific Plan that work together to offer a range
of housing types that cater to a variety of life stages and lifestyles. These guidelines are designed
to address all structure types within the four planning areas and shall be used as appropriate to
the focused housing typology.
Projects developed within the Specific Plan should incorporate elements of the City’s Sustainability
Plan to the greatest extent practical and utilize design strategies, building materials, and
construction methods that are compatible with the Palm Desert climate.
General Development Standards
• The Project shall be developed in accordance with the City’s Zoning Ordinance, except
as otherwise provided by the Refuge Specific Plan.
• All improvements constructed on the property shall conform to applicable building
ordinances and codes in effect at the time construction occurs.
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 47
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
35
• Where the provisions of this Specific Plan conflict with land use or building ordinances,
regulations, and/or codes, the provisions of this Specific Plan shall control.
Site Planning
• All built elements of the Specific Plan area should be developed in a cohesive and
integrated manner such that they function as and are recognizable as a single
destination. This includes consideration of structures, hardscape, and landscaping that
visually tie these elements together in an effective and pleasing manner.
• Building frontages shall be located at the front property line where no setback
requirement exists, or at the required setback. Where additional setback is necessary or
a prevailing setback exists, activate the area with landscape or common area features.
• Common open space shall be located at the ground level in a manner that is accessible
and visible to residential units, promoting safety and the use of outdoor areas.
• All primary residential structures shall be designed ensure that all street-fronting units
have a primary entrance facing the street or internal private circulation.
• Entries shall be designed according to simple and harmonious proportions in relationship
to the overall size and scale of the building. Design entries in proportion to the number
of units being accessed.
• All pedestrian entries shall incorporate shelter elements.
• All multi-story development of two stories or more shall mitigate negative shade/shadow
and privacy impacts by stepping back upper floors and avoiding direct views into
neighboring single-family yards as feasible.
• All proposed residential development within 50 feet of Planning Area 5 shall be no greater
than one-story, contained within 18 feet.
• Internal circulation should minimize pedestrian/vehicle conflicts to the greatest extent
possible. Structures should be linked to sidewalks or paseos.
• Structures within Planning Area 1 and Planning Area 2 shall incorporate methods to
screen line of sight from residential structures towards the Riverside County Sheriff’s
Station. Methods shall include window treatments which are integral to the window
construction, such as frosted windows; window films and/or spandrel glass shall be
prohibited. Landscaping may be used when permanently maintained.
• Where multi-family projects are adjacent to single-family zones, provide a sensitive
transition by maintaining a height compatible with adjacent buildings. Mitigate
negative shade/shadow and privacy impacts by stepping back upper floors and
avoiding direct views into neighboring single-family yards.
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 48
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
36
• All exterior façades of the building shall be treated with an equal level of detail,
articulation, and architectural rigor when visible from the public right-of-way or common
open space.
• Long expanses of walls or fences should incorporate openings, changes in materials,
texture, and/or landscaping. Fence materials such as chain link, wrought iron spears,
barbed wire, wood, and vinyl shall be prohibited.
Parking
• All single-family residential structures shall be provided a minimum of two covered
parking spaces located within an enclosed garage.
• All multi-family residential shall be provided a minimum of one covered parking spaces
located within an enclosed garage or carport.
• A minimum of 50% of all residential parking not located within a garage or carport is
recommended to be shaded by landscape shade trees.
• Detached and attached garages, carports, and accessory structures shall be
designed as integral parts of the project and consistent with the principal structures of
the project, and shall match in terms of scale, material, color, and roof form.
• Surface parking lots for multi-family developments shall be screened from public streets
by a minimum 42” masonry block wall, in combination with desert native landscaping
and/or berms. Trees, shrubbery, planter boxes, climbing plants, vines, green walls, or
berms can be used to soften views from the public right-of-way.
Circulation
• Entry roads and street access points to Planning Area 4 shall incorporate features such
as contrasting markings, signage, and/or lighting so that pedestrian crossings are visible
to moving vehicles during the day and at night.
• A continuous pedestrian circulation shall be provided to link all Planning Areas of the
Specific Plan with the central communal open space area.
• Use ornamental low-level lighting to highlight and provide security for pedestrian paths
and entrances. Ensure that all parking areas and pedestrian walkways are illuminated.
• Utilize adequate, uniform, and glare-free lighting, such as dark-sky compliant fixtures,
to avoid uneven light distribution, harsh shadows, and light spillage. All exterior lighting
shall be designed pursuant to Palm Desert Municipal Code Section 24.16.
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 49
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
37
• Paseos shall be provided to facilitate pedestrian access to central community
amenities, and Planning Areas 4 and 5, such that pedestrians will not need to walk the
perimeter of a block to access said amenities.
• All paseos shall utilize pedestrian-level lighting, benches, landscaping, shade trees, or
special paving so that they are safe and visually interesting spaces.
• Entry roads shall be designed with a landscape parkway separating the curb from the
sidewalk
Streetscape Design
Attention to streetscape design enables the community to have a thoughtful aesthetic that
promotes character and visual interest. Streetscape design should include the following
considerations:
• Internal circulation should minimize pedestrian/vehicle conflicts to the greatest extent
possible.
• Where possible, front doors should be placed along streets, common drive aisles (not
including project entries) and common open spaces.
o When front doors are along access drives, special attention should be paid to
make these entries safe, pedestrian friendly, and attractive.
• Streetscene diversity should be encouraged by differing the styles, colors, and materials of
the homes.
• Wall planes on building façades should be varied to provide movement along the
building elevations for visual interest.
• Porches or covered entry spaces should be provided for stepped massing and transition
from public to private realm.
• Low courtyard walls or fences (36 to 40-inches in height) may also be used to transition
from public to private realm.
• Balconies, color blocking or other features are encouraged to minimize massing.
• In planning areas where single family detached homes are contemplated, streetscene
diversity should be enhanced by avoiding the placement of the same floorplan, with the
same elevation style and color scheme, adjacent to each other or across the street from
one another.
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 50
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
38
Architectural Principles
Architectural detailing of building facades is a key feature of quality design that can truly liven up
a streetscene. Paramount to this, however, is applying the right detail that is appropriate to the
architectural style. The following are suggested considerations:
• All building elements, such as materials and color, detail elements (porches, balconies,
courtyards, awnings, surface treatments, and materials), and functional elements
(lights, exterior stairs, guardrails, gutters, downspouts, screen walls, electrical
enclosures, or similar features) should be integral to the buildings design, consistent with
the architectural vernacular of the building, and complement the surrounding
neighborhood.
• The treatment of entries (doors, vestibules, porches or courtyards) should consider using
enhanced trim or details to emphasize these as primary focal points.
• Building design should be sensitive and responsive to the varying temperatures and
outdoor living opportunities of the Coachella Valley.
• All accessory structures should be compatible in design with the primary buildings, and
be visually related to the development.
Colors and Materials
The primary goal of color and materials palettes is to further enhance and define the architectural
styles within the Refuge. The composition of color and materials should be applied in a manner
that complements building massing and seeks to achieve a harmonious and visually interesting
community.
The plotting of elevations, color, and material palettes should be selected with the design
objectives of avoiding monotony, providing depth and interest through colorful design schemes,
and creating character and long-term value.
• Selected colors and materials should be appropriate to the styles they represent and
used to further differentiate from the other styles.
• Building façades should be designed to incorporate the use of
contrasting/complementary colors and materials.
• The predominant building colors should be chosen to create aesthetically pleasing
building elevations with other tones/colors used to accentuate architectural
elements/features.
• Finish materials should be appropriate in their use and application, be durable, and of
high quality.
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 51
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
39
• Materials, when included, should be appropriately used in relation to the building style,
scale, location, and function.
• Architectural screens and accessory structures should be compatible in material, color,
and texture to the main buildings.
Materials and Finishes
The use of complementary building materials can promote a harmonious appearance and
provide interest and variety to the selected architectural styles. The following material and finish
principles should be considered:
• Exterior materials shall consider compatibility with the desert environment.
• Use high-quality, durable, low-maintenance materials.
• Place lighter materials above materials of a heavier weight.
• Material finishes should express permanence and quality.
• Use style-appropriate concrete roof tile blends (where appropriate), overly dramatic
blends with extreme contrast are prohibited. Cool roof material should be considered.
Stucco
Stucco finish should project high quality and be appropriate to the architectural style.
• All stucco trim details (such as window surrounds, windowsills, roof eaves, column
details, lintels, etc.) must be constructed with a level of precision and accuracy to
express the authentic execution of the architectural style.
• Use clean, crisp and smooth stucco details.
• Carefully locate stucco control joints, if applicable, on elevation designs.
• Heavy Lace, Light Lace and Spanish Texture stucco finishes are prohibited
Wood
Wood is a material used in many architectural styles. However, maintenance concerns, a desire
for long-term architectural quality, and new high-quality manufactured alternative wood
materials make use of real wood material less desirable. Where “wood” is referred to in these
guidelines, it can also be interpreted as simulated wood trim with style-appropriate wood texture.
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 52
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
40
Massing, Scale and Articulation
Building size should be considered during the design phase to determine appropriate massing,
scale and articulation.
Smaller homes stand to benefit from a simpler, streamlined architectural treatment characterized
by stacked massing, simple rooflines, and an acute attention to detail to maximize livable square
footage for the residents. Architecture that results in a simplified massing should pay special
attention to entries and front façade treatments to enhance the front elevation.
Larger structures should incorporate design methods that offer human scale to the building
massing as well as articulation to provide visual movement along the primary elevations.
• Architectural elements may be used to break up the massing and enhance the pedestrian
scale of the building including features that create shadow and relief, balconies, trellises,
recesses, overhangs, awnings, and porches.
• Multi-story living spaces are permitted per Table 3.2: Development Standards.
• When designing two-story homes, “recessed” second story elements are encouraged to
create human-scale buildings.
Roof Form
Roof form is an important design element that conveys the character of the community when
observed from both the external edges and the inside of the neighborhoods.
• Roof forms are encouraged to reinforce the architectural style of the home.
• Roof pitches are encouraged to vary based upon chosen architectural styles.
• Flat roofs are permitted where appropriate to the style and location.
Architectural Projections (for Multi-Story Structures)
As part of the overall composition of a two-story dwelling, balconies or projections provide relief
and interest at the second story. Additionally, these elements help shape outdoor rooms.
• Covered balconies and living area cantilevers are encouraged when appropriate to
the architectural style.
• Balconies and projections shall proportionally complement and be integrated into the
overall massing of the home.
• Architectural projections such as media niches are encouraged to facilitate massing
articulation.
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 53
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
41
• Opportunities for creating shaded areas and usable outdoor spaces are encouraged.
• Multi-story structures adjacent to the sheriff station or existing single family homes shall
include step backs to minimize visual intrusion into adjacent uses.
Garages
Where attached or detached garages are included, the intent is to tie them into the overall
project while reducing their visual emphasis. Garage appearance should complement the
architectural style of the homes they are accommodating. Some of the following methods may
be used to enhance garage facilities (not all have to be included):
• Provide different style door patterns (as appropriate to the architectural style).
• Provide different colors for garage doors (does not apply to multiple doors in one
building).
• Include window lites as a door design variation.
Carports
These structures should be compatible with the style, color and materials of the primary buildings
(this may include metal supports).
• Prefabricated carport structures are prohibited.
Windows
Window details differentiate architectural styles and can provide a high level of architectural
enrichment.
• The selection and proportion of the windows to the façade shall be responsive to the
architectural style of the building. Size and shape shall be considered to assure a
balanced relationship with the surrounding roof and walls.
• Divided lite windows are encouraged and should reflect the architectural style,
simulated divided-lite is acceptable.
• Non-street-facing and rear yard windows may delete the divided lites.
• Attention to window placement is imperative to encourage offsetting windows from
adjacent homes.
• Windows in Planning Area 1 and 2 which face the neighboring sheriff station shall
incorporate window screening which is integrated into the window construction to
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 54
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
42
preclude direct line of site from residential units. Use of films as a means of screening is
prohibited.
Shutters
All shutters shall be constructed of durable, climate appropriate materials and be consistent with
the architectural style of the structure.
• Use only wood or simulated wood material for shutters.
• Mount shutters on finished wall material; embedded shutters prohibited.
• Match shutter size to the recessed opening window width.
• Use material at least one-and-a-half-inch thick so as to provide substantial
dimensionality, avoiding a tacked-on appearance.
Lighting
Appropriate lighting is essential in creating an inviting evening atmosphere for the community.
• All lighting shall be non-obtrusive.
• Limit all exterior lighting to the minimum necessary for safety.
• Shield all exterior lighting to minimize glare and light spill onto adjacent properties.
• Use exterior entry lights that complement the architectural style.
• Refer to PDMC Section 24.16 for City’s outdoor lighting requirements.
Ornamental Details
Use details that appear as functional elements and match the architectural style.
Screening:
• Rooftop equipment such as air conditioning units, antennas and communication
equipment, mechanical equipment, and vents shall be fully screened from view by
use of a parapet or other architecturally compatible screening.
• Place utilities such as gas, electric, and water meters in side yard setbacks or in
landscaped areas and out of the line-of-sight from crosswalks or sidewalks to the
greatest extent feasible.
• Utilities such as power lines, transformers, and wireless facilities should be placed
underground or on rooftops when appropriately screened by a parapet.
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 55
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
43
• Any mechanical or electrical equipment should be buffered by planting materials in a
manner that contributes to the quality of the existing landscaping on the property and
the public streetscape.
• Trash enclosures shall be located so that they are not visible from the public right-of-
way or neighboring properties. Screen outdoor standalone trash enclosures using walls
consistent with the architectural character of the primary building(s) and locate them
so that they are out of the line-of-sight from public streets.
• Noise and odor-generating functions shall be located within enclosed structures so as
not to create a nuisance for building residents or adjacent neighbors.
Mechanical Equipment
Mechanical equipment includes but not limited to:
• HVAC equipment,
• Gas and electric meters,
• Cable/TV panels,
• Pool and spa equipment, and
• Exterior landscape/lighting equipment.
Trash Enclosures and Bins
Refuse and recyclable materials storage areas should be designed consistent with the City’s
Zoning Code. Enclosures should be provided to accommodate the numbers and types of trash
containers as required by the disposal company.
• Community enclosures should be positioned in a centrally convenient area for
residents but screened to the greatest extent possible.
• Trash enclosures areas that can be overlooked from above are suggested to
incorporate roof structures to screen the contents of the enclosure from view.
o Such roof structures should be designed to allow the doors of the refuse
container to fully open.
• To enhance safety, lighted person access is recommended at each enclosure.
• Individual bins for households should be screened to the greatest extent possible from
public view.
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 56
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
44
Recreation & Common Facilities
Common recreation facilities such as pools, spas, clubhouses, management offices, barbecues
and other facilities appropriate to the development may be included. Common recreation
facilities should be key character elements for the neighborhood.
• All architectural and community elements, such as furnishings, lighting standards, and
trash receptacles shall be consistent with the selected overall architectural character
for the neighborhood.
• Clubhouse and other common buildings should exhibit 360-degree architecture.
• Colors, massing, roof pitch, and materials should be compatible with residential
buildings or project theme.
Site Specific
• Planning Area 3 – Lots located along the eastern and southern edges of the Refuge
Specific Plan shall be limited to one story. Pitched roof homes in those locations shall be
limited to a maximum height of 18’ from the approved pad elevation. Flat roof, or
parapet roof structures in those locations shall be limited to a maximum height of 16’ from
the approved pad elevation.
• Planning Area 1 and 2 – Structures adjacent to the Riverside County Sheriff Station shall
incorporate screening which blocks direct line of sight from the residences into the sheriff
station property.
• Planning Area 2 – Structures adjacent to the public street, and existing single family
residential shall be limited to two stories or shall incorporate site-sensitive step backs on
upper floors. Direct views into neighboring single-family yards shall be avoided.
• All Planning Area – Roof decks shall be prohibited in all areas.
• Planning Area 4 – Landscape shade trees shall be provided along the perimeter and
throughout the site. On street parking areas shall be provided with shade trees.
4.3 Landscape Design Guidelines
The Refuge includes a generous amount of open space to serve the residents. Each planning
area will feature a central amenity that includes both passive and active recreational
opportunities. The landscape buffer trail in Planning Area 3 will offer a walking path that both
contributes to the active amenities of the Refuge and serves as a buffer to the adjacent existing
neighborhoods.
The community character is further enhanced through landscape elements. Selective plantings
reinforce the scale of streetscapes, neighborhoods, and pedestrian spaces. Strategic locations of
trees and shrubs define community focal points and soften architectural massing. The landscape
design should incorporate the following concepts:
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 57
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
45
• Landscape treatments shall maximize the use of native desert and compatible
drought-tolerant plant materials. Species must comply with City and Coachella Valley
Water District water conservation ordinance requirements. Selecting drought tolerant,
native landscaping will limit irrigation needs and conserve water.
• Encourage the use of plants as a major design element including using contrasting
textures and mass planting of bold or fine plant material.
• Use of turf grass should be limited to functional play and active use areas.
• Use decorative gravel, decomposed granite, boulders, and similar materials as a
texture and design element; size material suitable to remain in place after installation.
• As feasible, landscape in or around retention basins to enhance their appearance.
• Front yards shall provide a minimum of two 24” box shade trees. This requirement may
be reduced to one on-site tree when combined with street trees permanently
maintained within landscape areas.
• Front yard areas shall provide for a minimum of 60% landscape areas consisting of live
plant materials, and a mixture of decomposed granite, cobble, or boulders.
• Front yard areas shall be limited to a maximum of 40% paved area for driveways.
• On corner lots, the driveway shall be oriented as far from the corner as possible.
Walls and Fences
Walls and fences should be an integral part of site design, especially in areas of public visibility.
Careful consideration shall be given to their placement so as to assure a natural transition
between land uses in addition to privacy, where needed. Walls and fencing should be consistent
with community visual theme.
Lighting
Preserve the nighttime dark sky by modulating the number, lumens, casting, and character of
exterior light sources. Utilize low intensity, direct and indirect light sources (as appropriate) to the
extent required for safety, functionality, and accentuation of landscape design.
• Refer to PDMC Section 24.16 for Outdoor Lighting Requirements.
• Light fixtures should complement the architecture and enhance the landscape.
Irrigation
Planting and irrigation design must meet Coachella Valley Water District (CVWD) standards and
the State of California Model Efficient Water Ordinance (MELO).
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 58
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
46
• Landscape treatments should maximize the use of native desert and compatible
drought tolerant plant materials.
• Landscape plans must address wind and water erosion issues and demonstrate the
water efficiency gained from plant and irrigation systems.
• All areas not covered by structures, drives, parking or hardscape should be
appropriately landscaped.
• The use of turf should be limited to functional play and active use areas.
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 59
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
47
CHAPTER 5: PLAN ADMINISTRATION
5.1 Overview
This chapter describes the procedures for administration and implementation of the Refuge
Specific Plan. The City of Palm Desert Development Services Department shall have the
responsibility for plan administration and implementation as established in this chapter.
5.2 Implementation
Entitlement approvals and construction permits shall be reviewed by all applicable departments
and agencies (Planning Division, Public Works, Building and Safety, Fire, etc.) where necessary to
ensure consistency with the Specific Plan, PDCC, and applicable building codes. This Specific Plan
establishes the general intent and comprehensive framework for the future development of the
Refuge project. However, prior to construction, various implementing approvals are required, as
noted below.
Specific Plan (SP) - The Specific Plan will cover approximately 106.4 acres to provide
comprehensive development guidelines, allowable uses, and standards. The Specific Plan
requires public hearings before the Planning Commission and the City Council.
Precise Plan (PP) – A Precise Plan application is required for uses specified in Chapter 3 of this
Specific Plan showing the site and architectural plans in greater detail for the proposed project.
Each PP will require approval by the Planning Commission.
Tentative Parcel Map (TPM)/Tentative Tract Map (TTM) – TPM/TTMs are intended to subdivide the
property into smaller parcels/lots for development or sale. TPM/TTMs may be filed with each phase
of development as necessary in accordance with Chapter 26.20 TENTATIVE MAP of the PDCC.
Implementing Tentative Maps need not reflect the exact lotting shown in this Specific Plan so long
as they achieve comparable walkability and buffering designs, incorporate the standards and
guidelines contained in Chapters 3 and 4, and lie within the total density and dwelling unit ranges
shown on Table 2. Each TPM/TTM will require approval by the Planning Commission.
5.3 Administration
Administrative Changes - Modifications that are consistent with the purpose and intent of the
Refuge Specific Plan are allowed at the discretion of the Development Services Director or
designee. Unless the modification is a request in a change of height. Height changes shall require
a specific plan amendment. If proposed modifications exceed 15% of deviation from specified
standards the changes shall be deemed to require a Specific Plan Amendment necessitating City
Council approval. Changes at 15% or under the deviation threshold shall be considered being
within substantial conformance and not subject to council approval. Therefore, it is intended that
this Specific Plan provide City Staff with the flexibility to interpret the details of project development
as well as those items described in general terms in the Specific Plan without requiring a formal
Specific Plan Amendment. Furthermore, the director or designee shall also have the authority to
approve substantial conformance designations on tentative maps that have been previously
approved by the Planning Commission without the need for secondary Planning Commission
review.
Requests for administrative changes shall be made in writing. If/when it is determined that
changes or adjustments are necessary or appropriate, the Development Services Director or
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 60
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
48
designee may issue approval. After approval, any such administrative change shall be attached
to the Specific Plan as an addendum and may be further changed and amended from time to
time as necessary.
Representative examples of such changes may include, but are not limited to:
The addition of new information to the Specific Plan maps or text that do not substantially
change the effect of any regulation. The new information may include more detailed, site-
specific information.
Changes to infrastructure such as drainage systems, roads, water and sewer systems, etc.
Deviations not exceeding 15% of the development regulations set forth in Chapter 3 of
this Specific Plan.
Transfer of up to 70 units between Planning Areas 2and 3. See Table 2.1.
Formal Amendments - If it has been determined that the proposed change is not in conformance
with the intent of the current Specific Plan approval, the Specific Plan may be amended in
accordance with the procedures set forth in Chapter 25.78.080 of the Palm Desert Municipal Code
(PDMC) and require approval by the City Council.
5.4 Interpretation
Uses Not Listed - All uses not listed as allowed in this Specific Plan are prohibited. However, the
Development Services Director may determine that a use not listed is included within, similar to or
comparable to a listed use and, once so determined; it shall be treated in the same manner as a
listed use.
Application of Standards - Where there is ambiguity between the Specific Plan and the Zoning
Code, the Development Services Director shall review pertinent information and determine which
code or standard applies. All determinations shall be in writing and shall be attached to the
Specific Plan as noted under Administrative Changes, earlier in this section.
Maintenance Plan – The maintenance concept is flexible and may be applied to alternative site
plans so long as private streets, common area lots, public streetscapes and public sidewalks are
designated for private maintenance. Public maintenance is limited to public streets from curb to
curb. See Figure 2.9 Maintenance Plan for reference.
5.5 Enforcement
The enforcement of the provisions of this Specific Plan shall be by the following:
The City of Palm Desert Development Services Department shall enforce the development
standards and regulations set forth herein.
Any administrative decision or interpretation of this Specific Plan may be appealed to the
Planning Commission per Chapter 25.02.040 ADMINISTRATIVE RESPONSIBILITY APPEALS of
the PDMC. Likewise, any decision by the Planning Commission may be appealed to the
City Council.
The City of Palm Desert shall administer the provisions of the Refuge Specific Plan in
accordance with the State of California Government Code, Subdivision Map Act, the City
of Palm Desert General Plan, and the PDMC.
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 61
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
49
The Specific Plan development procedures, regulations, standards, and specifications
shall supersede the relevant provisions of the PDMC, as they currently exist or may be
amended in the future.
All regulations, conditions, and programs contained herein shall be deemed separate
distinct and independent provisions of this Specific Plan. In the event that any such
provision is held invalid or unconstitutional, the validity of all the remaining provisions of this
Specific Plan shall not be affected.
Any development regulation and building requirement not addressed in this Specific Plan
shall be subject to all relevant City of Palm Desert ordinances, codes, and regulations.
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 62
NOPARKINGNOPARKING
NOPARKING NOPAR
KI
NG
NOPARKING
COMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARCOMPACTCARGerald Ford Drive
Woodward Drive Portola AvenueShepherd LaneJulie Drive
PUBLIC MAINTENANCEPRIVATE
MAINTENANCE
PRIVATE
MAINTENANCE
CLR/W
SIDEWALK
LANDSCAPE AREA
R/WGUTTER
CURB &
GUTTER
CURB &
LANDSCAPE AREA
SIDEWALKIF PRESENT
MEDIAN
Exhibit Date: October 11, 2022
SPECIFIC PLANREFUGE:
MSA
Civil Engineering Land Surveying Landscape ArchitecturePlanning Environmental Services Dry Utility Coordination GIS
MSAConsultinginc.com
CONSULTING, INC.
MAINTENANCE PLAN
FIGURE 2.9
PAGE 50
N.T.S.
Source: City of Palm Desert / MSA Consulting, Inc.
Public Maintenance
Privately Maintained
Legend:
Project Boundary
TYPICAL MAINTENANCE ROAD SECTION
N.T.S.
Note: Maintenance concept is flexible and may applied to
alternative site plans so long as private streets, common area lots,
public streetscapes and public sidewalks are designated for
private maintenance. Public maintenance is limited to public
streets from curb to curb.
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 63
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
51
CHAPTER 6: GENERAL PLAN CONSISTENCY ANALYSIS
6.1 Applicable Land Use Policy Consistency
Policy 1.2: Open space preservation. Balance the development of the city with the
provision of open space, and especially the hillsides surrounding the City, so as to create
both high quality urban areas and high-quality open space.
1.3 Traffic generation. Balance medium and high intensity/density development with
pedestrian-oriented and bicycle friendly design features so as to maximize trip and VMT
reduction.
1.4 Phasing of public facilities. Require new parks, open spaces and public facilities be
constructed concurrent with, or prior to, the development of each Neighborhood. All
required parks, open spaces and public facilities should be constructed before 75 percent
of the dwelling units are constructed.
1.6 Community Amenities. Balance the impacts of new development, density, and
urbanization through the provision of a high-level of neighborhood and community
amenities and design features
Policy Responses: As addressed in Section 2.4 of the Specific Plan, the project intends to
provide for sufficient open space within the residential community via landscaped buffers,
a central recreational amenity, and linear paseos to encourage the use of active
transportation. Furthermore, planning Areas 4&5 are designated as Open Space &
Recreation areas to help provide for high quality open spaces in the city. The
walkable/bikeable nature of the circulation system will aid in VMT reductions to access the
central amenity and we will work with staff to come to a phasing agreement that is
satisfactory to both parties.
2.1 Pedestrian focus. Design the streetscape of high-volume corridors to balance regional
traffic flow with pedestrian movement and safety and the unique physical environment of
the area.
2.3 Landscaping. Require development projects to incorporate high quality landscaping
in order to extend and enhance the green space network of the city.
2.4 Tree planting. Encourage the planting of trees that appropriately shade the sidewalk
and improve the pedestrian experience throughout the city.
2.5 Streetscape. Enhance the pedestrian experience through streetscape improvements
that could include new street lighting, tree planting, and easement dedications to
increase the size of the sidewalks and pedestrian amenities.
2.7 Public gathering spaces. Improve existing and create new gathering spaces
throughout the city to provide beautiful, comfortable, and inviting public and pedestrian
spaces, encouraging walking and public gathering spaces.
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 64
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
52
2.12 Destination Accessibility. Direct the development of new centers, parks, schools, and
similar destinations so as to provide all residences within town ¼ mile to at least two
amenities.
Policy Responses: The pedestrian is a central focus of this project with ease of movement
and access at the forefront of design planning. It is the intent to have the project
landscaping, trees, and streetscape be inviting, comfortable, and complimentary of each
other to provide a high-quality experience. This is also why we are committing to having
all residences be located within the desired quarter mile radius of our central recreational
amenity to further enhance the accessibility of the destination.
3.1 Complete neighborhoods. Through the development entitlement process, ensure that
all new Neighborhoods (areas with a “Neighborhood” General Plan Designation) are
complete and well-structured such that the physical layout and land use mix promote
walking to services, biking and transit use, are family friendly and address the needs of
multiple ages and physical abilities. New neighborhoods should have the following
characteristics:
• Contain short, walkable block lengths.
• Contain a high level of connectivity for pedestrians, bicycles, and vehicles where
practicable.
• Are organized around a central focal point such as a park, school, civic building, or
neighborhood retail such that most homes are no more than one-quarter mile from this
focal point.
• Have goods and services within a short walking distance.
• Contain a diversity of housing types, where possible.
• Have homes with entries and windows facing the street.
• Have a grid or modified grid street network (except where topography necessitates
another street network layout).
• Provide a diversity of architectural styles.
3.2 Conventional neighborhood design. Discourage the construction of new residential
neighborhoods that are characterized by cul-de-sacs, sound walls, long block lengths,
single building and housing types and lack of access to goods and services.
3.3 Variety of types of neighborhoods. Promote a variety of neighborhoods within the City
and ensure that neighborhood types are dispersed throughout the City.
3.4 Balanced neighborhoods. Within the allowed densities and housing types, promote a
range of housing and price levels within each neighborhood in order to accommodate
diverse ages and incomes. For development projects larger than five acres, require that a
diversity of housing types be provided and that these housing types be mixed rather than
segregated by unit type.
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 65
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
53
3.5 Housing affordability. Ensure affordable housing is distributed throughout the City to
avoid concentrations of poverty and to be accessible to jobs.
3.7 Walkable neighborhoods. Require that all new neighborhoods be designed and
constructed to be pedestrian friendly and include features such as short blocks, wide
sidewalks, tree-shaded streets, buildings that define and are oriented to streets or public
spaces, traffic-calming features, convenient pedestrian street crossings, and safe streets
that are designed for pedestrians, cyclists and vehicles.
• Provision of sidewalks. Except within designated rural areas, require sidewalks of at least
six feet in width on both sides of streets in neighborhoods and prohibit obstructions that
would impede use of the sidewalk.
• Block size. Require new neighborhoods to be designed with blocks no longer than 600 to
800 feet. Exceptions can be made if mid-block pedestrian and bicycle connections are
provided.
3.10 Shared driveways. Allow and encourage new commercial and residential
developments to have common driveways serving multiple units, to minimize the number
of curb cuts along any given block to improve pedestrian safety.
3.12 Tree-lined streets. Require trees on both sides of at least 60 percent of new and existing
streets within the project and on the project’s side of bordering streets, between the
vehicle travel way and walkway at intervals averaging no more than 50-100 feet
(excluding driveways and utility vaults). This standard shall apply whenever new streets are
constructed or when existing streets and sidewalks are significantly rehabilitated with
existing neighborhoods. Ensuring the appropriate revenue stream to provide long term
maintenance.
3.13 Shaded sidewalks. Require shade over at least 30 percent of the length of sidewalks
on streets within a project. Trees must provide shade within 10 years of landscape
installation and should be as water efficient as possible.
3.14 Access to daily activities. Require development patterns such that the majority of
residents are within one-half mile walking distance to a variety of neighborhood goods
and services, such as supermarkets, restaurants, churches, cafes, dry cleaners,
laundromats, farmers markets, banks, hair care, pharmacies and similar uses.
3.15 Access to parks and open spaces. Require the design of new neighborhoods and,
where feasible, retrofit existing neighborhoods, so that 60 percent of dwelling units are
within a ¼ mile walking distance of a usable open space such as a tot-lot, neighborhood
park, community park or plaza/green.
3.16 Neighborhood transitions. Require that new neighborhoods provide appropriate
transitions in scale, building type and density between different General Plan designations.
3.17 Gated communities. Strongly discourage the construction of new gated communities
except in the Rural or Resort General Plan Designations.
3.18 Soundwalls. Allow the use of soundwalls to buffer new Neighborhoods from existing
sources of noise pollution such as railroads and limited access roadways. Prohibit the use
of soundwalls to buffer residential areas from arterial or collector streets. Instead design
approaches such as building setbacks, landscaping and other techniques shall be used.
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 66
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
54
In the case where soundwalls might be acceptable, require pedestrian access points to
improve access from the neighborhoods.
3.19 Subdivision gateways. Discourage the use of signs to distinguish one residential project
from another. Strive for neighborhoods to blend seamlessly into one another.
3.21 Infill neighborhoods. In existing developed areas of the city, encourage development
that repairs connectivity, adds destinations, and encourages complete neighborhoods.
This can be achieved by increasing intersection density, reducing block size, providing new
community amenities and destinations.
Policy Responses: It is the intent of the project to provide for a complete neighborhood as
defined by the general plan. As stated, all homes will be within a quarter mile of the central
recreational amenity and will incorporate design standards that avoid obstacles to
pedestrian activity. The neighborhood will be balanced with a range of densities and
housing types as well as varying levels of affordability. The affordable housing component
is weaved into the project as well as the surrounding community to avoid concentrations
of poverty in one particular area. We will work with city staff to refine conditions and
standards that meet the goals and objectives around neighborhood character, streets,
gates, soundwalls, signage, and neighborhood connections.
6.2 Applicable Mobility Policy Consistency
1.1 Complete Streets. Consider all modes of travel in planning, design, and construction of
all transportation projects to create safe, livable, and inviting environments for pedestrians,
bicyclists, motorists and public transit users of all ages and capabilities.
1.2 Transportation System Impacts. Evaluate transportation and development projects in a
manner that addresses the impacts of all travel modes on all other travel modes through
the best available practices.
1.3 Facility Service Levels. Determine appropriate service levels for all modes of
transportation and develop guidelines to evaluate impacts to these modes for all related
public and private projects.
1.6 Emergency Vehicle Access. Evaluate the impacts of transportation network changes
on emergency vehicle access and response times.
3.4 Access to Development. Require that all new development projects or redevelopment
projects provide connections from the site to the external pedestrian network.
6.1 Fair Share Costs. Require that new development pay for its fair share of construction
costs related to new and/or upgraded infrastructure needed to accommodate the
development.
Policy Responses: The proposed project recognizes the need for alternative methods of
travel which is why we have proposed an internal project street network and that allows
for the safe and efficient travel of nonmotorized traffic that feeds out to the existing
circulation system. Furthermore, we will work with city staff to ensure emergency vehicles
have access to the property by abiding by all applicable building codes and regulations
as well as providing for the projects’ needed infrastructure fair share costs.
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 67
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
55
6.3 Applicable Health and Wellness Policy Consistency
1.8 New development. Ensure that new residential developments provide adequate on-
site recreational and open space amenities consistent with the values and standards of
the community and the needs of new development.
Policy Response: As previously stated, the proposed project will provide adequate on site
recreational and open space for new Palm Desert residents.
6.4 Applicable Environmental Resources Policy Consistency
1.2 Landscape design. Encourage the reduction of landscaping water consumption
through plant selection and irrigation technology.
1.3 Conservation performance targeted to new construction. Incentivize new construction
to exceed the state’s Green Building Code for water conservation by an additional 10
percent.
2.1 View corridor preservation. Protect and preserve existing, signature views of the hills
and mountains from the city.
3.1 Open space network. Require new development to comply with requirements of the
CVMSHCP.
3.2 Grading and vegetation removal. Limit grading and vegetation removal of new
development activities to the minimum extent necessary to reduce erosion and
sedimentation.
4.3 Landscape design. Continue to encourage new developments to incorporate native
vegetation materials into landscape plans and prohibit the use of species known to be
invasive according to the California Invasive Plant Inventory
Policy Responses: The applicant intends to comply with all CVMSHCP and CALGREEN
requirements as well as be a proactive partner in finding solutions to ensure landscape
design is well thought out and water conscious as well as ensuring that scenic views are
taken into consideration during the planning process.
6.1 Passive solar design. Require new buildings to incorporate energy efficient building and
site design strategies for the desert environment that include appropriate solar orientation,
thermal mass, use of natural daylight and ventilation, and shading.
6.3 Energy Efficient Buildings. Encourage new buildings and buildings undergoing major
retrofits to exceed Title 24 energy efficiency standards.
6.4 Community development–subdivisions. When reviewing applications for new
subdivisions, require all residences be oriented along an east west access, minimizing
western sun exposure, to maximize energy efficiency.
7.3 Reducing GHG emissions. In consulting with applicants and designing new facilities,
prioritize the selection of green building design features that enhance the reduction of
greenhouse gas emissions.
7.4 Heat Island reductions. Require heat island reduction strategies in new developments
such as light-colored cool roofs, light-colored paving, permeable paving, right-sized
parking requirements, water efficient vegetative cover and planting, substantial tree
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 68
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
56
canopy coverage, south and west side water-efficient tree planting, and shaded asphalt
paving.
8.5 Construction-related emissions. Require construction activities, including on-site
building and the transport of materials, to limit emissions and dust
9.1 Disturbance of human remains. In areas where there is a high chance that human
remains may be present, the City will require proposed projects to conduct a survey to
establish occurrence of human remains, if any. If human remains are discovered on
proposed project sites, the project must implement mitigation measures to prevent
impacts to human remains in order to receive permit approval.
9.2 Discovery of human remains. Require that any human remains discovered during
implementation of public and private projects within the City be treated with respect and
dignity and fully comply with the California Native American Graves Protection and
Repatriation Act and other appropriate laws.
9.3 Tribal coordination. Require notification of California Native American tribes and
organizations of proposed projects that have the potential to adversely impact cultural
resources.
9.4 Protected sites. Require sites with significant cultural resources to be protected.
10 Mitigation and preservation of cultural resources. Require development to avoid
archaeological and paleontological resources, whenever possible. If complete
avoidance is not possible, require development to minimize and fully mitigate the impacts
to the resource
Policy Responses: The applicant will work with city staff to make strides towards ecological
responsibility with respect to reductions in GHG emissions, solar design, energy efficiency
and heat island mitigation. Furthermore, we remain committed to respecting sensitive
resources including tribal resources by diligently following CEQA related requirements,
mitigation, and monitoring.
6.5 Applicable Noise Policy Consistency
1.1 Noise Compatibility. Apply the City of Palm Desert’s Noise Compatibility Matrix, as a
guide for planning and development decisions. The City will require projects involving new
development or modifications to existing development to implement mitigation measures,
where necessary, to reduce noise levels to at least the normally compatible range in the
City’s Noise Compatibility Matrix. Mitigation measures should focus on architectural
features and building design and construction, rather than site design features such as
excessive setbacks, berms and sound walls, to maintain compatibility with adjacent and
surrounding uses
1.3 Mixed Use. Require that mixed-use structures and areas be designed to prevent transfer
of noise from commercial uses to residential uses, and ensure a 45 dBA CNEL level or lower
for all interior living spaces.
Policy Responses: The applicant will work to ensure the recreational amenity as a central
portion of the project does not create adverse noise impacts for new residents and that
construction noise is controlled to the greatest extent possible.
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 69
REFUGE: SPECIFIC PLAN
57
6.6 Applicable Safety Policy Consistency
3.1 Flood Risk in New Development. Require all new development to minimize flood risk
with siting and design measures, such as grading that prevents adverse drainage impacts
to adjacent properties, on-site retention of runoff, and minimization of structures located
in floodplains.
Policy Response: As part of the entitlement process the applicant shall submit preliminary
and precise grading plans that takes into account adverse drainage impacts, retention,
runoff, and floodplains. The applicant shall cooperate with the city to ensure satisfactory
standards are met.
6.7 Applicable Public Utilities and Services Policy Consistency
1.1 Stormwater infrastructure for new development. Require development projects pay for
their share of new stormwater infrastructure or improvements necessitated by that
development (regional shallow groundwater).
1.2 On-site stormwater retention and infiltration. Whenever possible, stormwater shall be
infiltrated, evapotranspirated, reused or treated onsite in other ways that improve
stormwater quality and reduce flows into the storm drain system.
1.3 Groundwater infiltration. Encourage the use of above-ground and natural stormwater
facilities in new development and redevelopment, such as vegetated swales and
permeable paving.
2.2 Sewer infrastructure for new development. Require development projects to pay for
their share of new sewer infrastructure or improvements necessitated by that
development.
3.4 Water infrastructure for new development. Require development projects to pay for
their share of new water infrastructure or improvements necessitated by that project.
7.2 Review of new development. Work with the Riverside County Sherriff’s Department and
the Riverside County Fire Department to review and modify development proposals to
incorporate defensible space, Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design (CPTED),
and other public safety design concepts into new development.
Policy Responses: The applicant will comply with any needed associated fees as it pertains
to stormwater infrastructure, retention, as well as sewer and water infrastructure.
Furthermore, given the proximity of the project to the Riverside County Sheriff’s station
along Gerald Ford we anticipate working closely with them to review all proposals for
public safety best practices and compliance.
Resolution No. 2022-93 Page 70