HomeMy WebLinkAbout258C FRANK GOODMANMEMBER - CMA OF CALIF. & NEV. • CALIF. "0" BLOCK • NCMA
PRECISION BLOCK: CONCRETE - LIGHT WEIGHT - VENEER: ALSO
STRUCTURAL SLUMPED & SPLIT FACE BLOCK
OTHER OFF ICES & MFG. LOCATIONS
2320 SO. MAIN STREET
BLOCK CO. Jf4Q SANTA ANA, CALIFORNIA
(714)527.2239
MAIN OFFICE
8042 KATELLA AVENUE
STANTON, CALIF.90680
(714) 527-2239
e-v.s ru (. I
Ci'y^a�.Js ooze _ So
as&'
4510 RUTILE STREET
RIVERSIDE, CALIF.92509
(714) 685-1521
R.. )' 1A1>104 f�
3+s-aase
..�th�.-
t ��'
:Y:. .a��.,a�
$ +� ��
~'al �
4
l
73-510 FRED WARING DRIVE, PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA 92260
TELEPHONE (619) 346-0611
June 17, 1985
ARCHITECTURAL COMMISSION ACTION
CASE NO: 258 C
APPLICANT (AND ADDRESS): FRANK GOODMAN, 77-900 Avenue of States,
Palm Desert, CA 92260.
NATURE OF PROJECT/APPROVAL SOUGHT: Exterior remodel and sign program.
LOCATION: 44-850 San Pablo
ZONE: Commercial
Upon reviewing the submitted plans and the presentations by staff and by the
applicant, the architectural commission granted preliminary approval to this case.
Date of Action: June 11, 1985
Vote: Carried 3-0
(An appeal of the above action may be made in writing to the City Clerk of the City
of Palm Desert within fifteen (15) days of the date of the decision.)
STAFF COMMENTS: Please read the attached minutes.
MINUTES
ARCHITECTURAL COMMISSION
JUNE 11, 1985
LOCATION: 73-820 El Paseo
ZONE: C-1 S.P.
Bank of America is proposing to change their existing sign program to match
the new corporate colors.
Commissioner Cook indicated that he would prefer the existing sign program
remain as is. He noted that the proposed colors look flashy and do not match
the colors and design of the building.
Commissioner Gregory suggested changing the red to rust . He explained that
the commission should try to remain consistent with their decisions regarding
signs. Commissioner Martin advised that he would approve the signs as
proposed.
It was moved by Commissioner Cook, seconded by Commissioner Martin to
continue this case until a more persuasive proposal is submitted or more
commissioners are present to make a motion. Carried 3-0
B. Preliminary Plans:
1. CASE NO: 259 C
APPLICANT (AND ADDRESS): J.W. ROBINSONS CO., 600 W. 7th Street, Los
Angeles, CA 90017, Attn: Fred Lo Nigro; LEO A. DALY, 3333 Wilshire Blvd.
#200, Los Angeles, CA 90010.
NATURE OF PROJECT/APPROVAL SOUGHT: Preliminary architectural plan
approval of plans for a department store.
LOCATION: South side Palm Desert Town Center.
ZONE: P.C. (3) S.P.
Mr. Robert Smith of Leo A. Daly, architects, discussed the salient points of
the building indicating the building and landscaping materials to be used.
Commissioner Gregory indicated that the Washingtonia Palms would be
adequate but he would like to research the Red Hot Poker and the Statis. He
also indicated that he would like to see a more detailed landscape plan. Upon
further study Commissioner Gregory suggested replacing the Statis with the
Green -leaved Gazania - Mitsuwa or Sunrise Yellow. Replace the Red Hot
Poker with Day Lily.
Commissioner Cook questioned the projection of the west entrance of the
building. Mr. Robert Smith indicated that they had been discussing it
being flat with no projections. Commissioner Cook suggested that the west
entrance be restudied.
Moved by Commissioner Martin, seconded by Commissioner Cook to grant
preliminary approval subject to the west entrance being restudied. Carried 3-0
2. CASE NO: 258 C
APPLICANT (AND ADDRESS): FRANK GOODMAN, 77-900 Avenue of States,
Palm Desert, CA 922 00.
NATURE OF PROJECT/APPROVAL SOUGHT: Exterior remodel and sign
program.
LOCATION: 44-850 San Pablo
ZONE: Commercial
Commissioner Gregory indicated that he would prefer to see something
besides stucco on the fascia. Commissioner Martin suggested that the
building be completely stucco with the inserts painted a different color.
MINUTES
ARCHITECTURAL COMMISSION
JUNE 11, 1985
The applicant was proposing a bright red glossy tile. Commissioner Martin
indicated that a tile with a flat finish would be more preferable.
Commissioner Cook's only objection was with the tile appearing bright and
flashy.
Commissioner Gregory noted that he would like to see the landscape redone.
The street trees are small and do not enhance the appearance of the building.
He suggested replacing the existing trees with high crown 15 gallon Ficus
trees or palms.
It was moved by Commissioner Cook, seconded by Commissioner Martin to
grant conceptual preliminary approval subject to the following conditions:
1. That the tile be a subdued color with a dull matte finish.
2. That a landscape plan be submitted increasing the size of the street trees.
IV. DISCUSSION ITEMS:
j.. PIETRO'S
Mr. Diaz presented a colored drawing for the rear of the restaurant. He
informed the commission that the applicant is proposing to enclose the rear
of the restaurant in order to conceal the supplies stored there. The
applicant is proposing to remove the existing landscaping and replace it with
13 Italian Cypress trees.
Commissioner Martin indicated that the arches do not match the design of
the building. He suggested that the applicant raise the height of the walls to
conceal the supplies.
Commissioner Cook thought the arches and the pillars were not needed.
2. ARTHUR MOSS - Southwest corner Monterey do Fred Waring - Professional
Office Building.
Commissioner Martin, asking for comments and suggestions, presented the
plans and indicated the salient points of the building.
Commissioner Cook stated that he would like to see the front elevation.
Commissioner Gregory questioned if there would be berming like the building
across the street. Commissioner Martin indicated that there would not be.
Commissioners' Cook and Gregory noted that they liked the plans as far as
they went.
V. ADJOURNMENT:
The meeting was adjourned at 3:30 p.m.
4
STEVE,SMITH, Assbdale Planner
/dig
CITY OF PALM DESERT INTEROFFICE MEMORANDUM
TO: ARCHITECTURAL COMMISSION
FROM: DIRECTOR OF ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES
DATE: JUNE 5, 1985
SUBJECT: REMODEL 44-850 SAN PABLO AVENUE
The applicant has resubmitted plans for the remodeling of an existing office building at
44-850 San Pablo Avenue. The applicant at this time proposes to restucco the exterior of
the building with a sandstone color, as well as place a reddish glazed tile on the fascia of
the existing overhang. The applicant will also screen the existing roof -mounted air
conditioning units with a stucco screen the same color as proposed for the walls of the
building.
A sign plan has been provided and if approval should, should be required to meet code.
RAMON A. DIAZ
DIRECTOR OF ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES
Am
June 4, 1985
73-510 FRED WARING DRIVE, PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA 92260
TELEPHONE (619) 346-0611
ARCHITECTURAL COMMISSION ACTION
CASE NO: 258 C
APPLICANT (AND ADDRESS): FRANK GOODMAN, 77-900 Avenue of States,
Palm Desert, CA 92260.
NATURE OF PROJECT/APPROVAL SOUGHT- Request for exteriorrme
LOCATION: 44-850 San Pablo
ZONE: Commercial
Upon reviewing the submitted plans and the presentations by the staff and by the
applicant, the architectural commission continued this case.
Date of Action: May 28, 1985
Vote: Carried 4-0
(An appeal of the above action may be made in writing to the City Clerk of the City
of Palm Desert within fifteen ( 15) days of the date of the decision.)
STAFF COMMENTS: Please read the attached minutes.
MINUTES
ARCHITECTURAL COMMISSION
MAY 28, 1985
8. CASE NO: 219 C
APPLICANT (AND ADDRESS): R.J. CHRISTOFF do ASSOC., 174 S. Orange
Street, Suite B, Orange, CA 92666.
NATURE OF PROJECT/APPROVAL SOUGHT: Approval of a trash
compactor.
LOCATION: Palm Desert Town Center Sizzler
ZONE: PC (3) S.P.
Subject to landscape plan being approved by staff prior to building permit
issuance.
9. CASE NO: 253 C
APPLICANT (AND ADDRESS): BERNIE SOLOMON, 74-700 Highway 111,
Palm Desert, CA 92260.
NATURE OF PROJECT/APPROVAL SOUGHT: Preliminary plan approval of
2 industrial buildings.
LOCATION: West side Corporate Way, south of Hovley Lane
ZONE: S.I. S.P.
Subject to the following:
1. That the trees be upsized and additional landscaping materials be
provided.
III. CASES:
A. Final Drawings: None
B. Preliminary Plans:
1. CASE NO: 258 C
APPLICANT (AND ADDRESS): FRANK GOODMAN, 77-900 Avenue of
States, Palm Desert, CA 92260.
NATURE OF PROJECT/APPROVAL SOUGHT: Request for exterior remodel.
LOCATION: 44-850 San Pablo
ZONE: Commercial
Mr. Diaz pointed out the concerns of staff.
The commission was concerned with the roof mounted equipment not being
adequately screened and the building appearing choppy.
Commissioner Leung felt the overall building needed to be restudied and
made into a full mass. Commissioner Cook indicated that the proposed
materials do not improve the appearance of the building as they should.
It was moved by Commissioner Holden, seconded by Commissioner Cook to
return this case to the applicant for restudy of mass forms and material
selection. Carried 4-0
2• CASE NO: 257 C
APPLICANT (AND ADDRESS): VALLEY CHRISTIAN ASSEMBLY, P.O. Box
3074, Palm Desert, CA 92260.
NATURE OF PROJECT/APPROVAL SOUGHT: Preliminary approval for
remodel addition and parking lot for church.
DATE: May 28, 1985
ARCHITECTURAL COMMISSION
CASE NO: 258 C
APPLICANT (AND ADDRESS): FRANK GOODMAN, 77-900 Avenue of States, Palm
Desert, CA 92260.
NATURE OF PROJECT/APPROVAL SOUGHT: Request for exterior remodel.
LOCATION: 44-850 San Pablo
ZONE: Commercial
DISCUSSION:
The applicant is proposing a change of facade for an existing commercial structure at
44-850 San Pablo Avenue. The applicant proposes to modify the existing front and
sides by adding a red metal facia and glass windows.
Staff's concern is that the plans do not provide for the screening of the existing roof
mounted equipment, and because of the facia design a sign program should be part of
this submittal.
Staff is also concerned that the proposed modification does not really create the
type of feeling or statement that San Pablo Avenue should have in the future. The
roof line, materials, and colors are of concern.
RECOMMENDATION:
The plans be returned to the applicant for restudy to incorporate the concerns raised.
r.
/ P4
DEPfi1Gy REVIEW/ -OARD
APPo.aCAMCH F-CRm: *W6rznnM3 n4!Aj 34mmas a poe nnIng dMem a
77
IM
REQUEST! (Desvfbe spectffc nature of approval nspusew ).
PROPERTY DESCRIPTION:
ASSESSORS PARCEL NO.
Nephone
EXISTING ZONING ����%1P✓��/
Property Owner Authonzation The unaenignea states Mat they on the amp (sl of the property described herein and hereby give author,
IzWlon for the filing at this oppiiadtlon.
01
i 00 BY MY SIGNA%RE�"IS AGREEMENT, Abealve the City of Palm Dome" at all liabilities regarding any deed restrictions
/) /) Mgt may be awholible to the property described herein.
Applicants Signature
( FOR STAFF USE ONLY) Etm
❑ Ministerial Act
❑ Categorical Esempnon
❑ Negative Declaration
❑ Other
$►atue
E.A. No.
Date
Accepted by:
CLUE Ho. o-s(i G
Reference Case No.
NEW MET
FASGIA 6-- --)
4
BP,YoNo CPaFNTjA it
G.L GAP
I j' B6YONv'CPAINT;
---NEW MET: FASCIA— ---�-- - -- --I
NGW
stucco — 7 1
PARAPET L � r' I
----- -- - --- -----!l_II--- -----_ r. 11-----------�--W--.---
I I
i I!
% NEW 5T UCcc
O E
&P. 5P'NGG I j �. '- - i 1ST' T K_
k — Srucaa
�G,LCap
J.
y
/ FIX' Panit=L
- STUCCO
6,I-CAP
IV
T0170FExIST'G PARapET' H1CT.
NEW 5rucco "
PARapET � ', p'
PiEjtlNP(FAINT,
�,- NEW 57UCCo
�/ OYEZ P-XIGT'&
gP. 51 DI NG
WEST
G, I. CA P
- - - -
ToPoF Ex15T'G
PA,APET�
I
i
T
�1►1
- -- -I_;
I
,�
��
-
II
II
- -
----- -- - -
NEw stucco — ---
PARAPET
.I
I I,,
I
I I
1'
! II
III
I
j
I
i
;�
I N'
I
1
I
%
EX15T'G WP, PASGIA II
6EyoND (paINT)
I
I
I I
I
I
I �
�
I
I
'�
--NEw--Uc'o- � - --
PARaf'�T� o
I
I;
NEw 5Tucco
ovEP, EKI4,T'G
I,P. 51PINC,
e - 5rucco
�,Tucco
-I IF 1,
-�
NEw'sTucco III � i I NEW STLIC'.a
i !� �ovEExl-r'G ' I �aVEff Exlsj'G
�D iIDIwa F I! BD IDING `
I� I;
� 6L.. � I / GL, � i �+-�� 6L..
I
I 5Tucco �a _ - -
( , 5Tucco `a STUCCO STUCCO `�
APJACENT PLDG
`NEW 5-rUCCO OVER AI t�fj �x15'r'G DRS.
UISTro 5Tucco F1X'0 FANEL5 ABOVE
(sAhtC PLANE AS AF-OV9) - (NEW poor, PULLS)
I
�i F VA&Teg dFLow
----
PASCIA T
r I�
NORTH
NEW MET
FASG IA.
NEw STUCCO OVE9
EXIT>T ra 5TUCCO
(SAME PLANE ps ABOVE)
6.1, GAP
— ---EXIST'G Roof LINE — —
1 oP oP ExISTIG
�AP.APET
l�
I it N I=EK 5TX I 7 G
/ I 6L. i 7 PrD. `+1 Lit IJr
NEw 5Tucco
PaFzaPET
LIrE FIXTs
EL5 V• ��
M _PANELS
E
- SOLI cogr i-
� � wD.IvRs,
SOUTH
EAST
n'tMe MID
,v 2 3 1985
Efl,'1,joNMENTAL SERVICES
CI-fY OF PALM DES 'IT
NEW EXTERIOR ELEVATIONS
s
z�
O
v
i
W
! W
U)
f
[
FV S
W
_
t
V
z
�y�M LL
I W J
a
i L1J i= LLi
Lu Z
W
_ N
LL aAL 2 O
iO a
` Q
Z
' o
I—
~ > O
i a C'3
i O
J
IW a Y
a Z
i Z Q
N cc
V.
W
L
I
io
W
i
DATE
5/ I rol85
SHEET
4
999Z-9hE (6L9)
1 0 3 1 1 H O d V
NO1X3S '3 WVIIIIM
a3NMO - NvvyaooJ NNVH=l
'AI-IVO `1»3S30 WlVd '3AV 018Vd NVS 058titi
JNlaiing 301330 JNIISIX3 13CIOW3d
s
W�
F-
H
Q
M
W
I
rN</H�J3/\o 9,151X�
V ).
m
W N
Z
O W
O m
N \
V N+IH2i3na O,I50x�3 -
— - --.. --......
----
24
i
W
� J
LU
_ ! cn
W
- J
W
W
o
Y v
m
m
TILT A'FASCIA
PA, 9K BROWN -rCNEr,
M4,TTE r-INtSH.
SANDSTONE w-u6
(BASE 200)
Sul -
I
coff
i � j
GLAZED TILE FASCIA
�
JIII �
hj
II
1
I
{ , ..I� _. -. I1I �. LI
.- � - _.---- . .. .._:- _. .....A..... - _.- _.
11.
iJyt fit ilt(�1 I
G, r
Z
O
U
x
w
uj
m
N
W
�
S
Q
U
J
J
S
3
a
la
Z
0
J
W J
Q
Ci
W F cc(a)W Z
— W
L O
Oa
r� Z
V C
Z o
~ > O
W o a
J
W .a Z
Z Q
J N CC
W 0 V"
Lo
co
et
O�
f W
DATE
5�30�85
SHEET
SOUTH ELEV.
is
FIGU5 TREES
IZEMAIN i\ \
)4 wu
zess
JCs)
rAizKIWCv I-O-r
ALESSANDRO DR.
LANDSCAPE PLAN
w
r t-M TlMaS `-12 H1 >
` W
\�Ma�N J
\ a
Z
F-
O
v
w
"'
m
•
N
W
�
c
a�
J
J
tY
3
a
0
Z
J
m
LL
a
v
cr.
w
C)
cc
W
Z
EL
L
w
a
JUL
O
0
a
-�
Z
Z
p
♦^�
>
0
a
XJ
O
w
.a
Z
J
z
y
Q
LU
0
U.
v
oV
2
w
cc
DATE
to / 13/85
SHEET
L-1