The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About288C STANLEY BS IMPERIAL SIGN COMPANY1 i \ •. �- �. VU IAGE f' E AGENDA ITEM NO: III-A-9 CASE NO: 288 C APPLICANT (AND ADDRESS): STANLEY B'S, c/o IMPERIAL SIGN OOMPANY, 46-120 Calhoun Street, Indio, CA 92201. NATURE OF PROJECT/APPROVAL SOUGHT: Approval of monument sign. LOCATION: 73-101 Highway 111 ZONE: C-1 DIS(11.S9I(N_ When the commission approved amendments for the restaurant in November signage fronting on Highway 111 was deferred pending completion of landscaping and the gazebos which appeared to block the proposed signs. Reality has confirmed the commissions suspicions and the applicant has returned with a monument signs placed out at the northern tip of the triangular property. The sign will consist of two faces set in a V-shape oriented to the northeast and northwest. Each face will be 38 square feet. The copy design will be similar to the Highway 74 facing wall signs and will be illuminate ivory letters on a dark brown stucco will be illuminated ivory letters on a dark brown stucco cabinets. The monument base will be 2' S" tall and similar to the trim detail on the building. 0 0 MET oq PO M o o 0 m 73-510 FRED WARING DRIVE, PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA 92260 TELEPHONE (619) 346.0611 February 16, 1988 CASE NO: 288 C APPLICANT (AND ADDRESS): STANLEY B'S c/o IMPERIAL SIGNS COMPANY, 46-120 Calhoun Street, Indio, CA 92201. NATURE OF PROJECT/APPROVAL SOUGHT: Approval of monument sign. LOCATION: 73-101 Highway ZONE: C-1 Upon reviewing the submitted plans and presentations by staff and by the applicant, the architectural commission authorized staff to approve the proposed sign if applicant provides a double-faced single plane sign scaled down in size. Date of Action: February 9, 1988 Vote: Carried 5-0 (An appeal of the above action may be made in writing to the City Clerk of the City of Palm Desert within fifteen (15) days of the date of the decision.) STAFF COMMENTS: Please read the attached minutes. Upon receiving final approval it is your responsibility to submit the plans approved by the architectural commission to the department of building and safety. CONTINUED CASES: In order to be placed on the next meetings agenda, revised plans must be submitted no later than noon the Wednesday prior to the next meeting. Iloilo . 1 Dkvit N 1 • �.. „. ... LOCATION: 73-160 El Paseo. ZONE: C-1 CommissiOner Day noted that the commission, at the previous review of this case, had only asked that the awning be broken up. The applicant felt the awning looked smother as one piece. He noted that they are two separate businesses owned by the same person. Commissioner Holden indicated the cccmussicn likes to review the exact graphics to be placed on the awning and suggested that drawings detailing the graphics to scale be provided. Commissioner McCrea suggested that "Palm Springs Reservations" add Inc. after their name to clarify that they are a business. It was moved by Cam issioner Drury, seconded by Commissioner issioner Sullivan to return this case to the applicant for restudy. Carried 5-0 5. CASE NO: PP 87-29 APPLICANT (AND ADDFIESS): DOVECAND DEVELOPNENP, 135 Columbia Drive, Rancho Mirage, CA 92270. NATURE OF PRDJBCP/APPRMM SOUGHT: Approval of change to approved plans. LOCATION: South side E1 Paseo, approx. 180' east of San Luis Rey. ZONE: C-1 Commission reviewed the proposed deletion of the planters and some members felt that replacing them with potted plants would be acceptable. It was moved by Commissioner McCrea, seconded by Camdssioner Cook to grant approval. Carried 3-1-1 (Commissioner Drury opposed, Commissioner Sullivan abstaining). 6. CASE ND: 288 C APPLICANT (AND ADDRESS): STANLEY B' S c/o IMPMIAL SIGNS CTMPANY, 46-120 Calhoun Street, Indio, CA 92201. 11 r. •• a •• r o: r •.. NATURE OF PROJECT/APPROVAL SOUGHT: Approval of monument sign. LOCATION: 73-101 Highway ZONE: C-1 The applicant explained the proposal and presented pictures showing a model of how the proposed sign would sit on the site. He indicated it was rather high and said he could delete the pedestal which is 2-1/2 feet in height. Commissioner McCrea suggested that a single sign be used and felt that the sign would be too tall even without the pedestal. Commissioner Sullivan liked the pedestal and suggested that the sign be parallel with Highway 111 which would make it visible. Commissioner Cook noted that it would be visible from both sides of the building if it were one sign placed parallel to Highway 111. He felt the "V" concept was unnecessary. It was moved by Commissioner Holden, seconded by Commissioner Cook to give staff authorization to approve the proposed sign if the applicant provides a double-faced, single plane sign scaled down. Carried 5-0 7. CASE NO: PP/CUP 86-50 APPLICANT (AND ADDRESS): R.C. ROBERTS, NATURE OF PRO,JBCr/APPROVAL SOLUM Final landscape plans for 426 unit mobil home/RV park. LOCATION: North side Frank Sinatra Drive at end of Del Safari Dr. ZONE: R-1-M It was moved by Commissioner Holden, seconded by Commissioner Sullivan to continue this case. Carried 5-0 B. Preliminary Plans: 1. CASE NO: 306 C APPLICANT (AND ADDRESS): ONE ELEVEN TOWN CENTER/JOHN ASH ASSOCIATES, Jonathan Ochshorn, 3600 Wilshire Blvd. Suite 420, Los Angeles, CA 90010. 7 Palm Desert Disposal, Inc. 41-575 Eclectic Street P.O. Box 3876 Palm Desert, California 92261-3876 619/324-1741 December 18, 1987 Stanley B's Restraunt 73-101 Hwy. 111 Palm Desert, CA 92260 To Whom It May Concern: fA Waste Management Company CI N Effective December 21, 1987, Palm Desert Disposal will increase service to Stanley B's four -yard container to six times per week. If you should have any further questions, please call us. Sincere ly,// C�a1,Q 7 i G64ty� Greg Martin Operations Manager 4 December 1, 1987 i,Av Oq rm�u M D n 73-510 FRED WARING DRIVE, PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA 92260 TELEPHONE (619) 346-0611 ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW COMMISSION ACTION CASE NO: 288 C AMENDMENT APPLICANT (AND ADDRESS): DOMINICK MANCUSO, 305 Tolosa Circle, Palm Desert, CA 92260. NATURE OF PROJECT/APPROVAL SOUGHT: Amendments to working drawings for restaurant/office building under construction. LOCATION: Palms to Pines Village (Carl's Jr. Center). ZONE: C-I Upon reviewing the submitted plans and presentations by staff and by the applicant, the architectural commission approved the plans as amended. Date of Action: November 24, 1987 Vote: Carried 3-2 (Chairman Gregory and Commissioner Drury opposed) (An appeal of the above action may be made )n writing to the City Clerk of the City of Palm Desert within fifteen (15) days of the.date of the decision.) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ STAFF COMMENDS: Please read the attached minutes. Upon receiving final approval it is your responsibility to submit the plans approved by the architectural commission to the department of building and safety. r, MINUTES ARCHITECTURAL COMMISSION NOVEMBER 24. 1987 ZONE: PC (2) This item was continued on a minute motion basis. Ill. CASES: A. Final Drawings: 1. CASE NO: 288 C AMENDMENT APPLICANT (AND ADDRESS): DOMINICK MANCUSO, 305 Tolosa Circle. Palm Desert, CA 92260. NATURE OF PROJECT/APPROVAL SOUGHT: Amendments to working drawings for restaurant/office building under construction. LOCATION: Palms to Pines Village (Carl's Jr. Center). ZONE: C-1 Mr. Drell reviewed the changes that were made to the plans that had been approved originally. He explained that the commission could approve the changes, require modifications or reject the amendments completely. He indicated that commission should review whether the building is acceptable as built rather than what it could have been. Chairman Gregory asked what the applicant was willing to do. Mr. Orel indicated that commission could require that wooden elements be added to the windows to provide the french look that had been deleted. Chairman Gregory explained that the problem the commission faces is not having the chance to review the changes prior to construction of the changes. He felt the original building was far superior and hoped that something could be done to make this building worth approving. Commissioner Drury was obiected to the changes of the second story which completely altered the appearance of the buiidinq. She noted that the deletion of the french appearance was not as much a concern as the deletion of the grid work which provided character to the second storv. 3 MINUTES ARCHITECTURAL COMMISSION NOVEMBER 24. 1987 Commissioner Hoiden felt the building should be judged on its own merits rather than on how it should have been built. He indicated that he would vote for approval if he judged it on its own merits. Commissioner McCrea aareed with Commissioner Holden. Mr. Mancuso questioned why he was not informed at the time of inspection that the building did not comply with the plans and would have to be reviewed by the architectural commission again. Chairman Gregory felt that a building should not be allowed to be changed in the middle of construction if It is still "acceptable". He wanted something better than "acceptable" and advised that the applicant appeal to city council if they receive a negative vote. He noted that the information he pointed out could be brought before the city council. Commissioner Sullivan indicated it would be economically unfeasible to ask the applicant to do the building over. He felt the applicant would take the easy way out if the commission asked for additional chances. Mr. Diaz explained that the applicant is responsible for submitting_ any chances to previously approved plans. it was moved by Chairman Gregory. seconded by Commissioner Drury to deny the amendments to the approved plan. Motion died with a 2-3 vote. A new motion was made by Commissioner Holden, seconded by Commissioner McCrea to approve the building as amended. Motion carried 3-2 (Chairman Gregory and Commissioner Drury opposed). - Commissioner Holden indicated that the building was reviewed on its own merits and no decision was made based on financial hardship. He felt that if this buildina had come in like this oriainally he would have approved it. He noted that this was not setting a precedent. 2. CASE NO: 1397 SA APPLICANT (AND ADDRESS): TEMPLE CONSTRUCTION. 747 Eugene Road, Palm Springs. CA 92264. NATURE OF PROJECT/APPROVAL SOUGHT: Approval of identification signs. landscape plan. Cook Street and Country Club landscaping. 4 November 16, 1987 0 a COMT CV PMUM o 0 o m 73.510 FRED WARING DRIVE, PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA 92260 TELEPHONE (619) 346-0611 ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW COMMISSION ACTION CASE NO: 288 C AMENDMENT APPLICANT (AND ADDRESS): DOMINICK MANCUSO, 305 Tolosa Circle, Palm Desert, CA 92260. NATURE OF PROJECT/APPROVAL SOUGHT: Amendments to working drawings for restaurant/office building under construction. LOCATION: Palms to Pines Village (Carl's Jr. Center). ZONE: C-I Upon reviewing the submitted plans and presentations by staff and by the applicant, the architectural commission: 1. Denied requested landscape substitution for trellis structure. Applicant may modify trellis so not to interfere with CVWD easement. Carried 4-1 2. Main sign located on elevator tower approved. Two signs on ends denied pending review of impact of trellis structures on visibility. Carried 4-1 3. No action taken on window treatment changes. Date of Action: November 10, 1967 (An appeal of the above action may be made in writing to the City Clerk of the City of Palm Desert within fifteen (15) days of the date of the decision.) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ STAFF COMMENTS: Please read the attached minutes. Upon receiving final approval it is your responsibility to submit the plans approved by the architectural commission to the department of building and safety. to 40 MINUTES ARCHITECTURAL COMMISSION NOVEMBER 10, 1987 felt the aluminum fascia would be susceptible to dents and bangs from objects. The applicant's architect should provide an acceptable solution. It was moved by Commissioner Holden, seconded by Commissioner Sullivan to continue this matter to allow the applicant's architect time to provide details showing how the carport fits in with the building. Carried 5-0 9. CASE NO: 288 C AMENDMENT APPLICANT (AND ADDRESS): DOMINICK MANCUSO, 305 Tolosa Circle, Palm Desert, CA 92260. NATURE OF PROJECT/APPROVAL SOUGHT: Amendments to working drawings for restaurant/office building under construction. LOCATION: Palms to Pines Village (Carl's Jr. Center). ZONE: C-1 Commission reviewed the proposed amendments to the building. It was moved by Commissioner Holden, seconded by Commissioner McCrea to: I. Deny requested landscape substitution for trellis structure. Applicant may modify trellis so not to interfere with CVWD easement. Carried 4-1 2. Main sign located on elevator tower approved. Two signs on ends denied pending review of impact of trellis structures on visibility. Carried 4-1 3. No action taken on window treatment changes. 10. CASE NO: 1359 SA APPLICANT (AND ADDRESS): D & A SHADE COMPANY for SPECTACULAR SHADES, P.O. Box 417, Palm Springs, CA 92263. NATURE OF PROJECT/APPROVAL SOUGHT: Approval of an awning with signage for new business. 2 r 0 1_ J ARCHITECTURAL COMMISSION CASE NO: 288 C AMENDMENT AGENDA ITEM NO: 111-A-10 DATE: NOVEMBER 10, 1967 APPLICANT (AND ADDRESS): DOMINICK MANCUSO, 305 Tolosa Circle, Palm Desert, CA 92260. NATURE OF PROJECT/APPROVAL SOUGHT: Amendments to working drawings for restaurant/office building under construction. LOCATION: Palms to Pines Village (Carl's Jr. Center). ZONE: C-I DISCUSSION: The restaurant originally named Aggie's has been changed to "Stanley B's" and is in the final stages of construction. The original plans called for gazebos located at each end to soften the two story elevations. The applicant is proposing to eliminate those gazebos and replace them with landscaping (large trees) of similar scale to accomplish the same purpose. Also, a portion of the covered entrance walkway has been enclosed with glass creating a foyer reception area for the restaurant. Some architectural details have been simplified and french individual lite doors have been replaced with double pane glass. PD/dlg (�Uf:a�Wr ®:ff :Y)E 73-510 FRED WARING DRIVE, PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA 92260 TELEPHONE (619) 346-0611 July 15. 1986 ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW COMMISSION ACTION CASE NO: 288 C APPLICANT (AND ADDRESS): FRANK 8 AGNES MANCUSO, 72-281 Highway Ill, Palm Desert, CA 92260. NATURE OF PROJECT/ APPROVAL SOUGHT: Approval of working drawing and landscape plan. LOCATION: Palms to Pines Village (Carl's Jr. Center). 20NE: C-I Upon reviewing the submitted plans and presentations by staff and by the applicant, the architectural commission approved this case by minute motion. Date of Action: July 8, 1986 Vote: Carried 4-0 (An appeal of the above action may be made in writing to the City Clerk of the City of Palm Desert within fifteen (15) days of the date of the decision.) STAFF COMMENTS: Please read the attached minutes. 14ESTFIELD MT- T 7 DIF December 16, 1985 PlanningCommission ENITy OF PALM SERVICES CITY OF PALM DESERT c/o Mr. Phil Drell City of Palm Desert 73510 Fred Waring Palm Desert CA. 92260 Re: New Restaurant & Office Space in Palms to Pines Village Gentlemen: We are in agreement with the request made by Mr. Domanic Mancuso in case number CUP 09-78 and the amendments to the CUP granted originally to Palms to Pines Village, and specifically parcel 6. We ask that you grant his request. However, since I cannot be in attendance at the Planning Commission meeting to voice our support for this project, I've asked Mr. Sandy Baum of SunCastle Realty to represent us in this matter. Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely, El Paseo Commerical Center By: Westfield Capital Corporation Ronald Executi RFH:jt cc: Sandy Baum THE WESTFIELD COMPANIES. 4750 Von Karman SUIte 101, Newport Beaeh. California 92oo0 „713-955-0800 jo S4- CSTY OF PAt.jA DESERT ERS'i E . i 1, ;tOM FORT O.tIE Y:.'•� 0�• i"r:13' 1`.f; pT �_ . 1 V �.-- �-- AD U lA 1 510 • ' (�E��a P hT ■ �� v In COMP1 Distinctive Signage since 1961 INDIO, 46-120 CALIFORNIACALHO ST. (619) 347-3566 CONTRACTORS LIC. NO. 2�% IJ� ,t t� lJ rALM Dr"SF �-T JOB LOCATION I — DRAWN BY -. MAF DESCRIPTION � ! ` �/�1 ILL -AM• I�[Iv1 (UM��T I� N ` This is an original unpublished drawing, created by IMPERIAL SIGN. It is submitted for your ion with a project being planned for you bysonal use in tIMPERIAL SIGN. If is not to be shown to anyone out - side your organization, nor is it to be repro - duced, copied or exhibited in any fashion. — MEMBER — _ CITY LIC. NO. I,� 1.6 I (�,�, N I - - CUSTOMERIFIRM ADDRESS �3-IDI I t ' III DRAWING NO. � WORKMANS COMP. NO. 42�719 STA �� 1 -s CUSTOMER/FIRM NAME f1 CUSTOMER APPROVAL PHONE DATE I�29�B'3 SCALE 10_2n eR0Wr1 5TOC/cc GAE5INf_T TO MATGH TRIM ..ON I31.0G1. p , rip IVOo 7-`( ILLIAMIINtATFD COPY CUT OK of 51Cjrl FA restaurant, a spirit's- —_ _.� ._ ---- --- MQI'IUN1C—NT SASE TG E5E GC:hI'GThUc:TE-D - gY GWHM-s CCNTWT0t2. f_TAIL A-F-E- fix, �" "` - — -- -- T11F- 5AMff S Low! � TIM YJAIi,.Dra SAIL 2,_5, -- — - - — -- sEF DF-TAiL 2Z I N �4i �aDW�t gLl�sE welrtTS. F00 T INci I'F I Ha �F.r2_' F i;_ kT10N'- _ SIGN EL�-VATIQH i/zo= It-Dn r-` L: G.AfJ i Nr-T ' 1 _f00ThGi i �IGIr Off 1/Z,. - I'-ot, Af-RIAL VCW Of 51rAH L CATIOM Z ANra£ IRON fRAML RACV& " /0 FLOURE%_t— Tu6£5 5 ACRYL IG WE a BALL AST TYp I LLUNI. CAS. SST No SC.ALG mpf.6a% 5il �. Co�pany In Distinctive Slgnage since 1961 46.120 CALHOUN ST. (619) 347-3566 INDIO, CALIFORNIA 92201 345.1155 SEE NOTE I• 5Ef! NOTE 2. CONTRACTORS LIC. NO. - 20713 CITY LIC. NO. 1102-0 WORKMANS COMP. NO. 42$719 DRAWN BY JOB LOCATION pAL1\4 DESEY�T — MAF DRAWING NO. CUSTOMER/FI RM ADDRESS 73-101 HWY III - CUSTOMER/FIRM NAME MQMKOo : GONST"C-T ION CUSTOMER APPROVAL 5—O 5�E HOTff a --restaurant and spirits u restaurant and spirits �ICGN ELEVATION 112" = 1' -0" ELEVATION D 2" 4�f 8 y SIDE 5ECTION a 'HALO' ILLUMINATED SIGrNAGE O MTG fWAcf-eT (5) NEON TUBE a (ABRICATED METAL LETTE►-HCA 4 r12.Aly5�orzMer� 5 ixLAS� 7TAND(5) 6 STANDARD H0051NCA Q7 pEcOtzATIVE 12AGEWAY lei FLUO'ESCENT LIGHTING G ALUMINUM LETTER(5) 10, MTV• STutD (5) 11. restaurant and spifih ELEVATION F ❑n❑ ❑ aD 10/27/0-7 11 / 10 /87 ADD. NOTED This is an original unpublished drawing, — Mc - created by IMPERIAL SIGN. It is submitted for your personal use in connection with a project being planned for you by IMPERIAL SIGN. It is not to be shown to anyone out- side your organization, nor is it to be repro- duced, copied or exhibited in any fashion. NOTES: 1, TEXTOF-ED AND FAINTED TO MATLH WALL 50KFACE, 2. fAF3121CATED LETTEtzIhCa W/ 512M,5HED Q0LD 'Wi215G0' PAGE AND WHITE 92 TUF-H, 3. 4" f C.O. ALUMINUM W1 WHITE ENAMEL flH15H. ELEVATIOH H P j 7 y. 1 Q s �R jj 1. f I l I f Amount jz F'3 y I i 01 z�` � l 9� St, �h3 � ' w aj 40-%Z" " - I+ 3. f ice- ♦ Al.s� {� — ' p°ad, yt ; NONE mown lie F� M%- !Ra --- _ da Lit NUNN Y ► , 9 go 16 oil tt 1 _ j ( tea S Ilk pd Y. ♦V•��4 r � C.4 T � P� � i , ° d � L e y I t t 1 [lQ Y loop 00 o 00 ��~� _ �.,, ,� • Ire - � � f � solo ur —I— p v ° lee TF A jYe af'.4e.. rosy � 64 >"a'.w,,,�. "°•evrN it% 41'✓.�', r*` 'i .�'� 4,._ -`� m• .-_'�'m`�,` _-_ .",.-..c sf�'—... �•�^-.--'� '4,_._ � is \ I �Y w�>�� 4 �>��ry �~ .T p ) • ' � E. ��' .... � f ..:. ,-.. - , -.c"T _ ..: y -12 � �i ',!r .. - an ^' 1p 00, Ito v -71 } S� `a^..e,�+��:��„pr. {%};,• �,.,� *' ' ! �•, ram.. Y °' or It VI It E4 Y� s » r e�sew•�• mc:�•e...+.ry ew.a-ems_,.::wur:.v ., _.�_, �{ ;. ' . �, e j j f Pi, g 4 v t _ V _ 1 t � �` � 1 �� ' S, �f i 3 �y m-•--�...A -�w '� � i V P r ti V P � � �. � .Y✓�ye 8 glr¢� �w�r-. � e ! sw..+v..>9s ...- . . � •em.•�.svn d " e IVI ti it lb P4 / g .?j ' t ` . M 1zr OrE4 j �9 MOO • - - e. \ °.+ � •c :: r•'�. Y .�+-+; ;var. ;�s'�"1'�:. u•nt.. ,. �^,'3a i .'?.. ti'.t 3>,� - ,t'�a: z p .. � f �� & vTiY l�•^._m •yyawy F,�' �m�ms�.o M'TT•mwe�• �aw/,e.+atfYoY 1 ) ,. .,..- _ _ -,{, NO 0 OR ON ja- �! f V q .3J '� •{t 4..' ; y \ 3. �1b Y A Q t (� s � � 4 ? OR t• zS40 �.I � r m 00 4 ..",<5:1"4 �i✓M+fdy� z� ff� \$" - i 1' Lr' $ (£ Alz d.. °y�'+ p r i� Y Sb� "•eJy,,u` ' yf'""tva 5y As F� 3 _ WL a ma e3 loop CL 010 go VA H c #fix:..• Tk 'M"\:V t � - < _ S \ j c t 6 ]pp r rvt.•.s '•G.� I Asi el / ' C . 2 1 1 s T i iy k ,,,erg -�`�-m,..s �r'"�': �'� '°i f,. f� '�� •aye t _s ti r � e t .' j 1 ] 1-7 14 f A .� f t � �/A� 4 a�.�iY � �-,--.r..nc a . - .Y.�.:,.t �'�.% n �••a+ - ,ti \, � � � � 5�^",v— -�] r >r 87 a -v3� 9fJ[ � � n SSSyppp - _ 8Y8Y8Y( r .f a - � + � � - ' - ear.-� yc • -t . . - 2 3y. ♦ r 1 f OW •r 3 Y ¢f.` - i _ I un..wew. tlm� 1 • \ dO...::_,._�, � • � f A G � jd wtL � b � �- t \ � E c IF swo Ir 4jp k. 9 T'x '`,A �` ,j p ��•�ev�� a+ h t � rF •4 11 n 2Z i•ci1f P �- pq C { t d f1q l/ iIWO, PARS rj�— i.'. wri �r_19 I RU r.�►a�—'J4 carve,,,, •Onts .4tA■lft.,- I - �; �•? r c:'-�r°'�'y'�a�cjr%.� )jam i VmPit W tOld Aut i +iel., son i 1 sj irfm WNW MA t t 1Y!•l ,a11° -r s� C, {yyynry ( y, ��, __ `'4 ► � � � :fit: it /fit e 1 �14A� fiy+. iR,lrpp � ��ig x L -' RLh IL p " {` a�a.'>laiM�° f !I{: :'t � � s ';-;+� �' Y g_•g' I � y� r " .,r81 f �s�,� // iv AW � 4M�� IIifi'lIM `"-r.•..rl:� 444�(1■1b /�M ' '*�' di1� � r; Oft IL JIM s ci 7 aw f. I oi- Op elf wn t�i d � ! d taE114 :A t s" - •.:;— Sit' � `' AMR.. ( _ a �Ilk, * eater r•�. \OV y' imam 11 1 k N1T LY \ I