Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2023-02-07 PRC Regular Meeting Agenda PacketCity of Palm Desert Page 1 PARKS AND RECREATION COMMISSION CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA AGENDA (HYBRID MEETING) City Hall – Administrative Conference Room 73-510 Fred Waring Drive Palm Desert, CA 92260 Pursuant to Assembly Bill 361, this meeting may be conducted by teleconference. •To participate via Zoom, use the following link: https://palmdesert.zoom.us Meeting ID: 875 1653 2082 •To participate via phone: Dial (213) 338-8477 enter the Zoom Meeting ID: 875 1653 2082 followed by #. Indicate that you are a participant by pressing # to continue. During the meeting, press *9 to add yourself to the queue and wait for the Recording Secretary to announce your name/phone number. Press *6 to unmute your line and limit your comments to three minutes. •Written public comment may also be submitted to smuir@palmdesert.gov. Emails received one hour prior to the meeting will be distributed to the Commission. Any correspondence received during or after the meeting will be distributed to the Commission as soon as practicable and retained for the official record. Emails will not be read aloud except as an ADA accommodation. 1.CALL TO ORDER 2.ROLL CALL 3.NON-AGENDA PUBLIC COMMENT: This time has been set aside for the public to address the Parks and Recreation Commission on issues that are not on the agenda for up to three minutes. Because the Brown Act does not allow the Committee to act on items not listed on the agenda, members may briefly respond or refer the matter to staff for a report and recommendation at a future meeting. 4.CONSENT CALENDAR: All matters listed on the Consent Calendar are considered routine and may be approved by one motion. The public may comment on any items on the Consent Agenda within the three-minute time limit. Individual items may be removed by Commissioners for a separate discussion. A.APPROVAL OF MINUTES RECOMMENDATION: Approve the Parks and Recreation Regular Meeting minutes of January 3, 2023. Tuesday February 7, 2023 8:30 a.m. Regular Meeting Page 1 Parks and Recreation Commission Agenda February 7, 2023 City of Palm Desert Page 2 EXCLUDED CONSENT ITEMS: Items removed from the Consent Calendar for separate discussion are considered at this time. 5.ACTION CALENDAR A.ACCEPT LAND DONATION (Shawn Muir, Senior Management Analyst and Deborah Glickman, Management Analyst) RECOMMENDATION: Provide recommendation to the City Council to accept 10-acre land donation from the Slaughter Family 6.INFORMATIONAL REPORTS & COMMENTS A.NORTH PALM DESERT PARK UPDATE (Gianno Feoli, Interwest) a.Initial survey findings and next steps b.Commissioner feedback B.UPDATES FROM PARTNER ORGANIZATIONS a.Family YMCA of the Desert (Paula Simonds, Ex-Officio) b.Desert Recreation District (Kevin Kalman, Ex-Officio) c.Palm Desert Aquatic Center (David Keyes, Aquatic Manager) d.First Tee – Coachella Valley (Teal Guion, Director) e.Friends of the Desert Mountains (Tammy Martin, Executive Director) f.Palm Desert Library (Alina Prunean, Branch Manager) g.Friends of the Library (Karen Gonzales, Library) C.PARKS AND RECREATION COMMISSIONERS a.Civic Center/PDAC (Commissioner Maldonado) b.Cahuilla Hills Park/Fox Hiking Park (Chair Dawson) c.Ironwood Park (Commissioner Akkerman) d.Coyote Sightings (Commissioner Perry) e.Commissioner Involvement (Chair Dawson) D.CITY COUNCIL LIAISON E.CITY STAFF a.New University Neighborhood Parks (Nick Melloni, Senior Planner) b.PDAC Fees Study Update (Liberty Urban, Deputy Director of Finance and Shawn Muir, Senior Management Analyst) c.Library Update – Request for COD speaker at upcoming meeting (Shawn Muir, Senior Management Analyst) d. Follow-up on bike trail request (Shawn Muir, Senior Management Analyst Nick Melloni, Senior Planner) e. Follow-up on North Sphere Regional Park questions (Shawn Muir, Senior Management Analyst) f.Follow-up on skate park pad requirements (Shawn Muir, Senior Management Analyst) g.Update on options for conducting virtual or hybrid meeting (Anthony Mejia, City Clerk) Page 2 Parks and Recreation Commission Agenda February 7, 2023 City of Palm Desert Page 3 F.ATTENDANCE REPORT 7.ADJOURNMENT: The next Regular Meeting will be held on March 7, 2023, at 8:30 a.m. AFFIDAVIT OF POSTING I hereby certify under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing agenda for the Parks and Recreation Commission was posted on the City Hall bulletin board and City website not less than 72 hours prior to the meeting. /s/ Monique M. Lomeli, CMC Recording Secretary PUBLIC NOTICES Agenda Related Materials: Pursuant to Government Code §54957.5(b)(2) the designated office for inspection of records in connection with this meeting is the City Clerk’s Office, City Hall, 73-510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert. Staff reports for all agenda items and documents provided to a majority of the legislative bodies are available for public inspection at City Hall and on the City’s website at www.cityofpalmdesert.org. Americans with Disabilities Act: It is the intention of the City of Palm Desert to comply with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) in all respects. If, as an attendee or a participant at this meeting, or in meetings on a regular basis, you will need special assistance beyond what is normally provided, the city will attempt to accommodate you in every reasonable manner. Please contact the Office of the City Clerk, (760) 346-0611, at least 48 hours prior to the meeting to inform us of your needs and to determine if accommodation is feasible. Page 3 City of Palm Desert Page 1 PARKS AND RECREATION COMMISSION CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA MINUTES Pursuant to Assembly Bill 361, this meeting was conducted by teleconference, and there will be in-person public access to the meeting location. 1. CALL TO ORDER A Regular Meeting of the Parks and Recreation Commission was called to order by Chair Dawson on Tuesday, January 3, 2023, at 8:30 a.m., in the Administrative Conference Room, City Hall, located at 73-510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert, California. 2. ROLL CALL Present: Commissioners Randy Guyer, James Henderson, John Maldonado, Paul Murphy, David O’Donnell, Ralph Perry, and Chair Gerald Dawson Absent: Vice Chair Gregg Akkerman and Commissioner Flint. Ex-Officio Members Paula Simonds and Kevin Kalman Liaison(s) Present: Councilmember Evan Trubee Staff Present: Martin Alvarez, Public Works Director; Andy Ramirez, Deputy Director; Shawn Muir, Senior Management Analyst; Marisol Lopez, Recording Secretary, were present at Roll Call. Other staff members presented reports or responded to questions as indicated in the minutes. 3. NON-AGENDA PUBLIC COMMENT: NONE. 4. CONSENT CALENDAR: CONSENT CALENDAR ITEM A was removed by Chair Dawson. 5. ACTION CALENDAR A. APPROVAL OF MINUTES Tuesday January 3, 2023 8:30 a.m. Regular Meeting Parks and Recreation Commission Minutes January 3, 2023 City of Palm Desert Page 2 ALL ACTIONS ARE DRAFT, PENDING APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES MOTION BY CHAIR DAWSON, CARRIED 7-0-2, to approve the Parks and Recreation Commission Regular Meeting minutes of January 03, 2023. with one correction to reflect City Manager was present during the meeting. 6. INFORMATIONAL REPORTS & COMMENTS A. UPDATES FROM PARTNER ORGANIZATIONS • FAMILY YMCA OF THE DESERT Ex-Officio, Paula Simonds, provided a written report regarding Family YMCA. • DESERT RECREATION DISTRICT Community Services Manager, Brenda Nutcher provided an update regarding DRD. • PALM DESERT AQUATIC CENTER Aquatic Manager, David Keyes provided a written report. • FIRST TEE – COACHELLA VALLEY Director, Teal Guion provided an update regarding First Tee. • FRIENDS OF THE DESERT MOUNTAINS Executive Director, Tammy Martin provided an update regarding Friends of the Desert Mountains. • PALM DESERT LIBRARY No report was provided. • FRIENDS OF THE LIBRARY President, Karen Gonzales provided an update regarding Friends of the Library. B. PARKS AND RECREATION COMMISSIONERS Chair Dawson stated his concern regarding the Commission’s involvement in the Parks and Recreation Commission and requested a follow-up at the next meeting on February 7th, 2023. Discussion followed, which included clarification from Staff that the North Sphere Regional Park Sub-Committee’s scope was to select a design consultant for the park, which has been completed. No park review updates were provided. C. CITY COUNCIL LIAISON Council member, Evan Trubee requested an update regarding North Sphere Park’s public outreach executed by Interwest. Parks and Recreation Commission Minutes January 3, 2023 City of Palm Desert Page 3 ALL ACTIONS ARE DRAFT, PENDING APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES D. CITY STAFF Erica Powell, Management Analyst provided a report regarding the 2023 Desert X Exhibition. North Sphere Park - Interwest Consultant, Gianno Feoli provided an update regarding the online survey for North Sphere Park. A final report will be provided at the February Council meeting. Shawn Muir, Senior Management Analyst provided an update on the following items: • Bump & Grind Trailhead improvements - Construction plans for the restroom facilities have been prepared, and Staff are working on a notice of inviting bids for construction. • Civic Center Park Fitness Equipment – Construction has been delayed due to a supply chain issue. E. ATTENDANCE REPORT The attendance report was provided with the agenda materials. The Commission took no action on this matter. 7. ADJOURNMENT The Parks and Recreation Commission adjourned at 9:55 a.m. Respectfully submitted, Marisol Lopez, Administrative Assistant Recording Secretary ATTEST: Shawn Muir, Senior Management Analyst Secretary APPROVED BY THE PARKS AND RECREATION COMMISSION: __/__/2023 CITY OF PALM DESERT COMMUNITY SERVICES DIVISION INTEROFFICE MEMORANDUM To: Parks and Recreations Commission From: Shawn Muir, Senior Management Analyst Date: February 7, 2023 Subject: Land Donation Background: In September 2022, Mr. Don Slaughter contacted the City regarding two properties that were inherited by him and his three siblings. The properties are located west of Homme Adams Park in the City. The APNs are 628-030-011 (approximately four acres) and 628-030-009 (approximately five acres) (Attachment 1). Mr. Slaughter conveyed that his family wished to donate these parcels to the City to be conserved as a public park. City Staff contacted the City Attorney for counsel on potentially accepting the land donation. Mr. Hargreaves advised that an environmental study be completed to determine whether there were any environmental concerns related to the property, and to communicate with the owners to confirm any conditions they may have for transfer, and timing. Staff commissioned a Phase I Environmental Site Assessment that was conducted by Earth Systems (Attachment 2). The assessment revealed that the site has had some development in the past. Remnants of former structures and paved pads, an asphalt paved road, water valves and fire hydrant. The site consists of primarily of mountainous desert terrain, characterized by a ridge that crosses much of the southern part of the site from west to east. There are no Recognized Environmental Conditions associated with the site. Mr. Slaughter was contacted to further discuss the details of the property transfer. Staff talked with him in December, and anticipate that if approved, the item will go before the City Council in March. Mr. Slaughter also conveyed that it would be preferable to have a sign placed at the entrance to the property signifying that it had been donated by his parents to the City. Staff commissioned a sign company that specializes in sandstone engraving to create a mock-up of a potential sign design (Attachment 3). Mr. Slaughter agreed this type of sign, including the design and approximate size of 3 feet by 2 feet would be acceptable. Overview: The City is seeking input from the Parks and Recreation Commission on whether to accept donation of the two parcels described. Financial Impact: The anticipated financial impact associated with acceptance of the property donation includes the fabrication and installation of the sandstone sign. The total cost for the sign is estimated to Parks and Recreation Commission Land Donation Page 2 be under $3,000. Future land management or maintenance may also incur some costs; however those cannot be determined at this time. Attachment 1: Location Attachment 2: Phase I Environmental Site Assessment Attachment 3: Sign Example 628030011 Riverside County, CA SEARCH Address Owner Name Company Or Trust APN Property Map Aerial Birds-Eye Road Street View Parcel boundaries: ...loading map... © 2022 TomTom, © Vexcel Imaging, © 2022 Microsoft Cor poration© 2022 TomTom, © Vexcel Imaging, © 2022 Microsoft Corporation 250 feet250 feet Stewart | Property Information https://stewartnow.com/Private/PropertyProfile.aspx?pid=15873327 1 of 3 9/14/2022, 1:14 PM 628030009 Riverside County, CA SEARCH Back to Search Results Address Owner Name Company Or Trust APN Property Map Property Information Aerial Birds-Eye Road Street View Parcel boundaries: ...loading map... © 2022 TomTom, © Vexcel Imaging, © 2022 Microsoft Cor poration© 2022 TomTom, © Vexcel Imaging, © 2022 Microsoft Corporation 500 feet500 feet Stewart | Property Information https://stewartnow.com/Private/PropertyProfile.aspx?pid=15873334 1 of 3 9/14/2022, 1:13 PM City of Palm Desert  73510 Fred Waring Drive  Palm Desert, California 92260 File No. 305770‐001  Doc. No. 22‐12‐705  Report of Phase I  Environmental Site Assessment  APNs 628‐030‐009 & 628‐030‐011  W of Calle De Los Campesinos, N of South Cliff Road  Palm Desert, Riverside County, California            December 13, 2022          Submitted By:  Earth Systems Pacific  79811B Country Club Drive  Bermuda Dunes, California 92203              ©2022 Earth Systems Pacific  Unauthorized use or copying of this document is strictly prohibited   without the express written consent of Earth Systems Pacific.    Earth Systems________________________________________________ 79‐811 Country Club Drive, Suite B  |  Bermuda Dunes, CA 92203  |  Ph: 760.345.1588  |  www.earthsystems.com December 13, 2022 File No. 305770‐001  Doc. No. 22‐12‐705  City of Palm Desert  73510 Fred Waring Drive  Palm Desert, California 92260  Attention:  Ms. Deborah Glickman, Management Analyst  Subject: Report of Phase I Environmental Site Assessment  Project: APNs 628‐030‐009 & 628‐030‐011  W of Calle De Los Campesinos, N of South Cliff Road  Palm Desert, Riverside County, California  As  you  requested,  Earth  Systems  Pacific  [Earth  Systems]  has  completed  this  Phase I  Environmental Site Assessment [ESA] of the site referenced above.  This report was prepared for  your exclusive use.  It was prepared to stand as a whole, and no part should be excerpted or used  in exclusion of any other part.  This project was conducted in accordance with our proposal dated  November 29, 2022.  Thank you for this opportunity to be of service.  If you have any questions  regarding this report, or the information contained herein, please contact this office at your  convenience.     I declare that, to the best of my professional knowledge and belief, I meet the definition of  Environmental Professional as defined in 40 CFR 312.10.  I have the specific qualifications based  on education, training and experience to assess a property of the nature, history and setting of  the subject site.  I have endeavored to perform this project in conformance with the standards  and practices set forth in 40 CFR 312.    Respectfully submitted,  EARTH SYSTEMS PACIFIC  Alexander Schriener, Jr., PG 7198   Associate Geologist   ESA/asj/jt/klm/cgj  Distribution:  6/City of Palm Desert  1/BER EARTH SYSTEMS PACIFIC  Report of Phase I  Environmental Site Assessment  APNs 628‐030‐009 & 628‐030‐011  W of Calle De Los Campesinos, N of South Cliff Road  Palm Desert, Riverside County, California    December 13, 2022    TABLE OF CONTENTS  1.0 INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................ 1  1.1 Project Information ............................................................................................... 1  1.2 Purpose and Scope of Work .................................................................................. 1  1.3 Definitions ............................................................................................................. 2  1.4 Qualifications ......................................................................................................... 3  1.5 Exclusions and Data Gaps ...................................................................................... 3  1.6 Limitations and Reliance ........................................................................................ 4  2.0 GENERAL SITE INFORMATION ...................................................................................... 5  2.1 Size, Location, and Name ....................................................................................... 5  2.2 Assessor’s Parcel Number(s) .................................................................................. 5  2.3 Township, Range, Section ...................................................................................... 5  2.4 Site Boundaries ...................................................................................................... 5  2.5 Current Development and Access ......................................................................... 5  2.6 Zoning/Land Use Records ...................................................................................... 5  2.7 Site Topography .................................................................................................... 6  2.8 Surface Water Bodies ............................................................................................ 6  2.9 Geology and Hydrogeology ................................................................................... 6  3.0 SITE RECONNAISSANCE ................................................................................................ 7  3.1 Onsite Observations .............................................................................................. 7  3.2 Site Vicinity Observations ...................................................................................... 7  4.0 HISTORICAL INFORMATION .......................................................................................... 8  5.0 RECORDS REVIEW ........................................................................................................ 9  5.1 Agency Database Search Report ............................................................................ 9  5.2 California EPA, State Water Resources Control Board ......................................... 10  5.3 California Department of Toxic Substances Control ............................................ 10  5.4 Tribal Records ...................................................................................................... 10  5.5 Engineering and Institutional Controls ................................................................ 10  5.6 Environmental Cleanup Liens .............................................................................. 10  5.7 California Department of Conservation, Geologic Energy Management Division 10  6.0 INTERVIEWS, GENERAL RESEARCH, AND PRIOR REPORTS .......................................... 11  6.1 Current Owners/Occupants/Operators ............................................................... 11  6.2 Past Owners/Occupants/Operators ..................................................................... 11  6.3 Owners/Occupants of Neighboring Properties .................................................... 11  6.4 California Department of Conservation – California Geological Survey ............... 12  TABLE OF CONTENTS, continued ii  EARTH SYSTEMS PACIFIC  7.0 SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS .................................................................................. 12  8.0 RECOMMENDATIONS ................................................................................................. 13    Appendix A  Figures  Appendix B  Photographs  Appendix C  Agency Database Search Report   Appendix D     Additional Documentation   Appendix E  Qualifications Statement    Appendix F  Reliance Form                   December 13, 2022  ‐ 1 ‐  File No. 305770‐001      Doc. No. 22‐12‐705  EARTH SYSTEMS PACIFIC  1.0 INTRODUCTION  1.1 Project Information  This report presents the findings of the Phase I Environmental Site Assessment [ESA] conducted  by Earth Systems Pacific [Earth Systems] for APNs 628‐030‐009 & 628‐030‐011, located west of  Calle De Los Campesinos, and north of South Cliff Road, in Palm Desert, Riverside County,  California [the site].  This project was conducted for the City of Palm Desert in accordance with  our proposal dated November 29, 2022.  This project was performed in conjunction with a gift of  the site to the City of Palm Desert.  The City wants to secure the  site  from  any  further  development and use it to provide additional public access to the mountain trails in the vicinity.   This project has been performed at the request of the client for due diligence purposes.  We are  not aware of special requirements for this ESA.      1.2 Purpose and Scope of Work  The purpose of an ESA is to evaluate the potential for the presence of soil or groundwater  contamination that may be present because of the past use, handling, storage, or disposal of  hazardous materials or petroleum products on or near the property.  The scope of work for this  evaluation is based on the United States Environmental Protection Agency Final All Appropriate  Inquiry Rule (2006) [US EPA AAI]; and, the ASTM Standard E1527‐13, Standard Practice for  Environmental Site Assessments, and consisted of the tasks listed below.    Site  Reconnaissance:    This  involved a  visual  reconnaissance  of the  site,  noting  physical  evidence of potential contamination or possible sources of contamination; and observation  of adjacent properties to identify readily observable visual evidence of possible impacts to  the subject site.  Figures depicting the site location and layout are presented in Appendix A.   Significant onsite features were photographed to document current conditions.  Selected site  photographs are presented in Appendix B.      Records  Review:    Records  regarding  the  regulatory  status  and  history of the site were  evaluated regarding the possible presence of Recognized Environmental Conditions [REC].   Regulatory agency records were reviewed by obtaining a report listing known sites that  generate, store, use, and/or have released hazardous materials from a firm that specializes  in maintaining a database of this type of information.  A copy of the agency database search  report is presented in Appendix C and is discussed in Section 5.1.  The search radius for the  agency database search was in accordance with the US EPA AAI and ASTM standard E1527‐ 13 as measured from the approximate center of the site.  Other sources of information are  listed in the references section of this report and may include the following categories of  information  (note  that  each  category  is  utilized  at  the  discretion  of  Environmental  Professional [EP] until, in the EP’s opinion, sufficient data has been obtained):        Historical aerial photographs    Topographic maps   California Department of Oil, Gas, and Geothermal Resources maps   Fire insurance maps  December 13, 2022  ‐ 2 ‐  File No. 305770‐001      Doc. No. 22‐12‐705  EARTH SYSTEMS PACIFIC   Land title information   Local street directories   Zoning/land use records   Engineering and institutional controls, such as deed restrictions and restrictive zoning  to a radius of ¼ mile, if contained in publicly available lists/registries   Tribal records of subject property and adjoining properties (if tribal land)   Local government records such as building department files   Environmental cleanup liens     If the property was not previously developed, sources such as building department files and  street directories were not reviewed.   Relevant supporting documents are provided in  Appendix D.     Interviews:    Persons  familiar  with  the  site  were  interviewed  (if  possible)  regarding  the  potential presence of RECs on the site or in a position to affect the site, including the site  owner/operator/occupant,  former  site  owners/operators/occupants (if reasonably  accessible),  neighboring  property occupants  (if  the  site  is  abandoned),  and  selected  government personnel likely to have information regarding environmental conditions at or  near the site.  Information from persons who were successfully contacted is presented in  Section 6.     Report Preparation:  This report was prepared to present our findings, conclusions, and  recommendations.    1.3 Definitions  ASTM E1527‐13 provides definitions for 102 terms and 27 acronyms used in the ESA process.   Earth Systems endeavors to use these terms and acronyms within the meaning provided by ASTM  E1527‐13.  The majority of these terms are either obvious in their meaning or are seldom used in  this report, but a few are significant enough to warrant defining here, as follows:     Site: The term “site” is used in place of the term “property” as defined by ASTM E1527‐13  and is the physical location that is the subject of the assessment.  The site can include more  than one parcel of land, or only a portion of a parcel of land, depending on the needs of the  client.  ESAs focus primarily on activities that occur within the boundaries of the site, or that  could potentially affect conditions and activities within the boundaries of the site.  RECs on  offsite properties that are not likely to affect the site are not considered to be RECs for the  subject site.    Recognized Environmental Condition [REC]: the presence or likely presence of any hazardous  substances  or  petroleum  products  in,  on,  or  at  a  property:  due to a release to the  environment;  under  conditions  indicative  of  a  release  to  the  environment;  or  under  conditions that pose a material threat of a future release to the environment.  The term does  not include de minimis conditions.    December 13, 2022  ‐ 3 ‐  File No. 305770‐001      Doc. No. 22‐12‐705  EARTH SYSTEMS PACIFIC  Controlled Recognized Environmental Condition [CREC]: An REC resulting from a past release  of hazardous substances or petroleum products that has been addressed to the satisfaction  of the applicable regulatory authority, with hazardous substances or petroleum projects  allowed to remain in place subject to the implementation of required controls.     Historical Recognized Environmental Condition [HREC]:  A past release of any hazardous  substances or petroleum products that has occurred in connection with the property and has  been  addressed  to  the  satisfaction  of  the  applicable  regulatory authority or meeting  unrestricted  use  criteria  established  by  a  regulatory  authority,  without  subjecting  the  property to any required controls (such as use restriction).  HRECs are no longer RECs for a  site.    De minimus: A condition that generally does not present a threat to human health or the  environment and that generally would not be the subject of an enforcement action if brought  to the attention of appropriate governmental agencies.       Environmental Professional [EP]: An EP is defined by US EPA AAI as “a person who possesses  sufficient specific education, training, and experience necessary to exercise professional  judgment to develop opinions and conclusions regarding conditions indicative of releases or  threatened releases (of hazardous substances) on, at, in, or to a property, sufficient to meet  the objectives and performance factors (of the rule).”  Specific minimum credentials are  required by US EPA AAI and ASTM E1527‐13 to be identified as an EP.       User: The “user” of the report is defined by ASTM Practice E1527‐13 as the party for whom  the assessment is being conducted (the “client”), not the EP.       1.4 Qualifications  Work  on  this  project  was  performed  under  the  direct  supervision of an Environmental  Professional [EP], in accordance with the US EPA AAI and ASTM E 1527‐13 requirements.  Mr. Alex  Schriener, Jr. (PG) was the lead EP, the project manager, and provided senior review.  Mr. Josh  Thomas,  Field  Services  Supervisor,  conducted  the  site  reconnaissance.    Ms.  Kirsten  Murch,  Project Geologist, conducted historical aerial photograph review, other historical review, and  agency database review.  A qualifications statement regarding the personnel who performed this  evaluation is presented in Appendix E.    1.5 Exclusions and Data Gaps   The scope of work for this ESA did not include testing the air, groundwater, soil, or building  materials for the presence of hazardous constituents.     The US EPA AAI and ASTM E1527‐13 require that gaps in the data used in evaluating the site be  identified.  Data gaps encountered in this project, and their significance to the project, are  summarized below.      December 13, 2022  ‐ 4 ‐  File No. 305770‐001      Doc. No. 22‐12‐705  EARTH SYSTEMS PACIFIC   As stated in the proposal, land title information would only be reviewed if furnished by  the Client.  Land title information was not provided to Earth Systems, and therefore was  not reviewed.  Because of the availability of other data sources, and limited development  of the site, the lack of title information is not considered to be significant.      Historical street directories were not requested since a street address is needed for that  research.    This  data  gap  is  not  considered  significant  due  to  the site’s remote and  relatively undeveloped nature.     Sanborn maps were not available for the site.  This data gap is not considered to be  significant due to the generally undeveloped nature of the site and vicinity.   Further investigations regarding the data gaps do not appear warranted.  1.6 Limitations and Reliance  This report has been prepared for the exclusive use of the City of Palm Desert.  Other parties  participating  in  the  transaction  for  which  this  project  was  conducted may also use the  information presented in this report, provided said parties agree that Earth Systems shall have  no additional liability arising from such use than described in the contract under which this  project was conducted.  Any other use of or reliance on the information and opinions contained  in this report without the written authorization of Earth Systems is at the sole risk of the user (to  apply for written authorization to rely on this report, please complete and submit the application  provided in Appendix F).   Note that the conclusions and recommendations rendered in this report are opinions based on  readily available information obtained to date within the scope of the work authorized by the  client and apply only to site conditions as of the date of the site visit.  The scope of work for this  project was developed to address the needs of the client as part of a property transaction  (purchase, sale, refinance, etc.) and may not meet the needs of other users.    It should be noted that any level of assessment cannot ascertain that a property is completely  free of chemical or toxic substances.  We believe the scope of work has been appropriate to allow  the client to make an informed business decision.  According to US EPA AAI and ASTM E1527‐13:  the “shelf life” of an ESA report is six months; an “Update” can be provided to the client within  the first year of the report’s publication (at an additional cost); and if the report is older than one  year, the ESA should be re‐conducted.  Changes in site conditions can render this report obsolete  within a shorter period of time.  Use of this report outside of these time frames or after site  conditions have changed is at the sole risk of the user and without liability and legal exposure to  Earth Systems.      The  results  contained  in  this  report  are  based  upon  the  information  acquired  during  the  assessment, including information obtained from third parties. Earth Systems makes no claim as  to the accuracy of the information obtained from others.  In ad dition, it is possible that variations  exist beyond or between points evaluated during this assessment, and that changes in conditions  can occur in the future due to the works of man, contaminant migration, variations in rainfall or  December 13, 2022  ‐ 5 ‐  File No. 305770‐001      Doc. No. 22‐12‐705  EARTH SYSTEMS PACIFIC  temperature, a broadening of knowledge, changes in regulatory standards, and/or other factors  not apparent at the time of the field investigation.      The services performed by Earth Systems have been conducted in a manner consistent with the  level of care and skill ordinarily exercised by members of our profession currently practicing  under similar conditions in the site vicinity.  No warranty, express or implied, is offered.   2.0 GENERAL SITE INFORMATION  2.1 Size, Location, and Name   The site consists of two legal parcels totaling 9.18 acres located west of Calle De Los Campesinos,  and north of South Cliff Road, in Palm Desert, Riverside County, California.  The site location is  depicted in Figure 1.  The site layout is depicted in Figure 2.     2.2 Assessor’s Parcel Number(s)  The site is identified as Assessor’s Parcel Numbers [APNs] 628‐030‐009 & 628‐030‐011.  Copies  of the Assessor’s Parcel Map and of the report from the Riversi de County Information Technology  Geographic Information Services [RCIT] website are included in Appendix D.     2.3 Township, Range, Section  The site is located in the southeast quarter of the northwest quarter of Section 30, Township 5  South, Range 6 East, San Bernardino Baseline and Meridian.   2.4 Site Boundaries  The property boundaries are not defined.  For the purposes of this report, the boundaries were  estimated based on the RCIT map with aerial photo, which depicts APN boundaries, and Earth  Point Township and Range tool for Google Earth.    2.5 Current Development and Access  The site is primarily undeveloped mountainous desert accessed from Calle De Los Campesinos  parallel to the east boundary.  A paved asphalt road, which generally follows the base of the  canyon on the south part of the site, crosses east to west and accesses two paved pads.  Evidence  of a former small structure was observed near the center of the north boundary of APN 628‐030‐ 011.  Water valves were observed near the northwest corner of the same parcel.      2.6 Zoning/Land Use Records  Zoning/Land Use information was obtained from the City of Palm Desert Development Services  Department website, which indicated that the property zoning is designated as Hillside Planned  Residential – H.P.R.  December 13, 2022  ‐ 6 ‐  File No. 305770‐001      Doc. No. 22‐12‐705  EARTH SYSTEMS PACIFIC  2.7 Site Topography  The surface of the site is rugged mountainous terrain characterized by a ridge that is oriented  west/east and runs nearly the length of the site.  The elevation of the site ranges from about 430  feet above mean sea level in the northeast corner to about 700 feet above mean sea level along  the ridgeline near the center of the west boundary.        2.8 Surface Water Bodies  Given the largely exposed bedrock nature of the site, the only surface water body onsite is an  intermittent stream in the southwest portion of the site.  Rainwater infiltrates the site where soil  eroded from the mountains can collect.  The nearest surface water body is a man‐made storm  runoff channel parallel to Calle De Los Campesinos, approximately 400 feet east of the subject  site, that contains water only during hydrologic events.  Water bodies are not located in a position  to transport contaminants onto the site or be readily affected by contaminants released at the  site.     2.9 Geology and Hydrogeology  The site is located in the Coachella Valley of Southern California.  The Coachella Valley is part of  the tectonically active Salton Trough, which is a closed, internally draining basin bound by the  San Jacinto and Santa Rosa Mountains to the southwest; the San Bernardino Mountains to the  northwest; and the Little San Bernardino and Orocopia Mountains to the northeast and east.   These mountain ranges, and the basement rock underlying the Coachella Valley, are primarily  composed of granitic and metamorphic rock.  Within the Coachella Valley, the basement complex  is overlain by a series of unconsolidated and semi‐consolidated continental clastic sediments  eroded from the surrounding mountain ranges; lacustrine deposits of ancient Lake Cahuilla; and  wind‐blown sand deposited in the active blow‐sand area of Riverside County (DWR, 1964).  The  site is located on mountainous foothill terrain of the Santa Rosa Mountains.    The northwest trending San Andreas fault zone is the major geologic feature of the Coachella  Valley.  The Banning, Mission Creek, and Garnet Hill faults, which are part of the San Andreas  fault  system,  divide  the  Coachella  Valley  into  four  distinct  hydrogeologic  subbasins.    Each  subbasin is further divided into subareas, based on either the type of water‐bearing formation,  water quality, areas of confined groundwater, forebay areas, groundwater divides, or surface  water divides.  The site is located in the Santa Rosa Mountains outside the south extent of the  Thermal subarea of the Indio subbasin.  This subarea consists of the confined portion of the Indio  subbasin, where water from the up‐gradient Palm Springs subarea moves into the interbedded  sands, silts and clays underlying the central portion of the valley.  Groundwater in this subarea  generally flows in a southeasterly direction toward the Salton Sea.  The water‐bearing materials  in this area have been divided into four units:  a semi‐perched zone at the ground surface and  extending to a depth of up to 100 feet below ground surface [bgs]; an upper aquifer which is 150  to 300 feet thick; a lower aquifer in excess of 500 feet thick; and an aquitard between these two  aquifers which is 100 to 200 feet thick.  The semi‐perched zone may be the uppermost water‐ bearing zone under the site.  Water quality within this zone is generally poor.  The deeper and  upper  aquifers  are  typically  used  for  water  supply.    Throughout  the  Thermal  subarea,  the  December 13, 2022  ‐ 7 ‐  File No. 305770‐001      Doc. No. 22‐12‐705  EARTH SYSTEMS PACIFIC  horizontal permeability is several times the vertical permeability resulting in a predominantly  lateral flow of groundwater (DWR, 1964).    The depth to groundwater near the site was evaluated via data available on the California  Statewide  Groundwater  Elevation  Monitoring  System  [CASGEM]  database.    Groundwater  elevation in a CASGEM well (ID: 47724) at approximately 260 feet above mean sea level and  located approximately 2 miles east‐northeast of the site, was approximately ‐275 feet on October  15, 2021.    3.0 SITE RECONNAISSANCE  3.1 Onsite Observations  Earth Systems personnel visited the site on December 6, 2022, to observe current site conditions  and adjacent land use.  Photographs of selected onsite features are presented in Appendix B.  A  summary of our findings is presented below.     The site was observed to consist of mountainous desert terrain, including an intermittent  stream channel in the southwest portion of the site (Photos 1‐ 3).  Mature native shrubs  were scattered throughout the site and were thickest in the where runoff tended to  collect in low areas (Photo 2).  The vegetation did not show unusual signs of stress.   Two “paved pads” were along the paved road, which crossed the southern part of the site  from east to west (Photos 4‐6).  The use of the pads is unknown and the pavement  throughout was deteriorated.  A locked gate to deter vehicle entrance was at the base of  the paved road.  Therefore, dumping was not observed onsite; and trash, windblown and  hand carried, was minor.  An unpaved trail continued westward from the end of the paved  road (Photo 1).      What appeared to be the remains of a former structure, likely a  residence, were observed  near the center of the north boundary of APN 628‐030‐011 [4‐acre parcel] (Photo 7).   Wood debris was observed in the vicinity of the structure ruins (Photo 8).  A fire hydrant  was located near the north center of the same parcel (Photo 9).  CVWD water valves were  observed near the northwest corner of APN 628‐030‐011 (Photo 10).  The remainder of  this parcel appeared to have been graded (Photo 11).     Evidence of the onsite use, storage, or disposal of hazardous materials was not observed.    3.2 Site Vicinity Observations  The site vicinity generally consisted of undeveloped mountainous terrain.  The remains of a  former structure, and consisting of tile and other building materials, were observed beyond the  center of the north boundary of APN 628‐030‐011 (Photo 12).  Scattered homes were in the  extended vicinity to the south and west; and a storm water channel and residential complexes  were to the east.   December 13, 2022  ‐ 8 ‐  File No. 305770‐001      Doc. No. 22‐12‐705  EARTH SYSTEMS PACIFIC  Evidence was not observed that the site was adversely affected by activities on properties in the  site vicinity.    4.0 HISTORICAL INFORMATION  Information regarding the history of the site was obtained from various sources, as listed in the  references section of this report.  The results of this research are summarized chronologically in  the following table.  Footnotes regarding the sources of historical information are provided  following the table.    Table 1 – Summary of Historical Site Usage    Date  Source  Discussion  1938  ERIS aerial  photo  The site was undeveloped mountainous desert west of an alluvial fan webbed  with runoff channels.  The vicinity was undeveloped mountainous desert, and  Route 74 was in the extended vicinity to the east.  1948  ERIS aerial  photo  A large, white, irregularly shaped object was at or near the southeast corner of  the site.  It is possible that the shape is a flaw in the photograph.  The vicinity  was generally unchanged.  1954  ERIS aerial  photo  The white object observed in the 1948 photo was gone.  One structure was visible onsite near the center of the north boundary of APN 628‐030‐011.  A  second structure was near the first, but off site to the north.  In the extended  vicinity, the storm water control channel to the east was partially complete.  1959  USGS  Topographic  map  The site is depicted as mostly undeveloped mountainous terrain.  Two small  structures are depicted near the center of the north boundary of APN 628‐030‐ 011 – one onsite and one offsite to the north.  A network of trails and/or dirt  roads were offsite between the base of the hills and the storm water channel.   In the vicinity, scattered houses were at the base of the hills to the north.        1959  ERIS aerial  photo  The  site  was  generally unchanged.   Approximately  10 residences had  been  developed along with South Cliff Road to the south.  Another building was south  of the southeast corner of the site.  A road from Route 74 accessed a gravel pit  northeast of the subject site; and the storm water channel appeared to be  complete.  1965  ERIS aerial  photo  The site was generally unchanged.  A large building had been completed along  the west side of Route 74 at the current location of St. Margaret’s Episcopal  Church.  1972  ERIS aerial  photo  By 1972, the road had been built along the south boundary of APN 628‐030‐011 and terminated at a large, cleared area.  The remainder of the site was generally  unchanged.  Scattered houses were beyond the west, northeast, and east ends  of the site.  A residential complex and Palm Desert Community Presbyterian  Church complex were along the west side of Route 74.  1975  ERIS aerial  photo  The site and vicinity were generally unchanged. 1984  ERIS aerial  photo  The road appeared to have been developed westward of the cleared area.  The  immediate vicinity was unchanged.  Housing development had expanded to east  of Route 74.  1988  USGS  Topographic  map  The east portion of the asphalt road is depicted onsite.  Development in the  vicinity to the east and south had boomed, including housing developments east  and west of Route 74; houses along South Cliff Road; unimproved roads, such as  Calle De Los Campesinos; and the storm water runoff channel.   1989  ERIS aerial  photo  The site and vicinity appeared to be generally unchanged; however, the photo  was of only fair quality.  December 13, 2022  ‐ 9 ‐  File No. 305770‐001      Doc. No. 22‐12‐705  EARTH SYSTEMS PACIFIC  1996  ERIS aerial  photo  By 1996, the second clearing or pad was visible approximately 230 feet west of  the first clearing.  In the vicinity, South Cliff Road was partially paved.  A water  tank (reservoir) was approximately ¼ mile north of the east end of the site.  2002  ERIS aerial  photo  The site was generally unchanged.  In the vicinity, residential development east  of the storm water channel had resumed.  South Cliff Road was fully paved.      2005  ERIS aerial  photo  The site and vicinity were generally unchanged. 2009  ERIS aerial  photo  The site and vicinity were generally unchanged. 2010  ERIS aerial  photo  The site and vicinity were generally unchanged. 2012  ERIS aerial  photo  The site and vicinity were generally unchanged. 2014  ERIS aerial  photo  The site and vicinity were generally unchanged. 2016  ERIS aerial  photo  The site and vicinity were generally unchanged. 2018  ERIS aerial  photo  The site and vicinity were generally unchanged. 2020  ERIS aerial  photo  The site and vicinity were generally unchanged. 12‐06‐2022  Riverside  County  Department of  Transportation  Book Map 192 did not depict a county‐maintained road onsite.    Historical information footnotes:    We attempted to obtain historical information from a standard s et of resources, including historical aerial photographs,  historical USGS topographic maps, Sanborn fire insurance maps, historical street directories, chain‐of‐title documents,  city building permit files, and personnel interview.  However, historical information was not obtained from some  sources, as follows:  Sanborn Fire Insurance maps: Sanborn maps for the site and vicinity were requested from ERIS, a firm that specializes  in maintaining this type of information.  They indicated that Sanborn Fire Insurance maps are not available for the site.    Historical City Directories:  Actual addresses are required to conduct searches using historical street directories.  The  RCIT website indicates that addresses have not been assigned to the site.  Further, Historical Street Directories were  not requested due to the remote and undeveloped nature of much of the site and vicinity.   Chain of Title documents:  Chain of title documents were not provided prior to publication of this report and, therefore,  were not reviewed.   City Building Permits were researched via the Records Request Portal and no files for the site were found (App. D.).         County Building Permits:  The RCIT website indicates that there are no building permits on file for the site.      5.0 RECORDS REVIEW  5.1 Agency Database Search Report  A report summarizing the information available from regulatory agencies regarding sites that  generate, store, use, and/or have released hazardous materials was obtained from a firm that  specializes in maintaining a database of this type of information.  The publications reviewed in  the database search are referenced in the database report, presented in Appendix C.  The search  radii used for each list were in accordance with the US EPA AAI and ASTM E1527‐13 guidelines as  December 13, 2022  ‐ 10 ‐  File No. 305770‐001      Doc. No. 22‐12‐705  EARTH SYSTEMS PACIFIC  measured from the approximate center of the site.  Significant information obtained in the  database search is summarized below.   The site is not listed in the database report.    Sites were not found for the surrounding properties.     The database search did not find unplottable listings categorized as unmapped, due to vague  address listings or the inability of the automated search system to identify the location of the  release site.    Sites were not identified in the agency database review; therefore, RECS were not found.   5.2 California EPA, State Water Resources Control Board  The California Environmental Protection Agency [EPA], State Water Resources Control Board  [SWRCB] GeoTracker website was accessed to research records on file regarding known problems  at the site address.  The database search found no results for the site or properties in the vicinity.  5.3 California Department of Toxic Substances Control  The California Department of Toxic Substances Control [DTSC] EnviroStor website was accessed  to research records on file regarding known problems at the site address or in the site vicinity.   The database search found no results for the site or properties in the vicinity.   5.4 Tribal Records  This site is not within ¼ mile of tribal land, and therefore tribal records for the subject property  or adjoining properties were not reviewed.     5.5 Engineering and Institutional Controls   Engineering and Institutional Controls [EICs] (e.g., deed restrictions and restrictive zoning) were  not  identified  for  the  subject  site  in  the  agency  database  search report.  Engineering and  Institutional Controls to a radius of ¼ mile were not identified.    5.6 Environmental Cleanup Liens  Recorded Environmental Cleanup Liens [ECLs] on a property are indicators that contamination  exists or existed at the site.  ECLs are “encumbrances on a property for the recovery of incurred  cleanup costs on the part of a state, tribal, or federal government agency or other third party”  (EPA 2005).  In the EP’s judgment, an ECL is not likely to be an issue onsite or in the vicinity due  to lack of evidence that a release has occurred onsite.     5.7 California Department of Conservation, Geologic Energy Management Division  The California Department of Conservation, Geologic Energy Management Division [CalGEM]  maps  on  the  CalGEM  website  were  reviewed  for  information  regarding  historic  oil‐well  or  December 13, 2022  ‐ 11 ‐  File No. 305770‐001      Doc. No. 22‐12‐705  EARTH SYSTEMS PACIFIC  geothermal drilling activities near the site.  The maps and databases did not depict permitted oil  or geothermal wells within 1 mile of the site.    6.0 INTERVIEWS, GENERAL RESEARCH, AND PRIOR REPORTS  6.1 Current Owners/Occupants/Operators   A current owner of the site, Mr. Don Slaughter, was contacted by telephone regarding his  knowledge of the historical usage of the site and he provided the following information:    Mr. Don Slaughter, current owner of the site, was contacted by telephone on December 8, 2022,  regarding his knowledge of the historical usage of the site.  He  provided  the  following  information:   Mr. Slaughter stated that his father constructed the road onsite.  Aerial photographs show  the road onsite by 1972; therefore, Mr. Slaughter’s parents had purchased the site at least  by that year.   He is not aware of underground storage tanks/above ground storage tanks/vent pipes  onsite now and/or in the past.   He is not aware of any Environmental Cleanup Liens assigned to the  site  or  have  knowledge/suspicion of the release of hazardous materials onsite.   He is not aware of any previous environmental studies conducted for the site.   A  1954  aerial  photo  shows  a  small  building  near  the  north  boundary of the east  parcel.  Mr. Slaughter was unaware of how the building was used; and was not aware of  the following associated features onsite now or in the past:      o septic system  o underground and/or above ground storage tanks               o underground piping   o water well onsite or how water was sourced   6.2 Past Owners/Occupants/Operators  Contact  information  for  past  owners,  occupants,  or  operators  of the site was not readily  available.      6.3 Owners/Occupants of Neighboring Properties  The US EPA recommends that interviews with persons on adjoining properties be conducted for  properties that are “abandoned.”  The site is gated, and the client is in active developments to  acquire the site.  Therefore, the site is not considered to be abandoned and interviews of  owners/occupants of neighboring properties were not conducted.   December 13, 2022  ‐ 12 ‐  File No. 305770‐001      Doc. No. 22‐12‐705  EARTH SYSTEMS PACIFIC  6.4 California Department of Conservation – California Geological Survey  The California Department of Conservation Geologic Map of California was reviewed regarding  the geologic composition of the site.  The site is comprised of the following rock types:   1. Generalized Rock Types: grMz    General Lithology  plutonic rocks   Age      Mesozoic   Description    Mesozoic granite, quartz monzonite, granodiorite, and         quartz diorite  2. Generalized Rock Types: m   General Lithology  mixed rocks   Age      pre‐Cenozoic   Description    Undivided pre‐Cenozoic metasedimentary and meta‐  volcanic  rocks  of  great  variety.    Mostly  slate,  quartzite,  hornfels, chert, phyllite, mylonite, schist, gneiss, and minor  marble.  7.0 SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS  This report presents the findings of the Phase I Environmental Site Assessment [ESA] conducted  by Earth Systems Pacific [Earth Systems] for APNs 628‐030‐009 & 628‐030‐011, located west of  Calle De Los Campesinos, and north South Cliff Road, in Palm Desert, Riverside County, California  [the site].  We have endeavored to perform this ESA in general conformance with the scope and  limitations  of  ASTM  Practice  E1527‐13.    Exceptions  to  or  deletions  from  this  practice  are  described in Sections 1.5 and 1.6 of this report.  The purpose of this assessment was to evaluate  the site for the presence of Recognized Environmental Conditions [REC] related to the current or  past use, handling, storage, or disposal of hazardous materials or petroleum products on or near  the subject property.  This assessment has revealed no evidence of RECs in connection with this  property except as discussed in the project summary presented below.    Our  findings  and  conclusions are summarized as follows:      1. The site was observed to consist of mountainous desert terrain, characterized by a ridge  that crossed much of the south part of the site from west to east.     2. An asphalt paved road and two associated paved pads were on the south portion of the  site, generally following the ridgeline.  An unpaved trail continued westward from the end  of the paved road.  The asphalt may contain total petroleum hydrocarbons; and there is  a concern that the paved roads and pads could possibly contain hydrocarbons and heavy  metal (lead) from vehicles using leaded gasoline prior to its ban in California in 1992.  If  the road is to be removed the material should be tested for these substances.        3. Relatively new set of water valves and a fire hydrant were observed near the north  boundary of the east parcel.      4. Evidence of the onsite use, storage, or disposal of hazardous materials was not observed.  December 13, 2022  ‐ 13 ‐  File No. 305770‐001      Doc. No. 22‐12‐705  EARTH SYSTEMS PACIFIC    5. By 1954, a structure, probably a small home, had been constructed on the east parcel of  the site.  At some point after that, the structure was demolished  or  possibly  burned.  Issues that could or would be associated with older residential sites may include  the following:   septic system,    underground piping,    older lead piping remaining in the ground,    the potential for a heating fuel AST/UST to have been onsite,   buried trash, and   heavy metals (from lead‐based paint and/or termiticides) and/or OCPs (pesticides)  in the soil.     The site owner stated that he was unaware of ASTs/USTs onsite now or in the past.  Given  the remote location and age of the building site, it is unlikely that water pipes or septic  system were installed at the site; and more likely that an outhouse was used and surface  water was collected and/or carried.       Most of these potential features are more of a geotechnical concern if development of  the site includes structures or export of soil from the site.  These would be considered a  REC if public area (such as a park or seating area) were to be constructed at that location.   Other RECs at that location may include a UST and/or soil contamination.  However, it is  unlikely that a UST is present.       6. Evidence was not observed during the site visit of the presence of drums, storage tanks,  water wells, drywells, potential PCB‐containing equipment (such as transformers), sumps,  pits, ponds, lagoons, stained soil, stressed vegetation (other than due to weather), or  onsite septic system.    7. The site vicinity consists of primarily undeveloped mountainous desert terrain.  Evidence  was not observed that the site was adversely affected by activities in the site vicinity.        8. The site, site vicinity, and unplottable sites were not identified in the agency database  review.      8.0 RECOMMENDATIONS  RECs were not identified for this site.   However, further investigations  are  recommended  depending on future actions and use of the site.  These are identified as Items 2 and 5 in Section  7.  Further investigations are recommended as follows:    1. The asphalt onsite should be sampled and tested for TPH and lead if it is to be removed.  December 13, 2022  ‐ 14 ‐  File No. 305770‐001      Doc. No. 22‐12‐705  EARTH SYSTEMS PACIFIC  2.  Soil sampling should be conducted from the former structure site and analyzed for OCPs  and heavy metals (lead paint, arsenic used for pest control), if soil is to be removed from  this location, or if the location is planned as a public area.    3. A geophysical survey of the former location of a structure/possible residence near the  center of the north boundary of APN 628‐030‐011 is advised to evaluate for the presence  of underground features, such as underground piping and tanks, if construction is planned  for this location.       ‐o0o‐  December 13, 2022  ‐ 15 ‐  File No. 305770‐001      Doc. No. 22‐12‐705  EARTH SYSTEMS PACIFIC  REFERENCES    California Department of Conservation, California Geological Survey, Geologic Map of California,  Geologic Data Map No. 2, Compilation and Interpretation by: Charles W. Jennings, dated  1977, https://maps.conservation.ca.gov/cgs/gmc/, website accessed December 8, 2022.     _____,  Geologic  Energy  Management  Division  [CalGEM],  https://maps.conservation.ca.gov/doggr/wellfinder/#openModal/‐ 118.94276/37.10257/6, website accessed December 7, 2022.    California  Department  of  Toxic  Substances  Control,  EnviroStor  website,  http://www.envirostor.dtsc.ca.gov/public/default.asp, accessed December 7, 2022.     _____, Department of Water Resources [DWR], 1964, Bulletin Number 108 – Coachella Valley  Investigation, July 1964.    California  Environmental  Protection  Agency,  State  Water  Resources Control Board,  https://geotracker.waterboards.ca.gov/, website accessed December 7, 2022.    California  Statewide  Groundwater  Elevation  Monitoring  System  [CASGEM],  https://www.casgem.water.ca.gov, website accessed December 7, 2022.    City  of  Palm  Desert,  Development  Services  Planning  Division,  2022, Zoning  and  Land  Use  Interactive  Map,  https://cpd.maps.arcgis.com/apps/View/index.html?appid=179bbcfe81114c0da54b800 e9ccc0ff2, website accessed December 7, 2022.    _____,  2022,  Records  Request  Portal,   https://palmdesertca.govqa.us/WEBAPP/_rs/(S(tbjwgmhehfnpjalakb0hq4qn))/openreco rdssummary.aspx?view=1&sSessionID=, website accessed December 7, 2022.    Earth Point, 2022, Tools for Google Earth, Township and Range ‐ Public Land Survey System on  Google Earth, https://www.earthpoint.us/townships.aspx, website accessed December  6, 2022.    ERIS, Database Report, APNs 628‐030‐009 & 628‐030‐011, Calle De Los Campesinos/South Cliff  Road, Palm Desert, CA, Order Number: 22120200578, dated December 6, 2022.    _____, Fire Insurance Maps, APNs 628‐030‐009 & 628‐030‐011, Calle De Los Campesinos/South  Cliff Road, Palm Desert, CA, Order Number: 22120200578, dated December 6, 2022.    _____, Historical Aerials, APNs 628‐030‐009 & 628‐030‐011, Calle De Los Campesinos/South Cliff  Road, Palm Desert, CA, Order Number: 22120200578, dated December 6, 2022.    December 13, 2022  ‐ 16 ‐  File No. 305770‐001      Doc. No. 22‐12‐705  EARTH SYSTEMS PACIFIC  Riverside  County  Department  of  Transportation, https://rctlma.org/trans/Road‐ Maintenance/County‐Maintained‐Road‐Book,  and  https://rctlma.org/Portals/7/documents/roadbook/rbp192.pdf,  website  accessed  December 6, 2022.      Riverside County Information Technology, Riverside County Geographic Information Services,  https://gis1.countyofriverside.us/Html5Viewer/index.html?viewer=MMC_Public,   website accessed December 2, 2022.      Slaughter, Don, site owner, telephone conversation, December 8, 2022.    _____, email contact, December 8, 2022.    United States Environmental Protection Agency, 2013, 40 CFR Part 312, Standards and Practices  for All Appropriate Inquiries, Final Rule, dated November 13, 2013.  United States Geologic Survey, 7.5 minute Rancho  Mirage,  Calif. Quadrangle,  1957,  photo‐ revised 1988.       EARTH SYSTEMS PACIFIC  Appendix A    Figures  Approximate Scale: 1" = 2,000’ 0 2,000’4,000’ Figure 1 Site Location Approximate Site Boundary Base Map: USGS 7-1/2' Quadrangle, Rancho Mirage, Calif., 1957, photo-revised 1988. APNs 628-030-009 & -011 W of Calle De Los Campesinos, N of South Cliff Road Palm Desert, Riverside County, California File No.: 305770-001 Earth Systems 12/13/2022 LEGEND SITE LEGEND Figure 2 Site Layout Approximate Site Boundary Approximate Scale: 1" = 250’ 0 250 500 Reference: Google Earth, June 11, 2021 Earth Systems File No.: 305770-001 APNs 628-030-009 & -011 W of Calle De Los Campesinos, N of South Cliff Road Palm Desert, Riverside County, California Paved Road Paved Pad Paved Pad Structure RemainsRidge Ridge Structure Remains (Offsite) Hydrant Water Valves 12/13/2022 EARTH SYSTEMS PACIFIC  Appendix B    Photographs  Site Photographs Page 1 of 2 Earth Systems Photo 1: 5.18-acre parcel is mostly desert landscape, except- ing asphalt road and pad. Hiking trails throughout; minor trash. Photo 3: View of 4-acre parcel looking west from east side. Photo 5: Asphalt road that is gated. Photo 6: Asphalt road is deteriorated. Photo 4: Both pads, which can be seen on aerial map, are asphalt. View is to east. Photo 2: A north-facing view of 5.18-acre parcel. File No. 305770-00112/13/2022 APNs 628-030-009 & -011 W of Calle De Los Campesinos, N of South Cliff Road Palm Desert, Riverside County, California Asphalt PadsStorm Water Channel Storm Drain Inlet Site PhotographsEarth Systems Photo 7: Remains of structure onsite near center of north boundary of 4-acre parcel. Photo 9: Fire hydrant onsite near center of north boundary of 4-acre parcel. Photo 11: Remainder of 4-acre parcel seemed to have been graded. Fairly clean with very small amount of domestic trash. Photo 12: Remains of second structure offsite, north of 4-acre parcel. Photo 10: Water valves located near northwest corner of 4-acre parcel. Photo 8: Debris possibly from structure on 4-acre parcel. APNs 628-030-009 & -011 W of Calle De Los Campesinos, N of South Cliff Road Palm Desert, Riverside County, California Page 2 of 2File No. 305770-00112/13/2022 EARTH SYSTEMS PACIFIC  Appendix C    Agency Database Search Report   Project Property:APNs 628-030-009 & -011 Calle De Los Campesinos/South Cliff Road Palm Desert CA Project No:305770-001 Report Type:Database Report Order No: 22120200578 Requested by:Earth Systems Pacific Date Completed: December 6, 2022 2 erisinfo.com | Environmental Risk Information Services Order No: 22120200578 h-Table of Contents Notice:IMPORTANT LIMITATIONS and YOUR LIABILITY Reliance on information in Report:This report DOES NOT replace a full Phase I Environmental Site Assessment but is solely intended to be used as database review of environmental records. License for use of information in Report:No page of this report can be used without this cover page,this notice and the project property identifier. The information in Report(s)may not be modified or re-sold. Your Liability for misuse:Using this Service and/or its reports in a manner contrary to this Notice or your agreement will be in breach of copyright and contract and ERIS may obtain damages for such mis-use,including damages caused to third parties,and gives ERIS the right to terminate your account, rescind your license to any previous reports and to bar you from future use of the Service. No warranty of Accuracy or Liability for ERIS:The information contained in this report has been produced by ERIS Information Inc.("ERIS")using various sources of information,including information provided by Federal and State government departments.The report applies only to the address and up to the date specified on the cover of this report,and any alterations or deviation from this description will require a new report.This report and the data contained herein does not purport to be and does not constitute a guarantee of the accuracy of the information contained herein and does not constitute a legal opinion nor medical advice.Although ERIS has endeavored to present you with information that is accurate,ERIS disclaims,any and all liability for any errors,omissions,or inaccuracies in such information and data,whether attributable to inadvertence,negligence or otherwise,and for any consequences arising therefrom.Liability on the part of ERIS is limited to the monetary value paid for this report. Trademark and Copyright:You may not use the ERIS trademarks or attribute any work to ERIS other than as outlined above.This Service and Report (s)are protected by copyright owned by ERIS Information Inc.Copyright in data used in the Service or Report(s)(the "Data")is owned by ERIS or its licensors.The Service,Report(s)and Data may not be copied or reproduced in whole or in any substantial part without prior written consent of ERIS. Table of Contents Table of Contents...........................................................................................2 Executive Summary........................................................................................3 Executive Summary: Report Summary.......................................................................................................................4 Executive Summary: Site Report Summary - Project Property...................................................................................9 Executive Summary: Site Report Summary - Surrounding Properties......................................................................10 Executive Summary: Summary by Data Source.......................................................................................................11 Map...............................................................................................................12 Aerial.............................................................................................................15 Topographic Map..........................................................................................16 Detail Report.................................................................................................17 Unplottable Summary...................................................................................18 Unplottable Report........................................................................................19 Appendix: Database Descriptions.................................................................20 Definitions.....................................................................................................37 3 erisinfo.com | Environmental Risk Information Services Order No: 22120200578 h-Executive Summary Property Information: Project Property:APNs 628-030-009 & -011 Calle De Los Campesinos/South Cliff Road Palm Desert CA Project No:305770-001 Coordinates: Latitude:33.7072957 Longitude:-116.4020328 UTM Northing:3,729,862.74 UTM Easting:555,410.05 UTM Zone:11S Elevation:552 FT Order Information: Order No:22120200578 Date Requested:December 2, 2022 Requested by:Earth Systems Pacific Report Type:Database Report Historicals/Products: Aerial Photographs Historical Aerials Photographs ERIS Xplorer ERIS Xplorer Excel Add-On Excel Add-On Fire Insurance Maps US Fire Insurance Maps Executive Summary 4 erisinfo.com | Environmental Risk Information Services Order No: 22120200578 h-Executive Summary: Report Summary Database Searched Search Radius Project Property Within 0.12mi 0.125mi to 0.25mi 0.25mi to 0.50mi 0.50mi to 1.00mi Total Standard Environmental Records Federal rr-DOE FUSRAP-aa Y 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 rr-NPL-aa Y 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 rr-PROPOSED NPL-aa Y 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 rr-DELETED NPL-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-SEMS-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-SEMS ARCHIVE-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-ODI-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-CERCLIS-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-IODI-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-CERCLIS NFRAP-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-CERCLIS LIENS-aa Y PO 0 ---- 0 rr-RCRA CORRACTS-aa Y 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 rr-RCRA TSD-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-RCRA LQG-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 rr-RCRA SQG-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 rr-RCRA VSQG-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 rr-RCRA NON GEN-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 rr-RCRA CONTROLS-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-FED ENG-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-FED INST-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-LUCIS-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-NPL IC-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-ERNS 1982 TO 1986-aa Y PO 0 ---- 0 rr-ERNS 1987 TO 1989-aa Y PO 0 ---- 0 rr-ERNS-aa Y PO 0 ---- 0 rr-FED BROWNFIELDS-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-FEMA UST-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 DOE FUSRAP NPL PROPOSED NPL DELETED NPL SEMS SEMS ARCHIVE ODI CERCLIS IODI CERCLIS NFRAP CERCLIS LIENS RCRA CORRACTS RCRA TSD RCRA LQG RCRA SQG RCRA VSQG RCRA NON GEN RCRA CONTROLS FED ENG FED INST LUCIS NPL IC ERNS 1982 TO 1986 ERNS 1987 TO 1989 ERNS FED BROWNFIELDS FEMA UST Executive Summary: Report Summary 5 erisinfo.com | Environmental Risk Information Services Order No: 22120200578 Database Searched Search Radius Project Property Within 0.12mi 0.125mi to 0.25mi 0.25mi to 0.50mi 0.50mi to 1.00mi Total rr-FRP-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 rr-DELISTED FRP-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 rr-HIST GAS STATIONS-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 rr-REFN-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 rr-BULK TERMINAL-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 rr-SEMS LIEN-aa Y PO 0 ---- 0 rr-SUPERFUND ROD-aa Y 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 State rr-RESPONSE-aa Y 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 rr-ENVIROSTOR-aa Y 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 rr-DELISTED ENVS-aa Y 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 rr-SWF/LF-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-SWRCB SWF-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-WMUD-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-HWP-aa Y 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 rr-SWAT-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-C&D DEBRIS RECY-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-RECYCLING-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-PROCESSORS-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-CONTAINER RECY-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-LDS-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-LUST-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-DELISTED LST-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-UST-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 rr-UST CLOSURE-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-HHSS-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 rr-UST SWEEPS-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 rr-AST-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 rr-AST SWRCB-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 rr-TANK OIL GAS-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 rr-DELISTED TNK-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 rr-CERS TANK-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 rr-DELISTED CTNK-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 rr-HIST TANK-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 FRP DELISTED FRP HIST GAS STATIONS REFN BULK TERMINAL SEMS LIEN SUPERFUND ROD RESPONSE ENVIROSTOR DELISTED ENVS SWF/LF SWRCB SWF WMUD HWP SWAT C&D DEBRIS RECY RECYCLING PROCESSORS CONTAINER RECY LDS LUST DELISTED LST UST UST CLOSURE HHSS UST SWEEPS AST AST SWRCB TANK OIL GAS DELISTED TNK CERS TANK DELISTED CTNK HIST TANK 6 erisinfo.com | Environmental Risk Information Services Order No: 22120200578 Database Searched Search Radius Project Property Within 0.12mi 0.125mi to 0.25mi 0.25mi to 0.50mi 0.50mi to 1.00mi Total rr-LUR-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-CALSITES-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-HLUR-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-DEED-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-VCP-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-CLEANUP SITES-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-DELISTED CLEANUP-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-DELISTED COUNTY-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 Tribal rr-INDIAN LUST-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-INDIAN UST-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 rr-DELISTED ILST-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-DELISTED IUST-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 County rr-LOP RIVERSIDE-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-UST RIVERSIDE-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 Additional Environmental Records Federal rr-FINDS/FRS-aa Y PO 0 ---- 0 rr-TRIS-aa Y PO 0 ---- 0 rr-PFAS TRI-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-PFAS NPL-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-PFAS WATER-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-PFAS SSEHRI-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-ERNS PFAS-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-HMIRS-aa Y 0.125 0 0 --- 0 rr-NCDL-aa Y 0.125 0 0 --- 0 rr-TSCA-aa Y 0.125 0 0 --- 0 rr-HIST TSCA-aa Y 0.125 0 0 --- 0 rr-FTTS ADMIN-aa Y PO 0 ---- 0 rr-FTTS INSP-aa Y PO 0 ---- 0 rr-PRP-aa Y PO 0 ---- 0 rr-SCRD DRYCLEANER-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-ICIS-aa Y PO 0 ---- 0 LUR CALSITES HLUR DEED VCP CLEANUP SITES DELISTED CLEANUP DELISTED COUNTY INDIAN LUST INDIAN UST DELISTED ILST DELISTED IUST LOP RIVERSIDE UST RIVERSIDE FINDS/FRS TRIS PFAS TRI PFAS NPL PFAS WATER PFAS SSEHRI ERNS PFAS HMIRS NCDL TSCA HIST TSCA FTTS ADMIN FTTS INSP PRP SCRD DRYCLEANER ICIS 7 erisinfo.com | Environmental Risk Information Services Order No: 22120200578 Database Searched Search Radius Project Property Within 0.12mi 0.125mi to 0.25mi 0.25mi to 0.50mi 0.50mi to 1.00mi Total rr-FED DRYCLEANERS-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 rr-DELISTED FED DRY-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 rr-FUDS-aa Y 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 rr-FORMER NIKE-aa Y 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 rr-PIPELINE INCIDENT-aa Y PO 0 ---- 0 rr-MLTS-aa Y PO 0 ---- 0 rr-HIST MLTS-aa Y PO 0 ---- 0 rr-MINES-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 rr-SMCRA-aa Y 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 rr-MRDS-aa Y 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 rr-URANIUM-aa Y 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 rr-ALT FUELS-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 rr-CONSENT DECREES-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 rr-AFS-aa Y PO 0 ---- 0 rr-SSTS-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 rr-PCBT-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-PCB-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 State rr-DRYCLEANERS-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 rr-DELISTED DRYCLEANERS-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 rr-DRYC GRANT-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 rr-PFAS-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-PFAS GW-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-HWSS CLEANUP-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-TOXIC PITS-aa Y 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 rr-DTSC HWF-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-INSP COMP ENF-aa Y 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 rr-SCH-aa Y 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 rr-CHMIRS-aa Y PO 0 ---- 0 rr-HIST CHMIRS-aa Y PO 0 ---- 0 rr-HAZNET-aa Y PO 0 ---- 0 rr-HAZ GEN-aa Y PO 0 ---- 0 rr-HAZ TSD-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-HIST MANIFEST-aa Y PO 0 ---- 0 rr-HW TRANSPORT-aa Y 0.125 0 0 --- 0 FED DRYCLEANERS DELISTED FED DRY FUDS FORMER NIKE PIPELINE INCIDENT MLTS HIST MLTS MINES SMCRA MRDS URANIUM ALT FUELS CONSENT DECREES AFS SSTS PCBT PCB DRYCLEANERS DELISTED DRYCLEANERS DRYC GRANT PFAS PFAS GW HWSS CLEANUP TOXIC PITS DTSC HWF INSP COMP ENF SCH CHMIRS HIST CHMIRS HAZNET HAZ GEN HAZ TSD HIST MANIFEST HW TRANSPORT 8 erisinfo.com | Environmental Risk Information Services Order No: 22120200578 Database Searched Search Radius Project Property Within 0.12mi 0.125mi to 0.25mi 0.25mi to 0.50mi 0.50mi to 1.00mi Total rr-WASTE TIRE-aa Y PO 0 ---- 0 rr-MEDICAL WASTE-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 rr-HIST CORTESE-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-CDO/CAO-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-CERS HAZ-aa Y 0.125 0 0 --- 0 rr-DELISTED HAZ-aa Y 0.5 0 0 0 0 - 0 rr-GEOTRACKER-aa Y 0.125 0 0 --- 0 rr-MINE-aa Y 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 rr-LIEN-aa Y PO 0 ---- 0 rr-WASTE DISCHG-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 rr-EMISSIONS-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 rr-CDL-aa Y 0.125 0 0 --- 0 Tribal No Tribal additional environmental record sources available for this State. County rr-HWG RIVERSIDE-aa Y 0.125 0 0 --- 0 rr-HZH RIVERSIDE-aa Y 0.125 0 0 --- 0 rr-MED WST RIVERSIDE-aa Y 0.25 0 0 0 -- 0 rr-RMP RIVERSIDE-aa Y PO 0 ---- 0 Total:0 0 0 0 0 0 * PO – Property Only * 'Property and adjoining properties' database search radii are set at 0.25 miles. WASTE TIRE MEDICAL WASTE HIST CORTESE CDO/CAO CERS HAZ DELISTED HAZ GEOTRACKER MINE LIEN WASTE DISCHG EMISSIONS CDL HWG RIVERSIDE HZH RIVERSIDE MED WST RIVERSIDE RMP RIVERSIDE 9 erisinfo.com | Environmental Risk Information Services Order No: 22120200578 h-Executive Summary: Site Report Summary - Project Property Map Key DB Company/Site Name Address Direction Distance (mi/ft) Elev Diff (ft) Page Number No records found in the selected databases for the project property. Executive Summary: Site Report Summary - Project Property 10 erisinfo.com | Environmental Risk Information Services Order No: 22120200578 h-Executive Summary: Site Report Summary - Surrounding Properties Map Key DB Company/Site Name Address Direction Distance (mi/ft) Elev Diff (ft) Page Number No records found in the selected databases for the surrounding properties. Executive Summary: Site Report Summary - Surrounding Properties 11 erisinfo.com | Environmental Risk Information Services Order No: 22120200578 h-Executive Summary: Summary by Data Source No records found in the selected databases for the project property or surrounding properties. Executive Summary: Summary by Data Source ^_Palm DesertPalm DesertRancho MirageRancho MiragePalm DesertPalm Desert Pines To Palms HwyHi g h w a y 111 P orto la A v eMesaViewDrMesa V ie w D r Hi g h w a y 111 Mesa View Dr UV74 UV111 E l P a s e o H a y s t a c k R d Alamo DrB e l A ir R d Bu r s e r a Wa y C a l l i a n d r a S t S o m e r a R d G r a p e v i n e S t Sk y w a r d Wa y Q u ai l T r lAjoLnPitahaya St A m b e r S t I r o n w o o d S t BoxthornLnSouthcl i f f Rd M esaTrlVerbaSantaDrDesertLily Dr Irontree DrJoshuaTreeS t Vi st a Pa s e oShadowMountainDrP i n y o n S t H o m e s t e a d R d OasisTrl Chia DrDe e r G ra s s Dr J u n i p e r S t S a n G o rg o n i o W a y Center CtUpperway W Fo x ta i l L nCoyote RdBeav e r t a i l St Lupine LnTa m a r i s k S t EdgehillDrN View DrRacquet LnHed g e h o g St Prairie DrAnd re a s C a nyon Dr Silver Spur TrlC a r r i a g e T r l D a le a L n Salt C e d a r S tGoldenRodLn CalledelosCampesinosD e s e r t R o s e D r G o l d f l o w e r S t VerbenaRdB u c k b o a r d T r l Ti e r r a d e lO r o T u m bleweed LnCrestviewDrWi l l o w S t Opal DrPlaza WayMonterraCirNVistadeFlores Bajada Trl Vista Viejo DrHahn Canyon Way Painters Path L o m a V i s t a L n C h e ls eaCirS a n d p ip e r C ir C i t r u s C t Se g u ra C t Y u c c a C t Ocotillo DrSandpi per St Fran k F e l t r o pDrS t o n e EagleDr Ta m a r i s k S t E d gehi l l Dr Calle de los CampesinosEl P a s e o O a s i s Tr l S t o ne E ag l e G o l f C l ub B i g h or n G o l f C l u b 116°23'W116°23'30"W116°24'W116°24'30"W116°25'W 33°43'N33°43'N33°42'30"N33°42'30"N33°42'N33°42'N33°41'30"N33°41'30"N0.25 0 0.250.125 Miles Order Number: 22120200578 Map: 1.0 Mile Radius 1:18400 Ad dress: Calle De Los Campesinos/South Cliff Road, Palm Desert, CA Source: © 2021 E SRI StreetMap Premium © ERIS Information Inc. ^_Project Pro perty Bu ffer O utline #*Sites with H igher Elevation ")Sites with Same Elevation #*Sites with Lower Elevation (Sites with U nknown Elevation Areas with Higher Elevation Areas with Same Elevation Areas with Lower Elevation Areas with Unknown Elevation National Wetland Indian Reserve Land 100 Year Flood Zone 500 Year Flood Zone FWS Special Designation AreasFreeways; Highw ays Traffic Circle; Ramp Major & Minor Arterial Traffic Circle; Ramp Local Road Rail Country State Plume National Priorities List (Active, D elisted, Proposed, Institutional C ontrol) ^_ Rancho MirageRancho MiragePalm DesertPalm Desert Pines To Palms HwyUV74 S o u th c l i f f R d B e l A i r R dVi s t a Pa s e o S o m e r a R d Upperway W H o m e s t e a d R d S k y w a r d W a y H a y s t a c k R dEdgehill DrB u r s e r a W a y C a l l i a n d r a S tShadowMountainDrTierradelOro W i l l o w S t Ta m a r i s k S t A m b r o s i a S t V istadeFlo r e s D e e r G r a s s D r E a g leRdChe l s e a Cir G r a p e v i n e S tCitrus C t V i s t a M o n t e C a c tu sCtMcCormick D r Ocotillo DrFr a n k F e l t r o p Dr Thrush Rd Stone Eagle Dr CalledelosCampesinosEdgehi l l DrW i l l o w S t CA-74St o n e E a g l e G o l f C l ub 116°24'W116°24'30"W 33°42'30"N33°42'30"N33°42'N33°42'N0.1 0 0.10.05 Miles Order Number: 22120200578 Map: 0.5 Mile Radius 1:9200 Ad dress: Calle De Los Campesinos/South Cliff Road, Palm Desert, CA Source: © 2021 E SRI StreetMap Premium © ERIS Information Inc. ^_Project Pro perty Bu ffer O utline #*Sites with H igher Elevation ")Sites with Same Elevation #*Sites with Lower Elevation (Sites with U nknown Elevation Areas with Higher Elevation Areas with Same Elevation Areas with Lower Elevation Areas with Unknown Elevation National Wetland Indian Reserve Land 100 Year Flood Zone 500 Year Flood Zone FWS Special Designation AreasFreeways; Highw ays Traffic Circle; Ramp Major & Minor Arterial Traffic Circle; Ramp Local Road Rail Country State Plume National Priorities List (Active, D elisted, Proposed, Institutional C ontrol) ^_ Southcliff R d Edgehill DrCalle de los CampesinosV i s t aPaseoThrush Rd Eagle Rd 116°24'W 33°42'30"N33°42'30"N0.07 0 0.070.035 Miles Order Number: 22120200578 Map: 0.25 Mile Radius 1:4600 Ad dress: Calle De Los Campesinos/South Cliff Road, Palm Desert, CA Source: © 2021 E SRI StreetMap Premium © ERIS Information Inc. ^_Project Pro perty Bu ffer O utline #*Sites with H igher Elevation ")Sites with Same Elevation #*Sites with Lower Elevation (Sites with U nknown Elevation Areas with Higher Elevation Areas with Same Elevation Areas with Lower Elevation Areas with Unknown Elevation National Wetland Indian Reserve Land 100 Year Flood Zone 500 Year Flood Zone FWS Special Designation AreasFreeways; Highw ays Traffic Circle; Ramp Major & Minor Arterial Traffic Circle; Ramp Local Road Rail Country State Plume National Priorities List (Active, D elisted, Proposed, Institutional C ontrol) ^_ 116°23'30"W116°24'W116°24'30"W 33°43'N33°43'N33°42'30"N33°42'30"N33°42'N33°42'NSe rvice L ayer Cre dits: Source: Esri, Maxar, Ea rthstar Geog ra phics, a nd the G IS User Commu nity0.1 0 0.10.05 Miles Order Number: 22120200578Aerial 1:10000 Address: Calle De Los Campesinos/South Cliff Road, Palm Desert, CA © ERIS Info rmation Inc. Source: ESRI World Imager y Year: 2021 ^_ 116°23'W116°23'30"W116°24'W116°24'30"W116°25'W116°25'30"W 33°43'30"N33°43'30"N33°43'N33°43'N33°42'30"N33°42'30"N33°42'N33°42'N33°41'30"N33°41'30"N33°41'N33°41'N0.35 0 0.350.175 Miles Order Number: 22120200578Topographic Map 1:24000 Address: Calle De Los Campesinos/South Cliff Road, CA © ERIS Info rmation Inc. Source: USGS Topographic Map Quad rangle(s): La Quinta, CA; Rancho Mirage, CA Year: 2015 17 erisinfo.com | Environmental Risk Information Services Order No: 22120200578 h-Detail Report Map Key Number of Records Direction Distance (mi/ft) Elev/Diff (ft) Site DB No records found in the selected databases for the project property or surrounding properties. Detail Report 18 erisinfo.com | Environmental Risk Information Services Order No: 22120200578 h-Unplottable Summary Total: 0 Unplottable sites DB Company Name/Site Name Address City Zip ERIS ID No unplottable records were found that may be relevant for the search criteria. Unplottable Summary 19 erisinfo.com | Environmental Risk Information Services Order No: 22120200578 h-Unplottable Report No unplottable records were found that may be relevant for the search criteria. Unplottable Report 20 erisinfo.com | Environmental Risk Information Services Order No: 22120200578 h-Appendix: Database Descriptions Environmental Risk Information Services (ERIS) can search the following databases. The extent of historical information varies with each database and current information is determined by what is publicly available to ERIS at the time of update. ERIS updates databases as set out in ASTM Standard E1527-13 and E1527-21, Section 8.1.8 Sources of Standard Source Information: "Government information from nongovernmental sources may be considered current if the source updates the information at least every 90 days, or, for information that is updated less frequently than quarterly by the government agency, within 90 days of the date the government agency makes the information available to the public." Standard Environmental Record Sources Federal Formerly Utilized Sites Remedial Action Program:rr-DOE FUSRAP-bb The U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) established the Formerly Utilized Sites Remedial Action Program (FUSRAP) in 1974 to remediate sites where radioactive contamination remained from the Manhattan Project and early U.S. Atomic Energy Commission (AEC) operations. The DOE Office of Legacy Management (LM) established long-term surveillance and maintenance (LTS&M) requirements for remediated FUSRAP sites. DOE evaluates the final site conditions of a remediated site on the basis of risk for different future uses. DOE then confirms that LTS&M requirements will maintain protectiveness. Government Publication Date: Mar 4, 2017 National Priority List:rr-NPL-bb Sites on the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)'s National Priorities List of the most serious uncontrolled or abandoned hazardous waste sites identified for possible long-term remedial action under the Superfund program. The NPL, which EPA is required to update at least once a year, is based primarily on the score a site receives from EPA's Hazard Ranking System. A site must be on the NPL to receive money from the Superfund Trust Fund for remedial action. Sites are represented by boundaries where available in the EPA Superfund Site Boundaries maintained by the Shared Enterprise Geodata and Services (SEGS). Site boundaries represent the footprint of a whole site, the sum of all of the Operable Units and the current understanding of the full extent of contamination; for Federal Facility sites, the total site polygon may be the Facility boundary. Where there is no polygon boundary data available for a given site, the site is represented as a point. Government Publication Date: Jul 26, 2022 National Priority List - Proposed:rr-PROPOSED NPL-bb Sites proposed - by the EPA, the state agency, or concerned citizens - for addition to the NPL due to contamination by hazardous waste and identified by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) as a candidate for cleanup because it poses a risk to human health and/or the environment. Sites are represented by boundaries where available in the EPA Superfund Site Boundaries maintained by the Shared Enterprise Geodata and Services (SEGS). Site boundaries represent the footprint of a whole site, the sum of all of the Operable Units and the current understanding of the full extent of contamination; for Federal Facility sites, the total site polygon may be the Facility boundary. Where there is no polygon boundary data available for a given site, the site is represented as a point. Government Publication Date: Jul 26, 2022 Deleted NPL:rr-DELETED NPL-bb Sites deleted from the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)'s National Priorities List. The National Oil and Hazardous Substances Pollution Contingency Plan (NCP) establishes the criteria that the EPA uses to delete sites from the NPL. In accordance with 40 CFR 300.425.(e), sites may be deleted from the NPL where no further response is appropriate. Sites are represented by boundaries where available in the EPA Superfund Site Boundaries maintained by the Shared Enterprise Geodata and Services (SEGS). Site boundaries represent the footprint of a whole site, the sum of all of the Operable Units and the current understanding of the full extent of contamination; for Federal Facility sites, the total site polygon may be the Facility boundary. Where there is no polygon boundary data available for a given site, the site is represented as a point. Government Publication Date: Jul 26, 2022 DOE FUSRAP NPL PROPOSED NPL DELETED NPL Appendix: Database Descriptions 21 erisinfo.com | Environmental Risk Information Services Order No: 22120200578 SEMS List 8R Active Site Inventory:rr-SEMS-bb The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA) Superfund Program has deployed the Superfund Enterprise Management System (SEMS), which integrates multiple legacy systems into a comprehensive tracking and reporting tool. This inventory contains active sites evaluated by the Superfund program that are either proposed to be or are on the National Priorities List (NPL) as well as sites that are in the screening and assessment phase for possible inclusion on the NPL. The Active Site Inventory Report displays site and location information at active SEMS sites. An active site is one at which site assessment, removal, remedial, enforcement, cost recovery, or oversight activities are being planned or conducted. This data includes SEMS sites from the List 8R Active file as well as applicable sites from the SEMS GIS/REST file layer obtained from EPA's Facility Registry Service. Government Publication Date: Sep 28, 2022 SEMS List 8R Archive Sites:rr-SEMS ARCHIVE-bb The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA) Superfund Enterprise Management System (SEMS) Archived Site Inventory displays site and location information at sites archived from SEMS. An archived site is one at which EPA has determined that assessment has been completed and no further remedial action is planned under the Superfund program at this time. This data includes sites from the List 8R Archived site file. Government Publication Date: Sep 28, 2022 Inventory of Open Dumps, June 1985:rr-ODI-bb The Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA) provides for publication of an inventory of open dumps. The Act defines "open dumps" as facilities which do not comply with EPA's "Criteria for Classification of Solid Waste Disposal Facilities and Practices" (40 CFR 257). Government Publication Date: Jun 1985 Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation and Liability Information System - CERCLIS: rr-CERCLIS-bb Superfund is a program administered by the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to locate, investigate, and clean up the worst hazardous waste sites throughout the United States. CERCLIS is a database of potential and confirmed hazardous waste sites at which the EPA Superfund program has some involvement. It contains sites that are either proposed to be or are on the National Priorities List (NPL) as well as sites that are in the screening and assessment phase for possible inclusion on the NPL. The EPA administers the Superfund program in cooperation with individual states and tribal governments; this database is made available by the EPA. Government Publication Date: Oct 25, 2013 EPA Report on the Status of Open Dumps on Indian Lands:rr-IODI-bb Public Law 103-399, The Indian Lands Open Dump Cleanup Act of 1994, enacted October 22, 1994, identified congressional concerns that solid waste open dump sites located on American Indian or Alaska Native (AI/AN) lands threaten the health and safety of residents of those lands and contiguous areas. The purpose of the Act is to identify the location of open dumps on Indian lands, assess the relative health and environment hazards posed by those sites, and provide financial and technical assistance to Indian tribal governments to close such dumps in compliance with Federal standards and regulations or standards promulgated by Indian Tribal governments or Alaska Native entities. Government Publication Date: Dec 31, 1998 CERCLIS - No Further Remedial Action Planned:rr-CERCLIS NFRAP-bb An archived site is one at which EPA has determined that assessment has been completed and no further remedial action is planned under the Superfund program at this time. The Archive designation means that, to the best of EPA's knowledge, assessment at a site has been completed and that EPA has determined no further steps will be taken to list this site on the National Priorities List (NPL). This decision does not necessarily mean that there is no hazard associated with a given site; it only means that, based upon available information, the location is not judged to be a potential NPL site. Government Publication Date: Oct 25, 2013 CERCLIS Liens:rr-CERCLIS LIENS-bb A Federal Superfund lien exists at any property where EPA has incurred Superfund costs to address contamination ("Superfund site") and has provided notice of liability to the property owner. A Federal CERCLA ("Superfund") lien can exist by operation of law at any site or property at which EPA has spent Superfund monies. This database is made available by the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). This database was provided by the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). Refer to SEMS LIEN as the current data source for Superfund Liens. Government Publication Date: Jan 30, 2014 RCRA CORRACTS-Corrective Action:rr-RCRA CORRACTS-bb RCRA Info is EPA's comprehensive information system, providing access to data supporting the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA) of 1976 and the Hazardous and Solid Waste Amendments (HSWA) of 1984. At these sites, the Corrective Action Program ensures that cleanups occur. EPA and state regulators work with facilities and communities to design remedies based on the contamination, geology, and anticipated use unique to each site. Government Publication Date: Sep 5, 2022 SEMS SEMS ARCHIVE ODI CERCLIS IODI CERCLIS NFRAP CERCLIS LIENS RCRA CORRACTS 22 erisinfo.com | Environmental Risk Information Services Order No: 22120200578 RCRA non-CORRACTS TSD Facilities:rr-RCRA TSD-bb RCRA Info is EPA's comprehensive information system, providing access to data supporting the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA) of 1976 and the Hazardous and Solid Waste Amendments (HSWA) of 1984. This database includes Non-Corrective Action sites listed as treatment, storage and/or disposal facilities of hazardous waste as defined by the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA). Government Publication Date: Sep 5, 2022 RCRA Generator List:rr-RCRA LQG-bb RCRA Info is EPA's comprehensive information system, providing access to data supporting the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA) of 1976 and the Hazardous and Solid Waste Amendments (HSWA) of 1984. RCRA Info replaces the data recording and reporting abilities of the Resource Conservation and Recovery Information System (RCRIS) and the Biennial Reporting System (BRS). A hazardous waste generator is any person or site whose processes and actions create hazardous waste (see 40 CFR 260.10). Large Quantity Generators (LQGs) generate 1,000 kilograms per month or more of hazardous waste or more than one kilogram per month of acutely hazardous waste. Government Publication Date: Sep 5, 2022 RCRA Small Quantity Generators List:rr-RCRA SQG-bb RCRA Info is the EPA's comprehensive information system, providing access to data supporting the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA) of 1976 and the Hazardous and Solid Waste Amendments (HSWA) of 1984. RCRA Info replaces the data recording and reporting abilities of the Resource Conservation and Recovery Information System (RCRIS) and the Biennial Reporting System (BRS). A hazardous waste generator is any person or site whose processes and actions create hazardous waste (see 40 CFR 260.10). Small Quantity Generators (SQGs) generate more than 100 kilograms, but less than 1,000 kilograms, of hazardous waste per month. Government Publication Date: Sep 5, 2022 RCRA Very Small Quantity Generators List:rr-RCRA VSQG-bb RCRA Info is the EPA's comprehensive information system, providing access to data supporting the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA) of 1976 and the Hazardous and Solid Waste Amendments (HSWA) of 1984. A hazardous waste generator is any person or site whose processes and actions create hazardous waste (see 40 CFR 260.10). Very Small Quantity Generators (VSQG) generate 100 kilograms or less per month of hazardous waste, or one kilogram or less per month of acutely hazardous waste. Additionally, VSQG may not accumulate more than 1,000 kilograms of hazardous waste at any time. Government Publication Date: Sep 5, 2022 RCRA Non-Generators:rr-RCRA NON GEN-bb RCRA Info is EPA's comprehensive information system, providing access to data supporting the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA) of 1976 and the Hazardous and Solid Waste Amendments (HSWA) of 1984. RCRA Info replaces the data recording and reporting abilities of the Resource Conservation and Recovery Information System (RCRIS) and the Biennial Reporting System (BRS). A hazardous waste generator is any person or site whose processes and actions create hazardous waste (see 40 CFR 260.10). Non-Generators do not presently generate hazardous waste. Government Publication Date: Sep 5, 2022 RCRA Sites with Controls:rr-RCRA CONTROLS-bb List of Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA) facilities with institutional controls in place. RCRA gives the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) the authority to control hazardous waste from the "cradle-to-grave." This includes the generation, transportation, treatment, storage, and disposal of hazardous waste. RCRA also set forth a framework for the management of non-hazardous solid wastes. The 1986 amendments to RCRA enabled EPA to address environmental problems that could result from underground tanks storing petroleum and other hazardous substances. Government Publication Date: Sep 5, 2022 Federal Engineering Controls-ECs:rr-FED ENG-bb This list of Engineering controls (ECs) is provided by the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). ECs encompass a variety of engineered and constructed physical barriers (e.g., soil capping, sub-surface venting systems, mitigation barriers, fences) to contain and/or prevent exposure to contamination on a property. The EC listing includes remedy component data from Superfund decision documents issued in fiscal years 1982-2020 for applicable sites on the final or deleted on the National Priorities List (NPL); and sites with a Superfund Alternative Approach (SAA) Agreement in place. The only sites included that are not on the NPL; proposed for NPL; or removed from proposed NPL, are those with an SAA Agreement in place. Government Publication Date: Oct 27, 2022 RCRA TSD RCRA LQG RCRA SQG RCRA VSQG RCRA NON GEN RCRA CONTROLS FED ENG 23 erisinfo.com | Environmental Risk Information Services Order No: 22120200578 Federal Institutional Controls- ICs:rr-FED INST-bb This list of Institutional controls (ICs) is provided by the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). ICs are non-engineered instruments, such as administrative and legal controls, that help minimize the potential for human exposure to contamination and/or protect the integrity of the remedy. Although it is EPA's expectation that treatment or engineering controls will be used to address principal threat wastes and that groundwater will be returned to its beneficial use whenever practicable, ICs play an important role in site remedies because they reduce exposure to contamination by limiting land or resource use and guide human behavior at a site. The IC listing includes remedy component data from Superfund decision documents issued in fiscal years 1982-2020 for applicable sites on the final or deleted on the National Priorities List (NPL); and sites with a Superfund Alternative Approach (SAA) Agreement in place. The only sites included that are not on the NPL; proposed for NPL; or removed from proposed NPL, are those with an SAA Agreement in place. Government Publication Date: Oct 27, 2022 Land Use Control Information System:rr-LUCIS-bb The LUCIS database is maintained by the U.S. Department of the Navy and contains information for former Base Realignment and Closure (BRAC) properties across the United States. Government Publication Date: Sep 1, 2006 Institutional Control Boundaries at NPL sites:rr-NPL IC-bb Boundaries of Institutional Control areas at sites on the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)'s National Priorities List, or Proposed or Deleted, made available by the EPA's Shared Enterprise Geodata and Services (SEGS). United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)'s National Priorities List of the most serious uncontrolled or abandoned hazardous waste sites identified for possible long-term remedial action under the Superfund program. Institutional controls are non-engineered instruments such as administrative and legal controls that help minimize the potential for human exposure to contamination and/or protect the integrity of the remedy. Government Publication Date: Jul 26, 2022 Emergency Response Notification System:rr-ERNS 1982 TO 1986-bb Database of oil and hazardous substances spill reports controlled by the National Response Center. The primary function of the National Response Center is to serve as the sole national point of contact for reporting oil, chemical, radiological, biological, and etiological discharges into the environment anywhere in the United States and its territories. Government Publication Date: 1982-1986 Emergency Response Notification System:rr-ERNS 1987 TO 1989-bb Database of oil and hazardous substances spill reports controlled by the National Response Center. The primary function of the National Response Center is to serve as the sole national point of contact for reporting oil, chemical, radiological, biological, and etiological discharges into the environment anywhere in the United States and its territories. Government Publication Date: 1987-1989 Emergency Response Notification System:rr-ERNS-bb Database of oil and hazardous substances spill reports made available by the United States Coast Guard National Response Center (NRC). The NRC fields initial reports for pollution and railroad incidents and forwards that information to appropriate federal/state agencies for response. These data contain initial incident data that has not been validated or investigated by a federal/state response agency. Government Publication Date: Aug 28, 2022 The Assessment, Cleanup and Redevelopment Exchange System (ACRES) Brownfield Database:rr-FED BROWNFIELDS-bb Brownfields are real property, the expansion, redevelopment, or reuse of which may be complicated by the presence or potential presence of a hazardous substance, pollutant, or contaminant. Cleaning up and reinvesting in these properties protects the environment, reduces blight, and takes development pressures off greenspaces and working lands. This data is provided by the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and includes Brownfield sites from the Cleanups in My Community (CIMC) web application. Government Publication Date: Sep 13, 2022 FEMA Underground Storage Tank Listing:rr-FEMA UST-bb The Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) of the Department of Homeland Security maintains a list of FEMA owned underground storage tanks. Government Publication Date: Dec 31, 2017 FED INST LUCIS NPL IC ERNS 1982 TO 1986 ERNS 1987 TO 1989 ERNS FED BROWNFIELDS FEMA UST 24 erisinfo.com | Environmental Risk Information Services Order No: 22120200578 Facility Response Plan:rr-FRP-bb List of facilities that have submitted Facility Response Plans (FRP) to EPA. Facilities that could reasonably be expected to cause "substantial harm" to the environment by discharging oil into or on navigable waters are required to prepare and submit Facility Response Plans (FRPs). Harm is determined based on total oil storage capacity, secondary containment and age of tanks, oil transfer activities, history of discharges, proximity to a public drinking water intake or sensitive environments. Government Publication Date: Dec 31, 2021 Delisted Facility Response Plans:rr-DELISTED FRP-bb Facilities that once appeared in - and have since been removed from - the list of facilities that have submitted Facility Response Plans (FRP) to EPA. Facilities that could reasonably be expected to cause "substantial harm" to the environment by discharging oil into or on navigable waters are required to prepare and submit Facility Response Plans (FRPs). Harm is determined based on total oil storage capacity, secondary containment and age of tanks, oil transfer activities, history of discharges, proximity to a public drinking water intake or sensitive environments. Government Publication Date: Dec 31, 2021 Historical Gas Stations:rr-HIST GAS STATIONS-bb This historic directory of service stations is provided by the Cities Service Company. The directory includes Cities Service filling stations that were located throughout the United States in 1930. Government Publication Date: Jul 1, 1930 Petroleum Refineries:rr-REFN-bb List of petroleum refineries from the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) Refinery Capacity Report. Includes operating and idle petroleum refineries (including new refineries under construction) and refineries shut down during the previous year located in the 50 States, the District of Columbia, Puerto Rico, the Virgin Islands, Guam, and other U.S. possessions. Survey locations adjusted using public data. Government Publication Date: Aug 30, 2022 Petroleum Product and Crude Oil Rail Terminals:rr-BULK TERMINAL-bb List of petroleum product and crude oil rail terminals made available by the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA). Includes operable bulk petroleum product terminals located in the 50 States and the District of Columbia with a total bulk shell storage capacity of 50,000 barrels or more, and/or the ability to receive volumes from tanker, barge, or pipeline; also rail terminals handling the loading and unloading of crude oil that were active between 2017 and 2018. Petroleum product terminals comes from the EIA-815 Bulk Terminal and Blender Report, which includes working, shell in operation, and shell idle for several major product groupings. Survey locations adjusted using public data. Government Publication Date: Feb 4, 2022 LIEN on Property:rr-SEMS LIEN-bb The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA) Superfund Enterprise Management System (SEMS) provides Lien details on applicable properties, such as the Superfund lien on property activity, the lien property information, and the parties associated with the lien. Government Publication Date: Sep 28, 2022 Superfund Decision Documents:rr-SUPERFUND ROD-bb This database contains a listing of decision documents for Superfund sites. Decision documents serve to provide the reasoning for the choice of (or) changes to a Superfund Site cleanup plan. The decision documents include Records of Decision (ROD), ROD Amendments, Explanations of Significant Differences (ESD), along with other associated memos and files. This information is maintained and made available by the US EPA (Environmental Protection Agency). Government Publication Date: Sep 28, 2022 State State Response Sites:rr-RESPONSE-bb A list of identified confirmed release sites where the Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC) is involved in remediation, either in a lead or oversight capacity. These confirmed release sites are generally high-priority and high potential risk. This database is state equivalent NPL. Government Publication Date: Oct 17, 2022 EnviroStor Database:rr-ENVIROSTOR-bb The EnviroStor Data Management System is made available by the Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC). Includes Corrective Action sites, Tiered Permit sites, Historical Sites and Evaluation/Investigation sites. This database is state equivalent CERCLIS. Government Publication Date: Oct 17, 2022 FRP DELISTED FRP HIST GAS STATIONS REFN BULK TERMINAL SEMS LIEN SUPERFUND ROD RESPONSE ENVIROSTOR 25 erisinfo.com | Environmental Risk Information Services Order No: 22120200578 Delisted State Response Sites:rr-DELISTED ENVS-bb Sites removed from the list of State Response Sites made available by the EnviroStor Data Management System, Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC). Government Publication Date: Oct 17, 2022 Solid Waste Information System (SWIS):rr-SWF/LF-bb The Solid Waste Information System (SWIS) database made available by the Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery (CalRecycle) contains information on solid waste facilities, operations, and disposal sites throughout the State of California. The types of facilities found in this database include landfills, transfer stations, material recovery facilities, composting sites, transformation facilities, waste tire sites, and closed disposal sites. Government Publication Date: Aug 3, 2022 Solid Waste Disposal Sites with Waste Constituents Above Hazardous Waste Levels:rr-SWRCB SWF-bb This is a list of solid waste disposal sites identified by California State Water Resources Control Board with waste constituents above hazardous waste levels outside the waste management unit. Government Publication Date: Sep 20, 2006 Waste Management Unit Database:rr-WMUD-bb The Waste Management Unit Database System tracks and inventories waste management units. CCR Title 27 contains criteria stating that Waste Management Units are classified according to their ability to contain wastes. Containment shall be determined by geology, hydrology, topography, climatology, and other factors relating to the ability of the Unit to protect water quality. Water Code Section 13273.1 requires that operators submit a water quality solid waste assessment test (SWAT) report to address leak status. The WMUDS was last updated by the State Water Resources control board in 2000. Government Publication Date: Jan 1, 2000 EnviroStor Hazardous Waste Facilities:rr-HWP-bb A list of hazardous waste facilities including permitted, post-closure and historical facilities found in the Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC) EnviroStor database. Government Publication Date: Oct 17, 2022 Sites Listed in the Solid Waste Assessment Test (SWAT) Program Report:rr-SWAT-bb In a 1993 Memorandum of Understanding, the State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB) agreed to submit a comprehensive report on the Solid Waste Assessment Test (SWAT) Program to the California Integrated Waste Management Board (CIWMB). This report summarizes the work completed to date on the SWAT Program, and addresses both the impacts that leakage from solid waste disposal sites (SWDS) may have upon waters of the State and the actions taken to address such leakage. Government Publication Date: Dec 31, 1995 Construction and Demolition Debris Recyclers:rr-C&D DEBRIS RECY-bb This listing of Construction and Demolition Debris Recyclers is maintained by the California Intergrated Waste Management Board-common C&D materials include lumber, drywall, metals, masonry (brick, concrete, etc.), carpet, plastic, pipe, rocks, dirt, paper, cardboard, or green waste related to land development. Government Publication Date: Jun 20, 2018 Recycling Centers:rr-RECYCLING-bb This list of Certified Recycling Centers that are operating under the state of California's Beverage Container Recycling Program is maintained by the California Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery. Government Publication Date: Oct 11, 2022 Listing of Certified Processors:rr-PROCESSORS-bb This list of Certified Processors that are operating under the state of California's Beverage Container Recycling Program is maintained by the California Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery. Government Publication Date: Oct 11, 2022 Listing of Certified Dropoff, Collection, and Community Service Programs:rr-CONTAINER RECY-bb This list of Certified Dropoff, Collection, and Community Service Programs (non-buyback) operating under the state of California's Beverage Container Recycling Program is maintained by the California Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery. Government Publication Date: Oct 11, 2022 DELISTED ENVS SWF/LF SWRCB SWF WMUD HWP SWAT C&D DEBRIS RECY RECYCLING PROCESSORS CONTAINER RECY 26 erisinfo.com | Environmental Risk Information Services Order No: 22120200578 Land Disposal Sites:rr-LDS-bb Land Disposal Sites in GeoTracker, the State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB)'s data management system. The Land Disposal program regulates of waste discharge to land for treatment, storage and disposal in waste management units. Waste management units include waste piles, surface impoundments, and landfills. Government Publication Date: Jul 25, 2022 Leaking Underground Fuel Tank Reports:rr-LUST-bb List of Leaking Underground Storage Tanks within the Cleanup Sites data in GeoTracker database. GeoTracker is the State Water Resources Control Board's (SWRCB) data management system for managing sites that impact groundwater, especially those that require groundwater cleanup (Underground Storage Tanks, Department of Defense and Site Cleanup Program) as well as permitted facilities such as operating Underground Storage Tanks. The Leak Prevention Program that overlooks LUST sites is the SWRCB in California's Environmental Protection Agency. Government Publication Date: Jul 25, 2022 Delisted Leaking Storage Tanks:rr-DELISTED LST-bb List of Leaking Underground Storage Tanks (LUST) cleanup sites removed from GeoTracker, the State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB)'s database system, as well as sites removed from the SWRCB's list of UST Case closures. Government Publication Date: Jul 25, 2022 Permitted Underground Storage Tank (UST) in GeoTracker:rr-UST-bb List of Permitted Underground Storage Tank (UST) sites made available by the State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB) in California's Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). Government Publication Date: Jul 20, 2022 Proposed Closure of Underground Storage Tank Cases:rr-UST CLOSURE-bb List of UST cases that are being considered for closure by either the California Environmental Protection Agency, State Water Resources Control Board or the Executive Director that have been posted for a 60-day public comment period. Government Publication Date: May 5, 2021 Historical Hazardous Substance Storage Information Database:rr-HHSS-bb The Historical Hazardous Substance Storage database contains information collected in the 1980s from facilities that stored hazardous substances. The information was originally collected on paper forms, was later transferred to microfiche, and recently indexed as a searchable database. When using this database, please be aware that it is based upon self-reported information submitted by facilities which has not been independently verified. It is unlikely that every facility responded to the survey and the database should not be expected to be a complete inventory of all facilities that were operating at that time. This database is maintained by the California State Water Resources Control Board's (SWRCB) Geotracker. Government Publication Date: Aug 27, 2015 Statewide Environmental Evaluation and Planning System:rr-UST SWEEPS-bb The Statewide Environmental Evaluation and Planning System (SWEEPS) is a historical listing of active and inactive underground storage tanks made available by the California State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB). Government Publication Date: Oct 1, 1994 Aboveground Storage Tanks:rr-AST-bb A statewide list from 2009 of aboveground storage tanks (ASTs) made available by the Cal FIRE Office of the State Fire Marshal (OSFM). This list is no longer maintained or updated by the Cal FIRE OSFM. Government Publication Date: Aug 31, 2009 SWRCB Historical Aboveground Storage Tanks:rr-AST SWRCB-bb A list of aboveground storage tanks made available by the California State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB). Effective January 1, 2008, the Certified Unified Program Agencies (CUPAs) are vested with the responsibility and authority to implement the Aboveground Petroleum Storage Act (APSA). Government Publication Date: Dec 1, 2007 Oil and Gas Facility Tanks:rr-TANK OIL GAS-bb Locations of oil and gas tanks that fall under the jurisdiction of the Geologic Energy Management Division of the California Department of Conservation (CalGEM) (CCR 1760). CalGEM was formerly the Division of Oil, Gas, and Geothermal Resources (DOGGR). Government Publication Date: Oct 6, 2022 LDS LUST DELISTED LST UST UST CLOSURE HHSS UST SWEEPS AST AST SWRCB TANK OIL GAS 27 erisinfo.com | Environmental Risk Information Services Order No: 22120200578 Delisted Storage Tanks:rr-DELISTED TNK-bb This database contains a list of storage tank sites that were removed by the State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB) in California's Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and the Cal FIRE Office of State Fire Marshal (OSFM). Government Publication Date: Oct 6, 2022 California Environmental Reporting System (CERS) Tanks:rr-CERS TANK-bb List of sites in the California Environmental Protection Agency (CalEPA) Regulated Site Portal which fall under the Aboveground Petroleum Storage and Underground Storage Tank regulatory programs. The CalEPA oversees the statewide implementation of the Unified Program which applies regulatory standards to protect Californians from hazardous waste and materials. Government Publication Date: Oct 7, 2022 Delisted California Environmental Reporting System (CERS) Tanks:rr-DELISTED CTNK-bb This database contains a list of Aboveground Petroleum Storage and Underground Storage Tank sites that were removed from in the California Environmental Protection Agency (CalEPA) Regulated Site Portal. Government Publication Date: Oct 7, 2022 Historical Hazardous Substance Storage Container Information - Facility Summary:rr-HIST TANK-bb The State Water Resources Control Board maintained the Hazardous Substance Storage Containers listing and inventory in th 1980s. This facility summary lists historic tank sites where the following container types were present: farm motor vehicle fuel tanks; waste tanks; sumps; pits, ponds, lagoons, and others; and all other product tanks. This set, published in May 1988, lists facility and owner information, as well as the number of containers. This data is historic and will not be updated. Government Publication Date: May 27, 1988 Site Mitigation and Brownfields Reuse Program Facility Sites with Land Use Restrictions:rr-LUR-bb The Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC) Site Mitigation and Brownfields Reuse Program (SMBRP) list includes sites cleaned up under the program's oversight and generally does not include current or former hazardous waste facilities that required a hazardous waste facility permit. The list represents land use restrictions that are active. Some sites have multiple land use restrictions. Government Publication Date: Oct 17, 2022 CALSITES Database:rr-CALSITES-bb This historical database was maintained by the Department of Toxic Substance Control (DTSC) for more than a decade. CALSITES contains information on Brownfield properties with confirmed or potential hazardous contamination. In 2006, DTSC introduced EnviroStor as the latest Brownfields site database. Government Publication Date: May 1, 2004 Hazardous Waste Management Program Facility Sites with Deed / Land Use Restrictions:rr-HLUR-bb The Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC) Hazardous Waste Management Program (HWMP) has developed a list of current or former hazardous waste facilities that have a recorded land use restriction at the local county recorder's office. The land use restrictions on this list were required by the DTSC HWMP as a result of the presence of hazardous substances that remain on site after the facility (or part of the facility) has been closed or cleaned up. The types of land use restriction include deed notice, deed restriction, or a land use restriction that binds current and future owners. Government Publication Date: Feb 18, 2021 Deed Restrictions and Land Use Restrictions:rr-DEED-bb List of Deed Restrictions, Land Use Restrictions and Covenants in GeoTracker made available by the State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB) in California's Environmental Protection Agency. A deed restriction (land use covenant) may be required to facilitate the remediation of past environmental contamination and to protect human health and the environment by reducing the risk of exposure to residual hazardous materials. Government Publication Date: Jul 25, 2022 Voluntary Cleanup Program:rr-VCP-bb List of sites in the Voluntary Cleanup Program made available by the Department of Toxic Substances and Control (DTSC). The Voluntary Cleanup Program was designed to respond to lower priority sites. Under the Voluntary Cleanup Program, DTSC enters site-specific agreements with project proponents for DTSC oversight of site assessment, investigation, and/or removal or remediation activities, and the project proponents agree to pay DTSC's reasonable costs for those services. Government Publication Date: Oct 17, 2022 GeoTracker Cleanup Program Sites:rr-CLEANUP SITES-bb A list of Cleanup Program sites in the state of California made available by The State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB) of the California Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). SWRCB tracks leaking underground storage tank cleanups as well as other water board cleanups. DELISTED TNK CERS TANK DELISTED CTNK HIST TANK LUR CALSITES HLUR DEED VCP CLEANUP SITES 28 erisinfo.com | Environmental Risk Information Services Order No: 22120200578 Government Publication Date: Jul 25, 2022 Delisted Cleanup Program Sites:rr-DELISTED CLEANUP-bb A list of Cleanup Program sites which were once included - and have since been removed from - the list of Cleanup Program Sites in GeoTracker. GeoTracker is the State Water Resource Control Boards' data management system for sites that impact, or have the potential to impact, water quality in California, with emphasis on groundwater. Government Publication Date: Jul 25, 2022 Delisted County Records:rr-DELISTED COUNTY-bb Records removed from county or CUPA databases. Records may be removed from the county lists made available by the respective county departments because they are inactive, or because they have been deemed to be below reportable thresholds. Government Publication Date: Nov 29, 2022 Tribal Leaking Underground Storage Tanks (LUSTs) on Indian Lands:rr-INDIAN LUST-bb LUSTs on Tribal/Indian Lands in Region 9, which includes California. Government Publication Date: Apr 8, 2022 Underground Storage Tanks (USTs) on Indian Lands:rr-INDIAN UST-bb USTs on Tribal/Indian Lands in Region 9, which includes California. Government Publication Date: Apr 8, 2022 Delisted Tribal Leaking Storage Tanks:rr-DELISTED ILST-bb Leaking Underground Storage Tank facilities which have been removed from the Regional Tribal LUST lists made available by the EPA. Government Publication Date: Apr 9, 2022 Delisted Tribal Underground Storage Tanks:rr-DELISTED IUST-bb Underground Storage Tank facilities which have been removed from the Regional Tribal UST lists made available by the EPA. Government Publication Date: Apr 20, 2022 County Riverside County - Local Oversight Program List:rr-LOP RIVERSIDE-bb A list of Leaking Underground Storage Tank (LUST) facilities in Riverside County. This list is made available by Riverside County Department of Environmental Health. Environmental Cleanup Program provides oversight of assessments and cleanups at properties that have been, or may have been, contaminated with hazardous substances from LUSTs or releases associated with other commercial/industrial use. Government Publication Date: Jul 5, 2022 Riverside County - Underground Storage Tanks List:rr-UST RIVERSIDE-bb A list of registered Underground Storage Tank (UST) sites in Riverside County. This list is made available by Riverside County Department of Environmental Health. The Hazardous Materials Management Branch (HMMB) regulates and oversees the inspections of constructions, repairs, upgrades, system operation and removal of UST systems. Government Publication Date: Jul 5, 2022 Additional Environmental Record Sources Federal Facility Registry Service/Facility Index:rr-FINDS/FRS-bb DELISTED CLEANUP DELISTED COUNTY INDIAN LUST INDIAN UST DELISTED ILST DELISTED IUST LOP RIVERSIDE UST RIVERSIDE FINDS/FRS 29 erisinfo.com | Environmental Risk Information Services Order No: 22120200578 The Facility Registry Service (FRS) is a centrally managed database that identifies facilities, sites, or places subject to environmental regulations or of environmental interest. FRS creates high-quality, accurate, and authoritative facility identification records through rigorous verification and management procedures that incorporate information from program national systems, state master facility records, and data collected from EPA's Central Data Exchange registrations and data management personnel. This list is made available by the Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA). Government Publication Date: Nov 2, 2020 Toxics Release Inventory (TRI) Program:rr-TRIS-bb The EPA's Toxics Release Inventory (TRI) is a database containing data on disposal or other releases of over 650 toxic chemicals from thousands of U. S. facilities and information about how facilities manage those chemicals through recycling, energy recovery, and treatment. One of TRI's primary purposes is to inform communities about toxic chemical releases to the environment. Government Publication Date: Aug 24, 2021 Perfluorinated Alkyl Substances (PFAS) Releases:rr-PFAS TRI-bb List of Toxics Release Inventory (TRI) facilities at which the reported chemical is a Per- or polyfluorinated alkyl substance (PFAS) included in the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)'s consolidated PFAS Master List of PFAS Substances. The EPA's Toxics Release Inventory (TRI) is a database containing data on disposal or other releases of over 650 toxic chemicals from thousands of U.S. facilities and information about how facilities manage those chemicals through recycling, energy recovery, and treatment. Government Publication Date: Aug 24, 2021 PFOA/PFOS Contaminated Sites:rr-PFAS NPL-bb List of National Priorities List (NPL) and related Superfund Alternative Agreement (SAA) sites where PFOA or PFOS contaminants have been found in water and/or soil. The site listing is provided by the Federal Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). Government Publication Date: Oct 4, 2022 Perfluorinated Alkyl Substances (PFAS) Water Quality:rr-PFAS WATER-bb The Water Quality Portal (WQP) is a cooperative service sponsored by the United States Geological Survey (USGS), the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), and the National Water Quality Monitoring Council (NWQMC). This listing includes records from the Water Quality Portal where the characteristic (environmental measurement) is in the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)'s consolidated PFAS Master List of PFAS Substances. Government Publication Date: Jul 20, 2020 SSEHRI PFAS Contamination Sites:rr-PFAS SSEHRI-bb This PFAS Contamination Site Tracker database is compiled by the Social Science Environmental Health Research Institute (SSEHRI) at Northeastern University. According to the SSEHRI, the database records qualitative and quantitative data from each known site of PFAS contamination, including timeline of discovery, sources, levels, health impacts, community response, and government response. The goal of this database is to compile information and support public understanding of the rapidly unfolding issue of PFAS contamination. All data presented was extracted from government websites, news articles, or publicly available documents, and this is cited in the tracker. Disclaimer: The source conveys this database undergoes regular updates as new information becomes available, some sites may be missing and/or contain information that is incorrect or outdated, as well as their information represents all contamination sites SSEHRI is aware of, not all possible contamination sites. This data is not intended to be used for legal purposes. Limited location details are available with this data. Access the following for the most current informations https://pfasproject.com/pfas- contamination-site-tr acker/ Government Publication Date: Dec 12, 2019 National Response Center PFAS Spills:rr-ERNS PFAS-bb National Response Center (NRC) calls from 1990 to the most recent complete calendar year where there is indication of Aqueous Film Forming Foam (AFFF) usage. NRC calls may reference AFFF usage in the "Material Involved" or "Incident Description" fields. Data made available by the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). Disclaimer: dataset may include initial or misidentified incident data not yet validated or investigated by a federal/state response agency.  Government Publication Date: Feb 23, 2022 Hazardous Materials Information Reporting System:rr-HMIRS-bb US DOT - Department of Transportation Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA) Incidents Reports Database taken from Hazmat Intelligence Portal, U.S. Department of Transportation. Government Publication Date: Sep 1, 2020 National Clandestine Drug Labs:rr-NCDL-bb The U.S. Department of Justice ("the Department"), Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA), provides this data as a public service. It contains addresses of some locations where law enforcement agencies reported they found chemicals or other items that indicated the presence of either clandestine drug laboratories or dumpsites. In most cases, the source of the entries is not the Department, and the Department has not verified the entry and does not guarantee its accuracy. TRIS PFAS TRI PFAS NPL PFAS WATER PFAS SSEHRI ERNS PFAS HMIRS NCDL 30 erisinfo.com | Environmental Risk Information Services Order No: 22120200578 Government Publication Date: Aug 30, 2022 Toxic Substances Control Act:rr-TSCA-bb The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) is amending the Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA) section 8(a) Inventory Update Reporting (IUR) rule and changing its name to the Chemical Data Reporting (CDR) rule. The CDR enables EPA to collect and publish information on the manufacturing, processing, and use of commercial chemical substances and mixtures (referred to hereafter as chemical substances) on the TSCA Chemical Substance Inventory (TSCA Inventory). This includes current information on chemical substance production volumes, manufacturing sites, and how the chemical substances are used. This information helps the Agency determine whether people or the environment are potentially exposed to reported chemical substances. EPA publishes submitted CDR data that is not Confidential Business Information (CBI). Government Publication Date: Apr 11, 2019 Hist TSCA:rr-HIST TSCA-bb The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) is amending the Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA) section 8(a) Inventory Update Reporting (IUR) rule and changing its name to the Chemical Data Reporting (CDR) rule. The 2006 IUR data summary report includes information about chemicals manufactured or imported in quantities of 25,000 pounds or more at a single site during calendar year 2005. In addition to the basic manufacturing information collected in previous reporting cycles, the 2006 cycle is the first time EPA collected information to characterize exposure during manufacturing, processing and use of organic chemicals. The 2006 cycle also is the first time manufacturers of inorganic chemicals were required to report basic manufacturing information. Government Publication Date: Dec 31, 2006 FTTS Administrative Case Listing:rr-FTTS ADMIN-bb An administrative case listing from the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, & Rodenticide Act (FIFRA) and Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA), together known as FTTS. This database was obtained from the Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA) National Compliance Database (NCDB). The FTTS and NCDB was shut down in 2006. Government Publication Date: Jan 19, 2007 FTTS Inspection Case Listing:rr-FTTS INSP-bb An inspection case listing from the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, & Rodenticide Act (FIFRA) and Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA), together known as FTTS. This database was obtained from the Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA) National Compliance Database (NCDB). The FTTS and NCDB was shut down in 2006. Government Publication Date: Jan 19, 2007 Potentially Responsible Parties List:rr-PRP-bb Early in the site cleanup process, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) conducts a search to find the Potentially Responsible Parties (PRPs). The EPA looks for evidence to determine liability by matching wastes found at the site with parties that may have contributed wastes to the site. This listing contains PRPs, Noticed Parties, at sites in the EPA's Superfund Enterprise Management System (SEMS). Government Publication Date: Sep 28, 2022 State Coalition for Remediation of Drycleaners Listing:rr-SCRD DRYCLEANER-bb The State Coalition for Remediation of Drycleaners (SCRD) was established in 1998, with support from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Office of Superfund Remediation and Technology Innovation. Coalition members are states with mandated programs and funding for drycleaner site remediation. Current members are Alabama, Connecticut, Florida, Illinois, Kansas, Minnesota, Missouri, North Carolina, Oregon, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, and Wisconsin. Since 2017, the SCRD no longer maintains this data, refer to applicable state source data where available. Government Publication Date: Nov 08, 2017 Integrated Compliance Information System (ICIS):rr-ICIS-bb The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency's Enforcement and Compliance History Online system incorporates data from the Integrated Compliance Information System - National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (ICIS-NPDES). ICIS-NPDES is an information management system maintained by the Office of Compliance to track permit compliance and enforcement status of facilities regulated by the NPDES under the Clean Water Act. This data includes permit, inspection, violation and enforcement action information for applicable ICIS records. Government Publication Date: Oct 15, 2022 Drycleaner Facilities:rr-FED DRYCLEANERS-bb A list of drycleaner facilities from Enforcement and Compliance History Online (ECHO) online search. The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) tracks facilities that possess NAIC and SIC codes that classify businesses as drycleaner establishments. Government Publication Date: Jun 25, 2022 TSCA HIST TSCA FTTS ADMIN FTTS INSP PRP SCRD DRYCLEANER ICIS FED DRYCLEANERS 31 erisinfo.com | Environmental Risk Information Services Order No: 22120200578 Delisted Drycleaner Facilities:rr-DELISTED FED DRY-bb List of sites removed from the list of Drycleaner Facilities (sites in the EPA's Integrated Compliance Information System (ICIS) with NAIC or SIC codes identifying the business as a drycleaner establishment). Government Publication Date: Jun 25, 2022 Formerly Used Defense Sites:rr-FUDS-bb Formerly Used Defense Sites (FUDS) are properties that were formerly owned by, leased to, or otherwise possessed by and under the jurisdiction of the Secretary of Defense prior to October 1986, where the Department of Defense (DOD) is responsible for an environmental restoration. The FUDS Annual Report to Congress (ARC) is published by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE). This data is compiled from the USACE's Geospatial FUDS data layers and Homeland Infrastructure Foundation-Level Data (HIFLD) FUDS dataset. Government Publication Date: Jul 12, 2022 Former Military Nike Missile Sites:rr-FORMER NIKE-bb This information was taken from report DRXTH-AS-IA-83A016 (Historical Overview of the Nike Missile System, 12/1984) which was performed by Environmental Science and Engineering, Inc. for the U.S. Army Toxic and Hazardous Materials Agency Assessment Division. The Nike system was deployed between 1954 and the mid-1970's. Among the substances used or stored on Nike sites were liquid missile fuel (JP-4); starter fluids (UDKH, aniline, and furfuryl alcohol); oxidizer (IRFNA); hydrocarbons (motor oil, hydraulic fluid, diesel fuel, gasoline, heating oil); solvents (carbon tetrachloride, trichloroethylene, trichloroethane, stoddard solvent); and battery electrolyte. The quantities of material a disposed of and procedures for disposal are not documented in published reports. Virtually all information concerning the potential for contamination at Nike sites is confined to personnel who were assigned to Nike sites. During deactivation most hardware was shipped to depot-level supply points. There were reportedly instances where excess materials were disposed of on or near the site itself at closure. There was reportedly no routine site decontamination. Government Publication Date: Dec 2, 1984 PHMSA Pipeline Safety Flagged Incidents:rr-PIPELINE INCIDENT-bb A list of flagged pipeline incidents made available by the U.S. Department of Transportation (US DOT) Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA). PHMSA regulations require incident and accident reports for five different pipeline system types. Government Publication Date: Jul 7, 2020 Material Licensing Tracking System (MLTS):rr-MLTS-bb A list of sites that store radioactive material subject to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) licensing requirements. This list is maintained by the NRC. As of September 2016, the NRC no longer releases location information for sites. Site locations were last received in July 2016. Government Publication Date: May 11, 2021 Historic Material Licensing Tracking System (MLTS) sites:rr-HIST MLTS-bb A historic list of sites that have inactive licenses and/or removed from the Material Licensing Tracking System (MLTS). In some cases, a site is removed from the MLTS when the state becomes an "Agreement State". An Agreement State is a State that has signed an agreement with the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) authorizing the State to regulate certain uses of radioactive materials within the State. Government Publication Date: Jan 31, 2010 Mines Master Index File:rr-MINES-bb The Master Index File (MIF) is provided by the United State Department of Labor, Mine Safety and Health Administration (MSHA). This file, which was originally created in the 1970's, contained many Mine-IDs that were invalid. MSHA removes invalid IDs from the MIF upon discovery. MSHA applicable data includes the following: all Coal and Metal/Non-Metal mines under MSHA's jurisdiction since 1/1/1970; mine addresses for all mines in the database except for Abandoned mines prior to 1998 from MSHA's legacy system (addresses may or may not correspond with the physical location of the mine itself); violations that have been assessed penalties as a result of MSHA inspections beginning on 1/1/2000; and violations issued as a result of MSHA inspections conducted beginning on 1/1/2000. Government Publication Date: Aug 3, 2022 Surface Mining Control and Reclamation Act Sites:rr-SMCRA-bb An inventory of land and water impacted by past mining (primarily coal mining) is maintained by the Office of Surface Mining Reclamation and Enforcement (OSMRE) to provide information needed to implement the Surface Mining Control and Reclamation Act of 1977 (SMCRA). The inventory contains information on the location, type, and extent of Abandoned Mine Land (AML) impacts, as well as information on the cost associated with the reclamation of those problems. The inventory is based upon field surveys by State, Tribal, and OSMRE program officials. It is dynamic to the extent that it is modified as new problems are identified and existing problems are reclaimed. Government Publication Date: Aug 18, 2022 Mineral Resource Data System:rr-MRDS-bb DELISTED FED DRY FUDS FORMER NIKE PIPELINE INCIDENT MLTS HIST MLTS MINES SMCRA MRDS 32 erisinfo.com | Environmental Risk Information Services Order No: 22120200578 The Mineral Resource Data System (MRDS) is a collection of reports describing metallic and nonmetallic mineral resources throughout the world. Included are deposit name, location, commodity, deposit description, geologic characteristics, production, reserves, resources, and references. This database contains the records previously provided in the Mineral Resource Data System (MRDS) of USGS and the Mineral Availability System/Mineral Industry Locator System (MAS/MILS) originated in the U.S. Bureau of Mines, which is now part of USGS. The USGS has ceased systematic updates of the MRDS database with their focus more recently on deposits of critical minerals while providing a well-documented baseline of historical mine locations from USGS topographic maps. Government Publication Date: Mar 15, 2016 DOE Legacy Management Sites:rr-URANIUM-bb The U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Office of Legacy Management (LM) currently manages radioactive and chemical waste, environmental contamination, and hazardous material at over 100 sites across the U.S. The LM manages sites with diverse regulatory drivers (statutes or programs that direct cleanup and management requirements at DOE sites) or as part of internal DOE or congressionally-recognized programs, such as but not limited to: Formerly Utilized Sites Remedial Action Program (FUSRAP), Uranium Mill Tailings Radiation Control Act (UMTRCA Title I, Tile II), Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA), Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA), Decontamination and Decommissioning (D&D), Nuclear Waste Policy Act (NWPA). This site listing includes data exported from the DOE Office of LM' s Geospatial Environmental Mapping System (GEMS). GEMS Data disclaimer: The DOE Office of LM makes no representation or warranty, expressed or implied, regarding the use, accuracy, availability, or completeness of the data presented herein. Government Publication Date: Jun 21, 2022 Alternative Fueling Stations:rr-ALT FUELS-bb This list of alternative fueling stations is sourced from the Alternative Fuels Data Center (AFDC). The U.S. Department of Energy's Office of Energy Efficiency & Renewable Energy launched the AFDC in 1991 as a repository for alternative fuel vehicle performance data, which provides a wealth of information and data on alternative and renewable fuels, advanced vehicles, fuel-saving strategies, and emerging transportation technologies. The data includes Biodiesel (B20 and above), Compressed Natural Gas (CNG), Electric, Ethanol (E85), Hydrogen, Liquefied Natural Gas (LNG), Propane (LPG) fuel type locations. Government Publication Date: Oct 10, 2022 Superfunds Consent Decrees:rr-CONSENT DECREES-bb This list of Superfund consent decrees is provided by the Department of Justice, Environment & Natural Resources Division (ENRD) through a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) applicable file. This listing includes Consent Decrees for CERCLA or Superfund Sites filed and/or as proposed within the ENRD's Case Management System (CMS) since 2010. CMS may not reflect the latest developments in a case nor can the agency guarantee the accuracy of the data. ENRD Disclaimer: Congress excluded three discrete categories of law enforcement and national security records from the requirements of the FOIA; response is limited to those records that are subject to the requirements of the FOIA; however, this should not be taken as an indication that excluded records do, or do not, exist. Government Publication Date: Sep 15, 2022 Air Facility System:rr-AFS-bb This EPA retired Air Facility System (AFS) dataset contains emissions, compliance, and enforcement data on stationary sources of air pollution. Regulated sources cover a wide spectrum; from large industrial facilities to relatively small operations such as dry cleaners. AFS does not contain data on facilities that are solely asbestos demolition and/or renovation contractors, or landfills. ECHO Clean Air Act data from AFS are frozen and reflect data as of October 17, 2014; the EPA retired this system for Clean Air Act stationary sources and transitioned to ICIS-Air. Government Publication Date: Oct 17, 2014 Registered Pesticide Establishments:rr-SSTS-bb List of active EPA-registered foreign and domestic pesticide-producing and device-producing establishments based on data from the Section Seven Tracking System (SSTS). The Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act (FIFRA) Section 7 requires that facilities producing pesticides, active ingredients, or devices be registered. The list of establishments is made available by the EPA. Government Publication Date: Mar 30, 2022 Polychlorinated Biphenyl (PCB) Transformers:rr-PCBT-bb Locations of Transformers Containing Polychlorinated Biphenyls (PCBs) registered with the United States Environmental Protection Agency. PCB transformer owners must register their transformer(s) with EPA. Although not required, PCB transformer owners who have removed and properly disposed of a registered PCB transformer may notify EPA to have their PCB transformer de-registered. Data made available by EPA. Government Publication Date: Oct 15, 2019 Polychlorinated Biphenyl (PCB) Notifiers:rr-PCB-bb Facilities included in the national list of facilities that have notified the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) of Polychlorinated Biphenyl (PCB) activities. Any company or person storing, transporting or disposing of PCBs or conducting PCB research and development must notify the EPA and receive an identification number. URANIUM ALT FUELS CONSENT DECREES AFS SSTS PCBT PCB 33 erisinfo.com | Environmental Risk Information Services Order No: 22120200578 Government Publication Date: Jul 28, 2022 State Dry Cleaning Facilities:rr-DRYCLEANERS-bb A list of drycleaner related facilities that have EPA ID numbers. These are facilities with certain SIC codes: power laundries, family and commercial, linen supply, commercial laundry, dry cleaning and pressing machines - Coin Operated Laundry and Dry Cleaning. This is provided by the Department of Toxic Substance Control. Government Publication Date: Dec 20, 2021 Delisted Drycleaners:rr-DELISTED DRYCLEANERS-bb Sites removed from the list of drycleaner related facilities that have EPA ID numbers, made available by the California Department of Toxic Substance Control. Government Publication Date: Feb 28, 2020 Non-Toxic Dry Cleaning Incentive Program:rr-DRYC GRANT-bb A list of grant recipients of the Non-Toxic Dry Cleaning Incentive Program made available by the California Air Resources Board (CARB). The program provides grants to eligible dry cleaning businesses to assist them in transitioning away from PERC machines to alternative non-toxic and non-smog forming technologies. Government Publication Date: Feb 28, 2020 Per- and Polyfluoroalkyl Substances (PFAS):rr-PFAS-bb List of FAA Part 139 Airports, Selected Landfills, and Chrome Plating Facilities from California Water Boards PFAS Investigations, as well as sites from the State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB)'s GeoTracker at which one or more of the potential contaminants of concern are in the PFAS Master List of PFAS Substances made available by the Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA). Government Publication Date: Feb 15, 2022 PFOA/PFOS Groundwater:rr-PFAS GW-bb A list of water wells from the Groundwater Ambient Monitoring and Assessment Program (GAMA) Groundwater Information System with the groundwater chemical perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA) (NL = 0.014 UG/L) or perfluorooctanoic sulfonate (PFOS) (NL = 0.013 UG/L). The GAMA Groundwater Information System search is made available by California Water Boards. Government Publication Date: Aug 27, 2022 Hazardous Waste and Substances Site List - Site Cleanup:rr-HWSS CLEANUP-bb The Hazardous Waste and Substances Sites (Cortese) List is a planning document used by the State, local agencies and developers to comply with the California Environmental Quality Act requirements in providing information about the location of hazardous materials release sites. This list is published by California Department of Toxic Substance Control. Government Publication Date: May 20, 2021 Toxic Pit Cleanup Act Sites:rr-TOXIC PITS-bb The Toxic Pits Cleanup Act (TPCA) list identifies sites suspected of containing hazardous substances where cleanup has not yet been completed. This list was maintained by the State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB), is not longer maintained, and updates are not planned. Government Publication Date: Jul 1, 1995 List of Hazardous Waste Facilities Subject to Corrective Action:rr-DTSC HWF-bb This is a list of hazardous waste facilities identified in Health and Safety Code (HSC) § 25187.5. These facilities are those where Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC) has taken or contracted for corrective action because a facility owner/operator has failed to comply with a date for taking corrective action in an order issued under HSC § 25187, or because DTSC determined that immediate corrective action was necessary to abate an imminent or substantial endangerment. Government Publication Date: Jul 18, 2016 EnviroStor Inspection, Compliance, and Enforcement:rr-INSP COMP ENF-bb A list of permitted facilities with inspections and enforcements tracked in the Department of Toxic Substance Control (DTSC) EnviroStor. Government Publication Date: Apr 29, 2021 School Property Evaluation Program Sites:rr-SCH-bb DRYCLEANERS DELISTED DRYCLEANERS DRYC GRANT PFAS PFAS GW HWSS CLEANUP TOXIC PITS DTSC HWF INSP COMP ENF SCH 34 erisinfo.com | Environmental Risk Information Services Order No: 22120200578 A list of sites registered with The Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC) School Property Evaluation and Cleanup (SPEC) Division. SPEC is responsible for assessing, investigating and cleaning up proposed school sites. The Division ensures that selected properties are free of contamination or, if the properties were previously contaminated, that they have been cleaned up to a level that protects the students and staff who will occupy the new school. Government Publication Date: Oct 17, 2022 California Hazardous Material Incident Report System (CHMIRS):rr-CHMIRS-bb A list of reported hazardous material incidents, spills, and releases from the California Hazardous Material Incident Report System (CHMIRS). This list has been made available by the California Office of Emergency Services (OES). Government Publication Date: Aug 15, 2022 Historical California Hazardous Material Incident Report System (CHMIRS):rr-HIST CHMIRS-bb A list of reported hazardous material incidents, spills, and releases from the California Hazardous Material Incident Report System (CHMIRS) prior to 1993. This list has been made available by the California Office of Emergency Services (OES). Government Publication Date: Jan 1, 1993 Handlers from Hazardous Waste Manifest Data:rr-HAZNET-bb A list of handlers not otherwise classified as Treatment, Storage, Disposal facilities (TSDF) or generators from the facilities and manifests data made available by the California Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC) in their Hazardous Waste Tracking System (HWTS). Government Publication Date: Oct 24, 2016 Generators from Hazardous Waste Manifest Data:rr-HAZ GEN-bb List of handlers listed as having generated waste from the facilities and manifests data made available by the California Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC) in their Hazardous Waste Tracking System (HWTS). Government Publication Date: Dec 31, 2017 TSDF from Hazardous Waste Manifest Data:rr-HAZ TSD-bb List of Treatment, Storage, and Disposal Facilities (TSDFs) from the facilities and manifests data made available by the California Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC) in their Hazardous Waste Tracking System (HWTS). Government Publication Date: Dec 31, 2017 Historical Hazardous Waste Manifest Data:rr-HIST MANIFEST-bb A list of historic hazardous waste manifests received by the Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC) from year the 1980 to 1992. The volume of manifests is typically 900,000 - 1,000,000 annually, representing approximately 450,000 - 500,000 shipments. Government Publication Date: Dec 31, 1992 DTSC Registered Hazardous Waste Transporters:rr-HW TRANSPORT-bb The California Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC) maintains this list of Registered Hazardous Waste Transporters. Government Publication Date: Sep 6, 2022 Registered Waste Tire Haulers:rr-WASTE TIRE-bb This list of registered waste tire haulers is maintained by the California Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery. Government Publication Date: Oct 11, 2022 California Medical Waste Management Program Facility List:rr-MEDICAL WASTE-bb This list of Medical Waste Management Program Facilities is maintained by the California Department of Public Health. The Medical Waste Management Program (MWMP) regulates the generation, handling, storage, treatment, and disposal of medical waste by providing oversight for the implementation of the Medical Waste Management Act (MWMA). The MWMP permits and inspects all medical waste off-site treatment facilities, medical waste transporters, and medical waste transfer stations. This list contains transporters, treatment, and transfer facilities. Government Publication Date: Oct 31, 2022 Historical Cortese List:rr-HIST CORTESE-bb List of sites which were once included on the Cortese list. The Hazardous Waste and Substances Sites (Cortese) List is a planning document used by the State, local agencies and developers to comply with the California Environmental Quality Act requirements for providing information about the location of hazardous sites. Government Publication Date: Nov 13, 2008 CHMIRS HIST CHMIRS HAZNET HAZ GEN HAZ TSD HIST MANIFEST HW TRANSPORT WASTE TIRE MEDICAL WASTE HIST CORTESE 35 erisinfo.com | Environmental Risk Information Services Order No: 22120200578 Cease and Desist Orders and Cleanup and Abatement Orders:rr-CDO/CAO-bb The California Environment Protection Agency "Cortese List" of active Cease and Desist Orders (CDO) and Cleanup and Abatement Orders (CAO). This list contains many CDOs and CAOs that do NOT concern the discharge of wastes that are hazardous materials. Many of the listed orders concern, as examples, discharges of domestic sewage, food processing wastes, or sediment that do not contain hazardous materials, but the Water Boards' database does not distinguish between these types of orders. Government Publication Date: Dec 6, 2021 California Environmental Reporting System (CERS) Hazardous Waste Sites:rr-CERS HAZ-bb List of sites in the California Environmental Protection Agency (CalEPA) Regulated Site Portal which fall under the following regulatory programs: Hazardous Chemical Management, Hazardous Waste Onsite Treatment, Household Hazardous Waste Collection, Hazardous Waste Generator, RCRA LQ HW Generator. The CalEPA oversees the statewide implementation of the Unified Program which applies regulatory standards to protect Californians from hazardous waste and materials. Government Publication Date: Oct 7, 2022 Delisted Environmental Reporting System (CERS) Hazardous Waste Sites:rr-DELISTED HAZ-bb This database contains a list of sites that were removed from the California Environmental Protection Agency (CalEPA) in the following regulatory programs: Hazardous Chemical Management, Hazardous Waste Onsite Treatment, Household Hazardous Waste Collection, Hazardous Waste Generator, RCRA LQ HW Generator. Government Publication Date: Nov 29, 2018 Sites in GeoTracker:rr-GEOTRACKER-bb GeoTracker is the State Water Resource Control Boards' data management system for sites that impact, or have the potential to impact, water quality in California, with emphasis on groundwater. This is a list of sites in GeoTracker that aren't otherwise categorized as LUST, Land Disposal Sites (LDS), Cleanup Sites, or sites having Waste Discharge Requirements (WDR). This listing includes program types such as Underground Injection Control (UIC), Confined Animal Facilities (CAF), Irrigated Lands Regulatory Program, plans, and non-case information. Government Publication Date: Jul 25, 2022 Mines Listing:rr-MINE-bb This list includes mine site locations extracted from the Mines Online database, maintained by the California Department of Conservation. Mines Online (MOL) is an interactive web map designed with GIS features that provide information such as the mine name, mine status, commodity sold, location, and other mine specific data. Please note: Mine location information is provided to assist experts in determining the location of mine operators in accordance with California Civil Code section 1103.4 and reflects information reported by mine operators in annual reports provided under Public Resources Code section 2207. While the Division of Mine Reclamation (DMR) attempts to populate MOL with accurate location information, the DMR cannot guarantee the accuracy of operator reported location information. Government Publication Date: Jun 23, 2022 Recorded Environmental Cleanup Liens:rr-LIEN-bb The California Department of Toxic Substance Control (DTSC) maintains this list of liens placed upon real properties. A lien is utilized by the DTSC to obtain reimbursement from responsible parties for costs associated with the remediation of contaminated properties. Government Publication Date: Aug 3, 2022 Waste Discharge Requirements:rr-WASTE DISCHG-bb List of sites in California State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB) Waste Discharge Requirements (WDRs) Program in California, made available by the SWRCB via GeoTracker. The WDR program regulates point discharges that are exempt pursuant to Subsection 20090 of Title 27 and not subject to the Federal Water Pollution Control Act. The scope of the WDRs Program also includes the discharge of wastes classified as inert, pursuant to section 20230 of Title 27. Government Publication Date: Jul 25, 2022 Toxic Pollutant Emissions Facilities:rr-EMISSIONS-bb A list of criteria and toxic pollutant emissions data for facilities in California made available by the California Environmental Protection Agency - Air Resources Board (ARB). Risk data may be based on previous inventory submittals. The toxics data are submitted to the ARB by the local air districts as requirement of the Air Toxics "Hot Spots" Program. This program requires emission inventory updates every four years. Government Publication Date: Dec 31, 2020 Clandestine Drug Lab Sites:rr-CDL-bb The Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC) maintains a listing of drug lab sites. DTSC is responsible for removal and disposal of hazardous substances discovered by law enforcement officials while investigating illegal/clandestine drug laboratories. Government Publication Date: Jan 19, 2021 CDO/CAO CERS HAZ DELISTED HAZ GEOTRACKER MINE LIEN WASTE DISCHG EMISSIONS CDL 36 erisinfo.com | Environmental Risk Information Services Order No: 22120200578 Tribal No Tribal additional environmental record sources available for this State. County Riverside County - Hazardous Waste Generator Sites List:rr-HWG RIVERSIDE-bb A list of Hazardous Waste Generator Sites in the County of Riverside. This list is made available by Riverside County Department of Environmental Health which has been designated as the CUPA for the County. Government Publication Date: Jul 5, 2022 Riverside County - Disclosure Facility List:rr-HZH RIVERSIDE-bb A list of facilities disclosed to Riverside County Department of Environmental Health (DEH). This list is made available by Riverside County DEH which has been designated as the CUPA for the County. A business is required to establish and submit a Business Plan if the facility handles hazardous material equal to or greater than 55 gallons, 500 pounds or 200 cubic feet at any time during the year. Government Publication Date: Jul 5, 2022 Riverside County - Medical Waste Facilities:rr-MED WST RIVERSIDE-bb This list of active and inactive medical waste facilities is maintained by the County of Riverside Department of Environmental Health. Government Publication Date: Feb 9, 2022 Riverside County - California Accidental Release Prevention Program Sites:rr-RMP RIVERSIDE-bb This list of Riverside County California Accidental Release Prevention Program sites is maintained by the County of Riverside Department of Environmental Health. AB 3777 was enacted in 1986 to minimize potential emergencies involving acutely hazardous materials by requiring facilities which handle these materials to submit Risk Management Prevention Plans. The Riverside County Department of Environmental Health Hazardous Materials Branch began implementation of this Program County-wide in January 1991. All cities within Riverside County are included in this list. Government Publication Date: Jul 5, 2022 HWG RIVERSIDE HZH RIVERSIDE MED WST RIVERSIDE RMP RIVERSIDE 37 erisinfo.com | Environmental Risk Information Services Order No: 22120200578 h-Definitions Database Descriptions:This section provides a detailed explanation for each database including:source,information available,time coverage,and acronyms used.They are listed in alphabetic order. Detail Report:This is the section of the report which provides the most detail for each individual record.Records are summarized by location,starting with the project property followed by records in closest proximity. Distance:The distance value is the distance between plotted points,not necessarily the distance between the sites'boundaries.All values are an approximation. Direction: The direction value is the compass direction of the site in respect to the project property and/or center point of the report. Elevation:The elevation value is taken from the location at which the records for the site address have been plotted.All values are an approximation. Source:Google Elevation API. Executive Summary:This portion of the report is divided into 3 sections: 'Report Summary'-Displays a chart indicating how many records fall on the project property and,within the report search radii. 'Site Report Summary'-Project Property'-This section lists all the records which fall on the project property.For more details,see the 'Detail Report' section. 'Site Report Summary-Surrounding Properties'-This section summarizes all records on adjacent properties,listing them in order of proximity from the project property.For more details,see the 'Detail Report'section. Map Key:The map key number is assigned according to closest proximity from the project property.Map Key numbers always start at #1.The project property will always have a map key of '1'if records are available.If there is a number in brackets beside the main number,this will indicate the number of records on that specific property.If there is no number in brackets,there is only one record for that property. The symbol and colour used indicates 'elevation':the red inverted triangle will dictate 'ERIS Sites with Lower Elevation',the yellow triangle will dictate 'ERIS Sites with Higher Elevation'and the orange square will dictate 'ERIS Sites with Same Elevation.' Unplottables:These are records that could not be mapped due to various reasons,including limited geographic information.These records may or may not be in your study area,and are included as reference. Definitions Project Property: Project No: Requested By: Order No: Date Completed: APNs 628-030-009 & -011 Calle De Los Campesinos/South Cliff Road Palm Desert CA 305770-001 Earth Systems Pacific 22120200578 December 03, 2022 Please note that no information was found for your site or adjacent properties. EARTH SYSTEMS PACIFIC  Appendix D    Additional Documentation   See All FAQs  Home FAQs Submit a Request My Records Center Search By Reference Number Login How do I get copies of resolutions, minutes and/or agendas? How do I request copies of building plans/drawings for my home or business? How long do I have to wait for a response? How do I get a copy of all the HOAs in the City? How do I get a copy of my business license? RECORDS REQUEST PORTAL FAQs   Export As: Public Records Request Archive Instructions Click column headers to organize the information in ascending or descending order. Perform a keyword search by utilizing the textbox underneath the column header. Scroll pages by using the numeric page values found both on the top and bottom of the archive. FILTER YOUR SEARCH: Request Number  Create Date  Summary  Request Status  Details   No data to display Search for keywords 628-030-011, 628-030-009  REQUEST NUMBER  CREATE DATE FROM (MM/DD/YYYY) 01/01/1962 CREATE DATE TO (MM/DD/YYYY) 12/31/1996 Closed Requests FILTER Riverside County Parcel Report APN(s):628030009,628030011 DISCLAIM ER Maps, permit information and data are to be used for reference purposes only. Map features are approximate, and are not necessarily accurate to surveying or engineering standards. The County of Riverside makes no warranty or guarantee as to the content (the source is often third party), accuracy, timeliness, or completeness of any of the data provided, and assumes no legal responsibility for the information contained on this map. Any use of this product with respect to accuracy and precision shall be the sole responsibility of the user. M APS/IM AGES PARCEL APN 628-030-009-0, 628-030- 011-1 Supervisorial District Boundaries for Districts 2, 4 and 5 will be updated in January, 2023. Boundaries for Districts 1 and 3 will be updated in January, 2025. V MANUEL PEREZ, DISTRICT 4 Previous APN 628030009 628030011 Township/Range T5SR6E SEC 30 N Owner Name NOT AVAILABLE ONLINE Elevation 582 ft Address Thomas Bros. Map Page/Grid PAGE: 848, GRID: C3 PAGE: 848, GRID: D3 Mailing Address 628030009 PO BOX 9552 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92658 628030011 PO BOX 9552 NEWPORT BEACH CA 92658 Indian Tribal Land NOT IN A TRIBAL LAND page 1 of 5 12/2/2022 12:30:31 PM Legal Description 628030009 Recorded Book/Page: / Subdivsion Name: Lot/Parcel: Block: Tract Number: 628030011 Recorded Book/Page: / Subdivsion Name: Lot/Parcel: Block: Tract Number: City Boundary PALM DESERT City Spheres of influence NOT IN A CITY SPHERE Lot Size 628030009 Recorded lot size is 5.18 acres 628030011 Recorded lot size is 4.00 acres March Joint Powers Authority NOT IN THE JURISDICTION OF THE MARCH JOINT POWERS AUTHORITY Property Characteristcs 628030009 Year Constructed: Baths: Bedrooms: Construction Type: Garage Type: Property Area (sq ft): Roof Type: Stories: Pool: NO Central Cool: NO Central Heat: NO 628030011 Year Constructed: Baths: Bedrooms: Construction Type: Garage Type: Property Area (sq ft): Roof Type: Stories: Pool: NO Central Cool: NO Central Heat: NO County Service Area NOT IN A COUNTY SERVICE AREA Annexation Date N/A LAFCO Case N/A Proposals N/A PLANNING more... Specific Plans NOT IN A SPECIFIC PLAN Historic Preservation Districts NOT IN A HISTORIC PRESERVATION page 2 of 5 12/2/2022 12:30:31 PM DISTRICT Land Use Designations CITY Agricultural Preserve NOT IN AN AGRICULTRAL PRESERVE General Plan Policy Overlays N/A Area Plan (RCIP)Western Coachella Valley Airport Influence Areas NOT IN AN AIRPORT INFLUENCE AREA General Plan Policy Areas NOT IN A GENERAL PLAN POLICY AREA Airport Compatibility Zones NOT IN AN AIRPORT COMPATIBLITY AREA Zoning Classifications (ORD. 348)CHECK WITH THE CITY FOR MORE INFORMATION Zoning Districts and Zoning Areas NOT IN A ZONING DISTRICT/AREA Zoning Overlays NOT IN A ZONING OVERLAY Community Advisory Councils NOT IN A COMMUNITY ADVISORY COUNCIL Enviromental Justice Communities NOT IN AN ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE COMMUNITY Residential Permit Stats N/A ENVIRONMENTAL more... CVMSHCP (Coachella Valley Multi-Species Habitat Conservation Plan) Plan Area COACHELLA VALLEY WRMSHCP (Western Riverside County Multi- Species Habitat Conservation Plan) Cell Group NOT IN A CELL GROUP CVMSHCP (Coachella Valley Multi-Species Habitat Conservation Plan) Conservation Area NOT COACHELLA VALLEY CONSERVATION AREA WRMSHCP Cell Number NOT IN A CELL NUMBER CVMSHCP Fluvial Sand Transport Special Provision Areas NOT IN A FLUVIAL SAND TRANSPORT SPECIAL PROVISION AREA HANS/ERP (Habitat Acquisition and Negotiation Strategy/Expedited Review Process) NOT IN A HANS/ERP PROJECT WRMSHCP (Western Riverside County Multi- Species Habitat Conservation Plan) Plan Area NOT IN A WESTERN RIVERSIDE COUNTY PLAN FEE AREA Vegetation (2005)NOT IN A VEGETATION AREA Fire Fire Hazard Classification (Ord. 787)NOT IN A FIRE HAZARD ZONE Fire Responsibility Area NOT IN A FIRE RESPONSIBILITY AREA DEVELOPMENT FEES CVMSHCP (Coachella Valley Multi-Species Habitat Conservation Plan) Fee Area (Ord 875) COACHELLA VALLEY RBBD (Road & Bridge Benefit District) NOT IN A ROAD BRIDGE BENEFIT DISTRICT WRMSHCP (Western Riverside County Multi-Species Habitat Conservation Plan) Fee Area (Ord. 810) NOT IN A WESTERN RIVERSIDE COUNTY PLAN FEE AREA DIF (Development Impact Fee Area Ord. 659) WESTERN COACHELLA VALLEY, AREA 2 Western TUMF (Transportation Uniform Mitigation Fee Ord. 824) NOT IN THE WESTERN TUMF FEE AREA SKR Fee Area (Stephen’s Kagaroo Rat Ord. 663.10) NOT IN THE SKR FEE AREA Eastern TUMF (Transportation Uniform Mitigation Fee Ord. 673) IN OR PARTIALLY WITHIN A TUMF FEE AREA DA (Development Agreements)NOT IN A DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT TRANSPORTATION more... Circulation Element Ultimate Right-of-Way NOT IN A CIRCULATION ELEMENT RIGHT-OF-WAY Road Book Page 192 Transportation Agreements NOT IN A TRANS AGREEMENT CETAP (Community and Environmental Transportation Acceptability Process) Corridors NOT IN A CETAP CORRIDOR HYDROLOGY page 3 of 5 12/2/2022 12:30:31 PM Flood Plan Review OUTSIDE FLOODPLAIN, REVIEW NOT REQUIRED Watershed WHITEWATER Water District COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DISTRICT Flood Control District NOT IN A FLOOD CONTROL DISTRICT GEOLOGIC Fault Zone NOT IN A FAULT ZONE Paleontological Sensitivity LOW POTENTIAL (L): FOLLOWING A LITERATURE SEARCH, RECORDS CHECK AND A FIELD SURVEY, AREAS MAY BE DETERMINED BY A QUALIFIED VERTEBRATE PALEONTOLOGIST AS HAVING LOW POTENTIAL FOR CONTAINING SIGNIFICANT PALEONTOLOGICAL RESOURCES SUBJECT TO ADVERSE IMPACTS.Faults NOT IN A FAULT LINE Liquefaction Potential MODERATE Subsidence SUSCEPTIBLE MISCELLANEOUS School District DESERT SANDS UNIFIED Communities PALM DESERT Lighting (Ord. 655)ZONE: B Census Tract 451.24 Farmland OTHER LANDS Special Notes WITHIN THE SANTA ROSA AND SAN JACINTO NATIONAL MONUMENT Tax Rate Areas 018003 - CITRUS PEST CONTROL 2 018003 - CITY OF PALM DESERT 018003 - CO FREE LIBRARY 018003 - CO STRUCTURE FIRE PROTECTION 018003 - COACHELLA VALLEY JOINT BLO HS 018003 - COACHELLA VALLEY PUBLIC CEMETERY 018003 - COACHELLA VALLEY REC & PK 018003 - COACHELLA VALLEY RESOURCE CONS 018003 - COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DISTRICT 018003 - CSA 152 018003 - CV MOSQUITO & VECTOR CONTROL 018003 - CVWD IMP DIST 6 018003 - DESERT COMMUNITY COLLEGE 018003 - DESERT SANDS UNIFIED SCHOOL 018003 - GENERAL 018003 - GENERAL PURPOSE 018003 - RIV CO REGIONAL PARK & OPEN SP 018003 - RIVERSIDE CO OFC OF EDUCATION Department of Enviromental Health Permits Se ptic Pe r mits Record Id Application Date Plan Check Approved Date Final Inspection Date Approved Date N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A We ll Wate r Pe rmits Record Id PE Permit Paid Date Permit Approved Date Well Finaled Date N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A PLUS PERMITS & CASES Administr ativ e Case s Case Case De scription Status page 4 of 5 12/2/2022 12:30:31 PM N/A N/A N/A Building and Safe ty Case s Case Case De scription Status N/A N/A N/A Code Case s Case Case De scription Status N/A N/A N/A Fire Case s Case Case De scription Status N/A N/A N/A Planning Case s Case Case De scription Status N/A N/A N/A Sur v e y Case s Case Case De scription Status N/A N/A N/A Tr ansportation Case s Case Case De scription Status N/A N/A N/A page 5 of 5 12/2/2022 12:30:31 PM EARTH SYSTEMS PACIFIC  Appendix E    Qualifications Statement  EARTH SYSTEMS PACIFIC  Earth Systems Pacific  Qualifications Statement for Environmental Work    The principals of the Earth Systems companies have been consulting for an average of over 20 years,  and the combined staff numbers nearly 100. Earth Systems’ multidisciplinary professional staff has  extensive experience with and education in chemistry, geology, geophysics, hydrogeology, mechanical  engineering, civil engineering, mapping, soil science, drafting, and surveying. Our senior project and  staff  professionals  include  Certified  Engineering  Geologists,  Registered  Geologists,  Registered  Environmental Assessors and Professional Engineers. These professionals are highly qualified, holding  an average of two registrations and/or certifications in their area of expertise. To continue to meet our  commitment to technical expertise, Earth Systems considers it essential to train our personnel in the  latest  scientific  advancements  in  assessment  and  mitigation  techniques.  This  involves  continuing  education in the form of training seminars, literature reviews, and pertinent conferences to remain  abreast of recent developments in this complex and rapidly changing field.  The Environmental Professional [EP] who provided oversight for this project meets the qualifications  specified by US EPA AAI and ASTM E1527‐13. An EP is defined by US EPA AAI as ”a person who possesses  sufficient specific education, training, and experience necessary to exercise professional judgment to  develop opinions and conclusions regarding conditions indicative of releases or threatened releases (of  hazardous substances) on, at, in, or to a property, sufficient to meet the objectives and performance  factors (of the rule).” In addition, an environmental professional must have:   A state, tribal, or territory‐issued certification or license (Professional Engineer or Professional  Geologist) and three years of relevant full‐time work experience; or    A Baccalaureate degree or higher in science or engineering and five years of relevant full‐time  work experience; or    Ten years of relevant full‐time work experience.  The attached resumes describe the credentials of the professionals who performed field, research  and/or report preparation work on the project.         Earth Systems Resume      Alexander Schriener Jr., P.G.   Associate Geologist  Mr. Schriener has over thirty‐seven years as an alternative energy, natural  resource and environmental geologist.  He has seven years consulting  experience specifically in the field of environmental geology.  Mr. Schriener  also manages geothermal energy services for Earth Systems.      Key Qualifications:  Mr. Schriener experience performing Phase I Environmental Site  Assessments to evaluate the potential presence of soil and groundwater  contamination at industrial, commercial, residential and agricultural  properties, as well as vacant land.  He has performed Phase II Investigations  to evaluate whether contamination is actually present, and the  concentration and extent of those contaminants.  If contaminates are found,  then site remediation is required.  Mr. Schriener has successfully performed  numerous Phase III site remediation and brought sites to closure with public  agencies.    Mr. Schriener has over thirty years’ experience in geothermal resource  management, development and exploration.  Mr. Schriener has also been an expert witness in legal proceedings involving  geothermal energy management and well drilling.    Relevant Project Experience:  Gasoline Station Investigation and Closure   Mr. Schriener was project manager for an assessment of gasoline stations  with potential leaking underground storage tanks.  He placed monitoring  wells, completed groundwater and soil assessments and successfully got  agency closure on 5 of 7 sites he was managed between 2004 and 2008.     Phase II Site Assessments and Phase III Site Closure   Mr. Schriener was project manager on numerous Phase II site assessments  in the Coachella Valley and southern California.  At each site, he selected the  investigative methods, oversaw sampling and analysis activities, reviewed  the laboratory data, and prepared a report meeting the requirements of the  lender or agency.  If contamination was found, Mr. Schriener prepared a  work plan to mitigate the site and obtain closure.  Significant sites that were  evaluated and closure was obtained included several parcels of farm land  over 20 acres each, a metal salvage yard, an industrial warehouse, a former  cattle ranch and former sewage treatment facility.    Geothermal Exploration and Development   Mr. Schriener over thirty years’ experience in geothermal energy including  geology, geochemistry, geophysics, drilling, reservoir modeling, land  leasing, exploration, and field development.  He has managed the resource  staff and activities in the three major geothermal fields in California: The  Geysers, Coso and The Salton Sea, as well as Desert Peak in Nevada and  Roosevelt/Blundell in Utah.  Mr. Schriener has regularly managed an annual  drilling and resource department budget of over $10 Million.     .  REGISTRATIONS AND CERTIFICATIONS  Professional Geologist, State of California,  2001 (No. 7198)    EDUCATION  B.S., Geology  University of Washington  Seattle, Washington 1976    M.S., Geology  Oregon State University   Corvallis, Oregon 1978    MS Thesis; The Geology and Mineralization  of the Northern Part of the Washougal  Mining District, Skamania County,  Washington.     Professional Affiliations:   Member: Geological Society of America  Member: American Association of  Petroleum Geologists.  Member: Geothermal Resources Council    Publications  19 publications and field trip guidebooks,  including published in: Geological Society of  America, Association of Petroleum  Geologists, United States Geological Survey  Open File Report, Stanford Geothermal  Program Conference, Geothermal  Resources Council Transactions,  Department of Energy, Journal of Scientific  Drilling, and Geochemistry, Geophysics and  Geosystems.              EMAIL  aschriener@earthsystems.com    PRIME OFFICE LOCATION  Bermuda Dunes, CA   EARTH SYSTEMS PACIFIC  Appendix F    Reliance Form EARTH SYSTEMS PACIFIC  Application for Authorization to Rely on Environmental Report  This form serves as an application for third parties to apply for permission to use and rely on the referenced  report [Report].  It is the applicant’s responsibility to obtain the approval of the original client prior to submitting  the form.  As a condition of approval for authorization to use and rely on the referenced Report, applicant agrees  to waive any conflict of interest arising out of, and applicant will not object to, our representation of our original  client; that Earth Systems Pacific’s liability for errors and omissions from the Report shall be limited to $15,000;  and Earth Systems Pacific shall have no liability for any other cause or action.  Use of this Report without written  permission releases Earth Systems Pacific from any liability that may arise from the use of this Report.    Reference:  Report of Environmental Site Assessment, APNs 628‐030‐009 & 628‐030‐011, W of Calle De Los  Campesinos, N of South Cliff Road, Palm Desert, Riverside County, California, File No. 305770‐ 001, Doc. No. 22‐12‐705, dated December 13, 2022.      Original Client:  City of Palm Desert, 73510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert, California 92260, Ms. Deborah  Glickman, Management Analyst, 760‐776‐6441     To be completed by Applicant.  A  processing  fee  of  $200  made  payable  to  Earth  Systems  Pacific must  accompany application.  Submit to Earth Systems Pacific, 79811 Country Club Drive, Indio, California 92203.   Signature signifies applicant’s acceptance of the use and liability limitations described above, and caveats  described below*.      By:                              (Company Name)                           (Print Name)                                              (Address)                            (Signature)    Title:                              (City, State, Zip)          Date:           (Telephone)              (FAX)  Approval of Original Client  By:                            (Print Name)                                (Signature)    For Earth Systems Pacific’s use only                  Approved for re‐use with caveat that findings discussed in Report were based on available  information and site conditions as noted at time of Report but may not be applicable to current site  conditions.                   Disapproved (application fee to be refunded).    By:    Date:                 (Earth Systems Pacific)  *Caveats ‐ Applicant understands and agrees that the referenced Report is a copyrighted document, that Earth Systems Pacific is the  copyright owner, and that unauthorized use or copying of the Report is strictly prohibited without the express written permission of Earth  Systems Pacific.  Applicant understands that Earth Systems Pacific may withhold such permission at its sole discretion, or grant permission  upon such terms and conditions as it deems acceptable.  Applicant acknowledges that: (1) Earth Systems Pacific did not have an  opportunity  to  evaluate  the  applicant’s  relationship  to  the  site;  (2)  Applicant‐specific  information  can  affect  the  conclusions  and  recommendations presented in the Report; (3) The Report speaks only to conditions observed onsite at the time of the site visit, and site  conditions may have changed since that time; (4) The scope of the Report was limited to the scope defined by our proposal; (4) The shelf  life of the Report, as defined by the EPA All Appropriate Inquiry [AAI] guidelines, is six months (the Report expires after six months and  should not be relied upon without an update in accordance with the AAI guidelines); and, (5) Earth Systems Pacific maintains its contract  with the original client for the Report.     NORTH PALM DESERT PARK Envisioning a New Regional Park for Palm Desert SNAPSHOT DATE: 01/23/2023 IN WHAT SECTOR WOULD YOU PREFER THE PARK? POPULAR RESPONSEA Resident - Property Owner 281 responses Resident - Property Owner - Español 1 responses Business Owner 3 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner 32 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner - Español 3 responses NORTH PALM DESERT PARK Envisioning a New Regional Park for Palm Desert SNAPSHOT DATE: 01/23/2023 ARE YOU A YEAR-ROUND OR SEASONAL RESIDENT? Resident - Property Owner 232 responsesRESPONSE HIERARCHY Resident - Property Owner - Español 1 responses Business Owner 2 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner 28 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner - Español 3 responses 1. Year-round Resident 88% 2. Seasonal 11% 3. N/A 1% NORTH PALM DESERT PARK Envisioning a New Regional Park for Palm Desert SNAPSHOT DATE: 01/23/2023 WHAT IS YOUR AGE? Resident - Property Owner 246 responsesRESPONSE HIERARCHY Resident - Property Owner - Español 1 responses Business Owner 3 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner 32 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner - Español 3 responses 1. 41 to 60 38% 2. 60 and over 33% 3. 20 to 40 22% NORTH PALM DESERT PARK Envisioning a New Regional Park for Palm Desert SNAPSHOT DATE: 01/23/2023 WHAT IS YOUR GENDER? Resident - Property Owner 246 responsesRESPONSE HIERARCHY Resident - Property Owner - Español 1 responses Business Owner 3 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner 32 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner - Español 3 responses 1. Male 57% 2. Female 39% 3. Prefer not to say 3% NORTH PALM DESERT PARK Envisioning a New Regional Park for Palm Desert SNAPSHOT DATE: 01/23/2023 WHICH BEST DESCRIBES YOU? Resident - Property Owner 246 responsesRESPONSE HIERARCHY Resident - Property Owner - Español 1 responses Business Owner 3 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner 32 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner - Español 3 responses 1. White 76% 2. Hispanic 14% 3. Asian 8% NORTH PALM DESERT PARK Envisioning a New Regional Park for Palm Desert SNAPSHOT DATE: 01/23/2023 WHAT IS YOUR ZIP CODE? Resident - Property Owner 246 responsesRESPONSE HIERARCHY Resident - Property Owner - Español 1 responses Business Owner 3 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner 32 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner - Español 3 responses 1. 92211 67% 2. 92260 18% 3. 92234 11% NORTH PALM DESERT PARK Envisioning a New Regional Park for Palm Desert SNAPSHOT DATE: 01/23/2023 1 2 3 4 5 HOW WOULD YOU MOST-LIKELY ACCESS THESE PARK? Resident - Property Owner 246 responsesRESPONSE HIERARCHY Resident - Property Owner - Español 1 responses Business Owner 3 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner 32 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner - Español 3 responses 1. By automobile / motorcycle 2. By bicycle 3. Walking Rank: 1 - most likely 5 least likely Choices: • By automobile/motorcycle • By bicycle • By public transportation • By skateboard, scooter, or similar • By walking NORTH PALM DESERT PARK Envisioning a New Regional Park for Palm Desert SNAPSHOT DATE: 01/23/2023 WHAT ARE THE AGES OF THE CHILDREN IN YOUR HOUSEHOLD? Resident - Property Owner 246 responsesRESPONSE HIERARCHY Resident - Property Owner - Español 1 responses Business Owner 3 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner 32 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner - Español 3 responses 1. N/A 57% 1. 10 to 15 years old 12% 2. 0 to 2 years old 7% NORTH PALM DESERT PARK Envisioning a New Regional Park for Palm Desert SNAPSHOT DATE: 01/23/2023 HOW MANY ADULTS LIVE IN YOUR HOUSEHOLD? Resident - Property Owner 246 responsesRESPONSE HIERARCHY Resident - Property Owner - Español 1 responses Business Owner 3 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner 32 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner - Español 3 responses 1. 2 adults 74% 2. 3 adults 10% 3. 1 adult 8% NORTH PALM DESERT PARK Envisioning a New Regional Park for Palm Desert SNAPSHOT DATE: 01/23/2023 WHEN WOULD YOU MOST LIKELY VISIT THE PARKS? Resident - Property Owner 246 responsesRESPONSE HIERARCHY Resident - Property Owner - Español 1 responses Business Owner 3 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner 32 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner - Español 3 responses 1. Weekly 57% 2. Daily 27% 3. Monthly 12% NORTH PALM DESERT PARK Envisioning a New Regional Park for Palm Desert SNAPSHOT DATE: 01/23/2023 WHEN WOULD YOU MOST LIKELY VISIT THE PARKS? Resident - Property Owner 246 responsesRESPONSE HIERARCHY Resident - Property Owner - Español 1 responses Business Owner 3 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner 32 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner - Español 3 responses 1. Weekends 68% 2. Weekday mornings 53% 3. Weekday late 44% afternoons NORTH PALM DESERT PARK Envisioning a New Regional Park for Palm Desert SNAPSHOT DATE: 01/23/2023 WOULD YOU VISIT ALONE OR WITH COMPANY? Resident - Property Owner 246 responsesRESPONSE HIERARCHY Resident - Property Owner - Español 1 responses Business Owner 3 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner 32 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner - Español 3 responses 1. With family 65% 2. With friends 52% 3. Alone 42% NORTH PALM DESERT PARK Envisioning a New Regional Park for Palm Desert SNAPSHOT DATE: 01/23/2023 WHEN VISITING A PARK, WHAT ACTIVITIES MOST ENTICE YOU? Resident - Property Owner 258 responsesRESPONSE HIERARCHY Resident - Property Owner - Español 1 responses Business Owner 3 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner 32 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner - Español 3 responses 1. Walking and/or 74% Strolling 2. Exercising, running, 55% or jogging 3. Relaxing, getting 54% away NORTH PALM DESERT PARK Envisioning a New Regional Park for Palm Desert SNAPSHOT DATE: 01/23/2023 SELECT THE BENEFITS YOU FEEL THESE PARKS WOULD PROVIDE Resident - Property Owner 247 responsesRESPONSE HIERARCHY Resident - Property Owner - Español 1 responses Business Owner 3 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner 32 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner - Español 3 responses 1. Promotes health 93% and wellness 2. Provides recreational 88% experiences 3. Strengthens 82% community image NORTH PALM DESERT PARK Envisioning a New Regional Park for Palm Desert SNAPSHOT DATE: 01/23/2023 HOW OFTEN ARE PARKS A PART OF YOUR FITNESS ROUTINE? Resident - Property Owner 246 responsesRESPONSE HIERARCHY Resident - Property Owner - Español 1 responses Business Owner 3 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner 32 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner - Español 3 responses 1. Often 77% 2. Sometimes 20% 3. Never 3% NORTH PALM DESERT PARK Envisioning a New Regional Park for Palm Desert SNAPSHOT DATE: 01/23/2023 HOW OFTEN DO YOU OR YOUR CHILDREN PARTICIPATE IN ORGANIZED SPORTS FIELD PLAY? Resident - Property Owner 246 responsesRESPONSE HIERARCHY Resident - Property Owner - Español 1 responses Business Owner 3 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner 32 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner - Español 3 responses 1. Often 37% 2. Never 33% 3. Sometimes 30% NORTH PALM DESERT PARK Envisioning a New Regional Park for Palm Desert SNAPSHOT DATE: 01/23/2023 WHAT TYPE OF ORGANIZED SPORTS? Resident - Property Owner 254 responsesRESPONSE HIERARCHY Resident - Property Owner - Español 1 responses Business Owner 3 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner 32 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner - Español 3 responses 1. Pickleball 38% 2. Soccer 31% 3. Basketball 28% 4. Disc Golf 20% 5. Football 8% NORTH PALM DESERT PARK Envisioning a New Regional Park for Palm Desert SNAPSHOT DATE: 01/23/2023 WHAT TYPE OF NON-SPORTS EVENTS WOULD MOST ENTICE YOU TO VISIT THE PARK Resident - Property Owner 246 responsesRESPONSE HIERARCHY Resident - Property Owner - Español 1 responses Business Owner 3 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner 32 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner - Español 3 responses 1. Farmer’s Market 88% 2. Live Music 73% 3. Food Trucks 62% 4. Antique or Art 44% Markets 5. Movie Night 33% NORTH PALM DESERT PARK Envisioning a New Regional Park for Palm Desert SNAPSHOT DATE: 01/23/2023 WHAT VALUES ARE MOST IMPORTANT FOR YOU SELECTING TO VISIT THE PARK? Resident - Property Owner 250 responsesRESPONSE HIERARCHY Resident - Property Owner - Español 1 responses Business Owner 3 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner 32 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner - Español 3 responses 1. Cleanliness 77% 2. Aesthetic and 59% beauty 3. Many trees and 51% lushly landscape 4. Safety and lighting 50% 5. Ample locations for 20% sitting and resting NORTH PALM DESERT PARK Envisioning a New Regional Park for Palm Desert SNAPSHOT DATE: 01/23/2023 PASSIVE PARK: WHAT COMPONENTS WOULD YOU LIKE TO SEE ? Resident - Property Owner 252 responsesRESPONSE HIERARCHY Resident - Property Owner - Español 1 responses Business Owner 3 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner 32 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner - Español 3 responses 1. Walking, hiking and/or biking 2. Exercise trails 3. Bathrooms 4. Wide walkways and paths 5. Cleaning/litter removal 6. Several trash receptacles 7. Lighting 8. Benches 9. Outdoor fitness and exercise 10. Festivals and community events NORTH PALM DESERT PARK Envisioning a New Regional Park for Palm Desert SNAPSHOT DATE: 01/23/2023 PASSIVE PARK: RATE THE 5 MOST IMPORTANT COMPONENTS Resident - Property Owner 246 responsesRESPONSE HIERARCHY Resident - Property Owner - Español 1 responses Business Owner 3 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner 32 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner - Español 3 responses 1. Bathrooms 58% 2. Walking, hiking 51% and/or biking 3. Exercise trails 37% 4. Cleaning/litter 33% removal 5. Lighting 30% NORTH PALM DESERT PARK Envisioning a New Regional Park for Palm Desert SNAPSHOT DATE: 01/23/2023 ACTIVE RECREATIONAL PARK: WHAT COMPONENTS WOULD YOU LIKE TO SEE ? Resident - Property Owner 244 responsesRESPONSE HIERARCHY Resident - Property Owner - Español 1 responses Business Owner 3 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner 32 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner - Español 3 responses 1. Bathrooms 2. Walking, hiking and/or biking 3. Exercise trails 4. Lighting 5. Benches 6. Cleaning/litter removal 7. Wide walkways and paths 8. Several trash receptacles 9. Outdoor fitness and exercise 10. Drinking fountains NORTH PALM DESERT PARK Envisioning a New Regional Park for Palm Desert SNAPSHOT DATE: 01/23/2023 ACTIVE RECREATIONAL PARK: RATE THE 5 MOST IMPORTANT COMPONENTS Resident - Property Owner 244 responsesRESPONSE HIERARCHY Resident - Property Owner - Español 1 responses Business Owner 3 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner 32 responses Resident - Non-Property Owner - Español 3 responses 1. Bathrooms 56% 2. Walking, hiking 43% and/or biking 3. Exercise trails 30% 4. Cleaning/litter 27% removal 5. Lighting 27% NORTH PALM DESERT PARK Envisioning a New Regional Park for Palm Desert SNAPSHOT DATE: 01/23/2023 SUMMARY • Future park to be located at corner of Portola Rd. and Frank Sinatra Dr. • Overwhelming responses provided by Year-round Residents from the North Palm Desert area. • The majority of the responses were provided by groups ages 40 and over with no kids. • The majority of the programming selections are aligned with more passive uses focused on health and wellness. • Event programming will be important for the operations of the park (potential added demands on Staff). • Restrooms, cleanliness, and connected path networks were among the most important considerations for the respondents. • Responses have not captured the feedback from a significant number of families. NORTH PALM DESERT PARK Envisioning a New Regional Park for Palm Desert SNAPSHOT DATE: 01/23/2023 NEXT STEPS • Conduct planning analysis by staff to identify the potential density build-out of the area to determine counts for potential future families that may be moving in. • Research if possible data can be collected on current home sales to identify trends in families vs. retirees home sales. • Research to determine if nearby college campus will have on-campus residents and at what density. NORTH PALM DESERT PARK Envisioning a New Regional Park for Palm Desert SNAPSHOT DATE: 01/23/2023 FOR DISCUSSION PURPOSES PASSIVE PARK (Possible Programming Components) • Parking • Open Lawn Areas • Restrooms • Children’s Play Area • Corner Arts Plaza • Exercise ‘Hub’ • Disc Golf ACTIVE PARK (Possible Programming Components) • Parking • Multi-use Play Fields (Soccer, Football) • Baseball/Softball Fields • Tennis Courts • Pickleball Courts • Basketball Courts • Dog Park - Off Leash Dog Run • Children’s Playground • Splash Pad • Flexible Event Space • Sculpture ‘Desert Garden’ • Interconnected walking paths and trails • Bicycle paths • Exercise and agility equipment • Future YMCA/Community Center • Disc Golf • Beach Volleyball NORTH PALM DESERT PARK Envisioning a New Regional Park for Palm Desert SNAPSHOT DATE: 01/23/2023 FOR DISCUSSION PURPOSES PASSIVE PARK (Possible Programming Components) • Parking • Open Lawn Areas • Restrooms • Children’s Play Area • Corner Arts Plaza • Exercise ‘Hub’ • Disc Golf RE S T R O O M + F A C I L I T I E S PARKINGOP E N LA W N OP E N LA W N CORNER ARTS PLAZA CHILDREN’S PLAY AREA EXERCISE HUB I-1 0 GERALD FORD DR NORTH PALM DESERT PARK Envisioning a New Regional Park for Palm Desert SNAPSHOT DATE: 01/23/2023 FOR DISCUSSION PURPOSES ACTIVE PARK (Possible Programming Components) • Parking • Multi-use Play Fields (Soccer, Football) • Baseball/Softball Fields • Tennis Courts • Pickleball Courts • Basketball Courts • Dog Park - Off Leash Dog Run • Children’s Playground • Splash Pad • Flexible Event Space • Sculpture ‘Desert Garden’ • Interconnected walking paths and trails • Bicycle paths • Exercise and agility equipment • Future YMCA/Community Center • Disc Golf • Beach Volleyball PARKINGPARKINGFAMILY FRIENDLYDOG PARK FLEX EVENT SPACE SCULPTURE DESERT GARDEN 4 BASEBALL SOFTBALL FIELDS CONTINUOUS MULTI-USE TRAILS BASKETBALL 8 MULTI-USE FIELDS TENNIS PICKLEBALL EXERCISE NATURE TRAILSPORTOLA RDFRANK SINATRA DR FAMILY YMCA OF THE DESERT 43-930 San Pablo Avenue, Palm Desert, CA 92260 760-341-9622 Fax: 760-779-9651 www.ymcaofthedesert.org February 7, 2023 Family YMCA of the Desert City of Palm Desert Commission Report FROM: Paula Simonds,CEO School Age & Early Childhood Education: Reagan: 41 (Waitlist 13) Carter – 68 (Waitlist 80) Jean Benson: CSPP: 40 FFS: 31 **CSPP = California State Preschool Program **FFS = Fee for Service Jean Benson Child Development Center: We are in the first steps of reviewing the Outdoor program space at Jean Benson Child Development Center to create outdoor learning environment. Working with nationally recognized firm Nature Explorer to help present a variety of programmatic space options, this would be a welcomed enhancement for children and staff. Programs as of 1/13/23 Basketball: 232 max registration reached: 42 on waitlist –Start date 1/14/23 Y Rookies: 3 classes: 57 regsitered max registration is 62 --Start date 1/14/23 Flag Football: 77 registered max registration is 256 --Starts 3/31/23 Youth & Government: 23 registered – Cal State Y&G Conference -2/10-13/23 Spring Break currently promoted and Summer Day Camp promotion launch is 3/2/23 Camp Oakes: June 17-June 24, 2023 – promotion launch is February 1, 2023 Parents Night Out: February 11, 2023 Ages 5 and Up 5:30pm-9:00pm Activities, Crafts, Games, Movies, Pizza 43930 San Pablo Avenue - YMCA Tae Kwon Do, Parkinson’s and Senior Movement Classes started January 2023 Middle School |Teen programming as has been a high priority request. Working on developing new program and updating space for summer. College of the Desert partnership: COD Athletics/basketball hosted YMCA Night on 1/14/23. A great time was had by all with meet & greet with former UCLA and NBA player Pooh Richardson, COD Coach, as well as halftime free throw contests. Next up, YMCA day at Spring Baseball game. Date: January 18, 2023 To: City of Palm Desert Parks and Recreation Commission From: Brenda Nutcher, Community Services Coordinator Subject: November and December participation numbers. Numbers reflective December 15, 2022 through January 17, 2023 Palm Desert Community Center • 2436 members utilized the gymnasium and fitness center facilities. • 293 additional gym and fitness center users paid the daily walk-in fee. • 785 people registered for classes, camps, and special programs. • 77 additional people paid to participate in classes on a drop-in basis. • 262 Desert Willow Resident Cards issued. • 79 Fitness Center Passes issued. • 5 Community Center room rentals for the month. Palm Desert Parks • park reservations • hours of rental use Palm Desert Skate Park • 40 skate park memberships sold. • 364 skaters used the park. • 286 bikers used the park. Palm Desert Community Center • We had 97 children register for winter Camp. • Senior Games registration is open. We currently have 906 athletes enrolled. The number is increasing daily. • Desert Mountains for Kids Fest was a lot of fun. Lots of different vendors offering activities for the children and adults. There were over 1500 visitors throughout the event. • Sunday Sounds Concert Series with the Palm Desert Library has a few more shows coming up, February 19, the band Hotflash, March 5, The Gand Band, March 19, Palm Springs Gay Men’s Choir and on April 2, Michael Gagliardi. • In partnership with AAA Automobile Club of Southern California, we will be offering a Keeping the Keys workshop Saturday, February 25, from 10am to noon. This is a free workshop for seniors and to help them with best practices to keep them driving and stay on the road longer. . December 16th – January 15th, 2022-23 Passes 25 Punch Card: 40 New 27 Renewed Total: 67 3 Month Pass: 13 New 8 Renewed Total: 21 Annual Pass: 3 New 1 Renewed Total: 4 Fitness Pass: 0 New 0 Renewed Total: 0 Water Exercise Punch Card: 0 New 0 Renewed Total: 0 Water Exercise Monthly: 17 New 44 Renewed Total: 61 Admission Lap Swim Non-Resident: 848 Resident: 412 Total: 1,260 The facility was closed for the holiday, December 24th-26th and open New Year’s Eve & New Year’s Day. Gate Entries/Water Exercise Attendance Lap Swim entries = 1,798 Water Exercise Class Attendance = 965 Total entries: 2,763 *Swim Lessons Private Swim Lessons: Non-Resident = 8 Resident = 13 Total: 21 participants Rec. Swim Team: Non-Resident = 4 Resident = 7 Total: 11 participants User Groups Palm Desert Swim Club Scorpions Water Polo Xavier High School Tritons Elite Otters Salton Sea The University of Lethbridge Swim Team from Alberta, Canada - The University used the Lap Pool to practice 1 ½ hours each day, from January 2nd-8th. Aquartist Inc. – A Synchronized Swim Team that had a duet from Japan, practiced here for 8 hours on January 8th. *Groups swim lessons are not offered November-February. Category Event Title Location Number of Events Attendance Event Desert Kids Fun Fest Civic Center Park 1 1500 Event Yoga with a Ranger Saturday Mountains National Monument 1 14 Training BLM Volunteer only trainings Mountains National Monument 1 20 Event Star Party in the Monument Mountains National Monument 1 33 Guided Hike Birding Walk-About, Desert Willow Desert Willow Golf Park 2 18 Guided Hike Art Smith Trail Interpretative Hike Art Smith Trailhead Parking Lot 3 20 Guided Hike Carrizo Canyon Trail Interpretative Hike Art Smith Trailhead Parking Lot 2 35 Guided Hike Dead Indian Canyon Trail Interpretative Hike Art Smith Trailhead Parking Lot 2 26 Guided Hike Randall Henderson Interpretative Randall Henderson Trail 1 13 Outreach Dead Indian Canyon Adaptive Sports Hike Cahilla Hills Park 1 6 Event Desert Mountains Art Faire Mountains National Monument 1 178 Lectures Hiking 101; Scorpions; History of San Jacinto Mt; Building Hwy 74 Mountains National Monument 4 117 Guided Hike Hiking 101 Randall Henderson 1 6 Friends of the Desert Mountains Category Event Title Location Number of Events Guided Hike Art Smith Trail Interpretative Hike Art Smith Trailhead Parking Lot 1 Guided Hike Randall Henderson Interpretative Randall Henderson Trail 1 Event Star Party in the Monument National Monument Visitor Center 1 Lectures Plants Can't Move, So What National Monument Visitor Center 1 Location Number of Events Attendance Hopalong Cassidy Trail 1 13 Friends of the Palm Desert Library February 7, 2023 The Annual Meeting of the Friends of the Palm Desert Library was held on January 5, 2023. Primary objectives were to • share our financial health (included in our Jan summary to Parks and Rec • create a budget for 2023 • elect officers for the new year The budget that we created for 2023 includes: • expected income of over $40,000 • $5,000 for the City of PD 50th Anniversary • $17,500 for Children, Youth and Adult programs • $10,000 for newspapers and magazines for library patrons • $1,000 for additions to the library’s collection During 2022 our Vice-President resigned leaving our board with a president and a secretary/treasurer. Our election of officers for 2023 resulted in filling four positions; Karen Gonzales reelected as President, Jann Buller as Treasurer; two new members, who are also Book Store volunteers, were elected to Vice President and Secretary. Coachella Library will be relocating to a new building with a smaller space for the Friends’ Book Store. Excess inventory is being donated to the Friends of the Palm Desert Library. Other donations from our patrons continue to enable our book store to do well. Cahuilla Hills Park Review For February 2023 meeting Reviewer: Jerry Dawson The Cahuilla Hills Park looks great. Well maintained and offers open space with areas and tables for casual picnicking. The parking lot seems to be well used almost any day of the week and most times of the day. Luckily, the size of the parking area is adequate for the volumes of cars using it – and coming into and leaving the lot is simple. The park itself is not the main attraction however. This park is the starting place for several walking trails of various levels that are favorites for many people. With clean restrooms, water and maps available, it is serving a significant need. CITY OF PALM DESERT DEVELOPMENT SERVICES DEPARTMENT PARKS AND RECREATION COMMISSION MEMORANDUM To: Chair and Members Parks and Recreation Commission From: Nick Melloni, Principal Planner Date: February 7, 2023 Case No: MISC 22-0040 Subject: Informational - University Park Phase 2 - Park Sites “D” and “E” BACKGROUND On November 10, 2016, the Palm Desert City Council adopted Ordinance No. 1312 approving the University Neighborhood Specific Plan (UNSP). The UNSP covers approximately 400 acres generally bordered by Gerald Ford Drive on the north, Frank Sinatra Drive on the South, Portola Avenue on the west, and College Drive and Technology Drive on the east. The UNSP establishes the framework for allowed land uses, parks and development standards within its boundaries. Existing City parks within the UNSP include the University Dog Park (2.4-acres) and University Park East (2.5-acres). On November 20, 2018, the Palm Desert Planning Commission adopted Resolution No. 2745 (Attachment No. 2) approving a master plan and design guidelines for a 174+ acre, 1,069-unit residential subdivision within the UNSP (Case No. VTTM 37506 and PP 18-0005). The approval established the general design, size, and location of five (5) parks within the subdivision, and an art trail walk, to be built over multiple phases (see Figure 1 below). Park sites “A” through “E” were approved as public parks to be constructed by the developer and dedicated to the City in lieu of parkland fees associated with the subdivision. FIGURE 1 – University Park – Preliminary Site Plan (See Next Page) Parks & Recreation Commission Staff Report University Park – Phase 2 February 7, 2023 Page 2 of 3 On February 5, 2019, the Palm Desert Parks and Recreation Commission held a discussion of Park Sites A and B within Phase 1 of the University Park Development. Phase 1 is currently under development. Phase 2 of the University Park Development is planned to begin construction and contains park site D and E as shown on Figure 1. An overview of the approved park sizes is provided below on Table 1. TABLE 1 – University Park – Preliminary Site Plan PROPOSED PARKS ACRES Dog Park (existing) 2.4 University Park East (existing) 2.5 Park A (existing) 1.3 Park B (existing) 1.0 Park C (future) 1.2 Park D (proposed) 1.1 Park E (proposed 0.6 Park F – The Grove (private open space) 3.4 Park G – Grand Paseo (future) 3.6 TOTAL 17.2 Parks & Recreation Commission Staff Report University Park – Phase 2 February 7, 2023 Page 3 of 3 OVERVIEW The item is being presented as an informational overview of the park sites. The general design was previously approved by the Palm Desert Planning Commission under Resolution No. 2745. The developer has provided landscape construction drawings for review by City Staff (Attachment No. 1). Park D: Located at the northwest corner of the planned Wild Song Drive and Radford Drive, Park D is 1.1 acres in size and is designed to be a “mini park” under the City’s General Plan Park Classification Standard. As proposed, following are the park features: • One (1) Shade Structure • Paved pedestrian path • Three (3) Picnic tables • Trash receptacles. • Shade trees and landscape. • Open turf play area. • Exterior lighting (10’ light posts, and 42” lighting bollards) Park E: Located on a through lot between Radford Drive, and Tubman Street, Park E (Identified as Park “B” on plans is 0.6 acres in size and is designed to be a “mini park” unde r the City’s General Plan Park Classification Standard. The preliminary plan for Park E features raised eight (8) garden plots. During the final civil design of the site, it was determined that the steep slope of the site could not support the envisioned garden plots due to the need to provide appropriate slope for accessibility. As a result, the number of garden planters was reduced from eight to three. As proposed, following are the park features: • Paved pedestrian path • Three (3) Picnic tables • Trash receptacles. • Shade trees and landscape. • Open turf play area. • Exterior lighting (10’ light posts, and 42” lighting bollards). • Three (3) raised concrete garden planters. The proposed park design substantially conforms with the preliminary layout for parks approved by Planning Commission. The developer will construct the parks as shown on the plans for later City acceptance. City staff will finalize approval of the construction drawings. Attachments: 1. Park Plans 2. Planning Commission Resolution No. 2745 AUGUST 2018 UNIVERSITY PARK INVESTORS, LLC PALM DESERT, CA2018047 L1.815300 Park D PE 246.0PE 245.5PE 256.5PE 242.5PE 253.5PE 254.5PE 242.560" ROUN D 60" ROUND 60" ROUND 60" ROUND 60" ROUN D 60" ROUND 60" ROUND 60" ROUN D (8) 60"ROUNDTABLES 10CHAIRS W/H W/H 10CHAIRS 10CHAIRS10CHAIRS 10CHAIRS 10CHAIRS10CHAIRS10CHAIRS FOODPREP. CABLE/I.T. FIRERISER ELEC. MENS WOMENS STORAGE 1 BALLR OO M BREEZE WA Y 1 FOYER STORAG E 2 OFFICE FITNE S S FITNESS STOR. 3 MENS WOMEN S STORAG E 4 OUTDO O R SHOWE RSJAN. JAN. W/HTEL./CABLE ELEC.MAINROOM ACIDROOM OUTDOOR HEATER AREA POOLEQUIPMENT STORAGE SHOW. WOMENS MENS VEST. 1 VEST. 2 VEST. 3 GROVE HOU SE 50'-0" 30'-0" 50'-0" 30'-0" 4'-0" 14'-6" 15'-0" 14'-6" 2'-0" 4'-0" 14'-6" 15'-0" 14'-6" 2'-0" 13'-0"13'-0"2'-0" 1'-0"8'-0"12'-0"8'-0"1'-0" 2'-0"SITE MAP, N.T.S.77-899 WOLF RD.PH. (760) 777-9131FAX (760) 777-9132PALM DESERT, CALIC# 2754, EXP 04/30/2492211HERMANNPALM DESERT, CAPARK "B"DESIGNGROUPSUITE 102UNIVERSITY PARK - PHASE 2 60" ROUND 60" ROUND 60" ROUND 60" ROUND 60" ROUND 60" ROUND 60" ROUND 60" ROUND (8) 60"ROUNDTABLES 10CHAIRS W/H W/H 10CHAIRS10CHAIRS10CHAIRS10CHAIRS10CHAIRS10CHAIRS10CHAIRSFOODPREP. CABLE/I.T. FIRERISER ELEC. MENS WOMENS STORAGE 1 BALLROOM BREEZEWA Y 1 FOYER STORAGE 2 OFFICE FITNESS FITNESS STOR. 3 MENS WOMENS STORAGE 4 OUTDOORSHOWERS JAN. JAN. W/HTEL./CABLE ELEC.MAINROOM ACIDROOM OUTDOOR HEATE R AREAPOOLEQUIPMENT STORAGE SHOW.WOMENS MENS VEST. 1 VEST. 2 VEST. 3 GROVE HOUSE 50'-0" 30'-0" 50'-0" 30'-0" 4'-0" 14'-6" 15'-0" 14'-6" 2'-0" 4'-0" 14'-6" 15'-0" 14'-6" 2'-0" 13'-0"13'-0"2'-0" 1'-0"8'-0"12'-0"8'-0"1'-0" 2'-0"77-899 WOLF RD.PH. (760) 777-9131FAX (760) 777-9132PALM DESERT, CALIC# 2754, EXP 04/30/2292211HERMANNDESIGNGROUPSUITE 102 60" ROUND 60" ROUND 60" ROUND 60" ROUND 60" ROUND 60" ROUN D 60" ROUND 60" ROUND (8) 60"ROUNDTABLES 10CHAIRS W/H W/H 10CHAIRS 10CHAIRS10CHAIRS 10CHAIRS 10CHAIRS10CHAIRS 10CHAIRS FOODPREP. CABLE/ I.T. FIRERISER ELEC. MENS WOME N S STORA G E 1 BALLR O OM BREEZEW AY 1 FOYER STORAG E 2 OFFICE FITNES S FITNESS STOR. 3 MENS WOMENS STORAG E 4 OUTDOO RSHOWER S JAN. JAN. W/HTEL./CABLE ELEC.MAINROOM ACIDROOM OUTDOOR HEATER AREA POOLEQUIPMENT STORAGE SHOW. WOMENS MENS VEST. 1 VEST. 2 VEST. 3 GROVE H OU S E 50'-0" 30'-0" 50'-0" 30'-0" 4'-0" 14'-6" 15'-0" 14'-6" 2'-0" 4'-0" 14'-6" 15'-0" 14'-6" 2'-0" 13'-0"13'-0"2'-0" 1'-0"8'-0"12'-0"8'-0"1'-0" 2'-0"BACAABCCBCAAACCAPE 220.7PE 221.5PE 222.1PE 222.8PE 234.5PE 236.2PE 238.0PE 240.0PE 240.5PE 239.5PE 237.8PE 236.3PE 234.5PE 233.3PE 231.8PE 230.3PE 241.5PE 240.5PE 239.577-899 WOLF RD.PH. (760) 777-9131FAX (760) 777-9132PALM DESERT, CALIC# 2754, EXP 04/30/2292211HERMANNDESIGNGROUPSUITE 102SITE MAP, N.T.S. PE 246.0PE 245.5PE 256.5PE 242.5PE 253.5PE 254.5PE 242.560" ROUN D 60" ROUN D 60" ROUN D 60" ROUN D 60" ROUN D 60" ROUND 60" ROUN D 60" ROUN D (8) 60"ROUNDTABLES 10CHAIRS W/H W/H 10CHAIRS 10CHAIRS10CHAIRS 10CHAIRS 10CHAIRS10CHAIRS 10CHAIRS FOODPREP. CABLE / I.T. FIRERISER ELEC. MENS WOMENS STORAGE 1 BALLROOM BREEZ E WA Y 1 FOYE R STORA G E 2 OFFICE FITNESS FITNES S STOR. 3 MENS WOME N S STORA G E 4 OUTDO OR SHOWE RS JAN. JAN. W/HTEL./CABLE ELEC.MAINROOM ACIDROOM OUTDOOR HEATER AREA POOLEQUIPMENT STORAGE SHOW.WOMENS MENS VEST. 1 VEST. 2 VEST. 3 GROVE HO USE 50'-0" 30'-0" 50'-0" 30'-0" 4'-0" 14'-6" 15'-0" 14'-6" 2'-0" 4'-0" 14'-6" 15'-0" 14'-6" 2'-0" 13'-0"13'-0"2'-0" 1'-0"8'-0"12'-0"8'-0"1'-0" 2'-0"77-899 WOLF RD.PH. (760) 777-9131FAX (760) 777-9132PALM DESERT, CALIC# 2754, EXP 04/30/2292211HERMANNDESIGNGROUPSUITE 102SITE MAP, N.T.S. 77-899 WOLF RD.PH. (760) 777-9131FAX (760) 777-9132PALM DESERT, CALIC# 2754, EXP 04/30/2292211HERMANNDESIGNGROUPSUITE 102 60" ROUN D 60" ROUND 60" ROUND 60" ROUND 60" ROUN D 60" ROUND 60" ROUND 60" ROUN D (8) 60"ROUNDTABLES 10CHAIRS W/H W/H 10CHAIRS 10CHAIRS10CHAIRS 10CHAIRS 10CHAIRS10CHAIRS10CHAIRS FOODPREP. CABLE/I.T. FIRERISER ELEC. MENS WOMENS STORAGE 1 BALLR OO M BREEZE WA Y 1 FOYER STORAG E 2 OFFICE FITNE S S FITNESS STOR. 3 MENS WOMEN S STORAG E 4 OUTDO O R SHOWE RSJAN. JAN. W/HTEL./CABLE ELEC.MAINROOM ACIDROOM OUTDOOR HEATER AREA POOLEQUIPMENT STORAGE SHOW. WOMENS MENS VEST. 1 VEST. 2 VEST. 3 GROVE HOU SE 50'-0" 30'-0" 50'-0" 30'-0" 4'-0" 14'-6" 15'-0" 14'-6" 2'-0" 4'-0" 14'-6" 15'-0" 14'-6" 2'-0" 13'-0"13'-0"2'-0" 1'-0"8'-0"12'-0"8'-0"1'-0" 2'-0"IA77-899 WOLF RD.PH. (760) 777-9131FAX (760) 777-9132PALM DESERT, CALIC# 2754, EXP 04/30/2292211HERMANNDESIGNGROUPSUITE 102SITE MAP, N.T.S. 60" ROUN D 60" ROUND 60" ROUND 60" ROUND 60" ROUN D 60" ROUND 60" ROUND 60" ROUN D (8) 60"ROUNDTABLES 10CHAIRS W/H W/H 10CHAIRS 10CHAIRS10CHAIRS 10CHAIRS 10CHAIRS10CHAIRS10CHAIRS FOODPREP. CABLE/I.T. FIRERISER ELEC. MENS WOMENS STORAGE 1 BALLR OO M BREEZE WA Y 1 FOYER STORAG E 2 OFFICE FITNE S S FITNESS STOR. 3 MENS WOMEN S STORAG E 4 OUTDO O R SHOWE RSJAN. JAN. W/HTEL./CABLE ELEC.MAINROOM ACIDROOM OUTDOOR HEATER AREA POOLEQUIPMENT STORAGE SHOW. WOMENS MENS VEST. 1 VEST. 2 VEST. 3 GROVE HOU SE 50'-0" 30'-0" 50'-0" 30'-0" 4'-0" 14'-6" 15'-0" 14'-6" 2'-0" 4'-0" 14'-6" 15'-0" 14'-6" 2'-0" 13'-0"13'-0"2'-0" 1'-0"8'-0"12'-0"8'-0"1'-0" 2'-0"IA77-899 WOLF RD.PH. (760) 777-9131FAX (760) 777-9132PALM DESERT, CALIC# 2754, EXP 04/30/2292211HERMANNDESIGNGROUPSUITE 102SITE MAP, N.T.S. 77-899 WOLF RD.PH. (760) 777-9131FAX (760) 777-9132PALM DESERT, CALIC# 2754, EXP 04/30/2292211HERMANNDESIGNGROUPSUITE 102 77-899 WOLF RD.PH. (760) 777-9131FAX (760) 777-9132PALM DESERT, CALIC# 2754, EXP 04/30/2292211HERMANNDESIGNGROUPSUITE 102 77-899 WOLF RD.PH. (760) 777-9131FAX (760) 777-9132PALM DESERT, CALIC# 2754, EXP 04/30/2292211HERMANNDESIGNGROUPSUITE 102SECTION/ELEVATIONNOT TO SCALE2765431098141238567SECTION/ELEVATIONNOT TO SCALEAVFV146.5EQ.3ISOMETRICNOT TO SCALEEQ.INSTALL DRIPLINE AT 8" O.C. WITH IN 2' WIDE TURF AREA.ADJACENT TO HARDSCAPE42 77-899 WOLF RD.PH. (760) 777-9131FAX (760) 777-9132PALM DESERT, CALIC# 2754, EXP 04/30/2292211HERMANNDESIGNGROUPSUITE 102SIDEWALK 12"12"18"12"12"12"12"36"12"12"18"12" 60" ROUN D 60" ROUND 60" ROUND 60" ROUND 60" ROUN D 60" ROUND 60" ROUND 60" ROUN D (8) 60"ROUNDTABLES 10CHAIRS W/H W/H 10CHAIRS 10CHAIRS10CHAIRS 10CHAIRS 10CHAIRS10CHAIRS10CHAIRS FOODPREP. CABLE/I.T. FIRERISER ELEC. MENS WOMENS STORAGE 1 BALLR OO M BREEZE WA Y 1 FOYER STORAG E 2 OFFICE FITNE S S FITNESS STOR. 3 MENS WOMEN S STORAG E 4 OUTDO O R SHOWE RSJAN. JAN. W/HTEL./CABLE ELEC.MAINROOM ACIDROOM OUTDOOR HEATER AREA POOLEQUIPMENT STORAGE SHOW. WOMENS MENS VEST. 1 VEST. 2 VEST. 3 GROVE HOU SE 50'-0" 30'-0" 50'-0" 30'-0" 4'-0" 14'-6" 15'-0" 14'-6" 2'-0" 4'-0" 14'-6" 15'-0" 14'-6" 2'-0" 13'-0"13'-0"2'-0" 1'-0"8'-0"12'-0"8'-0"1'-0" 2'-0"CABBACAABCCBCAAACCAPE 220.7PE 221.5PE 222.1PE 222.8PE 234.5PE 236.2PE 238.0PE 240.0PE 240.5PE 239.5PE 237.8PE 236.3PE 234.5PE 233.3PE 231.8PE 230.3PE 241.5PE 240.5PE 239.577-899 WOLF RD.PH. (760) 777-9131FAX (760) 777-9132PALM DESERT, CALIC# 2754, EXP 04/30/2292211HERMANNDESIGNGROUPSUITE 102SITE MAP, N.T.S. PE 246.0PE 245.5PE 256.5PE 242.5PE 253.5PE 254.5PE 242.560" ROUN D 60" ROUND 60" ROUND 60" ROUND 60" ROUN D 60" ROUND 60" ROUND 60" ROUN D (8) 60"ROUNDTABLES 10CHAIRS W/H W/H 10CHAIRS 10CHAIRS10CHAIRS 10CHAIRS 10CHAIRS10CHAIRS10CHAIRS FOODPREP. CABLE/I.T. FIRERISER ELEC. MENS WOMENS STORAGE 1 BALLR OO M BREEZE WA Y 1 FOYER STORAG E 2 OFFICE FITNE S S FITNESS STOR. 3 MENS WOMEN S STORAG E 4 OUTDO O R SHOWE RSJAN. JAN. W/HTEL./CABLE ELEC.MAINROOM ACIDROOM OUTDOOR HEATER AREA POOLEQUIPMENT STORAGE SHOW. WOMENS MENS VEST. 1 VEST. 2 VEST. 3 GROVE HOU SE 50'-0" 30'-0" 50'-0" 30'-0" 4'-0" 14'-6" 15'-0" 14'-6" 2'-0" 4'-0" 14'-6" 15'-0" 14'-6" 2'-0" 13'-0"13'-0"2'-0" 1'-0"8'-0"12'-0"8'-0"1'-0" 2'-0"CAB77-899 WOLF RD.PH. (760) 777-9131FAX (760) 777-9132PALM DESERT, CALIC# 2754, EXP 04/30/2292211HERMANNDESIGNGROUPSUITE 102SITE MAP, N.T.S. 77-899 WOLF RD.PH. (760) 777-9131FAX (760) 777-9132PALM DESERT, CALIC# 2754, EXP 04/30/2292211HERMANNDESIGNGROUPSUITE 102····· 77-899 WOLF RD.PH. (760) 777-9131FAX (760) 777-9132PALM DESERT, CALIC# 2754, EXP 04/30/2292211HERMANNDESIGNGROUPSUITE 102 77-899 WOLF RD.PH. (760) 777-9131FAX (760) 777-9132PALM DESERT, CALIC# 2754, EXP 04/30/2292211HERMANNDESIGNGROUPSUITE 102 PE 223.0 PE 222.0 PE 220.7 PE 220.7 PE 221.5 PE 222.1 PE 222.8 PE 227.5 PE 229.0 PE 231.0 PE 232.5 PE 234.5 PE 236.2 PE 238.0 PE 240.0PE 240.5 PE 240.8 PE 239.5 PE 237.8 PE 236.3 PE 234.5 PE 233.3 PE 231.8 PE 230.3 PE 244.4 PE 244.9 PE 245.4 PE 245.8 PE 245.2 PE 244.4 PE 245.5 PE 256.5 PE 242.5 PE 241.5 PE 240.5 PE 239.5 PE 238.5 PE 237.2 PE 236.0 PE 234.5 PE 248.5 PE 249.5 PE 251.0 PE 252.0 PE 253.5 PE 254.5 PE 237.1 PE 230.0 PE 242.5 PE 241.5 PE 240.5PE 240.5 PE 230.0 PE 239.5XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXSB SB SB FAX (760) 777-9132 PH. (760) 777-9131 PALM DESERT, CA SUITE 102 H ERMANN LIC# 2754 92211 EXP. 04/30/22 DESIGN G ROUP 77-899 WOLF RD. 39249 Leopard Street | Suite A-101 SYMBOL LEGEND GENERAL NOTES KEYED NOTES PE 223.0 PE 222.0 PE 220.7 PE 220.7 PE 221.5 PE 222.1 PE 222.8 PE 227.5 PE 229.0 PE 231.0 PE 232.5 PE 234.5 PE 236.2 PE 238.0 PE 240.0PE 240.5 PE 240.8 PE 239.5 PE 237.8 PE 236.3 PE 234.5 PE 233.3 PE 231.8 PE 230.3 PE 244.4 PE 244.9 PE 245.4 PE 245.8 PE 245.2 PE 244.4 PE 245.5 PE 256.5 PE 242.5 PE 241.5 PE 240.5 PE 239.5 PE 238.5 PE 237.2 PE 236.0 PE 234.5 PE 248.5 PE 249.5 PE 251.0 PE 252.0 PE 253.5 PE 254.5 PE 237.1 PE 230.0 PE 242.5 PE 241.5 PE 240.5PE 240.5 PE 230.0 PE 239.5XXXXXXXXXXXXXXX'SB' 'SC' FAX (760) 777-9132 PH. (760) 777-9131 PALM DESERT, CA SUITE 102 H ERMANN LIC# 2754 92211 EXP. 04/30/22 DESIGN G ROUP 77-899 WOLF RD. 39249 Leopard Street | Suite A-101 FAX (760) 777-9132 PH. (760) 777-9131 PALM DESERT, CA SUITE 102 H ERMANN LIC# 2754 92211 EXP. 04/30/22 DESIGN G ROUP 77-899 WOLF RD. 39249 Leopard Street | Suite A-101 FAX (760) 777-9132 PH. (760) 777-9131 PALM DESERT, CA SUITE 102 H ERMANN LIC# 2754 92211 EXP. 04/30/22 DESIGN G ROUP 77-899 WOLF RD. 39249 Leopard Street | Suite A-101 SECTION 1N/A SCALE:4N/A SCALE: 6N/A SCALE:INGRADE PULLBOX DETAIL FIXTURE TYPE 'SD' DETAILFIXTURE TYPE 'SC' DETAIL METER PEDESTAL 'PA' METER/PEDESTAL PANEL 'PA' 9N/A SCALE:TYPICAL CONDUIT TRENCH DETAIL 3N/A SCALE:LIGHTING CONTROL DIAGRAM 11N/A SCALE:METER PEDESTAL DETAIL 7N/A SCALE:GROUND BUS & SYSTEM DETAIL10N/A SCALE:GROUND ROD DETAIL 8N/A SCALE:METER PEDESTAL BASE DETAIL 5N/A SCALE:SINGLE LINE DIAGRAM 2N/A SCALE:PANEL SCHEDULE FAX (760) 777-9132 PH. (760) 777-9131 PALM DESERT, CA SUITE 102 H ERMANN LIC# 2754 92211 EXP. 04/30/22 DESIGN G ROUP 77-899 WOLF RD. 39249 Leopard Street | Suite A-101 A TYPE MANUFACTURER / MODEL NUMBER VA VOLT.LAMP TYPE DESCRIPTION AND NOTESSYMBOL SB SC 2N/A SCALE:ABBREVIATIONS 3N/A SCALE:LEGENDN/A SCALE:ELECTRICAL GENERAL NOTES 4 1N/A SCALE:LIGHTING FIXTURE SCHEDULE PALM DESERT AQUATIC CENTER FEE ANALYSIS Potential Fee Adjustment & Cost Recovery Discussion PDAC FEE HISTORYThe Palm Desert Aquatic Center (PDAC) fees were established in 2011 and have not been adjusted since inception. Rising operational costs and future capital project plans prompted a fee analysis YMCA INVOLVEMENT •YMCA partners with health insurance providers to offer cost relief for those with fixed incomes •City receives all revenue, including concession sales •YMCA receives administration & management fees The Family YMCA of the Desert has been the operator of the Aquatic Center since its opening in 2011. Started in 1982, this 501(c)3 charitable community service organization has provided excellent service to the city in daily management and operation. The YMCA also offers a variety of aquatics programs for patrons of the facility. Award of a new contract with YMCA is anticipated in February 2023. REGIONAL COST & AMENITY COMPARISON The Cove, Riverside The Drop Zone, Perris REGIONAL COST & AMENITY COMPARISON $4 $6 $25 $25 $33 8 4 8 9 5 $0 $5 $10 $15 $20 $25 $30 $35 PDAC Jurupa Park The Cove Water Park The Drop Zone Splash Kingdom Resident Adult Day Pass Number of Amenities LOCAL COST & AMENITY COMPARISON Fritz Burns Pool, La Quinta Palm Springs Swim Center LOCAL COST & AMENITY COMPARISON $4 $5 $3 $4 8 2 2 3 $0 $1 $2 $3 $4 $5 $6 $7 $8 $9 PDAC Palm Springs Swim Center Fritz Burns La Quinta Pawley Pool Resident Adult Day Pass Number of Amenities CONSUMER PRICES •6.5% Increase overall •Food 10.4% •Energy 7.3% •Other 5.7% 8 PDAC ADMISSION HISTORY 0 10,000 20,000 30,000 40,000 50,000 60,000 70,000 80,000 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 Resident Adult Resident Youth/Senior Resident Junior Non-Resident Adult Non-Resident Youth/Senior Non-Resident Junior •Majority of admissions have been from non-residents since 2011 •Admissions expected to return to pre-pandemic levels in 2023 •5-year pre-pandemic average used to project future attendance CURRENT FEE BREAKDOWN Admission Type Resident Non-Resident 30% 70% Resident Non-Resident •Fees were established to achieve a 60% cost recovery rate (Reso. 2011-32) •Cost recovery is down to 33% at end of FY 21/22 due to increased operational and capital costs •All costs not recovered through fees are subsidized by General Fund ($1.8M budgeted for FY 22/23) GENERAL FUND SUBSIDY Fiscal Year 14/15 15/16 16/17 17/18 18/19 19/20 20/21 21/22 22/23 General Fund Subsidy $503,641 $683,341 $613,833 $657,877 $709,937 $794,884 $1,026,000 $1,400,500 $1,805,294 (budgeted) Cost Recovery %63%56%59%59%58%40%26%33%32% (estimated) 0 200,000 400,000 600,000 800,000 1,000,000 1,200,000 1,400,000 1,600,000 1,800,000 2,000,000 General Fund Subsidy to PDAC 14/15 15/16 16/17 17/18 18/19 19/20 20/21 21/22 22/23 Costs not covered by admission fees must be subsidized by General Fund dollars Main Cost Drivers: •Facility repairs and maintenance •Upcoming capital expenditures to keep facility attractive and competitive Assumptions for Analysis Attendance in 2023 and beyond will return to pre-pandemic levels (5-year average) Fees will increase in proportion to current amounts Capital costs will align with 5-year budgeted CIP projections Operating expenditures will increase 4% per year Other program/food/retail revenues will level out to pre-pandemic averages (fees not set by city) OPTIONS ANALYZED BY STAFF Option Impact to Patron Experience Impact to Fees Impact to Cost Recovery 1. Fees remain the same No impact No impact •Cost recovery increases slightly in 2023 due to increased attendance •33% cost recovery by end of year 5 2. Immediate increase to 60% cost recovery Largest immediate impact on fees Increase by approx. 250% immediately, no additional increases for 5 years •Initial increase to 60% cost recovery •Declines to 49% cost recovery by end of year 5 due to rising expenses 3. Gradual increase to 60% cost recovery over 5 year Gradual impact on fees through annual increases Increase an average of 20% per year over next 5 years, with greatest increase in initial year and softer increases to follow •Cost recovery slowly increases to reach 60% at end of year 5 •Cost recovery declines below 60% after year 5 IMPACT ON FEES Fee Options Analyzed Option 1 (Fees remain same) Option 2 (Immediate increase to 60% recovery)* Option 3 (Gradual increase to 60% recovery) Admission Type Year 1 Year 1 Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Resident Adult 4.00 14.25 9.50 11.75 14.00 16.25 18.50 Resident Youth/Senior 3.00 10.75 7.25 9.00 10.50 12.25 13.75 Resident Junior 2.50 9.00 6.00 7.50 8.75 10.25 11.50 Non-Resident Adult 6.00 21.50 14.50 17.75 21.00 24.25 27.50 Non-Resident Youth/Senior 4.50 16.25 10.75 13.25 15.75 18.25 20.75 Non-Resident Junior 3.75 13.50 9.00 11.00 13.25 15.25 17.25 *Option 2 cost recovery % would drop below 60% after year 1 unless an inflator is built in GENERAL FUND SUBSIDY 0 200,000 400,000 600,000 800,000 1,000,000 1,200,000 1,400,000 1,600,000 1,800,000 2,000,000 General Fund Subsidy to PDAC 14/15 15/16 16/17 17/18 18/19 19/20 20/21 21/22 22/23 23/24 24/25 25/26 26/27 27/28 Assuming a 5-year ramp up of fees to 60% cost recovery Large CIP expenditures in FY 24/25 & FY 25/26 GF Subsidy $1.1M in FY 27/28 ADDITIONAL CONSIDERATIONS Raising Non-Resident Fees more than Resident Fees •Shifts the cost increase burden from residents to non-residents •May affect attendance due to heavy non- resident usage Raising Fees on Annual Passes & Punch Passes •Consider increasing punch passes and annual passes proportionately •25-punch passes & 3- month passes are the most popular options •Annual passes rarely sold (less than 10 per year) Other Options •Establish a different recovery rate (not 60%) •Decreased recovery rate would increase GF subsidy •Increase promotional programs or incentives QUESTIONS? THANK YOU! CITY OF PALM DESERT ATTENDANCE REPORT Advisory Body: Prepared By: Year 2022 2022 2022 2022 2022 2022 2022 2022 2022 2022 2022 2022 Month Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Date 4th 1st 1st 5th 3rd 7th 12th 2nd 13th 11th 1st 6th Akkerman, Gregg - Vice Chair P P P P P P P P P P P P 0 0 Dawson, Gerald - Chair P P P P P P P P P P P P 0 0 Flint, Lori P P P P P P P P P P P P 0 0 Guyer, Randy P P P P E P P P P E P P 2 0 Henderson, James P P P P A P P 1 1 Maldonado, John P P P P P P 0 0 Murphy, Paul B.P P P P P P P P P P P P 0 0 O'Donnell, David P P P P P P 0 0 Perry, Ralph P P P P P P P P P P P P 0 0 Palm Desert Municipal Code 2.34.010: P Present A Absent E Excused -No meeting Parks and Recreation Commission Marisol Lopez Total Absences Total Unexcused Absences Monthly: Three unexcused absences from regular meetings in any twelve-month period shall constitute an automatic resignation of members holding office on boards that meet monthly.