Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
Agenda Package - Palm Desert City Council - Regular Meeting_May09_2024
PALM DESERT CITY COUNCIL MEETING AGENDA Thursday, May 9, 2024 4:00 p.m. Council Chamber, City Hall 73-510 Fred Waring Drive Palm Desert, California This is a joint meeting of the Palm Desert City Council, Successor Agency to the Palm Desert Redevelopment Agency, and the Palm Desert Housing Authority. Pursuant to Assembly Bill 2449, this meeting may be conducted as a hybrid meeting allowing public access via teleconference or in person, and up to two Councilmembers may attend remotely. WATCH THE MEETING LIVE: Watch the City Council meeting live at the City’s website: www.palmdesert.gov under the “Council Agenda” link at the top of the homepage, or on the City’s YouTube Channel. OPTIONS FOR PARTICIPATING IN THIS MEETING: If unable to attend the meeting in person, you may choose from the following options: OPTION 1: VIA EMAIL Send your comments by email to: CouncilMeetingComments@palmdesert.gov. Emails received prior to 10:00 a.m. on the day of the City Council meeting will be made part of the record and distributed to the City Council. Emails will not be read aloud at the meeting. OPTION 2: LIVE VIA ZOOM Access via palmdesert.gov/zoom or zoom.us, click “Join Meeting” and enter Webinar ID 833 6744 9572. 1. OPTION 3: LIVE VIA TELEPHONE (213) 338-8477 and enter Meeting ID 833 6744 9572 followed by #.1. Indicate that you are a participant by pressing # to continue.2. During the meeting, press *9 to add yourself to the queue and wait for the Mayor or City Clerk to announce your name/phone number. Press *6 to unmute your line and limit your comments to three minutes. 3. Pages 1.CALL TO ORDER - 4:00 P.M. 2.ROLL CALL 3.PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE Mayor Pro Tem Harnik 4.INSPIRATION Councilmember Kelly 5.AWARDS, PRESENTATIONS, AND APPOINTMENTS 5.a RECOGNITION - CIVIC ACADEMY PARTICIPANTS 5.b RECOGNITION - RETIRED COMMISSIONER KAREL LAMBELL 5.c PROCLAMATION - POLLINATOR WEEK 6.CITY MANAGER COMMENTS 6.a SHERIFF DEPARTMENT UPDATE 7.MAYOR/COUNCILMEMBER REPORTS AND REQUESTS FOR ACTION 8.NONAGENDA PUBLIC COMMENTS This time has been set aside for the public to address the City Council on issues that are not on the agenda for up to three minutes. Speakers may utilize one of the three options listed on the first page of the agenda. Because the Brown Act does not allow the City Council to act on items not listed on the agenda, members may briefly respond or refer the matter to staff for a report and recommendation at a future meeting. 9.CONSENT CALENDAR All matters listed on the Consent Calendar are considered routine and may be approved by one motion. The public may comment on any items on the Consent Agenda within the three-minute time limit. Individual items may be removed by the City Council for a separate discussion. RECOMMENDATION: To approve the consent calendar as presented. 9.a APPROVAL OF CITY COUNCIL, SUCCESSOR AGENCY, AND HOUSING AUTHORITY MINUTES 9 RECOMMENDATION: Approve the Minutes of April 25, 2024. 9.b APPROVAL OF WARRANT REGISTERS 21 RECOMMENDATION: Approve the warrant registers issued for the period 4/22/2024 to 4/25/2024. City Council Meeting 2 9.c RECEIVE AND FILE APPLICATIONS FOR ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE LICENSES 33 RECOMMENDATION: Receive and file application for alcoholic beverage license for Jackson 6843 (Food Mart) 72300 Highway 111, Palm Desert, California 92260-2747 9.d ADOPTION OF ORDINANCE NO. 1412 ADDING CHAPTER 9.71 TO TITLE 9 (PUBLIC PEACE, MORALS AND WELFARE) OF THE PALM DESERT MUNICIPAL CODE, ESTABLISHING REGULATIONS PROHIBITING THE UNLAWFUL POSSESSION OF CATALYTIC CONVERTERS 37 RECOMMENDATION: Adopt Ordinance No. 1412 entitled, “AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, ADDING CHAPTER 9.71 (UNLAWFUL POSSESSION OF A CATALYTIC CONVERTER PROHIBITED) TO TITLE 9 (PUBLIC PEACE, MORALS AND WELFARE) OF THE PALM DESERT MUNICIPAL CODE, ESTABLISHING REGULATIONS PROHIBITING THE UNLAWFUL POSSESSION OF CATALYTIC CONVERTERS IN THE CITY” 9.e ADOPTION OF ORDINANCE NO. 1413 AMENDING CHAPTER 2.74 OF THE PALM DESERT MUNICIPAL CODE TO ESTABLISH A PALM DESERT LIBRARY BOARD OF TRUSTEES AND LIBRARY ADVISORY COMMITTEE AND MAKING A FINDING OF EXEMPTION UNDER CEQA 45 RECOMMENDATION: Adopt Ordinance No. 1413 entitled, “AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, AMENDING CHAPTER 2.74 OF THE PALM DESERT MUNICIPAL CODE TO ESTABLISH A LIBRARY BOARD OF TRUSTEES AND LIBRARY ADVISORY COMMITTEE, AND MAKING A FINDING OF EXEMPTION UNDER CEQA.” 9.f APPROVE RESOURCE PRESERVATION AND ENHANCEMENT COMMITTEE 2024/2025 WORK PLAN 51 RECOMMENDATION: Approve the Resource Preservation and Enhancement Committee’s 2024/2025 Work Plan. 9.g RECEIVE AND FILE A CERTIFICATE OF APPRECIATION FROM THE WORLD ROMA FEDERATION 57 RECOMMENDATION: Receive and file a Certificate of Appreciation from the World Roma Federation. City Council Meeting 3 9.h APPROVAL OF EIGHTEEN (18) SCULPTURES AND SIX (6) ALTERNATE SCULPTURES FOR THE FY 2025/2026 EL PASEO SCULPTURE EXHIBITION 61 RECOMMENDATION: Approve eighteen (18) sculptures and six (6) alternate sculptures for the 2025/2026 El Paseo Sculpture Exhibition. 1. Approve honorarium of $5,000 for each of the participating artists.2. Authorize staff to finalize negotiations of the subject contracts with the eighteen (18) artists and authorize City Manager to execute same, subject to the satisfaction of the City Attorney. 3. Authorize City Manager to make changes to sculpture selection based on staff recommendation. 4. 9.i AUTHORIZE CITY MANAGER TO AWARD LIBRARY FURNITURE, FIXTURE, FINISHES, AND EQUIPMENT CONTRACTS TO MULTIPLE VENDORS TO OUTFIT THE LIBRARY LOCATED AT 73-300 FRED WARING DRIVE IN THE ADDITIONAL AMOUNT OF $42,000 99 RECOMMENDATION: Authorize increase of $42,000 to previously approved City Manager Not to Exceed threshold of $650,000 for furniture, fixture, and equipment (FF&E) vendors for the library located at 73-300 Fred Waring Drive, for a total of $692,000. 1. Authorize the City Manager to execute any agreements, amendments, and all other documents necessary to effectuate this action. 2. Authorize the City Attorney to make any necessary non-monetary changes to the agreement. 3. 9.j APPROVE A ONE YEAR LEASE AGREEMENT WITH ONE, ONE-YEAR EXTENSION WITH CHRIS NELSON FOR THE OPERATION OF A REMOTE CONTROLLED RACETRACK ON THE VACANT CITY-OWNED PARCEL, ASSESSOR’S PARCEL NO. 640-091-010 101 RECOMMENDATION: Approve a one (1) year lease agreement with one (1), one (1) year extension with Chris Nelson for the operation of a remote controlled racetrack on the vacant City-owned parcel with Assessor’s Parcel No. (APN) 640-091-010. 1. Authorize the City Attorney to make necessary, nonmonetary changes to the lease agreement. 2. Authorize the City Manager to execute the lease and any and all related documents. 3. City Council Meeting 4 9.k RESOLUTION FOR THE NATIONAL WILDLIFE FEDERATION’S MAYORS’ MONARCH PLEDGE TO RENEW THE CITY’S EFFORTS TO PROTECT AND ENHANCE THE POLLINATOR POPULATION 111 RECOMMENDATION: Adopt a Resolution entitled “A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, AUTHORIZING THE CITY TO ENTER INTO THE NATIONAL WILDLIFE FEDERATION MAYORS’ MONARCH PLEDGE.” 1. Authorize staff to work in collaboration with the Living Desert Zoo and Gardens and University of California, Riverside (UCR) Palm Desert Center to carry out the three specific actions listed below within the next year: 2. Issue a Proclamation to raise awareness about the decline of the monarch butterfly and the species’ need for habitat. a. Increase the area of pollinator-friendly demonstration garden at Civic Center Park. b. Support milkweed propagation by planting milkweed at various City parks and medians, where advisable. c. 9.l RESOLUTION DENYING A STREET VACATION OF AN 8,582 SQUARE FOOT PORTION OF SHADOW LAKE DRIVE IN FAVOR OF A PROPERTY AT 73745 SHADOW LAKE DRIVE 119 RECOMMENDATION: Adopt a Resolution entitled, “A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, DENYING A PROPOSED STREET VACATION OF AN 8,582 SQUARE FOOT PORTION OF SHADOW LAKE DRIVE IN FAVOR OF A PROPERTY AT 73745 SHADOW LAKE DRIVE IS CONSISTENT WITH THE CITY OF PALM DESERT GENERAL PLAN (APNS: 627-342-001).” 9.m RESOLUTION OF SUPPORT FOR THE PROPOSED CHUCKWALLA NATIONAL MONUMENT, INCLUDING EXPANSION OF JOSHUA TREE NATIONAL PARK 139 RECOMMENDATION: Adopt a Resolution entitled “A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, IN SUPPORT OF THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE PROPOSED CHUCKWALLA NATIONAL MONUMENT AND EXPANSION OF JOSHUA TREE NATIONAL PARK VIA AN ADJACENT NATIONAL MONUMENT.” City Council Meeting 5 9.n APPROVE THE START OF PROCEEDINGS TO LEVY AND COLLECT ANNUAL ASSESSMENTS AND GRANT PRELIMINARY APPROVAL OF THE 2024-25 ENGINEER’S REPORT FOR CONSOLIDATED PALM DESERT LANDSCAPING AND LIGHTING MAINTENANCE DISTRICT NO.1 161 RECOMMENDATION: Adopt a Resolution entitled “A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, DECLARING ITS INTENTION TO INITIATE PROCEEDINGS FOR THE LEVY AND COLLECTION OF ANNUAL ASSESSMENTS FOR CONSOLIDATED PALM DESERT LANDSCAPING AND LIGHTING MAINTENANCE DISTRICT NO. 1 FOR FISCAL YEAR 2024-25. 1. Adopt a Resolution entitled “A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, DECLARING ITS INTENTION TO LEVY AND COLLECT THE ANNUAL ASSESSMENTS FOR CONSOLIDATED PALM DESERT LANDSCAPING AND LIGHTING MAINTENANCE DISTRICT NO. 1 FOR FISCAL YEAR 2024-25 AND PRELIMINARY APPROVAL OF THE ENGINEER’S REPORT.” 2. Set a public hearing to be held at the City Council meeting of June 27, 2024, at 4 p.m. 3. 9.o APPROVE THE START OF PROCEEDINGS TO LEVY THE ANNUAL ASSESSMENT FOR CITY OF PALM DESERT BENEFIT ASSESSMENT DISTRICT NO. 1 FOR FISCAL YEAR 2024/2025 243 RECOMMENDATION: Adopt a Resolution entitled “A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, INITIATING PROCEEDINGS FOR THE LEVY AND COLLECTION OF ASSESSMENTS FOR PLAM DESERT BENEFIT ASSESSMENT DISTRICT NO. 1 FOR FISCAL YEARS 2024/2025.” 1. Adopt a Resolution entitled “A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, DECLARING ITS INTENTION TO LEVY THE ANNUAL ASSESSMENT FOR CITY OF PALM DESERT BENEFIT ASSESSMENT DISTRICT NO. 1 FOR FISCAL YEAR 2024/2025, PURSUANT TO THE BENEFIT ASSESSMENT ACT OF 1982 AND APPOINTING A TIME AND PLACE FOR THE PUBLIC HEARING ON THESE MATTERS.” 2. Set a public hearing to be held at the City Council meeting of June 27, 2024, at 4 p.m. 3. 10.ACTION CALENDAR The public may comment on individual Action Items within the three-minute time limit. Speakers may utilize one of the three options listed on the first page of the agenda. City Council Meeting 6 10.a INTRODUCTION OF AN ORDINANCE ADDING SECTION 2.38.070 TO THE PALM DESERT MUNICIPAL CODE TO ALLOW FOR THE ELECTRONIC OR PAPER FILING OF CAMPAIGN FINANCE DISCLOSURE STATEMENTS 283 RECOMMENDATION: Introduce an Ordinance entitled, “AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, ADDING SECTION 2.38.070 TO THE PALM DESERT MUNICIPAL CODE APPROVING ELECTRONIC AND PAPER METHODS OF FILING CAMPAIGN FINANCE DISCLOSURE STATEMENTS.” 10.b REQUEST FOR DIRECTION REGARDING LUPINE PLAZA PROJECT CST00015 289 RECOMMENDATION: Provide staff direction on the Lupine Plaza Project CST00015. 11.PUBLIC HEARINGS The public may comment on individual Public Hearing Items within the three- minute time limit. The applicant or appellant will be provided up to five minutes to make their presentation. Speakers may utilize one of the three options listed on the first page of this agenda. 11.a APPEAL OF THE DEVELOPMENT SERVICES DIRECTOR DETERMINATION THAT A LIVING ROOM CANNOT BE COUNTED AS A BEDROOM FOR PURPOSES OF A SHORT-TERM RENTAL 321 RECOMMENDATION: Find that this report, including attachments, and any additional evidence provided at the hearing provides satisfactory evidence that the Development Services Director’s determination was correct. 1. Adopt a Resolution entitled “A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, UPHOLDING THE DEVELOPMENT SERVICES DIRECTOR DETERMINATION THAT A LIVING ROOM CANNOT BE COUNTED AS A BEDROOM FOR PURPOSES OF A SHORT- TERM RENTAL AND MAKING FINDINGS IN SUPPORT THEREOF.” 2. 12.INFORMATION ITEMS 13.ADJOURNMENT City Council Meeting 7 14.PUBLIC NOTICES Agenda Related Materials: Pursuant to Government Code §54957.5(b)(2) the designated office for inspection of records in connection with this meeting is the Office of the City Clerk, Palm Desert Civic Center, 73-510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert. Staff reports for all agenda items considered in open session, and documents provided to a majority of the legislative bodies are available for public inspection at City Hall and on the City’s website at www.palmdesert.gov by clicking “Council Agenda” at the top of the page. Americans with Disabilities Act: It is the intention of the City of Palm Desert to comply with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) in all respects. If, as an attendee or a participant at this meeting, or in meetings on a regular basis, you will need special assistance beyond what is normally provided, the city will attempt to accommodate you in every reasonable manner. Please contact the Office of the City Clerk, (760) 346-0611, at least 48 hours prior to the meeting to inform us of your needs and to determine if accommodation is feasible. AFFIDAVIT OF POSTING I, Níamh M. Ortega, Assistant City Clerk of the City of Palm Desert, do hereby certify, under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California, that the foregoing agenda for the Palm Desert City Council, Successor Agency for the Palm Desert Redevelopment Agency, and Housing Authority, was posted on the City Hall bulletin board and City website www.palmdesert.gov no less than 72 hours prior to the meeting. /S/ Níamh M. Ortega Assistant City Clerk City Council Meeting 8 Palm Desert City Council Meeting Minutes April 25, 2024 1 Palm Desert City Council, Successor Agency to the Palm Desert Redevelopment Agency, and Housing Authority Regular Meeting Minutes April 25, 2024, 3:45 p.m. Present: Mayor Pro Tem Jan Harnik, Councilmember Kathleen Kelly, Councilmember Gina Nestande, Councilmember Evan Trubee, and Mayor Karina Quintanilla 1. CALL TO ORDER - CLOSED SESSION - 3:45 P.M. A Regular Meeting of the Palm Desert City Council was called to order by Mayor Quintanilla on Thursday, April 25, 2024, at 3:45 p.m. in the Council Chamber, City Hall, located at 73-510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert, California. 2. PUBLIC COMMENT FOR CLOSED SESSION ITEMS ONLY None. 3. RECESS TO CLOSED SESSION Mayor Quintanilla adjourned to Closed Session at 3:45 p.m. 4. CLOSED SESSION AGENDA The following items were considered in closed session: 4.a Closed Session Meeting Minutes: March 28, 2024 4.b Conference with Real Property Negotiations pursuant to Government Code Section 54956.8 4.b.1 Property Description: Vacant lot west of Painter's Path, South of Fred Waring (APN 640-091-010) 5. ROLL CALL - REGULAR MEETING - 4:00 P.M. 6. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE Councilmember Nestande led the Pledge of Allegiance. 7. INSPIRATION Councilmember Trubee provided words of inspiration. 8. REPORT OF CLOSED SESSION City Attorney Shah stated no reportable actions were taken by the City Council. 9 Palm Desert City Council Meeting Minutes April 25, 2024 2 9. AWARDS, PRESENTATIONS, AND APPOINTMENTS 9.a RECOGNITION: GERALD DAWSON, PARKS AND RECREATION COMMITTEE The City Council expressed their appreciation to Mr. Dawson for 21 years of service on the Parks and Recreation Committee. 9.b PRESENTATION: WILDFLOWER FESTIVAL UPDATE Friends of the Desert Mountains representative Tammy Martin narrated a PowerPoint presentation and responded to City Council inquiries. 10. CITY MANAGER COMMENTS City Manager Hileman introduced Homeless and Support Services Manager Ivan Tenorio and welcomed him to the City's team. 10.a TOWN HALL MEETINGS Finance Director Chavez informed the City Council that a series of town hall meetings were scheduled during the month of May to gather resident input on various topics of interest. 11. MAYOR/COUNCILMEMBER REPORTS AND REQUESTS FOR ACTION Councilmembers reported on their attendance at various meetings and events. Councilmember Kelly requested that staff provide an update at a future City Council meeting regarding the economic impact of upcoming closure and announced bankruptcy of Rite-Aid and 99 cent stores respectively, located in the Palms to Pines shopping center in Palm Desert. 12. NON-AGENDA PUBLIC COMMENTS Sue Townsley, Cathedral City resident, thanked the City of Palm Desert for its support of a recent jazz event in Cathedral City. Alan Carvalho, Cathedral City resident, displayed a video of the jazz event. Patrick Cameron, Desert Hot Springs, representing the Cannabis Workers Coalition, spoke about the value of standardized trainings offered by the Coalition and shared their primary objective of advocating for the allocation of cannabis tax revenue for the benefit of cannabis industry workers. Brad Anderson, Rancho Mirage resident, expressed his desire for public comment to be heard at study sessions. 10 Palm Desert City Council Meeting Minutes April 25, 2024 3 13. CONSENT CALENDAR Motion by: Councilmember Kelly Seconded by: Mayor Pro Tem Harnik To approve the consent calendar as presented. Motion Carried (5 to 0) 13.a APPROVAL OF CITY COUNCIL, SUCCESSOR AGENCY, AND HOUSING AUTHORITY MINUTES Approve the Minutes of April 11, 2024. Motion Carried (5 to 0) 13.b APPROVAL OF WARRANT REGISTERS Approve the warrant registers issued for April 12, 2024. Motion Carried (5 to 0) 13.c RECEIVE AND FILE APPLICATIONS FOR ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE LICENSES Receive and file applications for alcoholic beverage licenses for: 1. Palm Valley Country Club 76200 Country Club Dr., Palm Desert, California 92211 2. Monterey Country Club 41500 Monterey Ave., Palm Desert, California 92260-2173 3. Mojave Resort 73721 Shadow Mountain Drive, Palm Desert, California 92260-4841 Motion Carried (5 to 0) 13.d ADOPTION OF ORDINANCE NO. 1410 RELATIVE TO THE PURCHASING SYSTEM AND PUBLIC WORKS CONTRACTS AND MAKING FINDINGS UNDER CEQA Adopt Ordinance No. 1410 entitled, “AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, REPLACING CHAPTER 3.30 IN ITS ENTIRETY AND RESCINDING ORDINANCES NO. 224, 423, 586, 927, 928, 986, 1162, 1166, 1204, 1229, 1276, 1317, 1335 AND 1392 RELATIVE TO THE PURCHASING SYSTEM AND PUBLIC WORKS CONTRACTS AND MAKING FINDINGS UNDER CEQA.” Motion Carried (5 to 0) 11 Palm Desert City Council Meeting Minutes April 25, 2024 4 13.e ADOPTION OF ORDINANCE NO. 1411 TO ADOPT A ZONING ORDINANCE AMENDMENT TO IMPLEMENT RESIDENTIAL AND MIXED-USE OBJECTIVE DESIGN STANDARDS AND MAKING A FINDING OF EXEMPTION UNDER CEQA Adopt Ordinance No. 1411 entitled, “AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, APPROVING A ZONING ORDINANCE AMENDMENT OF THE PALM DESERT MUNICIPAL CODE TO ADD CHAPTER 25.42 – MULTIFAMILY AND MIXED-USE OBJECTIVE DESIGN STANDARDS, AMENDING OTHER CHAPTERS OF TITLE 25 TO IMPLEMENT CITY-WIDE MULTIFAMILY AND MIXED-USE RESIENTIAL OBJECTIVE DESIGN STANDARDS AND MAKING A FINDING OF EXEMPTION UNDER THE CALIFORNIA ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY ACT, CASE NO. ZOA24-0001” Motion Carried (5 to 0) 13.f RATIFY A LETTER OF SUPPORT FOR ASSEMBLY BILL 2485: RHNA TRANSPARENCY REFORM ACT Ratify issuance of a letter of support for Assembly Bill 2485: Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) Transparency Reform Act. Motion Carried (5 to 0) 13.g RESOLUTION NO. 2024-014 TO AUTHORIZE DESTRUCTION OF OBSOLETE RECORDS FROM THE CITY CLERK AND CITY MANAGER DIVISIONS Adopt Resolution No. 2024-014 entitled, "A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, SETTING FORTH ITS FINDINGS AND AUTHORIZING THE DESTRUCTION OF PAPER RECORDS FROM THE CITY CLERK AND CITY MANAGER DIVISIONS, AS INDICATED ON THE RECORDS RETENTION SCHEDULE (ADOPTED DECEMBER 15, 2022) RECORDS FROM 2005 THROUGH 2020". Motion Carried (5 to 0) 13.h ACCEPT CONTRACT NO. C45010 AS COMPLETE FOR THE BRIDGE PREVENTATIVE MAINTENANCE PROGRAM (PROJECT NO. MFA00007) 1. Accept Contract C45010 with MLC Constructors, Inc., of Corona, California, for the Bridge Preventative Maintenance Program as complete. (Project MFA00007) 2. Authorize the Mayor to execute and the City Clerk to file the Notice of Completion. Motion Carried (5 to 0) 12 Palm Desert City Council Meeting Minutes April 25, 2024 5 13.i ACCEPT CONTRACT NO. C45210 AS COMPLETE FOR THE FISCAL YEAR 2022/23 CATCH BASIN AND DRAIN CLEANING PROJECT (PROJECT NO. CDR00002) 1. Accept Contract No. C45210 with United Storm Water, Inc., of City of Industry, California, for the Fiscal Year 2022/23 Catch Basin and Drain Cleaning Project as complete. (Project No. CDR00002) 2. Authorize the Mayor to execute and the City Clerk to file the Notice of Completion. Motion Carried (5 to 0) 13.j RECEIVE AND FILE UPDATE ON COMMUNITY HEROES MURAL Receive and file update on Community Heroes mural to be installed at the City’s Corporate Yard. Motion Carried (5 to 0) 13.k RELEASE THE GRADING BOND FOR THE MILLENNIUM APARTMENTS PROJECT Release the Grading Bond for the Millennium Apartments Project in the full amount of $189,393.50. Motion Carried (5 to 0) 13.l AUTHORIZE AND AWARD CONTRACT NO. C47460 TO TKE ENGINEERING, INC., AS AN ADDITIONAL CONSULTANT TO THE ON-CALL CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT CONTRACT IN AN AGGREGATE AMOUNT NOT TO EXCEED $11,739,394 1. Authorize and award Contract No. C47460 to TKE Engineering, Inc., as an additional consultant to the On-Call Construction Management Contract in an aggregate amount not to exceed $11,739,394. 2. Authorize the City Manager to execute said agreements and subsequent task orders. 3. Direct the City Attorney, Director of Finance, and Director of Public Works/Capital Projects to review annual expenditures and performance of the vendors under said Agreement. Motion Carried (5 to 0) 13 Palm Desert City Council Meeting Minutes April 25, 2024 6 13.m RATIFY CHANGE ORDER NO. 1 TO CONTRACT NO. C46150 WITH THE VAN DYKE CORPORATION FOR HILARY STORM REPAIRS IN THE AMOUNT NOT TO EXCEED $609,760 1. Ratify Change Order No. 1 to Contract No. C46150 with the Van Dyke Corporation for Hilary Storm Repairs in an amount not to exceed $609,760. 2. Authorize the Director of Finance to set aside a contingency in an amount not to exceed $30,488. 3. Authorize the City Manager to review and approve written requests for the use of contingency per Section 3.30.170 B of the Palm Desert Municipal Code. 4. Authorize City Manager to execute the change order and any documents necessary to effectuate the actions taken herewith. Motion Carried (5 to 0) 13.n AWARD CONTRACT NO. C47470 TO WESTERN STATE BUILDERS FOR PALMA VILLAGE PARK IMPROVEMENTS IN AN AMOUNT NOT TO EXCEED $381,437 (PROJECT NO. MPK00007) 1. Waive any minor proposal irregularities and award Contract No. C47470 to Western State Builders, Inc., of Escondido, California, in an amount not to exceed $381,437 to construct improvements at Palma Village Park. 2. Authorize the Director of Finance to set aside $78,000 in contingency for unforeseen circumstances. 3. Appropriate $176,000 to CDBG Account No. 2204649-4400100, Palm Village Park Capital Project. 4. Authorize the City Manager to review and approve change orders for any unforeseen circumstances per Palm Desert Municipal Code Section 3.30.170. 5. Authorize the City Attorney to make any necessary, non-monetary changes to the Agreement. 6. Authorize the City Manager to execute said agreement and contract amendments as needed to complete said work. Motion Carried (5 to 0) 14 Palm Desert City Council Meeting Minutes April 25, 2024 7 13.o APPROVE FISCAL YEAR 2024/25 WORK PLAN FOR THE CULTURAL RESOURCE PRESERVATION COMMITTEE Approve the Fiscal Year 2024/25 Annual Work Plan for the Cultural Resources Preservation Committee. Motion Carried (5 to 0) 14. ACTION CALENDAR 14.a INTRODUCE ORDINANCE NO. 1412 ADDING CHAPTER 9.71 TO TITLE 9 (PUBLIC PEACE, MORALS AND WELFARE) OF THE PALM DESERT MUNICIPAL CODE, ESTABLISHING REGULATIONS PROHIBITING THE UNLAWFUL POSSESSION OF CATALYTIC CONVERTERS Public Safety Analyst Hurtado narrated a PowerPoint presentation and responded to City Council inquiries. Daryl Terrell, Moreno Valley resident, expressed his support for the proposed ordinance prohibiting unlawful possession of catalytic converters. Brad Anderson, Rancho Mirage resident, expressed his opposition to creating an ordinance to address the theft of catalytic converters. Motion by: Councilmember Kelly Seconded by: Mayor Pro Tem Harnik Introduce Ordinance No. 1412 entitled, “AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, ADDING CHAPTER 9.71 (UNLAWFUL POSSESSION OF A CATALYTIC CONVERTER PROHIBITED) TO TITLE 9 (PUBLIC PEACE, MORALS AND WELFARE) OF THE PALM DESERT MUNICIPAL CODE, ESTABLISHING REGULATIONS PROHIBITING THE UNLAWFUL POSSESSION OF CATALYTIC CONVERTERS IN THE CITY.” Motion Carried (5 to 0) 15 Palm Desert City Council Meeting Minutes April 25, 2024 8 14.b REQUEST FOR OUT-OF-STATE TRAVEL FOR MAYOR QUINTANILLA TO ATTEND THE NALEO ANNUAL CONFERENCE IN LAS VEGAS, NEVADA City Clerk Mejia presented a staff report and responded to City Council inquiries. Motion by: Councilmember Kelly Seconded by: Councilmember Nestande Authorize out-of-state travel for Mayor Quintanilla to attend the National Association of Latino Elected and Appointed Officials (NALEO) Annual Conference held on June 17-20, 2024, in Las Vegas, Nevada, with the understanding that she will forgo her attendance at the 2024 International Council of Shopping Centers (ICSC) Annual Conference in Las Vegas, Nevada. NOES (1): Councilmember Trubee Motion Carried (4 to 1) 14.c ADOPT THE PALM DESERT RAIL STATION FEASIBILITY STUDY Management Analyst Mager and Kimley Horn representative Darryl DePencier narrated a PowerPoint presentation and responded to City Council inquiries. Motion by: Councilmember Kelly Seconded by: Mayor Pro Tem Harnik 1. Adopt the Palm Desert Rail Station Feasibility Study. 2. Direct staff to submit the study to Riverside County Transportation Commission (RCTC) for their consideration to include in the Tier 2 study. Motion Carried (5 to 0) 14.d INTRODUCTION OF ORDINANCE NO. 1413 OF THE CITY COUNCIL, AMENDING CHAPTER 2.74 OF THE PALM DESERT MUNICIPAL CODE TO ESTABLISH A PALM DESERT LIBRARY BOARD OF TRUSTEES AND LIBRARY ADVISORY COMMITTEE AND MAKING A FINDING OF EXEMPTION UNDER CEQA Director of Library Services Shaffer presented a staff report and responded to City Council inquiries. Motion by: Councilmember Kelly Seconded by: Councilmember Trubee Introduce Ordinance No. 1413 entitled, “AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, AMENDING CHAPTER 2.74 OF THE PALM DESERT MUNICIPAL CODE TO ESTABLISH A LIBRARY BOARD OF TRUSTEES AND LIBRARY ADVISORY COMMITTEE, AND MAKING A FINDING OF EXEMPTION UNDER CEQA.” 16 Palm Desert City Council Meeting Minutes April 25, 2024 9 Motion Carried (5 to 0) 14.e APPROVE RECOMMENDATIONS FOR UNIVERSITY DOG PARK PARKING AND EL PASEO MID-BLOCK CROSSWALKS Deputy Director of Public Works Chavez narrated a PowerPoint presentation and responded to City Council inquiries. Motion by: Mayor Quintanilla Consider the University Dog Park Parking and El Paseo Crosswalks items separately due to differences in the project type and geographical locations. Motion Fails Motion by: Councilmember Kelly Seconded by: Councilmember Nestande 1. Approve additional street parking and a standard crosswalk with a Rectangular Rapid Flashing Beacon (RRFB) system on University Park Drive. 2. Approve the replacement of three RRFB systems at mid-block crosswalks on El Paseo and Larkspur Lane. 3. Approve two new mid-block crosswalks with RRFB systems on El Paseo. 4. Approve asphalt finish with decorative art on all five mid-block crosswalks. 5. Authorize the removal of multi-colored decorative crosswalk painting. NOES (1): Mayor Quintanilla Motion Carried (4 to 1) 17 Palm Desert City Council Meeting Minutes April 25, 2024 10 15. PUBLIC HEARINGS 15.a CONSIDER MAKING A FINDING OF EXEMPTION UNDER CEQA AND APPROVE A STREET VACATION OF AN 8,582 SQUARE FOOT PORTION OF SHADOW LAKE DRIVE IN FAVOR OF A PROPERTY AT 73745 SHADOW LAKE DRIVE Mayor Pro Tem Harnik recused herself from this item due to proximity to her residence, and left the Council Chamber. Mayor Quintanilla opened the public hearing. Principal Planner Flores narrated a PowerPoint presentation and responded to City Council inquiries. Mayor Quintanilla closed the public hearing, there being no member of the public wishing to speak. Following the close of the vote, Mayor Pro Tem Harnik returned to the Council Chamber. Motion by: Councilmember Kelly Seconded by: Councilmember Nestande 1. Direct staff to prepare a resolution of denial for the City Council's consideration at a future meeting. 2. Direct staff and City Attorney to explore potential next steps. RECUSED (1): Mayor Pro Tem Harnik Motion Carried (4 to 0) 16. INFORMATION ITEMS None. 17. ADJOURNMENT The City Council adjourned at 6:26 p.m. Respectfully submitted, _________________________ Níamh M. Ortega, CMC Assistant City Clerk/Assistant Secretary _________________________ Anthony J. Mejia, MMC City Clerk/Secretary 18 1 Study Session of the Palm Desert City Council (CC), Successor Agency to the Palm Desert Redevelopment Agency (SARDA), and Housing Authority (HA) Minutes April 25, 2024, 3:15 p.m. Present: Mayor Pro Tem Jan Harnik, Councilmember Kathleen Kelly, Councilmember Gina Nestande, Councilmember Evan Trubee, Mayor Karina Quintanilla Pursuant to Assembly Bill 2449, this meeting was conducted by teleconference and there was in-person public access to the meeting location. 1. CALL TO ORDER - STUDY SESSION A Study Session of the Palm Desert City Council was called to order by Mayor Quintanilla on Thursday, April 25, 2024, at 3:15 p.m. in the Council Chamber, City Hall, located at 73-510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert, California. 2. STUDY SESSION TOPICS 2.a STUDY SESSION: STORM WATER PROTECTION PLAN Deputy Director of Public Works Chavez and Project Manager Neal Ennis narrated a PowerPoint presentation and responded to City Council inquiries. 3. ADJOURNMENT The City Council adjourned the Study Session at 3:32 p.m. Respectfully submitted, _________________________ Níamh M. Ortega, CMC Assistant City Clerk/Assistant Secretary _________________________ Anthony J. Mejia, MMC City Clerk/Secretary 19 20 Check DateCheck Number Vendor NameBank ID Check Register Amount PaidInvoiceTransaction Desc 4/22/2024 - 4/22/2024 City of Palm Desert Account Number 04/22/202402002714 U S POSTMASTERW1 Brightside Postage May/Jun2443026001104417 BRIGHTSIDE MAY24 7,492.78 04/22/202402002715 ESCRIBE SOFTWARE LTD.W1 Agenda Management Software43620011104190 5849 10,010.00 04/22/202402002715 ESCRIBE SOFTWARE LTD.W1 Agenda Management Software43620011104190 5840 17,640.00 Examined and Approved Total For Bank ID - W1 35,142.78City Manager Examined and Approved Mayor or Mayor Pro-Tem Audited and Found Correct Director of Finance 04/22/2024Report Date 1Page City and Housing DocuSign Envelope ID: 7883CFCC-9AB8-4610-B8F4-A8399730BB84 21 22 Check DateCheck Number Vendor NameBank ID Check Register Amount PaidInvoiceTransaction Desc 4/25/2024 - 4/30/2024 City of Palm Desert Account Number 04/25/202400001719 AMS CONNECTW1 R/M ALARM - STATE BLDG43696025104195 4528979 144.00 04/25/202400001719 AMS CONNECTW1 R/M ALARM - CORPYARD43310001104330 4552578 407.99 04/25/202400001720 CDW LLCW1 Library Laptops44001004524136 QS47854 29,466.87 04/25/202400001720 CDW LLCW1 Sales tax difference (10.75%)44001004524136 QS47854 818.42 04/25/202400001720 CDW LLCW1 FY2324 Equipment Replacement44040005304190 QR53321 1,645.47 04/25/202400001720 CDW LLCW1 5 Toners42120001104190 QS65671 420.09 04/25/202400001720 CDW LLCW1 FY2324 Laptop Replacements44040005304190 QR47743 5,754.62 04/25/202400001721 CITY NETW1 St outreach & engage FEB 202443090002254212 2024-0200-121 9,403.31 04/25/202400001721 CITY NETW1 St outreach & engage FEB 202443090002264212 2024-0200-121 9,403.30 04/25/202400001722 ESRIW1 ESRI FY 24/2514301001100000 94695179 20,976.16 04/25/202400001722 ESRIW1 ESRI FY 23/2443620011104190 94695179 6,992.05 04/25/202400001723 FAMILY YMCA OF THE DESERTW1 AQUATIC CTR - 3RD PARTY REV37999991100000 022024 -900.00 04/25/202400001723 FAMILY YMCA OF THE DESERTW1 AQUATIC CTR - 3RD PARTY REV37999991100000 032024 -1,714.40 04/25/202400001723 FAMILY YMCA OF THE DESERTW1 AQUATIC CTR - 3RD PARTY REVEN37999991100000 012024 -380.00 04/25/202400001723 FAMILY YMCA OF THE DESERTW1 AQUATIC CTR - SUPPLIES42190002424549 022024 3,625.70 04/25/202400001723 FAMILY YMCA OF THE DESERTW1 AQUATIC CTR - SUPPLIES42190002424549 032024 2,673.80 04/25/202400001723 FAMILY YMCA OF THE DESERTW1 AQUATIC CTR - SUPPLIES42190002424549 012024 994.72 04/25/202400001723 FAMILY YMCA OF THE DESERTW1 AQUATIC CTR - OTHER EXPENSES43090002424549 022024 10,569.53 04/25/202400001723 FAMILY YMCA OF THE DESERTW1 AQUATIC CTR - MERCHANT FEES43090002424549 022024 -1,164.63 04/25/202400001723 FAMILY YMCA OF THE DESERTW1 AQUATIC CTR - OTHER EXPENSES43090002424549 032024 9,729.74 04/25/202400001723 FAMILY YMCA OF THE DESERTW1 AQUATIC CTR - OTHER EXPENSES43090002424549 012024 6,049.30 04/25/202400001723 FAMILY YMCA OF THE DESERTW1 AQUATIC CTR - MERCHANT FEES43090002424549 012024 -896.86 04/25/202400001723 FAMILY YMCA OF THE DESERTW1 AQUATIC CTR - MANAGEMENT FEE43093002424549 022024 16,666.76 04/25/202400001723 FAMILY YMCA OF THE DESERTW1 AQUATIC CTR - MANAGEMENT FEE43093002424549 032024 16,666.67 04/25/202400001723 FAMILY YMCA OF THE DESERTW1 AQUATIC CTR - MANAGEMENT FEE43093002424549 012024 16,666.67 04/25/202400001723 FAMILY YMCA OF THE DESERTW1 AQUATIC CTR - FOOD / MERCHANDI48011002424549 032024 1,356.63 04/25/202400001723 FAMILY YMCA OF THE DESERTW1 AQUATIC CTR - COST OF GOODS48011002424549 032024 259.60 04/30/2024Report Date 1Page City and Housing DocuSign Envelope ID: 5907ED88-8F21-42FC-ACDA-D675F981A251 23 Check DateCheck Number Vendor NameBank ID Check Register Amount PaidInvoiceTransaction Desc 4/25/2024 - 4/30/2024 City of Palm Desert Account Number 04/25/202400001723 FAMILY YMCA OF THE DESERTW1 AQUATIC CTR - FOOD / MERCHANDI48011002424549 012024 539.62 04/25/202400001723 FAMILY YMCA OF THE DESERTW1 AQUATIC CTR - CONTRACTED LABOR48021012424549 022024 86,370.87 04/25/202400001723 FAMILY YMCA OF THE DESERTW1 AQUATIC CTR - CONTRACTED LABOR48021012424549 032024 131,095.98 04/25/202400001723 FAMILY YMCA OF THE DESERTW1 AQUATIC CTR - CONTRACTED LABOR48021012424549 012024 80,714.03 04/25/202400001724 FEDERAL EXPRESS CORP.W1 HDL Biz Lic Renewals43660001104422 8-460-19017 35.86 04/25/202400001724 FEDERAL EXPRESS CORP.W1 Housing-1st Amer Title Insuran43660008734195 8-460-19017 25.89 04/25/202400001725 FIRSTCHOICE COFFEE SERVICEW1 KITCHEN SUPPLIES42190001104340 737375 2,435.75 04/25/202400001725 FIRSTCHOICE COFFEE SERVICEW1 COFFEE AND KITCHEN SUPPLIES42190001104340 739134 1,922.33 04/25/202400001726 HORIZON PROFESSIONAL LANDSCAPEW1 EXTRA WORK - SANDPIPER CT W43321002754695 6696 1,098.32 04/25/202400001726 HORIZON PROFESSIONAL LANDSCAPEW1 EXTRA WORK - DW PERIMETER43320004414195 6699 2,478.67 04/25/202400001727 HR GREEN PACIFIC INCW1 DW FIRECLIFF INSP & CONSTR MGM48092004414195 173514 5,737.50 04/25/202400001728 INNOVATIVE INTERFACES INCW1 Clarivate Milestone1 04.27.2443620012524662 INV-INC36700 2,275.00 04/25/202400001729 KIMLEY-HORN AND ASSOCIATES INC.W1 Rail Station Feas Stud MR2443090001104430 27747366 16,731.58 04/25/202400001730 MARIPOSA LANDSCAPES INCW1 MR24 LMA 1 MONTHLY LANDS MAINT43370011104614 106922 41,125.38 04/25/202400001730 MARIPOSA LANDSCAPES INCW1 EXTRA WORK - ENTRADA DEL PASEO43921011104614 107239 963.88 04/25/202400001731 MICHAEL BAKER INTERNATIONAL INCW1 WALK N ROLL PD ENG50001032134633 1207772 2,746.29 04/25/202400001732 NV5 INCW1 NORTH SPHERE DRY UTILITY43090001104159 380058 618.00 04/25/202400001733 OTIS ELEVATOR COW1 ELEVATOR SVC - PARKVIEW OFFICE43696015104195 100401435589 2,636.88 04/25/202400001734 PFM ASSET MANAGEMENT LLCW1 Investment Mgmt FEB2443090001104159 14151779 3,681.23 04/25/202400001735 PURE WATER PARTNERS LLCW1 WATER DISPENSER - SHERIFF SS43695005104195 1688050 134.35 04/25/202400001736 RHYTHM TECH PRODUCTIONS LLCW1 PD Concerts 2024 - 5/02/2443061011104416 1310 3,000.00 04/25/202400001737 RIVERSIDE COUNTY FIRE DEPT.W1 FY 23/24 Fire Prot OCT-DEC Q243045002304220 235298 820,816.41 04/25/202400001737 RIVERSIDE COUNTY FIRE DEPT.W1 FY 23/24 Fire Trk33 OCT-DEC Q243045002304220 235299 865,306.65 04/25/202400001738 STAPLES BUSINESS ADVANTAGEW1 OFFICE SUPPLIES - CITY HALL42110001104300 6001206870 45.44 04/25/202400001738 STAPLES BUSINESS ADVANTAGEW1 Finance desk mat42110001104150 6001114184 43.00 04/25/202400001738 STAPLES BUSINESS ADVANTAGEW1 Tape disp, eraser, whiteboard42110001104159 6001205961 261.25 04/25/202400001739 VERIZON WIRELESS SERVICES LLCW1 EOC MAR08-APR0722899501100000 9961011877 64.50 04/30/2024Report Date 2Page City and Housing DocuSign Envelope ID: 5907ED88-8F21-42FC-ACDA-D675F981A251 24 Check DateCheck Number Vendor NameBank ID Check Register Amount PaidInvoiceTransaction Desc 4/25/2024 - 4/30/2024 City of Palm Desert Account Number 04/25/202400001740 VINTAGE ASSOCIATESW1 LMA 17 EXTRA WORK - CC PARK43320011104610 232468 1,907.67 04/25/202400001740 VINTAGE ASSOCIATESW1 LMA 16 EXTRA WORK - PARKS43320011104611 232469 940.98 04/25/202400001741 WEX HEALTH INCW1 MAR 2024 COBRA Monthly43090001104154 0001924766-IN 85.00 04/25/202400001742 ZOOM VIDEO COMMUNICATIONS INCW1 Zoom Services 06/24-04/2514301001100000 INV252806852 13,874.25 04/25/202400001742 ZOOM VIDEO COMMUNICATIONS INCW1 Zoom Services 4/24-6/2443620011104190 INV252806852 4,624.75 04/25/202402002717 ACCURATE FIRST AID SERVICESW1 FIRST AID SUPPLIES - CITY HALL42190001104340 C-2465 110.19 04/25/202402002717 ACCURATE FIRST AID SERVICESW1 FIRST AID SUPPLIES - CITY HALL42190001104340 C-2466 145.56 04/25/202402002718 CHAVEZ, RANDYW1 REIMB PESTICIDE LICENSE43120001104340 0324RC-REIMB 45.00 04/25/202402002719 CHUCK, BRADW1 REIMB FOR LANDSCAPE SUPPLIES43910001104611 0408BCHUCK-REIMB 93.47 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 72880 Hwy 111 - Fire Meter43510001104340 800645741286FB24 88.29 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 1150 WASHINGTON & I-1043510001104614 587615849914AP24 381.91 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 Portola Ave - Landscape43510001104614 805025629618AP24 84.56 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 1052 CORPORATION YARD43510001104330 315177847704MR24 619.29 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 (A) 1057 City Hall43510001104340 315187847714MR24 272.80 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 (B) 1057 Portola CC43510001104344 315187847714MR24 415.67 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 248 RAC WELL RMT BY LAKE43510001104610 332429853174MR24 2,116.74 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 1093 CIVIC CENTER PARK43510001104610 315245847772MR24 4,681.10 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 1054 CITY PARKS43510001104611 315181847708MR24 1,856.69 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 10364 HOVLEY SOCCER PARK43510001104611 316695849222MR24 1,852.68 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 1051 ST MEDIANS "4"43510001104614 315175847702MR24 2,203.25 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 1055 ST MEDIANS "5"43510001104614 315183847710MR24 5,145.79 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 10528 Entrada /Eric Johnson43510001104614 317287849814MR24 488.73 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 1141 AQUATIC CENTER43510002424549 512541849896MR24 717.68 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 13 1050 Primrose II43510002734682 315173847700MR24 29.04 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 1 1050 Diamondback43510002754643 315173847700MR24 35.19 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 18 1050 Monterey Meadows43510002754680 315173847700MR24 40.11 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 17 1050 The Glen43510002754681 315173847700MR24 42.57 04/30/2024Report Date 3Page City and Housing DocuSign Envelope ID: 5907ED88-8F21-42FC-ACDA-D675F981A251 25 Check DateCheck Number Vendor NameBank ID Check Register Amount PaidInvoiceTransaction Desc 4/25/2024 - 4/30/2024 City of Palm Desert Account Number 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 2 1050 Hovley Estates43510002754682 315173847700MR24 29.04 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 15 1050 Hovley Estates43510002754682 315173847700MR24 31.50 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 22 1050 Sonata I43510002754683 315173847700MR24 43.80 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 20 1050 Sonata II43510002754684 315173847700MR24 72.72 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 16 1050 Hovley Collection43510002754685 315173847700MR24 32.73 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 21 1050 Hovley Collection43510002754685 315173847700MR24 29.04 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 5 1050 La Paloma I43510002754686 315173847700MR24 30.27 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 19 1050 La Paloma I43510002754686 315173847700MR24 30.27 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 6 1050 La Paloma II43510002754687 315173847700MR24 63.00 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 3 1050 La Paloma III43510002754693 315173847700MR24 38.88 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 7 1050 Sandpiper43510002754694 315173847700MR24 71.61 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 8 1050 Sandpiper43510002754695 315173847700MR24 60.54 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 4 1050 Hovley Court West43510002754696 315173847700MR24 59.79 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 14 1050 Palm Court43510002754697 315173847700MR24 38.88 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 10560 HAYSTACK43510002764374 330551849952MR24 1,279.65 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 10561 HAYSTACK43510002764374 330559849954MR24 1,938.41 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 (3) 1056 Presidents Plaza43510002774373 315185847712MR24 2,091.03 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 (5) 1056 Presidents Plaza43510002774373 315185847712MR24 383.12 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 (1) 1056 Vineyards43510002784374 315185847712MR24 39.05 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 (7) 1056 Vineyards43510002784374 315185847712MR24 43.97 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 12 1050 Waring Court43510002794374 315173847700MR24 37.65 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 11 1050 Palm Gate43510002804374 315173847700MR24 31.50 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 (4) 1056 The Grove43510002814374 315185847712MR24 154.82 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 (2) 1056 Presidents Plaza 343510002824373 315185847712MR24 80.70 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 (8) 1056 Presidents Plaza 343510002824373 315185847712MR24 68.57 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 (6) 1056 Portola Place43510002834374 315185847712MR24 41.51 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 10 1050 Canyon Crest43510002864374 315173847700MR24 47.49 04/30/2024Report Date 4Page City and Housing DocuSign Envelope ID: 5907ED88-8F21-42FC-ACDA-D675F981A251 26 Check DateCheck Number Vendor NameBank ID Check Register Amount PaidInvoiceTransaction Desc 4/25/2024 - 4/30/2024 City of Palm Desert Account Number 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 9 1050 PDCC43510002994374 315173847700MR24 193.22 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 (1) 1161 - 73710 FW43696015104195 652499886934MR24 113.81 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 (3) 1161 - 73710 FW FP43696015104195 652499886934MR24 86.99 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 (2) 1161 - 73720 FW43696025104195 652499886934MR24 72.95 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 (4) 1161 - 72559 Hwy 11143698005104195 652499886934MR24 76.64 04/25/202402002720 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST.W1 (5) 1161 - 72559 Hwy 111 FP43698005104195 652499886934MR24 40.65 04/25/202402002721 County of Riverside SheriffW1 Law Enf Serv 11/16 - 12/13/2343040001104210 SH0000045033 1,569,545.03 04/25/202402002721 County of Riverside SheriffW1 Law Enf Serv 12/14 - 1/10/2443040001104210 SH0000045143 1,515,329.70 04/25/202402002722 DATA TICKET INCW1 CITATTION PROCESSING MAR-2443090001104422 163972 182.24 04/25/202402002723 DAVID REYES JR.W1 CINCO DE MAYO 2024 ADVANCE11501001100000 CINCODEMAYO2024 1,400.00 04/25/202402002724 DAVIS, LORIW1 Poet Laureate for CE 4/02/2443092004364650 3 875.00 04/25/202402002725 DEPARTMENT OF PESTICIDE REGULATIONW1 LATE FEES LIC.83372 AND 13762143630001104300 83372-137621FEES 60.00 04/25/202402002726 DESERT AIR CONDITIONING INC.W1 HVAC SRVS - CORPYARD43310001104330 247485 1,070.22 04/25/202402002726 DESERT AIR CONDITIONING INC.W1 HVAC SRVS - CORPYARD43310001104330 247703 1,961.00 04/25/202402002726 DESERT AIR CONDITIONING INC.W1 HVAC SRVS - CORPYARD43310001104330 247723 1,306.22 04/25/202402002726 DESERT AIR CONDITIONING INC.W1 HVAC SRVS - CITY HALL43310001104340 247644 9,589.00 04/25/202402002726 DESERT AIR CONDITIONING INC.W1 HVAC PM - CORP YARD43310001104330 247725 1,949.00 04/25/202402002726 DESERT AIR CONDITIONING INC.W1 HVAC PM - ARTISTS COUNCIL43885001104800 247725 1,456.00 04/25/202402002726 DESERT AIR CONDITIONING INC.W1 HVAC PM - FS #67 #7143310002304220 247725 1,097.00 04/25/202402002726 DESERT AIR CONDITIONING INC.W1 HVAC PM - iHUB BUILDING43950004254430 247725 1,608.00 04/25/202402002726 DESERT AIR CONDITIONING INC.W1 HVAC SRVS - CITY HALL43310001104340 247960 147.00 04/25/202402002726 DESERT AIR CONDITIONING INC.W1 DEVELOP SRVS LOBBY HVAC REPLAC44001004504161 247790 8,574.29 04/25/202402002727 DESERT FIRE EXTINGUISHERW1 R/M FIRE SYSTEM - PARKS43310001104611 12479753 239.77 04/25/202402002727 DESERT FIRE EXTINGUISHERW1 R/M FIRE SYSTEM - FS #33 67 7143310002304220 12479430 242.78 04/25/202402002727 DESERT FIRE EXTINGUISHERW1 FIRE SYSTEM -SERVICE CORP YARD43310001104330 12479805 803.94 04/25/202402002727 DESERT FIRE EXTINGUISHERW1 R/M FIRE SYSTEM - PS ART BLDG43885001104800 12479834 89.22 04/25/202402002727 DESERT FIRE EXTINGUISHERW1 R/M FIRE SYSTEM - PDAC43090002424549 12479808 247.85 04/30/2024Report Date 5Page City and Housing DocuSign Envelope ID: 5907ED88-8F21-42FC-ACDA-D675F981A251 27 Check DateCheck Number Vendor NameBank ID Check Register Amount PaidInvoiceTransaction Desc 4/25/2024 - 4/30/2024 City of Palm Desert Account Number 04/25/202402002728 DESERT PROMOTIONAL & EMBROIDERY LLCW1 Historic Site Plaques 13 & 1443062001104470 96281 1,172.88 04/25/202402002729 DESERT RECREATION DISTRICTW1 MR24 PARKS/REC SRVS-PORTOLA CC43090001104344 3642 9,584.54 04/25/202402002729 DESERT RECREATION DISTRICTW1 MAR24 PARK SRVS - CC PARK43092001104610 3641 47,502.99 04/25/202402002730 DESERT TREE SPRAYINGW1 MR24 RODENT/GOPHER CTRL - CC43320011104610 2711 290.00 04/25/202402002730 DESERT TREE SPRAYINGW1 MR24 GOPHER/RODENT CTRL -PARKS43320011104611 2711 275.00 04/25/202402002730 DESERT TREE SPRAYINGW1 MR24 RODENT CTRL - GARDENS43910001104611 2711 80.00 04/25/202402002730 DESERT TREE SPRAYINGW1 MR24 RODENT CTRL - ENTRADA43921011104614 2711 130.00 04/25/202402002730 DESERT TREE SPRAYINGW1 MR24 RODENT/GOPHER CTRL - K/B43321002854374 2711 80.00 04/25/202402002731 DRAGON'S EXTERMINATORW1 MR24 PEST CONTROL - CC PARK43310001104610 89237048 50.00 04/25/202402002731 DRAGON'S EXTERMINATORW1 MR24 PEST CONTROL - PARK BLDGS43310001104611 89237048 180.00 04/25/202402002731 DRAGON'S EXTERMINATORW1 MR24 PEST CTRL - COMM GARDENS43910001104611 89237048 10.00 04/25/202402002732 EARTH SYSTEMSW1 TASK 2 - DW PARKING LOT48092004414195 845396 5,448.50 04/25/202402002733 EDTECHNOLOGYFUNDS INCW1 E-Rate Cat 2 Consult-MAR 202443090002524662 2442 1,387.50 04/25/202402002734 Empower Retirement LLCW1 Def Comp Qrtly Fee Jul23-Sep2343090001104159 385488 250.00 04/25/202402002734 Empower Retirement LLCW1 401aDef Comp Qrtly Fee Jul-Sep43090001104159 385489 250.00 04/25/202402002734 Empower Retirement LLCW1 Def Comp Qrtly Fee Oct23-Dec2343090001104159 392156 250.00 04/25/202402002734 Empower Retirement LLCW1 401aDef Comp Qrtly Fee Oct-Dec43090001104159 392158 250.00 04/25/202402002735 ENGINEERING RESOURCESW1 PROFESSIONAL ENG HAYSTACK50004544204370 60052 5,400.51 04/25/202402002736 FAIR HOUSING COUNCIL OFW1 CDBG 23-24 MAR2443880002204800 INV#9 1,569.31 04/25/202402002737 FIND FOOD BANKW1 FINDT1APR2443090002364195 382951 2,887.50 04/25/202402002737 FIND FOOD BANKW1 FIND Food Bank to provide SB 143090002364195 382950 4,166.66 04/25/202402002738 FRONTIER COMMUNICATIONS INCW1 D/U CIRCUIT FRED WARING43650001104159 7605686932-324 60.99 04/25/202402002738 FRONTIER COMMUNICATIONS INCW1 PHONE SVC43060011104211 7608629848-324 146.52 04/25/202402002738 FRONTIER COMMUNICATIONS INCW1 TRAFFIC SIGNAL LINE SVC43650001104250 7603459146-324 60.99 04/25/202402002738 FRONTIER COMMUNICATIONS INCW1 PCC PHONE SRV43650001104344 7605682560-324 153.84 04/25/202402002738 FRONTIER COMMUNICATIONS INCW1 VALLEY CRIMESTOPPERS HOTLINE43914002294210 7603417867-324 183.25 04/25/202402002738 FRONTIER COMMUNICATIONS INCW1 EP PHONE SVC43695002714491 7606749012-324 128.39 04/30/2024Report Date 6Page City and Housing DocuSign Envelope ID: 5907ED88-8F21-42FC-ACDA-D675F981A251 28 Check DateCheck Number Vendor NameBank ID Check Register Amount PaidInvoiceTransaction Desc 4/25/2024 - 4/30/2024 City of Palm Desert Account Number 04/25/202402002738 FRONTIER COMMUNICATIONS INCW1 PARKVIEW BLDG ALARM SRV43696015104195 7603468393-324 162.93 04/25/202402002738 FRONTIER COMMUNICATIONS INCW1 PARKVIEW BLDG PHONE SRV43696015104195 7606741960-324 109.41 04/25/202402002738 FRONTIER COMMUNICATIONS INCW1 PARKVIEW BLDG FIRE ALARM43696015104195 7607791904-324 100.00 04/25/202402002738 FRONTIER COMMUNICATIONS INCW1 PARKVIEW BLDG ALARM SRV43696015104195 7608361142-324 106.73 04/25/202402002738 FRONTIER COMMUNICATIONS INCW1 STATE BLDG INTERNET SRV43696025104195 3101746165-324 55.98 04/25/202402002738 FRONTIER COMMUNICATIONS INCW1 HENDERSON BLDG PHONE SRV43698005104195 7607766715-324 264.51 04/25/202402002739 GLOBAL CTI GROUP INC.W1 10 Replacement Phones44040005304190 170258 6,014.61 04/25/202402002740 GLS USW1 TOT letters to Hotels43660001104150 5261223 50.26 04/25/202402002741 GUTIERREZ, ELEOBANIW1 NH Orientation F&B43125001104154 ELI G 03.29.2024 254.06 04/25/202402002742 HORIZON LIGHTING INC.W1 R/M ELEC/LIGHT - PPIII43321002824373 346048 396.73 04/25/202402002742 HORIZON LIGHTING INC.W1 R/M ELECT/LIGHT - CORPYARD43310001104330 349174 734.78 04/25/202402002742 HORIZON LIGHTING INC.W1 ELECT/LIGHTING - FS #3343310002304220 348484 7,542.87 04/25/202402002742 HORIZON LIGHTING INC.W1 ELECT/LIGHTING - FS #3343310002304220 348694 2,178.30 04/25/202402002742 HORIZON LIGHTING INC.W1 R/M ELECT/LIGHT - CORPYARD43310001104330 341380 1,452.00 04/25/202402002743 ICMAW1 Amy L. dues 7/1/24-6/30/2514301001100000 AL1113677 200.00 04/25/202402002744 IMPRESSION DESIGNW1 ARBOR DAY SUPPLIES43905001104614 15586 1,140.00 04/25/202402002745 JOHN KALISKI ARCHITECTS INCW1 ODS FEB-2443090001104470 6763 11,063.01 04/25/202402002746 KINCAID INDUSTRIES INCW1 R/M PLUMBING - PARKS43310001104611 5331 327.60 04/25/202402002746 KINCAID INDUSTRIES INCW1 R/M PLUMBING - PORTOLA COMM43310001104344 5404 458.95 04/25/202402002746 KINCAID INDUSTRIES INCW1 R/M PLUMBING - PARKVIEW43696015104195 5413 450.00 04/25/202402002747 KNORR SYSTEMS INCW1 CO#1 - R/M PUMPS43311012424549 231189 483.45 04/25/202402002747 KNORR SYSTEMS INCW1 R/M EXTRA AQUATIC CENTER PUMPS43311012424549 223984 5,032.91 04/25/202402002747 KNORR SYSTEMS INCW1 R/M PDAC PUMPS43311012424549 230221 27,264.37 04/25/202402002748 LOCK SHOP INC.W1 DOOR LOCK SRV - CC PARK43310001104610 A135858 230.00 04/25/202402002749 MAGER, VANESSAW1 Reimbu: Spring Into Work 202443125001104417 #65 125.00 04/25/202402002750 Mark MooreW1 PRONTO EXAM REIM M. MOORE43120001104420 ICC EXAM 4.3.24 305.00 04/25/202402002751 MEJIA, ANTHONYW1 CCAC 4.1-4.5.24 Mejia43115001104111 MILEAGE 04.1.24 152.76 04/30/2024Report Date 7Page City and Housing DocuSign Envelope ID: 5907ED88-8F21-42FC-ACDA-D675F981A251 29 Check DateCheck Number Vendor NameBank ID Check Register Amount PaidInvoiceTransaction Desc 4/25/2024 - 4/30/2024 City of Palm Desert Account Number 04/25/202402002751 MEJIA, ANTHONYW1 CCAC 4.1-4.5.24 Mejia43120001104111 MIE 4.1-4.5.24 333.00 04/25/202402002751 MEJIA, ANTHONYW1 CCAC 4.1-4.5.24 Mejia43120001104111 PRK 4.1.-4.5.24 75.00 04/25/202402002752 MOLINA, AMBERW1 City Wide Training43121011104154 1353828817951593 144.98 04/25/202402002753 OPERATION SAFEHOUSE INCW1 CDBG AWARD FY23/2443880002204800 CDBG 23/24 8,500.00 04/25/202402002754 ORTEGA, NIAMHW1 CCAC 4.1-4.5.24 Ortega43115001104111 MILEAGE 04.1.24 166.16 04/25/202402002754 ORTEGA, NIAMHW1 CCAC 4.1-4.5.24 Ortega43120001104111 MEI 04.01-05.24 333.00 04/25/202402002754 ORTEGA, NIAMHW1 CCAC 4.1-4.5.24 Ortega43120001104111 PRK 4.1.-4.05.24 135.00 04/25/202402002755 PALMER ELECTRICW1 ELECT REPAIRS - CC PARK43321001104610 5436 599.60 04/25/202402002755 PALMER ELECTRICW1 ELECT REPAIRS - PARKS43325011104611 5394 119.92 04/25/202402002755 PALMER ELECTRICW1 ELECT REPAIRS - PARKS43325011104611 5439 480.81 04/25/202402002755 PALMER ELECTRICW1 ELECT REPAIRS - MEDIANS43325011104614 5437 239.84 04/25/202402002755 PALMER ELECTRICW1 ELECT REPAIRS - ENTRADA DEL PA43921011104614 5438 797.86 04/25/202402002755 PALMER ELECTRICW1 ELECT REPAIRS - ENTRADA DEL PA43921011104614 5453 239.84 04/25/202402002755 PALMER ELECTRICW1 ELECT REPAIRS - CC PARK43321001104610 5376 599.60 04/25/202402002755 PALMER ELECTRICW1 ELECT REPAIRS - CC PARK43321001104610 5381 1,284.36 04/25/202402002755 PALMER ELECTRICW1 ELECT REPAIRS - MEDIANS43325011104614 5313 239.84 04/25/202402002756 PATTON DOOR & GATEW1 R/M GATE - CORP YARD43310001104330 95716 150.00 04/25/202402002756 PATTON DOOR & GATEW1 R/M GATE - FS #3343310002304220 95632 300.00 04/25/202402002757 PLANIT PRINT WORKSW1 Courtesy Cart Stickers43610001104417 929963 982.75 04/25/202402002758 POWELL, ERICAW1 Poet Lauret meeting 4/08/2443125004364650 ERICA POET 4/08 58.17 04/25/202402002758 POWELL, ERICAW1 Cultural Arts Comm. meeting43125004364650 ERICA CAC 4/10 12.98 04/25/202402002759 POWERFUL PEST MANAGEMENTW1 MAR24 PEST CONTROL - PDAC43311012424549 304901 185.00 04/25/202402002760 PROPER SOLUTIONS INC.W1 TEMP STAFF SERVICES PE 4/05/2443003001104300 15791 840.72 04/25/202402002760 PROPER SOLUTIONS INC.W1 TEMP STAFF SERVICES PE 4/12/2443003001104300 15819 1,401.20 04/25/202402002760 PROPER SOLUTIONS INC.W1 TEMP STAFF SERVICES PE 3/29/2443003001104300 15766 840.72 04/25/202402002761 QUINN COMPANYW1 EXTRA GNRTRS SVCS - CORPYARD43310001104330 WOG00018643 557.19 04/25/202402002762 QUINTANILLA, KARINAW1 Quintanilla 3.2024 Mile Rmbrs.43115001104110 MILEAGE 03.2024 149.68 04/30/2024Report Date 8Page City and Housing DocuSign Envelope ID: 5907ED88-8F21-42FC-ACDA-D675F981A251 30 Check DateCheck Number Vendor NameBank ID Check Register Amount PaidInvoiceTransaction Desc 4/25/2024 - 4/30/2024 City of Palm Desert Account Number 04/25/202402002763 RIVERSIDE ASSESSOR -COUNTYW1 LIEN RELEASES 82784-8278643640001104422 24-81844 60.00 04/25/202402002764 SOULE, THOMASW1 Remimbu:Outlook Forum & Winter43120001104417 2024-022024-0391 1,299.00 04/25/202402002765 STERLING ADMINISTRATIONW1 MAR24 Admin Fees43090001104154 769895 154.00 04/25/202402002766 THE RETAIL COACH LLCW1 Retail Mkt Analysis - Instl 543090001104430 5231 4,583.00 04/25/202402002767 TOIT TRAINING LLCW1 Sub to IT Courses 2024-202643620001104190 TOIT-2461 1,995.00 04/25/202402002768 TOWNSEND PUBLIC AFFAIRS INCW1 Grant Management Svcs 4/2443090001104159 21493 9,000.00 04/25/202402002769 TURF STAR INCW1 GOLF CART - TORO SAND PRO 504044045005304614 3318563-00 34,516.85 04/25/202402002770 US BANKW1 Mar24 US Bank Analysis Fee43090001104159 MAR24ANALYSISFEE 819.39 04/25/202402002771 VASQUEZ, AILEENW1 Empl Appreciation F&B Pi Day43095011104154 AVASQUEZ 3.29.24 91.80 04/25/202402002772 VISIT GREATER PALM SPRINGSW1 Q4 Contribution for GPS43220001104800 CI-000239 106,250.00 04/25/202402002773 WATERLINE TECHNOLOGIES INCW1 CHEMICALS - AQUATIC CENTER42111002424549 5677064 1,541.90 04/25/202402002773 WATERLINE TECHNOLOGIES INCW1 CHEMICALS - AQUATIC CENTER42111002424549 5672499 822.35 04/25/202402002773 WATERLINE TECHNOLOGIES INCW1 CHEMICALS - AQUATIC CENTER42111002424549 5679600 862.95 04/25/202402002774 STEVEN H. CHERNOVEW1 05-02-24 CNCRT SRIES STLY DAN43061011104416 MAY 2 CONCERT 3,400.00 Examined and Approved Total For Bank ID - W1 5,740,435.24City Manager Examined and Approved Mayor or Mayor Pro-Tem Audited and Found Correct Director of Finance 04/30/2024Report Date 9Page City and Housing DocuSign Envelope ID: 5907ED88-8F21-42FC-ACDA-D675F981A251 31 Check DateCheck Number Vendor NameBank ID Check Register Amount PaidInvoiceTransaction Desc 4/25/2024 - 4/30/2024 City of Palm Desert Account Number 04/25/202400002533 WILLDAN FINANCIAL SERVICESW3 FY22/23 ANNUAL CONT DISCLOSURE43090007034195 010-58078 1,980.00 Examined and Approved Total For Bank ID - W3 1,980.00City Manager Examined and Approved Mayor or Mayor Pro-Tem Audited and Found Correct Director of Finance 04/30/2024Report Date 10Page Successor Agency DocuSign Envelope ID: 5907ED88-8F21-42FC-ACDA-D675F981A251 32 CITY OF PALM DESERT CITY CLERK DEPARTMENT INTEROFFICE MEMORANDUM To: From: Date: BUILDING AND SAFETY DIVISION AND PLANNING DIVISION , CITY CLERK Subject: APPLICATION FOR ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE LICENSE(S) BY: _____________________________________________________ A copy of the subject ABC License Application is attached for your review and recommendation to the City Council or to another department(s) for further action. A response is required. Please mark the appropriate response below and return to my office by __________________________ Responding Department: __________________________ Date:_______________ Response: No comment – okay to present to City Council. Refer to ______________________________________ related comments (attach additional sheets, if necessary): _________________________________ _________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________ Other – Additional comments (attach additional sheets, if necessary): _________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________ JACKSON 6843 72300 Highway 111, Palm Desert, California 92260-2747 Wednesday, April 17, 2024. April 29, 2024Building and Safety April 10, 2024 33 CITY OF PALM DESERT CITY CLERK DEPARTMENT INTEROFFICE MEMORANDUM To: From: Date: BUILDING AND SAFETY DIVISION AND PLANNING DIVISION , CITY CLERK Subject: APPLICATION FOR ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE LICENSE(S) BY: _____________________________________________________ A copy of the subject ABC License Application is attached for your review and recommendation to the City Council or to another department(s) for further action. A response is required. Please mark the appropriate response below and return to my office by __________________________ Responding Department: __________________________ Date:_______________ Response: No comment – okay to present to City Council. Refer to ______________________________________ related comments (attach additional sheets, if necessary): _________________________________ _________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________ Other – Additional comments (attach additional sheets, if necessary): _________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________ JACKSON 6843 72300 Highway 111, Palm Desert, California 92260-2747 Wednesday, April 17, 2024. April 29, 2024Development Services: Planning April 10, 2024 34 35 36 Page 1 of 1 CITY OF PALM DESERT STAFF REPORT MEETING DATE: May 9, 2024 PREPARED BY: Michelle Nance, Deputy Clerk I REQUEST: ADOPTION OF ORDINANCE NO. 1412 ADDING CHAPTER 9.71 TO TITLE 9 (PUBLIC PEACE, MORALS AND WELFARE) OF THE PALM DESERT MUNICIPAL CODE, ESTABLISHING REGULATIONS PROHIBITING THE UNLAWFUL POSSESSION OF CATALYTIC CONVERTERS RECOMMENDATION: Adopt Ordinance No. 1412 entitled, “AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, ADDING CHAPTER 9.71 (UNLAWFUL POSSESSION OF A CATALYTIC CONVERTER PROHIBITED) TO TITLE 9 (PUBLIC PEACE, MORALS AND WELFARE) OF THE PALM DESERT MUNICIPAL CODE, ESTABLISHING REGULATIONS PROHIBITING THE UNLAWFUL POSSESSION OF CATALYTIC CONVERTERS IN THE CITY” BACKGROUND/ANALYSIS: On April 25, 2024, the City Council unanimously introduced Ordinance No. 1412 for first reading. This report provides for the City Council to waive further reading and ado pt the ordinance. The ordinance shall be effective 30 days from adoption. FINANCIAL IMPACT: There is no direct financial impact with this action. ATTACHMENTS: Ordinance No. 1412 37 38 ORDINANCE NO. 1412 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, ADDING CHAPTER 9.71 (UNLAWFUL POSSESSION OF A CATALYTIC CONVERTER PROHIBITED) TO TITLE 9 (PUBLIC PEACE, MORALS AND WELFARE) OF THE PALM DESERT MUNICIPAL CODE, ESTABLISHING REGULATIONS PROHIBITING THE UNLAWFUL POSSESSION OF CATALYTIC CONVERTERS IN THE CITY WHEREAS, the citizens of the City of Palm Desert (the “City”) have experienced rising catalytic converter thefts from automobiles over the past several years, with Palm Desert averaging 6 catalytic converter thefts a month; and WHEREAS, there is currently no City legislation applicable within the City of Palm Desert to define and punish catalytic converter thefts absent an identifiable victim; and WHEREAS, there is currently no City, State, or Federal legislation applicable within the City of Palm Desert requiring individuals discovered to be in possession of detached catalytic converters to provide proof to law enforcement as to how they obtained catalytic converters, thus limiting law enforcement’s ability to: (1) protect the public by preventing catalytic converter thefts; and (2) seize suspected stolen catalytic converters when no victim is present; and WHEREAS, the Legislature has enacted, and the Governor has signed into law, Senate Bill (SB) 1087 and Assembly Bill (AB) 1740, which generally prohibit: (1) individuals from purchasing a used catalytic converter from anyone other than certain specified sellers, including automobile dismantlers, automotive re pair dealers, or an individual possessing documentation, as specified, that they are the lawful owner of the catalytic converter; and (2) requires core recyclers to keep a detailed written record, including the year, make, and model of the car form which a catalytic converter was removed, as well as a copy of the vehicle’s title, prior to purchasing a catalytic converter from a seller; and WHEREAS, the Legislature has not expressed its intent, whether explicitly or impliedly, to occupy the field of catalytic converter theft legislation; and WHEREAS, pursuant to Article XI, Section 5 of the California Constitution, the City, as a charter city, has broad discretionary power to make and enforce within its limits all ordinances and regulations in respect to municipal affairs; and WHEREAS, catalytic converter thefts are on the rise because individuals are incentivized to commit catalytic converter thefts for multiple reasons including, but not limited to: (1) the ease and undetectable nature of committing such thefts, potentially in a matter of seconds and through the use of common tools such as a 39 Ordinance No. 1412 Page 2 reciprocating saw; (2) the ability to recycle catalytic converters at scrap metal yards for high dollar returns ranging from $200 to $1,200 per catalytic converter; an d (3) loopholes in legislation protecting criminals from prosecution unless a victim can be identified; and WHEREAS, preventing these crimes at present is nearly impossible due to the ease and speed with which catalytic converter thefts can be committed and the difficulty of tracing a particular catalytic converter back to its prior owner (the victim), because catalytic converters typically have no identifying markers; and WHEREAS, the citizens of Palm Desert and the Riverside County Sheriff’s Department are in need of legislation criminalizing mere possession of catalytic converters absent proof of ownership or lawful possession, for multiple reasons including, but not limited to, the following: (1) achieving deterrence by establishing zero-tolerance for catalytic converter thefts; (2) establishing sanctions for possessing stolen catalytic converters; (3) preventing criminals from profiting from the sale and recycling of stolen catalytic converters; (4) providing indirect justice to the victims of catalytic converter theft cases that have gone or will go unsolved for the reasons discussed above; and (5) minimizing the fiscal and personnel impact on the City of Palm Desert and the Riverside County Sheriff’s Department by reducing the time invested in deterring and investigating catalytic converter thefts; and WHEREAS, individuals who are in possession of stolen catalytic converters recycle them for substantial profit while victims of these thefts suffer tremendous consequences in the form of costly repairs, inconvenience, and feelings of a lack of safety in the community; and WHEREAS, the City desires to regulate the possession of detached catalytic converters within its jurisdiction in order to better protect its citizens, their property, and their community; and WHEREAS, regulating possession of detached catalytic converters neither contradicts nor duplicates the statutes adopted by the Legislature on the topic of catalytic converters; and WHEREAS, this Ordinance is necessary to provide the City and the Riverside County Sheriff’s Department clear legal authority to better protect th e public and deter this criminal activity; and WHEREAS, all other legal prerequisites to the adoption of this Ordinance have occurred. 40 Ordinance No. 1412 Page 3 THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT DOES HEREBY ORDAIN AS FOLLOWS: SECTION 1. Incorporation of Recitals. The Recitals set forth above are incorporated herein and made an operative part of this Ordinance. SECTION 2. Addition of Chapter 9.71 to Title 9 of the Palm Desert Municipal Code. Chapter 9.71 is hereby added to Title 9 (Public Peace, Morals and Welfare) of the Palm Desert Municipal Code to read in its entirety as follows: “Chapter 9.71 UNLAWFUL POSSESSION OF A CATALYTIC CONVERTER 9.71.010 Purpose. The purpose of this chapter is to regulate the possession of detached catalytic converters absent proof of ownership or lawful possession, to assist in deterring future thefts, establish sanctions for possessing stolen catalytic converters, and minimize th e fiscal and personnel impact on the City of Palm Desert and the Riverside County Sheriff’s Department by reducing the time invested in deterring and investigating catalytic converter thefts. 9.71.020 Definitions. For the purposes of this chapter, the following meanings shall apply: A. “Lawful possession” includes (1) being the lawful owner of the catalytic converter or (2) in possession of the catalytic converter with the lawful owner’s written consent. It is not required to prove the catalytic converter was stolen to establish the possession is not a “lawful possession.” B. “Documentation or other proof” means written document(s) that clearly identify the vehicle from which the catalytic converter originated based on the totality of the circumstances, and includes, but is not limited to, the following types of documents: (1) Bill of sale from the original owner with the signature of the vehicle owner authorizing removal of the catalytic converter, as well as the name, address, and telephone number of the vehicle owner. (2) Documentation from an auto-body shop or similar business proving that the owner relinquished the catalytic converter to the auto-body shop or similar business. (3) Verifiable electronic communication from the previous owner to the possessor relinquishing ownership of the catalytic converter. (4) Photographs of the vehicle from which the catalytic converter originated clearly showing the license plate number and vehicle 41 Ordinance No. 1412 Page 4 identification number (VIN) of the car from which the catalytic converter was removed. 9.71.030 Unlawful possession of a catalytic converter prohibited. A. It shall be unlawful to possess any catalytic converter that is not attached to a vehicle, unless the possessor has valid documentation or other proof to verify that they are in lawful possession of the catalytic converter. B. It is unlawful for any person to falsify or cause to be falsified any information in any documentation or other proof intended to show valid proof of ownership or possession of a catalytic converter. 9.71.040 Violations – Misdemeanor A. Each and every violation of this section shall constitute a separate violation and shall be subject to all remedies and enforcement measures authorized by the Palm Desert Municipal Code. Each and every catalytic converter unlawfully possessed is a separate violation of this section. B. Any person who violates any provision of this chapter is guilty of a misdemeanor, and upon conviction punished by a fine not to exceed one thousand dollars ($1,000), or by imprisonment for a term not exceeding six months or both. C. The remedies provided herein are not to be construed as exclusive remedies. The City is authorized to pursue any proceedings or remedies provided by law.” SECTION 3. CEQA. The City Council finds that adoption of this Ordinance is exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (“CEQA”) as it is not a “Project” as defined by CEQA. (CEQA Guidelines 15060(c)(3)). Pursuant to Section 15378(a), a “Project” means the whole of an action, which has a potential for resulting in either a direct physical change in the environment or a reasonably foreseeable indirect physical change in the environment. The requested action is to amend the Municipal Code to create a new criminal offense and is exempt from CEQA under the “common sense” exemption (CEQA Guidelines 15061(b)(3)), as it can be seen with certainty that there is no possibility that the activity in question may have a significant effect on the environment. The requested action is further exempt under Section 15060(c)(2), as it will not result in a direct or reasonably foreseeable indirect physical change in the environment. SECTION 4. Severability. If any section, subsection, subdivision, sentence, clause, phrase, or portion of this Ordinance for any reason is held to be invalid or unconstitutional by the decision of any court of competent jurisdiction, such decision shall not affect the validity of the remaining portions of this Ordinance. The City Council hereby declares that it would have adopted this Ordinance, and each section, subsection, subdivision, sentence, clause, phrase, or portion thereof, irrespective of the fact that any one or more sections, subsections, subdivisions, sentences, clauses, phrases, or portions thereof be 42 Ordinance No. 1412 Page 5 declared invalid or unconstitutional. SECTION 5. Publication. The Mayor shall sign this Ordinance and the City Clerk shall cause a summary of this ordinance to be published within fifteen (15) days after its passage at least once, in a newspaper of general circulation, published and circulated in the City of Palm Desert, California. SECTION 6. Effective Date. This Ordinance takes effect thirty (30) days from and after the date of its passage. ADOPTED ON ___________________, 2024. KARINA QUINTANILLA MAYOR ATTEST: ANTHONY J. MEJIA CITY CLERK I, Anthony J. Mejia, City Clerk of the City of Palm Desert, California, do hereby certify that Ordinance No. 1412 is a full, true, and correct copy, and was introduced at a regular meeting of the Palm Desert City Council on April 25, 2024, and adopted at a regular meeting of the City Council held on __________, 2024, by the following vote: AYES: NOES: ABSENT: ABSTAIN: RECUSED: IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and affixed the official seal of the City of Palm Desert, California, on _______________. ANTHONY J. MEJIA CITY CLERK 43 44 Page 1 of 1 CITY OF PALM DESERT STAFF REPORT MEETING DATE: May 9, 2024 PREPARED BY: Michelle Nance, Deputy Clerk I REQUEST: ADOPTION OF ORDINANCE NO. 1413 AMENDING CHAPTER 2.74 OF THE PALM DESERT MUNICIPAL CODE TO ESTABLISH A PALM DESERT LIBRARY BOARD OF TRUSTEES AND LIBRARY ADVISORY COMMITTEE AND MAKING A FINDING OF EXEMPTION UNDER CEQA RECOMMENDATION: Adopt Ordinance No. 1413 entitled, ““AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, AMENDING CHAPTER 2.74 OF THE PALM DESERT MUNICIPAL CODE TO ESTABLISH A LIBRARY BOARD OF TRUSTEES AND LIBRARY ADVISORY COMMITTEE, AND MAKING A FINDING OF EXEMPTION UNDER CEQA.” BACKGROUND/ANALYSIS: On April 25, 2024, the City Council unanimously introduced Ordinance No. 1413 for first reading. This report provides for the City Council to waive further reading and adopt the ordinance. The ordinance shall be effective 30 days from adoption. FINANCIAL IMPACT: There is no direct financial impact with this action. ATTACHMENTS: Ordinance No. 1413 45 46 ORDINANCE NO. 1413 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, AMENDING CHAPTER 2.74 OF THE PALM DESERT MUNICIPAL CODE TO ESTABLISH A PALM DESERT LIBRARY BOARD OF TRUSTEES AND LIBRARY ADVISORY COMMITTEE City Attorney’s Summary The purpose of this ordinance is to amend the Palm Desert Municipal Code to establish the City Council as the Library Board of Trustees and establishing a Library Advisory Committee. WHEREAS, pursuant to Resolution No. 2023-047, as of July 1, 2024, or upon transfer of property, whichever is later, that City of Palm Desert will withdraw from the Riverside County Library System (RCLS) and shall assume the responsibility for the provision of library services within the City’s jurisdiction; and WHEREAS, the City is authorized to establish a municipal public library pursuant to Section 101 of the Palm Desert Charter and Article XI, Section 5 of the California Constitution; and WHEREAS, for the efficient operation and management of the Palm Desert Public Library, it is the desire of the City Council to serve as the Library Board of Trustees and establish a Library Advisory Committee. THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT DOES HEREBY ORDAIN AS FOLLOWS: SECTION 1. Recitals. The recitals above are each incorporated by reference and adopted as findings of the City Council. SECTION 2. Amendment to Municipal Code. The Palm Desert Municipal Code Chapter 2.74, Public Library, is hereby amended to read as follows: Section 2.74.060 Library Board of Trustees A. Established. The Library Board of Trustees (“Board”) is hereby established and shall serve as the legislative body responsible for the fiduciary and administrative oversight and establishing policies and long-term plans for the library. The faithful implementation of the policies adopted by the board shall be the responsibility of the city employees assigned to the library. 47 Ordinance No. 1413 Page 2 B. Members. The Board shall consist of the five members of the City Council. The Board Members shall individually hold office for a term which coincides with their respective terms of office on the City Council. C. Meetings. Regular meetings of the Board shall be held concurrently with the regular City Council meeting. Special meetings may be held from time to time as necessary and in accordance with the Ralph M. Brown Act. Section 2.74.070 Library Advisory Committee A. Established. A Library Advisory Committee (“Committee”) is hereby established for the City of Palm Desert. The provisions set forth in Chapter 2.34 of this code shall apply to this Committee, except as otherwise required by state law. If there is any conflict between this chapter and Chapter 2.34 of this code, the provisions of this chapter shall control. B. Purpose. The Committee shall advise and provide input to the Board relative to programming and space planning; monitor performance indicators, activities, and outcomes; assist staff in connecting with community groups and organizations; and such other functions as the Library Board of Trustees may request. C. Members. The Committee shall be comprised of five community members and up to two alternate members. D. Meetings. The Committee may hold monthly regular meetings at such date, time, and place as set by Committee resolution or minute order. E. Responsibilities. The Committee has the following responsibilities: 1. Provide input on programming and space planning; 2. Monitor performance indicators, activities, and outcomes; 3. Assist staff in connecting with community groups and organizations; and 4. Other functions as the Library Board of Trustees may request. 48 Ordinance No. 1413 Page 3 SECTION 3. Severability. If any section, subsection, clause or phrase of this Ordinance or any part thereof is for any reason held to be invalid, unconstitutional, or unenforceable by the decision of any court of competent jurisdiction, such decision shall not affect the validity of the remaining portion of the Ordinance. The City Council declares that it would have passed each section, subsection, paragraph, sentence, clause, or phrase thereof, irrespective of the fact that any one or more section, subsection, sentence, clause or phrase would be declared invalid, unconstitutional or unenforceable. SECTION 4. Publication. The City Clerk of the City of Palm Desert, California, is hereby directed to publish a summary of this Ordinance in the Desert Sun, a newspaper of general circulation, published and circulated in the City of Palm Desert, California, and shall be in full force and effective thirty (30) days after its adoption. ADOPTED ON ___________________, 2024. KARINA QUINTANILLA MAYOR ATTEST: ANTHONY J. MEJIA CITY CLERK I, Anthony J. Mejia, City Clerk of the City of Palm Desert, California, do hereby certify that Ordinance No. 1413 is a full, true, and correct copy, and was introduced at a regular meeting of the Palm Desert City Council on April 25, 2024, and adopted at a regular meeting of the City Council held on __________, 20 24, by the following vote: AYES: NOES: ABSENT: ABSTAIN: RECUSED: IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and affixed the official seal of the City of Palm Desert, California, on ____________________. ANTHONY J. MEJIA CITY CLERK 49 50 Page 1 of 2 CITY OF PALM DESERT STAFF REPORT MEETING DATE: May 9, 2024 PREPARED BY: Amy Lawrence, Deputy Director of Economic Development REQUEST: APPROVE RESOURCE PRESERVATION AND ENHANCEMENT COMMITTEE 2024/2025 WORK PLAN RECOMMENDATION: Approve the Resource Preservation and Enhancement Committee’s 2024/2025 Work Plan. BACKGROUND/ANALYSIS: In advance of the February 26, 2024, Resource Preservation and Enhancement Committee (RPEC) meeting, members were asked to submit up to three (3) priorities that they would like to have considered for inclusion in their 2024/2025 Work Plan. Relevant priori ties submitted included water conservation, sustainable landscaping, energy conservation, active transportation, air quality, electrification of the City’s fleet, recycling education, and adoption of a LEED certification policy. Of the individual priorities submitted, the Committee’s consensus was to prioritize water conservation, sustainable landscaping, and energy conservation for the 2024/2025 workplan. At its April 15, 2024, RPEC meeting, staff worked with the Committee to outline specific projects related to the three (3) priorities chosen. Below is the Resource Preservation and Enhancement Committee’s draft 2024/2025 workplan for City Council consideration. Project Description Cost Time/Process Develop a Climate Action Plan Hire a consultant to develop a formal climate action plan. Staff time and est. *$118K in grant funds - *amount included in proposed FY 24/25 budget Estimated 12 months including City Council approval to proceed, posting RFP, award of contract, community engagement, RPEC review throughout process, to City Council approval of plan. Adoption of Ordinances and/or Policies Propose at least one ordinance/policy related to water and/or energy conservation. Staff time Staff will work with RPEC to develop new ordinances and/or policies for City Council consideration. The first one estimated to be taken forward by the end of Q4 2024. Education and Outreach Conduct education and outreach for water and energy conservation and sustainable landscaping. Staff time Staff will draft a comprehensive education and outreach plan for RPEC to adopt including promotion of utility rebates, community partnerships, useful tips, etc. via the City’s website, BrightSide newsletter, social media, and other means. Staff will also continue participating in the Mayor’s Challenge for Water Conservation, Mayor’s Monarch Pledge, and look at other relevant initiatives. 51 City of Palm Desert Resource Preservation and Enhancement Committee 2024/2025 Work Plan Page 2 of 2 Because RPEC meets bimonthly and proposes initiatives that often require coordination between various departments and partner agencies, staff proposed that the work plan extend through December 31, 2025, with the intent that the next two -year plan be adopted prior to the end of 2025. Legal Review: This report has been reviewed by the City Attorney’s office. FINANCIAL IMPACT: There is no cost associated with adopting the work plan. There may be costs associated with proposed projects which will require subsequent City Council approval. ATTACHMENTS: List of Individual Priorities Submitted by RPEC Members for Considera tion 52 Resource Preservation and Enhancement Committee List of Individual Priorities Submitted for Proposed 2024/2025 Workplan Member 1 1. Conversion to desert landscape initiatives/incentives 2. Further recycling education • Radio (La Quinta currently has), TV, etc. • BRIGHTSIDE 3. Water reduction initiatives/incentives • In conjunction with CVWD • CVWD newsletter • BRIGHTSIDE Member 2 1. Discuss and analyze the adoption of LEED certification policy for new commercial, residential communities and public (city) buildings. Public (city) buildings being remodeled and/or updated significantly should be part of then proposed certification. 2. Perform a review and update of approved desert flora trees and shrubs to determine any invasive species are removed to promote more shade trees 3. Promote Environmental CVWD equipment and Rebates to the public. Member 3 1. Community solar program 2. Encampment Clean Up Program STAFF RESPONSE: Falls under the City’s Homeless and Support Services Division 3. Zero-Emission Vehicle Fleet for city vehicles Member 4 1. Energy Conservation 2. Sustainable Landscaping 3. Bike/runner safety 4. Air quality Member 5 1. Electrify the City’s fleet • Seek Federal or State funding or programs- https://beamforall.com/ • Ties in with the Green Fleet environmental initiative 2. Active Transportation • Enhanced pedestrian crosswalks • Leading Pedestrian Intervals (LPI) at signalized intersections • Residential E-Bike rebate – Pilot Program - https://pwp.cityofpasadena.net/ebike-rebate-program/ Member 6 1. Water Consumption • Require all front yard lawn be replaced with xeriscape. This should apply to all property types (residential, commercial, retail, etc.). 53 Resource Preservation and Enhancement Committee List of Individual Priorities Submitted for Proposed 2024/2025 Workplan • CVWD’s Landscape Rebate program merely provides capped financial incentive – we need action. 2. Air Pollution: Sheriffs to cite drivers of vehicles visibly belching exhaust STAFF RESPONSE: Enforced by law enforcement and the California Vehicle Code 3. Noise Pollution: Sheriffs to cite drivers of vehicles exceeding the city decibel limit between 10pm and 7am. (See Ordinance #1246.) STAFF RESPONSE: Enforced by law enforcement and the California Vehicle Code Member 7 1. Pacaso: This is a new “home share” model, where homes are sold through “fractional ownership,” where one home may have as many as eight owners. Under this model, a management company handles the property, scheduling “owners” into the home for their assigned period. This sounds like an extremely risky situation for all concerned. I understand several homes in Palm Springs have been sold under this model. I understand the City has studied the problem but I don't know if any action has been taken. Can we get an update? STAFF RESPONSE: On May 22, 2022, the City Council amended the City’s zoning ordinance to prohibit timeshares and co-owned homes in residential neighborhoods. 2. Leaf blowers: I know we have an ordinance covering them, but don't know if there has been any real enforcement. I believe PSP has backed off of their action, probably because of resistance from landscapers. I'd appreciate an update, and possibly suggestions for improving this situation. (I've studied it at some Length, and actually submitted a writeup on the matter.) STAFF RESPONSE: On October 18, 2021, staff brought an informational report on gas-powered leaf blowers before the Resource Preservation and Enhancement Committee which explained the complexities of enforcing gas-powered leaf blowers. The report stated that “given the challenges that Palm Springs continues to face with their ordinance (i.e. problematic enforcement, lack of incentives for participation, etc.) and advisement that a regional ban may work best as it would then be enforceable across all cities, if the Resource Preservation & Enhancement 54 Resource Preservation and Enhancement Committee List of Individual Priorities Submitted for Proposed 2024/2025 Workplan Committee were inclined to make a recommendation to the City Council regarding gas-powered leaf blowers, staff recommends that it be to refer the matter to CVAG for a potential regional ban.” At that time, RPEC opted not to make a recommendation to the City Council. Since then, the sale of gas- powered lawn equipment has been banned by the State of California. Additionally, the City recently began proactively promoting trade-in incentives to landscapers through Southern California Air Quality Management District. We will also soon promote these incentives via social media and on the City’s website. 3. Fire hydrant parking prohibition: When I was attending the PD Civic Academy we visited the department that is responsible for painting the NO PARKING red paint on the curb. When I mentioned that it seemed most of the red paint had worn off, the person joked that it was now "Pink Paint." Can we get an update? STAFF RESPONSE: The City is presently seeking proposals from contractors for a range of paint striping services, encompassing tasks such as re-painting red curbs. This initiative marks the launch of a new, multi-year program aimed at addressing painting needs in a much more responsive manner. Proposals are due in late February, and staff anticipates beginning work in late spring or early summer. 55 56 Page 1 of 1 CITY OF PALM DESERT STAFF REPORT MEETING DATE: May 9, 2024 PREPARED BY: Anthony J. Mejia, City Clerk Amy Lawrence, Deputy Director of Economic Development REQUEST: RECEIVE AND FILE A CERTIFICATE OF APPRECIATION FROM THE WORLD ROMA FEDERATION RECOMMENDATION: Received and file a Certificate of Appreciation from the World Roma Federation. BACKGROUND/ANALYSIS: On March 28, 2024, the City Council discussed and approved replacement of a bronze plaque at the Desert Holocaust Memorial due to the wording used on one of the signs containing a derogatory term commonly associated with those of Roma/Romani descent. The World Roma Federation has awarded the City of Palm Desert a Certificate of Appreciation for updating the terminology and respectfully acknowledging the Roma community. Legal Review: This report has been reviewed by the City Attorney’s office. FINANCIAL IMPACT: There is no fiscal impact associated with this action. ATTACHMENT: 1. World Roma Federation - Certificate of Appreciation 57 58 59 60 Page 1 of 2 CITY OF PALM DESERT STAFF REPORT MEETING DATE: May 9, 2024 PREPARED BY: Erica Powell, Management Analyst REQUEST: APPROVAL OF EIGHTEEN (18) SCULPTURES AND SIX (6) ALTERNATE SCULPTURES FOR THE 2025/2026 EL PASEO SCULPTURE EXHIBTION RECOMMENDATION: 1. Approve eighteen (18) sculptures and six (6) alternate sculptures for the 2025/2026 El Paseo Sculpture Exhibition. 2. Approve honorarium of $5,000 for each of the participating artists. 3. Authorize staff to finalize negotiations of the subject contracts with the eighteen (18) artists and authorize City Manager to execute same, subject to the satisfaction of the City Attorney. 4. Authorize City Manager to make changes to sculpture selection based on staff recommendation. BACKGROUND/ANALYSIS: The El Paseo Sculpture Exhibition was developed in 1992 by the Palm Desert City Council in an effort to draw people to both El Paseo and the City. The Exhibition, which is open to artists in the USA, Canada, and Mexico, rotates every two (2) years and is located on the medians on El Paseo between Highway 74 and Portola Avenue. At its meeting of September 13, 2023, the Cultural Arts Committee authorized staff to seek proposals for artwork to display during the 2025/2026 El Paseo Sculpture Exhibition. The Call for Artists was promoted both locally and nationally for a period of three months which resulted in approximately 96 submittals by artists from all over the United States, Canada, and Mexico. At its March 13 and April 10, 2024, meetings, the Cultural Arts Committee reviewed all proposals and selected the following eighteen (18) sculptures and six (6) alternates for the 2025/2026 El Paseo Sculpture Exhibition: 1. Nine Ancestral Feathers by Adrian Susnea Litman (Santa Rosa, CA) 2. Ode to Calder II by Chris Rench (Hood River, OR) 3. Growing Wings by Hilde DeBruyne (Cumming, IA) 4. In My Element by Lovemore Bonjisi (Palm Desert, CA) 5. Unbearable Lightness of Being by Patricia Vader (Martinez, CA) 6. Champion by Russell Whiting (Breaux Bridge, LA) 7. Over the Falls by Alex Gall (Vista, CA) 8. Mirale Towers by Charles Sherman (Van Nuys, CA) 9. Vortex of Creation by Ivan Butorac (Los Angeles, CA) 10. Gilded Godiva by Karen & Tony Barone (Rancho Mirage, CA) 11. Extended Expanse by Jennifer Kapnek (Portland, OR) 61 City of Palm Desert 2025/2026 El Paseo Sculpture Exhibition Approval Page 2 of 2 12. Artemis by Lyle London (Tempe, AZ) 13. Tickets Please by Stephen Landis (Loveland, CO) 14. Spiral 1-2 by Ray Katz (Pontiac, MI) 15. Water Totem by Anne Faithe Nicholls (Palm Springs, CA) 16. Living Steel by Diego Harris (Upper Lake, CA) 17. Hopes and Dreams by Tim Shockley (Palm Desert, CA) 18. Human Nature by Art Garcia (Dallas, TX) – Pad 16 Alternates (in case artists above are unable to participate) 1. Rattlesnake Shake by Jimmy Descant (Tucson, AZ) 2. Mind the Gap by Aaron Alderman (Brevard, NC) 3. Spiral Dance by Harold Linke (Lake Oswego, OR) 4. Life Leaf by Hilde DeBruyne (Cumming, IA) 5. Resolve by Steve Grater (Tucson, AZ) 6. Flora by Ray Katz – (Pontiac, MI) Pad 16 Strategic Plan: Palm Desert’s public art program, particularly the El Paseo Sculpture Exhibition, creates a better community for residents and visitors to Palm Desert. This concept is in line with the Arts & Culture Mini-Vision of the 2013-2033 Strategic Plan, Envision Palm Desert – Forward Together which states: “Arts and culture give a community its soul. Palm Desert is the cultural core of the Coachella Valley. Cultural tourism drives economic growth in Palm Desert. The community is host to internationally recognized cultural events that bring significant economic benefits to the City. Palm Desert is a leader in arts education, ensuring a well-rounded population that possesses high levels of creativity and critical thinking skills.” Appointed Body Recommendation: At its regularly scheduled April 10, 2024, meeting, the Cultural Arts Committee voted unanimously to approve eighteen (18) sculptures and six (6) alternates for the 2025/2026 El Paseo Sculpture Exhibition. FINANCIAL IMPACT: Costs associated with the preparation of the 2025/2026 El Paseo Sculpture Exhibition, including artwork honorariums in the amount of $5,000 for each of the eighteen (18) artists (total of $90,000), de-installation and installation costs, marketing, etc. has been requested as part of the FY 2024/2025 Public Art Budget (Fund 436). There is no fiscal impact to the General Fund associated with this request. ATTACHMENTS: 1. 2025/2026 El Paseo Sculpture Exhibition Selections 2. Draft Contract 62 2025-2026 EL PASEO SCULPTURE EXHIBITION 18 Selections 6 Alternates 63 Nine Ancestral Feathers by Adrian Susnea Litman •Stainless Steel •H 14' x W 6' x D 6’ •Santa Rosa, CA 64 Ode to Calder II by Chris Rench •Mild Steel •H 8.5' x W 7.5' x D 4.5’ •Hood River, OR 65 Growing Wings by Hilde DeBruyne •Painted Metal •H 8' x W 4’ •Cumming, IA 66 In My Element by Lovemore Bonjisi •Cobalt Stone •H 75" x W 43" x D 18“ •Artist will supply base to raise to 8' height requirement. •Palm Desert, CA 67 Unbearable Lightness of Being by Patricia Vader •Powder Coated Steel •H 63" x W 63" x D 63“ •Artist will supply base to raise to 8' height requirement. •Martinez, CA 68 Champion by Russell Whiting •Torch Carved Steel Plate •H 72" x W 54" x 24" •Artist will supply base to raise to 8' height requirement. •Breaux Bridge, LA 69 Over the Falls by Alex Gall •Corten Steel •H 88" X W 42" x 20" •Artist will supply base to raise to 8' height requirement. •Vista, CA 70 Miracle Towers by Charles Sherman •Stainless Steel, Stained Glass, Crystals, Fossils and Mirrors •H 10' x W 18" x D 1" •Van Nuys, CA 71 Vortex of Creation by Ivan Butorac •Powder Coated Steel, Tempered Glass Prints, LED Lights, Aluminum, Wood Base •H 6' plus 2' base (shown) x W 6' x D 6' •Los Angeles, CA 72 Gilded Godiva by Karen & Tony Barone •Aluminum, Automotive Paint •H 8.1' x W 4.3' x D 6.8’ •Rancho Mirage, CA 73 Extended Expanse by Jennifer Kapnek •Aluminum, Steel, Wood, Acrylic, Finish •H 8' x W 7' x D 4' •Portland, OR 74 Artemis by Lyle London •Copper with Patina •H 96" x W 30" x D 30" •Tempe, AZ 75 Tickets Please by Stephen Landis •Fiberglass, Glass Fiber Reinforced Concrete (GRFC), Steel •H 10' x W 5' x D 4 ‘ •Loveland, CO 76 Spiral 1-2 by Ray Katz •Painted Steel •H 8' x W 8' x D 8' (base fits within requirements for art pad) •Pontiac, MI 77 Water Totem by Anne Faith Nicholls •Wood, Steel, Concrete, Fiberglass, Paint •H 8' x W 2' x D 3' •Palm Springs, CA 78 Living Steel by Diego Harris •Corten Steel, Steel Rebar •H 9.8' x W 6.3' x D 3.5' •Upper Lake, CA 79 Hopes and Dreams by Tim Shockley •Steel, Paint •Sculpture: H 38" x W 24" •Base: H 58" x 22" cylindrical •Palm Desert, CA 80 Large Pad: Human Nature by Art Garcia •Steel, Enamel •H 96" x W 44" x 9" (Three figures) •Dallas, TX 81 Rattlesnake Shake by Jimmy Descant Alternate •Aluminum, Metals •H 8' x W 2' x D 4" •Tuscon, AZ 82 Mind the Gap by Aaron Alderman Alternate •Steel and Copper •H 107" x W 29" x D 23" •Brevard, NC 83 Spiral Dance by Harold Linke Alternate •Bronze with Titanium White Powder Coat •H 144" x W 46" x D 57“ •Lake Oswego, OR 84 Life Leaf by Hilde DeBruyne Alternate •Corten Steel •H 8' x W 4' x D 4' •Cumming, IA 85 Resolve by Steve Grater Alternate •Steel and Stainless Steel •H 98" x W 28" x D 25" •Tucson, AZ 86 70. Flora by Ray Katz Pad 16 Alternate •Stainless Steel •H 9' x W 9' x D 5.8’ •Pontiac, MI •NO: 57.1% -YES: 42.9% 87 88 Contract No. C42970X 1 AGREEMENT FOR TEMPORARY PUBLIC EXHIBITION OF SCULPTURE This Agreement is entered into this 14th day of April 2022, by and between the City of Palm Desert, a California municipal corporation (“City”) and John Doe (“Artist”) Type of Business, Location of Business, for display of an artwork entitled “Title” (“Sculpture”) as part of the 2025/2026 El Paseo Sculpture Exhibition (“Exhibition”). RECITALS A. The Artist desires to loan the Sculpture to the City for public display; and B. The Cultural Arts Committee and the Palm Desert City Council have approved a temporary exhibition of the Sculpture in a public place located on El Paseo between Street and Street (“Exhibition Site”). THEREFORE, for good and valuable consideration, including, without limitation, the mutual promises, conditions, and agreements set forth herein, the City and the Artist agrees as follows: 1. Ownership The Artist retains all ownership rights in the Sculpture unless sold as provided in Section 2 below. Notwithstanding the foregoing, City is entitled to exclusive possession during the Exhibition Period (as defined herein). 2. Sale of Sculpture Artist may sell the Sculpture during the term of this Agreement; however, the Sculpture cannot be removed until the end of the Exhibition. If sold, Artist may assign his or her rights under this Agreement with the written consent of the City, which will not be unreasonably withheld. Under no circumstances shall sale of the Sculpture terminate this Agreement or adversely affect City’s rights hereunder including, but not limited to, City’s right of exclusive possession. 3. Reproduction Rights Artist hereby grants City, in perpetuity, the right to photograph, film, videotape, or otherwise depict the Sculpture at any time during the Exhibition Period and to use such photographs, film, videotapes, or depictions at any time thereafter for purposes of promotion relating to the Exhibition or the City. Such reproduction and images which 89 Contract No. C42970X 2 feature the Sculpture as art for publicity, promotion, and educational purposes shall, to the extent reasonably possible and appropriate, give reference to the Artist. Reproduction and images of Sculpture in which the purpose of the reproduction or image is predominantly unrelated to the Sculpture shall not require reference to Artist. 4. Exhibition Period The “Exhibition Period” shall mean the period from November 1, 2024 through October 31, 2026. The Exhibition Period may be shortened or extended in duration by written mutual agreement between Artist and City. Notwithstanding the foregoing, City reserves the right, in its sole discretion and with or without cause, to decline or terminate the Exhibition at any time. 5. Transportation, Installation, Removal, and Maintenance 5.1 Transportation of the Sculpture to and from the Exhibition Site shall be the responsibility of Artist. The Sculpture must arrive at the Exhibition Site ready to be secured to the preexisting pad with tabs or another preapproved installation mechanism. City shall bear the Reasonable Cost of installation and removal. “Reasonable Cost” shall mean those sums set forth in Exhibit “A”, which is attached hereto and incorporated by this reference. Once the Sculpture is removed from the pad, Artist is solely responsible for removing it from the premises. If the Sculpture sells during the Exhibition Period, Artist shall remain responsible for removal of Sculpture at the end of the Exhibition Period. If Artist fails to remove Sculpture from the pad within fourteen (14) days of scheduled deinstallation date, then City will remove and dispose of Sculpture as necessary and will withhold the Reasonable Cost from the balance of the Exhibition Honorarium. Expenses in excess of the balance of honorarium will be the responsibility of the Artist. 5.2 During the Exhibition Period, City shall be responsible for the maintenance of the Sculpture. City shall take reasonable steps to utilize the maintenance procedures and/or methods described by Artist and set forth on Exhibit “B”, which is attached hereto and incorporated herein by this reference, but City reserves the right to decline implementation of any or all, or any part thereof, of such procedures and/or methods if circumstances, including but not 90 Contract No. C42970X 3 limited to considerations of cost, render such implementation unreasonable. In the event City declines to implement such procedures and/or methods, Artist may undertake such procedures and/or methods at Artist’s sole expense. 6. Exhibition Honorarium City shall pay Artist an exhibition honorarium of five thousand dollars and no/100ths ($5,000) for the loan and exclusive possession of the Sculpture during the Exhibition Period (“Exhibition Honorarium”). City’s obligation for payment is conditioned upon the complete installation and timely removal of Sculpture. Artist shall not be entitled to payment in the event this Agreement is cancelled or otherwise terminated, for any reason, prior to completion of installation the Sculpture. Payment shall be made in accordance with the following schedule. Installation of Sculpture. Four thousand dollars ($4,000) of the Exhibition Honorarium upon completion of delivery and installation of Sculpture. Removal of Sculpture. One thousand dollars ($1,000) of the Exhibition Honorarium upon removal of Sculpture. 7. Liability for Damage or Injury 7.1 City shall insure the Sculpture against damage or loss in the amount of XXXX dollars and no/100ths ($XX,XXX.00), which the parties agree is the fair market value of the Sculpture and the extent of the City’s liability in the event of its damage or loss. 7.2 City’s obligation to provide insurance is solely for the duration of the Exhibition Period and only while the Sculpture is located on at the Exhibition Site. Artist is responsible and liable for any damage or destruction that may occur during transportation of the Sculpture to and/or from the Exhibition Site. 7.3 To the fullest extent permitted by law, Artist shall indemnify and hold City harmless from any and all claims, losses, damages, injuries, and/or liabilities, of any kind whatsoever, including reasonable attorney fees and costs, arising out of or related to the transportation, installation and/or deinstallation of the Sculpture by Artist, defects of the Sculpture, faulty workmanship of the Artist, or any negligent acts or willful misconduct of the Artist and its agents except such loss or damage caused by the sole negligence or willful misconduct of the City. 91 Contract No. C42970X 4 Artist's obligation to indemnify shall survive expiration or termination of this Agreement and shall not be restricted to insurance proceeds, if any, received by Artist, the City, its officials, officers, employees, agents, or volunteers. 8. El Paseo Sculpture Exhibition Guidelines Attached hereto and made a part hereof is Exhibit “C”, which are the Guidelines for the El Paseo Sculpture Exhibition. In the event of conflict between this Agreement and the Guidelines, this Agreement will prevail. 9. Entire Agreement This Agreement represents the entire Agreement between City and Artist and no other representations, whether oral, written or implied, have been made nor may be relied upon by either City or Artist. This Agreement may be modified only by writing made after the date of this Agreement and signed by both City and Artist. 10. Governing Law This Agreement is entered into in and shall be governed by the laws of the State of California. Venue shall be in Riverside County. 11. Death of Artist In the event of Artist’s death prior to the completion of the Exhibition Period, City will return the Sculpture after the conclusion of the Exhibition Period to the person(s) designated in Exhibit “D” at the expense of Artist’s estate or Artist’s designee. 12. Miscellaneous Provisions This Agreement shall be binding on the successors and assigns of the Parties. There are no intended third party beneficiaries of any right or obligation assumed by the Parties. Artist has all requisite power and authority to conduct its business and to execute, deliver, and perform the Agreement. This Agreement may be signed in counterparts, each of which shall constitute an original. 92 Contract No. C42970X 5 CITY OF PALM DESERT Dated: Karina Quintanilla, Mayor ATTEST: Dated: Anthony J. Mejia, City Clerk ARTIST: Dated: Artist [printed name and title] John Doe (Artist) P.O. Box city, st xxx xxx-xxx-xxxx APPROVED AS TO FORM: City Attorney 93 Contract No. C42970X 6 Exhibit A: Transportation, Installation, and Removal Methods and Associated Cost Installation/deinstallation coordinated and performed by City of Palm Desert. The Artist is responsible for transporting the artwork to the assigned site at the assigned date and time, whereas the City will provide technical assistance with the installation process and in securing the Sculpture to the foundation. Sculptures must arrive install ready with tabs to secure the sculpture to the concrete pad. If sculpture does not arrive install ready, installation may be rescheduled for a date that this requirement can be met. Please note that the concrete pad cannot be altered in any way to accommodate additional hardware to secure the Sculpture. Listed below are detailed installation methods provided by the artist including required bolt and screw sizes necessary for securing the Sculpture to the concrete pad. Crane needed to install Sculpture? Artist Name Artwork Title Date 94 Contract No. C42970X 7 Exhibit B: Maintenance Requirements and Procedure Artist Name: John Doe Listed below are maintenance procedures/methods provided by the artist for the Sculpture titled “Art”. 95 Contract No. C42970X 8 Exhibit C: Guidelines for the 2025/26 El Paseo Sculpture Exhibition 1. The Public Art Department will facilitate the Exhibition on behalf of the City of Palm Desert. 2. All sculptures MUST be delivered and picked up from the assigned site pad on El Paseo at the assigned dates and times. 3. The City of Palm Desert will provide the following for the El Paseo Sculpture Exhibition. • A crane, if needed for installation of sculpture. The installation period is tentatively scheduled from November 1, 2024 to October 31, 2026. • Advertising and promotion of the Exhibition • Signage • Pads/Lighting/Maintenance • Dedication • Insurance for estimated value 4. All sculptures MUST be designed with tabs or other devices that can be utilized to easily secure the artwork to the concrete pads, and the base of the sculpture must fit on the existing pad site as designated in the Call for Entries. 5. All packing and crating materials MUST be removed by the artist at the time of installation. 6. The Exhibition period will not exceed two years. 7. Sculpture can be sold at any time, but must remain in its designated location for the entire Exhibition Period. 8. Bio, resume, or CV for the artist and a thorough description of the Sculpture must be supplied. 9. Artist must provide digital image at 300 dpi suitable for publication in advertising. 96 Contract No. C42970X 9 Exhibit D: Designated Beneficiary of Artist in case of Death or Incapacity of Artist Below, as provided by the artist, is the name of the artist’s designated beneficiary, to include address, phone number, and email address. 97 98 Page 1 of 2 CITY OF PALM DESERT STAFF REPORT MEETING DATE: May 9, 2024 PREPARED BY: Gary Shaffer, Library Services Director REQUEST: AUTHORIZE CITY MANAGER TO AWARD LIBRARY FURNITURE, FIXTURE, FINISHES, AND EQUIPMENT CONTRACTS TO MULTIPLE VENDORS TO OUTFIT THE LIBRARY LOCATED AT 73-300 FRED WARING DRIVE IN THE ADDITIONAL AMOUNT OF $42,000 RECOMMENDATION: 1. Authorize increase of $42,000 to previously approved City Manager Not to Exceed threshold of $650,000 for furniture, fixture, and equipment (FF&E) vendors for the library located at 73- 300 Fred Waring Drive, for a total of $692,000. 2. Authorize the City Manager to execute any agreements, amendments, and all other documents necessary to effectuate this action. 3. Authorize the City Attorney to make any necessary non -monetary changes to the agreement. BACKGROUND/ANALYSIS: The City is taking over local library services from the County of Riverside beginning July 1, 2024. Over the past year staff has worked diligently to take all steps necessary for withdrawal from Riverside County Library System. Concurrently, staff has worked with the College of the Desert to maintain an on-going short-term lease for the current library facility from the college, while plans to design and build a new library are developed. City staff has worked with the City’s library design consultant on recommendations to update the leased facilities to include painting, some new flooring, and furniture package equipment (FF&E) vendors. On March 14, 2024, the City Council took action to authorize the City Manager to enter into contractual agreements equaling $650,000. Bids are coming in higher than expected and additional funding in the amount of $42,000 is requested for related costs. The higher bids include, security cameras, the lap-top kiosk, and laptops. Given the timing considerations to complete this process ahead of July 1, staff requests the City Council authorize the City Manager to finalize an d award related purchase contracts. Procurement of library-specific equipment will follow the City’s existing purchasing policies and procedures. An update of all final contract amounts will be provided upon completion. Legal Review: This report has been reviewed by the City Attorney’s office. FINANCIAL IMPACT: 99 City of Palm Desert Authorize City Manage to Award Library Equipment Contracts Page 2 of 2 Funds in the amount $692,000 are currently budgeted in the Library’s Building Capital Project Budget Account No. 4524136-4400100. Fund 452 Reno Under Contract Amount Total Original Budget $692,000.00 3.14.24 Approval for CM Little Free Library $3,369.52 Java Connections (Laptop Kiosk)56,265.97 Quality Office Furnishings 311,052.12 G/M Business Interiors 46,837.90 Quality Office Furnishings 37,947.40 CDW Laptops 30,285.29 Vector (Security Cameras)50,689.88 $155,551.92 Balance Available for Project $42,000.00 $42,000.00 New Total Budget $197,551.92 $692,000.00 This Request Remaining for Other Items Painting, Flooring, etc. (approx..) 100 Page 1 of 2 CITY OF PALM DESERT STAFF REPORT MEETING DATE: May 9, 2024 PREPARED BY: Eric Ceja, Director of Economic Development REQUEST: APPROVE A ONE (1) YEAR LEASE AGREEMENT W ITH ONE (1), ONE (1) YEAR EXTENSION WITH CHRIS NELSON FOR THE OPERATION OF A REMOTE CONTROLLED RACETRACK ON THE VACANT CITY- OWNED PARCEL WITH ASSESSOR’S PARCEL NO. 640-091-010 RECOMMENDATION: 1. Approve a one (1) year lease agreement with one (1), one (1) year extension with Chris Nelson for the operation of a remote controlled racetrack on the vacant City -owned parcel with Assessor’s Parcel No. (APN) 640-091-010. 2. Authorize the City Attorney to make necessary, nonmonetary changes to the lease agreement. 3. Authorize the City Manager to execute the lease and any and all related documents. BACKGROUND/ANALYSIS: The Racetrack is located on a vacant City lot on Painters Path behind Desert Crossing Shopping Center (APN# 640-091-010). In December 2023, the City executed a one (1) year lease with Adam Drake for the operations of the racetrack. The lease allows either party to terminate it with thirty (30) days’ notice. Mr. Drake has informed staff that he wishes to exercise the termination clause and has recommended Chris Nelson as a replacement for the management of the track. Staff interviewed Mr. Nelson and, based on his experience with and knowledge of RC racing, recommends moving forward with a lease with him for one (1) year with one (1) extension of one (1) year for one dollar ($1) per year. As the leaseholder, Mr. Nelson is responsible for the upkeep and maintenance of the racetrack, submittal of all required insurances to the City, being open a minimum of one (1) weekday and one (1) weekend day per week and p roducing a minimum of one (1) signature event per year. In the past, operators were not required to open on specific days or times or for any specified amount of time per month. When leasing with Mr. Drake, staff introduced clauses requiring one (1) signature event annually and a minimum of fifteen (15) hours of track availability per month. Under the new lease with Mr. Nelson, the track would now be required to be open at least one (1) weekday and one (1) weekend day per week with at least one (1) signature event annually to allow broader community access to the track. 101 City of Palm Desert RC Racetrack Lease – Chris Nelson Page 2 of 2 Operators No specified hours Open a minimum of 15 hours per month Open 1 weekday and 1 weekend day per week Signature Event Previous Operators X Current Operator X X Mr. Nelson as Operator X X X Track Location Legal Review: This report has been reviewed by the City Attorney’s office. FINANCIAL IMPACT: The lease agreement calls for the payment of one dollar ($1) to the City annually . Other than minimal staff time to facilitate the agreement and observe operations of the facility, there are no additional costs incurred by the City. ATTACHMENT: 1. Lease Agreement 102 Contract No. ___________ 1 CITY OF PALM DESERT LEASE AGREEMENT This Lease Agreement (“Lease”) is made and entered into as of this 25th day of April 2024, by and between the City of Palm Desert, a Municipal Corporation (Landlord) and Chris Nelson (“Tenant”) with a principal place of business at ___________________, California, with reference to the following facts: 1. Description of the Leased Premises. Landlord leases to Tenant, and Tenant leases from Landlord, for the term and upon the terms and conditions in this Lease, the Premises (Exhibit A). 2. Term. The term of this Lease shall be for one (1) year, commencing on April 25, 2024 (the “Term Commencement Date”). The term will be automatically extended for an additional one (1) year unless either party gives thirty (30) days prior written notice of termination prior to the expiration of the then current term. 3. Date of Lease and Legal Effect. The terms, covenants and conditions of this Lease shall become legally binding on the Term Commencement Date. 4. Rent. During the term of this Lease and any extension thereof, Tenant shall pay Landlord one dollar ($1.00) per year as minimum yearly rent. 5. Utilities & Maintenance: Improvements: Condition of Premises. A. Provided by Landlord. Landlord shall provide neither services nor maintenance for the Premises. Landlord shall pay for and provide water utility service to the Premises. This water utility service shall be limited to reasonable water usage in connection to the Premises only. Tenant takes all necessary actions to transfer water utility services provided to Premises from Tenant to Landlord. Notwithstanding the foregoing, Landlord shall provide no other service or maintenance for the Premises. B. Provided by Tenant. Except as otherwise provided in this Lease, Tenant shall pay any and all expenses required and keep and maintain the Premises and every part thereof in and about the Premises in good order, condition and repair, normal wear and tear excepted. Tenant shall be responsible for general upkeep of the Premises and shall provide service therefore. Tenant shall also inspect and provide reasonable upkeep for the grounds of which the Premises are a part, to the extent that such areas are used by Tenant. Tenant shall not make or cause to be made any alterations, additions, or improvements to or of the Premises or any part thereof without the prior written consent of Landlord. Tenant shall keep the Premises free and clear of any liens or encumbrances which may arise from such work, materials furnished or obligations incurred by or for Tenant. C. As-Is Condition. Tenant warrants and agrees that Tenant has inspected the Premises. Tenant agrees to take possession of the Premises in an AS-IS condition (which exists on the Term Commencement Date) and Tenant further agrees that Landlord shall have no responsibility for any repairs or improvements to the Premises, prior to, or as a condition of, Tenant’s occupation of the Premises. Landlord makes no representations regarding the condition, status, compliance with laws or suitability for a particular purpose for Tenant’s use. 103 Contract No. ___________ 2 D. Condition Upon Surrender. Upon expiration or sooner termination of this Lease, Tenant shall surrender the Premises to Landlord in as good condition as when received, ordinary wear and tear and damage by fire, earthquake, or act of God excepted, and including any repairs or improvements made by Tenant. The Tenant shall, at its sole cost and expense, remove from the Premises all of its movable trade fixtures and equipment, and such other items the Tenant has installed or placed on the Premises, and the Tenant shall repair all damage to the improvements resulting from such removal. If Tenant fails to maintain the Premises in good order and repair, after thirty (30) days prior written notice, Landlord may, at its option, make such repairs, and Tenant shall pay the reasonable cost thereof additional rent hereunder within ten (10) days after receipt of a written statement therefor. In the event the giving of thirty (30) days prior notice may result in additional damage to the Premises, Landlord may make such repairs, at Tenant’s expense, within thirty (30) days prior written notice. 6. Taxes. A. Landlord Taxes. Landlord shall have no responsibility for payment of any real property taxes and assessments levied and assessed against the land of which the Premises are a part. B. Tenant Taxes. Tenant agrees to pay, before delinquent, all real and personal property taxes levied or assessed on Tenant’s property located on the Premises, at Tenant’s sole cost and expenses, if any. C. Revenue & Taxation Code Section 107.6, Possessory Interest Tax. Tenant recognizes and understands that this Lease may create a possessory interest subject to property taxes and that, in the event that a possessory interest is created, Tenant shall be responsible for payment of any taxes levied against such possessory interest. 7. Insurance and Indemnification. A. Landlord’s Insurance. Landlord shall obtain and maintain, at Landlord’s sole cost and expense, insurance in such coverages and in such amounts as Landlord determines, in Landlord’s sole discretion. B. Tenant’s Insurance. Tenant shall obtain and maintain, at Tenant’s sole cost and expense, broad-form comprehensive public liability insurance with limits not less than One Million Dollars ($1,000,000) per person and One Million Dollars ($1,000,000) each occurrence, insuring any and all liability of Tenant with respect to the Premises, and property damage liability insurance with a limit not less than One Million Dollars ($1,000,000) each accident or Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000) combined single limit, Tenant shall name Landlord as an additional insured, at Tenant’s sole cost and expense. C. Indemnification. Except for the sole negligence of Landlord, Tenant shall defend, indemnify and keep and hold Landlord, including Landlord’s officers, officials, agents, employees and volunteers, their successors and assigns, harmless from any and all costs, liability, damage or expense (including costs of suit and fees and expenses of legal services) claimed by anyone by reason of injury to or death of persons, or damage to or destruction of property, including property of Tenant, sustained in, on or about the Premises or arising out of Tenant’s use or occupancy thereof. D. Assumption of Risk. To the extent permitted by law, Tenant assumes any and all risk of loss, damage or injury of any kind to any person or property which is in, on or about the Premises. 104 Contract No. ___________ 3 Tenant’s assumption of risk shall include without limitation loss or damage caused by defects within the Premises or any fixture therein, accident, fire or other casualty on the Premises. To the extent permitted by law, Tenant hereby waives all claims and demands against Landlord, its respective officials, officers, employees, volunteers and agents for injury to persons or damage to property arising for any reason. E. Waiver of Claims. Tenant has been advised by its legal counsel concerning the content and effect of California Civil Code Section 1542, which provides: A GENERAL RELEASE DOES NOT EXTEND TO CLAIMS THAT THE CREDITOR OR RELEASING PARTY DOES NOT KNOW OR SUSPECT TO EXIST IN HIS OR HER FAVOR AT THE TIME OF EXECUTING THE RELEASE AND THAT, IF KNOWN BY HIM OR HER, WOULD HAVE MATERIALLY AFFECTED HIS OR HER SETTLEMENT WITH THE DEBTOR OR RELEASED PARTY. Tenant hereby waives the benefit of California Civil Code Section 1542 and all other State or federal statutes or judicial decisions of similar effect. The provisions of this Section shall survive the termination of this Lease. 8. Permitted Use; Compliance with Laws. A. Tenant shall use the Premises solely for the purpose of operating a remote controlled car racetrack. Tenant is responsible for compliance with all local, State, and Federal laws. The only vehicles permitted on the site are small remote controlled vehicles on the racetrack. Tenant will take necessary measures to ensure that dust is not generated on the site that is blown onto adjoining property. B. Tenant is responsible for compliance with all local, State, and Federal laws. C. Tenant shall cause the Premises to be open a minimum of one (1) weekday and one (1) weekend day and produce a minimum of one (1) signature event per year unless authorized otherwise in writing by City. D. Tenant will post hours of operations at the Premises. 9. Hazardous Materials. Tenant shall not cause or permit any Hazardous Materials, as defined below to be brought upon, kept, used, discharged, deposited or leaked in or about the Premises by Tenant or any of Tenant’s agents or by anyone in the Premises (other than Landlord or its agents, employees, or contractors). If Tenant breaches the obligations stated in this preceding sentence, or if the presence of any Hazardous Material on the Premises caused or suffered or permitted by Tenant or any of Tenant’s agents or by anyone in the Premises (other than Landlord or its agents, employees, or contractors) results in contamination of the Premises, or if contamination of the Premises by any Hazardous Material otherwise occurs for which Tenant is equally liable, then Tenant shall indemnify, defend and hold Landlord harmless from any and all claims, damages, costs, liabilities and expenses (including, without limitation, diminution in value or use of the Premises, attorney’s fees, consultant fees and expert fees) which arise during or after the term as a result of such contamination. This indemnification shall include, without limitation costs incurred in connection with any investigation of site conditions or any clean-up remedial, removal or restoration work on or under the Premises. “Hazardous Material” means any material or waste which is or becomes regulated by any State or Federal governmental 105 Contract No. ___________ 4 authority or by common law decisions, including without limitation (i) all chlorinated solvents, (ii) petroleum products or by-products, (iii) asbestos and (iv) polychlorinated biphenyls. 10. Landlord’s Right to Enter Premises. Landlord reserves, and shall at any and all times have, the right to enter the Premises upon reasonable notice to Tenant to inspect same, to submit the Premises to prospective tenants, to post notices of non-responsibility, and to repair the Premises. 11. Assignment and Subleasing. Tenant shall not assign, mortgage, or hypothecate this Lease in whole or in part, nor sublet all or any part of the Premises, without the prior written consent of Landlord in each instance, which consent may be withheld, reasonably or otherwise, in Landlord’s sole and absolute discretion. 12. Termination. Either party hereto may terminate this Lease at any time upon thirty (30) days prior written notice to the other party. 13. Reporting and Accounting Requirements. At all times during the term of this lease, Tenant shall maintain books and records sufficient to evaluate the revenue generation of the facility, Tenant shall make available to City such books and records upon request. 14. No Waiver of Breach. No failure of either Landlord or Tenant to insist upon the strict performance by the other of any covenant, agreement, term or condition of this Lease or to exercise any right or remedy consequent upon a breach thereof, shall constitute a waiver of any such breach of such covenant, agreement, term or condition. No waiver of any breach shall affect or alter this Lease, but each and every covenant, condition, agreement, and term of this Lease shall continue in full force and effect with respect to any other than existing or subsequent breach. 15. Time is of the Essence. Time is of the essence of this Lease and of each provision. 16. Notices. All notices and other communication hereunder shall be in writing and shall be delivered in person or sent by registered or certified mail, postage prepaid commercial overnight courier (Such as Express Mail, Federal Express, etc.) with written verification of receipt or by facsimile or email. A notice shall be deemed given: (a) when delivered by personal delivery (as evidenced by the receipt); (b) three (3) days after deposit in the mail if sent by registered or certified mail; (c) one (1) business day after having sent by commercial overnight courier mail; (c) one business day after having been sent by commercial overnight courier as evidenced by the written verification of receipt; (d) on the date of confirmation if faxed or emailed. If to Landlord: City of Palm Desert Attention: City Manager 73510 Fred Waring Drive Palm Desert, CA 92260 If to Tenant: Chris Nelson ______________________ _________, CA 92223 Any party may change its address for receiving notice by written notice given to the other named above. 106 Contract No. ___________ 5 17. Entire Agreement/Amendment. This Lease contains the entire agreement of the parties with respect to the matters covered by this Lease, and not other agreements, statements, or promise made by any party, or to any employee, officer, or agent of any party, which is not contained in this Lease shall be binding or valid. This Lease may not be modified except by written instrument duly executed by the parties hereto or their successors in interest. 18. Survival of Indemnities. The obligations of the indemnifying party under each and every indemnification and hold harmless provision contained in this Lease shall survive the expiration or earlier termination of this Lease to and until the last to occur of (a) the last date permitted by law for the bringing of any claim or action with respect to which indemnification may be claimed by the indemnifying party against the indemnifying party under such provision or (b) the date on which any claim or action of or which indemnification may be claimed under such provision is fully and finally resolved, and if applicable, any compromise thereof or judgment or award thereon is paid in full by the indemnifying party and the indemnified party in compromise thereof or upon judgment or award thereon and in defense of such action or claim, including reasonable attorney’s fees incurred. 19. Heading. The subject headings of the section and paragraphs of this Lease are included for purposes of convenience only and shall not affect the construction or interpretation of any of its provisions. 20. Attorney’s Fees. Should either party commence any legal action or proceeding against the other based on this Lease, the prevailing party shall be entitled to an award of attorney’s fees. 21. Counterparts. This Agreement may be executed in any one or more counterparts, and all so executed shall constitute one and the same instrument. 22. Governing Law. Venue. This agreement shall be construed and governed by the laws of the State of California. If any action is brought to interpret or enforce any term of this Lease, the action shall be brought in a state or federal court situation in the County of Riverside, State of California. [SIGNATURES ON NEXT PAGE] 107 Contract No. ___________ 6 In WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have caused this Agreement to be executed by their duly authorized representatives on the date first above written. LANDLORD: Dated: By: Name: L. Todd Hileman Its: City Manager TENANT: Dated: By: Name: Chris Nelson Its: Approved as to form: By: Best Best & Krieger LLP City Attorney QC: Insurance: Initial Review Final Approval 108 Contract No. ___________ 7 Exhibit A DESCRIPTION OF PREMISES APN 640-091-010, vacant property behind the Desert Crossing Shopping Center on Painters Path as delineated below on the map but excluding that portion of the property indicated by the shaded area designated as “Project Location” on the map. 109 110 Page 1 of 2 CITY OF PALM DESERT STAFF REPORT MEETING DATE: May 9, 2024 PREPARED BY: Shawn Muir, Community Services Manager REQUEST: RESOLUTION FOR THE NATIONAL WILDLIFE FEDERATION’S MAYORS’ MONARCH PLEDGE TO RENEW THE CITY’S EFFORTS TO PROTECT AND ENHANCE THE POLLINATOR POPULATION RECOMMENDATION: 1. Adopt a Resolution entitled “A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, AUTHORIZING THE CITY TO ENTER INTO THE NATIONAL WILDLIFE FEDERATION MAYORS’ MONARCH PLEDGE.” 2. Authorize staff to work in collaboration with the Living Desert Zoo and Gardens and University of California, Riverside (UCR) Palm Desert Center to carry out the three specific actions listed below within the next year: a. Issue a Proclamation to raise awareness about the decline of the monarch butterfly and the species’ need for habitat. b. Increase the area of pollinator-friendly demonstration garden at Civic Center Park. c. Support milkweed propagation by plan ting milkweed at various City parks and medians, where advisable. BACKGROUND/ANALYSIS: The monarch butterfly is known for the migration it makes every year from Canada and the eastern, central, and western United States to the central mountains of Mexico . Palm Desert is on the west coast flyway for monarchs heading to and from Mexico. Unfortunately, the monarch butterfly is disappearing, and scientists indicate that the population has declined by 90% over the last twenty years. Like all butterflies, monarchs lay their eggs on select plants, called “host plants”, the only plants their caterpillars can eat. For monarchs in Palm Desert, desert milkweed (Asclepias subulata) is the host plant. Studies show that milkweed across the United States declined by 58% from 1999 to 2010, which has critically affected the monarch population. The City has partnered with The Living Desert Zoo and Gardens since 2021 to create public awareness and increase the number of monarch butterflies in Palm Desert and the Coachella Valley. Increasing the number of monarchs in the Coachella Valley is important because they are significant pollinators for local fruit, nut, and vegetable growers. After staff were authorized to collaborate with The Living Desert Zoo and Gardens on the Pledge in 2021 a monarch butterfly mural was installed within the City, a pollinator garden with directional signage and QR code directing residents to native planting resources was established in Civic Center Park, and milkweed planting began in various lan dscaped areas throughout the City. 111 City of Palm Desert Approve Renewal of Mayors’ Monarch Pledge Page 2 of 2 These pledged actions have made significant progress and additional actions are planned for 2024, including the expansion of the pollinator garden in Civic Center Park, addition of a bench with pollinator-themed art, and continuing to include milkweed in City landscape plans. Upon completion of all items, the City will be asked to submit a simple reporting form regarding the action measures taken on an annual basis. This information will be used by the National Wildlife Federation to track the collective outcomes and impacts of this action. Staff will continue to explore ways to implement additional pledge actions alongside community partners to create awareness and appreciation for monarch butterfly habitats should the City Council approve entering into this pledge once again. Action Items Committed for 2024 Communications and Convening▸ Issue a proclamation to raise awareness about the decline of the monarch butterfly and the species’ need for habitat. This proclamation must incorporate a focus on monarch conservation. Create a community art project to enhance and promote monarch and pollinator conservation as well as cultural awareness and recognition. Program and Demonstration Gardens▸ Plant or maintain a monarch and pollinator-friendly demonstration garden at City Hall or another prominent or culturally significant community location. Legal Review: This report has been reviewed by the City Attorney’s office. Strategic Plan: The Mayors’ Monarch Pledge and associated projects foster a partnership with The Living Desert Zoo and Gardens and UCR Palm Desert Center to create areas within the City dedicated to conservation of pollinator species. This concept aligns with Priority 2 of the Strategic Plan which focuses on innovative ideas to provide recreation to the community through creative collaboration with partner agencies. The Strategic Plan also points out that art and culture drive economic growth in the City which supports the installation of the monarch mural. FINANCIAL IMPACT: The annual maintenance cost for the pollinator garden is included in the Civic Center Park Landscape Maintenance Contract (LMA 17) under Account No. 1104610-4332001. ATTACHMENTS: 1. Resolution 2. Exhibit A 3. Site Map 112 RESOLUTION NO. __________ A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, AUTHORIZING THE CITY TO ENTER INTO THE NATIONAL WILDLIFE FEDERATION MAYORS’ MONARCH PLEDGE WHEREAS, the large and brilliantly colored monarch butterfly is among the most easily recognizable of the butterfly species that call North America home; and WHEREAS, the monarch butterfly population has declined by approximately 90 percent since the 1990s. Monarch butterflies face habitat loss and fragmentation in the United States and Mexico; and WHEREAS, Mayors and other local executives are taking action to help save the monarch butterfly; and WHEREAS, through the National Wildlife Federation Mayors’ Monarch Pledge, U.S. municipalities and other communities are committing to create habitat for the monarch butterfly and pollinators, and to educate citizens on how they can make a difference at home and in their community; and WHEREAS, as part of the Mayors’ Monarch Pledge, the City is required to take at least three action items. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Palm Desert, California: SECTION 1. The Mayor is hereby authorized to issue a Proclamation pursuant to Pledge Action Item under Communications and Convening in Exhibit A of this Resolution on behalf of the City to raise awareness about the decline of the monarch butterfly and the species’ need for habitat. SECTION 2. The City Manager or designee is hereby directed to utilize the appropriate City staff and departments to accomplish at least two of the Pledge Action items listed in Exhibit A. SECTION 3. The City Manager or designee is hereby encouraged but not required to utilize appropriate City staff and departments to accomplish additional Pledge Action Items listed in Exhibit A beyond those required in Sections 1 and 2 above. 113 ADOPTED ON ________________, 2024. KARINA QUINTANILLA MAYOR ATTEST: ANTHONY J. MEJIA CITY CLERK I, Anthony J. Mejia, City Clerk of the City of Palm Desert, hereby certify that Resolution No. 2024-__ is a full, true, and correct copy, and was duly adopted at a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Palm Desert on _______________________, by the following vote: AYES: NOES: ABSENT: ABSTAIN: RECUSED: IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and affixed the official seal of the City of Palm Desert, California, on ___________________. ANTHONY J. MEJIA CITY CLERK 114 115 116 SANPABLOAVECARMEL CIRSANPASCUALAVEKRUG AVE SAN PASCUAL AVEPRIVATE ST SAN PASCUAL AVEPRIVATE ST M A GN ESI A FA LLS D R SEBASTIAN WAYPRIVATE ST SANPABLOAVECARMEL CIRCARMEL CIRHEITZ CTMARTINI C T PRIVATE ST PRIVATE ST SAN PASCUAL AVEPRIVATE STCARMEL CIRFRED WARING DR MASSON STPRIVATE STRANCHO RD RANCHO RD PRIVATE RD PRIVATE STPRIVATE ST M A GN ESI A FA LLS D R SANPABLOAVEFRED WARING DRSANPABLOAVE CARMEL CIRSANPASCUALAVEKRUG AVE SAN PASCUAL AVEPRIVATE ST SAN PASCUAL AVEPRIVATE ST M A GN ESI A FA LLS D R SEBASTIAN WAYPRIVATE ST SANPABLOAVECARMEL CIRCARMEL CIRHEITZ CTMARTINI C T PRIVATE ST PRIVATE ST SAN PASCUAL AVEPRIVATE STCARMEL CIRFRED WARING DR MASSON STPRIVATE STRANCHO RD RANCHO RD PRIVATE RD PRIVATE STPRIVATE ST M A GN ESI A FA LLS D R SANPABLOAVEFRED WARING DR Mayor's Monarch PledgePollinator Friendly Demonstration Garden I GARD ENLOCATION VICINITY MAP117 118 Page 1 of 1 CITY OF PALM DESERT STAFF REPORT MEETING DATE: May 9, 2024 PREPARED BY: Carlos Flores, AICP, Principal Planner REQUEST: RESOLUTION DENYING A STREET VACATION OF AN 8,582 SQUARE FOOT PORTION OF SHADOW LAKE DRIVE IN FAVOR OF A PROPERTY AT 73745 SHADOW LAKE DRIVE RECOMMENDATION: Adopt a Resolution entitled, “A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, DENYING A PROPOSED STREET VACATION OF AN 8,582 SQUARE FOOT PORTION OF SHADOW LAKE DRIVE IN FAVOR OF A PROPERTY AT 73745 SHADOW LAKE DRIVE IS CONSISTENT WITH THE CITY OF PALM DESERT GENERAL PLAN (APNS: 627-342-001).” BACKGROUND/ANALYSIS: Gordon German (Owner/Applicant) filed Street Vacation 23-0008 (Vacation) to vacate an 8,852 square foot (sf) portion of Shadow Lake Drive adjacent to an existing single family residential property at 73745 Shadow Lake Drive. Chapter 3, Part 3, Division 9 of the Streets and Highway Code allows for Street Vacation proceedings to be initiated by the City Council or to act on a petition or request of an interested person. On April 25, 2024, the City Council held a duly noticed public hearing to consider the Vacation request by the owner. Attachment 2 of this staff report provides detail on the request that was considered at the April 25th meeting. After consideration, the City Council voted 4-0 (Councilmember Harnik recused) to deny the request and instructed staff to bring back a resolution of denial to formally deny the proposed Vacation. A draft resolution for denial can be found attached to this report. Legal Review: This report has been reviewed by the City Attorney’s office. FINANCIAL IMPACT: None ATTACHMENTS: 1. Draft Resolution 2. April 25, 2024, City Council Staff Report 119 120 RESOLUTION NO. ____ A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, DENYING A PROPOSED STREET VACATION OF AN 8,582 SQUARE FOOT PORTION OF SHADOW LAKE DRIVE IN FAVOR OF A PROPERTY AT 73745 SHADOW LAKE DRIVE IS CONSISTENT WITH THE CITY OF PALM DESERT GENERAL PLAN (APNS: 627-342-001) CASE NOS. ST23-0008 WHEREAS, Gordon German, the owner of the property located at 73745 Shadow Lake Drive, did submit a request for a street vacation to vacate an 8,582 square foot portion of Shadow Lake Drive adjacent to 73745 Shadow Lake Drive; and WHEREAS, the Project site (73745 Shadow Lake Drive) has a land use designation of Conventional Suburban Neighborhood in the General Plan adopted on November 10, 2016; and WHEREAS, street vacation proceedings may be initiated by the City Council or may act on a petition or request of an interested person, pursuant to Chapter 3, Part 3, Division 9 of the Streets and Highways Code; and WHEREAS, California Government Code Section 65402 requires that prior to the streets being vacated by the City Council, the Planning Commission shall make a finding that the proposed street vacation is consistent with the City’s General Plan; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission of the City of Palm Desert, California, did on the 19th day of March 2024, consider the request for street vacation identified above and adopt Planning Commission Resolution 2860 finding the request to be consistent with the Palm Desert General Plan ; and WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Palm Desert, California, did on the 25th day of April 2024, consider the request for street vacation identified above at a duly noticed public hearing and voted to deny the project; and WHEREAS, all other legal prerequisites to the adoption of this Resolution have occurred; and NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Palm Desert, California, as follows: SECTION 1. Recitals. The City Council hereby finds that the foregoing recitals are true and correct and are incorporated herein as substantive findings of this Resolution. SECTION 2. Project Denial. The City Council was unable to make the necessary findings under Chapter 3, Part 3, Division 9 of the California Streets and Highways Code, and hereby denies the proposed street vacation of a 8,582 square foot portion of Shadow Lake Drive adjacent to 73745 Shadow Lake Drive (ST 23-0008). ADOPTED ON ________________, 20__. 121 CITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION 2 Karina Quintanilla MAYOR ATTEST: ANTHONY J. MEJIA CITY CLERK 122 CITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION 3 I, Anthony J. Mejia, City Clerk of the City of Palm Desert, hereby certify that Resolution No. 2022-__ is a full, true, and correct copy, and was duly adopted at a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Palm Desert on _______________________, by the following vote: AYES: NOES: ABSENT: ABSTAIN: RECUSED: IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and affixed the official seal of the City of Palm Desert, California, on ______________, 2024. ANTHONY J. MEJIA CITY CLERK 123 CITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION 4 124 Page 1 of 3 CITY OF PALM DESERT STAFF REPORT MEETING DATE: April 25, 2024 PREPARED BY: Carlos Flores, AICP, Principal Planner REQUEST: CONSIDER MAKING A FINDING OF EXEMPTION UNDER CEQA AND APPROVE A STREET VACATION OF AN 8,582 SQUARE FOOT PORTION OF SHADOW LAKE DRIVE IN FAVOR OF A PROPERTY AT 73745 SHADOW LAKE DRIVE RECOMMENDATION: Adopt a Resolution entitled, “A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, MAKING A FINDING OF EXEMPTION UNDER CEQA AND APPROVING A PROPOSED STREET VACATION OF AN 8,582 SQUARE FOOT PORTION OF SHADOW LAKE DRIVE IN FAVOR OF A PROPERTY AT 73745 SHADOW LAKE DRIVE IS CONSISTENT WITH THE CITY OF PALM DESERT GENERAL PLAN (APNS: 627 -342- 001).” BACKGROUND/ANALYSIS: Gordon German (Owner/Applicant) has filed Street Vacation 23 -0008 (Vacation) to vacate an 8,852 square foot (sf) portion of Shadow Lake Drive adjacent to an existing single family residential property at 73745 Shadow Lake Dri ve. Chapter 3, Part 3, Division 9 of the Streets and Highway Code allows for Street Vacation proceedings to be initiated by the City Council. Legal Review: This report has been reviewed by the City Attorney’s office. Planning Commission Recommendation: California Government Code Section 65402 requires that prior to streets being vacated by the City Council, the Planning Commission make a finding that the proposed vacation is consistent with the City’s General Plan. On March 19, 2024, the City of Palm Desert Planning Commission adopted Resolution No. 2860 finding this request to be consistent with the Palm Desert General Plan. Project Description: The proposed Vacation area off Shadow Lake Drive was dedicated for public use as part of Lot F in the Shadow Mountain Park Estates, Unit No. 1, as shown on a map recorded in Book 28 at Pages 18 and 19 of maps in the office of the County Recorder for Riverside County, California. The Vacation area has remained vacant and unimproved since recordation, with no phys ical improvements existing or planned. The area has an existing drainage easement reserved to the City of Palm Desert and a sanitation easement reserved to the Coachella Valley Water District. The Vacation proposes the 8,582 sf to be vacated in favor of 73745 Shadow Lake Drive, which has an existing single family residential home. If approved, the Owner would be able to construct Page 483 of 495125 City of Palm Desert ST23-0008 SHADOW LAKE DR VACATION________________________________________ Page 2 of 3 structures further west into the existing vacant and unimproved area. The Owner’s property line would be further west, allowing for structures to be constructed further west and still meet side yard setback requirements. The Owner is seeking this approval to build accessory structures and/or add to the primary dwelling in the future, in addition to improving the area, which would otherwise be left vacant and unimproved. The Vacation would reserve a 3,316 sf drainage easement to the City of Palm Desert and a 20’ wide CVWD Sanitation easement throughout the site. All new construction for 73745 Shadow Lake Drive would be subject to th e PDMC development standards. As shown below in Table 1, the existing property is designated as residential within the City’s General Plan and surrounded by residential designations. The vacation would allow for expansion of existing residential uses adjacent to other residential properties. Table 1 – General Plan Land Use Designation Property Site Existing Land use General Plan Land Use Designation 73745 Shadow Lake Drive Existing Residential Conventional Suburban Neighborhood North Existing Residential Small Town Neighborhood South Existing Residential Golf Course & Resort Neighborhood East Existing Residential Conventional Suburban Neighborhood West Existing Residential Golf Course & Resort Neighborhood The proposed Vacation is consistent with the City of Palm Desert General Plan goals and policies relating to land use and mobility. The General Plan Land Use Element promotes having complete neighborhoods, conventional neighborhood design, appropriate roadway scale, and encouragement of infill neighborhoods. The General Plan Mobility Element envisions an interconnected multi-modal transportation system that promotes livable streets and ongoing monitoring of the transportation facilities. The proposed Vacation area is not needed for street purposes, is unnecessary for present or prospective public use, and can be conveyed to the adjacent property owner without compromising the operational capacity of the roadway. Environment Review: City staff has reviewed the project in accordance with CEQA and recommends that the Project is exempt from environmental review pursuant to Class 1, Section 15301 – Existing Facilities. This Section pertains to existing highways and streets and this projec t can be found that the vacation of the subject right of way will not result in a direct or reasonably foreseeable indirect physical change in the environment. Therefore, no further environmental review is required under CEQA and a notice of exemption may be adopted. Public Review Pursuant to Sections 8322 and 8323 of the California Streets and Highways Code, due notice of the public hearing was given including: A public hearing notice for this item was published in the Desert Sun on April 12, 2024, distributed to property owners within 300 feet of the project site, and three (3) notices were posted along the line of the street to be vacated . No comments have been received from the public as of the date of publishing this report. Page 484 of 495126 City of Palm Desert ST23-0008 SHADOW LAKE DR VACATION________________________________________ Page 3 of 3 FINANCIAL IMPACT: None ATTACHMENTS: 1. Draft Resolution 2. Street Vacation Plans (Exhibit A and B of the resolution) 3. Public Hearing Notice Page 485 of 495127 Page 486 of 495128 RESOLUTION NO. ____ A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, MAKING A FINDING OF EXEMPTION UNDER CEQA AND APPROVING A PROPOSED STREET VACATION OF AN 8,582 SQUARE FOOT PORTION OF SHADOW LAKE DRIVE IN FAVOR OF A PROPERTY AT 73745 SHADOW LAKE DRIVE IS CONSISTENT WITH THE CITY OF PALM DESERT GENERAL PLAN (APNS: 627-342-001) CASE NOS. ST23-0008 WHEREAS, Gordon German, the owner of the property located at 73745 Shadow Lake Drive, did submit a request for a street vacation to vacate an 8,582 square foot portion of Shadow Lake Drive adjacent to 73745 Shadow Lake Drive; and WHEREAS, the Project site (73745 Shadow Lake Drive) has a land use designation of Conventional Suburban Neighborhood in the General Plan adopted on November 10, 2016; and WHEREAS, under Section 21067 of the Public Resources Code, Section 15367 of the State California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines (Cal. Code Regs., tit. 14, § 15000 et seq.) and the City of Palm Desert’s (“City’s”) Local CEQA Guidelines, the City is the lead agency for the Project; and WHEREAS, pursuant to the requirements of the CEQA, the State Guidelines for Implementation of CEQA (State CEQA Guidelines) and the City of Palm Desert CEQA Implementation Requirements, the City of Palm Desert Development Services Department has determined that the Project will not have a significant impact on the environment and that the Project is exempt under Section 15301(c) – Class 1, Existing Facilities; therefore, no further environmental review is necessary; and WHEREAS, street vacation proceedings may be initiated by the City Council or may act on a petition or request of an interested person, pursuant to Chapter 3, Part 3, Division 9 of the Streets and Highways Code; and WHEREAS, California Government Code Section 65402 requires that prior to the streets being vacated by the City Council, the Planning Commission shall make a finding that the proposed street vacation is consistent with the City’s General Plan; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission of the City of Palm Desert, California, did on the 19th day of March 2024, consider the request for street vacation identified above and adopt Planning Commission Resolution 2860 finding the request to be consistent with the Palm Desert General Plan ; and WHEREAS, pursuant to Sections 8322 and 8323 of the California Streets and Highways Code, due notice of the public hearing was given; WHEREAS, all other legal prerequisites to the adoption of this Resolution have occurred; and Page 487 of 495129 CITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION 2 NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Palm Desert, California, as follows: SECTION 1. Recitals. The City Council hereby finds that the foregoing recitals are true and correct and are incorporated herein as substantive findings of this Resolution. SECTION 2. Findings for Street Vacation. Under Chapter 3, Part 3, Division 9 of the California Streets and Highways Code, the City Council hereby finds: 1. The proposed street vacation conforms with the City of Palm Desert General Plan. The proposed street vacation is consistent with the City of Palm Desert General Plan, including goals and policies relating to land use and mobility. 2. The proposed street vacation will have no environmental effects that adversely impact the public safety or welfare. 3. The portion of right of way being vacated is unnecessary for present or prospective public use. SECTION 3. Project Approval. The City Council finds that the proposed street vacation of a 8,852 square foot portion of Shadow Lake Drive adjacent to 73745 Shadow Lake Drive legally described in Exhibit A and depicted in Exhibit B, attached hereto is consistent with the General Plan. ADOPTED ON ________________, 20__. Karina Quintanilla MAYOR ATTEST: ANTHONY J. MEJIA CITY CLERK Page 488 of 495130 CITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION 3 I, Anthony J. Mejia, City Clerk of the City of Palm Desert, hereby certify that Resolution No. 2022-__ is a full, true, and correct copy, and was duly adopted at a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Palm Desert on _______________________, by the following vote: AYES: NOES: ABSENT: ABSTAIN: RECUSED: IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and affixed the official seal of the City of Palm Desert, California, on ______________, 2024. ANTHONY J. MEJIA CITY CLERK Page 489 of 495131 CITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION 4 Page 490 of 495132 APPROVED TY 02/20/2024 Page 491 of 495133 APPROVED TY 02/20/2024 Page 492 of 495134 APPROVED TY 02/20/2024 Page 493 of 495135 Page 494 of 495136 C I T Y O F P A L M D E S E R T 73-510 FRED WARING DRIVE PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA 92260-2578 TEL: 760-346-0611 PLANNING@PALMDESERT.GOV CITY OF PALM DESERT PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE CASE NO. ST23-0008 NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN THAT A PUBLIC HEARING WILL BE HELD BEFORE THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, TO CONSIDER ADOPTING A NOTICE OF EXEMPTION PURSUANT TO THE CALIFORNIA ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY ACT (CEQA) AND APPROVE A STREET VACATION OF AN 8,582 SQUARE FOOT PORTION OF SHADOW LAKE DRIVE IN FAVOR OF A PROPERTY AT 73745 SHADOW LAKE DRIVE The City of Palm Desert (City), in its capacity as the Lead Agency for this project and pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), has determined the project to be exempt from further environmental review pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15301, Existing Facilities. PROJECT LOCATION: 73745 Shadow Lake Drive in the City of Palm Desert, located in Riverside County. Assessor’s Parcel Numbers 627-342-001 PROJECT DESCRIPTION: The consideration is a request to vacate an 8,582 square foot portion of public right of way in favor of 73745 Shadow Lake Drive, which has an existing single family residential home. PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION: On March 19, 2024, the City of Palm Desert Planning Commission adopted Resolution No. 2860 finding this request to be consistent with the Palm Desert General Plan. PUBLIC HEARING: NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the City Council of the City of Palm Desert, California, will hold a Public Hearing on Thursday, April 25, 2024. The City Council meeting begins at 4:00 p.m. in the Council Chamber at 73510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert, California. Pursuant to Assembly Bill 2449, this meeting may be conducted as a hybrid meeting, allowing public access via teleconference or in person. Options for remote participation will be listed on the Posted Agenda for the meeting at: https://www.palmdesert.gov/connect/city-council REVIEW OF PROJECT INFORMATION: Information concerning the proposed Street Vacation is available for review in the Office of the City Clerk at 73510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert, California during regular business hours and on the City’s website at City Council Meetings | City of Palm Desert COMMENT ON THIS APPLICATION: Response to this notice may be made as follows: Written comments may be submitted to the City Council by letter to the address below or email at CouncilMeetingComments@palmdesert.gov. Transmittal prior to the start of the meeting is required. Any correspondence received during or after the meeting will be distributed to the City Council as soon as practicable and retained for the official record. Any challenge of the proposed project in court may be limited to raising only those issues raised at the public hearing described in this notice, or in written correspondence delivered to the City Clerk at, or prior, to the public hearing. (Government Code Section 65009[b][2]). Si necesita ayuda con esta notificación, por favor llame a la Ciudad de Palm Desert y comuníquese con Gloria Sanchez (760) 346-0611 ext. 354 PUBLISH: THE DESERT SUN ANTHONY J. MEJIA, MMC, CITY CLERK APRIL 12, 2024 CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA Page 495 of 495137 138 Page 1 of 4 CITY OF PALM DESERT STAFF REPORT MEETING DATE: May 9, 2024 PREPARED BY: Anthony J. Mejia, City Clerk Katie Barrows, Protect California Deserts Coalition REQUEST: RESOLUTION OF SUPPORT FOR THE PROPOSED CHUCKWALLA NATIONAL MONUMENT, INCLUDING EXPANSION OF JOSHUA TREE NATIONAL PARK RECOMMENDATION: Adopt a Resolution entitled “A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, IN SUPPORT OF THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE PROPOSED CHUCKWALLA NATIONAL MONUMENT AND EXPANSION OF JOSHUA TREE NATIONAL PARK VIA AN ADJACENT NATIONAL MONUMENT.” BACKGROUND/ANALYSIS: All the lands included in this proposal are within the new 25 th Congressional District, which is represented by Raul Ruiz, M.D. On September 25, 2023, Congressman Ruiz held a press conference to announce his support for the proposed Chuckwalla National Monument and expansion of Joshua Tree National Park. The press conference was attended by a large coalition of local organizations, tribal leaders, youth, and state and local officials. On September 21, 2023, Congressman Ruiz introduced H.R. 5660, the Chuckwalla National Monument Establishment and Joshua Tree National Park Expansion Act of 2023, a bill to “provide for the protection of natural and cultural resources, Tribal collaborative management, sustainable economic development, enhanced recreation, and equitable access on Federal lands in eastern Imperial and Riverside counties, California, and fo r other purposes.” On April 16, 2024, U.S. Senators Alex Padilla and Laphonza Butler joined Congressman Ruiz to announce bicameral legislation (H.R. 8031, S. 4132) to create the Chuckwalla National Monument and expand Joshua Tree National Park. (House Bill, Senate Bill). They also urged President Biden to use his authority granted by the Antiquities Act to establish the Chuckwalla National Monument as well as expand Joshua Tree National Park by approximately 17,915 acres to be managed by the National Park Service. National Parks can only be technically expanded via legislation, but the Antiquities Act could be used to create a ‘de facto’ expansion. Congress could decide in the future to come back and make the formal addition. A coalition of local non-profits and other organizations (the Protect California Deserts Campaign) is working with Congressman Ruiz, and Senators Padilla and Butler to gain the support of the Biden Administration on a proposal to conserve federal public lands in Riverside and Impe rial Counties for present and future generations to enjoy. The proposal would designate a new Chuckwalla National Monument that would border the southern edge of Joshua Tree National Park and permanently protect recreational access to popular places like t he Mecca Hills and Orocopia Mountains. The proposed protections would honor and recognize the cultural histories of Indigenous peoples, enhance access to world -class nature for local residents and visitors, 139 City of Palm Desert Chuckwalla National Monument and Expansion of Joshua Tree National Park Page 2 of 4 protect fragile desert wildlife by providing connectivity between existing protected lands, and help boost local economies. National monuments can be established in two ways: through federal legislation or, more commonly, through presidential use of the Antiquities Act. Given current gridlock in Congres s, the coalition is pursuing the latter option and seeks to work closely with Congressman Ruiz and California senators to advocate with the Biden Administration. The City Council is requested to consider a resolution supporting the designation of the propo sed Chuckwalla National Monument and expansion of Joshua Tree National Park, and directing staff to forward the resolution to President Biden, Representative Ruiz, Representative Calvert, Senator Butler, and Senator Padilla. The proposal would protect special deserts, mountains, and woodlands spanning from the eastern Coachella Valley almost to the Colorado River (see attached map). The new monument would safeguard World War II historical sites, the Bradshaw Trail and other designated routes, cultural landscapes, and vital habitats for a diverse array of species, including chuckwalla, desert bighorn sheep, and desert tortoise. The proposal also includes an expansion to Joshua Tree National Park. To highlight key elements, the proposal would: Establish a Chuckwalla National Monument stretching from the Mecca Hills in the west to approximately 10 miles west of the Arizona border in Riverside and Imperial Counties; this would include protection for a wide array of cultural, historic and natural resources; Expand Joshua Tree National Park in the Eagle Mountain area; Require an inter-agency study of recreation needs on public lands in the region; especially under-resourced but popular day-use sites; Honor the homelands of the Cahuilla, Chemehuevi, Mojave, Quechan, and Serrano peoples. The proposed Chuckwalla National Monument and other protections would only apply to federal public lands. Such a designation would not affect existing lawful use of private property. Rights of way, utility corridors and infrastructure would not be impacted. The proposed Joshua Tree National Park expansion includes only those lands identified in a 2016 assessment by the National Park Service for inclusion in the Park. The expansion would cover only Bureau of Land Management (BLM) lands in the area, not privately owned lands. It also would not affect a proposed pump storage project and other existing or proposed activities on private lands. The proposed protection of public lands is compatible with and complementary to both the Coachella Valley Multiple Species Habitat Conservation Plan (CVMSHCP) and the Desert Renewable Energy Conservation Plan (DRECP). It’s important to note that the draft Chuckwalla National Monument boundary does not exactly match the CVMSHCP conservation area boundaries. While the goals of the proposed national monument and the CVMSHCP are compatible, some variation is expected. The previously designated national monuments in the region which overlap with the CVMSHCP, the Santa Rosa and San Jacinto Mountains National Monument and the Sand to Snow National Monument, provide opportunities for ongoing collaboration and cooperative management. Like other national monuments in the region, the national monument designation would ultimately involve 140 City of Palm Desert Chuckwalla National Monument and Expansion of Joshua Tree National Park Page 3 of 4 development of a management plan for the public lands with significant collaboration with local, state, and federal partners and input from the public. The proposal was also crafted to be complementary to the goals of the DRECP. All areas prioritized for renewable energy development were purposefully excluded from the proposed national monument boundaries. The proposal reflects input from various partners including the renewable energy industry, utilities, water districts, and others to ensure that the proposed monument does not conflict with infrastructure and renewal energy development. Adjustments to the proposed national monument boundaries have been made to address these concerns. National Monuments generally permit existing recreational uses to continue and in fact provide a better experience for users with increased signage for improved access and interpretation. OHV use is permissible within national monuments on legal routes and within designated areas. The draft proposal will benefit Riverside and Imperial Counties in several ways, including: Protecting crucial plant and wildlife habitat and migration corridors. Safeguarding indigenous sites, landscapes of importance, and other significant cultural resources. Protecting important historic sites and landscapes. Enhancing equitable and sustainable recreation access to federal public lands. Boosting local economies by attracting visitors (see attachment on economic benefits) Promoting tourism and recreation which are an essential part of the desert region’s economy. The National Monument designation would preserve and enhance the extensive recreational and environmental education opportunities in this spectacular landscape. Monument designation would attract outdoor recreation enthusiasts, translating into dollars for the local economies of the Coachella Valley, Palo Verde Valley, and surrounding communities. The coalition of organizations supporting the Protect California Deserts proposal continues to reach out to local elected officials, tribes, community leaders, recreation groups, the agricultural community, and stakeholders to solicit their input and support. Local supporters include Alianza Coachella Valley, CactusToCloud Institute, California Audubon, Council of Mexican Federations in North America (COFEM), Desert Trails Coalition, Friends of the Desert Mountains, Imperial Irrigation District, Mojave Desert Land Trust, National Parks Conservatio n Association, Native American Land Conservancy, Sierra Club, Wildlands Conservancy, and Visit Greater Palm Springs JPA, among numerous others. Cities and agencies in the region are being asked to consider a resolution or letter of support. Cathedral City, Desert Hot Springs, Banning, Indian Wells, Indio, and Palm Springs have recently adopted resolutions or letters of support. Other supporters and more information are available at https://protectchuckwalla.org/. Legal Review: This report has been reviewed by the City Attorney’s office. FINANCIAL IMPACT: There is no financial impact associated with adoption of the proposed resolution. 141 City of Palm Desert Chuckwalla National Monument and Expansion of Joshua Tree National Park Page 4 of 4 ATTACHMENTS: 1. Draft Resolution 2. Map of Proposed Chuckwalla National Monument and Joshua Tree National Park Expansion 3. Chuckwalla National Monument – Proposal Summary 4. Economic Benefits of Conservation Lands 5. Padilla, Butler, Ruiz introduce legislation and call on Biden to establish Chuckwalla National Monument - Press Release (4/16/24) 6. Letter to President Biden and Secretary Haaland to use AA to designate Chuckwalla National Monument (4/16/24) - signed by Padilla, Butler, Ruiz + 23 Members of Congress 142 RESOLUTION NO. 2024-____ A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, IN SUPPORT OF THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE PROPOSED CHUCKWALLA NATIONAL MONUMENT AND EXPANSION OF JOSHUA TREE NATIONAL PARK VIA AN ADJACENT NATIONAL MONUMENT WHEREAS, the proposed Chuckwalla National Monument and expansion of Joshua Tree National Park contain spectacular public lands that are a scenic, environmental, economic, cultural, and recreational resource both locally as well as across our state; and WHEREAS, the proposed Chuckwalla National Monument and expansion of Joshua Tree National Park support year-round habitats for diverse wildlife such as desert bighorn sheep, desert tortoise, a wide variety of birds, and many other species; and WHEREAS, publicly owned and federally managed desert lands constitute a public wildland resource of extraordinary and inestimable value and deserve to be protected for present and future generations; and WHEREAS, securing permanent protection for the proposed Chuckwalla National Monument and expansion of Joshua Tree National Park will secure the quality of life and recreational opportunities directly related to our public lands for generations to come; and WHEREAS, multiple studies have shown that National Monuments create jobs and support positive economics for communities nearby; and WHEREAS, these areas contain significant cultural, archeological, historic, and scientific values worthy of permanent protection; and WHEREAS, it remains in the City’s interest to maintain and protect the California desert as a recreational resource and a place for citizens of and visitors to Palm Desert to recreate, spend time with family, or simply gaze into the night sky. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Palm Desert, California, as follows: SECTION 1. That the City Council of the City of Palm Desert hereby affirms its support for the establishment via legislation or executive action of the proposed Chuckwalla National Monument and expansion of Joshua Tree National Park. SECTION 2. That the City Council asks President Biden to designate the proposed Chuckwalla National Monument and expansion of Joshua Tree National Park promptly through Presidential proclamation via the Antiquities Act. 143 Resolution No. 2024-____ Page 2 SECTION 3. That the City Council hereby directs the City Clerk to send a copy of this resolution to United States President Joe Biden, Representative Dr. Raul Ruiz, Representative Ken Calvert, Senator Laphonza Butler, and Senator Alex Padilla . ADOPTED ON ________________, 2024. KARINA QUINTANILLA MAYOR ATTEST: ANTHONY J. MEJIA CITY CLERK I, Anthony J. Mejia, City Clerk of the City of Palm Desert, hereby certify that Resolution No. 2024-__ is a full, true, and correct copy, and was duly adopted at a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Palm Desert on _______________________, by the following vote: AYES: NOES: ABSENT: ABSTAIN: RECUSED: IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and affixed the official seal of the City of Palm Desert, California, on ___________________. ANTHONY J. MEJIA CITY CLERK 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 Padilla, Butler, Ruiz Introduce Legislation and Call on President Biden ... https://www.padilla.senate.gov/newsroom/press-releases/padilla-butler-r... 1 of 6 4/30/2024, 11:30 AM 151 Padilla, Butler, Ruiz Introduce Legislation and Call on President Biden ... https://www.padilla.senate.gov/newsroom/press-releases/padilla-butler-r... 2 of 6 4/30/2024, 11:30 AM 152 Padilla, Butler, Ruiz Introduce Legislation and Call on President Biden ... https://www.padilla.senate.gov/newsroom/press-releases/padilla-butler-r... 3 of 6 4/30/2024, 11:30 AM 153 Padilla, Butler, Ruiz Introduce Legislation and Call on President Biden ... https://www.padilla.senate.gov/newsroom/press-releases/padilla-butler-r... 4 of 6 4/30/2024, 11:30 AM 154 Padilla, Butler, Ruiz Introduce Legislation and Call on President Biden ... https://www.padilla.senate.gov/newsroom/press-releases/padilla-butler-r... 5 of 6 4/30/2024, 11:30 AM 155 This site is registered on wpml.org (https://wpml.org ) as a development site. Padilla, Butler, Ruiz Introduce Legislation and Call on President Biden ... https://www.padilla.senate.gov/newsroom/press-releases/padilla-butler-r... 6 of 6 4/30/2024, 11:30 AM 156 April 16, 2024 The Honorable Joseph R. Biden Jr. President The White House 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington, DC 20500 The Honorable Debra A. Haaland Secretary U.S. Department of the Interior 1849 C Street NW Washington, DC 20240 Dear President Biden and Secretary Haaland: We write to request that you issue a proclamation under the Antiquities Act of 1906 to designate the Chuckwalla National Monument in eastern Imperial and Riverside counties in California. We have introduced the “Chuckwalla National Monument Establishment and Joshua Tree National Park Expansion Act of 2024” to conserve iconic and sensitive California landscapes, foster Tribal collaborative management of sacred public lands, and increase recreation and equitable access to the outdoors. Our bill would establish a new Chuckwalla National Monument to protect approximately 627,855 acres of public lands while also expanding Joshua Tree National Park by adding approximately 17,915 acres of previously designated public lands. We request that you use your authority under the Antiquities Act to protect these iconic landscapes included in the map titled “Proposed Chuckwalla National Monument and Joshua Tree National Park Expansion” and dated April 12, 2024. We also request that you visit the proposed designations and would be happy to host you for the visit this spring. Our efforts enjoy broad support from federal, tribal, state, and local officials, and was crafted in close coordination with affected communities and key stakeholders after years of grassroots advocacy to bring greater protections and recreation opportunities in the California Desert. Our legislation also carefully balances the land use needs of the energy industry so that as we protect our most sensitive landscapes, we also ensure that California and the nation are able to meet our clean energy goals. Our bill has earned support from numerous elected officials, businesses, conservation and outdoor recreation organizations, and key partners in the energy industry. We are proud of the support we have built to date and are confident that any Antiquities Act designation would enjoy equally broad support. The proposed Chuckwalla National Monument’s vast desert landscape spanning the area along Joshua Tree National Park’s southern boundary, along Interstate 10 from the eastern Coachella Valley, and all the way to the Colorado River are worthy of permanent protection. This area has a unique, biodiverse ecosystem, is home to habitats for species like the Chuckwalla lizard and the endangered desert tortoise, and contains critical migration corridors for desert bighorn sheep. This area is also cherished for 157 outdoor recreation activities like hiking and rock climbing. Preserving this vast desert landscape will help ensure more equitable access to nature and recreation, protect biodiversity, and preserve decades of cultural riches, particularly for the local tribal communities. The lands we are proposing for protection include the homelands of the Iviatim, Nüwü, Pipa Aha Macav, Kwatsáan, and Maara’yam peoples (Cahuilla, Chemehuevi, Mojave, Quechan, and Serrano nations). Designating the Chuckwalla National Monument would help to protect important spiritual and cultural values tied to the land such as multi-use trail systems established by Indigenous peoples, sacred sites and objects, traditional cultural places, geoglyphs, petroglyphs, pictographs, and native plants and wildlife. Our legislation would also further our shared goals to honor Tribal sovereignty and advance cooperative management of federal public lands by allowing Tribes to voluntarily engage in cooperative management of the public lands within the National Monument. We hope that any presidential proclamation under the Antiquities Act would include similar direction for the Bureau of Land Management to provide ample opportunity for federally recognized tribes to co-steward the Monument. Finally, our legislation directs Interior to conduct an ethnographic study and cultural resources survey for the land within and adjacent to the proposed Monument to assess the importance of these lands to affected Indian Tribes. Establishing the Chuckwalla National Monument would contribute to the Administration’s goal under Executive Order 14008 of permanently conserving 30 percent of the United States lands and coastal waters by 2030, as well as the Administration’s America the Beautiful initiative, which is intended to address the three interlocking crises of nature loss, climate change, and inequitable access to the outdoors. Thank you for your leadership and consideration of our request. We look forward to working with you to permanently conserve this unique desert landscape in California for future generations to enjoy, and we would be pleased to host you for an in-person visit in the near future. Sincerely, Alex Padilla United States Senator Laphonza Butler United States Senator Raul Ruiz, M.D. Member of Congress Page 2 158 Adam B. Schiff Member of Congress Julia Brownley Member of Congress J. Luis Correa Member of Congress Juan Vargas Member of Congress Barbara Lee Member of Congress Mark Takano Member of Congress Katie Porter Member of Congress Ted W. Lieu Member of Congress Mike Thompson Member of Congress Nanette Diaz Barragán Member of Congress Salud Carbajal Member of Congress Jim Costa Member of Congress Robert Garcia Member of Congress Jimmy Panetta Member of Congress Jared Huffman Member of Congress Page 3 159 Tony Cárdenas Member of Congress Jimmy Gomez Member of Congress Kevin Mullin Member of Congress Doris Matsui Member of Congress Brad Sherman Member of Congress Eric Swalwell Member of Congress Ro Khanna Member of Congress Mike Levin Member of Congress Page 4 160 Page 1 of 2 CITY OF PALM DESERT STAFF REPORT MEETING DATE: May 9, 2024 PREPARED BY: Chris Gerry, Project Manager REQUEST: APPROVE THE START OF PROCEEDINGS TO LEVY AND COLLECT ANNUAL ASSESSMENTS AND GRANT PRELIMINARY APPROVAL OF THE 2024-25 ENGINEER’S REPORT FOR CONSOLIDATED PALM DESERT LANDSCAPING AND LIGHTING MAINTENANCE DISTRICT NO.1 RECOMMENDATION: 1. Adopt a Resolution entitled “A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, DECLARING ITS INTENTION TO INITIATE PROCEEDINGS FOR THE LEVY AND COLLECTION OF ANNUAL ASSESSMENTS FOR CONSOLIDATED PALM DESERT LANDSCAPING AND LIGHTING MAINTENANCE DISTRICT NO. 1 FOR FISCAL YEAR 2024-25. 2. Adopt a Resolution entitled “A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, DECLARING ITS INTENTION TO LEVY AND COLLECT THE ANNUAL ASSESSMENTS FOR CONSOLIDATED PALM DESERT LANDSCAPING AND LIGHTING MAINTENANCE DISTRICT NO. 1 FOR FISCAL YEAR 2024-25 AND PRELIMINARY APPROVAL OF THE ENGINEER’S REPORT.” 3. Set a public hearing to be held at the City Council meeting of June 27, 2024, at 4 p.m. BACKGROUND/ANALYSIS: The City of Palm Desert (City) administers 35 landscapi ng and lighting maintenance districts (LLDs) that comprise of Consolidated Palm Desert Landscaping and Lighting Maintenance District No. 1. These LLDs pay for the maintenance of perimeter landscaping and streetlight benefits for residential subdivisions. The City created these LLDs pursuant to the provisions of the Landscaping & Lighting Act of 1972, Part 2 of Division 15 of the California Streets and Highways Code. District boundaries can be found in the Vicinity Map (Attachment 4). LLDs are intended to recover all costs that the City incurs in their administration and maintenance. In some cases, however, there is a “finding of general benefit”. A general benefit would be any improvement that benefits either properties outside LLD No. 1 or the public at large. Examples of general benefits include the landscaped median on Haystack Road (Zone #2, Canyon Cove) and perimeter streetlights that directly illuminates parcels outside the Sonata development (Zone #6, Sonata 1). The City General Fund will pay approximately $157,878.41 in general benefits that are listed preliminarily in the 2024-25 Engineer’s Report (Report). Approximately 83% of this balance will be allocated to maintaining the Canyon Cove District (Haystack Greenbelt). The remainder will be allocated to LLDs with a benefit, such as street landscaping or lighting that fronts a major arterial street and that benefits the community at large. 161 City of Palm Desert Approve Resolutions for Consolidated LLD No. 1 Page 2 of 2 Legal Review: This report has been reviewed by the City Attorney’s office. FINANCIAL IMPACT: The assessment and collection of the levy amount will finance both ongoing maintenance of LLDs and associated administrative costs. The general benefit costs have been included in the Proposed FY 2024-25 Budget. ATTACHMENTS: 1. Resolution (Initiate Proceedings) 2. Resolution (Intent to Levy) 3. 2024-25 Engineer’s Report 4. Vicinity Map 162 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, DECLARING ITS INTENTION TO INITIATE PROCEEDINGS FOR THE LEVY AND COLLECTION OF ANNUAL ASSESSMENTS FOR CONSOLIDATED PALM DESERT LANDSCAPING AND LIGHTING MAINTENANCE DISTRICT NO. 1 FOR FISCAL YEAR 2024-25 The City Council of the City of Palm Desert (hereafter referred to as the “City Council”) does resolve as follows: WHEREAS, the City Council, through previous resolutions, has formed and levied annual assessments for the Consolidated Palm Desert Landscaping and Lighting Maintenance District No. 1 (hereafter referred to as the “District”), pursuant to the provisions of the Landscaping and Lighting Act of 1972, part 2, division 15 of the Streets and Highways Code of the State of California, commencing with section 22500 (hereafter referred to as the “Act”), that provide for the collection of assessments by the County of Riverside on behalf of the City of Palm Desert to pay for the maintenance and services of improvements related thereto; and, WHEREAS, the City Council desires to initiate proceedings for the levy and collection of annual assessments for fiscal year 2024-25 for the landscape and lighting improvements and services that provide benefit to the properties within the District, pursuant to the provisions of the Act; and, WHEREAS, the City has retained Willdan Financial Services for the purpose of assisting with the annual levy of the District, including the preparation and filing of an Engineer’s Annual Levy Report (hereafter referred to as the “Report”) with the city clerk, in accordance with the Act. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, DETERMINED, AND ORDERED BY THE CITY COUNCIL, THE LEGISLATIVE BODY FOR THE DISTRICT, AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. The above recitals are true and correct. Section 2. Order. The City Council hereby orders Willdan Financial Services to prepare and file with the city clerk the Report on the levy of assessments for the District for the fiscal year commencing July 1, 2024, and ending June 30, 2025, in accordance with chapter 3, section 22622 of the Act. Section 3. Improvements and Services. The improvements within the District include, but are not limited to, turf, groundcover, shrubs and trees, irrigation systems, street lighting, water features, entry monuments, drainage systems and all appurtenant facilities and operations related thereto. The Report will provide a more detailed description of the improvements and services that the District provides and shall describe any new improvements or substantial changes of the improvements for which properties are assessed. 163 RESOLUTION NO. 2024-____ 2 Section 4. Necessity for Levy and Collection of Assessments. The City Council hereby determines that to provide the improvements generally described in section 3 of this resolution and shown, in detail, in the Report, it is necessary to levy and collect assessments within the District for fiscal year 2024-25 and that these assessments will be outlined and described in the Report and imposed, pursuant to the provisions of the Act and the requirements of California Constitution article XIII D. PASSED, APPROVED, AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the Palm Desert City Council, held on this 9th day of May, 2024, by the following vote, to wit: AYES: NOES: ABSENT: ABSTAINED: KARINA QUINTANILLA, MAYOR CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA ATTEST: ANTHONY J. MEJIA, CITY CLERK CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA 164 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, DECLARING ITS INTENTION TO LEVY AND COLLECT THE ANNUAL ASSESSMENTS FOR CONSOLIDATED PALM DESERT LANDSCAPING AND LIGHTING MAINTENANCE DISTRICT NO. 1 FOR FISCAL YEAR 2024 -25 AND PRELIMINARY APPROVAL OF THE ENGINEER’S REPORT The City Council of the City of Palm Desert (hereafter referred to as the “City Council”) does resolve as follows: WHEREAS, the City Council, pursuant to provisions of the Landscaping and Lighting Act of 1972, part 2, division 15 of the Streets and Highways Code of the State of California, commencing with section 22500 (hereafter referred to as the “Act”), did, by previous resolution, order the preparation of the Engineer’s Annual Levy Report (hereafter referred to as the “Report”) for the district known and designated as Consolidated Palm Desert Landscaping and Lighting Maintenance District No. 1. (hereafter referred to as the “District”); and, WHEREAS, the City Council proposes to levy and collect assessments against lots and parcels of land within the various zones of the District for fiscal year 2024 -25, to pay the maintenance, servicing, and operation of the improvements related thereto, pursuant to the provisions of the Act; and, WHEREAS, Willdan Financial Services has prepared and filed the Report with the city clerk, pursuant to section 22623 of the Act, and the Report has been presented to City Council and is hereby incorporated by reference; and WHEREAS, the City Council has examined and reviewed the Report, as presented, and is preliminarily satisfied with the description of the District, zones, and improvements identified therein; each of the budget items and documents as set forth therein; and is satisfied that the proposed assessments contained therein have been spread in accordance with the special benefits received from the improvements, operation, maintenance, and services to be performed within the District, as set forth in the Report or as modified by City Council action and incorporated herein. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, DETERMINED, AND ORDERED BY THE CITY COUNCIL FOR THE DISTRICT, THE LEGISLATIVE BODY FOR THE DISTRICT, AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. The above recitals are true and correct. Section 2. Intention: The City Council hereby declares its intention to order the annual levy and collection of assessments within the District, over and including the land within the District boundary and to levy and collect assessments on such land to pay for the annual costs and expenses of the improvements and services described in section 5 of this resolution for fiscal year 2024-25, pursuant to the provisions of the Act. 165 RESOLUTION NO. 2023-____ 2 Section 3. Approval: The Report has been prepared and filed with the city clerk. The city clerk has presented to the City Council the Report on the proposed improvements, assessments, and levy and collection of assessments for fiscal year 2024-25, in accordance with chapter 1, article 4 of the Act, and is hereby approved, as required by section 22623 of the Act, on a preliminary basis. Section 4. Boundaries and Designation: The description of the District boundary and the zones therein are outlined in the Report and by reference is made part of this resolution. The District includes thirty-three (33) benefit zones and sub-zones: Canyon Cove (Zone 2); Vineyards (Zone 3); Parkview Estates (Zone 4); Cook and Country Club (Zone 5): sub-zones are Desert Mirage, Sandcastles, and Primrose 2; Hovley Lane (Zone 6): sub -zones are Monterey Meadows, Hovley Glen, Hovley Estates, Sonata I, Sonata II, Hovley Collection, La Paloma I, La Paloma II, La Paloma III, Sandpiper Court, Sandpiper West, Hovley Court West, Diamondback and Palm Court; Waring Court (Zone 7); Palm Gate (Zone 8); The Grove (Zone 9); Portola Place (Zone 11); Palm Desert Country Club (Zone 13); K&B at Palm Desert (Zone 14); Canyon Crest (Zone 15); and, Shepard Lane (Zone 16): sub-zones are College View Estates I, College View Estates II, Sundance East, Sundance West, Petunia I, and The Boulders. This District is designated as “Consolidated Palm Desert Landscaping and Lighting Maintenance District No. 1”. Section 5. Description of Improvements: Reference is hereby made to the Report for a detailed description of the improvements. The improvements within the District include, but are not limited to, turf, groundcover, shrubs and trees, irrigation systems, street lighting, water features, entry monuments, drainage systems, and all appurtenant facilities and operations related thereto. Section 6. Proposed Assessment Amounts: The proposed assessments are outlined in the Report. District Assessments are calculated in accordance with the method of apportionment established for the District and do not exceed the assessment rates and annual inflationary adjustment previously authorized by City Council and approved by the property owners, in accordance with the provisions of California State Constitution article XIII D. Section 7. Notice of Public Hearing: The City Council hereby declares its intention to conduct a public hearing concerning the District improvements and the levy of assessments, in accordance with chapter 3 of the Act. Notice is hereby given that a public hearing on these matters will be held by the City Council on Thursday, June 27, 2024 at 4:00 p.m., or as soon thereafter as feasible, at City Hall (in the City Council Chambers), which is located at 166 RESOLUTION NO. 2023-____ 3 73-510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert, California. At the public hearing, all interested persons shall be afforded the opportunity to hear and to be heard. Section 8. Publication and Posting of Notice: The City shall give notice of the time and place of the public hearing to all property owners within the District by causing the publishing of this resolution once in the local newspaper not less than ten (10) days before the date of the public hearing, and by a posting a copy of this resolution on the official bulletin board customarily used by the City Council for the posting of notices pursuant to the Act. For fiscal year 2024-25, no new or increased assessments are proposed and a mailing of a notice and ballot to property owners is not required. Section 9. Direction to City Clerk. The city clerk is hereby authorized and directed to give notice of this public hearing, as provided by law. PASSED, APPROVED, AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the Palm Desert City Council, on the 9th day of May, 2024, by the following vote, to wit: AYES: NOES: ABSENT: ABSTAINED: KARINA QUINTANILLA, MAYOR CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA ATTEST: ANTHONY J. MEJIA, CITY CLERK CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA 167 168 City of Palm Desert Consolidated Palm Desert Landscaping and Lighting District No. 1 2024/2025 ENGINEER’S ANNUAL LEVY REPORT Intent Meeting: May 9, 2024 Public Hearing: June 27, 2024 27368 Via Industria Suite 200 Temecula, CA 92590 T 951.587.3500 | 800.755.6864 F 951.587.3510 www.willdan.com 169 ENGINEER'S REPORT AFFIDAVIT Establishment of Annual Assessments for the: Consolidated Palm Desert Landscaping and Lighting District City of Palm Desert, County of Riverside, State of California This Report identifies the parcels within the District and the relevant zones therein, as they existed at the time of passage of the Resolution of Intention. Reference is hereby made to the Riverside County Assessor’s maps for a detailed description of the lines and dimensions of parcels within the District. The Undersigned respectfully submits the enclosed Report as directed by the City Council. Dated this ____________ day of ______________, 2024. Willdan Financial Services Assessment Engineer On Behalf of the City of Palm Desert By: ________________________________ Daniel Louie, Project Manager District Administrative Services By: ________________________________ Tyrone Peter P.E. # C 81888 170 TABLE OF CONTENTS I. OVERVIEW ...................................................................................... 1 A. Introduction .............................................................................. 1 B. Compliance with the Current Legislation ............................... 2 C. General Description of the District and Services................... 2 D. Improvements Authorized by the 1972 Act ............................ 3 II. SPECIFIC IMPROVEMENTS AND SPECIAL BENEFIT ZONES ..... 4 III. METHOD OF APPORTIONMENT .................................................. 16 A. General ................................................................................... 16 B. Benefit Analysis ..................................................................... 17 C. Assessment Methodology ..................................................... 19 D. Assessment Range Formula ................................................. 21 IV. DISTRICT BUDGETS ..................................................................... 22 A. Description of Budget Items .................................................. 22 B. District Budgets ..................................................................... 25 APPENDIX A — DISTRICT BOUNDARY MAPS ................................. 31 APPENDIX B — 2024/2025 ASSESSMENT ROLL ............................. 32 171 2024/2025 Consolidated Palm Desert Landscape and Lighting District No.1 Page 1 I. Overview A. Introduction The City of Palm Desert (hereafter referred to as “City”) annually levies and collects special assessments in order to provide and maintain improvements within the Consolidated Palm Desert Landscaping and Lighting Maintenance Assessment District No.1 (hereafter referred to as the “District”). The District was formed in 1993, through the consolidation of several individual landscaping and lighting maintenance districts that previously existed within the City. The original districts and subsequent annexations of various territories and developments to the Consolidated District are identified as separate Zones and/or Sub-zones (hereafter referred to jointly as “Zones”). The District and the Zones therein have been established and are levied annual assessments pursuant to the Landscaping and Lighting Act of 1972, Part 2 of Division 15 of the California Streets and Highways Code (hereafter referred to as the “1972 Act”). This Engineer’s Annual Levy Report (hereafter referred to as the “Report”) describes the District and improvements, any proposed changes to the District or improvements and the proposed budgets and assessments for Fiscal Year 2024/2025. The proposed assessments are based on the City’s estimated cost to maintain the improvements that provide special benefit to properties within the District. The various improvements within the District and the costs of those improvements are identified and budgeted separately for each Zone, including the expenditures, deficits, surpluses, revenues, and reserves. The word “parcel,” for the purposes of this Report, refers to an individual property assigned its own Assessment Number by the Riverside County Assessor’s Office. The Riverside County Auditor/Controller uses Assessment Numbers and specific Fund Numbers, to identify on the tax roll, properties assessed for special district benefit assessments. Each parcel within a Zone is assessed proportionately for only those improvements provided in that Zone from which the parcel receives special benefit. At a noticed Public Hearing, the City Council will consider all testimony and written comments presented and may direct any necessary modifications to the Report and approve the Report as submitted or amended. Following approval of the Report, the City Council by resolution, shall order the improvements to be made, and confirm the levy and collection of assessments pursuant to the 1972 Act. The assessment rates and method of apportionment described in this Report as approved by the City Council defines the assessments to be applied to each parcel within the District for Fiscal Year 2024/2025. The assessments as approved will be submitted to the Riverside County Auditor/Controller to be included on the property tax roll for each parcel for the fiscal year. 172 2024/2025 Consolidated Palm Desert Landscape and Lighting District No.1 Page 2 B. Compliance with the Current Legislation The City Council annually conducts a public hearing to accept public comments and testimony, to review the Report and adopt the annual assessments to be levied on the County tax roll for the fiscal year. The assessments described in this Report and subsequently approved by the City Council have been prepared in accordance with the 1972 Act and in compliance with the provisions of the California Constitution, Article XIIID (hereafter referred to as the “Article XIIID”), which was enacted by the passage of Proposition 218 in November 1996. In compliance with the provisions of Article XIIID, in Fiscal Year 1997/1998, the City conducted property owner ballot proceedings for the special benefit assessments applicable to each of the existing Zones within the District. At that time, the assessments presented to property owners included the assessment range formula previously established for the District and described in this Report. Upon tabulation of the ballots returned, it was determined that majority protest did not exist, and the City Council approved and adopted the assessments and assessment range formula balloted and approved by the property owners. Similar proceedings have been conducted for all new or increased assessments including any annexations to the District. C. General Description of the District and Services The City annually levies and collects assessments in order to maintain and service various improvements within the District. For Fiscal Year 2024/2025, the District is comprised of thirty-three (33) separate benefit Zones, each funding specific improvements and services. The District provides for the maintenance and operation of local landscaping and lighting improvements and associated appurtenances located within the public right-of-ways and dedicated landscape easements. The improvements and the annual costs of those improvements are identified and budgeted separately for each Zone, including the expenditures, deficits, surpluses, revenues, and reserves. The improvements provided and for which parcels are levied special benefit assessments within the District can be categorized as three (3) improvement types. 1. Local street lighting (residential street lighting associated with the properties within the Zone and specific subdivisions). 2. Local landscaping improvements including parkways, perimeters, entryways, local medians, and internal landscaped amenities. 173 2024/2025 Consolidated Palm Desert Landscape and Lighting District No.1 Page 3 3. Special Zone services including tree trimming, graffiti and weed abatement and landscape maintenance of flood control areas (retention and detention basins). The costs associated with the improvements authorized by the provisions of the 1972 Act are equitably spread among the benefiting parcels in proportion to the special benefit they receive. Only parcels that receive special benefits from the improvements are assessed, and each Zone consists of parcels that benefit from those specific improvements. Landscape improvements maintained by the District and associated with each Zone were either installed as a condition of development or were installed for the benefit of the properties assessed. The landscape improvements associated with each Zone may include, but are not limited to: open space areas; medians; parkways; slopes; retention or detention basin areas; and public right-of-ways or easements that provide special benefits to the parcels. These improvements may include, but are not limited to: turf, ground cover, shrubs and trees, irrigation systems, decorative lighting, water features, entry monuments, drainage systems, hardscapes and associated appurtenances. Similar to landscape improvements, street lighting improvements funded through District assessments were installed for the benefit of properties within each of the Zones and the assessments provide for the maintenance, operation and energy costs related to those street light improvements. D. Improvements Authorized by the 1972 Act As applicable or may be applicable to this proposed District, the 1972 Act defines improvements to mean one or any combination of the following: The installation or planting of landscaping. The installation or construction of statuary, fountains, and other ornamental structures and facilities. The installation or construction of public lighting facilities. The installation or construction of any facilities which are appurtenant to any of the foregoing, or which are necessary or convenient for the maintenance or servicing thereof, including, but not limited to, grading, clearing, removal of debris, the installation or construction of curbs, gutters, walls, sidewalks, or paving, or water, irrigation, drainage, or electrical facilities. The maintenance or servicing, or both, of any of the foregoing. The acquisition of any existing improvement otherwise authorized pursuant to this section. Incidental expenses associated with the improvements include, but are not limited to: The cost of preparation of the report, including plans, specifications, estimates, diagrams, and assessments; 174 2024/2025 Consolidated Palm Desert Landscape and Lighting District No.1 Page 4 The costs of printing and advertising, as well as the publishing, posting and mailing of notices; Compensation payable to the County for collection of assessments; Compensation of any engineer or attorney employed to render services; Any other expenses incidental to the construction, installation, or maintenance and servicing of the improvements; Any expenses incidental to the issuance of bonds or notes pursuant to Section 22662.5. Costs associated with any elections held for the approval of a new or increased assessment. The 1972 Act defines "maintain" or "maintenance" to mean furnishing of services and materials for the ordinary and usual maintenance, operation, and servicing of any improvement, including: Repair, removal, or replacement of all or any part of any improvement. Providing for the life, growth, health, and beauty of landscaping, including cultivation, irrigation, trimming, spraying, fertilizing, or treating for disease or injury. The removal of trimmings, rubbish, debris, and other solid waste. The cleaning, sandblasting, and painting of walls and other improvements to remove or cover graffiti. II. Specific Improvements and Special Benefit Zones The boundaries of each Zone, the location of improvements and special benefit received by the properties and property owners within each Zone are described in this section of the Report. In any given fiscal year, City staff will determine the scope of work for each Zone as assessment revenues allow. Any necessary reductions in the scope of work will likely include but are not limited to; the frequency of mowing and edging turf areas; the application of fertilizers and aeration of turf; trimming and pruning of shrubs, trees and ground cover; trash pick- up in landscaping areas; and weed and litter control. The allocation of special benefit and general benefit of the improvements provided within the District are summarized in the Method of Apportionment section of this Report and are identified in the budget for each Zone. A description of the District improvements and the level of annual service each Zone will receive are provided in the following: Zone #2 (Canyon Cove): Zone #2 includes Tracts 11636-1, 2, 3, & 4 and Tract 23485, generally located South of Deep Canyon Tennis Club, North of Haystack Road, West of Marrakesh Country Club, and East of Highway 74. The streets within the Zone include Ambrosia Street, Sweetbrush Lane, Deer Grass Drive, Lotus Court, Calliandra Street, Aber Street and Alamo Drive. 175 2024/2025 Consolidated Palm Desert Landscape and Lighting District No.1 Page 5 These parcels benefit from the maintenance and operation of street lighting encompassing the streets within the Zone, the landscaped parkway along the East side of Highway 74 and the landscaped areas on the North side of Haystack Road, adjacent to the above-mentioned tracts and installed as part of these residential developments. The interior local street lighting has been identified and allocated as 100% special benefit with no general benefit allocation. The parkway landscaping along Highway 74 has been identified as 100% special benefit to the parcels within the Zone. However, it has been determined that the landscaped median on Haystack Road (although installed as part of the development) not only provides a special benefit to properties within Canyon Cove, but also provides a general benefit. The proportionate general benefit of this improvement has been identified and eliminated from the Zone assessments. Although there is a general benefit component, the majority (83%) of the median landscaping on Haystack Road is a flood control channel and was required for development of the homes within Canyon Cove. Therefore, pursuant to Article XIIID Section 5a (assessments used to fund flood control and drainage systems), the majority of the costs for this landscaped area could be considered exempt. However, in recognition of the general benefit this improvement area provides and the previous assessments applied to properties within the Zone, it was determined that the City would fund a large portion of the costs associated with this landscaped median area. Refer to the budget section of this Report for details on the allocation of benefit and related assessments. Zone #3 (Vineyards): Zone #3 consists of the parcels in Tracts 12181-1 and 12181-2 on the West side of Portola Avenue. The streets within the Zone include Martini Court, Heitz Court, Mondavi Court, Callaway Court, Stony Hill Court, Masson Street, Krug Avenue, Sebastian Way, and San Pasqual Avenue/Rutledge Way. These parcels receive special benefits from the operation and maintenance of street lighting improvements within the Zone boundaries and the landscaped area along the West side of Portola Avenue, from the northern boundary to the southern boundary of the two tracts. Both the street lighting and landscape improvements identified for this Zone were installed as part of the residential development and the ongoing maintenance and operation of these improvements provide special benefits to properties within the Zone. It has further been determined that these improvements were installed and are maintained solely for the benefit of properties within the Zone and the improvements provide no measurable benefit to properties outside the Zone. Any benefit conveyed to other properties or to the public at large (general benefit) is incidental. Therefore, both the interior tract street lighting and the parkway 176 2024/2025 Consolidated Palm Desert Landscape and Lighting District No.1 Page 6 (perimeter) landscaping costs have been identified and apportioned 100% as a special benefit to the parcels within the Zone. Zone #4 (Parkview Estates): Zone #4 consists of the parcels in Tract 8237, South of Magnesia Falls Drive, North of Fred Waring Drive, West of Deep Canyon Road, and East of Portola Avenue. These parcels receive special benefits from the operation and maintenance of street lighting along Primrose Drive, Desert Star Boulevard, Vanda Circle, Palmilla Circle, Myrsine Avenue, Gazania Place, Rutledge Avenue, Buttonwood Drive, Silktree Lane, Santolina Drive, Balsam Lane, and Erin Street. The street lighting improvements were installed as part of the residential development and are considered a special benefit to the properties within the development (i.e., Zone). The ongoing operation and maintenance of interior residential street lighting provides no measurable general benefit to properties outside the Zone or to the public at large. To the extent that some streetlights associated with the Zone are located on the perimeter of the residential development and provides direct illumination to parcels outside the Zone, a portion of the maintenance costs has been identified as a general benefit. This Zone has twenty interior streetlights and five perimeter streetlights resulting in an allocation of the Zone costs as 90% special benefit and 10% general benefit. Zone #5 (Cook and Country Club): Zone #5 consists of three (3) separate residential subdivisions identified as Sub- zones. These three Sub-zones are known and identified as: Desert Mirage (Tract 25639) Sandcastles (Tract 21338-1) Primrose II (Tract 25436) Each of these Sub-zones has specific local improvements maintained by the District that were installed as part of these residential developments. These three subdivisions were originally part of a larger Zone known as Cook and Country Club and were proportionately assessed for median landscaping in the area as well as their local (tract specific) improvements. In fiscal year 1997/1998 it was determined that the median landscaping in the Cook and Country Club area was largely a general benefit and this portion of the assessment was eliminated. However, it was determined that the parcels within these three (3) Sub-zones receive special benefit from tract maintained by the District, and each parcel within the respective Sub-zones should continue to be assessed proportionately for the cost of services associated with those local improvements. The parcels in all three (3) Sub-zones receive special benefits from tract street lighting; the parcels in the Primrose II Sub-zone also receive special benefits from parkway landscaping; and 177 2024/2025 Consolidated Palm Desert Landscape and Lighting District No.1 Page 7 the parcels in the Desert Mirage Sub-zone also receive special benefits from parkway landscaping, detention basin landscaping, and entrance landscaping. Upon review of the specific street lighting improvements associated with each of these Sub-zones, the street lighting facilities have been identified as interior tract streetlights. These streetlights provide little or no direct illumination to parcels outside the Sub-zones and therefore the costs of maintaining these improvements are allocated as 100% special benefit with no general benefit. The property owners in the Sub-zone known as Desert Mirage were balloted in Fiscal Year 2004/2005 for an increase in their maximum assessment rates. The proposed levy increase would fund new maintenance costs required after the City of Palm Desert renovated the improvements with water efficient landscaping and irrigation systems. Majority protest did not exist; therefore, the City moved forward with the plans to renovate and maintain the improvements in the Desert Mirage Sub-zone. The 2004/2005 reballoting determined that 15% of the improvements within the Desert Mirage Sub-zone are of a general benefit to those properties outside of the Sub-zone. Therefore, this percentage of the costs of maintaining the Sub-zone has been removed from the assessment and must be funded from other sources. Refer to the budget for Zone 5 in Section IV of this Report for specifics regarding the proposed assessment for the current fiscal year and the maximum assessment. Zone #6 (Hovley Lane): Parcels within this Zone are located generally East of Monterey Avenue and West of Portola Avenue and includes parcels and tracts along Hovley Lane West. Zone 6 includes the following subdivisions and Sub-zones: Monterey Meadows (Tracts 21791 and 22741) Hovley Glen (Tract 25217) Hovley Estates (Tract 24591) Sonata I (Tract 23982) Sonata II (Tracts 24254 -1, 2, 3) Hovley Collection (Tract 24603) La Paloma I (Tract 24773-1) La Paloma II (Tract 24773) La Paloma III (Tract 29045) Sandpiper Court (Tract 27370) Hovley Court West (Tract 29585) Sandpiper West (Tract 29579) Diamondback Road (Tract 29893) Palm Court (Tract 25373) 178 2024/2025 Consolidated Palm Desert Landscape and Lighting District No.1 Page 8 The parcels within each of the fourteen (14) Sub-zones of Zone 6 (Hovley Lane) receive benefit from various improvements that were installed as part of the separate residential developments and are specific to each tract and subdivision. The assessment for each Sub-zone funds and provides for the parkway landscaping improvements adjacent to each tract along Hovley Lane as well as specific in-tract improvements. The in-tract improvements may include street lighting; dry well and retention basin landscape maintenance; and landscaping of additional parkway areas. The improvements within Zone 6 include street lighting on Clover Lane, Meadow Lane, Hovley Lane West, Centennial Circle, Posada Court, Via Fonda, Sonata Court, Avenida Arcadia, Avenida Solana, Sandpiper Court, Avenida Rosario, Sandpiper Court West Hovley Court, Diamondback Road, and Palm Court; landscaped parkways along Hovley Lane West, Monterey Avenue, Portola Avenue and landscaped retention basins located within Hovley Estates, Hovley Collections, La Paloma 1, La Paloma 2, Sandpiper Court, and Sandpiper Court West. Upon review of the specific street lighting improvements associated with each of these Sub-zones, the street lighting facilities have been identified as tract specific streetlights. To the extent that some streetlights associated with Hovley Glen, Sonata I and Hovley West Sub-zones are located on the perimeter of the development and provide direct illumination to parcels outside the subdivision, a portion of the maintenance costs (15%) have been identified as a general benefit component. Therefore, the cost of maintaining the street light improvements is allocated as 85% special benefit to properties within these Sub-zones. Similarly, it has been determined that a portion of the parkway landscape improvements associated with Hovley Glen, Sonata I and Hovley Court West Sub- zones provide a general benefit to properties outside of these Sub-zones. Therefore, 15% of the costs of maintaining these landscaped areas has been removed from the assessments and will be funded from other sources. Also, a portion of Hovley Collection has been determined to provide some general benefit, which has been set at 7.97%.The landscape improvements associated with each of the remaining Sub-zones provide no measurable general benefit to properties outside the Zone or to the public at large, and therefore, their specific local landscaping improvements and the corresponding assessments have been identified 100% as a special benefit to parcels within the Sub-zones. The property owners in the nine (9) Sub-zones known as Hovley Glen, Hovley Estates, Sonata I, Sonata II, La Paloma I, Sandpiper Court, Sandpiper West, Hovley West and Hovley Collection, were balloted in Fiscal Year 2004/2005 for an increase in their maximum assessment rates. In conjunction with the assessment increase, the City proposed to renovate the existing improvements with more water efficient landscaping and modifications to the irrigation system. For seven (7) of the nine (9) Sub-zones balloted, majority protest did not exist and the City has moved forward with the plans to renovate and maintain the 179 2024/2025 Consolidated Palm Desert Landscape and Lighting District No.1 Page 9 improvements in those Sub-zones. However, majority protest existed in Hovley West and Hovley Collection, and the proposed assessment increase for these two Sub-zones will not be imposed. Without the additional maintenance funding, the City will not be able to renovate the improvements for these two Sub-zones, but will continue to maintain the existing improvements at a level of service compensatory with the available assessment revenues at the existing assessment rates. Refer to the budgets for Zone 6 in Section IV of this Report for specifics regarding the proposed assessment for the current fiscal year and the maximum assessment. In Fiscal Year 2004/2005 the Palm Court Sub-zone was annexed to Zone 6 through property owner protest hearing proceedings. Upon conclusion of a noticed Public Hearing, it was determined that a majority protest did not exist. Upon review of the specific improvements associated within this Sub-zone, benefit conveyed to other properties or to the public at large (general benefit) has been determined by comparison to be incidental. Therefore, the costs of the on-going operation and maintenance of the improvements have been identified and apportioned 100% as a special benefit to the parcels within the Sub-zone. Zone #7 (Waring Court): Zone 7 consists of Tract 25304, North of Fred Waring Drive and East of Phyllis Jackson Lane. These parcels receive special benefit from the ongoing maintenance of landscaped parkways along Fred Waring Drive and Phyllis Jackson Lane adjacent to the tract. The improvements were installed as part of the residential development, and it has been determined that the operation and maintenance of the landscape improvements provide no measurable general benefit to other properties outside the Zone or to the public at large. Therefore, the local landscaping improvements associated with this Zone and the costs of providing these improvements have been identified as 100% special benefit to parcels within Zone 7. Zone #8 (Palm Gate): Zone 8 consists of the parcels in Tract 24287 located East of Deep Canyon Road, and North of Fred Waring Drive, on Coral Bells Circle, Daylily Circle, and Moss Rose Drive. These parcels receive benefit from the maintenance and operation of local street lighting at the entrances to the development at the corners of Deep Canyon Road and Coral Bells Circle, Daylily Circle, and Moss Rose Drive. These parcels also receive special benefit from the maintenance of the landscaped parkways adjacent to the development on Deep Canyon Road. 180 2024/2025 Consolidated Palm Desert Landscape and Lighting District No.1 Page 10 Both the street lighting and landscape improvements identified for this Zone were installed as part of the residential development and the ongoing maintenance and operation of these improvements provide special benefit to properties within the Zone. It has been determined that these improvements were installed and are maintained solely for the benefit of properties within the Zone and provide no measurable benefit to properties outside the Zone or to the public at large. Therefore, both the interior tract street lighting and the parkway (perimeter) landscaping costs have been identified and apportioned 100% as a special benefit to the parcels within the Zone. In conjunction with a proposed renovation and upgrade of the existing landscape improvements the property owners in Zone 8 were balloted in Fiscal Year 2004/2005 for an increase in their maximum assessment rates. Majority protest existed and the maximum assessment rate was not increased over the amount previously approved for the Zone. Since the assessment increase was not approved the City did not move forward with the proposed renovations, but continued to maintain the existing improvements at a level of service compensatory with the available assessment revenues at that time. The property owners in Zone 8 were balloted again during Fiscal Year 2017/2018 for an increase in their maximum assessment rate effective beginning Fiscal Year 2018/2019. Majority protest did not exist and based on the approval of the new assessment rate, the City has moved forward with the proposed renovations. Zone #9 (The Grove): Zone 9 consists of the parcels in Tract 24984 South of Goleta Avenue and West of Deep Canyon Road. These parcels receive special benefits from the improvements and maintenance of street lighting at the entrance to the development at the corner of Deep Canyon Road and Royal Canyon Lane as well as interior street lighting on Kings Canyon Lane, Indian Canyon Lane, Hazel Canyon Lane, and Royal Canyon Lane. These parcels also receive special benefits from the improvements and maintenance of parkway landscaping adjacent to the tract on Deep Canyon Road, and interior landscaping, including an entryway median, parkway landscaping and palm tree trimming within the public right-of-ways on Royal Canyon Lane that were installed as part of the residential tract development. Both the street lighting and landscape improvements identified for this Zone were installed as part of the residential tract development and the ongoing maintenance and operation of these improvements provide special benefit to properties within the Zone. It has further been determined that these improvements were installed and are maintained solely for the benefit of properties within the Zone and the improvements provide no measurable benefit to properties outside the Zone or to the public at large. Therefore, both the tract street lighting and the landscaping 181 2024/2025 Consolidated Palm Desert Landscape and Lighting District No.1 Page 11 costs (parkways and interior landscaping) have been identified and apportioned 100% as a special benefit to the parcels within the Zone. As part of the overall landscaping costs for this Zone, specialized maintenance (palm tree trimming) is budgeted separately as this service is not covered under the regular maintenance contract the City has with its landscape contractor. However, like other landscape maintenance within the Zone this service benefits only the properties within the Zone and has been identified as 100% special benefit. Zone #11 (Portola Place): Zone 11 is generally located South of Santa Rosa Way and East of Portola Avenue and consists of the parcels in Tract 27692. These parcels receive special benefits from the servicing and maintenance of the landscaped parkways adjacent to the tract on Portola Avenue and Santa Rosa Way, and interior tract landscaping on Olive Court installed as part of the residential development. The developer (D & F Development) was conditioned to form the necessary District Zone for the public improvements that would be installed as part of subdivision tract 27692. In a letter to the City dated April 4, 1994, the developer (sole owner of the property at that time) requested inclusion of the parcels within the tract into the District and to be assessed annually for the cost of maintaining the improvements. This letter constitutes a 100% landowner petition pursuant to Article XIIID and supports a position that the assessments imposed prior to July 1, 1997 were exempt from the requirements of Article XIIID. Although the assessments for these improvements were identified as exempt in fiscal Year 1997/1998 and not subject to the procedural requirements of a protest balloting procedure, the improvements and the related assessments for this Zone were identified as 100% special benefit. It has been determined that the ongoing operation and maintenance of the improvements provide no measurable general benefit to other properties outside the Zone or to the public at large. Therefore, these improvements, the corresponding assessments and the annual inflationary adjustment previously approved by landowner petition are in compliance with the substantive requirements of Article XIIID. However, any future increases to the assessments will require property owner ballot proceedings. Zone #13 (Palm Desert Country Club): Zone 13 is located generally South of Hovley Lane East, North of Fred Waring Drive, West of Warner Trail, and West of Washington and is commonly referred to as the Palm Desert Country Club area. 182 2024/2025 Consolidated Palm Desert Landscape and Lighting District No.1 Page 12 The parcels within this Zone receive special benefits from the servicing and maintenance of entryway landscaping on State Street and Washington Avenue, parkway landscaping along Fred Waring Drive and local residential street lighting within the Zone. Parcels within Zone 13 were annexed into the City in Fiscal Year 1994/1995. Prior to City annexation the local improvements within this Zone were assessed and collected by the County through a County Service Area (CSA). When the properties were annexed to the City, the City established this territory as Zone 13 within the District and the CSA fund balance was transferred to the Zone 13 account. For the first two years, the City used the fund balance to fully cover the annual cost of providing the improvements. In Fiscal Year 1996/1997 the remaining fund balance was designated as reserves and the District levied its first annual assessment for the Zone. Because the reserve fund balance was greater than the amount typically held in reserves, the City Council determined that a portion of the reserves would be used each year to offset the annual expenditures thereby allowing the annual assessments to remain fairly constant and also gradually reduce the reserve fund to normal levels. In Fiscal Year 1997/1998, in compliance with Article XIIID, a property owner ballot proceeding was conducted to approve the existing annual assessment. At that time, the property owners approved the proposed assessment amount plus an annual inflation adjustment. The assessment amount approved by the property owners was based on the continued policy of utilizing reserve fund contributions to offset the actual expenses for the Zone. In Fiscal Year 1999/2000, property owners within Zone 13 were re-balloted for an increased assessment to cover the maintenance costs associated with the new landscaping improvements to be installed on Fred Waring Drive. Property owners were balloted for an amount sufficient to cover the actual Zone expenses, although a portion of the existing reserves continued to be used to reduce the annual assessments. Majority protest did not exist; therefore, the City has moved forward with the landscaping improvements plans for Zone 13. The street lighting and landscape improvements assessed within this Zone clearly provide special benefits to properties within the Zone, therefore, both the street lighting and the landscaping costs (parkways and interior landscaping) have been identified and apportioned 100% as a special benefit to parcels within the Zone. Zone #14 (K & B at Palm Desert): Zone 14 is located generally North of Frank Sinatra Drive, West of Portola Avenue, East of Monterey Avenue and South of Gerald Ford Drive. The Zone includes the parcels in Tracts 28258 and 28258-1. The properties within the boundaries of Zone 14 benefit from street lighting within the development located on Drexell Drive, Heatherwood Drive, Emerson Drive and 183 2024/2025 Consolidated Palm Desert Landscape and Lighting District No.1 Page 13 Jamerson Road, and Colebridge Street, as well as landscaping associated with the retention basin area located on Heatherwood Drive and dry well areas within the subdivisions installed by the developer as part of the residential development. In conjunction with a proposed renovation and upgrade of the existing landscape improvements, the property owners in Zone 14 were balloted in Fiscal Year 2004/05 for an increase in their maximum assessment rates. Majority protest did not exist, and based on the approval of the new assessment rate, the City has moved forward with the plans to renovate the improvements with more water efficient landscaping and modifications to the irrigation system. It has been determined that fifteen percent (15%) of the improvements within the K & B Palm Desert Sub-Zone are of a general benefit to those properties outside of the Sub-zone. Therefore, this percentage of the costs of maintaining the Sub- zone has been removed from the assessment and must be funded from other City funding sources. Zone #15 (Canyon Crest): Zone 15 consists of Tract 25102-1 and 25102 generally located east of Deep Canyon Road, south of the Whitewater River Channel, north of Moss Rose Drive, and west of the Palm Desert High School. This Zone was established and annexed to the District on March 11, 1999, pursuant to the Act and a property owner ballot proceeding. These parcels receive special benefit from the operation and maintenance of landscaped parkways along the east side of Deep Canyon Road from Magnesia Falls (Whitewater River Channel), south to the end of the development (approximately 100 feet north of Buttonwood Drive); perimeter landscaping along the Whitewater River Channel (the northern boundary of the development and District) from Deep Canyon Road eastward to the western boundary of the development (approximately 675 linear feet of the total 1275 feet is landscaped). The improvements for this Zone were installed as part of the residential developments. It has been determined that the ongoing operation and maintenance of the landscape improvements provide no measurable general benefit to other properties outside the Zone or to the public at large. Therefore, the local landscaping improvements associated with this Zone and the associated annual costs have been identified as 100% special benefit to parcels within Zone 15. 184 2024/2025 Consolidated Palm Desert Landscape and Lighting District No.1 Page 14 Zone #16 (Shepard Lane): Zone #16 consists of six (6) separate residential subdivisions identified as Sub- zones. These six Sub-zones are known and identified as: College View Estates I (Tract 29444) College View Estates II (Tract 30087) Sundance West (Tract 30216) Sundance East (Tract 30503) Petunia I (Tract 30025) Boulders (Tract 30030) Each of these Sub-zones has specific local improvements maintained by the District that were installed as part of these residential developments. There are several residential subdivisions within the area known as Shepherd Lane. The parcels within each of the six (6) Sub-zones of Zone 16 (Shepard Lane) receive benefit from various improvements that were installed as part of the separate residential developments and are specific to each tract and subdivision. Perimeter landscaping for the Shepherd Lane residential developments includes parkway/perimeter landscaping on the west side of Portola Avenue between Frank Sinatra Drive and Gerald Ford Drive, as well as landscaping on the north side of Frank Sinatra Drive and the south side of Gerald Ford Drive on either side of Shepherd Lane. These improvements benefit the property development within the Shepherd Lane area and each residential subdivision is assessed a proportional share of the costs associated with these landscaped areas as well as specific in- tract improvements. Specific in-tract improvements include: Sub-Zone College View Estates I: This Sub-zone’s proportional benefit of parkway/perimeter landscaping along the west side of Portola Avenue adjacent to the residential subdivision (generally between Frank Sinatra Drive and Gerald Ford Drive); Parkway landscaping along both sides of Shepherd Lane adjacent to the residential subdivision (generally between Frank Sinatra Drive and Gerald Ford Drive); Streetlights within the residential subdivision and/or adjacent to the subdivision on both the east and west sides of Shepherd Lane and the west side of Portola Avenue installed as part of the residential subdivision. 185 2024/2025 Consolidated Palm Desert Landscape and Lighting District No.1 Page 15 Sub-Zone College View Estates II: This Sub-zone’s proportional benefit of parkway/perimeter landscaping on both sides of Shepherd Lane and the west side of Portola Avenue adjacent to the residential subdivision, installed as part of the development of properties therein; Streetlights within and adjacent to the residential subdivision. Sub-Zone Sundance West: Two landscape easements located on the west side of Shepherd Lane at Kokopelli Circle. Two landscape easements located on the west side of Shepherd Lane at Chinook Circle. Parkway landscaping along Shepherd Lane adjacent to the residential subdivision. Specifically, the parkway area on the west side of Shepherd Lane which extends the length of Tract 30216. Streetlights within the residential subdivision and/or adjacent to the subdivision on both the east and west sides of Shepherd Lane and the west side of Portola Avenue installed as part of the residential subdivision. Sub-Zone Sundance East: This Sub-zone’s proportional benefit of perimeter/parkway landscaping on the west side of Portola Avenue between Frank Sinatra Drive and Gerald Ford Drive associated with the development. Parkway landscaping on Shepherd Lane adjacent to the residential development installed as part of the development of properties therein. Streetlights within and adjacent to the residential subdivision. Sub-Zone Petunia I: Three landscape easements identified as the parkway landscaping on the east side of Shepherd Lane adjacent to the tract north and south of East Petunia Place and the parkway landscaping easement on the west side of Portola Avenue adjacent to the tract. Two landscape easements identified as the parkway landscaping on the west side of Shepherd Lane adjacent to the tract north and south of West Petunia Place. 186 2024/2025 Consolidated Palm Desert Landscape and Lighting District No.1 Page 16 Sub-Zone The Boulders: Parkway landscaping on Shepherd Lane adjacent to the residential development installed as part of the development of properties therein. This Sub-zone’s proportional benefit of parkway/perimeter landscaping on the west side of Portola Avenue between Frank Sinatra Drive and Gerald Ford Drive, as well as landscaping on the north side of Frank Sinatra Drive and the south side of Gerald Ford Drive on either side of Shepherd Lane. Streetlights within and adjacent to the residential subdivision. It has been determined upon review of the specific improvements that a portion of the street lighting and parkway landscape improvements associated with the College View Estates I, College View Estates II, Sundance East, and Petunia I Sub-zones provide some general benefit to properties outside of these Sub-zones. These improvements include the parkway/perimeter maintenance along Portola Avenue. A portion of the maintenance costs up to 15% have been identified by the City as a general benefit component have been removed from the assessments and will be funded from other sources. The improvements associated with the remaining Sub-zones provide no measurable general benefit to properties outside the Zone, therefore, their specific local landscaping improvements are allocated 100% as special benefit to parcels within the Sub-zones. III. Method of Apportionment A. General The 1972 Act permits the establishment of assessment districts by agencies for the purpose of providing certain public improvements which include the construction, maintenance and servicing of public lights, landscaping and appurtenant facilities. The 1972 Act further requires that the cost of these improvements be levied according to benefit rather than assessed value: “The net amount to be assessed upon lands within an assessment district may be apportioned by any formula or method which fairly distributes the net amount among all assessable lots or parcels in proportion to the estimated benefits to be received by each such lot or parcel from the improvements.” The formula used for calculating assessments in each Zone of the District therefore reflects the composition of the parcels, and the improvements and services provided, to fairly apportion the costs based on estimated benefit to each parcel. 187 2024/2025 Consolidated Palm Desert Landscape and Lighting District No.1 Page 17 In addition, pursuant to Article XIIID Section 4 a parcel’s assessment may not exceed the reasonable cost of the proportional special benefit conferred on that parcel and provides that only special benefits are assessable and the District must separate the general benefits from the special benefits. Therefore, in compliance with the new assessment requirements only assessments that are identified as either “Exempt Assessments” or “Special Benefit Assessments” are assessed. The costs of any improvements considered to be “General Benefit” have been eliminated from the District assessments. B. Benefit Analysis Each of the proposed improvements, the associated costs and assessments has been carefully reviewed by the City and has been identified and allocated based on benefit pursuant to the provisions of the 1972 Act and Article XIIID of the California Constitution. Each improvement and the associated costs have been identified as either “general benefits” or “special benefits”. Although some existing assessments within the District qualified as exempt assessments pursuant to Article XIIID, Section 5 of the Constitution and did not require a ballot proceeding under the provisions of Section 4, the improvements associated with these assessments are considered a special benefit to the assessed properties and are in compliance with the substantive requirements of Article XIIID Section 4. The maximum assessment rates shown in this report are consistent with the provisions of Article XIIID and any new or increased assessments shall be subject to the provisions of Section 4 therein. Special Benefits The method of apportionment (or method of assessment) is based on the premise that each of the assessed parcels within the District and Zones receives benefit from the improvements maintained and financed by District assessments. Specifically, the assessments associated with each Zone are for the maintenance of local street lighting and landscaped improvements installed as part of the original development of the parcels within the Zones or were later installed for the benefit of those properties. The desirability and security of properties within each Zone is enhanced by the presence of street lighting and well-maintained landscaping in close proximity to those properties. The landscape improvements provided by the District may include landscaped medians, parkways, entryways, slopes and appurtenant facilities. Street lighting improvements may include energy costs and necessary maintenance to the facilities related thereto. The annual assessments outlined in this Report are proposed to cover the estimated costs to provide necessary service, operation, administration and maintenance required each year to keep these improvements in a healthy, vigorous and satisfactory condition. The special benefits associated with the local landscaping improvements are specifically: 188 2024/2025 Consolidated Palm Desert Landscape and Lighting District No.1 Page 18 Enhanced desirability of properties through association with the improvements. Improved aesthetic appeal of properties within the Zones providing a positive representation of the area. Enhanced adaptation of the urban environment within the natural environment from adequate green space and landscaping. Environmental enhancement through improved erosion resistance, and dust and debris control. Increased sense of pride in ownership of property within the District resulting from well-maintained improvements associated with the properties. Reduced criminal activity and property-related crimes (especially vandalism) against properties in the District through well-maintained surroundings and amenities including abatement of graffiti. Enhanced environmental quality of the parcels within the Zones by moderating temperatures, providing oxygenation and attenuating noise. The special benefits of street lighting are the convenience, safety and security of property, improvements and goods. Specifically: Enhanced deterrence of crime and aid police protection. Increased nighttime safety on roads and highways. Improved ability of pedestrians and motorists to see. Improved ingress and egress to property. Reduced vandalism and other criminal acts and damage to improvements or property. Improved traffic circulation and reduced nighttime accidents and personal property loss. Increased promotion of business during nighttime hours in the case of commercial properties. The preceding special benefits contribute to a specific enhancement and desirability of each of the assessed parcels. General Benefit Contributions Prior to the passage of Proposition 218, some of the District assessments included maintenance of landscaped medians on various arterial streets within the City. However, since the maintenance of most arterial medians within the City were funded by the City’s General Fund, it was determined that the existing 189 2024/2025 Consolidated Palm Desert Landscape and Lighting District No.1 Page 19 assessments for these improvements were not a special benefit and in Fiscal Year 1997/1998 the District assessments related to arterial medians were eliminated. In addition, any improvement and the associated costs that are considered a general benefit to properties outside the respective Zones or to the public at large have been identified and excluded from the annual assessments. The improvements and associated costs considered to be a general benefit for each Zone are described in Specific Improvements and Special Benefit Zones (Section II). The General Benefit Contribution amount excluded from the annual assessment for each Zone is reflected in the District Budgets (Section IV B). In making this determination it should be noted that parkway, perimeter landscaping and interior landscaping within the City is either funded or maintained by individual property owners or through some type of association, except those maintained and funded through a special District. The City does not usually maintain these types of improvements from General Fund Revenues and, like other similar improvements within the City, the ongoing maintenance of these improvements are a special benefit to the properties associated with the improvements. Additional General Fund Contributions In some cases, a Zone’s total operating cost may exceed the maximum assessment allowed. In such a case and at the City’s discretion, the annual shortfall may be funded through an Additional General Fund Contribution or steps may be taken to reduce the total operating cost for the Zone (such as reducing the service levels). The Additional General Fund Contribution amount for each Zone is reflected in the District Budgets (Section IV B). C. Assessment Methodology Pursuant to the 1972 Act, the costs of the District may be apportioned by any formula or method that fairly distributes the net amount to be assessed, among assessable parcels in proportion to the estimated benefits to be received by each such parcel from the improvements. The apportionment of costs used for each Zone should reflect the composition of the parcels, and the improvements and services provided based on each parcel’s estimated special benefit. Equivalent Benefit Units: To assess benefits equitably, it is necessary to relate the different type of parcel improvements to each other. The Equivalent Benefit Unit method of assessment apportionment uses the single-family home as the basic unit of assessment. A single-family home equals one Equivalent Benefit Unit (EBU). Every other land use is converted to EBUs based on an assessment formula that equates the property’s specific development status, type of development (land use), and size of the property, as compared to a single-family home (SFR). 190 2024/2025 Consolidated Palm Desert Landscape and Lighting District No.1 Page 20 The EBU method of apportioning benefit is typically seen as the most appropriate and equitable assessment methodology for districts formed under the 1972 Act, as the benefit to each parcel from the improvements are apportioned as a function of land use type, size and development. Assessed parcels within Zones 2, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 11, 14, 15 and 16 are single- family residential parcels and the application of the EBU method of spread results in an equal assessment. The following table reflects the various property types and applicable EBUs that may be applied to properties within Zones 3 and 13. LAND USE /EQUIVALENT BENEFIT UNITS (Zones 3 and 13) Property Type Land Use Code EBU Type Factor Multiplier to Calculate EBU Commercial COM 6.00 Acreage Residential and Commercial Vacant VAC 0.30 Acreage Single Family Residential SFR 1.00 Units Condominiums CON 0.80 Units Multifamily Residential (Apartment, Duplex, Triplex, etc.) MFR 0.80 Units Single Family Vacant Lot SFV 1.00 Lot Exempt NON 0.00 Parcels Exempt parcels include easements and landscaped areas or common areas. The benefit formula applied to parcels in each Zone is based on the preceding Equivalent Benefit Unit (EBU) tables. Each parcel’s EBU correlates the parcel’s special benefit received as compared to the other parcels in the Zone. Parcel Type EBU x Acres or Units = Parcel EBU Total Balance to Levy in Zone / Total EBU in Zone = Levy per EBU Parcel EBU x Levy per EBU = Parcel Levy Amount 191 2024/2025 Consolidated Palm Desert Landscape and Lighting District No.1 Page 21 D. Assessment Range Formula Any new or increase in assessments, require certain noticing and meeting requirements by law. The Brown Act defines the terms “new or increased assessment” to exclude certain conditions. These certain conditions included “any assessment that does not exceed an assessment formula or range of assessments previously adopted by the agency or approved by the voters in the area where the assessment is imposed.” This definition was later confirmed by Senate Bill 919 (the Proposition 218 implementing legislation). An assessment range formula for the District assessments has been confirmed through property owner ballot proceedings in compliance with Article XIIID, except those existing assessments within the District which qualified as exempt assessments pursuant to Article XIIID, Section 5 of the Constitution and did not require a ballot proceeding under the provisions of Section 4. The assessment range formula shall be applied to the future assessments within the District. The following describes this assessment range formula: Wherein, if the proposed assessment (levy per unit or rate) is less than or equal to, the prior year’s maximum assessment plus the adjustments described in the following, then the proposed assessment is not considered an increased assessment. The purpose of establishing an assessment range formula is to provide for reasonable increases and inflationary adjustments to the assessment amounts without requiring costly noticing and mailing procedures, which would be added to the District costs and assessments. If the proposed assessment is less than the maximum assessment approved in the previous fiscal year adjusted by a percentage no greater than three percent (3.0%), or the annual percentage increase of the Consumer Price Index (CPI), whichever is the lesser of the two, the assessment shall not be considered as an increase. Each year the City shall compute the percentage difference between the CPI on January 1, of each year and the CPI for the previous January 1, or a similar time period, as determined by the Bureau of Labor Statistics for all urban consumers for the Los Angeles, Anaheim and Riverside Area. This percentage difference shall then establish the range of increased maximum assessments allowed based on CPI each year. Should the Bureau of Labor Statistics revise such index or discontinue the preparation of such index, the City shall use the revised index or comparable system as approved by the City Council for determining fluctuations in the cost of living. Starting fiscal year 2019/2020 the annual percentage change in the Consumer Price Index (CPI) of “All Urban Consumers” for the Riverside-San Bernardino-Ontario Area will be used. If CPI is less than three percent (3.0%), then the allowable adjustment to the maximum assessment for each Zone may be increased by CPI. If CPI is greater 192 2024/2025 Consolidated Palm Desert Landscape and Lighting District No.1 Page 22 than three percent (3.0%), then the allowable adjustment to the maximum assessment for each Zone may be increased by three percent (3.0%). The fact that an assessment range formula is adopted for District assessments does not require that the adjustment be applied each year, nor does it restrict the assessments to the adjustment amount. If the budget and assessments for a given Zone do not require an increase or the increase is less than the allowable adjustment, then the required budget and assessment shall be applied. If the budget and assessments for a given Zone require an increase greater than the allowable adjustment then the proposed assessment is considered an increased assessment and mailed notices, as well as property owner protest ballots are required by Article XIIID to impose the assessment increase. For Fiscal Year 2024/2025, the Bureau of Labor Statistics has established CPI at 2.88% for the January 2023 to January 2024 period. Therefore, the previous maximum assessment for each Zone within the District has been adjusted by 2.88% to establish the current maximum assessment allowed. IV. District Budgets A. Description of Budget Items The following describes the services and costs that are funded through the District, shown in the District Budgets. DIRECT COSTS: Maintenance Costs — Includes contracted labor, material and equipment required to properly maintain the landscaping, irrigation systems, drainage systems, fencing, and entry monuments within the Zone. Landscape Utilities— Includes utility costs for water required for irrigation of landscaped areas and the utility costs for electricity required to operate irrigation systems and ornamental lighting for landscaped areas. Landscape Extras — Includes the replacement of any materials and equipment needed to make repairs to irrigation systems. Tree Pruning — Includes the cost of trimming and pruning trees located within the landscaped area. Street Lighting — Utility costs for electricity required to operate streetlights, as well as the maintenance of the streetlights. 193 2024/2025 Consolidated Palm Desert Landscape and Lighting District No.1 Page 23 ADMINISTRATION COSTS: District Administration — The cost to particular departments and staff of the City, for providing the coordination of District services and operations, response to public concerns and education, as well as procedures associated with the levy and collection of assessments. This item also includes the costs of contracting with professionals to provide administrative, legal or engineering services specific to the District including required notices, mailings or property owner protest ballot proceedings. County Administration Fee — This is the cost to the Zone for the County to collect District assessments on the property tax bills. Note: - The administrative costs of the District are borne by each Zone in proportion to the aggregate costs of the entire District. Costs related to direct administration are identified as exempt, general and special benefits in the same proportion as the benefit finding for the Direct Service costs. All costs related to the levy of assessments such as county fees and contract administration is applied to each Zone regardless of any benefit findings (no general benefit). LEVY BREAKDOWN: Reserve Collection/(Contribution)— This item includes funds collected or contributed by the Zone’s Reserve Fund in order to cover the cost of operation for the Zone. Negative amounts shown for this budget item are contributions from the Reserve Fund that are used to reduce the Balance to Levy. Positive amounts shown for this budget item are collections for the Reserve Fund that would be used in future years to reduce the Balance to Levy. The Reserve Fund eliminates the need for the City to transfer funds from non-District accounts. CIP Collection/(Contribution) — This item includes funds for the associated costs to perform Capital Improvements as indicated by the Zone’s Capital Improvement Plan (CIP), also referred to as improvement renovations, provided during a property owner ballot. If a majority protest does not exist for the proposed renovations, then a CIP collection may be included on the Zone’s budget to pay for future costs of the improvements. Positive amounts shown for this budget item are collections for CIP, and may be collected in installments over a period not to exceed five fiscal years. Negative amounts shown for this budget item are contributions to pay for CIP using funds previously collected and are used to reduce the Balance to Levy. The proposed Capital Improvements can include but are not limited to such things as maintenance and replacement of irrigation; maintenance and replacement of lighting; and replacement of shrubs, turf, trees, and other landscaping improvements. General Benefit Contribution — This item includes funds for the associated costs of any improvements that are considered a general benefit to properties outside the respective Zones or to the public at large. The improvements and associated 194 2024/2025 Consolidated Palm Desert Landscape and Lighting District No.1 Page 24 costs considered to be a general benefit for each Zone are described in Specific Improvements and Special Benefit Zones (Section II). These funds are added to the Zone account to reduce assessments and may be from either non-District or District sources including City General Fund Contributions and interest earnings. Additional General Fund Contribution — This item includes additional funds for Zones where the total operating cost exceeds the maximum assessment allowed by an amount greater than the maximum Reserve Collection. An additional General Fund Contribution is performed at the City’s discretion and in lieu of taking steps to reduce the total operating cost for the Zone, such as reducing the service levels. These funds may be from either non-District or District sources including City General Fund Contributions and interest earnings. Balance to Levy — This is the total amount to be collected for the current fiscal year through assessments (for special benefits) or from other revenue sources (for general benefits). The Balance to Levy represents the sum of Total Direct and Administration Costs, the Reserve Account/Other Revenue Source, the Beginning Balance, and the Contribution Replenishment. Only those costs related to the improvements identified as special benefits are levied and collected on the tax roll. DISTRICT STATISTICS: Active Parcels — The total number of parcels within the Zone boundary. Parcels Levied — The total number of parcels within the Zone that are assessed. Non-assessable lots or parcels may include parcels of land principally encumbered by public right-of-ways, easements, common areas, and/or parcels within the boundaries of the Zone that currently do not benefit from the improvements due possibly to development restrictions. Total Equivalent Benefit Units (EBU) — Equivalent Benefit Unit (EBU) is a numeric value calculated for each parcel based on the parcel’s land use and size. The EBU shown in the Zone budget (Section IV B) represents the sum total of the parcel EBUs that receive special benefits from the improvements. Applied Rate per EBU — This amount represents the rate being applied to each parcel’s individual EBU. The Levy per Equivalent Benefit Unit is the result of dividing the total Balance to Levy, by the sum of the Zone EBUs, for the fiscal year. 195 2024/2025 Consolidated Palm Desert Landscape and Lighting District No.1 Page 25 B. District Budgets CANYON COVE (1)VINEYARDSPARKVIEW ESTATES (2)DESERT MIRAGE (3)SANDCASTLESPRIMROSE IIZone 02 Zone 03 Zone 04 Zone 05 DM Zone 05 SC Zone 05 PR Maintenance Costs $47,000.00 $3,000.00 $0.00 $6,500.00 $0.00 $4,100.00 Landscape Utilities (Water/Electrical) 50,000.00 2,700.00 0.00 3,500.00 0.00 2,000.00 Landscape Extras (Materials/Special Maintenance) 25,000.00 2,500.00 0.00 5,750.00 0.00 2,000.00 Tree Pruning 20,000.00 1,500.00 0.00 4,000.00 0.00 850.00 Street Lighting 500.00 1,500.00 4,800.00 850.00 1,800.00 250.00 Annual Direct Costs (Subtotal)$142,500.00 $11,200.00 $4,800.00 $20,600.00 $1,800.00 $9,200.00 District Administration $12,892.53 $2,581.53 $811.51 $2,769.87 $1,409.16 $1,847.35 County Administration Fees 191.57 149.27 168.07 100.86 106.50 104.62 Administration Costs (Subtotal)$13,084.10 $2,730.80 $979.58 $2,870.73 $1,515.66 $1,951.97 Total Operating Costs $155,584.10 $13,930.80 $5,779.58 $23,470.73 $3,315.66 $11,151.97 Reserve Fund Collection/(Contribution) 3,573.98 (4,589.00)616.51 (871.31) (1,229.62) (6,626.40) CIP Collection/(Contribution) 0.00 2,048.21 0.00 (6,493.14)250.96 3,466.43 General Benefit Contribution (General Fund)(129,134.80)0.00 (577.96) (3,520.29)0.00 0.00 General Fund Contribution (General Fund) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Levy Adjustments (Subtotal)($125,560.82)($2,540.80)$38.55 ($10,884.73)($978.66)($3,159.97) Balance To Levy $30,023.28 $11,390.00 $5,818.13 $12,586.00 $2,337.00 $7,992.00 District Statistics Active Parcels 225 147 176 29 41 37 Parcels Levied 222 132 172 29 41 37 Total Equivalent Benefit Units (EBU) 222.00 134.00 172.00 29.00 41.00 37.00 Current Year Maximum Rate Per EBU 135.24 97.28 33.83 581.09 79.52 267.56 Current Year Applied Rate per EBU 135.24 85.00 33.83 434.00 57.00 216.00 Above/Below Maximum Rate ($0.00) ($12.28)$0.00 ($147.09) ($22.52) ($51.56) Prior Year Maximum Rate per EBU 131.46 94.56 32.88 564.83 77.30 260.07 Prior Year Applied Rate per EBU 131.46 85.00 32.88 434.00 57.00 216.00 CPI Increase for Fiscal Year 2024/2025 2.88% 2.88% 2.88% 2.88% 2.88% 2.88% Reserve Fund Estimated Beginning Reserve Balance - June 30, 2024 ($22,413.84)$15,733.64 $2,859.31 $16,831.66 $3,882.15 $15,547.97 Reserve Fund Collection/(Contribution) 3,573.98 (4,589.00)616.51 (871.31) (1,229.62) (6,626.40) Estimated Ending Reserve Balance - June 30, 2025 ($18,839.86)$11,144.64 $3,475.82 $15,960.35 $2,652.53 $8,921.57 CIP Fund Estimated Beginning CIP Fund Balance - June 30, 2024 $0.00 $25,007.11 $0.00 $20,545.10 $1,774.72 $11,890.66 CIP Fund Collection/(Contribution) 0.00 2,048.21 0.00 (6,493.14)250.96 3,466.43 Estimated Ending CIP Fund Balance - June 30, 2025 $0.00 $27,055.32 $0.00 $14,051.96 $2,025.68 $15,357.09 (1) Designates a Percentage of Direct and Administrative Fees as General Benefit (2) Designates 10% of Direct and Administrative Fees as General Benefit (3) Designates 15% of Direct and Administrative Fees as General Benefit 196 2024/2025 Consolidated Palm Desert Landscape and Lighting District No.1 Page 26 MONTEREY MEADOWSHOVLEY GLEN (3)HOVLEY ESTATESSONATA I (3)SONATA IIHOVLEY COLLECTION (1)Zone 06 MM Zone 06 HG Zone 06 HE Zone 06 S1 Zone 06 S2 Zone 06 HC Maintenance Costs $1,850.00 $3,650.00 $1,750.00 $4,275.00 $5,850.00 $4,600.00 Landscape Utilities (Water/Electrical) 1,600.00 3,200.00 1,500.00 2,200.00 2,750.00 1,900.00 Landscape Extras (Materials/Special Maintenance) 750.00 2,500.00 1,000.00 2,500.00 2,500.00 800.00 Tree Pruning 1,500.00 3,000.00 2,500.00 1,850.00 7,000.00 2,500.00 Street Lighting 850.00 0.00 0.00 200.00 400.00 400.00 Annual Direct Costs (Subtotal)$6,550.00 $12,350.00 $6,750.00 $11,025.00 $18,500.00 $10,200.00 District Administration $2,000.31 $1,856.93 $1,768.90 $1,749.93 $2,461.95 $1,936.35 County Administration Fees 106.03 94.75 94.75 94.75 131.41 105.09 Administration Costs (Subtotal)$2,106.34 $1,951.68 $1,863.65 $1,844.68 $2,593.36 $2,041.44 Total Operating Costs $8,656.34 $14,301.68 $8,613.65 $12,869.68 $21,093.36 $12,241.44 Reserve Fund Collection/(Contribution)(8,675.81) (5,216.79)4,062.04 (2,877.84) (3,168.99)470.39 CIP Collection/(Contribution) 5,277.87 0.00 (5,363.69)0.00 0.00 0.00 General Benefit Contribution (General Fund) 0.00 (2,145.63)0.00 (1,930.80)0.00 (5,229.68) General Fund Contribution (General Fund) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Levy Adjustments (Subtotal)($3,397.94)($7,362.42)($1,301.65)($4,808.64)($3,168.99)($4,759.29) Balance To Levy $5,258.40 $6,939.26 $7,312.00 $8,061.04 $17,924.37 $7,482.15 District Statistics Active Parcels 40 16 17 16 94 38 Parcels Levied 40 16 16 16 94 38 Total Equivalent Benefit Units (EBU) 40.00 16.00 16.00 16.00 94.00 38.00 Current Year Maximum Rate Per EBU 135.24 433.70 610.86 503.82 190.68 196.90 Current Year Applied Rate per EBU 131.46 433.70 457.00 503.82 190.68 196.90 Above/Below Maximum Rate ($3.78)$0.00 ($153.86)$0.00 $0.00 $0.00 Prior Year Maximum Rate per EBU 131.46 421.57 593.77 489.72 185.35 191.39 Prior Year Applied Rate per EBU 131.46 421.57 457.00 489.72 172.00 191.39 CPI Increase for Fiscal Year 2024/2025 2.88% 2.88% 2.88% 2.88% 2.88% 2.88% Reserve Fund Estimated Beginning Reserve Balance - June 30, 2024 $15,600.89 $7,638.38 $2,828.88 $6,567.78 $7,408.19 $504.41 Reserve Fund Collection/(Contribution)(8,675.81) (5,216.79)4,062.04 (2,877.84) (3,168.99)470.39 Estimated Ending Reserve Balance - June 30, 2025 $6,925.08 $2,421.59 $6,890.92 $3,689.94 $4,239.20 $974.80 CIP Fund Estimated Beginning CIP Fund Balance - June 30, 2024 $2,201.36 $0.00 $10,847.17 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 CIP Fund Collection/(Contribution) 5,277.87 0.00 (5,363.69)0.00 0.00 0.00 Estimated Ending CIP Fund Balance - June 30, 2025 $7,479.23 $0.00 $5,483.48 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 (1) Designates a Percentage of Direct and Administrative Fees as General Benefit (2) Designates 10% of Direct and Administrative Fees as General Benefit (3) Designates 15% of Direct and Administrative Fees as General Benefit 197 2024/2025 Consolidated Palm Desert Landscape and Lighting District No.1 Page 27 LA PALOMA ILA PALOMA IILA PALOMA IIISANDPIPER COURTSANDPIPER WESTHOVLEYCOURT WEST (3)Zone 06 L1 Zone 06 L2 Zone 06 L3 Zone 06 SP Zone 06 SW Zone 06 HW Maintenance Costs $2,000.00 $2,000.00 $1,800.00 $2,200.00 $2,200.00 $3,100.00 Landscape Utilities (Water/Electrical) 1,500.00 1,500.00 1,500.00 2,000.00 1,500.00 1,000.00 Landscape Extras (Materials/Special Maintenance) 1,500.00 1,250.00 1,250.00 1,500.00 1,250.00 5,000.00 Tree Pruning 800.00 650.00 1,550.00 2,000.00 3,500.00 1,250.00 Street Lighting 200.00 200.00 0.00 200.00 200.00 200.00 Annual Direct Costs (Subtotal)$6,000.00 $5,600.00 $6,100.00 $7,900.00 $8,650.00 $10,550.00 District Administration $1,768.90 $1,768.90 $1,758.56 $1,747.17 $1,762.17 $1,762.17 County Administration Fees 94.75 94.75 94.28 94.75 94.75 94.75 Administration Costs (Subtotal)$1,863.65 $1,863.65 $1,852.84 $1,841.92 $1,856.92 $1,856.92 Total Operating Costs $7,863.65 $7,463.65 $7,952.84 $9,741.92 $10,506.92 $12,406.92 Reserve Fund Collection/(Contribution)(1,719.53) (1,452.21)121.71 373.13 (784.77)2,319.98 CIP Collection/(Contribution)(864.12) (1,275.44) (3,499.55) (2,707.05) (2,506.15) (7,298.23) General Benefit Contribution (General Fund) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 (1,860.68) General Fund Contribution (General Fund) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Levy Adjustments (Subtotal)($2,583.65)($2,727.65)($3,377.84)($2,333.92)($3,290.92)($6,838.92) Balance To Levy $5,280.00 $4,736.00 $4,575.00 $7,408.00 $7,216.00 $5,568.00 District Statistics Active Parcels 17 19 17 19 19 18 Parcels Levied 16 16 15 16 16 16 Total Equivalent Benefit Units (EBU) 16.00 16.00 15.00 16.00 16.00 16.00 Current Year Maximum Rate Per EBU 578.18 595.19 433.91 593.83 589.28 458.40 Current Year Applied Rate per EBU 330.00 296.00 305.00 463.00 451.00 348.00 Above/Below Maximum Rate ($248.18) ($299.19) ($128.91) ($130.83) ($138.28) ($110.40) Prior Year Maximum Rate per EBU 562.00 578.54 421.77 577.22 572.79 445.58 Prior Year Applied Rate per EBU 330.00 296.00 305.00 463.00 451.00 348.00 CPI Increase for Fiscal Year 2024/2025 2.88% 2.88% 2.88% 2.88% 2.88% 2.88% Reserve Fund Estimated Beginning Reserve Balance - June 30, 2024 $8,010.45 $7,423.13 $6,240.57 $7,420.41 $9,190.31 $6,117.01 Reserve Fund Collection/(Contribution)(1,719.53) (1,452.21)121.71 373.13 (784.77)2,319.98 Estimated Ending Reserve Balance - June 30, 2025 $6,290.92 $5,970.92 $6,362.28 $7,793.54 $8,405.54 $8,436.99 CIP Fund Estimated Beginning CIP Fund Balance - June 30, 2024 $6,020.72 $10,412.40 $23,635.36 $10,254.82 $7,716.95 $11,561.09 CIP Fund Collection/(Contribution)(864.12) (1,275.44) (3,499.55) (2,707.05) (2,506.15) (7,298.23) Estimated Ending CIP Fund Balance - June 30, 2025 $5,156.60 $9,136.96 $20,135.81 $7,547.77 $5,210.80 $4,262.86 (1) Designates a Percentage of Direct and Administrative Fees as General Benefit (2) Designates 10% of Direct and Administrative Fees as General Benefit (3) Designates 15% of Direct and Administrative Fees as General Benefit 198 2024/2025 Consolidated Palm Desert Landscape and Lighting District No.1 Page 28 DIAMONDBACKPALM COURTWARING COURTPALM GATETHE GROVEPORTOLA PLACEZone 06 DB Zone 06 PC Zone 07 Zone 08 Zone 09 Zone 11 Maintenance Costs $1,500.00 $1,500.00 $2,750.00 $1,650.00 $6,050.00 $2,700.00 Landscape Utilities (Water/Electrical) 950.00 750.00 1,500.00 600.00 5,250.00 1,000.00 Landscape Extras (Materials/Special Maintenance) 1,000.00 850.00 750.00 750.00 5,000.00 500.00 Tree Pruning 1,500.00 1,000.00 950.00 2,000.00 6,100.00 1,500.00 Street Lighting 200.00 200.00 0.00 0.00 4,200.00 0.00 Annual Direct Costs (Subtotal)$5,150.00 $4,300.00 $5,950.00 $5,000.00 $26,600.00 $5,700.00 District Administration $1,772.99 $1,452.98 $1,764.93 $1,882.38 $3,109.18 $1,814.74 County Administration Fees 96.63 96.63 94.75 104.62 136.58 98.04 Administration Costs (Subtotal)$1,869.62 $1,549.61 $1,859.68 $1,987.00 $3,245.76 $1,912.78 Total Operating Costs $7,019.62 $5,849.61 $7,809.68 $6,987.00 $29,845.76 $7,612.78 Reserve Fund Collection/(Contribution)(142.98)2,287.31 (983.14) (7,799.04) (11,449.50) (1,590.98) CIP Collection/(Contribution)(1,896.64) (3,536.92) (1,050.55)11,357.04 3,233.74 (1,697.80) General Benefit Contribution (General Fund) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 General Fund Contribution (General Fund) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Levy Adjustments (Subtotal)($2,039.62)($1,249.61)($2,033.68)$3,558.00 ($8,215.76)($3,288.78) Balance To Levy $4,980.00 $4,600.00 $5,776.00 $10,545.00 $21,630.00 $4,324.00 District Statistics Active Parcels 20 20 16 37 105 23 Parcels Levied 20 20 16 37 105 23 Total Equivalent Benefit Units (EBU) 20.00 20.00 16.00 37.00 105.00 23.00 Current Year Maximum Rate Per EBU 582.93 404.90 665.84 355.17 326.36 301.10 Current Year Applied Rate per EBU 249.00 230.00 361.00 285.00 206.00 188.00 Above/Below Maximum Rate ($333.93) ($174.90) ($304.84) ($70.17) ($120.36) ($113.10) Prior Year Maximum Rate per EBU 566.62 393.57 647.21 345.23 317.23 292.68 Prior Year Applied Rate per EBU 249.00 230.00 361.00 300.00 206.00 188.00 CPI Increase for Fiscal Year 2024/2025 2.88% 2.88% 2.88% 2.88% 2.88% 2.88% Reserve Fund Estimated Beginning Reserve Balance - June 30, 2024 $5,758.68 $2,392.37 $7,230.88 $13,388.64 $35,326.11 $7,681.20 Reserve Fund Collection/(Contribution)(142.98)2,287.31 (983.14) (7,799.04) (11,449.50) (1,590.98) Estimated Ending Reserve Balance - June 30, 2025 $5,615.70 $4,679.68 $6,247.74 $5,589.60 $23,876.61 $6,090.22 CIP Fund Estimated Beginning CIP Fund Balance - June 30, 2024 $13,089.06 $22,294.61 $29,851.22 $33,664.27 $38,997.49 $22,133.47 CIP Fund Collection/(Contribution)(1,896.64) (3,536.92) (1,050.55)11,357.04 3,233.74 (1,697.80) Estimated Ending CIP Fund Balance - June 30, 2025 $11,192.42 $18,757.69 $28,800.67 $45,021.31 $42,231.23 $20,435.67 (1) Designates a Percentage of Direct and Administrative Fees as General Benefit (2) Designates 10% of Direct and Administrative Fees as General Benefit (3) Designates 15% of Direct and Administrative Fees as General Benefit 199 2024/2025 Consolidated Palm Desert Landscape and Lighting District No.1 Page 29 PD COUNTRY CLUBK & B ATPALM DESERT (3)CANYON CRESTCOLLEGE VIEW ESTATES II (3)SUNDANCE WESTCOLLEGE VIEWESTATES I (3)Zone 13 Zone 14 Zone 15 Zone 16 CV2 Zone 16 SD Zone 16 CV1 Maintenance Costs $6,300.00 $12,500.00 $3,500.00 $3,750.00 $3,500.00 $3,500.00 Landscape Utilities (Water/Electrical) 7,500.00 1,800.00 1,000.00 2,500.00 1,500.00 2,500.00 Landscape Extras (Materials/Special Maintenance) 20,000.00 3,500.00 3,000.00 5,750.00 5,750.00 5,750.00 Tree Pruning 6,000.00 6,750.00 2,100.00 2,750.00 2,750.00 3,000.00 Street Lighting 35,000.00 400.00 0.00 350.00 200.00 350.00 Annual Direct Costs (Subtotal)$74,800.00 $24,950.00 $9,600.00 $15,100.00 $13,700.00 $15,100.00 District Administration $12,728.96 $3,309.61 $2,312.01 $1,801.11 $1,808.11 $1,599.40 County Administration Fees 877.30 163.84 118.72 102.27 102.27 102.27 Administration Costs (Subtotal)$13,606.26 $3,473.45 $2,430.73 $1,903.38 $1,910.38 $1,701.67 Total Operating Costs $88,406.26 $28,423.45 $12,030.73 $17,003.38 $15,610.38 $16,801.67 Reserve Fund Collection/(Contribution)(48,934.51) (11,734.98) (72.13) (1,507.39)422.83 742.91 CIP Collection/(Contribution) 14,702.91 3,712.16 (3,985.60) (6,096.88) (9,057.21) (7,567.79) General Benefit Contribution (General Fund) 0.00 (4,263.63)0.00 (2,551.11)0.00 (2,520.80) General Fund Contribution (General Fund) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Levy Adjustments (Subtotal)($34,231.60)($12,286.45)($4,057.73)($10,155.38)($8,634.38)($9,345.67) Balance To Levy $54,174.66 $16,137.00 $7,973.00 $6,848.00 $6,976.00 $7,456.00 District Statistics Active Parcels 1,865 165 71 32 36 32 Parcels Levied 1,681 163 67 32 32 32 Total Equivalent Benefit Units (EBU) 2,161.71 163.00 67.00 32.00 32.00 32.00 Current Year Maximum Rate Per EBU 44.40 183.84 240.23 702.72 682.25 505.57 Current Year Applied Rate per EBU 32.00 99.00 119.00 214.00 218.00 233.00 Above/Below Maximum Rate ($12.40) ($84.84) ($121.23) ($488.72) ($464.25) ($272.57) Prior Year Maximum Rate per EBU 43.16 178.70 233.51 683.06 663.16 491.43 Prior Year Applied Rate per EBU 32.00 99.00 119.00 214.00 218.00 233.00 CPI Increase for Fiscal Year 2024/2025 2.88% 2.88% 2.88% 2.88% 2.88% 2.88% Reserve Fund Estimated Beginning Reserve Balance - June 30, 2024 $119,659.52 $31,062.83 $9,696.71 $13,069.21 $12,065.48 $10,681.79 Reserve Fund Collection/(Contribution)(48,934.51) (11,734.98) (72.13) (1,507.39)422.83 742.91 Estimated Ending Reserve Balance - June 30, 2025 $70,725.01 $19,327.85 $9,624.58 $11,561.82 $12,488.31 $11,424.70 CIP Fund Estimated Beginning CIP Fund Balance - June 30, 2024 $53,823.99 $71,744.83 $38,710.07 $68,149.83 $33,728.32 $56,435.66 CIP Fund Collection/(Contribution) 14,702.91 3,712.16 (3,985.60) (6,096.88) (9,057.21) (7,567.79) Estimated Ending CIP Fund Balance - June 30, 2025 $68,526.90 $75,456.99 $34,724.47 $62,052.95 $24,671.11 $48,867.87 (1) Designates a Percentage of Direct and Administrative Fees as General Benefit (2) Designates 10% of Direct and Administrative Fees as General Benefit (3) Designates 15% of Direct and Administrative Fees as General Benefit 200 2024/2025 Consolidated Palm Desert Landscape and Lighting District No.1 Page 30 PETUNIA I (3)SUNDANCE EAST (3)THE BOULDERSL&L TOTALZone 16 P1 Zone 16 SE Zone 16 BD District Maintenance Costs $5,000.00 $2,000.00 $6,300.00 $158,375.00 Landscape Utilities (Water/Electrical) 1,500.00 2,500.00 1,500.00 112,700.00 Landscape Extras (Materials/Special Maintenance) 3,850.00 5,750.00 5,750.00 125,000.00 Tree Pruning 1,450.00 2,000.00 950.00 95,250.00 Street Lighting 350.00 200.00 200.00 54,200.00 Annual Direct Costs (Subtotal)$12,150.00 $12,450.00 $14,700.00 $545,525.00 District Administration $1,423.17 $1,398.26 $1,538.97 $84,371.01 County Administration Fees 102.27 93.81 94.75 4,400.45 Administration Costs (Subtotal)$1,525.44 $1,492.07 $1,633.72 $88,771.46 Total Operating Costs $13,675.44 $13,942.07 $16,333.72 $634,296.46 Reserve Fund Collection/(Contribution)(995.06)323.99 (7,604.76)(114,711.94) CIP Collection/(Contribution)(4,452.48) (7,736.95) (4,696.96)(37,733.82) General Benefit Contribution (General Fund)(2,051.91) (2,091.12)0.00 (157,878.41) General Fund Contribution (General Fund) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Levy Adjustments (Subtotal)($7,499.44)($9,504.07)($12,301.72)($310,324.17) Balance To Levy $6,176.00 $4,438.00 $4,032.00 $323,972.29 District Statistics Active Parcels 32 14 16 3,469 Parcels Levied 32 14 16 3,238 Total Equivalent Benefit Units (EBU) 32.00 14.00 16.00 3,720.71 Current Year Maximum Rate Per EBU 448.79 716.46 497.61 0.00 Current Year Applied Rate per EBU 193.00 317.00 252.00 0.00 Above/Below Maximum Rate ($255.79) ($399.46) ($245.61)$0.00 Prior Year Maximum Rate per EBU 436.23 696.42 483.69 0.00 Prior Year Applied Rate per EBU 193.00 317.00 252.00 0.00 CPI Increase for Fiscal Year 2024/2025 2.88% 2.88% 2.88% 0.00% Reserve Fund Estimated Beginning Reserve Balance - June 30, 2024 $10,293.88 $9,156.77 $20,671.73 $425,527.10 Reserve Fund Collection/(Contribution)(995.06)323.99 (7,604.76)(114,711.94) Estimated Ending Reserve Balance - June 30, 2025 $9,298.82 $9,480.76 $13,066.97 $310,815.14 CIP Fund Estimated Beginning CIP Fund Balance - June 30, 2024 $42,268.48 $26,959.96 $46,622.85 $740,341.57 CIP Fund Collection/(Contribution)(4,452.48) (7,736.95) (4,696.96)(37,733.82) Estimated Ending CIP Fund Balance - June 30, 2025 $37,816.00 $19,223.01 $41,925.89 $702,607.74 (1) Designates a Percentage of Direct and Administrative Fees as General Benefit (2) Designates 10% of Direct and Administrative Fees as General Benefit (3) Designates 15% of Direct and Administrative Fees as General Benefit 201 2024/2025 Consolidated Palm Desert Landscape and Lighting District No.1 Page 31 Appendix A — District Boundary Maps The Boundary Maps for the District and/or Zones are on file in the office of Public Works and are by reference made part of this Report. The Boundary Maps are also available for inspection at the Office of Public Works. 202 2024/2025 Consolidated Palm Desert Landscape and Lighting District No.1 Page 32 Appendix B — 2024/2025 Assessment Roll Parcel identification, for each lot or parcel within the District, shall be the parcel as shown on the Riverside County Assessor's map for the year in which this Report is prepared. Non-assessable lots or parcels may include areas of public streets and other roadways (typically not assigned an APN by the County); dedicated public easements, open space areas and rights-of-ways including public greenbelts and parkways; utility rights-of-ways; common areas; landlocked parcels, small parcels vacated by the County, bifurcated lots, and any other property that cannot be developed. These types of parcels are considered to receive little or no benefit from the improvements and are therefore exempted from assessment. Properties outside the District boundary receive no direct or special benefits from the improvements provided by the District and are not assessed. Parcel identification, for each lot or parcel within the District, shall be the parcel as shown on the Riverside County Assessor's map for the year in which this Report is prepared. The land use classification for each parcel is based on the Riverside County Assessor’s Roll. A listing of parcels assessed within this District, along with the proposed assessment amounts, shall be submitted to the City Clerk, under a separate cover, and by reference is made part of this Report. Approval of this Report (as submitted or as modified) confirms the method of apportionment and the maximum assessment rate to be levied against each eligible parcel and thereby constitutes the approved levy and collection of assessments for the fiscal year. The parcels and the amount of assessment to be levied shall be submitted to the County Auditor/Controller and included on the property tax roll for the fiscal year. If any parcel submitted for collection is identified by the County Auditor/Controller to be an invalid parcel number for the current fiscal year, a corrected parcel number and/or new parcel numbers will be identified and resubmitted to the County Auditor/Controller. The assessment amount to be levied and collected for the resubmitted parcel or parcels shall be based on the method of apportionment and assessment rate approved in this Report. Therefore, if a single parcel has changed to multiple parcels, the assessment amount applied to each of the new parcels shall be recalculated and applied according to the approved method of apportionment and assessment rate rather than a proportionate share of the original assessment. 203 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name 628-291-001 72910 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 $135.24 $135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-291-002 72930 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-291-003 72950 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-291-004 72970 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-291-005 72980 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-291-006 72990 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-291-008 72995 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-291-009 72975 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-291-010 72955 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-291-011 72935 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-291-012 72915 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-291-013 72895 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-291-014 72875 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-292-001 72915 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-292-002 72935 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-292-003 72955 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-292-004 72975 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-292-005 72995 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-292-008 72990 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-292-009 72970 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-292-010 72950 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-292-011 72930 CALLIANDRA DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-292-012 72910 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-293-001 72870 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-293-002 72890 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-293-003 72910 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-293-004 72930 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-293-005 72950 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-293-006 72970 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-293-007 72990 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-293-008 73010 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-293-009 73030 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-293-010 73050 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-293-011 73070 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-294-001 73015 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-294-002 73035 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-294-003 73055 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-294-004 73075 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-294-005 73010 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-294-006 73030 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-294-007 73050 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-294-008 73070 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-295-001 73015 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-295-002 73035 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-295-003 73055 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-295-004 73075 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-295-006 73050 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-295-007 73030 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-295-008 73010 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-295-010 73070 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-295-011 73090 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-301-001 72690 AMBROSIA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-301-002 72710 AMBROSIA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-301-003 72730 AMBROSIA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-301-004 72750 AMBROSIA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-301-005 72770 AMBROSIA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-301-006 72790 AMBROSIA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-301-007 72810 AMBROSIA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-301-008 72830 AMBROSIA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-301-009 72850 AMBROSIA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-302-001 72855 AMBROSIA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-302-002 72835 AMBROSIA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-302-003 72815 AMBROSIA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-302-004 72795 AMBROSIA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-302-005 72775 AMBROSIA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-302-006 72770 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-302-007 72790 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-302-008 72810 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-302-009 72830 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-302-010 72850 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-302-011 72870 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-302-012 72890 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-303-001 72630 LOTUS CT SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-303-002 72640 LOTUS CT SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-303-003 72650 LOTUS CT SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-303-004 72660 LOTUS CT SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-303-005 72670 LOTUS CT SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-303-006 72680 LOTUS CT SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-303-007 72690 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-303-008 72710 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-303-009 72730 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-303-010 72750 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-303-011 72770 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-303-012 72790 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-303-013 72810 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-303-014 72830 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-303-015 72850 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-303-016 72870 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-303-017 72890 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-303-018 72895 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-303-019 72875 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-303-020 72855 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-303-021 72835 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 1 of 37 204 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 628-303-022 72815 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-303-023 72795 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-303-024 72775 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-303-025 72755 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-303-028 72715 SWEETBUSH DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-303-029 72705 SWEETBUSH LN SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-303-032 72735 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 628-303-034 72725 SWEETBUSH LN SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-431-001 73090 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-431-002 73110 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-431-003 73130 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-431-004 73150 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-431-005 73170 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-431-006 73190 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-431-007 73210 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-431-008 73230 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-431-009 73250 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-432-001 73090 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-432-002 73110 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-432-003 73130 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-432-004 73150 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-432-005 73170 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-432-006 73175 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-432-007 73155 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-432-008 73135 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-432-009 73115 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-432-010 73095 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-433-001 47391 CALICO CACTUS LN SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-433-002 47371 CALICO CACTUS LN SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-433-003 47331 CALICO CACTUS LN SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-433-004 47291 CALICO CACTUS LN SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-433-005 47251 CALICO CACTUS LN SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-433-006 47290 PRINCES PLUME LN SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-433-007 47280 PRINCES PLUME LN SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-433-008 47270 PRINCES PLUME LN SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-433-009 73195 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-433-010 73175 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-433-011 73155 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-433-012 73135 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-433-013 73115 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-433-014 73095 DEER GRASS DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-433-016 73110 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-433-019 73170 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-433-022 73200 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-433-023 73130 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-434-001 73251 AMBER ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-434-002 47330 CALICO CACTUS LN SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-434-003 73230 DESERT ROSE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-434-004 73235 DESERT ROSE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-434-005 73230 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-441-001 47440 HELIOTROPE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-441-002 47410 HELIOTROPE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-441-003 47370 HELIOTROPE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-441-004 47340 HELIOTROPE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-441-024 47310 HELIOTROPE AVE SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-441-025 47270 HELIOTROPE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-441-026 47240 HELIOTROPE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-441-027 47210 HELIOTROPE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-441-028 47170 HELIOTROPE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-020 73450 DESERT ROSE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-021 73430 DESERT ROSE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-022 73410 DESERT ROSE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-023 73390 DESERT ROSE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-024 73370 DESERT ROSE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-025 73350 DESERT ROSE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-026 73330 DESERT ROSE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-027 73310 DESERT ROSE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-028 73290 DESERT ROSE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-029 73270 DESERT ROSE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-030 47310 BLAZING STAR LN SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-031 47270 BLAZING STAR LN SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-032 47230 BLAZING STAR LN SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-033 47190 BLAZING STAR LN SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-034 NO SITUS ADDRESS SFV 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-035 47235 GOLDEN BUSH CT SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-036 47265 GOLDEN BUSH CT SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-037 47295 GOLDEN BUSH CT SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-038 47290 GOLDEN BUSH CT SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-039 47260 GOLDEN BUSH CT SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-040 47230 GOLDEN BUSH CT SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-041 47190 GOLDEN BUSH CT SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-042 47195 ROSE SAGE CT SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-043 47235 ROSE SAGE CT SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-044 47265 ROSE SAGE CT SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-045 47295 ROSE SAGE CT SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-046 47290 ROSE SAGE CT SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-047 47260 ROSE SAGE CT SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-048 47230 ROSE SAGE CT SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-049 47190 ROSE SAGE CT SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-050 47195 SAND SAGE CT SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-051 47235 SAND SAGE CT SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-052 47265 SAND SAGE CT SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 2 of 37 205 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 630-442-053 47295 SAND SAGE CT SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-054 47290 SAND SAGE CT SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-055 47260 SAND SAGE CT SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-056 47230 SAND SAGE CT SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-057 47190 SAND SAGE CT SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-058 47175 HELIOTROPE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-059 47215 HELIOTROPE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-060 47245 HELIOTROPE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-442-061 47275 HELIOTROPE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-443-001 73250 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-443-002 73270 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-443-003 73290 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-443-004 73310 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-443-005 73330 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-443-006 73350 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-443-007 73370 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-443-008 73390 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-443-009 73410 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-443-010 73430 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-443-011 73450 CALLIANDRA ST SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-443-012 73455 DESERT ROSE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-443-013 73435 DESERT ROSE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-443-014 73415 DESERT ROSE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-443-015 73395 DESERT ROSE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-443-016 73375 DESERT ROSE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-443-017 73355 DESERT ROSE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-443-018 73335 DESERT ROSE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-443-019 73315 DESERT ROSE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-443-020 73295 DESERT ROSE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-443-021 73275 DESERT ROSE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-443-022 73255 DESERT ROSE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-444-001 47175 BLAZING STAR LN SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-444-002 47195 BLAZING STAR LN SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-444-003 47215 BLAZING STAR LN SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-444-004 47245 BLAZING STAR LN SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-444-005 47275 BLAZING STAR LN SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 630-444-006 73250 DESERT ROSE DR SFR 1.00 135.24 135.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 622-170-009 43342 CALLAWAY CT MFR 2.40 233.47 204.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-170-010 43343 CALLAWAY CT MFR 1.60 155.65 136.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-001 43400 STONY HILL CT ##A SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-002 43400 STONY HILL CT ##B SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-003 43370 STONY HILL CT ##A SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-004 43370 STONY HILL CT ##B SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-006 43344 MONDAVI CT ##A SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-007 43344 MONDAVI CT ##B SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-008 43345 MONDAVI CT ##A SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-009 43345 MONDAVI CT ##B SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-011 43407 HEITZ CT ##A SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-012 43407 HEITZ CT ##B SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-013 43408 MARTINI CT ##A SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-014 43408 MARTINI CT ##B SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-016 43409 MARTINI CT ##A SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-017 43409 MARTINI CT ##B SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-018 43429 MARTINI CT ##A SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-019 43429 MARTINI CT ##B SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-021 43401 STONY HILL CT ##A SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-022 43401 STONY HILL CT ##B SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-023 43402 CALLAWAY CT ##A SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-024 43402 CALLAWAY CT ##B SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-026 43405 MONDAVI CT ##A SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-027 43405 MONDAVI CT ##B SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-028 73840 RUTLEDGE WAY SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-029 43406 HEITZ CT ##B SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-031 43375 MONDAVI CT ##A SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-032 43375 MONDAVI CT ##B SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-033 43376 HEITZ CT ##A SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-034 43376 HEITZ CT ##B SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-036 43403 CALLAWAY CT ##A SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-037 43403 CALLAWAY CT ##B SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-038 43404 MONDAVI CT ##A SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-039 43404 MONDAVI CT ##B SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-041 43348 MARTINI CT ##A SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-042 43348 MARTINI CT ##B SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-043 43349 MARTINI CT ##A SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-044 43349 MARTINI CT ##B SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-046 43371 STONY HILL CT ##A SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-047 43371 STONY HILL CT ##B SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-048 43372 CALLAWAY CT ##A SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-049 43372 CALLAWAY CT ##B SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-051 43346 HEITZ CT ##A SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-052 43346 HEITZ CT ##B SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-053 43347 HEITZ CT ##A SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-054 43347 HEITZ CT ##B SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-056 43340 STONY HILL CT ##A SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-057 43340 STONY HILL CT ##B SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-058 43341 STONY HILL CT ##A SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-059 43341 STONY HILL CT ##B SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-061 43377 HEITZ CT ##A SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-062 43377 HEITZ CT ##B SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-063 43378 MARTINI CT ##A SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-064 43378 MARTINI CT ##B SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-066 43379 MARTINI CT ##A SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 3 of 37 206 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 622-171-067 43379 MARTINI CT ##B SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-069 43373 CALLAWAY CT ##A SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-070 43373 CALLAWAY CT ##B SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-071 43374 MONDAVI CT ##A SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-171-072 43374 MONDAVI CT ##B SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-180-001 43430 STONY HILL ST SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-180-002 43440 STONY HILL ST SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-180-003 43450 STONY HILL ST SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-180-004 43460 STONY HILL ST SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-180-005 43470 STONY HILL ST SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-180-006 43480 STONY HILL ST SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-180-007 43490 STONY HILL ST SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-180-008 73985 KRUG AVE SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-180-009 73969 KRUG AVE SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-180-010 73953 KRUG AVE SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-180-011 73937 KRUG AVE SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-180-012 73921 KRUG AVE SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-180-013 73905 KRUG AVE SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-180-014 73889 KRUG AVE SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-180-015 73875 KRUG AVE SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-180-016 73857 KRUG AVE SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-180-017 73841 KRUG AVE SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-180-018 73825 KRUG AVE SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-180-019 73809 KRUG AVE SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-180-020 73793 KRUG AVE SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-180-021 73777 KRUG AVE SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-180-022 73761 KRUG AVE SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-001 73760 KRUG AVE SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-002 73780 KRUG AVE SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-003 73796 KRUG AVE SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-004 73812 KRUG AVE SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-005 73828 KRUG AVE SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-006 73844 KRUG AVE SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-007 73849 MASSON ST SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-008 73833 MASSON ST SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-009 73819 MASSON ST SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-010 73807 MASSON ST SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-011 73800 MASSON ST SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-012 73810 MASSON ST SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-013 73812 MASSON ST SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-014 73826 MASSON ST SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-015 73842 MASSON ST SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-016 73858 MASSON ST SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-017 73874 MASSON ST SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-018 73890 MASSON ST SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-019 73906 MASSON ST SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-020 73920 MASSON ST SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-021 73932 MASSON ST SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-022 73933 MASSON ST SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-023 73921 MASSON ST SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-024 73907 MASSON ST SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-025 73891 MASSON ST SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-026 73875 MASSON ST SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-027 73876 KRUG AVE SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-028 73892 KRUG AVE SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-029 73908 KRUG AVE SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-030 73924 KRUG AVE SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-031 73940 KRUG AVE SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-032 73956 KRUG AVE SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-033 43467 STONY HILL ST SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-034 43455 STONY HILL ST SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-035 43443 STONY HILL ST SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-036 43431 STONY HILL ST SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-037 73931 RUTLEDGE WAY SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-038 73917 RUTLEDGE WAY SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-039 73903 RUTLEDGE WAY SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-040 73889 RUTLEDGE WAY SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-041 73875 RUTLEDGE WAY SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-042 73861 RUTLEDGE WAY SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-043 73847 RUTLEDGE WAY SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-044 73833 RUTLEDGE WAY SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-045 73819 RUTLEDGE WAY SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-046 73805 RUTLEDGE WAY SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-047 43428 SAN PASCUAL AVE SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-048 43442 SAN PASCUAL AVE SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-049 43456 SAN PASCUAL AVE SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 622-181-050 43468 SAN PASCUAL AVE SFR 1.00 97.28 85.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 624-170-001 43260 RUTLEDGE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-170-002 43230 RUTLEDGE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-170-003 43200 RUTLEDGE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-170-004 74301 SANTOLINA DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-170-005 74321 SANTOLINA DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-170-006 74305 BUTTONWOOD DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-170-007 74315 BUTTONWOOD DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-171-001 43205 SILK TREE LN SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-171-002 43235 SILK TREE LN SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-171-003 43255 SILK TREE LN SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-171-004 74420 BUTTONWOOD DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-171-005 74410 BUTTONWOOD DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-171-006 74400 BUTTONWOOD DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-171-007 74390 BUTTONWOOD DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-171-008 74380 BUTTONWOOD DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 4 of 37 207 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 624-171-009 74360 BUTTONWOOD DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-171-010 74350 BUTTONWOOD DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-171-011 74351 SANTOLINA DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-171-012 74361 SANTOLINA DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-171-013 74381 SANTOLINA DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-171-014 74391 SANTOLINA DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-171-015 74401 SANTOLINA DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-171-016 74411 SANTOLINA DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-171-017 74421 SANTOLINA DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-002 43260 SILK TREE LN SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-003 43240 SILK TREE LN SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-004 43210 SILK TREE LN SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-005 43180 SILK TREE LN SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-006 43150 SILK TREE LN SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-007 43120 SILK TREE LN SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-008 43100 SILK TREE LN SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-009 43082 SILK TREE LN SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-010 43081 SILK TREE LN SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-012 74450 SANTOLINA DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-013 74420 SANTOLINA DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-014 43150 BALSAM LN SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-015 43120 BALSAM LN SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-016 43100 BALSAM LN SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-017 43042 BALSAM LN SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-018 43041 BALSAM LN SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-019 43081 BALSAM LN SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-020 43101 BALSAM LN SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-021 43121 BALSAM LN SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-022 43151 BALSAM LN SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-023 43150 BUTTONWOOD DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-024 43120 BUTTONWOOD DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-025 43100 BUTTONWOOD LN SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-026 43080 BUTTONWOOD DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-027 43042 BUTTONWOOD DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-028 43041 BUTTONWOOD DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-029 43081 BUTTONWOOD DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-030 43101 BUTTONWOOD DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-031 43121 BUTTONWOOD DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-032 43151 BUTTONWOOD DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-033 43150 RUTLEDGE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-034 43120 RUTLEDGE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-035 43100 RUTLEDGE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-036 43080 RUTLEDGE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-037 43050 RUTLEDGE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-172-041 NO SITUS ADDRESS SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-180-001 74237 RUTLEDGE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-180-002 74263 MYRSINE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-180-003 74267 MYRSINE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-180-004 74277 MYRSINE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-181-003 74241 DESERT STAR BLVD SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-181-004 74261 DESERT STAR BLVD SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-181-005 74281 DESERT STAR BLVD SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-181-006 74301 MYRSINE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-181-007 74321 MYRSINE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-181-008 74341 MYRSINE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-181-009 74361 MYRSINE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-181-010 74370 PRIMROSE DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-181-011 74360 PRIMROSE DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-181-012 74350 PRIMROSE DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-181-013 74340 PRIMROSE DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-181-014 74320 PRIMROSE DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-181-015 74306 PRIMROSE DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-181-016 74292 PRIMROSE DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-181-017 74278 PRIMROSE DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-181-018 74264 PRIMROSE DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-182-001 43561 VANDA CIR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-182-002 43550 VANDA CIR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-182-003 43551 PALMILLA CIR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-182-004 43550 PALMILLA CIR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-182-005 43520 PALMILLA CIR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-182-006 43480 PALMILLA CIR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-182-007 43420 PALMILLA CIR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-182-008 74383 MYRSINE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-182-009 74397 MYRSINE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-182-010 74413 MYRSINE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-182-011 74427 MYRSINE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-182-012 74443 MYRSINE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-182-013 74457 MYRSINE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-182-014 74473 MYRSINE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-182-015 74489 MYRSINE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-182-016 74484 MYRSINE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-182-017 74474 MYRSINE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-182-018 74458 MYRSINE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-182-019 74448 MYRSINE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-182-020 74428 MYRSINE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-182-021 74429 BUTTONWOOD DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-182-022 74449 BUTTONWOOD DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-182-023 74459 BUTTONWOOD DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-182-024 74469 BUTTONWOOD DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-182-025 74479 BUTTONWOOD DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-183-001 74398 MYRSINE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-183-002 74388 MYRSINE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 5 of 37 208 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 624-183-003 74378 MYRSINE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-183-004 74366 MYRSINE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-183-005 74346 MYRSINE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-183-006 74326 MYRSINE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-183-007 74306 MYRSINE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-183-008 74286 MYRSINE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-183-009 74276 MYRSINE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-183-010 74216 MYRSINE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-183-011 43300 RUTLEDGE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-183-012 43270 RUTLEDGE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-183-013 74325 BUTTONWOOD DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-183-014 74335 BUTTONWOOD DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-183-015 74345 BUTTONWOOD DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-183-016 74355 BUTTONWOOD DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-183-017 74365 BUTTONWOOD DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-183-018 74375 BUTTONWOOD DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-183-019 74385 BUTTONWOOD DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-183-020 74395 BUTTONWOOD DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-190-001 74015 RUTLEDGE WAY SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-190-002 74025 RUTLEDGE WAY SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-190-003 74035 RUTLEDGE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-190-004 74045 RUTLEDGE WAY SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-190-005 74055 RUTLEDGE WAY SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-190-006 74073 RUTLEDGE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-190-007 74089 RUTLEDGE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-190-008 74105 RUTLEDGE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-190-009 74121 RUTLEDGE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-190-010 74135 RUTLEDGE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-190-011 74153 RUTLEDGE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-190-012 74169 RUTLEDGE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-190-013 74185 RUTLEDGE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-190-014 74201 RUTLEDGE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-190-015 74217 RUTLEDGE AVE SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-194-011 74250 PRIMROSE DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-194-012 74230 PRIMROSE DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-194-013 74190 PRIMROSE DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-194-014 74170 PRIMROSE DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-194-015 74150 PRIMROSE DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-194-016 74130 PRIMROSE DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-195-001 74230 ERIN ST SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-195-002 74200 ERIN ST SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-195-003 74170 ERIN ST SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-195-004 74140 ERIN ST SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-195-006 74165 PRIMROSE DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-195-007 74195 PRIMROSE DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-195-008 74235 PRIMROSE DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-206-002 74131 ERIN ST SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-206-003 74161 ERIN ST SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-206-004 74181 ERIN ST SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-206-005 74201 ERIN ST SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-206-006 74241 ERIN ST SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-211-001 74255 PRIMROSE DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-211-002 74265 PRIMROSE DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-211-003 74285 PRIMROSE DR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-211-004 43585 VANDA CIR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-211-005 43621 VANDA CIR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-211-008 43590 VANDA CIR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-211-009 43580 VANDA CIR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-211-010 43581 PALMILLA CIR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-211-011 43591 PALMILLA CIR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-211-016 43590 PALMILLA CIR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-211-017 43580 PALMILLA CIR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-211-039 43621 PALMILLA CIR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-211-040 43620 PALMILLA CIR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 624-211-049 43620 VANDA CIR SFR 1.00 33.83 33.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 620-361-067 38610 DESERT MIRAGE DR SFR 1.00 581.09 434.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Desert Mirage 620-361-068 38620 DESERT MIRAGE DR SFR 1.00 581.09 434.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Desert Mirage 620-361-069 38630 DESERT MIRAGE DR SFV 1.00 581.09 434.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Desert Mirage 620-361-070 38640 DESERT MIRAGE DR SFR 1.00 581.09 434.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Desert Mirage 620-361-071 38651 DESERT MIRAGE DR SFR 1.00 581.09 434.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Desert Mirage 620-361-072 38661 DESERT MIRAGE DR SFR 1.00 581.09 434.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Desert Mirage 620-361-073 38671 DESERT MIRAGE DR SFR 1.00 581.09 434.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Desert Mirage 620-361-074 38681 DESERT MIRAGE DR SFR 1.00 581.09 434.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Desert Mirage 620-361-075 38691 DESERT MIRAGE DR SFV 1.00 581.09 434.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Desert Mirage 620-361-076 38701 DESERT MIRAGE DR SFV 1.00 581.09 434.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Desert Mirage 620-361-077 38711 DESERT MIRAGE DR SFR 1.00 581.09 434.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Desert Mirage 620-361-078 38721 DESERT MIRAGE DR SFR 1.00 581.09 434.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Desert Mirage 620-361-079 38731 DESERT MIRAGE DR SFR 1.00 581.09 434.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Desert Mirage 620-361-080 38741 DESERT MIRAGE DR SFR 1.00 581.09 434.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Desert Mirage 620-361-081 38751 DESERT MIRAGE DR SFR 1.00 581.09 434.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Desert Mirage 620-361-082 38760 DESERT MIRAGE DR SFV 1.00 581.09 434.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Desert Mirage 620-361-083 38770 DESERT MIRAGE DR SFV 1.00 581.09 434.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Desert Mirage 620-361-084 38780 DESERT MIRAGE DR SFR 1.00 581.09 434.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Desert Mirage 620-361-085 38790 DESERT MIRAGE DR SFR 1.00 581.09 434.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Desert Mirage 620-361-086 38800 DESERT MIRAGE DR SFR 1.00 581.09 434.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Desert Mirage 620-361-087 38830 DESERT MIRAGE DR SFR 1.00 581.09 434.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Desert Mirage 620-362-017 NO SITUS ADDRESS SFV 1.00 581.09 434.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Desert Mirage 620-362-018 38738 DESERT MIRAGE DR SFR 1.00 581.09 434.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Desert Mirage 620-362-019 38728 DESERT MIRAGE DR SFR 1.00 581.09 434.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Desert Mirage 620-362-020 38718 DESERT MIRAGE DR SFR 1.00 581.09 434.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Desert Mirage 620-362-021 38635 DESERT MIRAGE DR SFR 1.00 581.09 434.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Desert Mirage 620-362-022 38625 DESERT MIRAGE DR SFR 1.00 581.09 434.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Desert Mirage Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 6 of 37 209 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 620-362-023 38615 DESERT MIRAGE DR SFR 1.00 581.09 434.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Desert Mirage 620-362-024 38605 DESERT MIRAGE DR SFR 1.00 581.09 434.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Desert Mirage 632-421-001 41945 CARLOTTA DR SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-421-002 41955 CARLOTTA DR SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-421-003 41965 CARLOTTA DR SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-421-004 41960 FREEDOM CT SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-421-005 41950 FREEDOM CT SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-421-006 41940 FREEDOM CT SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-421-007 41945 FREEDOM CT SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-421-008 41955 FREEDOM CT SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-421-009 41965 FREEDOM CT SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-421-010 41960 MARYN CT SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-421-011 41950 MARYN CT SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-421-012 41940 MARYN CT SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-421-013 41945 MARYN CT SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-421-014 41955 MARYN CT SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-421-015 41965 MARYN CT SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-421-016 41960 HEMINGWAY CT SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-421-017 41950 HEMINGWAY CT SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-421-018 41940 HEMINGWAY CT SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-421-019 41945 HEMINGWAY CT SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-421-020 41955 HEMINGWAY CT SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-421-021 41965 HEMINGWAY CT SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-421-022 41975 HEMINGWAY CT SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-421-023 41985 HEMINGWAY CT SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-421-024 41995 HEMINGWAY CT SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-422-001 75525 DEMPSEY DR SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-422-002 75535 DEMPSEY DR SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-422-003 75545 DEMPSEY DR SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-422-004 75555 DEMPSEY DR SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-422-005 75565 DEMPSEY DR SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-422-006 75575 DEMPSEY DR SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-422-007 75585 DEMPSEY DR SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-422-008 75595 DEMPSEY DR SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-422-009 75605 DEMPSEY DR SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-422-010 75615 DEMPSEY DR SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-422-011 75625 DEMPSEY DR SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-422-012 75635 DEMPSEY DR SFV 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-422-013 75645 DEMPSEY DR SFR 1.00 267.56 216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 632-361-001 75687 EASY ST SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-002 75695 EASY ST SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-003 75701 EASY ST SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-004 75707 EASY ST SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-005 75713 EASY ST SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-006 75748 EASY ST SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-007 75742 EASY ST SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-008 75734 EASY ST SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-009 75728 EASY ST SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-010 75720 EASY ST SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-011 75712 EASY ST SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-012 75706 EASY ST SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-013 75700 EASY ST SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-014 75694 EASY ST SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-015 75686 EASY ST SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-016 75685 DOLMAR CT SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-017 75699 DOLMAR CT SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-018 75715 DOLMAR CT SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-019 75729 DOLMAR CT SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-020 75745 DOLMAR CT SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-021 75744 DOLMAR CT SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-022 75730 DOLMAR CT SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-023 75714 DOLMAR CT SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-024 75698 DOLMAR CT SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-025 75686 DOLMAR CT SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-026 75683 DUVAL CT SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-027 75701 DUVAL CT SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-028 75713 DUVAL CT SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-029 75727 DUVAL CT SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-030 75743 DUVAL CT SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-031 75746 DUVAL CT SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-032 75732 DUVAL CT SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-033 75716 DUVAL CT SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-034 75696 DUVAL CT SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-035 75688 DUVAL CT SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-036 41550 CARLOTTA DR SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-037 41520 CARLOTTA DR SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-038 75733 SANDCASTLE LN SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-361-039 75741 SANDCASTLE LN SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-362-001 75740 SANDCASTLE LN SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 632-362-002 75724 SANDCASTLE LN SFR 1.00 79.52 57.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 622-290-061 40743 DIAMONDBACK DR SFR 1.00 582.93 249.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Diamond Back 622-290-062 40725 DIAMONDBACK DR SFR 1.00 582.93 249.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Diamond Back 622-290-063 40697 DIAMONDBACK DR SFR 1.00 582.93 249.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Diamond Back 622-290-064 40669 DIAMONDBACK DR SFR 1.00 582.93 249.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Diamond Back 622-290-065 40641 DIAMONDBACK DR SFR 1.00 582.93 249.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Diamond Back 622-290-066 40613 DIAMONDBACK DR SFR 1.00 582.93 249.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Diamond Back 622-290-067 40585 DIAMONDBACK DR SFR 1.00 582.93 249.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Diamond Back 622-290-068 40557 DIAMONDBACK DR SFR 1.00 582.93 249.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Diamond Back 622-290-069 40529 DIAMONDBACK DR SFR 1.00 582.93 249.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Diamond Back 622-290-070 40501 DIAMONDBACK DR SFR 1.00 582.93 249.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Diamond Back 622-290-071 40500 DIAMONDBACK DR SFR 1.00 582.93 249.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Diamond Back 622-290-072 40528 DIAMONDBACK DR SFR 1.00 582.93 249.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Diamond Back Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 7 of 37 210 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 622-290-073 40556 DIAMONDBACK DR SFR 1.00 582.93 249.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Diamond Back 622-290-074 40588 DIAMONDBACK DR SFR 1.00 582.93 249.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Diamond Back 622-290-075 40612 DIAMONDBACK DR SFR 1.00 582.93 249.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Diamond Back 622-290-076 40640 DIAMONDBACK DR SFR 1.00 582.93 249.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Diamond Back 622-290-077 40668 DIAMONDBACK DR SFR 1.00 582.93 249.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Diamond Back 622-290-078 40696 DIAMONDBACK DR SFR 1.00 582.93 249.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Diamond Back 622-290-079 40724 DIAMONDBACK DR SFR 1.00 582.93 249.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Diamond Back 622-290-080 40742 DIAMONDBACK DR SFR 1.00 582.93 249.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Diamond Back 622-330-001 40765 AVENIDA CALAFIA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-002 40785 AVENIDA CALAFIA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-003 40805 AVENIDA CALAFIA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-004 40825 AVENIDA CALAFIA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-005 40845 AVENIDA CALAFIA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-006 40865 AVENIDA CALAFIA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-007 40885 AVENIDA CALAFIA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-008 40905 AVENIDA CALAFIA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-009 40925 AVENIDA CALAFIA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-010 40945 AVENIDA CALAFIA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-011 40920 AVENIDA CALAFIA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-012 40900 AVENIDA CALAFIA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-013 40880 AVENIDA CALAFIA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-014 40860 AVENIDA CALAFIA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-015 40840 AVENIDA CALAFIA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-016 40820 AVENIDA CALAFIA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-017 40800 AVENIDA CALAFIA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-018 40780 AVENIDA CALAFIA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-019 40760 AVENIDA CALAFIA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-020 40765 AVENIDA ESTRADA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-021 40785 AVENIDA ESTRADA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-022 40805 AVENIDA ESTRADA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-023 40825 AVENIDA ESTRADA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-024 40845 AVENIDA ESTRADA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-025 40865 AVENIDA ESTRADA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-026 40885 AVENIDA ESTRADA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-027 40905 AVENIDA ESTRADA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-028 40925 AVENIDA ESTRADA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-029 40940 AVENIDA ESTRADA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-030 40920 AVENIDA ESTRADA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-031 40900 AVENIDA ESTRADA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-032 40880 AVENIDA ESTRADA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-033 40860 AVENIDA ESTRADA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-034 40840 AVENIDA ESTRADA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-035 40820 AVENIDA ESTRADA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-036 40800 AVENIDA ESTRADA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-037 40780 AVENIDA ESTRADA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-038 40760 AVENIDA ESTRADA SFR 1.00 196.90 196.90 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 622-330-039 40764 HOVLEY CT SFR 1.00 458.40 348.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Court West 622-330-040 40790 HOVLEY CT SFR 1.00 458.40 348.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Court West 622-330-041 40804 HOVLEY CT SFR 1.00 458.40 348.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Court West 622-330-042 40830 HOVLEY CT SFR 1.00 458.40 348.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Court West 622-330-043 40854 HOVLEY CT SFR 1.00 458.40 348.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Court West 622-330-044 40890 HOVLEY CT SFR 1.00 458.40 348.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Court West 622-330-047 40957 HOVLEY CT SFR 1.00 458.40 348.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Court West 622-330-048 40921 HOVLEY CT SFR 1.00 458.40 348.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Court West 622-330-049 40887 HOVLEY CT SFR 1.00 458.40 348.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Court West 622-330-050 40851 HOVLEY CT SFR 1.00 458.40 348.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Court West 622-330-051 40827 HOVLEY CT SFR 1.00 458.40 348.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Court West 622-330-052 40801 HOVLEY CT SFR 1.00 458.40 348.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Court West 622-330-053 40787 HOVLEY CT SFR 1.00 458.40 348.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Court West 622-330-054 40761 HOVLEY CT SFR 1.00 458.40 348.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Court West 622-330-059 40924 HOVLEY CT SFR 1.00 458.40 348.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Court West 622-330-060 40960 HOVLEY CT SFR 1.00 458.40 348.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Court West 622-300-001 40750 CENTENNIAL CIR SFR 1.00 610.86 457.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Estates 622-300-002 40780 CENTENNIAL CIR SFR 1.00 610.86 457.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Estates 622-300-003 40810 CENTENNIAL CIR SFR 1.00 610.86 457.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Estates 622-300-004 40840 CENTENNIAL CIR SFR 1.00 610.86 457.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Estates 622-300-005 40870 CENTENNIAL CIR SFR 1.00 610.86 457.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Estates 622-300-006 40900 CENTENNIAL CIR SFR 1.00 610.86 457.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Estates 622-300-007 40930 CENTENNIAL CIR SFR 1.00 610.86 457.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Estates 622-300-009 40965 CENTENNIAL CIR SFR 1.00 610.86 457.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Estates 622-300-010 40935 CENTENNIAL CIR SFR 1.00 610.86 457.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Estates 622-300-011 40905 CENTENNIAL CIR SFR 1.00 610.86 457.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Estates 622-300-012 40875 CENTENNIAL CIR SFR 1.00 610.86 457.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Estates 622-300-013 40845 CENTENNIAL CIR SFR 1.00 610.86 457.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Estates 622-300-014 40815 CENTENNIAL CIR SFR 1.00 610.86 457.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Estates 622-300-015 40785 CENTENNIAL CIR SFR 1.00 610.86 457.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Estates 622-300-016 40755 CENTENNIAL CIR SFR 1.00 610.86 457.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Estates 622-300-018 40960 CENTENNIAL CIR SFR 1.00 610.86 457.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Estates 622-290-044 40747 GLENWOOD LN SFR 1.00 433.70 433.70 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Glen 622-290-045 40717 GLENWOOD LN SFR 1.00 433.70 433.70 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Glen 622-290-046 40687 GLENWOOD LN SFR 1.00 433.70 433.70 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Glen 622-290-047 40657 GLENWOOD LN SFR 1.00 433.70 433.70 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Glen 622-290-048 40627 GLENWOOD LN SFR 1.00 433.70 433.70 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Glen 622-290-049 40597 GLENWOOD LN SFR 1.00 433.70 433.70 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Glen 622-290-050 40567 GLENWOOD LN SFR 1.00 433.70 433.70 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Glen 622-290-051 40537 GLENWOOD LN SFR 1.00 433.70 433.70 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Glen 622-290-052 40530 GLENWOOD LN SFR 1.00 433.70 433.70 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Glen 622-290-053 40560 GLENWOOD LN SFR 1.00 433.70 433.70 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Glen 622-290-054 40590 GLENWOOD LN SFR 1.00 433.70 433.70 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Glen 622-290-055 40620 GLENWOOD LN SFR 1.00 433.70 433.70 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Glen 622-290-056 40650 GLENWOOD LN SFR 1.00 433.70 433.70 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Glen 622-290-057 40680 GLENWOOD LN SFR 1.00 433.70 433.70 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Glen Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 8 of 37 211 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 622-290-058 40710 GLENWOOD LN SFR 1.00 433.70 433.70 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Glen 622-290-059 40740 GLENWOOD LN SFR 1.00 433.70 433.70 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Glen 622-340-001 40750 AVENIDA ARCADA SFR 1.00 578.18 330.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma I 622-340-002 40780 AVENIDA ARCADA SFR 1.00 578.18 330.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma I 622-340-003 40810 AVENIDA ARCADA SFR 1.00 578.18 330.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma I 622-340-004 40840 AVENIDA ARCADA SFR 1.00 578.18 330.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma I 622-340-005 40870 AVENIDA ARCADA SFR 1.00 578.18 330.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma I 622-340-006 40900 AVENIDA ARCADA SFR 1.00 578.18 330.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma I 622-340-007 40930 AVENIDA ARCADA SFR 1.00 578.18 330.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma I 622-340-008 40960 AVENIDA ARCADA SFR 1.00 578.18 330.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma I 622-340-009 NO SITUS ADDRESS SFV 1.00 578.18 330.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma I 622-340-010 40935 AVENIDA ARCADA SFR 1.00 578.18 330.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma I 622-340-011 40905 AVENIDA ARCADA SFR 1.00 578.18 330.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma I 622-340-012 40875 AVENIDA ARCADA SFR 1.00 578.18 330.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma I 622-340-013 40845 AVENIDA ARCADA SFR 1.00 578.18 330.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma I 622-340-014 40815 AVENIDA ARCADA SFR 1.00 578.18 330.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma I 622-340-015 40785 AVENIDA ARCADA SFR 1.00 578.18 330.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma I 622-340-016 40755 AVENIDA ARCADA SFR 1.00 578.18 330.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma I 622-340-018 40750 AVENIDA ROSARIO SFR 1.00 595.19 296.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma II 622-340-019 40780 AVENIDA ROSARIO SFR 1.00 595.19 296.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma II 622-340-020 40810 AVENIDA ROSARIO SFR 1.00 595.19 296.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma II 622-340-021 40840 AVENIDA ROSARIO SFR 1.00 595.19 296.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma II 622-340-022 40870 AVENIDA ROSARIO SFR 1.00 595.19 296.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma II 622-340-023 40900 AVENIDA ROSARIO SFR 1.00 595.19 296.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma II 622-340-024 40930 AVENIDA ROSARIO SFR 1.00 595.19 296.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma II 622-340-025 40960 AVENIDA ROSARIO SFR 1.00 595.19 296.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma II 622-340-026 40965 AVENIDA ROSARIO SFR 1.00 595.19 296.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma II 622-340-027 40935 AVENIDA ROSARIO SFR 1.00 595.19 296.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma II 622-340-028 40905 AVENIDA ROSARIO SFR 1.00 595.19 296.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma II 622-340-029 40875 AVENIDA ROSARIO SFR 1.00 595.19 296.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma II 622-340-030 40845 AVENIDA ROSARIO SFR 1.00 595.19 296.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma II 622-340-031 40815 AVENIDA ROSARIO SFR 1.00 595.19 296.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma II 622-340-032 40785 AVENIDA ROSARIO SFR 1.00 595.19 296.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma II 622-340-033 40755 AVENIDA ROSARIO SFR 1.00 595.19 296.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma II 622-300-020 40748 AVENIDA SOLANA SFR 1.00 433.91 305.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma III 622-300-021 40776 AVENIDA SOLANA SFR 1.00 433.91 305.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma III 622-300-022 40808 AVENIDA SOLANA SFR 1.00 433.91 305.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma III 622-300-023 40836 AVENIDA SOLANA SFR 1.00 433.91 305.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma III 622-300-024 40868 AVENIDA SOLANA SFR 1.00 433.91 305.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma III 622-300-025 40896 AVENIDA SOLANA SFR 1.00 433.91 305.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma III 622-300-026 40956 AVENIDA SOLANA SFR 1.00 433.91 305.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma III 622-300-027 40963 AVENIDA SOLANA SFR 1.00 433.91 305.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma III 622-300-028 40931 AVENIDA SOLANA SFR 1.00 433.91 305.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma III 622-300-029 40893 AVENIDA SOLANA SFR 1.00 433.91 305.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma III 622-300-030 40861 AVENIDA SOLANA SFR 1.00 433.91 305.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma III 622-300-031 40833 AVENIDA SOLANA SFR 1.00 433.91 305.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma III 622-300-032 40801 AVENIDA SOLANA SFR 1.00 433.91 305.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma III 622-300-033 40773 AVENIDA SOLANA SFR 1.00 433.91 305.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma III 622-300-034 40741 AVENIDA SOLANA SFR 1.00 433.91 305.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma III 622-290-004 40751 MEADOW LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-005 40725 MEADOW LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-006 40697 MEADOW LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-007 40669 MEADOW LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-008 40641 MEADOW LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-009 40613 MEADOW LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-010 40585 MEADOW LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-011 40557 MEADOW LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-012 40529 MEADOW LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-013 40501 MEADOW LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-014 40500 MEADOW LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-015 40528 MEADOW LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-016 40556 MEADOW LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-017 40588 MEADOW LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-018 40612 MEADOW LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-019 40640 MEADOW LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-020 40668 MEADOW LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-021 40696 MEADOW LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-022 40724 MEADOW LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-023 40750 MEADOW LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-024 40751 CLOVER LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-025 40725 CLOVER LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-026 40697 CLOVER LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-027 40669 CLOVER LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-028 40641 CLOVER LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-029 40613 CLOVER LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-030 40585 CLOVER LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-031 40557 CLOVER LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-032 40529 CLOVER LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-033 40501 CLOVER LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-034 40500 CLOVER LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-035 40528 CLOVER LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-036 40556 CLOVER LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-037 40588 CLOVER LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-038 40612 CLOVER LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-039 40640 CLOVER LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-040 40668 CLOVER LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-041 40696 CLOVER LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-042 40724 CLOVER LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-290-043 40750 CLOVER LN SFR 1.00 135.24 131.46 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 622-311-027 40747 PALM CT SFR 1.00 404.90 230.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Palm Court 622-311-028 40729 PALM CT SFR 1.00 404.90 230.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Palm Court 622-311-029 40701 PALM CT SFR 1.00 404.90 230.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Palm Court Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 9 of 37 212 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 622-311-030 40673 PALM CT SFR 1.00 404.90 230.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Palm Court 622-311-031 40645 PALM CT SFR 1.00 404.90 230.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Palm Court 622-311-032 40617 PALM CT SFR 1.00 404.90 230.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Palm Court 622-311-033 40589 PALM CT SFR 1.00 404.90 230.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Palm Court 622-311-034 40561 PALM CT SFR 1.00 404.90 230.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Palm Court 622-311-035 40533 PALM CT SFR 1.00 404.90 230.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Palm Court 622-311-036 40505 PALM CT SFR 1.00 404.90 230.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Palm Court 622-311-037 40504 PALM CT SFR 1.00 404.90 230.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Palm Court 622-311-038 40532 PALM CT SFR 1.00 404.90 230.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Palm Court 622-311-039 40560 PALM CT SFR 1.00 404.90 230.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Palm Court 622-311-040 40592 PALM CT SFR 1.00 404.90 230.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Palm Court 622-311-041 40616 PALM CT SFR 1.00 404.90 230.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Palm Court 622-311-042 40644 PALM CT SFR 1.00 404.90 230.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Palm Court 622-311-043 40672 PALM CT SFR 1.00 404.90 230.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Palm Court 622-311-044 40700 PALM CT SFR 1.00 404.90 230.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Palm Court 622-311-045 40728 PALM CT SFR 1.00 404.90 230.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Palm Court 622-311-046 40746 PALM CT SFR 1.00 404.90 230.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Palm Court 622-340-039 40753 SANDPIPER CT SFR 1.00 593.83 463.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sandpiper Court 622-340-040 40783 SANDPIPER CT SFR 1.00 593.83 463.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sandpiper Court 622-340-041 40817 SANDPIPER CT SFR 1.00 593.83 463.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sandpiper Court 622-340-042 40847 SANDPIPER CT SFR 1.00 593.83 463.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sandpiper Court 622-340-043 40879 SANDPIPER CT SFR 1.00 593.83 463.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sandpiper Court 622-340-044 40909 SANDPIPER CT SFR 1.00 593.83 463.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sandpiper Court 622-340-045 40941 SANDPIPER CT SFR 1.00 593.83 463.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sandpiper Court 622-340-046 40971 SANDPIPER CT SFR 1.00 593.83 463.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sandpiper Court 622-340-048 40968 SANDPIPER CT SFR 1.00 593.83 463.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sandpiper Court 622-340-049 40938 SANDPIPER CT SFR 1.00 593.83 463.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sandpiper Court 622-340-050 40906 SANDPIPER CT SFR 1.00 593.83 463.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sandpiper Court 622-340-051 40876 SANDPIPER CT SFR 1.00 593.83 463.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sandpiper Court 622-340-052 40844 SANDPIPER CT SFR 1.00 593.83 463.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sandpiper Court 622-340-053 40814 SANDPIPER CT SFR 1.00 593.83 463.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sandpiper Court 622-340-054 40782 SANDPIPER CT SFR 1.00 593.83 463.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sandpiper Court 622-340-055 40752 SANDPIPER CT SFR 1.00 593.83 463.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sandpiper Court 622-340-058 40755 W SANDPIPER CT SFR 1.00 589.28 451.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sandpiper West 622-340-059 40785 W SANDPIPER CT SFR 1.00 589.28 451.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sandpiper West 622-340-060 40819 W SANDPIPER CT SFR 1.00 589.28 451.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sandpiper West 622-340-061 40849 W SANDPIPER CT SFR 1.00 589.28 451.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sandpiper West 622-340-062 40881 W SANDPIPER CT SFR 1.00 589.28 451.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sandpiper West 622-340-063 40911 W SANDPIPER CT SFR 1.00 589.28 451.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sandpiper West 622-340-064 40943 W SANDPIPER CT SFR 1.00 589.28 451.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sandpiper West 622-340-065 40973 W SANDPIPER CT SFR 1.00 589.28 451.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sandpiper West 622-340-066 40970 W SANDPIPER CT SFR 1.00 589.28 451.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sandpiper West 622-340-067 40940 W SANDPIPER CT SFR 1.00 589.28 451.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sandpiper West 622-340-068 40908 W SANDPIPER CT SFR 1.00 589.28 451.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sandpiper West 622-340-069 40878 W SANDPIPER CT SFR 1.00 589.28 451.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sandpiper West 622-340-070 40846 W SANDPIPER CT SFR 1.00 589.28 451.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sandpiper West 622-340-071 40816 W SANDPIPER CT SFR 1.00 589.28 451.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sandpiper West 622-340-072 40784 SANDPIPPER CT SFR 1.00 589.28 451.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sandpiper West 622-340-073 40754 W SANDPIPER CT SFR 1.00 589.28 451.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sandpiper West 622-281-065 40755 SONATA CT SFR 1.00 503.82 503.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata I 622-281-066 40789 SONATA CT SFR 1.00 503.82 503.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata I 622-281-067 40823 SONATA CT SFR 1.00 503.82 503.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata I 622-281-068 40857 SONATA CT SFR 1.00 503.82 503.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata I 622-281-069 40891 SONATA CT SFR 1.00 503.82 503.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata I 622-281-070 40925 SONATA CT SFR 1.00 503.82 503.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata I 622-281-071 40959 SONATA CT SFR 1.00 503.82 503.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata I 622-281-072 40993 SONATA CT SFR 1.00 503.82 503.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata I 622-281-073 40990 SONATA CT SFR 1.00 503.82 503.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata I 622-281-074 40964 SONATA CT SFR 1.00 503.82 503.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata I 622-281-075 40930 SONATA CT SFR 1.00 503.82 503.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata I 622-281-076 40896 SONATA CT SFR 1.00 503.82 503.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata I 622-281-077 40862 SONATA CT SFR 1.00 503.82 503.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata I 622-281-078 40824 SONATA CT SFR 1.00 503.82 503.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata I 622-281-079 40794 SONATA CT SFR 1.00 503.82 503.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata I 622-281-080 40760 SONATA CT SFR 1.00 503.82 503.82 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata I 622-311-001 40785 POSADA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-311-002 40755 POSADA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-311-003 40735 POSADA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-311-004 40695 POSADA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-311-005 40665 POSADA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-311-006 40635 POSADA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-311-007 40605 POSADA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-311-008 40575 POSADA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-311-009 40520 POSADA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-311-010 40550 POSADA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-311-011 40580 POSADA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-311-012 40610 POSADA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-311-013 40640 POSADA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-311-014 40670 POSADA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-311-015 40735 VENTANA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-311-016 40695 VENTANA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-311-017 40665 VENTANA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-311-018 40635 VENTANA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-311-019 40605 VENTANA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-311-020 40575 VENTANA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-311-021 40520 VENTANA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-311-022 40550 VENTANA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-311-023 40580 VENTANA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-311-024 40610 VENTANA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-311-025 40640 VENTANA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-311-026 40670 VENTANA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-312-001 73455 TERRAZA DR SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 10 of 37 213 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 622-312-002 73441 TERRAZA DR SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-312-003 73435 TERRAZA DR SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-312-004 73421 TERRAZA DR SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-312-005 73413 TERRAZA DR SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-312-006 73401 TERRAZA DR SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-321-001 40681 TERRAZA DR SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-321-002 40653 TERRAZA DR SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-321-011 73504 TERRAZA DR SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-321-021 40632 VIA FONDA SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-321-022 40654 VIA FONDA SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-321-023 40686 VIA FONDA SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-321-024 40712 VIA FONDA SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-321-025 40744 VIA FONDA SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-321-027 73548 TERRAZA DR SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-321-028 73554 TERRAZA DR SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-321-029 73566 TERRAZA DR SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-321-030 40580 VIA FONDA SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-321-031 40600 VIA FONDA SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-321-032 40621 TERRAZA DR SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-321-033 40593 TERRAZA DR SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-321-034 40561 TERRAZA DR SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-321-035 40535 TERRAZA DR SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-321-036 73470 TERRAZA DR SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-321-037 73482 TERRAZA DR SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-321-038 73488 TERRAZA DR SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-321-039 73496 TERRAZA DR SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-321-040 73512 TERRAZA DR SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-321-041 73520 TERRAZA DR SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-321-042 73532 TERRAZA DR SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-321-043 73540 TERRAZA DR SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-006 40603 VIA FONDA SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-012 40746 CABANA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-024 40744 BARANDA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-036 40748 TERRAZA DR SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-037 73463 TERRAZA DR SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-038 40745 VIA FONDA SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-039 40715 VIA FONDA SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-040 40683 VIA FONDA SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-041 40657 VIA FONDA SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-042 40629 VIA FONDA SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-043 40590 CABANA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-044 40622 CABANA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-045 40650 CABANA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-046 40688 CABANA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-047 40716 CABANA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-048 40743 CABANA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-049 40711 CABANA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-050 40685 CABANA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-051 40651 CABANA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-052 40625 CABANA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-053 40595 CABANA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-054 40592 BARANDA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-055 40620 BARANDA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-056 40652 BARANDA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-057 40680 BARANDA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-058 40710 BARANDA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-059 40747 BARANDA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-060 40713 BARANDA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-061 40679 BARANDA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-062 40655 BARANDA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-063 40623 BARANDA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-064 40589 BARANDA CT SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-065 40598 TERRAZA DR SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-066 40630 TERRAZA DR SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-067 40660 TERRAZA DR SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-068 40690 TERRAZA DR SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 622-322-069 40720 TERRAZA DR SFR 1.00 190.68 190.68 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 624-340-001 74765 WARING CT SFR 1.00 665.84 361.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 07, Waring Court 624-340-002 74775 WARING CT SFR 1.00 665.84 361.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 07, Waring Court 624-340-003 74785 WARING CT SFR 1.00 665.84 361.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 07, Waring Court 624-340-004 74795 WARING CT SFR 1.00 665.84 361.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 07, Waring Court 624-340-005 74805 WARING CT SFR 1.00 665.84 361.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 07, Waring Court 624-340-006 74815 WARING CT SFR 1.00 665.84 361.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 07, Waring Court 624-340-007 74825 WARING CT SFR 1.00 665.84 361.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 07, Waring Court 624-340-008 74835 WARING CT SFR 1.00 665.84 361.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 07, Waring Court 624-340-009 74830 WARING CT SFR 1.00 665.84 361.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 07, Waring Court 624-340-010 74820 WARING CT SFR 1.00 665.84 361.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 07, Waring Court 624-340-011 74810 WARING CT SFR 1.00 665.84 361.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 07, Waring Court 624-340-012 74800 WARING CT SFR 1.00 665.84 361.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 07, Waring Court 624-340-013 74790 WARING CT SFR 1.00 665.84 361.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 07, Waring Court 624-340-014 74780 WARING CT SFR 1.00 665.84 361.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 07, Waring Court 624-340-015 74770 WARING CT SFR 1.00 665.84 361.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 07, Waring Court 624-340-016 74760 WARING CT SFR 1.00 665.84 361.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 07, Waring Court 624-352-001 74510 CORAL BELLS CIR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-002 74520 CORAL BELLS CIR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-003 NO SITUS ADDRESS SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-004 74540 CORAL BELLS CIR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-005 74550 CORAL BELLS CIR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-006 74560 CORAL BELLS CIR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-007 74570 CORAL BELLS CIR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-008 74580 CORAL BELLS CIR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-009 NO SITUS ADDRESS SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 11 of 37 214 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 624-352-010 74555 CORAL BELLS CIR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-011 74545 CORAL BELLS CIR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-012 74535 CORAL BELLS CIR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-013 74525 CORAL BELLS CIR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-014 74515 CORAL BELLS CIR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-015 74505 CORAL BELLS CIR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-016 74510 DAYLILY CIR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-017 74520 DAYLILY CIR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-018 74530 DAYLILY CIR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-019 74540 DAYLILY CIR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-020 74550 DAYLILY CIR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-021 74560 DAYLILY CIR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-022 74570 DAYLILY CIR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-023 74580 DAYLILY CIR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-024 74565 DAYLILY CIR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-025 74555 DAYLILY CIR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-026 74545 DAYLILY CIR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-027 74535 DAYLILY CIR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-028 74525 DAYLILY CIR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-029 74515 DAYLILY CIR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-030 74505 DAYLILY CIR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-031 74510 MOSS ROSE DR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-032 74520 MOSS ROSE DR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-033 74530 MOSS ROSE DR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-034 74540 MOSS ROSE DR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-035 74550 MOSS ROSE DR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-036 74560 MOSS ROSE DR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 624-352-037 74570 MOSS ROSE DR SFR 1.00 355.17 285.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 625-551-001 44375 INDIAN CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-551-002 44401 INDIAN CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-551-003 44425 INDIAN CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-551-004 44451 INDIAN CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-551-005 44475 INDIAN CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-551-006 44500 INDIAN CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-551-007 44476 INDIAN CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-551-008 44450 INDIAN CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-551-009 44426 INDIAN CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-551-010 44400 INDIAN CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-551-011 44376 INDIAN CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-551-012 44375 KINGS CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-551-013 44401 KINGS CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-551-014 44425 KINGS CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-551-015 44451 KINGS CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-551-016 44475 KINGS CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-551-017 44500 KINGS CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-551-018 44476 KINGS CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-551-019 44450 KINGS CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-551-020 44426 KINGS CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-551-021 44400 KINGS CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-551-022 44376 KINGS CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-552-001 44300 KINGS CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-552-002 44276 KINGS CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-552-003 44250 KINGS CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-552-004 44226 KINGS CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-552-005 44200 KINGS CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-552-006 44201 KINGS CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-552-007 44225 KINGS CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-552-008 44251 KINGS CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-552-009 44275 KINGS CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-552-010 44301 KINGS CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-552-011 44300 INDIAN CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-552-012 44276 INDIAN CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-552-013 44250 INDIAN CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-552-014 44226 INDIAN CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-552-015 44200 INDIAN CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-552-016 44201 INDIAN CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-552-017 44225 INDIAN CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-552-018 44251 INDIAN CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-552-019 44275 INDIAN CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-552-020 44301 INDIAN CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-552-021 44300 HAZEL CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-552-022 44276 HAZEL CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-552-023 44250 HAZEL CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-552-024 44226 HAZEL CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-552-025 44200 HAZEL CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-552-026 44201 HAZEL CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-552-027 44225 HAZEL CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-552-028 44251 HAZEL CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-552-029 44275 HAZEL CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-552-030 44301 HAZEL CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-552-031 44375 HAZEL CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-561-001 44376 HAZEL CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-561-002 44426 HAZEL CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-561-003 44450 HAZEL CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-561-004 44476 HAZEL CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-561-005 44500 HAZEL CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-561-006 44501 HAZEL CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-561-007 44475 HAZEL CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-561-008 44451 HAZEL CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-561-009 44425 HAZEL CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-561-010 44401 HAZEL CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-561-011 44426 GRAND CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 12 of 37 215 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 625-561-012 44450 GRAND CANYON DR SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-561-013 44476 GRAND CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-561-014 44500 GRAND CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-561-015 44501 GRAND CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-561-016 44475 GRAND CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-561-017 44451 GRAND CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-561-018 44425 GRAND CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-561-019 44410 SILVER CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-561-020 44440 SILVER CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-561-021 44470 SILVER CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-561-022 44481 SILVER CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-561-023 44469 SILVER CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-561-024 44441 SILVER CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-561-025 44409 SILVER CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-562-006 44225 GRAND CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-562-007 44219 GRAND CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-562-008 44220 GRAND CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-562-009 44226 GRAND CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-562-010 44250 GRAND CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-562-011 44276 GRAND CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-562-012 44300 GRAND CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-562-013 44378 GRAND CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-562-015 44401 GRAND CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-562-016 44375 GRAND CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-562-019 44251 GRAND CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-562-020 44367 SILVER CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-562-021 44343 SILVER CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-562-022 44319 SILVER CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-562-023 44293 SILVER CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-562-024 44269 SILVER CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-562-025 44243 SILVER CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-562-026 44217 SILVER CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-562-027 44218 SILVER CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-562-030 44292 SILVER CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-562-031 44316 SILVER CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-562-032 44340 SILVER CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-562-033 44364 SILVER CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-562-034 44301 GRAND CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-562-037 44275 GRAND CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-562-038 44268 SILVER CANYON LN ##17 SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 625-562-040 44244 SILVER CANYON LN SFR 1.00 326.36 206.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 627-122-015 73929 OLIVE CT SFR 1.00 301.10 188.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 11, Portola Place 627-122-016 73935 OLIVE CT SFR 1.00 301.10 188.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 11, Portola Place 627-122-017 73941 OLIVE CT SFR 1.00 301.10 188.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 11, Portola Place 627-122-018 73947 OLIVE CT SFR 1.00 301.10 188.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 11, Portola Place 627-122-019 73953 OLIVE CT SFR 1.00 301.10 188.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 11, Portola Place 627-122-020 73959 OLIVE CT SFR 1.00 301.10 188.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 11, Portola Place 627-122-021 73965 OLIVE CT SFR 1.00 301.10 188.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 11, Portola Place 627-122-022 73969 OLIVE CT SFR 1.00 301.10 188.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 11, Portola Place 627-122-023 73973 OLIVE CT SFR 1.00 301.10 188.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 11, Portola Place 627-122-024 73977 OLIVE CT SFR 1.00 301.10 188.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 11, Portola Place 627-122-025 73983 OLIVE CT SFR 1.00 301.10 188.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 11, Portola Place 627-122-026 73989 OLIVE CT SFR 1.00 301.10 188.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 11, Portola Place 627-122-027 73995 OLIVE CT SFR 1.00 301.10 188.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 11, Portola Place 627-123-001 73919 OLIVE CT SFR 1.00 301.10 188.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 11, Portola Place 627-123-002 73945 SANTA ROSA WAY SFR 1.00 301.10 188.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 11, Portola Place 627-123-003 73955 SANTA ROSA WAY SFR 1.00 301.10 188.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 11, Portola Place 627-123-004 73965 SANTA ROSA WAY SFR 1.00 301.10 188.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 11, Portola Place 627-123-005 73990 OLIVE CT SFR 1.00 301.10 188.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 11, Portola Place 627-123-006 73980 OLIVE CT SFR 1.00 301.10 188.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 11, Portola Place 627-123-007 73956 OLIVE CT SFR 1.00 301.10 188.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 11, Portola Place 627-123-008 73950 OLIVE CT SFR 1.00 301.10 188.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 11, Portola Place 627-123-009 73944 OLIVE CT SFR 1.00 301.10 188.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 11, Portola Place 627-123-010 73923 OLIVE CT SFR 1.00 301.10 188.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 11, Portola Place 009-000-805 77912 MICHIGAN DR ##A1 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-000-806 77912 MICHIGAN DR ##A2 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-000-807 77912 MICHIGAN DR ##A3A CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-000-808 77912 MICHIGAN DR ##A4A CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-000-809 77912 MICHIGAN DR ##A5A CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-000-810 77912 MICHIGAN DR ##A6A CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-000-811 77910 MICHIGAN DR ##AB CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-000-812 77910 MICHIGAN DR ##B CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-000-813 77910 MICHIGAN DR ##CB CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-000-814 77910 MICHIGAN DR ##DB CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-000-815 77910 MICHIGAN DR ##EB CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-000-816 77910 MICHIGAN DR ##FB CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-000-817 77910 MICHIGAN DR ##GB CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-000-818 77910 MICHIGAN DR ##HB CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-000-819 77900 MICHIGAN DR ##C1C CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-000-820 77900 MICHIGAN DR ##C2C CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-000-821 77900 MICHIGAN DR ##C3 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-000-822 77900 MICHIGAN DR ##C4C CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-000-823 77900 MICHIGAN DR ##C5C CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-000-824 77900 MICHIGAN DR ##C6C CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-000-825 77900 MICHIGAN DR ##C7C CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-000-826 77900 MICHIGAN DR ##C8C CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-000-827 77900 MICHIGAN DR ##C9 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-000-828 77900 MICHIGAN DR ##C10 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-000-829 77900 MICHIGAN DR ##C11C CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-000-830 77900 MICHIGAN DR ##C12C CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-612-940 77565 MICHIGAN DR ##1A CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-612-941 77565 MICHIGAN DR ##2B CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 13 of 37 216 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 009-612-942 77585 MICHIGAN DR ##1A CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-612-943 77585 MICHIGAN DR ##2B CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-612-944 77625 MICHIGAN DR ##1A CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-612-945 77625 MICHIGAN DR ##2B CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-612-946 77625 MICHIGAN DR ##3C CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-612-947 77625 MICHIGAN DR ##4D CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-612-948 77665 MICHIGAN DR ##1A CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-612-949 77665 MICHIGAN DR ##2B CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-612-950 77665 MICHIGAN DR ##3C CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-612-951 77665 MICHIGAN DR ##4D CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-612-952 77695 MICHIGAN DR ##1A CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-612-953 77695 MICHIGAN DR ##2B CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-612-954 77695 MICHIGAN DR ##3C CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-612-955 77695 MICHIGAN DR ##4D CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-612-956 77725 MICHIGAN DR ##1A CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-612-957 77725 MICHIGAN DR ##2B CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-612-958 77725 MICHIGAN DR ##3C CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-612-959 77725 MICHIGAN DR ##4D CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-612-960 77735 MICHIGAN DR ##1A CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-612-961 77735 MICHIGAN DR ##2B CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-612-962 77755 MICHIGAN DR ##1A CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 009-612-963 77755 MICHIGAN DR ##2B CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-020-006 NO SITUS ADDRESS REC 7.10 315.15 227.12 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-020-010 NO SITUS ADDRESS REC 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-020-011 NO SITUS ADDRESS REC 6.82 302.76 218.20 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-020-013 42240 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-020-015 NO SITUS ADDRESS REC 3.95 175.42 126.42 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-020-017 NO SITUS ADDRESS REC 2.93 130.14 93.78 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-020-019 NO SITUS ADDRESS REC 3.66 162.37 117.02 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-020-021 77245 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-031-001 42140 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-031-002 42160 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-031-003 42180 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-031-004 77040 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-031-005 77050 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-031-006 77060 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-031-007 77070 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-031-008 77080 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-031-009 77090 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-031-010 77100 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-031-011 77110 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-031-012 77120 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-031-013 77130 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-031-014 77140 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-031-015 77150 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-031-016 77160 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-031-017 77170 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-031-018 77180 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-031-019 77190 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-031-020 77200 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-031-021 77210 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-032-001 42280 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-032-002 42260 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-032-003 42240 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-032-004 77045 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-032-005 77055 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-032-006 77075 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-032-007 77085 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-032-008 77095 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-032-009 77105 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-032-010 77115 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-032-011 77125 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-032-012 77135 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-032-013 77145 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-032-014 77155 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-032-015 77165 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-032-016 77175 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-032-017 77185 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-032-018 77195 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-032-019 77205 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-032-020 77215 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-033-002 42145 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-033-003 42155 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-033-004 42165 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-033-005 42175 KANSAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-033-006 42245 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-033-007 42255 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-033-008 42265 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-033-009 42275 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-033-010 42305 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-033-011 42335 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-034-001 42240 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-034-002 42260 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-034-003 42245 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-034-004 42280 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-034-005 42300 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-034-006 42330 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-034-007 42265 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-034-008 42285 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-034-009 42305 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-041-001 77220 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-041-002 77230 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 14 of 37 217 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 637-041-003 77240 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-041-004 77250 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-041-005 77260 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-041-006 77270 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-041-007 77280 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-041-008 77290 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-041-009 77300 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-041-010 77320 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-041-011 77340 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-041-012 77360 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-041-013 77380 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-042-001 77500 MICHIGAN DR MFR 25.60 1136.64 819.20 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-043-001 77225 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-043-002 77235 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-043-003 77245 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-043-004 77255 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-043-005 77265 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-043-006 77275 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-043-007 77285 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-043-008 77295 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-043-009 77305 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-043-010 77325 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-043-011 77345 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-043-012 77365 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-043-013 77385 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-043-014 NO SITUS ADDRESS SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-043-015 NO SITUS ADDRESS SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-044-006 77405 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-044-007 77419 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-044-008 77431 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-044-009 77445 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-044-010 77457 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-044-011 77469 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-044-012 77481 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-045-001 77260 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-045-002 77270 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-045-003 77280 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-045-004 77290 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-045-005 77300 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-045-006 77310 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-045-007 77320 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-045-008 77330 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-045-009 77340 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-045-010 77350 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-045-011 77360 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-045-012 77370 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-045-013 77380 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-046-001 77265 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-046-002 77275 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-046-003 77285 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-046-004 77295 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-046-005 77305 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-046-006 77315 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-046-007 77325 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-046-008 77335 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-046-009 77345 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-046-010 77355 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-046-011 77365 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-046-012 77375 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-046-013 77385 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-046-014 42325 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-046-015 42345 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-046-016 42365 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-047-001 42260 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-047-002 42280 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-047-003 42300 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-047-004 42320 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-047-005 42340 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-047-006 42360 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-047-008 42380 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-051-001 77600 MICHIGAN DR MFR 51.20 2273.28 1638.40 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-051-002 77800 MICHIGAN DR MFR 70.40 3125.76 2252.80 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-052-012 77493 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-052-013 77507 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-052-014 77519 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-052-015 77533 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-052-016 77547 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-052-017 77559 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-061-001 42125 IDAHO ST MFR 51.20 2273.28 1638.40 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-062-001 77775 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-062-002 77785 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-062-003 77795 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-062-004 77805 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-062-005 77815 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-062-006 77825 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-062-007 77835 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-062-008 77845 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-062-009 77855 MICHIGAN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-001 77805 CALIFORNIA DR ##A1 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-002 77805 CALIFORNIA DR ##A2 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-003 77805 CALIFORNIA DR ##A3 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-004 77805 CALIFORNIA DR ##A4 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 15 of 37 218 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 637-063-005 77805 CALIFORNIA DR ##A5 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-006 77805 CALIFORNIA DR ##A6 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-007 77805 CALIFORNIA DR ##A7 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-008 77805 CALIFORNIA DR ##A8 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-009 77805 CALIFORNIA DR ##A9 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-010 77805 CALIFORNIA DR ##A12 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-011 77805 CALIFORNIA DR ##A11 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-012 77805 CALIFORNIA DR ##A10 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-013 77815 CALIFORNIA DR ##B1 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-014 77815 CALIFORNIA DR ##B2 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-015 77815 CALIFORNIA LN ##B3 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-016 77815 CALIFORNIA DR ##B4 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-017 77815 CALIFORNIA DR ##B5 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-018 77815 CALIFORNIA DR ##B6 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-019 77815 CALIFORNIA DR ##B7 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-020 77815 CALIFORNIA DR ##B8 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-021 77815 CALIFORNIA DR ##B9 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-022 77815 CALIFORNIA DR ##B12 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-023 77815 CALIFORNIA DR ##B11 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-024 77815 CALIFORNIA DR ##B10 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-025 77835 CALIFORNIA DR ##C1 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-026 77835 CALIFORNIA DR ##C2 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-027 77835 CALIFORNIA DR ##C3 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-028 77835 CALIFORNIA DR ##C4 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-029 77835 CALIFORNIA DR ##C5 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-030 77835 CALIFORNIA DR ##C6 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-031 77835 CALIFORNIA DR ##C7 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-032 77835 CALIFORNIA DR ##C8 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-033 77835 CALIFORNIA DR ##C9 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-034 77835 CALIFORNIA DR ##C12 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-035 77835 CALIFORNIA DR ##C11 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-036 77835 CALIFORNIA DR ##C10 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-037 77845 CALIFORNIA DR ##D1 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-038 77845 CALIFORNIA DR ##D2 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-039 77845 CALIFORNIA DR ##D3 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-040 77845 CALIFORNIA DR ##D4 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-041 77845 CALIFORNIA DR ##D5 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-042 77845 CALIFORNIA DR ##D6 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-043 77845 CALIFORNIA DR ##D7 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-044 77845 CALIFORNIA DR ##D8 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-045 77845 CALIFORNIA DR ##D9 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-046 77845 CALIFORNIA DR ##D12 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-047 77845 CALIFORNIA DR ##D11 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-048 77845 CALIFORNIA DR ##D10 CON 0.80 35.52 25.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-050 77765 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-051 77755 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-052 77745 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-053 77735 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-063-054 77725 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-071-005 42355 WASHINGTON ST COM 2.82 125.21 90.24 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-071-006 42455 WASHINGTON ST COM 3.54 157.18 113.28 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-071-007 42500 WASHINGTON ST COM 3.48 154.51 111.36 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-081-001 77500 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-081-002 77510 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-081-003 77520 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-081-004 77530 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-081-005 77540 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-081-006 77550 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-081-007 77560 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-081-008 77570 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-081-009 77580 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-081-010 77590 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-081-011 77600 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-081-012 77610 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-081-013 77620 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-081-014 77630 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-081-015 77640 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-081-016 77650 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-081-017 77660 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-081-018 77670 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-081-019 77680 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-081-020 NO SITUS ADDRESS REC 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-081-022 42420 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-081-024 42400 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-082-001 77515 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-082-002 77525 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-082-003 77535 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-082-004 77545 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-082-005 77555 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-082-006 77565 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-082-007 77575 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-082-008 77585 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-082-009 77595 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-082-010 77605 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-082-011 77615 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-082-012 77625 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-082-013 77635 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-082-014 77645 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-082-015 77655 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-082-016 77665 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-082-017 77675 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-082-018 77695 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 16 of 37 219 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 637-082-019 77715 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-091-001 42355 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-091-002 42385 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-091-003 42405 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-091-004 42425 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-091-005 42445 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-091-006 42465 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-091-007 42485 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-091-008 42505 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-091-009 42525 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-091-010 42535 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-091-011 42555 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-092-001 42350 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-092-002 42380 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-092-003 42400 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-092-004 42420 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-092-005 42440 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-092-006 42460 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-092-007 42480 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-092-008 42500 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-092-009 42520 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-092-010 42540 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-092-011 42560 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-093-001 42300 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-093-002 42320 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-093-003 42340 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-093-004 77140 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-093-005 77150 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-093-006 77160 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-093-007 77170 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-093-008 77180 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-093-009 77190 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-093-010 77200 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-093-011 77210 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-093-012 77220 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-093-013 77230 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-093-014 77240 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-093-015 77250 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-094-001 42365 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-094-002 42385 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-094-003 42405 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-094-004 42425 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-094-005 42445 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-094-006 42465 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-094-007 42475 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-094-008 42495 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-094-009 42505 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-094-010 42525 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-094-011 42545 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-095-001 77145 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-095-002 77155 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-095-003 77165 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-095-004 42400 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-095-005 42420 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-095-006 42440 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-095-007 42460 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-095-008 42480 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-095-009 42500 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-095-010 42520 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-095-011 42540 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-095-012 42405 IOWA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-095-013 42425 IOWA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-095-014 42445 IOWA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-095-015 42465 IOWA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-095-016 42485 IOWA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-095-017 42505 IOWA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-095-018 42525 IOWA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-095-019 42545 IOWA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-096-001 77185 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-096-002 77195 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-096-003 77205 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-096-004 77215 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-096-005 77225 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-096-006 77235 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-096-007 77245 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-096-008 77255 MINNESOTA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-096-009 42400 IOWA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-096-010 42420 IOWA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-096-011 42440 IOWA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-096-012 42460 IOWA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-096-013 42480 IOWA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-096-014 42500 IOWA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-096-015 42520 IOWA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-096-016 42540 IOWA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-101-001 42575 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-101-002 42595 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-101-003 42615 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-101-004 42635 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-101-005 42655 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-101-006 42675 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-101-007 42695 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-101-008 42725 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 17 of 37 220 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 637-101-009 42745 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-101-010 42775 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-102-001 42580 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-102-002 42600 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-102-003 42620 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-102-004 42640 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-102-005 42660 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-102-006 42680 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-102-007 42700 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-102-008 42730 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-102-009 42760 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-111-003 42835 CONNECTICUT ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-111-004 42865 CONNECTICUT ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-111-005 42875 CONNECTICUT ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-111-006 42925 CONNECTICUT ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-111-007 42945 CONNECTICUT ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-111-008 42955 CONNECTICUT ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-111-009 42975 CONNECTICUT ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-111-010 42995 CONNECTICUT ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-111-011 43005 CONNECTICUT ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-111-012 43015 CONNECTICUT ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-111-013 43021 CONNECTICUT ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-111-014 42805 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-111-015 77010 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-111-016 77020 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-112-001 42930 CONNECTICUT ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-112-002 42950 CONNECTICUT ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-112-003 42970 CONNECTICUT ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-112-004 42990 CONNECTICUT ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-112-005 43000 CONNECTICUT ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-112-006 43020 CONNECTICUT ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-112-007 77070 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-112-008 77080 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-112-009 77090 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-112-010 42845 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-112-011 42875 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-112-012 42905 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-112-013 42915 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-112-014 42935 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-112-015 42955 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-112-016 42985 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-113-001 42790 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-113-002 42820 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-113-003 42850 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-113-004 42880 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-113-005 42900 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-113-006 42920 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-113-007 42940 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-113-008 42960 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-113-009 42980 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-113-010 43000 WISCONSIN AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-113-011 77130 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-113-012 77150 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-113-013 77160 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-113-014 77170 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-113-015 77180 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-114-001 77184 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-114-002 77183 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-114-003 77182 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-114-004 77181 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-114-005 77180 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-114-006 77179 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-114-007 77178 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-114-008 77176 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-115-001 77095 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-115-002 77085 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-115-003 77075 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-115-004 77065 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-115-005 77061 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-115-006 77055 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-115-007 77051 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-115-008 77045 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-115-009 77041 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-115-010 77031 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-115-011 77025 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-121-001 42565 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-121-002 42585 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-121-003 42605 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-121-004 42615 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-121-005 42625 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-121-006 42635 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-121-007 42655 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-121-008 42675 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-121-009 42695 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-121-010 42715 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-121-011 42735 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-121-012 42755 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-121-013 42775 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-121-014 42795 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-121-015 42815 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-122-001 42560 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-122-002 42580 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 18 of 37 221 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 637-122-003 42600 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-122-004 42620 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-122-005 42640 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-122-006 42660 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-122-007 42680 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-122-008 42700 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-122-009 42720 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-122-010 42740 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-122-011 42760 KANSAS ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-122-012 77210 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-122-013 77220 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-122-014 77230 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-122-015 42705 IOWA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-122-016 42695 IOWA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-122-017 42675 IOWA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-122-018 42665 IOWA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-122-019 42645 IOWA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-122-020 42625 IOWA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-122-021 42605 IOWA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-122-022 42585 IOWA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-122-023 42565 IOWA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-123-001 42560 IOWA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-123-002 42580 IOWA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-123-003 42600 IOWA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-123-004 42620 IOWA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-123-005 42640 IOWA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-123-006 42660 IOWA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-123-007 42680 IOWA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-123-008 42700 IOWA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-123-009 42720 IOWA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-124-001 77235 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-124-002 77225 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-124-003 42900 MASSACHUSETTS CT SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-124-004 42920 MASSACHUSETTS CT SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-124-005 42940 MASSACHUSETTS CT SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-124-006 42960 MASSACHUSETTS CT SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-124-007 42980 MASSACHUSETTS CT SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-124-008 43000 MASSACHUSETTS CT SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-124-009 43005 MASSACHUSETTS CT SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-124-010 42985 MASSACHUSETTS CT SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-124-011 42965 MASSACHUSETTS CT SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-124-012 42945 MASSACHUSETTS CT SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-124-013 42925 MASSACHUSETTS CT SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-124-014 42895 MASSACHUSETTS CT SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-124-015 42875 MASSACHUSETTS CT SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-124-016 77205 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-124-017 77195 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-124-018 77185 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-131-001 77286 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-131-002 77290 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-131-003 77294 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-131-004 77298 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-131-005 77302 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-131-006 77306 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-131-007 77310 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-131-008 77314 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-131-009 77318 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-131-010 77322 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-131-011 77326 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-131-012 77330 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-131-013 77334 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-131-014 77338 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-131-015 77340 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-131-016 77350 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-131-017 77360 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-131-018 77370 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-131-019 77380 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-131-020 77390 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-131-021 77400 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-131-022 77410 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-131-023 42445 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-131-024 42435 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-131-025 42415 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-131-026 42375 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-131-027 42395 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-132-001 77305 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-132-002 77315 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-132-003 77325 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-132-004 77335 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-132-005 77330 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-132-006 77320 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-132-007 77310 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-132-008 77300 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-133-001 77346 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-133-002 77355 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-133-003 77365 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-133-004 77375 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-133-005 77385 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-133-006 77395 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-133-007 77405 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-133-008 42505 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-133-009 42535 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 19 of 37 222 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 637-133-010 42565 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-133-011 42605 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-133-012 77410 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-133-013 77400 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-133-014 77390 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-133-015 77380 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-133-016 77370 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-133-017 77360 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-133-018 77350 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-134-001 77255 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-134-002 77265 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-134-003 77275 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-134-004 77285 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-134-005 77295 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-134-006 77305 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-134-007 77309 RHODE ISLAND CT SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-134-008 77315 RHODE ISLAND CT SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-134-009 77319 RHODE ISLAND CT SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-134-010 77325 RHODE ISLAND CT SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-134-011 77329 RHODE ISLAND CT SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-134-012 77347 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-134-013 77349 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-134-014 77351 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-134-015 77353 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-134-016 77355 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-134-017 77361 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-134-018 77365 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-134-019 77375 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-134-020 77385 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-134-021 77395 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-134-022 77405 MISSOURI DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-134-023 42635 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-134-024 42665 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-134-025 42705 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-134-026 42755 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-141-001 42785 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-141-002 42815 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-141-003 42825 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-141-004 42845 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-141-005 42905 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-141-006 42915 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-141-007 42925 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-141-008 42935 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-141-009 42945 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-141-010 42955 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-141-011 42965 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-141-012 42975 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-141-013 42985 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-141-014 42995 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-141-015 42999 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-141-016 43005 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-141-017 43009 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-141-018 43015 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-142-001 42900 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-142-002 42910 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-142-003 42920 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-142-004 42930 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-142-005 42940 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-142-006 42960 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-142-007 42970 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-142-008 42980 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-142-009 42990 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-142-010 43000 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-142-011 43010 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-142-012 43030 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-142-013 43005 DELAWARE ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-142-014 42995 DELAWARE ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-142-015 42985 DELAWARE ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-142-016 42975 DELAWARE ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-142-017 42955 DELAWARE ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-142-018 42935 DELAWARE ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-142-019 42925 DELAWARE ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-142-020 42905 DELAWARE ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-142-021 42895 DELAWARE ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-190-009 77120 CALIFORNIA DR MFR 60.80 2699.52 1945.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-190-010 NO SITUS ADDRESS REC 7.51 333.40 240.28 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-190-011 NO SITUS ADDRESS REC 3.96 175.82 126.72 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-190-012 43740 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-190-016 NO SITUS ADDRESS REC 3.93 174.49 125.76 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-190-018 77200 CALIFORNIA DR COM 28.56 1268.06 913.92 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-190-021 NO SITUS ADDRESS REC 2.90 128.94 92.92 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-190-025 76726 KENTUCKY AVE REC 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-190-027 NO SITUS ADDRESS REC 1.84 81.78 58.94 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-190-028 43607 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-190-029 76719 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-190-032 43530 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-190-037 43615 ELKHORN TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-190-038 43610 ELKHORN TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-190-040 NO SITUS ADDRESS REC 3.99 177.02 127.58 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-202-006 43360 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-202-007 43380 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-202-008 43400 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 20 of 37 223 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 637-202-009 77010 UTAH CIR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-202-010 77020 UTAH CIR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-202-011 77030 UTAH CIR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-202-012 77040 UTAH CIR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-202-013 77039 UTAH CIR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-202-014 77029 UTAH CIR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-202-015 43470 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-202-016 43490 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-202-018 43510 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-202-019 43350 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-203-001 43365 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-203-002 43385 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-203-003 43405 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-203-004 43425 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-203-005 43445 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-203-006 43465 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-203-007 43485 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-203-008 43505 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-203-009 43325 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-203-010 43345 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-211-001 77175 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-211-002 43020 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-211-003 43040 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-211-004 43060 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-211-005 43080 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-211-006 43100 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-211-007 43120 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-211-008 43140 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-211-009 43160 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-211-010 43180 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-211-011 43200 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-211-012 43220 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-211-013 43240 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-211-014 43260 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-211-015 43280 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-211-016 43300 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-211-017 43320 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-211-018 43340 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-211-019 43360 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-212-001 77165 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-212-002 77161 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-212-003 43065 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-212-004 43085 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-212-005 43105 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-212-006 43125 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-212-007 43145 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-212-008 43185 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-212-009 43205 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-212-010 43235 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-212-011 43255 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-212-012 43275 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-212-013 43305 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-212-014 43325 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-212-015 43345 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-212-016 43365 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-221-001 43029 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-221-002 43035 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-221-003 43049 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-221-004 43065 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-221-005 43085 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-221-006 43105 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-221-007 43115 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-221-008 43135 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-221-009 43155 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-221-010 43175 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-221-011 77330 WYOMING AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-221-012 77320 WYOMING AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-221-013 77310 WYOMING AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-222-001 43050 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-222-002 43070 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-222-003 43090 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-222-004 43110 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-222-005 43120 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-222-006 43140 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-222-007 43160 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-222-008 43180 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-222-009 43045 DELAWARE ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-222-010 43085 DELAWARE ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-222-011 43105 DELAWARE ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-222-012 43125 DELAWARE ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-222-013 43135 DELAWARE ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-222-014 43155 DELAWARE ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-222-015 43175 DELAWARE ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-223-001 42900 DELAWARE ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-223-002 42920 DELAWARE ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-223-003 42940 DELAWARE ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-223-004 42960 DELAWARE ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-223-005 42980 DELAWARE ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-223-006 43000 DELAWARE ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-223-007 43100 DELAWARE ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-223-008 43120 DELAWARE ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-223-009 43140 DELAWARE ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 21 of 37 224 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 637-223-010 43160 DELAWARE ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-223-011 77450 WYOMING AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-223-012 77470 WYOMING AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-223-013 43125 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-223-014 43095 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-223-015 43065 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-223-016 43035 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-223-017 43005 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-223-018 42985 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-231-001 43385 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-231-002 43405 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-231-003 43415 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-231-004 43425 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-231-005 43435 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-231-006 43445 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-231-007 43455 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-231-008 43465 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-232-001 43380 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-232-002 43400 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-232-003 43410 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-232-004 43420 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-232-005 43430 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-232-006 43440 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-232-007 43450 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-232-008 43460 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-232-009 43470 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-233-001 77325 WYOMING AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-233-002 77335 WYOMING AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-233-003 43195 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-233-004 43205 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-233-005 43215 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-233-006 43235 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-233-007 43255 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-233-008 43285 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-233-009 43305 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-233-010 43325 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-233-011 43345 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-233-012 43365 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-233-013 43385 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-233-014 43405 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-233-015 43425 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-233-016 77295 WYOMING AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-233-017 77305 WYOMING AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-234-001 43200 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-234-002 43210 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-234-003 43220 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-234-004 43240 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-234-005 43260 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-234-006 43280 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-234-007 43300 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-234-008 43320 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-234-009 43340 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-234-010 43360 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-234-011 43380 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-234-012 43400 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-234-013 43420 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-234-014 43440 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-234-015 77475 WYOMING AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-234-016 77455 WYOMING AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-234-017 77425 WYOMING AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-234-018 43205 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-234-019 43225 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-234-020 43245 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-234-021 43265 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-234-022 43285 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-234-023 43305 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-234-024 43325 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-234-025 43345 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-234-026 43365 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-234-027 43385 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-234-028 43405 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-234-029 43425 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-234-030 43445 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-234-031 43465 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-241-001 77110 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-241-002 77120 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-241-003 77130 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-241-004 77140 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-241-005 77150 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-241-006 77160 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-241-007 77170 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-241-008 77180 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-241-009 77190 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-241-010 77200 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-242-001 77220 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-242-002 77230 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-242-003 77240 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-242-004 77250 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-242-005 77260 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-243-001 77280 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-243-002 77290 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-243-003 77300 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 22 of 37 225 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 637-243-004 77310 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-244-001 77105 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-244-002 77115 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-244-003 77125 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-244-004 77135 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-244-005 77145 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-244-006 77078 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-244-007 77074 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-244-008 77070 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-244-009 77066 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-244-010 77062 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-244-011 77058 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-245-001 77057 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-245-002 77061 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-245-003 77065 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-245-004 77069 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-245-005 77073 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-245-006 77077 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-245-007 77215 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-245-008 77225 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-245-009 77235 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-245-010 77245 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-245-011 77255 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-245-012 77265 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-246-001 77285 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-246-002 77295 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-246-003 77305 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-246-004 43501 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-246-005 43511 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-246-006 43521 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-246-007 43530 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-246-008 43520 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-246-009 43510 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-246-010 43500 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-246-011 43490 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-246-012 43480 ILLINOIS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-251-001 77010 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-251-002 77010 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-251-003 76998 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-251-004 43671 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-251-005 43655 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-252-001 77030 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-252-002 77040 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-252-003 77050 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-252-004 77060 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-252-005 77070 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-252-006 77080 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-252-007 77090 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-252-008 77100 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-253-001 77031 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-253-002 77041 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-253-003 77045 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-253-004 77055 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-253-005 77065 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-253-006 77071 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-253-007 77075 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-253-008 77081 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-253-009 77085 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-253-010 77095 INDIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-253-011 77014 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-253-012 77018 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-253-013 77022 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-253-014 77026 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-253-015 77030 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-253-016 77034 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-253-017 77038 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-253-018 77042 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-253-019 77046 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-253-020 77050 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-253-021 77054 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-254-001 77011 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-254-002 77015 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-254-003 77017 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-254-004 77021 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-254-005 77025 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-254-006 77027 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-254-007 77031 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-254-008 77033 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-254-009 77037 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-254-010 77041 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-254-011 77045 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-254-012 77049 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-254-013 77053 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-255-001 77009 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-255-002 77007 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-255-003 43725 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-255-004 43771 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-261-001 76998 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-261-002 43845 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-262-001 43770 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-262-004 77030 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-262-005 77040 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 23 of 37 226 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 637-262-006 77050 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-262-007 77060 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-262-008 77070 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-262-009 77080 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-262-010 77090 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-262-011 77100 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-262-012 77110 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-262-013 77120 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-262-014 77130 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-262-015 77140 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-262-016 77150 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-262-017 77160 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-262-018 77170 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-262-021 43800 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-262-022 77180 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-263-001 77025 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-263-002 77035 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-263-003 77045 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-263-004 77055 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-263-017 77185 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-263-018 77175 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-263-019 77165 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-263-020 77155 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-263-021 77145 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-263-022 77125 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-263-023 77115 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-263-024 77105 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-263-025 77095 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-263-026 77085 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-263-027 77075 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-263-028 77065 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-271-001 43765 LOUISIANA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-271-002 43755 LOUISIANA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-271-003 43725 LOUISIANA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-271-004 43719 LOUISIANA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-271-005 43715 LOUISIANA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-271-006 43709 LOUISIANA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-271-007 43705 LOUISIANA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-271-008 43695 LOUISIANA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-271-009 43685 LOUISIANA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-271-010 43675 LOUISIANA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-271-011 43665 LOUISIANA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-271-012 43655 LOUISIANA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-271-014 43635 ELKHORN TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-272-001 43650 LOUISIANA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-272-002 43670 LOUISIANA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-272-003 NO SITUS ADDRESS SFV 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-272-004 43690 LOUISIANA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-272-005 43700 LOUISIANA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-272-006 43710 LOUISIANA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-272-007 43720 LOUISIANA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-272-008 43730 LOUISIANA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-272-009 77210 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-272-010 77220 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-272-011 77230 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-272-012 77250 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-272-013 77261 OHIO CIR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-272-014 77271 OHIO CIR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-272-015 77281 OHIO CIR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-272-016 77290 OHIO CIR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-272-017 77304 OHIO CIR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-272-018 77310 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-272-019 77320 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-272-020 77330 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-272-021 77340 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-272-022 43785 ELKHORN TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-272-023 43765 ELKHORN TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-272-024 43745 ELKHORN TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-272-025 43725 ELKHORN DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-272-026 43705 ELKHORN TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-272-027 43685 ELKHORN TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-273-002 43640 ELKHORN TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-273-003 43660 ELKHORN TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-273-004 43680 ELKHORN TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-273-005 43700 ELKHORN TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-273-006 43720 ELKHORN TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-273-007 43740 ELKHORN TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-273-008 43760 ELKHORN TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-273-009 43780 ELKHORN TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-273-016 43620 ELKHORN TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-274-006 77245 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-274-009 77295 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-274-013 77341 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-274-014 77333 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-274-015 77305 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-274-016 77265 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-274-017 77255 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-274-018 77235 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-274-019 77225 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-274-020 77215 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-274-021 77205 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-274-022 77195 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 24 of 37 227 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 637-281-002 43445 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-281-003 43465 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-281-004 43485 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-281-005 43505 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-281-006 43523 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-281-007 NO SITUS ADDRESS SFV 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-281-008 43565 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-281-009 43585 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-281-010 43605 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-281-011 43625 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-281-012 43645 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-281-013 43665 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-281-014 NO SITUS ADDRESS SFV 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-281-015 43705 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-281-016 43725 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-282-001 43485 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-282-002 43505 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-282-003 43525 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-282-004 43545 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-282-005 43565 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-282-006 43585 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-282-007 43605 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-282-008 43625 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-282-009 43645 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-282-010 43665 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-282-011 43685 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-282-012 43705 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-282-013 43725 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-282-014 43745 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-282-015 43765 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-282-024 43750 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-282-025 43720 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-282-026 43700 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-282-027 43680 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-282-028 43660 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-282-029 43640 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-282-030 43620 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-282-031 43600 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-282-032 43580 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-282-033 43560 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-282-034 43540 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-282-035 43520 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-282-036 43500 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-282-037 43480 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-282-038 43460 TEXAS AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-290-002 43564 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-290-003 43590 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-290-004 43622 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-290-005 43650 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-290-006 43684 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-290-007 43710 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-290-008 43736 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-290-009 43760 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-290-010 43794 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-290-011 43830 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-290-012 43862 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-290-013 43890 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-290-014 43922 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-290-015 43950 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-290-017 43530 WARNER TRL SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-320-047 43400 WARNER TRL COM 6.72 298.37 215.04 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-361-001 NO SITUS ADDRESS SFV 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-361-002 76540 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-361-003 76550 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-361-004 76560 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-361-005 76572 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-361-006 76586 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-361-007 76596 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-361-008 76608 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-361-009 76622 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-361-010 76634 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-361-011 76648 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-361-012 76658 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-361-013 76670 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-361-014 76684 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-361-015 76696 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-361-016 76706 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-361-017 76716 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-361-018 76726 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-361-019 76738 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-362-001 76510 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-362-003 43131 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-362-004 43161 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-362-005 43181 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-362-006 43211 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-362-007 43241 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-362-008 43281 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-362-009 43301 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-362-010 43331 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-362-011 43351 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-362-012 43381 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-362-014 43101 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 25 of 37 228 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 637-363-001 43371 ALABAMA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-363-002 43341 ALABAMA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-363-003 76567 HAWAII CIR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-363-004 76551 HAWAII CIR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-363-005 76540 HAWAII CIR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-363-006 76554 HAWAII CIR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-363-007 43231 ALABAMA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-363-008 43175 ALABAMA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-363-009 76589 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-363-010 76579 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-363-011 76567 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-363-012 76555 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-363-013 76545 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-363-014 43100 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-363-015 43130 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-363-016 43160 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-363-017 43180 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-363-018 43210 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-363-019 43240 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-363-020 43280 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-363-021 43300 VIRGINIA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-364-001 76735 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-364-002 76723 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-364-003 76713 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-364-004 76701 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-364-005 76693 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-364-006 76677 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-364-007 76667 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-364-008 76653 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-364-009 76643 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-364-010 76631 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-364-011 76623 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-364-012 43158 ALABAMA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-364-013 43188 ALABAMA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-364-014 43220 ALABAMA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-364-015 43250 ALABAMA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-364-016 43280 ALABAMA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-364-017 43310 ALABAMA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-364-018 43340 ALABAMA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-364-019 43370 ALABAMA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-364-020 43400 ALABAMA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-364-021 43420 ALABAMA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-364-022 43360 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-364-023 43390 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-371-001 76752 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-371-002 76762 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-371-003 76776 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-371-004 76788 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-371-005 76800 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-371-006 76812 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-371-007 76822 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-371-008 76832 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-371-009 76842 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-371-010 76852 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-371-011 76862 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-371-012 76872 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-371-013 76884 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-371-014 76896 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-371-015 76908 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-371-016 76920 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-371-017 76932 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-371-018 76944 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-371-019 76956 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-371-020 76968 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-371-021 76980 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-371-022 76994 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-372-001 76995 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-372-002 76983 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-372-003 76975 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-372-004 76963 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-372-005 76951 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-372-006 76941 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-372-007 76927 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-372-008 76917 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-372-009 76903 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-372-010 76891 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-372-011 76881 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-372-012 76869 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-372-013 76859 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-372-014 76849 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-372-015 76839 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-372-016 76829 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-372-017 76819 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-372-018 76809 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-372-019 76795 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-372-020 76785 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-372-021 76773 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-372-022 76759 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-372-023 76751 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-372-024 77005 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-372-025 77015 NEW YORK AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-381-001 43401 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 26 of 37 229 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 637-381-002 43421 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-381-003 43441 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-381-004 43471 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-381-005 43491 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-381-006 43509 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-381-007 43523 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-381-008 43541 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-381-009 43553 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-381-010 43565 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-381-011 43591 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-381-012 43611 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-381-013 43633 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-381-014 43651 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-381-015 43667 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-381-016 43685 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-381-017 43701 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-381-018 43717 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-381-019 43731 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-381-020 43745 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-381-021 43755 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-381-022 43769 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-382-001 43410 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-382-002 43430 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-382-003 43460 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-382-004 43480 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-382-005 43500 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-382-006 43516 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-382-007 43534 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-382-008 43548 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-382-009 43562 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-382-010 43586 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-382-011 43602 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-382-012 43620 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-382-013 43644 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-382-014 43656 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-382-015 43674 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-382-016 43690 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-382-017 43708 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-382-018 43726 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-382-019 43744 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-382-020 43770 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-391-001 42020 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-391-002 42050 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-391-003 42100 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-391-004 42140 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-391-005 42180 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-391-006 42210 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-391-007 42230 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-391-008 42250 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-391-009 42270 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-391-010 42290 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-391-011 42310 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-391-012 42340 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-391-013 42380 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-391-014 42400 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-391-015 42430 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-391-016 42460 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-391-017 42500 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-391-018 42530 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-391-019 42570 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-391-020 42610 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-391-021 42630 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-391-022 42650 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-391-023 42680 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-391-024 42700 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-391-025 42720 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-391-026 42750 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-391-027 42770 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-391-028 42790 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-392-001 42635 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-392-002 42575 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-392-003 42535 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-392-004 42505 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-392-005 42465 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-392-006 42435 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-392-007 42395 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-392-008 42345 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-392-009 42315 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-392-010 42295 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-392-011 42275 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-392-012 42255 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-392-013 42235 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-392-014 42215 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-392-015 42185 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-392-016 42145 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-392-017 42105 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-392-018 42055 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-392-019 76690 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-392-020 76716 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-392-021 76724 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-392-022 76732 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-392-023 76740 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 27 of 37 230 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 637-392-024 76748 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-392-025 76756 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-392-026 76762 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-392-027 76768 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-392-028 76772 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-392-029 76776 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-392-030 76780 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-392-031 76786 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-392-032 76790 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-392-033 76796 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-392-034 76804 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-393-001 42775 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-393-002 42755 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-393-003 42725 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-393-004 42685 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-393-005 76812 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-393-006 76820 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-393-007 76828 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-394-001 76827 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-394-002 76819 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-394-003 76811 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-394-004 76803 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-394-005 76795 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-394-006 76787 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-394-007 76779 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-394-008 76771 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-394-009 76763 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-394-010 76755 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-394-011 76747 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-394-012 76739 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-394-013 76731 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-394-014 76723 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-394-015 76715 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-394-016 76699 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-401-001 42810 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-401-002 42840 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-401-003 42860 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-401-004 42880 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-401-005 42900 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-401-006 42930 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-401-007 42970 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-401-008 43020 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-401-009 43040 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-401-010 43060 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-401-011 43080 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-401-012 43100 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-401-013 43120 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-401-014 43140 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-401-015 43160 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-401-016 43180 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-401-017 43200 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-401-018 43220 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-401-019 43240 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-401-020 43260 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-401-021 43280 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-402-001 42795 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-402-002 42815 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-402-003 42845 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-402-004 42875 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-402-005 42895 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-402-006 42905 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-402-007 42935 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-402-008 43015 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-402-009 43035 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-402-010 43055 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-402-011 43075 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-402-012 43095 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-402-013 43115 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-402-014 43135 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-402-015 43155 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-402-016 43175 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-402-017 43195 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-402-018 76962 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-402-019 76944 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-402-020 76936 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-402-021 76928 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-402-022 76920 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-402-023 76912 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-402-024 76904 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-402-025 76896 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-402-026 76888 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-402-027 76880 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-402-028 76872 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-402-029 76864 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-402-030 76856 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-402-031 76848 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-402-032 76840 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-402-033 76836 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-403-001 76835 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-403-002 76843 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-403-003 76851 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-403-004 76859 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 28 of 37 231 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 637-403-005 76867 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-403-006 76875 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-403-007 76883 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-403-008 76891 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-403-009 76899 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-403-010 76907 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-403-011 76915 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-403-012 76923 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-403-013 76931 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-403-014 76939 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-403-015 76947 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-403-016 76955 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-403-017 76963 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-403-018 76971 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-403-019 76979 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-403-020 76987 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-403-021 76995 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-411-001 43535 OREGON CIR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-411-002 43525 OREGON CIR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-411-003 43515 OREGON CIR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-411-004 43505 OREGON CIR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-411-005 43510 OREGON CIR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-411-006 43520 OREGON CIR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-411-007 43530 OREGON CIR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-411-008 76750 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-411-009 76764 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-411-010 76778 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-411-011 76792 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-411-012 76806 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-411-013 76820 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-411-014 76834 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-411-015 76848 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-411-016 76862 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-411-017 76876 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-411-018 76890 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-411-019 76904 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-411-020 76918 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-411-021 76932 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-411-022 76946 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-411-023 76960 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-411-024 76974 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-411-025 76988 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-412-001 76733 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-412-002 76747 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-412-003 76761 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-412-004 76775 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-412-005 76789 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-412-006 76803 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-412-007 76817 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-412-008 76831 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-412-009 76845 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-412-010 76859 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-412-011 76873 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-412-012 76887 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-412-013 76901 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-412-014 76915 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-412-015 76929 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-412-016 76943 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-412-017 76957 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-412-018 76971 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-412-019 76985 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-412-020 76999 KENTUCKY AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-412-021 43631 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-421-001 43783 VIRGINIA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-421-002 76550 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-421-003 76540 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-421-004 76530 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-421-005 76520 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-421-006 76510 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-422-001 76580 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-422-002 76610 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-422-003 42025 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-422-004 76650 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-423-001 76676 OKLAHOMA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-423-002 76698 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-423-003 76710 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-423-004 76718 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-423-005 76726 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-423-006 76734 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-423-007 76740 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-001 76733 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-002 76725 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-003 76717 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-004 76709 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-005 76701 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-006 76693 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-007 76679 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-008 76667 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-009 76655 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-010 76645 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-011 76633 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-012 76621 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 29 of 37 232 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 637-424-013 76597 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-014 76585 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-015 76573 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-016 76565 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-017 76547 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-018 76535 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-019 76527 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-020 76515 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-021 76536 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-022 76548 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-023 76560 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-024 76574 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-025 76588 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-026 76600 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-027 76612 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-028 76624 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-029 76636 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-030 76656 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-031 76668 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-032 76676 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-033 76684 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-034 76696 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-035 76710 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-036 76718 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-037 76728 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-424-038 76734 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-425-002 76715 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-425-003 76707 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-425-004 76699 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-425-005 76691 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-425-006 76679 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-425-007 76667 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-425-008 76655 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-425-009 76641 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-425-010 76629 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-425-011 76615 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-425-012 76601 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-425-013 76589 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-425-014 76577 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-425-015 76563 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-425-016 76547 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-425-017 76535 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-425-018 76525 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-425-019 76727 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-431-001 76756 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-431-002 76764 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-431-003 76772 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-431-004 76780 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-431-005 76792 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-431-006 76804 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-431-007 76826 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-431-008 76848 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-431-009 76862 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-431-010 76884 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-431-011 76896 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-431-012 76908 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-431-013 76920 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-431-014 76932 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-431-015 76944 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-431-016 76956 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-431-017 76968 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-431-018 76974 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-431-019 76986 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-001 76983 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-002 76979 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-003 76967 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-004 76955 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-005 76949 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-006 76937 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-007 76925 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-008 76913 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-009 76901 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-010 76889 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-011 76871 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-012 76855 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-013 76833 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-014 76811 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-015 76797 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-016 76785 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-017 76773 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-018 76765 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-019 76757 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-020 76749 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-021 76741 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-022 76742 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-023 76750 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-024 76758 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-025 76766 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-026 76774 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-027 76790 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-028 76800 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-029 76820 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 30 of 37 233 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 637-432-030 76840 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-031 76860 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-032 76880 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-033 76894 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-034 76910 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-035 76920 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-036 76930 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-037 76940 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-038 76954 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-039 76968 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-040 76980 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-041 76990 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-432-042 43835 TENNESSEE AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-433-001 76995 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-433-002 NO SITUS ADDRESS SFV 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-433-003 76971 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-433-004 76959 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-433-005 76947 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-433-006 76935 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-433-007 76923 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-433-008 76911 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-433-009 76891 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-433-010 76881 FLORIDA AVE SFV 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-433-011 76869 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-433-012 76847 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-433-013 76825 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-433-014 76803 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-433-015 NO SITUS ADDRESS SFV 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-433-016 76785 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-433-017 76769 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-433-018 76757 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-433-019 76745 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-433-021 76739 FLORIDA AVE SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-001 77295 COLORADO ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-002 77305 COLORADO ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-003 77315 COLORADO ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-004 77325 COLORADO ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-005 77335 COLORADO ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-006 77345 COLORADO ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-007 77355 COLORADO ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-008 77365 COLORADO ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-009 77375 COLORADO ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-010 77385 COLORADO ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-011 77395 COLORADO ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-012 77405 COLORADO ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-013 77415 COLORADO ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-014 77425 COLORADO ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-015 77420 COLORADO ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-016 77410 COLORADO ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-017 77400 COLORADO ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-018 77390 COLORADO ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-019 43300 ARIZONA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-020 43310 ARIZONA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-021 43320 ARIZONA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-022 43330 ARIZONA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-023 77405 NEW MEXICO DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-024 77415 NEW MEXICO DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-025 77470 NEW MEXICO DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-026 77460 NEW MEXICO DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-027 77450 NEW MEXICO DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-028 77440 NEW MEXICO DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-029 77430 NEW MEXICO DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-030 77420 NEW MEXICO DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-031 77410 NEW MEXICO DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-032 77400 NEW MEXICO DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-033 77390 NEW MEXICO DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-034 77380 NEW MEXICO DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-035 77370 NEW MEXICO DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-036 77360 NEW MEXICO DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-037 77350 NEW MEXICO DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-038 77340 NEW MEXICO DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-039 77330 NEW MEXICO DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-040 77335 NEW MEXICO DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-041 77345 NEW MEXICO DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-042 77355 NEW MEXICO DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-043 77365 NEW MEXICO DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-044 77375 NEW MEXICO DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-045 77385 NEW MEXICO DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-046 43325 ARIZONA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-047 43315 ARIZONA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-048 43305 ARIZONA ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-049 77340 COLORADO ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-050 77330 COLORADO ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-051 77320 COLORADO ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-052 77310 COLORADO ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-053 77300 COLORADO ST SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 637-470-054 77160 CALIFORNIA DR SFR 1.00 44.40 32.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club X637-071-003 77915 AVENUE OF THE STATES MFR 57.60 2557.44 1843.20 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club X637-190-006 43300 ELKHORN TRL MFR 112.80 5008.32 3609.60 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 694-361-001 37981 DREXELL DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-361-002 37967 DREXELL DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-361-003 37939 DREXELL DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 31 of 37 234 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 694-361-004 37911 DREXELL DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-361-005 37883 DREXELL DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-361-006 37855 DREXELL DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-361-007 37827 DREXELL DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-361-008 37799 DREXELL DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-361-009 37771 DREXELL DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-361-010 37743 DREXELL DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-362-001 37734 DREXELL DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-362-002 37762 DREXELL DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-362-003 37790 DREXELL DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-362-004 37818 DREXELL DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-362-005 37846 DREXELL DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-362-006 37874 DREXELL DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-362-007 37902 DREXELL DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-362-008 37930 DREXELL DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-362-009 73518 HEATHERWOOD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-362-010 73530 HEATHERWOOD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-362-012 37881 EMERSON DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-362-013 37853 EMERSON DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-362-014 73541 JAMESON RD SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-362-015 73533 JAMESON RD SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-362-016 73521 JAMESON RD SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-362-017 37875 COLEBRIDGE ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-362-018 37847 COLEBRIDGE ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-362-019 37819 COLEBRIDGE ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-362-020 37791 COLEBRIDGE ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-362-021 37763 COLEBRIDGE ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-362-022 37735 COLEBRIDGE ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-363-001 37764 COLEBRIDGE ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-363-002 37792 COLEBRIDGE ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-363-003 37820 COLEBRIDGE ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-363-004 37817 EMERSON DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-363-005 37789 EMERSON DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-363-006 37761 EMERSON DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-364-001 73507 HEATHERWOOD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-364-002 73513 HEATHERWOOD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-364-003 73521 HEATHERWOOD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-364-004 73533 HEATHERWOOD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-364-005 73541 HEATHERWOOD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-364-006 73553 HEATHERWOOD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-364-007 73561 HEATHERWOOD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-364-008 73573 HEATHERWOOD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-364-009 73581 HEATHERWOOD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-364-010 73593 HEATHERWOOD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-364-011 73601 HEATHERWOOD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-364-012 73613 HEATHERWOOD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-364-013 73621 HEATHERWOOD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-364-014 73631 HEATHERWOOD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-365-001 37762 EMERSON DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-365-002 37790 EMERSON DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-365-003 37818 EMERSON DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-365-004 37846 EMERSON DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-365-005 37874 EMERSON DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-365-006 37902 EMERSON DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-365-007 37930 EMERSON DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-365-008 73590 HEATHERWOOD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-365-009 73600 HEATHERWOOD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-365-010 73610 HEATHERWOOD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-365-011 73620 HEATHERWOOD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-365-012 73630 HEATHERWOOD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-365-013 37879 HOLLISTER DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-365-014 37851 HOLLISTER DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-365-015 73621 WILLINGTON RD SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-365-016 73613 WILLINGTON RD SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-365-017 73601 WILLINGTON RD SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-365-018 37871 DRISCOLL ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-365-019 37843 DRISCOLL ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-365-020 37815 DRISCOLL ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-365-021 37787 DRISCOLL ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-365-022 37759 DRISCOLL ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-366-001 37813 HOLLISTER DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-366-002 37785 HOLLISTER DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-366-003 37757 HOLLISTER DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-366-004 37760 DRISCOLL ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-366-005 37788 DRISCOLL ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-366-006 37816 DRISCOLL ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-367-001 37744 HOLLISTER DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-367-002 37772 HOLLISTER DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-367-003 37800 HOLLISTER DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-367-004 37828 HOLLISTER DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-367-005 37856 HOLLISTER DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-367-006 37884 HOLLISTER DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-367-007 37912 HOLLISTER DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-371-001 37729 HOLLISTER DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-371-002 37701 HOLLISTER DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-371-003 37673 HOLLISTER DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-371-004 37645 HOLLISTER DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-371-005 37617 HOLLISTER DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-371-006 37589 HOLLISTER DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-371-007 37592 DRISCOLL ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-371-008 37620 DRISCOLL ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-371-009 37648 DRISCOLL ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 32 of 37 235 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 694-371-010 37676 DRISCOLL ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-371-011 37704 DRISCOLL ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-371-012 37732 DRISCOLL ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-372-001 37731 DRISCOLL ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-372-002 37703 DRISCOLL ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-372-003 37675 DRISCOLL ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-372-004 37647 DRISCOLL ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-372-005 NO SITUS ADDRESS SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-372-006 NO SITUS ADDRESS SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-372-007 37594 EMERSON DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-372-008 37622 EMERSON DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-372-009 37650 EMERSON DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-372-010 37678 EMERSON DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-372-011 37706 EMERSON DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-372-012 37734 EMERSON DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-373-001 37733 EMERSON DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-373-002 37705 EMERSON DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-373-003 37677 EMERSON DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-373-004 37649 EMERSON DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-373-005 37621 EMERSON DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-373-006 37593 EMERSON DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-373-007 37596 COLEBRIDGE DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-373-008 37624 COLEBRIDGE ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-373-009 37652 COLEBRIDGE ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-373-010 37680 COLEBRIDGE ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-373-011 37708 COLEBRIDGE ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-373-012 37736 COLEBRIDGE ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-374-001 37707 COLEBRIDGE ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-374-002 37679 COLEBRIDGE ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-374-003 37651 COLEBRIDGE ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-374-004 37623 COLEBRIDGE ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-374-005 37595 COLEBRIDGE ST SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-374-006 37594 DREXELL DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-374-007 37622 DREXELL DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-374-008 37650 DREXELL DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-374-009 37678 DREXELL DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-374-010 37706 DREXELL DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-375-001 37715 DREXELL DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-375-002 37687 DREXELL DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-375-003 37659 DREXELL DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-375-004 37631 DREXELL DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-375-005 37603 DREXELL DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-375-006 37575 DREXELL DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-375-007 37547 DREXELL DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-375-008 73500 WOODWARD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-375-009 73510 WOODWARD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-375-010 73520 WOODWARD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-375-011 73530 WOODWARD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-375-012 73540 WOODWARD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-375-013 73550 WOODWARD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-375-014 73560 WOODWARD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-375-015 73570 WOODWARD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-375-016 73580 WOODWARD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-375-017 73590 WOODWARD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-375-018 73600 WOODWARD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-375-019 73610 WOODWARD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-375-020 73620 WOODWARD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-375-021 73630 WOODWARD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-375-022 73640 WOODWARD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-375-023 73650 WOODWARD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-375-024 73660 WOODWARD DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-375-025 37548 HOLLISTER DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-375-026 37576 HOLLISTER DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-375-027 37604 HOLLISTER DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-375-028 37632 HOLLISTER DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-375-029 37660 HOLLISTER DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-375-030 37688 HOLLISTER DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 694-375-031 37716 HOLLISTER DR SFR 1.00 183.84 99.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 624-351-001 43496 AMARYLLIS WAY SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-351-002 43468 AMARYLLIS WAY SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-351-003 43440 AMARYLLIS WAY SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-351-004 43412 AMARYLLIS WAY SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-351-005 43384 AMARYLLIS WAY SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-351-006 43356 AMARYLLIS WAY SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-351-007 43328 AMARYLLIS WAY SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-351-009 43300 AMARYLLIS WAY SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-352-038 74582 MOSS ROSE DR SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-352-039 74594 MOSS ROSE DR SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-352-040 74606 MOSS ROSE DR SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-352-041 74618 MOSS ROSE DR SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-352-042 74630 MOSS ROSE DR SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-352-043 74649 WATERLILY CIR SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-352-044 74637 WATERLILY CIR SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-352-045 74625 WATERLILY CIR SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-352-046 74613 WATERLILY CIR SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-352-047 74601 WATERLILY CIR SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-352-048 74574 WATERLILY CIR SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-352-049 74580 WATERLILY CIR SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-352-050 74592 WATERLILY CIR SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-352-051 74604 WATERLILY CIR SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-352-052 74616 WATERLILY CIR SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-352-053 74628 WATERLILY CIR SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 33 of 37 236 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 624-352-054 74653 STRAWFLOWER CIR SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-352-055 74641 STRAWFLOWER CIR SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-352-056 74629 STRAWFLOWER CIR SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-352-057 74617 STRAWFLOWER CIR SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-352-058 74605 STRAWFLOWER CIR SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-352-059 74570 STRAWFLOWER CIR SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-352-060 74578 STRAWFLOWER CIR SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-352-061 74590 STRAWFLOWER CIR SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-352-062 74602 STRAWFLOWER CIR SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-352-063 74614 STRAWFLOWER CIR SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-352-064 74626 STRAWFLOWER CIR SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-371-001 74501 COLUMBINE DR SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-371-002 74513 COLUMBINE DR SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-371-003 74527 COLUMBINE DR SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-371-004 74539 COLUMBINE DR SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-371-005 74551 COLUMBINE DR SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-371-006 74563 COLUMBINE DR SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-371-007 74506 LAVENDER WAY SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-371-008 74518 LAVENDER WAY SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-371-009 74526 LAVENDER WAY SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-371-010 74538 LAVENDER WAY SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-371-011 74546 LAVENDER WAY SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-371-012 74558 LAVENDER WAY SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-371-013 74566 LAVENDER WAY SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-372-001 74509 LAVENDER WAY SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-372-002 74517 LAVENDER WAY SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-372-003 74529 LAVENDER WAY SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-372-004 74537 LAVENDER WAY SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-372-005 74549 LAVENDER WAY SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-372-006 74557 LAVENDER WAY SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-372-007 74569 LAVENDER WAY SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-372-008 74581 LAVENDER WAY SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-372-010 74605 LAVENDER WAY SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-372-011 74617 LAVENDER WAY SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-372-012 74629 LAVENDER WAY SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-372-013 74641 LAVENDER WAY SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-372-014 74657 LAVENDER WAY SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-372-015 74593 LAVENDER WAY SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-373-001 74578 LAVENDER WAY SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-373-002 74590 LAVENDER WAY SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-373-003 74602 LAVENDER WAY SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-373-004 74614 LAVENDER WAY SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 624-373-005 74626 LAVENDER WAY SFR 1.00 240.23 119.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 694-381-001 74101 E COLLEGE VIEW CIR SFR 1.00 505.57 233.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates I 694-381-002 74107 E COLLEGE VIEW CIR SFR 1.00 505.57 233.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates I 694-381-003 74113 E COLLEGE VIEW CIR SFR 1.00 505.57 233.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates I 694-381-004 74119 E COLLEGE VIEW CIR SFR 1.00 505.57 233.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates I 694-381-005 74125 E COLLEGE VIEW CIR SFR 1.00 505.57 233.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates I 694-381-006 74131 E COLLEGE VIEW CIR SFR 1.00 505.57 233.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates I 694-381-007 74137 E COLLEGE VIEW CIR SFR 1.00 505.57 233.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates I 694-381-008 74143 E COLLEGE VIEW CIR SFR 1.00 505.57 233.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates I 694-381-009 74140 E COLLEGE VIEW CIR SFR 1.00 505.57 233.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates I 694-381-010 74134 E COLLEGE VIEW CIR SFR 1.00 505.57 233.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates I 694-381-011 74128 E COLLEGE VIEW CIR SFR 1.00 505.57 233.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates I 694-381-012 74122 E COLLEGE VIEW CIR SFR 1.00 505.57 233.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates I 694-381-013 74116 E COLLEGE VIEW CIR SFR 1.00 505.57 233.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates I 694-381-014 74110 E COLLEGE VIEW CIR SFR 1.00 505.57 233.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates I 694-381-015 74104 E COLLEGE VIEW CIR SFR 1.00 505.57 233.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates I 694-381-016 74098 E COLLEGE VIEW CIR SFR 1.00 505.57 233.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates I 694-382-001 74092 W COLLEGE VIEW CIR SFR 1.00 505.57 233.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates I 694-382-002 74086 W COLLEGE VIEW CIR SFR 1.00 505.57 233.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates I 694-382-003 74080 W COLLEGE VIEW CIR SFR 1.00 505.57 233.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates I 694-382-004 74074 W COLLEGE VIEW CIR SFR 1.00 505.57 233.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates I 694-382-005 74068 W COLLEGE VIEW CIR SFR 1.00 505.57 233.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates I 694-382-006 74062 W COLLEGE VIEW CIR SFR 1.00 505.57 233.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates I 694-382-007 74056 W COLLEGE VIEW CIR SFR 1.00 505.57 233.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates I 694-382-008 74050 W COLLEGE VIEW CIR SFR 1.00 505.57 233.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates I 694-382-009 74053 W COLLEGE VIEW CIR SFR 1.00 505.57 233.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates I 694-382-010 74059 W COLLEGE VIEW CIR SFR 1.00 505.57 233.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates I 694-382-011 74065 W COLLEGE VIEW CIR SFR 1.00 505.57 233.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates I 694-382-012 74071 W COLLEGE VIEW CIR SFR 1.00 505.57 233.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates I 694-382-013 74077 W COLLEGE VIEW CIR SFR 1.00 505.57 233.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates I 694-382-014 74083 W COLLEGE VIEW CIR SFR 1.00 505.57 233.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates I 694-382-015 74089 W COLLEGE VIEW CIR SFR 1.00 505.57 233.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates I 694-382-016 74095 W COLLEGE VIEW CIR SFR 1.00 505.57 233.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates I 694-211-001 74140 E SCHOLAR LN SFR 1.00 702.72 214.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates II 694-211-002 74134 E SCHOLAR LN SFR 1.00 702.72 214.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates II 694-211-003 74128 E SCHOLAR LN SFR 1.00 702.72 214.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates II 694-211-004 74122 E SCHOLAR LN SFR 1.00 702.72 214.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates II 694-211-005 74116 E SCHOLAR LN SFR 1.00 702.72 214.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates II 694-211-006 74110 E SCHOLAR LN SFR 1.00 702.72 214.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates II 694-211-007 74104 E SCHOLAR LN SFR 1.00 702.72 214.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates II 694-211-008 74098 E SCHOLAR LN SFR 1.00 702.72 214.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates II 694-211-009 74101 E SCHOLAR LN SFR 1.00 702.72 214.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates II 694-211-010 74107 E SCHOLAR LN SFR 1.00 702.72 214.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates II 694-211-011 74113 E SCHOLAR LN SFR 1.00 702.72 214.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates II 694-211-012 74119 E SCHOLAR LN SFR 1.00 702.72 214.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates II 694-211-013 74125 E SCHOLAR LN SFR 1.00 702.72 214.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates II 694-211-014 74131 E SCHOLAR LN SFR 1.00 702.72 214.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates II 694-211-015 74137 E SCHOLAR LN SFR 1.00 702.72 214.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates II 694-211-016 74143 E SCHOLAR LN SFR 1.00 702.72 214.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates II 694-212-001 74092 W SCHOLAR LN SFR 1.00 702.72 214.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates II Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 34 of 37 237 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 694-212-002 74086 W SCHOLAR LN SFR 1.00 702.72 214.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates II 694-212-003 74080 W SCHOLAR LN SFR 1.00 702.72 214.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates II 694-212-004 74074 W SCHOLAR LN SFR 1.00 702.72 214.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates II 694-212-005 74068 W SCHOLAR LN SFR 1.00 702.72 214.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates II 694-212-006 74062 W SCHOLAR LN SFR 1.00 702.72 214.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates II 694-212-007 74056 W SCHOLAR LN SFR 1.00 702.72 214.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates II 694-212-008 74050 W SCHOLAR LN SFR 1.00 702.72 214.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates II 694-212-009 74053 W SCHOLAR LN SFR 1.00 702.72 214.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates II 694-212-010 74059 W SCHOLAR LN SFR 1.00 702.72 214.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates II 694-212-011 74065 W SCHOLAR LN SFR 1.00 702.72 214.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates II 694-212-012 74071 W SCHOLAR LN SFR 1.00 702.72 214.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates II 694-212-013 74077 W SCHOLAR LN SFR 1.00 702.72 214.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates II Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 35 of 37 238 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 694-212-014 74083 W SCHOLAR LN SFR 1.00 702.72 214.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates II 694-212-015 74089 W SCHOLAR LN SFR 1.00 702.72 214.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates II 694-212-016 74095 W SCHOLAR LN SFR 1.00 702.72 214.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates II 694-231-019 74093 W PETUNIA PL SFR 1.00 448.79 193.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Petunia I 694-231-020 74087 W PETUNIA PL SFR 1.00 448.79 193.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Petunia I 694-231-021 74081 W PETUNIA PL SFR 1.00 448.79 193.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Petunia I 694-231-022 74075 W PETUNIA PL SFR 1.00 448.79 193.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Petunia I 694-231-023 74069 W PETUNIA PL SFR 1.00 448.79 193.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Petunia I 694-231-024 74063 W PETUNIA PL SFR 1.00 448.79 193.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Petunia I 694-231-025 74057 W PETUNIA PL SFR 1.00 448.79 193.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Petunia I 694-231-026 74051 W PETUNIA PL SFR 1.00 448.79 193.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Petunia I 694-231-027 74048 W PETUNIA PL SFR 1.00 448.79 193.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Petunia I 694-231-028 74054 W PETUNIA PL SFR 1.00 448.79 193.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Petunia I 694-231-029 74060 W PETUNIA PL SFR 1.00 448.79 193.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Petunia I 694-231-030 74066 W PETUNIA PL SFR 1.00 448.79 193.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Petunia I 694-231-031 74072 W PETUNIA PL SFR 1.00 448.79 193.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Petunia I 694-231-032 74078 W PETUNIA PL SFR 1.00 448.79 193.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Petunia I 694-231-033 74084 W PETUNIA PL SFR 1.00 448.79 193.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Petunia I 694-231-034 74090 W PETUNIA PL SFR 1.00 448.79 193.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Petunia I 694-232-001 74100 E PETUNIA PL SFR 1.00 448.79 193.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Petunia I 694-232-002 74106 E PETUNIA PL SFR 1.00 448.79 193.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Petunia I 694-232-003 74112 E PETUNIA PL SFR 1.00 448.79 193.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Petunia I 694-232-004 74118 E PETUNIA PL SFR 1.00 448.79 193.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Petunia I 694-232-005 74124 E PETUNIA PL SFR 1.00 448.79 193.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Petunia I 694-232-006 74130 E PETUNIA PL SFR 1.00 448.79 193.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Petunia I 694-232-007 74136 E PETUNIA PL SFR 1.00 448.79 193.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Petunia I 694-232-008 74142 E PETUNIA PL SFR 1.00 448.79 193.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Petunia I 694-232-009 74145 E PETUNIA PL SFR 1.00 448.79 193.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Petunia I 694-232-010 74139 E PETUNIA PL SFR 1.00 448.79 193.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Petunia I 694-232-011 74133 E PETUNIA PL SFR 1.00 448.79 193.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Petunia I 694-232-012 74127 E PETUNIA PL SFR 1.00 448.79 193.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Petunia I 694-232-013 74121 E PETUNIA PL SFR 1.00 448.79 193.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Petunia I 694-232-014 74115 E PETUNIA PL SFR 1.00 448.79 193.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Petunia I 694-232-015 74109 E PETUNIA PL SFR 1.00 448.79 193.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Petunia I 694-232-016 74103 E PETUNIA PL SFR 1.00 448.79 193.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Petunia I 694-232-017 74105 E CHINOOK CIR SFR 1.00 716.46 317.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance East 694-232-018 74111 E CHINOOK CIR SFR 1.00 716.46 317.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance East 694-232-019 74117 E CHINOOK CIR SFR 1.00 716.46 317.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance East 694-232-020 74123 E CHINOOK CIR SFR 1.00 716.46 317.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance East 694-232-021 74129 E CHINOOK CIR SFR 1.00 716.46 317.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance East 694-232-022 74135 E CHINOOK CIR SFR 1.00 716.46 317.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance East 694-232-023 74141 E CHINOOK CIR SFR 1.00 716.46 317.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance East 694-232-024 74144 E CHINOOK CIR SFR 1.00 716.46 317.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance East 694-232-025 74138 E CHINOOK CIR SFR 1.00 716.46 317.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance East 694-232-026 74132 E CHINOOK CIR SFR 1.00 716.46 317.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance East 694-232-027 74126 E CHINOOK CIR SFR 1.00 716.46 317.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance East 694-232-028 74120 E CHINOOK CIR SFR 1.00 716.46 317.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance East 694-232-029 74114 E CHINOOK CIR SFR 1.00 716.46 317.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance East 694-232-030 74106 E CHINOOK CIR SFR 1.00 716.46 317.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance East 694-231-002 74083 CHINOOK CIR SFR 1.00 682.25 218.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance West 694-231-003 74077 CHINOOK CIR SFR 1.00 682.25 218.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance West 694-231-004 74071 CHINOOK CIR SFR 1.00 682.25 218.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance West 694-231-005 74065 CHINOOK CIR SFR 1.00 682.25 218.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance West 694-231-006 74059 CHINOOK CIR SFR 1.00 682.25 218.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance West 694-231-007 74053 CHINOOK CIR SFR 1.00 682.25 218.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance West 694-231-008 74047 CHINOOK CIR SFR 1.00 682.25 218.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance West 694-231-009 74041 CHINOOK CIR SFR 1.00 682.25 218.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance West 694-231-010 74040 CHINOOK CIR SFR 1.00 682.25 218.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance West 694-231-011 74046 CHINOOK CIR SFR 1.00 682.25 218.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance West 694-231-012 74052 CHINOOK CIR SFR 1.00 682.25 218.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance West 694-231-013 74058 CHINOOK CIR SFR 1.00 682.25 218.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance West 694-231-014 74064 CHINOOK CIR SFR 1.00 682.25 218.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance West 694-231-015 74070 CHINOOK CIR SFR 1.00 682.25 218.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance West 694-231-016 74076 CHINOOK CIR SFR 1.00 682.25 218.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance West 694-231-017 74082 CHINOOK CIR SFR 1.00 682.25 218.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance West 694-382-018 74081 KOKOPELLI CIR SFR 1.00 682.25 218.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance West 694-382-019 74075 KOKOPELLI CIR SFR 1.00 682.25 218.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance West 694-382-020 74069 KOKOPELLI CIR SFR 1.00 682.25 218.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance West 694-382-021 74063 KOKOPELLI CIR SFR 1.00 682.25 218.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance West 694-382-022 74057 KOKOPELLI CIR SFR 1.00 682.25 218.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance West 694-382-023 74051 KOKOPELLI CIR SFR 1.00 682.25 218.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance West 694-382-024 74045 KOKOPELLI CIR SFR 1.00 682.25 218.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance West 694-382-025 74039 KOKOPELLI CIR SFR 1.00 682.25 218.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance West 694-382-026 74038 KOKOPELLI CIR SFR 1.00 682.25 218.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance West 694-382-027 74044 KOKOPELLI CIR SFR 1.00 682.25 218.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance West 694-382-028 74050 KOKOPELLI CIR SFR 1.00 682.25 218.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance West 694-382-029 74056 KOKOPELLI CIR SFR 1.00 682.25 218.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance West 694-382-030 74062 KOKOPELLI CIR SFR 1.00 682.25 218.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance West 694-382-031 74068 KOKOPELLI CIR SFR 1.00 682.25 218.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance West 694-382-032 74074 KOKOPELLI CIR SFR 1.00 682.25 218.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance West 694-382-033 74080 KOKOPELLI CIR SFR 1.00 682.25 218.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance West 694-391-016 74090 ALPINE LN SFR 1.00 497.61 252.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, The Boulders 694-391-017 74084 ALPINE LN SFR 1.00 497.61 252.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, The Boulders 694-391-018 74078 ALPINE LN SFR 1.00 497.61 252.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, The Boulders 694-391-019 74072 ALPINE LN SFR 1.00 497.61 252.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, The Boulders 694-391-020 74066 ALPINE LN SFR 1.00 497.61 252.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, The Boulders 694-391-021 74060 ALPINE LN SFR 1.00 497.61 252.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, The Boulders 694-391-022 74054 ALPINE LN SFR 1.00 497.61 252.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, The Boulders 694-391-023 74048 ALPINE LN SFR 1.00 497.61 252.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, The Boulders 694-391-024 74053 ALPINE LN SFR 1.00 497.61 252.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, The Boulders 694-391-025 74057 ALPINE LN SFR 1.00 497.61 252.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, The Boulders 694-391-026 74063 ALPINE LN SFR 1.00 497.61 252.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, The Boulders Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 36 of 37 239 APN Situs Address Land Use Code Equivalent Dwelling (Benefit) Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge District Name City of Palm Desert Consolidated Landscape and Lighting District Preliminary Report (sorted by District Name and Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/2025 694-391-027 74067 ALPINE LN SFR 1.00 497.61 252.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, The Boulders 694-391-028 74075 ALPINE LN SFR 1.00 497.61 252.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, The Boulders 694-391-029 74081 ALPINE LN SFR 1.00 497.61 252.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, The Boulders 694-391-030 74087 ALPINE LN SFR 1.00 497.61 252.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, The Boulders 694-391-031 74093 ALPINE LN SFR 1.00 497.61 252.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, The Boulders District Name (Sorted in similar order as budget from ER) Parcel Count EDU Sum Maximum Charge Landscape and Lighting District Zone 02, Canyon Cove 222 222.00 $30,023.28 $30,023.28 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 03, Vineyards 132 134.00 $13,035.52 $11,390.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 04, Parkview Estates 172 172.00 $5,818.76 $5,817.04 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Desert Mirage 29 29.00 $16,851.61 $12,586.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Primrose II 37 37.00 $9,899.72 $7,992.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 05, Sandcastles 41 41.00 $3,260.32 $2,337.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Diamond Back 20 20.00 $11,658.60 $4,980.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Collection 38 38.00 $7,482.20 $7,482.20 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Court West 16 16.00 $7,334.40 $5,568.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Estates 16 16.00 $9,773.76 $7,312.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Hovley Glen 16 16.00 $6,939.20 $6,939.20 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma I 16 16.00 $9,250.88 $5,280.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma II 16 16.00 $9,523.04 $4,736.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, La Paloma III 15 15.00 $6,508.65 $4,575.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Monterey Meadows 40 40.00 $5,409.60 $5,258.40 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Palm Court 20 20.00 $8,098.00 $4,600.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sandpiper Court 16 16.00 $9,501.28 $7,408.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sandpiper West 16 16.00 $9,428.48 $7,216.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata I 16 16.00 $8,061.12 $8,061.12 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 06, Sonata II 94 94.00 $17,923.92 $17,923.92 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 07, Waring Court 16 16.00 $10,653.44 $5,776.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 08, Palm Gate 37 37.00 $13,141.29 $10,545.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 09, The Grove 105 105.00 $34,267.80 $21,630.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 11, Portola Place 23 23.00 $6,925.30 $4,324.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 13, Palm Desert Country Club 1,681 2,161.71 $95,979.84 $69,174.58 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 14, K&B at Palm Desert 163 163.00 $29,965.92 $16,137.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 15, Canyon Crest 67 67.00 $16,095.41 $7,973.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates I 32 32.00 $16,178.24 $7,456.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, College View Estates II 32 32.00 $22,487.04 $6,848.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Petunia I 32 32.00 $14,361.28 $6,176.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance East 14 14.00 $10,030.44 $4,438.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, Sundance West 32 32.00 $21,832.00 $6,976.00 Landscape and Lighting District Zone 16, The Boulders 16 16.00 $7,961.76 $4,032.00 TOTAL 3,238 3,720.71 $505,662.10 $338,970.74 *Totals include 2 Handbilled parcels for $5,452.80 Note: Slight variances in totals due to rounding Willdan Financial Services Fiscal Year 2024/25 Preliminary Report Page 37 of 37 240 GE RALD FORD DR TAMARISK ROW DR OASIS CLUB DRELDORADO DRPITAHAYA ST COOK STTOWN CENTERWAYS H A DOWMOUNTAIN D R 42ND AVE FRANK SINATRA DR FRE D WARING DR WASHINGTON STWARNER TRLMAGNESIA FALLS DR HOV LE Y LN W COOK ST FRE D WARING DR EL PAS EO HAYSTACK RD HOV LE Y LN E PORTOLA AVE PORTOLA AVEVARNER RD FRE D WARING DR ELDORADODRMILES AVE FRANK SINATRA DR GER A LDFO RDDR GERALDFOR D DR COOK ST COUNTRY CLUB DR PORTOLA AVEVARNER RD FRE D WARING DR PORTOLA AVE COOK ST MONTEREY AVE HOV LE Y LN E VARNER RD ELDORADO DRFRANK SINATRA DR COOK STHOV LE Y LN E HOV LE Y LN E MERLE DRPORTOLAAVE MONTEREY AVEDINAH SHORE DR ECLECTICSTMONTEREY AVECORPORATEWAYCALIFORNIA AV E AVENUEOF THESTATES TENNESSEEAVEKANSASST RUTLEDGE WAY SAN PASCUAL AVEPARK V IE W DR FAIRWAY DRSAN PABLO AVEDE ANZA WAY ALE SSANDRO DR DEEP CANYON RDSAN GORGONIO WAY CALLE DELOS CAMPESINOSSAN LUISREY AVECOUNTRY CLUB DR COUNTRY CLUB DR HARRISLN HWY 111 WASHINGTON STBAD No. 1 WARING COURT PARK WAY S THE GROVEPARKWAYS PORTOLAPLACEPARKWAYS PALM GATEPARKWAYS CANYON CREST PRIM ROSE II PARKWAYS DESE RT M IRA GE PARKWAYAND E NTRA NCE IS LANDS COLLE GEVIEW ES TATE SI PARK WAY S COLLE GE VIEW IIPARKWAYS SUNDANCE WES T PARK WAYS SUNDANCE E AST PARKWAYS PETUNIA I PARK WAY S BOULDERS PA RKWAYS KAUFMA N A ND B ROADDEVELOPMENT PARKWAY S PALM DE SERTCC PE RIM ETERLANDSCAPE PRES IDENT'S P LAZA I PRES IDENT'S P LAZA II PRES IDENT'S P LAZA III THE GLEN PARK WAY MONTE REY M EADOWSPARKWAY SONATA II PARKWAY HOV LEY ESTATES PARKWAY HOV LEYCOLLECTIONPARKWAY HOV LEYCOURT WES TPARKWAY SONATA I PA RKWAY DIAM ONDBACKPARKWAY LA PALOMA II PA RKWAY LA PALOMA I PARK WAY SANDP IPE RCT WE STPARKWAY LA PALOMA III PARK WAY SANDP IPE R CT PARKWAY PALM COURT PARK WAY VINE YAR DSPARKWAYS Consolidated Palm D esertLandscape & LightingDistrict No. 1 City Boundary IPAGE 31 A 241 242 Page 1 of 1 CITY OF PALM DESERT STAFF REPORT MEETING DATE: May 9, 2024 PREPARED BY: Chris Gerry, Project Manager REQUEST: APPROVE THE START OF PROCEEDINGS TO LEVY THE ANNUAL ASSESSMENT FOR CITY OF PALM DESERT BENEFIT ASSESSMENT DISTRICT NO. 1 FOR FISCAL YEAR 2024-25 RECOMMENDATION: 1. Adopt a Resolution entitled “A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, INITIATING PROCEEDINGS FOR THE LEVY AND COLLECTION OF ASSESSMENTS FOR PLAM DESERT BENEFIT ASSESSMENT DISTRICT NO. 1 FOR FISCAL YEARS 2024/2025.” 2. Adopt a Resolution entitled “A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, DECLARING ITS INTENTION TO LEVY THE ANNUAL ASSESSMENT FOR CITY OF PALM DESERT BENEFIT ASSESSMENT DISTRICT NO. 1 FOR FISCAL YEAR 2024/2025, PURSUANT TO THE BENEFIT ASSESSMENT ACT OF 1982 AND APPOINTING A TIME AND PLACE FOR THE PUBLIC HEARING ON THESE MATTERS.” 3. Set a public hearing to be held at the City Council meeting of June 27, 2024, at 4 p.m. BACKGROUND/ANALYSIS: The City of Palm Desert (City) Benefit Assessment District No. 1 was formed to assess property owners for the maintenance of the drainage system within Section 29. It was formed pursuant to state law, and maximum levy amounts were established at that time. Each parcel is assessed based on a weighted measure of apportionment known as Equivalent Benefit Unit (EBU), which may take into consideration land use, development status, size of the property, location of the property, development plans or restrictions, vehicular trip generation, street frontage, densities, or other property-related factors. The full levy amount of $574.02 per EBU is being proposed for Fiscal Year 2024-25. BAD No. 1 Street boundaries are found in the Engineer’s Report (page 12). Staff recommends the City Council declare its intention to levy the full assessment and to set the public hearing date for June 27, 2024, pursuant to state law. FINANCIAL IMPACT: The assessment and collection of the full levy amount covers the ongoing maintenance of the Section 29 retention basin, a potential expansion, and associated administrative costs. ATTACHMENTS: 1. Resolution (Initiate Proceedings) 2. Resolution (Intent to Levy) 3. 2024-25 Engineer’s Report 243 244 RESOLUTION NO. 2024-____ 1 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, INITIATING PROCEEDINGS FOR THE LEVY AND COLLECTION OF ASSESSMENTS FOR PALM DESERT BENEFIT ASSESSMENT DISTRICT NO. 1 FOR FISCAL YEAR 2024/2025 The City Council of the City of Palm Desert (hereafter referred to as the “City Council”) does resolve as follows: WHEREAS, the City Council, by previous action and resolution, formed the ”Palm Desert Benefit Assessment District No. 1” (hereafter referred to as the “District”), pursuant to the Benefit Assessment Act of 1982, chapter 6.45, division 2, title 5 of the Government Code of the State of California, commencing with section 54703 (hereafter referred to as the “Act”), that provides for the collection of assessments by the County of Riverside on behalf of the City of Palm Desert to pay for the maintenance, operation, and services of improvements related thereto; and, WHEREAS, the City Council desires to initiate proceedings for the levy and collection of annual assessments for the fiscal year 2024/2025 for the maintenance, operation, and servicing of the drainage basin and facilities that provide benefit to the property within the District pursuant of the provisions of the Act; and, WHEREAS, the City has retained Willdan Financial Services for the purpose of assisting with the annual levy of the District, including the preparation and filing of an Engineer’s Annual Levy Report (hereafter referred to as the “Report”) with the city clerk, in accordance with the provisions of the Act. NOW, THEREFORE, LET IT BE RESOLVED, DETERMINED, AND ORDERED BY THE CITY COUNCIL, THE LEGISLATIVE BODY FOR THE DISTRICT, AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. The above recitals are true and correct. Section 2. Order. The City Council hereby orders Willdan Financial Services for the purpose of assisting with the annual levy of the District, including the preparation and filing of the Report with the city clerk, in accordance with the provisions of the Act. Section 3. Purpose of District. The purpose of this District is to fund the activities necessary to operate, maintain, and serve the drainage basin constructed in a portion of Section 29, Township 4 South, Range 6, East SBM and to be enlarged in connection with current and new development of properties. The maintenance, operation, and servicing of these improvem ents may include, but are not limited to, all materials, equipment, labor and incidental expenses deemed necessary to keep the drainage basin in satisfactory condition. The Report will provide a more detailed description of the improvements and services that the District provides and will describe any 245 RESOLUTION NO. 2024-____ 2 new improvements or substantial changes of the improvements for which properties are assessed. Section 4. Necessity for Levy and Collection of Assessments. The City Council hereby determines that to provide the improvements generally described in section 3 of this resolution and shown, in detail, in the Report, it is necessary to levy and collect assessments within the District for fiscal year 2024/2025 and that such improvements will be outlined and described in the Report and imposed, pursuant to the provisions of the Act and the requirements of California Constitution articles XIII C and XIII D. PASSED, APPROVED, AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the Palm Desert City Council, held on this day of , 2024, by the following vote, to wit: AYES: NOES: ABSENT: ABSTAINED: ________________________________ KARINA QUINTANILLA, MAYOR CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA ATTEST: __________________________________ ANTHONY J. MEJIA, CITY CLERK CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA 246 RESOLUTION NO. 2024-____ 1 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, DECLARING ITS INTENTION TO LEVY THE ANNUAL ASSESSMENT FOR CITY OF PALM DESERT BENEFIT ASSESSMENT DISTRICT NO. 1 FOR FISCAL YEAR 2024/2025, PURSUANT TO THE BENEFIT ASSESSMENT ACT OF 1982 AND APPOINTING A TIME AND PLACE FOR THE PUBLIC HEARING ON THESE MATTERS The City Council of the City of Palm Desert, California (hereafter referred to as the “City Council”), does resolve as follows: WHEREAS, the City Council, by previous action and resolution, formed the “Palm Desert Benefit Assessment District No. 1” (hereafter referred to as the “District”), pursuant to the Benefit Assessment Act of 1982, chapter 6.4, division 2, t itle 5 of the Government Code of the State of California, commencing with section 54703 (hereafter referred to as the “Act”), for purpose of levying annual assessments upon benefiting properties within the District for the maintenance, operation, and servicing of drainage basin and facilitie s related thereto; and, WHEREAS, an Engineer’s Annual Levy Report (hereafter referred to as the “Report”) was prepared, filed, and approved by the City Council in connection with the District and the levy of assessments, pursuant to section 54716 of the Act; and, WHEREAS, the City Council conducted property owner protest proceedings relating to the improvements and services described in the Report , the levy and collection of annual assessments, and an assessment range formula related thereto, in accordance with the provisions of California Constitution article XIIII D; and NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, DETERMINED, AND ORDERED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, THE LEGISLATIVE BODY FOR THE DISTRICT, AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. Intention. The City Council hereby declares its intention to seek the annual levy of the District assessments pursuant to the Act, over and including the land within the District boundaries to pay the costs of the operation, maintenance, and servicing of the drainage basin and improvements and expenses related thereto for fiscal year 2024/2025. Section 2. Boundaries. The boundaries of the District are described in the Report and include the parcels within the District at the time of this resolution of intention and are identified on the Riverside County Assessor’s Secured Roll, as of June 2007, and on the Assessor’s Parcel Map. Section 3. Notice of Public Hearing. Notice is hereby given that a public hearing on these matters will be held on Thursday, June 27, 2024, at 4:00 p.m., or as soon thereafter as feasible, at City Hall (in the City Council Chambers), 247 RESOLUTION NO. 2024-____ 2 which is located at 73-510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert, California. At the public hearing, all interested persons shall be afforded the opportunity to hear and to be heard. PASSED, APPROVED, AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the Palm Desert City Council, held on the day of , 2024, by the following vote, to wit: AYES: NOES: ABSENT: ABSTAINED: KARINA QUINTANILLA, MAYOR CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA ATTEST: ANTHONY J. MEJIA, CITY CLERK CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA 248 27368 Via Industria Suite 200 Temecula, California 92590 T 951.587.3500 | 800.755.6864 F 951.587.3510 www.willdan.com City of Palm Desert Benefit Assessment District No. 1 2024/2025 ENGINEER’S ANNUAL LEVY REPORT Intent Meeting: May 9, 2024 Public Hearing: June 27, 2024 249 ENGINEER'S REPORT AFFIDAVIT Benefit Assessment District No.1 The District includes parcels of land within the subdivisions know as Parcel Map No. 24255 (Monterey 170)/ Assessment District 2004-02 (Section 29) City of Palm Desert, County of Riverside, State of California This Report and the enclosed budget, assessments, descriptions and diagrams describe the Benefit Assessment District No.1, and include each lot, parcel, and subdivision of land within the District, as they existed at the time of the passage of the Resolution of Intention. Reference is hereby made to the Riverside County Assessor’s maps for a detailed description of the lines and dimensions of parcels within the District. The undersigned respectfully submits the enclosed Report as directed by the City Council. Dated this ____________ day of ______________, 20 24. Willdan Financial Services Assessment Engineer On Behalf of the City of Palm Desert By: ________________________________ Daniel Louie, Project Manager District Administrative Services By: ________________________________ Tyrone Peter P.E. # C 81888 250 TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION ............................................................................... 1 PART I — PLANS AND SPECIFICATIONS ..................................... 3 A. Benefiting Properties within the District .............................................. 3 B. Funding authorized by the 1982 Act ..................................................... 3 C. Description of Services ......................................................................... 4 PART II — METHOD OF APPORTIONMENT .................................. 5 A. General .......................................................................................................................... 5 B. Benefit Analysis ......................................................................................................... 6 C. Assessment Methodology ..................................................................................... 6 D. Assessment Range Formula ................................................................................ 8 PART III — DISTRICT BUDGET..................................................... 10 PART IV — DISTRICT DIAGRAMS ................................................ 11 PART V — ASSESSMENT ROLL .................................................. 13 251 2024/2025 Benefit Assessment District No. 1 Page 1 INTRODUCTION Pursuant to the provisions of the Benefit Assessment Act of 1982, being Chapter 6.4 of the California Government Code, commencing with Section 54703 (hereafter referred to as the “1982 Act”), and in compliance with the substantive and procedural requiremen ts of the California State Constitution Article XIIID (hereafter referred to as the “California Constitution”), the City Council of the City of Palm Desert, County of Riverside, State of California (hereafter referred to as “City”), proposes to levy special benefit assessments for the district designated as: City of Palm Desert Benefit Assessment District No. 1 Benefit Assessment District No. 1 (hereafter referred to as “District”), which includes lots and parcels of land within the subdivisions known as Monterey 170 and subdivision known as Section 29, within the City limits of Palm Desert. The areas included in the District are also known as Parcel Map No. 24255 (Monter ey 170) / Assessment District 2004-02 (Section 29). The Engineer’s Annual Levy Report (hereafter referred to as the “Report”) describes the District, the services, and the proposed assessments to be levied against properties in connection with the special benefits that the properties will receive from the maintenance and servicing of the District improvements and facilities for Fiscal Year 2024/2025. The District and the assessments described herein will provide a funding source (annual assessments) for the continued operation, maintenance and servicing of t he drainage basin, including expansions thereto. The services and assessments described in this Report are based on the current and planned development of properties within the District and represent an estimate of the direct expenditures, incidental expenses, and fund balances that will be necessary to operate, maintain and service the drainage basin that provides special benefits to properties within the District. The structure of the District (organization), the proposed services, the method of apportionment, and assessments described herein are based on the current and proposed development within the District; and by reference, the plans and specifications for the drainage basin and expansion thereto are made part of this Report. The word “parcel,” for the purposes of this Report, refers to an individu al property assigned its own Assessor’s Parcel Number (APN) by the Riverside County Assessor’s Office. The Riverside County Auditor-Controller uses Assessor’s Parcel Numbers and specific Fund Numbers to identify properties to be assessed on the tax roll fo r the special benefit assessments. As part of this District, the City of Palm Desert conducted a Property Owner Protest Ballot proceeding for the proposed levy of a new assessment pursuant to the provisions of the California Constitution, Article XIIID Section 4. In conjunction with this ballot proceeding, the City Council conducted a noticed public hearing to consider public testimonies, comments and written protests regarding the formation of the District and levy of 252 2024/2025 Benefit Assessment District No. 1 Page 2 assessments. At the public hearing, property owner protest ballots received were tabulated and a majority protest did not exist for the proposed assessments and the assessment range formula presented and described herein. The City Council approved the Report, ordered the formation of the District, and approved the levy and collection of assessments. Each subsequent fiscal year, a Report is prepared and presented to the City Council describing any changes to the proposed services, the annual budget and assessments for that fiscal year, and the City Council shall hold a noticed public hearing regarding these matters prior to approving and ordering the proposed levy of assessments. If the proposed assessments for the District exceed the maximum assessment described herein (as approved by the property owners), the new or increased assessment must be confirmed through another property owner protest ballot proceeding before such an assessment may be imposed. It should be noted that an increased assessment of an individual property resulting from changes in development or land use does not constitute an increased assessment. This Report consists of five (5) parts: Part I Plans and Specifications: A description of the District boundaries and the proposed improvements associated with the District. Part II The Method of Apportionment: A discussion of benefits the services provided to properties within the District and the method of calculating each property’s proportional special benefit and annual assessment. This section also identifies and outlines an Assessment Range Formula that provides for an annual adjustment to the Maximum Assessment Rate that establishes limits on future assessments, but also provides for reasonable cost adjustments due to inflation without the added expense of additional property owner protest ballot proceedings. Part III The District Budget: An estimate of the annual costs to operate, maintain and service the drainage basin improvements and facilities installed and constructed to support current and proposed development within the District. This budget includes an estimate of anticipated direct maintenance costs and incidental expenses including, but not limited to administration expenses and the collection of appropriate fund balances. The special benefit assessments are based on the overall operation, maintenance and serv icing costs minus any costs that are considered general benefit or not assessed as special benefit. The proposed assessments for the Fiscal Year 2024/2025, shall be based on the estimated net annual cost of operating, maintaining and servicing the District improvements for that fiscal year. The Maximum Assessments Rate (Rates per 253 2024/2025 Benefit Assessment District No. 1 Page 3 Equivalent Benefit Unit) identified in the budget of this Report shall be adjusted annually by the Assessment Range Formula described in the method of apportionment. Part IV District Diagram: A Diagram showing the exterior boundaries of the District is provided in this Report and includes all parcels that will receive special benefits from the services. Parcel identification, the lines and dimensions of each lot, parcel and subdivision of land within the District, are inclusive of all parcels as shown on the Riverside County Assessor's Parcel Maps as they existed at the time of the passage of the Resolution of Intention, and shall include all subsequent subdivisions, lot line adjustments or par cel changes therein. Reference is hereby made to the Riverside County Assessor’s maps for a detailed description of the lines and dimensions of each lot and parcel of land within the District. Part V Assessment Roll: A listing of the proposed assessment amount to be applied to each parcel within the District for the Fiscal Year 2024/2025. The proposed assessment amount for each parcel is based on the parcel’s proportional special benefit as outlined in the method of apportionment and the Maximum Assessment Rates. PART I — PLANS AND SPECIFICATIONS A. Benefiting Properties within the District The territory within the District consists of all lots, parcels and subdivisions of land within the subdivision known as Monterey 170 and the proposed subdivision known as Section 29, which encompasses an area of land totaling approximately four hundred sixty acres (460 acres). The subdivisions are generally located: North of Gerald Ford; Southwest of Interstate 10; West of Portola Avenue; and, East of Monterey Avenue. B. Funding authorized by the 1982 Act As generally defined by the 1982 Act and applicable to this District, the City may impose a benefit assessment to finance the maintenance, operation and servicing costs associated with the drainage basin described below. 254 2024/2025 Benefit Assessment District No. 1 Page 4 C. Description of Services The purpose of this District is to fund the activities necessary to operate, maintain and service the drainage basin constructed in a portion of Section 29, Township 4 South, Range 6 East SBM and to be enlarged in connection with current and new developmen t of properties. The maintenance, operation and servicing of these improvements may include but are not limited to all materials, equipment, labor, and incidental expenses deemed necessary to keep the drainage basin in satisfactory condition. The maintenan ce of the improvements and related activities shall be funded entirely through the District assessments. The District services are generally described as: • Drainage basin maintenance that may include but is not limited to inspection, repair, removal and replacement, and servicing of drainage basins, inlets, catch basins, manholes, outlets, drywells, pumps, filters and storm drain pipes installed in connection with the development of benefiting properties as well as any off -site improvements and facilities directly associated with the aforementioned infrastructure that is deemed necessary to service or protect the properties; • All appurtenant, equipment, materials and service contracts related to the operation, maintenance and servicing of the aforementioned improvements and facilities; • Detailed maps and descriptions of the location and extent of the specific improvements to be maintained by the District are on file in the Office of Public Works and by reference are made part of this Report. The annual cost to provide the services determined to be of special benefit shall be allocated to each property in proportion to the special benefits received from those various services. Drainage Basin Maintenance The drainage basin maintenance may include but is not limited to: grading of access perimeter roads, repair of erosion of slopes to access roads, debris clearance, anchor mat repairs, dust control through the application of soil stabilization agents, weed abatement, mosquito and vector control, storm drain inlets and outlets, pumps, filters and pipes. The annual assessments for this District are intended to support the drainage basin and the maintenance program that will adequately regulate and control storm water runoff resulting from current and proposed development within the District. This maintenance program may include but is not limited to: inspection and documentation of the system; cleaning, servicing or repair of the facilities and equipment; and the partial removal, replacement or rehabilitation of equipment and facilities. The drainage basin will cover an area of approximately 4 acres. The Public Works Department shall authorize and schedule all operational activities and maintenance of the drainage basin. 255 2024/2025 Benefit Assessment District No. 1 Page 5 A portion of the services described above might not be performed on an annual basis but due to an extraordinary event, such as replacement of the anchor mats and other major facility repairs, the funds necessary for these activities are collected as part of the annual assessments. The monies collected each year for these extraordinary services shall be accumulated in a special fund of the District (Reserve /Capital Improvement Fund). The monies accumulated for these activities shall be spent as needed to perform the services deemed necessary by the City. This process of providing a reserve/capital improvement shall continue until such time the District is dissolved; or the City determines that such funding procedures require modification. Changes in the process of providing a reserve/capital improvement that would result in an increase in the annual assessment rate must be presented to the property owners for approval prior to imposing such an increase. In March 2022, the City initiated an evaluation of the Section 29 Retention Basin. Following an assessment of the basin's capacity, which stands at 45.4 acre -feet, an additional 16.3 acre-feet of retention volume was deemed necessary to mitigate overflow risks and accommodate the storage requirements for a 100 -year storm event. The City has since designed for its improvement and expansion, and in December 2023, awarded a construction contract of approximately $4.63 million. The project is estimated to be completed in October 2024. The City will analyze the maintenance costs of these improvements following the project and incorporate them in future assessments. PART II — METHOD OF APPORTIONMENT A. General The 1982 Act permits the establishment of assessment districts by agencies for the purpose of providing for the maintenance, operation and servicing of drainage and flood control improvements as well as streets, roads, and appurtenant facilities. The 1982 Act further requires that the cost of these improvements be levied according to benefit rather than assessed value: “The amount of the assessment imposed on any parcel of property shall be related to the benefit to the parcel which will be derived from the provision of the service.” Furthermore: “The annual aggregate amount of the assessment shall not exceed the estimated annual cost of providing the service, except that the legislative body may, by resolution, determine that the estimated cost of work authorized … is greater than can be conveniently raised from a single annual assessment and order that the estimated cost shall be raised by an assessment levied and collected in installments…. The revenue derived from the assessment shall not be used to pay the cost of any service other than the service for which the assessment was levied.” 256 2024/2025 Benefit Assessment District No. 1 Page 6 The method of apportionment described in this Report for allocation of special benefit assessments utilizes commonly accepted engineering practices and in compliance with the provisions of the 1982 Act and the California Constitution. The formulas used for calculating assessments reflect the composition of parcels within the District and the improvements and services provided, to fairly apportion the costs based on the special benefits to each parcel. B. Benefit Analysis Each of the proposed services, and the associated costs and assessments have been carefully reviewed, identified, and allocated based on special benefit pursuant to the provisions of the 1982 Act and the California Constitution. The drainage basin improvements associated with this District are necessary and essential requirements for existing development, and the orderly development of future properties within the District to their full potential, consistent with the conditions for development of the proper ties, protection of downstream properties which would be negatively affected by increased storm runoff from the developed properties without the basin, and the applicable portions of the City General Plan. As such, the ongoing operation, servicing, and maintenance of those improvements would otherwise be the direct financial obligation of each individual property owner. Since the existing parcels and proposed new development to be assessed are directly served by the drainage basin, each parcel has a direct investment in the proper maintenance of the various improvements that is over and above any general benefits that may be conferred by such improvements and services. The construction and installation of these improvements are only necessary for the properties within the District. As such, these improvements were not required nor necessarily desired by any properties or developments outside the District boundary and any public access or use of the improvements by others is incidental. Therefore, it has been determined that the ongoing maintenance, servicing and operation of the District improvements provide no measurable general benefit to properties outside the District or to the public at large, but clearly provide distinct and special benefits to properties within the District. C. Assessment Methodology All costs associated with the services shall be fairly distributed among the parcels based upon the special benefit received by each parcel. Additionally, in compliance with the California Constitution Article XIIID Section 4, each parcel’s assessment may not exceed the reasonable cost of the proportional special benefit conferred to that parcel. The benefit formula used to determine the assessment obligation is therefore based upon both the services that benefit the parcels within the District as well as t he gross acreage of each property as compared to other parcels that benefit from those services. The method of apportionment established for this District and described herein, reflects 257 2024/2025 Benefit Assessment District No. 1 Page 7 the proportional special benefit each property receives from the services based on the gross acreage of that parcel as compared to the total gross acreage of all properties within the District except those that retain runoff on-site and do not receive any special benefit from those services. Equivalent Benefit Units In order to assess benefits equitably it is necessary to relate each property’s proportional special benefits to the special benefits of all other properties within the District. The method of apportionment established for this district, formed under the 1 982 Benefit Act, will utilize a weighted method of apportionment known as an Equivalent Benefit Unit (EBU) methodology. This proportional weighting may be based on several factors that may include but are not limited to: the type of development (land use), development- status (developed versus undeveloped), size of the property, location of the property, development plans or restrictions, vehicular trip generation, street frontage, densities or other property related factors. Generally, for most districts the calculation of each parcel’s proportional special benefit can be reasonably determined by applying one or more of these factors. Since the drainage basin will be constructed to retain runoff from the properties within the District and the cost of maintenance is directly related to the size of the basin, each parcel’s proportional special benefit has been based on the parcel’s gross acreage as compared to the total gross acreage of all other parcels within the District except those that retain runoff on-site and do not receive any special benefit from those services. Generally, storm water runoff occurs from the entire parcel before and after development. Thus, the gross size of a parcel prior to development provides a relative comparison to the amount of runoff the parcel will contribute to the drainage basin and thus the cost of maintenance. Therefore, it has been determined that for this District, each parcel ’s proportional benefit (Equivalent Benefit Units) shall be equal to the parcel’s gross acreage before development (rounded to two decimal places). Exempt Parcels — This land use identifies properties that are not assessed and are assigned 0.00 EBU. This land use classification may include but is not limited to: • Lots or parcels identified as public streets and other roadways (typically not assigned an APN by the County) which are otherwise included in the gross acreage of the parcel prior to development. • Dedicated public easements including open space areas, utility rights-of-way, greenbelts, parkways, parks or other publicly owned properties that are part of the District improvements or may provide other benefits to private properties within the District. • Private properties that cannot be developed independently from an adjacent property, such as common areas, sliver parcels or bifurcated lots or properties with very restrictive development use but are included in the gross acreage prior to development. 258 2024/2025 Benefit Assessment District No. 1 Page 8 • Parcels owned by the school district, Coachella Valley Water District and private developers that will not be assessed as part of this benefit assessment district, since the runoff generated by these properties shall be captured and retained onsite through the construction and grading of the sites. These types of parcels are considered to receive little or no benefit from the improvements and are therefore exempted from assessment but shall be reviewed annually by the assessment engineer to confirm the parcels’ current development status. Government owned properties or public properties are not necessarily exempt properties and shall be subject to special benefit assessment unless it qualifies for an exempt status. The following formula is used to calculate each parcel’s EBU (proportional benefit). Total Budget / Total EBU (Gross Acres) = Assessment Rate per EBU (Parcel’s Acreage / Total Net Acreage) x Total EBU = Parcel’s EBU Assessment Rate per EBU x Parcel’s EBU = Parcel Levy Amount For all subsequent parcel subdivisions that result in a final map of buildable residential lots, the number of EBUs assigned to such lots shall be calculated by taking the EBU initially calculated for the original Parcel (identified at the time of this Rep ort) and apportioning the original assigned EBUs equally to the new buildable residential lot(s) or by equivalent gross acreage for non-residential lots created by a subdivision map. The corresponding assessment shall be levied against the applicable corre sponding Assessor’s Parcel Number(s). D. Assessment Range Formula Any new or increased assessment requires certain noticing and meeting requirements by law. Prior to the passage of Proposition 218 (California Constitution Articles XIIIC and XIIID), legislative changes in the Brown Act defined a "new or increased assessme nt" to exclude certain conditions. These conditions included "any assessment that does not exceed an assessment formula or range of assessments previously adopted by the agency or approved by the voters in the area where the assessment is imposed." This definition and conditions were later confirmed through Senate Bill 919 (Proposition 218 implementing legislation). If the proposed annual assessment (levy per EBU) for the upcoming fiscal year is less than or equal to the adjusted Maximum Assessment Rate, then the proposed annual assessment is not considered an increased assessment. The purpose of establishing an Assessment Range Formula is to provide for reasonable increases and inflationary adjustment to annual assessments without requiring costly noticing and mailing procedures, which could add to the District costs and assessments. As part of the District formation, the notice and assessment ballots presented to the 259 2024/2025 Benefit Assessment District No. 1 Page 9 property owners for approval, included a maximum assessment amount for Fiscal Year 2007/2008 (initial maximum assessment), identification of the corresponding Maximum Assessment Rate and a summary of the Assessment Range Formula described herein. The Assessment Range Formula for this District shall be applied to all future assessments and is generally defined: The Maximum Assessment Rate is equal to the (Initial) Maximum Assessment Rate established for Fiscal Year 2007/2008 adjusted annually by the greater of three percent (3%) or the annual percentage change in the Consumer Price Index (CPI) of “All Urban Consumers” for the Los Angeles-Long Beach-Anaheim Area for March. Starting fiscal year 2019/2020 the Maximum Assessment Rate will be adjusted annually by the greater of three percent (3%) or the annual percentage change in the Consumer Price Index (CPI) of “All Urban Consumers” for the Riverside-San Bernardino-Ontario Area. Beginning in the second fiscal year (Fiscal Year 2008/2009) and each fiscal year thereafter, the Maximum Assessment Rate will be recalculated, and a new Maximum Assessment Rate established for the fiscal year utilizing the Assessment Range Formula described above. The adjusted Maximum Assessment Rate shall be calculated independent of the District’s annual budget and proposed assessment. The ann ual percentage change in CPI shall be based on available data provided by the U.S. Department of Labor; Bureau of Labor Statistics at the time the annual Report is prepared. Should the Bureau of Labor Statistics revise such index or discontinue the prepara tion of such index, the City shall use the revised index or comparable system as approved by the City Council for determining fluctuations in the cost of living. Any proposed annual assessment (rate per EBU) less than or equal to the calculated (adjusted) Maximum Assessment Rate is not considered an increased assessment, even if the proposed assessment is greater than the assessment applied in the prior fiscal year. To impose a new or increased assessment other than the annual inflationary adjustment provided by the preceding Assessment Range Formula, the City must comply with the provisions of the California Constitution Article XIIID Section 4c, that requires a publ ic hearing and certain protest procedures including mailed notice of the public hearing and property owner protest balloting. Property owners, through the balloting process, must approve a proposed new or increased assessment before such an assessment may be imposed. 260 2024/2025 Benefit Assessment District No. 1 Page 10 PART III — DISTRICT BUDGET Direct Costs Total Section 29 Storm Drain and Basin Maintenance $ 100,000.00 $ 100,000.00 Administration City Administration Overhead $ 15,093.07 Professional fees for Administration 3,049.67 County Administration Fee 457.12 $ 18,599.86 RESERVE FUND /CIP FUND $ 141,807.72 BALANCE TO LEVY (1) $ 260,407.58 Parcels Levied 787 Total EBU's (Gross Acres) 453.66 FY 2024/2025 MAXIMUM LEVY PER EBU $ 734.60 FY 2024/2025 LEVY PER EBU $ 574.02 FY 2023/2024 MAXIMUM LEVY PER EBU $ 704.60 FY 2023/2024 LEVY PER EBU $ 574.02 Estimated Beginning Reserve Balance - June 30, 2024 $ 926,124.10 Reserve Fund Adjustments - Estimated Ending Reserve Balance - June 30, 2025 $ 926,124.10 Beginning CIP Fund Balance - June 30, 2024 $ 2,555,780.62 CIP Fund Adjustments 141,807.72 Estimated CIP Balance - June 30, 2025 $ 2,697,588.34 (1) Slight variance from Charge total sum on Assessment Roll due to rounding. 261 2024/2025 Benefit Assessment District No. 1 Page 11 PART IV — DISTRICT DIAGRAMS The parcels within Benefit Assessment District No. 1, Parcel Map No. 24255 (Monterey 170) / Assessment District 2004-02 (Section 29) consist of lots, parcels and subdivisions of land located in the planned residential and commercial development known as Section 29 and Monterey 170. The District covers approximately four hundred sixty acres (460 acres) in the City of Palm Desert. The following District Diagram is based on the Riverside County Assessor’s Maps and the Riverside County Assessor’s information and identifies all the parcels of land within the proposed District, as the same existed at the time this Report was prepared. T he combination of this map and the Assessment Roll contained in this Report constitutes the District Assessment Diagram. 262 2024/2025 Benefit Assessment District No. 1 Page 12 263 2024/2025 Benefit Assessment District No. 1 Page 13 PART V — ASSESSMENT ROLL Parcel identification for each lot or parcel within the District is based on the Assessment Diagram presented herein and is based on available parcel maps and property data from the Riverside County Assessor’s Office at the time the Engineer’s Report was p repared. A listing of the proposed lots and parcels to be assessed within this District along with the assessment amounts is provided herein. Non-assessable lots or parcels may include, but are not limited to , public streets and other roadways (typically not assigned an APN by the County); dedicated public easements, open space areas, right-of-ways, common areas; bifurcated lots, and any other property that cannot be developed or has little or no value. These types of parcels are considered to receive little or no benefit from the improvements and are therefore exempted from assessment. If any parcel submitted for collection is identified by the County Auditor -Controller to be an invalid parcel number for the fiscal year, a corrected parcel number and/or new parcel numbers will be identified and resubmitted to the County Auditor -Controller. The assessment amount to be levied and collected for the resubmitted parcel or parcels shall be based on the method of apportionment and assessment rate described in this Report as approved by the City Council. Therefore, if a single parcel is subdivide d to multiple parcels, the assessment amount applied to each of the new parcels shall be recalculated and applied according to the approved method of apportionment and assessment rate rather than a proportionate share of the original assessment. 264 APN Situs Address Land Use Benefit Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge 694-060-013 73550 DINAH SHORE DR COM 3.61 $2,619.92 $2,072.20 694-060-014 73600 DINAH SHORE DR COM 11.42 8,287.95 6,555.30 694-060-017 73760 DINAH SHORE DR COM 1.04 754.77 596.98 694-060-026 73750 DINAH SHORE DR COM 3.43 2,489.29 1,968.88 694-060-031 73650 DINAH SHORE DR COM 1.87 1,357.13 1,073.40 694-060-034 NO SITUS AVAILABLE COM 2.04 1,480.13 1,170.70 694-060-036 73450 DINAH SHORE DR COM 4.54 3,295.24 2,606.34 694-061-001 73700 DINAH SHORE DR ##101 COM 0.17 126.50 100.04 694-061-002 73700 DINAH SHORE DR ##102 COM 0.17 126.50 100.04 694-061-003 73700 DINAH SHORE DR ##103 COM 0.17 126.50 100.04 694-061-004 73700 DINAH SHORE DR ##104 COM 0.17 126.50 100.04 694-061-005 73700 DINAH SHORE DR ##105 COM 0.17 126.50 100.04 694-061-006 73700 DINAH SHORE DR ##106 COM 0.17 126.50 100.04 694-061-007 73700 DINAH SHORE DR ##107 COM 0.17 126.50 100.04 694-061-008 73700 DINAH SHORE DR ##201 COM 0.17 126.50 100.04 694-061-009 73700 DINAH SHORE DR ##202 COM 0.17 126.50 100.04 694-061-010 73700 DINAH SHORE DR ##203 COM 0.17 126.50 100.04 694-061-011 73700 DINAH SHORE DR ##204 COM 0.17 126.50 100.04 694-061-012 73700 DINAH SHORE DR ##205 COM 0.17 126.50 100.04 694-061-013 73700 DINAH SHORE DR ##206 COM 0.17 126.50 100.04 694-061-014 73700 DINAH SHORE DR ##207 COM 0.17 126.50 100.04 694-061-015 73700 DINAH SHORE DR ##301 COM 0.17 126.50 100.04 694-061-016 73700 DINAH SHORE DR ##302 COM 0.17 126.50 100.04 694-061-017 73700 DINAH SHORE DR ##303 COM 0.17 126.50 100.04 694-061-018 73700 DINAH SHORE DR ##304 COM 0.17 126.50 100.04 694-061-019 73700 DINAH SHORE DR ##305 COM 0.17 126.50 100.04 694-061-020 73700 DINAH SHORE DR ##306 COM 0.17 126.50 100.04 694-061-021 73700 DINAH SHORE DR ##307 COM 0.17 126.50 100.04 694-061-022 73700 DINAH SHORE DR ##401 COM 0.17 126.50 100.04 694-061-023 73700 DINAH SHORE DR ##402 COM 0.17 126.50 100.04 694-061-024 73700 DINAH SHORE DR ##403 COM 0.17 126.50 100.04 694-061-025 73700 DINAH SHORE DR ##404 COM 0.17 126.50 100.04 694-061-026 73700 DINAH SHORE DR ##405 COM 0.17 126.50 100.04 694-061-027 73700 DINAH SHORE DR ##406 COM 0.17 126.50 100.04 694-061-028 73700 DINAH SHORE DR ##407 COM 0.17 126.50 100.04 694-061-030 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##101 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-031 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##102 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-032 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##103 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-033 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##104 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-034 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##105 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-035 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##106 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-036 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##107 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-037 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##108 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-038 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##109 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-039 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##110 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-040 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##111 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-041 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##112 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-042 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##113 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 City of Palm Desert Benefit Assessment District No. 1 Final Prelim Report (Sorted by Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/25 265 APN Situs Address Land Use Benefit Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge City of Palm Desert Benefit Assessment District No. 1 Final Prelim Report (Sorted by Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/25 694-061-043 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##114 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-044 73660 DINAH SHORE DR CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-045 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##116 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-046 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##117 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-047 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##218 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-048 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##219 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-049 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##220 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-050 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##221 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-051 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##222 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-052 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##223 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-053 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##224 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-054 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##225 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-055 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##226 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-056 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##227 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-057 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##228 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-058 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##229 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-059 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##230 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-060 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##231 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-061 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##232 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-062 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##233 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-063 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##234 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-064 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##235 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-065 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##236 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-066 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##237 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-067 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##238 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-068 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##239 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-069 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##240 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-070 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##241 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-071 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##242 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-072 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##243 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-073 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##244 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-074 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##245 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-075 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##246 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-076 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##247 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-077 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##248 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-061-078 73660 DINAH SHORE DR ##249 CON 0.06 44.58 35.26 694-080-005 73820 DINAH SHORE DR COM 0.40 290.30 229.60 694-080-006 73800 DINAH SHORE DR COM 1.36 987.01 780.66 694-080-007 73818 DINAH SHORE DR COM 0.33 239.49 189.42 694-080-008 73814 DINAH SHORE DR COM 0.33 239.49 189.42 694-080-009 73810 DINAH SHORE DR COM 0.33 239.49 189.42 694-080-010 73808 DINAH SHORE DR COM 0.39 283.04 223.86 694-080-011 73806 DINAH SHORE DR COM 0.52 377.38 298.48 694-080-012 73812 DINAH SHORE DR COM 0.38 275.78 218.12 694-080-013 73816 DINAH SHORE DR COM 0.40 290.30 229.60 694-080-014 73802 DINAH SHORE DR COM 0.33 239.49 189.42 694-080-015 73804 DINAH SHORE DR COM 0.63 457.22 361.62 694-081-001 73850 DINAH SHORE DR ##101 COM 0.15 108.86 86.10 266 APN Situs Address Land Use Benefit Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge City of Palm Desert Benefit Assessment District No. 1 Final Prelim Report (Sorted by Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/25 694-081-002 73850 DINAH SHORE DR ##102 COM 0.10 72.57 57.40 694-081-003 73850 DINAH SHORE DR ##103 COM 0.11 79.83 63.14 694-081-004 73850 DINAH SHORE DR ##104 COM 0.10 72.57 57.40 694-081-005 73850 DINAH SHORE DR ##105 COM 0.11 79.83 63.14 694-081-006 73850 DINAH SHORE DR ##106 COM 0.12 87.09 68.88 694-081-007 73850 DINAH SHORE DR ##107 COM 0.13 94.35 74.62 694-081-008 73850 DINAH SHORE DR ##108 COM 0.14 101.60 80.36 694-081-009 73850 DINAH SHORE DR ##109 COM 0.19 137.89 109.06 694-081-010 73850 DINAH SHORE DR ##110 COM 0.15 108.86 86.10 694-081-011 73850 DINAH SHORE DR ##111 COM 0.15 108.86 86.10 694-081-012 73850 DINAH SHORE DR ##112 COM 0.15 108.86 86.10 694-081-013 73850 DINAH SHORE DR ##113 COM 0.14 101.60 80.36 694-081-014 73850 DINAH SHORE DR ##114 COM 0.14 101.60 80.36 694-081-015 73850 DINAH SHORE DR ##115 COM 0.27 195.95 154.98 694-081-016 73900 DINAH SHORE DR ##201 COM 0.13 94.35 74.62 694-081-017 73900 DINAH SHORE DR ##202 COM 0.08 58.06 45.92 694-081-018 73900 DINAH SHORE DR ##203 COM 0.08 58.06 45.92 694-081-019 73900 DINAH SHORE DR ##204 COM 0.08 58.06 45.92 694-081-020 73900 DINAH SHORE DR ##205 COM 0.09 65.32 51.66 694-081-021 73900 DINAH SHORE DR ##206 COM 0.08 58.06 45.92 694-081-022 73900 DINAH SHORE DR ##207 COM 0.08 58.06 45.92 694-081-023 73900 DINAH SHORE DR ##208 COM 0.09 65.32 51.66 694-081-024 73900 DINAH SHORE DR ##209 COM 0.09 65.32 51.66 694-081-025 73950 DINAH SHORE DR ##301 COM 0.12 87.09 68.88 694-081-026 73950 DINAH SHORE DR ##302 COM 0.08 58.06 45.92 694-081-027 73950 DINAH SHORE DR ##303 COM 0.10 72.57 57.40 694-081-028 73950 DINAH SHORE DR ##304 COM 0.11 79.83 63.14 694-081-029 73950 DINAH SHORE DR ##305 COM 0.12 87.09 68.88 694-081-030 73950 DINAH SHORE DR ##306 COM 0.13 94.35 74.62 694-081-031 73950 DINAH SHORE DR ##307 COM 0.13 94.35 74.62 694-081-032 73950 DINAH SHORE DR ##308 COM 0.21 152.41 120.54 694-081-033 74000 DINAH SHORE DR ##401 COM 0.07 50.80 40.18 694-081-034 74000 DINAH SHORE DR ##402 COM 0.07 50.80 40.18 694-081-035 74000 DINAH SHORE DR ##403 COM 0.07 50.80 40.18 694-081-036 74000 DINAH SHORE DR ##404 COM 0.07 50.80 40.18 694-081-037 74000 DINAH SHORE DR ##405 COM 0.07 50.80 40.18 694-081-038 74000 DINAH SHORE DR ##406 COM 0.07 50.80 40.18 694-081-039 74000 DINAH SHORE DR ##407 COM 0.07 50.80 40.18 694-081-040 74000 DINAH SHORE DR ##408 COM 0.07 50.80 40.18 694-081-041 74000 DINAH SHORE DR ##409 COM 0.06 43.54 34.44 694-081-042 74000 DINAH SHORE DR ##410 COM 0.07 50.80 40.18 694-081-043 74000 DINAH SHORE DR ##411 COM 0.07 50.80 40.18 694-081-044 74000 DINAH SHORE DR ##412 COM 0.07 50.80 40.18 694-081-045 74000 DINAH SHORE DR ##413 COM 0.07 50.80 40.18 694-081-046 74000 DINAH SHORE DR ##414 COM 0.09 65.32 51.66 694-090-001 34550 MONTEREY AVE COM 12.81 9,296.73 7,353.18 694-090-006 34700 MONTEREY AVE COM 1.36 987.01 780.66 694-090-007 34620 MONTEREY AVE COM 0.82 595.11 470.68 267 APN Situs Address Land Use Benefit Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge City of Palm Desert Benefit Assessment District No. 1 Final Prelim Report (Sorted by Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/25 694-090-008 34580 MONTEREY AVE COM 1.00 725.74 574.02 694-090-009 34540 MONTEREY AVE COM 1.22 885.40 700.30 694-090-010 34460 MONTEREY AVE ##103 COM 0.43 312.07 246.82 694-090-011 34220 MONTEREY AVE COM 15.20 11,031.25 8,725.10 694-090-012 34500 MONTEREY AVE COM 9.21 6,684.07 5,286.72 694-090-013 34460 MONTEREY AVE CMV 0.93 674.94 533.82 694-090-014 34420 MONTEREY AVE COM 0.93 674.94 533.82 694-090-015 34380 MONTEREY AVE COM 1.30 943.46 746.22 694-090-016 34340 MONTEREY AVE COM 1.01 733.00 579.76 694-090-017 34300 MONTEREY AVE COM 1.21 878.15 694.56 694-090-021 34140 MONTEREY AVE COM 1.43 1,037.81 820.84 694-090-022 34200 MONTEREY AVE COM 2.17 1,574.86 1,245.62 694-090-023 34500 MONTEREY AVE CMV 0.50 362.87 287.00 694-090-024 NO SITUS AVAILABLE CMV 1.98 1,436.97 1,136.54 694-090-027 34740 MONTEREY AVE COM 3.02 2,191.73 1,733.54 694-090-028 34900 MONTEREY AVE COM 2.81 2,039.33 1,612.98 694-090-029 34860 MONTEREY AVE COM 1.72 1,248.27 987.30 694-090-031 34660 MONTEREY AVE COM 2.39 1,734.52 1,371.90 694-090-032 34940 MONTEREY AVE COM 8.26 5,994.61 4,741.40 694-090-040 34260 MONTEREY AVE COM 1.00 725.74 574.02 694-090-041 34180 MONTEREY AVE COM 0.96 696.71 551.04 694-090-042 34100 MONTEREY AVE COM 1.29 936.20 740.48 694-130-016 NO SITUS AVAILABLE CMV 14.62 10,610.32 8,392.16 694-130-017 NO SITUS AVAILABLE CMV 11.16 8,099.26 6,406.06 694-130-018 NO SITUS AVAILABLE CMV 3.75 2,721.53 2,152.56 694-130-021 NO SITUS AVAILABLE CMV 26.41 19,166.79 15,159.86 694-130-022 35900 MONTEREY AVE COM 22.25 16,147.72 12,771.94 694-140-001 35476 CORTESIA WAY SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-002 35462 CORTESIA WAY SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-003 35448 CORTESIA WAY SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-004 35434 CORTESIA WAY SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-005 35420 CORTESIA WAY SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-006 35406 CORTESIA WAY SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-007 35392 CORTESIA WAY SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-008 35378 CORTESIA WAY SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-009 35364 CORTESIA WAY SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-010 35350 CORTESIA WAY SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-011 73640 CIERRA ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-012 73626 CIERRA ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-013 73612 CIERRA ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-014 73598 CIERRA ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-015 73584 CIERRA ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-016 73570 CIERRA ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-017 73556 CIERRA ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-018 73542 CIERRA ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-019 73528 CIERRA ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-020 73514 CIERRA ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-021 73500 CIERRA ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 268 APN Situs Address Land Use Benefit Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge City of Palm Desert Benefit Assessment District No. 1 Final Prelim Report (Sorted by Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/25 694-140-022 73486 CIERRA ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-023 73472 CIERRA ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-026 73430 CIERRA ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-027 35375 DOMANI DR SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-028 35383 DOMANI DR SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-029 NO SITUS AVAILABLE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-030 NO SITUS AVAILABLE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-031 NO SITUS AVAILABLE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-032 35439 DOMANI DR SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-033 35453 DOMANI DR SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-034 NO SITUS AVAILABLE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-035 NO SITUS AVAILABLE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-036 NO SITUS AVAILABLE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-037 35432 DOMANI DR SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-038 35446 DOMANI DR SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-039 NO SITUS AVAILABLE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-040 NO SITUS AVAILABLE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-041 NO SITUS AVAILABLE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-042 NO SITUS AVAILABLE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-043 NO SITUS AVAILABLE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-044 NO SITUS AVAILABLE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-045 NO SITUS AVAILABLE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-046 NO SITUS AVAILABLE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-047 NO SITUS AVAILABLE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-048 NO SITUS AVAILABLE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-049 35414 SERENO LN SFR 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-050 35428 SERENO LN SFR 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-051 35442 SERENO LN SFR 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-052 35456 SERENO LN SFR 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-053 35515 BAINS AVE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-054 35501 BAINS AVE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-055 35487 BAINS AVE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-056 35473 BAINS AVE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-057 35459 BAINS AVE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-058 35445 BAINS AVE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-059 NO SITUS AVAILABLE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-060 NO SITUS AVAILABLE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-061 NO SITUS AVAILABLE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-062 NO SITUS AVAILABLE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-063 NO SITUS AVAILABLE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-064 NO SITUS AVAILABLE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-065 NO SITUS AVAILABLE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-066 NO SITUS AVAILABLE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-067 35452 BAINS AVE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-068 35466 BAINS AVE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-069 35480 BAINS AVE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-070 35483 CORTESIA WAY SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-071 35469 CORTESIA WAY SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 269 APN Situs Address Land Use Benefit Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge City of Palm Desert Benefit Assessment District No. 1 Final Prelim Report (Sorted by Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/25 694-140-072 35455 CORTESIA WAY SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-073 35441 CORTESIA WAY SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-074 35427 CORTESIA WAY SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-075 35413 CORTESIA WAY SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-076 35399 CORTESIA WAY SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-090 73444 CIERRA ST SFR 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-140-091 73458 CIERRA ST SFR 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-001 35481 DOMANI DR SFR 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-002 35495 DOMANI DR SFR 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-003 35509 DOMANI DR SFR 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-004 35523 DOMANI DR SFR 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-005 35537 DOMANI DR SFR 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-006 35551 DOMANI DR SFR 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-007 35565 DOMANI DR SFR 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-008 35579 DOMANI DR SFR 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-009 35593 DOMANI DR SFR 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-010 73435 TRAVERS ST SFR 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-011 73441 TRAVERS ST SFR 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-012 73447 TRAVERS ST SFR 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-013 73453 TRAVERS ST SFR 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-014 73467 TRAVERS ST SFR 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-015 73481 TRAVERS ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-016 73495 TRAVERS ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-017 73509 TRAVERS ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-018 73523 TRAVERS ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-019 73537 TRAVERS ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-020 73551 TRAVERS ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-021 73565 TRAVERS ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-022 73579 TRAVERS ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-023 73593 TRAVERS ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-024 73607 TRAVERS ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-025 73621 TRAVERS ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-026 73635 TRAVERS ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-029 35630 CORTESIA WAY SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-030 35616 CORTESIA WAY SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-031 35602 CORTESIA WAY SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-032 35588 CORTESIA WAY SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-033 35574 CORTESIA WAY SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-034 35560 CORTESIA WAY SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-035 35546 CORTESIA WAY SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-036 35532 CORTESIA WAY SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-037 35518 CORTESIA WAY SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-038 35504 CORTESIA WAY SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-039 35490 CORTESIA WAY SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-040 35474 DOMANI DR SFR 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-041 35488 DOMANI DR SFR 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-042 35502 DOMANI DR SFR 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-043 35516 DOMANI DR SFR 0.22 159.66 126.28 270 APN Situs Address Land Use Benefit Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge City of Palm Desert Benefit Assessment District No. 1 Final Prelim Report (Sorted by Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/25 694-150-044 35530 DOMANI DR SFR 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-045 35544 DOMANI DR SFR 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-046 35572 DOMANI DR SFR 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-047 35586 DOMANI DR SFR 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-048 73474 TRAVERS ST SFR 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-049 73488 TRAVERS ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-050 73502 TRAVERS ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-051 73516 TRAVERS ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-052 73530 TRAVERS ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-053 73544 TRAVERS ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-054 73558 TRAVERS ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-055 73572 TRAVERS ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-056 73586 TRAVERS ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-057 73600 TRAVERS ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-058 73614 TRAVERS ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-059 73628 TRAVERS ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-060 73642 TRAVERS ST SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-061 73645 GRANITA DR SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-062 73631 GRANITA DR SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-063 73617 GRANITA DR SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-064 73603 GRANITA DR SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-065 73589 GRANITA DR SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-066 73575 GRANITA DR SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-067 73561 GRANITA DR SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-068 73547 GRANITA DR SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-069 73533 GRANITA DR SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-070 73519 GRANITA DR SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-071 35533 SERENO LN SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-072 35519 SERENO LN SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-073 35505 SERENO LN SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-074 35491 SERENO LN SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-075 35477 SERENO LN SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-076 35494 BAINS AVE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-077 35508 BAINS AVE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-078 35522 BAINS AVE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-079 35536 BAINS AVE SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-080 35539 CORTESIA WAY SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-081 35525 CORTESIA WAY SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-082 35511 CORTESIA WAY SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-083 35497 CORTESIA WAY SFV 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-090 35638 CORTESIA WAY SFR 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-150-091 35638 CORTESIA WAY SFR 0.22 159.66 126.28 694-240-001 34550 SPYDER CIR COM 0.66 478.99 378.84 694-240-002 NO SITUS AVAILABLE CMV 0.52 377.38 298.48 694-240-003 34750 SPYDER CIR COM 0.50 362.87 287.00 694-240-004 NO SITUS AVAILABLE CMV 0.50 362.87 287.00 694-240-005 NO SITUS AVAILABLE CMV 0.50 362.87 287.00 694-240-007 73725 DINAH SHORE DR CMV 1.30 943.46 746.22 271 APN Situs Address Land Use Benefit Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge City of Palm Desert Benefit Assessment District No. 1 Final Prelim Report (Sorted by Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/25 694-240-008 73771 DINAH SHORE DR COM 2.13 1,545.83 1,222.66 694-240-009 NO SITUS AVAILABLE CMV 0.56 406.41 321.44 694-240-010 NO SITUS AVAILABLE CMV 0.50 362.87 287.00 694-240-011 NO SITUS AVAILABLE CMV 0.50 362.87 287.00 694-240-012 NO SITUS AVAILABLE CMV 0.50 362.87 287.00 694-240-013 NO SITUS AVAILABLE CMV 0.56 406.41 321.44 694-240-014 NO SITUS AVAILABLE CMV 1.01 733.00 579.76 694-240-015 34901 SPYDER CIR COM 0.56 406.41 321.44 694-240-016 34801 SPYDER CIR COM 0.50 362.87 287.00 694-240-017 NO SITUS AVAILABLE CMV 0.50 362.87 287.00 694-240-018 NO SITUS AVAILABLE CMV 0.50 362.87 287.00 694-240-019 NO SITUS AVAILABLE CMV 0.62 449.96 355.88 694-240-020 NO SITUS AVAILABLE CMV 1.02 740.25 585.50 694-240-021 NO SITUS AVAILABLE CMV 0.94 682.20 539.56 694-240-022 73605 DINAH SHORE DR ##100A COM 1.00 725.74 574.02 694-240-023 73605 DINAH SHORE DR ##200B COM 0.59 428.19 338.66 694-240-024 73605 DINAH SHORE DR ##300C COM 0.47 341.10 269.78 694-240-025 73605 DINAH SHORE DR ##400D COM 0.99 718.48 568.26 694-240-026 73605 DINAH SHORE DR ##500E COM 0.56 406.41 321.44 694-240-027 73605 DINAH SHORE DR ##600F COM 0.46 333.84 264.04 694-240-028 73605 DINAH SHORE DR ##700G COM 0.43 312.07 246.82 694-240-029 73605 DINAH SHORE DR ##800H COM 0.55 399.16 315.70 694-240-030 73605 DINAH SHORE DR ##900I COM 0.62 449.96 355.88 694-240-031 73605 DINAH SHORE DR ##1000 COM 0.80 580.59 459.20 694-240-032 73605 DINAH SHORE DR ##1100 COM 0.81 587.85 464.94 694-240-033 73605 DINAH SHORE DR ##1200 COM 1.19 863.63 683.08 694-240-034 73605 DINAH SHORE DR ##1500 COM 0.54 391.90 309.96 694-240-035 73605 DINAH SHORE DR ##1600 COM 0.54 391.90 309.96 694-240-047 73750 SPYDER CIR COM 0.61 442.70 350.14 694-240-048 73760 SPYDER CIR COM 0.61 442.70 350.14 694-241-001 73605 DINAH SHORE DR ##1400 COM 0.23 166.92 132.02 694-241-002 73605 DINAH SHORE DR ##1400 COM 0.20 145.15 114.80 694-241-003 73605 DINAH SHORE DR ##1401 COM 0.20 145.15 114.80 694-241-004 73605 DINAH SHORE DR ##1400 COM 0.23 166.92 132.02 694-241-006 73605 DINAH SHORE DR ##1320 COM 0.31 224.98 177.94 694-241-007 73605 DINAH SHORE DR ##1310 COM 0.14 101.60 80.36 694-241-008 73605 DINAH SHORE DR ##1300 COM 0.14 101.60 80.36 694-241-010 34390 GATEWAY DR ##A-100 COM 0.75 543.23 429.66 694-241-011 34360 GATEWAY DR ##B-100 COM 0.30 217.29 171.86 694-241-012 34330 GATEWAY DR ##C-100 COM 0.38 277.67 219.62 694-241-013 34330 GATEWAY DR ##C-110 COM 0.38 277.67 219.62 694-241-014 34300 GATEWAY DR ##D-100 COM 0.29 208.21 164.68 694-241-015 34300 GATEWAY DR ##D-110 COM 0.26 185.14 146.42 694-241-016 34300 GATEWAY DR ##D-120 COM 0.29 208.21 164.68 694-241-017 34470 GATEWAY DR ##E-100 COM 0.29 208.21 164.68 694-241-018 34470 GATEWAY DR ##E-110 COM 0.29 208.21 164.68 694-241-019 34500 GATEWAY DR ##F-100 COM 0.26 185.14 146.42 694-241-020 34500 GATEWAY DR ##F-110 COM 0.19 138.83 109.80 272 APN Situs Address Land Use Benefit Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge City of Palm Desert Benefit Assessment District No. 1 Final Prelim Report (Sorted by Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/25 694-241-021 34500 GATEWAY DR ##F-120 COM 0.26 185.14 146.42 694-241-022 34420 GATEWAY DR ##G-100 COM 1.91 1,388.34 1,098.10 694-241-023 34450 GATEWAY DR ##H-100 COM 1.82 1,318.89 1,043.16 694-241-024 34450 GATEWAY DR ##H-110 COM 1.75 1,272.66 1,006.60 694-250-001 73816 RIVERA CT SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-002 73830 RIVERA CT SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-003 73823 RIVERA CT SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-007 35768 RAPHAEL DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-008 35782 RAPHAEL DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-009 73809 RIVERA CT SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-010 35796 RAPHAEL DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-011 35810 RAPHAEL DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-012 35824 RAPHAEL DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-013 73812 DA VINCI CT SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-014 73824 DA VINCI CT SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-015 73861 DA VINCI CT SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-016 73847 DA VINCI CT SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-017 73833 DA VINCI CT SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-018 73819 DA VINCI CT SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-019 35838 RAPHAEL DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-020 35852 RAPHAEL DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-021 35866 RAPHAEL DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-022 35880 RAPHAEL DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-023 35887 RAPHAEL DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-024 35873 RAPHAEL DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-025 35859 RAPHAEL DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-026 35845 RAPHAEL DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-027 35831 RAPHAEL DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-028 35817 RAPHAEL DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-029 35803 RAPHAEL DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-030 35789 RAPHAEL DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-031 35775 RAPHAEL DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-032 35761 RAPHAEL DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-033 73768 CEZANNE DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-034 73782 CEZANNE DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-035 73796 CEZANNE DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-036 73810 CEZANNE DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-037 73824 CEZANNE DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-038 73838 CEZANNE DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-039 73852 CEZANNE DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-040 73866 CEZANNE DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-041 73880 CEZANNE DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-042 73845 CEZANNE DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-043 73831 CEZANNE DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-044 73817 CEZANNE DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-045 73803 CEZANNE DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-046 73789 CEZANNE DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-047 73775 CEZANNE DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 273 APN Situs Address Land Use Benefit Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge City of Palm Desert Benefit Assessment District No. 1 Final Prelim Report (Sorted by Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/25 694-250-048 73761 CEZANNE DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-049 73810 VAN GOGH DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-050 73806 PICASSO DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-051 73820 PICASSO DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-250-052 35747 RAPHAEL DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-001 73628 DALI CT SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-002 35877 MATISSE DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-003 35863 MATISSE DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-004 73677 KANDINSKY WAY SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-005 73663 KANDINSKY WAY SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-006 73649 KANDINSKY WAY SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-007 73635 KANDINSKY WAY SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-008 35860 RENOIR PL SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-009 35867 RENOIR PL SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-010 35853 RENOIR PL SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-011 35839 RENOIR PL SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-012 35825 RENOIR PL SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-013 35811 RENOIR PL SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-014 73642 KANDINSKY WAY SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-015 73656 KANDINSKY WAY SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-016 73670 KANDINSKY WAY SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-017 73684 KANDINSKY WAY SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-018 73698 KANDINSKY WAY SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-019 73712 KANDINSKY WAY SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-020 73726 KANDINSKY WAY SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-021 73740 KANDINSKY WAY SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-022 73754 KANDINSKY WAY SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-023 73768 KANDINSKY WAY SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-024 73782 VAN GOGH DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-025 73796 VAN GOGH DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-026 73775 VAN GOGH DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-027 73761 VAN GOGH DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-028 35856 MATISSE DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-029 35870 MATISSE DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-030 73645 PICASSO DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-031 73659 PICASSO DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-032 73673 PICASSO DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-033 73687 PICASSO DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-034 73701 PICASSO DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-035 73715 PICASSO DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-036 73729 PICASSO DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-037 73743 PICASSO DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-038 73757 PICASSO DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-039 73771 PICASSO DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-040 73785 PICASSO DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-041 73799 PICASSO DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-042 73813 PICASSO DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-260-043 73827 PICASSO DR SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 274 APN Situs Address Land Use Benefit Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge City of Palm Desert Benefit Assessment District No. 1 Final Prelim Report (Sorted by Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/25 694-260-049 73596 PICASSO DR SFR 0.35 256.43 202.82 694-260-050 73610 PICASSO DR SFR 0.35 256.43 202.82 694-260-051 73624 PICASSO DR SFR 0.35 256.43 202.82 694-260-052 73638 PICASSO DR SFR 0.35 256.43 202.82 694-260-053 73652 PICASSO DR SFR 0.35 256.43 202.82 694-260-054 73666 PICASSO DR SFR 0.35 256.43 202.82 694-260-055 73680 PICASSO DR SFR 0.35 256.43 202.82 694-260-056 73694 PICASSO DR SFR 0.35 256.43 202.82 694-260-057 73708 PICASSO DR SFR 0.35 256.43 202.82 694-260-058 73722 PICASSO DR SFR 0.35 256.43 202.82 694-260-059 73736 PICASSO DR SFR 0.35 256.43 202.82 694-260-060 73750 PICASSO DR SFR 0.35 256.43 202.82 694-260-061 73764 PICASSO DR SFR 0.35 256.43 202.82 694-260-062 73778 PICASSO DR SFR 0.35 256.43 202.82 694-260-063 73792 PICASSO DR SFR 0.35 256.43 202.82 694-260-072 35833 RENOIR PL SFR 0.34 244.10 193.06 694-270-002 35933 MATISSE DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-270-003 35919 MATISSE DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-270-004 35905 MATISSE DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-270-005 35891 MATISSE DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-270-006 73635 DALI CT SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-270-007 73649 DALI CT SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-270-008 73642 DALI CT SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-270-009 35874 RENOIR PL SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-270-010 35888 RENOIR PL SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-270-011 35902 RENOIR PL SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-270-012 35923 RENOIR PL SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-270-013 35909 RENOIR PL SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-270-014 35895 RENOIR PL SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-270-015 35881 RENOIR PL SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-270-016 73789 VAN GOGH DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-270-017 35884 MATISSE DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-270-018 35898 MATISSE DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-270-019 35912 MATISSE DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-270-020 35926 MATISSE DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-270-026 35937 RENOIR PL SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-027 35951 RENOIR PL SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-028 35965 RENOIR PL SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-029 35979 RENOIR PL SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-030 35993 RENOIR PL SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-031 73615 VERMEER WAY SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-032 73629 VERMEER WAY SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-033 73643 VERMEER WAY SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-034 73657 VERMEER WAY SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-035 73671 VERMEER WAY SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-036 73685 VERMEER WAY SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-037 73699 VERMEER WAY SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-038 73713 VERMEER WAY SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 275 APN Situs Address Land Use Benefit Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge City of Palm Desert Benefit Assessment District No. 1 Final Prelim Report (Sorted by Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/25 694-270-039 73727 VERMEER WAY SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-040 35996 CHAGALL LN SFV 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-041 35982 CHAGALL LN SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-042 35968 CHAGALL LN SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-043 35954 CHAGALL LN SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-044 35940 CHAGALL LN SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-045 73720 VERMEER WAY SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-046 73706 VERMEER WAY SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-047 73692 VERMEER WAY SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-048 73678 VERMEER WAY SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-049 73664 VERMEER WAY SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-050 73650 VERMEER WAY SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-051 73636 VERMEER WAY SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-052 73622 VERMEER WAY SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-053 73625 OKEEFFE WAY SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-054 73639 OKEEFFE WAY SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-055 73653 OKEEFFE WAY SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-056 73667 OKEEFFE WAY SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-057 73681 OKEEFFE WAY SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-058 73695 OKEEFFE WAY SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-059 73709 OKEEFFE WAY SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-060 73723 OKEEFFE WAY SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-061 73702 OKEEFFE WAY SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-062 73688 OKEEFFE WAY SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-063 73674 OKEEFFE WAY SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-064 73660 OKEEFFE WAY SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-065 73646 OKEEFFE WAY SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-270-066 73632 OKEEFFE WAY SFR 0.37 266.93 211.12 694-280-002 35894 RAPHAEL DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-280-003 35908 RAPHAEL DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-280-004 35922 RAPHAEL DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-280-005 35936 RAPHAEL DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-280-006 35950 RAPHAEL DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-280-007 35943 RAPHAEL DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-280-008 35929 RAPHAEL DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-280-009 35915 RAPHAEL DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-280-010 35901 RAPHAEL DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-280-011 73894 CEZANNE DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-280-012 73908 CEZANNE DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-280-013 73922 CEZANNE DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-280-014 73936 CEZANNE DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-280-018 73915 CEZANNE DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-280-019 73901 CEZANNE DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-280-020 73887 CEZANNE DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-280-021 73873 CEZANNE DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-280-022 73859 CEZANNE DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-280-023 73824 VAN GOGH DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-280-024 73838 VAN GOGH DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 276 APN Situs Address Land Use Benefit Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge City of Palm Desert Benefit Assessment District No. 1 Final Prelim Report (Sorted by Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/25 694-280-025 73852 VAN GOGH DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-280-026 73866 VAN GOGH DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-280-027 73859 VAN GOGH DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-280-028 73845 VAN GOGH DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-280-029 73831 VAN GOGH DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-280-030 73817 VAN GOGH DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-280-031 73803 VAN GOGH DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-280-032 73758 MONET DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-280-033 73772 MONET DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-280-034 73786 MONET DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-280-035 73800 MONET DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-280-036 73814 MONET DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-280-047 73880 VAN GOGH DR SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-280-048 73894 VAN GOGH DR SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-280-049 73908 VAN GOGH DR SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-280-050 73922 VAN GOGH DR SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-280-051 73936 VAN GOGH DR SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-280-052 73828 MONET DR SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-280-053 73842 MONET DR SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-280-054 73901 VAN GOGH DR SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-280-055 73887 VAN GOGH DR SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-280-056 73873 VAN GOGH DR SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-431-001 34130 GATEWAY DR ##A100 COM 0.20 148.76 117.64 694-431-002 34130 GATEWAY DR ##A110 COM 0.20 148.76 117.64 694-431-003 34130 GATEWAY DR ##A120 COM 0.20 148.76 117.64 694-431-004 34130 GATEWAY DR ##A200 COM 0.20 148.76 117.64 694-431-005 34130 GATEWAY DR ##A210 COM 0.20 148.76 117.64 694-431-007 34100 GATEWAY DR ##B100 COM 0.14 98.95 78.26 694-431-008 34100 GATEWAY DR ##B110 COM 0.14 98.95 78.26 694-431-009 34100 GATEWAY DR ##B120 COM 0.14 98.95 78.26 694-431-010 34100 GATEWAY DR ##B130 COM 0.14 98.95 78.26 694-431-011 34100 GATEWAY DR ##B200 COM 0.14 98.95 78.26 694-431-012 34100 GATEWAY DR ##B210 COM 0.14 98.95 78.26 694-431-013 34100 GATEWAY DR ##B220 COM 0.14 98.95 78.26 694-431-014 34100 GATEWAY DR ##B230 COM 0.14 98.95 78.26 694-431-015 34100 GATEWAY DR ##B240 COM 0.14 98.95 78.26 694-431-017 34160 GATEWAY DR ##C100 COM 0.26 187.83 148.56 694-431-018 34160 GATEWAY DR ##C110 COM 0.26 187.83 148.56 694-431-019 34160 GATEWAY DR ##C120 COM 0.26 187.83 148.56 694-431-021 34190 GATEWAY DR ##D100 COM 0.30 217.88 172.32 694-431-022 34190 GATEWAY DR ##D110 COM 0.30 217.88 172.32 694-431-023 34190 GATEWAY DR ##D120 COM 0.30 217.88 172.32 694-431-025 34220 GATEWAY DR ##E100 COM 0.26 187.83 148.56 694-431-026 34220 GATEWAY DR ##E110 COM 0.26 187.83 148.56 694-431-027 34220 GATEWAY DR ##E120 COM 0.26 187.83 148.56 694-431-029 34250 GATEWAY DR ##F100 COM 0.31 225.39 178.26 694-431-030 34250 GATEWAY DR ##F110 COM 0.31 225.39 178.26 694-431-031 34250 GATEWAY DR ##F120 COM 0.31 225.39 178.26 277 APN Situs Address Land Use Benefit Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge City of Palm Desert Benefit Assessment District No. 1 Final Prelim Report (Sorted by Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/25 694-431-032 34250 GATEWAY DR ##F130 COM 0.31 225.39 178.26 694-431-034 34280 GATEWAY DR ##G100 COM 0.37 266.71 210.94 694-431-035 34280 GATEWAY DR ##G110 COM 0.37 266.71 210.94 694-431-036 34280 GATEWAY DR ##G120 COM 0.37 266.71 210.94 694-440-001 73957 RUBENS LN SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-440-002 73943 RUBENS LN SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-440-003 73929 RUBENS LN SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-440-004 73793 MONET DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-440-005 73779 MONET DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-440-006 73765 MONET DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-440-007 73751 MONET DR SFR 0.36 258.07 204.12 694-440-010 73950 VAN GOGH DR SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-011 73964 VAN GOGH DR SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-012 73978 VAN GOGH DR SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-013 73992 VAN GOGH DR SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-014 73930 MONDRIAN PL SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-015 73944 MONDRIAN PL SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-016 73958 MONDRIAN PL SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-017 73972 MONDRIAN PL SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-018 73986 MONDRIAN PL SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-019 73993 MONDRIAN PL SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-020 73979 MONDRIAN PL SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-021 73965 MONDRIAN PL SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-022 73951 MONDRIAN PL SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-023 73937 MONDRIAN PL SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-024 73923 MONDRIAN PL SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-025 73909 MONDRIAN PL SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-026 73895 MONDRIAN PL SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-027 73881 MONDRIAN PL SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-028 73867 MONDRIAN PL SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-029 73853 MONDRIAN PL SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-030 73839 MONDRIAN PL SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-031 73825 MONDRIAN PL SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-032 73811 MONDRIAN PL SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-033 73797 MONDRIAN PL SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-034 73783 MONDRIAN PL SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-035 73769 MONDRIAN PL SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-036 73755 MONDRIAN PL SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-037 73741 MONDRIAN PL SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-038 73734 MONDRIAN PL SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-039 73748 MONDRIAN PL SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-040 73762 MONDRIAN PL SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-041 73776 MONDRIAN PL SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-042 73821 MONET DR SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-043 73807 MONET DR SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-044 73856 MONET DR SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-045 73870 MONET DR SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-046 73943 VAN GOGH DR SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 278 APN Situs Address Land Use Benefit Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge City of Palm Desert Benefit Assessment District No. 1 Final Prelim Report (Sorted by Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/25 694-440-047 73929 VAN GOGH DR SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-440-048 73915 VAN GOGH DR SFR 0.31 223.35 176.64 694-490-001 73298 WARHOL LN SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-002 73312 WARHOL LN SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-003 73326 WARHOL LN SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-004 73340 WARHOL LN SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-005 73354 WARHOL LN SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-006 73368 WARHOL LN SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-007 73382 WARHOL LN SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-008 73396 WARHOL LN SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-009 73410 WARHOL LN SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-010 35565 PERUGINO TER SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-011 35579 PERUGINO TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-012 35593 PERUGINO TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-013 35607 PERUGINO TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-014 35621 PERUGINO TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-015 35635 PERUGINO TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-016 35649 PERUGINO TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-017 35663 PERUGINO TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-018 35677 PERUGINO TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-019 35691 PERUGINO TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-020 35705 PERUGINO TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-021 35719 PERUGINO TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-022 35733 PERUGINO TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-023 35747 PERUGINO TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-024 35738 PERUGINO TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-025 35724 PERUGINO TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-026 35710 PERUGINO TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-027 35696 PERUGINO TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-028 35682 PERUGINO TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-029 35668 PERUGINO TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-030 35654 PERUGINO TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-031 35640 PERUGINO TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-032 35626 PERUGINO TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-033 35612 PERUGINO TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-034 35598 PERUGINO TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-035 35584 PERUGINO TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-036 35570 PERUGINO TER SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-037 35575 PASINI TER SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-038 35589 PASINI TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-039 35603 PASINI TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-040 35617 PASINI TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-041 35631 PASINI TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-042 35645 PASINI TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-043 35659 PASINI TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-044 35673 PASINI TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-045 35687 PASINI TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-046 35701 PASINI TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 279 APN Situs Address Land Use Benefit Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge City of Palm Desert Benefit Assessment District No. 1 Final Prelim Report (Sorted by Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/25 694-490-047 35715 PASINI TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-048 35729 PASINI TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-490-049 35743 PASINI TER SFR 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-001 73458 HENRI DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-002 73472 HENRI DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-003 73486 HENRI DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-004 73500 HENRI DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-005 73514 HENRI DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-006 73528 HENRI DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-007 73542 HENRI DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-008 73556 HENRI DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-009 73570 HENRI DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-010 73584 HENRI DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-011 73598 HENRI DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-012 73612 HENRI DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-013 73626 HENRI DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-014 73686 HENRI DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-015 73700 HENRI DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-016 73714 HENRI DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-017 73711 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-018 73697 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-019 73683 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-020 73669 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-021 73655 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-022 73641 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-023 73627 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-024 73613 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-025 73609 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-026 73595 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-027 73581 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-028 73567 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-029 73553 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-030 73539 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-031 73525 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-032 73511 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-033 73497 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-034 73483 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-035 73469 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-036 73455 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-037 73452 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-038 73466 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-039 73480 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-040 73494 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-041 73508 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-042 73522 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-043 73536 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-044 73550 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-045 73564 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 280 APN Situs Address Land Use Benefit Units Maximum Special Assessment Charge City of Palm Desert Benefit Assessment District No. 1 Final Prelim Report (Sorted by Assessor's Parcel Number "APN") Fiscal Year 2024/25 694-500-046 73578 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-047 73592 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-048 73606 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-049 73620 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-050 73634 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-051 73648 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-052 73676 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-053 73690 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-054 73704 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-055 73718 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-056 73732 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-057 73746 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-058 73760 RAPHAEL DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-059 73801 HENRI DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-060 73787 HENRI DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-500-061 73773 HENRI DR SFV 0.35 252.48 199.68 694-510-001 NO SITUS AVAILABLE CMV 11.72 8,506.97 6,728.54 694-510-013 NO SITUS AVAILABLE CMV 20.36 14,776.07 11,687.04 694-510-014 NO SITUS AVAILABLE CMV 18.58 13,484.25 10,665.28 Summary Fields Value APN Total:787 EBU Total:453.66 Max Sp Assess:$329,236.26 Charge Total:$260,401.70 281 282 Page 1 of 2 CITY OF PALM DESERT STAFF REPORT MEETING DATE: May 9, 2024 PREPARED BY: Anthony J. Mejia, City Clerk REQUEST: INTRODUCTION OF AN ORDINANCE ADDING SECTION 2.38.070 TO THE PALM DESERT MUNICIPAL CODE TO ALLOW FOR THE ELECTRONIC OR PAPER FILING OF CAMPAIGN FINANCE DISCLOSURE STATEMENTS RECOMMENDATION: Introduce an Ordinance entitled “AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, ADDING SECTION 2.38.070 TO THE PALM DESERT MUNICIPAL CODE APPROVING ELECTRONIC AND PAPER METHODS OF FILING CAMPAIGN FINANCE DISCLOSURE STATEMENTS.” BACKGROUND/ANALYSIS: Assembly Bill 2452 (AB 2452) went into effect on January 1, 2013, which added Government Code §84615. This law allows a local government agency to mandate online or electronic filing for an elected officer, candidate, committee, or other person who is required to file statements, reports, or other documents under the Political Reform Act, so long as the filer receives contributions or makes expenditures totaling two thousand dollars ($2,000) or more in a calendar year. The California Fair Political Practices Commission supports and encourages efforts to move from a paper-based reporting system to an electronic system. Electronic filing makes it easier for officials to comply with reporting obligations and provides the public with the information in a more accessible and consistent format. On January 1, 2021, Assembly Bill 2151 (AB 2151) went into effect requiring a local government agency to post on its internet website, within 72 hours of the applicable filing deadline, a copy of any specified statement, report, or other document filed with that agency in paper format. This bill requires that the statement, report, or other document be made available for four years from the date of the election associated with the filing. All Fair Political Practices Commission (FPPC) forms are public records. By shifting to an electronic system, the public can directly access campaign finance statements on the City’s website. The system is also beneficial to the end user by providing multiple prompts to ensure timely filing, storing previous statements for user reference, and permitting a single filing for multiple offices. Additionally, filers submitting their campaign finance statements electronically will greatly help with reducing the labor of complying with AB 2151. 283 City of Palm Desert Ordinance – Electronic Filing of Campaign Finance Disclosure Statements Page 2 of 2 For the City to use and accept electronic campaign filings, the City Council must adopt an Ordinance with required findings approving the use of an electronic system, which includes that the system: Will operate securely and effectively and will not unduly burden filers; Must be available free of charge to filers and the public for viewing filings; and Must include a procedure for filers to comply with the requirement that they sign statements and reports under penalty of perjury. Although State law authorizes the City to mandate electronic filing, staff recognizes that such mandate could have a direct effect on those committees or individuals who do not have computer access or familiarity with computer programs. To ensure that the same opportunity to comply with the Political Reform Act is afforded to all committees/individuals without unduly burdening anyone, the City Clerk recommends the City Council approve an Opt -In/Out Program. In short, to ensure reporting continuity and accurate accounting of contributions/expenditures, once a committee/individual chooses to file a report electronically, the commi ttee/individual is deemed “opted-in” and shall be required to file all future statements electronically using the City Clerk’s system. On the other hand, any committee/individual who wishes to continue to paper -file may “opt-out” of the electronic filing system by filing all original statements with the City Clerk. Should a committee/individual choose to only paper-file, the City Clerk will continue to accept such reports until the committee/individual “opts-in”. Proposed Electronic System Since April 2022, the City has contracted with NetFile for software to allow for the electronic filing of Statements of Economic Interest (Form 700). The implementation of this software was successful and has significantly improved the compliance rate and reduced user errors. Subsequently, the City amended the contract to add an online AB 1234 Ethics Training module for elected and appointed officials. The implementation of this module improved the efficiency of tracking compliance and issuing notifications and reminders about upcoming deadlines. City staff has negotiated with NetFile who has agreed to allow the City to use the electronic filing system for campaign finance disclosure documents as a pilot program through June 30, 2025, without charge. If the City decides to end the pilot program, NetFile will transfer all stored data to the City and the program will end. Otherwise, the contract will automatically be renewed for a term ending June 30, 2028, at a three-year guaranteed price of $1,600 annually. Legal Review: This report has been reviewed by the City Attorney’s office. FINANCIAL IMPACT: There is no fiscal impact associated with enacting the subject ordinance. If approved, the City will commence a pilot program through June 30, 2025, to allow for the electroni c filing of campaign finance disclosure documents. If successful, the contract will be automatically renewed at a three-year guaranteed price of $1,600 annually. ATTACHMENT: 1. Draft Ordinance 284 ORDINANCE NO. ____ AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, ADDING SECTION 2.38.070 TO THE PALM DESERT MUNICIPAL CODE APPROVING ELECTRONIC AND PAPER METHODS OF FILING CAMPAIGN FINANCE DISCLOSURE STATEMENTS City Attorney’s Summary The purpose of this ordinance is to amend the Palm Desert Municipal Code to allow for the electronic or paper filing of campaign finance disclosure statements required by Chapter 4 of the Political Reform Act. WHEREAS, California Government Code Section 84615 provides that a legislative body of a local government agency may adopt an ordinance that requires an elected officer, candidate, committee, or other person required to file statements, reports, or other documents required by Chapter 4 of the Political Reform Act, except those whose contributions and expenditures each total less than two thousand dollars ($2,000) in a calendar year, to file such statements, reports, or other documents online or electronically with the City Clerk; and WHEREAS, the City will enter into an agreement with a vendor qualified by the Secretary of State for campaign disclosure documents that meets the requirements set by Government Code Section 84615; and WHEREAS, the City Council approves the use of an electronic system, which includes that: it will operate securely and effectively and will not unduly burden filers; it must be available free of charge to filers and the public for viewing filings; and it must include a procedure for filers to comply with the requireme nt that they sign statements and reports under penalty of perjury. THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT DOES HEREBY ORDAIN AS FOLLOWS: SECTION 1. The recitals above are each incorporated by reference and adopted as findings of the City Council. 285 Ordinance No. _____ Page 2 SECTION 2. The City Council hereby approves the addition of Section 2.38.070, Campaign Finance Disclosure Statements - Electronic Filing System, to be added to Chapter 2.38, General Municipal Elections, to read as follows: Section 2.38.070 Campaign Finance Disclosure Statements - Electronic Filing System A. Required Use of Electronic Filing System. 1. Except as set forth in subsection B of this Section 2.3 8.070, any elected officer, candidate, committee, other person required to file specified statements, reports, forms, or other documents with the City Clerk as required by Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 84100 of Title 9 of the California Government Code, also known as the Political Reform Act), and that has received contributions or made expenditures of $2,000 or more in a calendar year, may electronically file such statements using the City's online system according to procedures established by the City Clerk. However, to ensure reporting continuity, once a statement, report, form, or other document is filed electronically on behalf of any elected officer, candidate, committee, or other person, all future statements, reports, forms, and other documents filed on behalf of that officer, candidate, committee, or other person must be filed electronically. 2. An elected officer, candidate, committee, or other person may choose not to use the electronic filing system by filing all original statements, reports, forms, or other documents in paper format with the City Clerk, until such time as the City Council determines that electronic filing is mandatory for all filers. B. Paper Filing Not Required After Electronic Filing. Any elected officer, candidate, committee, or other person who has electronically filed a statement, report, form, or other document using the City's online system is not required to file a copy of that document in a paper format with the City Clerk. C. Filing Options When a Copy Must be Filed with the City Clerk. In any instance in which an original statement, report, form, or other docum ent must be filed with the Secretary of State or other agency, and a copy of that document is required to be filed with the City Clerk, the filer may electronically file a copy with the City Clerk or may file in a paper format. D. Paper Filing When Cannot File Electronically. If, for technical reasons, the City's system is not capable of accepting a particular type of statement, report, form, or other document, an elected officer, candidate, committee, or other person shall timely file that document in paper format with the City Clerk. 286 Ordinance No. _____ Page 3 E. Internet Posting of Data. The City Clerk shall ensure that the City's system makes all electronically filed statements, reports, forms, or other documents available on the internet in an easily understood format that provides the greatest public access. The data shall be made available free of charge and as soon as possible after receipt/deadline. The data made available on the internet shall not contain the street name of the persons or entity representatives listed on the electronically filed forms or any bank account number required to be disclosed by the filer. The City Clerk's office shall also make a complete, unredacted copy of the statement, report, form, or other document available to the Fair Political Practices Commission for Government Code Section 87200 filers. F. Records Retention. The City Clerk's office shall maintain records according to the City's records retention schedule and applicable State law commencing from the date filed, a secured, official version of each online or electronic statement, report, form, or other document, which shall serve as the official version of that record. Section 3. Severability. If any section, subsection, clause, or phrase of this Ordinance or any part thereof is for any reason held to be invalid, unconstitutional, or unenforceable by the decision of any court of competent jurisdiction, such decision shall not affect the validity of the remaining portion of the Ordinance. The City Council declares that it would have passed each section, subsection, paragraph, sentence, clause, or phrase thereof, irrespective of the fact that any one or more section, subsection, sentence, clause, or phrase would be declared invalid, unconstitutional or unenforceable. SECTION 18. Publication. The City Clerk of the City of Palm Desert, California, is hereby directed to publish a summary of this Ordinance in the Desert Sun, a newspaper of general circulation, published and circulated in the City of Palm Desert, California, and shall be in full force and effective thirty (30) days after its adoption. ADOPTED ON ___________________, 2024. KARINA QUINTANILLA MAYOR ATTEST: ANTHONY J. MEJIA CITY CLERK 287 Ordinance No. _____ Page 4 I, Anthony J. Mejia, City Clerk of the City of Palm Desert, California, do hereby certify that Ordinance No. ____ is a full, true, and correct copy, and was introduced at a regular meeting of the Palm Desert City Council on _________, 2024, and adopted at a regular meeting of the City Council held on __________, 20 24, by the following vote: AYES: NOES: ABSENT: ABSTAIN: RECUSED: IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and affixed the official seal of the City of Palm Desert, California, on ____________________. ANTHONY J. MEJIA CITY CLERK 288 Page 1 of 3 CITY OF PALM DESERT STAFF REPORT MEETING DATE: May 9, 2024 PREPARED BY: Neal Ennis, Project Manager REQUEST: REQUEST FOR DIRECTION REGARDING LUPINE PLAZA PROJECT CST00015 RECOMMENDATION: Provide staff direction on the Lupine Plaza Project CST00015. BACKGROUND/ANALYSIS: In September 2020, as a response to the State of California’s COVID -19 restrictions on business operations, the City of Palm Desert installed a temporary plaza and closed traffic for a section of Lupine North of El Paseo. The plaza provided an outdoor rest and eating area for visitors to El Paseo and a space for local restaurants to serve food. The temporary plaza was removed in December of 2021. In April 2022, the City Council authorized staff to work with M.I.G. Consultants to explore various options to reinstate the elements of the temporary Lupine Plaza. Attached to this report is the consultant’s study, which includes two options for various degrees of improvements to the corridor: Option 1: “Slow Street” – vehicle lanes remain open, pedestrian enhancements. Option 2: “Permanent One-Way Street and plaza – one-way northbound, pedestrian amenities.” Option 3: “Full Permanent Plaza” – close the street to vehicle traffic and add pedestrian amenities. On June 23, 2022, the City Council directed city staff to proceed with Option 3 (“Full Permanent Plaza”) of the conceptual design package, and appropriated $4,000,000 to fund the project . On September 29, 2022, the City Council approved a contract with Interwest to prepare the necessary documents to move forward with Option 3. After the City Council’s decision to proceed with Option 3, p roperty and business owners, in proximity to Lupine, expressed concern with the full street closure and requested a reduction to the project scope to keep the street open for vehicular traffic. Staff continued to engage these owners to provide project updates. General feedback from this group confirmed that the reduced project scope included in Option 1 (“Slow Street”) would be better supported. In June 2023, staff returned to City Council with the property and business owner feedback and revisited the three design options. The City Council approved staff to decrease the scope of the project and proceed with Option 1. 289 City of Palm Desert Request for Direction - Lupine Plaza Page 2 of 3 Staff and Interwest held a Lupine Lane Community Meeting in February 2024 with respective stakeholders and participants to discuss and identify project design preferences, as it related to the narrowing of the street or single-side sidewalk expansion. A preferred design selection was unable to be obtained from the group, as the discussion was primarily centered around the participants not wanting either version of the project. The overall feedback was that the project was not an efficient improvement to the adjacent business corridor and would potentially cause unwanted impacts, such as commerce disruption, vagrancy, and loss of parking. Staff presented the project to the El Paseo Parking and Business Improvement District (EPPBID) Board Members in February 2024, which also yielded criticism and concerns similar to the Lupine Lane Community Meeting. The EPPBID recommended staff to focus their efforts on other areas of El Paseo, specifically El Paseo from Portola to Hwy 111. Given the feedback received from the recent public engagement meetings, staff request s City Council’s direction on the following two (2) choices regarding the Lupine Plaza Project: 1. Proceed with the design and construction of Option 1 (“Slow Street”) project. - OR - 2. Discontinue the current project. Strategic Plan: Land Use, Housing & Open Space – Priority 1: “Enhance Palm Desert as a first-class destination for premier shopping and national retail businesses.” Land Use, Housing & Open Space – Priority 5: “Utilize progressive land-use policies and standards to support ongoing future needs.” Tourism and Marketing – Priority 1: “Improve access to Palm Desert and its attractions to enhance the ease of lifestyle.” Transportation – Priority 1: “Create walkable neighborhoods and areas within Palm Desert that would include residential, retail, services and employment centers, and parks, recreations, and open space to reduce the use of low occupancy vehicles.” FINANCIAL IMPACT: Budget in the amount of $4,000,000 was approved for this project. To date, $562,135 has been encumbered with Interwest Consulting Group Inc for design. The table below provides the financial impacts of the two options as presented. Option 1 Option 2 Slow Street Discontinue Original Capital Budget 4,000,000 4,000,000 Less: Design Contract/Costs to Date (562,135) (170,832) Less: Est. Construction Costs (1,356,892) - Est. Funds Available for Reallocation 2,080,973 3,829,168 Lupine Plaza Project 290 City of Palm Desert Request for Direction - Lupine Plaza Page 3 of 3 ATTACHMENTS: 1. M.I.G. Conceptual Design Alternatives 2. Interwest Presentation Boards 3. Interwest Lupine Lane 30% Furnishing Package 4. Interwest Lupine Plaza 30% Design 5. Lupine Power Point 291 292 293 294 295 296 297 298 299 300 301 302 303 304 305 306 CITY OF PALM DESERTLUPINE LANE | LUPINE LANE 307 CITY OF PALM DESERTLUPINE LANE | SITE IMPROVEMENTS LUPINE LANE HARDSCAPE PLAN HARDSCAPE SCHEDULE FURNISHING SCHEDULE 308 CITY OF PALM DESERTLUPINE LANE | EXISTING CONTEXT + CHARACTER 309 CITY OF PALM DESERTLUPINE LANE | HS-101 CITY SHALL FURNISH IW OF ANY CITY-STANDARDS THE CITY WISHES TO USE FOR THESE IMPROVEMENTS IN LIEU OF THE PROPOSED PALETTE; CITY SHALL APPROVE OR DENY PROPOSED MATERIALS AND COLOR SELECTIONS. HS-102 HS-103 HS-104 HARDSCAPE SCHEDULEHARDSCAPE PLAN HARDSCAPE PALETTE SIKACOLOR U12 SUNSET BEIGE 310 CITY OF PALM DESERTLUPINE LANE | FURNISHING PROPOSED TO BE REVIEWED AND APPROVED BY CITY; IF CITY DESIRES ANY STANDARD FURNISHING THE CITY SHALL ISSUE TO IW THE APPROPRIATE MANUFACTURER AND MODEL NUMBERS. FN-101 FN-102 FURNISHING SCHEDULEHARDSCAPE PLAN FURNISHING PALETTE 311 CITY OF PALM DESERTLUPINE LANE | FURNISHING PALETTE 36 BENCHESwww.urbastyle.com by phone 800.388.8728 | mail wtile@wausautile.com | wausautile.comwausautile.com BENCHESBENCHBENCH SWEEP SWEEP PRODUCT DESCRIPTION Characteristics Prefabricated concrete element Finish: >Acid wash : a light acid etch finish with an even and flat texture across the entire surface >Weatherstone : a sandblast finish exposing rock and giving a subtle texture and weathered look >Ground & polished: a flat, smooth and polished surface with exposed rock and matrix Free standing Factory sealed Delivery information Delivery only on pallets PROJECT STUDY INFORMATION Specific dimensions in custom manufacturing (only on order): on demand SHIPPING FEES On demand COLORS ! Special custom manufacturing. Order and delivery time on request Element Lengthinch Widthinch Heightinch Weightlbs/p ZB.SW.01 72 varies 17 3/4 1,030 - 2,065 SHAPE HANDLING*1’-4½”7”1’-11½”1’-5¾”72” 72” 1’-7¾”3¾” 69”1½”1½” Top View Front View Side View Handling Geometry 1’-4½”7”1’-11½”1’-5¾”72” 72” 1’-7¾”3¾” 69”1½”1½” Top View Front View Side View Handling Geometry 1’-4½”7”1’-11½”1’-5¾”72” 72” 1’-7¾”3¾” 69”1½”1½” Top View Front View Side View Handling Geometry 1’-4½”7”1’-11½”1’-5¾”72” 72” 1’-7¾”3¾” 69”1½”1½” Top View Front View Side View Handling Geometry 1’-4½”7”1’-11½”1’-5¾”72” 72” 1’-7¾”3¾” 69”1½”1½” Top View Front View Side View Handling Geometry To match is there also a bench Sweep with length 48” available Markus Kurkowski DESIGNER Acid wash Weatherstone Ground & Polished A20 - White W20 - White G20 - White A21 - Buff W21 - Buff G21 - Buff A22 - Sand W22 - Sand G22 - Sand A23 - Gray W23 - Gray G23 - Gray A24 - Brick red W24 - Brick red G24 - Brick red A25 - Brown W25 - Brown G25 - Brown A26 - Charcoal W26 - Charcoal G26 - Charcoal A30 - Star W30 - Star G30 - Star A31 - Fog W31 - Fog G31 - Fog A38 - Night W33 - Misty gray G33 - Misty gray W38 - Night G38 - Night FN-101 FN-102 312 CITY OF PALM DESERTLUPINE LANE | CX PD PLANT SCHEDULEPLANTING PLAN LANDSCAPE PALETTE 313 CITY OF PALM DESERTLUPINE LANE | LANDSCAPE PALETTE PLANT SCHEDULEPLANTING PLAN BACCHARIS X ‘THOMPSON’ LAVANDULA ANGUSTIFOLIA OPUNTIA MICRODASYS DASYLIRION WHEELERI HESPERALOE PARVIFLORA ECHINOCACTUS GRUSONII INORGANIC MATERIALS 314 5OFSHEETSHEETSBENCHMARKLOCATIONBASIS OF BEARINGSELEVATIONDATUMCITY OF PALM DESERTPROJECT C44190TITLE SHEETLUPINE LANEUNDERGROUND SERVICE ALERTAT LEAST TWO DAYS BEFORE YOU DIG811DIAL TOLL FREEDig SafelyDIG ALERTOF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIASLPSLPGLCHECKED BYDRAWN BYDESIGNED BYC-100ANY MODIFICATION OF THIS PLANMUST BE APPROVED BY THE CITYPRIOR TO CONSTRUCTIONCITY PERMIT #:CITY ISSUE DATE:FOR CITY USE ONLY30% PRELIMINARY SETNOT FOR CONSTRUCTIONBENCHMARKVICINITY MAPWSNEN.T.S.CIVIL ENGINEERGLEN LEWIS, PEINTERWEST CONSULTANT GROUP1500 S. HAVEN AVENUE, STE. 220ONTARIO, CA 91761TEL: 909.618.7384GEOTECHNICAL ENGINEERNINYO & MOORE1500 S HAVEN AVE, STE. 220ONTARIO, CA 91761TEL: 408.435.9000LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTCALVIN, GIORDANO & ASSOCIATES, INC.1800 ELLER DRIVE, STE 600FORT LAUDERDALE, FL 33316TEL: 954.921.8807315 LEGENDCOLD MILL AND OVERLAY 2"EXISTING ASPHALT CONCRETECONSTRUCT PCC SIDEWALK(DEPTH PER PLAN)EXISTING CLASS II AGGREGATE BASEBBCCAAWSNE30% PRELIMINARY SETNOT FOR CONSTRUCTION316 WSNELEGENDREMOVE EXISTING PAVEMENTAPPROX. 5-INCH DEPTH ASPHALT ORAPPROX. 4-6-INCH DEPTH CONCRETE30% PRELIMINARY SETNOT FOR CONSTRUCTION317 WSNELEGENDCOLD MILL AND OVERLAY 2"CONSTRUCT 4" PCC SIDEWALK30% PRELIMINARY SETNOT FOR CONSTRUCTION318 30% PRELIMINARY SETNOT FOR CONSTRUCTION319 320 Page 1 of 7 CITY OF PALM DESERT STAFF REPORT MEETING DATE: May 9, 2024 PREPARED BY: Richard D. Cannone, AICP, Development Services Director REQUEST: APPEAL OF THE DEVELOPMENT SERVICES DIRECTOR DETERMINATION THAT A LIVING ROOM CANNOT BE COUNTED AS A BEDROOM FOR PURPOSES OF A SHORT-TERM RENTAL RECOMMENDATION: 1. Find that this report, including attachments, and any additional evidence provided at the hearing provides satisfactory evidence that the Development Services Director’s determination was correct. 2. Adopt a Resolution entitled “A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, UPHOLDING THE DEVELOPMENT SERVICES DIRECTOR DETERMINATION THAT A LIVING ROOM CANNOT BE COUNTED AS A BEDROOM FOR PURPOSES OF A SHORT-TERM RENTAL AND MAKING FINDINGS IN SUPPORT THEREOF.” BACKGROUND/ANALYSIS: APPLICANT’S INITIAL REQUEST On March 5, 2024, the Development Service Director (“Director”) sent an email (see Attachment 2) to Ms. Carrie Kropfl of Casa Monterey 239, LLC (“Owner”) clarifying that a living room cannot be used as a bedroom for purposes of Short-Term Rental (“STR”). The Director included the following interpretation of a bedroom for purposes of a STR: For purposes of the short-term rental regulations, I have interpreted bedroom to mean a private room intended for sleeping that is separated from other rooms by a door, having at least one window that meets the egress/rescue requirements, has a closet/storage area, and is accessible to a bathroom without crossing into another bedroom. This is based in part on the city’s ordinance allowing for on -site and off-site owners. On-site means they are present and must stay at the property and the intent would be that a guest would have a private room. If you wish to convert your living room to a bedroom, Jason [Finley] can assist with what permits would be needed. Prior to this date, and up to Director’s determination letter provided on March 25, 2024, there were numerous emails and phone calls with staff and the Owner requesting that the Property be permitted as a three-bedroom STR unit. 321 City of Palm Desert Appeal of STR Bedroom Determination Page 2 of 7 SHORT-TERM RENTAL (STR) PERMIT HISTORY In November 2021, the Owner purchased a condominium unit at 239 Serna Drive in Palm Desert (“Property”). In January 2022, the Owner applied for and was issued a STR Permit for a three- bedroom unit. In 2023, the Owner renewed their STR Permit for a three-bedroom unit. Beginning in July 2023 the Development Services Department created internal procedures with staff to ensure that the regulations adopted by City Council were being enforced when applications wer e submitted, including renewals of STR permits. On January 24, 2024, the Owner applied to renew their permit for a 3-bedroom STR unit. Consistent with new procedures, staff confirmed the number of bedrooms through the Riverside County Assessor and separate property details available to staff from RealQuest and Lawyers Title (see Attachment 3) which showed a 2-bedroom unit for this Property. Staff also reviewed building permit records and there were no building permits for a bedroom addition. On February 1, 2024, the Owner revised their renewal request for a 2-bedroom STR unit and staff approved and issued a renewal of STR Permit NO. STR2022-0020. It should also be noted that the Riverside County Assessor (“Assessor”) records for the Property showed the unit as having 2-bedrooms and a den/family room when the application for renewal was reviewed. However, on March 4, 2023, at the Owners request, the Assessor changed the property record to reflect 3-bedrooms and with no den/family (see Attachment 4). These facts are contrary to the Appellants statement that “Nothing has changed during the decades where the Property was classified as a three-bedroom condo. The city should continue to recognize the Property as a three-bedroom condo and allow the Kropfl's to market and rent it as a three-bedroom.” DIRECTOR’S DETERMINATION/INTERPRETATION On March 25, 2024, the Owner sent an email clarifying that they would like to submit an appeal on three items (see Attachment 5). Pursuant to PDMC § 2.72.020 the Director provided a written decision (see Attachment 6) to the Owner on March 25 for the following three requested items: 1. Can you continue to use the third bedroom (den), based on the floor plans provided? 2. Can you use the living room as a bedroom to sleep two additional guests for a Short-Term Rental? 3. Can up to four overnight guests per bedroom be permitted for a Short-Term Rental? Included in that written decision was the response to each of the three questions, the aut hority for that determination/interpretation (Director or Building Official), and the appeal process/body for each. 322 City of Palm Desert Appeal of STR Bedroom Determination Page 3 of 7 Request 1. The determination for Request #1 was made by the Building Official as authorized by the California Building Code. Chapter 2.18 of the PDMC establishes a Building Board of Appeals (“Board”) to hear appeals regarding the interpretation of the California Building Code by the Building Official. The appeal of this request is scheduled to be considered by the Board on May 23, 2024. The Board’s decision may be appealed to the City Council and therefore the specifics of this request should not be discussed or considered at this time. Request 2. The determination for this request was made by the Development Services (Community Development) Director under the authority granted by PDMC Chapter 2.12. The Director’s determination was related to PDMC Chapter 5.10, which is under Title 5 Business Taxes, Licenses, and Regulations which is NOT part of the City’s Zoning Code. As a result, an appeal of the Director’s determination/interpretation is considered by the City Council in accordance with PDMC Chapter 2.72. After extensive research, the Director issued his determination based on two factors: 1) The Director concluded that based on the language contained in PDMC §5.10.090(G) which establishes that the maximum number of overnight guests shall not exceed two persons per bedroom coupled with fact that on -site STR owners must occupy at least one bedroom, which shall diminish the number of be drooms for overnight guests. In other words, a one-bedroom unit CANNOT be issued an On-Site Short Term Rental Permit, because the On -Site Owner must be present and must stay at the property in a bedroom; not a living room or having the ability to share the rented bedroom. 2) Due to the lack of a definition of a bedroom and for purposes of Chapter 5.10 Short Term Rentals, the Director interpreted a bedroom room to mean: A private room intended for sleeping that is separated from other rooms by a door, having at least one window that meets the Emergency Escape and Rescue Opening requirements of the California Building code, has a closet/storage area, and is accessible to a bathroom without crossing into another bedroom. Request 3. PDMC §5.10.090(G) explicitly states that the maximum number of overnight guests shall not exceed two persons per bedroom. This was not a matter of interpretation, but a strict code requirement. As such, there is no right to appeal because it does not involve the exercise of administrative discretion or personal judgment (see PDMC §2.72.010(B)). 323 City of Palm Desert Appeal of STR Bedroom Determination Page 4 of 7 LETTER OF APPEAL On April 4, 2024, an appeal was filed (see Attachment 7) by Mr. Shaun Murphy, of Slovak Brown Empey Murphy & Pinkney LLP (“Appellant”), on behalf of the Owner for the following: 1. Whether the Kropfl's may continue to use the third bedroom (den) for short-term rentals. 2. Whether the Kropfl's may use their code compliant living room as an additional sleeping room to accommodate two more guests. DIRECTOR’S RESPONSE TO APPEAL LETTER The following are specific responses to each issue submitted by the Appellant. 1. Whether the Kropfl’s may continue to use the third bedroom (den) for short-term rentals. As stated above, this appeal is based on a determination made by the Building Official from the California Building Code and pursuant to PDMC must be heard by the City’s Building Board of Appeals. This appeal hearing is scheduled for May 23, 2024. The Board’s decision may be appealed to the City Council and therefore the specifics of this request should not be discussed or considered at this time. 2. Whether the Kropfl’s may use their code compliant living room as an additional sleeping room to accommodate two more guests. The Appellant incorrectly states in the appeal letter that this determination was made by the Building Official, when the Director’s written determination provided on March 25, 2024, clearly states that this determination was made by the Dire ctor. The Appellant states that it is “puzzling” and believes the reference to PDMC §5.10.090(G) is irrelevant to defining the term “bedroom”. PDMC §5.10.090(G) includes the following language: If the use is on-site owner short-term rental, the owner shall be deemed to occupy at least one bedroom, which shall diminish the number of bedrooms for overnight guests accordingly… Based on this limitation imposed and the Director ’s experience, this language aided in his determination that if it was City Council’s intent to allow an owner to stay in a room, other than a bedroom, then City Council would have not included this limitation. The Appellant further disputes the Director’s interpretation that a bedroom must have a door and believes this interpretation is arbitrary. The Appellant’s basis is derived from the definition of “bedroom” from Merriam-Webster, Cambridge Dictionary, and Britannica Dictionary, and as stated in the appeal letter, “all which referenced a room for sleeping with no mention of a door.” The Appellant also conjectures in a footnote wondering how parents would react after learning that removing the door to their teenager’s bedroom, for whatever reason means that the room is no longer a bedroom. 324 City of Palm Desert Appeal of STR Bedroom Determination Page 5 of 7 While the Appellants statements in general may seem reasonable, the fact is what is being considered is a dwelling that is being used for lodging purposes less than 27 consecutive days that must be licensed to do so. While the Appellant tries to provide an example in a “typical” family setting with parents and teenagers, the unit is question is NOT typical and the Owners are seeking a permit for the unit to be rented to a Transient1 that is required to pay a Transient Occupant Tax (TOT) and a Tourism Business Improvement District (TBID) assessment. “Typical” residential properties are not required to be licensed or required to pay TOT or TBID. Only transit uses i.e. hotel, motel, bed and breakfast, and short-term rentals pay the TOT and TBID. The Appellant provides the definition of “bedroom” but chooses to omit the definition of “living room.” Using the Appellant’s same references: Merriam-Webster defines living room as, “a room in a residence used for the common social activities of the occupants.” Cambridge Dictionary defines living room as “the room in a house or apartment that is used for relaxing in and entertaining guests.” Britannica Dictionary defines living room as “a room in a house for general family use — usually singular.” NOTE: None of the definitions define a living room as a room used for sleeping. Additionally, these three dictionary references used by the Appellant provide for definitions for hotel, motel, and bed and breakfast; the transient uses the Director references and are defined as: Merriam-Webster Hotel - an establishment that provides lodging and usually meals, entertainment, and various personal services for the public. Motel - an establishment which provides lodging and parking and in which the rooms are usually accessible from an outdoor parking area. Bed and Breakfast - an establishment (such as an inn) offering lodging and breakfast. Cambridge Dictionary Hotel - a building where you pay to have a room to sleep in, and where you can sometimes eat meals. Motel - a hotel for people travelling by car, usually with spaces for ca rs next to each room. Bed and Breakfast - a room to sleep in for the night and a morning meal, or a private house or small hotel offering this. 1 PDMC § 5.10.030 Definitions. “Transient” means any person who seeks to rent or who does rent a privately- owned residential unit for a period less than twenty-seven consecutive days. 325 City of Palm Desert Appeal of STR Bedroom Determination Page 6 of 7 Britannica Dictionary Hotel - a place that has rooms in which people can stay especially when they are traveling: a place that provides food, lodging, and other services for paying guests. Motel - a place that is next to a road and that has rooms for people to stay in especially when they are traveling by car. Bed and Breakfast - a house or small hotel in which someone can rent a room to sleep in for a price that includes breakfast the next morning. Furthermore, the term “room” was a consistent term used in the definition to describe bedroom, living room, and within the three transient use types. Again, the Appellant’s referenced sources define a “room” as: Merriam-Webster: Room - a partitioned part of the inside of a building especially such a part used as a lodging. Cambridge Dictionary: Room - a part of the inside of a building that is separated from other parts by walls, floor, and ceiling. Britannica Dictionary: Room - a part of the inside of a building that is divided from other areas by walls and a door and that has its own floor and ceiling. Of the three “room” definitions, the Britannica Dictionary does explicitly include a door in their definition. It should be further noted that the definitions of the three transient uses define it as a “room to stay”. What those transient uses definitions do not include is that the room has a door. However, when staying at any transient use, whether that be a hotel, motel, bed and breakfast, or short-term rental, there is an expectation of privacy, and that form of privacy always involves a door to that room where a guest is staying. One could wonder how parents would react if they stayed with their teenager, or even staying alone in a hotel room, motel room, or short-term rental without a door. CONCLUSION/RECOMMENDATION Based on the Director’s determination provided on March 25, 2024, and the additional information provided in response to the Appellant’s letter, a living room cannot be counted as a bedroom for short-term rental. Furthermore, it is reasonable to conclude that there is implied privacy when sleeping in any room, whether that be a hotel room, motel room, bed room in a bed and breakfast, or bedroom in a short-term rental, and that implied privacy, while not always explicit (except for the definition of “room” from Britannica Dictionary) includes a door. Legal Review: This report has been reviewed by the City Attorney’s office. 326 City of Palm Desert Appeal of STR Bedroom Determination Page 7 of 7 FINANCIAL IMPACT: There is no financial impact associated with the item. ATTACHMENTS: 1. Draft City Council Resolution 2. March 5, 2024, email to C. Kropfl from R. Cannone 3. Property details from RealQuest and Lawyers Title 4. Copy of Riverside County Assessor Audit Trail 5. March 25, 2024, email to C. Kropfl from R. Cannone 6. March 25, 2024, Director’s Written Determintion 7. April 4, 2024, Appeal of determination submitted by S. Murphy, Esq. 8. PowerPoint Presentation 327 328 RESOLUTION NO. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, UPHOLDING THE DEVELOPMENT SERVICES DIRECTOR DETERMINATION THAT A LIVING ROOM CANNOT BE COUNTED AS A BEDROOM FOR PURPOSES OF A SHORT-TERM RENTAL AND MAKING FINDINGS IN SUPPORT THEREOF WHEREAS, On March 25, 2024 the Development Services Director, in accordance with Palm Desert Municipal Code 2.72.020 provided as Written Determination to Ms. Carrie Kropfl, Applicant, that a living room cannot count as a bedroom for purposes of a short-term rental unit; and WHEREAS, On April 9, 2024, Mr. Shaun Murphy, Esq. on behalf of the Applicant filed an appeal of the Development Services Director’s determination that a living room cannot count as a bedroom for purposes of a short-term rental unit; and WHEREAS, on May 9, 2024, the City Council conducted a hearing to consider the Applicant’s appeal, and duly considered all evidence, testimony of the applicant and interested parties, and the evaluation and recommendation by staff, at said hearing; and WHEREAS, notices of said hearing were made at the time and in the manner required by law. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, by the City Council of the City of Palm Desert as follows: SECTION 1. RECITALS. That the foregoing recitals are true and correct and are incorporated herein as substantive findings of this Resolution. SECTION 2. FINDINGS. The findings for denial of the Applicants appeal are hereby adopted as follows: 1. PDMC §5.10.090(G) establishes that the maximum number of overnight guests shall not exceed two persons per bedroom coupled with fact that on-site short- term rental owners must occupy at least one bedroom, which shall diminish the number of bedrooms for overnight guests. It was the intent of the City Council that this limitation would not allow any guests, or even an owner, to stay overnight in a room other than a bedroom. 2. The Development Services Director’s interpretation of a definition of bedroom for purposes of a short-term rental unit is correct, as stated, “a private room intended for sleeping that is separated from other rooms by a door, having at least one window that meets the Emergency Escape and Rescue Opening requirements of the California Building code, has a closet/storage area, and is accessible to a bathroom without crossing into another bedroom. SECTION 3. ACTION. Based on the evidence and testimony presented, and the findings contained in Section 2, the City Council does hereby deny the subject appeal 329 Resolution No. 2024- ____ filed by Mr. Shaun Murphy, Esq., and upholds the Development Services Director’s determination that a living room cannot count as a bedroom for purposes of a short -term rental unit. ADOPTED ON ______2024. KARINA QUINTANILLA MAYOR ATTEST: ANTHONY J. MEJIA CITY CLERK I, Anthony J. Mejia, City Clerk of the City of Palm Desert, hereby certify that Resolution No. 2024-____ is a full, true, and correct copy, and was duly adopted at a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Palm Desert on ____________, by the following vote: AYES: NOES: ABSENT: ABSTAIN: RECUSED: IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and affixed the official seal of the City of Palm Desert, California, on ___________________, 2024. _________________ ANTHONY J. MEJIA CITY CLERK 330 From:Richard Cannone To:ckropfl@gmail.com Cc:Rosie Lua; Jason Finley; Lorena Ritchey Subject:RE: Monterey Country Club - Den and Bedroom Definition Date:Tuesday, March 5, 2024 1:53:00 PM Attachments:image001.png image002.png image003.png Ms. Kropfl: Good afternoon. Lorena forwarded me your email below and I wanted to clarify the following: 1. Advertising number of bedrooms – The city does not regulate advertisements on private transactions. 2. The room adjacent to the atrium - The room attached to the atrium does not meet the definition of a bedroom because it cannot meet the emergency egress and rescue openings per the California Building Code. 3. Using the Living Room as a Bedroom – For purposes of the short-term rental regulations, I have interpreted bedroom to mean a private room intended for sleeping that is separated from other rooms by a door, having at least one window that meets the egress/rescue requirements, has a closet/storage area, and is accessible to a bathroom without crossing into another bedroom. This is based in part on the city’s ordinance allowing for on-site and off-site owners. On-site means they are present and must stay at the property and the intent would be that a guest would have a private room. If you wish to convert your living room to a bedroom, Jason can assist with what permits would be needed. Please let us know if you have any additional questions. Best regards, Richard From: Lorena Ritchey <lritchey@palmdesert.gov> Sent: Monday, March 4, 2024 2:58 PM To: Richard Cannone <rcannone@palmdesert.gov> Cc: Rosie Lua <rlua@palmdesert.gov>; Jason Finley <jfinley@palmdesert.gov> Subject: Monterey Country Club - Den and Bedroom Definition Heads up and I believe you were working on a response to letter to this owner. She has reached out again with questions, and would like some answers. Lorena Ritchey, CCEO Management Analyst City of Palm Desert 331 73510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert, CA 92260 lritchey@palmdesert.gov | 760.776.6477 | www.palmdesert.gov From: Carrie Kropfl <ckropfl@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, March 4, 2024 2:19 PM To: Jason Finley <jfinley@palmdesert.gov> Cc: Lorena Ritchey <lritchey@palmdesert.gov> Subject: Re: Short-Term Rental Permit 239 Serena Dr, Palm Desert - Bedroom Definition STR2022-0020 Hi Jason and Lorena,I contacted the HOA at Monterey CC and the Monterey CC onsite leasing and sales office last week. They have been handing out floor plans for our unit (the Alhambra unit) that show it as a three bedroom (the room attached to the atrium as "bedroom #2). The Hi Jason and Lorena, I contacted the HOA at Monterey CC and the Monterey CC onsite leasing and sales office last week. They have been handing out floor plans for our unit (the Alhambra unit) that show it as a three bedroom (the room attached to the atrium as "bedroom #2). The onsite leasing and sales office is also advertising these properties as a three bedroom "for sale or lease" (season and long-term leases). Are STR owners the only people that are not allowed to use and/or advertise their properties as 3 bedrooms? Jason, you had mentioned a couple of weeks ago (when we met you in person) that you have been dealing with this issue with Monterey CC for the past decade and that they are fully aware that these are not legally three bedrooms. Can you forward the communication that you have had with them about this? We appreciate your help. Sincerely, Carrie Kropfl 949-554-4448 ---------- Forwarded message --------- From: Jason Finley <jfinley@palmdesert.gov> Date: Tue, Feb 27, 2024 at 4:22 PM Subject: RE: Short-Term Rental Permit 239 Serena Dr, Palm Desert - Bedroom Definition STR2022-0020 To: Carrie Kropfl <ckropfl@gmail.com>, Lorena Ritchey <lritchey@palmdesert.gov> Thank you for your email and information. I apologize for the delay; we are working through correspondence and meetings. I hope this email will suffice and put into writing the Building and Safety Division’s position rather than a phone call. First, let me address a common question in the Short-Term Rental program “Why the change in my permit?” The answer is that when this program was created, it was presumed to address all the requirements. As the program was evaluated, staff observed the need to address and review what applicants were designating as bedrooms. This evaluation came from discovering that many applicants 332 were using areas that were either unpermitted or not qualified to be used as bedrooms (sleeping rooms). As with any program, a shift occurred to examine what areas were used, resulting in some permits being revoked or modified. The red-outlined questions: 1. ATTACHED ARE THE TWO FLOOR PLANS THAT MONTEREY CC HOA PROVIDED ME WHEN I ASKED FOR THE ORIGINAL FLOOR PLANS FOR MY UNIT. BASED ON THESE FLOOR PLANS, MY UNIT IS WHAT THEY CALL THE "ALAHAMBRA PLAN" WHICH WAS BUILT AS A THREE BEDROOM (DUE TO THE CLOSET IN THE 3RD BEDROOM, LOCATION OF THE LINEN CLOSET IN THE HALL AND LOCATION OF THE CLOSET IN THE 2ND BEDROOM). NOTHING HAS BEEN CHANGED IN OUR CONDO. IT MATCHES THE ALAHAMBRA FLOOR PLAN EXACTLY. The information you have attached is not the construction plans but marketing materials used by the Monterey Country Club HOA. I’ve attached an approved City permitted floor plan to your unit from our archives that labeled this room as a den. Also attached is a letter between the developer and our former Chief Building Official (1981) about the concern about using the den as a bedroom. Similarly, a correspondence inquiry was made by an outside agency building official to support this area as a den. The California Building Codes still require this level of emergency egress and rescue, and we are not applying new standards to the Short-Term Rental Program. 2. WHEN I LOOK UP THE CALIFORNIA BUILDING CODE DEFINITION OF A "HABITABLE ROOM" IT STATES: "HABITABLE ROOMS USED FOR SLEEPING SHALL HAVE NATURAL LIGHT BY MEANS OF AT LEAST ONE EXTERIOR WINDOW THAT, IF IT CAN BE OPENED, HAS SCREENING WITH A TIGHT FITTING FRAME. NATURAL VENTILATION SHALL BE PROVIDED BY EXTERIOR OPENINGS THAT CAN BE OPENED, OR IN LIEU OF EXTERIOR OPENINGS A MECHANICAL VENTILATING SYSTEM. " The California Building and the California Residential Code define habitable spaces as “A space in a building for living, sleeping, eating, or cooking. Bathrooms, toilet rooms, closets, halls, storage or utility spaces, and similar areas are not considered habitable spaces. Light and ventilation are required for these spaces and can be achieved in several ways. 3. IN ADDITION A "HABITABLE ROOM" IS DEFINED AS "A SPACE FOR LIVING, SLEEPING, EATING OR COOKING" The code’s intent in defining rooms is to apply certain code requirements to specific spaces. When a room is labeled for use as a sleeping room, the emergency egress and rescue aspect of the code is applied. If a room is labeled as a den, office, theater, or media room, these egress and rescue standards are not required. 4. BASED ON THIS CODE, WE CAN SLEEP PEOPLE IN HABITABLE ROOMS. OUR LIVING ROOM AND THIS 3RD BEDROOM ARE HABITABLE ROOMS. SO, IF WE CALL OUR THIRD BEDROOM A "DEN, OFFICE, MEDIA ROOM OR BONUS ROOM" THEN WE CAN SLEEP PEOPLE IN IT AND WE CAN SLEEP PEOPLE IN THE LIVING ROOM. WHICH MEANS OUR CONDO CAN SLEEP 8 PEOPLE (PER YOUR RULE OF 2 PEOPLE PER ROOM). The answer is you cannot sleep people in a habitable room alone. A habitable room used for 333 sleeping purposes requires emergency egress and rescue openings. Where people fall asleep in their own homes is an uncontrollable occurrence. As Chief Building Official, I must apply the code as it states, and deviating from this could put the occupants in jeopardy and the City liable. As I stated at our counter, a front room or living room meets the building code definition of a habitable space. If emergency egress and rescue requirements are achieved, the building code is silent on whether you can sleep there or not. I did say this would come to a Short-Term Rental Program policy decision if these areas (front rooms, living rooms, and similar spaces) would be allowed. That discussion resulted in researching other programs that conclusively excluded front rooms, living rooms, and similar spaces. The City decided to align with other jurisdictions' definitions and not allow it to be counted toward the program. 5. ALSO, I HAVE A QUESTION REGARDING BABIES AND TODDLERS WHO SLEEP IN CRIBS AND PACK-N-PLAYS (WE HAVE BOTH). MOST PARENTS WILL HAVE THEIR KIDS SLEEP IN THE ROOM WITH THEM. A LOT OF OUR GUESTS ARE GRANDPARENTS, PARENTS AND THEIR CHILDREN. WE HAVE A LOT OF PEOPLE WITH BABIES AND TODDLERS. SO HOW DO WE ACCOUNT FOR BABIES AND TODDLERS? NOW, UNDER YOUR RULE - THESE PEOPLE WILL NOT RENT OUR SPACE (A 2 BEDROOM THAT SLEEPS 4). WHEN THESE GUESTS GO TO SEARCH ON AIRBNB FOR A PLACE THAT CAN ACCOMODATE 6 PEOPLE, OUR LISTING WILL NOT SHOW UP. THIS IS A LARGE PORTION OF OUR GUESTS. The current Short-Term Rental Ordinance Section 5.10.090(G) Maximum Number of Occupants does not address the inquiry about families with young children. It strictly states the maximum number of overnight guests and residents for a short-term rental unit shall not exceed two persons per bedroom. We are discussing with the Director of Development Services to consider amending this ordinance section to include minors. By providing these documents and responses from our archives, I hope this settles the emergency egress and rescue requirements for Monterey Country Club. Thank you. Jason Finley Chief Building Official City of Palm Desert 73510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert, CA 92260 jfinley@palmdesert.gov | 760.776.6420 | www.palmdesert.gov From: Carrie Kropfl <ckropfl@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, February 27, 2024 9:26 AM 334 To: Lorena Ritchey <lritchey@palmdesert.gov> Cc: Jason Finley <jfinley@palmdesert.gov> Subject: Re: Short-Term Rental Permit 239 Serena Dr, Palm Desert - Bedroom Definition STR2022-0020 Good morning Lorena and Jason. Thank you for your email below. I spoke with Lorena last night. I understand you are both going to call me this morning and wanted to put my questions down in an email to help with this discussion. I understand you have a job to do, but I am asking Good morning Lorena and Jason. Thank you for your email below. I spoke with Lorena last night. I understand you are both going to call me this morning and wanted to put my questions down in an email to help with this discussion. I understand you have a job to do, but I am asking you to take into consideration the position STR owners are in. We bought specifically in an area that allows STRs. We triple checked (calling the city, the hoa and due diligence) before purchasing to ensure we bought in the right area. We purchased a three bedroom condo (per all of the sales and marketing materials that not only our realtor provided but the onsite property management/sales office at Monterey CC). We were awarded (for the past two years) an STR license from the city for a 3 bedroom. Now, all of a sudden, we are being told we can no longer advertise as a three bedroom or we will lose our license and be fined (and if we don't pay the fine, a lien will be put on our property). Your new rule is taking away a minimum of 30% of our income (that's just based on what we can charge). Some STR owners think this will take away up to 50% of their income because, not only will this affect what we can charge, but how many people will book. These properties are our livelihood. Some STR owners at Monterey CC have been doing this for decades and it is their retirement and ONLY source of income. This is how I support my family. My husband and I bought this property as a retirement plan as well, instead of investing in a 401K. We are good stewards who have followed all the rules, we have 5 star reviews, our guests love the experience we provide, our neighbors appreciate us and all we do to ensure that our guests are 5 star guests who follow the rules. We employ a cleaning staff, gardners, pest control, handymen, plumbers, and more. We send paying customers to Monterey CC to help increase their bottom line. Guests have purchased in Monterey CC after staying at our property because they loved it so much. We pay the city 12% of our income. Our guests spend money at restaurants, boutiques and more. We are upstanding citizens who are doing positive things for the Palm Desert Community. We had planned on retiring here in the next 5 years because we love it so much, but now, your rule will make that impossible. What you are imposing is a 30-50% income reduction for us. In addition, you have just dropped our home values throughout Monterey by 20-30%. For round numbers, as an example, let's say that I was projecting to make $100,000 this year in revenue at my property (before you imposed this new rule). Your new rule will cause a $30,000-$50,000 reduction in revenue. Which means, now I have zero profit and will be losing money. We had planned on keeping this property for the next 30+ years and when we died, we planned on passing along this property to our son. Over a 30 year period, these losses will amount to $900,000 - $1,500,000. And, this number does not take into account a rise in rental rates. Also, you have reduced our property value by 20-30% because now we can't sell our property as a 3 bedroom. We estimate our property value to be somewhere around $700,000. This means, you just reduced the value of our property by $140,000 - $210,000. From my understanding there are 1,200 condos within Monterey CC and approximately 900 of these units have rooms attached to an atrium. That's roughly $126,000,000 - $189,000,000 in losses for property owners throughout the community. So with this in mind, following is the email you sent me. My questions are in RED: 335 The extra bedroom(s), and I would presume many at the atriums, are used as auxiliary bedrooms. The technical answer to the question is they do not meet the minimum standards the state has set for a room to be considered a bedroom. Monterey Country Club has had a marketing and real estate history that conflicts with the California Building Code’s minimum requirements for these rooms adjacent to the atriums. Occasionally, we’ve received old marketing advertisements that labeled these rooms as bedrooms. Our archived building records from when Monterey Country Club was first constructed consistently label these rooms “dens.” The anomaly is that there are properties within Monterey Country Club that do have a technically acceptable 3rd bedroom. ATTACHED ARE THE TWO FLOOR PLANS THAT MONTEREY CC HOA PROVIDED ME WHEN I ASKED FOR THE ORIGINAL FLOOR PLANS FOR MY UNIT. BASED ON THESE FLOOR PLANS, MY UNIT IS WHAT THEY CALL THE "ALAHAMBRA PLAN" WHICH WAS BUILT AS A THREE BEDROOM (DUE TO THE CLOSET IN THE 3RD BEDROOM, LOCATION OF THE LINEN CLOSET IN THE HALL AND LOCATION OF THE CLOSET IN THE 2ND BEDROOM). NOTHING HAS BEEN CHANGED IN OUR CONDO. IT MATCHES THE ALAHAMBRA FLOOR PLAN EXACTLY. Now, a den, office, media room, or bonus room is a legal use of space with an atrium. It meets the building code’s definition of a “habitable space.” “Habitable Spaces” (except sleeping rooms) do not require emergency egress and escape design, achieved by a minimum-sized window or door that leads directly to the public way. WHEN I LOOK UP THE CALIFORNIA BUILDING CODE DEFINITION OF A "HABITABLE ROOM" IT STATES: "HABITABLE ROOMS USED FOR SLEEPING SHALL HAVE NATURAL LIGHT BY MEANS OF AT LEAST ONE EXTERIOR WINDOW THAT, IF IT CAN BE OPENED, HAS SCREENING WITH A TIGHT FITTING FRAME. NATURAL VENTILATION SHALL BE PROVIDED BY EXTERIOR OPENINGS THAT CAN BE OPENED, OR IN LIEU OF EXTERIOR OPENINGS A MECHANICAL VENTILATING SYSTEM. " IN ADDITION A "HABITABLE ROOM" IS DEFINED AS "A SPACE FOR LIVING, SLEEPING, EATING OR COOKING" BASED ON THIS CODE, WE CAN SLEEP PEOPLE IN HABITABLE ROOMS. OUR LIVING ROOM AND THIS 3RD BEDROOM ARE HABITABLE ROOMS. SO, IF WE CALL OUR THIRD BEDROOM A "DEN, OFFICE, MEDIA ROOM OR BONUS ROOM" THEN WE CAN SLEEP PEOPLE IN IT AND WE CAN SLEEP PEOPLE IN THE LIVING ROOM. WHICH MEANS OUR CONDO CAN SLEEP 8 PEOPLE (PER YOUR RULE OF 2 PEOPLE PER ROOM). 336 CAN YOU CONFIRM THIS? ALSO, I HAVE A QUESTION REGARDING BABIES AND TODDLERS WHO SLEEP IN CRIBS AND PACK-N-PLAYS (WE HAVE BOTH). MOST PARENTS WILL HAVE THEIR KIDS SLEEP IN THE ROOM WITH THEM. A LOT OF OUR GUESTS ARE GRANDPARENTS, PARENTS AND THEIR CHILDREN. WE HAVE A LOT OF PEOPLE WITH BABIES AND TODDLERS. SO HOW DO WE ACCOUNT FOR BABIES AND TODDLERS? NOW, UNDER YOUR RULE - THESE PEOPLE WILL NOT RENT OUR SPACE (A 2 BEDROOM THAT SLEEPS 4). WHEN THESE GUESTS GO TO SEARCH ON AIRBNB FOR A PLACE THAT CAN ACCOMODATE 6 PEOPLE, OUR LISTING WILL NOT SHOW UP. THIS IS A LARGE PORTION OF OUR GUESTS. To further add frustration and confusion, a challenge we discovered is that the Country Assessor’s Office has and will change the labeling and listing of a room to a bedroom with a closet. This can conflict with the minimum code requirements if the room does not have egress an escape. AGAIN, OUR 3RD BEDROOM HAS A CLOSET AND MATCHES THE ALAHAMBRA PLAN EXACTLY. Furthermore, when an atrium enclosure permit is reviewed, the rooms adjacent to the atrium can no longer be labeled as bedrooms. A permit will not be issued until the room use is corrected. As Chief Building Official, it is my responsibility to ensure these areas are caught in plan review and corrected and are not allowed within the Short-Term Rental Program or any other City of Palm Desert permitting or licensing program until such time the California Building and Residential Codes are amended by the California Building and Standards Commission to revise the technical requirements. ARE YOU APPLYING THESE RULES TO EVERYONE IN MONTEREY CC: SELLERS OF PROPERTIES WITH THIS BEDROOM, LONG-TERM RENTALS WITH THIS BEDROOM? OR ARE YOU ONLY APPLYING THIS RULE TO STR OWNERS? ONE OF THE STR OWNERS RECENTLY WENT TO THE ONSIGHT SALES/RENTAL OFFICE AT MONTEREY CC AND ASKED THEM IF THEY WERE HAVING ISSUES WITH THE CITY FOR ADVERTISING, SELLING AND RENTING OUT OUR PLAN AS A 3 BEDROOM. THE OFFICE CLAIMED THE CITY HAS NEVER CONTACTED THEM ABOUT THIS. IF YOU ARE ONLY APPLYING THIS TO STR OWNERS, ISN'T THIS DISCRIMINATION? I apologize for the length. It's important to provide context as to why these were researched, applied to the technical aspects of the state code, and the determinations made. Should you have any questions, I can be reached at 760-776-6428 and email jfinley@palmdesert.gov. 337 ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS: - AREN'T WE GRANDFATHERED IN? FROM MY UNDERSTANDING, YOU CAN'T CHANGE BUILDING CODE TO STRUCTURES THAT WERE BUILT PRIOR TO THE CODE BEING CREATED. WHEN WERE THESE CODES CREATED? FROM MY UNDERSTANDING YOU CAN ONLY ENFORCE CODES WHEN SOMEONE DOES A SIGNIFICANT REMODEL TO A PROPERTY. CAN YOU PROVIDE A COPY OF THESE CODES YOU ARE REFERENCING AND THE DATE THEY WERE ENACTED? - YOU AWARDED US LICENSES FOR A 3 BEDROOM IN THE PAST. THIS SETS A PRECEDENT. OWNERS WHO HAVE ALREADY RECEIVED AN STR PERMIT FOR A 3 BEDROOM SHOULD BE GRANDFATHERED IN. CAN YOU CONFIRM THIS? - WHO HAS TASKED YOU WITH IMPLEMENTING THESE RULES/CODES? WHO IS PUSHING YOU TO DO THIS? HOTELS, MONTEREY HOA, SOMEONE AT MONTEREY CC? - DOES THE STATE HAVE JURISDICTION OVER THE CITY GENERAL PLAN? - CAN YOU PROVIDE PROOF (COPIES OF ORIGINAL DRAWING OR ARCHITECTURAL PROOF) THAT THE UNITS IN QUESTION WERE NOT CONSTRUCTED AS 3 BEDROOMS? - WERE THE DWELLINGS IN THE ORIGINAL DEVELOPMENT GRANTED ENTITLEMENT AS A 3RD BEDROOM? - IF YOU DON'T CONSIDER THESE 3 BEDROOMS, WHY ARE YOU ALLOWING REALTORS TO SELL THESE AS 3 BEDROOMS? - CAN YOU PROVIDE ME THE CITY CODES THAT STATE WHAT A BEDROOM IS AND THE DATE THIS CODE WAS ENACTED? - WHAT ARE YOU DOING TO DETERMINE IF THIS IS AN ISSUE WITH EACH AND EVERY STR? HOW ARE YOU CONFIRMING THE BEDROOMS AT EVERY STR IN PALM DESERT ARE LIVING UP TO YOUR CODES? WHAT OTHER COMMUNITIES/HOA's ARE HAVING THIS ISSUE? - HOW MANY FIRES HAVE THERE BEEN IN THE LAST 5 YEARS IN RESIDENTIAL HOMES IN PALM DESERT? OF THESE RESIDENTIAL HOMES, HOW MANY OF THE FIRES WERE STRs? HOW MANY OF THESE FIRES TOOK PLACE AT CONDO COMMUNITIES? HOW MANY OF THESE FIRES TOOK PLACE AT MONTEREY CC? THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME AND CONSIDERATION. Sincerely, Carrie Kropfl Founder Streetubez www.streetubez.com 949-554-4448 On Fri, Feb 23, 2024 at 3:41 PM Lorena Ritchey <lritchey@palmdesert.gov> wrote: Good afternoon Carrie, 338 This is in response to your inquiry about what is considered a bedroom. This is the Chief’s Building Official, Jason Finley response, and he has been included in the response as well. The extra bedroom(s), and I would presume many at the atriums, are used as auxiliary bedrooms. The technical answer to the question is they do not meet the minimum standards the state has set for a room to be considered a bedroom. Monterey Country Club has had a marketing and real estate history that conflicts with the California Building Code’s minimum requirements for these rooms adjacent to the atriums. Occasionally, we’ve received old marketing advertisements that labeled these rooms as bedrooms. Our archived building records from when Monterey Country Club was first constructed consistently label these rooms “dens.” The anomaly is that there are properties within Monterey Country Club that do have a technically acceptable 3rd bedroom. Now, a den, office, media room, or bonus room is a legal use of space with an atrium. It meets the building code’s definition of a “habitable space.” “Habitable Spaces” (except sleeping rooms) do not require emergency egress and escape design, achieved by a minimum-sized window or door that leads directly to the public way. To further add frustration and confusion, a challenge we discovered is that the Country Assessor’s Office has and will change the labeling and listing of a room to a bedroom with a closet. This can conflict with the minimum code requirements if the room does not have egress an escape. Furthermore, when an atrium enclosure permit is reviewed, the rooms adjacent to the atrium can no longer be labeled as bedrooms. A permit will not be issued until the room use is corrected. As Chief Building Official, it is my responsibility to ensure these areas are caught in plan review and corrected and are not allowed within the Short-Term Rental Program or any other City of Palm Desert permitting or licensing program until such time the California Building and Residential Codes are amended by the California Building and Standards Commission to revise the technical requirements. I apologize for the length. It's important to provide context as to why these were researched, applied to the technical aspects of the state code, and the determinations made. Should you have any questions, I can be reached at 760-776-6428 and email jfinley@palmdesert.gov. 339 Lorena Ritchey, CCEO Management Analyst City of Palm Desert 73510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert, CA 92260 lritchey@palmdesert.gov | 760.776.6477 | www.palmdesert.gov 340 4/17/24, 3:40 PM View Order https://www.titlepro247.com/Orders/Home/Html/B33121228 1/16 Subject Property Location Report Date: 04/17/2024 Property Address 239 SERENA DR Order ID: R145872561 City, State & Zip PALM DESERT, CA 92260-2157 County RIVERSIDE COUNTY Property Use Condominium Unit (Residential) Mailing Address 246 W ESCALONES, SAN CLEMENTE, CA 92672-5109 Parcel Number 622-082-020 Census Tract 0449.29 Latitude 33.74486 Thomas Bros Pg-Grid Longitude -116.389517 Legal Description Details Lot Number: 4-6 City, Municipality, Township: PALM DESERT Tract No: 11454 Brief Description: UNIT 20 CM 023/032 INT IN COMMON LOTS 4,5 & 6 TR 11454 MB 097/082 Current Ownership Information *Source of Ownership data: Recorder Information Primary Owner Name(s)CASA MONTEREY 239 LLC, Sale Price Transfer Date 07/14/2022 Recording Date 08/03/2022 Vesting Recorder Doc #2022-0343714 Book/Page Latest Full Sale Information Primary Owner Name(s)KROPFL, KEITH JOSEPH; TANNER KROPFL, CARRIE Sale Price $495,000 Sale Date 11/15/2021 Recording Date 12/09/2021 Vesting Living Trust Recorder Doc #2021-0727610 Book/Page Financing Details at Time of Purchase 1 Loan Amount $396,000 Origination Lender Name 5TH STREET CAPITAL INC Loan Type New Conventional Recording Doc #2021-0727611 Property Characteristics Bedrooms 2 Year Built 1979 Living Area (SF)1,670 Bathrooms/Partial 1.75 Garage/No. of Cars Attached Garage/2 Price ($/SF)$296/SF Total Rooms Stories/Floors 1 Story Lot Size (SF/AC)1,686/.04 Construction Type Wood No. of Units 1 Fireplace 1 Fireplace Exterior Walls No. of Buildings Pool Roof Material/Type Tile Basement Type/Area Heat Type Central Foundation Type Style A/C Central Property Type Residential View Golf Course Adjacent Elevator Land Use Condominium Unit (Residential)Zoning PR5 Assessment & Taxes Assessment Year 2023 Tax Year 2023 Tax Exemption Total Assessed Value $504,900 Tax Amount $6,597.88 Tax Rate Area 18-049 Land Value $71,400 Tax Account ID 622082020 Improvement Value $433,500 Tax Status No Delinquency Found Improvement Ratio 85.86%Delinquent Tax Year 341 4/17/24, 3:40 PM View Order https://www.titlepro247.com/Orders/Home/Html/B33121228 2/16 Total Value Market Improvement Value Market Land Value Market Value Year 342 4/17/24, 3:40 PM View Order https://www.titlepro247.com/Orders/Home/Html/B33121228 3/16 Lien History Trans. ID Recording Date Lender Amount Purchase Money 1 12/09/2021 5TH STREET CAPITAL INC $396,000 YES Loan Officer Insights Trans.ID 1 Loan Officer ROBERT FORBES PAINTER NMLS#272709 Broker BROKER SOLUTIONS INC NMLS#6606 Loan Company 5TH STREET CAPITAL INC NMLS#1436495 Disclaimer THIS REPORT IS INTENDED FOR USE BY YOU AS AN END USER SOLELY FOR YOUR INTERNAL BUSINESS PURPOSES. YOU SHALL NOT RESELL, RELICENSE OR REDISTRIBUTE THIS REPORT, IN WHOLE OR IN PART. THE USE OF THIS REPORT BY ANY PARTY OTHER THAN YOURSELF FOR ANY PURPOSE IS STRICTLY PROHIBITED. THIS REPORT IS PROVIDED AS-IS WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND, EITHER EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING WITHOUT LIMITATION, ANY WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY, NON-INFRINGEMENT, OR FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. INTERCONTINENTAL EXCHANGE, INC. (ICE) SHALL HAVE NO LIABILITY IN CONTRACT, TORT, OR OTHERWISE ARISING OUT OF OR IN CONNECTION WITH THIS REPORT. ICE DOES NOT REPRESENT OR WARRANT THAT THE REPORT IS COMPLETE OR FREE FROM ERROR. YOU UNDERSTAND AND ACKNOWLEDGE THAT THE AVAILABILITY, COMPLETENESS AND FORMAT OF THE DATA ELEMENTS MAY VARY SUBSTANTIALLY FROM AREA-TO- AREA. THE INFORMATION CONTAINED IN THIS REPORT IS DERIVED FROM PUBLICLY AVAILABLE SOURCES FOR THE SUBJECT PROPERTY OR COMPARABLE PROPERTIES LISTED ABOVE AND HAS NOT BEEN INDEPENDENTLY VERIFIED BY ICE THROUGH ANY FORM OF INSPECTION OR REVIEW. THIS REPORT DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AN APPRAISAL OF ANY KIND AND SHOULD NOT BE USED IN LIEU OF AN INSPECTION OF A SUBJECT PROPERTY BY A LICENSED OR CERTIFIED APPRAISER. THIS REPORT CONTAINS NO REPRESENTATIONS, OPINIONS OR WARRANTIES REGARDING THE SUBJECT PROPERTY'S ACTUAL MARKETABILITY, CONDITION (STRUCTURAL OR OTHERWISE), ENVIRONMENTAL, HAZARD OR FLOOD ZONE STATUS, AND ANY REFERENCE TO ENVIRONMENTAL, HAZARD OR FLOOD ZONE STATUS IS FOR INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY AND SHALL BE INDEPENDENTLY VERIFIED BY THE END USER. THE INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN SHALL NOT BE UTILIZED: (A) TO REVIEW OR ESTABLISH A CONSUMER'S CREDIT AND/OR INSURANCE ELIGIBILITY OR FOR ANY OTHER PURPOSE THAT WOULD CAUSE THE REPORT TO CONSTITUTE A "CONSUMER REPORT" UNDER THE FAIR CREDIT REPORTING ACT, 15 U.S.C. § 1681 ET SEQ.; OR (B) IN CONNECTION WITH CERTIFICATION OR AUTHENTICATION OF REAL ESTATE OWNERSHIP AND/OR REAL ESTATE TRANSACTIONS. ADDITIONAL TERMS AND CONDITIONS SHALL APPLY PURSUANT TO THE APPLICABLE AGREEMENT. Copyright CONFIDENTIAL, PROPRIETARY AND/OR TRADE SECRET. TM SM ® TRADEMARK(S) OF INTERCONTINENTAL EXCHANGE, INC. AND ITS SUBSIDIARIES AND AFFILIATES. © 2024 INTERCONTINENTAL EXCHANGE, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. 343 4/17/24, 3:40 PM View Order https://www.titlepro247.com/Orders/Home/Html/B33121228 4/16 To view the Online Document Retrieval, please click on the link below Online Document Retrieval (2022-0343714) Deed - Intra-family Transfer or Dissolution Complete 344 4/17/24, 3:40 PM View Order https://www.titlepro247.com/Orders/Home/Html/B33121228 5/16 345 4/17/24, 3:40 PM View Order https://www.titlepro247.com/Orders/Home/Html/B33121228 6/16 346 4/17/24, 3:40 PM View Order https://www.titlepro247.com/Orders/Home/Html/B33121228 7/16 To view the Online Document Retrieval, please click on the link below Online Document Retrieval (2021-0727611) Mortgage - New Conventional Complete 347 4/17/24, 3:40 PM View Order https://www.titlepro247.com/Orders/Home/Html/B33121228 8/16 348 4/17/24, 3:40 PM View Order https://www.titlepro247.com/Orders/Home/Html/B33121228 9/16 349 4/17/24, 3:40 PM View Order https://www.titlepro247.com/Orders/Home/Html/B33121228 10/16 350 4/17/24, 3:40 PM View Order https://www.titlepro247.com/Orders/Home/Html/B33121228 11/16 351 4/17/24, 3:40 PM View Order https://www.titlepro247.com/Orders/Home/Html/B33121228 12/16 352 4/17/24, 3:40 PM View Order https://www.titlepro247.com/Orders/Home/Html/B33121228 13/16 353 4/17/24, 3:40 PM View Order https://www.titlepro247.com/Orders/Home/Html/B33121228 14/16 354 4/17/24, 3:40 PM View Order https://www.titlepro247.com/Orders/Home/Html/B33121228 15/16 355 4/17/24, 3:40 PM View Order https://www.titlepro247.com/Orders/Home/Html/B33121228 16/16 356 4/17/24, 3:56 PM RealQuest.com ® - Report https://pro.realquest.com/jsp/report.jsp?&action=confirm&type=getreport&recordno=0&reportoptions=0&1713394587071&1713394587072 1/2 Property Detail Report For Property Located At : 239 SERENA DR, PALM DESERT, CA 92260- 2157 Owner Information Owner Name:CASA MONTEREY 239 Mailing Address:246 W ESCALONES, SAN CLEMENTE CA 92672-5109 Vesting Codes:/ / Location Information Legal Description:UNIT 20 CM 023/032 INT IN COMMON LOTS 4,5 & 6 TR 11454 MB 097/082 County:RIVERSIDE, CA APN:622-082-020 Census Tract / Block:449.29 / 1 Alternate APN:622-082-020 Township-Range-Sect:Subdivision: Legal Book/Page:Map Reference:/ Legal Lot:4 Tract #:11454 Legal Block:School District:DESERT SANDS INDIO Market Area:322 School District Name:DESERT SANDS INDIO Neighbor Code:Munic/Township:CITY OF PALM DESERT Owner Transfer Information Recording/Sale Date:08/03/2022 / 07/14/2022 Deed Type:QUIT CLAIM DEED Sale Price:1st Mtg Document #: Document #:343714 Last Market Sale Information Recording/Sale Date:12/09/2021 / 11/15/2021 1st Mtg Amount/Type:$396,000 / CONV Sale Price:$495,000 1st Mtg Int. Rate/Type: 4.50 / ADJ Sale Type:FULL 1st Mtg Document #:727611 Document #:727610 2nd Mtg Amount/Type:/ Deed Type:GRANT DEED 2nd Mtg Int. Rate/Type:/ Transfer Document #:Price Per SqFt:$296.41 New Construction:Multi/Split Sale: Title Company:CHICAGO TITLE-INLAND EMPIRE Lender:5TH STREET CAP INC Seller Name:BARLOW DOROTHEA A Prior Sale Information Prior Rec/Sale Date:08/16/2016 / 06/23/2016 Prior Lender:WELLS FARGO BK NA Prior Sale Price:$240,000 Prior 1st Mtg Amt/Type:$228,000 / CONV Prior Doc Number:350522 Prior 1st Mtg Rate/Type:/ Prior Deed Type:GRANT DEED Property Characteristics Gross Area:2,174 Parking Type:ATTACHED GARAGE Construction: Living Area:1,670 Garage Area:504 Heat Type:CENTRAL Tot Adj Area:1,800 Garage Capacity:Exterior wall: Above Grade:Parking Spaces:3 Porch Type: Total Rooms:Basement Area:Patio Type: Bedrooms:2 Finish Bsmnt Area:Pool: Bath(F/H):2 /Basement Type:Air Cond:CENTRAL Year Built / Eff:1979 / 1980 Roof Type:Style: Fireplace:Y / 1 Foundation:Quality: # of Stories:1 Roof Material:SLATE Condition: Other Improvements:YES Site Information Zoning:PR5 Acres:County Use:CONDO OR PUD WITH PRIVATE ENTR (A11) Lot Area:Lot Width/Depth:x State Use:R02 Land Use:CONDOMINIUM Res/Comm Units:/Water Type:TYPE UNKNOWN Site Influence:GOLF COURSE Sewer Type:TYPE UNKNOWN 357 4/17/24, 3:56 PM RealQuest.com ® - Report https://pro.realquest.com/jsp/report.jsp?&action=confirm&type=getreport&recordno=0&reportoptions=0&1713394587071&1713394587072 2/2 Tax Information Total Value:$504,900 Assessed Year:2023 Property Tax:$6,597.88 Land Value:$71,400 Improved %:86%Tax Area:018049 Improvement Value:$433,500 Tax Year:2023 Tax Exemption: Total Taxable Value:$504,900 358 359 360 From:Carrie Kropfl To:Richard Cannone Cc:Michelle Nance Subject:Re: Appeals Process for taking something to the City Counsel Date:Monday, March 25, 2024 9:55:20 AM Attachments:pdlogo_e8fc6661-d5ed-470d-b1e5-b34884233d29.png hoabanner_c920930b-ff28-4ade-ba4e-9142ce7b516a.png Thank you. I appreciate that. Once I receive this, how long do I have? Is there a timeframe associated? Also, there are three things we will be appealing: 1. To allow to use the room in question (room attached to atrium) as a habitable room that guests are allowed to sleep 2. To allow us to sleep additional guests in our living room 3. To allow us to sleep up to 4 guests per bedroom My address: 246 West Escalones San Clemente, Ca 92672 Get Outlook for iOS From: Richard Cannone <rcannone@palmdesert.gov> Sent: Monday, March 25, 2024 8:18:30 AM To: Carrie Kropfl <Carrie.Kropfl@lifestylerentalproperties.com> Cc: Michelle Nance <mnance@palmdesert.gov> Subject: Re: Appeals Process for taking something to the City Counsel Hi Carrie, I am putting together a formal letter that I will be mailing to you later today, however I need your mailing address. I will also send a copy of the letter to you via email as a courtesy. On Mar 22, 2024, at 6:27 Richard D. Cannone, AICP Director of Development Services City of Palm Desert 73510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert, CA 92260 rcannone@palmdesert.gov | 760.776.6438 | www.palmdesert.gov 361 PM, Carrie Kropfl <Carrie.Kropfl@lifestylerentalproperties.com> wrote: Good evening Richard and Michelle, I still have not received a phone call or email regarding the appeals process. I spoke with Michelle two days ago and she had said Richard would be contacting me to go over the appeals process. Can someone please get back to me as soon as possible. Thank you, Carrie Kropfl Get Outlook for iOS From: Carrie Kropfl <Carrie.Kropfl@lifestylerentalproperties.com> Sent: Wednesday, March 20, 2024 11:59:49 AM To: Michelle Nance <mnance@palmdesert.gov> Subject: Re: Appeals Process for taking something to the City Counsel Hi Michelle, We would like to appeal the usage of our condo. We purchased a 3-bedroom condo in December of 2021, and were awarded STR permits from the city for a 3 bedroom in 2022 and 2023. In 2024, when we went to renew our STR permit with the city, we were that it is not a three bedroom, it is a two bedroom. We were told that one of the bedrooms is not legally a 3 bedroom, so we can no advertise it or use it as a 3 bedroom. We own an STR. This change has reduced our occupancy rate from 6 guests to 4 guests and is having a negative financial impact on our business. We made a request from Lorena Ritchey, as a compromise, to use our living room as a space to sleep two additional guests. She has refused this request. We have two appeals: 1. To allow us to continue to use the room in question as a bedroom 362 2. To allow us to sleep 2 additional guests in our living room Thank you! Carrie Kropfl 949-554-4448 From: Michelle Nance <mnance@palmdesert.gov> Sent: Wednesday, March 20, 2024 11:49 AM To: Carrie Kropfl <Carrie.Kropfl@lifestylerentalproperties.com> Subject: RE: Appeals Process for taking something to the City Counsel Hi Carrie, I’m happy to get you connected with the appropriate member of staff. Can you provide the subject of the appeal? This information will help me get you to the best person. Thank you, Michelle Michelle Nance Deputy City Clerk I City of Palm Desert 73510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert, CA 92260 mnance@palmdesert.gov | 760.776.6301 | www.palmdesert.gov From: Carrie Kropfl <Carrie.Kropfl@lifestylerentalproperties.com> Sent: Wednesday, March 20, 2024 11:45 AM To: Michelle Nance <mnance@palmdesert.gov> Subject: Appeals Process for taking something to the City Counsel Hi Michelle,I just left you a message. I would like information on how to file an appeal with the city. Can you please forward me information? I would love to chat as well.Thank you!Carrie Kropfl949-554-4448 Hi Michelle, I just left you a message. I would like information on how to file an appeal with the city. Can you please forward me information? I would love to chat as well. 363 Thank you! Carrie Kropfl 949-554-4448 364 365 366 367 368 369 370 371 372 A T T O R N E Y S SHAUN M. MURPHY, ESQ. PARTNER ADMITTED IN CA, Ml, TX, NY AND THE U.S. SUPREME COURT REPLY TO· 1800 E. Tahquitz Canyon Way Palm Springs, California 92262 T (760) 322-2275 • F (760) 322-2107 murpt,y@sbemp.com April 4, 2024 VIA HAND DELIVERY Anthony Mejia City Clerk City of Palm Desert 73-510 Fred Waring Drive Palm Desert, California 92260 RE: Keith Kropfl and Carrie Kropfl appeal of decision from building official related to short-term rental regulations Dear Mr. Mejia: We represent Keith Kropfl and Carrie Kropfl who own the real property within the Monterey Country Club at 239 Serena Drive, Palm Desert (the "Property''). Mr. and Mrs. Kropfl (pronounced Cropful) recently received an adverse decision from Mr. Jason Finley, the City's Building Official (the "CBO''). The CBO made three determinations. Under Section 2.72.010, the Kropfl's appeal the decision on the first and second issues only. A copy of the decision is attached as Exhibit A. ISSUE NO. 1: Whether the Kropfl's may continue to use the third bedroom for short-term rentals. The reasons from the CBO for the denial are in Exhibit A. The Kropfl's intentionally bought a property in an area that allowed short-term rentals. They checked with the city, with the homeowner's association of the Monterey Country Club, and did their own due diligence before purchasing. The sellers had purchased the property in 2016 as a three- bedroom condo. The sellers listed the property in 2021 as a three-bedroom condo, the Monterey Country Club property managemenVsales office provided sales and marketing information showing their floorplan as a three-bedroom condo. The Monterey Country Club homeowner's association provided a floorplan also showing the Property as a three- bedroom condo (with the original builder's, Sunrise Division, logo on it). Their realtor also identified the Property as a three-bedroom condo. The Property has been classified as a Palm Springs, CA T (760) 322-2275 SLOVAK BARON EMPEY MURPHY & PINKNEY LLP Indian Wells, CA Costa Mesa, CA T (760) 322-9240 T (714) 435-9592 San Diego, CA T (619) 501-4540 www.sbemp.com Princeton, NJ T (609) 955-3393 New York, NY T (212) 829-4399 373 Anthony Mejia April 4, 2024 Page2 three-bedroom condo for decades, and the County of Riverside Assessor's Office recognizes it as a three-bedroom condo. After they bought the Property, they applied to the city and the city issued a short- term rental permit for 2022, and again for 2023, for a three-bedroom condo . By issuing the permits, the city recognized the Property as a three-bedroom condo. The Kropfl's recently applied to renew their permits for 2024, and were told -for the first time -that the permit could not be renewed as a three-bedroom rental and could be used only as a two bedroom. The Kropfl's made the City aware that currently, the Monterey Country Club's onsite property management/sales office was continuing to sell and lease their exact floor plan as a three-bedroom condo, the homeowner's association was continuing to pass out floor plans showing it as a three-bedroom condo, and sellers/realtor's within the Monterey Country Club were continuing to list and sell it as a three-bedroom condo. The city responded by saying, "the City does not regulate advertising or private transactions." With actual knowledge, the city is allowing the very same floorplan at issue here to be advertised, leased long-term, and sold as three-bedroom condos. The city's sudden change in position has and will continue to have a significant financial impact on the Kropfl's. The change causes an income loss of at least 30% based on the amount of rent. The change will likely cause greater losses because fewer people will rent the Property if it accommodates only four people instead of six. A 30% reduction in revenue would be between $30,000 to $50,000 yearly. The Property is a principal source of income for the Kropfl's. It is how they support their family. Their Property is highly rated, they make sure their guests follow the rules, and they have received no complaints from either the City or the Association . Their Property combined with other similarly situated properties provide a significant economic benefit to the City. They employ a cleaning staff, gardeners, pest control, handymen, plumbers, and more. They send customers to Monterey Country Club for golf. Past guests have bought property in Monterey Country Club after staying at their property. Each transaction contributes to the Palm Desert economy in addition to the 12% tax they pay to the city. In addition to a loss in revenue, the city's change of position has impaired the Property's value. The change is estimated to cause a loss of value between 20% and 30%. Nothing has changed during the decades where the Property was classified as a three-bedroom condo. The city should continue to recognize the Property as a three- bedroom condo and allow the Kropfl's to market and rent it as a three-bedroom. ISSUE NO. 2: Whether the Kropfl's may use their code compliant living room as an additional sleeping room to accommodate two more guests. The CBO determined they could not use the living room as a bedroom. The basis for the denial is set forth under Issue 2 in Exhibit A 374 Anthony Mejia April 4, 2024 Page 3 The CBO admits that the term "bedroom" is not defined in Chapter 5.10 regulating short-term rentals. The CBO interpreted bedroom to mean: a private room intended for sleeping that is separate from other rooms by a door, having a least one window that meets the Emergency Escape and Rescue Opening requirements of the California Building code, has a closet/storage area, and is accessible to a bathroom without crossing into another bedroom. The CBO based his interpretation "in part on the city's ordinance differentiating between on-site and off-site owners. Specifically, §5.10.090(G) ... " The CBO also based his decision on definitions in the American Planning Association, Planners Dictionary, and his profession experience. He did not, however, provide any information from those resources to justify or explain his interpretation. First, the CBO's reliance on § 5.10.090(G) is puzzling because it is irrelevant to defining the term "bedroom." That section merely states the obvious presumption that an on-site owner will be deemed to occupy at least one bedroom. The presumption makes one less bedroom available for rent, but it does not aid the effort to define a "bedroom." Since we have no information about what the Planners Dictionary provides or the CBO's professional experience, there is no basis to evaluate the information on which he purportedly relied. The Kropfl's dispute the CBO's definition of bedroom; particularly, the requirement that it have a door. The CBO cites no provision in the city's Code of Ordinances requiring a bedroom to have a door.1 There are many sources other than the Planners Dictionary that define bedroom with no reference to a door. For example, Merriam-Webster defines bedroom to mean, "a room furnished with a bed and intended primarily for sleeping ." (https://www.merriam- webster.com/dictiona ry/bedroom#dictionary-entry-1 ). No mention of a door. The Cambridge Dictionary defines bedroom to mean, "a room used for sleeping in." (https://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/bedroom ). No mention of a door. Dictionary.com defines bedroom to mean, "a room furnished and used for sleeping." (https://www.dictionary.com/browse/bedroom ). No mention of a door. And The Britannica Dictionary defines bedroom to mean, "a room used for sleeping." (http s://www.britannica.com/dictlonary/bedroom). No mention of a door. It is apparent that the CBO selected a source to use that would support the conclusion he wanted to reach. In an earlier communication dated February 27, 2024, to Mrs. Krapfl, the CBO explained his interpretation of an acceptable sleeping room. He said, "As I stated at our counter, a front room or living room meets the building code definition of a habitable space. If emergency egress and rescue requirements are achieved, the building code is I wonder how parents would react after learnlng that removing the door to their teenager's bedroom for whatever reason means that the room is no longer a bedroom as determined by the CBO. 375 Anthony Mejia April 4, 2024 Page4 silent on whether you can sleep there or not. I did say this would come to a Short-Term Rental Program policy decision if these areas (front rooms, living rooms, and similar spaces) would be allowed. That discussion resulted in researching other programs that conclusively excluded front rooms, living rooms, and similar spaces. The City decided to align with other jurisdictions' definitions and not allow it to be counted toward the program." (Emphasis added.) The CBO admits that the city's Code of Ordinances have no provisions defining an acceptable sleeping room. He also admits "If emergency egress and rescue requirements are achieved, the building code is silent on whether you can sleep [in a living room) or not." He referred to other jurisdictions who specifically adopted regulations governing the use. Rather than amend the Code of Ordinances to conform to what other jurisdictions have done -to specifically address the issue -the city adopted a policy based on what other jurisdictions had implemented. The city is applying a shadow regulation -one that has not gone through the formal procedures to amend the Code of Ordinances -including providing notice to residents. The room that the Kopfl's want to use for more guests is a "room furnished and used for sleeping," or "a room used for sleeping." It has windows that comply with the Emergency Escape and Rescue Opening requirements of the California Building code, has a closet/storage area, and is accessible to a bathroom without crossing into another bedroom. There is nothing in the California Building Code nor is there any provision in the city's Code of Ordinances prohibiting them from using the room as an acceptable sleeping room. The CBO's determination that a door is required for a room to be classified as a bedroom is arbitrary. It should be reversed and the Kopfl's should be allowed to advertise and rent the space as an additional sleeping room . SMM: sv Encl.: Exhibit A Fee Payment Sincerely, SBEMPLLP BY: Shaun M. Murphy 376 EXHIBIT A 377 March 25, 2024 VIA US MAIL AND EMAIL Ms. Carrie Kropfl 246 West Escalones San Clemente, CA 92672 CITY OJ PAlM D~SIRI 73-510 FRED WAIUNC DRIVE PALM DESERT , CAUFORNIA 92260-2578 TEL: 760•346·0611 INFO@PALMDES!RT.GOV Subject: Monterey Country Club -Den and Bedroom Interpretation Dear Ms. Kropfl: I wanted to provide a formal response to the three questions below that you have raised in connection with using your property in Monterey Country Club and the ability to appeal the determinations we have provided you. Question 1: Can you continua to use the third bedroom, based on the floor plans provided (attached)? No, the third bedroom you reference is considered a den and cannot be used as a bedroom. Mr. Jason Finley, CBO the City's Building Official responded on February 27, 2024 that the information you provided is not the construction plans, but rather marketing materials. Mr. Finley then provided you with a copy of the approved floor plan (attached) that was permitted for your unit from our permitting archives, and the room in question was labeled as a den. Mr. Finley also provide you with a letter dated September 28, 1981 (attached) from the Sunrise Company, the developer to our former Chief Building Official clarifying that "the den Is not Intended to be used for sleeping purposes." Furthermore, Mr. Finley reviewed and concurred with the 2022 California Residential Code (§A310.1 -Emergency Escape and Rescue Opening Required1) which states: Every sleeping room shall have not less than one operable emergency escape and rescue opening. Emergency escape and rescue openings shall open directly into a public way (§R310.1 ). In applying this life, health, and safety requirement for "Den" space(s) adjacent to the atriums of the Monterey Country Club floor layout, it is determined these atriums do not meet the minimum code requirements for a bedroom or sleeping room . They lack direct access to a public way and cannot be used as such. This determination was also based upon documentation from the original developer acknowledging that these areas could only serve as a den. An outside independent building official was also used and concurred (attached) in 1979. 1 Cited California Residential Code Definitions (Sect ion §202): EMERGENCY ESCAPE AND RESCUE OPENING. An operable exterior window, door, or other similar device that provides a means of escape and access for rescue in the event of an emergency. PUBLIC WAY. Any street, alley, or other parcel ofland open lo the outside air leadi ng to a public street, that has been deeded, dedicated, or otherwise permanently appropriated to the public for public use and that has a clear width and height of not less than IO feet (3048 mm). 378 C. Krapfl -Interpretations Page 2 of 3 March 25, 2024 Appeal of Building Official's Interpretation Pursuant to Palm Desert Municipal Code (PDMC) Chapter 2.18, the Building Board of Appeals1 a letter of appeal must be submitted requesting an appeal of the Building Official's interpretation. Once the letter is received a hearing will be scheduled with the Building Board of Appeals. If you wish to appeal against Mr. Finley's interpretation, submit to the City Clerk a letter requesting the appeal along with a check in the amount of $276.00. A hearing will be scheduled no sooner than ten days after receiving your request. Question 2: Can you use your llving room as a bedroom to sleep two additional guests for a Short-Term Rental? No, the living room cannot be used as a bedroom. Chapter 5.10 of the PDMC includes the regulations for operating a Short-Term Rental Unit with the City of Palm Desert. §5.10.090(G) establishes that the maximum number of overnight guests shall not exceed two persons per bedroom. §5.10.030 includes definitions, however a definition of "bedroom• is not included. Chapter 2.12 of the PDMC establishes that the Community Development (Development Services) Director shall enforce the standards of the POMC pertaining to the use of land, the erection, construction, reconstruction, moving, conversion, alteration, or addition to any building or structure, which involves the interpretation of those standards. For purposes of the short-term rental regulations, I have interpreted bedroom to mean: a private room Intended for sleeping that is separated from other rooms by a door, having at least one window that meets the Emergency Escape and Rescue Opening requirements of the California Building code, has a closet/storage area, and is accessible to a bathroom without crossing into another bedroom. This interpretation is based in part on the city's ordinance differentiating between on-site and off-site owners. Specifically, §5.10.090(G) establishes that on-site owners shall be deemed to occupy at least one bedroom, which shall diminish the number of bedrooms for overnight guests accordingly. In other words, a one-bedroom unit CANNOT be Issued an On-Site Short Term Rental Permit, because the On-Site Owner must be present and must stay at the property in a bedroom The interpretation was also based on in part on definitions of bedrooms and sleeping rooms contained in the American Planning Association, Planners Dictionary, and my professional experience. Appeal of Director's Interpretation Chapter 2. 72 establishes procedures for appeals to City Council that requires an appellant file a written notice of appeal specifying the specific decision from which the appeal is taken, the specific grounds for the appeal, and the relief or action requested from the City Council. This notice must be submitted to the City Clerk within ten (10) days after receiving this written letter along with a check in the amount of $276.00. Once deemed sufficient, the City Clerk will schedule the appeal for a hearing by the City Council at a regular meeting, but not later than forty-five days after receipt of the notice of appeal. The City Clerk will cause the notice of hearing to be given to the appellant not less than ten days prior to the hearing unless that notice Is waived in writing by the appellant. 379 C. Krapfl -Interpretations Page 3 of 3 March 25, 2024 Question 3: Can up to four overnight guests per bedroom be permitted for a Short- Term Rental? No, only two overnight guests are permitted per bedroom. As stated above, PDMC §5.10.090(G) explicitly states that the maximum number of overnight guests shall not exceed two persons per bedroom. This is not a matter of interpretation, but a strict code requirement. As such, there is no right to appeal the decision Is ministerial and does not involve the exercise of administrative discretion or personal judgment (see PDMC §2. 72.01 O(B)) Sincerely, RICHARD D. CANNONE, AICP DIRECTOR OF DEVELOPMENT SERVICES Attachments cc. Todd L. Hileman, City Manager lsra Shah, City Attorney Jason Finley, CBO Building Official 380 ALHAMBRA PLAN 300 SQUARE FOOTAGE 1634 Three Bedroom, Two Bath ATIUUM ,..,., u·•· BEOROOM2 ,, ... ' ,,.,. E MASTER ~ BATH ~--- J • PATIO LIVINCROOM S\Ol'IHG CIIUHG " ....... . DININCROOM SI.OPINC Cl,U,-G BEOROOMJ ,,.~, ,,r MASTER BEDROOM 11 • , u·r MIi ; / • MONTEREY COUNTRY CLUB -a SUMISE 1COMPANY RESALE DIVISION 381 J I I I I I I I ··L . I I 1· I : ,. • I f I i· ! I ~ _J. .• . ---i---.............. E. . . I ti. i I ' I ·-,L__• • I I I i. 382 ,. . .. 7 i:--- ~,11~, . l .• "·-.... !·. ____ ... _._._. -· ... · -· ... " ....... ' _,.,,,..- Febrvary 7 • 197t Daryl Vflby Chtaf Buttd1ng Off1~1•1 City of Modesto Butldtnt ln,pectfon City Ha 1, 801 • 11th Strftt P. O. B01& 142 Modesto, Ca1tfom1a 953~3 RECltV1 D AUG 2 '> 1979 auwaa au..-..,._,.._ tUY al PAI.II 1.U£H1 Subject: tMrgency Egress end Rescue llflldaws • Stcttou 1304 and 1404, 1971 Ull1fora BuUdtng Code Dear Mr, llt11ey: You asked the question tn your lettctr of .January 30, 1979, • ••• are the egress or rescue windows requtred by SoctlDI\S 1304 and 1404 also req1dred exits as defined 1n Chapter 337• The 1ncwer to th1s question 1s "no", as the emergency egr.ss ~nd "scue .rlndows do not coa,ly with the requtre111ents tn Chapter 33. H~ever, the dosfgn exemples whtch you enclosed wtth your letter have probleais •htch are not solved by the answer to your question. Tht tnt.nt of the code fs that wfftdQIIS required by Sections 1304 end 1404 i,. 1v1tlable so that rescue can be effected from tht extertor, or tn the alternative. one may escape f•oan that window to the exterior of the butldtnq wfthaut having to travel through the bu1ld1ng ttself. If these emergency wtndows open onto an fnterfor court or a so-called atrtum, they do not •et the f ntent of ttse code. Wa note from your letter that you 1ndtcated Sntion 1304 was refer.-ed ta by Sectton 1406. Actually, the reference fn Sectton 1406 1s to Section 1306 for yards and courts havtng req11tred windows opentng theretn. It 1s our opinion that the windows required by Secttons 1~04 and 1404 for tme1"9ency eyress and rescue should open to th~ t>ltertor of the but ldfng and not fr.to courts or atrtums. As 383 ,I Ci t.t of Palr-l'\~~;-rt t !j-2~'~ Pr i ct l ·: \' ,ur t.anc- Palm D~~~rt ~j~~o ': I '. I Th.iR iii in rilU('i~n~e to Itel'I No. l c.•f. ycHu rlan Check n'>tes --... rt·lating to our conddminiul"ls to >:e ccnstructed at the abc,v& arlcfrnsa~s. • .. -: Sonc of thoi::1• ~tni ts include a ~l•~n, ·•hit.'h. is servml b·: a ~•·pat'ata bathr:-o:n. The room i~ •~\r•.Jr~y (~!"ti fic,S u a "ll,•n" on t.hc pl~m.1. '• 'l'lt•· den if. not intQn1ecl to be u'>·•.I f~r ~l".''.:t ,in~, p\1,poses. H11,,:1ar ro~:,s in o\lr ~ontere~' co .. ,nt ~..-··ti,h -7,:,rM">l~Y. ore t11n,ished .i:1,l ~t.o~n aq -\~ns . ;,l.t ,,:-•"-'' .,d,:-.··1,('o,;;i',ut"t:S ,111,t ,vlvo?rt:i.i;i n11 r-'.ltc1· 1ills dcsc?"il:t,• • ••• ,.,,,>~, ·,:-. ,"'I ':'!,.:n, w, •. ,r,.. !a:->!) i.ir ,_.l ti~ tho ,~ro·,i,.it,r. • •.-1 ;:,:t;t:iC\n 11n2 of tlt6 C '.al i for:, i -1 !l ~•:t l t'h ;\!l•l g-,fcty {:o•~r-H ! "i'( :;. !CI:. ion 12( 4. ·,,e h,,.,,. .1lnol•1t•·•l·:• ne\ ir,tQnt to •aoln••· t~1~•.:<• ser:ti,:,ns, ,,, .,./:f,_1..'.'::,_ le. ~--i. --,_ M11ll:.:-• i~ •. :~-[~\, 'r. ~ '-' • ,.,. rr:-,, . .! • :P•1~ ... ,\ ... l •.;t ,1r: •. •~: t ;, ~ ;•,·,·.;•. ,1.,r,t -., 114 I J18 61'4~ 384 APPEAL OF DIRECTOR’S DETERMINATION COUNTING A LIVING ROOM AS A BEDROOM FOR SHORT-TERM RENTALS CITY COUNCIL MAY 9, 2024 385 Background What is before the Council is an appeal of Development Services (Community Development) Director’s determination that a living room cannot be considered a bedroom for purposes of a short-term rental unit. PDMC Chapter 2.12.010 establishes that it shall be the duty of the Director “to enforce the provisions of this code pertaining to the use of land, the erection, construction, reconstruction, moving, conversion, alteration, or addition to any building or structure.” PDMC Chapter 2.72 establishes that City Council will hear appeals from any person aggrieved by an administrative decision. 05/09/2024 CITY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM 11.A 2 386 Initial Request (Attachment 2) CITY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM 11.A 305/09/2024 March 5, 2024 –Director sent an email to Owner clarifying that a living room cannot be used as a bedroom for purposes of Short-Term Rental (“STR”), specifically: For purposes of the short-term rental regulations,I have interpreted bedroom to mean a private room intended for sleeping that is separated from other rooms by a door,having at least one window that meets the egress/rescue requirements,has a closet/storage area, and is accessible to a bathroom without crossing into another bedroom.This is based in part on the city’s ordinance allowing for on-site and off-site owners.On-site means they are present and must stay at the property and the intent would be that a guest would have a private room.If you wish to convert your living room to a bedroom,Jason [Finley]can assist with what permits would be needed. 387 STR Permit History November 2021 Owner purchased 239 Serna Drive January 2022 Owner obtained a STR Permit for a 3-Bedroom Unit January 2023 Owner renewed 3 Bedroom STR Permit July 1, 2023 Development Services Department created internal procedures with staff to ensure that the regulations adopted by City Council were being enforced when applications were submitted, including renewals of STR permits 05/09/2024 CITY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM 11.A 4 388 STR Permit History January 24, 2024 05/09/2024 CITY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM 11.A 5 Owner applied to renew 3 Bedroom STR Permit Staff confirmed the number of bedrooms through: Riverside County Assessor RealQuest & Lawyers Title (Attachment 3) All showed a 2-bedroom unit for this Property. Staff also reviewed building permit records and there were no building permits for a bedroom addition. 389 05/09/2024 CITY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM 11.A 6 Attachment 3 390 STR Permit History February 1, 2024 Owner revised their renewal request for a 2-bedroom STR unit and staff approved and issued a renewal March 4, 2024 Owner requests and Riverside County Assessor changed the property records from a 2-bedroom unit, with a den to a 3-bedroom property, with no den (Attachment 4) 05/09/2024 CITY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM 11.A 7 391 STR Permit History This is contrary to the Appellants statement that “Nothing has changed during the decades where the Property was classified as a three-bedroom condo. The city should continue to recognize the Property as a three-bedroom condo and allow the Kropfl's to market and rent it as a three-bedroom.” 05/09/2024 CITY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM 11.A 8 Attachment 4 392 Director’s Determination March 25,2024,the Owner sent an email clarifying that they would like to submit an appeal on three items (Attachment 5). 1.Can they continue to use the third bedroom (den),based on the floor plans provided? 2.Can you use the living room as a bedroom to sleep two additional guests for a Short-Term Rental? 3.Can up to four overnight guests per bedroom be permitted for a Short-Term Rental? 05/09/2024 CITY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM 11.A 9 393 Director’s Determination (Attachment 6). March 25,2024 -Pursuant to PDMC §2.72.020 the Director provided a written determination to the Owner. Request 1.The determination for Request #1 was made by the Building Official as authorized by the California Building Code. Chapter 2.18 of the PDMC establishes a Building Board of Appeals (“Board”)to hear appeals regarding the interpretation of the California Building Code by the Building Official. The appeal of this request is scheduled to be considered by the Board on May 23,2024. The Board’s decision may be appealed to the City Council and therefore the specifics of this request should not be discussed or considered at this time. 05/09/2024 CITY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM 11.A 10 394 Director’s Determination (see Attachment 6). Request 2.Can you use the living room as a bedroom to sleep two additional guests for a Short-Term Rental? 1.The Director concluded that based on the language contained in PDMC §5.10.090(G)which establishes that the maximum number of overnight guests shall not exceed two persons per bedroom coupled with fact that on- site STR owners must occupy at least one bedroom,which shall diminish the number of bedrooms for overnight guests.In other words,a one-bedroom unit CANNOT be issued an On-Site Short Term Rental Permit,because the On- Site Owner must be present and must stay at the property in a bedroom;not a living room or having the ability to share the rented bedroom. 05/09/2024 CITY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM 11.A 11 395 Director’s Determination (Attachment 6). Request 2 cont. 2.Due to the lack of a definition of a bedroom and for purposes of Chapter 5.10 Short Term Rentals,the Director interpreted a bedroom room to mean: A private room intended for sleeping that is separated from other rooms by a door, having at least one window that meets the Emergency Escape and Rescue Opening requirements of the California Building code, has a closet/storage area, and is accessible to a bathroom without crossing into another bedroom 05/09/2024 CITY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM 11.A 12 396 Director’s Determination (Attachment 6). Request 3.Can up to four overnight guests per bedroom be permitted for a Short-Term Rental? PDMC §5.10.090(G)explicitly states that the maximum number of overnight guests shall not exceed two persons per bedroom. This was not a matter of interpretation,but a strict code requirement.As such, there is no right to appeal because it does not involve the exercise of administrative discretion or personal judgment (see PDMC §2.72.010(B)). 05/09/2024 CITY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM 11.A 13 397 Letter of Appeal (Attachment 7) On April 4, 2024, an appeal was filed (see Attachment 7) by Mr. Shaun Murphy, of Slovak Brown Empey Murphy & Pinkney LLP (“Appellant”), on behalf of the Owner for the following: 2.Whether the Kropfl's may use their code compliant living room as an additional sleeping room to accommodate two more guests. 05/09/2024 CITY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM 11.A 14 398 Response to Appeal 05/09/2024 CITY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM 11.A 15 1.The Appellant states that it is “puzzling”and believes the reference to PDMC §5.10.090(G)is irrelevant to defining the term “bedroom”. PDMC §5.10.090(G)includes the following language: If the use is on-site owner short-term rental,the owner shall be deemed to occupy at least one bedroom,which shall diminish the number of bedrooms for overnight guests accordingly… Based on this limitation imposed and the Director’s experience,this language aided in his determination that if it was City Council’s intent to allow an owner to stay in a room,other than a bedroom,then City Council would have not included this limitation. 399 Response to Appeal 05/09/2024 CITY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM 11.A 16 2.The Appellant further disputes the Director’s interpretation that a bedroom must have a door and believes this interpretation is arbitrary. The Appellant’s basis is derived from the definition of “bedroom”from Merriam-Webster,Cambridge Dictionary,and Britannica Dictionary,and as stated in the appeal letter,“all which referenced a room for sleeping with no mention of a door.” 400 Response to Appeal 05/09/2024 CITY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM 11.A 17 The Appellant provides the definition of “bedroom”but chooses to omit the definition of “living room.”Using the Appellant’s same references: Merriam-Webster defines living room as,“a room in a residence used for the common social activities of the occupants.” Cambridge Dictionary defines living room as “the room in a house or apartment that is used for relaxing in and entertaining guests.” Britannica Dictionary defines living room as “a room in a house for general family use —usually singular.” NOTE:None of the definitions define a living room as a room used for sleeping. 401 Response to Appeal 05/09/2024 CITY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM 11.A 18 Additionally,these three dictionary references used by the Appellant provide for definitions for hotel,motel,and bed and breakfast: Merriam-Webster Hotel -an establishment that provides lodging and usually meals,entertainment,and various personal services for the public. Motel -an establishment which provides lodging and parking and in which the rooms are usually accessible from an outdoor parking area. Bed and Breakfast -an establishment (such as an inn)offering lodging and breakfast. Cambridge Dictionary Hotel -a building where you pay to have a room to sleep in,and where you can sometimes eat meals. Motel -a hotel for people travelling by car,usually with spaces for cars next to each room. Bed and Breakfast -a room to sleep in for the night and a morning meal,or a private house or small hotel offering this. 402 Response to Appeal 05/09/2024 CITY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM 11.A 19 Britannica Dictionary Hotel -a place that has rooms in which people can stay especially when they are traveling:a place that provides food,lodging,and other services for paying guests. Motel -a place that is next to a road and that has rooms for people to stay in especially when they are traveling by car. Bed and Breakfast -a house or small hotel in which someone can rent a room to sleep in for a price that includes breakfast the next morning. “Room”was a consistent term used in the definition to describe bedroom, living room,and within the three transient use types. 403 Response to Appeal 05/09/2024 CITY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM 11.A 20 Merriam-Webster:Room -a partitioned part of the inside of a building especially such a part used as a lodging. Cambridge Dictionary:Room -a part of the inside of a building that is separated from other parts by walls,floor,and ceiling. Britannica Dictionary:Room -a part of the inside of a building that is divided from other areas by walls and a door and that has its own floor and ceiling. Britannica Dictionary does explicitly include a door in their definition of “room”. 404 Response to Appeal 05/09/2024 CITY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM 11.A 21 3.The Appellant also conjectures in a footnote wondering how parents would react after learning that removing the door to their teenager’s bedroom,for whatever reason means that the room is no longer a bedroom. •While the Appellant tries to provide an example in a “typical”family setting with parents and teenagers,the unit is question is NOT typical and the Owners are seeking a permit for the unit to be rented to a Transient. •What is being considered is an application for a dwelling to be used for lodging purposes to a Transient that must obtain a STR Permit to do so. PDMC §5.10.030 Short Term Rental Definitions.“Transient”means any person who seeks to rent or who does rent a privately-owned residential unit for a period less than twenty-seven consecutive days. 405 Response to Appeal 05/09/2024 CITY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM 11.A 22 •Short Term Rentals are required to pay: Transient Occupant Tax (TOT)and Tourism Business Improvement District (TBID)assessment. •“Typical”residential properties are not required to be licensed or required to pay TOT or TBID. •Only Transient uses i.e.hotel,motel,bed and breakfast,and short-term rentals pay the TOT and TBID. 406 Response to Appeal 05/09/2024 CITY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM 11.A 23 •It should be further noted that the definitions of the three transient uses define it as a “room to stay”.What those transient uses definitions do not include is that the room has a door. •However,when staying at any transient use,whether that be a hotel, motel,bed and breakfast,or short-term rental,there is an expectation of privacy,and that form of privacy always involves a door to that room where a guest is staying. •One could wonder how parents would react if they stayed with their teenager (or alone)in a hotel room,motel room,or short-term rental without a door. 407 Staff Conclusion 05/09/2024 CITY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM 11.A 24 1.Based on the Director’s determination provided on March 25,2024,and the additional information provided in response to the Appellant’s letter,a living room cannot be counted as a bedroom for short-term rental. 2.It is reasonable to conclude that there is implied privacy when sleeping in any room,whether that be a hotel room,motel room,bedroom in a bed and breakfast,or bedroom in a short-term rental,and that implied privacy,while not always explicit (except for the definition of “room”from Britannica Dictionary)includes a door. 408 Staff Recommendation 05/09/2024 CITY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM 11.A 25 1.Find that the staff report,including attachments,and any additional evidence provided at this hearing provides satisfactory evidence that the Development Services Director’s determination was correct. 2.Adopt a Resolution entitled “A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT,CALIFORNIA,UPHOLDING THE DEVELOPMENT SERVICES DIRECTOR DETERMINATION THAT A LIVING ROOM CANNOT BE COUNTED AS A BEDROOM FOR PURPOSES OF A SHORT-TERM RENTAL AND MAKING FINDINGS IN SUPPORT THEREOF”(Attachment 1) 409