Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutCivic Center Addition CITY OF PALM DESERT Interoffice Memorandum TO: Mayor Crites and City Council Members FROM: Pat Conlon, Director of Building and Safety SUBJECT: CIVIC CENTER ADDITION DATE: June 28, 1990 STAFF RECOMMENDATION: 1 ) Approve proposal from John Outcault, Architect, for the preparation of working drawings, and bidding administration for the proposed Civic Center office additions (Attachment A) . 2) Appropriate $41, 800. 00 plus 10% contingency of $4, 180. 00 from the unallocated Construction Tax Fund for the preparation of the Administration wing working drawings. 3) Appropriate $41, 800. 00 plus 10% contingency of $4, 180. 00 fro■ the unallocated Construction Tax Fund for the preparation of the Community Services wing working drawings. 4) Upon completion of the working drawings, authorize staff to proceed to advertise for bids and report back to council with the recommendation on the lowest responsible bid. BACKGROUND: In September 1989 the City Council authorized the services of John Outcault for the preparation of the preliminary plans presented now before you. With your approval, for the preparation of working drawings, the architect and his various consulting engineers will have the working drawings ready to go out to bid on or prior to November 1, 1990. With the anticipated thirty day bid period, staff will be presenting back to you for your review and approval, the lowest qualified bid on December 13, 1990. With your review and approval of the actual contract costs for construction, construction start is anticipated in mid January of 1991 and completion approximately fifteen months later, March 1, 1992. PLANNING & DESIGN PHILOSOPHY: Unlike the initial design of the civic center, a tea■ concept was utilized in the preliminary design layout. The Administrative Design Team consisted of Carlos Ortega, Dave Yrigoyen, Sheila Gilligan, Paul Gibson, Larry McAllister, Linda Russell, Paul Shillcock and myself. 1 Page two. . . Mayor Crites and City Council Members Civic Center Addition June 28, 1990 The Community Services Design Team consisted of Dick Folkers, Ray Diaz, Frank Allen, Ken Weller, Mary Spencer and myself. Through six working sessions together, both teams' input, architect' s expertise, along with the steering committee' s guidance, resulted in the preliminary design before you. The following elements are the various design considerations considered by the design team members. 1) Building the shell now - stay flexible. Improve only what is necessary to meet today' s staffing needs. This amounts to approximately 3, 000 square feet of future expansion area in the Community Services wing and 2, 600 square feet of undeveloped area in the Administration wing. With the shell in place these undeveloped areas could be easily improved at a later date. Since the initial design in 1979, construction and move-in in 1982, and knowing the earliest we can complete these additions is March of 1992, it was the goal of the two design teams to plan out ten years from now past the year 2000, taking into consideration the City of Pal■ Desert' s current and future growth needs. 2) Design for openness. Try to avoid compartmentalization wherever possible . A good example of this is the open office administration area co-inhabited by Finance, Personnel, RDA, and Economic Development. This concept promotes communication and all overall awareness of the various job functions each individual, as well as each department, experiences. Had this philosophy been utilized in 1979, it is doubtful that the two (2) separate wings, i. e. Administration and Community Services, would have been designed and created. , Where needed for privacy, the use of mid-height movable partitions will be utilized. Flexibility still remains because virtually any layout can be achieved. 3) Special design features. A) Public Art Facilitation - The 8' wide corridor connecting the new administrative wing to the existing offices is envisioned to become a gallery for art work. Extensive use of energy efficient skylights for natural lighting will be utilized throughout the new areas, as well as special lighting fixtures required for accent lighting of the various wall hung art pieces. Page three. . . Mayor Crites and City Council Members Civic Center Addition June 28, 1990 The design team will be working closely with the Public Arts Commission in developing these features. B) Minimal changes are needed to existing office staff areas to facilitate the additions. As shown by the dotted lines on the floor plan, the removing and repositioning of non-structural partition walls are kept to a minimum. This, in conjunction with careful work scheduling, will keep disruptions to ongoing business to a minimum. C) Loading and unloading driveway for civic center supplies. Currently, all supplies, e. g. xerox paper, etc. are wheeled through the lobby area to the store room. D) Public restroom accessibility without the need to unlock the staff offices. For special functions, e. g. Golf Cart Parade, 4th of July, etc. the public may utilize, through the corridors, the bathrooms in both wings without the need of staff supervision or the worry of theft. Portapotties are ok by real bathrooms are nicer. FISCAL IMPACT: Projected cost for both 10, 000 square foot wings (20,000 square foot total ) is 2. 2 million dollars. This is equivalent to, as the architect points out in his proposal, to approximately $110. 00 per square foot of floor area. No additional appropriation is necessary in Fiscal Year 1990/91. The proposed budget has 2. 4 million dollars allocated for the construction of this project. Yesterday' s Cost Vs. Today' s Cost Vs. Tomorrow' s Cost - In 1982 the existing Palm Desert Civic Center was constructed by Snedaker Construction for the total cost of $2,506, 957.00 which included all ten change orders as well as extensive site work. For a comparison of the cost of the structure alone (excluding site work), the existing civic center structure was built according to the contractor' s breakdown for the cost of $2, 016, 726. 00. That cost, divided by the square footage of 25, 426 which is the size of the existing civic center structure, equals a cost of $79. 32 per square foot. Today' s cost of our sa•e civic center structure (excluding site work) would be approximately $110.00 to $120. 00 per square foot or approximately 2.8 to 3. 0 million dollars. Page four. . . Mayor Crites and City Council Members Civic Center Addition June 28, 1990 An example of today' s construction cost is the Palm Desert YMCA recently awarded to R. D. Pillow Construction. The base bid for the 10, 214 square foot building was $1, 227, 000. This bid was for the structure only. The cost per square footage for the YMCA structure is approximately $120. 00 per square foot. A bit more expensive due to the relatively small size of the YMCA structure, ( i. e. 10, 214 square foot YMCA vs. 20, 000 square foot for the proposed civic center addition) . For structure vs. structure comparison, the increase of construction cost from 1982 to present (i. e. $79. 32 per square foot to $110. 00 per square foot ) reflects a 38% increase over the last eight years. This is approximately equal to a 4. 5% increase in structure cost per year compounded yearly since 1982. How does this compare to the national average? Statistics taken from the April 1990 Edition of American City & County, Attachment 8, shows what was built in the base year of 1982 for $100. 00 will now cost $122. 00 or a 22% increase over the last eight years or approximately 3% increase compounded yearly since 1982. This shows Palm Desert' s construction costs are accelerating more rapidly over the last eight years than the national average. Tomorrow' s cost ? Using the 4. 5% figure for yearly construction cost increases, our proposed addition of 20, 000 square feet for 2. 2 million in 1990 will cost approximately 2. 74 million in 1995 ( i. e. $137. 00 per square foot) and 3. 41 million in the year 2000 (i. e. $170. 00 per square foot) . Respectfully'f submitted, r-PCL °CrtAll —L&" PAT COLON DIRECTOR OF BUILDING & SAFETY PC:djb Attachment •• 0 0 m d A x z GI i d _ I 1 dH = n rn n - VI b GN F I:, -- . —'I - 1 t....if ..__=.0___i iii-2.1 M • • TA ./ Y I ?-I :O u4 y j. ___,T_ T--o r 1 ,-..., \\\\:.:\ ‘,.._‘,_ ,.,__:),___....._.,___.,.. ._ .....___ . . , , --ij II II II X C u rn p fo :1- ` i ( / .r. • . ii ... . . , 1 •` •'`� ••AAA II • • Ir 11 -II II II I • ' �•/ Q—Cr-p---17--7 RI I ,.." t . . a �__Q__- -_t._.� » fa_ \ F x.A T 7 ). p /a• x a F li i� Tr tr p — > Q CA it D6 1" ti a ma 1i_._L__1j___u__Jr___u_ vA s b y O n T • L. 11 IAT z p i Gl oPc V p r\ .1, N r • f Y g �- -31 2. y N. _ - / P t ; ; FRED\\\\-, / \ WAR ING DRIV E O DRAWING TITLE cEV'i` p 3`� JOHN F. OUTCAULT — ARCHITECT A.I.A. REVISION$ STRUCTURAL ELECTRICAL m m NC..ErT,�a,t_ � I L:Y 9- m E;4� PROJECT A CORPORATION �� o.u»np» fm ADDITIONS TO EXISTING 74.133 El PASEO,SUITE 11 T•I•.619-346.0630 m.. 10,61 PALM DESERT.CALIFORNIA 92260 PLUMBING MECHANICAL i 6 PAL M D L S E RT CIVIC CENTEi<, CALIF STATE LIC NO C2452 ,__ _--- O t9 9 DRAWN CHECKED SQUARE FOOTAGE O I 1 , :x ZII tl3ervrIN 133, -�p i{ °7 0.i it 't1b"�v o-,1 .,,Q)I 1 3,ej5 1 311/0 IA NOIL) Oad 9NI /vM H1zION • � yomF • � o2x; I 1 o �� S —N z - -1' Z m �C179 rJNI LSI]CJ �� f r`dO11IOOV NBN 1 71- .',4. OI 1 I I _ ru++aa, 11,.IZ ` Marl to 1 1 I I '1 . a��..o . - I�o _ r n -I L-L T —,--r—T , , 61 ri II , bl x II -� I �T scro v) 2nv4 il _I I - Il'J�NC) I -IIlyNOy / err Cpl/-Iz ,�,�c, iI Z 0 iI C.J,-;) • (r+rlor) (ry) r Z ,LI N,1z II tilFd ,;Z1,0 ,41><,b (aiw:a ,vii/ll ,zla,11 ZI`L 371a'JG 371c1�O r. X+9VNvW J Li7 Ib"',nauro. daivlS 3vl �o �alddo v;xS pva:Xa- �3 • � nao 71woNo» I F� �N 1� ;2�I177 � , D F t T._.. 0 \ O __ __ _AZlp -1`d 9 - 1lv ri - ' �n07 -Iris WA O�3 n 3 u�Z! 4. z , 2 � / _ rolivzuilnlwad (-�., .- - -- - ___ ��111 TT CJ/ \i nnt 0 w 0 0 ^ w IIXII I 9 _ 2 5 j y C—. —�- -t �r � XUd 731 • -1 1-1 rl d/� �.�.Joa r • D -ia $ 'I-- - al.bz 0 fl C I 1F -udw - w.ov3>< �a�lois •a,vds i _ =a I 1 zaiwo2 3 l-x,nn.1 5 L.� I I i I ---- ST—, • a m 5 1 �l o Z 8- a I . I I ACP201 fj--—IC'�1'� I - �+ona_ 41.•�I - - O 7D0 1�r.n»: ���nnm I `- - I _ s174Tio i. {^.r+0us.<ts '7g auM �) cpI t,SI u • v�nv Nan 1 • Z131nJ NP7 1 -. o _ 2 ....., I I �srr e 1 m • I 3a/Ko1T "13NMasri3d 3,N' NI . -I -71,1,.O] 3nnnm - tiR)3"1'7 A LI') I �Y7nnao __ _-�. I �Il ..,o - 1 o u - I � I I i p p D I I /.^ __. I I _. L uVI. -- D D c.) (-irrod) V�V I to,4i n,(LI 14.\\„."L ni.z1 n1.z1• 91.71 71u Z1m I IIPJ.vIA - I y7i - II . B✓.4C 3-Idd0 W 3 1�7C] 153 Iv= a7 0 3-,Is40 < 1 i In --- — i I i I r- I ` 1 I 0----0----p----b---=❑ 0 � LI- --D---11 .. . U 11:11----- 1 1 D q 1 I 1 ; . K c - I—+ El x,.n,3nlba z c 1 I 71-1VM o D 1 r ,`o_ _ —G-- q n -- - 1 1 1 ���- --n 1 Z nmy V '� > v Yy z n r f • 1 r \ �� U --El-- — —� n ❑ - D -II-- — i-——Et 1i —CJ —1= LT E—— I —II--Er—LE1—--o---M-— - — xlsrlrio covactco wcE_1� < < 0 El 14 ii U xa I 1 9— �— �— U w lat I I t -= - - --- --- • n . ,. . ,f..,3 I 1 �hEr oI . h A. II 4 J- (r I --- i . 1 ________ 11 dI_ q FUTU1cE _ ; . jI I I EXPANSION t'V T V(M E'lPiFiSTDu1 ltluly B U11-DING O SAFETY I 1 p c g N I >$ a o II nEonor.v I I - 'o2 ' ----� a I1 (�II MEN O worI.aE11 I--.1 - JANROIES - 0 0 :STOEAG6 sTarr _— d f r 1 I 1 —/ • I Y1 1 �� ReeM i Y. I P I = I m ... 1_--G - - 1-I- - a --Co- - i 1 • SRJPJ�`f' /l1l - J t __ _CON.CR cH CC ..�i.aRIF6 bPFIC� .- - ® • a Z $ - '- 1/ IUI 4-� 20 i(i ?O x i fi I ❑ t.o813Y I g I CON FE¢-ENC.G CPU•.,sue -p/w 5-1-Arr. -_ - I O 11 ri ❑- 1 11 1 O ..4.. �i OFFICE __ I H -< - I mcJNTII(L.- I I Q r,Z n Y �. I - MEW ��= 20 r I1 ._ Q N Q V M1 W V Q = \� - _-.__-. - ,- 4z 01 FIcE. !owl., O e.--' IfiYII STOfI- W I.,"-.F i. _ I - I" CCNfEk. � ---}� Z �oN r_______. f �3 I ^_°r z ... .4 - --ST,..,..r. m�La -' 1n.17 I 0 n s a 1 PLANNING (MOVaaa.r rrno t) I o ! r GODe Tt..2 - EI IFORGE sTcceGe I - LLJ ?Or1Z �--yI —n c ) C ST OR>JG4r O 7 II:In IJ a-4, Li — { _I'-- I / Vlom 1 I En+iSr C G RFlWCOOUcT. x I L`RV+c. - Op*IGE TO 544021FF STA OW - �� U 12.,1 z 1 Z. 0 F ❑ —❑ — —❑ OFClctr--- 4 Z i,"R, -OPP 1 G�--_- Cy I7 'I �/1 /, 1 I E.x 1 1 ---' 1---- Cl 1..1 -1:yY. I 1 I1 IMAMNORTH F I- 15 C EXISTING _BLDG p ---' 1 - ° X w Q Y I -- 13i T EAST Q w6 z �_ ®----�----� u DATE i= NEW A017?lT fO NI SOUTH SHEET NUMBER %a. APIL7L3.3 j97F I Arell. � 1970 i-{ EAS-C --_WING ADDITION •1 JNF IS,19H0 t 3 5.;� SCkl-.C-: 1/6".IO a 4 s...,. ti , t . _ _ I • 4 ., I NEW ADDITION \ e �I • i j . V V . F Z W V _ WE1 , - - 0 i....— , -. 2. ----1 n , , • -n - . _ _ ___ ,_ .._..._ . _ _.. ____ L--_, g iiii p .., j , , , . 1111M1 IIIIMI • S T ELEVATION - - N O (ZT H VI-t r-r--.it3N . - - 5-c...0. _-_iieft ,- - • cr 0 . r • • i f1 • m • 1 CC m _ - re a ,. .-4 i ' in _I-. t� o-rz +�-- ET E.-_-E A T IN==N o M.T r -W_ N c ATD t�t�c� 1� - -._ — —— - o a A_�y _ i 1 '1 I ¢E N Ew_AO 012101V ------- a a - ; i • - • o11 ._.• ,,,e. + - _ . „'ter t - I U _ - 4- , -- ... r C _ _ i 1-1 _ . .� - _—_--.__._- U . ' oO I Z • - EAST- EL. - i O N - N O TZT H WING A�DOITQN-;-- rz sCIaLE, YD• I-O ---- Q NEW ADDITION - • I Q g nc PiAmj _ _ FQ —` W 1 IL-N La ,, , --1 0 ...„,...:'2 ,,o Z - - - N 0 R. T H EL E V AT 1 O N - EAST WING Ats.10 D IT}aN _ g, ,�i3 g{•-ALE �D-=_t=c- o Z Z W Q- E. ---. ;*-4 7 t III U _.',1 L'il TI g 1, , .t� +, , , - J W U EAST ELEVATION - E AST WING A D C I TICK ~ YI� In In at.5-c .. .,�•..'' (�. N 1 I ' NEW n.OD,T10,4 0 z w on W1 � s CI _WW o a - _ �t L ._�. �� SI*ET htucarcEN SOUTH EL... EVATION - EAST WING ADDITION - -• .� — ATTACHMENT A T H E OFFICE 0 F AGENDA PACKET JOHN F . OUTCAULT SECTION L ARCHITECT A . I . A . A CORPORATION, ''EETIN2 DATE b/�B Igo 74-133 EL PASEO/HMS PLAZA SUITE 11 PALM DESERT,CALIFORNIA 92260 May 18 , 19 9 0 TELEPHONE(619)346.0630 Pat Coplon _ c/o City of Palm Desert 73-510 Fred Waring Dr. Palm Desert, CA. 92261 Ref : Additions to Civic Center Building Dear Pat; You have requested me to send a letter of proposal for the architectural-engineering documentation for additions to the existing Civic Center building complex. This proposal is based on the previously submitted preliminary concepts, reviewed by the Civic Center committee. In August of 1989, you authorized my office to prepare a conceptual plot plan for additions to the Civic Center. This was done, at a cost of $760 .00 . In September of 1989, the Council authorized my office to proceed with preliminary plans for the above Civic Center expansion. (September 28,1989 Council meeting) . These preliminary plans are being completed, with an approved quotation of $20 , 000 . 00 . (my letter of September 9, 1989 ) . This proposal is for architectural-engineering working drawings and specifications, necessary to provide the city with documents sufficient to request• bid proposals. A more formal agreement form can be eventually used to itemize the necessary parts of services . The project essentally is as follows: A. Two wings of building additions . ( 1 ) Administration wing to the north, approx. 10,000 sq. ft. ( 2 ) Public works/Engineering wing to the east, approx. 10, 000 sq. ft. A preliminary cost estimate for each wing would be at $110 . 00 per sq. ft. or $1,100,000 .00 for each wing or $2,200, 000 .00 for both. The following services will be provided in this proposal: . < - THE OFFICE OF JOHN F . OUTCAULT ARCHITECT A . I . A . A CORPOR A TION 74-133 EL PASEO/ HMS PLAZA SUITE 11 PALM DESERT,CALIFORNIA 92260 TELEPHONE(619)346-0630 A. Working drawings for: ( 1 ) Architectural ( 2 ) Structural ( 3 ) Electrical ( 4 ) Mechanical ( 5 ) Plumbing ( 6 ) Fire Sprinkler ( 7 ) Landscape and Irrigation B. Written specifications for all the above. C. Calculations for Structural and Title 24 requirements . The proposal fee for the above is as follows: A. Working drawings and specifications: ( 1 ) Administration wing $38 , 000 . 00 ( 2 ) Public Works wing $38 , 000 . 00 B. Bidding of documents: ( 1 ) Administration wing $3, 800. 00 ( 2 ) Public Works wing $3, 800 .00 C. Construction Administration: ( 1 ) Administration wing $14, 000 . 00 ( 2 ) Public Works wing $14, 000 . 00 Not included in the above services are the following; A. Reproduction of documents for bidding. B. Soils Investigation Report. C. Materials Testings and Masonry Laboratory observations . D. Artist renderings . You may wish to consider authorization of working drawings and specifications portions only, leaving the bidding and construction administration for a later date. Of a construction budget of $2,200,000 .00, the fees quoted above are approximately 6% of the construction amount. I will await your reply. Sincerely, -ivy. Wttif - - Joh F. Outcault Arc itect, A.I .A. JFO/pam ATTAC71 NT 3 MUNICIPAL COST INDEXLJ The Iinidg i Calif ld tore than a point this Current figures were not available for this month's month, reflecting pia It lie-ether indexes. The Cow marktbasket, but increases were reported in the fuel oils 'Imam Cat Isis Alibi almost a point.as did the Con- family,according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. sumer Price Index. The Praiser him Iatha showed the • Tel strongest gain,jumping almost two points so dose at 114.9 - Compiled by Joe Morris 1 TH • MOST RECENT MARKETBASKET an WI PercentAt-A-Glance Changes Clangs From: Canal Most Recent • Inds: Month last Year MUNICIPAL COST INDEX I cc n Air Conditioners 1193 • 31 Last Year Previous Month This Month [IIAwed 113.7 .2 IA AmpimitBall leariags 125.3 I1 4.6 121.8 W Coal 96.6 - 5 2.4 117.2��-120.6� C.._aaintlou Devises 105.3 .1 2.1 Percent Change By: Month 1.0 Year 3.9 Concrete Products 111.7 .1 1.4 Construction Maebi.ary 111.2 .1 4.7 Diesel Fuel 53.6 5.7 35.9 1ibet,te Components 119.7 .7 1.1 CONSTRUCTION COST INDEX Baeteie Power 120.7 .1 5.0 Last Year Previous Month This Month Flaw Coverings 119.0 • -.1 Fuel 05 No.2 53.4 6.7 33.9 Foundry Products 115.1 -.2 3.0 121.6 122.2 Furniture 130.1 .3 3.4 118.8/ Gasoline 63.1 -2.4 9.2 Generator Sets 129.6 .5 5.1 Percent Change By: Month .49 Year 2.9 (lass 109.0 -.4 -2.1 Glass Containers 115.9 I 3.2 Gypsum Products 117.9 -1.7 -4.3 CONSUMER PRICE INDEX (BLS) Hardware 120.7 .2 5.3 Healing Equip.e.t 125.1 I 5.2 Last Year Previous Month This Month Industrial(henda s 113.4 -.2 -2.1 l.C.Engines 115.1 -.2 3.4 -127.4 l,os CA 0 121.1�126.1 LP Gas 50.1 14.4 27.9 Lauber 121.4 .5 2.3 Percent Change By: Month 1.0 Year 5.2 Metal Fabrications 120.0 .2 3.2 Mixed Fertilisers 114.1 -.6 -4.1 Motor Natural a Parts 179.5 • 1.4 PRODUCER PRICE INDEX (BLS) Nita Gas s 79.5 1.6 3.5 Office Madsines 109.9 .3 1.7 Last Year Previous Month This Month Paint 120.4 0 5.9 Piper 129.5 • .2 Passenger Can 5333 35 0 59.1 113.0-114.9 Plastics 127.7 -3.7 -12.4 110.3 Plumbing Fixtures 130.7 .1 5.7 Plywood 115.2 -1.7 10.3 Percent Change By: Month 1.7 Year 4.2 Partlead Cement 101.9 -.5 .1 Pups 115.7 0 4.4 Residual Fad 45.1 5.7 30.0 Rubber 107.6 1.2 -.7 These figures are alcalated our a base year of 1912. Sand,Gravel 123.1 -.1 2.1 Sanitary Papers 126.5 -.2 12.7 QUARTERLY MUNICIPAL TRENDS Soaps,Detergents 120.0 1.6 -3.0 Sporting Goods 110.5 .5 4.4 Current Percent Change From: Steel Mill Products 114.1 -.4 1.1 Level Last Qtr. Last Year • Switcigsar 119.3 .6 4.9 Syntbetic Fibers 106.2 -.4 7.0 Receipts 756.3 1.0 6.3 Tins,Tubes 97.3 • 2.0 Federal Gra is 1111.3 -.00 6.6 • Tools,Di. 114.4 -.1 2.5 Durable Purchases 33.1 3.1 3.3 Trams/omen 111.3 -.3 6.2 Couruables 52.7 1.9 2.1 Tn.:Winless 121.4 .2 3.9 Services 479.3 1.7 7.5 ; Tracks 116.9 -.3 1.4 Structures 71.0 -.1 4.9 ; Valves 121.2 .6 5.5 Salaries,Wages 373.9 1.6 7.0 t Wire,Cable 142.9 -2.1 -4.0 Surplus 44.9 -5.5 -9.0 Wiring Devices 130.1 -.4 3.6 Employment 14.074M .04 2.3 E 98 American City&County/April 1990 a:G =':C.A F.'.CKET SECT;GN '�- MEETING DATE 6 /4?/90 INTEROFFICE MEMORANDUM - CITY OF PALM DESERT '10: Honorable Mayor and City Council FRCP% Public Art Selection Subccnrnittee� DATE: June 28, 1990 SUBJECT': City Hall Expansion Plans On June 13, 1990, the Public Art Selection Subcarmittee reviewed the City Hall expansion plans containing a Public Art Gallery. The committee enthusiastically supports the idea for a gallery in the City Hall. This type of display could became the programs best public education tool and piLliute interest beyond the indoor display. • CS/db