Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2024-12-09 LAC Special Meeting LIBRARY ADVISORY COMMITTEE CITY OF PALM DESERT MEETING AGENDA Monday, December 9, 2024 1:00 p.m. Administrative Conference Room, City Hall 73-510 Fred Waring Drive Palm Desert, CA 92260 Pursuant to Assembly Bill 2449, this meeting will be conducted as a hybrid meeting and there will be in-person access to this location. To participate via Zoom, use the following link: https://palmdesert.zoom.us/j/88579677455 or call (213) 338-8477, Zoom Meeting ID: 885 7967 7455 • Written public comment may also be submitted to cityclerk@palmdesert.gov. E-mails received by 8:00 a.m. prior to the meeting will be distributed to the Committee. Any correspondence received during or after the meeting will be distributed to the Committee as soon as practicable and retained for the official record. Emails will not be read aloud except as an ADA accommodation. • Pages 1.CALL TO ORDER 2.ROLL CALL 3.NON-AGENDA PUBLIC COMMENTS This time has been set aside for the public to address the Library Advisory Committee on issues that are not on the agenda for up to three minutes. Speakers may utilize one of the three options listed on the first page of the agenda. Because the Brown Act does not allow the Library Advisory Committee to act on items not listed on the agenda, members may briefly respond or refer the matter to staff for a report and recommendation at a future meeting. 4.CONSENT CALENDAR All matters listed on the Consent Calendar are considered routine and may be approved by one motion. The public may comment on any items on the Consent Agenda within the three-minute time limit. Individual items may be removed by the Library Advisory Committee for a separate discussion. RECOMMENDATION: To approve the consent calendar as presented. 4.a APPROVAL OF MINUTES 5 RECOMMENDATION: Approve the Minutes of November 7, 2024. 5.ACTION CALENDAR The public may comment on individual Action Items within the three-minute time limit. Speakers may utilize one of the three options listed on the first page of the agenda. 5.a RECOMMEND CONCEPTUAL DESIGN OF THE NEW LIBRARY FACILITY BE PRESENTED TO CITY COUNCIL 9 RECOMMENDATION: Recommend Conceptual Design of the new Library facility be presented to City Council. 5.b PROVIDE FEEDBACK ON LIBRARY UPDATES RELATED TO LIBRARY CARDS, GRAND OPENING, LIBRARY PROGRAMS AND PARTNERSHIPS, AND ENGAGEMENT AT THE LIBRARY AND IN THE COMMUNITY. 43 RECOMMENDATION: Provide feedback on library updates related to statistics, the grand opening, library partnerships and programs, and engagement at the library. 6.INFORMATIONAL REPORTS & COMMENTS 6.a LIBRARY ADVISORY COMMITTEE MEMBERS 6.b CITY COUNCIL LIAISON 6.c CITY STAFF 6.d ATTENDANCE REPORT 57 7.ADJOURNMENT The next Regular Meeting will be held on January 27, 2025 at 1 p.m. Library Advisory Committee Meeting December 9, 2024 2 8.PUBLIC NOTICES Agenda Related Materials: Pursuant to Government Code §54957.5(b)(2) the designated office for inspection of records in connection with this meeting is the Office of the City Clerk, Palm Desert Civic Center, 73-510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert. Staff reports for all agenda items considered in open session, and documents provided to a majority of the legislative bodies are available for public inspection at City Hall and on the City’s website at www.palmdesert.gov. Americans with Disabilities Act: It is the intention of the City of Palm Desert to comply with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) in all respects. If, as an attendee or a participant at this meeting, or in meetings on a regular basis, you will need special assistance beyond what is normally provided, the City will attempt to accommodate you in every reasonable manner. Please contact the Office of the City Clerk, (760) 346-0611, at least 48 hours prior to the meeting to inform us of your needs and to determine if accommodation is feasible. AFFIDAVIT OF POSTING I hereby certify under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing agenda for the Library Advisory Committee was posted on the City Hall bulletin board and City website not less than 72 hours prior to the meeting. /S/ Erika Castellano Recording Secretary Library Advisory Committee Meeting December 9, 2024 3 4 1 LIBRARY ADVISORY COMMITTEE CITY OF PALM DESERT REGULAR MEETING MINUTES November 7, 2024, 1:00 p.m. Present: Member Jann Buller, Member Matthew Johnson, Member Risa Lumley, Member Cathy Malone, Member Robin Stewart Others Present: Liaison(s) Present: Alternate Member Ralph Perry, Recording Secretary Erika Castellano, Director of Library Services Gary Shaffer, Assistant City Manager Chris Escobedo, Assistant Director Library Services Shannon Vonnegut, Library Manager Jose Garcia, Library Manager Lauren Hancock Councilmember Evan Trubee 1. CALL TO ORDER A Special Meeting of the Library Advisory Committee was called to order by Chair Stewart on November 7, 2024, at 1:00 p.m. in the Administrative Conference Room, City Hall, located at 73-510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert, California. 2. ROLL CALL 3. NON--AGENDA PUBLIC COMMENTS 4. PRESENTATIONS 4.a NEW LIBRARY CONCEPTUAL DESIGN PRESENTATION Richärd Kennedy Architects narrated a PowerPoint presentation on the Palm Desert Library conceptual design options and responded to Committee member inquiries. During the course of discussion, the committee expressed support for the high end option and concerns regarding the Visitors Center, exterior and interior materials, and the size of meetings rooms. No formal action was taken at this time. 5. CONSENT CALENDAR Motion by: Member Johnson Seconded by: Member Buller To approve the consent calendar as presented. Motion Carried (5 to 0) 5 Library Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes November 7, 2024 2 5.a APPROVAL OF MINUTES Motion by: Member Johnson Seconded by: Member Buller Approve the Minutes of September 23, 2024. Motion Carried (5 to 0) 6. CONSENT ITEMS HELD OVER 7. ACTION CALENDAR 7.a LIBRARY UPDATES AND STATISTICS Library Services Director Shaffer, Library Manager Garcia, and Library Manager Hancock narrated a PowerPoint presentation and responded to Committee member inquiries. Motion by: Member Lumley Seconded by: Member Malone Receive and file library updates related to statistics, the grand opening, library partnerships and programs, and engagement at the library. Motion Carried (5 to 0) 8. INFORMATIONAL REPORTS & COMMENTS 8.a LIBRARY ADVISORY COMMITTEE MEMBERS None. 8.b CITY COUNCIL LIAISON Councilmember Trubee provided thank you cards to Committee Members on behalf of the City Council. 8.c CITY STAFF Recording Secretary Castellano provided information on a live, interactive AB1234 Ethics Training session, facilitated by attorneys from Best Best and Krieger on January 30, 2025, in the Palm Desert Council Chamber or virtually via Zoom. Library Services Director Shaffer provided information on the Library's Grand Opening on November 20, 2024. 8.d ATTENDANCE REPORT Report provided; no action taken on this item. 9. ADJOURNMENT The Library Advisory Committee adjourned at 2:11 p.m. 6 Library Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes November 7, 2024 3 Respectfully submitted, _________________________ Erika Castellano, Sr. Administrative Assistant Recording Secretary _________________________ Gary Shaffer, Director of Library Services Secretary _________________________ DATE APPROVED BY LIBRARY ADVISORY COMMITTEE 7 8 Page 1 of 1 CITY OF PALM DESERT LIBRARY ADVISORY COMMITTEE STAFF REPORT MEETING DATE: December 9, 2024 PREPARED BY: Ryan Lamb, Senior Project Manager SUBJECT: RECOMMEND CONCEPTUAL DESIGN OF THE NEW LIBRARY FACILITY BE PRESENTED TO CITY COUNCIL RECOMMENDATION: Present Conceptual Design of New Library Facility to City Council. BACKGROUND/ANALYSIS: On June 8, 2023, the City Council voted to form a Library Task Force and on October 12, 2023, the City Council voted to withdraw from the Riverside County Library System and self -operate its library beginning July 1, 2024. Library services for residents are currently administered from a 1990s leased facility located on the neighboring College of the Desert campus. The City will continue to operate from this location until a new facility is designed, constructed, and outfitted on city-owned land. March 28, 2024, the City approved a contract for architectural services with Richärd Kennedy Architects (RKA) for Conceptual Design of the New Library Facility. RKA developed two (2) conceptual designs for the project. A “Low Option” for the then-approved $20M project budget, and a “High Option” in anticipation of Measure G passing and increasing the project budget to $30M. Both options were presented to the Library Advisory Committee on November 7, 2024. Primary focus of the discussion was on the High Option as th e Measure G vote was tracking at over 65% in favor of the ballot measure. Comments received from the committee would be addressed and the revised High Option design would be presented at the next committee meeting on December 9, 2024. ATTACHMENTS: 1. New Library Conceptual Design Presentation 9 10 MUNICIPAL LIBRARYCITY OF PALM DESERT December 9th, 2024 Conceptual Design Update – Library Advisory Committee 11 CONCEPTUAL DESIGN SUBMITTAL •ADA Parking Quantity and Locations •Meeting Room Quantity and Types •Multi-Purpose Room Furniture Configurations UPDATES 12 18 1 19 5 3 2 8 16 4 7 6 12 17 9 3 CONCEPTUAL DESIGN SUBMITTAL 1.Outdoor cafe 2.Firepit area 3.Outdoor maker space 4.Private outdoor event space 5.Misting seep 6.Book drop 7.Lockers 8.Drop-off 9.Public parking area 10.Existing Trash Enclosure 11.Solar Canopy 12.Gated parking area 13.Utility Yard 14.Trash Enclosure 15.Pump House 16.Loading dock 17.Staff patio 18.Children’s courtyard 19.Adult courtyard 6 11 1314 10 15PREVIOUS LANDSCAPE PLAN Existing Accessible Parking Stall 2 Proposed Accessible Parking Stall 4 Total Accessible Parking Stalls 6 (3 required) 13 18 1 19 5 3 2 8 16 4 7 6 12 17 9 4 CONCEPTUAL DESIGN SUBMITTAL 1.Outdoor cafe 2.Firepit area 3.Outdoor maker space 4.Private outdoor event space 5.Misting seep 6.Book drop 7.Lockers 8.Drop-off 9.Public parking area 10.Existing Trash Enclosure 11.Solar Canopy 12.Gated parking area 13.Utility Yard 14.Trash Enclosure 15.Pump House 16.Loading dock 17.Staff patio 18.Children’s courtyard 19.Adult courtyard 6 11 1314 10 15REVISED LANDSCAPE PLAN Existing Accessible Parking Stall 2 Proposed Accessible Parking Stall 5 Total Accessible Parking Stalls 7 (3 required) 14 EXISTING MEETING SPACES*5 CONCEPTUAL DESIGN SUBMITTAL 0’80’40’20’ Room: Area: 338 Sq Ft QTY: 3 Room: Area: 487 Sq Ft QTY: 1 Multi-Purpose Room: Area: 1558 Sq Ft QTY: 1 487 sf 1,558 sf 338 sf *City of Palm Desert Library to verify existing uses 338 sf 338 sf 15 PROPOSED MEETING SPACES 6 CONCEPTUAL DESIGN SUBMITTAL 0’80’40’20’ Focus Rooms: 1-2 people Area: 50 Sq Ft each QTY: 3 Small Meeting Rooms: 4-6 people Area: 162 Sq Ft each QTY: 2 Large Meeting Rooms: 8-10 people Area: 277 Sq Ft QTY: 1 Community Bldg Executive Meeting Room: 8-10 people Area: 247 Sq Ft QTY: 1 Storytime Room: 12-16 people Area: 460 Sq Ft QTY: 1 The Lab Workspace: 20-40 people Area: 715 Sq Ft QTY: 1 Community Bldg Multi-Purpose: 50-150 people Area: 1560 Sq Ft QTY: 1 460 sf 715 sf 162 sf 162 sf 277 sf 50 sf (x3) 1560 sf 247 sf 16 7 CONCEPTUAL DESIGN SUBMITTAL MULTI-PURPOSE ROOM •General Table Layout •South Orientation •Arrangement: •36 Seats •18 Tables 17 8 CONCEPTUAL DESIGN SUBMITTAL MULTI-PURPOSE ROOM •General Seating Layout •South Orientation •Arrangement: •138 Seats 18 9 CONCEPTUAL DESIGN SUBMITTAL MULTI-PURPOSE ROOM •Banquet Seating with 20’ x 8’ stage •East Orientation •Arrangement: •112 Seats •14 Tables 19 10 CONCEPTUAL DESIGN SUBMITTAL MULTI-PURPOSE ROOM •Banquet Seating with 20’ x 8’ stage •Expansion into Café / Friends of the Library Bookstore •East Orientation •Arrangement: •176 Seats •22 Tables 20 11 CONCEPTUAL DESIGN SUBMITTAL MULTI-PURPOSE ROOM •Banquet Seating with 20’ x 8’ stage •Expansion into outside breezeway •East Orientation •Arrangement: •168 Seats •21 Tables 21 CONCEPTUAL DESIGN 22 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY In conjunction with the City of Palm Desert, the design team led by Richärd Kennedy Architects has engaged in a series of visioning and focus group meetings to develop the conceptual design for the new Palm Desert Municipal Library. This report documents the process and relevant findings to date and lays out a proposed overall concept with pricing options for how the new Library can be realized in the future. The vision for the Palm Desert Municipal Library is to create a dynamic and inclusive space that provides equal access to resources and technologies for all residents. This project aims to foster community participation and collaboration, advance educational outcomes, and maximize the return on the community’s shared investment by creating safe, welcoming, and innovative spaces. 13 CONCEPTUAL DESIGN SUBMITTAL SITE 23 A conceptual plan was developed that represents a cohesive vision to address the objectives, space requirements, and functional needs for the new Palm Desert Municipal Library. CONCEPTUAL DESIGN SUBMITTAL 14DESIGN PLAN 14 24 ZONING FLOOR PLAN 15 ADULT CHILDREN’S STAFF YOUNG ADULT MULTIPURPOSE SORT COMMONS CAFÉ + VISITORS MEET SHADE CANOPY INNOVATE 0’80’40’20’ The low volume ‘boulder’ to the right of the entry provides a large meeting room and several zoom rooms. Additional meeting rooms are located along the east wall with the young adult collection and teen zone adjacent towards the interior, abutting the staff and service functions of the library. The larger ‘boulder’ volume to the left of the entry contains the lab space and innovation studio. The adult collection area fills the two bars at the northwest corner with the quieter more reflective reading spaces facing views into the park. To the northeast, the children’s area features a low volume ‘boulder’ containing the story time program room adjacent to an exterior play area. A much larger ‘boulder’ volume to the southwest holds all the community functions such as the multipurpose room, demonstration kitchen, café, Friends of the Library bookstore, and the Palm Desert visitor center. CONCEPTUAL DESIGN SUBMITTAL Total Floor Area = 25,892 gsf 25 16 CONCEPTUAL DESIGN SUBMITTAL NATIVE PALM GROVE CONCEPT The building concept is defined by (3) main architectural elements inspired by regional palm groves – the ‘palm tree canopy’ shade screen providing shade for all outdoor program areas, the lower volume ‘boulder’ forms highlighting key program areas, and the ‘riverbed’ surface materials and planting approach that defines major pathways through the site and building. 26 17 Inspiration Literal Abstraction PATTERN: Like the natural canopies of the palm groves, the dense interconnected fronds block much of the sunlight creating a cooler, shaded environment below. CONCEPTUAL DESIGN SUBMITTAL SHADE 27 18 1 19 5 3 2 8 16 4 7 6 12 17 9 18 CONCEPTUAL DESIGN SUBMITTAL 1.Outdoor cafe 2.Firepit area 3.Outdoor maker space 4.Private outdoor event space 5.Misting seep 6.Book drop 7.Lockers 8.Drop-off 9.Public parking area 10.Existing Trash Enclosure 11.Solar Canopy 12.Gated parking area 13.Utility Yard 14.Trash Enclosure 15.Pump House 16.Loading dock 17.Staff patio 18.Children’s courtyard 19.Adult courtyard 6 11 1314 10 15REVISED LANDSCAPE PLAN 28 Approach from adjacent parking at office building to the south SOUTH ELEVATION CONCEPTUAL DESIGN SUBMITTAL 19 29 20 The exterior building palette is defined by three elements: plaster, stone, and glass. The main volume of the library is comprised of white plaster and acts as a backdrop to the ‘boulder’ forms of the lower volumes which are wrapped in stone veneer. Glass walls are also located where key views to the park and mountains are provided. EXTERIOR PALETTE CONCEPTUAL DESIGN SUBMITTAL Veneer Stone Glass Walls Plaster 30 Approach from primary drive north SOUTHWEST APPROACH 21 CONCEPTUAL DESIGN SUBMITTAL 31 22 Approach from drop-off towards west entry into site DROP OFF CONCEPTUAL DESIGN SUBMITTAL 32 Main entry (center), multipurpose space (right) BREEZEWAY CONCEPTUAL DESIGN SUBMITTAL 23 33 FLOATING WATER FEATURE EMBEDDED IN LANDSCAPE 24LANDSCAPE CONCEPTS CONCEPTUAL DESIGN SUBMITTAL ROCKING CHAIRS HIGH TOP SEATING WITH PARK VIEW READING LOUNGE MISTING SEEP MOVEABLE FURNITURE ORGANIZED PLAY INTERACTIVE PLAY 34 25 Approach at service desk into library stacks with views to the park INTERIOR CONCEPTUAL DESIGN SUBMITTAL 35 26 The material palette for the interior is inspired by Palm Desert through its desert experiences, the palms that populate the area, and the rare yet stunning desert blooms. INTERIOR PALETTE CONCEPTUAL DESIGN SUBMITTAL 36 27 Day view from park toward northwest corner PARK VIEW CONCEPTUAL DESIGN SUBMITTAL 37 28 Dusk view from park toward northwest corner PARK VIEW CONCEPTUAL DESIGN SUBMITTAL 38 APPENDIX 39 C O N C E P T U A L D E S I G N S U B M I T T A L AreaProgram 400Entry 1,552Library Services 2,061Multi-Purpose Room 733Meeting / Co-Working 931The Lab (converted space to MPR) 441Café 4,713Adult 862Young Adult 2,649Children 496Friends of the Library 1,837Workplace 1,865Building Service 775Visitor Center 19,315Total NSF 6,577Circulation (Gross Factor) 25,892Total GSF 1,400Outdoor 18,940Outdoor Support 19 MPR Meeting TheLab Café Adult YAChildren Workplace Building Service Visitor Center Circulation Library Services 19PROGRAM The program was developed through a series of interactive sessions with library administration, staff, and facilities. The result is a balanced program that supports the Palm Desert community and is flexible toadapttothefutureneeds. 40 1. Circulation Desk / Self-Checkout 2. Public PCs / Copy Print 3. Lab and Innovation Studio 4. Adult Collections 5. Reading Deck 6. Lounge Seating 7. Children’s Entry / Service Desk 8. Children’s Collections 9. Storytime 10. Children’s Outdoor Program 11. Restroom and Lactation Room 12. Teen’s Lounge 13. Young Adult Collection 14. Meeting Room 15. Holds and Book Drop 16. Restrooms 17. Automated Sorting Room 18. Exterior Book Drop 19. Staff Work Area and Enclosed Offices 20. Staff Hub and Kitchen 21. Staff Patio 22. Café Seating / Bookstore Display 23. Visitor Center 24. Executive Meeting Room (Green Room) 25. Demonstration Kitchen 26. Multipurpose Room 27. Checkout Lockers 28. 24/7 Holds (After Hours) FLOOR PLAN 13 4 5 5 4 6 7 8 8 9 111213 14 13 15 16 18 18 17 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 10 20 C O N C E P T U A L D E S I G N S U B M I T T A L SHADE CANOPY 0’ 80’40’20’ 2 41 42 Page 1 of 1 CITY OF PALM DESERT LIBRARY ADVISORY COMMITTEE STAFF REPORT MEETING DATE: December 9, 2024 PREPARED BY: Angelique Hodges, Management Aide I SUBJECT: PROVIDE FEEDBACK ON LIBRARY UPDATES RELATED TO LIBRARY CARDS, GRAND OPENING, LIBRARY PROGRAMS AND PARTNERSHIPS, AND ENGAGEMENT AT THE LIBRARY AND IN THE COMMUNITY. RECOMMENDATION: Provide feedback on library updates related to statistics, the grand opening, library partnerships and programs, and engagement at the library. BACKGROUND/ANALYSIS: Library Staff will be offering updates on the following:  Library statistics  Library grand opening  Library programs and partnerships  Engagement at the Library ATTACHMENTS: 1. Staff Report PowerPoint 43 44 LIBRARY ADVISORY COMMITTEE Gary Shaffer Library Services December 9, 2024 45 TODAY'S DISCUSSION •Library Statistics •Library Grand Opening •Library Partnerships and Programs •New Library Conceptual Design 246 3 LIBRARY STATISTICSJULY – NOVEMBER 2024 Metric November Fiscal YTD Notes Library cards issued 1,173 6,677 Number of active customers to date Checkouts Link+ 15,357 114 66,795 114 Physical and Digital checkouts (went live 10/31/24) Visits 9,738 38,477 Number of library visitors Study Room & Community Room bookings 134 804 Study Room and Community Room usage Lap-top Checkouts 501 2,853 Number of laptop sessions Online Help/Website visits 13,746 36,760 Visitors to the library's website to access info & resources 47 LIBRARY PROGRAMS JULY - NOVEMBER 2024 4 Type of Programs Number of Programs Attendees Examples Early Learners and Family Programming 52 571 Storytimes and Little Learners Lounge School Age Children 60 977 Afterschool Discovery and LEGO afternoons Young Adult 33 583 Class Visits and Teenscape Adult 48 1,730 Film Series, Learning In Retirement, Craft, Book Clubs, Grand Opening, and Mahjong Virtual 16 758 Virtual Author Talks YTD 209 4,619 *Does not include group meetings 48 5 OUTREACH & VOLUNTEERSJULY – NOVEMBER 2024 Type of Programs By the Numbers November By the Numbers FY to date Notes Outreach Events 6 13 Total attendance: 404 In-library Booksales # / $ $2,092 $8,904 Volunteer Hours 167.5 655.5 Volunteers 8 9 Bookstore volunteers 49 6 RIVERSIDE COUNTY P.D. LIBRARYVS. MUNICIPAL OCTOBER 2024 Statistics RCLS-PD March 2023 Palm Desert Oct. '24 Municipal Library Notes Library Visits 7,870 9,989 a.k.a. door-count Meeting Room Use ?28 Groups Meeting Room Attendance 506 1,016 Children’s Programs ?, 280 91, 1,366 a.k.a. pre-school & school-aged Teen Programs ?, 120 19, 365 a.k.a. young adult Adult Programs ?, 495 14, 242 Volunteer Hours 431 167.5 Volunteers 29 8 Circulation ?14,184 a.k.a. checkouts 50 7 CUSTOMER FEEDBACK •Net Promoter Score: 85.7/100 •Positive Feedback: 55.5 •Examples: “I walk in and there is someone to greet me, find the book I want right away and help me with a new card. I was very impressed.” “The Libby (eBook) app is great! The directions for installing were helpful and in its use.”“You mean I can take the laptop anywhere in the library and work on it?” •Negative Feedback: 4.5 •Examples: “Absolutely hate the new computer system for patron’s use.” “You should turn the empty unused portion of the library into a gaming and board game spot.” “The evening lighting is a bit soft for my aging eyes.” “The library is too cold.” October 2024 51 GRAND OPENING - IMAGES 8 52 PARTNERSHIPS & COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT •Partner Spotlight: Shops at Palm Desert •Profile: Retail •The space allows exposure to a substantial cross-section of the community: families, youth, adults and older adults. •Offers space for library programming & outreach before, after and during the operational transition. •Reciprocal cross-promotion agreement in place. •On average, 20 cards are issued at each event, and on average 50-75 face-to-face impressions. 9 53 Palm Desert Reads One Book, One Community is designed to encourage literacy and community involvement by reading a single book that brings our community together. If you have a recommendation, please share it with us using this form. Link to the form: https://forms.office.com/g/wQ8kVWPCg2 54 THANK YOU Gary Shaffer gshaffer@palmdesert.gov 760.776.6460 55 56 CITY OF PALM DESERT ATTENDANCE REPORT Advisory Body: Prepared By: Year 2024 2024 2024 2024 2024 2024 2025 Month July Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec Jan Date 22-Jul 26-Aug 23-Sep 28-Oct 7-Nov 9-Dec 27-Jan Buller, Jann E P P - P 1 0 Johnson, Matt P A P - P 1 1 Lumley, Risa P P P - P 0 0 Malone, Cathy E E P - P 2 0 Murphy, Paul P-Voting P P - E 0 0 Perry, Ralph P P-Voting P - P 0 0 Stewart, Robin P P P - P 0 0 Palm Desert Municipal Code 2.34.010: P Present A Absent E Excused - No meeting Erika Castellano Library Advisory Committee Monthly- Three unexcused absences from regular meetings in any twelve-month period on appointed bodies that meet monthly. Total Absences Total Unexcused Absences 57