The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About2025-01-21 PSC Special Meeting Agenda Packet PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE CITY OF PALM DESERT MEETING AGENDA Tuesday, January 21, 2025 3:30 p.m. Administrative Conference Room, City Hall 73-510 Fred Waring Drive Palm Desert, CA 92260 Pursuant to Assembly Bill 2449, this meeting will be conducted as a hybrid meeting and there will be in-person access to this location. To participate via Zoom, use the following link: https://palmdesert.zoom.us/j/83733443742 or call (213) 338-8477, Zoom Meeting ID: 837 3344 3742 • Written public comment may also be submitted to cityclerk@palmdesert.gov. E-mails received by 8:00 a.m. prior to the meeting will be distributed to the Committee. Any correspondence received during or after the meeting will be distributed to the Committee as soon as practicable and retained for the official record. Emails will not be read aloud except as an ADA accommodation. • Pages 1.CALL TO ORDER 2.ROLL CALL 3.NONAGENDA PUBLIC COMMENTS This time has been set aside for the public to address the Public Safety Committee on issues that are not on the agenda for up to three minutes. Speakers may utilize one of the three options listed on the first page of the agenda. Because the Brown Act does not allow the Public Safety Committee to act on items not listed on the agenda, members may briefly respond or refer the matter to staff for a report and recommendation at a future meeting. 4.PRESENTATIONS 4.a HAYSTACK ROAD TRAFFIC CALMING PROJECT 5 RECOMMENDATION: This is a presentation, there is no action required with this item. 5.CONSENT CALENDAR All matters listed on the Consent Calendar are considered routine and may be approved by one motion. The public may comment on any items on the Consent Agenda within the three-minute time limit. Individual items may be removed by the Public Safety Committee for a separate discussion. RECOMMENDATION: To approve the consent calendar as presented. 5.a APPROVAL OF MINUTES 13 RECOMMENDATION: Approve the Minutes of December 10, 2024. 5.b PALM DESERT SPECIALIZED UNITS REPORT 19 RECOMMENDATION: Approve the report for the month of December 2024. 5.c RIVERSIDE COUNTY FIRE DEPARTMENT/CAL FIRE MONTHLY REPORT 25 RECOMMENDATION: Approve the report for the month of December 2024. 5.d CODE COMPLIANCE REPORT 33 RECOMMENDATION: Approve the report for the month of December 2024. 5.e EMERGENCY SERVICES COORDINATOR MONTHLY REPORT 39 RECOMMENDATION: Approve the report for the month of December 2024. 5.f COP MONTHLY REPORT 43 RECOMMENDATION: Approve the report for the month of December 2024. 5.g AUTOMATED LICENSE PLATE READER SHARED NETWORK INFORMATION REPORT 51 RECOMMENDATION: Approve the report for the month of December 2024. 6.CONSENT ITEMS HELD OVER 7.ACTION CALENDAR The public may comment on individual Action Items within the three-minute time limit. Speakers may utilize one of the three options listed on the first page of the agenda. 7.a UPDATE ON COOLING AND WARM CENTERS, SHELTERS, AND COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION ON PURCHASING AND INSTALLING AN EMERGENCY GENERATOR FOR THE PALM DESERT COMMUNITY CENTER BUILDING 67 RECOMMENDATION: Provide feedback on the City's Cooling and Warming Centers. Public Safety Committee Meeting January 21, 2025 2 7.b DEVELOPMENT OF 2025 WORKPLAN 77 RECOMMENDATION: Provide feedback on the Public Safety Committee 2025 Workplan. 8.INFORMATIONAL REPORTS & COMMENTS 8.a PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE MEMBERS 8.b CITY COUNCIL LIAISON 8.c POLICE/FIRE 8.c.1 POLICE 8.c.2 FIRE 8.d CITY STAFF 8.d.1 FLOCK SAFETY CAMERA SUBCOMMITTEE UPDATE 8.e ATTENDANCE REPORT 79 9.ADJOURNMENT The next Regular Meeting will be held on February 11, 2025, at 3:30 p.m. 10.PUBLIC NOTICES Agenda Related Materials: Pursuant to Government Code §54957.5(b)(2) the designated office for inspection of records in connection with this meeting is the Office of the City Clerk, Palm Desert Civic Center, 73-510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert. Staff reports for all agenda items considered in open session, and documents provided to a majority of the legislative bodies are available for public inspection at City Hall and on the City’s website at www.palmdesert.gov. Americans with Disabilities Act: It is the intention of the City of Palm Desert to comply with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) in all respects. If, as an attendee or a participant at this meeting, or in meetings on a regular basis, you will need special assistance beyond what is normally provided, the City will attempt to accommodate you in every reasonable manner. Please contact the Office of the City Clerk, (760) 346-0611, at least 48 hours prior to the meeting to inform us of your needs and to determine if accommodation is feasible. AFFIDAVIT OF POSTING I hereby certify under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing agenda for the Public Safety Committee was posted on the City Hall bulletin board and City website not less than 72 hours prior to the meeting. /S/ Erika Castellano Recording Secretary Public Safety Committee Meeting January 21, 2025 3 4 Page 1 of 1 PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE CITY OF PALM DESERT STAFF REPORT MEETING DATE: January 21, 2025 PREPARED BY: Neal Ennis, Project Manager SUBJECT: PRESENTATION – HAYSTACK ROAD TRAFFIC CALMING PROJECT RECOMMENDATION: This is a presentation, there is no action required with this item. BACKGROUND/ANALYSIS: The Public Safety Committee requested an update on the Haystack Road Traffic Calming Project. FINANCIAL IMPACT: There is no financial impact associated with this item. ATTACHMENTS: 1. Presentation – Update on Haystack Road Traffic Calming Project 5 6 City of Palm Desert Public Safety Committee Haystack Road Traffic Calming Project January 21, 2025 7 Haystack Road •Traffic Calming Measures •Narrow Vehicle Drive Lane Widths •Add Cross Walks •Add Buffered Bike Lanes •Infrastructure Improvements •Crack Seal Asphalt •Seal Coat Asphalt •ADA Ramps 8 9 Civil Construction 10 SEAL COATING •390,000 Square feet of sealcoating completed; equivalent to surface area of 7 NFL Football Fields. 11 Questions 12 PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE CITY OF PALM DESERT REGULAR MEETING MINUTES December 10, 2024, 3:30 p.m. Present: Committee Member Joseph Butts, Vice Chair Terry Kramer, Committee Member Douglas Luhring, Committee Member Stephen Nelson, Committee Member Frank Taylor, Chair Kevin Wahlstrom, Committee Member Jeff Alley Staff Present: Assistant City Manager Chris Escobedo, Public Safety Analyst Daniel Hurtado, Code Compliance Supervisor Pedro Rodriguez, Recording Secretary Erika Castellano 1. CALL TO ORDER A Regular Meeting of the Public Safety Committee was called to order by Chair Wahlstrom on December 10, 2024, at 3:32 p.m. in the Administrative Conference Room, City Hall, located at 73-510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert, California. 2. ROLL CALL 3. NON-AGENDA PUBLIC COMMENTS 4. PRESENTATIONS 4.a UPDATE ON FIRE STATIONS 102, 33, and 71 Senior Project Manager Leyva narrated a PowerPoint presentation on the construction updates to fire stations 102, 33, and 71 and responded to Committee member inquiries. 5. CONSENT CALENDAR Motion by: Committee Member Alley Seconded by: Chair Wahlstrom To approve the consent calendar excluding item 5e, which was held over for separate discussion. Motion Carried (7 to 0) 13 Public Safety Committee Meeting Minutes December 10, 2024 2 5.a APPROVAL OF MINUTES Motion by: Committee Member Alley Seconded by: Chair Wahlstrom Approve the Minutes of November 12, 2024. Motion Carried (7 to 0) 5.b PALM DESERT SPECIALIZED UNITS REPORT Motion by: Committee Member Alley Seconded by: Chair Wahlstrom Approve the report for the month of November 2024. Motion Carried 5.c RIVERSIDE COUNTY FIRE DEPARTMENT/CAL FIRE MONTHLY REPORT Motion by: Committee Member Alley Seconded by: Chair Wahlstrom Approve the report for the month of November 2024. Motion Carried 5.d CODE COMPLIANCE REPORT Motion by: Committee Member Alley Seconded by: Chair Wahlstrom Approve the report for the month of November 2024. Motion Carried 5.f COP MONTHLY REPORT Motion by: Committee Member Alley Seconded by: Chair Wahlstrom Approve the report for the month of October 2024. Motion Carried 14 Public Safety Committee Meeting Minutes December 10, 2024 3 5.g AUTOMATED LICENSE PLATE READER SHARED NETWORK REPORT Motion by: Committee Member Alley Seconded by: Chair Wahlstrom Approve the report for the month of November 2024. Motion Carried 6. CONSENT ITEMS HELD OVER 5.e EMERGENCY SERVICES COORDINATOR MONTHLY REPORT Public Safety Analyst Hurtado provided information on the Emergency Services training session held at the Indian Wells Tennis Gardens. Motion by: Committee Member Luhring Seconded by: Committee Member Butts Approve the report for the month of November 2024. Motion Carried 7. ACTION CALENDAR 7.a MEASURE G FIVE YEAR SPENDING PLAN IMPLEMENTATION Assistant City Manager Escobedo narrated a PowerPoint presentation on the Measure G five-year spending plan for public safety and responded to Committee member inquiries. Motion by: Chair Wahlstrom Seconded by: Committee Member Alley Provide feedback on the presentation on the implementation of Measure G, including the approved Five-Year Spending Plan. Motion Carried (7 to 0) 8. INFORMATIONAL REPORTS & COMMENTS 8.a PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE MEMBERS Committee member Alley requested an update on the use of iPads for digital agenda packets. Recording Secretary Castellano informed the committee they would be available in January 2025. 8.b CITY COUNCIL LIAISON Councilmember Trubee provided thank you notes to Committee members on behalf of the City Council and expressed his gratitude for their service. 15 Public Safety Committee Meeting Minutes December 10, 2024 4 8.c POLICE/FIRE 8.c.1 POLICE Lieutenant Porras of Riverside County Sheriff's Department provided an update on recent significant activity and responded to member inquiries. 8.c.2 FIRE Chief Beverlin of CalFire/Riverside County Fire Department provided an update on the current fire station renovations and responded to member inquiries. 8.d CITY STAFF Recording Secretary Castellano notified the committee of an error on the current agenda which stated the next meeting would take place on January 14, 2024. The minutes will reflect the correct date of January 14, 2025. Public Safety Analyst Hurtado provided information on the Heroes & Helpers event taking place on Saturday, December 14, 2024, at Target in Palm Desert. 8.d.1 ENHANCED FIREWORK NOTIFICATION VERBAL UPDATE Public Safety Analyst Hurtado notified the committee that staff is working internally to update the firework notification plan which would allow for an additional day to notify the public of firework displays. 8.e ATTENDANCE REPORT Report provided; no action taken on this item. 16 Public Safety Committee Meeting Minutes December 10, 2024 5 9. ADJOURNMENT The Public Safety Committee adjourned at 4:19 p.m. Respectfully submitted, _________________________ Erika Castellano, Sr. Administrative Assistant Recording Secretary _________________________ Chris Escobedo, Assistant City Manager Secretary _________________________ APPROVED BY THE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE 17 18 Page 1 of 1 PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE CITY OF PALM DESERT STAFF REPORT MEETING DATE: January 21, 2025 PREPARED BY: Lt. Dan Porras, Riverside County Sheriff’s Department Erika Castellano, Senior Administrative Assistant SUBJECT: PALM DESERT SPECIALIZED UNITS DECEMBER 2024 REPORTS RECOMMENDATION: Approve the report for the month of December 2024. BACKGROUND/ANALYSIS: Palm Desert Specialized Report for December 2024. FINANCIAL IMPACT: There is no financial impact with this report. ATTACHMENTS: 1. Palm Desert Specialized Unit Report December 2024. 19 20 This report was prepared by the Riverside County Sheriff’s Department for the City of Palm Desert DEPARTMENTAL REPORT ITEM NO. Year: 2024 REPORT: December *This report reflects the most current UCR data. Calls for Service Priority 1 ‐ Involve circumstances that pose a clearly defined threat to human life or property. Priority 2 ‐ Involve circumstances of an urgent but not life‐threatening nature (e.g., minor assaults and batteries) Priority 3 ‐ Involve circumstances which are neither urgent nor life threatening (e.g., disturbances of the peace) 21 This report was prepared by the Riverside County Sheriff’s Department for the City of Palm Desert Priority 4 ‐ Incident occurring in the past or "cold" calls. Part 1 Crime Data Part 1 Crimes: (as defined by the Federal Bureau of Investigation) Criminal homicide, forceable rape, robbery, aggravated assault, burglary, grand theft, grand auto theft, arson. 22 This report was prepared by the Riverside County Sheriff’s Department for the City of Palm Desert Select Part 2 Crime Data Part 2 Crimes: (as defined by the Federal Bureau of Investigation) Forgery, fraud and insufficient funds checks, sex offences felonies, sex offences misdemeanors, non‐aggravated assaults, weapons laws, offence against family, narcotics, liquor laws, drunk/alcohol/drugs, disorderly conduct, vagrancy, gambling, driving under the influence (alcohol and/or drugs), vehicle laws, vandalism, warrants, receiving stolen property, federal offences with or without money, miscellaneous felonies, and miscellaneous misdemeanors. 23 This report was prepared by the Riverside County Sheriff’s Department for the City of Palm Desert Traffic Data Collisions by Type Citations Traffic Safety Traffic Safety Definitions and Formulas: Traffic Enforcement Index ‐ A statistic that reflects the effectiveness of a traffic enforcement program in reducing accidents and is expressed as Hazardous Citations + DUI Arrests / Fatal & Injury Collisions. Traffic Collision Index ‐ A statistic that measures non‐injury collisions over fatal and injury collisions, expressed as Non‐Injury Collisions / Fatal & Injury Collisions. ALPR Assisted Investigations ‐As of 11/30/24 Total arrests = 118. Total amount recovered = $753,350 24 Page 1 of 1 PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE CITY OF PALM DESERT STAFF REPORT MEETING DATE: January 21, 2025 PREPARED BY: Chief Mike Beverlin, Riverside County Fire Department/Cal Fire Erika Castellano, Senior Administrative Assistant SUBJECT: RIVERSIDE COUNTY FIRE DEPARTMENT/CAL FIRE DECEMBER 2024 AND QURARTLY REPORTS RECOMMENDATION: Approve the Riverside County Fire Department/Cal Fire quarterly and December 2024 reports. BACKGROUND/ANALYSIS: Riverside County Fire Department/Cal Fire quarterly and December 2024 reports. FINANCIAL IMPACT: There is no financial impact with this report. ATTACHMENTS: 1. December 2024 Monthly Report 2. Quarterly Report 25 26 Bill Weiser Jurisdiction Summary for City of Palm Desert Fire Chief Riverside County Fire Department/ CAL FIRE 12/1/2024 to 12/31/2024 Incident Response Activity *At least 1 Resource Dispatched #Incident Type Com Fire 2 False Alarm 79 Medical 862 Multi-Fam Dwelling Fire 1 Other Fire 7 Other Misc 2 Public Service Assist 78 Res Fire 3 Rescue 5 Ringing Alarm 1 Standby 7 Traffic Collision 52 Vehicle Fire 1 Wildland Fire 1 1,101Incident Total Average Enroute to On-Scene Time *Units Responding Charlie, Delta, Bravo, Echo, Code 3 8 163 587 4 4.16 77.03 <5 Minutes +5 Minutes +10 Minutes +20 Minutes Average Min % 0 to 5 Min Enroute Time: Unit has been acknowledged as responding. On-Scene Time: Unit has been acknowledged as being On-Scene. Transport *Based on Units with a Transport time Jurisdiction Ambulance Responses DRM 41 EMC 429 JFK 4 RUHS 1 Total: 475 Ambulance Mutual Aid Given DRM 20 EMC 135 JFK 2 Total: 157 Ambulance Mutual Aid Received DRM 15 EMC 146 JFK 2 Other 1 Total: 164 Mutual Aid *Unit responses Jurisdiction Units Responses 572Engine 727Medic 260Squad 142Truck/Quint 1,701Total: Mutual Aid Given 188Engine 257Medic 115Squad 44Truck/Quint 604Total: Mutual Aid Received 3Breathing Support 21Brush 16Chief 1Dozer 359Engine 258Medic 7PIO 1Safety 2Truck/Quint 668Total: Page 1 of 21/1/2025 1:40:18PM 27 Truck Report T33 recorded 142 responses in City of Palm Desert from 12/1/2024 1:40:10 PM to 12/31/2024 1:40:10 PM T86 recorded 2 responses in City of Palm Desert from 12/1/2024 1:40:10 PM to 12/31/2024 1:40:10 PM Significant Incidents CAL FIRE / Riverside County Fire department resources responded to a commercial structure fire at 74894 Lennon Place in suite C1. The first arriving Company Officer reported light smoke from a single store commercial building. The fire was isolated and extinguished in the attic space above a restroom in the business. City of Palm Desert Building officials will need to follow up due to electrical damage in the building. 24CARRU187433 12/5/2024 4:49:00PM Units from CAL FIRE / Riverside County Fire responded to a structure fire at 904 Mesa Grande Drive in the City of Palm Desert. The first arriving Company Officer reported a single story residential structure with a working attic fire. Crews made an aggressive interior fire attack , until they were driven outside due to a partial roof collapse. The incident commander altered strategies, and a defensive attack was implemented for fire fighter safety. One resident was displaced, however they did not require assistance at this time . City of Palm Desert building officials will need to respond to red tag the structure. 24CARRU187820 12/6/2024 11:14:00AM CAL FIRE / Riverside County Fire Department responded to a residential structure fire at 43798 Virginia Avenue in the city of Palm Desert. The first arriving fire engine reported a single-story, single-family dwelling with heavy smoke and fire showing from the rear of the structure . The fire also threatened two additional residences on either side of the original residence; therefore, a second alarm was requested for extra staffing. Fire crews protected the exposures with hose lines and made an aggressive interior attack on the main fire . Fire crews were able to contain the fire to the home of origin without any additional damage to nearby homes. One resident was displaced from their home and has requested Red Cross assistance . The home was completely destroyed by fire and the Palm Desert Building and Safety Department was contacted to red-tag the home. 24CARRU190372 12/10/2024 4:43:00PM CAL FIRE / Riverside County Fire Department responded to a residential structure fire at 73629 Amir Drive in Palm Desert. The first arriving fire engine reported a single-story duplex with heavy smoke and fire coming from the garage. Fire crews quickly deployed hose lines and contained the fire to the garage. It was later determined that the fire originated from a vehicle. One resident was displaced from the home. The Palm Desert Building and Safety Department will also respond to the house and the structure. 24CARRU197992 12/23/2024 8:49:00AM Page 2 of 21/1/2025 1:40:18PM 28 Bill Weiser Jurisdiction Summary for City of Palm Desert Fire Chief Riverside County Fire Department/ CAL FIRE 10/1/2024 to 12/31/2024 Incident Response Activity *At least 1 Resource Dispatched #Incident Type Com Fire 2 False Alarm 243 Haz Mat 1 Medical 2,247 Multi-Fam Dwelling Fire 2 Other Fire 18 Other Misc 5 Public Service Assist 179 Res Fire 5 Rescue 11 Ringing Alarm 7 Standby 18 Traffic Collision 125 Vehicle Fire 4 Wildland Fire 5 2,872Incident Total Average Enroute to On-Scene Time *Units Responding Charlie, Delta, Bravo, Echo, Code 3 23 383 1,542 6 4.05 78.92 <5 Minutes +5 Minutes +10 Minutes +20 Minutes Average Min % 0 to 5 Min Enroute Time: Unit has been acknowledged as responding. On-Scene Time: Unit has been acknowledged as being On-Scene. Transport *Based on Units with a Transport time Jurisdiction Ambulance Responses DRM 100 EMC 1,161 JFK 8 Other 1 RUHS 1 Total: 1,271 Ambulance Mutual Aid Given DRM 46 EMC 358 JFK 4 Other 1 Total: 409 Ambulance Mutual Aid Received DRM 31 EMC 342 JFK 3 Other 1 Total: 377 Mutual Aid *Unit responses Jurisdiction Units Responses 1,508Engine 1,934Medic 1Rescue 633Squad 360Truck/Quint 4,436Total: Mutual Aid Given 534Engine 655Medic 261Squad 118Truck/Quint 1,568Total: Mutual Aid Received 3Breathing Support 25Brush 33Chief 1Dozer 870Engine 1Environmental Health 614Medic 8PIO 1Safety Page 1 of 31/1/2025 1:43:40PM 29 102Squad 4Truck/Quint 1,662Total: Page 2 of 31/1/2025 1:43:40PM 30 Truck Report T33 recorded 360 responses in City of Palm Desert from 10/1/2024 1:43:31 PM to 12/31/2024 1:43:31 PM T86 recorded 4 responses in City of Palm Desert from 10/1/2024 1:43:31 PM to 12/31/2024 1:43:31 PM Significant Incidents CAL FIRE/ Riverside County Fire Department resources responded to an unconscious 63-year-old male at the Oasis Country Club golf course. Bystanders witnessed the adult male having seizure like activity while playing golf, which caused the male to collapse on the ground striking his head. The patient ended up falling into a pond of water next to the 13th green of the golf course. Witnesses stated that the male was submerged under water for approximately half a minute before bystanders removed him from the pond. Fire crews arrived on scene to find the male patient in severe respiratory distress , with an altered mental status. Firefighters provided advanced life support and trauma treatment measures to the patient on scene and transported to the nearest most appropriate medical facility. On arrival to the hospital, the male patient was alert, oriented, and speaking with firefighters in full and complete sentences. The patient is currently being evaluated by hospital medical staff . 24CARRU172677 11/9/2024 8:49:00AM CAL FIRE / Riverside County Fire department resources responded to a commercial structure fire at 74894 Lennon Place in suite C1. The first arriving Company Officer reported light smoke from a single store commercial building. The fire was isolated and extinguished in the attic space above a restroom in the business. City of Palm Desert Building officials will need to follow up due to electrical damage in the building. 24CARRU187433 12/5/2024 4:49:00PM Units from CAL FIRE / Riverside County Fire responded to a structure fire at 904 Mesa Grande Drive in the City of Palm Desert. The first arriving Company Officer reported a single story residential structure with a working attic fire. Crews made an aggressive interior fire attack , until they were driven outside due to a partial roof collapse. The incident commander altered strategies, and a defensive attack was implemented for fire fighter safety. One resident was displaced, however they did not require assistance at this time . City of Palm Desert building officials will need to respond to red tag the structure. 24CARRU187820 12/6/2024 11:14:00AM CAL FIRE / Riverside County Fire Department responded to a residential structure fire at 43798 Virginia Avenue in the city of Palm Desert. The first arriving fire engine reported a single-story, single-family dwelling with heavy smoke and fire showing from the rear of the structure . The fire also threatened two additional residences on either side of the original residence; therefore, a second alarm was requested for extra staffing. Fire crews protected the exposures with hose lines and made an aggressive interior attack on the main fire . Fire crews were able to contain the fire to the home of origin without any additional damage to nearby homes. One resident was displaced from their home and has requested Red Cross assistance . The home was completely destroyed by fire and the Palm Desert Building and Safety Department was contacted to red-tag the home. 24CARRU190372 12/10/2024 4:43:00PM CAL FIRE / Riverside County Fire Department responded to a residential structure fire at 73629 Amir Drive in Palm Desert. The first arriving fire engine reported a single-story duplex with heavy smoke and fire coming from the garage. Fire crews quickly deployed hose lines and contained the fire to the garage. It was later determined that the fire originated from a vehicle. One resident was displaced from the home. The Palm Desert Building and Safety Department will also respond to the house and the structure. 24CARRU197992 12/23/2024 8:49:00AM Page 3 of 31/1/2025 1:43:40PM 31 32 Page 1 of 1 PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE CITY OF PALM DESERT STAFF REPORT MEETING DATE: January 21, 2025 PREPARED BY: Pedro Rodriguez, Code Compliance Supervisor SUBJECT: DECEMBER 2024 CODE COMPLIANCE ACTIVITY REPORT RECOMMENDATION: Approve the December 2024 Code Compliance Activity Report BACKGROUND/ANALYSIS: The attached report provides details regarding the types of calls handled by the code compliance division during this reporting period. ATTACHMENTS: 1. Cover Page 2. Code Compliance Activity Report 3. Citation Activity Chart 33 34 CITY OF PALM DESERT CODE COMPLIANCE DIVISION SHORT- TERM RENTAL ACTIVITY REPORT Pedro Rodriguez Code Compliance Supervisor prodriguez@cityofpalmdesert.org 760-776-6442 35 Code Compliance Division SHORT-TERM RENTAL ACTIVITY REPORT Monthly Report Details: This reporting period will reflect proactive patrols and investigations for December 2024 The Code Compliance swing shift officer performed 127 routine proactive patrols including monitoring short-term rental properties and responding to complaints regarding short-term rental violations. He performed and responded to 19 routine and after-hours code compliance complaints. During this reporting period, no citations were issued for operating a short-term rental property without a valid permit. No citations were issued for routine code compliance violations. Total Inspections: Routine Proactive STR inspections: 127 Code Compliance Routine After-hours Complaints: 19 Total Inspections: 146 Citations Issued: Operating without a Short-term Rental Permit: 0 Unruly Gathering/Noise Disturbance: 0 No Onsite Owner: 0 Occupancy Violation (minimum number of days): 0 Occupancy Violation (maximum number of guests): 0 Failure to Respond within 30 Minutes: 0 Failure to Renew Short-Term Rental Permit: 0 Failure to Remove Waste Container/Debris: 0 Other Operational Violations: 0 Other Citations: 0 Total Citations Issued: 0 Short-Term Rental Citations and Fines: Citations issued: 0 Fines issued: $0 Fines Collected: $0 Notes: 36 December 2024 146 127 19 TOTAL INSPECTIONS STR INSPECTIONS CODE CASES 0 0 0 0 TOTAL CITATIONS ISSUED NO STR PERMIT OPERATIONAL VIOLATIONS OTHER CITATIONS CITATIONS ISSUED 37 38 Page 1 of 1 PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE CITY OF PALM DESERT STAFF REPORT MEETING DATE: January 21, 2025 PREPARED BY: Daniel Hurtado, Public Safety Analyst SUBJECT: EMERGENCY SERVICES COORDINATOR REPORT RECOMMENDATION: 1. Approve the report for the month of December 2024. BACKGROUND/ANALYSIS: Emergency Services Coordinator Report for December 2024. FINANCIAL IMPACT: No fiscal impact. ATTACHMENTS: 1. Emergency Services Coordinator Report December 2024. 39 40 Emergency Services Division MONTHLY SERVICE REPORT Reporting Period: December 2024 City Internal Activities: Mass Sheltering: - Created an agreement with DSUSD to use schools if sheltering is needed. Emergency Operations Plan Update: - Progress continues on updating the City’s Emergency Operations Plan, including the integration of a comprehensive heat response element to address extreme heat events effectively. Emergency Management Performance Grant: - The project close-out for December 31, 2024, has been successfully submitted to the county for review. Pending review from the county. FEMA 4431 Winter Storms 2019 - The project has been reviewed and submitted for close-out evaluation to secure possible reimbursement for the City. Sheriff’s Contract Amendment: - Scheduled for council review on January 9, 2025, to incorporate the updated hours and personnel addition. COPS Inspection - Palm Desert COPS safety and monitoring site visit through the Riverside County Office on Aging. Events: - The Traveling 9/11 Memorial Painting Demonstration at Fire Station 33 City Training: FEMA Trainings: - Assisting new staff in completing the Incident Command System courses (ICS 100, 200, and 700). Current completion rate: 76 out of 141 employees trained. Future Items: Vehicle Impound Cost Recover Fees Law Enforcement Responsibilities MOU (College of the Desert, UCR, CSUSB PD) 41 42 Page 1 of 1 PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE CITY OF PALM DESERT STAFF REPORT MEETING DATE: January 21, 2025 PREPARED BY: Erika Castellano, Senior Administrative Assistant SUBJECT: CITIZENS ON PATROL DECEMBER 2024 REPORTS RECOMMENDATION: Approve the COP reports for the month of December 2024. BACKGROUND/ANALYSIS: Citizens on Patrol reports for the month of December 2024. FINANCIAL IMPACT: There is no financial impact with this report. ATTACHMENTS: 1. COP Reports for December 2024. 43 44 PREVIOUS MONTH'S ACTIVITY CURRENT MONTH'S ACTIVITY MTH/MTH % ACTIVITY CHANGE 7199 618 582 -5.83% 573 39 61 56.41% N/A 25 24 -4.00% 41 1 2 100.00% 173 10 22 120.00% 67 2 5 150.00% 322 15 25 66.67% 389 17 30 76.47% 207 9 31 244.44% 201 11 27 145.45% 2 ## 1 1 iii 0 2 1 iv 0 22 ## 1 12 v 1 2 6 vi 1 3 1 vii 1 4 0 5 ## 1 1 iv 2 2 0 v 1 3 1 vi 0 25 ## 1 2 iv 2 2 2 v 0 3 18 vi 1 31 ## 1 0 ii 31 27 # 1 27 ii Garage Door Open 0 0 ## 1 0 ii 0 0 ## 1 0 ii 0 2 0 ii 0 0 ## 1 0 ii 0 2 0 ii 0 0 ## 1 0 iv 0 2 0 v 0 3 0 vi 0 0 ## 1 0 iv 0 2 0 v 0 PALM DESERT CITIZENS ON PATROL (COPS) MONTHLY REPORT FOR THE MONTH OF: DECEMBER 2024 Trash & Homeless Abandoned vehicle I. Major Events and/or Incidents: J. Manpower Utilized During the Month / Members Stats K. Other: Mail Theft Animal Control contacted C. Number of Incidents Reported to Sheriff's Dept. For Action: D. Number of Incidents Reported to City For Action: C.+ D. = Total Number of Incidents Reported to City, Sheriff, etc.: E. Number of Citations Issued / Yellow Warning Citations Issued: F. Number of Flyers/Posters/Banners Removed from City areas: A. Total COPS Requests Received From Dispatch: MANPOWER AND INCIDENT PREPORT 1. Total Hours Patrolled (Patrols are usually 4-6 hours): 2. Total Number of Patrols Conducted: 3. Numbers of Members in Program: A. Requests Received from Sheriff's Dept. Dispatch for Assistance: B. Number of Incidents Responded to From Scanner and Via Observation: Traffic Control Assistance for Accidents Traffic Control Assistance for Disabled Vehicle Traffic Control Assistance for Accidents Traffic Control Assistance for Disabled Vehicle Traffic Control Assistance for Road Debris: Other: Request for Water Back Up Motor Officer(CSO) Suspicious Person Suspicious/Disabled Vehicle Back Up Cal Fire: Responded But Not Needed: Other: H. Special Evens: G. Vacation Home Check Program: F. Number of Flyers/Posters/Banners Removed from City areas: E. Number of Citations/Yellow Courtesy Warnings Given: Total Number of Patrols Conducted During Month Current Members in The Program B. Total COPS Incidents Responded to from Scanner Observation: Gate Vandalized Handicapped Parking Sign Total Hours Patrolled During Month Shopping Carts Traffic Accident Code Violations Graffiti D. Number of Incidents Reported to City For Action: C. Number of Incidents Reported to Sheriff's Dept. For Action: Citations Flyers/Poster/Banners Vacation Homes In Program During the Month Traffic Control Assistance for Road Debris Volunteer Applications Received for the Month/ In Progress: Number of Members in Training: Dumping of Misc Items Vacation Home Checks Done During the Month: 195 64 Citizen Flag Down: Debris In Road: Yellow Courtesy Warnings: 2023 YEAR-TO-DATE* 6506 518 25 13% 13% -33% Other: Automatic gate open at the Yard Debris In Road: Citizen Flag Down: Other: Traffic Signal Broken YEAR/YEAR % CHANGE 20% -4% 22% -48% 516 522 194 213 -20% 23% 7% 72 347 419 238 228 83 173 2024 YEAR-TO-DATE 7781 634 24 43 45 46 8 20 23 25 27 82 88 96 103 175 175 190 190 196 209 210 223 235 273 286 317 317 318 331 366 372 420 489 543 597 895 - 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240 260 280 300 320 340 360 380 400 420 440 460 480 500 520 540 560 580 600 620 640 660 680 700 720 740 760 780 800 820 840 860 880 900 920 940 DAVIS, PURNELL SMITH, RUTH AVANS, GEORGE MALUEG,CHERYL DOLHA, MITCH STONE, HARRY KELSEY,LOUISE NIEHAUS, TOM RICHERSON,LORI MAHER, BRIAN BERGER, STEVEN WOLFE, EARLE DAVIS, KURT LYNN, BELL SCARNA, JOSEPH WART-PICKERING, SHARON DOOLITTLE, LOYD SUMMERS, KAREN BENDELL DAVID GARLAND, JUDY DECKETT, MIKE LISTON, JEFF MORRISSEY, PAULINE MORRISSEY, ERIC ALLEY, JEFF ADAMS, ALAN MCDOW, KEN CURIA, PHIL BERRY, DEWEY PICKERING, SAM MACFARLANE,DAVE Hours Me m b e r s COPS Members Partol Hours -2024 Year-To -Date @ 12/31/24 47 48 Palm Desert Citizens on Patrol (COPS) – Monthly Patrol Area Breakdown Report from OCTOBER TO DECEMBER 2024 LOCATION HOVLEY GARDENS/SOCCER PARK, FALCON CREST A1 14 12 16 GUTHY-RENKER DISTRICT A2 9 8 15 CARLOTTA AREA A3 9 10 16 BEACON HILL A4 8 9 16 FREEDOM PARK A5 10 10 19 C.C. BUSINESS PARK A6 11 9 14 DESERT COUNTRY PLAZA A7 10 9 14 JOE MANN PARK A8 12 9 17 CALIFORNIA VILLAS A9 9 10 13 PALM DESERT COUNTRY CLUB A10 9 9 12 DESERT ROSE HOUSING B1 19 12 20 CIVIC CENTER PARK/CITYHALL B2 23 15 21 AQUATIC CENTER B3 18 15 21 COMMUNITY PARK/MAG FALLS B4 13 12 17 F CATALINA GARDENS APARTMENTS B5 16 11 20 R SANTA ROSA CITY PROPERTIES B6 17 12 20 E JOSLYN CENTER B7 16 12 20 Q PALMA VILLIAGE PARK B8 17 15 21 U TAOS APARTMENTS B9 16 12 22 E ALBERTSONS B10 17 17 27 N CANDLEWOOD APARTMENTS C1 10 10 9 C WASHINGTON CHARTER SCHOOL C2 16 13 14 Y CAHUILLA HILLS PARK C3 10 10 10 INDIAN CREEK VILLAS C4 10 9 10 O CAP HOMME PARK C5 10 10 10 F MESA VIEW AREA C6 9 9 12 SILVER SPUR RANCH C7 9 8 11 P HAYSTACK DRIVE AREA C8 9 9 12 A IRONWOOD PARK C9 9 8 12 T WILLOW/BURSERA WAY C10 9 7 10 R COSTCO SHOPPING CENTER D1 14 12 17 O WALMART SHOPPING CENTER D2 15 13 18 L DINAH SHORE INDUSTRIAL AREA D3 12 10 12 S UNIVERSITYPARK/DOG PARK D4 12 11 11 UNIVERSITY VILLIAGE SHOPPING CENTER D5 12 9 11 DESERT SPRINGS MARKET PLACE D6 19 15 13 BRISTOL FARMS, HOVLEY WEST/SAGEWOOD D7 15 11 18 LAS SERENAS APARTMENTS D8 8 5 11 RESIDENTIAL ARAS S OF HWY 111/E OF HWY 74 E1 11 4 8 PALMS TO PINES/WEST EL PASEO E2 12 7 11 CHAMBER OF COMMERCE E3 10 10 13 DESERT CROSSING SHOPPING CENTER E4 12 15 23 BUMP AND GRIND TRAIL HEAD E5 12 15 22 LAS SOMBRAS/OLIVE GARDEN E6 11 12 18 WARING PLAZA E7 9 9 13 ONE QUAIL PLACE E8 7 6 10 TOWN CENTER WAY/NORDSTROMS E9 10 9 19 WESTFIELD MALL AREA E10 9 7 20 DESERT POINTE APARTMENTS E11 5 1 8 EL PASEO SHOPPING AREA/N AND S PARKING LOTS E12 11 10 20 CV LINK E13 1 0 0 PATROL AREAS AVERAGE VISITS 12 10 15 COLOR LEGEND Oct Nov Dec 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 A1 A2 A3 A4 A5 A6 A7 A8 A9 A10 B1 B2 B3 B4 B5 B6 B7 B8 B9 B10 C1 C2 C3 C4 C5 C6 C7 C8 C9 C10 D1 D2 D3 D4 D5 D6 D7 D8 E1 E2 E3 E4 E5 E6 E7 E8 E9 E10 E11 E12 E13 49 50 Page 1 of 16 PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE CITY OF PALM DESERT STAFF REPORT MEETING DATE: January 21, 2025 PREPARED BY: Daniel Hurtado, Public Safety Analyst SUBJECT: AUTOMATED LICENSE PLATE READER SHARED NETWORK INFORMATION REPORT DECEMBER 2024 RECOMMENDATION: Approve the automated license plate reader shared network information report for December 2024. BACKGROUND/ANALYSIS: On June 2, 2022, Flock Safety was awarded a contract for a fixed location of the Automated License Plate Readers (ALPR) system. The system became operational in October 2022. The City has a contract with the Riverside County Sheriff's Department (RCSD) for law enforcement services and participates in the RCSD ALPR program. Therefore, the ALPR program and RCSD’s operator, Flock, are bound by Federal and State law, RCSD policy, and the requirements of the City's agreement with Flock. Palm Desert Shared Networks The City of Palm Desert is the owner of the data and RCSD manages it on its behalf according to state law, RCSD Policy 412, and the City’s agreement with Flock Safety. During a reporting period, the data is retrieved from RCSD which includes a review of the shared networks for the reporting period. Palm Desert data is shared only with other California agencies as is allowed by state law, SB 34 (2015). Flock by default deletes the data every 30 days. Once the data is deleted, it cannot be ret rieved. Flock is among the shortest of all the state statutes on data retention. Flock does not share with 3rd parties. Flock requires an investigative reason to search, and they provide an audit report to system administrators. Reporting In accordance with state law, City staff monitors the list of agencies with which Palm Desert data is shared. Beginning December 2023, the City has published its shared networks list. The following is the December 2024, shared network report with 296 California Agenc ies. Organization Name Shared Networks 51 Public Safety Committee City of Palm Desert Automated License Plate Reader Shared Network Information Report Page 2 of 16 Fremont CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Calistoga CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Elk Grove CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department La Habra CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Desert Hot Springs CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Baldwin Park CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Los Angeles County CA SD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department San Mateo County CA SO City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Lompoc CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Santa Clara CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Newark CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Westminster CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Cal Fire City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Santa Barbara County CA SO City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Daly City CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department OC Sheriff CA City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Rio Vista CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Anaheim CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department San Bernardino County CA SO City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Oakley CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Vallejo CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department 52 Public Safety Committee City of Palm Desert Automated License Plate Reader Shared Network Information Report Page 3 of 16 Danville CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Chino PD (CA) City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Indio CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Ukiah CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Tustin CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Yolo County CA SO City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Seaside CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department San Joaquin County CA SO City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Woodland CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Napa CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department California State Parks City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department San Pablo CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Pacific Grove CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Pleasanton CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Santa Cruz CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Hayward CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Visalia CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Stockton CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Escalon CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Sequoias Community College District CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Colma CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department 53 Public Safety Committee City of Palm Desert Automated License Plate Reader Shared Network Information Report Page 4 of 16 Monterey Park CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Lincoln CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Contra Costa County CA SO City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Alhambra CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Livermore CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Santa Rosa CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Dixon CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Hanford CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Menlo Park CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department San Mateo CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Livingston CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Kings County CA DAs Office City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Ontario CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Pomona CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Emeryville CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department San Leandro CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Fullerton CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Irvine CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Los Alamitos PD CA City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Mountain View CA PD (Santa Clara County) City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department LASD CA - San Dimas Station City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department 54 Public Safety Committee City of Palm Desert Automated License Plate Reader Shared Network Information Report Page 5 of 16 Marin County CA SO City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Alameda County CA SO City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Ventura CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department La Verne CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Hillsborough CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Brawley CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Angels Camp CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Garden Grove CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Union City CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Atherton CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department California Highway Patrol City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department NCRIC City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department San Luis Obispo CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Fort Bragg CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Rio Hondo College PD CA City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Barstow CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Glendora (CA) PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department San Fernando CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department City of Riverside CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Napa County CA SO City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Kings County Sheriff's Office CA City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department 55 Public Safety Committee City of Palm Desert Automated License Plate Reader Shared Network Information Report Page 6 of 16 Lodi CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Lakeport CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Solano County CA SO City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Nevada County CA SO City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Hercules CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Salinas CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Vernon CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Grass Valley CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Redwood City CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Cal State Fullerton (CA) City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Colton CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Simi Valley CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department San Bruno CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Imperial County CA SO City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Hemet CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Watsonville CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department West Valley Mission College Dist Campus (CA) City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Covina CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Redondo Beach CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Ridgecrest CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Milpitas CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department 56 Public Safety Committee City of Palm Desert Automated License Plate Reader Shared Network Information Report Page 7 of 16 Murrieta CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department West Sacramento CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department La Mesa CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Santa Monica CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department San Jose CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Bell Gardens CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Concord CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Merced County CA SO City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department El Centro CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department El Monte CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Monterey County CA SO City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Morgan Hill CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Dublin CA PD (ACSO) City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Suisun City CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Sonoma County CA SO City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Irwindale CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Soledad CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Oxnard CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Kern County CA SO City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Greenfield PD CA City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Tracy CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department 57 Public Safety Committee City of Palm Desert Automated License Plate Reader Shared Network Information Report Page 8 of 16 Citrus Heights CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Buena Park CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Culver City CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Menifee CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Escondido CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Orange County (CA) DA Office City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Gustine PD CA City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Bishop CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department San Ramon CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Mendota CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Capitola CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Brisbane CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department West Covina CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Mendocino County SO-CA City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Laguna Beach CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department San Marino CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Orange CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Beverly Hills CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Imperial City CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Azusa CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Los Angeles Port Police CA City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department 58 Public Safety Committee City of Palm Desert Automated License Plate Reader Shared Network Information Report Page 9 of 16 South Pasadena CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department San Gabriel CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Seal Beach CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Manteca CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Burlingame CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Hollister CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Chula Vista CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department McFarland CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Cloverdale CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Grover Beach CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Tehachapi CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Modoc County CA SO City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Gilroy CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Fairfield CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Woodlake CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Madera County SO CA City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Delano CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Marina CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Pasadena CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Placer County CA SO City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Placentia CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department 59 Public Safety Committee City of Palm Desert Automated License Plate Reader Shared Network Information Report Page 10 of 16 East Palo Alto CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Costa Mesa CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Yuba County Sheriffs Office City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Palm Springs CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Butte County CA SO City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department City of Newman CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Shafter PD CA City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department City of Lemoore CA City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Corona CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Porterville CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Anderson CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Coronado CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Upland CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Whittier CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Foothill-DeAnza CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department El Cerrito CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Redlands CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department South Gate CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Fontana CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Novato CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Foster City CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department 60 Public Safety Committee City of Palm Desert Automated License Plate Reader Shared Network Information Report Page 11 of 16 Stallion Springs CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Oceanside CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Lathrop CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Hermosa Beach PD CA City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Beaumont CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Cal State San Bernadino CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Campbell CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Montclair CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Fowler CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Folsom CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department San Pasqual CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Albany CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Reedley CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Carmel CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Burbank CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Cathedral City CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department National City CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department El Cajon CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Huntington Beach CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Auburn CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department East Bay Parks CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department 61 Public Safety Committee City of Palm Desert Automated License Plate Reader Shared Network Information Report Page 12 of 16 Clearlake CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Glendale CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department San Joaquin Delta College PD (CA) City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Vacaville CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Lake County CA SO City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Bakersfield CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Galt CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Newport Beach PD CA City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Riverside County CA District Attorney City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department San Bernardino CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Torrance CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department San Diego CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Arcadia CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Cypress CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department California Department of Corrections City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Alameda CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department ACRATT -CA City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department RCATF CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department UC Riverside PD (CA) City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Antioch CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Arvin CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department 62 Public Safety Committee City of Palm Desert Automated License Plate Reader Shared Network Information Report Page 13 of 16 Los Alto Hills CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Fresno CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Burbank Airport CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Lake County DA CA City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Santa Clara DA CA City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Santa Maria CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Clovis CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Moraga CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Benicia CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Piedmont CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Pinole CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Walnut Creek CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department CSU Long Beach PD (CA) City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Healdsburg CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Port Hueneme CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Winters CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Nevada City CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Willits CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Sausalito CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Richmond CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Santa Barbara PD CA City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department 63 Public Safety Committee City of Palm Desert Automated License Plate Reader Shared Network Information Report Page 14 of 16 Kensington CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Oakland CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Rocklin CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department South San Francisco CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Roseville CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Sacramento CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department St. Helena CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Farmersville CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Santa Clara County CA SO City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Truckee CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department San Rafael CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Yuba City CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Rialto PD CA City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Los Angeles CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Yreka CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Taft CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Sunnyvale CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Sutter County CA SO City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department San Francisco District Attorney CA City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department San Diego County CA SD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Ventura County District Attorney's Office CA City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department 64 Public Safety Committee City of Palm Desert Automated License Plate Reader Shared Network Information Report Page 15 of 16 Dinuba CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Clayton CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Port of Stockton CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Placer County CA DA Office City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department San Diego Harbor CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department San Francisco CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department California State University Long Beach Campus PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Los Gatos Monte Sereno PD - CA City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Central Marin CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Rohnert Park Department of Public Safety (CA) City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Williams CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Fountain Valley CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Amador County CA Sheriff's Office City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Carlsbad CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Tulare County CA SO City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Palo Alto CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Los Altos CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Ventura County CA SO City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Riverside County CA SO City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department San Luis Obispo County (CA) Sheriff City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department Cerritos College CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department 65 Public Safety Committee City of Palm Desert Automated License Plate Reader Shared Network Information Report Page 16 of 16 Stanford University CA PD City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department California Department of Insurance Fraud City of Palm Desert CA & Riverside County Sheriff's Department 66 Page 1 of 2 PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE CITY OF PALM DESERT STAFF REPORT MEETING DATE: January 21, 2025 PREPARED BY: Daniel Hurtado, Public Safety Analyst SUBJECT: UPDATE ON COOLING AND WARM CENTERS, SHELTERS, AND COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION ON PURCHASING AND INSTALLING AN EMERGENCY GENERATOR FOR THE PALM DESERT COMMUNITY CENTER BUILDING RECOMMENDATION: 1. Receive a presentation on the City's Cooling and Warming Centers and Shelters, and discuss the proposed purchase and installation of an emergency generator at the Palm Desert Community Center BACKGROUND/ANALYSIS: In recent years, the community has experienced several instances of severe weather, leading to power outages and a heightened demand for emergency shelters and cooling centers. These facilities serve distinct and critical purposes during extreme weather events. Assembly Bill 782 mandates that at least one designated emergency shelter, cooling center, or warming center must accommodate pets. When selecting and designating these locations, it is essential to ensure compliance with this requirement by identifying at least one facility capable of meeting these specific accommodations. The City of Palm Desert has designated five facilities as Cool Centers for extreme heat events and four facilities as Warming Centers for cold conditions:  Palm Desert Library – Pet Friendly & Warm Center  Palm Desert Community Center – Warm Center  Portola Community Center – Pet Friendly & Warm Center  Joslyn Senior Center – Warm Center  California State University San Bernardino Palm Desert Campus These centers play a critical role in safeguarding vulnerable populations, including the elderly, individuals without access to air conditioning, and others at heigh tened risk of weather-related illnesses. Cooling Centers offer safe, air-conditioned environments to mitigate extreme heat risks, while Warming Centers provide heated spaces to protect against severe cold -related health risks. However, these Centers typically operate only during regular business hours, and each facility must navigate unique challenges: 67 Public Safety Committee City of Palm Desert (PSC Recommendation for a Generator at Palm Desert Community Center ) Page 2 of 2  Joslyn Senior Center: Equipped with an operational emergency generator, but not owned or operated by the City.  Portola Community Center: Limited by its small size.  Library and Cal State Campus: Neither facility is City-owned. Differentiating Emergency Shelters and Cool Centers An emergency shelter provides temporary housing during emergencies, such as natural disasters (e.g., hurricanes or floods). Shelters offer food, water, sleeping arrangements, and basic needs for displaced individuals and families. The City coordinates with the County Department of Social Services and the American Red Cross to provide shelter services unt il more permanent housing solutions can be arranged. In contrast, Cooling Centers are dedicated facilities that provide temporary relief from extreme heat, offering cool, air-conditioned spaces where individuals can stay hydrated with access to water and light refreshments. Unlike emergency shelters, Cooling Centers do not provide full shelter services or overnight accommodations. Their primary purpose is to prevent heat -related illnesses by addressing the immediate dangers of high temperatures. Similarly, Warming Centers serve as safe, heated environments during periods of extreme cold, ensuring protection from weather-related health risks. Both types of centers are critical, short-term resources designed to meet specific community needs during extreme wea ther events. These efforts aim to enhance the City’s emergency preparedness and response capabilities. Currently, the City lacks fully reliable Cooling and Warming Centers or shelters to ensure the safety and well-being of residents during extreme weather events or other emergencies. This discussion is being presented to the City Council for further consideration. Strategic Plan: This discussion aligns with the Public Safety and Emergency Services section of the Palm Desert Strategic Plan, specifically Priority 1: Enhance the delivery of public safety services. The strategy is to expand the existing services provided by the fire and police departments to address future growth and safety concerns. One action step is to identify public safety needs, includin g new equipment. FINANCIAL IMPACT: No fiscal impact with making a recommendation. ATTACHMENTS: 1. Powerpoint 68 EMERGENCY COOLING CENTERS AND SHELTERS Public Safety Committee Review 69 OBJECTIVES ENHANCE EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS, FOCUS ON COOLING AND WARMING CENTERS TO SAFEGUARD RESIDENTS DURING EXTREME WEATHER EVENTS. MEET LEGAL COMPLIANCE, ADDRESS ASSEMBLY BILL 782 REQUIREMENTS FOR PET- FRIENDLY EMERGENCY FACILITIES. EVALUATE INFRASTRUCTURE INVESTMENTS, DISCUSS THE ADDITION OF AN EMERGENCY GENERATOR AND ALTERNATIVE FACILITY SOLUTIONS. 70 ASSEMBLY BILL 782 COMPLIANCE Ensuring Pet-Friendly Emergency Centers Legal Requirement mandates at least one designated emergency shelter, cooling, or warming center to accommodate pets. The Palm Desert Library and Portola Community Center are designated as pet-friendly facilities. Operational Challenges are the facilities without generators or city ownership face constraints meeting full compliance during emergencies. 71 COMMUNITY NEEDS Understnding Local Challenges Heatwaves significantly endanger populations without access to air conditioning Power Outages disrupt and impact daily life, from communication to critical medical equipment. Flooding, strong winds, and earthquakes exacerbate safety risks and necessitate robust emergency shelters/. 72 EXISTING LOCATIONS Not equipped with a Generator: •Palm Desert Community Center •Portola Community Center •Palm Desert Library •California State San Bernardino –Palm Desert Campus Equipped with a Generator: •Joslyn Center (Ages 55 & Older) 73 •https://www.arcgis.com/apps/dashboards/7a7fc6e4dd48469fae605c1e1 906035a 74 STRATEGIC ALIGNMENT AND RECOMMENDATIONS ALIGNMENT WITH STRATEGIC PLAN SUPPORTS THE CITY PRIORITY 1: ENHANCE PUBLIC SAFETY SERVICES RECOMMENDED INVESTMENT APPROVE $500,000 FOR GENERATOR INSTALLATION AT THE PALM DESERT COMMUNITY CENTER ALTERNATIVE OPTION CONSIDER FUTURE PARKVIEW LIBRARY AS A DESIGNATED EMERGENCY FACILITY. 75 THANK YOU •Daniel Hurtado, Public Safety Analyst 76 Page 1 of 2 PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE CITY OF PALM DESERT STAFF REPORT MEETING DATE: January 21, 2025 PREPARED BY: Daniel Hurtado, Public Safety Analyst Chris Escobedo, Assistant City Manager SUBJECT: DEVELOPMENT OF 2025 WORKPLAN RECOMMENDATION: 1. Staff recommends that the Public Safety Committee identify and establish two to three major priorities for the 2025 calendar year. BACKGROUND/ANALYSIS: For 2024, the Public Safety Committee (PSC) established a comprehensive work plan to guide its efforts. The key focus areas of the work plan include: Traffic Enforcement The PSC reviewed traffic enforcement programs, received updates, and provided input o n traffic calming initiatives and related Capital Improvement Projects (CIPs). Over the past year, the PSC received updates from law enforcement on speed enforcement measures and provided feedback to the City’s Capital Improvement Projects team on traffic calming improvements. Public Safety Budget The PSC conducted a review of the police and fire budgets, received updates, and analyzed fire and police contract rates and staffing levels. This included discussions on the development of a new fire station and minor adjustments to police staffing levels. Community-Oriented Policing The PSC engaged in discussions on community-oriented policing, received presentations on related programs, and worked on formulating recommendations for the City Council. This initiative received fewer resources due to the significant attention allocated to traffic enforcement and public safety priorities. Measure Success On November 5, 2024, voters approved the Palm Desert Public Safety, Roads, and City Services Measure, providing additional revenue to strengthen the City’s General Fund. The funding will be allocated to key priorities, including:  Expanding staffing levels for police, fire, and public works. 77 Public Safety Committee City of Palm Desert (Development of Public Safety Committee 2025 Work Plan) Page 2 of 2  Constructing a new fire station and renovating two existing stations.  Enhancing storm channel infrastructure and improving the retention basin. Next Steps PSC members are encouraged to submit their proposed priorities for 2025 individually before the next meeting. Staff will compile these submissions and provide a consolidated list for review and consideration. The compiled priorities will be discussed in depth at the subsequent meeting to ensure thorough evaluation and alignment. Staff recommends that the PSC identify and establish two to three major priorities for the 2025 calendar year. FINANCIAL IMPACT: No fiscal impact 78 CITY OF PALM DESERT ATTENDANCE REPORT Advisory Body: Prepared By: Year 2023 2023 2024 2024 2024 2024 2024 2024 2024 2024 2024 2024 2024 Month Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Date 12-Dec 9-Jan 13-Feb 12-Mar 9-Apr 14-May 11-Jun N/A N/A 9-Sep 8-Oct 12-Nov 10-Dec Alley, Jeff P P P P P P P - - P P P P 0 0 Bindman, Gary P N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A - - N/A N/A N/A N/A 0 0 Butts, Joseph P P P P P P P - - P P P P 1 0 Kramer, Terry P P P E P P P - - P P P P 2 0 Luhring, Douglas P P P P P P P - - P E P P 3 0 Nelson, Stephen P P P P P P P - - P E P P 1 0 Taylor, Frank P P A P P P P - - P P P P 1 1 Wahlstrom, Kevin P P P P P P P - - P P P P 0 0 Palm Desert Municipal Code 2.34.010: P Present A Absent E Excused - No meeting Monthly: Three unexcused absences from regular meetings in any twelve-month period shall constitute an automatic resignation of members holding office on boards that meet monthly. Public Safety Committee Erika Castellano Total Absences Total Unexcused Absences 79