Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutPost-Meeting Agenda Package - Palm Desert City Council - Special Meeting_Dec16_2025 PALM DESERT CITY COUNCIL SPECIAL REGULAR MEETING POST-MEETING AGENDA Tuesday, December 16, 2025 1:30 p.m. Council Chamber, City Hall 73-510 Fred Waring Drive Palm Desert, California This is a joint meeting of the Palm Desert City Council, Successor Agency to the Palm Desert Redevelopment Agency, Palm Desert Housing Authority and the Palm Desert Board of Library Trustees. Pursuant to Assembly Bill 2449, this meeting may be conducted as a hybrid meeting allowing public access via teleconference or in person, and up to two Councilmembers may attend remotely. WATCH THE MEETING LIVE: Watch the City Council meeting live at the City’s website: www.palmdesert.gov under the “Meeting Agendas” link at the top of the homepage, or on the City’s YouTube Channel. OPTIONS FOR PARTICIPATING IN THIS MEETING: If unable to attend the meeting in person, you may choose from the following options: OPTION 1: VIA EMAIL Send your comments by email to: CouncilMeetingComments@palmdesert.gov. Emails received prior to 10:00 a.m. on the day of the City Council meeting will be made part of the record and distributed to the City Council. Emails will not be read aloud at the meeting. OPTION 2: LIVE VIA ZOOM 1. Access via palmdesert.gov/zoom or zoom.us, click “Join Meeting” and enter Webinar ID 833 6744 9572. OPTION 3: LIVE VIA TELEPHONE 1. (213) 338-8477 and enter Meeting ID 833 6744 9572 followed by #. 2. Indicate that you are a participant by pressing # to continue. 3. During the meeting, press *9 to add yourself to the queue and wait for the Mayor or City Clerk to announce your name/phone number. Press *6 to unmute your line. Pages 1.CALL TO ORDER 2.ROLL CALL 3.ACTION CALENDAR The public may comment on individual Action Items. Speakers may comment in- person or utilize one of the three options listed on the first page of the agenda. Speakers are generally provided up to three (3) minutes. However, because a large number of speakers is anticipated, the Mayor may reduce the individual speaking time (potentially to two (2) minutes per speaker) to ensure the meeting can proceed in an orderly manner. 3.a CONSIDERATION OF A REQUEST FOR ACTION TO RESCIND CITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2024-038 RELATED TO LGBTQ PRIDE MONTH COMMEMORATIONS AND AMENDING CITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2018-09 RELATED TO DIVERSITY AND INCLUSION. 4 RECOMMENDATION: As requested, adopt a resolution amending Paragraph Six of City Council Resolution No. 2018-09, entitled: “A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, WELCOMING ALL WHO CHOOSE TO LIVE, WORK IN, OR VISIT OUR COMMUNITY AND AFFIRMING THE CITY OF PALM DESERT’S COMMITMENT TO UNITY, INCLUSION, AND SHARED COMMUNITY VALUES.” 1. As requested, adopt a resolution rescinding City Council Resolution NO. 2024-038, entitled: “A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, ESTABLISHING A POLICY RELATED TO LGBTQ PRIDE MONTH COMMEMORATIONS.” 2. RECOMMENDATION: To take no action and make no changes to Resolution No. 2018-09 and Resolution No. 2024-038. 4.ADJOURNMENT City Council Meeting 2 5.PUBLIC NOTICES Agenda Related Materials: Pursuant to Government Code §54957.5(b)(2) the designated office for inspection of records in connection with this meeting is the Office of the City Clerk, Palm Desert Civic Center, 73-510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert. Staff reports for all agenda items considered in open session, and documents provided to a majority of the legislative bodies are available for public inspection at City Hall and on the City’s website at www.palmdesert.gov. Americans with Disabilities Act: It is the intention of the City of Palm Desert to comply with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) in all respects. If, as an attendee or a participant at this meeting, or in meetings on a regular basis, you will need special assistance beyond what is normally provided, the City will attempt to accommodate you in every reasonable manner. Please contact the Office of the City Clerk, (760) 346-0611, at least 48 hours prior to the meeting to inform us of your needs and to determine if accommodation is feasible. AFFIDAVIT OF POSTING I hereby certify under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing agenda for the Palm Desert City Council was posted on the City Hall bulletin board and City website not less than 24 hours prior to the meeting. /S/ Michelle Nance Acting Assistant City Clerk City Council Meeting 3 Page 1 of 2 CITY OF PALM DESERT STAFF REPORT MEETING DATE: December 16, 2025 PREPARED BY: Richard D. Cannone, AICP, Assistant City Manager SUBJECT: CONSIDERATION OF A REQUEST FOR ACTION TO RESCIND CITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2024-038 RELATED TO LGBTQ PRIDE MONTH COMMEMORATIONS AND AMENDING CITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2018-09 RELATED TO DIVERSITY AND INCLUSION. RECOMMENDATION: 1. As requested, adopt a resolution amending Paragraph Six of City Council Resolution No. 2018-09, entitled: “A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, WELCOMING ALL WHO CHOOSE TO LIVE, WORK IN, OR VISIT OUR COMMUNITY AND AFFIRMING THE CITY OF PALM DESERT’S COMMITMENT TO UNITY, INCLUSION, AND SHARED COMMUNITY VALUES.” 2. As requested, adopt a resolution rescinding City Council Resolution NO. 2024-038, entitled: “A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, ESTABLISHING A POLICY RELATED TO LGBTQ PRIDE MONTH COMMEMORATIONS.” BACKGROUND/ANALYSIS: At the December 11, 2025, City Council meeting, the City Council requested that staff return with two action items for consideration: 1. Update Resolution No. 2018-09 to shift its emphasis from celebrating differences to celebrating the shared values that unite the community. 2. Rescind Resolution No. 2024-038 and discontinue the practice of displaying a banner on City Hall in November for Greater Palm Springs Pride. Resolution No. 2018-09 City Council Resolution No. 2018-09 was adopted on February 8, 2018, following a request from the City Council at its January 11, 2018, meeting. The resolution was intended to reinforce and affirm the City’s commitment to inclusiveness, diversity, and nondiscrimination. Resolution No. 2024-038 As a result of public comment at the May 23, 2024, City Council meeting, the City Council directed staff to explore options for recognizing Pride Month. Staff presented options to the City Council at their meeting on June 13, 2024, and the direction provided was memorialized through the adoption of Resolution No. 2024-038 on June 27, 2024. 4 City of Palm Desert City Council Requested Action on Resolutions 2018-09 & 2024-038 Page 2 of 2 Proposed Update As requested, staff has prepared the attached resolution updating Resolution No. 2018 -09. The proposed update modifies Paragraph Six to read as follows: WHEREAS, the City encourages all residents and visitors of Palm Desert to celebrate each other' s differences and learn from one another the values that unite us. FINANCIAL IMPACT: There is no financial impact related to this item. ATTACHMENTS: 1. Draft Resolution updating Resolution 2018-09 2. Draft Resolution rescinding Resolution 2024-038 3. Resolution 2018-09 4. Resolution 2024-038 5 RESOLUTION NO. 2025-____ A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, WELCOMING ALL WHO CHOOSE TO LIVE, WORK IN, OR VISIT OUR COMMUNITY AND AFFIRMING THE CITY OF PALM DESERT’S COMMITMENT TO UNITY, INCLUSION, AND SHARED COMMUNITY VALUES WHEREAS, the City of Palm Desert (" City") wants to reassure its residents and visitors that Palm Desert is a place that welcomes people of all backgrounds and cultures, celebrating diversity and inclusion; and WHEREAS, Palm Desert values all members of our community including, but not limited to, all religions, ancestries, and ethnicities as well as people of any disability, gender, sexual orientation, immigration status, or gender identity; and WHEREAS, the City will not tolerate any prejudice, racism, bigotry, hatred, bullying and violence towards any groups within our community; and WHEREAS, the City rejects any attempt to intimidate, threaten, or otherwise marginalize members of our community; and WHEREAS, the City values all residents regardless of where they are from, who they love, how they worship, how they look, their abilities, or how they vote; and WHEREAS, the City encourages all residents and visitors of Palm Desert to celebrate the values that unite us. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the City Council of the City of Palm Desert hereby affirms its commitment to promoting and nurturing a diverse, supportive, inclusive, and protective community. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Palm Desert, as follows: SECTION 1. That the foregoing Recitals are true and correct and are incorporated herein by this reference. SECTION 2. The City Council hereby makes the following statements in furtherance of the intent of this resolution:  The City recognizes, values, and will proactively work to promote diversity and inclusion within Palm Desert; and  The City will protect the rights and privileges of everyone in Palm Desert, regardless of religion, race, nationality, country of birth, immigration status, disability, gender, sexual orientation, or gender identity; and  The City does not tolerate discrimination, hate crimes, harassment, or assault; and  The City hereby rejects prejudice and bigotry in all forms, including but not limited 6 Resolution No. 2025-____ Page 2 to Islamophobia, anti- Semitism, racism, nativism, misogyny, and homophobia; and  The City will publicize its commitment to diversity in solicitations for bids, recruiting materials, committee/ commission applications, public art programs; and on its website;  The City will promote actual safety, a sense of security, and equal protection of constitutional and human rights, leading by example through equitable treatment of all by City officials and departments. SECTION 5. Resolution No. 2018-09 is hereby rescinded. ADOPTED ON __________________. EVAN TRUBEE MAYOR ATTEST: ANTHONY J. MEJIA CITY CLERK 7 Resolution No. 2025-____ Page 3 I, Anthony J. Mejia, City Clerk of the City of Palm Desert, hereby certify that Resolution No. 2025-__ is a full, true, and correct copy, and was duly adopted at a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Palm Desert on _______________________, by the following vote: AYES: NOES: ABSENT: ABSTAIN: RECUSED: IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and affixed the official seal of the City of Palm Desert, California, on ___________________. ANTHONY J. MEJIA CITY CLERK 8 RESOLUTION NO. 2025-____ A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, RECINDING RESOLUTION NO. 2024-038 ESTABLISHING A POLICY RELATED TO LGBTQ PRIDE MONTH COMMEMORATIONS WHEREAS, by Resolution No. 2024-038 adopted on June 27, 2024, City Council established a policy related to LGBTQ Pride Month; and WHEREAS, City Council now desires to rescind Resolution 2024-038 as a result of the City Council’s prior commitment under Resolution 2018-09 [or Resolution 2025- ##], to promoting and nurturing a diverse, supportive, inclusive, and protective community NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Palm Desert, as follows: SECTION 1. That the foregoing Recitals are true and correct and are incorporated herein by this reference. SECTION 2. Resolution No. 2024-038 is hereby rescinded. ADOPTED ON __________________. EVAN TRUBEE MAYOR ATTEST: ANTHONY J. MEJIA CITY CLERK 9 Resolution No. 2025-____ Page 2 I, Anthony J. Mejia, City Clerk of the City of Palm Desert, hereby certify that Resolution No. 2025-__ is a full, true, and correct copy, and was duly adopted at a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Palm Desert on _______________________, by the following vote: AYES: NOES: ABSENT: ABSTAIN: RECUSED: IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and affixed the official seal of the City of Palm Desert, California, on ___________________. ANTHONY J. MEJIA CITY CLERK 10 RESOLUTION NO. 2018-09 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, WELCOMING ALL WHO CHOOSE TO LIVE, WORK IN, OR VISIT OUR COMMUNITY AND AFFIRMING THE CITY OF PALM DESERT'S COMMITMENT TO DIVERSITY AND INCLUSION. WHEREAS, the City of Palm Desert ("City") wants to reassure its residents and visitors that Palm Desert is a place that welcomes people of all backgrounds and cultures, celebrating diversity and inclusion; and WHEREAS, Palm Desert values all members of our community including, but not limited to, all religions, ancestries, and ethnicities as well as people of any disability, gender, sexual orientation, immigration status, or gender identity; and WHEREAS, the City will not tolerate any prejudice, racism, bigotry, hatred, bullying and violence towards any groups within our community; and WHEREAS, the City rejects any attempt to intimidate, threaten, or otherwise marginalize members of our community; and WHEREAS, the City values all residents regardless of where they are from, who they love, how they worship, how they look, their abilities, or how they vote; and WHEREAS, the City encourages all residents and visitors of Palm Desert to celebrate each other's differences and learn from one another. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the City Council of the City of Palm Desert hereby affirms its commitment to promoting and nurturing a diverse, supportive, inclusive, and protective community. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the City Council of the City of Palm Desert hereby makes the following statements in furtherance of the intent of this resolution: The City recognizes, values, and will proactively work to promote diversity and inclusion within Palm Desert; and The City will protect the rights and privileges of everyone in Palm Desert, regardless of religion, race, nationality, country of birth, immigration status, disability, gender, sexual orientation, or gender identity; and The City does not tolerate discrimination, hate crimes, harassment, or assault; and The City hereby rejects prejudice and bigotry in all forms, including but not limited to Islamophobia, anti-Semitism, racism, nativism, misogyny, and homophobia; and 11 RESOLUTION NO. 2018-09 The City will publicize its commitment to diversity in solicitations for bids, recruiting materials, committee/commission applications, public art programs; and on its website; The City will promote actual safety, a sense of security, and equal protection of constitutional and human rights, leading by example through equitable treatment of all by City officials and departments. PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED by the Palm Desert City Council this 8th day of February, 2018 by the following vote, to wit: AYES: HARNIK, KELLY, NESTANDE, WEBER, and JONATHAN NOES: NONE ABSENT: NONE ABSTAIN: NONE ATTEST: RA E CE D. KLASSE`A1' CITY CLER CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNI l SABBY JO 1TI J, MAYOR 12 RESOLUTION NO. 2024-038 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, ESTABLISHING A POLICY RELATED TO LGBTQ PRIDE MONTH COMMEMORATIONS WHEREAS, the City staff sought direction provided direction on the recognition of LGBTQ Pride Month on June 13, 2024; and WHEREAS, the City of Palm Desert will issue a Proclamation for Pride Month on June 27, 2024; and WHEREAS, each May the City staff will forward a request to recognize Pride Month to Mayor and Mayor Pro Tem for consideration for recognition in June; and WHEREAS, the City staff included Pride Month in the City’s 2024 social media commemorations and recommended for future social media commemorations; and WHEREAS, the City of Palm Desert knows internationally that Pride is celebrated in June but will celebrate Pride in November due to cooler weather; and WHEREAS, upon request for participation in the Palm Springs Pride Parade, staff will circulate to Council members and staff. Those interested will be sent to participate in the event and represent the City; and WHEREAS, the City will display a banner at City Hall in November to commemorate Pride Month and coincide with local events. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Palm Desert, California, as follows: 1. As part of the City’s commitment to the City’s Diversity and Inclusion, the City recognizes, values, and will proactively work to promote diversity and inclusion within Palm Desert; and 2. The City will protect the rights and privileges of everyone in Palm Desert, regardless of religion, race, nationality, country of birth, immigration status, disability, gender, sexual orientation, or gender identity; and 3. The City will promote actual safety, a sense of security, and equal protection of constitutional and human rights, leading by example through equitable treatment of all by City officials and departments. DocuSign Envelope ID: 03CDF519-0469-48A2-8104-FBDDBE6C7FD4 13 DocuSign Envelope ID: 03CDF519-0469-48A2-8104-FBDDBE6C7FD4 Resolution No. 2024-038 ADOPTED ON JUNE 27, 2024. ATTEST: � DocuSigned by: �� J flly i0v 8063A 18972304 37 ANTHONY J. MEJIA CITY CLERK � DocuSigned by: L�?�� KARINA QUINTANILLA MAYOR Page 2 I, Anthony J. Mejia, City Clerk of the City of Palm Desert, hereby certify that Resolution No. 2024-038 is a full, true, and correct copy, and was duly adopted at a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Palm Desert on June 27, 2024, by the following vote: AYES: NOES: ABSENT: ABSTAIN: RECUSED: HARNIK, K ELLY, NESTANDE, AND QUINTANILLA TRUBEE NONE NONE NONE IN WI TNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and affixed the official seal of the 6/28/2024 City of Palm Desert, California, on _______ _In DocuSigned by: L!:=�t�; flly i0v ANTHONY J. MEJIA CITY CLERK 14 From:Dan Adams To:CityClerk Subject:Input for the City Council Date:Sunday, December 14, 2025 2:04:39 PM Today in America we woke up to the horrific news that 15 people were murdered and 40 others injured near Sydney as a father and son opened fire on a group of Jewish people who had gathered to celebrate Hanukkah. Why? As one Australian said on CBS radio, "It's because the government has allowed antisemitic speech to influence the minds of people who hate." And I thought ... that is exactly what the Palm Desert City Council is considering when they talk about Joe Pradetto's drive to stop supporting another minority group ... the LGBTQ community and its members, many of whom are Palm Desert residents. While your alleged desire to "build an inclusive community" may be admirable to some, in reality it sends a greater message that Palm Desert is no longer supportive of an oppressed group that has been increasingly targeted, not just by hate speech but by murderous acts (49 killed at Pulse Gay Nightclub in Florida). The most recent FBI statistics from 2023 show an 8.6% increase in attacks against LGBTQ individuals. Your actions, should they be carried out, merely reinforce the thoughts of some that gays and lesbians have no value in our society. And that only adds to the false legitimacy in the demented minds of some that attacks on that group are welcome, and even justified. And why not? The City of Palm Desert said so. There has been an increase in high profile assaults, murders, and hate crimes even in Palm Springs ... to the point that Palm Springs Police now must put sharpshooters on buildings and increase police presence during Pride events. I will close by adding that although I am a longtime Palm Springs resident, I and many others consider the entire Coachella Valley our home. We shop, we dine, we spend a lot of money in Palm Desert. Likewise, many LGBTQ tourists stay at resorts in Palm Desert. Should you decide to carry forth with your proposal to no longer recognize the LGBTQ community (in fact, slap the community in the face), I, for one, will discontinue spending any money there. Already, the news of what Palm Desert is considering has spread nationwide, the repercussions of which could be felt in Palm Desert for a long time to come. Daniel Adams Palm Springs, CA 92264 15 From:Matthew Sky To:City Hall Mail Cc:CityClerk Subject:Pride Statements /Palm Desert Date:Friday, December 12, 2025 10:16:05 PM Dear Palm Desert City Council, I was taken aback to read that Mayor Pedetto recently described Gay Pride as “divisive.” From my perspective, removing or diminishing recognition of Pride feels far more divisive. This raises concerns for me about what is truly behind such statements, as they do not align with my understanding of an inclusive and representative community. As a 67-year-old senior homeowner in Palm Desert, I believe our city is strongest when all residents feel seen, respected, and included. I hope that the leadership of Palm Desert, including our mayor, will continue to represent and embrace the diversity of the many people who call this community home. Sincerely, Carl Huckabay 16 From:James Jenkin To:City Hall Mail Cc:CityClerk Subject:Concern Regarding Recent Statements on Pride and Community Inclusion in Palm Desert Date:Friday, December 12, 2025 9:35:17 PM To the Palm Desert Council. I am a homeowner in South Palm Desert. It is with some irony that only a few weeks ago I was reflecting on how grateful I am to be in a community that has been openly welcoming and inclusive, including through the Council’s visible support for Pride. I was, in fact, considering writing to thank the Council for that signage, which I felt sent an important and affirming message. I was therefore deeply disappointed to hear recent comments by Mr. Mayor Pro Tim Joe Pedetto suggesting that celebrating Pride is “divisive”. This framing fundamentally misunderstands why Pride exists. Pride is not about division; it is about visibility, safety, and affirmation for people who have historically been marginalized, excluded, or made to feel unwelcome in many parts of the world and, unfortunately, still are. It is deeply troubling to see this issue being politicized in this way in our community. Statements like these risk sending a genuinely harmful message, particularly to LGBTQ+ young people, for whom visibility and acceptance are not abstract concepts, but factors that can directly affect mental health and wellbeing. The statistics around suicide and self-harm among LGBTQ+ youth are well documented and sobering. One has to wonder whether Mr. Pedetto is even aware of them. At the very least, his comments suggest a lack of understanding of what it means to belong to a marginalized community, one that continues to face violence, ridicule, and threats, and an apparent unwillingness to engage with that reality. I strongly urge the Council to consider the real-world impact of withdrawing or diminishing visible support for Pride. Inclusion is not performative, it is protective. Symbols matter, especially to those who are still unsure whether they belong. I hope the Council will reaffirm its commitment to an inclusive community and reject efforts to frame equality and recognition as somehow inappropriate or unnecessary. Respectfully, James Jenkin 17 From:City of Palm Desert To:City Hall Mail Subject:Resolution 2018-09 / Resolution 24-038 Date:Friday, December 12, 2025 3:55:35 PM Message submitted from the <City of Palm Desert> website. Site Visitor Name: Ron Noriega Site Visitor Email: What gives with resolution 2018-09 / 24-038? Is this really a problem? Nothing wrong with recognizing your LGBT plus community. We are also resident of Palm Desert. Please Respond, Ron Noriega 18 From:Patrick Flaherty To:City Hall Mail Subject:Anti Pride Month Resolution Date:Friday, December 12, 2025 6:06:47 PM Mayor Pro Tem Pradetto’s effort to unrecognize Pride month is horrible and advanced on false pretenses. What is next, Latino heritage or blacks? What problem is he solving or how is he making Palm Desert better? He is a MAGA bigot pure and simple. As long as he has anything to do with the city, we will not spend a dime there, we will tell our friends, we will fund his opponents, and we will tell every business there that we used to frequent exactly why. Leave him on the dustbin of history where he belongs. Patrick Flaherty (via mobile device) 19 From:Ian Kelly To:City Hall Mail; Evan Trubee; Joe Pradetto; Karina Quintanilla; Gina Nestande; Jan Harnik Subject:The Importance of Continuing to Celebrate Pride Month in Our City Date:Friday, December 12, 2025 6:55:08 PM Dear Mayor and Members of the City Council, I am writing as a resident of Palm Desert to express my strong support for the continued recognition and celebration of Pride Month. Pride is not merely a symbolic observance— it is a meaningful affirmation of inclusion, safety, and dignity for LGBTQ+ residents who are part of the fabric of our community. Pride Month exists because LGBTQ+ people have historically faced—and in many cases still face—discrimination, violence, and exclusion. Public acknowledgment by the city sends a powerful message that all residents are valued and protected. When a city chooses to celebrate Pride, it communicates that it stands for fairness, equal treatment, and human rights, not just in words but in action. Celebrating Pride also benefits the city as a whole. Inclusive communities are stronger, healthier, and more economically vibrant. Pride events support local businesses, encourage tourism, and foster a sense of belonging that attracts residents and visitors alike. Cities known for inclusivity are better positioned to grow, innovate, and thrive. Equally important is the impact Pride has on young people and families. For LGBTQ+ youth—and for those still discovering who they are—seeing their city openly celebrate Pride can be life-affirming. It can reduce isolation, improve mental health outcomes, and quite literally save lives by showing that they are not alone and that their community supports them. Recognizing Pride Month does not diminish anyone else’s values or beliefs. Rather, it reflects a commitment to ensuring that everyone, regardless of sexual orientation or gender identity, can live openly and safely. Pride is about visibility, respect, and the freedom to exist without fear. I urge you to continue supporting and celebrating Pride Month in Palm Desert. Doing so demonstrates leadership, compassion, and a commitment to equality that reflects the best of who we are as a community. Thank you for your time and for your service to Palm Desert. Sincerely, 20 Kelly Ian Kelly     , PD 92260 21 From:Debbie To:City Hall Mail Subject:Pride Date:Friday, December 12, 2025 8:30:48 PM Dear Mayor Pro Tem Pradetto I am writing to respectfully express my opposition to your decision to discontinue acknowledging Pride on the grounds that recognizing one community over another creates division rather than unity. Acknowledging Pride does not elevate one group above others; it recognizes a community that has historically faced exclusion, discrimination, and marginalization. Public acknowledgment is not about special treatment, but about visibility, dignity, and affirming that all residents belong. Unity is not achieved by treating unequal experiences as though they are the same, but by recognizing those differences and responding with inclusion. Pride acknowledgment does not exclude other communities; instead it has communicated that our city values fairness, respect, and the safety of all its residents. Eliminating this recognition sends the opposite message—that the unique challenges faced by LGBTQ+ residents are no longer worthy of acknowledgment. For many, this decision feels less like neutrality and more like erasure. True unity is not created by silence. It is built through understanding, empathy, and a willingness to publicly affirm that every community matters. A city can honor many groups throughout the year without diminishing any of them, and doing so strengthens—not weakens —the social fabric. I urge the city to reconsider this decision and to continue acknowledging Pride as a reflection of our shared commitment to inclusion, equity, and respect for all who call this city home. Thank you for your time and consideration. Debbie Midcalf 22 From:Samantha Shapiro To:City Hall Mail Subject:Concerned citizen writing about NBC Palm Springs Article and recognizing the LGBT+Pride Month Date:Friday, December 12, 2025 11:00:12 PM Good evening, I am a concerned resident of Palm Desert. Although I am not not LGBT+, I would like for the City Council and Mayor Pro Tem to continue allowing Palm Desert to display a banner in support of the LGBTQ+ community. https://www.nbcpalmsprings.com/2025/12/12/palm-desert-council-considers-rescinding-lgbtq- pride-month-recognition We should recognize LGBTQ+ Pride Month along with our sister cities like Palm Springs and support our thriving communities. It would be wise to not alienate our community, residents, and visitors. If the main goal is for all community members to be treated equally, it is okay to still support communities that have historically been unwelcomed, be better than our past, and welcome them as we would for any other community member. From, Samantha Shapiro Palm Desert 23 From:Wendy LaCapra To:City Hall Mail Subject:Rescinding Pride Date:Saturday, December 13, 2025 7:27:27 AM While I’m a resident of Palm Springs, I shop in Palm Desert, am a member of the Zoo, and frequently attend and support community events. Using the excuse of “unity” to rescind recognition of a group targeted for violence & discrimination in many parts of the world sends a chilling message. While certain groups may not be comfortable embracing all lifestyles, sending a message by supporting pride month is telling people who are subjected to violence elsewhere that they are safe to live, shop, and visit your community. Rescinding it is a deliberate notice of the opposite and will negatively effect business. Seeing a pride banner might make some people uncomfortable, but changing course will indicate hostility toward others. For the record, I am straight & Christian, but deeply concerned for those who are marginalized. Thank you, Wendy La Capra 24 From:Martins Gayming and Such Channel To:City Hall Mail Subject:Shame on you Date:Saturday, December 13, 2025 7:59:59 AM I am writing this to let you know that this proposal concerning erasing the gay flag & your association with Palm Springs Gay Pride will not stand. We will not stand by while you push trumps anti gay agenda. If this passes just know that we the gay community and our allies will protest and make DP hurt financially. And seeing our history as a force you know what we can do. Do what is right. 25 From:Steve Smelser To:City Hall Mail Subject:Higher Ground Date:Saturday, December 13, 2025 8:23:19 AM Thank you Joe for taking the intelligent high ground. As a resident of Palm Desert, I'm looking forward to your term. Keep Palm Desert evolving . Appliance Angels Appliance Service Expert Appliance Repairs Palm Desert 760-360p-44455 26 From:Joanne Kleveland To:City Hall Mail Subject:Palm Desert should continue to recognize Pride Month Date:Friday, December 12, 2025 2:38:50 PM We live in a unique valley and the LGBTQ+ community has felt welcome. We need to make sure they continue to feel welcome. With the current national administration scaring off our Canadian friends, we actually NEED to make sure LGBTQ+ friends WANT to be spending time in our valley. Not only is it the right thing to do as a humane city, but it's also fiscally responsible. Pride Month is one way we do this. Do not make the huge mistake of ending this. Joanne Kleveland Palm Desert 27 From:Joseph M To:City Hall Mail; Evan Trubee; Joe Pradetto; Karina Quintanilla; Gina Nestande; Jan Harnik Subject:Pride Date:Friday, December 12, 2025 3:36:55 PM Hello! I'm a resident of nearby Rancho Mirage--which means I spend a great deal of time (AND MONEY) in Palm Desert. I love your city. Please don't give into the current wave of homophobia and eliminate Pride from your City. It makes zero sense. It will only cause further division. Diversity is what makes our nation great, California great, and the Coachella Valley such a great place to live. Symbolically stepping away from something as harmless as Pride is unnecessary. It's hurtful. It's divisive. You might not know the feeling of being called slurs or the feeling of being in actual physical danger because of something as simple as whom you love...but it's a feeling I know all too well. You don't know the feeling of knowing if you clasp the hand of your spouse on a sidewalk, you could be harassed, even assaulted. Have some empathy and compassion. Maintain your City as a safe space. It's not only the decent thing to do, it's the financially prudent thing to do. Our community has enormous spending power, at a time when keeping restaurants and shops open, it's a curious time to create trouble for small business owners. Joseph Mullins 28 From:Lesnix To:City Hall Mail Subject:Anti Gay Pride Proposal Date:Friday, December 12, 2025 2:08:57 PM To Whom it May Concern: I was horrified to today to read of the proposal by Palm Desert City Council to ban participation, recognition of Gay Pride and the banning of the flag. While I live in Palm Springs and not Palm Desert I do an enormous of shopping in Palm Desert. If this proposal is put in place I will not spend a penny in Palm Desert and will work hard to ensure that no one else does the same. There is no room for hate like this and certainly not in this valley. I am disgusted and need you to know there will be severe consequences if you go ahead with this hateful proposal. I know in America these days hate has become more acceptable but it will not be tolerated especially here. I hope you will do the right thing but if you don't we will respond in huge numbers against it. I am sicken this is even being discussed. Sincerely, Jeffrey Lesser Palm Springs 29 From:sean@seantharrington.com To:City Hall Mail Subject:Constituent feedback: Nestande, cc: Pradetto Date:Saturday, December 13, 2025 8:36:34 AM Dear Councilwoman Nestande I’m exceptionally troubled to learn of Mayor Pro Tem Pradetto’s proposal to end the City’s recognition of Pride Month. This proposal suggests the City’s inclusive and welcoming nature is up for debate. My husband and I selected Palm Desert as our home in 2024 in large part to how we felt we would be treated as gay people. That Palm Desert is diverse and inclusive. Until now, we found Palm Desert to welcome us. I think the Mayor Pro Tem has signaled exactly how he feels about gay people and how Plam Desert should, in his estimation, treat gay people. Gay people are adept at reading between the lines. This measure isn’t about making the City less political - it’s about elevating a decisive - and hurtful - social issue that has become a political hot button. We are not Huntington Beach. Let’s not do this. Of all the matters before Council - is this truly something we want to do? Do we want to invite local, regional, and national scrutiny instead of inviting a diverse group of residents, taxpayers, businesses, and tourists? Please vote no on this hurtful initiative. Sean Harrington 30 From:Keith Coleman To:City Hall Mail Subject:Mayor Pro Tem Pradetto Date:Saturday, December 13, 2025 8:53:15 AM Dear Mayor and Councilmembers, Palm Desert Mayor Pro Tem Pradetto has mistakenly taken the position that erasing the gay community and the recognition of its existence and contributions is a good way to unite the city. What he is suggesting will have the exact opposite effect. It comes from the false pretense that we shouldn't be divided into groups, while he defends and promotes only one type of family and community members to support. That is the definition of division. Should we also not recognize other groups that don't fit into his profile of what we all are in our differences as human beings? With his misguided logic, let's cancel the golf cart parade and its "culture" for those of us who aren't into that "lifestyle" or ignore the religious charities that the majority of the city aren't associated or may not agree with? Shall we not recognize the Holocaust that decimated millions of Jews, gays and other outcast members of our society because it doesn't include him? In order to promote UNITY we need to be concentrating on recognizing and celebrating our differences and be united by being aware of who we are as a wide range of human beings. The gay community makes up a large group of people who also pay taxes, work on campaigns to make the city better and give back to our culture in many other ways. The fact that they are shunned, discriminated against (which he claims is a fallacy) and demeaned by many gives more reason for the city to educate others on their contributions to its success. It will be a sad day when we no longer recognize the struggles of gay people who live and work here. If a rainbow flag triggers him in any way he should not be representing us in government. His one-sided agenda will only be an excuse for more hatred and discrimination. He should be reprimanded for his position of bigotry and further divisiveness. This makes Palm Desert look no better than a hate-filled island where you are not allowed to be different. Many will no longer wish to work or shop there because they won't feel welcome any longer. I am appalled along with many others by Pradetto's narrow minded ignorance under the guise of bringing us together. In the end, it will have the exact opposite effect. Keith Coleman, 40 year valley resident. 31 From:jvdpdx@aol.com To:Joe Pradetto; Evan Trubee; KQuinanilla@palmdesert.gov; Gina Nestande; Jan Harnik Cc:City Hall Mail; ceo@pdacc.org Subject:Proposed cancellation of Pride Date:Saturday, December 13, 2025 8:59:32 AM Dear Palm Desert City Council: Councilor Pradetto has suggested Palm Desert drop its recognition of Pride Month, ban the Pride Flag at City Hall and drop its participation in Palm Springs Pride. He did so under the guise that such events "elevate" one group over another. Because nothing can be further from the truth, I write to express my opposition and to detail what actions I and other LGBTQ residents in the Coachella Valley will do if this is adopted. The Councilor appears to forget Pride began as a protest because LGBTQ residents were not treated equally as heterosexual residents. Do you believe true equality now exists? Do you believe hate crimes against the LGBTQ community no longer exist? Do you believe discrimination in everyday life has ceased to exist? Do you believe teenagers no longer scream "faggot" out their car windows when we walk by? Have you not seen the attempts by states to roll back marriage equality and to challenge current marriage equality in the Supreme Court? Have you seen similar attempts to roll back heterosexual marriage? Have you not seen hateful attacks on the trans community? (I know its fashionable in some quarters to do so. Do you agree with that?). Do you believe parents no longer reject their children when they come out as gay? Do you not see religions condemning us as "sinners"? Have you seen nationwide statistics for homeless LGBTQ youth? (A simple Google search will tell you that LGBTQ individuals are about 4.5% of the general population, they can be 20- 45% of the homeless youth population.). Why do you think that is? Because we are "equal"? How do you think such an action will be viewed in your business community: As promoting "equality"? Far from "elevating" one community over another, recognition of Pride is actually the recognition that discrimination still exists against the LGBTQ community in ways that doesn't affect other members of our society. Instead, it is an action that recognizes we still are not "equal", that I do not have the same "personal liberty" as others and that perhaps, just perhaps, the government might be sympathetic to our situation. Saying a form of "I can do this because some of my best friends are gay and I've even performed marriage ceremonies for them" while simultaneously siding with those who discriminate against us is not particularly persuasive. Yesterday, I had a delightful time shopping and dining on El Paseo. I will not be doing that in the future if Palm Desert puts out a message in support of those who 32 discriminate against me. Because that is how such an action will be perceived in the community at large. Is that the type of message you want to send? You can dress up "neutrality" language however you want, but putting lipstick on a pig never works. I suspect others will join me in such a protest. Sincerely, James H Van Dyke 33 From:GARY MICHAELS To:City Hall Mail Subject:Shocking news. Date:Saturday, December 13, 2025 9:13:13 AM To the Palm Desert City Council, We cannot tell you how saddened we are to be hearing the news stories that the Mayor is proposing recognizing pride month. We’ve recently evacuated the State of Florida and moved to Coachella Valley because of its inclusiveness and commitment to treating all residents with respect and dignity. It has surprised us how often and how many people we meet who have evacuated and left Florida for its toxicity towards the community. We have been so moved with how kind , considerate and caring everyone is in the Valley. We love Palm Desert and we love the shopping your community offers. Often coming to shop there each week or so. We were so looking forward to coming this Wednesday to do our Christmas shopping in downtown Palm Desert. Now we do not feel welcomed and have concerns with the political Direction your Coty is considering embarking on. Today has been a day of text and phone calls from so many in the community with disbelief and heartwrenching feelings. I feel you are strongly going down a wrong path and the victims will be the businesses that are so supported by such a large community with large disposable incomes. Please do not let the Mayor take you down such a cruel path. Thank you. Mark Lee and Gary Michaels. Cell Ps - If any council member would agree. I would love to meet personally or discuss on the phone. Thx you Sent from my iPhone 34 From:georgercovino To:City Hall Mail Cc:mark Subject:Resolution 24-38 Date:Saturday, December 13, 2025 11:10:04 AM While I am not a Palm Desert resident, should the city council decide to adopt the proposal to discontinue the display of banners, including the Pride Flag at City Hall, I will immediately boycott all Palm Desert businesses and encourage my friends to do the same. As a Palm Springs resident, I support businesses and restaurants throughout the valley that actively demonstrate and support equity and inclusion. At this fraught time in our country’s history, we don’t need local governments erasing gay visibility. Thank you for your consideration. George Covino Palm Springs 35 From:Carol Manners To:City Hall Mail Subject:Joe Pradetto remove flags Date:Saturday, December 13, 2025 11:12:06 AM Greetings Joe! Just saw you on the local news and my husband and I totally agree with your stance on removing the gay flags from government buildings. Your wording in the reason why the flags should be removed is 100 % correct. We live in Bermuda Dunes but support you 100% and if we can help, please let us know. Thank you for standing up for what is right and best for the community. Carol and Stanley Manners Bermuda Dunes, CA 92203 Sent from my iPhone 36 From:Brian Luke To:City Hall Mail Cc:p_consoli; Brian Luke Subject:Palm Desert Mayor Pro Tem Predetto"s anti-LGBTQ, anti-diversity proposal, request and revisit Date:Saturday, December 13, 2025 11:24:08 AM TO: Evan Trubee, Mayor Joe Predetto, Mayor Pro Tem Karina Quintanilla, Councilmmember Gina Nestande, Councilmember Jan Harnik, Councilmember I read with dismay Mayor Pro Tem Joe Predetto’s proposal to remove the display of Pride flag at Palm Desert City Hall, his request to rescind Resolution 24-38 which formally established how Palm Desert recognizes LGBTQ Month and “revisit” Resolution 2018-19, Palm Desert’s diversity and inclusion resolution approved in 2018. I can think of no other reason Mr. Predetto wants action on these items other than wanting to align Palm Desert with a pro-Trump MAGA agenda. It is an unfortunate mindset that will paint Palm Desert as an unwelcoming place to not only the LGBTQ community, but to any community that is not White. My husband and I own a home in Palm Springs. We spend half the year in the Coachella Valley. Until now, we make the trip to Palm Desert once a week to shop on El Paseo, eat lunch at Il Sogno, visit The Living Desert Zoo and Gardens, shop for clothing at Palm Desert Mall, purchase plants at Moller’s Garden Center, shop at Whole Foods. We take the time to make the drive because we feel welcome. That said, Palm Desert isn’t our only choice for these activities. If any of Mayor Pro Tem Predetto’s items are approved by the Palm Desert City Council, my husband and I will not spend another nickle in Palm Desert. I will also encourage our large circle of friends in the Valley to do the same. This isn’t a threat; it’s a fact. Why would I spend my hard earned money in a place that doesn’t value me? Sincerely, Brian Luke 37 From:Rob To:City Hall Mail Subject:Opposition to Pradetto"s Proposals Date:Saturday, December 13, 2025 11:37:40 AM Dear Mayor Trubee, I am writing to express my strong opposition to Councilmember Joe Pradetto's proposal to discontinue the city's recognition of Pride Month, ban the Pride Flag at City Hall, and remove the city’s participation in Palm Springs Pride. The actions outlined in this proposal would be a step backward in fostering an inclusive, respectful community. Pride Month and the Pride Flag represent vital symbols of visibility, support, and equality for the LGBTQ+ community. The city’s participation in Palm Springs Pride has demonstrated our commitment to embracing diversity and ensuring all residents feel valued and heard. The proposed changes would send the harmful message that our city is not fully supportive of its LGBTQ+ residents, which is contrary to the values of equality and respect that our community should uphold. I urge you to stand against this proposal and continue to promote inclusivity, acceptance, and unity in our city. Thank you for considering my concerns. I look forward to your leadership in maintaining a city that celebrates diversity and stands for equal rights for all. Sincerely, Robert S. Nowie Palm Desert, CA 92260 38 From:David Wolgin To:City Hall Mail; Evan Trubee; Joe Pradetto; Karina Quintanilla; Gina Nestande; Jan Harnik Subject:PLEASE READ - COMMENT FROM LOCAL RESIDENT Date:Saturday, December 13, 2025 11:46:16 AM I am writing to express my surprise, my outrage, and my overall concern about the recent news report identifying Joe Pradetto's proposal to drop Palm Desert's participation in Palm Springs Pride, to ban the Pride Flag at Palm Desert City Hall, and to drop recognition of Pride Month itself. How short-sighted, offensive, and "off the mark" can you be? I urge you to re-examine this issue and to consider landing on the side of respect for the local community, acceptance of diversity, and support for marginalized communities. There is ABSOLUTELY NO HARM in acknowledging the vulnerabilities of a marginalized community and expressing your support publicly. Any disagreement of this idea is most assuredly grounded in personal greed and political ideology, and NOT grounded in the interests of the people at large. HEED THIS WARNING: If you do not recognize this feedback from the community and if you do NOT abandon this proposal, I GUARANTEE that you will see an enormous backlash that will cost you and your city greatly. One prediction of these costs is that you will lose favor immediately and see a drop in the likelihood of being re-elected. Another prediction of this cost will be financial. If you want your city to thrive, you will probably want to avoid endorsing this homophobic, close-minded proposal and, instead, protect and defend the importance of Pride Month. If you do not, you will lose favor ACROSS THE NATION, and you will lose enormous sums of money, as people learn of your hateful politics and decide to purchase homes elsewhere and spend their recreational dollars in municipalities that promote respect and acceptance. Be better. Be on the right side of history. Love thy neighbor. Do unto others as you would have done to you. Think of your gay family members. Think of your daughters. Think of your sons. Think of your relatives. Think of your friends. And if you have it in you, think of those whom you have not yet met, for they, too, look upon you as community leaders whose job it is to champion these causes of love and respect. Make policies that reflect these values. Lead us toward the light, not the darkness. Sincerely, David M. Wolgin, Ph.D. Licensed Psychologist and Palm Springs Resident 39 From:Harold Katkov To:joe@joepradetto.com Cc:City Hall Mail Subject:The Pride Flag at Palm Desert City Hall Must Fly Date:Saturday, December 13, 2025 12:36:10 PM I’m a 68-year-old gay man living in Palm Desert. In seven decades on the planet, I’ve experienced my share of homophobia and marginalization. Why I’m writing Mayor Pro Tem Joe Perdetto and the Palm Desert City Council today Palm Desert's Mayor Pro Tem, Joe Perdetto, wants to stop flying the Pride flag at City Hall, claiming the LGBTQ+ community is “integrated enough” (his words). He says the flag creates division rather than unity, and needs to come down. Oh, Joe, No! The idea of a 28-year-old White, straight man proclaiming the LGBTQ+ community is “integrated enough” is ridiculous… inaccurate… and offensive. Joe's "conclusion" would be laughable if it weren’t so untrue and repugnant. Hate crimes are SIGNIFICANTLY UP. Thus, Joe's ridiculous statement of "enough" integration is categorically untrue. Here’s what’s REALLY needed, Joe and Palm Desert City Council Everybody needs inclusion, diversity, dignity and respect from their community and community government. Not just gay people; EVERYBODY. Flying the Pride flag at Palm Desert City Hall fosters all that, and more. That’s why it’s needed. Here’s what’s going to happen, Joe and Palm Desert City Council Thousands of gay people in the Coachella Valley – and the whole USA – are going to message Joe and Palm Desert City Council about this issue. And share their thoughts all over social media. Not just gay people… but also, the thousands of wonderful straight people that support human rights and inclusion for everybody. The Pride Flag needs to fly at Palm Desert City Hall. Period. Full stop. The resistance to the Mayor’s and City Council’s homophobia… is just beginning. Hal Katkov 40 41 From:Douglas Cook To:City Hall Mail Subject:Resolution 24-038 Date:Saturday, December 13, 2025 1:33:30 PM Dear Mayor and Members of the City Council, I am writing to express my strong support for maintaining Resolution 24-038 and to respectfully urge the Council not to repeal it. Palm Desert has long been a community that draws people from across the country (retirees, families, professionals, visitors, and those seeking a place where they feel safe, welcomed, and valued). For LGBTQ residents and visitors in particular, visible gestures such as acknowledging Pride Month or flying a banner carry real meaning. They send a simple and powerful message: you are welcome here. At a time when LGBTQ people face increased hostility and discrimination in many parts of the United States, these gestures are not divisive. They are reassuring. They do not elevate one group over others; they affirm that Palm Desert is a place where everyone belongs. Beyond values, there is also a practical and economic dimension to this issue. Communities that are perceived as inclusive and welcoming tend to attract visitors, residents, and investment. Palm Desert benefits when people want to come here—whether to vacation, to purchase property, or to make this city their home. Conversely, removing visible signs of inclusion risks sending the opposite message at a moment when our region is already navigating economic uncertainty, a softening real estate market, and growing competition from other destinations. Resolution 24-038 was adopted unanimously by the City Council. Repealing it just a year and a half later would signal instability and retreat, rather than unity. It risks conveying that Palm Desert’s commitment to inclusion is conditional or subject to shifting national political trends. That perception would not serve the City well. Palm Desert is home to a significant LGBTQ population, even if it is less visible than in neighboring cities. Those residents are business owners, professionals, taxpayers, volunteers, and neighbors. They contribute to the social and economic vitality of this community every day. Maintaining Resolution 24-038 affirms that they are seen, respected, and valued. I respectfully ask the Council to stand by its prior unanimous decision and to continue sending a clear, welcoming message about who we are as a city. Inclusion strengthens communities. It does not divide them. Thank you for your time, your service, and your thoughtful consideration of this issue. Sincerely, Douglas E. Cook, PhD, CPA , Palm Desert, CA 92260 42 cell 43 From:City of Palm Desert To:City Hall Mail Subject:Palm Desert must continue to recognize Pride Month Date:Saturday, December 13, 2025 2:21:19 PM Message submitted from the <City of Palm Desert> website. Site Visitor Name: Diane Warren Site Visitor Email: Dear Mr Pradetto, As a resident of Palm Desert, I am writing to express my absolute opposition to your proposal that the city rescind its recognition of Pride Month. The federal government and the governments of many states and localities are actively working to erase LGBTQ+ citizens. This erasure includes their autonomy, their potential for self-determination, their histories, and their participation in private and civic life. Against this backdrop, your proposal is particularly alarming. It is disingenuous to frame your proposal as based in “personal liberty, government neutrality.” As Elie Wiesel famously noted, "Neutrality helps the oppressor, never the victim. Silence encourages the tormentor, never the tormented.” Palm Desert must continue to overtly and unequivocally support its LGBTQ+ residents by recognizing Pride Month. Instead of upending the city’s history of support for its LGBTQ+ residents and visitors, please take this opportunity to thoughtfully reaffirm it. Sincerely, Diane Warren Palm Desert 44 45 From:Earthlink mail To:City Hall Mail Subject:Pradetto Proposal Date:Sunday, December 14, 2025 7:06:47 AM Palm Desert City Council ... I do not agree with changing LGBT recognition unless the full spectrum of recognition is changed... Black History month, Hispanic Heritage month... etc... wipe it all out or leave the current recognition programs as it.... The council should focus on reducing cost and taxes and making living in Palm Desert affordable... especially for Seniors. Michael Bimmer 46 From:City of Palm Desert To:City Hall Mail Subject:City of Palm Desert’s continued support of Pride Month and Maintaining a Commitment to Diversity Date:Sunday, December 14, 2025 8:40:17 AM Message submitted from the <City of Palm Desert> website. Site Visitor Name: Janet Haire Site Visitor Email: Janet Haire Palm Desert, CA 92260 Dear Mayor, I am writing to express my strong opposition to Councilmember Joe Pradetto's proposal to discontinue the city's recognition of Pride Month, ban the Pride Flag at City Hall, and remove the city’s participation in Palm Springs Pride. The actions outlined in this proposal would be a step backward in fostering an inclusive, respectful community. Pride Month and the Pride Flag represent vital symbols of visibility, support, and equality for the LGBTQ+ community. The city’s participation in Palm Springs Pride has demonstrated our commitment to embracing diversity and ensuring all residents feel valued and heard. I have been a 10+ year resident of Palm Desert and love this community. I not only live here, but I shop here and support the community. Palm Desert is known for its unique shopping opportunities such as El Paseo Shopping District, our local mall - The Shops at Palm Desert and stores like Costco. Many of the surrounding communities do not have these shopping opportunities and people come from all over the Coachella Valley to spend money in Palm Desert. I’m hearing from many of my friends in Palm Springs, Cathedral City, Rancho Mirage, and LaQuinta, to name a few, that they will no longer shop here if the City of Palm Desert drops its pledge to diversity. I hope City Council thinks long and hard about this decision as I would hate for the City to lose all this revenue….as it would hurt all of us in this wonderful community. Thank you for your consideration. I look forward to your leadership in maintaining a city that celebrates diversity and stands for equal rights for all. Sincerely, Janet Janet Haire Palm Desert, CA 92260 47 48 From:michael boytim To:City Hall Mail Subject:Pride Date:Sunday, December 14, 2025 8:57:30 AM Hello I just read an alarming fact that you as mayor decided to limit the LGBTQ display of the Pride Flag in Palm Desert. I just want to try to understand why you want to curtail something that we in the gay community fought so hard for over many years to be recognized and not treated as second class citizens. We pay taxes and visit a variety of merchants and restaurants in your area to support your community. I find this despicable that as a young man you’ve adopted such narrow mindedness and further create divisions within the community. I think your leadership style is deplorable and need to reconsider your decision which may affect failure at any future prospects in politics. We are a strong community with many connections which affect change. It is sad to hear that this perceived bigotry attitude exists in the progressive Coachella Valley, which I love so much. Michael Boytim Palm Springs CA 92262 Sent from my iPhone 49 From:City of Palm Desert To:City Hall Mail Subject:Palm Desert LGBTQ Pride Recognition Policies Date:Sunday, December 14, 2025 10:56:14 AM Message submitted from the <City of Palm Desert> website. Site Visitor Name: Keith Nielsen Site Visitor Email: Dear Sir, (I am using that title out of respect, not that you have earned it) What makes you think you need to, or have the right to, rescind a responsible and successful policy of inclusion? I will make every effort to find a public demonstration against this condemnable action so I can spend every moment that I can to speak out against your outrageous action against the rights of US citizens. Stay near your phone. The Cheeto Face Idiot that happens to reside in the White House, what is left of it after his horrific destruction of part of it, will certainly be contacting you any minute now to offer you a position on his staff. Keith D. Nielsen No longer able to fly the US flag at my house for fear of that being considered support for that fool. 50 From:robbie boswell To:City Hall Mail Subject:Homophobia Date:Sunday, December 14, 2025 1:11:26 PM You must be a Trumper oh no. You need to go. ‍‍‍‍‍‍‍‍‍ 51 From:Jason Levine To:City Hall Mail; Evan Trubee; Joe Pradetto; Karina Quintanilla; Gina Nestande; Jan Harnik Subject:My Opposition toMayor Pro Tem Joe Pradetto Date:Sunday, December 14, 2025 1:19:29 PM To Whom It May Concern: I am angry that Mr. Pradetto is hiding his bias behind the veneer of fairness for all. His suggestion that the city should cease all official recognition of Pride Month in June and no longer display the Pride banner are evidence of the attempt to make these communities feel invisible. Young people who are marginalized need to see that they are accepted by the majority. All we need do is look at the substance use and suicide rate in these communities and compare them with the general population to see that life is more difficult when you feel that you are not accepted. This lack of acceptance continues into the present day whether or not Mr. Pradetto thinks so or not. Do not support this attempt to continue marginalization of these communities. Sincerely, Jason Levine, Ph.D Sent from my iPhone. Please excuse any misspellings. 52 From:Sutter and Weber To:City Hall Mail Subject:You are a disgrace Date:Sunday, December 14, 2025 6:33:32 PM Mr. Pradetto- You are an absolute disgrace to MY city. We have never been politically active, but I assure you we will actively support your recall from office. Please don’t offer a fake apology- you have no place in our city. MOVE! Chuck Sutter and Bob Weber, Palm Desert Sent from my iPhone 53 From:Paul Messink To:City Hall Mail Subject:Next council meeting Date:Sunday, December 14, 2025 9:33:18 PM Hi Gina I live in your district in PD. I’m very disappointed at the current effort to implement what sounds like “Don’t say Gay Lite” here in PD. As a gay couple, my husband and I have never felt unwelcome here but we don’t like the direction this is going. I’m hoping I can speak at the upcoming session when this will be discussed. Can you tell me when that will be, and if I need to register in advance in order to speak to this issue? Paul Messink 54 From:Kevin McMahon To:alisa@pdacc.org; Thomas Soule Cc:City Hall Mail; Evan Trubee; Joe Pradetto; Karina Quintanilla; Gina Nestande; Jan Harnik Subject:Stop Council Member Pradetto"s proposal Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 8:07:10 AM Dear Palm Desert Chamber of Commerce and El Paseo Business Improvement District, While I don’t live in Palm Desert, I often shop and attend cultural events at the McCallum and other venues there. I saw on the news and read in the paper that Palm Desert City Council Member Joe Pradetto has proposed that Palm Desert drop its recognition of Pride Month and suggested other official erasures of LGBTQ community recognition. This insulting and frankly hurtful action is a scar on your city, and I don’t think it reflects the heart of your business community or the residents of Palm Desert. I urge you to use your considerable influence to discourage this from moving forward. We have many options for shopping, dining, and attending events in the valley. If Palm Desert moves forward with this, I will only drive through Palm Desert to get to somewhere else, and I know many others who will follow suit. Thank you, Kevin McMahon Kevin McMahon Palm Springs, CA 92264 www.kevin-mcmahon.com 55 From:Oli Lamb To:City Hall Mail Subject:Email for Council Member Quintanilla Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 8:11:22 AM ‌ Dear Councilmember Quintanilla, I am writing to you today specifically as a resident living within your district in Palm Desert, and as a gay man, to urge you to oppose the recent proposal introduced by Mayor Pro Tem Pradetto regarding the City’s recognition of Pride Month. I chose to live here because I love the community we have built. One of my greatest joys is the diversity that surrounds us in this district; I get to speak Spanish every day with my neighbors, learning their history and sharing in their culture. I celebrate the rich tapestry that countless groups have built here in Palm Desert. That tapestry is amazing precisely because of its different strands, not in spite of them. This is why the suggestion that recognizing Pride "elevates one group over another" feels like a fundamental misunderstanding of what makes our city strong. When we highlight a specific strand of that tapestry—whether it be through Hispanic Heritage Month or Pride Month—we are not saying that strand is superior to the rest. We are acknowledging that it is an essential part of the whole. For a gay resident, seeing the Pride banner is an assurance that we are safe and valued members of this community alongside our neighbors. While I understand the argument that this proposal aims to foster unity, I believe it has unfortunately achieved the opposite. Instead of creating a sense of fairness, the mere introduction of this proposal has sparked significant division. One need only look at the comments sections of recent news stories to see that this debate has fueled a cycle of anti- LGBT sentiment, leaving many of us feeling less safe and less welcome in the very district of Palm Desert you represent. I also want to highlight the significant economic risk this proposal poses. Palm Desert benefits immensely from being part of the Coachella Valley, a region globally recognized as a welcoming destination for the LGBTQ+ community. If Palm Desert distinguishes itself as the one city stepping back from inclusivity, we risk alienating a loyal customer base and harming our local businesses. I respectfully ask that you vote against this proposal. Please help ensure that Palm Desert remains a city that leads with inclusion, celebrating every strand of the tapestry that makes us who we are. Thank you for your time, for your service to our city and for your representation. Se lo agradezco mucho. Sincerely, Oliver Lamb 56 From:Diane Warren To:City Hall Mail Subject:please oppose Prodetto’s attempt to rescind Pride Month recognition Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 8:20:09 AM Dear Ms Quintanilla, As a resident of Palm Desert City Council District 1, I am writing to urge your strong opposition to Mayor Pro Tem Prodetto’s proposal that the city rescind its recognition of Pride Month. The federal government and the governments of many states and localities are actively working to erase LGBTQ+ citizens. This erasure includes their autonomy, their potential for self-determination, their histories, and their participation in private and civic life. Against this backdrop, Prodetto’s proposal is particularly alarming. It is disingenuous for Prodetto to frame his proposal as based in “personal liberty, government neutrality.” As Elie Wiesel famously noted, "Neutrality helps the oppressor, never the victim. Silence encourages the tormentor, never the tormented.” Palm Desert must continue to overtly and unequivocally support its LGBTQ+ residents by recognizing Pride Month. Please vote against any attempts to undo the city’s history of support for its LGBTQ+ residents and visitors. Sincerely, Diane Warren San Nicholas Avenue, Palm Desert ************************ Diane M. Warren (she/they) 57 From:Ryland Penta To:City Hall Mail Subject:Fw: Flags Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 9:52:46 AM Ryland Penta, MSc Community Relations Supervisor City of Palm Desert 73510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert, CA 92260 rpenta@palmdesert.gov | 760.776.6318 | www.palmdesert.gov From: Don Gmail Sent: Sunday, December 14, 2025 11:29 To: Ryland Penta <rpenta@palmdesert.gov> Subject: Flags Keep the inclusive flags flying, please. I love the diversity Palm Desert supports. Sent from my iPhone 58 From:Ryland Penta To:City Hall Mail Subject:Fw: Pradetto Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 9:52:55 AM Ryland Penta, MSc Community Relations Supervisor City of Palm Desert 73510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert, CA 92260 rpenta@palmdesert.gov | 760.776.6318 | www.palmdesert.gov From: DOUG MORIN Sent: Sunday, December 14, 2025 10:08 To: Community Relations <CommunityRelations@palmdesert.gov> Subject: Pradetto I have lived in Palm Desert for more than 40 years. I own property, and have, for most of that time. During all of those years I have defended the City and its residents against residents from west Valley who wonder how I can live here. “It’s homophobic”, I've heard. “The LGBTQ+ community isn’t represented,” and so many more, similar comments, to which I have always replied that PD is as inclusive and progressive as Palm Springs. We have everything the west Valley has, and for gay individuals, and couples such as myself and partner/husband, I/we have always been welcomed and respected wherever we have gone. I/we have never had anyone, or any business, treat us differently because of our sexuality or relationship. I am proud to live in Palm Desert and I/we truly do love this city. That said, I was shocked to learn about Pradetto’s desire to lay the groundwork that will change all of that. It starts with a flag, but it WILL move on to something else. I don’t need to go on. You know (unless you have buried your heads in the sand) where this can and will lead to. Flying a pride flag doesn’t hurt anyone! What it does do is demonstrate our city’s openness and acceptance of others. What it does do is show kindness, and respect, and love of our neighbors. I implore the Council to not give this issue any more of your energy than is needed to say “NO!” Keep our city the wonderful, vibrant, growing and kind city it is. Doug Morin PD resident 59 Sent from my iPad 60 From:Ryland Penta To:City Hall Mail Subject:Fw: Comments mayor pro temp regarding celebrating the gay community. Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 9:54:32 AM Ryland Penta, MSc Community Relations Supervisor City of Palm Desert 73510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert, CA 92260 rpenta@palmdesert.gov | 760.776.6318 | www.palmdesert.gov From: desertsunisfun@ Sent: Monday, December 15, 2025 9:00 To: Community Relations <CommunityRelations@palmdesert.gov> Subject: Comments mayor pro temp regarding celebrating the gay community. ‌ I watched the city council session in which mayor Joe Pradetto urged the council to remove support for gay pride events in Palm Desert. He very carefully chose words like inclusion and diversity and even referenced his close "friendships" to gay people as though that would camouflage his clear bigotry and prejudice against the LGBTQ community. It's like a white Confederate southerner saying that they "have black friends however... " If you're not going to allow your city to celebrate a unique community like the lgbtq one, then I suggest you forgo things like the Veterans parade in which we celebrate that particular community, or any Hispanic celebration (like the date festival ) in which we celebrate that community, or your golf cart parade which clearly celebrates the privilege and entitlement of exclusively white golfers. So the new mayor can use whatever pretty flowery words he wants about how much he loves the gay community in order to justify the fact that he does not want to fly a flag on their behalf. Mayor Pradetto has the political right to demonstrate his biases, but it will come at a cost. And the cost that I am putting forward is that I will urge all of my friends and family to not spend one bloody red scent in the town of Palm desert. If the mayor and council continue to marginalize an important, vibrant, inclusive, loving and beneficial segment of their community they may just pay the same price that Anita Bryant and the orange industry did way back in the '70s. Thanks for listening 61 Yahoo Mail: Search, Organize, Conquer 62 From:Ryland Penta To:City Hall Mail Subject:Fw: LGBTQ events Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 10:39:25 AM Ryland Penta, MSc Community Relations Supervisor City of Palm Desert 73510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert, CA 92260 rpenta@palmdesert.gov | 760.776.6318 | www.palmdesert.gov From: Lorne Zilkie Sent: Monday, December 15, 2025 10:33 To: Community Relations <CommunityRelations@palmdesert.gov> Subject: LGBTQ events ‌ I watched the Palm Desert city council meeting in which Mayor Joe Pradetto openly moved to withdraw support for LGBTQ Pride events. What followed was a textbook display of political cowardice: hiding exclusion behind sanitized buzzwords like “inclusion” and “diversity,” and invoking alleged “friendships” with gay people as if proximity somehow negates prejudice. It doesn’t. This rhetorical sleight of hand is as old as bigotry itself—no different than saying, “I’m not racist, but…” Let’s be clear: this was not about neutrality, fairness, or consistency. This was about deciding that the LGBTQ community is the one group unworthy of public acknowledgment. If Palm Desert truly intends to stop recognizing specific communities, then it must do so across the board. No Veterans Parade. No Hispanic cultural celebrations like the Date Festival. No golf cart parade celebrating wealth, entitlement, and an overwhelmingly white leisure class. Selective visibility is not principle—it is discrimination. 63 Mayor Pradetto can bathe his position in soft language all he wants. The reality is stark and unmistakable: he does not want the LGBTQ community visibly represented in his city. Refusing to fly a flag is not symbolic restraint—it is an explicit act of erasure. And erasure, no matter how politely packaged, is still erasure. The mayor has every legal right to govern from a place of bias. What he does not get is insulation from backlash. I will be urging my friends, family, and professional networks to withhold every single discretionary dollar from Palm Desert. Tourism, dining, festivals, real estate—none of it will see my support. Marginalizing a vibrant, inclusive, loving, and economically vital community is not just morally bankrupt; it is financially stupid. History has already shown how this ends. When public figures choose intolerance, they don’t just stain their reputations—they damage the economies they claim to protect. Anita Bryant learned that lesson the hard way in the 1970s. Entire industries learned alongside her. Palm Desert can decide whether it wants to be on the right side of history— or be remembered as another cautionary tale of small-minded leadership with large consequences. This city is being watched. And it will be judged accordingly. Lorne Zilkie Sent from my iPhone 64 From:Monet Allard-Wilcox To:City Hall Mail; Evan Trubee; Joe Pradetto; Karina Quintanilla; Gina Nestande; Jan Harnik; alisa@pdacc.org; Thomas Soule Cc:Emily Vogt Subject:Resolution 2018-09 Review Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 11:18:26 AM Dear Council and esteemed community members- It has come to my attention that Mayor Pro Tem, Joe Pradetto, included in this email, has requested a review of Resolution 2018-09. As a homeowner in the valley, a small business owner and a lifelong committed ally of ALL minority and underserved individuals, I want to voice my strong opposition to this “review". They say that all politics is local and this “review” is a classic example of that premise. I put the word review in quotation marks to highlight exactly what this actually IS, which IS the first step at reversing and removing established protections and principles. It is bad enough that under the current presidential administration our beloved neighbors are living in fear of ICE raids even if they are legal residents, but now the target shifts to also include people within the LGBTQI community? Because removing diversity, equity and inclusion protections from communities does just that. It puts a target on people by forcing them to live “underground”. Removing such protections says that you believe that somehow certain people are less than in value to others, to in this case, straight white cisgendered people. I will remind you all of the buying power of the LGBTQI community. I will also remind you all of the organizing power of the LGBTQI community. I will also remind you that removing such protections includes removing protections for people living with all types of disabilities. The Mayor Pro Tem may not like the LGBTQI community. He may not like people in wheelchairs or with intellectual disabilities. But I will remind him that it is a very big valley filled with many powerful voices and many retirees who love to use their time and energy productively to ensure the safe welfare of their fellow citizens whenever possible. I will be encouraging my many active friends and family to participate in the upcoming City Council meeting if this stays on the agenda. I will be encouraging them to mobilize and bring with them any and all people impacted by the rollback of DEI protections. I trust you all have thoroughly thought through what this will look like. Wheelchairs. Walkers. Vocal drag queens. Affluent and articulate members of the LGBTQI community. Members of the media. Quite the visual. This valley, home to the Coachella Valley Music Festival, The International Film Festival and so many other internationally attended affairs should reinvigorate it’s principles as a place of unity, hope and yes, Pride, not seek to dismantle it. In summary, all politics is indeed local and now you know that the whole world is and will be watching. Best- Monet Allard-Wilcox 65 From:June Engblom To:City Hall Mail Subject:Gay pride Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 12:30:47 PM The erasing of gay pride is an embarrassment to our wonderful city…I’ll be telling all my neighbors who feel the same as I do…we’ll make our feelings known at the ballot box Sent from my iPhone 66 From:Dori Smith To:City Hall Mail Subject:Please Nix Pradetto"s Hurtful Proposal re Pride Month Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 1:20:06 PM ‌ Dear City Council Members: What a way to put a big blot on the City of Palm Desert! We’re referring to Councilmember Joe Pradetto’s proposal to discontinue the City’s recognition of Pride Month, to ban the Pride flag at City Hall, and to stop the City’s participation in the Palm Springs Pride celebration. We have lived in Palm Desert for 26 years and are very upset that its leaders would drop its pledge (and public declarations) to support diversity. This action, if approved by the City Council, will be a step backward in fostering an inclusive, respectful community. Pride Month and the Pride flag are important symbols of equality and support for the LGBTQ+ community. We’re talking about REAL people who live, work, recreate and spend money in Palm Desert. Instead of affirming Palm Desert’s commitment to inclusivity, this action will signal a skepticism toward diversity and an unwillingness to try to strive for the goal that all residents feel valued and represented. We encourage all members of the City Council to vote against this hurtful action. Sincerely, Dori J. Smith & Rupert L. Smith Palm Desert 67 From:Trevor O"Donnell To:City Hall Mail Subject:Boycotting Palm Desert Businesses Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 2:24:55 PM ‌ To Mayor Trubee and members of City Council: I understand that Mayor Pro Tem Joe Pradetto is trying to rescind the city's Pride Month resolution and eliminate pride flag displays. I am a Palm Springs resident who shops regularly in Palm Desert, but if Mr. Pradetto succeeds, this shopping will come to an abrupt and permanent end. For now, I will be writing to my favorite Palm Desert businesses and encouraging them to stand by ALL the patrons who support your city's economy. I will also be joining together with the residents of Palm Springs, Cathedral City, Rancho Mirage, Palm Desert and other Valley communities to reject this kind of hateful politics. Yours, Trevor O'Donnell Palm Springs, CA 68 From:robbie boswell To:Sarah Castro Subject:Re: Homophobia Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 12:51:54 PM ‌ Awesome! We aren't going back to the 1950s thanks for your concern. Share that too please. On Mon, Dec 15, 2025, 12:22 PM Sarah Castro <scastro@palmdesert.gov> wrote: Hello Robbie, Thank you for your email. It will be shared with the City Council and made a part of the public record. Thank you again, Sarah Castro Senior Administrative Assistant City of Palm Desert 73510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert, CA 92260 scastro@palmdesert.gov | 760.776.6349 | www.palmdesert.gov From: robbie boswell > Sent: Sunday, December 14, 2025 1:11 PM To: City Hall Mail <cityhall@palmdesert.gov> Subject: Homophobia You must be a Trumper oh no. 69 You need to go. 70 From:Greg Ulrich To:CouncilMeeting Comments Cc:Cole Ruth Subject:Response to ACTION CALENDAR item 3.a Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 2:15:37 PM ‌ Dear Council Members, I am not typically involved in City Council meetings, and I have never before attended a civic meeting in Palm Desert. However, I feel compelled to participate today to express my strong opposition to the proposed amendment to rescind Resolution 2024-038. My wife and I chose to move to Palm Desert in part because of the city’s inclusive values and policies. Although we do not identify as members of the LGBTQ+ community, we recognize that Pride Month is important not only as a celebration for our queer neighbors, but also as a visible affirmation of acceptance for a historically marginalized group. That visibility benefits the community as a whole. Some have asked, including in comments on the Desert Sun article about this issue, “If there is a gay Pride Month, why not a straight Pride Month?” This question ignores, or chooses to ignore, the reality that straight people have never faced systemic discrimination or persecution based on their sexual orientation. Acknowledging and celebrating one group does not diminish another. Given how modest the City’s recognition of Pride Month already is, rescinding this resolution sends an unnecessary and troubling message. It risks signaling to LGBTQ+ residents that they are less welcome here, which runs counter to the values that make Palm Desert a place people want to live. For these reasons, I believe the proposed amendment to rescind Resolution 2024-038 is wrong, and I strongly oppose it. Thank you, Greg Ulrich Palm Desert, CA 92260 71 From:Carol Adney To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Resolutions 20 24–038 and 20 18–09 Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 2:36:26 PM ‌ Honorable Mayor and city council members, What is to be gained by rescinding resolutions intended to bring unity and goodwill to our community? There were campaign promises made concerning public safety and fiscal security. Those are better concerns for the Council and all who live here. “Can’t we all just get along?” Carol Adney, Resident , Palm Desert 72 From:Rappaport, Kathy To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Agenda Item - CONSIDERATION OF A REQUEST FOR ACTION TO RESCIND CITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2024-038 RELATED TO LGBTQ PRIDE MONTH COMMEMORATIONS AND AMENDING CITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2018-09 RELATED TO DIVERSITY AND INCLUSION. Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 2:46:35 PM ‌ In this time of upheaval and discord in many communities, I believe that the City ofPalm Desert should represent the very fabric of our Community. We are inclusive community which should reflect the diversity of the residents of all persuasions. I fail to see that targeting the previously approved LGBTQ Community for removal of the PRIDE Flag during PRIDE Month will only harm our communities interests This does not represent who we are.. There is already talk ofa boycott to our business, retail and hospitality sectors in our City. The Internationalcommunity is Boycotting visits to the US and many Canadians have sold theirproperty here. Other tourists have chosen to take their dollars to other locales inother countries. Few understand the differences in our 9 City Coachella Valley. Ourlifestyle is highly funded by our visitors spending time here. Kathy Rappaport Palm Desert, CA 92260 73 From:Craig McClure To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:We will avoid shopping and dining in Palm Desert if…. Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 3:05:27 PM If This action to rescind recognition of Pride passes by the Palm Desert City Council tomorrow, my partner and I will stop shopping and dining in Palm Desert. In the past, we’ve often ventured down to El Paseo and the larger shopping centers. Just this past weekend, we tried out the new Project Burger. When we are here in the valley during the winter, we have many choices of where to shop and dine. Craig McClure Palm Springs and Evanston, Illinois Sent from my iPad 74 From:Ted Peck To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Tomorrow"s Council Meeting Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 3:07:46 PM ‌ Please add this to your agenda. Also, I would like to address the Council. My name is Ted Peck, and I live in Palm Desert. I am writing you, in hopes of further understanding the motivation for an unprovoked attack on the Gay community, by attempting to erase us, why? I am a 68-year-old gay man, who lived the majority of my life closeted, and I didn't come out until I was 50 years old. I have 3 adult children and 3 grandchildren, who I adore and who are the world to me, yes, many Gay men, have children, of their own. My situation isn't unique, or unusual. From what I can tell, you say that the City should be neutral, really, about human rights. Gay rights are human rights, and Gay history is American history. Just as every other aspect of society, whether European American, African, Asian, or Hispanic American, we are all part of American history. And we routinely celebrate and embrace other cultures, why are you attempting to hide the rich and colorful history, not to mention the achievements of the Gay community to the betterment of mankind. Here is a brief history, June 28th , 1969, the Stonewall Riots occurred, patrons finally rose up and fought back, the riot lasted 3 days. I was 11 years old at that time, and aware of my sexuality, and I knew I was different. Hearing the comments from the adults, I soon learned that there was very little sympathy, after all they were "deviants" One year later in 1970 the first Nationwide Gay rights march was formed, and it was the birth of what we know of today, as Gay Pride month. In 1980 the AIDS Crises began to unfold, Ronald Reagan was the President, the epidemic was raging and nothing was being done. Around that time ACT UP was formed to bring attention to the AIDS crises. AIDS research wasn't funded, until it started to affect the Straight population. Tens of 75 thousands of us died, while the Government did nothing. In 1976 - 1977 Legionnaires disease occurred, for an disease that caused the deaths of only 28 people. The Federal Government spent 245 million dollars in research and prevention methods, and to find a cure. It wasn't until 1981 that money was spent to research AIDS, the amount was $200,000. Yes, only, two hundred thousand, while thousands of us were dying, versus 245 million for Legionnaires disease, why? As of 2024, 64 countries criminalize consensual Gay sex, of those 12 of them carry the death penalty. In 140 countries in this world, it is still illegal for Gays to get married. On November 27th 1978 San Francisco City Councilman Harvey Milk was gunned down, by Dan White, who also killed Mayor Mosconi. He was later convicted by a sympathetic jury who bought his "Twinky Defense" and only convicted him of Voluntary Manslaughter; he was sentenced to only 7 years and was paroled in less than 5 years. On June 24th , 1973, an arson fire was set at the Upstairs Lounge in New Orleans, 49 innocent people perished in the inferno, as they had no means of escape. Many found, clutching in each other's arms, their bodies fused together from the intense heat and flames. Subsequently, many churches in the area refused to hold funeral services for the victims. Discriminated against, even in death. June 12th , 2016, the Pulse Nightclub in Orlando 49 killed, 58 wounded. More recently? November 19th , 2025, two Gay patrons in San Diegos Hillcrest area, shot at. November 3rd 2025 two men arrested for planning an attack in the Detroit area of a Gay bar, how many could have died councilman? I could go on and on and cite laws, trigger laws intended to ban gay marriage is SCOTUS over turns Gay Marriage, the history of the sodomy laws in this country, not overturned until 2003, should i? 76 Will it matter to you. Does the Gay community matter to you. These are just a few examples of why Pride is so important to us, and why we have fought so long, at an unbearable cost, that you cannot imagine. I have been spit on, really, I have had death threats RIP F-G, DIE F-G, rocks thrown through my front window, twice!! And now hate crimes are increasing at a dramatic rate. Just look at the comments on Face Book and the people applauding you, homophobes and bigots. Is that a group you are "Proud" to cater to, while you attempt to further erase us? I have spent most of my life being ashamed of who I was. Why? Because I didn't see any positive roll models who look like me. And frankly people like you, who think we are deviant, expecting more rights than we deserve. Its not a contest my friend, we just want to live our lives and pursue our happiness, just as you do. Now you want to bring hate to Palm Desert. I stand in opposition to you, and I speak for hundreds of not thousands of Gay residents, in the city of PD, and surrounding cities. Most of us who are fairly affluent, including myself, and Gays LOVE to shop. I will no longer be spending my dollars in PD. Please reconsider your decision. I look forward to hearing from you. Ted Peck The Gallery community, 92211 - PD resident. This communication is solely for use by the intended recipient and may contain information that is privileged, confidential or copyrighted under applicable law. If you are not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any use, copying or distribution of this communication, in whole or in part, is strictly prohibited. Unless explicitly stated, this communication does not constitute a contract offer, a contract amendment, or an acceptance of a contract offer. ‌‌‌‌ 77 From:Matthew Collins To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Not Recognizing Divers and Displaying gay Flags Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 3:10:07 PM ‌ As A Gay man who lives in the Coachella Valley outside of Palm Desert This shows e you don't value me or my business in your city. by pulling your proclamation of gay Pride , your equal protections for all And not displaying flags and banners during pride month and for pride events How's your hatred towards my community. if passed I will no longer spend my money in your city. No Retail or Dining in PAlm Desert your saying you don't want me or my money and that's what's ts going to happen. Sincerely, Matthew Collins Yahoo Mail: Search, Organize, Conquer 78 From:Stuart Ackley To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Anti-LGBT+ proposals Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 3:15:31 PM ‌ Dear Palm Desert City Council, I am very distressed about the Anti-LGBT+ comments at your last City Council meeting by the Mayor Pro-Tem Pradetto. I have lived in the Coachella Valley for 34 years and I find these proposals disturbing. I have spent $1000s of dollars at Palm Desert's retailers and restaurants over the past 3 decades. As a gay person, I have always felt welcome in your city. Getting rid of the Pride Flag and getting rid of Pride Month for Palm Desert is very concerning to me. If such a ridiculous proposal is passed by the City Council, I will no longer spend any money in your city. Sincerely, Stuart W. Ackley 79 From:Harold Katkov To:CityClerk Subject:The Pride Flag at Palm Desert City Hall Must Fly/thank you for DISTRIBUTING THIS EMAIL TO COUNCIL MEMBERS PRIOR TO TOMORROW"S CITY COUNCIL MEETING Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 3:13:47 PM ‌ I’m a 68-year-old gay man living in Palm Desert. In seven decades on the planet, I’ve experienced my share of homophobia and marginalization. Why I’m writing Mayor Pro Tem Joe Perdetto and the Palm Desert City Council today Palm Desert's Mayor Pro Tem, Joe Perdetto, wants to stop flying the Pride flag at City Hall, claiming the LGBTQ+ community is “integrated enough” (his words). He says the flag creates division rather than unity, and needs to come down. Oh, Joe, No! The idea of a 28-year-old White, straight man proclaiming the LGBTQ+ community is “integrated enough” is ridiculous… inaccurate… and offensive. Joe's "conclusion" would be laughable if it weren’t so untrue and repugnant. Hate crimes are SIGNIFICANTLY UP. Thus, Joe's ridiculous statement of "enough" integration is categorically untrue. Here’s what’s REALLY needed, Joe and Palm Desert City Council Everybody needs inclusion, diversity, dignity and respect from their community and community government. Not just gay people; EVERYBODY. Flying the Pride flag at Palm Desert City Hall fosters all that, and more. That’s why it’s needed. Here’s what’s going to happen, Joe and Palm Desert City Council Thousands of gay people in the Coachella Valley – and the whole USA – are going to message Joe and Palm Desert City Council about this issue. And share their thoughts all over social media. Not just gay people… but also, the thousands of wonderful straight people that support human rights and inclusion for everybody. The Pride Flag needs to fly at Palm Desert City Hall. Period. Full stop. The resistance to the Mayor’s and City Council’s homophobia… is just beginning. -- Hal Katkov 80 81 From:Scott Graf To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:CONSIDERATION OF A REQUEST FOR ACTION TO RESCIND CITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2024-038 RELATED TO LGBTQ PRIDE MONTH COMMEMORATIONS Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 3:23:47 PM ‌ To the Palm Desert City Council: Should you decide to act to RESCIND CITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2024-038 RELATED TO LGBTQ PRIDE MONTH COMMEMORATIONS, I will not only never spend another dollar in your City, but I will also make sure no one I know does either. That includes our many winter visitors, whom we routinely take to the shops, galleries, and restaurants on El Paseo. A vote in favor of rescinding Pride Month Commemorations will be considered a hostile act against my community and me. Please don’t do it! John Scott Graf Palm Springs, CA 92264 82 From:Peter Grame To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:CONSIDERATION OF A REQUEST FOR ACTION TO RESCIND CITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2024-038 RELATED TO LGBTQ PRIDE MONTH COMMEMORATIONS Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 3:25:20 PM Seriously?!? Please tell me that this does NOT have the support of anybody but the a**hole that put forward this resolution. Appalling. Reject this stupid request for action or alienate a large part of your community and those from outside that will not support PD. That means the Living Desert (of which I am a big financial supporter, El Paseo, etc.). This is NOT good publicity for PD! Peter Grame iPhone reply... 83 From:Ken Priore To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Fwd: Palm Desert Deserves a Broader Vision of Unity Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 3:30:04 PM ‌ I am writing regarding Mayor Pro Tem Pradetto’s recent proposal to remove the Pride banner under the guise of "government neutrality." During this season of goodwill, his comments felt deeply out of step with the heart of our community. First, to categorize LGBTQ+ existence as merely a "private identity"—implying it is a hobby or a secret to be kept behind closed doors—is a profound misunderstanding. Sexual orientation and gender identity are not just private preferences; they are fundamental aspects of our humanity, our families, and our civil rights. To suggest otherwise diminishes the lived experience of our neighbors. Furthermore, it is disheartening that a leader in Palm Desert would hold such a limited vision of the Coachella Valley. Our region is world-renowned not for its bureaucratic "neutrality," but for its vibrant, diverse tapestry. By seeking to erase symbols of inclusion, Mr. Pradetto underestimates what makes our desert special. We are strong enough to celebrate everyone without feeling threatened. Let us not shrink Palm Desert’s spirit to fit a narrow policy, but rather embrace the expansive, welcoming vision that defines the Coachella Valley. Ken Priore 84 85 From:Dave Hund To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:CONSIDERATION OF A REQUEST FOR ACTION TO RESCIND CITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2024-038 Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 3:44:19 PM If Pride Month Commemorations are rescinded, I will not be spending my money in Palm Desert again Sincerely, Dave H. 86 From:steve@bogdanoff.com To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Resolution No. 2024-038 Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 3:48:16 PM ‌ To Whom It May Concern, My husband and I are presently scouting for real estate in the low desert for a winter home (we live in Santa Fe, NM). We are appalled that rescinding Resolution No. 2024-038 is being considered. We will not consider investing in real estate in Palm Desert if this resolution is rescinded. Furthermore, we will not spend our tax dollars in Palm Desert under any circumstances. This will encourage us to only invest and spend money in Palm Springs. Having the need to even send this email in this day and age disgusts us. Steve Bogdanoff www.bogdanoff.com www.artonwalls.com 87 From:Philip Hodges To:CouncilMeeting Comments; CityClerk Subject:Public comment for 3A: Palm Desert Council Meeting 12/16. Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 4:01:31 PM ‌ Please record this as public comments for Item 3A: CONSIDERATION OF A REQUEST FOR ACTION TO RESCIND CITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2024-038 RELATED TO LGBTQ PRIDE MONTH COMMEMORATIONS AND AMENDING CITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2018-09 RELATED TO DIVERSITY AND INCLUSION. Mayor and Councilmembers, My name is Philip Hodges, and I’m here to ask you one question: What are you afraid of? Six months ago, you voted to recognize Pride Month. And now you’re being asked to take it back. Because I can tell you what the LGBTQ families in this community are afraid of. They’re afraid their city is telling them they made a mistake. That recognizing their existence was too much. That they need to go back to being invisible. And I can tell you what local businesses are afraid of. They’re afraid Palm Desert is about to become the only city in the Coachella Valley that officially says Pride doesn’t belong here. Palm Springs celebrates it. Cathedral City celebrates it. No other city in this valley is rushing to undo its own commitments. If you pass this rescission, you become the outlier. The city that said no. Do you know what that does to a brand? Do you know what that does to tourism? This valley’s economy runs on people choosing to visit, to move here, to invest here. And increasingly, those people—especially younger professionals and families—make choices based on values. They want to know their neighbors will be welcomed. They want to know their kids will be safe. When you rescind Pride recognition, you’re not making a statement about flags or banners. You’re making a statement about who belongs in Palm Desert. And the market will respond accordingly. Assemblymember Greg Wallis—a Republican who represents this district—has already called this proposal "a slap in the face" to residents. He said removing these symbols sends the message that "some members of our community matter less than others". When your own Republican Assemblymember is telling you this is wrong, what does that tell you? It tells you this isn’t about left or right. It’s about right and wrong. Here’s what I know about this Council: In 2018, you passed a resolution welcoming everyone who "lives, works in, or visits" Palm Desert. You said this city is for everyone. Tonight, you get to decide if you meant it. 88 Because if you rescind this recognition, you’re not just reversing a resolution. You’re reversing a promise. And people will remember. The teenagers who are watching this meeting will remember. The families deciding where to build their lives will remember. The businesses deciding where to invest will remember. The tourists deciding where to spend their money will remember. And they will all ask the same question I’m asking you now: What were you so afraid of? Please. Vote no. Thank you. 89 From:Vincent Marchica To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:PRIDE in PALM DESERT Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 4:02:00 PM > >  > >> >> I am a 71 year old Palm Springs resident who has family members who work in Palm Desert. I also am a frequent shopper on El Paseo and we regularly attend the McCallum Theatre. >> By destroying Pride initiatives you send a message of hatred and intolerance to Palm Desert. Will Hispanic month, St Patrick’s day, Martin Luther Kings birthday be tossed? Christmas, Easter, Kwanza? >> You have seen initiatives against DISNEY and Target. Be aware that the power of the purse will be used if the erasure of LGBTQ programs are initiated. >> >> Thank you >> Vincent Marchica >> Sent from my iPhone 90 From:James Brown To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:"Erase the Gays" Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 4:08:59 PM ‌ Dear City Council of Palm Desert, I am writing to express my disbelief and outrage that in 2025 that the Palm Desert City Council is even agreeing to hear the legislation presented by Joe Pradetto to “erase” Gay Pride, the acknowledgement and celebration of Palm Springs and Coachella Valley Pride and to cease the hanging of Rainbow Flags or banners during Pride Month. You must realize that Mr. Pradetto is acting as part of a much larger national movement to attempt to “erase” minorities, their histories, and contributions to our national society, government and identification. We are a nation that CELEBRATES different segments of our culture and society in many different ways. Black Heritage Month, Hispanic Heritage Month, Veteran of the Military Memorial Month and even the Holiday Season itself and its celebration of different cultures that make up the USA. In fact, even "Merry Christmas" is a recognition and celebration of the Christian Holiday of Christmas…THAT is a celebrating one of the cultural differences here in our country. Does Palm Desert and Joe Pradetto think we should “cancel” all the above listed events so as not to offend those not being celebrated—or to promote some idea of “unity”? That is ridiculous. It is also ridiculous to not celebrate differences in the cultures and traditions and histories— they make up the fabric of this country. Ignoring those histories and banning their public celebration or recognition does NOT promote unity—it promotes disassociation, separation of cultures, ignorance of histories and contributions and goes further to promote differences, lack of understanding and promotes mistrust among our populace. What Joe Pradetto is doing is to PERSONALLY inflict his supposed “morality” on to others. He believes that instead of celebrating and learning about our differences, they should be hidden and, in fact, demonized. It is his type of views that foster mistrust, bigotry and even violence. His call to promote UNITY by ‘erasing the gays’ will not stand. And, the Palm Desert City Council should instead, make it clear that they will not tolerate such views meant to instill isolation and mistrust among residents and visitors alike. Joe Pradetto should be called out for exactly what he is—a bigot. And he should be sanctioned by the City Council for bringing such unwelcome and damaging attention to the city. 91 motion, it can expect a backlash, including boycotting of Palm Desert businesses, nationwide coverage of Palm Desert rolling-back diversity recognition and pressure being put on large corporations (like resorts, restaurant chains, retail) and major events (like Coachella Music Festival and the Paribas Indian Wells Tennis Tournament) to NOT do business, nor stay or spend money in Palm Desert. If Palm Desert wants to continue to enjoy the financial gains of offering a bigotry-free and diverse and welcoming city culture, it needs to stop Joe Pradetto in his tracks. What there should be is a “no confidence” vote in Pradetto’s supposed “leadership”. That won’t happen—but it should. Intolerance and bigotry in this country should be called out at every turn. The Palm Desert City Council needs to be smart and deliberate —and consider what this move truly is: it is a move to silence and “erase” a minority group—the LGBTQIA+ Community-- that not only contributes to our society as a whole, but also significantly contributes to the fabric and FINANCES of Palm Desert. Sincerely, James P. Brown Palm Springs, CA 92262 92 From:Michael Gettle To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Upcoming meeting Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 4:14:11 PM ‌ Really?! AS A FULLY DISABLED (LGBTQ+) VETERAN I WANT TO BE HEARD! I am in Palm Springs but hearing my neighbor, Palm Desert, wants to erase LGBTQ+ from Pride month is just terrible news. CONSIDERATION OF A REQUEST FOR ACTION TO RESCIND CITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2024-038 RELATED TO LGBTQ PRIDE MONTH COMMEMORATIONS I can't believe it. I thought I was safe living here. I moved to the Coachella Valley to feel safe. I don't want it to come down to 'voting with my dollars' but now I have to. I live in Palm Springs but I regularly go down to businesses located in Palm Desert. Those transactions are now on hold. AS A FULLY DISABLED VETERAN of the United States Army, my few disabled dollars that I get are very carefully thought out to make it through the month. Sometimes I drive a little out of my way down to Palm Desert stores to save a few bucks. That won't happen if this resolution passes. Joe Pradetto has no place on your council either. Hate has no place here! -- Thanks, Michael Gettle 93 From:Tom Dolle To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Public comment, Palm Desert City Council Special Meeting, December 16 Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 4:14:18 PM This is a comment in reference to Agenda Item 3A Palm Desert City Council Members, I am a graphic designer, an 11 year resident of Palm Springs, a business owner, and a frequent visitor to Palm Desert to visit friends, go shopping, eat at restaurants, and visit cultural institutions. I am active in the community and president of an HOA. I recently sat on a volunteer panel of designers to help Palm Desert explore a new logo design. I have also contributed my time and services to a number of organizations that have a connection to Palm Desert. My husband and I have been married for 46 years, and we have 2 adult children. What brought us to the desert from New York was not just the climate—it was also the warm, accepting lifestyle that we have come to cherish. We have been victims numerous times in the past of anti-gay physical and verbal violence, harassment, having crude notes left on our car, and other forms of anti-gay aggression that make us value the safety and acceptance that we never take for granted. Opening the door to bigots who would remove the legal protections that LGBTQ citizens count on is a step back to an uglier time when we had to hide who we were for no other reason than what we look like or who we choose to love. It will only increase the likelihood of anti-gay violence against your residents and visitors. This rollback is happening swiftly by many national politicians as the gay community becomes scapegoats for—and a distraction from—a deteriorating economy. Supporting equal rights for the LGBTQ community has no effect on anyone else, other than to reinforce that ALL Palm Desert residents and visitors are protected by the same rights and privileges. Please quash this divisive and mean-spirited effort for what it is—an attempt to inflict unnecessary cruelty on the LGBTQ community. If not, we will choose to do our business elsewhere. Thank you Tom Dolle, Palm Springs 94 From:Eric Warren To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Proposal to Rescind Pride Resolution Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 4:27:03 PM ‌ Good afternoon Mayor and Council Members, My name is Eric Warren, and I wish to address the proposal to remove the recognition ofPride Month and the Equality banner from city property in Palm Desert. Pride Month is not about politics. It is about people. It is about acknowledging thatmembers of our community—our neighbors, coworkers, friends, and family—deserve to liveopenly, safely, and with dignity. When the City recognizes Pride Month or displays anEquality banner, it sends a simple but powerful message: everyone belongs here. Removing that recognition does not make Palm Desert more neutral. It makes it quieter forsome voices and louder for others. Silence, especially from public institutions, can feel likeexclusion. And exclusion has real consequences for young people, for families, and forresidents who already feel uncertain about whether they are accepted. It is also important to remember that the Pride and Equality symbols do not represent onlyLGBTQ+ individuals. Allies are a large and essential part of what those symbols stand for.Allies—parents, siblings, friends, faith leaders, veterans, business owners—stand alongsidethe community and say, “You are not alone.” The Equality message belongs to everyonewho believes in fairness, respect, and shared humanity. Palm Desert has always prided itself on being welcoming, forward-thinking, andcommunity-driven. Taking down symbols of inclusion risks sending the opposite messageto residents, visitors, and future generations who are watching how we lead. I urge the Council to keep Pride Month recognition and the Equality banner on cityproperty—not as a political statement, but as a reflection of our values. Inclusionstrengthens communities. Visibility saves lives. And unity, not removal, is how Palm Desertmoves forward. Thank you for your time and consideration. 95 96 From:Jeff Drain To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:RESOLUTION NO. 2024-038 Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 4:36:51 PM ‌ Council, As a 25 year resident of Palm Desert I have always promoted the city as a friendly and welcoming place for LGBTQ residents and visitors. As it appears this is no longer the case I will no longer frequent or recommend: Mamma Gina CPK Eddie V's Talay Pacifica Papa Dan's Arhaus I am currently a volunteer at Revivals Palm Desert. I will petition the board of directors that the store be relocated to a more inclusive location. I think the Mayor and city council of Palm Desert have FA and are about to FO. Jeff Drain 97 From:Jeffrey Lilly To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:City Council attack on the LGBT community Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 4:41:16 PM To whom it may concern I request that my opposition be read before the council. I am a long term resident of Cathedral City who does the majority of my shopping and business in Palm Desert. After learning about the city mayor’s homophobia and bigotry over Pride, I am appalled that in 2025 this is an issue. Particularly given the large LGBT community in the Coachella valley. This is disgraceful. Know for sure that if that vile initiative passes, I will never again spend my hard earned dollars at any business in Palm Desert. I have plenty of other options and know many of us in the LGBT community will do the same. I also will do all within my power to bring attention to this bigotry in Palm Desert and actively push boycott of Palm Desert business who do not make it clear they do not support us. With all the issues that elected officials could focus on, the fact that a bigoted city council may pass this just shows it is time for leadership change in Palm Desert. Do the right thing and stop these bigots in their tracks. Jeffrey Lilly Sent from my iPhones 98 From:Keith Potter To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Council meeting Dec 16 1:30pm Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 5:19:57 PM To whom it may concern it concern, If the resolution to support LGBTQ Pride is rescinded, I intend to boycott every business in Palm Desert. I’ll strongly encourage others to also never spend a penny supporting any business in Palm Desert. Council members might as well also meet and consider renaming the town “Palm Deserted” while you’re all there together tomorrow. It’s a shame. The notion of rescinding the town’s support of the LGBTQ community appears to be mean-spirited and divisive. - Keith R Potter C.V. resident Sent from my iPhone 99 From:Glenn Motowidlak To:CouncilMeeting Comments Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 5:29:37 PM ‌ As a resident of Palm Desert, and a proud and confident gay man, I want to ensure that all people are welcome and able to celebrate who they are and who they love. I am going to borrow a posting from a neighbor as it speaks directly to how I feel. Fromi: Ken Priore Regarding Mayor Pro Tem Pradetto’s recent proposal to remove the Pride banner under the guise of "government neutrality," during this season of goodwill, his comments felt deeply out of step with the heart of our community. First, to categorize LGBTQ+ existence as merely a "private identity"—implying it is a hobby or a secret to be kept behind closed doors—is a profound misunderstanding. Sexual orientation and gender identity are not just private preferences; they are fundamental aspects of our humanity, our families, and our civil rights. To suggest otherwise diminishes the lived experience of our neighbors. Furthermore, it is disheartening that a leader in Palm Desert would hold such a limited vision of the Coachella Valley. Our region is world-renowned not for its bureaucratic "neutrality," but for its vibrant, diverse tapestry. By seeking to erase symbols of inclusion, Mr. Pradetto underestimates what makes our desert special. We are strong enough to celebrate everyone without feeling threatened. Let us not shrink Palm Desert’s spirit to fit a narrow policy, but rather embrace the expansive, welcoming vision that defines the Coachella Valley. 100 101 From:Sue Barnes To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Ban on pride flag and DEI policies Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 5:49:53 PM To Council Members, We live in Palm Springs, but we come to Palm Desert frequently to dine and shop. We are opposed to your proposed changes to your DEI policy, and if passed we will be altering our $ spending policy! We are allies of the LBGTQ community and we only support businesses and communities that demonstrate kindness to all. We have already boycotted products from many states and businesses and will not hesitate to do the same to Palm Desert, and we will be sad to have to do so. Sincerely, Sue Barnes Sent from my iPhone 102 From:Scott D To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:LGBTQ Council Resoluton Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 6:00:28 PM We live in Palm Springs. However, we often go to Palm Desert for dining, shopping, spas and entertainment. I am disheartened at the current proposal to remove the recognition of Pride Month. The hateful agenda proposed by a select group of people is wrong. If the proposal passes we have no intention of spending any more money in Palm Desert. We will it not renew our Living Desert membership or annual donation. We will no longer go to any restaurants or shop in any stores. We will make every effort to encourage our friends to join us in the boycott. There is absolutely no reason to erase Gay Pride Month. Respectfully, Scott Donnelly, CPA Wade Nishimoto, MD 103 From:Nixon Schwartz To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Request for Consideration Regarding Pride Month Recognition. Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 6:10:16 PM ‌ Dear Palm Desert Council Members, I hope this message finds you well. My husband and I are both professional businessmen residing in and working in Palm Desert, having relocated from New York City two years ago. We have come to love our community and appreciate its strong support for the LGBTQ community. I was disheartened to learn about the special meeting concerning the potential removal of the recognition of Pride Month, along with the Equality banner from city property in Palm Desert. I find it difficult to understand how this decision could yield any positive financial impact for our city. In contrast, I believe it could have detrimental effects on the many beloved businesses that thrive here. As representatives of our vibrant LGBTQ community and its allies, we ask: is this the message we wish to convey? I urge you to thoughtfully consider the implications of this decision before casting your vote. Thank you for your time and attention to this critical matter. Sincerely, Tom Nixon Palm Desert, CA 92260 Sent from my iPhone 104 From:Rob Ollander-Krane To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:REQUEST FOR ACTION TO RESCIND CITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2024-038 RELATED TO LGBTQ PRIDE MONTH COMMEMORATIONS Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 6:21:44 PM Attachments:IMG_7223.jpeg I’m a resident of Palm Desert and I am a gay man. A few weeks ago, I drove by the Civic Center and took this picture and posted it on my social media accounts. I wrote: Love that I live in a city that celebrates who I am. Why would you take this away? Gay men and women still need their communities to raise awareness and foster a sense of shared pride. Especially towards those who all too often face discrimination, violence and fear. Please don’t take away something that makes me feel welcome and safe in my community. Rob Ollander-Krane 105 From:Sharon Bell To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Let the Pride flag fly Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 6:39:25 PM ‌ If Joe Pradetto were truly interested in affirming Palm Desert’s commitment to unity and inclusion he wouldn’t have introduced a resolution so offensive to the LGBTQ community and their supporters. It’s utterly disingenuous. Regarding this: "Update Resolution No. 2018-09 to shift its emphasis from celebrating differences to celebrating the shared values that unite the community.” What — sorry — utter BS. Our "shared values" SHOULD be that we celebrate our differences. —Sharon Bell and Cary Baker, homeowners Palm Desert District 2 106 From:Joe Camareno To:CouncilMeeting Comments; alisa@pdacc.org; Thomas Soule Subject:LGBTQ+ Support Rescind Vote Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 6:41:15 PM To All Concerned: The proposal to end all LGBTQ Pride recognition which in essence is a move to erase an entire community that has historically been disenfranchised and in many states in our union, is still actively discriminated against by many on the far right, is a decidedly big step back, especially in California and in a city that is seemingly split 50/50 politically. I am a recent transplant to the Coachella Valley from Los Angeles and I’m appalled at this proposal. While I have enjoyed shopping in Palm Desert, spending thousands of dollars to date this year alone at Whole Foods, Best Buy, Apple Store, Costco, and many local restaurants, I will make a concerted effort to spend my gay dollars more locally, in Palm Springs and Cathedral City. The good thing is I can order from Apple directly as well as Best Buy when needed, but will go out of my way to go to La Quinta and shop there for Costco or order online. If this resolution proposed by your closed-minded pro-tem mayor passes, i.e, rescinds LGBTQ+ Pride/recognition etc., I can assure you that many businesses will feel the brunt of ire from the vast gay community that is supportive of many of your businesses, especially on El Paseo. While several businesses in your city have decided to remain “neutral”, we will actively look for those shops that openly support our community in Palm Desert, but avoid patronizing those that openly do not. The end game will more than likely be a boycott of your city wherever possible, especially in this valley known as an enclave of LGBTQ+ residents that lean left. Try us. We will not think twice about not patronizing businesses in Palm Desert. We have options. Many options. Alienate us and that will be reflected in what this capitalist society understands best, dollars, or lack thereof. I hope Tuesday’s meeting results in a sensible and sane result. All eyes are on your city council. Joe Camareno Resident of Cathedral City El Paseo is entirely within Joe Pradetto's district (the sponsor of this horrendous initiative) district. Here's what you can do. Email them: Palm Desert Chamber of Commerce alisa@pdacc.org El Paseo Business Improvement District & City of Palm Desert's Tourism & Marketing Manager tsoule@palmdesert.gov 107 Let them know you spend money in Palm Desert. Be specific and tell them where. Tell them you will no longer patronize those businesses if they repeal support for Pride. If there are restaurants/businesses you specifically patronize on El Paseo, look up their email addresses, send them an e-mail. Demand they take a stand. Please cut and paste and share in your other groups/pages. Sent from my iPhone 108 From:Ivan Dinh To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Pride Month Recognition Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 6:47:57 PM ‌ Hello, Pride Month is not about politics. It is about people. It is about acknowledging that members of our community—our neighbors, coworkers, friends, and family—deserve to live openly, safely, and with dignity. When the City recognizes Pride Month or displays an Equality banner, it sends a simple but powerful message: everyone belongs here. Removing that recognition does not make Palm Desert more neutral. It makes it quieter for some voices and louder for others. Silence, especially from public institutions, can feel like exclusion. And exclusion has real consequences for young people, for families, and for residents who already feel uncertain about whether they are accepted. It is also important to remember that the Pride and Equality symbols do not represent only LGBTQ+ individuals. Allies are a large and essential part of what those symbols stand for. Allies—parents, siblings, friends, faith leaders, veterans, business owners—stand alongside the community and say, “You are not alone.” The Equality message belongs to everyone who believes in fairness, respect, and shared humanity. Palm Desert has always prided itself on being welcoming, forward-thinking, and community- driven. Taking down symbols of inclusion risks sending the opposite message to residents, visitors, and future generations who are watching how we lead. I urge the Council to keep Pride Month recognition and the Equality banner on city property— not as a political statement, but as a reflection of our values. Inclusion strengthens communities. Visibility saves lives. And unity, not removal, is how Palm Desert moves forward. Thank you for your time and consideration. ID 109 From:Cbpho To:CouncilMeeting Comments Cc:cbpho@ Subject:Re: Resolution 2018-09 Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 6:50:44 PM ‌ To whom it may concern on the Palm Desert city council Taking rights away never makes a country or a city a better place. LGBTQIA people live and work in Palm Desert, and contribute to the city’s economy. LGBTQIA people from other valley cities shop and eat in Palm Desert. Let them have the flags and the Pride. And instead invite more minority groups to have their moment. Inviting more people to the table is where it’s at! Thank you Chris Bale, DRE #01920366 Equity Union •Real Estate- Palm Springs and the Coachella Valley. •Author Call/text 110 From:Christina McLean To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Please Keep Pride Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 7:02:54 PM ‌ Please continue to participate in LGBTQ+ Pride Month. I am a full time resident of Palm Desert. I purchased a very expensive house and chose Palm Desert as my community. If this community decides to single itself out as not supporting Pride I will know I chose the wrong place to be and leave. Christina McLean Moss Rose Drive Sent from Yahoo Mail for iPhone 111 From:RAYMOND LAFLEUR To:CouncilMeeting Comments; City Hall Mail; Evan Trubee; Joe Pradetto; Karina Quintanilla; Gina Nestande; Jan Harnik; Thomas Soule; alisa@pdacc.org Subject:Letter from Human Rights Campaign Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 7:13:01 PM ‌ Sending this in to be sure you’ve all received it. Copied your business leaders also. Rather than ramming this through, take the time to meet with our LGBT leaders and try to understand what you are truly doing. At tomorrow’s Council Meeting, agree to schedule a listening session. Raymond Lafleur OPEN LETTER To City of Palm Desert - Mayor Pro Tem Joe Pradetto and the Palm Desert City Council From: Brian O’Connor, Member, Board of Directors, Human Rights Campaign / HRC Foundation Mayor Pro Tem Pradetto and Councilmembers, As a member of the national Board of Directors of the Human Rights Campaign and HRC Foundation, (the largest civil rights organizations committed to equality for all Americans with a focus on the LGBTQ+ community) and as a Coachella Valley resident who works with organizations, families, employers, and civic leaders committed to equality, I am writing to address the Mayor 112 Pro Tem’s proposal to eliminate Pride Month recognition in Palm Desert, including the removal of the Pride banner at City Hall. This proposal has already drawn wide public criticism— including from State Assemblymember Greg Wallis, who correctly stated that “Pride Month recognition doesn’t create division; it affirms that every resident deserves to be celebrated and respected.” He further called the proposal a “slap in the face” to LGBTQ+ residents. 1. The premise of your proposal is flawed and historically inaccurate You stated that the government should not “celebrate the private identities of one group over another” and should serve as a “neutral referee.” That framing ignores a fundamental truth: the government has not historically been neutral toward LGBTQ+ people. Government institutions at every level —federal, state, and municipal—enforced discrimination for decades through laws that criminalized LGBTQ+ relationships, denied family recognition, barred military service, blocked adoption, stripped employment protections, and more. In that context, “neutrality” is not neutral. It is a return to silence, and silence has always benefited the status quo 113 —not the communities harmed by it. 2. Pride recognition is not favoritism—it is civic inclusion Pride Month is not about “celebrating private identities.” It is a public affirmation that LGBTQ+ residents belong fully in their own city. That message matters precisely because LGBTQ+ people continue to face harassment, discrimination, and violence across the country— including right here in California. Cities regularly acknowledge communities and causes— Veterans Day, Hispanic Heritage Month, Black History Month, Women’s History Month, Disability Awareness, Earth Day, Indigenous Peoples’ Day. None of these diminish anyone else. Visibility is not division. Inclusion is not preferential treatment. 3. The rhetoric of “unity” cannot be used to erase a community Your comments claim that Palm Desert is “welcoming and integrated” and that the government should avoid “well-intentioned speech” that might generate division. This reverses reality. Pride recognition does not create division—erasing it does. 114 The communities most harmed by discrimination do not experience “unity” simply because a city stops acknowledging them. They experience it when the city affirms them openly and unequivocally. 4. Palm Desert’s own stated values contradict your proposal The City’s existing inclusion resolution—2018-09— commits Palm Desert to upholding the dignity of residents across sexual orientation and gender identity and encourages residents to “celebrate each other’s differences.” Your proposal directly contradicts the City’s adopted values and dismantles an inclusion framework that Palm Desert publicly claimed to support. 5. The City has clarified that no action has been taken— this is the moment for leadership, not retreat The City Manager’s office confirmed that your request has merely been scheduled for future agenda placement, likely in January or February, and that any initial discussion will occur in a study session format to allow for full and thoughtful dialogue. That means there is time—right now—to avoid a needless, divisive, and harmful fight. It means you have 115 the opportunity to correct the course. My request, stated plainly and directly Mayor Pro Tem Pradetto: I call on you to withdraw this motion immediately. Not table it. Not reframe it. Withdraw it. And I call on the Palm Desert City Council to: 1. Reject any attempt to remove Pride Month recognition, and 2. Reaffirm the City’s commitments to inclusion and equality. Palm Desert should not become the “Huntington Beach of the Coachella Valley” on LGBTQ+ issues. Our region is known nationwide for its welcoming posture, its diversity, and its leadership. This proposal undermines all of that and sends the wrong signal to residents, tourists, businesses, and young people who deserve a community that stands with them—not one that retreats from acknowledging their existence. I am available to meet with you or any Councilmember— alongside local LGBTQ+ residents and leaders—to discuss why Pride recognition is not symbolic politics, but a vital statement of civic belonging. 116 The path forward is clear. Choose inclusion. Withdraw the proposal. Respectfully, Brian O'Connor Member, Board of Directors Human Rights Campaign and HRC Foundation Serving the Coachella Valley Affiliation listed for identification. Views expressed reflect my role as a board member and community leader. 117 From:Mike Kiraly To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Resolution re: recognition of Pride month Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 7:22:51 PM ‌ A very poorly considered idea, respected Council Members. Please don't approve. Thank you. Mike Kiraly, 118 From:Helen Shafton To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Palm Desert City Council Special Meeting 12/26/2025 Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 7:24:56 PM ‌ The proposals to be discussed do not align with my views or the views of anyone I know in Palm Desert. These actions would move our city backwards and negatively impact future growth and prosperity for our community. We must reject the narrow mindedness of the few and be a welcoming community. Helen Shafton Palm Desert, CA 92211 119 From:Yolanda Bender To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:PALM DESERT CITY COUNCIL SPECIAL MEETING 12/16 Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 7:30:05 PM ‌ My name is Yolanda Bender, and I am a professor at College of the Desert. I am a heterosexual woman who recognizes the systemic discrimination the LGBTQ+ community has faced, and continues to face, in our society and around the world. As an educator, I feel it is important to share this history with the Palm Desert City Council. I often hear that celebrating Pride is divisive, or that there should be a heterosexual day, month, or parade. The reason there is not is simple. Heterosexual people have not faced systemic discrimination. Systemic discrimination refers to inequality built into laws, policies, and institutions rather than individual prejudice. For LGBTQ+ people, this has included criminalizing same sex relationships, denying legal recognition to couples and transgender individuals, allowing people to be fired or evicted because of who they are, limiting access to healthcare and government services, and failing to protect them from violence and harassment. From the 1940s to today, this discrimination has been widespread and institutionalized. In the mid twentieth century, LGBTQ+ people were barred from government jobs during the Lavender Scare, labeled mentally ill by medical institutions, subjected to forced treatments, and targeted by police raids on bars and gathering spaces. During the AIDS crisis, government inaction and healthcare discrimination led to unnecessary suffering and death. Later policies such as Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell excluded openly gay people from military service, and same sex couples were denied marriage, adoption, and legal recognition. Even today, discriminatory laws continue to restrict transgender healthcare, limit LGBTQ+ inclusion in schools, and leave many without full workplace or housing protections. Pride began as a response to this injustice. Its modern roots trace back to the Stonewall Uprising of 1969, when LGBTQ+ patrons resisted a police raid after years of harassment, criminalization, and abuse. That resistance 120 sparked a movement, leading to the first Pride marches in 1970 and growing into a global call for visibility, dignity, and equal rights. Pride is both a celebration and a reminder of the ongoing fight for acceptance. The Pride flag represents visibility, diversity, solidarity, and the right for LGBTQ+ people to live openly and safely while honoring the struggles that made progress possible. If this resolution is passed, how can I, as an educator, look my students in the eye and tell them they are safe and accepted in our community? If anyone is offended by a rainbow flag or by a marginalized group acknowledging its progress while still seeking full equality, then perhaps the problem does not lie with Pride. Yolanda Bender 121 From:Libby Scheideler To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Special Meeting Comment 12-16-25 Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 7:40:49 PM Greetings, I am writing to ask you to oppose the action to rescind Resolution 2024-038 and amend 2018-09. As a seasonal visitor and prospective resident of Palm Desert I feel the proposed action sends a signal that Palm Desert is unwelcoming to outsiders and makes me question my plan to purchase real estate here and continue investing in the community my family has grown to love. Please make the right decision and deny this hateful action and reaffirm the city's commitment to inclusivity. Warm regards, Libby Scheideler 122 From:Nicole Johnson To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:OPPOSE Rescinding Resolution 2024-038 and Amending Resolution 2018-09 Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 7:44:08 PM ‌ Dear Councilmembers, I am writing to urge you to vote NO on the proposal to ban the Pride flag from City Hall and prevent the city from participating in Pride events. Banning the Pride flag and prohibiting city participation in Pride events sends a harmful message that some Palm Desert residents are less worthy of acknowledgement than others. Our LGBTQ+ neighbors, friends, and family members contribute to this community and deserve equal dignity and respect. Flying the Pride flag and participating in Pride events costs virtually nothing but means everything to those it affirms. This ban would make Palm Desert less welcoming and inclusive, values that should unite us, not divide us. This measure would also negatively impact tourism. LGBTQ+ travelers and their allies represent significant economic value to our desert communities. Banning Pride recognition signals that Palm Desert is not welcoming to all visitors, which will drive tourism dollars to more inclusive destinations. I respectfully ask you to reject this proposal and continue Palm Desert's commitment to recognizing all members of our community. We will not back down from this fight and are already organizing to remove any council member who supports this measure. Nicole Johnson 37651 Cannon Drive Palm Desert, CA 92211 123 From:Nicole Johnson To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:OPPOSE Rescinding Resolution 2024-038 and Amending Resolution 2018-09 Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 7:44:08 PM ‌ Dear Councilmembers, I am writing to urge you to vote NO on the proposal to ban the Pride flag from City Hall and prevent the city from participating in Pride events. Banning the Pride flag and prohibiting city participation in Pride events sends a harmful message that some Palm Desert residents are less worthy of acknowledgement than others. Our LGBTQ+ neighbors, friends, and family members contribute to this community and deserve equal dignity and respect. Flying the Pride flag and participating in Pride events costs virtually nothing but means everything to those it affirms. This ban would make Palm Desert less welcoming and inclusive, values that should unite us, not divide us. This measure would also negatively impact tourism. LGBTQ+ travelers and their allies represent significant economic value to our desert communities. Banning Pride recognition signals that Palm Desert is not welcoming to all visitors, which will drive tourism dollars to more inclusive destinations. I respectfully ask you to reject this proposal and continue Palm Desert's commitment to recognizing all members of our community. We will not back down from this fight and are already organizing to remove any council member who supports this measure. Nicole Johnson Palm Desert, CA 92211 124 From:Donald Schmoll To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:2025 December 16, special meeting re LGBTQ+ Pride activities Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 7:49:46 PM ‌ We wish to have our dissent to this agenda noted. We recently moved to this area specifically to enjoy a freer enjoyment of retirement. We were drawn specifically because, as members of the LGBTQ community the general consensus seemed to be one of inclusion, regardless of Race, Religion, Orientation, etc. This proposal smells very much like an attempt to squash that freedom for particularly partisan purposes. I have to believe the good mayor pro tem would have any number of other items to address to the good of the entire community as opposed to the detriment of one part of the general community. We should be spending more time lifting up and embracing groups rather than excluding them. I mean where will it end? Will the Greek heritage and Italian heritage festival be deemed too divisive? (We assure you the LGBTQ+ groups would not support that!) We and many others will be carefully monitoring the results of this "special" meeting. Thank you for your consideration Donald E. Schmoll Richard J. Kwilosz 125 From:Cass To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:12/16/25 Meeting About Resolution No. 2018-09 and Resolution No. 2024-038 Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 7:59:56 PM Dear Palm Desert City Council, I am incredibly disappointed to be writing to you today in opposition to removing the city's recognition of Pride. We are living in a time when the LGBTQ+ community is under attack, and the city's recognition of Pride helps LGBTQ+ residents of Palm Desert feel safe in this community. This is about recognizing a marginalized community that faces prejudice and discrimination. Now more than ever, Palm Desert must commit to supporting and uplifting LGBTQ+ people and all other marginalized members of our community. I want to be clear that for me, commitment to uplifting the marginalized members of our community is an issue that is very important; it is at the core of the values of this country, and it is the issue that has the greatest impact on who I choose to vote for. I urge you to continue to recognize Pride and continue to support the LGBTQ+ community. Thank you. Sincerely, Cass 126 From:Andrew Butler To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Pride in Palm Desert Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 8:29:07 PM ‌ Dear Mayor and Members of the City Council, I write to you as the Rector of St. Margaret’s Episcopal Church, and as a grateful partner in the civic and community life of Palm Desert. Our congregation has long valued the City’s commitment to inclusion, dignity, and the wellbeing of all who live, work, and visit here. A large percentage of our parish consists of LGBTQ+ individuals and couples. I myself am a married gay man and am deeply aware of the current movement to turn back rights gained by our community, including the current administration’s efforts to erase the existence of our transgender brothers and sisters and to invalidate marriage equality for ALL Americans. On a personal note, my husband and I lived in Palm Desert in 2020 and experienced homophobia to the point where we moved to Palm Springs. In addition, I received several hostile anonymous calls from residents who were upset that our church was lit in rainbow colors for Pride. Obviously, there is much work to be done. I am writing to respectfully urge the City Council to continue recognizing Pride as an official city observance. For many in our community, Pride is not merely symbolic. It is a public affirmation that LGBTQ+ residents are seen, valued, and protected. Such recognition communicates that Palm Desert is a city where EVERY person, regardless of sexual orientation or gender identity, belongs and can flourish. In a time when many individuals experience uncertainty, fear, or marginalization, visible 127 acts of welcome matter deeply. From a faith perspective, The Episcopal Church is committed to the dignity of every human being, a principle rooted in our belief that all people are created in the image of God. At St. Margaret’s, we witness firsthand how public recognition and support can foster healing, hope, and trust, especially among those who have historically felt excluded from civic and religious spaces. Civic recognition of Pride also reflects Palm Desert’s values as a diverse, compassionate, and forward-looking city. It strengthens community cohesion, supports mental and emotional wellbeing, and signals to residents and visitors alike that Palm Desert stands for fairness, respect, and mutual care. We are grateful for the leadership you provide and for the ways the city has worked to build a community where differences are not merely tolerated but honored. I hope you will continue this important tradition by recognizing Pride as a city observance and by affirming the dignity and worth of all your constituents. Thank you for your service to Palm Desert and for your thoughtful consideration of this request. Please know of our prayers for wisdom and courage as you lead. Respectfully yours, The Rev. Andrew Butler III Rector, St. Margaret’s Episcopal Church Palm Desert, California 128 129 From:Jo Ann Bollen To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Save Pride in Palm Desert Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 8:38:56 PM ‌ Dear Palm Desert City Council, Please vote NO on Mayor Pro Tem Pradetto's proposal to review and potentially rescind policies recognizing LGBTQ+ Pride Month, citing a desire for "government neutrality and unity." I do not believe that erasing a large part of the community that is active, vibrant and very supportive of this Valley is promoting unity. This proposal is kow-towing to evangelical extremists and Trump supporters who want to pretend that a large segment of our community does not exist or worse, believes they should "burn in hell." As long as there are hate crimes, derision, insults, and contempt shown against the LGBTQ+ community, there is a need for Pride and the Pride flag. As an ally, I stand up for our LGBTQ+ community whenever I can. Inclusivity is important to me. Equality is important to me. I can't vote in Palm Desert, because I live in Thousand Palms. But my money visits there often. And if this proposal passes, my money will take a permanent vacation to other parts of the Valley. Thank you for listening. Respectfully, Jo Ann Bollen Thousand Palms, CA Jo Ann Bollen (she/her/ella) Field Team 6 National Voter Registration Trainer and Concierge Team Lead Founder, Vote Coachella Valley Chair, Programs Committee, Democrats of the Desert Register to Vote at https://voterizer.org/ 130 131 132 133 From:BRIAN OCONNOR To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Fwd: From Human Rights Campaign (HRC) and HRC Foundation Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 8:43:49 PM Attachments:image.png We sent you safe versions of your files.msg Human Rights Campaign Letter to Palm Desert Mayor Pro Tem Joe Pradetto and the Palm Desert City Council.pdf Mimecast Attachment Protection has deemed this file to be safe, but always exercise caution when opening files. ‌ OPEN LETTER To Palm Desert Mayor Pro Tem Joe Pradetto and the Palm Desert City Council From: Brian O’Connor, Member, Board of Directors, Human Rights Campaign / HRC Foundation Date: December 15, 2025 Mayor Pro Tem Pradetto and Councilmembers, As a member of the national Board of Directors of the Human Rights Campaign and HRC Foundation, (the largest civil rights organizations committed to equality for all Americans with a focus on the LGBTQ+ community) and as a Coachella Valley resident who works with organizations, families, employers, and civic leaders committed to equality, I am writing to address the Mayor Pro Tem’s proposal to eliminate Pride Month recognition in Palm Desert, including the removal of the Pride banner at City Hall. This proposal has already drawn wide public criticism—including from State Assemblymember Greg Wallis, who correctly stated that “Pride Month recognition doesn’t create division; it affirms that every resident deserves to be celebrated and respected.” He further called the proposal a “slap in the face” to LGBTQ+ residents. 1. The premise of your proposal is flawed and historically inaccurate You stated that the government should not “celebrate the private identities of one group over another” and should serve as a “neutral referee.” That framing ignores a fundamental truth: the government has not historically been neutral toward LGBTQ+ people. Government institutions at every level—federal, state, and municipal— enforced discrimination for decades through laws that criminalized LGBTQ+ relationships, denied family recognition, barred military service, blocked adoption, stripped employment protections, and more. In that context, “neutrality” is not neutral. It is a return to silence, and silence has always benefited the status quo—not the communities harmed by it. 2. Pride recognition is not favoritism—it is civic inclusion Pride Month is not about “celebrating private identities.” It is a public affirmation that LGBTQ+ residents belong fully in their own city. That message matters precisely because LGBTQ+ people continue to face harassment, discrimination, and violence across the country—including right here in California. 134 Cities regularly acknowledge communities and causes—Veterans Day, Hispanic Heritage Month, Black History Month, Women’s History Month, Disability Awareness, Earth Day, Indigenous Peoples’ Day. None of these diminish anyone else. Visibility is not division. Inclusion is not preferential treatment. 3. The rhetoric of “unity” cannot be used to erase a community Your comments claim that Palm Desert is “welcoming and integrated” and that the government should avoid “well-intentioned speech” that might generate division. This reverses reality. Pride recognition does not create division—erasing it does. The communities most harmed by discrimination do not experience “unity” simply because a city stops acknowledging them. They experience it when the city affirms them openly and unequivocally. 4. Palm Desert’s own stated values contradict your proposal The City’s existing inclusion resolution—2018-09—commits Palm Desert to upholding the dignity of residents across sexual orientation and gender identity and encourages residents to “celebrate each other’s differences.” Your proposal directly contradicts the City’s adopted values and dismantles an inclusion framework that Palm Desert publicly claimed to support. 5. The City has clarified that no action has been taken—this is the moment for leadership, not retreat The City Manager’s office confirmed that your request has merely been scheduled for future agenda placement, likely in January or February, and that any initial discussion will occur in a study session format to allow for full and thoughtful dialogue. That means there is time—right now—to avoid a needless, divisive, and harmful fight. It means you have the opportunity to correct the course. My request, stated plainly and directly Mayor Pro Tem Pradetto: I call on you to withdraw this motion immediately. Not table it. Not reframe it. Withdraw it. And I call on the Palm Desert City Council to: 1. Reject any attempt to remove Pride Month recognition, and 2. Reaffirm the City’s commitments to inclusion and equality. Palm Desert should not become the “Huntington Beach of the Coachella Valley” on LGBTQ+ issues. Our region is known nationwide for its welcoming posture, its diversity, and its leadership. This proposal undermines all of that and sends the wrong signal to residents, tourists, businesses, and young people who deserve a community that stands with them—not one that retreats from acknowledging their existence. I am available to meet with you or any Councilmember—alongside local LGBTQ+ residents and leaders—to discuss why Pride recognition is not symbolic politics, but a 135 The path forward is clear. Choose inclusion. Withdraw the proposal. Respectfully, Brian O’Connor Member, Board of Directors Human Rights Campaign and HRC Foundation Serving the Coachella Valley Affiliation listed for identification. Views expressed reflect my role as a board member and community leader. 136 From:Michael Johnson To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:OPPOSE Rescinding Resolution 2024-038 and Amending Resolution 2018-09 Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 8:53:31 PM ‌ Dear Councilmembers, I am writing to urge you to vote NO on the proposal to ban the Pride flag from City Hall and prevent the city from participating in Pride events. Banning the Pride flag and prohibiting city participation in Pride events sends a harmful message that some Palm Desert residents are less worthy of acknowledgement than others. Our LGBTQ+ neighbors, friends, and family members contribute to this community and deserve equal dignity and respect. Flying the Pride flag and participating in Pride events costs virtually nothing but means everything to those it affirms. This ban would make Palm Desert less welcoming and inclusive, values that should unite us, not divide us. This measure would also negatively impact tourism. LGBTQ+ travelers and their allies represent significant economic value to our desert communities. Banning Pride recognition signals that Palm Desert is not welcoming to all visitors, which will drive tourism dollars to more inclusive destinations. I respectfully ask you to reject this proposal and continue Palm Desert's commitment to recognizing all members of our community. We will not back down from this fight and are already organizing to remove any council member who supports this measure. Michael Johnson Palm Desert, CA 92211 137 From:RAYMOND LAFLEUR To:CouncilMeeting Comments; City Hall Mail; Evan Trubee; Joe Pradetto; Karina Quintanilla; Gina Nestande; Jan Harnik; Thomas Soule; alisa@pdacc.org Subject:Feedback from Greater Palm Springs Pride Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 8:59:04 PM 138 From:camahon To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Agenda 12/16 Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 8:59:35 PM Council members- I am a resident of Palm Springs but use and support services and businesses in Palm Desert. The agenda item (Resolution 2018-09) proposes to remove and revoke language supportive of the LGBTQ community in the Coachella Valley and beyond should be denied. Thank you. Catherine Mahon Palm Springs CA 92265 Sent from my iPhone 139 From:Musclebearmike To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Opposition to the motion to recind Resolution 2024-038 and amend Resolution 2018-09 Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 9:10:17 PM ‌ Mayor Trubee and City Council, I am a resident of Palm Desert, and I am strongly opposed to the motion made by Mayor Pro Tem Pradetto during the December 11, 2025, City Council meeting. I am very disappointed and deeply saddened that this motion was made and respectfully request that the entire council vote against the motion. I chose to retire in the Coachella Valley and specifically Palm Desert because of the diverse, welcoming community and I am proud that Palm Desert recognizes the LGBT community. Additionally, I oppose the motion for the following reasons: 1. There has been significant effort to cutback or remove diversity initiatives across all sectors of American life since Donald Trump was reelected. Diversity has been made out to be something "bad". This is wrong because diversity is great for the economy and people feel safe living in a community where diversity is embraced. Just because someone doesn't believe in the concept of inclusion doesn't mean it isn't worth promoting. A minority of vocal opponents to diversity should not be allowed to overshadow recognizing a significant segment of the residents in the Coachella Valley. Celebrating our diversity should be embraced not cancelled. 2. City government is not the right governmental entity to engage in culture-war, wedge issues and it is not appropriate to spend time and tax dollars to purposefully minimize/ignore a significant population that choose to call the Coachella Valley and Palm Desert their home. The Council should be solving "local" problems like addressing traffic congestion, improving the tax base by attracting new businesses and promoting public safety and other basic needs of the residents, not engaging in cultural wars. 3. By Mayor Pro Tem Pradetto saying the City shouldn't be in the business of "celebrating the private identity of one group over another" then say the City is welcoming to everyone is contradictory at best and is simply wrong. Under his reasoning, the City should also not recognize contributions of other diverse groups like girl scouts, police and firemen, public service groups like Rotary, and VFW, etc. To do so would also be wrong. Saying there isn't a need to recognize the LGBT community is mis-guided, divisive, and will have the opposite effect by implying the LGBT community is no longer welcome in Palm Desert. 4. By eliminating recognition of LGBT pride and the LGBT residents, business may be affected because residents and tourist/guests may choose to boycott Palm Desert and make a conscience decision to shop in other cities in the Coachella Valley. Despite the current direction on the federal level, promoting diversify has been proven to be good for business. 140 In summary, I respectfully request that you quit wasting time on this issue and get back to doing your jobs that you were elected to do and work to improve the quality of life for ALL residents of Palm Desert and to vote against the motion made by Mayor Pro Tem Pradetto. Respectfully, Michael J. Stafford Palm Desert 141 From:Greg Brisendine To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Palm Desert"s decision about Pride Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 9:10:59 PM ‌ Dear Palm Desert Council, I hear you…it seems as if it’s not necessary to speak up and speak out in protection and support of the LGBTQ+ community. Surely we’re past the need for that. Except that we’re not. According to FBI data as summarized by USAFacts, hate crimes motivated by anti-LGBTQ+ bias have risen 110% since 2015 (link to the facts below). I live in Palm Springs and regularly shop and spend time in Palm Desert. Please support my continuing desire to travel and spend money safely in that community. Greg Brisendine Are hate crimes on the rise? usafacts.org 142 From:Jessica Baldwin Bookland To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Pride Flag Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 9:20:55 PM Hello, I’ve been lucky enough to call Palm Desert my home for almost my entire life. I grew up here, and when my husband and I decided to start a family we moved back to Palm Desert to do so. Our two daughters attend Washington Charter School, just like I did as a child. I appreciate so many of the things the City of Palm Desert does to better serve the residents. From pedestrian safety, to park improvements, to local civic engagement, I have always felt that the city’s goal is to improve the lives of the people who live here. The recent proposal to remove the pride flag does not serve the residents of Palm Desert. It does not improve the experience of any citizens. Pride flags are flown so that all people feel represented, welcomed, and accepted. In a time where so many Palm Desert residents are struggling with serious issues, I am stunned that the city government is using valuable resources to strip representation away from LGBTQ citizens. Diversity is Palm Desert’s strength, and should be celebrated. I also find the last-minute meeting timeline highly questionable. Who can attend a midday meeting with less than 24 hours notice? Please, focus your energy on improving our city and celebrating all of our citizens. Sincerely, Jessica Bookland 143 From:Ron@ To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Item 3.a. Tuesday, December 16, 2025 | Please reject staff recommendation for item 3.a. Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 9:33:50 PM ‌ Honorable Members of the Palm Desert City Council, I share my strong opposition to Item 3.a. This is not a discussion about neutrality; it is aprofoundly divisive and exclusionary act. The proposal is not a neutral policy, but as a political act that actively undermines corevalue of inclusivity. Inclusion is not division; discrimination is. The members of the LGBTQ+ community are not a separate, niche entity. We are integralto the mainstream fabric of Palm Desert. We are African American and Hispanic; we areJewish, Christian, and Muslim; we are your neighbors, teachers, first responders, businessowners, and essential workers. Recognizing Pride Month and displaying a Pride banner issimply an acknowledgment of the humanity and contributions of a significant portion ofyour constituents. The Pride Flag is not an endorsement of a political party or a protest banner. It is a widelyrecognized, established symbol of welcome, safety, and human dignity for a communitythat has historically faced systemic discrimination and violence. For our LGBTQ+ neighbors,friends, and family, the colors of the banner are a crucial visible sign that they are seen,valued, and safe in their own city. The community reaction highlights that removing a symbol of acceptance is seen assending a “chilling message” and a “painful blow” to the LGBTQ+ community and theirallies. The proposal attempts to re-frame the display of the Pride banner as "divisive." However,to equate a banner celebrating identity and equality with flags representing hate or politicalparties is a false and harmful comparison. By moving to remove this established symbol of support, this proposal does not fosterunity; it actively creates the division and discord it claims to prevent. It sends anunequivocal message of rejection to residents and visitors alike. This move is perceived asimporting a divisive, national "culture war" into our community, prioritizing partisangrandstanding over genuine representation. When community members state that the flag makes them feel “seen and valued andwanted and understood,” its removal directly strips that feeling of validation. I urge you to consider the tangible impact of your vote. Reject Item 3.a. Reinforce, inaction, that Palm Desert’s commitment to being an open, diverse, and welcoming home foreveryone is non-negotiable. Thank you. Ron deHarte Co-president of USA Prides 144 President of Palm Springs Pride Board Member, Safe Schools Desert Cities Board Member, LGBTQ Archives of the Desert 145 From:Lauren Wolfer To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Public Comment Item 3a Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 9:46:16 PM ‌ As someone who grew up in the Coachella Valley, I am deeply disappointed and alarmed that the Palm Desert City Council is considering rescinding its resolutions supporting diversity and Pride Month. Calling this an effort toward unity is disingenuous. Pride celebrations are not divisive. What is divisive is pushing a reactionary political agenda while falsely presenting it as neutral governance. This proposal is clearly part of a broader, national effort to undermine the hard- earned rights, visibility, and protections the LGBTQ+ community has fought for over decades. That is shameful. It is also entirely at odds with the City’s own Envision Palm Desert Strategic Plan, which describes Palm Desert as a thriving, safe community strengthened by diversity, cultural vitality, and a high quality of life for all residents and visitors. It is shocking that Palm Desert would reverse its stated commitment to being a diverse and inclusive community. Rescinding these resolutions sends a clear signal that the City of Palm Desert does not value the safety and inclusion of LGBTQ+ residents and visitors, at a time when their rights are under unprecedented attack. I urge the City Council to reject this politically motivated attack and reaffirm commitment to creating a safe, welcoming community for all residents and visitors. Lauren Wolfer -- Lauren Wolfer Outreach and Advocacy Director COOK Alliance 146 From:Richard Jessup To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:LGBTQ+A Recognition and Inclusion Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 9:53:52 PM ‌ As a citizen of the Coachella Valley, I feel that I must comment on your consideration of rescinding the city of Palm Desert's participation in Gay Pride, plus removing Diversity and Inclusion Verbiage from City sites. This is a surprisingly tone-deaf move, especially from a city that has been, up to now, considered to be a 'well-run' city. Will someone please explain to me why acknowledging the repression and discrimination of the gay community (who has a large percentage of residents in your city), and celebrating the forward steps that have been taken should be rescinded?! Are you saying that your gay/lesbian'transgender residents dont make good contributions to the city, and that they are not worth acknowledging and celebrating? This kind of targeted discrimination must be called out and stopped, because it only adds to the division that now continues to fester in our larger society. I thought that you were a more progressive and forward-thinking council than this. Also, you do realize that making this move will cost the city of Palm Desert ~ Not just in good will, but in actual dollars, when those of us who might consider spending money in your city take our hard-earned dollars elsewhere, in mass. Discrimination is a sickness, one that must be identified as such, and eradicated from a society that is attempting to take steps forward in representing, and including all people that choose to reside in, and visit this area. Don't make the mistake of going down the path of judgment and hate. And if you do, be prepared for 'blowback' that may overwhelm you. Richard H Jessup, Palm Springs resident 147 From:Daniel Logan To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Resolution Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 10:03:14 PM ‌ Dear Council members, I am writing you to oppose the proposed resolution of no longer supporting Gay Pride Month. We all know Pradetto won by a slim margin and was heavily endorsed by those who have historically voted to deny gays their rights. I’ve watched several interviews with Mr Pradetto and I’ve read his full comments. I’ve watched and read how he twists definitions of words and it seems to me, he’s having a very difficult time convincing himself this was a great idea for his maiden voyage as Mayor of Palm Desert. Let’s talk strategy. 1) Don’t give in to haters. Sincerely, Daniel Logan Sent from my iPhone 148 From:Sheila Goldner To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Inclusion Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 10:08:50 PM ‌ We're all people. What gives anybody the right to decide something about other people? 149 From:Rita Johnson To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:OPPOSE Rescinding Resolution 2024-038 and Amending Resolution 2018-09 Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 10:16:08 PM ‌ Dear Councilmembers, I am writing to urge you to vote NO on the proposal to ban the Pride flag from City Hall and prevent the city from participating in Pride events. Banning the Pride flag and prohibiting city participation in Pride events sends a harmful message that some Palm Desert residents are less worthy of acknowledgement than others. Flying the Pride flag and participating in Pride events costs virtually nothing but means everything to those it affirms. This ban would make Palm Desert less welcoming and inclusive, values that should unite us, not divide us. Our LGBTQ+ neighbors, friends, and family members contribute to this community and deserve equal dignity and respect. This measure would also negatively impact tourism. LGBTQ+ travelers and their allies represent significant economic value to our desert communities. Banning Pride recognition signals that Palm Desert is not welcoming to all visitors, which will drive tourism dollars to more inclusive destinations. We can't afford more losses of tourism revenue. I respectfully ask you to reject this proposal and continue Palm Desert's commitment to recognizing all members of our community. We are already organizing to remove any council member who supports this measure. We will not back down from this fight. Rita Johnson Monterey Country Club Palm Desert, CA 92211 150 From:Linh Ho Young To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Public Comment Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 10:26:01 PM ‌ Celebrating LGBTQ+ in November sends a message to the community, especially to the youth of the community that live, work and go to school in Palm Desert that they are seen in a time when the past kept them hidden and in the dark with shame and discrimination. The rainbow flag represents the struggle of the past and now with the ability to live in the open. Please think about your constituents, their future and what message you want to give the youth in your community. Here is a fact: “According to The Trevor Project's 2024 survey, 39% of LGBTQ+ youth considered suicide in the past year, with 12% attempting suicide. Overall, LGBTQ+ youth are more than four times more likely to attempt suicide than their peers. Suicide is a leading cause of death for young people aged 10-24.” “Suicide risk stems from minority stress, not identity. Risk factors include discrimination, bullying, lack of mental health care, anti-LGBTQ+ policies, and family rejection. Protective factors involve having accepting adults, access to gender- affirming care, and living in an accepting community, which significantly reduce the risk of suicide attempts.” Linh Young Sent from Gmail Mobile 151 From:Tom Keim To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Pradetto’s push to end Palm Desert Pride Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 10:30:35 PM To whom it may concern, I am appalled at the idea that somebody would suggest that we should end a pride event for a segment of a community like Palm Desert. How does that create inclusion you want to integrate a community so that everybody is on some sort of even Keel all the way through how is that celebrating one another’s differences as I have seen written. We’ve seen a lot of of this around the country things that are similar trying to erase the knowledge and existence of the gay community. I see Palm Desert as a very desirable place. I go there all the time, but I live in Palm Springs. It strikes me as a very vital and open community as it is. Why do we need to change anything about that? How is that going to make it better. I can tell you that if that measure that you’re presenting passes then every time I come to Palm Desert I’m going to be reminded that maybe I’m not wanted there. It’s just a very unfortunate proposal and very disappointing. Tom Keim Palm Springs. Sent from Toms iPhone 152 From:gcrainemd@ To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Emergency meeting? To abolish Pride recognition so Palm Desert can become a business wasteland ? Really? Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 11:13:28 PM I am a retired physician - and a member of LGBT Q+ community. - This issue is going to impact Palm Desert city tax base, your businesses , restaurants, shopping if Palm Desert decides to become a MAGA mouthpiece. The council person and any other council member who votes to rescind Pride will be responsible to your business community for their economic losses because of your bigotry and shortsightedness— a World without a visible contributing gay community that is embraced and welcomed is a city no one wants a part of— get a clue! Gary L Craine M D Palm Springs, CA 92262 Sent from my iPhone 153 From:Eric Gutierrez To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Support LGBTQ pride Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 11:41:09 PM Palm Desert Council members, My name is Eric Gutierrez and I’m concerned to hear that the city may be considering rescinding its recognition of LGBTQ pride. I urge you to stand strong for the rights of all the communities you serve and ensure a safe and supportive environment for your LGBTQ citizens by not caving to bigotry and fear. Pride and the pride flag are essentially about unity and inclusion. Do not mistake the calls to ban them as anything but ways to divide us. We are better than that. Please do the right thing. Thank you, Eric Gutierrez 154 From:Wayne Broder To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Please do not become the Huntington Beach of the Coachella Valley Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 11:45:32 PM ‌ Dear Council members, While my husband and I live in Cathedral City, we frequently travel to Palm Desert as many of our favorite 'big box' stores are there such as Best Buy, Islands and Bob's Furniture. That being said, Should Pradetto's motion pass, we will no longer be visiting your city. We have had many pleasant shopping and eating experiences there but any future plans would create a lack of appetite to eat or spend any of our money there. Nor would we be inclined to suggest Palm Desert to our many friends from out of state nor our Canadian friends. Anything less than a full-throated repudiation from you, the council, will be a capitulation to the far right. Palm Desert is absolutely beautiful and we love visiting but we cannot support a city that does not support us. Thank you for your time. Wayne and Rob Broder Cathedral City, CA 92234 155 From:George D To:City Hall Mail Subject:Please support the Gay community and keep flying the rainbow flag. Thank you, George Dobosh Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 10:12:00 AM You have my permission to share this email with the city council and make it part of the public record. George Dobosh Sent from my iPhone 156 From:Justin Schneider To:City Hall Mail; Evan Trubee; Joe Pradetto; Karina Quintanilla; Gina Nestande; Jan Harnik Subject:Stop the attack on Pride Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 4:54:36 PM ‌ Dear Palm Desert City Council Members, I am writing to express my deep concern and strong opposition to any effort to remove or diminish the City of Palm Desert’s recognition of Pride and its support for the LGBTQ+ community. Actions that seek to exclude, silence, or disregard the LGBTQ+ population undermine those values and send a harmful message not only to LGBTQ+ residents, workers, and visitors, but also to their families, friends, and allies. Removing Pride recognition is more than a symbolic act—it is a statement about who is, and is not, valued by this city. LGBTQ+ individuals contribute profoundly to the social, cultural, and economic fabric of Palm Desert. When the city takes steps that marginalize them, it is choosing division over community. If the Council proceeds with efforts to erase or restrict Pride recognition, I—and many others who stand firmly for equality—will no longer shop, dine, or spend money in Palm Desert. Communities flourish when they embrace diversity, not when they turn away from it. My support, as a consumer and visitor, will follow those cities that uphold dignity, inclusion, and respect for all. I urge you to reconsider this decision and reaffirm Palm Desert’s commitment to being a welcoming city for everyone, including the LGBTQ+ community. Thank you for your attention and for your service to the community. Justin Schneider Resident, Palm Springs Work, Palm Desert 157 From:Daniela Ryan To:City Hall Mail Subject:PRIDE Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 5:58:41 PM I believe if the City of Palm Desert wants to be an inclusive, modern American city it needs to absolutely embrace every group including honoring our LGBTQ communities, Hispanic and black and Native communities. It is the right and moral thing to do. Regards, Daniela Ryan 158 From:TERRY WOOD To:City Hall Mail Subject:Resolution to have only American flag and california state flag at fed, county, and city buildings Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 6:11:55 PM ‌ Joe, I am writing about the topic that was bought up by the pro tem mayor, You are totally correct ……….. A city, county, or federal government office in Palm Desert should just have the American Flag and California State Flag only. In the late 1990's , the city recognized the gay community in a resolution. There is no problem here in this city with discrimination of the gay community. We don't need to do a month of gay pride banners everywhere. It is not like before the 1980's when the gay community only had its bars and clubs as a refuge. They are treated like anyone else now. In fact many have moved here in the last 5 years to get away from the craziness of bigger crime ridden cities. Thank you Paul Benson in a NBC Facebook feedback for pointing this out that everyone is treated on an equal bias without being favored over any other group of people in the valley. Let's focus on more important issues in the city that need to be dealt with in a timely manner and not sexuality. 159 From:Tyler Hicks To:joe@joepradetto.com; City Hall Mail Cc:Ashley Marie Hicks Subject:Meeting request from Palm Desert District 2 residents Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 6:25:07 PM ‌ Mayor Pro Tem Pradetto, I live with my family in 'The Summit' neighborhood located in Palm Desert District 2, and I supported you with my vote in the 2024 election. I have some specific questions and things I'd like to ask you in regard to your recent proposal to rescind the council’s resolution related to LGBTQ Pride Month commemorations and to amend the council’s resolution related to diversity and inclusion. Based on the City's scheduling of a special meeting for tomorrow, 12/16 at 1:30pm, and spokesperson Soule's public comments, it sounds likely that you'll be hearing from a number of residents in that public forum, and I applaud the City for taking quick action to provide this opportunity based on the community's feedback. Unfortunately, I will be unable to attend due to prior commitment I have in my professional role providing community programming at the Library and Observatory for the City of Rancho Mirage. However, I would appreciate the opportunity for my family and I to visit with you directly and clearly communicate our feelings on the issue, and also to hear from you to try to understand more about why you made this proposal, and why you believe it is an issue that District 2 residents (specifically) would see as a prudent use of time and resources. I can be reached directly at 630-715-6053 or tylerjhicks@gmail.com. I look forward to hearing from you. Best, T.J. Hicks 160 From:Monica Bury To:City Hall Mail Subject:Keep gay pride month Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 7:08:38 PM Don’t go backwards. Keep gay pride month. Monica Bury 161 From:RAYMOND LAFLEUR To:CouncilMeeting Comments; City Hall Mail; Evan Trubee; Joe Pradetto; Karina Quintanilla; Gina Nestande; Jan Harnik; Thomas Soule; alisa@pdacc.org Subject:Letter from Human Rights Campaign Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 7:13:01 PM ‌ Sending this in to be sure you’ve all received it. Copied your business leaders also. Rather than ramming this through, take the time to meet with our LGBT leaders and try to understand what you are truly doing. At tomorrow’s Council Meeting, agree to schedule a listening session. Raymond Lafleur OPEN LETTER To City of Palm Desert - Mayor Pro Tem Joe Pradetto and the Palm Desert City Council From: Brian O’Connor, Member, Board of Directors, Human Rights Campaign / HRC Foundation Mayor Pro Tem Pradetto and Councilmembers, As a member of the national Board of Directors of the Human Rights Campaign and HRC Foundation, (the largest civil rights organizations committed to equality for all Americans with a focus on the LGBTQ+ community) and as a Coachella Valley resident who works with organizations, families, employers, and civic leaders committed to equality, I am writing to address the Mayor 162 Pro Tem’s proposal to eliminate Pride Month recognition in Palm Desert, including the removal of the Pride banner at City Hall. This proposal has already drawn wide public criticism— including from State Assemblymember Greg Wallis, who correctly stated that “Pride Month recognition doesn’t create division; it affirms that every resident deserves to be celebrated and respected.” He further called the proposal a “slap in the face” to LGBTQ+ residents. 1. The premise of your proposal is flawed and historically inaccurate You stated that the government should not “celebrate the private identities of one group over another” and should serve as a “neutral referee.” That framing ignores a fundamental truth: the government has not historically been neutral toward LGBTQ+ people. Government institutions at every level —federal, state, and municipal—enforced discrimination for decades through laws that criminalized LGBTQ+ relationships, denied family recognition, barred military service, blocked adoption, stripped employment protections, and more. In that context, “neutrality” is not neutral. It is a return to silence, and silence has always benefited the status quo 163 —not the communities harmed by it. 2. Pride recognition is not favoritism—it is civic inclusion Pride Month is not about “celebrating private identities.” It is a public affirmation that LGBTQ+ residents belong fully in their own city. That message matters precisely because LGBTQ+ people continue to face harassment, discrimination, and violence across the country— including right here in California. Cities regularly acknowledge communities and causes— Veterans Day, Hispanic Heritage Month, Black History Month, Women’s History Month, Disability Awareness, Earth Day, Indigenous Peoples’ Day. None of these diminish anyone else. Visibility is not division. Inclusion is not preferential treatment. 3. The rhetoric of “unity” cannot be used to erase a community Your comments claim that Palm Desert is “welcoming and integrated” and that the government should avoid “well-intentioned speech” that might generate division. This reverses reality. Pride recognition does not create division—erasing it does. 164 The communities most harmed by discrimination do not experience “unity” simply because a city stops acknowledging them. They experience it when the city affirms them openly and unequivocally. 4. Palm Desert’s own stated values contradict your proposal The City’s existing inclusion resolution—2018-09— commits Palm Desert to upholding the dignity of residents across sexual orientation and gender identity and encourages residents to “celebrate each other’s differences.” Your proposal directly contradicts the City’s adopted values and dismantles an inclusion framework that Palm Desert publicly claimed to support. 5. The City has clarified that no action has been taken— this is the moment for leadership, not retreat The City Manager’s office confirmed that your request has merely been scheduled for future agenda placement, likely in January or February, and that any initial discussion will occur in a study session format to allow for full and thoughtful dialogue. That means there is time—right now—to avoid a needless, divisive, and harmful fight. It means you have 165 the opportunity to correct the course. My request, stated plainly and directly Mayor Pro Tem Pradetto: I call on you to withdraw this motion immediately. Not table it. Not reframe it. Withdraw it. And I call on the Palm Desert City Council to: 1. Reject any attempt to remove Pride Month recognition, and 2. Reaffirm the City’s commitments to inclusion and equality. Palm Desert should not become the “Huntington Beach of the Coachella Valley” on LGBTQ+ issues. Our region is known nationwide for its welcoming posture, its diversity, and its leadership. This proposal undermines all of that and sends the wrong signal to residents, tourists, businesses, and young people who deserve a community that stands with them—not one that retreats from acknowledging their existence. I am available to meet with you or any Councilmember— alongside local LGBTQ+ residents and leaders—to discuss why Pride recognition is not symbolic politics, but a vital statement of civic belonging. 166 The path forward is clear. Choose inclusion. Withdraw the proposal. Respectfully, Brian O'Connor Member, Board of Directors Human Rights Campaign and HRC Foundation Serving the Coachella Valley Affiliation listed for identification. Views expressed reflect my role as a board member and community leader. 167 From:Grace Garner To:City Hall Mail Subject:Emergency Resolution Public Comment Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 7:19:45 PM ‌ Mayor and Councilmembers: I spoke at my first Palm Springs city council meeting when I was 19 years old. I was there in support of marriage equality. At the time the issue was highly controversial but our city council knew the importance of representing the LGBTQ+ community even then. As only a 19-year-old can, I started my comments with, “I don’t understand how this is an issue. Why is it an issue!?” I find myself thinking the same thing today about your latest meeting request. It is concerning and disappointing to hear you may rescind resolution no. 2024-038 wherein the council agreed to display a banner recognizing Pride month and requests that the council consider a Pride proclamation annually and may attend the Pride parade. This is a small act in support of a community that is regularly attacked and misrepresented, especially by our current President and administration. The LGBTQ+ community is beautiful and vibrant. I have the honor of serving with a majority LGBTQ+ city council. The vision and care my colleagues bring to our council discussions makes it clear they care about every single member of our community. For the last six years we have signed proclamations in support of Black History Month, Filipino Heritage Month, Hispanic Heritage Month, Pride Month, Juneteenth, Native American Heritage Month and many others. It is a joy to celebrate the diverse communities that make up Palm Springs and the Coachella Valley. It is not an act of division, it is an act of full-hearted embrace of every single resident and visitor. I urge you to maintain resolution no. 2024-038 and to take seriously the many public comments you are surely receiving on this topic. In your discussion of resolution no. 2018-09 may you remember that our differences are what makes each of us unique and what has created the incredible country and region we have the honor to represent. I leave you with the words I said at the end of my public comment in 2004, “everyone needs to care and love each other. If everyone did this, our world would be such a better place.” Grace Elena Garner, Esq. Palm Springs City Council, District 1 168 From:Liza Baldwin To:City Hall Mail Subject:Pride Week recognition Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 7:25:52 PM Greetings from a 34 year resident of Palm Desert. My husband and I moved to Palm Desert in 1991 and raised our three daughters here. Now we have another generation calling Palm Desert home - our two granddaughters live nearby and attend Washington Charter School. One of the things that makes Palm Desert a great place to live is the diversity of the city’s population. Our family supports and celebrates diversity and inclusion. Joe Pradetto's proposal to stop recognizing Pride Week in Palm Desert smells Trumpy to me, and his argument that recognizing the diversity in our community might create division rather than unity is imbecilic. Please vote NO on this short sighted political maneuver and keep up the recognition of Pride Week, including flying the banner! Sincerely, Liza Baldwin Golden Bush Ct, Palm Desert 169 From:David Catanzarite To:City Hall Mail Cc:ICE, Karen Lin, Spouse Subject:Recognition of Pride Should Continue and Be Expanded! Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 7:33:40 PM ‌ Dear Mayor Pradetto and City Council, I am a long-time resident of Palm Desert, and am appalled to learn that our city is even considering a halt to the city's recognition of LGBTQ Pride. Mr. Pradetto, you presented yourself in your city council campaign to be someone who would stand up for all the people of Palm Desert. Now you are leading a move to erase our LGBTQ neighbors and refuse them recognition at City Hall and in the city's calendar. For shame! I don't always agree with Greg Wallis, but his comments in the Desert Sun are absolutely on point: "Pride Month recognition does not create division. It affirms that every resident deserves to be celebrated and respected." The same is true for residents who are Hispanic, African American, and Asian. It is important that the city celebrate their unique histories, which belong to all Americans. Mr. Pradetto's proposal has already promoted fear, hate and bigotry. It is an embarrassment that Palm Desert is even considering such a measure. Please kill the proposal immediately. We need to do everything we can to make Palm Desert MORE safe and inclusive for all of its citizens, including young people. Every resident should know they belong to our community and can fully participate without fear of insult or psychological and physical intimidation. Our city needs to be safe for everyone or else Palm Desert is not really safe at all. Sincerely, David Catanzarite Executive Artistic Director 170 From:Ryland Penta To:City Hall Mail Subject:Fw: Pride Banners Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 7:44:50 PM Ryland Penta, MSc Community Relations Supervisor City of Palm Desert 73510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert, CA 92260 rpenta@palmdesert.gov | 760.776.6318 | www.palmdesert.gov From: Jeffrey Howard <jeffreyhoward@mindspring.com> Sent: Monday, December 15, 2025 18:38 To: Community Relations <CommunityRelations@palmdesert.gov> Subject: Pride Banners ‌ As a straight white 79 year old male I am horrified by the thought of removing pride banners from city hall. It’s tantamount to poking a stick in the eye of the LGBT community. Please reconsider an incredibly unwise decision. Jeffrey Howard Law Offices of Jeffrey M. Howard Palm Desert, CA 92260 Cell jeffreyhoward@ 171 From:Rikki Frucht To:City Hall Mail Subject:Do NOT end Pride recognition Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 7:56:11 PM ‌ We were shocked to learn that the city council is actually considering ending recognition of Pride month in Palm Desert. We strongly urge the rejection of this proposal. Pride does not elevate one group at the expense of another. What elevation is taking place? The only elevation that will take place is that of our sister cities which do recognize Pride. Friends are wondering why we chose to live here. Businesses will suffer, especially restaurants when others choose to take their money elsewhere. All we see is a political agenda, a red herring, that serves no benefit to anyone. Frankly the mere suggestion that this is even being considered has already adversely affected the reputation of our community. Palm Desert is a wonderful community. This proposal is the furthest thing from wonderful. Please put this idea to rest immediately and do a little public relations cleanup. Sue Frucht Rikki Frucht 172 From:klin77777@ To:City Hall Mail Subject:NO ON LGBTQ Pride ban and other groups Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 8:52:17 PM ‌ Dear Mr. Predetto: I am a voter who lives in Palm Desert and I met you at JC's Cafe earlier this year to talk about your values and your policies when you were campaigning. You talked about fiscal responsibility and managing homelessness, and crime. You presented yourself to be a reasonable man who would stand up for all the people of Palm Desert, but today I read otherwise. I read about you in the Desert Sun today and was very disappointed to see that you want to abolish recognizing LGBTQ pride month at city hall. I am shocked at your view and disagree with your proposal. You may ask yourself, "why recognize LGBTQ? Why don't straight people get recognition?" I will answer for you. It's because you already matter. Every day that you wake up, nobody is going to hurt you for being straight - you don't live in fear for being bullied or harmed for being you. You are telling LGBTQ that "they don't matter." This is why we NEED to speak up and let them KNOW they matter. Your proposal creates fear, hate, bigotry, and it is an embarrassment to Palm Desert. Please kill this proposal and do what's right. Make Palm Desert safe and inclusive to all so it will be a place that will shine to the world. I agree with Greg Wallis when he was quoted in today's Desert Sun paper saying "Pride Month recognition does not create division. It affirms that every resident deserves to be celebrated and respected." Palm Desert is better than that. We already drove away the Canadians (and all kinds of other groups of people) ...and our economy is suffering. How many more groups of people do we want to drive away? Do not insult and marginalize we the good people of Palm Desert. This also goes for recognizing #HispanicHeritageMonth #BlackHistoryMonth #NativeAmericanHeritageMonth #AAPIheritagemonth. The city needs to be safe for everyone or else Palm Desert is not really safe at all. Sincerely, Karen Lin American Citizen Resident and Voter 173 From:Sue Knollenberg To:City Hall Mail Subject:Nestande"s Constituents Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 8:57:04 PM Hello, we live in Council Member Nestande's 3rd District. We are a Lesbian couple who have resided in Palm Desert for 18 years. We are retired professionals and value the Coachella Valley for its embrace of diversity and acceptance of difference. We do not support the proposal to discontinue Palm Desert's support of Pride month and the removal of the Pride flag at City Hall. LGBT people vote with their dollars. I urge you to not support this divisive proposal. Susan Knollenberg Marsha Gronseth Palm Desert Sue Knollenberg “What we have enjoyed deeply we can never lose. All that we love deeply becomes a part of us.” Helen Keller 174 From:Scott Butterfield To:City Hall Mail Subject:Why? Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 10:08:48 PM ‌ Honorable Mayor Pro Tem Pradetto, Why in the world, especially at this time, would you start this homophobic dialogue. Are you trying to get some PUBLICITY? Guess it’s working for you. Shame. Do you not realize how many LGBTQ folks live in Palm Desert? Do you not realize how many LGBTQ people spend money in Palm Desert? Please, rethink this. There are so many, many positive things you could bring attention to instead of pulling people down. That is what you are attempting to do. Sincerely, Scott Butterfield 175 From:Jon Euzent To:City Hall Mail; Evan Trubee; Joe Pradetto; Karina Quintanilla; Gina Nestande; Jan Harnik; alisa@pdacc.org; Thomas Soule Subject:Support for Pride Recognition in Palm Desert — Unity, Community, and Economic Stability Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 3:43:22 AM ‌ I am writing as a new resident of the valley and supporter of our Palm Desert community to express my deep concern regarding the recent discussions about removing official recognition of Pride events in our city. Palm Desert has long been a place known for its inclusivity, welcoming spirit, and warm embrace of diversity. It’s one of the primary reasons I moved to the valley. That reputation is not only a point of pride for many of us who live here, but it is also a significant part of what makes our community attractive to visitors from across the country and around the world. For members of the LGBTQ+ community — including family members, friends, neighbors, and colleagues — Pride recognition is not simply symbolic. It represents visibility, safety, and affirmation in a world where too many still face discrimination, exclusion, or erasure. Official support from our local government sends a powerful message that Palm Desert truly stands with all of its residents. Removing that recognition would not only be hurtful on a personal and human level, but it also threatens to create further division at a time when unity and support are needed most. The community has the opportunity to lead with compassion and inclusion, not send a message that some of our citizens are less valued than others. In addition, in a moment when tourism has been challenging for our local businesses, preserving events and recognitions that bring visitors, support local vendors, and foster economic activity is critically important. Pride events have historically brought thousands of visitors to our region, filling hotel rooms, restaurants, shops, and supporting the small businesses that are the backbone of our local economy. Loss of official support risks 176 177 From:Jeffrey Bernstein To:City Hall Mail Subject:Comment on December 16, 2025 Council Meeting Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 6:55:34 AM ‌ ‌Mayor, Mayor pro tem and Councilmembers, Tomorrow, December 16, 2025 at 1:30 pm, the Palm Desert City Council will hold a special meeting to discuss Mayor pro tem Joe Pradetto's proposal to rescind Palm Desert City Council Resolution No. 2024-0183. ' This resolution, from 2024, includes the display of a banner at City hall in November to Commemorate Pride Month and coincide with local events. This proposal, to stop recognizing Pride Month and no longer display the banner, is a reminder that the fight for equality is not yet over. Veiled among suggestions that celebrating one group separates rather than unites, this move must be condemned for what it is: an attack on the LGBTQ+ community. Celebrating all is what unites us. We are a nation of Native Americans and immigrants, a great melting pot where all should be welcome, where all should be celebrated. The proposal before the Palm Desert City Council divides us. We are Valley of great diversity and it is important to recognize those communities that have long suffered discrimination. In this day and age, when there is an increase in hate and divisiveness, it saddens me that this proposal comes from a Council Member in a neighboring city with whom Palm Springs shares so much. It is unfortunate that in an era where we speak about Greater Palm Springs with such pride, if this proposal passes, we must now be in a position to remind the world that not all of Greater Palm Springs shares Palm Springs' values. I would be remiss if I didn't add that this proposal by Mayor pro tem Pradetto also poses a threat to our economy, one that is based on tourism, and ensuring that all feel welcome. We know the LGBTQ+ community plays a significant role in our economic success. I am so proud to live in and work for the City of Palm Springs, where all are celebrated. I'm proud of our City where all peoples are celebrated: LGBTQ+, Filipino, Latino, Black, Veterans, Native Americans and all others. I'm proud of our City where we hang flags for Pride Month, Juneteenth, Black History Month, POW/MIAs and so proudly display the California and United States I urge the Palm Desert City Council to do the right thing and uphold the resolution. Respectfully, Jeffrey Bernstein Coucilmember City of Palm Springs 442-305-9942 178 Jeffrey.Bernstein@palmspringsca.gov 179 From:Toby To:City Hall Mail Subject:Pride Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 7:22:32 AM I cannot strongly enough encourage the Palm Desert City council to discourage yet again another attempt to disparage and erase the gay community. It is appalling that any city here in the Coachella Valley would actively take steps to go backwards in their support of the LGBTQA+ community. Pride lifts all of us and encourages support of a very marginalized community to gain a measure of equality especially now during these very turbulent times. Please please do not make this egregious mistake by removing Pride symbols from your city. Thank you, Toby Shelley Cathedral City resident 180 From:SANDRA Gutierrez To:City Hall Mail Subject:Keep Pride Month Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 7:56:27 AM I am a 33 year resident of Palm Desert. I take pride in the diversity of our community. Opening our hearts and minds to others strengthens our community. Discontinuing Pride Month sends the message that the City Council and the city of Palm Desert do not support the LGBTQ+ community. It would be a cruel, insensitive message to send. I urge you to KEEP PRIDE MONTH in Palm Desert. Sincerely, Sandra Gutierrez Sent from my iPhone 181 From:Harold Katkov To:joe@joepradetto.com; City Hall Mail Subject:The Pride flag needs to fly proudly at Palm Desert City Hall. Period. Full stop. Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 8:12:45 AM ‌ Hello, Palm Desert Mayor Pro Tem Joe Perdetto and the City Council. My name is Hal Katkov. I’m a 68- year-old gay man living in Palm Desert. I’m concerned that Palm Desert Mayor Pro Tem Joe Perdetto and the City Council want to stop flying the Pride flag at City Hall. They claim the LGBTQ+ community is “integrated enough.” Sadly, that couldn’t be further from the truth. Here are three reasons why. Reason 1: HATE CRIMES HAVE INCREASED DRAMATICALLY IN THE U.S. · Data from the FBI shows that reported hate crimes increased dramatically in the U.S., with the number of reported incidents more than doubling from 2015 to 2024. DOUBLING. · That’s just REPORTED incidents; many aren’t reported, so the number is much higher. Reason 2: HATE CRIMES HAVE INCREASED DRAMATICALLY IN CALIFORNIA · California data shows rising hate crimes overall, with assaults and intimidation being common, often targeting race, sexual orientation, and gender identity. Reason 3: HATE CRIMES HAVE INCREASED DRAMATICALLY IN THE COACHELLA VALLEY · Palm Springs leads Riverside County in 2024 hate crimes in California, DOJ report says. · Yes, Palm Springs isn’t Palm Desert… but Palm Springs is just 12.4 miles from Palm Desert. There’s no wall separating them and the hate that’s increasing today. CONCLUSION · Mayor Pro Tem Joe Perdetto’s assertion that the LGBTQ+ community is “integrated enough” is patently false. · In fact – as the stats show – there’s never been a MORE IMPORTANT time to fly the Pride flag, which promotes unity, dignity, inclusion and respect. Not only for the LGBTQ+ community, but for EVERYBODY. The Pride flag needs to fly proudly at Palm Desert City Hall. Period. Full stop. -- Hal Katkov 182 183 From:Sukie de la Croix To:City Hall Mail Subject:Boycott Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 8:36:43 AM ‌ I was deeply saddened when I read that you were not supporting Gay Pride anymore. I realize that you have yet to vote on the matter, but even to consider doing this is enough for me to join the boycott of Palm Desert businesses. I have stopped going for Sunday breakfast with three friends at Paradise Cove—we have replaced that with the Palms in Rancho Mirage. Bill's Pizza is where I was going have my birthday celebration—I have friends looking for an alternative Pizzeria. The French Corner Cafe where I sometimes had lunch is now out of the question for me or my friends. Wholefoods I've replaced with Sprouts in Palm Springs. Chef Tania was where I took visiting vegans—now replaced by Native Foods in Palm Springs. I used to go to Starbucks near Revivals thrift store—now I choose Koffi in Rancho Mirage. I'm very sad that some of you are choosing to make me unwelcome in your town, but there are plenty of alternatives. 184 From:City of Palm Desert To:City Hall Mail Subject:In support of your proposals on the gay pride banner Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 9:15:47 AM ‌ Message submitted from the <City of Palm Desert> website. Site Visitor Name: Bob Mazur Site Visitor Email: While I emailed the City Clerk's office with the below comments for today's Council meeting, I think the council will be inundated with comments due to your 100% correct and on point proposals. Wanted you to know that you have our strong support and agreement on these issues. It's unfortunate that there is such a hysterical reaction. Stay Strong. 185 1 Michelle Nance From:City Hall Mail Subject:FW: Boycotting Palm Desert Businesses From: Trevor O'Donnell <trevodonnell@ Sent: Tuesday, December 16, 2025 8:49 AM To: theshops@chartwellproperties.net <theshops@chartwellproperties.net> Subject: Boycotting Palm Desert Businesses To the Shops at El Paseo: As you may know, Palm Desert Mayor Pro Tem Joe Pradetto is trying to rescind the city's Pride Month resolution and eliminate pride flag displays. I am a Palm Springs resident who shops and dines regularly in Palm Desert, but if Mr. Pradetto succeeds, this will come to an abrupt and permanent end. I would like to encourage the Shops at El Paseo to stand by ALL the patrons who support your stores and restaurants - and your city's economy. Tainting Palm Desert with the stink of anti-gay hatred is an incredibly bad move for local businesses. Yours, Trevor O'Donnell Palm Springs, CA 186 From:Fran Ferguson To:City Hall Mail Subject:Gay Rights Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 9:25:11 AM As a 30 year resident of Palm Desert I am both ashamed and angry that PD leadership would promote actions aimed at diminishing the gay community. The argument that gay pride is somehow discriminatory merely displays bigotry and insecurity. I recognize it is a sign of the times to target minorities but I want my voice heard loud and clear-gay contributions to our city, our world and our wellbeing are important and should be encouraged and appreciated not singled out for their pride. Fran Ferguson STRAIGHT Palm Desert resident Sent from my iPhone 187 From:Francisco Lopez To:City Hall Mail Subject:Fw: CANCELED Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 9:27:28 AM Francisco Lopez Visitor Center Specialist City of Palm Desert 73510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert, CA 92260 flopez@palmdesert.gov | 760.837.1661 | www.palmdesert.gov From: Gmail <cwg31869@ Sent: Monday, December 15, 2025 7:17:55 PM To: VcenterMail <Vcenter@palmdesert.gov> Subject: CANCELED My husband and I have canceled all up coming trios to your community. Your community and its current leadership appears to hate the LGBTQIA community and we have made a decisions we will no longer support communities that do not support us. For years your community has given the appearance of accepting and welcoming our community, that ended the minute your community leadership made it their mission to demonize the gay community. As he was elected by YOUR COMMUNITY he clearly shared the values of your entire population. it is clear your community has abused our community and stolen from our pocket books for years all while loathing our community. That ends today for me and my family, we will be traveling to Spain and Portugal where we are welcomed. Carl Gilbert Sent from my iPad 188 From:Gary Bennett To:City Hall Mail Subject:Opposition to proposal Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 9:39:19 AM ‌ I am opposed to the proposition to rescind City Council resolution 2024‑038, which outlines the city’s commemorations for LGBTQ Pride Month. Regards, Gary Bennett Palm Desert CA 92260 Sent from AT&T Yahoo Mail on Android 189 From:Dave Muth To:City Hall Mail Subject:Palm Desert Recognition Flags Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 9:55:12 AM Attachments:September - Suicide Prevention Month.png ‌ Hello Erika, Thank you for returning my telephone call yesterday. As a Palm Desert resident, I want to feel equally recognized and included in our community and I appreciate you bringing this to the attention of those who represent me as a resident and taxpayer. At your request, below are the causes that I would like the City Council to recognize by installing a flag on the side of City Hall. January: National Human Trafficking Prevention Month May: Mental Health Awareness Month and Memorial Month July: Independence Month September: Suicide Prevention Month November: Veterans Recognition Month To avoid recognizing any of my messages or purposes over another's, I would also like for the community to have input on the causes that they would like to have recognized as well. I would also encourage the City’s attorney to develop a standard-sized flag and duration that it is to be hung so that no one group is elevated or recognized over another. Attached to this email are the flags that I would like to see hung on the side of City Hall. Thank you for your consideration in this manner, David Muth 190 191 192 193 From:PollyOEntertainment LLC To:City Hall Mail Subject:Grave Concern over the Proposal to Rescind Resolution 2024-038 Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 9:58:09 AM ‌ Mayor Pro Tem Padretto, By means of introduction, our names are Rene Reyes and Shane Rosamonda. We recently purchased a home within the City of Palm Desert. We are small business owners, full time citizens of this fair city, and we are also a married gay couple. We are writing to you today to express our deep concern over your recent request to rescind City Council resolution number 2024-038 related to LGBTQ Pride Month Commemorations. After living in Coachella Valley for the last two- and one-half years, we decided to purchase a home in Palm Desert. Before making this decision, our main concerns were whether we would be safe in this area, and whether we would be welcome here. These are concerns that most, if not all, members of our large, economically powerful community, have to ask themselves before making a decision about where to live. They are also questions that no one should have to ask, but far too many of us do. Over our last three months as residents here we have been heartened by the welcome we have received from our neighbors and from the businesses we frequent and support in this city. We were especially encouraged to see the banner on City Hall commemorating Pride Month. A single banner, up for only a few weeks a year, made a significant difference in our lives. The fact that it was on City Hall made us feel welcome, safe, protected, and valued as members of this community by the local government in our chosen home. It also validated our decision to move here, make our lives here, and contribute to this community economically, culturally and as good citizens. That is why it is especially concerning and gravely disheartening that this governing body could rescind this small acknowledgement that has made a world of difference in our lives. That it could consciously affirm that we were wrong, that we are not safe, not welcome, not protected, nor valued in the City of Palm Desert. It is shocking that this decision could be made during this particular time of year. A time held sacred across the many cultures, creeds and different communities that make up the fabric of Palm Desert. There are vital challenges affecting any emergent city, including Palm Desert, but this issue, and your decisions today, speak to the content of 194 your individual characters and the content of your character as a governing body. Not acknowledging and celebrating our differences does not make us stronger, rather it makes us blind to those around us. A vibrant and healthy community is made so by our differences as people and what we can achieve together. Today, we encourage you to decline this proposal, and to affirm that every member of this community is safe, valued, and welcome here. Any other choice would be detrimental to every citizen of Palm Desert — economically, culturally, and socially. Please choose to affirm community, humanity and safety as vital ideals of the City of Palm Desert. Sincerely, Rene Reyes & Shane Rosamonda Co-Presidents Polly O. Entertainment _____________________________ Rene Reyes & Shane Rosamonda Polly O. Entertainment, LLC. www.pollyoentertainment.com 195 From:michael weitzel To:City Hall Mail Subject:Oppose Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 9:51:14 AM ‌ Dear Ms Harnik I live in Palm Desert moved to here 40 years ago. I oppose today's request to stop recognizing Pride month in our city. Honestly there has to be more important issues to confront than who gay women and men choose to love. Thank you, Michael Weitzel Palm Desert, CA 196 From:Bradford Dunkin To:City Hall Mail Subject:You’re making a problem where there is no problem. Fuck off. Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 10:42:10 AM ‌ Sent from the all new AOL app for iOS 197 From:Margery Shelton To:City Hall Mail Subject:The Pride Flag Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 10:45:54 AM ‌ Dear Mayor Pro Team, Joe Pradetto, and the Palm Desert City Council, Each of the Pride Flag's six rainbow colors has a unique meaning: Red: Life, Orange: Healing, Yellow: Sunlight, Green: Nature, Blue: Serenity, Purple: Spirit When you propose to take down the flag it is life, healing, sunlight, nature, serenity, and spirit that you want to negate. Those are a part of all of us. I assume you want to take the flag down as a way to ignore or marginalize my brothers and sisters of the LGBTQ community. That is not acceptable. They are as important in this community as anyone else. If the proposal to revise the diversity policy leads to marginalization of or discrimination against any group in our community, it is not acceptable. I strongly oppose this request. Maggie Shelton Palm Desert, CA 92260 198 From:Rikki Frucht To:City Hall Mail Subject:Re: Do NOT end Pride recognition Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 10:55:18 AM ‌ Thank you. We need to add that we have friends looking to move to the Valley and they will now be ruling out Palm Desert. If this is implemented they won't be the last. On Tue, Dec 16, 2025, 10:37 AM City Hall Mail <cityhall@palmdesert.gov> wrote: Good morning. Thank you for your email. It will be shared with the City Council and made part of the public record ahead of today’s meeting. Best, Michelle From: Rikki Frucht Sent: Monday, December 15, 2025 7:56 PM To: City Hall Mail <cityhall@palmdesert.gov> Subject: Do NOT end Pride recognition We were shocked to learn that the city council is actually considering ending recognition of Pride month in Palm Desert. We strongly urge the rejection of this proposal. Pride does not elevate one group at the expense of another. What elevation is taking place? The only elevation that will take place is that of our sister cities which do recognize Pride. Friends are wondering why we chose to live here. Businesses will suffer, especially restaurants when others choose to take their money elsewhere. All we see is a political agenda, a red herring, that serves no benefit to anyone. Frankly the mere suggestion that this is even being considered has already adversely affected the reputation of our community. Palm Desert is a wonderful community. This proposal is the furthest thing from wonderful. Please put this idea to rest immediately and do a little public relations cleanup. Sue Frucht Rikki Frucht 199 200 From:Pam Cleland To:CityClerk Subject:Gay Pride Flag Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 8:10:55 PM Dear City Council Members: I have lived in Palm Desert since 1989. I was a teacher at both Palm Desert Charter Middle School and Washington Charter School for 23 years. I have been an Ophelia Project Mentor for 10 years. I value our community and and the diversity we have. I respect each individual's rights to be who there are and express their identity. I encourage all City Council members to vote against the proposed plan to rescind the city's resolution recognizing Pride Month. Thank you for your thoughtful consider this matter and its impact on the residents in our community. Pam Cleland Sent from my iPhone 201 From:Sheryl Lehmann To:CityClerk Subject:Dec. 16 Special meeting of Palm Desert City Council Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 8:45:17 PM In 1992, our family proudly moved to Palm Desert and for the past 33 years, it has been our home. We applaud the city for adopting a resolution valuing and protecting the rights of all people. As a nation and in our community, we are witnessing actions of our fellow citizens that stoke division instead of inclusion. The LGBTQ+ community is experiencing verbal attacks and violence that strive to divide us as opposed to uniting us. As elected officials, we look to you as role models and to stand up and speak publicly in support of equality and acceptance. Flying a celebratory banner in, our opinion, is necessary and one of many ways in which council members in our city of Palm Desert can show support for the LGBTQ+ community. Thank you for the opportunity to share our thoughts. Sheryl and Allan Lehmann 202 From:Laura E James To:CityClerk Subject:Support for Pride Month Recognition Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 9:11:00 PM ‌ Dear Mayor, Mayor Pro Tem, and Members of the Palm Desert City Council, As a Palm Desert resident of more than ten years and a voter in District 2, I am writing to express my strong support for the continued recognition of Pride Month and for the display of Pride banners at City Hall. Recognizing Pride Month does not elevate one group over others or create division. Rather, it acknowledges the lived experiences of LGBTQ+ residents who have historically been marginalized; it affirms that they belong in our community. Palm Desert has a strong track record of inclusion, and this has always been a source of pride for me as a Palm Desert resident. Through cultural heritage commemorations, accessibility initiatives, and the investment required to earn Autism-Friendly City certification, the City has demonstrated that recognizing diverse experiences strengthens our community rather than divides it. Inclusivity is not a finite resource. Recognition exists precisely because some experiences are not universal. Supporting LGBTQ+ residents does not diminish anyone else. Instead, it reinforces Palm Desert’s values of respect, empathy, and belonging. This issue is personal to me, as my family includes members of the LGBTQ+ community. I want Palm Desert to remain a city where everyone feels seen, supported, and celebrated. I respectfully urge the City Council to continue recognizing Pride Month and to maintain the Pride banner at City Hall. Thank you for your consideration. Respectfully, Laura E James, MBA, CEcD Palm Desert Resident, District 2 203 From:Michael Davis To:CityClerk Subject:meeting Tuesday 12/16 Pride Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 9:20:08 PM Attachments:We sent you safe versions of your files.msg pride2.docx Mimecast Attachment Protection has deemed this file to be safe, but always exercise caution when opening files. ‌ Please submit the following letter to the Council and Mayor regarding Pride Initiatives Michael Davis One Eleven Living Publisher/Editorial Director www.111living.com 204 Mayor and Members of the City Council, My name is Michael Davis, and I am a proud resident of South Palm Desert. I am the former Editorial Director of Desert Magazine of Gannett, and currently Publisher/Editor of One Eleven Living. I want to begin by saying this plainly: I love this city. I chose to live here because Palm Desert represents the very best of the Coachella Valley—outstanding restaurants, world class shopping, cultural vitality, and a community that has long been known as welcoming, inclusive, and forward-thinking. That is why I am deeply troubled by the proposal to remove or diminish LGBTQ Pride initiatives during Pride Month. This issue has already ignited extraordinary public outcry from residents, visitors, business owners, and community members across the political spectrum. And that alone should give this Council serious pause. Let’s also be honest about what this proposal represents. You can call it whatever you want—budgetary, procedural, or political but taking away an already-established celebration that honors a historically marginalized community is, at its core, homophobic. Whether one agrees with that label or not, the impact is the same. When you single out LGBTQ Pride for removal, you are targeting one community and one community only. We have seen this playbook before. It mirrors efforts at the national level to roll back or diminish holidays and recognitions that honor minority groups—such as Indigenous Peoples’ Day, Martin Luther King Jr. Day, and other commemorations that acknowledge the full diversity of our country. Those actions were rightly called divisive, and this proposal falls squarely into that same category. Pride initiatives are not radical. They are not political stunts. They are a recognition of a community that contributes enormously to Palm Desert’s economy, culture, and identity. The LGBTQ community and our allies are business owners, homeowners, taxpayers, tourists, and longtime supporters of this city. Removing Pride initiatives sends a message, whether intended or not, that Palm Desert is no longer a welcoming city for everyone. And that message carries real consequences. Let me be very clear: if this proposal moves forward, there will be economic fallout. I am already aware of hundreds of peopl e locals and visitors alike who have said they will not shop, dine, stay, or invest in Palm Desert if Pride is taken away. I personally would participate in in a boycott of Palm Desert businesses not because I want to harm this city, but because I love it and refuse to watch it move backward. This is the last thing Palm Desert needs at a time when the economy is shaky, tourism is under pressure, key visitor groups including Canadians are feeling alienated, and the real estate market is softening. Why would we voluntarily damage our own economy? As a gay man, I find this proposal deeply offensive but beyond that, I find it unnecessary and harmful. It creates division where none needs to exist. Palm Desert has thrived because it has chosen inclusion over exclusion. This issue does not need further debate. It needs to be taken off the table today. If this Council rejects this proposal now, we can move forward together and continue promoting Palm Desert as the inclusive, welcoming city it has always been known to be. But if this proposal proceeds, businesses will be harmed, reputations will be damaged, and Palm Desert will lose far more than it gains. I urge you to do the right thing for our community, our economy, and our shared future. Thank You Michael Davis 213 631 0550 . 205 From:Michael J. Finland To:CityClerk Subject:Fw: Resolution No. 2024-038 Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 7:18:37 AM ‌ Good morning City Clerk of Palm Desert, As a Coachella Valley resident of the City of Palm Springs, I want to express my dismay over the expedited review process pertaining to the above noted resolution (LGBTQ Pride Month Commemorations). Due to federal government upheaval, we have witnessed an inordinate amount of unnecessary procedural modifications which have been disruptive in nature. Now we are seeing the “trickle down” effect and our local governmental institutions are attempting to replicate this process. There is an old saying: “there is no need to re- invent the wheel! If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it!” The proposed resolution rescinding would harm the LGBTQ community and does nothing to improve the overall quality of life in the Desert. We are experiencing the detrimental effects of the U.S. tariffs and an offshoot of that has been a decrease in tourism in our area. By further imposing restrictive measures, this would ultimately have a deleterious effect on our local municipalities and on our once thriving economy. Please reconsider implementation of this change. This veritably serves no legitimate purpose whatsoever. Thank you for your time and consideration in this matter. Respectfully submitted, Michael J. Finland Palm Springs Sent from the all new AOL app for iOS 206 From:Linda Singh To:CityClerk Subject:Meeting regarding gay pride Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 7:29:53 AM Hello, We live at 348 Metate Place in Bighorn. Currently in Minnesota for Christmas but back again in January. We are strongly against any move to stop acknowledging Pride. It is petty and small minded. Our 25 year old son who is in his third year of law school at Columbia is gay - what kind of message would you be sending to make him feel like Palm Desert is not his home away from home? I am so sick of this culture war nonsense. Regards, Linda Singh 207 From:Carol Long To:CityClerk Subject:PRIDE month Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 7:42:09 AM ‌ Please do not discontinue the tradition or PRIDE month in our City of Palm Desert it is a wholesome reminders to all to be in community with all people. Sincerely, Carol Long Palm Desert, 92260 Sent from AT&T Yahoo Mail for iPhone 208 From:Scott Connelly To:CityClerk Subject:Agenda Item 3.a – Opposition to Rescinding LGBTQ Pride Commemorations Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 7:45:02 AM ‌ To: Palm Desert City Council Subject: Public Comment on Dear Mayor and City Council Members, I am writing to express my strong opposition to the request to rescind City Council Resolution No. 2024-038 and the subsequent amendment of the city’s Diversity and Inclusion Resolution. Rescinding a policy specifically commemorating LGBTQ Pride Month, even with an amendment to a broader diversity resolution, risks sending a message of diminished commitment to the LGBTQ community. While the intent may be to promote overall unity, removing specific recognition can be perceived as lessening the value placed on the contributions and experiences of LGBTQ individuals within Palm Desert. Perception and Community Image The perception this action projects is crucial for Palm Desert's image as an inclusive community. Removing a specific resolution for LGBTQ Pride Month could signal to residents, visitors, and businesses that the city's dedication to this particular group's recognition is wavering. Maintaining specific commemorations helps reinforce the city's commitment to diversity and can positively impact how Palm Desert is viewed by those who value equality and inclusion. Impact on Inclusion Visible and specific recognition of marginalized groups is often vital for fostering a sense of belonging and inclusion. While broad diversity statements are important, specific acknowledgements like a Pride Month resolution can hold particular significance for communities that have historically faced marginalization. Removing this specific recognition may inadvertently diminish the sense of safety and validation felt by LGBTQ residents and visitors. I urge the Council to carefully consider the impact of rescinding Resolution No. 2024-038 and the importance of maintaining specific recognition for the LGBTQ community as a demonstration of Palm Desert's commitment to being a truly 209 welcoming and inclusive place for all. Sincerely, Scott Connelly Palm Springs and greater Coachella Valley 210 From:Harold Katkov To:Sarah Castro; CityClerk; Michelle Nance Subject:Good morning, all/Palm Desert resident Hal Katkov writing today Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 8:11:17 AM ‌ Hope you are well! Meantime, if my email below could be shared with Mayor Pro Tem Joe Perdetto and the City Council prior to today's meeting at 1:30... I'd appreciate it so much. Thanks for this and all you do. Here's my email! Hello, Mayor Pro Tem Joe Perdetto and Palm Desert City Council. My name is Hal Katkov. I’m a 68-year-old gay man living in Palm Desert. I’m concerned that Palm Desert Mayor Pro Tem Joe Perdetto and the City Council wants to stop flying the Pride flag at City Hall. They claim the LGBTQ+ community is “integrated enough.” Sadly, that couldn’t be further from the truth. Here are three reasons why. Reason 1: HATE CRIMES HAVE INCREASED DRAMATICALLY IN THE U.S. · Data from the FBI shows that reported hate crimes increased dramatically in the U.S., with the number of reported incidents more than doubling from 2015 to 2024. DOUBLING. · That’s just REPORTED incidents; many aren’t reported, so the number is much higher. Reason 2: HATE CRIMES HAVE INCREASED DRAMATICALLY IN CALIFORNIA · California data shows rising hate crimes overall, with assaults and intimidation being common, often targeting race, sexual orientation, and gender identity. Reason 3: HATE CRIMES HAVE INCREASED DRAMATICALLY IN THE COACHELLA VALLEY · Palm Springs leads Riverside County in 2024 hate crimes in California, DOJ report says. · Yes, Palm Springs isn’t Palm Desert… but Palm Springs is just 12.4 miles from Palm Desert. There’s no wall separating them and the hate that’s increasing today. CONCLUSION · Mayor Pro Tem Joe Perdetto’s assertion that the LGBTQ+ community is “integrated enough” is patently false. · In fact – as the stats show – there’s never been a MORE IMPORTANT time to fly the Pride flag, which promotes unity, dignity, inclusion and respect. Not only for the LGBTQ+ community, but for EVERYBODY. The Pride flag needs to fly proudly at Palm Desert City Hall. Period. Full stop. -- Hal Katkov 211 From:Eileen Stern To:CityClerk Subject:Pride Month Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 8:41:12 AM ‌ To the City Council considering dropping Pride Month: don’t do it. This isn’t just an attempt to erase progress in acceptance and inclusion, it will have real, damaging consequences for your city. Boycotts work. Ask Target. Ask Tesla. If you want to hurt local businesses, tourism, and your city’s reputation, eliminating Pride Month recognition is a guaranteed way to do it. I promise you won’t like the results. I won't shop in your town anymore if this goes through. Eileen Stern Rancho Mirage, CA 92270 212 From:Lori Gagnon To:CityClerk Subject:Resolution number 2024-0183 Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 8:43:42 AM As a resident of Palm Desert for over 50 years, and a business owner and taxpayer in Palm Desert for over 40 years, I stand with upholding the resolution. Let's do the right thing and be a kind and compassionate city. Lori Gagnon Palm Desert 213 From:John Dagres To:CityClerk Subject:today"s meeting Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 8:49:16 AM ‌ Council members, As a gay resident of Rancho Mirage for many years, I've spent much time and many dollars in your city. Some of our favorite restaurants and shops are there. Please know that if you do not overturn this anti- pride resolution, myself as well as many in our local community will look elsewhere when shopping or dining. This initiative has caused irreparable damage and I look to you to attempt to rectify the situation. Respectfully submitted, John Dagres Rancho Mirage 214 From:Jonathan Stutz To:CityClerk Subject:Fly the PRIDE Flag and support Inclusion & Belonging Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 8:50:53 AM ‌ Dear City Council Members, City Manager & City Clerk, I am writing to urge the City of Palm Desert to support flying the PRIDE flag and to affirm our collective commitment to inclusion and belonging for communities that have been historically underestimated, oppressed, and marginalized. This is not only a symbolic gesture —it is a strategic investment in the strength, prosperity, and cohesion of our city. Inclusion Strengthens Communities Flying the PRIDE flag does not diminish the culture or rights of heterosexual residents. Instead, it expands the circle of belonging, ensuring that all residents feel valued and respected. Research shows that inclusive communities are healthier, more innovative, and more economically resilient. The Community Business Case • Economic Growth: Cities that embrace diversity attract talent, tourism, and investment. A McKinsey study found that organizations with diverse leadership are 33% more likely to outperform financially, and these benefits extend to municipalities that foster inclusive climates. • Innovation & Competitiveness: Harvard Business Review reports that diverse teams and communities generate more creative solutions to complex challenges. Cities that embrace inclusion are better positioned to solve problems collaboratively. • Public Health & Safety: Studies from the Greater Good Science Center show that inclusive environments reduce stress, improve mental health, and strengthen social cohesion—benefits that extend to all residents, not just marginalized groups. • Retention & Engagement: Communities that visibly support inclusion experience higher civic engagement. Residents are more likely to volunteer, participate in local governance, and invest in the city’s future when they feel represented. Why the PRIDE Flag Matters Symbols are powerful. Flying the PRIDE flag signals to LGBTQ+ residents, allies, and visitors that our city is a place of safety, respect, and belonging. For heterosexual residents, it demonstrates that inclusion is not a zero-sum game—it is about strengthening the whole community without taking anything away. Empirical Evidence of Impact • Belonging drives performance: Inclusive climates increase civic participation and trust across all demographics. • Diversity makes us smarter: Research shows that exposure to diverse perspectives makes communities more creative, diligent, and resilient. 215 • Community strength: Inclusive practices strengthen democracy, expand social cohesion, and improve well-being for all residents. Flying the PRIDE flag is a visible, cost-free action that demonstrates our city’s leadership in building a culture of belonging. It affirms that every resident matters, and that inclusion strengthens—not divides—the community. By embracing diversity, equity, and inclusion, we position our city as a model of resilience, prosperity, and compassion. I respectfully urge you to support this initiative and help us lead with courage, vision, and unity. Sincerely, Jonathan Jonathan Stutz Founder & President Global Diversity Partners, Inc. www.globaldiversitypartners.net www.inclusivepebbles.com (book website) Mobile: 216 From:loisisrael To:CityClerk Subject:Pride Month Recognition Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 8:54:25 AM ‌ To the City Council considering dropping Pride Month: don’t do it. This isn’t just an attempt to erase progress in acceptance and inclusion, it will have real, damaging consequences for our city. Boycotts work. Ask Target. Ask Tesla. If you want to hurt local businesses, tourism, and our city’s reputation, eliminating Pride Month recognition is a guaranteed way to do it. You won’t like the results. Lois Israel Palm Desert Resident 217 From:Eileen Shields To:CityClerk Subject:Pride Flag Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 9:26:07 AM Doesn’t mayor pro team Pradetto have more important matters to deal with? How dare he begin his term by creating divisiveness and throwing gasoline on the flames of the culture war. Leave the rainbow flag up. We love our Palm Springs neighbors. Eileen Shields Palm Desert Sent from my iPhone 218 From:Brian Wilson To:CityClerk Subject:Pride month controversy Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 9:26:41 AM ‌ Just a quick note in the hopes whomever reads this remembers the true significance of what pride month can mean to a struggling person. It’s easy to forget this, when people get focused on whether or not this is an inclusive or a devisive issue, and become entirely focused on that being the defining measure of analyzing pride month festivities. The real item of importance, is that the flag shows a little support for a piece of our community; which can sometimes bring a person the hope they need. Many individuals in the LGBTQ+ community come from a hostile environment. In fact, it’s no secret that many people struggling with this issue experience severe depression, anxiety, and even a higher level of suicide/attempts, because they don’t have anyone in their immediate lives to help show them even basic compassion through the struggle. Seeing the flag, as simple as it may seem, can be the symbol that reminds them others out there acknowledge them in a way that may be lacking in their homes and social circles. If this gesture, and simple reminder, that they are INCLUDED in the wide tapestry of people that make up our towns and communities, is enough to even save one person from the isolation that some people feel, than I see that as well worth putting up a flag for a month. It should be no different for veterans, cancer survivors, etc, if it means one fewer person attempts to take their own life, it seems an admirable reason alone to fly the flag high. I hope this resonates with the people making this decision today. Thank you for your time. Brian Wilson Sent from Yahoo Mail for iPhone 219 From:john@prnewsworks.com To:CityClerk Subject:Pride Month proposal Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 9:34:36 AM Attachments:We sent you safe versions of your files.msg Document1.docx Mimecast Attachment Protection has deemed this file to be safe, but always exercise caution when opening files. ‌ To: Honorable City Council From John Hussar, Palm Desert resident since 1973 Re: Proposal for abolishing Pride Month It is baffling why a City Councilman would rally to drop Pride Month now, during Christmas,Hanukkah. There is so many other political and economic pressures that demand moreattention. The Council must realize that not only the obvious political acceptance and inclusion, but theabolishment has also real serious long term effects on the City economy at a time when wehave seen our beloved Canadian residents sell their homes and spend their money else wherebecause of actions of the Trump Administration. The Council should work to bring backsnowbirds and heal a reputation. The threat of boycott is strong not just in Palm Desert but in Palm Springs and elsewhere in theCoachella Valley. Boycotts work as we have seen with Target, Tesla etc I don’t see efforts by the current City Council to ensure inclusion of all residents. As a long-time resident, its easy to see that our beloved city has grown and provides homes andbusinesses for all who wish to be here. Do the right thing and be kind. Our city’s reputation is at stake. 220 To: Honorable City Council From John Hussar, Palm Desert resident since 1973 Re: Proposal for abolishing Pride Month It is baffling why a City Councilman would rally to drop Pride Month now, during Christmas, Hanukkah. The Council must realize that not only the obvious political acceptance and inclusion, the abolishment has real serious effects on the City economy at a time when we have seen our beloved Canadian residents sell their homes and spend their money else where because of actions of the Trump Administration. The Council should work to bring back snow birds. The threat of boycott is strong not just in Palm Desert but in Palm Springs and elsewhere in the Coachella Valley. Boycotts work as we have seen with Target, Tesla etc I don’t see efforts by the current City Council to ensure inclusion of all residents. As a long time resident, its easy to see that our beloved city has grown and provides homes and businesses for all who wish to be here. Do the right thing and be kind. 221 From:Elle Kurpiewski To:CityClerk Subject:Proposal Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 9:45:54 AM ‌ Good morning. It Is amazing and very disingenuous to claim that removal of the PRIDE flag and the celebration of Pride will provide unity. Seriously? How is that unity? The City Council is disenfranchising, for political and personal reasons a group of citizens who are simply displaying pride in who they are, after years of being locked in closets. This proposal is wrong, this proposal is hurtful and believe me when I say, the people of the Valley will remember this sad, sad, proposal. Ellen Kay Kurpiewski-citizen 222 From:leila namvar To:CityClerk Subject:Support for Our LGBTQ + community Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 9:54:59 AM ‌ Mayor and Council-members, My name is Leila Namvar, Candidate for California Assembly District 47, a Current Delegate to CADEM in AD 47, and I am sending this letter to you all because this decision matters, deeply, to real people who call Palm Desert home. For LGBTQ+ residents, Pride Month and the Pride banner are not political statements. They are signals of safety. They say, you belong here. For a young person questioning who they are, for a senior who has lived through decades of discrimination, for families simply trying to live openly and peacefully, those symbols matter. Removing the City’s recognition of Pride Month sends a message, whether intended or not, that LGBTQ+ residents are less welcome, less visible, or less valued. And once that message is sent, it cannot be undone by good intentions. Palm Desert is a diverse and compassionate community. We do not become more inclusive by taking recognition away. We do not strengthen unity by asking one group to quietly disappear from public life. Across the country, LGBTQ+ people are watching their rights, visibility, and dignity challenged. Local governments are often the last line of reassurance, the place where people look to feel safe in their own neighborhoods. Tonight, Palm Desert has the opportunity to choose compassion over exclusion, and belonging over silence. I urge you to keep Pride Month, keep the Pride banner, and stand clearly and publicly for the dignity and humanity of all residents. Regards, Leila Namvar Sent from Yahoo Mail for iPhone 223 From:P L To:CityClerk Subject:Subject: Opposition to Proposal to Rescind Resolution 2024-0183 Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 9:56:27 AM ‌ Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council, I am writing to express my opposition to the proposal to rescind Resolution 2024-0183, which provided recognition of the LGBTQ+ community in Palm Desert. Rescinding this resolution would be a step backward for our city. Recognition of Pride Month and the LGBTQ+ community is not about granting special treatment; it is about affirming that all residents are seen, valued, and welcome. Removing that recognition does not create neutrality or equality — instead, it sends a message of exclusion and division. Actions taken by government bodies carry weight far beyond policy language. When leadership withdraws visible support for a historically marginalized community, it signals that those individuals are less deserving of acknowledgment and protection. Across the country, we have seen how such signals embolden intolerance and, in some cases, lead to harassment, discrimination, and violence against minority groups. These are not abstract concerns — they are realities faced by LGBTQ+ people every day. Palm Desert should be striving to be a city where all residents feel safe, respected, and represented. Rescinding this resolution undermines that goal and risks making our city feel less safe for LGBTQ+ residents, visitors, and families. Inclusion should never be treated as controversial, nor should recognition be framed as divisive. What is truly divisive is the removal of affirming policies that foster belonging and community trust. I urge the City Council to reject this proposal and to reaffirm Palm Desert’s commitment to equality, dignity, and respect for all. Our city is strongest when we lead with inclusion and stand firmly against actions that marginalize or silence any part of our community. Thank you for your time, consideration, and service to the residents of Palm Desert. Respectfully, Pilar Flotterud Palm Desert Resident 224 From:P B To:CityClerk Subject:Opposition to Proposal to Rescind Resolution 2024-0183 Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 9:59:05 AM ‌ Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council, I am writing to express my opposition to the proposal to rescind Resolution 2024-0183, which provided recognition of the LGBTQ+ community in Palm Desert. Rescinding this resolution would be a step backward for our city. Recognition of Pride Month and the LGBTQ+ community is not about granting special treatment; it is about affirming that all residents are seen, valued, and welcome. Removing that recognition does not create neutrality or equality — instead, it sends a message of exclusion and division. Actions taken by government bodies carry weight far beyond policy language. When leadership withdraws visible support for a historically marginalized community, it signals that those individuals are less deserving of acknowledgment and protection. Across the country, we have seen how such signals embolden intolerance and, in some cases, lead to harassment, discrimination, and violence against minority groups. These are not abstract concerns — they are realities faced by LGBTQ+ people every day. Palm Desert should be striving to be a city where all residents feel safe, respected, and represented. Rescinding this resolution undermines that goal and risks making our city feel less safe for LGBTQ+ residents, visitors, and families. Inclusion should never be treated as controversial, nor should recognition be framed as divisive. What is truly divisive is the removal of affirming policies that foster belonging and community trust. I urge the City Council to reject this proposal and to reaffirm Palm Desert’s commitment to equality, dignity, and respect for all. Our city is strongest when we lead with inclusion and stand firmly against actions that marginalize or silence any part of our community. Thank you for your time, consideration, and service to the residents of Palm Desert. Respectfully, Pamela Birky, Resident of Palm Desert 225 From:leila namvar To:CityClerk Cc:Amalia Deaztlan Subject:DWD : To support LGBQ+ community Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 9:59:24 AM Attachments:We sent you safe versions of your files.msg Blank 21.pdf Mimecast Attachment Protection has deemed this file to be safe, but always exercise caution when opening files. ‌ Dear City Clerk, Please include the attached letter from the Democratic Women of the Desert into the record for today’s meeting. Thanks, Amalia DeAztlan President of Democratic Women of the Desert Sent from Yahoo Mail for iPhone 226 To the Palm Desert City Council, Democratic Women of the Desert write to express our strong opposition to Mayor Pro Tem Joe Pradeto’s proposal to discontinue the City of Palm Desert’s recognition of LGBTQ+ Pride Month at City Hall. This proposal reflects a troubling national trend that seeks to retreat from the long-standing understanding that diversity is not a weakness of the United States, but a core source of its strength, prosperity, and cultural vitality. Public recognitions such as Pride Month are not merely symbolic; they are the result of decades of struggle by 227 marginalized communities for visibility, dignity, and equal protection under the law. Withdrawing this recognition follows a historical pattern in which progress toward inclusion is met with backlash and efforts at erasure. Efforts to roll back diversity, equity, and inclusion are often framed as “neutral” or “non-political,” yet history shows that such claims have repeatedly been used to justify exclusion and inequality. Our nation’s most successful periods of democratic growth and civic participation have occurred when institutions acknowledged difference, affirmed pluralism, and recognized the contributions of communities long denied full inclusion. Palm Desert’s recognition of Pride Month signals a commitment to historical awareness, civic inclusion, and the fundamental principle that all residents belong in the public life of the city. Rescinding that recognition would send the opposite message—one that undermines equality, shared humanity, and the values that have strengthened both this community and the nation. We urge the City Council to reject this proposal and reaffirm its commitment to recognizing LGBTQ+ Pride as an essential and enduring part of Palm Desert’s past, present, and future. Respectfully, 228 Amalia DeAztlan President, Democratic Women of the Desert 229 From:Melissa Morgan To:CityClerk Subject:Pride banner Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 10:37:11 AM Please do not do this. I have had a business in Palm Desert for 25 years. I love Palm Desert and participate in everything from Fashion Week to BAM. This is not who we are collectively. This is an insult to our customers, visitors, neighbors, artists, students, basically all of us! Sincerely, Melissa Melissa Morgan Fine Art 73 660 El Paseo Palm Desert Ca C O 230 From:Michelle Martin To:CityClerk Subject:12/16 Special Meeting: Agenda Item 3a Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 10:42:15 AM I am writing as a resident of Palm desert, and I am appalled that the city council is calling the special meeting to consider obliterating the support of a kind and loving tradition here in this valley. Palm Desert is not a standalone city. It is part of the Coachella Valley and being a part of and supporting the Palm Springs Pride celebration every year, as well as upholding diversity and inclusion is imperative for the good health and welfare of our whole community. Our community is diverse and the diversities need to be celebrated, not hidden behind a bigoted conservative agenda. As a resident and a constituent, I urge you to continue supporting Palm Springs‘s pride and diversity and inclusion. Do not fall for the false pretenses of unity, when voting to NOT support unity is exactly what you’re considering. It’s disappointing that this is even coming up for a discussion. I expect better from Palm Desert. Michelle Martin Professional Services Bookkeeping | Mobile Notary Signing Agent | Consulting https://url.us.m.mimecastprotect.com/s/B7piC737zmhAX5gps8f9FoJ_s1?domain=mmnotary1.com *Sent from my iPhone* 231 From:tracey martin To:CityClerk Subject:Pride Flag Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 10:44:57 AM ‌ I can't even believe that I have to be concerned that the Pride Flag would be removed from city hall. Are you kidding me? ENOUGH IS ENOUGH! This is not only about PRIDE, it's about celebrating heritage and history of our communities. If we don't remember history, we are doomed to repeat it. Civil Rights and Civil Liberties are under attack. We can humanize one another by acknowledging our different experiences and finding common ground. Those of us actually from CA are sick of this crap. There will be consequences and boycotts. Test us! 232 From:joanna bozzani To:CityClerk Subject:Please Don’t Rescind Resolution 2024-0183 Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 10:58:53 AM ‌ Mayor and Council Members, I’m writing to ask you not to move forward with rescinding Resolution 2024-0183. When the City chose to recognize the LGBTQ+ community, it felt like a simple, positive statement: that Palm Desert is a place where everyone belongs. Taking that recognition back now doesn’t feel neutral or unifying — it feels like a step in the wrong direction and one that will land hardest on people who already feel vulnerable. I know some may see this as symbolic, but symbols matter. City actions send signals about who is welcome and who is not. When recognition is removed from one specific community, it sends a message that their inclusion is conditional or controversial, and that’s not the kind of message I want our city to be sending. We’re living in a time when LGBTQ+ people are facing more hostility and fear, not less. Local governments can either help lower the temperature or add to it. Rescinding this resolution risks doing the latter, even if that’s not the intention. Palm Desert has always felt like a community that looks out for its neighbors. I hope you’ll keep that spirit in mind and choose to stand by a decision that affirms respect, safety, and belonging for all. Thank you for listening and for your service to our city. Respectfully, Joanna Bozzani, Resident of Palm Desert 233 From:NotActuallyRon To:City Hall Mail; CityClerk Subject:Public Comment for 12/16/25 Special Meeting Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 11:00:20 AM ‌ Good morning, Please include the following as a public comment for the single agenda item at the December 16, 2025 special meeting. While I am more than willing to give Mayor Pro Tem Joe the benefit of the doubt and assume his intentions were pure, I struggle to follow his logic. The idea that raising a banner in support of a specific group somehow creates division is, frankly, quite fascinating. By that logic, perhaps we should do away with all banners entirely. After all, a banner honoring veterans could offend those who didn’t serve, Spanish Heritage Month might upset those without Spanish ancestry, and acknowledging the Jewish community clearly risks alienating non-Jews. What a wonderfully “unified” community we’d be one stripped of all recognition, color, and meaning. And why stop there? Imagine the perfect harmony that would emerge if we removed the Desert Holocaust Memorial from Civic Center Park. Or if we did away with Black History Month too, just to make sure no one feels left out. Surely, that’s the logical conclusion of this mindset. Mayor Pro Tem Joe, reality check, our world thrives on differences. It’s those differences that make our community vibrant, resilient, and exceptional. Leadership means embracing that, not retreating from it because a few bitter voices find comfort in sameness. You have the opportunity to bring a fresh perspective to the council. Be bold. Be innovative. Be the leader that moves us forward not backward into a beige blur of “unity.” You should take pride in being one of the youngest to serve in your role. If, however, the pressures of leadership still feel beyond reach, perhaps as suggested by your earlier hesitation to serve as mayor pro tem then perhaps it’s worth considering whether you’re ready for the responsibility. Luck may have placed you here, but courage and clarity will determine whether you stay. Sent with Proton Mail secure email. 234 From:Diane Morales To:CityClerk Subject:Public Comment for today’s special meeting Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 11:12:05 AM ‌ Hello Palm Desert City Council Members, My name is Diane Morales, and I am a resident of the Spanish Walk community in Palm Desert. I both live in Palm Desert and work in Palm Springs, and I am deeply disappointed that our elected City Council would consider revisiting a resolution to remove the LGBTQ+ flag during Pride Month. Removing this flag during a time meant for celebration and inclusion would create unnecessary division within our community. At the same time, our city openly benefits from the economic contributions that Pride Month brings from the LGBTQ+ community. If we are willing to welcome those economic benefits, we should also be willing to demonstrate visible support and inclusion by allowing the Pride flag to be displayed during this time. Palm Desert is home to people of many backgrounds, identities, and lived experiences—this diversity is what makes our city strong and vibrant. I respectfully ask the Council to reconsider any action that would remove the LGBTQ+ flag and instead affirm Palm Desert’s commitment to being an inclusive and welcoming city for all residents. Thank you for your time and consideration. Sincerely, Diane Morales Palm Desert Resident 235 From:Tari Beer To:CityClerk Subject:City of Palm Desert - Pride Meeting Today Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 11:37:01 AM ‌ I am a long time valley resident who has shopped locally for decades. I shop locally because I want to support our local economy and spend on El Paseo most of the time. I am appalled that the Mayor Protem is promoting a lack of inclusion and trying to destroy our beautiful, accepting and inclusive community. If the city council approves this abhorrent act of divisiveness and hate - I will no longer support Palm Desert business in any capacity. Furthermore, I will help actively promote revenue shifts and growth from the City of Palm Desert to other communities. Please vote this down and help keep our community a valued place for everyone. Tarilyn Beer President Democrats in Sun City Shadow Hills 236 From:William Choplin To:CityClerk; Jan Harnik; Gina Nestande; Evan Trubee; Joe Pradetto; kquintanlla@palmdesert.gov Subject:Resolution No. 2018-09 Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 11:21:21 AM Attachments:PastedGraphic-1.tiff ‌ Please add our comments to the meeting information for the 12/16/25 City Council Special Meeting Councilmember Pradetto has recommended that the language in Resolution No. 2018-09 be changed to remove the word “differences” and replace it with "a pledge to celebrate the values that unite us”. This recommendation appears to be in line with the federal governments efforts to remove diversity language from government policies at all levels. Councilmember Pradetto states that Palm Desert has already achieved cultural harmony. Why change something that already works? We suggest adding a word about our residents and visitors commonalities and expand inclusivity rather than diminish it. We respectfully suggest to Councilmember Pradetto that recognizing and celebrating our differences is how we learn to appreciate one another and increase understanding about who we all are. Lack of understanding about other’s fosters fear and avoidance. Current language: Suggested new language: Just add the word “commonalities” or a similar word describing what we have in common. For example: WHEREAS, the City encourages all resident and visitors of Palm Desert to celebrate each other’s commonalities and differences and learn from one another William Choplin and Nancy Nowak Palm Desert, CA 92260 237 From:Donald Zeigler To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Palm Desert Council Meeting Comments for December 15 council meeting Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 6:25:06 AM ‌ Please include the following comments to the council members regarding Item 3a on the council agenda for December 15, 2025 Comments Regarding Agenda Item 3a of the Palm Desert City Council Meeting of December 15, 2025. My name is Donald Zeigler, and I am a resident and voter in Palm Desert I am an ashamed voter in Palm District 2 which sent Mr. Pradetto to the City Council in last year’s election. My wife and I knew that he would bring the MAGA agenda to our city and tried hard to get someone else elected, but we didn’t try hard enough and here we are. At his very first meeting with the council, Mr. Pradetto spoke of his desire to eliminate DEI references from our city. He also has turned the city’s Resource Preservation and Enhancement citizen’s committee into a meaningless charade to further the MAGA anti climate change agenda. There is no doubt that if he succeeds in passing the resolution before the council today, this is just the beginning. Every effort to recognize communities other than the one he approves of will no longer be allowed by our city. Councilmember Quintanilla is the only person sitting on the board who was elected by a majority vote. Everyone else represents a minority of their electorate. They do not represent the Palm Desert that I am proud to live in. We can begin to fix this by having the registered voters in District Two start today on a recall effort to remove Council Member Pradetto from this board. It was truly surprising when members Nestande and Trubee agreed with Mr. Pradetto to put this resolution on the agenda. I thought they were better than that. I was hoping that Mr. Pradetto would be a fringe voice on the council with no real influence. Instead, he is a cancer that is destroying the entire body, and a recall is the only way to have him removed. The voters in member Nestande’s district might consider the same. Member Trubee will be standing for election in 2026 so he will be gone soon enough. To prevent our city from electing more fringe candidates like the majority supporting this resolution, we should consider council primaries and runoff elections, so we don’t end up with people serving on the council not elected by a majority of voters. A majority would never elect any of the people supporting this resolution. Donald Zeigler dzeigler_1999@ 238 From:Roadrunner Print & Ship To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Concern Regarding Proposed Rescission of Diversity and Pride Resolutions Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 6:30:56 AM ‌ Dear Mayor and Members of the Palm Desert City Council, I am writing as both a citizen of the Coachella Valley and as a representative of a diverse, locally rooted business that proudly serves Palm Desert, the greater valley, and visitors from beyond our region. I am deeply concerned and disappointed by the City Council’s consideration of rescinding its resolutions supporting diversity and Pride Month. Characterizing this action as an effort toward “unity” is troubling. Pride celebrations are not divisive; they are affirmations of inclusion, safety, and visibility for members of our community. What is truly divisive is advancing a reactionary political agenda while presenting it as neutral governance. This proposal aligns with broader national efforts that seek to diminish the rights, protections, and visibility of the LGBTQ+ community— rights that have been hard-earned over decades. This direction stands in direct conflict with Palm Desert’s own Envision Palm Desert Strategic Plan, which emphasizes fostering a thriving, safe community strengthened by diversity, cultural vitality, and a high quality of life for all residents and visitors. As a business that depends on a welcoming environment—one that attracts residents, employees, and tourists from all backgrounds—this proposed reversal is alarming. Rescinding these resolutions sends a clear and damaging message that the City of Palm Desert is stepping away from its stated commitment to inclusion at a time when LGBTQ+ individuals face increasing hostility and uncertainty nationwide. Such a signal undermines trust, harms community cohesion, and risks the reputation of Palm Desert as a welcoming destination and place to do business. I respectfully urge the City Council to reject this politically motivated action and to reaffirm Palm Desert’s commitment to being a safe, inclusive, and welcoming community for everyone who lives in, works in, and visits our diverse valley. Sincerely, Bob Kincaid Roadrunner Print and Ship 239 240 From:Rita Robinson To:CouncilMeeting Comments Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 7:37:32 AM ‌ I do hope members of the Palm Springs City Council keep their heads held high, and to have the courage to vote "NO" to rescind Resolution No. 2924-038. As a happily married straight woman, it is hard to believe that someone would want to take away the rights of another human being for pure prejudice. How petty and ugly that would be.-Rita Robinson 241 From:Scott Connelly To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Agenda Item 3.a – Opposition to Rescinding LGBTQ Pride Commemorations Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 7:39:16 AM ‌ To: Palm Desert City Council Subject: Public Comment on Agenda Item 3.a – Opposition to Rescinding LGBTQ Pride Commemorations Dear Mayor and City Council Members, I am writing to express my strong opposition to the request to rescind City Council Resolution No. 2024-038 and the subsequent amendment of the city’s Diversity and Inclusion Resolution. Rescinding a policy specifically commemorating LGBTQ Pride Month, even with an amendment to a broader diversity resolution, risks sending a message of diminished commitment to the LGBTQ community. While the intent may be to promote overall unity, removing specific recognition can be perceived as lessening the value placed on the contributions and experiences of LGBTQ individuals within Palm Desert. Perception and Community Image The perception this action projects is crucial for Palm Desert's image as an inclusive community. Removing a specific resolution for LGBTQ Pride Month could signal to residents, visitors, and businesses that the city's dedication to this particular group's recognition is wavering. Maintaining specific commemorations helps reinforce the city's commitment to diversity and can positively impact how Palm Desert is viewed by those who value equality and inclusion. Impact on Inclusion Visible and specific recognition of marginalized groups is often vital for fostering a sense of belonging and inclusion. While broad diversity statements are important, specific acknowledgements like a Pride Month resolution can hold particular significance for communities that have historically faced marginalization. Removing this specific recognition may inadvertently diminish the sense of safety and validation felt by LGBTQ residents and visitors. I urge the Council to carefully consider the impact of rescinding Resolution No. 2024-038 and the importance of maintaining specific recognition for the LGBTQ 242 community as a demonstration of Palm Desert's commitment to being a truly welcoming and inclusive place for all. Sincerely, Scott Connelly Palm Springs and Greater Coachella Valley 243 From:Ty Nasief To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Special Council Meeting 12/16/25 Re: Resolution 2024-038 Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 7:55:21 AM ‌ Dear Mayor and Members of the Palm Desert City Council, I am writing as a resident of the Coachella Valley and as someone who regularly works, shops, and dines in Palm Desert. I care deeply about the long-term health of our valley- not only economically, but socially and culturally as well. I urge you not to adopt the proposed resolution to rescind Resolution No. 2024-038, which promotes diversity and inclusion through Palm Desert’s participation in Pride Month celebrations. It has been argued that Resolution 2024-038 is unnecessary because Resolution 2018-09 already affirms inclusion and recognition of all residents. While Resolution 2018-09 does indeed express important values, Resolution 2024-038 meaningfully extends those values into visible and participatory action. The 2024 resolution goes beyond a general proclamation by encouraging tangible expressions of inclusion- such as the display of Pride flags, engagement through social media, and participation in Pride-related events that signal welcome and belonging to LGBTQ residents and visitors. Words alone are not always sufficient. Visibility matters. Public acknowledgment matters. For many LGBTQ individuals and families, seeing their city actively recognize Pride Month sends a clear message that they are safe, valued, and respected members of the community. By Councilman Pradetto’s own argument that additional resolutions are unnecessary, the proposed resolution to rescind 2024-038 would itself be unnecessary. Its practical effect would not be administrative efficiency, but rather a reversal of course on inclusion, one that would be widely interpreted as a step away from welcoming LGBTQ+ residents. Such an action risks being perceived as anti-LGBTQ in intent and impact, regardless of how it is framed procedurally. Palm Desert benefits from a diverse population and a regional economy driven by tourism, hospitality, and local spending. Many residents, workers, and visitors, myself included, pay close attention to whether a city demonstrates openness and respect for all people. While we strive to support the entire Coachella Valley economy, actions that suggest exclusion or retreat from inclusion would understandably give people pause when deciding where to live, work, visit, and spend their money. Palm Desert has long positioned itself as a welcoming, forward-looking city. Rescinding Resolution 2024-038 would undermine that reputation and send an unnecessary and divisive signal. For these reasons, I respectfully urge the City Council not to adopt the resolution to rescind Resolution 2024-038 and instead reaffirm Palm Desert’s commitment to inclusion, not just in principle, but in practice. Thank you for your time, consideration, and service to our community. Sincerely, 244 Ty Nasief Resident, Coachella Valley 245 From:Michael Alexander To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Maintain the current Pride resolution Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 7:58:18 AM I am a proud gay Palm Springs full-time resident. I shop at Moller’s, the mall, etc. That will change if you follow the bizarre, double-speak proposal of Pradetto. Of course bigots and haters are uncomfortable with change and equality. Too bad! We will not be silenced. We will not return to closets. Get use to it!! Do the right thing! Resist Pradetto’s MAGA proposal. Bianco, Trump, Pradetto should not determine the future of Palm Desert or the Coachella Valley. Endorse the current Pride resolution! Michael Alexander Sent from my iPhone 246 From:Adam Alvarado To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Res 2024-038 LGBTQ pride Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 8:01:11 AM If you vote yes we will stop going to shop and dine in Palm desert it’s that simple, money talks. Sent from my iPhone 247 From:James Williamson To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Council Meeting - Item 3a Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 8:05:30 AM As a prior Chair of the Board of Trustees of the Palm Springs Unified School District and a current Board Officer of Do The Right Thing, I shudder at the significant damage this issue has already had upon our youth. It is essential that young people have a safe and supportive environment in which to grow and establish their individual identities. It is especially true for young people who will identify as part of the lgbtq+ community. The act of initiating this discussion at a Council meeting by three Councilmembers communicates clearly to young people that being lgbtq+ is not something about which they should be confident, open and proud. It also communicates to bullies and others that they are sanctioned to ridicule and cause lgbtq+ students harm. In a national environment that is becoming increasingly divisive and abusive, I hope that we are better than that in this valley. I hope that this item will not only be thrown out for the hate-mongering it is but that Council will take affirmative steps that will signal to all that they are welcome and supported in and by the City of Palm Desert. James Williamson 248 From:CLAIRE BROWN To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:No 2024-038 Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 8:12:56 AM Dear Council Members I am appalled to read about your very deliberate intention to make this world more divisive by putting forward a resolution to not acknowledge pride month. You are allowing echoing and continuing to promote a world of hate by presenting this by telling your constituents not celebrate each other. Stop it. Get back to your day jobs of improving the city for all people. Stop allowing Trump to divide us. Your jobs and legacy should be about lifting us all up. Do the right thing. Claire Brown Sent from my iPhone 249 From:Richard von Ernst To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Resolution # 2018-09 Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 8:13:23 AM I am appalled at the idea of the city of Palm Desert adopting this divisive resolution. Wrapped in the false commitment to inclusion, this resolution is an obvious attempt of a very few to once again marginalize the LGBTQ community by erasure. Cancelling all references to and observance of Gay Pride month is not only demeaning to your gay brothers and sisters but is also shortsighted. The amount of money spent in Palm Desert and the tax benefits the city derives from the gay community and those who support them is far greater than this city council is aware. Adopting this resolution is not only malicious and cruel but myopic of the fiscal effect it will have on the city. Please reject this resolution. Richard von Ernst Rancho Mirage, CA 92270 Sent from a galaxy far, far away 250 From:Karin Gist To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Pride Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 8:19:09 AM ‌ This must fail. The Month of Pride is not divisive. It shows how inclusive our city is. Palm Springs has always been a safe place for the LGBTQ community. Let’s continue to be a beacon of inclusivity and not give in to hate disguised as equality. Karin Gist 251 From:Harry Martin To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Vote AGAINST resolution -- City-sponsored homophobia Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 8:28:56 AM ‌ My name is Harry Martin. I am a resident of Palm Desert and encouraging the council to reject the anti-LGBT resolution made by Mayor Pro Tem Joe Pradetto. This anti-Pride resolution was brought forward to move our city in lockstep with the discriminatory practices of the current president and his administration. Moreover, I would suggest this resolution was designed to bring the spotlight to Pradetto and his future political ambitions. If this resolution passes, tourism boycotts are a distinct possibility. There are several gay- friendly cities in the Coachella Valley that would love to promote the fact that Palm Desert is anti-LGBT to improve their economies. But most importantly, this discrimination-backed resolution sticks a knife in the back of every gay person living in Palm Desert. Please vote no. Harry Martin Palm Desert CA 92211 252 From:Murray Garrard To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Re: Meeting on city council resolution number 2024-038 Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 8:30:18 AM ‌ Dear Madam/Sir Regarding the meeting today, considering the request to rescind city council resolution number 2024-038 - regarding pride. As a resident of Palm Springs, Palm Desert has never seemed like a separate city. Indeed, for the decade I have lived here, I have regarded the Coachella Valley as one community - bound both by geography and, I assumed, shared values. We may not always be politically aligned, but I have always felt in the valley a broad tolerance for difference and respect for diversity. It's why so many communities, marginalized elsewhere, feel safe here. And, with rising anti-LGBTQIA+ hate bedeviling much of the rest of the country, we are so grateful to this valley for being a safe harbor. Pride, and the rainbow flag, may seem totemic, flippant even, to those who have not fought for access to life-saving medication, the right to love who they love, marry who they wish to marry. But to those of us who have, it celebrates triumph over what at times seemed like insurmountable odds. It is not meant to elevate one group above others (indeed, the LGBTQIA+ community is a broad church), but rather signifies a tolerance for everyone. The removal of rainbow flags and the disbanding of the city's pride activities signal the opposite: they suggest that Palm Desert will not tolerate difference and that diversity is no longer welcome. Indeed, rather than leveling the playing field and making the city more equal by celebrating no particular community, it is likely to signal to those so inclined that intolerance and hatred are, in fact, permitted, indeed encouraged. This would be a great shame. Palm Desert is not an oasis; it exists in a dynamic symbiosis with all other cities in the valley. What would life in the valley be like without access to Palm Desert’s Whole Foods and Total Wine & More? How would we cope without the assistance of all the wonderful small wellness businesses in Palm Desert? But if Palm Desert cancels Pride, I fear many will feel Palm Desert to have become unsafe. Reluctantly, for sure, we will put up with Ralphs, seek wellness treatments closer to home. This decision would be harmful to business, harmful to the broader Coachella Valley community, and it would signal to the country, indeed to the world, that only some people are welcome here. Are you sure that is the message that you want to send? Thank you for considering this at your meeting today. 253 Kind regards, best wishes, and may you have a very happy holidays! Murray Garrard 254 From:Guy Lkng To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:A sad day for democracy in Palm Desert Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 8:34:43 AM ‌ You people in city council should be ashamed of themselves for even considering Mayor Pro Tem Pradetto’s DISGUSTING recent proposal to remove the Pride banner under the guise of "government neutrality," during this season of goodwill, his comments felt deeply out of step with the heart of our community. First, to categorize LGBTQ+ existence as merely a "private identity"—implying it is a hobby or a secret to be kept behind closed doors—is a profound misunderstanding. You should apply the same to the “Christian values” you so desperately are trying to shove down our throats. Remember the declaration of independence and how we fought for RELIGIOUS FREEDOM. No one is asking for Christian values to go away but we don’t understand the OBSESSION with making everyone else a Christian. It’s gross. We will all remember this moment. The people you are trying to erase, the people you’re trying to silence. And you bend the knee. stand up against autocracy and stop being hypocrites Sent from Gmail Mobile 255 From:Geoff To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Public Comment on Item 3.a. Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 8:40:07 AM ‌ I am writing in opposition to item 3.a. on today's special meeting agenda, proposed by Mayor Pro Tem Pradeto with Mayor Trube and Councilmember Nestande voting to move this proposal forward for consideration. Mayor Pro Tem Pradeto said that local government should avoid involvement in what he called residents' private lives. A brief history lesson: The gains in legal protections that the lgbtq community has secured over the last half century only happened because so many brave individuals risked losing their jobs, homes, families and their very lives and stopped hiding who they are and who they love. And the very first protections our community won were won at the local level. At a time when the federal government and so many state and local governments are working to take away our rights and erase our history, it is more important than ever for our local governments to take a stand in support of our community. Now is the time to stand up for your residents, employees, and visitors whose rights are under attack, not join in with those who are trying to erase and silence us. The actions by the majority of this Council have caused a great deal of pain and anger. I encourage you turn this negative into a positive and to vote no on this item and instead take positive steps by reaffirming your support of Pride and the lgbtq community. Thank you for your consideration. Geoff Kors 256 From:bryan turner To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Joe Pradetto ending the city"s recognition of Pride Month Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 8:45:56 AM ‌ It's a travesty that Pro Tem Mayor Joe Pradetto has proposed ending the city's recognitionof Pride Month, including flying the Pride flag at City Hall, citing a desire for "governmentneutrality and unity." That's not unity, that's erasure. Please do not vote in favor of Pradetto's homophobia. Sincerely, Bryan Turner 257 From:Linda Joy Salas To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:LGBTQ+ issue Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 8:48:38 AM While I agree that making a particular group distinguished from another can create a sense of separation, the logic behind denying the LGBTQ+ community a Pride banner should also be denied to those participating in the golf cart parade, the Friday night classic car parades, even the pink breast cancer 5K walk. Those who are not a golfers, classic car owners or not empathetic toward cancer patients, might be offended by the use of city funds supporting these events. Do you find this logical? Palm Desert resident. Linda Salas Sent from my iPhone 258 From:Donna McCormick To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Proposal to Rescind City Council Resolution NO. 2024-038 Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 8:57:46 AM Dear Palm Desert City Council Members, I am shocked that Palm Desert is considering rescinding City Council NO. 2024-038. My husband and I spend 6 months of every year in Coachella Valley and I love how welcoming the valley is to the LGBTQ+ community. Creating a resolution that honors Pride Month — and then taking it back — will be seen as an affront to the LGBTQ+ community, especially in today’s political climate. Your proposal to rescind Pride Month anticipates that there will be no economic impact. I highly doubt that this is the case. I believe that LGBTQ+ dollars — if given the choice — will flow to those communities most welcoming, i.e., Palm Springs. Palm Springs had been suffering economically for years but now, it is flourishing. Your actions to rescind Pride will increase revenue in Palm Springs to the detriment of Palm Desert. Please vote “no” on rescinding Resolution NO. 2024-038 and, by doing so, continue to show that you appreciate and welcome your LGBTQ+ friends and neighbors. Respectfully, Donna McCormick 259 From:Sam Moore To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:The money I spend in Palm Desert weekly Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 8:58:35 AM ‌ I am in Palm Desert at least once every week and spend money at several businesses there. I've spent over $5000 at one of them in the past few months alone. Palm Desert choosing to rescind its support of the LGBTQ+ community, my community, will certainly affect my weekly spending there. If you won't support us, I won't support you. Regards, Sam Moore Palm Springs 260 From:whabbear@comcast.net To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Proposal to rescind City Council resolution 2024-038 Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 9:00:01 AM ‌ Dear Palm Desert City Council members: I am writing to express my strong opposition to the proposal to rescind City Council Resolution 2024-038. In my opinion, taking action to eliminate recognition of gay pride celebrations in the Coachella Valley by the City of Palm Desert would not advance a more inclusive message for the City, as Mayor Pro Tem Joe Pradetto has argued. In fact, it would do the exact opposite, sending a clear message that members of the LGBT+ community are NOT valued by the City, and are not welcome there. As a proud gay man living in Palm Springs, that is certainly the message I would take away from the Council rescinding the Resolution, and I would behave accordingly. That is, if the City of Palm Desert signals that it does not want me around, then I would comply (albeit reluctantly) with the City's wish and stop visiting Palm Desert's shops and restaurants. Robert McCann, Ph.D. Palm Springs CA 92262 261 From:Donna DuFresne To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Today’s meeting to adopt two resolutions Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 9:07:40 AM ‌ Please do NOT adopt the two resolutions put forth by mayor pro tem Joe Pradetto. Since moving to the Coachella Valley my husband and I have been so proud to be Palm Desert residents. It is a vibrant community focused on the the well-being and inclusion of all residents. Imagine our shock to find that we have elected members to the city council who are willing to throw that away in the interests of “same washing” all residents. We are not all the same. We have many and varied histories and backgrounds. Some experiences have been easier (those of the historical majority) and others have been much, much harder (the historical minorities.) Many groups have worked long and hard to be accepted and recognized as equals in society. The fight is certainly not over. All we have to do is pay attention to the current administration’s efforts to whitewash America and vilify people of color, women, and LGBTQIA+ individuals. One has to wonder why the city council would choose now to decide we are all “the same” and no longer need to celebrate our unique qualities and how they add to the fabric of our community. Is this an effort to try and align with the current regime? Or is the mayor pro tem simply too young and inexperienced to understand the historical perspective of what has come before him and what this erasure really means? Please, keep Palm Desert a welcoming, diverse home that celebrates its unique residents. Let’s not look back on this time and say that we too folded to the fascist leanings of the current administration. Thank you, Donna Du Fresne Palm Desert 262 From:Gary Armstrong To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Do not dis the LGBT community like this! Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 9:11:13 AM ‌ I'm writing in opposition to item 3.a on today's special meeting agenda, to move this proposal forward for consideration. This proposal is ill-advised and ill-timed and will result in so many of us in the Coachella Valley refraining from visiting or doing any kind of business in a place that is unwelcoming of LGBT people. I would say unwelcoming because there is simply NO reason to do this, to remove Pride flags during Pride month or during the Valley's Pride celebrations. The LGBT community is regularly discriminated against across this country. People constantly seek to dehumanize us. Pride celebrations show that we know who we are, our value and our worth to society, and we are proud of who we are, despite what so many unfortunately in this world do and say to try and demean us. When a city decides to show support of the gay community, it's not to the exclusion of other minority or majority groups or demographics. It just shows that your community cares about all people, and all are welcome there. There's no 'wrong' here that this proposal would be 'righting'. It would be purely discriminatory and disrespectful to do so. This proposal sends the message that people in the LGBT community are NOT welcome or wanted in Palm Desert. This will have severe financial consequences to all restaurants and businesses in Palm Desert, because we in the LGBT community will not patronize places where we are not wanted or are disrespected. This is a promise! I happen to not live in Palm Desert, but am next door in Rancho Mirage and I regularly dine and shop in Palm Desert. No more, if this proposal passes. Not only that, we will gather in force to protest. Is this what you really want? You could withdraw the proposal and do nothing, and guess what, nothing changes. Nobody is hurt or disenfranchised. Nobody is discriminated against and there are no boycotts. Pass this hateful proposal, and you can forget about me and so many in our community from spending any kind of money in Palm Desert! At a time when so many foreign tourists have decided not to visit the Coachella Valley because of the current political climate in America, this would be a disaster for the businesses of the Valley. DO NOT PASS THIS PROPOSAL! VOTE NO! Gary Armstrong Rancho Mirage, CA 263 From:Nora Sanchez To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:request to rescind Resolution No. 2024-038 Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 9:13:11 AM ‌ Hello, I am a full time resident of the City of the city of Palm Desert. I DO NOT support the request to rescind Resolution No. 2024-038 . Please listen to the people of your community! 264 From:Erik Kilbo To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Meeting Today - Pride Recognition - Comments Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 9:15:48 AM ‌ Dear Mayor and Council Members, I am writing regarding today’s special meeting and the proposed reconsideration and revocation of the Pride Month recognition. While I am not a resident of Palm Desert, I spend significant time in the city and regularly support its businesses. I have long valued Palm Desert and the Coachella Valley for their reputation as inclusive, welcoming communities. I retired in 2020 and relocated to this region from South Carolina, a place where intolerance was common and where I often felt compelled to hide who I was for my own safety. I chose to move here specifically because the valley has been a place where diversity is respected and individuals are able to live openly and without fear. As a veteran who served in the United States Navy during the 1980s, I did so out of a belief in the fundamental principle that all people are created equal. That belief remains central to how I view our communities today. History has shown us the consequences of exclusion, and it is important that we do not repeat those mistakes. I respectfully ask the Council to consider the broader impact of this decision. Revoking this recognition would send a message—not only to residents, but also to visitors and businesses— that Palm Desert may no longer be a place that welcomes all. It would also risk signaling to young people who may already face discrimination or bullying that they are not valued or supported. Palm Desert’s image as an inclusive and forward-looking city is an asset, both socially and economically. I urge you to preserve that reputation by rejecting this proposal. Thank you for your time and consideration. Respectfully, Erik Kilbo 265 From:michael weitzel To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Oppose request to stop recognizing Pride month Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 9:17:14 AM ‌ Dear City Counsil, I live in Palm Desert and moved to here 40 years ago. I oppose today's request to stop recognizing Pride month in our city. Honestly, there has to be more important issues to confront than a Pride banner about who gay women and men choose to love. Thank you, Michael Weitzel Palm Desert, CA 266 From:Patrick Patterson To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:My opposition to the proposal to rescind City Council Resolution 2024-038 Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 9:31:04 AM ‌ Dear Palm Desert City Council members: I am writing to express my strong opposition to the proposal to rescind City Council Resolution 2024-038. The council proposing to eliminate recognition of gay pride celebrations in the Coachella Valley would not advance a more inclusive message for the City, as Mayor Pro Tem Joe Pradetto has argued. In fact, it would do the exact opposite, sending a clear message that members of the LGBTQ+ community are NOT valued by the City, and are not welcome there. As a proud gay man living in Cathedral City, that is certainly the message I would take away from the Council rescinding the Resolution, and I would behave accordingly. That is, if the City of Palm Desert signals that it does not want me around, I will reluctantly stop visiting any of Palm Desert's shops and restaurants and spending my money in those areas where we are not wanted. I support those communities that support equal rights and inclusivity to all. Mayor Pro Tem Joe Pradetto is making a very bad decision that will have major repercussions to the city of Palm Desert. Patrick Patterson 267 From:Kim Rusch To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Pride Month vote Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 9:36:05 AM Good morning—This email is to request that you do NOT vote to cancel Pride Month in our beautiful city! It is so important to the LGBTQ+ community to know that they are accepted and welcomed as part of our Palm Desert community, especially now with the political climate. Please continue to support Pride Month in Palm Desert. Thank you for your time. Sincerely, A mom of an LGBTQ person 268 From:Peter Engelmaier To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Pride Recognition Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 9:39:27 AM ‌ Dear Council Members, My name is Peter Engelmaier, and my partner and I reside in Palm Springs. Up until 2 years ago, I rarely ventured into Palm Desert for many reasons, but one was a feeling that as I moved East in the Valley, things became less and less accepting. That takes me to two years ago, when I moved my 90-year-old mother to Atria Hacienda, an amazing assisted living facility in Palm Desert. We now go to Palm Desert weekly to take my mother to lunch or dinner. On average, we eat about 2/3 of the time in Palm Desert and the rest in Rancho Mirage. I can assure you that if you proceed with the action being pushed, it will be 0/3 of the meals eaten in Palm Desert. I will not support a community that fosters bigotry and homophobia. And make no mistake, that is exactly what this action will be doing, whether intended or not. This whole action is seated in ignorance and a failed attempt to hide a homophobic, anti-minority agenda. The idea that the other side feels slighted by a flag and a proclamation of support, you have got to be kidding me. You do understand the other side stands for bigotry, a feeling of superiority, and veiled (sometimes not so veiled) hatred, right? I came out late in life, so like any "straight" person, I failed to understand the importance of these small gestures from society. When I finally decided to live an authentic life and truly opened my eyes to my community, I learned so much. I was so ignorant of LGBT history that it was embarrassing. I believe many on your council suffer from similar ignorance. If I assume your council wasn't trying to be hateful and was just ignorant when this proposal arose, then hopefully you have learned a little something and are ready to apologize for what feels very much like a right-wing attack on the LGBT community. To this day, the gay community loses members to suicide merely for the reason that they do not feel accepted by family, friends, and or society. The epidemic of LGBT suicide amongst teens is astounding. Please reach out to the Trevor Project if you need specifics. It is small things like seeing a flag, seeing members of their community holding hands, a teacher, a friend, or even their government recognizing 269 270 From:mrswilcox@aol.com To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Pride flag Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 9:42:05 AM ‌ At a time when hate crimes are increasing and minority groups are being targeted by our own government, this action by the PD City Council is NOT a welcomed move. To hear that our own city is considering such a move is devastating and demoralizing. We love living in a blended community and we want to encourage love and inclusion. We want our city to do the same. Jim and Joanie Wilcox Palm Desert Sent from the all new AOL app for iOS 271 From:Jacob Frick To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:comments for todays meeting Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 9:43:43 AM ‌ My name is Jacob Frick. I’m a retired medical oncologist from Wisconsin, and I’m gay. My husband and I purchased our retirement home in South Palm Desert 17 years ago, and we have never regretted our decision. The beauty and diverse activities still amaze us, but above all we have always felt safe and welcome here. Sadly, reading Mr. Pradetto’s proposals last Thursday evening shattered that sense of safety and community motivating me to speak today at the council meeting. Proposal 2024-038 allows a Pride Banner to be displayed at city hall during November (which is Pride month in the desert). Proposal 2018-09 is an antidiscrimination statement which includes the statement ‘The City recognizes, values, and will proactively work to promote diversity and inclusion within Palm Desert.’ First I would like to address the proposal to ban the Pride Banner from city property. We lived here 16 years before Palm Desert finally displayed a Pride Banner at city hall last November. With 200,000 people attending Pride this year—many of whom were visitors—the economic incentive for Palm Desert to showcase the banner is irrefutable. Many of my generation in the LGBTQ community grew up in an environment filled with homophobia, and we lived fearful of separation from family, of job loss, violence, and hateful language. Overcoming this unjust discrimination was a gradual process requiring persistent efforts for over 50 years. The fact that I’m here to discuss a ban on the Pride banner today shows that we still aren’t finished with this task. The display of the Pride Banner signifies a commitment to supporting LGBTQ individuals worldwide in their battle against everyday homophobia. It poses no threat to anyone. The proposal to ban the Pride Banner after just two years suggests that the city council now views LGBTQ residents of Palm Desert as second-class citizens. For other LGBTQ residents of the Coachella Valley and visitors, it sends a clear message: ‘we do not want you in Palm Desert!.’ Even if the council rejects this proposal, some damage has already been done. Next I’ll address modifications to Resolution No. 2018-09. This resolution asserts, "The City recognizes, values, and will proactively work to promote diversity and inclusion within Palm Desert." It was approved with a 5-0 vote in 2018. The new proposal seeks to eliminate any reference to diversity in the resolution. To paraphrase his comments from last Thursday’s meeting, he aims to emphasize our similarities rather than our differences. That appears to be lifted directly from the Project 2025 handbook, a creation of The Heritage Foundation—a group known for its opposition to abortion, reproductive rights, LGBTQ rights, immigrants' rights, and racial equity. Personally, I would hope decisions regarding local governance in Palm Desert would reflect the community's values rather than those of a right-wing conservative organization in Washington, DC. On a more fundamental level, what is his aversion to the term "diversity"? The Oxford Dictionary defines diversity as "the practice or quality of including or involving people from a range of different social and ethnic backgrounds and of different genders, sexual orientations." Isn't that what Palm Desert embodies today? Does the council honestly believe this needs to be altered? If so, it’s a terrible message to send to LGBTQ residents, people of color, Latin Americans, and Asians who call our city home. Lastly, I believe that both of these proposals are detrimental to the business landscape in Palm Desert. Should either of these proposals pass, it could make national headlines, dissuading potential LGBTQ visitors who will perceive Palm Desert as no longer being ‘gay friendly.’ With a significant LGBTQ population in the Coachella Valley, local businesses could face repercussions as the city adopts an anti- LGBTQ stance. With 200,000 people attending Pride this year—many of whom were visitors—the economic incentive for Palm Desert to showcase the Pride banner even more prominently is irrefutable. 272 There's really no need to alter either resolution. Displaying a Pride Banner at city hall for a mere 30 days won't trouble anyone, and Mr. Pradetto could simply look the other way during that time. I admit my lack of experience in government, but as a city taxpayer it seems like all this effort to banish Pride banners and the word diversity from Palm Desert is a colossal waste of time. But someone is sp desperate to make it happen that this discussion is occurring at a ‘special’ meeting only two business days after being proposed. I ask Mr.Pradetto to withdraw his proposals and urge the council to maintain both resolutions as they currently stand. Thank you for the opportunity to address the council. Jacob Frick MD 12/15/2025 273 From:James Carver To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:PRIDE in PALM DESERT Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 9:48:20 AM ‌ To Whom It May Concern to My Neighboring Friends on The Palm Desert Council: Please do not buy into the HATE and SEPARATION and DEVISIVE methods that pull the citizens in your city AND OUR BELOVED COACHELLA VALLEY apart! I support Palm Desert showing their PRIDE for all their citizens and especially for their gay citizens during PRIDE WEEK. Can't we all just get along and celebrate each other AND HAVE A LITTLE PRIDE! Thank you! James Carver semajcarver@ 274 From:Judy Klein To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Rescinding LGBTQ Pride Month Commerations Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 9:48:29 AM ‌ City Council, As a new resident of Palm Desert, I’m appalled that the council is proposing to rescind the LGBTQ commemorations. This does the exact opposite of what you are proposing, and harms our LGBTQ community. We are proud to show support of our LGBTQ community, and this proposal shows that our council members are not. I am urging you to vote down this proposal for the better of our community. Judy Klein 275 From:Richard Price To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Why So Mean? Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 9:50:42 AM ‌ I'm a 66-year old gay man living in Palm Springs. The gay flag and the celebration ofGay Pride Month means a great deal to me and my family. I remember when I was inmy teens and 20's and no one had ever strung the words Gay and Pride togethermuch less put them on a parade down Main Street. The Rainbow Flag and PrideWeek mean so much more to people of my generation. It affirms that we matter andthat we are included in society. To take that away -- even symbolically -- is a slap inthe face. It feels like we're going back to the 1950s. It has nothing to do with"neutrality," and everything about taking away our dignity. We’re part of our societyand you can’t erase us. Please vote no on this petty and mean-spirited proposal. The Palm Desert City Council has better things to do with their time. Richard Price Palm Springs 276 From:JAMES SAWYER To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:CONSIDERATION OF A REQUEST FOR ACTION TO RESCIND CITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2024-038 RELATED TO LGBTQ PRIDE MONTH COMMEMORATIONS AND AMENDING CITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. 2018-09 RELATED TO DIVERSITY AND INCLUSION. Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 9:51:54 AM I am a resident of Palm Desert, and I am very against and reject the proposal to eliminate Palm Desert’s official recognition of Pride Month and the removal of our Pride Banner. This is a totally unnecessary action and a hurtful move to many and only promotes more division, and isn’t there enough of that in today’s world? Not to mention, I think it is a move that will hurt the city‘s economy. Please reject this proposal. Joan Sawyer 277 From:Stan Harvey To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Special Meeting - December 16, 2025 - Comment Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 10:00:24 AM Dear Palm Desert City Council Members: As a resident of Palm Desert for over 33 years, I am very disappointed that the council is considering rescinding a prior resolution that recognizes and celebrates the wonderful diversity of this community. I do not understand how rescinding the resolution to honor Pride Month uplifts and promotes peace and harmony in Palm Desert. Please vote NO to this negative and potentially harmful resolution. Thank you. Sincerely, Stan Harvey Palm Desert, CA 278 From:Kurt Kosek To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Opposition to the proposal to rescind City Council Resolution 2034-038 Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 10:09:52 AM Dear Palm Desert City Council members: I am writing to express my strong opposition to the proposal to rescind City Council Resolution 2024-038. In my opinion, taking action to eliminate recognition of gay pride celebrations in the Coachella Valley by the City of Palm Desert would not advance a more inclusive message for the City, as Mayor Pro Tem Joe Pradetto has argued. In fact, it would do the exact opposite, sending a clear message that members of the LGBT+ community are NOT valued by the City, and are not welcome there. As a proud gay man living in Palm Springs, that is certainly the message I would take away from the Council rescinding the Resolution, and I would behave accordingly. That is, if the City of Palm Desert signals that it does not want me around, I will comply (albeit reluctantly) with the City's wish and stop visiting Palm Desert's shops and restaurants. Regards Kurt Kosek 279 From:Carlos E Garcia To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:The importance of Pride Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 10:11:40 AM Palm Desert City Council: As a resident of Palm Desert for 7 years and a past member of the City Finance Committee, I would like to voice my support to maintain the city’s historic effort to stand with its LGBTQ + citizens and against the forces that would deny our existence. Pride ‍ is a movement that both celebrates our differences and our shared humanity in a single gesture. Please don’t drag our beloved city back into a past full of denial and neglect. Keep our city a beacon of civilized life with respect and consideration for all of its citizens. My husband (a past member of the City’s Architectural Review Committee) and I strongly urge the Council to support Pride. This is important to us personally. Carlos E García Dean Wallace Colvard Jr. Palm Desert CA. 92211 Sent from my iPhone so please forgive any typos. 280 From:NotActuallyRon To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Public Comment for 12/16/25 Special Meeting Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 10:57:07 AM ‌ Good morning, Please include the following as a public comment for the single agenda item at the December 16, 2025 special meeting. While I am more than willing to give Mayor Pro Tem Joe the benefit of the doubt and assume his intentions were pure, I struggle to follow his logic. The idea that raising a banner in support of a specific group somehow creates division is, frankly, quite fascinating. By that logic, perhaps we should do away with all banners entirely. After all, a banner honoring veterans could offend those who didn’t serve, Spanish Heritage Month might upset those without Spanish ancestry, and acknowledging the Jewish community clearly risks alienating non-Jews. What a wonderfully “unified” community we’d be one stripped of all recognition, color, and meaning. And why stop there? Imagine the perfect harmony that would emerge if we removed the Desert Holocaust Memorial from Civic Center Park. Or if we did away with Black History Month too, just to make sure no one feels left out. Surely, that’s the logical conclusion of this mindset. Mayor Pro Tem Joe, reality check, our world thrives on differences. It’s those differences that make our community vibrant, resilient, and exceptional. Leadership means embracing that, not retreating from it because a few bitter voices find comfort in sameness. You have the opportunity to bring a fresh perspective to the council. Be bold. Be innovative. Be the leader that moves us forward not backward into a beige blur of “unity.” You should take pride in being one of the youngest to serve in your role. If, however, the pressures of leadership still feel beyond reach, perhaps as suggested by your earlier hesitation to serve as mayor pro tem then perhaps it’s worth considering whether you’re ready for the responsibility. Luck may have placed you here, but courage and clarity will determine whether you stay. 281 From:JAMIE TRACHTENBERG To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Rescinding City Council Resolution 2024-038 Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 11:20:49 AM ‌ Dear Palm Desert City Council members: I am writing to express my strident opposition to the proposal to rescind City Council Resolution 2024-038. Taking this exclusionary action to eliminate recognition of the LGBTQ community and pride by the City of Palm Desert is reprehensible. This move would NOT advance a more inclusive message for the City as Mayor Pro Tem Joe Pradetto has stated. In fact, it would do the exact opposite, sending a clear message that members of the LGBTQ community are NOT valued by the City of Palm Desert and are not welcome there. I am an out and proud lesbian living in Palm Springs, a progressive and open city for all residents, and know what recognition and community support means for the safety and well being of all residents and visitors. Rescinding this ordinance will send the message that the City of Palm Desert is endorsing exclusion and fostering hate, endangering residents and visitors alike. I, for one, will stop patronizing all businesses in the City of Palm Desert and am fairly certain that the 70% of the population who support the community will do the same. Show the people of Palm Desert and the Coachella Valley as a whole, that Palm Desert cares about ALL people and do not rescind the ordinance. Respectfully, Jamie Trachtenberg, LCSW, ACHP-SW “I don’t want to end up simply having visited this world” ~Mary Oliver 282 From:Gregory H. To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Palm Desert"s recognition of Pride Month Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 12:08:36 PM ‌ Dear Council Members, I am adding my voice to those who are concerned about Palm Desert's proposal to cease recognition of LGBTQ Pride month. I believe that now, more than ever, we need to be embracing diversity and protecting all marginalized groups. Recognition of Pride month is a small but meaningful gesture to show broad support and inclusivity at the civic level. While I am a Rancho Mirage resident, I am a Palm Desert shopper and I have many friends who live in Palm Desert. Where I choose to spend my money matters to me, and knowing that my friends are valued members of the Palm Desert community matters to me even more. Please stand up for them. Thank you, Gregory Hruska 283 From:debravogler@me.com To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Comments re: Special Meeting Agenda; Tuesday, 12/16/25 Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 12:16:09 PM Importance:High ‌ Dear Palm Desert City Council: The Palm Desert City Council should find more constructive uses of its time rather than follow the current fad of embracing the divisiveness that comes from throwing politeness and considerateness out the window. Acknowledging various groups of people who have not always enjoyed the right to vote, hold a job, or marry, or who otherwise have been denied equal protection under our Constitution and laws, is not divisive. Celebrating our coming together as a society to do better by groups still subjected to hate is a positive—not a negative thing. Flying the LGBTQ flag during Pride celebrations is a welcome sign to those who, historically, were not welcome anywhere. Examples of more constructive issues upon which the City Council could focus include diversifying our local economy so it is not so dependent on tourism and/or construction of warehouses. We need more attention paid to developing excellence in STEM education and entrepreneurship in technology so that more of our young people can remain in the area after graduation. Another focal point could be constructing micro grids so that Palm Desert would be better prepared in the event of a major earthquake or other disaster that takes out the grid. Thank you for your consideration of this letter. Sincerely, Debra Vogler 284 Palm Desert, CA 285 From:Mitch Battersby To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Pride recognition Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 12:17:33 PM ‌ An Open Letter to Mayor Pro Tem Joe Pradetyo and the City of Palm Desert Mayor Pro Tem Pradetyo and Honorable Members of the Palm Desert City Council, I write to you as as a long-standing community leader who has worked for decades alongside residents, nonprofits, businesses, volunteers, and civic partners across the Coachella Valley. My views below reflect my role as a community leader and advocate for inclusion, equity, and community well-being. Recent comments and the proposed reconsideration of Pride Month recognition in Palm Desert compel a clear and direct response—not just on behalf of the LGBTQ+ community, but on behalf of the broader valley we all serve. Neutrality Is Not the Absence of Values Mayor Pro Tem Pradetyo, you stated that government should not “celebrate the private identities of one group over another” and should act as a “neutral referee.” Respectfully, neutrality does not mean silence in the face of inequity. Pride Month recognition is not about elevating one group above another; it is about acknowledging a community that has historically faced discrimination, exclusion, violence, and erasure, and affirming that they belong. Cities routinely recognize veterans, seniors, cultural heritage months, faith communities, small businesses, and countless civic groups. These recognitions are not endorsements of “private lives.” They are affirmations of presence, contribution, and belonging. To single out LGBTQ+ recognition as inappropriate while allowing others to stand is not neutrality, it is selective withdrawal. Pride Is Not Favoritism. It Is Public Acknowledgment Characterizing Pride recognition as “favoritism” or “celebrating private identities” fundamentally misunderstands what Pride represents. LGBTQ+ people are not asking the City to celebrate who they love in private. They are asking their government to acknowledge who they are in public, as residents, taxpayers, business owners, employees, volunteers, parents, seniors, and veterans. Pride Month exists because for generations LGBTQ+ people were told to be invisible, to be silent, to be ashamed. Public recognition is a corrective to that history, not a special privilege. Removing that recognition sends a message, intended or not, that LGBTQ+ residents are conditional participants in civic life. Inclusion Does Not Create Division. Erasure Does 286 You have also suggested that government should avoid “well-intentioned speech” that might generate division. History shows the opposite. Division arises when communities feel unseen, unsupported, or singled out for exclusion. Inclusion does not fracture communities; it strengthens them. Visibility saves lives. Affirmation reduces harm. Recognition tells young people, seniors, families, and visitors alike that this is a place where they are safe and valued. Silence, especially when it follows prior recognition, is not neutral. It is loud. And it causes real harm. The Economic Reality for Palm Desert and the Valley Beyond the moral implications, there are undeniable economic consequences to stepping away from LGBTQ+ inclusion. The Coachella Valley, particularly Palm Springs and its neighboring cities, has built a national and international reputation as an inclusive destination. LGBTQ+ travelers, residents, and retirees contribute tens of millions of dollars annually to our local economy through tourism, real estate, small business investment, events, and philanthropy. Palm Springs Pride alone generates a massive economic impact, supporting hotels, restaurants, transportation, retail, and hundreds of jobs. The strength of that impact relies on a valley-wide commitment to inclusion. When one city signals retreat, the ripple effects are felt far beyond city limits, by workers, businesses, and families throughout the region. Inclusion is not just the right thing to do. It is sound economic policy. For these reasons, I call on you, Mayor Pro Tem Pradetyo, to withdraw this motion immediately. Not table it. Not reframe it. Withdraw it. And I call on the Palm Desert City Council to: 1. Reject any attempt to remove Pride Month recognition, and 2. Reaffirm the City’s commitment to inclusion and equality for all residents. Palm Desert has the opportunity to stand on the right side of history, to lead with clarity, compassion, and courage. The LGBTQ+ community is not asking for special treatment. We are asking not to be singled out for exclusion. Our valley is strongest when every resident knows they belong. Respectfully Mitchell Battersby 287 288 From:Marvin Dorson To:CouncilMeeting Comments Cc:Marvin Dorson Subject:Special council meeting Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 12:33:09 PM ‌ Mayor and council members, I can’t believe that this is even happening. What kind of person would even suggest this at this time and say that it was an effort to combat the rise in hate crimes. This will only increase hate crimes. It will also impact the city of Palm Desert financially. As of today I will spend no more money in PD and will encourage the same of all who visit me. Do you really want Palm Desert to be the pit of hate in the valley? Six months ago, you voted to recognize Pride Month. What are you afraid of? Because I can tell you what the LGBTQ families in this community are afraid of. They’re afraid their city is telling them they made a mistake. That recognizing their existence was too much. That they need to go back to being invisible. And I can tell you what local businesses are afraid of. They’re afraid Palm Desert is about to become the only city in the Coachella Valley that officially says Pride doesn’t belong here. Palm Springs celebrates it. Cathedral City celebrates it. No other city in this valley is rushing to undo its own commitments. If you pass this rescission, you become the outlier. The city that said no. Do you know what that does to a brand? Do you know what that does to tourism? This valley’s economy runs on people choosing to visit, to move here, to invest here. And increasingly, those people—especially younger professionals and families—make choices based on values. They want to know their neighbors will be welcomed. They want to know their kids will be safe. When you rescind Pride recognition, you’re not making a statement about flags or banners. You’re making a statement about who belongs in Palm Desert. And the market will respond accordingly. Assemblymember Greg Wallis—a Republican who represents this district—has already called this proposal "a slap in the face" to residents. He said removing these symbols sends the message that "some members of our community matter less than others". When your own Republican Assemblymember is telling you this is wrong, what does that tell you? It tells you this isn’t about left or right. It’s about right and wrong. NO MORE PALM DESERT. WE SEE WHO YOU ARE. 289 From:Ryland Penta To:City Hall Mail Subject:Fw: Removal of flag and pride celebration Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 8:31:00 AM Ryland Penta, MSc Community Relations Supervisor City of Palm Desert 73510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert, CA 92260 rpenta@palmdesert.gov | 760.776.6318 | www.palmdesert.gov From: desertsunisfun <desertsunisfun Sent: Tuesday, December 16, 2025 7:38 To: Community Relations <CommunityRelations@palmdesert.gov> Subject: Removal of flag and pride celebration ‌ It was mighty uncomfortable watching your mayor squirm on The Rogan Report yesterday. It is very difficult to argue ones way past one's own bigotry and bias, particularly when you become aware of just how shameful those emotions are. As to the flag and pride celebrations in your city... sharing and celebrating a unique group or culture does not elevate them above the rest of the population. Sharing in and celebrating other cultures is how we get along. Society is an amalgamation of races, cultures, genders, and sexualities with many similarities and distinct differences. I am a non-hispanic male, but I would have no objections to a Mexican flag flying during a celebration week of Mexican culture. I would have no trouble attending such a celebration as it helps me better understand people who are different than me, and perhaps even experience people and things that are otherwise unfamiliar to me. I often attend the Native American powwows in this desert, despite the fact that I'm not Native American. The food , the music, the costumes are so marvelously unique and contrasting to that of my own life. And hey, they're a lot of fun. And gay pride celebrations and parades are a whole lot of fun too for those who who are not too hateful to attend . Gay pride celebrations are an open expression by a group of people who have long been repressed subjugated and hidden in closets. Is not an expression of superiority, it is an opening of arms and a show to those who have not yet come to terms with their sexuality that there is acceptance and love for them in the greater community. Pride celebrations in this desert have ALWAYS been inclusive and welcomed ALL people who live here or travel here for such an event. And on top of all of the good things that pride celebrations do spiritually for people, let's not forget that this year it was estimated that the Palm Springs gay pride celebration brought 32 million dollars in revenue to the valley. 290 Please don't let the biases of one man steer your community away from a reputation of inclusiveness. That would be a very high cost for Palm Desert to pay. It has also been my experience that men who are outspoken... specifically against the gay community often have issues in their own lives. I call it the Larry Craig syndrome. Larry Craig was a Republican senator from Idaho who was very outspoken and attempted to pass anti-gay legislation in his state. He was subsequently found having sex with men in men's bathrooms. Perhaps you might suggest that your mayor gets some psychological counseling to help him posture with his own potential repressed feelings. Thank you kindly for listening. I hope he and the Palm Desert city council do the right thing in the upcoming days. Yahoo Mail: Search, Organize, Conquer 291 From:Ryland Penta To:City Hall Mail Subject:Fw: Pride Banners Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 8:34:17 AM Ryland Penta, MSc Community Relations Supervisor City of Palm Desert 73510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert, CA 92260 rpenta@palmdesert.gov | 760.776.6318 | www.palmdesert.gov From: Jeffrey Howard <jeffreyhoward > Sent: Monday, December 15, 2025 18:37 To: Community Relations <CommunityRelations@palmdesert.gov> Subject: Pride Banners ‌ As a straight white 79 year old male I am horrified by the thought of removing pride banners from city hall. It’s tantamount to poking a stick in the eye of the LGBT community. Please reconsider an incredibly unwise decision. Jeffrey Howard Law Offices of Jeffrey M. Howard Palm Desert, CA 92260 Cell jeffreyhoward@ 292 From:Matt Kenny To:City Hall Mail; alisa@pdacc.org; cameron@visitgreaterps.com; VcenterMail; info@desertbusinessassociation.org Cc:ani.gasparyan@desertsun.com; kate.franco@desertsun.com; eric.hartley@desertsun.com; info@pspride.org Subject:Opposition to Palm Desert Rescinding Resolution 2024-038 Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 11:15:38 AM ‌ Dear Members of the City Council, It is with deep disappointment and profound anger that I write to express my absolute opposition to your discussion on rescinding resolution 2024-038 and removing the Pride flag from City Hall. I moved to Palm Desert just over a year ago after leaving Florida, where similar local and statewide actions were taken under the guise of “neutrality” but served only to advance division, intolerance, and fear. I chose California, and Palm Desert specifically, because it represented something different, a place that projected safety, progress, and inclusion. The Pride flag flying at City Hall was not symbolic politics. It was a visible signal that this city understood both the dignity of the LGBTQ+ community and the very real threats it continues to face on a national level. That flag matters. It tells people that Palm Desert was a safe place to live, participate, and belong. Removing it sends the opposite message. Some of you have publicly questioned why Pride Month exists, or why “gay people get a full month.” The answer is simple. When heterosexual or cis gender people are required to sit through public meetings where their equality under the law is debated, they can have a month as well. When heterosexual people must watch courts and legislatures decide whether they are fully human or deserving of basic civil rights, they can have a month too. Members of the LGBTQ+ community face these realities every single day. There has never been a moment when this Council, or any court, has debated whether a straight, white man deserves equal protection under the law. My community does not have that luxury. This legislation is framed as promoting equality or reducing division. If that were truly the goal, then consistency would be required. The Christmas tree, a clear religious symbol, would also need to be removed from City Hall in recognition of the Constitution’s mandate for separation of church and state. By the same logic, proclamations recognizing Hispanic Heritage Month or Breast Cancer Awareness Month would be rescinded for elevating specific communities or causes. Of course, such actions would be rightly viewed as absurd. Yet that same flawed logic is now being applied to Pride. This logic also sets up a lawsuit nicely as you are clearly targetting a specific group, while not holding other groups or causes to the same requirements. 293 These contradictions reveal this legislation for what it is, shortsighted, ill-considered, and harmful. I have included local tourism and business leaders on this correspondence because decisions like this have consequences. If Palm Desert chooses to signal that LGBTQ+ residents and visitors are unwelcome, I will make certain that message is widely known. The friends and family who visit me throughout the year will take their business elsewhere, and I will actively discourage others from spending their dollars in a city that chooses exclusion over leadership. You need only look to recent national examples (Target) to understand how quickly reputational damage becomes economic reality, and how much local businesses could suffer very real consequences. Palm Desert is strongest when it acknowledges that not everyone enjoys equal protection under the law, and when it accepts its responsibility to protect those who are most vulnerable. If that responsibility requires nothing more than flying a flag or making a proclamation on a piece of paper, to let people know they are not alone and that their lives matter, then it is not a burden. It is leadership. Finally, remember that your children are watching. Long after votes like these are forgotten, they will remember what their parents stood for. You may hope to teach them compassion and fairness, but decisions like this risk teaching them something far more damaging, that power can be used to exclude, diminish, and silence. And that their first bully's were at home. That is not the lesson Palm Desert should be imparting. Sincerely, Matt Kenny Palm Desert Resident and Tax Payer 294 From:DEAN & PHILIP To:City Hall Mail Subject:Limiting the LGBTQ VOICE Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 11:43:01 AM ‌ Palm Desert Should Not Silence The LGBTQ Voices. Palm Desert has long promoted itself as a welcoming, inclusive city, one that values diversity, civic participation, and mutual respect. That reputation is worth protecting. Which is why the City Council’s consideration of removing or restricting LGBTQ+ Pride displays on city property deserves serious concern from residents. For me, this issue is deeply personal. In 2008, my husband and I became the first male same- sex couple to marry in California on the steps of Indio City Hall attended by 87 members of the press.. At the time, that moment was both joyful and uncertain. We stood there not just for ourselves, but for countless LGBTQ+ people who had long been told they did not belong in public life. That marriage was about love, but also about visibility, dignity, and equal participation in our civic community. Pride signs and symbols serve a similar purpose today. They are not disruptive or radical statements. They are peaceful, symbolic expressions that say LGBTQ+ residents, families, and visitors belong here. For many, especially young people, seniors, or those who have faced discrimination. Seeing that acknowledgment in public spaces matters more than some realize. Visibility communicates safety, affirmation, and inclusion. When a city allows community expression on government property, whether for holidays, veterans’ commemorations, cultural celebrations, or civic causes. It assumes a responsibility to apply its rules fairly. Excluding LGBTQ+ expression while permitting others is not neutrality. It is a choice that elevates some voices while sidelining others. This is not about asking for special treatment. LGBTQ+ residents pay taxes, vote, own businesses, raise families, and volunteer throughout the Coachella Valley. For decades, the desert has benefited enormously from the LGBTQ+ community’s investment, financially, culturally, and socially. Gay residents helped revive neighborhoods, renovate homes, open businesses, support the arts, and contribute to the growth and vibrancy that so many now enjoy. That history should be acknowledged, not erased. It is also important to remember why Pride exists in the first place. LGBTQ+ people were once criminalized, fired from jobs, denied housing, and excluded from civic spaces entirely. Public recognition today is not excess or ideology; it is a corrective to that past and a reminder that equal dignity is a shared civic value. Some argue that removing Pride displays avoids controversy. But exclusion does not create unity, it creates silence. And silence almost always falls hardest on those who have already fought to be seen. Palm Desert has an opportunity here. It can reaffirm that public spaces belong to everyone by allowing Pride displays under the same neutral rules applied to other community expressions. Doing so costs the city nothing, but it sends a powerful message: that Palm Desert represents all of its residents. Local government is not just about managing property; it is about reflecting the people who live here. LGBTQ+ residents are not outsiders, and Pride is not a fringe concern. It is part of this community’s history, present, and future. Palm Desert should choose inclusion over erasure, consistency over contradiction, and representation over silence. Pride should not be hidden away. It should be acknowledged openly, respectfully, and equally. Because that is what a truly welcoming city does. Respectfully, 295 Philip Colavito Dean Seymour 296 From:City of Palm Desert To:City Hall Mail Subject:LGBTQ Flag Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 11:58:25 AM ‌ Message submitted from the <City of Palm Desert> website. Site Visitor Name: Darrell Baum Site Visitor Email: Do you even know why we celebrate Pride month? It's because we were told as children and young adults that we are less than others and that we had no rights to exist. Teens were kicked out of their homes and still are today. They are shamed for being who they are. We do not have a choice in being straight or gay. And who the hell would ever choose to be part of a minority group that is hated and victimized. Pride is about knowing that you are a human and that you are not less than. Pride flags at government and private buildings are reminders to bigoted, homophobic individuals that there is no place for shaming and hate. We need these symbols to remind ignorant hicks that it is not ok to cause mental and physical harm to others because they are different from themselves. Do you recall the horrors that happened to Mathew Shepherd because of ignorant, bigoted, homophobic individuals? Do you understand the pain that people with HIV/AIDS went through in the 80s and even today because of the ignorance!? There are so many examples of why we need to remind people that hate and intolerance is not allowed. So, yes, a flag at City Hall reminding these bigoted homophobes that it's not alright to hate is very necessary today. 297 From:Derek-Info To:CityClerk Cc:City Hall Mail Subject:Pride Month Recognition Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 12:18:38 PM ‌ Dear Mayor Pro Tem Joe Pradetto: I am writing to ask that you and your fellow city council members reconsider and rescind your request for the city to stop recognizing Pride Month. We in the LGBTQ+ community deserve to be free from hate speech, hate crimes, and discrimination. Recognizing Pride month and flying the Pride flag is simply a small gesture of support for our human and civil rights. Thank you for your consideration, Derek S. South Palm Desert Resident 298 From:Michael Marcotte To:City Hall Mail Subject:Diversity, Pride week, etc Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 12:29:07 PM ‌ My name is Michael Marcotte. I am a 7 year resident of Palm Desert and a registered voter. I am completely surprised and saddened by the out of touch actions of a few bigots and hate mongers on our city council that want to take this city backwards in time to an America that never existed. This country was built on inclusion of immigrants into a society of people largely fleeing oppression from backward thinking rulers of other countries. Now we have the same backward thinking creeping up in our own elected officials? You people have a responsibility to represent the people of Palm Desert. Not your own petty partisan differences. Work on making the city a safer more inclusive city for all our residents. Don't work on your petty politizaton of DEI and Pride Week. The mayor pro tem is an un elected position, appointed by your cronies on the council. You can all be replaced next election. You should seriously take the current political temperature and realize you are completely on the wrong side of this issue. Next election is less than a year away and the electorate will remember what you do here and vote accordingly. . 299 To the Palm Desert City Council, Mayor Pro Tern Pradetto opened his term by calling himself a "flawed man." He was right. This request to rescind Resolution Nb. 2024-038 is not just flawed. It is tone deaf, boneheaded, and revealing. Early on, he made it clear that Palm Desert was no longer a place for DEi. He prefers the language of "merit," as if merit exists in a vacuum, untouched by history, power, or access. As if people who are Black, women, or gay must have been given their roles instead of earning them. That presumption says far more about him than it does about anyone else. As a presumed straight white man in his 30s, he has the luxury of believing differences create division. When the world already reflects you, difference feels optional. Inconvenient. Something to be ignored for the sake of "getting along." When it doesn't reflect you, difference is survival. Government does not exist only to affirm the comfortable. It exists to protect, elevate, and sometimes correct. When entire groups have been historically marginalized, excluded from quality education, denied generational wealth, criminalized, or simply erased, pretending we are all starting from the same place is not neutrality. It is willful blindness. A so-called "merit-based" system that refuses to acknowledge this reality is not fair. It is lazy. And let's talk about hypocrisy. Palm Desert has a large Holocaust memorial at Civic Center Park. It commemorates a specific group. A specific history. A specific atrocity. No one is arguing it should be removed. Nor should they. That memorial exists because remembrance matters. Visibility matters. Acknowledgment matters. So why is Pride the target? Why is a temporary banner recognizing LGBTQ residents too much, while permanent monuments recognizing other communities are untouchable? If the objection is truly about not "celebrating differences," then be honest enough to apply that standard universally. Otherwise, this is not about unity. It is about selective discomfort. The truth is simple: Pride makes some people uneasy because it challenges the idea that the default experience is the only one that counts. It reminds us that there are neighbors, coworkers, family members who had to fight just to exist openly. 300 It was not long ago, within living memory, that a President of the United States could not even say the word "gay" while an entire generation d ied of AIDS. Funding was withheld. Care was delayed. Silence was policy. Because those lives were considered outside the community that mattered. That history does not disappear because it makes you uncomfortable. You do not create unity by telling people to shut up about who they are so others won't feel offended. You do not heal division by erasing difference. You deepen it. Rescinding Resolution No. 2024-038 sends a clear message, whether you intend it or not: some people are welcome here quietly, invisibly, and only on someone else's terms. Palm Desert can do better than that. You already did better than that when you adopted the resolution. Don 't walk it back now. -Someone who is paying attention 301 From:Barbara Cain To:CityClerk Subject:For Council 12/16 Emergency Meeting Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 11:59:24 AM ‌ Council Members - The proposal to relegate Pride to the past is disappointing. The hard-earned acknowledgment and appreciation in our Palm Desert community needs to continue - as much for the joy it currently brings - as to demonstrate our door of openness and fairness. Dropping Pride would close that door. It may well encourage homophobia. Is this just one more instance in this radicalized age toward making any and all diverse populations ‘others’? The proposed action if implemented would signal unwelcomeness to potential real estate buyers and those who support so many retail/restaurant businesses. Council: Please consider this especially with your hearts, and with the city’s pocket book in mind. Thank you. I realize I am submitting beyond deadline however the meeting came with short notice. Barbara Cain PD, 92260 bcaincos 302 303 304 305 306 307 308 309 310 311 312 313 314 315 316 From:Adam To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Joe Pradetto"s Proposal Date:Wednesday, December 17, 2025 11:27:30 AM ‌ Dear Palm Desert City Council, My name is Adam Koltun. I am a homeowner and tax payer in Palm Desert. My wife and I have made our full-time life here in the desert for the past few years. I had planned on writing this email in advance of the meeting on the insane, bigoted resolution put forth by Joe Pradetto. As the City Council decided to hold a meeting with barely any notice at 1:30pm on a working day, I am sending it now. First of all, while I now call Palm Desert home, I am originally from Chicago. As such, I am unfortunately familiar with dirty politics, though the small-town nature of them in Palm Desert adds a layer of absurdity that is absent from a city of millions. Instead of corrupt alderpeople running schemes to defraud millions from the city and personally enrich themselves (a despicable practice that at least has an understandable endgoal of personal enrichment), we have a guy who was most recently elected in 2024 trying to ram through a proposal that would make Nick Fuentes and Tucker Carlson smirk at one another. Whatever the ostensible justification or excuse, holding a meeting at 1:30pm on a working day with hardly any notice is an attempt to limit the people who are able to attend to the retired, the unemployed, and the terminally political. If you are trying to pull a political stunt meant to make yourself and your bigotry look rational, and your opponents standing up for human rights irrational - this is exactly what you would do. Curious that this is what was done, evidently with the support of more than just Pradetto! Let me be explicitly clear: It is pathetic, it is bush-league, and it is entirely predictable as a means of attempting to avoid public comment and public scrutiny, while ensuring what scrutiny does arrive, arrives as incoherent, unprofessional, and emotional as possible. This is not new. You are not slick. Having seen the meeting (which I watched while working, because again, I am gainfully employed and cannot simply manifest that away whenever a MAGA apparatchik decides to attack LGBTQIA+ people), I can now double-down on my assertion that Joe Pradetto is at least familiar with, if not directly enmeshed, in MAGA world. One does not simply accidentally include numerous references in his text and words ripped directly from MAGA/Fascist message boards. The odds are better that one would win the lottery. Multiple times. Without buying a ticket. Attempting to silence and hide minority identity under the guise of "Unity" or "Togetherness" or "Highlighting what we share as citizens" are literal Nick Fuentes Groyper, 4-chan, Mondoweiss, and Stormfront talking points. They are the literal catch-phrases of fascists! What, if he said the Fourteen Words ("We must secure the existence of our people and a future for white children"), was the City Council going to have polite debate on that as well? If 317 well? What if Pradetto wants to add a Swastika to City Hall, but says its just an obscure religious symbol meaning Love. Will that garner polite debate as well? Just how far is the City Council of Palm Desert willing to debase itself in the service of a man who clearly has sympathies, if not outright empathy, with White Nationalist causes. Congratulations, Palm Desert City Government. You let a fascist stand up and deliver talking points ripped right from the message boards of the people who are attempting to turn America into a fascist dictatorship. The insistence on referring to human beings as "citizens" - which implicitly sets forth the notion that non-citizens do not deserve rights, is a fascist talking point explicitly advanced on 4-chan and other white power social media. Making sure to stress the word "Unity" when discussing how to best discriminate against people is a MAGA/Fascist meme literally inspired by the V for Vendetta villainous politcal party, Norsefire's, creed: "Strength Through Unity. Unity Through Faith" The Strength they refer to is Fascism. The Faith they refer to is Christianity, in service to that Fascism. Pradetto's self-flattering insistence that he is willing to talk and listen was nakedly a lie. The crowd reaction to it, of mocking laughter and at least one audible "Bullshit!" on the livestream was, again, far too tame for what was being spewed on stage. But most people under 60 were unable to attend, so a more docile crowd (again, clearly the inevitable and only effect of the timing and lack of notice of the event, whatever the intention) was what Pradetto was able to spew his vile hatred at. Becoming a vehicle for MAGA/Fascist talking points is pathetic for a sundown town in rural Alabama. It is inconceivable, insane, and financial suicide for a Democratic city, in the middle of a Democratic valley, with a LGBTQIA+ population exceeding 25%. Pradetto's insistence that "all rules are fair" is literally, again, a MAGA talking point. They are not idiots (they are morally bankrupt, but not stupid) - they know that if one person has millions, and one person has nothing, and you treat them "equally" - that those with much will always win out. To Be Blunt: They say they want the government to be "impartial" because for most of America's 250+ year history, the government has been anything but impartial. Two Hundred and Fifty years of solely advancing the power of White Men, and NOW they want fairness? The absurdity is part of the point. They want to look directly at us, tell us that everything is fair, and then run us down with their Teslas. The intent of such a worldview is singular; creating a permanent White Christian Aristocracy, enshrined by their historical advantages over other groups, which will never change as everything is now "Fair and Impartial" (The same two words that Fox News constantly uses in self-reference. Again, not weird for literal 4chan memes. It's just weird that nobody said anything about it). I do not know what sort of decorum requires the City Council to treat these bigoted utterances with anything other than revulsion, expulsion, and an absolute salting of the earth from which they arose. The Mayor spoke of always embracing debate. Somehow I doubt that if someone were to suggest defecating in his cereal, that his response would be to "not put my finger on the scale, and let everyone have their say" - because that proposal is absurd, destructive, and not fit for discussion. Yet denying the rights and realities of LGBTQIA+ people, and their wider community, was given the dignity of a debate, the dignity of public discussion. It did not, and never will, warrant such debate. It did not, and never will, warrant such public discussion. Should we now suggest that Italian-Americans have too many rights, as one of 318 their own obviously is so ensconced from reality as to be able to put forth such a proposal? Would that warrant public debate too? Or is it only removing the rights from the vulnerable and marginalized that warrants public debate in Palm Desert? Anything, no matter how insane, becomes less insane when it is publicly debated by elected representatives. You know this. Yet you choose to ignore it, in the interest of...what exactly? It failed 4-1. Now, instead of Palm Desert being the "MAGA town that embraced hatred", we are merely the "MAGA-curious town that debated it". That is, to many, a distinction without a difference. It takes a long time to build a reputation, but an instant to lose one. One would have thought this would be known to CAREER POLITICIANS. One is forced to confront the reality that the City Council of Palm Desert either acted out of Evil, or Stupidity. Neither is of particular comfort. There will still be repercussions to the city's brand, to its businesses, and to its standing in the wider Coachella Valley. Was any of that taken into account before letting one of Nick Fuentes' devotees spew unmitigated bile from a public lectern? Doesn't seem so. Where is the City Council's fiduciary duty to the citizens of Palm Desert? Can we sue Pradetto for materially immiserating and impoverishing the very people he is sworn to represent? Of course not. But he can materially impoverish the businesses and individuals of Palm Desert by pushing his morally vacant MAGA bullshit. Joe Pradetto should be immediately stripped of his position, thrown out of office, and never allowed back into polite and civilized society. I know that won't happen, because a City Council capable of that would have the intenstinal fortitude to not have public debate on attacking LGBTQIA+ people in the first place! I understand that may sound harsh, but you need to understand that such harshness would not be required if you had saved Pradetto from himself and killed this in committee. You did not. Now we all must suffer. For your ignorance. For your naivete. For your hubris. For the same reason someone proposing the re-chatteling of Black people, the re-ghettoizing of Jews, or the banning of Catholics from public spaces would never reach public debate, this proposal never should have reached public debate. Because what he proposed is morally indistinguishable from any of those other proposals that the City Council would never, ever have public debate on. Next time the little MAGA sycophant tries to hijack our city government, in an attempt to create another MAGA backwater, where hate and division can run rampant under the banners of "Unity" and "Fairness" - maybe think about what public debate on that will cost. Maybe think about what not letting that out into the public square preserves. We create community not only by those things that we accept within our spaces, but also those things that we reject. Do your jobs and duty, and represent the people of Palm Desert. Not a few MAGA folks who pretend to be businesspeople, while running a self-aggrandizing MAGA merch store in El Paseo. Do we need to dredge up the books on which El Paseo businesses contribute the most in terms of payroll, taxes, and sales in El Paseo? Because I can see from my front porch it's not that ugly stain on our otherwise picturesque shopping district. I will put up gay dollars next to MAGA dollars in El Paseo and anywhere/everywhere else in Palm Desert. We all know which number would be larger - why are we pretending otherwise? I would imagine gay men at brunch on El Paseo alone out-spend that terrible little MAGA 319 merch store. You do realize that history is going to look back on that store with the same revulsion as a Hitler store? Because that is the case. Palm Desert is currently home to a business that will be looked at as morally indistinguishable from a store promoting the works and aesthetics of Adolf Hitler. That's what we should be proposing to remove, not a Pride banner. To allow someone to say that we are past bigotry when hate crimes against LGBTQIA+ people is on a double-digit percentage, year-over-year increase in California alone, is to allow them to use a public podium to spew hateful lies. Your actions seem to exist in a world ignorant of the Tolerance Paradox. If we tolerate intolerance, it will erode our ability to tolerate things that are actually worthwhile. You do not let Nazis into your Democracy, or you won't have a Democracy for much longer. You do not let MAGA bullshit ride in and attempt to hijack our symbols, our spaces, and our very language. Feel free to Google the Nazi Bar Analogy, if you are somehow unfamiliar with the concept. I am just one individual. But I am not alone in saying that, in addition to pledging my time, money, energy, and vote to almost anyone who runs to unseat Joe Pradetto, I am deeply dissapointed in both the Mayor and Councilwoman Nestande, for expressing interest and even support for "parts" of the most obvious attempt to manifest Mein Kampf in this desert in recent memory. Pradetto could not even be consistent in his lies. City Hall is not going to remove any accomodations for disabled people because they "highlight our differences". City Hall is not going to remove left-handed scissors because they "highlight our differences". City Hall is not going to stop giving employees automatic time off for an explicitly and only Christian Holiday in Christmas because it "highlights our differences". Is City Hall going to stop putting things on low shelves because it highlights our differences in height? It sure would be "fair" to put everything only on the top shelf always. To do anything else "divides us" - do you see how imbecilic, child-like, and nakedly bad-faith this reasoning is?? Do you know how incredibly naive and stupid it makes you look to engage with it? The person who is arguing with a man covered in shit does not make himself shine! City Hall is, and continues to, highlight people's differences all the time. Because that is reality. People are different. Those differences were largely used to justify hierarchies in our society for over two centuries, during which, the government was one of the preeminent dividers of Americans. Literally patrolling the boundaries between classes. And now the government is supposed to treat everyone equally, when we all start from such unequal starting points. Would a race be fair if one runner started 100 yards ahead of the other, but they both were going for the same finish line? According to Joe Pradetto, yes it would be. Because he knows that in 2025, he and his are the runner starting 100 yards ahead. We do not need to pretend that viewpoint has merit. Because it doesn't. Nobody even challenged Pradetto's basic assertion - that he was against highlighting personal differences. He isn't. If he was, he'd change his last name so he is flaunting his personal identity of Italian in everyone's faces. Do you see how stupid that sounds? It is simply applying his stated logic to his own life and experiences, and it doesn't even hold water there. He is just against highlighting the personal identities of anyone other than the White, Christian, Heterosexual, and Fascist people whose interests Pradetto seems single-mindedly 320 focused on advancing. I did not move to Palm Desert to be political. Naively, I thought that it would just be a quiet Liberal town in SoCal. Boy was I wrong. There is clearly an anti-Democratic, anti-human rights, pro-fascist, hateful population in Palm Desert. And small though it may be, it has captured at least 1 City Council seat, and the attention of the media. Congratulations! You have helped an angry inch define the entirety of Palm Desert in the eyes of the country. That is...an achievement, though probably not the one that 4 of the 5 City Councilmembers were aiming for. Perhaps do not allow someone to launder clearly fascist talking points through public debate! I hear it does wonders for a city's reputation. Palm Desert looks worse, not better, than it did before this incident. And Joe Pradetto, once he loses re-election, will find a home on some right-wing rag or radio station or tv station, spewing about how he "tried to bring fairness, but was shot down by the Woke Illiberal Mob" - he will only be able to do this because you let his absurd, obscene stunt reach the public. Shame on Joe Pradetto, and a less but still substantial amount of shame on the rest of the city council, and Mayor, for neglecting their duty as gatekeepers, and letting this obscene bigotry see the light of day. Respectfully, Adam Koltun 321 From:Rob Carian To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Comments Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 2:46:12 PM ‌ Unfortunately, with such short notice, the average working citizen in Palm Desert could not attend. But the room was absolutely flooded with people from other cities, as well as those that do not comprise the vast majority of citizens in Palm Desert we see every day. The people working, picking their kids up at school. I was able to attend, but there was nowhere to sit in the number of people wearing masks made me uncomfortable. So I left. One gentleman made the comment that he was raised by straight parents. Surprisingly most gay people are raised by straight parents because gay people can’t have kids together. And if you’d like to have a future tax base, I suggest you work on parks and family friendly things instead of catering to a vocal minority, whose population will fade. Palm Springs tourism is down despite having the regional airport while in every other Valley city tourism is up. Homelessness and drug use are off the charts in Palm Springs. Directly tied to homosexuality according to those I know in the Palm Springs city Police Department. We already have a flag that represents every single person in the city state and country. The United States flag. I do not identify with a rainbow flag. My four children do not identify with a rainbow flag. In fact, percentage of young people identifying with the LGBTQ movement is immensely down if you do the research. The fad is dying. Any additional flags to the flag of our country is simply a means of division. This is the most beautiful town in our valley. A huge reason why is that we haven’t allowed it to become like Palm Springs or areas of Cathedral city. The gay lifestyle is a lifestyle. It’s not just a group you affiliate with. It is not family friendly. It is not inclusive to those not in the lifestyle. And it is a small minority of people making a lot of noise to try to capture the city as yet another gay oasis. It’s heartbreaking to watch. I’ve honestly never seen such a sickly and feeble looking group of people in Palm Desert then I have today. You have to go to Cathedral city or Palm Springs in order to get that level of discomfort. Some might be offended, but you cannot argue with the obvious truth you can see with your eyes. These people are not trying to better the town for a future generation. They’re trying to turn it in to something for themselves, in the moment, without thought to our children or their future. Rob Carian Carian Management Services • Desert Mac Specialists 322 From:Bre K To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:nay to Pradetto"s requests Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 2:13:55 PM ‌ I have been a resident and property owner in Palm Desert since 2023. I am a Bisexual, Biracial, Jewish Woman. I am a Holocaust and Genocide Studies Historian and Educator and specialize in museum exhibit design and programming. I want to be crystal clear that Joe Pradetto’s request and reasoning to “discontinue” the PRIDE banner at Palm Desert City Hall AND “update” portions of the city’s inclusiveness resolution to focus less on “distinctions of our demographics…and celebrate values that unite us” are, in simple terms, ignorant and bigoted. Firstly, no one cares how many “LGBT” friends one has, or how many “Gay and Lesbian weddings” one officiates. Personal allyship and advocacy aren’t a surrogate for the benchmark success of inclusion in the wider community of Palm Desert. Nor do personal actions make one a surrogate voice FOR the LGBTQIA community as to whether Palm Desert is, in fact, “welcoming and integrated” per the actual experience of its LGBTQIA members. Pradetto’s rhetoric is merely a clumsy tokenization of the LGBTQI community that neither seeks to recognize or change systemic inequalities, or even asks about them. His words use the LGBTQI community as a prop, or a “box to be checked” to appear diverse and avoid criticism for utilizing MAGA talking points at a City Council meeting in Palm Desert where the constituency consistently votes Democrat: #small- town-politican-calls-emergency-meeting-at-1:30pm-on-a-Tuesday-to-push-ignorant- bigot-idea-through-while-most-people-can’t-attend-because-people-big-mad-about- his-bad-bigot-idea! The placement of a PRIDE flag within City Hall is a visual symbol that the community of Palm Desert recognizes LGBTQIA people as historically marginalized and oppressed, and therefore, commits, with good faith intent to recognize and validate LGBTQIA rights, safety, and voices as a valuable part of the Palm Desert community now and in the future. The written resolution furthers this principle by making an official and transparent written record of the community’s intent to not overlook these past inequities and indeed attempts to begin a constructive dialogue even before two actual humans start speaking. This is the power of symbols. Used wisely, they create an environment that encourages understanding, even when actual chat, say, to tell them about ALL the “Gay and Lesbian weddings” you’ve officiated, may not be possible...or even RELEVANT. A PRIDE flag is NOT a “celebration of private identities” or “picking favs” or a “prioritization” of a single expressed lifestyle identity, like Pradetto’s insecure ideas theorize. It is, rather, acknowledgement and allyship. Not because the LGBTQIA community is distinct in its makeup of human beings, BUT because the LGBTQIA community has lived in fear, institutionally and socially, for being WHO THEY ARE IN THEIR EVERYDAY LIVES. Pradetto’s interpretations and implicit “privatized” connotations towards the PRIDE flag say more about his own bias and insecurity than anything else, and it would be an embarrassment to let his prejudiced and ignorant emotional projection inform the future goals of the entire City of Palm Desert. Moreover, it is truly ignorant for Pradetto to insinuate the presence of an LGBTQIA PRIDE flag, or a written city resolution, or his personal participation in officiating “Gay and 323 Lesbian” weddings makes the City of Palm Desert a fully realized “welcoming and integrated” city in which “social harmony already exists.” While Palm Desert may be some of these things sometimes, and maybe we want to work or are working towards these things all the time, the idea that equity and inclusiveness have been achieved and can be moved past, is net dumb-dumb speak. In a world where the LGBTQIA community is STILL fighting for recognition, rights, and safety, the idea that Palm Desert, of all the places in ALL the world, has achieved some sort of guru-status “social harmony” and is “truly integrated” is deeply privileged, unserious and unhinged. Pradetto’s requests are a waste of time and energy and are now, at THIS moment, sowing the seeds of distrust and prejudice which makes members of this community feel unsafe and unseen. Finally, the Palm Desert City Council should NOT alter the wording of the resolution as requested by Pradetto. This weird obsession with altering the language of diversity in favor of “values that unite us” is exactly as close-minded as it sounds. It elevates a homogenous sameness and status quo and seeks to whitewash distinctions which this community has formerly and still values based on the people I have spoken with in Palm Desert recently. This agenda makes no consideration for the experiences of the individuals of communities that have faced and still face inequities and discrimination. The City Council of Palm Desert City KNOWS this. It is no mystery to any of them that the LGBTQIA community faces incredible prejudice, discrimination, and violence in 2025. Why then, would three Council members seek to turn the spotlight off the LGBTQIA community when they KNOW it needs allyship? Bigotry is at the top of my list. Or, and perhaps this is worse, business and profit over standing up to bigotry. Whatever the reason, Palm Desert needs to firmly nay this request and Democrats in Palm Desert need to actively challenge incumbents that support irrational and prejudiced civic actions such as expressed in Pradetto’s requests. Sincerely, Bricelyn Koltun Palm Desert, CA. 92211 324 From:Rick Sherman To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Rescinding the Resolution for Pride month Commemorations Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 1:29:47 PM ‌ Dear Palm Desert City Council, I hope you reconsider rescinding the resolution for Pride Month that was put forward. If you proceed forward, I will be boycotting any business in the city of Palm Desert in protest of such a divisive and hateful move by the city council. I do like to shop and eat in Palm Desert and there are many great places there, but it is not worth supporting a city with my money if they decide to adopt a policy that is harmful to LGBTQ people. Thank you, Rick Sherman Cathedral City, CA. 325 From:Seth Howell To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Subject: Support for Continued Recognition of Pride Month Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 1:25:07 PM ‌ Subject: Support for Continued Recognition of Pride Month Dear Members of the City Council, I am writing to express my strong concurrence with Assemblyman Greg Wallis’s public statement and with Palm Springs City Councilmember Jeffrey Bernstein’s denunciation of Mayor Pro Tem Joe Pradetto’s proposal to discontinue recognition of Pride Month and remove the Pride banner. This proposal is a clear reminder that the fight for LGBTQ+ equality is not yet over. Framed as an effort to promote unity, it instead sends a harmful message of exclusion. Ending recognition of Pride Month does not unite a community—it marginalizes one that has long faced discrimination and continues to do so today. Pride Month exists because LGBTQ+ people were historically denied visibility, safety, and equal treatment. Public recognition is not about separating one group from another; it is about affirming that LGBTQ+ residents and visitors are seen, valued, and welcome. Removing that recognition signals the opposite. At a time when anti-LGBTQ+ rhetoric and actions are increasing nationwide, this proposal is particularly troubling. It undermines the inclusive values that have helped define this region and that have made Palm Springs, and Greater Palm Springs, a destination known for acceptance and equality. Beyond its moral implications, this proposal also risks real economic harm. The LGBTQ+ community plays a vital role in the region’s tourism-based economy. Policies that suggest exclusion threaten not only people, but also the reputation and prosperity of the city. I urge the Palm Desert City Council to reject this proposal and to continue affirming its commitment to LGBTQ+ inclusion by upholding recognition of Pride Month. Sincerely, Seth M. Howell 326 From:Rich Barnes To:CouncilMeeting Comments Subject:Opposition to Rescinding Pride Month Recognition and Inclusion Commitments Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 1:11:13 PM Dear Mayor Pro Tem and Members of the Palm Desert City Council, I am a Palm Desert resident, married, and raising an infant daughter here. I am writing to express my deep disappointment that, in 2025, the City Council is considering rescinding its recognition of LGBTQ Pride Month and rolling back long-standing commitments to diversity and inclusion. The proposal put forward by Mayor Pro Tem Joe Pradetto suggests that recognizing Pride Month and similar acknowledgments is divisive, and that the City should instead focus on “values that unite us” by remaining neutral. I strongly disagree with that framing. Recognition and visibility of minority communities are not divisive. They are necessary. They send a clear message that people of all backgrounds are seen, respected, and safe in our city. This is true for women, African American, Pacific Islander, Hispanic, immigrant, and LGBTQ residents alike. These recognitions do not take anything away from others. They help ensure that everyone has a place. Palm Desert’s existing resolutions affirm that the City welcomes people regardless of who they love, how they worship, or how they identify. The Pride Month resolution builds on those values by offering a small but meaningful sign of support to a community that continues to face discrimination and hostility, particularly in today’s political climate. Visibility matters more now, not less. Removing Pride recognition does not create neutrality. It sends a message. It tells LGBTQ residents and families that their identities are something the City would rather not acknowledge. It asks them to be quieter, less visible, and less themselves. We should be honest about who that actually serves. As a parent, I want my daughter to grow up in a city that models empathy, courage, and inclusion. I want her to learn that when people are marginalized, we do not retreat from them. We stand with them. The direction this proposal points toward makes families like mine feel less welcome, and that is deeply troubling. I urge the City Council to reject this proposal and to reaffirm Palm Desert’s commitment to being a community that truly welcomes everyone. Our values should be demonstrated through action, not erased when they become politically uncomfortable for some. Thank you for your time and consideration. Sincerely, Richard Barnes 327 Palm Desert, CA 92260 328 From:Hugo Loyola To:CouncilMeeting Comments Cc:Hugo Loyola-ABM Subject:A letter urging you to NOT adopt the resolution to rescind city council resolution 2024-38 Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 12:52:19 PM ‌ December 16, 2025 Palm Desert City Council Palm Desert City Hall Dear Mayor, Mayor Pro Tem, and Council Members: I write on behalf of the City of Palm Springs Human Rights Commission to express deep concern regarding the item before the Palm Desert City Council concerning the potential rescission of City Council Resolution No. 2024-038, which establishes commemorations for LGBTQ Pride Month, and the proposed amendment to City Council Resolution No. 2018-09, affirming the City’s commitment to diversity and inclusion. For the greater Coachella Valley region, our communities’ strength lies in how we uphold values of equity, respect, and dignity for all residents. Pride Month recognition is not a symbolic gesture devoid of meaning; it is a civic affirmation that LGBTQ residents and families are valued members of the community. Visible recognition—such as official proclamations and inclusive observances—reinforces that municipal government stands with all its residents, particularly those who historically have endured discrimination and exclusion. Likewise, longstanding resolutions affirming diversity and inclusion—such as Palm Desert’s 2018-09—are foundational statements of community values and should not be weakened or amended in ways that could undermine their intent. These kinds of resolutions matter because they articulate public commitments to reject prejudice and protect the rights and well-being of all people, regardless of sexual orientation, gender identity, race, religion, ability, or other protected characteristics. We understand that public policy decisions are complex and that Councilmembers may wish to balance a range of perspectives. However, rescinding the Pride Month resolution and weakening a core diversity commitment risks signaling to LGBTQ individuals and other marginalized groups that their place in the city is conditional rather than embraced. Cities that champion inclusion not only protect the rights of all citizens—they also foster social cohesion, economic vitality, and civic pride. Recognition and celebration of diversity do not divide communities; they reinforce shared humanity and mutual respect. As leaders representing neighboring jurisdictions committed to human rights, we encourage the Palm Desert City Council to uphold these resolutions in their current form and to affirm, through continued support of inclusive commemorations, that Palm Desert stands with all its residents. Doing so will send a positive message about your City’s values and contribute to the Coachella Valley’s broader reputation as a welcoming and equitable region. Thank you for your thoughtful consideration on this important matter. 329 Respectfully, Hugo Loyola Chair, Human Rights Commission City of Palm Springs 330 From:Heidi Tragesser To:City Hall Mail Subject:Strong opposition to Pradetto’s proposal Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 12:47:47 PM ‌ I am writing to express strong opposition to the proposal to ban the PRIDE flag from City Hall and to prevent the City of Palm Desert from participating in PRIDE events. This action would send a clear and troubling message that our city is retreating from its long-standing commitment to inclusivity, respect, and equal representation for all residents. The PRIDE flag is not a political symbol; it is a widely recognized expression of dignity, belonging, and support for members of our community who have historically faced discrimination. Removing it would marginalize those residents and undermine the values Palm Desert claims to uphold. Palm Desert is a diverse, welcoming city, and many of us expect our local government to reflect and reinforce that reality—not to exclude or silence portions of the community. I urge you to reject this proposal and instead reaffirm Palm Desert’s commitment to inclusion by allowing the PRIDE flag to remain visible and by continuing the city’s participation in PRIDE events. This decision matters, and it will be remembered as a measure of whether our city leads with fairness and unity or turns away from them. We will not back down from this fight, and are already organizing to remove any council member who supports this measure. 331 From:City of Palm Desert To:City Hall Mail Subject:Flags Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 12:53:43 PM ‌ Message submitted from the <City of Palm Desert> website. Site Visitor Name: Karen Boyles Site Visitor Email: boylesck Please know that we support you regarding the flying of flags at City Hall and all city public areas. The only flags that should fly the the USA, California and Palm Desert. You are absolutely correct that dividing people or groups does not bring us together or make people accept these entities. Not flying a certain groups flag does not mean that we don't support them. When you do fly their flag that singles them out and give the impression that they are favored. One flag, USA, unites us and always will. Thank you. 332 From:Harriet Ortiz To:City Hall Mail Subject:Note to Pro-Tem Mayor Joe Pradetto Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 1:03:16 PM ‌ I am a resident of Palm Desert and have friends and family who identify with the LGBTQ community. This is so disheartening to hear of another voice speaking out with anti- diversity rhetoric. The Coachella Valley has long been a global destination for the LGBTQ community. They are the engine of our local economies. Many who identity as LGBTQ also live in Palm Desert. Generations of queer people from all over the world call the Coachella Valley home. Joe Pradetto‘s anti-diversity views are outdated, short sighted, incredibly disrespectful, and bad for the Coachella Valley culture and economy. Don't alienate yet another major demographic of people who make our communities the special places they are and our local businesses thrive. Thank you! 333 From:Bibi Marcotte To:CityClerk Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 1:10:23 PM ‌ I'm a resident of Palm Desert. I'm a voter. I'm very disappointed to hear that our diversity is on the table at this time in our city. I don't understand why you would want to take us backwards. It is our uniqueness that makes our city and state and country a wonderful place to live. Sadly in the direction that our city and current President want to take this country is seriously concerning. Please rethink your policies towards not having Pride and other celebrations of diversity . We are a country of immigrants and unique cultures and people that is a good thing not a bad thing. Resident of Palm Desert, Beata Marcotte 334 From:Joshua Friedes To:CityClerk Subject:The boycott of Palm Desert starts now! Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 1:16:24 PM I figure I spend over $3,000 a year in Palm Desert. I live in Palm Springs. No more. I’m a Jew and I know a thing or two about hate and being the target of hate. The voters of Palm Desert elected bigots. Don’t try to tell us this is about unity. This is about prejudice. The damage is done. Just like the shooters in Bondi beach made Jews all over the world feel insecure. The city council of Palm Desert have already made minorities, particularly the gay community feel unwelcome, attacked and vulnerable. Who are you going to come after next? Jews, immigrants, Blacks, Asians, the disabled. Your hate agenda is not my agenda. It is not the agenda of my friends in Palm Desert. I’ll shop at stores that prominently display the Pride Flag in Palm Desert. Happy Hanukkah. We will shine light where there is darkness. Joshua Friedes Sent from my iPhone 335 From:reiki4cats To:CityClerk Subject:A resident of Indio Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 1:17:25 PM ‌ Please vote this ugly thought DOWN to cause a division in our community. Our valley is a resort location and you need to stand up and show our community and country That everyone matters. You do not have the choice to hand pick citizens or delete their lives. Your YES vote is so out of order! I have lived in Indio at Sun City Shadow Hills for 20 exact years. I can no longer look up to your city if you do not respect all residents. Respectfully, Carole Nelson Indio 92203 Sent from the all new AOL app for iOS 336 From:Gailya Brown To:CityClerk Subject:Pride Celebration Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 1:39:00 PM ‌ I am a proud resident of Palm Desert. It never occurred to me that the leaders of the city I love would consider eliminating a Pride banner that recognizes the hard-won equality of th LGBT community. I don’t know the hearts of the council members proposing this change. I will take at face value their claim to celebrate what we have in common. I agree. We all have more in common than differences. But it is the differences the give texture to our culture. It’s the differences that help us truly understand one another. And when those differences have been used against people to repress them and deny them basic human rights, only by celebrating what they have overcome can we, perhaps, hold on to the progress and never, ever go back. The LGBT community contributes so much to Palm Desert — culturally, economically,intellectually, socially. Please! Let’s continue to celebrate Pride! Gailya Brown Gailya Brown 337 From:Jeffery Aubel To:City Hall Mail Subject:Wow. Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 1:45:17 PM ‌ I guess you’ll see how many gays and lesbians live in Palm Desert when you’re voted out next election. Pathetic 338 From:City of Palm Desert To:City Hall Mail Subject:Unity of our Community Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 2:17:56 PM ‌ Message submitted from the <City of Palm Desert> website. Site Visitor Name: Martha Osborne Site Visitor Email: qualitymgmt2003 Dear Joe, I read about your proposal to stop hanging banners during Pride week. I want you to know that I support your proposal 100%. I've never understood celebrating one group over another when we should be working towards unity of all. It seems rather immature and egotistical. I often wonder what Martin Luther King Jr. would think if he were around to see how society has shifted in the past 60 years. You have my support and permission to share this with your fellow Council members. Best Regards, Martha Osborne 339 From:Stephen Grande To:City Hall Mail Subject:Flags Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 2:33:41 PM ‌ Joe, I agree with you the only flags that should be flown from City Hall the national flag, the state flag and the city flag those fly without preference for race creed or color wishing you good luck and I’m sorry the Rogan report was kind of rough. Paragraph Steve. 340 From:KDG To:City Hall Mail; Information Mail Subject:Joe Pradetto Bigotry Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 2:43:19 PM ‌ This is the first time in eleven years I'm embarrassed to live in Palm Desert. Don't let Joe Pradetto's bigotry ruin our welcoming and beautiful city. Kerri Giard kdpalmdesert 341 From:Jane To:City Hall Mail Subject:Pride Month Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 3:16:01 PM ‌ I was unable to attend today's special council meeting. I would like to ask why you would want to step backwards in the stance of inclusion. I find it sad that separate flags are needed for different groups, but I do understand the meaning behind each one.After all, we are of one race: human beings. Would it be different if a heterosexual flag was questioned? Something to ponder. Jane Peterson Portola Country Club Palm Desert Yahoo Mail: Search, Organize, Conquer 342 From:Pastor Paul Chappell To:City Hall Mail Subject:ATTN: Mayor Evan Trubee and Mayor Pro Tem Joe Pradetto Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 3:35:05 PM Attachments:image001.png image002.png image003.png image004.png We sent you safe versions of your files.msg Lancaster Flag Ordinance.pdf Mimecast Attachment Protection has deemed this file to be safe, but always exercise caution when opening files. ‌ Dear Mayor Evan Trubee and Mayor Pro Tem Joe Pradetto, I understand that the issue of raising various flags has come to Palm Desert. The attached ordinance has been very helpful in our city to avoid promoting one group over another. This ordinance was cleared through our city’s legal council in June of 2024. Feel free to call me if you’d like. My cell number is: Sincerely, Dr. Paul Chappell Paul Chappell Senior Pastor | Lancaster Baptist Church President | West Coast Baptist College paulchappell.com 4020 E. Lancaster Blvd, Lancaster, CA 93535 343 344 345 From:Steve/Bob King/McClean To:City Hall Mail Subject:Equality Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 4:26:42 PM > > We write as new citizens of Palm Desert who were welcomed by our neighbors, merchants and city leaders. Unfortunately, we now are being asked to defend our presence in this city by a Mayor Pro Tem who questions the need to acknowledge our November celebration of Pride. > It is our hope that the city council will stand up to the bigotry and ignorance, and take “a walk in our shoes.” It doesn’t have to be a mile. > And to the people who are offended by a Pride Banner, the rainbow includes you when it offers a welcoming for people who have felt marginalized and hated in the past. And with this new proposal by the Mayor Pro Tem, we feel marginalized and hated once again. > Love is love, > Steve King and Bob McClean > Sent from my iPhone 346 From:Joni Moorhouse To:City Hall Mail Subject:PRIDE Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 4:27:12 PM ‌ I am ashamed of my city for even considering removing any rainbows or anything LGBQT from Palm Desert! Your rationale is flawed. I think you are as bad as Trump’s comments on the Boston shooting and the killing of the Reiners. Please let us remove hate from our government. Remember you’re in your position because people voted and we will vote you out! Joni Moorhouse 347 From:Steve Hernandez To:City Hall Mail Subject:LGBTQ Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 4:41:05 PM ‌ Shame on you Joe. We have fought and continue to fight for gay rights, and still people like you are trying to erase our accomplishments. Are you getting rid of Christmas next? 348 From:Jeffery Aubel To:City Hall Mail Subject:I’ll spend my money elsewhere Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 4:48:35 PM ‌ You just did a disservice to all the good restaurants in Palm desert. I will keep my money in Cat city, Rancho mirage and Palm Springs. Not a dime goes to Palm desert. You will eat crow for you bullshit. Peace, Jeff 349 From:City of Palm Desert To:City Hall Mail Subject:EXCELLENT statement today Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 5:06:56 PM ‌ Message submitted from the <City of Palm Desert> website. Site Visitor Name: Eric Cunningham Site Visitor Email: cunningham.eric You probably dont''remember me, but we met at a Mini MBA graduation ceremony at the Palm Desert iHub last year and back then it meant a lot that you would show up to something so specific and off-the-beaten-path like that. Today I watched the PD City Council meeting and thought you had an excellent and reasonable statement to the controversy created. Keep going, you're an example of an elected official who truly listens to their constituents. And that's rare. Thank you. -Eric Cunningham 350 From:Paul Bruner To:City Hall Mail Subject:Pride Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 5:14:07 PM ‌ Really Everyone should be inclusive PERIOD. You are creating a divide amongst people. WHY ??? Palm Desert will also lose a great deal of income for your businesses. Which means loss of taxes income for city. I am so glad I live in Rancho Mirage. You and your TYPE totally disgust me. 351 From:Penny Swartz To:City Hall Mail Subject:Gay Pride Month Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 5:25:08 PM ‌ Dear Mayor Trubee and the City of Palm Desert, I heard that you are considering rescinding the celebration of Gay Pride Month. Although my husband and I are straight...always have been...I was very disappointed to hear this. One of the reasons we fell in love with Palm Desert was its acceptance of a variety of life styles. Canceling it seems to have no purpose other than knuckling under to the Trump administrations to eviscerate DEI programs. I sincerely hope you will reconsider.’ Penny Swartz 38600 Nasturtium Way Palm Desert 352 From:slanschuetz@gmail.com To:City Hall Mail Subject:Pride Month Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 5:28:07 PM ‌ To Mayor Trubee, Mayor Pro Tem Pradetto, Councilmembers Quintanilla, Nestrande and Harnik, I just learned of the proposal to drop flying the Pride flag in Palm Desert during Pride month – something which was discussed today at an emergency meeting. I don’t know the results of said meeting, but I am contacting you to voice my strong support for including Palm Desert’s participation in Pride month – including flying the flag. I only recently became a property owner in Palm Desert. I was drawn to the area because of its diversity and inclusion. I consider flying the pride flag during pride month is a symbol of inclusion – not division as Mr. Pradetto seems to suggest. I strongly urge you not to change your current status of observing Pride Month. Sara Anschuetz Palm Desert 353 From:Kim Shepard To:CityClerk Subject:Proposed Pride Changes Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 5:48:24 PM ‌ I am writing as a resident of Palm Desert, and I am appalled that the city council is calling the special meeting to consider obliterating the support of a kind and loving tradition here in this valley. Palm Desert is not a standalone city. It is part of the Coachella Valley and being a part of and supporting the Palm Springs Pride celebration every year, as well as upholding diversity and inclusion is imperative for the good health and welfare of our whole community. Our community is diverse and the diversities need to be celebrated, not hidden behind a bigoted conservative agenda. As a resident and a constituent, I urge you to continue supporting Palm Springs‘s pride and diversity and inclusion. Do not fall for the false pretenses of unity, when voting to NOT support unity is exactly what you’re considering. It’s disappointing that this is even coming up for a discussion. I expect better from Palm Desert. Sent from Yahoo Mail for iPhone 354 From:RON NORIEGA To:Sarah Castro Subject:Re: Resolution 2018-09 / Resolution 24-038 Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 7:23:58 PM ‌ Thank you thank you. To the 4 council members who supported us 355 From:Steven Germann To:City Hall Mail Subject:ATTN: Mayor Pro Temp Joe Pradetto: 4 to 1 Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 8:40:57 PM ‌ As a former employee on El Paseo & frequent financial consumer of Palm Desert’s beauty, I am so happy to see your power grabbing hate fail, miserably. Your homophobia lost & probably stitched up your last time as an elected official. My husband & I couldn’t be more elated. Cheers! Steven Germann Palm Springs 356 From:John Lytle To:City Hall Mail Subject:What the hell Joe! Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 11:08:15 PM ‌ You don't get to dictate your prejudice on to others. Homosexuality is a blessing from God! Could you imagine a world in only black and white? I guess you can! Thank God your in the minority. 357 From:maxfield.barb To:City Hall Mail Subject:Today’s meeting/: proposed revisions Date:Wednesday, December 17, 2025 7:17:40 AM Dear City Council members, I am a resident of Palm Desert and feel strongly that removing the recognition of LGBTQ, Native American, black history, and Hispanic history is completely wrong. One of the best parts of living in Palm Desert is knowing that we respect our differences and the diversity of the people who live here or are originally from this region. Historically, these groups voices have not been at the table and they’ve been vastly underserved, so it is important to continue to highlight their presence and contributions. A provision to remove these recognitions signals disrespect, and an attempt to silence once again. Thank you for your consideration, Barbara Maxfield Palm Desert Sent from my iPhone 358 From:georgercovino To:Sarah Castro Subject:Re: City of Palm Desert- 12.16.25 Special Meeting Date:Wednesday, December 17, 2025 7:21:22 AM ‌ I am so glad that the city council did the right thing and will continue to recognize and celebrate Pride Month. Although I am not a resident, I will continue to support Palm Desert businesses and restaurants, and feel good about doing so. Since I wrote to express my concerns, I thought I should write to express my appreciation. Thank you and happy holidays! George Covino Palm Springs On Dec 15, 2025, at 1:59 PM, Sarah Castro <scastro@palmdesert.gov> wrote: Hello George, We would like to inform you that a special meeting is scheduled for tomorrow, December 16, at 1:30 p.m. Agenda materials are available for review on the City’s website here. Please let me know if you have any questions. Thank you, <pdlogosmall_72e0e3f9- a775-4c5b-a732- 3c364ad37d3c.jpg> Sarah Castro Senior Administrative Assistant City of Palm Desert 73510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert, CA 92260 scastro@palmdesert.gov | 760.776.6349 | www.palmdesert.gov <brightsideemailsig2_d8fbac77-8002-44ab-b507-252e2ed882ff.jpg> 359 From:Michael Harrington To:City Hall Mail Cc:CityClerk Subject:Banner Request Date:Wednesday, December 17, 2025 8:23:06 AM ‌ Subject: Follow-Up to Public Comment – Cultural Banner Policy Date: December 16, 2025 Dear City Manager, City Clerk, and Honorable Council Members, I spoke during public comment at today’s City Council meeting regarding the City of Palm Desert’s practice of flying temporary cultural or heritage banners at City Hall. I am writing to respectfully follow up in writing, understanding that public comment is not a dialogue, to ask for clarification on the City’s policy or criteria for approving such displays and the appropriate process for submitting a formal request. Specifically, I inquired whether a temporary Irish heritage banner on March 17 could be considered, consistent with municipal practices in other California cities that recognize Irish immigration history and civic contributions through temporary ceremonial displays. My request is intended as a policy-based inquiry regarding inclusion, consistency, and historical recognition, and not as a request for immediate Council action. I would appreciate any guidance from staff regarding how such requests are evaluated and the next steps, if any. Thank you for your time and consideration. 360 Respectfully, Michael Harrington harringtonmike Mike Harrington 361 From:Carol Adney To:City Hall Mail Subject:Thank you Date:Wednesday, December 17, 2025 10:42:27 AM ‌ Thank you for the vote yesterday. Thank you for your time. I think we are all to be complimented on the civility which took place. Amazing concept to have people raise hands and wave, and even more amazing that people did so. Carol Adney Sent from the all new AOL app for iOS 362 From:Earthlink mail To:City Hall Mail Subject:For Councilmember Quintanilla Date:Wednesday, December 17, 2025 10:44:54 AM Karina, This morning as I drove along El Paseo I was so taken back by all the beautiful art work. We are so lucky to see art all over the city and especially on El Paseo. I just want you and the Council to know how much I appreciate the City's work in promoting public art. Also, I like to thank you and the other three Council members who voted to dismiss the Pradetto proposal. I don't care what others think but Diversity and Inclusion but they are essential to American culture. We humans are diverse... and that's our strength. Again, thanks. Michael Bimmer 363 From:Scott Krause To:City Hall Mail Subject:Pride Date:Wednesday, December 17, 2025 10:51:36 AM Shame on you to remove Pride representation from Palm Springs. Guessing your hypocritical Catholic faith makes you behave in this obscene manner? Scott Krause Palm Desert Sent from my iPhone 364 From:Ryland Penta To:City Hall Mail Subject:Fw: Pride Limit Recognition Vote Date:Wednesday, December 17, 2025 11:11:08 AM Ryland Penta, MSc Community Relations Supervisor City of Palm Desert 73510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert, CA 92260 rpenta@palmdesert.gov | 760.776.6318 | www.palmdesert.gov From: Patricia Bernard <luv4enb Sent: Wednesday, December 17, 2025 11:07 To: Community Relations <CommunityRelations@palmdesert.gov> Subject: Pride Limit Recognition Vote ‌ The results of the vote concern me. As Christians we have been denied being able to have nativity displayed at any government building, yet you approve flying banners for LGBTQ. It concerns me that your city does not treat their citizens equally. You support gay rights, and so do I. But equality is not what your city is promoting. This is wrong. Patricia Bernard 365 From:gem mimms To:City Hall Mail Subject:Joe Date:Wednesday, December 17, 2025 11:28:11 AM ‌ Well, you didn't read the room on that issue - now did you? © 2015 Email is a written work that once created is copyright protected by the author. Emails sent to you privately can not be posted publicly to web sites, to message boards or to social media without the author's consent. Just because an email was sent to you privately does not mean that you own it and can do what you like with it. Posting of this private email will result in a DCMA takedown notice for copyright violation being sent to the web site's hosting provider or social media provider and will result in a web site or social media page shutdown. 366 From:Emily Vogt To:City Hall Mail Subject:Thank You Date:Wednesday, December 17, 2025 12:35:54 PM Thank you for your vote yesterday. I look forward to working with you in the future. Emily Vogt Palm Desert, CA 92260 367 From:Gillian Van Guilder To:City Hall Mail Subject:Pride Flag Date:Wednesday, December 17, 2025 12:48:48 PM Dear City council members, I would just like to take the time to say thank you for voting the way that you did last evening. Obviously with the community turnout that we had at that meeting you realize how many people this was going to affect and decided not to hurt those people. So thank you so so much. You really should feel good about what you did last night. With gratitude, Gillian Van Guilder PALM DESERT 368 From:joycevirtu To:CityClerk Subject:Keeping all things neutral Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 7:45:28 PM ‌ To The Palm Desert City Council: Being a long time resident of the Coachella Valley I believe that Mr. Predetto is correct in keeping all things and entities neutral. Respectfully, Joyce Virtue joycevirtu 369 From:PAUL POPOWICH To:CityClerk Subject:Concern Regarding Proposal to End Palm Desert’s Official Recognition of Pride Month Date:Monday, December 15, 2025 10:38:44 AM ‌ Dear Mayor Trubee, Mayor Pro Tem Pradetto, and Members of the Palm Desert City Council, I am writing as a resident of Palm Springs and as someone who cares deeply about the well-being, inclusivity, and reputation of the entire Coachella Valley. While I do not live in Palm Desert, our cities are closely connected socially, culturally, and economically and actions taken in one community resonate throughout the region. I am concerned about the proposal to end Palm Desert’s official recognition of Pride Month and to discontinue displaying the Pride banner at City Hall. This is not only an issue for LGBTQ+ residents, but also for our allies the many families, friends, businesses, faith leaders, and community members who stand in solidarity with marginalized communities and believe in visible support for inclusion. This is not the time for actions that could be interpreted as pulling back from that support. Across the country, marginalized communities are increasingly being targeted through rhetoric, legislation, and policy. In this climate, public recognition and allyship from local governments matter more, not less. These gestures send a clear message about who is welcome, who is valued, and whose safety and dignity are taken seriously. Palm Desert benefits directly from its proximity to Palm Springs and the powerful, globally recognized identity it represents one rooted in diversity, openness, and inclusion. That reputation brings measurable economic value, from tourism and events to business investment and regional visibility. Pride recognition is part of that broader ecosystem; it reflects values that attract visitors, residents, and businesses to the entire valley, including Palm Desert. Ending this recognition risks sending an unintended message that 370 some members of the community and those who support them are less worthy of visibility or affirmation. That perception matters, both socially and economically. I respectfully urge the City Council to maintain Palm Desert’s official recognition of Pride Month and to continue demonstrating leadership that aligns with the inclusive values that strengthen our region as a whole. Thank you for your time and thoughtful consideration. Sincerely, Paul Popowich Palm Springs, CA Sent from my iPad 371 From:Monique Lomeli To:Michelle Nance Subject:Public Comment Received By Phone 12/16/2025 Date:Tuesday, December 16, 2025 10:29:19 AM Caller: Dean Genth Phone: Email: figfinesse A resident of Rancho Mirage who works and shops in Palm Desert and has always taken pride in the welcoming atmosphere the City provides. Caller disagrees with Mayor Pro Tem Pradetto's proposal; believes it is disappointing and dangerous territory as it does not convey a message of inclusivity. Monique Lomeli Senior Deputy Clerk City of Palm Desert 73510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert, CA 92260 mlomeli@palmdesert.gov | 760.776.6302 | www.palmdesert.gov 372 From:Richard Altman To:City Hall Mail Subject:Keep Pride in Coachella Valley Date:Wednesday, December 17, 2025 3:18:02 PM ‌ Do Not Stop "Pride" in Coachella Valley (especially Palm Desert). These are decent law abiding citizens and we will VOTE YOU OUT if you continue with taking Freedoms away from our law abiding citizens. Thank You Do the Morally Right Thing. 373 From:GREG TURNER To:City Hall Mail Subject:Thank you Date:Wednesday, December 17, 2025 2:55:41 PM Mayer Pro Tem, , thank you for your wisdom regarding celebrating gay pride. I believe whatever individuals choose to do is their business but a municipality or governmental body should not choose to celebrate sin. I have family and friends that no longer will go to Palm Springs. I’m sorry Palm Desert is acting so WOKE. 374