The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About1991-03-12 Y 4 � �. 1-L�..�w 1 r_� PALM DESERT ARC��IIT�CiUR}1L REVIEW �[M�IISSI(�T 7.[]FSDAY, NAR(I3 12, 1991 ��r**�r�rir�t�-x�ar�r*�r�rx*�**�t��r�r*�r�r�t�r�r�x**��t�t�r�r*�r**�-x�t�t�r*�t�t�t*�rc�r�r�r* I. CALL ZO ORDER The meeting was called to order at 12:15 p.m. Catmission Members Ctaxrent Meeting Year to Date Present Absent Present Absent Ron GY�egory, Chaixman X 4 1 Rick Holden X 5 0 F`rank Urrutia X 5 0 Russell N�C�rea X 5 0 Christopher VanVliet X 5 0 Wayne Conr�or, Alternate X 2 3 Staff Present: Phil Drell Steve Smith Jeff Winklepleck Pat Bedrosian Donna Bitter II. APPROVAL, OF MiN[TrES: It was moved by Cannissioner McCxea, seconded by Commissioner Urrutia, to apprave the minutes of the Februazy 26, 1991 rneeting as sul�mitted. Nbtion carried 5-1, Cc�rmissioner Connor abstaining. III. It was nr�v+ed by Cxc[tnissioner VanVliet, seoorr.3ed by �mni.ssior�er McC�ea, to ap�Ove the follaa�ing ca..�es by minute m�tion. Nbtiori carried 5-0. 1. C.�1SE NO.- 1922 SA APPLICANP (Ai�ID Ai�RESS): SUZANNE M, 73-655 El Paseo, Suite M, Palm Desert, CA 92260 NATURE OF PROJEGT/APPROVAL SOUGHT: Approval of business identification sign LCX'ATI�V: 73-655 El Paseo, Suite M Z0�- C-1 Signage approved, by minute motion, subject to the sign being reduced in size to allaa a 3" border on the top and bottan. 2. CASE N0.- 1926 SA A1'PLICANr (ADID ADDRFSS): IMPERIAL SIGN OOMI'ANY for STAPLES, 46-120 Calhoun Street, Indio, CA 92201 , � � N�A�ESS ARQ�IITF]CIURAL R�T2�J C�T�SSIC[�i Ng1RQ3 12, 1991 1�ZURE OF PI�OJF]C.T/APFRClVAL SOUC�iT: Appraval of revised business identification signage LOCATI0�1: 72-871 Highway 111 3. C�1SE laU.• CUP 90-22 APPLICANP (AND ADDRESS): Cx�AUDIA F�URGER, 10490 Wilshire Blvd., Suite 1502, Los Angeles, CA 90049 I�,7.[JRE OF PRU7F.7Cr/APPi�7VAL SO�: Approval of outdoor magazine and newsstand I�OCATIO[�T: Northwest corner of San Pablo and Highway 111 ZC�tE• C-1 S.P. Case continued, by minute motion, as applicant was not present with revised plans. 4. CASE ND.: 1928 SA APPLICANP (Al�ID ADDRFSS): IN�ERIAL SIC�V C�MPANY, INC.for RON'S AUTOMOTIVE & TOWING, 46-120 Calhoun Street, Indio, CA 92201 I�Z[JRE OF PfiC�7E7LT/APPRaVAL SO[JC�-�r- Approval of freestand�rig sign I,OQ�TI�i: 75-140 St. Charles Place 7.ONE: S.I. F`reestandirx� sign appraved, by minute motion, subject to the sign bei.ng moved northerly between the first and second palms. 5. C�SE NU.' PP 90-28 APPLICANP (ArID ADDRFSS): PEGGY AI�S, 82-500 Highway 111, Suite No. 3, Indio, CA 92201 1�12URE OF PROJ�CT/APPROVAL SOUC�iT: Final approval of landscape plans Lt)CATION: Southeast corner of Acacia and F`red Waring 2 �w � � ARQ�ITF7CAJRAL REUIEW OCNT�SSI�i N�,RCH 12, 1991 Z�: R-1 (Pr'oposed O.P. ) Final approval of landscape plans granted, by minute motion, subject to the changes discussed by camtission and Phil Drell. 6. CASE ND.: TT 24539 APPLIC�NP (At�ID A�S): WILLIAMS OCN�ANY for TRIAD PACIFIC DEVELOPNN�N'I' C70RP., 42-600 Cook Street, Suite 135, Palm Desert, CA 92260 I�,ZUEZE OF PRQ.7�CT/APPI�OVAL SOtJG�PP: Prel�m�naW approval of model units, landscaping and entzy design I�OCATIOI�i: Northeast corner of Cook Street and Havley Lane 7�' PR-9 Prel�minazy appraval granted, by minute motion, subject to the addition of more color variations on the buildings when the w�orkirig drawings are presented. 7. CASE 1�U.: PP 89-28 APPLICANP (A1� ADDRESS): ARC�iISTRUCI'URE, 42-280 Beacon Hill, Palm Desert, CA 92260 NATURE OF PROJECT/APPROVAL SOUGHT: Final approval of architectural and landscape plans for six (6) unit apartment ccxnplex LOCATIO�i: South side of Fred Waring Drive, east side of San Pablo 7.O1�• R-3 S.O. Architectural plans received final approval, by minute motion. Land.scaping plans approved subject to changes being made as outlined with applicant and Qzairman Gregory. 8. C�1SE ND: TT 24773 APPLICANT (AI�ID ADDRESS): ARTHOFER ENTERPRISES, INC., 73-700 Highway 111, Suite #8, Palm Desert, CA 92260 1�12URE OF PRO/Q�GT/APPRCNAL SOUC�iT: Prelimiriary approval of plans for a 38 lot single family subdivision 3 � � � ARQiITflCiURAL REVIEW �1M�SSION N�,RCH 12, 1991 IACATI�i: South side of Havley Lane between Nbnterey Avenue and Portola Avenue Z�: PR-5 Preliminary approval granted on architectural plans only, by minute motion, with the follawing conditions: 1) Take one of the three car garage models and change it to a side garage entry. 2) Vary roof tile colors. 3) More contrast needed in the color range on the exterior textures. 9. C�1.SE NO.: pppLlCAl�f� (ArD A�RESS): J.E. DUFLOTH, 1001 Shoreline Drive, #206, Alameda, CA 94501 I�Z[)RE OF PI2�JF]C,T/APPROVAL SOUC#�: 12 - 14 foot high protectiwe screen for hon� on Shadaw Nbuntain Golf Course I�OCI1TI�i: 73-358 Grapevine Protective screen approved, by minute motion, subject to the screen being rio higher than the top of the fascia of the Yxxrie. 1V. (�SES: A. p,�el;minaYv P1anS: 1. CASE ND.• TT 24287 p,ppL,IC�N� (p�ID ADDRF�S); TONY GONZALES for T.R.A. ARCHITECTS, 190Q E. Tahquitz Canyon, Palm Springs, CA 92263 NATURE OF PROJEGT/APPROVAL SOUGHT: Approval of preliminazy landscape plan LOCATI�T: Deep Canyon Road, north of F�ed Wari.ng Drive 4 . • ��" �.r� NILI�PES ARC�iITF]GZI7RAL REVIE�T C�M�SSI�i N�RCH 12, 1991 Z�IE• PR-5 Steve Smith n�oted the changes made in the per�meter wall, adding the pop-outs. Chairman Gregory expressed his reservations on the landscapi.ng plan noting that the pockets all have a different type of planting, showing nr� uniformity. He added that the pop-out projections on the wall will eventually end up with white circles froin watering the lawn. Chairman Gregory added that camLission had requested that the palms be changed to California Fan Palms, and this was not done. The applicant noted that the awner was asking to use date palms. Ccnmission informed h�m that a plan w�uld have to be pravided shawing the use of the date palms. Chairman Gregory nr�ted that if the tall date paLns were planted, all that would be seen at eye level va�uld be a forest of telephone poles. If these date palm trees were planted, c�nission caould require life size filler planting with these trees. Chairnlan Gregory noted that a lot of the plant material listed was frost prone, adding that the carissa green carpet will freeze and would be e,xtrexnely expensive. Action• It was moved by Comnissioner Urrutia, seconded by Camtissioner McC;rea, to continue the landscaping plans to restudy as discussed with camiission. Nbtion carried 5-0. 2. CASE ND.: PP 90-13 APPLICAI�fP (Al� AIIDRF�S): DSL SERVIC� 00., 3501 Jamboree Road, Suite 5000, North Tawer, Newport Beach, CA 92658-6030 NATURE OF PROJEG�/APPROVAL SQ��: Preliminary approval of revised Mezvyn's building only LCX'ATI�T: East side Highway 111 between FYed Waring and Parkvi�ca 7,�: P.C. (3) regional cannercial Steve Smith presented the revised elevations for the Mervyn's buildi.ng. Catmissioner Holden noted that the signage was not being approved at this time. 5 � � 1KIIV[tI'F� ARC�IIT�CIURAL REUIEW �NMISSIC�i NP�RQ3 12, 1991 Action: It was moved by Camtissioner VanVliet, seconded by CarmLissioner McG`rea, to grant preliminary appraval of the revised Mervyn's building with the follawing conditions: 1) Wood trellis area to be extended length wise to fill entire area. 2) GYeate a pitch (slope) on this same element. Nbtion carried 4-0-1, Chairman Gregory abstaining. V. ADDID ('ASFS: 1. ('ASE I�U.' APPLICANP (ArID A1�RFS.S): A.R. WOODARD, 73-280 Ca.talina Way, Palm Desert, CA 92260 1�ZURE OF PRUJF7C,T/APPRWAL SOUC�iT: Approval of height limit in excess of 15 feet LCX'ATIO�t: 72-849 Sierra Vista Z0�' R-1 Steve Smith presented the plarLs on the 17-1/2' height on the single family hane rioti.rig that the applicant would be acIlzering to the 20' set back. The applicant, Mr. Woodard, presented photos of other Y�mes in the neighbort�ood exceed�ng the 15' height limit. Action• It was maved by Coimtissioner McCYea, seconded by Caimissioner Van Vliet, to approve the 17-1/2' height for the single family hoine. Nbtion carried 5-0. VI. The meeting adjourned at 1:45 p.m. .� 1 w _ ' `� � � � { �J . �t� S Jl'J1 1 LI ASSOCIATE PLANNSR SS/db 6