The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About0530 MI�UTES PALM DESERT PLANNING C�MMISSION MEETING TUESDAY - MAY 30, � 978 7 : 00 PNT - CITY HALL COJr1CIL CHAMBERS I . CALL TO ORDER The regula_r meeting of the Palm Dese.rt Planning Commission . was called to c�rder by Secretary Paul A. Will.iams due to the absence of Chairman Berkey. On a motion by Commissioner Kryder , seconded by ` Commissioner Kelly, the Commission nominated Commissioner Snyder to � be the Temporary Presiding Officer; motion carried. (AYES : Kelly, Kryder; ABSTAIN: Snyder) . II . PLEDGE - Commissioner Kelly III . ROLL CALL Present : Commissioner KELLY Commissioner KRYDER Commissioner SNYDER Excused Absence : Chairman BEi3,KEY Others Present : Paul A. Williams - Director of Environmental Services Ralph Cipriani - Associate Planner Clyde Beebe - Director of Public Works Kathy Shorey - Planning Secretary � ;' IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES � A. MINUTES of the regular meeting of r�Iay 17, 1978 of the Planning Commission . Tdr. Williams noted the following corrections to the minutes : Page Two, 3rd paragraph , after Public Hearing add the word "open" . Page Two , 4th paragraph, lst sentence, delete seCond "southwest" . Page Four, 6th paragraph, after Commissioner Kelly add: "stated she had received calls asking about, " etc . Page Four, next to last p�ragraph "speak in behalf" should read "speak on behalf . " Page Four, last paragraph , "Paul Dowd" should be "Paula Dowd. " Page Five , next to last paragraph, "Commissioner Driskel" should be "Commissioner Kelly. " ;�, On a motion by Commissioner Kelly, seconded by Commissioner Kryder , the minutes were approved as corrected; carried unanimously (3-0) . V. WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS - None 114inutes Palm Desert Planning Commission 114ay 30, 1978 Page Two VI . PUBLIC HEARINGS Temporary Presiding Officer Snyder announced that prior to this meeting, the Commission had met in a Study Session for the purpose of clarifying the staff recommendations . No decisions were reached. He then explained the Public Hearing procedures to those present . A. Case Nos. C/Z 02-78 and Related Draft EIR, CHACAHUALA �ir LTD. , Applicant Reqest for approval of a Change of Zone from R-1 20, 000 to PR-4 on a 37. 8 acre parcel located south of Little Bend and north of Mesa View extended be- tween Alamo and Arrow Trail and related Draft EIR. Mr. Williams reviewed the case and noted the related develop- ment plan. He also reviewed the correspondence received from Mr . Fred W. Griggs, Jr . , President of Silver Spur Ranchers Association and h4r . Leland Scheu. Regarding the EIR, Mr . Williams noted a late response received from the South Coast Air Quality Control District . Staff recommends approval of the Change of Zone to PR-4 and certifi- cation of the final. EIR. Temporary Presiding Officer Snyder declared the Public Hearing open and asked the applicant to speak at this time . I . HAROLD HOUSLEY, 73-700 Highway 111 , Engineer on project , and representative of Chacahuala, addressed the Commission and noted that a planned unit develop- ment is the best project for the area involved and he would answer any questions. ::� � Temporary Presiding Officer Snyder asked if there was anyone wishing to speak in FAVOR of the project . WILLIAM ALEXANDER, 48-698 Desert Flower, representing the California Teachers Association which owns 11 acres adjacent to the property, noted their approval of the pro j ect . EUGENE KAY, owner of property north of development , gave his approval of the project . KAY CRAIG, Belair and Alamo , spoke in favor. TOM 0` SULLIVAN, 72-990 Homestead, spoke �.o the Commission & asked to have a few things clarified regarding the traf- fic on Homestead and Alamo and the density. 1�4ARGARET KAY, lives across from Mr . O' Sullivan , spoke in favor of the project as the developers have met all the conditions. DICK ARNOLD, 73-722 Santa Rosa, stated it is an excel- lent proposal in the way it deals with the drainage control problem. �rrrt� Temporary Presiding Officer Snyder asked if there was anyone wishing to speak in OPPOSITION of the project . ROBERT HAVER, 73-360 Broken Arrow, noted his concern for traffic, lighting, and flood control . Minutes Palm Desert Planning Commission May 30, 1978 Page Three VI . PUBLIC HEARINGS (Cont . ) A. Case Nos. C/Z 02-78 and Related Draft EIR (Cont . ) FRED GRIGGS, 73-549 Feather Trail , representing Board of Directors of Silver Spur Ranchers Asso- ciation , spoke noting his objections to the Change of Zone of PR-4 from R-1-20, 000 and to the addi- �,,,,, tional traffic that will be created. He stated two problems that should be solved or completed before any development should be considered and that is the flood and drainage control issue and the completion of the proposed �ire station . MRS . HARRY NUDD, 73-409 Little Bend Trail, opposed due to flood control problem. JOHN MCMANN, 73-269 Broken Arrow, opposed due to flood control problem. ED PECK, 73-610 Buckboard Trail , opposed due to the flood control problem not being completely solved and the density should be lower. HAROLD BIRD, 47-967 Sun Corral Trail , opposed due to the flood control issues , tra�fic and it would lower the value of adjacent homes. Temporary Presiding Officer Snyder asked if the applicant would like to make a REBUTTAL at this time. Mr,. Housley noted that Littl.e Bend Trail would be an �,,,, extension of Homes�ead and that Alamo would be widened and Chia would be extended. Also, drainage from the south side of Portola (extended) would cut off and divert to Deep Canyon Channel . He stated that for normal rainfall sufficient drainage is being provided. Mr. Housley noted that he had met with the people from Silver Spur and that the plans had been modified. A. T. WILKES , Architect for the project , addressed the Commission noting various points about the careful planning of the channeling of the water, which would only benefit adjacent homes; original zoning as stated in the Riverside County General Plan is 3-5 units per acre; the proposal is less dense than the R-1 next to the proj�ct; he does not feel that Silver Spur will be affected by any additional traffic; the tennis courts will be adjacent to present tennis courts and they will be recessed plus low glare lights will be used; lots were placed carefully with regard to the view and sun control ; and, project will bring about money for flood control . GENE SCOTHORN, Consulting Engineer, noted that the proposed drainage is in line with the Master Drainage Plan for the City, and that the developer can only '�+° deal with the drainage of the property involved and that big floods are a regional problem. He also stated that adjacent property owners would benefit from drain- age control within the project and that the City is re- quiring the developer to contribut'e to off-site drainage facilities and that no run off from this project should affect Silver Spur . Minutes Palm Desert Planning Commission May 30, 1978 Page Four VI . PUBLIC HEARINGS (Cont . ) A. Case Nos. C/Z 02-78 and Related Draft EIR (Cont . ) Commissioner Kryder asked if there was an outlet from the project onto Mesa View. �Zr. Williams stated no. Temporary Presiding Officer Snyder declared the Public Hear- � ing closed and asked for the pleasure of the Commission. `� � Commissioner Kryder stated that it is a well thought out development and that the project is a good one for the area. He then noted that the drainage and flood control is his main concern ��r�r��that he wants more time to study the draft EIR. �,�� j 1��.Commissioner Kelly stated that the increase in density, drain- �.�:. ,,,s �� a�e�"'and fire protection are her concerns and she would like more ��"�� . �.�a�lme. n--�, " Temporary Presiding Officer Snyder requested that Staff make certain determinations with regard to the land down stream and the traffic problem. Commissioner Kelly asked for further study to be done on the traffic situation. On a motion by Commissioner Kryder , seconded by Commissioner Kelly, the cases were continued to July 5, 1978 for further study; carried unanimously (3-0) . Mr. Housley asked what was to be done now. Mr . Williams stated that Staff is to address the City ' s responsibilities with regard '� to drainage and also Staff will provide more information on traffic � and access. � Temporary Presiding Officer Snyder noted that the Planning Commission needs additional input from Staff , the applicant gave a fine presentation. B. Case Nos. DP 09-78 and 126MF - CHACAHUALA, LTD. , Applicant Mr . Williams noted that these cases had been reviewed with the related Case No. C/Z 02-78 and that they should be continued to the meeting of July 5, 1978. On a motion by Commissioner Kryder seconded by Commissioner Kelly the cases were continued; carried unanimously (3-0) . C. Case Nos. DP 05-78 and 117MF - TERRA INDUSTRIES , Applicant Request for approval of a Development Plan and Pre- liminary Design Review for a 200-unit condominium project to be located on approximately 33 acres at the northwest corner of Fairhaven Drive and 44th Avenue. Mr. Williams reviewed the cases and passed out pictures of � sirnilar projects already developed in other areas . He then noted "� the concerns of the Design Review Board and letters from the City of Rancho Mirage and Mr . Balch. Mr. Williams noted the applicants letter presented earlier in the day addressing the concerns of the Design Review Board. One of the main concerns with the project is that the parking areas are too tight . Mr. Williams stated that Staff is recommending denial of the project. Minutes Palm Desert Planning Commission May 30, 1978 Page Five VI . PUBLIC HEARINGS (Cont . ) C. Case Nos. DP 05-78 and 117MF (Cont . ) Temporary Presiding O�ficer Snyder declared the Public Hearing open and asked if the appiicant wished to speak .at this time. ROBERT KRIESE, of Terra Industries , addressed the Commission and stated that the Design Review Board �"` had not considered the application properly. He reviewed the various points of the letter presented today. Mr. Kriese noted that the proposal is similar to Portola Del Sol . He suggested that perhaps car- ports instead of garages would be better. Mr . Kriese further stated that there would be one guest parking space per unit and that parking spaces would be signed as guest parking only and violators would be towed away. DANIEL SALERNO, architect for the project , addressed the Commission and pointed out that the units would be very private and that this concept has won awards in other areas. He noted that there is a 50 ft . width in the garage area and that there will be guest parking throughout the project . There are limited recreational �acilities because they are trying to keep the homes at an affordable price . Mr . Salerno noted that cedar material would be used instead of shake and that there would be a fully enclosed garden for all units. � Temporary Presiding Officer Snyder asked if there was anyone � wishing to speak in FAVOR or in OPPOSITION to the proposed project . Being none , he declared the Public Hearing closed and asked for the pleasure of the Commission . Commissioner Kryder stated that he felt the Commission was re- viewing the case prematurely due to the comments of the Design Review Board. �..*�.��,�'f. � '"�� "/,,��1�Commissioner Kelly stated that planned PR zoning uses the word �X``' ��'u��que" and that this proposal does not follow that definition . With ��--��'�regard to Portola Del Sol it is not coming out as proposed. The pro- �, ject should remain single story so the view is not destroyed. Temporary Presiding Officer Snyder indicated that the case should be continued to give the applicant time to solve its problems with the Design Review Board. Mr. Williams noted that the Design Review Board would like alternatives. Some discussion followed regarding what would happen if the Commission rejected or continued the cases. Mr. Williams noted the Design Review Board is stating that the basic concept is wrong. The applicant could appeal the Commission ' s decision to the City Council . Mr. Kriese asked that the cases be continued to discuss further the motor court concept with the Design Review Board. He asked when the next Design Review Board meet- �, ing would be. 117r. Dick Arnold stated that all they wanted was a fair- shake. Mr. Williams noted that the next Design Review Board meeting would be June 6, 1978, and that this case would be first on the agenda. On a motion by Commissioner Kelly, seconded by Commissioner Kryder, the cases were continued to July 5 , 1978; carried unanimously ( 3-0). THERE WAS A BRIEF RECESS AT 9:23 P.T�. T� 11'IEFTING WAS RECJONVIIVID AT 9:33 P.M. Minutes Palm Desert Planning Commission May 30, 1978 Page Six VI . PUBLIC HEARINGS (Cont . ) D. Case N�. CUP 04-78 - HOPE LUTHERAN CHURCH, Applicant Request for approval of a Conditional Use Permit for a church-school complex partially developed, at the northwest corner of Portola Avenue and Fairway Drive . Mr. Williams reviewed the case noting the conditions of approval , both standard and special . Temporary Presiding Officer Snyder declared the Public Hearing open and asked if the applicant would like to speak at this time. �HARRY SCHMITZ, 43-900 Primrose, President of Hope ��r��Luthern Church, addressed the Commission, noting �y� ��'` � that the Church operates a non-profit pre-school o�,. `�'` I_��,� �.nd the first phase of the project will provide �° �� _��'i��"" ��.� additional classrooms for this purpose . He then � addressed himself to Special Condition No . 2 which requires curb and gutter . Mr . Schmitz noted that " the church had already paid for curb and gutter and that if they are required to put curb and gutter in, it would cause the runoff to run onto adjacent : property and cause erosion . GARY WIEDLE, 74-110 Old Prospector Trail , addressed the Commission and spoke regarding Standard Condi- ' tion No. 5 . He noted that the church does not feel it should have to bear the burden of the cost and that putting the property in an assessment district for the future total area would be a better solution. Mr. Wiedle requested that Condition No . 5 be deleted. RICK �iOLDEN, 44-615 Santa Margarita, architect for the project and Vice President of the Church, addres- sed the Commission and noted that he had used a court- yard concept to buffer the noise from the schoolrooms. He stated that the parking lot would be enclosed with a wall and landscaped. Temporary Presiding Officer Snyder asked if there was anyone wishing to speak in FAVOR of the project . MR. SILVERTON, resident across the street on Fairway, stated that he approved the project but objected to the entrance/exit on Fairway . Temporary Presiding Officer Snyder asked if there was anyone wishing to speak in OPPOSITION of the project . ASEL AMELIAR, 74-085 Fairway Dr. , spoke in opposition to the exit on Fairway. MR. GALLO, resident across from parking lot , spoke in opposition to the traffic problem that already exists on Portola and also he objected to the exit on Fairway. CARL AMELIAR, 74-085 Fairway, stated that the wall will not disguise the fact thatit ' s �. parking lot and that a higher wall with more landscaping would be helpful . Also objected to exit on Fairway. Minutes Palm Desert Planning Commission May 30, 1978 Page Seven VI . PUBLIC HEARING (Cont . ) D. Case No. CUP 04-78 (Cont . ) Temporary Presiding Officer Snyder asked if the applicant would like to make a REBUTTAL at this time. Mr. Holden addressed himself to the entrance/exit on Fairway and noted that it is a hazard to pull �` out on Portola and he felt that this was a safer pattern. I . HAROLD HOUSLEY, Engineer on project , Chairman of the Building Committee, noted that an exit is needed on Fairway and he also stated that churches do not cause depreciation to adjacent dwellings. Some discussion followed regarding locating the parking lot on Lantana instead of Fairway. Commissioner Kelly asked Mr. Beebe to comment at this time. Mr . Beebe noted that there is no problem with an exit/entrance on Fairway and he would prefer only one exit/entrance on Portola. Commissioner Kelly asked about the perimeter wall and if a gate could be used. Mr . Holden stated that there would be a wall on all street sides, that the north entrance on Portola � would be right turn only, and due to the varied times '' of use , a gate would not betoo practical . � Commissioner Kryder stated that low wall landscaping and berm- ing would improve the situation. Temporary Presiding Officer Snyder stated that possibl� another condition could be considered stating that proper and adequate land- scaping should be used on wall adjace�t to residential areas . Mr . Williams noted that under the Ordinance , parking lots ad- �acent to residential lots are required to hav� a minimum 32 foot Q��gh wall . �<v��r�� ' Commissioner Kelly asked if the driveway could be moved closer ��to Portola. Mr. Williams indicated that it could be moved 20 feet or ,-�=�f1 so closer to Portola. He also noted that the undergrounding could be � ;�waivered under the Ordinance. '' r r � ��,;, `_ ��4 ��y ��.�.5 l�iy�z� �, Mr. Williams suggested the following revision to Standard -Con __,-__ '�' tion No. 5 - "Al1 overhead utility distribution shall be undergrounded as a part of construction of said lines. " Also Special Condition No. 4 could be added to read - "Proposed driveway along Fairhaven shall be moved westerly with the approval of the Director of Public Works as a part of Phase II . " Mr. Williams then noted that all the special conditions should read as "as a part of Phase II" . � Ori a motion by Commissioner Kelly, seconded by 'Cammissioner Kryder, the Commission approved Case No . CUP 04-78, with the noted changes, by Planning Commission Resolution No. 360 ; carried unanimously (3-0) . Minutes Palm Desert Planning Commission May 30, 1978 Page Eight VI . PUBLIC HEARINGS (Cont . ) E. Case Nos. CUP 03-78 and 124MF - WARREN SLAUGHTER, Applicant Request for approval of Conditional Use Permit and Preliminary Design Review to allow the extension of an existing driveway, the creation of a pad for parking, the improvement of an existing driveway and a water line extension on a parcel located within the Hillside Overlay District . �` Mr. Williams reviewed the cases and noted on an aerial photo the area involved and proposed changes . He then reviewed the condi- tions of approval . Temporary Presiding Officer Snyder declared the Public Hearing open and asked if the applicant wished to speak at this time . WARREN SLAUGHTER, noted his agreement with the conditions. Temporary Presiding Officer Snyder asked if there was anyone wishing to speak in FAVOR or in OPPOSITION to the proposed project . Being none, he declared the Public Hearing closed and asked for the pleasure of the Commission . On a motion by Commissioner Kelly, seconded by Commissioner Kryder, the Commission approved Cases No . CUP 03-78 and 124MF by Planning Commission Resolution No. 361 ; carried unanimously ( 3-0) . F. Case Nos . DP 08-78 and 125MF - ROGER BOYAR DEVELOPMENT, Applicant . `� � Request for approval of a Development Plan Amendment and Preliminary Design Review to provide for a peri- meter wall and landscaped areas which would separate the existing phase of the Kings Point condominium project �on Lot l and a portion of Lot 2 of the recorded tract from future development of the project . Mr . Williams reviewed the cases and the conditions of approval including the Design Review conditions . Temporary Presiding Officer Snyder declared the Public Hearing open and asked the applicant if he wished to speak at this time . STUART GREEN, noted his agreement with the conditions and stated he would answer any questions. Temporary Presiding Officer Snyder asked if there was anyone wishing to speak in FAVOR of the project . JAMES BURBON, lawyer representing the property owners , stated that an agreement had been reached between the applicant , the property owners and the residents of the present development and that he would like a few � things clarified with regard to encroachment , the � existing roadway being moved, the location of the wall in question , when will the wall go in and what type of wall it will be. Temporary Presiding Officer Snyder asked if there was anyone wishing to speak in OPPOSITION to the project . Minutes Palm Desert Planning Commission May 30, 1978 Page Nine VI . PUBLIC HEARINGS (Cont. ) F. Case Nos. DP 08-78 and 125MF (Cont . ) MR. STINE, 46-806 Shadow Mountain Drive, spoke about the condition of the road in the area involved and that it has not been repaired from the storm in 1976 . He noted that there are no provisions for drainage �•► �� n Shadow Mountain Drive . He objected to the increase �� in traffic which will occur and he asked if Green Way �� (� �� il be a public street . It was noted that it would be . � � ��""�� There was some discussion about easements, drainage and the tennis courts. DAVID MAYBERRY, resident of Kings Point , asked if the tennis courts will be lighted and if they will have to be approved by the Design Review Board at a public hearing. He noted that the residents object to lighting and that the current courts are not lighted. It was noted that the - Design Review Board meeting is not a public � � �.`. ..._: hearing. (q� � Mr. Green noted that the courts would be lighted �� z. �--�'^tf as approved in the subdivision . �j. . Temporary Presiding Officer Snyder asked if the Commission could make this decision or would it have to be left up to the Design Review Board. Commissioner Kelly asked if the courts are to be recessed. Mr. Williams indicated that if the courts are to be lighted they have to be recessed and that it is part of Design Review Condition No . 1 '�' that the tennis court lighting proposal be submitted to them as a part of the final construction drawings . Mr. Green asked that the case be continued so that he can deal with the lighting issue as he was not prepared. He asked that the composit?on of t:�e wall be decided here. Mr . Williams noted that slumpstone had been suggested and that a Design Review Condition No. 4 could be added to read - "Proposed adobe slumpstone wall separating the original project from the subject project, shall be constructed prior to the construction of any dwell- ing units . " Mr. Green agreed that he would fence the construction site from existing units. MRS . FRIEDLANDER, resident of Kings Point , noted that the wall is necessary for security and construction �easons. r�� r� ?�� O POLICI , construction foreman, noted that the ground ��'` ,�� ) ill be kept watered during grading. � � Commissioner Kelly noted that the location of the tennis courts �" X and how they are lighted is up to the Design Review Board and that they can handle this later . On a motion by Commissioner Kelly, seconded by Commissioner Kryder , the Commission approved Case Nos. DP 08-78 and 125114F with the noted condition added, by Planning Commission Resolution No . 362 ; carried unanimously ( 3-0) . Minutes Palm Desert Planning Commission May 30, 1978 Page Ten VI . PUBLIC HEARINGS (Cont . ) G. Case No. TT 12556 - TRANSCOPIC DEVELOPMENT CORP . , Applicant Request for approval of a Tentative Tract Map to create an 81-lot subdivision to provide for 80 � condominium units and common open space at the � northwest corner of Cook Street and 44th Avenue. �i Mr . Williams reviewed the case and the conditions of approval and noted the staff ' s recommendation of approval . Temporary Presiding Officer Snyder declared the Public Hearing open and asked if the applican� wished to speak at this time . BILL L0, noted his agreement with the conditions . Temporary Presiding Officer Snyder asked if there was anyone wishing to speak in FAVOR or in OPPOSITION to the project . Being none , he declared the Public Hearing closed and asked for the plea- sure of the Commission . On a motion by Commissioner Kryder, seconded by Commissioner Kelly, the Commission approved Case No. TT 12556 by Planning Commis- sion Resolution No. 363 ; carried unanimously (3-0) . H. Case No. TT 12725 - WILLARD �. JORDAN , Applicant Request for approval of a Tentative Tract Map to � create a 5-lot subdivision to provide for 4 con- dominium units and common open space on a . 42 acre parcel located east of Highway 74, north of Verba Santa. �7r. Williams reviewed the case and its conditions of approval and tn.e indica.ted the Staff ' s recommendation of approval . Temporary Presiding Officer Snyder declared the Public Hearing open and asked if the applicant wished to speak at this time. HAROLD HOUSLEY, representing the applicant , noted his agreement with the conditions and the Staff ' s recommendations. Temporary Presiding Officer Snyder asked if there was anyone wishing to speak in FAVOR or in OPPOSITION to the project . Being none, he declared the Public Hearing closed and asked for the plea- sure of the Commission. On a motion by Commissioner Kelly, seconded by Commissioner Kryder, Case No . TT 12725 was approved by Planning Commission Re- solution No. 364; carried unanimously (3-0) . :�I . Continued Case No . GPA 02-78 - Joint Public Eearing with � Parks and Recreation Commission - CITY OF PALM DESERT, � applicant . Mr. Williams noted that due to the lateness of the hour, the Parks and Recreation Commission had requested that the hearing be continued to June 14, 1978. On a minute motion by Commissioner Kelly , seconded by Commis- sioner Kryder , the case was continued to June 14, 1978 ; carried unanimously ( 3-0) . Minutes Palm Desert Planning Commission May 30, 1978 Page Eleven VIII . OLD BUSINESS A. Continued discussion of the Christina Sinatra Youth Center Brochure. Temporary Presiding Officer Snyder noted that it was a fine proposal and that the City Council should take action. This was taken as a motion and seconded by Commissioner Kelly; carried un- � animously (3-0) . IX. NEW BUSINESS A. Consideration of proposed projects to be undertaken by C.V.C.W.D. Mr. Williams reviewed the proposed projects with the Commission and noted that they are in conformance with the adopted Palm Desert General Plan . On a motion by Commissioner Kryder , seconded by Commissioner Kelly, the Commission approved the proposed projects as being in conformance with the adopted Palm Desert General Plan, by Planning Commission Resolution No . 365; carried unanimously (3-0) . X. DESIGN REVIEW BOARD ITEMS A. Review of Cases, acted on by the Design Review Board at their meeting of May 23 , 1978 . Mr. Cipriani reviewed Case No. 47C and noted that he had drawn � in the trash enclosure area which was acceptable to the applicant . _ The Commission indicated a willingness to remove the parking barricade shown on the east side of the project in order to create a driveway thereby eliminating two parking spaces . The Commission believed this modification would improve access and circulation for the p•roject . Mr. Cipriani noted that these modi�ication� would b� shown on the final construction drawings. On a motion by Commissioner Kryder, seconded by Commissioner Kelly, the actions of the Design Review Board were approved by Plan- ning Commission Resolution No . 366; carried unanimously (3-0) . XI . DISCUSSION ITEMS - None XII . ORAL COMMUNICATIONS - None XIII . COMMENTS A. City Staff Mr. Williams noted that the date had been finalized for the tour of the City for Friday, June 16 , to start � at 8 : 30 a.m. He also noted that on June 10, from 9 : 30 a.m. to 3 : 30 p.m. there would be a Planning Workshop in Indio. Those Commissioners present noted their intention to attend. B. City Attorney Not present Minutes Palm Desert Planning Commission May 30, 1978 Page Twelve XIII . COMMENTS (Cont . ) C. Planning Commissioners Commissioner Kryder asked if the Commission would be receiving a copy of the proposed City budget for 1978/79 . Mr. Williams noted that they should be receiving it shortly. Commissioner Kelly asked if the curb and gutters re- ' quired on the Hope Lutheran Church case should not have been a standard condition . It was noted that they should have been. XIX. ADJOURNMENT On a motion by Commissioner Kryder, seconded by Commissioner Kelly, the meeting was adjourned at 11 : 20 p.m. ; carried unanimously (3-0) . C��;��'��-�^ PAUL A. WILLIA112S , Secretary � � ATTEST: WALTER SNYDER, Te rary Presiding Officier /ks