HomeMy WebLinkAbout0115 /"���'� MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION
� �
., .
TUESDAY - JANUARY 15, 2008
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * � * * *
I. CALL TO ORDER
Chairperson Campbell called the meeting to order at 6:00 p.m.
II. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
Commissioner Tanner led in the pledge of allegiance.
III. ROLL CALL
Members Present: Sonia Campbell, Chair
Dave Tschopp, Vice Chair
Connor Limont
Mari Schmidt
Van Tanner
�
Members Absent: None
Staff Present: Lauri Aylaian, Director of Community Development
Bob Hargreaves, Deputy City Attorney
Tony Bagato, Principal Planner
Ryan Stendell, Associate Planner
Renee Schrader, Associate Planner
Hart Ponder, Code Compliance Manager
Shawn Kilpatrick, Code Compliance Officer
Tonya Monroe, Administrative Secretary
IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Request for consideration of the December 18, 2007 meeting minutes.
Action:
It was moved by Commissioner Limont, seconded by Commissioner
Schmidt, approving the December 18, 2007 meeting minutes. Motion carried
4-0-1 (Commissioner Tanner abstained).
�
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION JANUARY 15. 2008
V. SUMMARY OF COUNCIL ACTION
w.r�
Ms. Aylaian summarized pertinent January 10, 2008 City Council actions.
VI. ORAL COMMUNICATIONS
None.
VII. CONSENT CALENDAR
A. Case No. PP 03-19 - SCOTELLE DEVELOPMENT, LLC, Applicant
Request for approval of a one-year time extension for Phase
III (one remaining building) of Case No. PP 03-19 (which
allowed the construction of five office buildings totaling 53,662
gross square feet) on property located at 39-800 Portola.
Action:
It was moved by Commissioner Tschopp, seconded by Commissioner
Limont, approving the Consent Calendar by minute motion. Motion carried
5-0.
VIII. PUBLIC HEARINGS „�
Anyone who challenges any hearing matter in court may be limited to raising
only those issues he, she or someone else raised at the public hearing
described herein, or in written correspondence delivered to the Planning
Commission at, or prior to, the public hearing.
Chairperson Campbell dismissed herself from Public Hearing A and turned the meeting
over to Vice Chairperson Tschopp. For the record, Commissioner Tanner stated that he
listened to the tape recording of the December 18, 2007 meeting. Also for the record, Mr.
Hargreaves explained that Chairperson Campbell excused herself due to a conflict under
the Political Reform Act because she owns a business within 500 feet of the establishment
at issue.
A. Case No. CUP 96-15 - CITY OF PALM DESERT, Applican�
(Continued from December 4 and 18, 2007)
Request for consideration of an amendment to an approved
conditional use permit to eliminate nightly music entertainment
in the outdoor dining patio area of the Augusta's Restaurant
(Augusta's). Subject property is located at 73-995 EI Paseo
(APN 627-272-005).
.■r�
2
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION JANUARY 15 2008
Ms. Aylaian explained that this item had been continued from December 4
� and 18, 2007. She asked Mr. Stendell for a staff report to give an update on
what had transpired since the last meeting and to report on a couple of items
that have arisen since the agenda was published last Friday.
Mr. Stendell recalled that at the December 18, 2007 meeting it was staff's
request that this item be continued in an attempt to take several more
readings in the month that transpired between this hearing and the next one.
Since that time staff identified that they would be monitoring both December
20 and December 22 as identified dates. Staff also discussed a third date
undisclosed at the time because they knew they wanted a third reading and
the applicant indicated they would be purchasing some additional curtains
as a sound mitigation measure and staff wanted to take one more reading
before this hearing to see if any progress had been made.
He stated he would go through the data to make everyone thoroughly aware
of the findings. December 20, 2007, finro Code Enforcement officers, the
Code Enforcement Manager and he himself arrived at Augusta's at
approximately 8:30 p.m. They were introduced to the sound consultant who
showed the mitigation measures as they were proposed that evening. They
were placing panels in different positions trying to get a hold on where the
worst of the sound was coming from and the sound engineer that was onsite
�..►
that evening was really anxious to see what he could do.
Staff's observation was that the band was a three-member band with a
synthesized component to it, so the sounds they were producing with the
instruments were synthesized in the background by a computer essentially.
The Thursday night band readings that were included in the report and the
graphs showed that actually all four ten-minute readings were taken in
compliance around the 51 and a half, and 53 and some change, level
readings. It was staff's intention also that night to begin a series of spot
checks. They also made the Planning Commission aware of where they
would visit several reporting party addresses and where the worst of the
complaints were coming from to determine if they have merit and if they were
reasonable. He displayed a map showing the four different locations they
visited.
That evening three members of staff left at approximately 9:00 p.m. to visit
the four locations. The first they visited was the Candlewood Apartments.
That apartment complex is built around a central courtyard. They entered the
gate from the central, which was a back patio with approximately three or
four handful units. At that location staff could clearly hear the music at 9:00
p.m. Once they looked over the wall, there was a fairly clear shot where the
sound very easily gets there and they could clearly hear the music. The
�.�.
3
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION JANUARY 15. 2008
second location was 73922 Shadow Mountain. Staff stood in the patio of the
reporting party's address and could clearly hear the music at 9:15 p.m. The �'
address at 45-831 Mountain View is approximately at the intersection of
Fairway and Portola. Staff could hear the music; it was not as clear as it was
at the finro previous locations, but as the ambient calmed down as the cars
slowly started passing the stop sign at Portola and Fairway,the music started
becoming more apparent. So they could definitely hear it, but it wasn't as
clear as at the first finro locations.
Mr. Stendell stated that the fourth location was the Shadow Mountain Resort
and Tennis Club. Standing on the second-story balcony adjacent to the units
that face out northeast they could hear the music, but it wasn't as clear as
the first finro. Those were all under readings that were in compliance with the
ordinance that evening, which was December 20, 2007.
December 22, 2007, a Saturday night, Code Enforcement Officer Shawn
Kilpatrick began some readings at approximately 10:38 p.m. The graph in the
report shows that all four of the ten-minute averages, which is the way they
measure sound per the sound ordinance, which is a ten-minute A-weighted
average, are exceeding the sound levels. That evening at about 10:45 p.m.
Mr. Stendell arrived and also met the Code Enforcement Manager onsite and
they also agreed to do the spot checks again. The perception was that if it
was bad at 53, it was going to be worse at 58, but he still wanted to again �
make the rounds and see what the findings were. That evening as he arrived
at Candlewood, he realized that he didn't posses the knowledge to get into
the gate; Code Enforcement had that. The long string of apartments fairly
well shielded the music; he could hear it, but couldn't make a clear
determination that it was worse than two nights before.
The second location on Shadow Mountain, Mr. Stendell could clearly hear
it and could clearly make the determination that it was louder than December
20. The last location he visited was the Mountain View address because he
didn't have access into the Shadow Mountain Resort. At Mountain View and
Shadow Lake Drive he was really blown away at what he could hear at that
location. It was a lull in the music and at the end of the song and the
beginning of another, the crowd applauded and it was fairly loud. To make
the determination that the reporting parties' complaints had merit, he would
definitely say in that circumstance, at that level of music, that they definitely
have merit.
Staff also conducted a sound study last Saturday evening. Although the
sound levels are coming down, they were actually closer to 55 than they
have been on any other Saturday night that he could see, he believed the
band on Saturday night was the loudest band they had, and perhaps
�
4
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION JANUARY 15. 2008
Augusta's representatives could confirm that. It is a five-member band, a
� classic rock and rock `n roll music type.
Mr. Stendell said the results of Saturday's study were distributed to the
Commission (attached hereto as Exhibit A). He also pointed out that
Augusta's had indicated to staff that they had received some new sound
mitigation cloth and they were doing their best to get it installed strategically
before Saturday night, but the report states that was not in place for the
Saturday night reading. It was also reported by Code Enforcement Officer
Shawn Kilpatrick that not only could he hear the music at all four locations,
he could actually identify the song that was being played. That was the latest
information from this past Saturday evening.
In conclusion, there were a couple of things going on that he would like to
touch on. First, they had been talking the most about getting a specific
decibel level. The City's Noise Ordinance and the existing restaurant CUP
(conditional use permit) reference noise to be in compliance with the City's
Noise Ordinance. The City's Noise Ordinance does in fact list 55 decibels
after 10:00 p.m. as the permissible sound limit to operate under a ten-minute
A-weighted average.
The other component of the Noise Ordinance is that staff has the ability to
;�,,, make the determination that a business or a commercial business is in
violation if the sound levels coming from the commercial business are
impacting the residential zones. There are a few sections that basically say
that the operation of any instrument, machine, loudspeaker, or similar device
befinreen the hours of 10:00 p.m. and 8:00 a.m. to be plainly audible from the
property line can also constitute a violation. Basically, the ordinance touches
on finro ways to define a violation. The third he also wanted to touch on is that
they are talking about the existing conditional use permit in place. The
existing conditional use permit by its nature should never be creating any
nuisance to the surrounding property owners. A conditional use permit is
given conditionally based on the fact that it is going to be in harmony with the
surrounding uses and is not going to be creating an undue impact and
certainly not creating any public nuisances.
Unfortunately in this case, after a great deal of further review, staff believes
that the sound levels being created in its current state is creating a public
nuisance for the surrounding residential zones and are ultimately
recommending to the Planning Commission that the CUP be modified to
eliminate any outdoor amplified music of any kind. In his report he also
indicated to the Commission that staff would be happy to re-entertain an
application for a CUP if necessary improvements are constructed to assure
the City that sound levels would not be generating a nuisance to the
�
5
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION JANUARY 15. 2008
surrounding area. He stated he would be happy to answer any questions. He
noted that the representatives from Augusta were present in the audience. �
Vice Chair Tschopp asked for any questions of staff.
Commissioner Limont stated that when she looks at the January 14, 2008
chart that shows 72.1 decibels at 11:00 p.m., her understanding was that
when they were talking about 55 decibels, it is an average, and it shoots up
to 72, and this was over ten minutes that they get the 55 average. Mr.
Stendell said that was right. He explained that with the 72, they were going
to find a lot of peaks in there and the peaks could be anything from a diesel
truck going by to a loud person talking depending on how close they are to
the meter. They were really looking at the average. When looking at the
graph, the average was the green bar furthest to the right; they had the low,
the high and the average.
Vice Chair Tschopp said on that same thought, looking at the Augusta 12/20
study, on the far right at 9:35 p.m. it shows it was at 76 decibels as a high,
and this was during a 60-minute reading he assumed. Mr. Stendell said yes.
Vice Chair Tschopp asked if that meant that for at least 20 minutes there
were readings that high. Mr. Stendell said no, it was one peak. He could let
the Code officers who are trained on it speak, but his understanding was that
even one-hour average or two-minute average, the high is the peak, not any �
other form of that. The high is one time that goes by. Vice Chair Tschopp
indicated that it wasn't an average then. Mr. Stendell stated that the average
in the 12/20 case on the far right where they were looking at 76 would be
53.16. Vice Chair Tschopp said there would be no way to tell how long or
how long it was at the high peak. Ms. Aylaian explained that what they were
looking at is a time-weighted average, not a statistical average across the
board. If they have a truck go by at 75 decibels and they are there for one
minute, that counts as 1/60th of the interval. If the rest of the time the music
or other ambient noises are closer to 50 decibels, then 59/60% of that
average is at 50 decibels.
There were no other questions for staff. Mr. Stendell also informed
Commission that along with the latest sound results, he also passed out an
E-mail that was received from a local resident, as well as a voice mail when
he returned from lunch today from a neighbor living on Shadow Lake Drive
that actually didn't have a problem with the music and wanted to see if he
would enter that into the record as well. Her name was Cynthia.
Vice Chair Tschopp stated that the hearing was still o en from the last
meeting and asked the applicant to address the Commission.
�.r
6
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION JANUARY 15. 2008
MS. TIFFANY WINDSOR, Director of Events for Augusta Restaurant,
� said she, too, would like the Commission to follow along with tonighYs
staff report so that she could address each discussion point.
On December 20, in follow-up to the last hearing, she worked with the
sound consultant that they hired to begin the sound mitigation testing
that they had all agreed to at the last hearing. Concurrently, both she
and Code Enforcement were sound testing with their respective
equipment on that Thursday night. The staff report indicates the same
information; however, there is no specific reference at this point in the
report that Code Enforcement's reading was in the 52-decibel range
level, which concurred with her findings.
Next in the staff report is the graph, which they were just looking at,
which Code Enforcement provided to the Commission. There was a
big discussion on this in the report, but what staff failed to point out to
them is that the highs, as indicated in red, are not music. She would
show them her findings, starting with #1 (documents were displayed
on the overhead projector and are attached hereto as Exhibit B).
From speaking with Code Enforcement, she understood the City's
equipment software does not provide this kind of detailed report as
her software does. They could see on her report that the traffic on the
� surrounding streets causes spikes in the readings. A passenger car
passing by, even an airplane passing overhead, will cause a spike to
over 60 decibels. The next chart was displayed. She stated that a
passenger truck passing by will cause a spike to over 70 decibels. A
diesel passenger truck will cause a spike to nearly 80 decibels.
Ms. Windsor stated that this is never clearly defined in Code
Enforcement's reports. Code Enforcement takes a series of ten-
minute and one-hour readings. All of these measurements are
weighted together and reported as"music". She has numerous results
of those findings over many nights should they wish to review more
of these charts. She said she isn't a sound engineer, but it was clearly
not the music at Augusta that's measuring three, four and five
decibels over code.
(The next chart was displayed.) Ms. Windsor stated that with
reference to Candlewood Apartments, she was there on January 12,
2008 with her decibel reader at 9:43 p.m., and while she was there,
Lauri, the City's Planning Director, happened to stop by and, as she
was sure Lauri could attest, at that point they could not hear the music
playing at this location. She did do a reading on the equipment, and
even with the music playing, which they could not hear, the average
�
7
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION JANUARY 15 2008
at this location was 50.7 decibels. The second page showed how her
equipment showed them a similar graph that they see from staff in """�'
some instances. On that same night she went to Shadow Mountain
Resort and she could not hear the music from that location. (They
went on to Chart 3.) She said she also went to 73-922 Shadow
Mountain and she could not hear the music. The noise that she did
hear and she measured was the traffic on the street. Again, they
could see the spikes with the traffic. The average was 50.8 decibels.
On December 22, in cooperation with Code Enforcement and what
they had agreed to for testing purposes, they repeated this process
with their Saturday night band. They asked the band to play at various
sound levels while they tested various placement locations of both the
sound mitigation mattress panels and the theatrical sound curtains on
loan to them. In the days following the testing she did not hear back
from staff as to the results of their testing.
When she received her copy of staff's report last Friday, Ms. Windsor
said this was the first that she found out that their readings came in
at an average of 58.28. When she got to this point in the report, she
started to get really angry. She feels like she was totally blind sided
by staff. They were testing the band, moving the amplification of the
sound up and down, requesting the band to lower and raise their „�
speakers, trying to test their mitigation options, and staff's reporting
this testing to the Commission as if they were in noncompliance. This
misinformation from staff was not acceptable.
On January 12 she was back on Larrea Street again and the
surrounding neighborhood to measure and work with her sound
consultant. There was a surprise visit by Code Enforcement and they
started measuring at 10:50 p.m. Per the interoffice memo the
Commission received from Code Enforcement, their first
measurement started at 10:50 for ten minutes. She also took a
reading at 10:50 and they could see that there was considerable
traffic, and even with that the average was 54.7. The next
measurement started at 11:10 and she too took a measurement.
Staff's average sound was 54.24 and she had 54.7.
Next there was a note here that Officer Shawn Kilpatrick then went to
the Shadow Mountain Tennis Resort. (The next chart was displayed.)
She noted that he reported that he was able to hear the band playing
and lots of yelling while standing on a tennis court. He could clearly
hear a rendition of a Prince song. She actually noted at that time that
it was "Twist and ShouY' and she did note that the crowd was singing
�
8
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION JANUARY 15. 2008
along with the band. Her results from that night, the average, on the
� next page, was 55.4. She requested a follow-up meeting with their
testing with staff and Code Enforcement and was declined several
times. This certainly wasn't the cooperation she was expecting after
they all agreed to work together after their last hearing.
Ms. Windsor said she was finally granted a meeting on January 8.
When she sat down at the meeting, she was immediately told by staff
that they were now taking the position that the outdoor music at
Augusta is a nuisance to the surrounding neighborhood. She inquired
as to why this was coming up now since they were only midway in the
process of testing and implementing mitigation measures that staff,
the Planning Commission, and Augusta had agreed to. And it was
clear that she was reaching a level that the CUP stipulates. It's
amazing to her how Code Enforcement and staff want to hold the
decibel measurement against them when they don't comply, but when
they do comply with the lawful decibel code, they have to scramble for
another way to attack them and try and shut them down. They are
calling a well-run establishment a public nuisance. This is outrageous
behavior from a responsible City. It is clear from all of the past hearing
minutes that they were instructed by the Commission to bring their
decibel readings in under 55. They are right on target for that. Even
�, though they have now uncovered that they have to deal with traffic
thaYs outside of their control, but nonetheless is factored into their
music readings.
Per the Planning Commission's directions from previous meetings,
they have spent tens of thousands of dollars, and it's obvious that she
has been working diligently with Code Enforcement and staff, and she
felt very confident that they will have all of their newly purchased
panels in place and will be in total compliance for this upcoming
weekend. The one thing she couldn't do is comply with a moving
target. She can't have staff give her their opinion one week and then
change it the next. This is bad faith, she was sure, along with all other
sorts of legal issues. She has been cooperative and delivered
everything she promised. The conclusion in the staff report is
unacceptable. She was prepared with all of her documentation to put
up a fight, but hoped it didn't come to that. After all of this effort that
has been invested to be a successful partner in this community, they
find themselves abandoned by City Hall with this staff report
presented to Commission, which ultimately wants to put them out of
business with its reckless assessment labeling one of the city's most
successful and oldest businesses on the street as a public nuisance.
She stated that she was available for any questions.
�
9
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION JANUARY 15 2008
There were no questions. Vice Chair Tschopp thanked her. Moving forward
to request if any persons wished to speak in FAVOR or OPPOSITION, Vice +�+
Chair Tschopp said the next question was a little bit double negative, but
asked for those people who were OPPOSED to eliminating music at
Augusta's to step forward. There was no response. He then asked for those
persons in FAVOR of eliminating the music. He noted that he had three blue
Request to Speak cards and would start with these individuals first.
MR. JOHN CORCORAN, on Shadow Mountain Golf Course Lane,
about a mile and a half from Augusta, said the fact that he can't sleep
at night must be wrong, because all these charts and graphs, and the
last meeting with the attorney and architect, he must be wrong. All this
noise coming in his windows must be in his head. He called the
Riverside Sheriff's Department and they get calls all the time. They
must be wrong. He thought it was time they stopped procrastinating
and do something about this. The gal has got to quit making the
noise. There's a lot of restaurants in this valley that don't have noise
and they seem to survive. She's in the wrong area. He thanked them.
MR. JOHN MORRIS said that he spoke at the December meeting and
represents the Shadow Mountain Resort, which has been in operation
since about 1946. They are a hotel operation with about 85 to 90 units
that are anywhere from one night to one month, whatever people �
want; a regular operation. They charge $230 to $630 per night for
their units. They get guests that call their office at night and ask,
"What's the noise?" and "Where's the party going on?" This has been
happening for years, as they know. They've also had complaints from
people on the golf course next to them that call their office and think
they're having a party over there, and of course it's Augusta's, not
them. He was sorry he didn't have more present to represent the
Resort, but he is not about to ask a guest to come down here and
complain to the Planning Commission; that's not quite the right thing
to do. They complain to the office and they try to handle it from there.
He stated that the music has also been past 11:30 p.m. They know
that from their police records which they had in their last report. If they
look at the one, it was five minutes to 12 and they were still playing.
The excuse was that people requested an encore. Is that a reason to
exceed 11:30? He didn't know. Not in his mind it isn't. The Band-Aid
methods they have been doing before like when they have the
meetings in the Spring where they said that they could continue their
permit for the next three or four weeks during the summer, then they
were going to modify it. But when they came back in the Fall, it was
the same thing. Now they are doing something about it, but not at the
wwr
10
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION JANUARY 15. 2008
time they said they would. He wasn't sure just how good this will do
� if they move these panets around one night and the next night they
don't. He was sure they would still be exceeding the 55 dbs after
10:00 p.m. He thought it was time to put a stop to it, let them make
their adjustments again, their permanent fixes to the noise, then go
back in and monitor it again and see about reissuing a report at that
time.
Mr. Morris emphasized that this noise is interFering with their operating
business. They are a business establishment. They are costing them.
They have a lot of guests that come back time after time and if these
guests don't come back, they're hurting. They have two choices. They
either eliminate it now or change the code. That's the way he looked
at it. If they wanted to come back and request permits six months
from now when they have it repaired, fine, that's up to them. But right
now the choice is to eliminate it or change the code. He thanked
them.
MS. SARAH DRAKE came forward and said she lives on Sierra
Madre in Rancho Mirage, but for most of 2007 she lived on Shadow
Mountain in Palm Desert. First, she wanted to thank the staff
members, specifically Shawn Kilpatrick, Ryan Stendell, Tonya, who
have been so helpful to her, and patient, and informative. Also, Ms.
`" Aylaian and Carlos Lopez [sic. Ortega] who took the time to call her
back personally and discuss with her at length the complaints she had
on the complete disruption of any serenity that she expected as a
resident of south Palm Desert. The staff has been very, very helpful
to her, returned phone calls, sent E-mails with documentation,
patiently answered her questions, provided cell phone numbers and
contact information to be used on weekend nights when the
disturbance was greater than it is from 8:00 to 5:00. These staff
members always work above and beyond the call of duty with
exemplary professionalism and she just wanted to thank the staff for
all of their help. And just a couple of words to the members of the
Planning Commission: vision and responsibility. The vision they have
for Palm Desert, not just for right now, but for five years from now, ten
years from now, and 20 years from now. And their responsibility to the
laws of this city, which have been reiterated tonight, to the citizens of
south Palm Desert, and to the visitors who come to this very unique
area for the kind of relaxation that they expect when they come to
south Palm Desert. It is a very special community and they have a
great responsibility in their hands. She thanked them.
�
11
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION JANUARY 15. 2008
MS. BEVERLY BURIES, 45-831 Mountain View, the street behind
Shadow Mountain, said she was present to request that the �
Commission accept the recommendation of the staff report to shut
down the outside music at Augusta Restaurant immediately. They've
lived in this community for 23 years and have owned this property for
six. For five of those years she has continuously had to call the
Sheriff's Department to request that they go out to Augusta and shut
down the music. They've reported the noise nuisance over and over
and over again. Her husband is a retired peace officer and the
thought that she has to call a sheriff to a non-life threatening or non-
essential violation absolutely offends her. She has to take a sheriff
that should be out watching for and fighting crime to address a noise
issue at one o'clock in the morning. This is not an issue that has taken
place in the last finro years, this has gone on for five years, six years
or more. She believed they have had their conditional use permit
since 1999 and they've called over all that time.
As she talked to her neighbors, she found that people have had to go
to dual-paned windows, which she applauds that, but not for sound
attenuation so that a restaurant can operate in their community.
They've often had to move their own personal activities and their
guests inside because they couldn't communicate over the noise. As
strange as it sounds, her home is three blocks as the crow flies from
this establishment, but she can hear it as if they are playing right ""�
outside her door. She thought that they kind of alluded to that, Ryan,
that he was surprised when he got that far away that he could hear it
as clearly as he could.
Ms. Buries said they have attempted over the years to call the
restaurant to say, "Please turn the music down; it's 11:30, iYs 12:00"
but no one will pick up at that hour. They just will not do it. She had a
neighbor tell her at one time, she got on the bike, she was so mad at
11:30 p.m. she got on her bike and rode down to tell them to turn off
the music. What do they do? How do they deal with it short of calling
out the sheriff sending them out? It took them several years to
understand that there isn't an automatic report from the Sheriff's
Department to the City Code Violation. Once they found that out, they
had to mobilize their troops, so to speak, to say as soon as you report
to the Sheriff, you have to call on Monday and report it to Code
Enforcement as well, because there's not an automatic transfer of
information.
Continuous disregard for the City Noise Code should have mandated
this action long, long ago. If she as a community member were
wrr
12
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION JANUARY 15. 2008
continuously annoying her neighbors with parties and sounds coming
�• that loud within their community, they would be reported over and
over again and it wouldn't take five or six years for action to be taken
by the City. She could guarantee them that.
Ms. Buries said the question she has for this Commission is why
should the benefit of one outweigh the benefit of the entire
community? This isn't just a couple of homes where they sound
tested; this is an entire community of people who have been there a
lot longer than Augusta has been there. And they've been offended
for all the time they've been there by this outdoor sound. She thought
they should stop. Stop the noise. Please. She thanked them.
Vice Chair Tschopp asked if anyone else wished to speak in favor of
eliminating the music.
MS. MARION ROYSTON, a resident of Candlewood Apartments, said
she originally moved to the desert in 1961 and she has raised three
children here. She knew of the need for entertainment, if anybody
does, especially at this end of the valley and especially now that Red
74 isn't here. However, this is the wrong place and the wrong time.
Their property faces EI Paseo commercial property. Nobody
� apparently gave any thought to the fact that this noise was going out
into residential income areas. It was not commercial. The permit
should never have been issued in her estimation. The one gal spoke,
and she didn't mean to laugh, but she thought it was funny when they
attributed traffic to throwing the decibels. Have they ever driven up
and down Highway 111 at 11 o'clock at night? They wouldn't see a
car for three blocks. Portola has heavy traffic in the daytime, but
except for the emergency vehicles at night, it is almost dead quiet
after 8:30 or 9:00. All of the Planning Commissioners all live here, so
they've been out on these streets out late at night and know what the
traffic is like or is not like. They don't have any heavy traffic that's
going to interfere with anything. The thing that does throw her are
these studies that seem to be confined, and she too wanted to add
her thanks to the City, she thought they had been very diligent on their
behalf and they all appreciate their efforts. But why have these
studies now coming up in December and January? The previous
speaker did mention five years. That is how long they have been
calling the Sheriff's or Police Department now, again and again. About
two years ago they finally said, "Don't call us, call the City." What kind
of a little tweak came in there she wasn't too sure, but something did,
somebody slapped their hands or quit padding the pockets or
something, she didn't know. She wasn't accusing, she was just saying
�..r
13
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION JANUARY 15. 2008
they just almost quit taking the calls for the disturbance. They had it
up to here. Shawn has been very cooperative. She was one of the �
patios identified on the map with a big red circle that they parked on
to check.
Ms. Royston mentioned that she came to the first meeting in
December and did give a brief summation at that time and she was
given a card by somebody in Code Enforcement. She didn't have the
card any longer and didn't remember the name, but he said if she had
any further comments, please call him. The very next night, and this
is how they've cooperated off and on through the years, the very next
night that music was still blasting at 1:30 in the morning. They were
just telling us where they stood as opposed to them. This has
happened in history with this noise. Every time they get their hand
slapped, they pull back a month, five weeks, whatever. All of a
sudden, bit by bit they are right back where they were. They have
absolutely no respect for the community as far as their noise, and
they have no respect for what the City is telling them either because
they continually violate what they've been given again and again and
again, a chance to correct. She thought they were all through horsing
around with this issue. They've had more than enough chance. It's
been over five years now, and she wanted to say nine, but her
numbers get mixed up sometimes and she wanted to be fair to �
everyone, but it's been a long time in excess of five years. And they
have repeatedly, there was finrice last year they were put in violation
that she was aware of, and immediately after 30 days they were right
back. She thought taking those things into consideration, they have
no right to have any type of music, she didn't care if they wanted to
play around with curtains or barriers, or whatever they rig up.
Whatever they put up, they can be sure it will come down and they
will be right back where they are. So she would like to please plead
her case in adding her absolute assent to the others before her and
that the noise be discontinued ASAP. She thanked them for their
time.
There was no one wishing to speak. Vice Chair Tschopp asked the restaurant
representatives if they would like rebut or make any comments.
MS. DENISE ROBERGE, the owner of Plaza Roberge and Augusta
Restaurant, which is at Plaza Roberge, came forward. She said she
has heard a lot of exaggeration, but she would do the same. She said
it has become very obvious to them that the City is never going to be
satisfied no matter how much money they spend or what they do to
bring their noise level into compliance. This is not just about noise.
�
14
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION ____ __ JANUARY 15, 2008
Hart, the head of Code Enforcement, has said on numerous
� occasions that the City Council should not have given them a permit
for outdoor music and has voiced this to many people, which is totally
unfair. And just who is Hart to decide what Council should and should
not do? Hart disagrees with Council's decision and therefore is going
to find a way to shut down the music so he and his Code officers will
do whatever they need to do to accomplish this. When Hart realized
that they could, and would, bring the music to code, he had to come
up with another way to stop the music. And all of a sudden now they
are a public nuisance.
She took it personally that she and her business are considered a
public nuisance by the City of Palm Desert. Perhaps they have
forgotten how deteriorated the east end of EI Paseo was before she
came and cleaned it up. If she had to live with keeping the noise level
within lawful code, then anyone that complains has to tolerate the
lawful code if they want to live by this commercial neighborhood.
Perhaps now the nuisance is the people making the phone calls.
Code Enforcement needs to take a different path rather than the path
of least resistance, which is Augusta.
Ms. Roberge stated that she feels that she has been harassed by
Code Enforcement. She wanted them to know that they are seriously
� effecting her business at this peak season. She could not do a job
running her business and fighting a moving target. She has added a
sliding roof to the patio, she had curtains made for the patio wall,
added sound barriers for behind the band, put up a wall of sound
barriers, ordered over 100 feet of new theater curtains to be installed.
After this effect and achieving very positive results, they find
themselves now labeled a public nuisance. As she said earlier, this is
not just about noise. She said she was going to read them an E-mail
that is going to reinforce her position. (See attached Exhibit C.) This
made her really sad when she got this E-mail. They should decide
how it made them feel. "We measured sound levels at Augusta
unannounced on Saturday night. The readings were remarkably close
to 55 decibels." And it says, "Attached is the report from the Code
Enforcement Officer." Then it says, "They were also trying to install
new sound curtains that just arrived on Saturday, but did not have
them up at the time of our monitoring. With the curtains, it is entirely
possible that they will come in under 55 decibels, which leaves us in
the uncomfortable position of them arguing that they are compliant
and the residents will still not be satisfied. Our staff believes that even
at 55 decibels they present a disturbance to the neighbors." Then it
...�.
15
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION _ JANUARY 15. 2008
says, "We need to talk about how the presentation will be made at
tomorrow's hearing." �r
They didn't let Planning Commission know that they were in
compliance at 55. They didn't like the idea that they are putting
curtains up that will bring it under 55. They didn't share that with them.
And sending this E-mail basically says that it doesn't matter what they
do, we will harass them, which is totally unfair. She spent a lot of
money, she'll give them the receipts, over $50,000, and if she had
known that the City was just putting this whole figure out there with no
meanings or had no mind to accept it even if they made it to 55. This
E-mail is just unforgivable and if she was part of the Planning
Commission, she would really be upset with this coming out at this
time. And she was going to take them to the Code Enforcement report
that was attached to this. Ms. Roberge said she has also been at
Candlewood Apartments on many occasions, and on one with the
police officers, and you cannot hear the music there. She asked Lauri
if she was there on Friday night or Saturday night.
Ms. Aylaian replied that yes, she was.
Ms. Roberge asked if she heard the music.
Ms. Aylaian said not from where she was standing.
w
Ms. Roberge asked if she was standing at Candlewood.
Ms. Aylaian wasn't sure this was appropriate, but explained that her
understanding is that where she was situated was not the same place as
where the measurements were being taken from.
Ms. Roberge said she was just asking her if she heard the music.
Ms. Aylaian noted she was at ground level outside the wall adjacent to
Candlewood and she did not hear it.
Ms. Roberge said okay. She asked if Tiffany was there; Tiffany also
went up to some of the other places. No, you could not hear the music
as Mr. Kilpatrick has said. "I could clearly hear the music." She was
sorry, this was just not correct. And they have their statistics to back
it up, too. So when the Code officers are not reporting correctly, how
can they make a correct decision? And when the City doesn't want
them to meet the 55 decibels that they've told them to meet in order
to keep their permit, this was just not acceptable. The law is the law
�
16
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION JANUARY 15, 2008
and they've made it there and shame on them for not informing her
� that once they made it to 55 that wasn't going to be good enough.
They knew that all along and so did Code. So Code has led them
down a really expensive path and the City has totally sabotaged them.
She thought it was just terrible that they would do this behind the
Commission's back. If she was them, she would seriously consider
calling for the resignation of Hart, who has lied on numerous
occasions, to them and well as the Commission, who has publicly
expressed that he is in disagreement with the City Council's decision
and is going to any extreme to get his way and stop the music and
would love to shut down the restaurant. He has lied to her on
numerous occasions, he has lied to Tiffany, and now he has lied to
the Commission. So if they want this happening at City Hall, where
they can't trust their staff to give them the proper information, then
they were all going to suffer from that, not just her. She thanked them.
Vice Chair Tschopp asked if Ms. Roberge would like to put the E-mail into
the record.
Ms. Roberge said yes, definitely. (She handed the finro-page E-mail to
the Commission. See attached Exhibit C.)
,�, Mr. Hargreaves thought the E-mail needed some explanation. What
happened was Ryan forwarded to him the staff report that was going to be
presented, so he forwarded that on to their attorney because he wanted
them to be aware of what was happening. What he did not see when he
forwarded it on was that it included some exchanges back and forth; he
didn't go down through the text. When this was discovered, their attorney
assured him that would be deleted.
Ms. Roberge said iYs there. What they're doing and their activities are
there.
Mr. Hargreaves thought if they review the E-mail, there's nothing he
considered illegitimate or untoward about it. His understanding is, and he
wasn't engaged in the process, the City had hoped in good faith that by
reducing the sound levels below 55 the sound issues in the neighborhood
would be resolved. He thought it became clear as the noise levels approach
55 that that wasn't going to be the case, and this was explained earlier. The
Noise Ordinance has two prongs. There's the objective measurements,
sound measurements, and then there's the more general kind of public
nuisance aspect that if you're causing excessive noise within the
neighborhood that's disturbing people, a reasonable person, then you're in
violation of the sound ordinance and a public nuisance. He thought that was
..r
17
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION JANUARY 15 2008
what staff ultimately determined was that even if they meet the 55 decibel
levels, which are kind of the objective standards, it was unlikely they were �wwr
going to be able to meet the more general standard of not being bothersome
to their neighbors. He thought that was the decision before the Planning
Commission tonight.
Ms. Roberge said so they think it's okay to lead them down the path,
to spend all the money, time and effort that they've done to
accomplish 55 decibels, which is the code, and then once they are
getting there, you get frightened that they're getting there, as it says
in the E-mail, "With the curtains it is entirely possible that they will
come in under 55 decibels, which leaves us in this uncomfortable
position of them arguing that they are compliant." And even at the
bottom it says, "We need to talk about how we're going to do this
presentation, will be made at tomorrow's hearing."
Ms. Aylaian interjected that she is the author of the E-mail. She felt
uncomfortable that we have focused on one aspect of the Noise Ordinance,
which is the quantitative measurement of decibels. It is true that staff has
focused on that; however, she thought that previously we were never even
close to that level and staff had no way of knowing just how good a marriage
it would be befinreen having 55 decibels and a residential neighborhood in
close proximity. As we got there and honed in on that level, staff was able to '
determine that it still isn't a good fit, it does not provide a harmonious �
exchange befinreen the two, so at that point it seemed uncomfortable
because we had focused on 55 and we would now be looking more closely
at the other portion of the ordinance.
Ms. Roberge was sorry that it felt uncomfortable; that was a costly
feeling for her. And how could they leave it `till Friday, and this is
Tuesday, to inform them of that, of her direction? That's City's
responsibility, to number one, they made the code to 55 and they
should know that 55 is what works.
Mr. Hargreaves asked if Ms. Roberge would inform the Commission of the
date of that E-mail.
Ms. Roberge noted the Commission had it.
Commissioner Limont said January 13.
Ms. Roberge said it was Monday.
�
18
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION __ JANUARY 15. 2008
Ms. Aylaian stated that staff met with Ms. Windsor on Tuesday a week ago
� and at that point advised her what staff's recommendation was going to be,
that regardless of whether or not the 55 decibels were achieved, that we still
did not believe it was a good fit and recommended for modification of the
Conditional Use Permit on the basis of that.
Ms. Roberge stated that every time she has been here for the last
meetings here, Ms. Aylaian has said that she believed they couldn't
get it to 55 and thaYs why she pushed the Planning Commission to
where they even said, well, if they get it in compliance, they're okay.
So they did bring it into compliance. She let them believe...she
thought they couldn't do that, number one. And then when she found
out they could, then she had to change the playing field, which is just
not okay. If the compliance is 55, and if they keep it there, they're
within the law. And if they want to live near a commercial area, then
they have to live within 55 decibels, too. What is okay for one has got
to be okay for the other. And she was telling them something--why
don't they all go down to these different locations and take their own
readings on how much noise they hear because this information is not
accurate from your Code Enforcement people. And she knows that.
Ms. Aylaian proposed to the Commission one of two things. One is that
�, without the newly purchased sound curtains, or sound attenuation curtains,
we're close to 55 decibels. We could, if the Commission desires, postpone
this to give the applicant an opportunity to hang the curtains. It's possible that
with the additional sound attenuation it would bring it down significantly below
the 55 decibels and it could again be something that provides better
protection for the neighborhood. Alternatively, the Commission could close
the public testimony and take action on the staff recommendation, which is
that the CUP be modified to eliminate outdoor music.
Vice Chair Tschopp asked if Ms. Roberge had any additional comrr�ents.
Ms. Roberge said the law is the law. It's 55 decibels. They are going
to be in that area. And why were they changing the rules now? She
said they have made every effort, but she would tell them something,
the City has not been fair to them, accurate with them, or
accommodating to them in any way. When the Code Enforcement
encourage people to call, hold their hands, that's not good. It's very
obvious what's going down here.
Vice Chair Tschopp said he would leave the public hearing open for the
moment and would ask the Commission for their comments, though he had
a question. He asked if the comment to keep it open or continue it, if it would
.�
19
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION JANUARY 15. 2008
be done with the assistance of the other neighbors and if they would be
listening from other areas within the city like they did before. Ms. Aylaian ••�
presumed staff would do what was done before. They established the four
areas from which they receive the greatest number of complaints. They
would go back to each of those four areas and monitor again, not just with
the decibels, but how disturbing the noise is to a resident.
Vice Chair Tschopp asked for Commission comments.
Commissioner Limont said this is a tough one. Having visited Augusta,
having walked the neighborhood when the band is playing, the one thing she
could say and thought everyone would agree on, is that sound is a very fluid
thing and it travels. The way that our valley is located and where Augusta is
located at the base of an alluvial fan, with different heights of buildings,
depending where you are and where you're walking, or where you're sitting,
or where you're situated, you may or may not hear the sound. She had a little
bit of trouble comparing trucks to music. She lives five houses to Highway 74
and if there is one place where trucks go up and down on a pretty regular
basis, it's 74. She was not disturbed by them; she can sleep at night and she
goes to bed early. The concern she had is when they have music and it's
playing and you're asleep and if they're asleep and they hit 71 decibels, if it's
on a repetitive basis, it's going to disturb someone's sleep. Just in looking at
the aerial photo of where Augusta's Restaurant is, and you look out and see �
the neighborhood surrounding it, it is, to her, very obvious that they could say
as a town we've erred. We erred in allowing amplified music outside. Period.
Because it is not fair to the rest of the residents because it travels. The
difficulty is that we also want to be very fair to the businesses on EI Paseo
and the businesses in Palm Desert. She felt to a certain extent they weren't
being fair to Shadow Mountain, and yet in the same breath she could say
definitely, Denise and Tiffany have done everything we've asked as far as
trying to mitigate the sound. The reality of it is that as we go through this
exercise, we're finding that 55 decibels is not working for the residents.
Based on that they needed to take a strong look. Her recommendation would
be to take a strong look; she was in agreement with staff that our ordinance
needs to be adjusted and that we have to do something with regard to
amplified music outside in the city of Palm Desert.
Commissioner Tanner said the Planning Commission is a sounding board
and we make recommendations to the Council. He wasn't suggesting that
had he been here nine years ago on Planning Commission that he'd be
looking at this any differently. If this was presented to him today with the
understanding that neighbors would be effected, he would vote it down. He
is a businessman here in the Coachefla Valley, he is also a resident of Palm
Desert, and he has also been effected by noise in the past--it is not leading
.wr�
20
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION JANUARY 15. 2008
him to his decision one way or another, he was just saying that there is a
� time and place and he thought that at this point his recommendation to the
Planning Commission is that they pull the conditional use permit and not let
this happen. He supposed that the apologies go to Augusta's for trying to
make the necessary..., but at this point, again, his stance is that they pull the
conditional use permit and not allow this to go any further.
Commissioner Schmidt said her feeling is that they have to be very careful
not to confuse decibel readings with a nuisance. A decibel reading is a
variable thing that can be defined in the eye of the beholder, as they have
heard. The reason she was so insistent when they talked about whether to
continue this matter or to when, she wanted to convince herself that there
was ample reason to do what was being proposed. She could not ignore that
the music that comes from Augusta's Restaurant is disturbing all of the
residency in that area, or a goodly portion of it. She is not staff. She has to
depend partially what they recommend to them, but she did not wish anyone
any harm or to close a business, but she was convinced that the music that
emanates from that restaurant, particularly on the weekend late at night, is
causing a nuisance to the residency of the area. They have a responsibility
to both. She was in favor or pulling the exterior permit, or however it was
done, for music at that restaurant. She wasn't at all sure that was the end of
it. She presumed that, and staff could tell her, that music is still allowed
inside the restaurant, but what--behind closed doors? Or open doors? And
`�` music is still going to filter. She didn't want the residency to feel, the people
who live in the area, to feel they have carte blanche now to anytime they
hear music from indoors that they are going to call and we're going to start
this all over again. That is not her intent.
Vice Chair Tschopp said that he does have sympathy for the applicant from
the very beginning of this latest go-around on the noise issue. And he said
the latest because this has been going on since 2000 or something like that.
But at this point we zeroed in on the decibels and lately it has been brought
up that the nuisance part of it is just as big an aspect. So at that point he was
disappointed. At the same time, everybody is entitled to quiet enjoyment to
their home. Clearly tonight they had heard from many people, and at a
meeting prior to this they talked about the number of phone calls they
received over the years. In the year 2000, 16 times the police responded,
and he knew that was going back a few years, but that has been an on-going
problem that's not corrected. They pointed the way to Saturday night and the
decibels are still over, but not by much and he was pushing it there, but they
are still not in compliance. Even if they were at 55, they would still probably
be a nuisance to their neighbors. The whole problem with this is that's trying
to put a square peg in a round hole--it's the wrong place for a nightclub.
When this first started out, he thought it would first be dinner with
�
21
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION JANUARY 15. 2008
accompanying music, something quiet, acoustical guitars, a piano,
something of that nature. But it turned into a full-fledged nightclub at night +�
with rock and roll music and dancing. He didn't think that was what was
originally intended. He could not say at this point they would approve anyone
for a nightclub facing south Palm Desert outdoors. So he had a problem with
this from the beginning. Since it is a CUP, and that's a conditional use permit
and not something of permanency, he would not be in favor of extending it
at this time.
For clarification purposes, Mr. Hargreaves stated that with CUP's the
Planning Commission has the jurisdiction to issue them and amend them. If
they act tonight, they would actually be making a decision with respect to the
CUP. It is not a recommendation to the City Council. However, the applicant
would have the right within 15 days to appeal that decision to the City
Council and during that appeal, the Planning Commission's action would be
stayed. Within the appropriate time frame, it would be heard by the City
Council.
Vice Chair Tschopp called for additional questions. There was no response.
He asked for a motion.
Action:
Commissioner Tanner moved that they pull the conditional use permit and �
disallow music to continue at Augusta's in an outside venue. Commissioner
Limont seconded the motion. Vice Chair Tschopp asked for any further
comments.
Ms. Aylaian clarified that the Commission was not actually pulling or revoking
the conditional use permit. They still need a CUP to operate the restaurant,
so they wanted to modify it to eliminate the outdoor music. Commissioners
Tanner and Limont modified their motion.
For clarification, Commissioner Schmidt said in the report at the back of the
packet, there presumably was the original CUP and portions are struck
through. Ms. Aylaian said yes, it is staff's recommendation that it be modified
so that it just reads as the remainder does after the strikeouts, so Items 1
and 2 stay in place; Items 3, 4 and 5 are deleted. Commissioner Schmidt
said that in essence that is revoking the outdoor permit for entertainment and
music. Ms. Aylaian said that was correct. Commissioner Schmidt asked if
that was Commissioner Tanner's intent. He said yes.
Vice Chair Tschopp called for the vote on the amended motion. Motion
carried 4-0-1 (with Chairperson Campbell's vote recorded as an abstention).
�
22
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION ___ JANUARY 15. 2008
(Someone from the audience asked to readdress the Commission. Vice Chair Tschopp
°� explained it was not the appropriate time.)
It was moved by Commissioner Tanner, seconded by Commissioner Limont,
adopting Planning Commission Resolution No. 2462 modifying Case No. 96-
15 (Amendment No. 3) eliminating Department of Community Development
Condition Nos. 3,4 and 5. Motion carried 4-0-1 (with Chairperson Campbell's
vote recorded as an abstention).
For clarification, Mr. Hargreaves said the record should reflect that the public
hearing was closed.
Chairperson Campbell returned to the meeting.
B. Case No. TPM 35741 -THE EVANS PROPERTY, Applicant
Request for approval of a tentative parcel map to subdivide a
5.3-acre parcel (Parcel 2 of PM 31515) into two parcels
approximately 2.762 and 2.567 acres in area for a property
located on the southwest corner of Gerald Ford Drive and
Cook Street at 36891 Cook Street.
� Ms. Schrader reviewed the staff report. She indicated a condition was
included about recording an update to the CC&R's, but the applicant brought
her a copy of them and they were fine and didn't need to be updated. It
addresses the reciprocal access agreement, it addresses the landscape
maintenance issue and it does address building maintenance issues, so that
condition could be struck. Other than that, staff recommended approval of
the parcel map.
Commissioner Schmidt noted there were five other parcels that were not part
of this. Ms. Schrader said that was correct. Commissioner Schmidt asked if
those were under separate ownership. Ms. Schrader believed they were
actually part of the larger map originally approved as Parcel Map 31515. She
said she would like to have the property owner address that issue.
Commissioner Schmidt expressed curiosity that all of the ingress and egress
/accesses are owned by each parcel in the division and wondered about the
rest of the buildings and any agreements with them that give them use.
Chairperson Campbell o�ened the public hearing and asked the applicant to
address the Commission.
...
23
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION JANUARY 1� 2008
MR. RICK EVANS came forward for the Village at University Park. He
stated his address as 36891 Cook Street, Suite 6, in Palm Desert. He �
believed the question asked was, number one, are there any other
parcels effected by this particular parcel split. He said no, this is the
only one. The original map, 31515, made this Parcel 2 of that map.
There are several parcels. All of these maps are covered in a set of
CC&R's that have been recorded and those particular documents lay
out the maintenance operation of everything on every parcel that is in
common, and it also lays out the responsibility of individual buildings
that might be owned by other individuals other than themselves. For
example, in this particular case, they are doing this for financing
reasons and that's it. Their permanent loan is available on one of the
buildings and not on the other building, so in order to finalize their
permanent financing on one building, they need to do this lot split.
The way the CC&R's are written, the owner of the largest parcel in
Parcel 2 is the manager of the common facilities in the entire parcel
if his family and their company are not the owners of any other
parcels. If they are owners of any one parcel, they are the manager
of everything. The CC&R's go further to explain that the maintenance
responsibility and the common area is for signage, landscaping,
parking lots, drainage, parking lot lighting--the whole potpourri of
things. He thought that answered the question. �
Commissioner Schmidt said yes, she just wanted to be certain that she
understood that these other parcels which were excluded have rights to the
parking and so forth.
Mr. Evans concurred.
Commissioner Schmidt noted it was a curious boundary.
Mr. Evans agreed that it was a really strange boundary map, but it's
all for financing.
Commissioner Schmidt thanked him.
There were no other questions for the applicant. Chairperson Campbell
asked for any testimony in FAVOR or OPPOSITION to this application.
There was none and she closed the public hearing and asked the
Commission for comments.
�
24
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION JANUARY 15. 2008
Action:
� It was moved by Commissioner Tschopp, seconded by Commissioner
Tanner, adopting the findings as presented by staff. Motion carried 5-0.
It was moved by Commissioner Tschopp, seconded by Commissioner
Tanner, adopting Planning Commission Resolution No. 2463 approving Case
No. TPM 35741, subject to conditions. Motion carried 5-0.
C. Case No. PP 07-04 - OCHOA DESIGN ASSOCIATES, Applicant
Request for recommendation of approval to the City Council of
a Precise Plan of Design to construct a 8,913 square foot
automotive tire facility with a tower element at 32 feet. Subject
property is located at 73-741 Spyder Circle (APN: 694-240-
011)
Mr. Stendell reviewed the staff report. The staff recommendation was that
Planning Commission recommend to City Council approval of the project. He
noted that both the architect and owner were present.
Vice Chair Tschopp asked what was inside the tower. It was unclear in the
� picture. Mr. Stendell said a tire.
There were no other questions for staff. Chairperson Campbell opened the
public hearing and asked the applicant to address the Commission.
MR. JUAN CARLOS OCHOA, the architect for the project, 73-626
Highway 111, clarified that what they see as a tire is more of a
sculptural element, which is the logo of the business. It wasn't going
to be a rubber tire hanging in that space, but the identity of the
business. He was present to answer any questions.
There were no questions of the applicant. Chairperson Campbell asked if
anyone wished to speak in FAVOR or OPPOSITION to the proposal. There
was no one and the public hearing was closed. Chairperson Campbell asked
for Commission comments.
Vice Chair Tschopp asked Mr. Stendell about the south side, which has
residential, and if there was a setback between this building on the south
side. Mr. Stendell explained that when adjacent to a residential zone or
across the street, the Service Industrial zone requires a 25-foot setback from
property line. In this case, they are across 35th Avenue from residentially
zoned property, so in this circumstance the project does have a 25-foot 3-
�
25
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION JANUARY 15. 2008
inch setback from the rear property line along 35th Avenue. They were also
dealing with a property line wall and some distance of landscaped parkway, �
sidewalk, and then curb and 35th Avenue across the street to residential. It
meets the standards for when directly adjacent to residential. In other
circumstances, there is no requirement for an interior rear property line. Vice
Chair Tschopp thanked him.
Chairperson Campbell asked for any other questions or comments.
Commissioner Limont said she didn't like the tower. She knew they could do
this within 30 feet. They didn't need an extra two feet. She took great pride
in the fact that Palm Desert doesn't have billboards along the highway and
didn't want to see a tower with a tire in it. Other than that, she thought it was
just fine, it was wonderful. She knew that lobbing it off was a very pedestrian
way to approach it, but wanted it lobbed off.
Commissioner Schmidt agreed totally. She couldn't vote in favor of this
marvelous project with a billboard on top of it. If the tire was removed, she
thought it would be great.
Vice Chair Tschopp stated that when he looked at the building he wasn't in
love with the tower and obviously he couldn't figure out what it was. He didn't
normally didn't have a problem with tower elements when they work into the �
architectural design of the building. Here he agreed that it was more of an
advertising statement as opposed to an architectural element. So he wasn't
crazy about the tower and thought it should be brought down, maybe
redesigned a little bit, and he could live with it. He thought it would be a very
fine project.
Commissioner Tanner concurred.
Chairperson Campbell stated that she also liked the building, the great
architecture and the lines of it. The tower tire was like a billboard and if it was
lowered, fine, otherwise she concurred with her other commissioners.
Chairperson Campbell asked if there was a motion.
Commissioner Schmidt noted they had some options. They could turn it
down entirely or they could approve it with a condition to remove the tower.
She thought the 26-foot height limit to match the rest of the building would
be her recommendation.
Commissioner Limont suggested 30 feet. She said the building has finro other
similar elements. Commissioner Schmidt asked if that would be without the
tire; Commissioner Limont concurred. Vice Chair Tschopp asked if that was
�
26
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION_ _ JANUARY 15. 2008
motion. Commissioner Schmidt said yes. Vice Chair Tschopp seconded the
�- motion.
Action:
It was moved by Commissioner Schmidt, seconded by Vice Chair Tschopp,
approving the project with a maximum height of 30 feet and elimination of the
tire element.
Before the vote was taken, Ms. Aylaian asked for clarification as to whether
or not the Commission wanted to see the redesign back before them or if it
was something satisfied with staff review, as long as it meets the terms.
Chairperson Campbell didn't think it needed to come back. They specified
the 30 feet, and then it could go to Council. Ms. Aylaian said that without the
tower, it didn't need to go to Council, the Planning Commission's decision
would be final. Commissioner Schmidt thought that if the architect could
speak, he would probably tell them he was going to remove the tire, but he
can't, so she didn't want to turn down his project. She felt if the building was
brought into compliance without a tire feature in what was to be a 30-foot
tower, it didn't need to come back to them.
Commissioner Tanner suggested that it be consistent with the other similar
roof elements. There are a couple of cylinder units or squared-off units in
silver. If the architect could bring that tire element down to be more
� consistent with that line, the tire would be eliminated, which he thought was
not consistent with what they'd like to see happen; they didn't want a
billboard on top of the building and they didn't want advertising on top of the
building. If the architect could be consistent with the line, bringing it down to
whaYs acceptable, he thought it would be acceptable to the Planning
Commission. Commissioner Schmidt stated that she wasn't keen on the tire
element at any height.
Chairperson Campbell reiterated that the motion was for approval of 30-feet
without the tire element. She called for the vote. Motion carried 5-0.
It was moved by Commissioner Schmidt, seconded by Vice Chair Tschopp,
adopting Planning Commission Resolution No. 2464 approving Case No. PP
07-04 as amended, subject to conditions. Motion carried 5-0.
D. Case Nos. CUP 07-06 and PP 07-05 - JEWISH FEDERATION OF
PALM SPRINGS, Applicant
Request for approval of Conditional Use Permit 07-06, Precise
Plan 07-05, and a Mitigated Negative Declaration of
....
27
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION JANUARY 15. 2008
Environmental Impact as it pertains thereto, to allow
construction of a new 18,166 square foot private K-6 school +�
building located in a PR-5 residential zone for the Jewish
Federation of Palm Springs on a ten-acre property located on
the southwest corner of Portola Avenue and Julie Lane at 36-
333 Portola Avenue.
Ms. Schrader reviewed the staff report and recommended that the granting
of the conditional use permit and subsequent precise plan would not create
any negative impacts, and that the Planning Commission adopt the findings
and adopt a Planning Commission resolution to approve the subject
property, with conditions attached.
With regard to the parking, Commissioner Limont asked if they were
requiring trees in the parking lot as with other facilities. Ms. Schrader said
yes. Referring to a power point image, she showed the location of the
entrances, including Shepherd Lane and the emergency access on Portola.
She pointed out the parking lot and said the trees have been approved by
the City's Landscape Specialist to be appropriate in size and number. _
Commissioner Schmidt said that in driving around the property, particularly
on Shepherd, she noticed that the change in elevation from the street level
to the top of the lot is fourto five feet depending on where you are. When the �
elevations of the building were shown at 20 feet, she asked what plane that
was at; was it the street level? Ms. Schrader said that was a good question
and responded that the elevations were shown primarily from the Julie Lane
viewpoint, but the area where the buildings are is proposed to be graded to
be at basically street level, almost street elevation with Julie. She said
Commissioner Schmidt was right that there is a retention wall and the
elevation continues to get higher. There was actually quite a difference from
the rear or south end of the property to this. There was almost a ten-foot
drop in elevation. Pointing to the image, she said there is some pretty strong
grading that happens right between the spot where trees are placed and the
playground, which is a combination playground and retention area, and then
a higher area. But the buildings themselves are set at the lowest portion of
the property.
Commissioner Schmidt said she asked that because there is a considerable
residential development existing around it and if a 20-foot building is set five
or six feet higher, it would tower over those homes. What she saw was the
developed area approximately ten feet lower than the rest of the periphery.
If that was right, it was okay with her. She also expressed concern with the
transmission lines. She assumed that was why there is such a large setback,
but those lines concerned her near children. Ms. Schrader asked if she
�
28
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION _ JANUARY 15. 2008
meant the electrical poles. Commissioner Schmidt said they are the high
� powered lines that don't get buried, or she didn't think they could be. But they
run entirely north and south a long way along Portola. She just worried about
that.
Commissioner Schmidt also noted that the parking is front loaded off of
Portola, which is allowable in the setback under those lines. She thought
they were transmission lines and they are there and were not like a phone
line where they can bury the pole. Ms. Schrader indicated that no one from
the Public Works Department was present, but she knew there was a
wooden-type electrical pole right on the corner of Portola and Julie, but
exactly the size or frequency of the poles and how they operate she didn't
know. Ms. Aylaian explained that there are high-voltage transmission lines
that run north-south on Portola. The City would love to see them
undergrounded, but it was clearly beyond the scope of this project or any
project of this size. Commissioner Schmidt said she understood, she was
just concerned about the use of the ground around those power lines. Ms.
Aylaian noted that there were a couple of other schools along Portola.
Vice Chair Tschopp asked if it was correct that the only access is off of Julie
Lane and Shepherd Lane. Ms. Schrader replied that the regular automobile
access that would bring the school students and/or family visitors would enter
� through Julie Lane and Shepherd Lane. There is an emergency access on
the Portola side for Fire Department access. With the times of drop off and
pick up, Vice Chair Tschopp asked if staff considered the need to stack cars
on either Shepherd or Julie. Ms. Schrader said they didn't take a look at that
aspect because it is such a small school. Vice Chair Tschopp said it is at this
time, but it was his understanding that the Federation would like to expand
in the future. He said he could save that question for the applicant.
For the future expansion of the school where they currently would have wild
flowers, Chairperson Campbell noted they have single family homes
adjacent to it. Ms. Schrader said yes, to the south. Chairperson Campbell
said they would eventually have buildings there with parking and
playgrounds. She asked if that was correct. Ms. Schrader said eventually, but
thought the project proponent would have a better idea of their proposed
expansion.
Chairperson Campbell o�ened the public hearing and asked the applicant to
address the Commission.
MR. ALLEN NEIMAN, as 919 Inverness Drive in Rancho Mirage,
informed the Commission that he is on the Board of the Jewish
Federation of Palm Springs and Desert Area, which was named a
�
29
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION JANUARY 15 2008
long time ago before Palm Desert was incorporated. He explained
that the original plans that were approved by the Planning �
Commission and City Council were for a ten-acre project which
included swimming pools and a soccer field. It came to their attention
that was something they couldn't afford to do. So they looked at it
again and really decided to downsize the project. They then decided
to go with five acres. The other five acres they have absolutely no
plans for and didn't see any need in the immediate future for anything.
Of course, if anything was going to be developed on that property, the
five acres, they would come before the City Planning Commission,
Architectural, etc. They had no plans whatsoever. The school itself at
this present time has 63 students, so he thought right now they were
planning on eight or nine classrooms. It's really relatively small. He
said most of the parents car pool. The traffic will not really be a
consideration. They would also have Jewish Family Service offices
and then the Federation offices, but no other types of offices.
Mr. Neiman noted that both Jewish Family Service, although it has
that name, serves 60% non-Jewish people. The school itself is
nonsectarian. They don't have too many non-Jewish children, but they
do have some and accept them. There was absolutely no bias that
way. He asked for any questions. (There were no questions.) Mr.
Neiman said that Mr. Ricciardi could also answer questions. '
�
MR. ROBERT RICCIARDI, the project architect, 75-400 Gerald Ford
Drive, Suite 115, in Palm Desert, California, addressed the
Commission. Regarding the transmission lines, He said the Public
Works Department was very concerned about them, so they had them
set back a little bit farther. The school is the building farthest to the
west. The kids would be playing in the play yard, but they would be
quite a distance from the high transmission lines, so they didn't see
any power problems coming from that. The building closest to the
power lines is split between Jewish Federation and Jewish Family
Services. They were basically offices.
He explained that the kids would be dropped off in front. They have
a drop-off lane for them in the plan so they can be dropped off. Most
of the kids would really be coming by bus rather than cars, so they
have places for the bus to stay there during the day. They would pick
up the kids and bring them in the morning. Mr. Ricciardi said they
worked very closely with the landscape staff. They had quite a few
meetings with staff, with Ms. Aylaian and the Planning staff and
Renee. The Architectural Review Board liked the plans and the look
of the building and everything.
�
30
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION __ JANUARY 15. 2008
Mr. Ricciardi also said they agreed with everything in the conditions.
� They thought they had a very fine looking building. They kept it low
key and not very tall because of the residential, so it wouldn't look like
a typical school that they see in public schools with the big flying roofs
that architecturally try to make a big statement. They tried to keep it
lower down because of the residential. The back property line has a
slope where they would have a lot of trees and a nice park-like setting
and that playground. They wouldn't see a bunch of things that were
normally seen: basketballs, chain-link fences; they wouldn't have any
of that in this school facility.
Mr. Ricciardi said they did have very nice decorative walls on all the
streets except for Julie Lane. He thought they have a very nice project
that would be very complementary to the city. He was available to
answer any questions.
Commissioner Schmidt asked if the entire parcel was deeded as one plat.
Mr. Ricciardi answered that right now it is finro, but it will be deeded as
one. That would be a condition of approvat.
Commissioner Schmidt indicated that included the future development area.
� Mr. Ricciardi said yes, because they are going in there now to take
care of their retention areas so that they don't have these big huge
things on the ground. The big cost there was they moved the water
retention area back to the other project, so it will be really one piece
of ground. If they ever wanted to re-subdivide that, they would have
to come back to the Planning Commission for approval. He said they
do have room for expansion, and some day they would grow because
Palm Desert is one of the fastest growing communities around and
the whole desert is exploding. They are in a recession now because
of the residential, but his business is still very good right now with the
commercial.
Vice Chair Tschopp asked if the project had any special landscaping or art.
Mr. Ricciardi said they had some artistic design in the architecture.
Vice Chair Tschopp clarified that he meant just on the corner at Julie Lane.
Mr. Ricciardi stated that they were handling that right now with
landscaping on Julie Lane. Staff says they might have some ideas.
On the grading plan they have a little retaining wall there and nice
.w.�
31
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION JANUARY 15 2008
landscaping in there. He pointed out a very decorative wall and the
meandering sidewalk which he said ties in with the rest of the street. �+
There was a meandering sidewalk along Julie.
Chairperson Campbell said she has the same question as Commissioner
Tschopp in regard to stacking of the cars, because there have been
problems at Lincoln School and Carter School. Even when Carter School put
in that extra lane, people still take the two lanes and there is always a
problem there. Here they were going to be around single-family homes that
are going to be complaining about the traffic.
Mr. Ricciardi explained that it won't be like most public schools
because most public schools are way under car parked. Here they
were not, so people who are bringing their kids by private automobile
have a lot of car parking spaces. They can just stop and wait for the
kids or wait out in front.
Chairperson Campbell asked for clarification that cars would be able to be
parked inside the compound and not just on the street.
Mr. Ricciardi said there was no parking on the street; they are way
over car parked on this project because of that. And with an
expansion, they would be able to judge it then because in four, five or �
six years, whenever they come back with an expansion, they will have
a track record on what is happening here. But right not they are way
over car parked, so people can park their cars and then go and wait
at the front door for their children. They don't have to pick their
children up. The other problems that occur with kids is when they are
walking home or doing a lot of different things and they won't have
that problem here. Most of the kids will be bussed in.
Chairperson Campbell noted that when this was first approved years ago,
they did have some letters of complaint from the neighbors regarding having
a school there and the noise. They wanted to have peace and quiet. She
hasn't seen any letters.
Mr. Ricciardi indicated they have a different project; they don't have
soccer fields, there wouldn't be a lot of activities after school, and it
was more of an academic school, K-6 or 5.
Chairperson Campbell said they would be quiet children.
Mr. Ricciardi said no, they would be kids, but it's less than 70 kids and
would be a lot lower key than a normal public school.
�
32
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION ____ JANUARY 15. 2008
There were no other questions. Chairperson Campbell thanked Mr. Ricciardi.
� She then asked for testimony in FAVOR or OPPOSITION to this application.
MS. PATRICIA ROSBURG, 74-074 Scholar Lane West between
Monterey, Portola and Gerald Ford, said there is already a fair
amount of traffic on Portola. All the new houses east of them haven't
been built yet, but she has been around a lot of public schools and
private schools where the cars do stack up and there is no entrance
from Shepherd to this school. They have to wander through the
neighborhood from Frank Sinatra down to Shepherd, which connects
to Julie Lane,which goes into Portola. Everybody will be coming down
Portola or up Portola from Gerald Ford or down from Highway 111.
There was really only one way in there because they weren't going to
be meandering through that neighborhood to Julie Drive as was
suggested. They were going from Portola into that school parking lot,
jamming up on Portola. There was no other way for them to go. She
knew they have had this property for quite some time. This is zoned
residential property and it should stay that way. There are one-story
houses all over. The City keeps approving variances of roofs, towers,
and variances for air-conditioning units and she thought it is just
getting carried away where pretty soon nobody was going to have a
view of anything. She said it will be noisy; children are noisy, she
� didn't care what they said.
Chairperson Campbell asked if there was anyone else wishing to speak.
There was no response.
Mr. Ricciardi came forward to offer rebuttal comments. He pointed out
that the City has a red light there at Julie and that is to go into the
development to the east. He said it is a well-controlled intersection
and traffic won't be jamming up. The City has already planned for this
to have a signal there at that intersection. It is already there.
Ms. Rosburg said the main problem is befinreen Frank Sinatra coming
down to Portola where the City has still not put a light in there. People
constantly run the stop signs like they don't exist. To put a light on
Julie Drive when there is nothing built across the street yet, it just
didn't solve the problem. Just put the light on Julie. They have to put
one on Frank Sinatra also.
Ms. Aylaian advised that the Public Works Department has scheduled to
install the light at Frank Sinatra and Portola in the not too distant future. She
couldn't tell them the exact date, but she could look into that.
.�
33
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION JANUARY 15 2008
Commissioner Schmidt noted that there is a light at Julie now. Staff
concurred. Commissioner Schmidt asked the applicant what kind of night �
time activity there would be at the school.
Mr. Neiman said that since the school is in session, they've really
never had any night time activities at all. He couldn't recall any. There
are teacher meetings held during the day. The school is pretty well
closed at four or five o'clock in the afternoon. He said he knew they
made plenty of room for them to come in and be on the school
property to pick up the children and he has been at the school when
parents have dropped off and picked up their children, and they were
talking about just a handful of cars. They only have 63 students and
it would go up over that amount, he hoped. He said there isn't any
traffic and he thought they didn't have any activities at night.
Commissioner Tanner asked if there were any planned social events, fund
raisers or street fair type of operations, Saturday or Sunday events.
Mr. Neiman said no. It's possible that once a year they might have a
daytime function on a Sunday, but he didn't anticipate any fund
raisers there. They usually do that offsite at hotels or something. But
they might. Once a year they have an event for the holocaust
remembrance; they usually have that at the City park. They might `
have some activities on a Sunday for a holiday, but that was about it. �
There were no other questions. Chairperson Campbell closed the public
hearing and asked for comments from the Commission.
Vice Chair Tschopp thought it was a very good project, much reduced in
scope from what they had seen previously, and he thought it would fit in very
well with the neighborhood. So he was very much in favor.
Commissioner Tanner concurred. He was very much in favor also. He
thought it was a good location and as Mr. Ricciardi said, things will continue
to grow and he thought it was a good spot for it. He wished them luck.
Commissioner Limont said she liked the project. She also agreed with
Commissioner Tschopp that they needed to always be aware of the traffic
issue. She knew they kept an eye on it, especially with the schools in the
area. She thought it was wonderful.
Commissioner Schmidt thought what was interesting was, and they have all
read this, that a residential development on the same ground will increase
the car traffic and would have 24-hour usage. That was one of the things she
..r
34
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION__ JANUARY 15. 2008
looked at to see the difference. This was a much lower use than a residential
«� community for car trips per day. Commissioner Tanner said triple.
Commissioner Schmidt concurred.
Chairperson Campbell stated that she wasn't in favor of the project when it
originally came before the Planning Commission years ago, because she
didn't think it was a very good location. Now that the school is smaller, and
hopefully it would stay that small, otherwise she was concerned about the
surrounding neighbors and the noise, keeping the peace and quiet. They've
had complaints regarding the Catholic School on Deep Canyon. The school
was there first and the people came later. That's one thing. But now the
people are here first and the school is coming later. She was so-so with it
and it wasn't because she is a religious person, but she would go along with
the other Commissioners, but with doubts. Hopefully when anything comes
in front of them regarding the rest of the property they would look at it a lot
closer.
Action:
It was moved by Vice Chair Tschopp, seconded by Commissioner Limont,
adopting the findings as presented by staff. Motion carried 5-0.
It was moved by Vice Chair Tschopp, seconded by Commissioner Limont,
� adopting Planning Commission Resolution No. 2465 approving Case Nos.
CUP 07-06 and PP 07-05, subject to conditions. Motion carried 5-0.
Commissioner Tanner wished them good luck. Mr. Neiman thanked them.
IX. MISCELLANEOUS
None.
X. COMMITTEE MEETING UPDATES
A. ART IN PUBLIC PLACES - No meeting.
B. LANDSCAPE BEAUTIFICATION - No meeting.
C. PROJECT AREA 4 COMMITTEE - (Next meeting will be March 2008)
D. PARKS & RECREATION - No meeting.
XI. ELECTION OF OFFICERS AND COMMITTEE LIAISONS
A. Election of Chairperson and Vice Chairperson
Chairperson Campbell suggested Vice Chairperson Tschopp as the Chair
and Commissioner Tanner as the Vice Chair. Commissioner Tschopp was
w.
35
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION JANUARY 15 2008
a little hesitant to accept being Chair if it was difficult for people to
understand what he was trying to say. He asked for comments. He said if .�
there was a concern, he would be happy to step aside. Chairperson
Campbell said she was standing in the back earlier and she could
understand him. Commissioner Tanner asked if it was painful to speak. Vice
Chair Tschopp said no. Commissioner Schmidt suggested that they try it and
see. It was determined that if at any time he wasn't able to do it,
Commissioner Tanner would step in.
.
Action:
It was moved by Chairperson Campbell, seconded by Commissioner Limont,
electing Dave Tschopp as Chairperson and Van Tanner as Vice Chairperson
by minute motion. Motion carried 5-0.
B. Appointment of an Art in Public Places Representative,
Appointment of a Landscape Committee Representative,
Appointment of a Parks & Recreation Commission
Representative, and Appointment of a Project Area 4 Committee
Representative.
After some discussion, it was determined that Sonia Campbell would remain
the Art in Public Places representative, Connor Limont would remain the
Landscape Committee representative, Van Tanner would remain as the �
Parks and Recreation representative, and Mari Schmidt agreed to be the
Project Area 4 representative. Ms. Aylaian informed her that the committee
meets the third Monday of the month at 3:00 p.m. in the Administrative
Conference Room and the staff liaison is Dave Yrigoyen in the
Redevelopment Agency. She said they've been meeting quarterly.
Action:
It was moved by Commissioner Tschopp, seconded by Commissioner
Tanner, by minute motion appointing Sonia Campbell as the Art in Public
Places representative, appointing Connor Limont as the Landscape
Committee representative, appointing Van Tanner as the Parks& Recreation
Commission representative, and appointing Mari Schmidt as the Project Area
4 Committee representative. Motion carried 5-0.
XII. COMMENTS
None.
..riwr
36
F
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION JANUARY 15. 2008
�. XIII. ADJOURNMENT
Chairperson Campbell adjourned the meeting at 8:17 p.m.
� .------�
� �� �
i' '� �--�
`� LAURI AYLAIAN, Secretary
ATTEST:
SONIA M. CAMPBELL, Chairperson
Palm Desert Planning Commission
/tm
�
..�.
37
�MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT A JANUARY 15,2008
� ` * ��
� , � "�
�
�
�
1
� CITY t3F PA�M DESERT
..�
�
�
�
PLANNlNG DEPARTMENT
�
INTEROFFfCE IwAEMORANDUM
�
�
� Ta: Hart Ponder Jr., Code Compiiance Manager
�
�
� From: Johnny Terfehr, Cade Compliance Officer
�
� Date: January 14, 2008
Subjec� Augusta's Night-Time Sound Levets I
� 4n Saturday January 12, 2008 I perfarmed sound measurements at A ' �
ugusta s
Restaurant. Five measurements were taken, ail from the nearest residential property ,
line (same location as was done previously). ,
�
;, The first measurement started at 10:50 PM and continued for ten minutes. The average '
# A weighted sound level was 55.13 decibels. The band was piaying du�ing this ten
� minute period.
�
�� The second measurement started at 11;00 PM and was far ten minutes. The average A
weighted sound level was 56.02 decibeis. The band was playmg during this ten minute I
� period.
£
�
} The third measurement started at 11:10 PM and was for ten minutes. The average A
'� weighted sound level was 54.24 decibels. The band was playing during this ten minute
� period.
� '
` The fourth measuremen# started at 11:20 PM and was for ten minutes. The average A
''� weighted sound level was 54.82 decibels. The band was playing during this ten minute
period.
:; The fifth measurement (dane concurrently on a second meter} started at 1 Q:50 PM and
� was for 43 minutes. The band played the entire pe�iod. The average A weighted saund
� level was 55.45 decibels.
�
, Officer Shawn Kilpatrick was also present and here a�e his findings:
.�
,
° "On Satur+day night, between 10:30 PM and 11:30 PM I monitored sound levels from fhe
following locations; her� ar�e my obseivations:
�
M�,���._�.___---
-- - — _ _ _ _ _
, PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT A JANUARY 15,2008
� €
� I�Aerna Tea: H�rt P"c�r�ef�r, Jr.
�E: t�u�usta's �i'c���-T�me Saunci Lev�ls
��� 1t1�2�E�C F'2[qe 2
1Q.53 P'lV�: Shado�Lafce f�rive and Ma�ur�ta�'r� �'ae�r�r. f tnra� abte fe� clea�ly�hear �
� "�-t�artsche TQni�hf"arrd "Gr�l, Ya�e R�afdy G��� l�e�g,. i
.� 11:�? F'�: Sh�dvw l�fauntain Tennis Re�ar�ae�c��F-�t�te��. � ��s a�b�le to� �ear the band ���
�� pfaying and lv�'s of y�flirrg v�hile �f�rrdfng c�n F�e ��r�rr���c�e�rt. �ec�e��d�a0ear�y hear a
;b r�ndi�rart of a "Prrnce"sang.
�
11:19 PIV�t: At Carrdfewood Aparfinenfs, 1 could�fea�y hear"`Fr�ak 4uf'.
t arf hear"Brick House".
11:23 PM: A�the comer of Farrway and Portata, 6�ot��d c e y
ft should be noted that�he new "sound curtains"tfra�v�ere suppvsed to be behind the
stage were not in place. The mattresses wer� Ir�,�fac+�, but no lvviver curtains were
instalted below ftr�m."
i nt sound level measurements? '
� Attached a owmg the pert ne
r;
nny Terfehr
� Code Compliance Officer
G:'�odt�id+rmY terteP+rM1y Cocu^x'^ts�rste�Ot t26B dac
�
---__.______-- __._
µ MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT A JANUARY 15,2008
�
�
1� �
� `t a
u;
C� `^ �
M
m
�=i
�
� � i
a
,� a �
�n �
0
� ;
00 �
a
N I
� �
� N r I
e-1 �n �
� M �
h
jV
i.� I
� I
1 I
O I
I
� I
� j
•� �
L
� I
� �
� !
� I
�
� II
�
�
� � �
d
__ ------------- -
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT A JANUARY 15,2008
. �
�
�
�
� "' . . ...,.. . s
, a I
m � �
r` N I
ri
r-�
� I
� � I
� �
�
a
a�
a�
�
�
L� N
•_ �
C � __
C a
Qj °`? o
� ~ �
4D �.-�
M1 �
d� W I
� p� �, � �
�
N " �
.
N � � �
; �"� , i
7 i i � �
� (Q p
(!q � N J
` � Q ■
� �
�
� . � i
� a
a � �
� �
auo ^ � I
c
.�
� '� �,
;;� .�,, '�
�
� `
H
+'a
�
�
i` 3 "'
�
�A u;
� �'
Q � ,_ �
a
f�J �
n
O
r-1
r�
ic
I
� i
I
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
� j u m���
_�<.�.��._ . � �j.16/�,i�`
_. . ..
� _____.._ ___ �, ,
��� �� � , ;
� ��,�, � t
`�o�� � � � � � ������� � �� �� � � � �4
�
r-� 'c�
; � � � : � ;
. ,
� �r. • m � �^ ___�..�.:�_._.. � � '� � �
�__.� E � '
, � � � � ��
E '� , . '
_ �m
� .__... _. ___---.
� �� � � � �:a o ��
�h- �, .
�� � z o a ���
� � m
, w � ��
� � ,
N � � `' �.` �
� �° I `
� � � � �_ .� ,
� Q � � �
�, � r ; �
N � -�
� � :t' �; � �
� � � (
F+ W � � (
I -� "^�-�
�� a � �' �, � (
1 Q, _,., ,�, ,,,.,,,, .
I,CV[ � � i , , t�i � � � C�.�
4 _ — ____ � . _ .�
4 T .�.uL
d�� �� . � � � � �
i `
' i� ,,,,J . — — °� -- L2= ' Sp c�`�
-- -- ,.�
� -
� i � _....r.. � ` ^�, O ` � '�
8
- - ,.._. �
a7 I +� � � i - z
� 1 � '��� � � �, ' � ' '��1 � _
� ' +-' �y ; — - -. ,_. _ . .
c � ,, - I,
� . , , �
� � � � ' � �
` �
i i
� ,
�� � � ' ' �
�
� i
� r ' � �
G1 f � � �.�. � -- — `�"' i
_�- ' � �
� ' � �
, �
cn� � __ � � — �c
- � r �
�. � - _..._ , � �� -R �;
��� V � � ��,,� � �
.... � � �
, , � _
ca
( N; ,n � � I � � k
� � �
.� ��.
, �.. _..___ —.
�
�,°'��+� .v . � _..... _
� i � � : � � � J �
€ 1� '�t/1 � ""'�-,_ ' � � � � � -
P
_� _ c_ss �.
` 1,� ' +y C...�` �. . ,— -- C s J
� _
. 2
M1 ,^ »�
� �
y�( C � "L7 ! p -1
� �„ �_� O � . �� -- �� --- - I �
Q ��I� d �, I � l
,
� '� `
, I _... �
i �
� i. - ��. __. E � , � 3
� � {
� i �.,, � ! :. s , �. I I 2 �
�-' � � . . � � � F - � ; � � � �
`--
�, ,__ _--�- � �e - , a �, °
i� a � ' � �
, r Q ' � a 4 ��
a� , � . �
� u
o � o � o 0 0 0 4 0 0 =
Li � '� O C�?1 tl�D � c�D u�7 ��Q' c'3 N Q � V1 _.- ,
43 �
y � �
ro r.,
� � -� � �
� � � Y � �
� pf �� � _, � o � �n u� c��t �
�` 'j _ , .� �( ��� �i +�' � � S ♦ ♦
I °' � 'o ' ,� '; � o '� ' � �
� � �o ; � ° ca ,
, �, t� � i t� '� " . w " - e �
� `-j� L w , ', m � >. .� cn ,�, z ,r, �
vf �- m � c�,3 u- �''i � '°� �
' ��� �, � � rn E � � l �� � � `O ' t�
�
cn _. r _`—_
� ,
, � ..�ra � i� .
._.___
� I.....__—_ ____. „ �
_ �,
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
i
�
; .w_ew_t_n�m_��
R
�c— � �7 ; �`J �—
�, ��.. �t�► � � u�C' z- �t"V
�
�"*�; i " I
i
. ;
t .�
�-' � � �
8' *��e
.� ..� �
� � -� � 6�"�
� � ���,. �e�r�,�" -� q.� � � � �
.--- -*.•..., ..
` .�,. �.��-3.- -,� n,�r�a
..�_.
'�� `..�
�
�` .:_? ;
��� �
.�
�� , �� � '�
��,, � �
� � �
�
� � � �
� � �
...' r�,
� � i
� :, �
� �
�a;
�a
��3 °; � �
s �
�
���..A� �'�, �
�;., �
t�}' �' � � � �
��§� �
�� ��!u � �
; �, 'W". �
��y, � �
��� �� � � � �
s� ,��;
,, ���� '�"„'
�''� � ��
d' �
� „��• �� �
:�,`` —,� � � � �� _
+c '�--" -�r` �I )
� � ,� a.�r-'
��� �
a
��;,
;�
r-
MINUTES JANUARY 15,2008
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSI01� EXHIBIT B
�
r'i
' index ---date--- --time-- Sounci Level unit
1 12-22-2007 2Q:16:51 52.5 �� � � ��
2 12-22-20b"I 20:16.52 53.6 �B �
3 I2-22-2007 20:16:53 58.p dB
4 12-22-2�tJ7 20:36:54 5h.9 �� j�
5 12-22-2007 20:16:55 55.6 d� �/j� ���'
6 12-22-2.Of17 20:16:56 ��.4 d� ��`�,, t�' �,.
7 12-22-2C)07 2t7:26:57 Sl.] d� ys �
8 12-22-2n(37 2U:16:5$ 50.5 dB �
9 12-22-7.007 ?.Os16:55 52.� d� ��+ �
10 L2-22-20Q7 2Q:1�:00 �9.� �g { �� �'�"��
11 12-22-2007 2Q:17:01 ��.� `�B �(1I
i2 12-22-ZOQ7 2(1:17:92 ��.� �g
13 12-22-2007 �G:i�t:03 4�.7 �s
?4 12-22-20C?7 2b:17:04 50.4 dB
15 12-'L"L-2007 7[1:17:05 51.2 ��
i£ 1Z-22-20�?7 2C�:1�:06 �l.$ �� ��
I7 12-22-20D7 20:17:07 50.6 dB
I8 12-22-ZC)07 20:1"7:0$ 51.$ d8
19 12-22-2007 20:17:09 51.9 dB
�� I2-22-2007 20:17:1d '�1.� ��
21 12-22-200`r 2q:17:11 51 .5 dB
?_2 32-22-20t�7 20:I7:12 53.A dB
23 12-22-2007 20:1?.1.3 52.2 d8
29 12-?.2.-20Q7 2Q:17:19 52.7 dB
2S 12-22-2D1�7 2Q:17:i5 5"l.l dB
26 12-22-2CJ�? ?.0:17:16 ��.4 ��
27 12-22-2007 2Q:1?:l7 �4.fi d�
28 12-2?_-2Q07 2C1:17:1f3 56.2 d�
29 12-?2-2.�07 20:17:19 51.8 ci8
30 12-22-2007 20:17:20 52.9 d8
31 12-22-20p7 2q:17:21 Sq.9 dB
32 12-22-2007 2():1"7:22 `��.� d�
33 12-22-2007 20:17:23 51.1 d8
34 12-22-2Q07 2(J.17t29 51 .1 d�
��.p dB
35 12-2.2-2QU`� 20:1"7:25 S�.Q dH
36 12-22-2007 2Q:17:26 dB
37 12-27-2007 2Q:17:27 52.7 dE�
38 12-22-2007 20:]7:28 dB
39 1?.-22-2007 20:17,29 ��.�
40 12-22-2�Q7 20:17:30 53.5 dB
� ��.� dB
4l 12-22-2p07 20:17:31 d8
42 12-?_2-2(�4a 20:1�:32 ��.A
93 12-22-2007 20:17:33 52.8 d8
55.q ciI3
44 12-22-2QtJ7 20:2"1:39 dB
95 12-22-20t77 2(3:1�7:35 5�t.9
�"� 96 12-22-'LQ07 2�:1"1:36 59.2 d8
� 4"I 22-22-2407 20:17:37 54.0 d$
54.2 �8
4� 12-22-2007 2G.3"J:3S e1B
A9 12-?_7-2097 2d:1?:�9 �y.�
50 12-22-2Q0� 20:17:Af7 �`'.�' ��
�1 12-22-2Q(J1 ?Q:17:91 54.3 d�
52 12-22-2�p7 20:17:A2 55.2 dB
53 12-22-20n7 2Q;17:43 55.1 �a
56.4 d�
54 i2-22-?Ot�? 20:17:44 55.� dH
55 12-22-2C1Q7 20:1'I:AS 58.1 dR
56 12-22-2C)Q7 20:17.46 �B
57 i'1-22-`lGOI 2fl:17:97 57.9 d�
5B 12-22-2007 20:17:48 55.2
59 12-22-2007 2Q:17:49 5E�.2 dB
60 12-22-200"? 2fii:17:5Q 57.8 �
61 12-22-2t�07 20:17:51 6I.1 dB
62 12-22-2007 20:17:5a 58.8 d$
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
` 59.'I dB
63 12-22-2007 20:]7:53 �'l.9 d�
64 12-22-200? 20:17:59 �3 Z d6
65 12-22-2q0? 20:i'1:55 59.G dB
66 12-22-20a� 2Q:17:56 53.6 dB
67 12-22-2007 20:1�:5? 4g.9 dB
68 za-z2-zao� 2(�:17:58 � d8
69 12-22-20G7 20:17:59 5�.6 da
"70 12.-`l.'_-2bt�7 20:18:Q0 51.3 �B
71 12-22-20Q7 2Q:i8:01 �p.'l ��
72 12-22-2QC�`i 20:1€3:0'l 49.1 d8
73 12-22-2007 20:ie:Q3 �Q.O ci8
74 12-22-20Q7 2U:18:04 A9.�3 d6
75 12-2'L-2047 20a1$:Q5 52.2 d�
76 Y2-22-IUUJ 70:18:06 5p.7 ��
"]7 12-22-20�7 20:18:n'] �n.S dB
�8 12-'12-2b07 20:18:(�8 ,3.3 dB
"79 12-22-2(707 2b:1H:09 52.8 c3B
80 12-22-aoQ7 2Q:18:10 56.1 dB
81 12-22-2007 2Q:18:II 53.?_ dB
82 1"Z-22-2007 20s18:12 �� o ��
83 12-22-2007 20:18:13 �S.Q d8
84 12-22-2(�t�7 20:lfl:ld 55.1 CIB
85 12-22-2007 20:i8:15 �4.� dB
86 12-22-20Q7 20:18:16 51.9 dB
87 12-22-2�0"7 20:1$:1� 50.9 dB
98 12-22-2007 20:18:18 50.5 dB
89 12-'L2-20Q7 2t�:18:19 50.7 dB
90 12-22-2(1Q�7 20:18:20 50.8 d8
91 12-22-2Q07 20:18:21 51.6 dB
q2 12-?..2-^c007 20:18:22 ��.� d�
53 12-22-�Q07 2q:18.23 5Q.3 �
A4 12-2?.-2Q07 2p:18:29 52.9 dB
95 12-22-200? 2Q:I8:25 �3.7 �a
96 12-22-2q�7 20:18:26 51 ,6 da
97 12-22-"L(?07 2q:18:27 50.2 da
98 12-22-'1007 20:18:28 51.2 dB
99 12-22-2007 2Q:I8:29 52.1 dB
iQ0 12-22-'lOQ7 2Q:1$:30 �� ,� dB
1pl 12-22-20p7 Z0:18:31 5�.9 dB
102 12-22-2�1U7 2U:7E3z32 �4..7 dB
103 12-22-20Q7 20:18:33 64.8 dB
109 12-2Z-200"3 20:18:34 52.3 d�
1�5 12-22-200"l 20:18:35 53.� dH
106 12-22-2�107 2D:18:36 53 � dB
147 12-22-200"7 2Q:1f3:37 5� 5 clF3
10$ 12-22-7.Q07 2D.18:3$ 52.`7 dB
1Q9 1a-z�-2ao�r 2a:is:s4 52.7 dH
11C1 12-22-?_007 20:18:40 56.6 �8
111 12-22-2fl0`► 20:18:41 53.9 dB
112 12-22-2047 2q:18:42 52.3 d�
li3 12-22-2007 2n:18:43 54.8 dB
114 12-22-204�7 20:1$:A9 55.0 c38
115 17-22-20d7 2�1:1�:45 55.9 dB
I26 12-22-200`) 20.18:46 57.7 �B
lI7 12-22-2Qt?7 ZQ:1$.47 56.2 dB
118 12-22-20�7 2�:78.48 ��.2 dB
i 19 12-22-200`I 241 c 18.9 9 dB
120 I2-22-ZQ07 20:18:5t7 ��.2 dB
121 1�-22-2U0°� 20»18.51 56.9 ciE3
Z22 12-`12-2007 20;18:52 d�
I?3 17.-22-20Q7 2C�:1�:�3 �6<� �
12A 12-2?-2007 2Q.18.�4 �2.� d8
125 12-2�-2007 20:18:55
�-
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
' �12fi 12-22-2007 2Q:1$:56 51.7 dB
127 12-22-2ad7 20:18:57 52.� �B
12B 12-22-20b7 2Q:1$:5$ ��.`� d�
129 12-22-2007 20:i8:59 54.0 dB
130 12-22-200'� 20:19:�C1 51.2 dB
131 12-22-ZbOi 20:13:01 53.2 dB
132 I2-22-2Q07 2Q:19:Q2 53.1 dB
133 17.-22-2U07 2(l:19:03 ����' ��
139 12-22-2007 20:19:04 �1�9 d�
135 I2-22-2007 20:19:05 56.8 �$
136 12-22-20Q7 20:19:06 53.2 dB
137 12-7.2-2007 2t1:19:0 7 `-i3.5 `�e
138 12-22-20Q7 20:19:08 55.9 �a
L39 12-22-2Q07 21J:19:49 52.2 d8
i$0 12-22-2007 20:19:1{1 53.0
191 12-`12-2Q07 ZC�.19:11 ��•� "�g
192 12-�Z-Z007 2A:19:12 `�1.3 �8
I$3 12-22-20Q7 20:19:I3 50.9 �a
14� 12.-22-2t�07 20:19:14 56.?. dH
145 12-'L2-2007 20:19:15 52.9 ��
ia� i�-x2-zoo� 2a:��:�6 �i.z �a
14� 12-22-2007 20:19:17 5d.9 �B
149 12-22-20Q7 20:19:28 51.5 <�B
199 12-2.2-2007 20:19:19 52.7 dB
15t1 12-22-2Q47 24:19:20 53.9 �B
15l 12-22-200� 2C1:19:27 52.3 dE#
152 12-22-20�7 20:19:22 57.9 dB
153 12-22-20C1"7 20:19:23 ��.9 ��
154 12-2?-2Q07 2t�:1�:?4 53.A d�
155 12-??-70Q7 20:19:25 `1.8 d9
156 12-22-2�Q'? 20:19:26 5Q.3 dB
157 12-22-2007 20;i9:27 50.3 dB
158 12-22-2q�a 24:19:2E 56.3 dB
159 12-22-2007 20:19:29 50.3 dB
160 12-22-2tJ0"7 20:19:3CY 50.B dB
161 12-22-2D0�7 2t�:19:31 50.1 d�
262 12-22-20Q'1 2b:19:32 51.7 ciE3
763 12-22-2�70"7 20:19:33 �1.3 d�
154 12-22-2007 20:19:39 51.4 d8
155 12-22-20f37 2C�:1�:35 ��.�' ��
l66 12-22-2.0�'T 20;19:36 `_i(7.0 dB
1�7 1'1-22-2007 2Q:I9:37 `-��.a �8
168 12-22-2007 20:19:38 5Q.9 dB
I69 12-22-7Q0�7 70:I9:39 99.7 dt3
49.7 d�
1'tU 12-22-2407 20:19:90 52.� d8
171 1.2-22-2007 20:19.41 dS
172 1�-22-?.OD7 2�J:19:42 55.7
1�3 12-22-2007 20:19;43 49.6 dB
179 12-22-2007 2i�:I�:4� �Q.� `��
175 12-22--20i1"I 20:19:95 57_.1 �g
276 12-22-2007 20:19:46 SC1.5 d3
1�7 12-22-2007 20:19:47 50.4 dB
178 i2-22-2��t7 2C�:19:A8 St;.� �B
179 12-22-20Q7 20;19:99 5�.3 d�
18t3 12-22-2QC�7 2�:13:50 52.5 dB
181 12-22-2007 20:19s51 53.3
287 12-22-�t7b7 20:i9:52 50.0 d@
IB3 12-22-20�7 20:19:53 51.I d8
189 12-22-200� 20:1�:54 53.3 dB
195 12-22-2C�Q7 20:19:55 60.3 d8
3.86 12-22-20C1"7 2Q:19;5£ 5E,.4 d�
lg7 12-22-2CJ07 20:19:57 53.8 dB
1£3� 12-22-2fJ07 20:19:58 59.� d$
nnwurEs
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
' 51.$ dB
' 189 12-72-?_OD? 20.19:59 53.9 dg
S90 12-22-2fJ0� 26:20:Q0 56.3 dB
191 12-22-2Q07 20:ZCJ:�I g3.3 �a
].92 12-22-2Q07 2U:2C�:b2 51.9 dB
]93 12-22-2U�7 20:2Q:03 52.0 dB
199 12-22-20Q7 20:2Q:04 51.6 dg
195 12-2�-2�0"1 20:20:U5 54.� dR
l96 12-'12-2007 2Q:2fJ:(J6 52.7 dB
197 12-22-200"l 20:2Q;f�7 53.� dB
14A 1'L-22-200? 20:24:4£� 53.5 d6
199 12-22-200? 20:20:09 50.'7 dS
�pp 12-?_�-2007 ZU:20:1a 5a.2 dg
2Q1 12-22-2QG7 20:20:11 5�.� dB
2Q? i2-22-"1.U07 20:7.6:12 55.3 ciB
20� 12-22-?.007 20:"1Q:13 55.5 dB
2U9 12-2?.-7.Ob7 2.CD:20:14 52.7 dE
205 i2.-22-2Q0`� 2q:20:15 32.9 dB
206 12-22-200� 20:2(�:1� 56.� dR
2p7 IZ-22-200? 2�:2Q:3? �4.� dR
108 12-22-200� 2(�:20:18 51.2 dE3
209 12-22-20�7 20:20:19 51.9 d�
21t1 12-22-2007 20:20:20 �9.2 �B
2i1 12-22-200`1 20:2�:27 52.0 d�
212 12-22-2t3d7 20:20:22 5a.5 dB
213 12-22-200� 20:20:23 �5.4 d8
214 12-22-2Qt77 20:7_�J:24 gd.2 ds
215 12-22-20t17 2U:20c25 51.5 dB
21h 1?.-22-2007 20:20:26 �0.5 dB
21� 12-22-24a7 ?.Q:2Q:27 52.6 d8
� 21 A 12--22-2ClCi`1 Z0:�0:2.8 52.3 dB
2i9 12-22-20C�7 20:2C1:29 52.2 dA
7.20 12-22-20�7 20:2(�:30 51.4 �a
�� 221 12-22-20(77 20:20:31 5�.0 �B
t� 222 12-22-2Qa�J 2�:2q:32 55.6 dS
223 12-22-200Wt 2q:2U:33 �2.� ��
224 12-22-2U�7 20:20.34 ��.� ��
225 12-22-2Q07 20:2(1:35 52.9 d8
22€� 12-'12-2007 20:20:36 5�.1 dg
227 12-22-�4�� 2a:20:37 5�.� dt3
228 1�-22-?.407 20:20:3$ dB
229 12-22-2007 20:20:34 55.� d�
23Q 12-22-20�i7 2.0:20:At� 53.9 dB
231 12-22-20C17 ?.f1:20:41 52.5 ci8
232 i2-22-20Q7 20:2b:92 55.1 ��
233 12-22-�0�7 20:2U:43 ��
239 12-22-20G� 20:2{�:49 54.Z dB
235 12-22-2bfl�l 20:2(i:45 53.5 d8
236 12-22-2fl0? 2J:20;96
237 12-22-20�7 i0:20:4? `�5.�i dE3
�Fs.� dB
238 12.-22-2Q03 20:7.0:98 dE
239 12-22-2Qt7? 20:20:A9 56.7
52.2 dF3
290 12-22-20fl7 20:20:50 dB
2�1 12-22-2�07 2Q:20:51 53.9
d8
242 I2-'l2-'1U07 24:20:52 52.8 dB
293 A2-22-200"7 20c20:53 55.0 d�
294 12-22-2Qd7 ?.Q:ZC1;59 S�.I dH
;�45 12-`12-20tD7 ZQ:2C1.55 54.7 dB
296 12-22-2pC�7 20:20:56 dB
247 12-22-20�7 2�:2Q:57 ��.5 ��
2A6 12-22,-2�?d7 20:20:58 59.9
54.tl '�a
249 1"1-22-2007 "1.U:2t�:�9 ��.7 dB
250 12-22-2Qt}7 2�:21:00 55.2 d�
251 i2-22-2aQ7 2Ci:21;C�1
�.
�;
�
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
',
;
' � . 252 I2-22-2007 20:21:02 52.2 d8
253 12-22-2007 20:21:03 53.0 dB
259 12-22-2007 20:2i:Od 52.3 �8
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
' 38�'/"'N1 '
� ,� '
' ._ � � -���� �-
� �� �
�' � c ��`1 '
o u :c,� r� � r °
.. � 3 ����
, � �
.. . -
, � ; 1 `
L J � � � � u� �� ; ,h
�i ' ( �
� _ - .--� - - ---- - � � _..__.
___ __ ._ ..- j
.� � ' _._..-- _. _._ _____-�
� J
� ; �_ �` �'` �� ,C3 r.
(Q��.. . _. Y____,. __.. � - ' �— '_ . ,_ ..._,...m_ - .� ` � � ,:,
�� � � _; �_..�,___ __ !� � �
� r-- --- —� � t/)
cv � � � � 1► 1►
�, .� ° e � -
, _w. i i � j f0 .> �
�_ � ; �C r � �
m � _1 . { . , , , .. � � �
p � •- - o
, , , c ;.- � �
�
, , � �
; � , i�
i _ ; __. _ ---- - --} k � I - � � � �
� 1 � I( , � l � O � ��
,�,�. ci. 1�; ..! - _� i �
�
� I .
;
i � Qf
� �.
� � � �
4 R'"�I r� � i, _ _ - _. � � o
�i .c� -� f � � S �
;•��� E1t � I � E ��� �
� �
� ('�;� , _ co cv
` p�' O ' �C <C
+�, ,
r�'� ,� � � � .
� L]. � }
� —.—. "�_ ; Z
__ _
�
i
� I �
�� ,
4a � � i � I _�
..� � ., ,
�� � c , . _._ _
� �
!� •i., � ,
C7) i . _ l �
�` -_
J � �� `
�
.i-L�+� Q' �, . . �`� ' � � '. I —' `_3
4 ' —— ._.. I .a�
�6, }._�..,� _ E _-�--...._
L�1 +�"�'., °� F i i � � �� i �
y � ,� ,. .
r tl9, �'J ! ' ' ; 4 91
- ' _ ; _ , � f � M
; �'t va � ,�„�w . �_— __�_._
( � � �� ��"��+�� �� � � �
� _ � � �
i��j�� � � � .: � ��' ��«y�a ,�� � �._— -- � ` � � . � ..J � I
'`� �y Af.� _ � . - �a !�
� •,,�,�y�� ��" Q�+'
Y" �''�±I V) � ^ Y'Ir'e�' - � . �:� ;=+ C,5) � j�.
!
� ���, �7° _ �. ;_ � � t� - �� � � � _,
% � � -�=_ . � i '
� t
c�S ` -- "^' � -- I_ � , �
� ..� I O .�.- } -�-- j
a'�. �'I � �i � i _ � � } ;
� � � ` " �.." j . r � � ' � �
� N 1ql � , � j ' S r
1 � � a.i . . �� � � � t�u
� a.y ' �
"�.. �
.__� � _ o �� i, � �'t �C
N � �
G
� o 0 o a o 0 o r� o o a � }
� °'• �� •� p p o 0 0 0 0 0 � ci fl ' , , �;
`� r i� �� + t7 Oi a�o � cfl �n v cn c� �- ,v^, 'i _ �i
N .- i_..�_._�. �
'� C3C
3 ( �
N '��, { t-- .
v► �O,�E ,y. �----- a
� �� � � u"i o `�'i �n � � � �
� �
� �� .,. �, .- ( 7 �� ��
� '_ �-; ctt �; � �' � p � > a,
� � +� , � � , �c � 1 �-o p =
ii. t�15 I i i l� N a F- ... �,
� �, '� Ct i ' tY . ! � . � w + cn
�' '� '- � ; � x � +n � � ''
IW � � �g, � � � a � ty � � r.r
�, �, rn E �� � '�'► v� ;�
� � � � � � r
t�____._ _______.___ - -
�_
_._
_._---. _________.___._ ._;
fdIINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
r
� +
�
�
_�,. - —
-- - .
�"r-_ _...�
'�j' I Q'` ,
�„'Q r•�. l� � �17 7 �' '
tiw� �..,,r L,i^'f I {.t'7 �
� � �
q �
° ' �____�
� �_____�
_ _
, ___
E � -� � �
� � � � �
� � �
�
� �
� '�
� � �
�
___��� _ f �._---- � �
� --� �.. , e7.
� ___.._. , � �
,�'r, , � --- - + - - ;P
t
'a 'I '� �
...,.,. '��'' �,,,
� ___.... �
� � - �
, , __ ----�- � �
i I ,�
.s-.,
�{� �
�„ �
�
�� �
a � �
r �
,F� � g � � � � �
,� � �
� �,
�
;
.. �-- �.,
� ; �.� � � � I
� ,
� � ��� � t
�.; �; � ♦
�,; � .,.....
��� � � � � �
� � '��� � �
;,
l_.�. ,
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
. � ��
IftC'I2X ---CI3i'.2--- -"'Li,i��P.,-' S(7UPtC3 Level unit �V �� f�
1 12-22-20Q7 22:38:�7 52.7 dB
2 12-2�-2007 22:38:48 50.7 dH
3 22-22-20C�7 22:38;99 51.0 d8
4 12-?.2-7_007 22:36:50 �1.4 �B
5 12-22-20t17 22:3fi:S1 58.9 d9
b 12-22-20Q'] 22:3�:52 55.4 d8
7 12-22-2t1Q7 72:38:53 5�•� d�
8 12-22-20€7? 22:3II:54 53.0 ��
9 1?-22-2Q0'J 22:38:55 53.5 dB
10 12-22-2007 22:3�:56 54.�i ��
I1 72-22-2007 22:3�:57 51.2 �B
12 12-22-2U07 22:38:56 53.6 d$ �
13 12-22-2007 22:38:59 5Z.'1. ��
i� i2-zz-Zaa�t zz:��:aa 5�.� �B
15 12-z2-2007 22:39:01 53.'l d5
16 12-22-2007 22:39:02 �0.4 `��
17 12-22-2007 22:39:03 56.2 dB
18 1?_-72-200! 22:39:Q4 52.7 d�
b+� 11-2�-2007 22:39:C15 52.5 dF3
20 12-2'L-20Q7 22:39:06 53.4 dg
21 12-22-20Q7 22:39:0`7 'a7.p c1B
22 12-22-2007 22:39:08 53.5 dB
23 12-22-200? 22:39:09 50.� d�
29 12-22-2QQ'� 22:39:30 52.5 dB
25 12-2?-2U�7 22:39:1.1 51.8 �a
26 12-22-2007 22:39:12 53.� `�B
27 12-22-20Q7 22:39:13 55.0 ciB
28 12-22-2C�47 22:39:19 6fl.Q dB
29 I2-22-2C7b7 22:39:15 52_1 �A
�0 12-22-�'(��7 22:39sI6 53.8 dH
31 12-22-20Q7 22:39:17 52..9 d�
32 l2-?.2-2f�07 22:39:19 51.4 ��
33 12-22-2Q07 22:39:i9 5�.� d�
39 12-22-2007 22:39:20 56.0 dB
35 12-22-200? 22:39:21 52.6 d�
36 12-22-2007 22:39:22 J9.9 d8
37 12-22-2007 22:39:23 53.7 dH
38 12-22-�C7Q7 22:39:29 `_i2.D �H
39 12.-7_7_-20b7 22:39:?.5 54.7 c1B
9t7 12-22-2f107 22:39:26 50.� �B
A1 12-22-2007 22.39:?? 53.7 dB
92 12-?.2-20d)7 ?2;39.:� 53.3 �B
93 1?_-22-20C17 22::i9:79 53.'� tIB
A4 i2-22-20£�7 22:39:30 `_>�.ti d�
95 12-22-2qfl7 22:39:33 53.� dB
A6 12-22-200i 22:39:31 5�T.1 d�
4? 12-22-2007 22.39:33 ��•`� dB
48 12-�2-"LQQ7 22:39:34 53.Q ��
�t9 12-22-20077 22:3�:35 57.� �
50 12-22-200? 22:39:36 53.9 d8
51 12-22-2007 �2:3�;37 55.1 dB
52 1�-22-2Q�3� 22:39;38 53.7 dB
53 12-22-2007 22;39:39 53.9 dB
54 22-22-2007 22:39:4�1 51.E# dB
55 I2-22-20{�7 22;39:41 ��.� �a
56 12-22-2007 22:39:A2 53.8 rIB
57 12-22-2{707 22:39:43 53.A d�
5B I2-22-2b0'� 22:39:44 �9.3 dB
59 12-22-2q0'7 22:39:95 52.9 dB
60 i2-22-200�r 22:34:�6 58.3 d0
61 12-22-2DQ7 22:39:47 53.9 ��
62 12-22-200? 22c�9:4ft 53.7 dB
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
�
63 'i2-22-20Q7 22:39:99 59.6 dH
64 12-22-2007 22:39:5Q �9•� dB
65 12-22-2007 22:39:51 ��.� d�
66 12-22-20f17 22:39:52 52.8 dB
57 12-22-2007 22:39:53 52.7 ��
6$ 12-22-2007 ?_2:39:59 54.5 ��
69 12-22-20(�7 22:39:55 52.3 dB
70 12-22-2007 22:39:56 55.9 d�
71 12-22-2QQ7 7.2:39:57 54.1 dB
72 12-22-2007 22:39:58 53.6 d�
?3 12-22-2C�0� 22:3�:59 53.3 d�
74 12-22-20Q7 22:4q:00 �g•� d�
75 12-22-20fl'7 22:94:01 59.z dB
76 12-22-2007 22t90:02 ��•3 '��
77 12-22-20(l7 22:40:03 55.3 ��
78 12-22-204J7 'L2:9U:C}9 �5."7 dB
79 12-22-2�0�7 22:90:t1� 55.3 dB
80 12-22-�007 22:AO:Q6 53.9 d8
E31 12-22-20(J? 22:9D:07 53.$ d�
82 12-22-2U07 22:90:08 52.2 dB
83 12-22-2007 22:40:09 52.6 dB
89 12-22-2007 22:90:10 �6.1 c!6
85 12-22-20Q7 22:40:11 5�7.3 dB
86 12-22-20C?7 22:4fl:12 54.8 da
87 12-22-2007 22:40:13 ��.� ��
88 12-22-2QQ7 22:9�:14 ��.8 ��
89 12-22-200� 22:90:15 �$.g d�
9t} 12-22-1Up7 22:40:16 59.8 d�
92 12-22-2097 22:40:I'7 56.9 dA
92 12-22-2007 22:4Q:18 58.2 dB
93 12-22-2pq7 22:4t1:19 58.�1 c3B
99 12-22-2Q07 22:A0:?0 SB.O dB
i 95 12-22-2C107 7_?.:90:21 5�.6 d$
96 12-22-2U07 2.2:90:22 59.$ dH
97 12-?.2-2d�07 22:4Q:23 58.0 dB
98 12-22-2�Q7 22:40c29 6t�.7 dB
9y 12-22-2007 22:40:25 6�.9 d8
100 12-22-2007 22:�Ifl:25 69.5 d�
101 12-22-2�?�7 22:90:27 6`�.� d$
lU2 12-22-2007 22s90:28 6b.7 dB
103 12-22-2C�d7 22:40:29 ��.� �B
l04 12-22-2t107 22.40:30 �0•a ��
1i�5 12-22-2007 22cA0:31 79.0 dB
106 12-22-2d07 22:40:32 ��.� ��
10? 12-22-2(?07 22:90.33 7 J.7 df3
10$ 12-22-20Q7 22:40:39 12.2 d9
109 12-22-2�07 22:40:35 69.5 c3B
110 12-22-2�07 27:44:36 �$.� da
lll I1_-22-2047 22:4D:37 70,�7 d6
112 12-22-2007 22:94:38 ��.� ��
113 12-�2-2007 22:40:39 ��.� d�
114 12-22-2C�n7 22:90:A0 62.4 dB
115 12-22-200? 22:�0:92 59.5 dB
li6 12-22-2QQ7 22:90:92 ��.� `�$
117 12-22-20R? 22:4t3:43 56.3 d�
119 12-22-20t�7 22;4fl:49 55.1 dB
ii� ��-22-2afl-r 22:40:45 5a .a aa
�zc� i�-z�-Zoc�7 Z2:Qn.�s 53.7 as
121 12-22-?.t307 22:A0:47 53.6 d�
122 2Z-22-20t77 22:4Q:9$ a7.£1 dB
123 12-�2-2003 22:�Oc49 54.1 dB
Z29 12-22-20q? 22:40:50 57.(7 �
125 12-22-20Q7 ?2:90;51 61,2 d�
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
�
I26 1?-22-2Q07 22:40:52 57.6 dB
127 1?_-22-ZOQ7 22:Ad:53 63.8 ��
�28 12-22-2Q�7 22:A0:54 59.3 dB
129 12-?_2-20Q7 22:dt�:55 6(}.3 dB
130 12-22-2J47 22:9f}:56 62.7 dB
131 12-22-?.007 22:9�:57 62.A d8
132 i2-22-20D7 22:90:58 63.7 dl3
133 12-21-2.007 22:90:59 61.8 d�
139 12-22-2007 27.:92:Q0 59.7 dB
135 12-22-20C17 22:41:01 54.0 de
136 12.-22-2Q0� 22:9I:f�2 55.4 d�
137 12-22-2007 22.41:03 �4.� d�
13Ei 12-22-20t17 ZZt91.04 �5.7 �B
139 12-22-20d7 22:41:05 56.5 dB
14Q 22-22-2007 "Z2:41:p6 �7�� �
141 12-22-2Up7 22:41:07 55.6 ds
192 12-22-20t17 22:47.:06 56.2 dg
143 1�-?.2-2007 ?_2:91:Q9 59.9 d�
144 1?.-22-2007 22:41:10 54.9 d8
145 12-?2-2047 Z?_:41:11 54.�r d6
1�6 12-22-20Q7 22:42:12 56.3 dg
147 12-22-2Q07 22:41:13 53.2 dB
19$ 22-22-20Q7 22:41:14 54.1 dS
199 12-22-2007 22:41a15 59.9 �8
I50 12-22-20Q7 22:A1:16 5A.1 ��
isi iz-aa-zoo� �a:Qi:�� ��.� a�
152 12-22-2407 22:41:18 53."� d8
153 12-22-20t77 22:91:19 54.1 dB
154 12-22-2Q07 22:41:20 52.8 dII
155 12-22-200'7 22:d1:21 59.2 dB
156 12-27-200`� 22:41c22 5a.7 dB
157 ]2-22-2Q07 22.:91 :23 52.6 dB
15B 12-22-2007 22:41:29 56.3 dB
159 12-22-20n7 22:41:?.5 `��.� ��
16C1 12-22-2Q07 22;41:26 53.3 dB
161 12-22-2007 22:41:27 52.8 dB
162 12-22-2007 22:A1:28 54.� `�B
163 12-22--2007 22:91;29 52.2 dB
169 12-22-20�7 22:A1:30 �z�� ��
I65 12-22-20q7 22:��:31 53.9
166 12-22-2007 22:A1:32 ��.' ��
157 12-22-2Q07 22:A1:33 55.4
368 12-22-2a97 22:41c39 5�.9 dB
169 12-22-ZQ07 22:91:35 55.q dB
17d 12-22-2p07 22:41:36 �t.� �$
Y71 1�-22-29Ci7 22:A1:37 5A.7 dB
172 l"Z-22-2t107 22:91:3E 55.1 c3H
1'73 12-22-2607 22:41:39 54.0 dB
174 12-22-2Q�7 22:91:40 52.6 dB
175 12-22-2007 22:92z91 52.5 dB
176 12-22-�OQ7 22:4?:42 5A.9 dB
177 12-22-2007 22:�1:43 35.1 dB
i7#3 12-22-2(7Q"1 22;9it49 56.2 dB
179 22-22-20C17 22:41:45 55.? �
1$Q 12-22-2007 22:91:46 55.$ ciB
181 12-22.-2007 22:41:47 53.8 d�
182 12-22-2t70? 22:41:4$ 56.5 clB
183 I2-22-20t17 22:41:49 52.7 d8
184 22-22-2f3f}7 22:A 3 :50 55.3 �
�a5 �2-2a-�o��a zz:�r:�� s2.�
186 12-7_2-2C?Cl"t 22:4I:52 52.7 d�
I67 12-22-2pt}7 22:41:53 54.3
188 12-22-20Q� 22.A1:54 a6.5 dS
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EY.HIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
;
, 1E�9 12-?_'L-2007 22:9�:55 53.6 ��
190 12-22-2�0
7 22:91:56 55.8 dB
191 12-22-2407 72:41:57 �4.1 d�
192 12-22-2�07 22:91:58 51.3 d8
193 12-22-2q07 22:91:59 `��.7 ��
194 12-22-2Q07 22:92:00 53.?. a$
195 12-22-2QQ7 22:92.01 54.� �B
196 12-22-?.007 22;92:02 56.2 dH
197 12-22-2007 22:42:�3 53.5 ��
198 12-22-ZQ07 7.2:92:(��1 54.� `�B
i99 12-22-20C�7 ?.2:92:05 SZ.� ��
2Q0 12-22-20(�7 'Z2:92.:06 54.9 d�
201 12-22.-200`i 22:42:(�7 54.R dB
202 12-22-2qQ7 22:4'1:U8 54.d dS
203 12-22-2qQ7 22:42:09 53.7 ciH
204 12-22-2007 22:4i:10 �6.9 dB
205 12-22-2007 22:42:11 54.5 �g
2Ufi 12-22-200� 22:42:12 57,0 dB
207 12-22-2007 22:�'l' :13 59.5 dB
208 12-22-20Q7 22:92:19 �2.� �B
209 12-22-2007 22:42:15 59.6 dB
?lU 12-22-7.00� 22:92:16 53.2 d8
211 12-22-20(�� 27..:42:1? 53.2 dB
212 12-22-2007 22:42:1$ 55.9 d6
213 12-22-2Q07 22:92:19 5�.2 dB
214 12-22-2007 2?:42:20 54.8 d8
215 12-22-20(�? 22:9?_:21 56.? dB
21b 12-22-2007 22:92:22 53.3 dB
217 12-22-2007 22:42:23 �3.�
216 12-22-2{�(�"7 77:42:29 55.5 dB
219 12-22-2007 22:��:25 59.2 dH
22f� I2-22-2047 7_2:92:26 58.8 dB
221 12-22-20b7 22:92:27 59.6 ��
222 12-22-200'T 22:42:28 55.5 dB
223 12-22-20Q7 22:92:2� 58.1 ris
229 12-22-2Q07 22:42:3Q �5.� dS
225 12-22-2t�Q7 22:42:31 ��.� �
226 12-22-20p7 22:92.32 ��.$
227 12-22-2DtJ7 22:42:33 53.4 d�
228 1?-22-2f�07 22:4?_:34 53.1 �g
229 12-7.2-2C�Q7 22:97:35 56.2 dH
23Q 12-22-20t37 22:92:36 5�.1 d8
231 12-22-2QC7 22:G2:37 53.6
232 12-22-2d3G�7 22:42:38 55.E �S
233 12-22-2007 22:92:35 b0.9 �a
239 12-22-2Qf�7 22:42:�0 59.7 dB
235 12-22-2Qfl"1 22:42.:41 6t�.'� �B
235 1�-22-2407 22:42;92 61.Q dB
23"� 7.2-"22-2007 22:42:93 63.1
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
' �� ��
� �� ..� _ f �
- _ , , �
i
�} �'�� -_____ �.
_._ . --,----� -- c� - I a
�•r� i � � �rn G � },
_ t- , �
�� q_.._.. � � :a tY � j '
.» � � �
' c"> ____ _-- - -- - - + _—�_ --- - � 'cC -
e-� F- ,
� ? —�— - � � �n � � d�
' a� �. _.. ..__�__— _ � _.
� .. _ -- .
� w�- g .,_
� ,�, ; ' � � c� r.� �
!O-j - , ! f. � � t.
O, s. ' tt'j (
.
,
r
!
N� , ,� t ; , } . _....._? �j �
� �� � i 1 � . _._
I ' �' �
c� -- , �► #►
.-, � �;'� r - � � � � � � I
�j � 1
� '"^" swY- � �.. ; I �� t 4
� � ��
Q i .� � C � � �
�
r i � .a' � :
� � r � � .�
; � ;..� ` __ �
, a , -•- - _, �
� , �- � .� ' , � 1 �. _ , � ,
.^�„, p, .� � I '
C7 � � •
ar '�' ; t � .c
� ('�
���r � i " ...�.�� . ; �_m � z �
, �(� � � � � �
'`� �� i � � E �
{�; �."_ ��.--�—� _I __ __ ca co
� r , � �
� � , � � i O `Q `C
� �. ,__ o
{ �, c�. - _ - .
Q1 R ny,�. 1 _ �-_ _.�- �
( (71j �' (�'� � '- � i
' Q7f �� �ll1� -'c-; ' � �
' A= - -� -- - ; --
—�� � j �' � � 1 � � �-� �s
( �' � � � �� � � � 1
?p ,�.� � � _.m_ � _._; , . ,_ - i I �
�� � ' , � �
� �
_-��� � � �
�� ""�"�. 1 < . -° � t► < �
j H , . � .._ "_ • .
� � � _. , ti..
.i-. • ?' ; �1 'm ,-� ,
4J i ,"N,n '�p Q �
i'g � ::� '�" � . - -- --� _ _~ ' � >>;
� � _.."'� � : �� J � �:�
°�.� � � � � . . . . r��
� � ��E �
',� ' — __- � � _L. ._.I
�` e. .
�� U1 �
�
_
� � I�
�! , -° � � � ' '�Q �� �
��� ,� ; � . �--t - � � - -�� ��
� � , � _ ` � � �
j � � � � I , � � .
o. � i �
a �, � i
� ( ' r'� � �- � ; • ' � � � �
a , � I. i i ._ b
' � I � � ' � � ; _ �
�� ' � -� '� -- I v � � �
ai - � �� >
,o v j �
� � i c`a m
� � �`� � , _. �.
, ._ � ;� o �G.�� 4 cC Q
�� � � O O O O O � O C7 4 C3 O O �' � I
N dU
p �j p p � CN?� CO C? ; � i
t.� �I � CD W vQG � t{y tA d 'W1 -
� r, i
�
} � ' �
� I ( __— E
v1 � ! I 0' �+, � .
, �p � c'� r3
� C�� � � X� �y � `p r" N
� (f� � r, � !)
C '�'� ''� ��
4 �
� �.' � f I .� , � � � '�—r C3
� � � � � �
� (� Q � � � N � �j ! {� 4
tis
> "'� � i ' ,-
� . � � Q- t.. i � f�I, � � �L. r � Z � �
ay ' C� E �`T � �'► � � a Q N �
�x � � � � �, r �' __
--
, ________.__ ..._
--- ---
L.----_____ _._.___-----
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
� 1
e
, , .._.__._....... .—._.a.r�... .._ __,. �,.e,..e
,,�M ��".-..,:.�� rz+� �`...�....,m.. �'?
1
9 �� � �'
f-,.�"'i` -�T- ; a.IC� �
�
rw � �� � � � � ��� � �� �
��
� :.':�.-
�.,. � � �
� -�,--. �
�,�µ; -� � � �
�� � � � � ;
,.�„� �
��;
� .---w "
� � ;
��, � � ;
��.
�
r�....
b 4d'F :
��� �g�`� z �
� �,,i , �
�.' �.
� � �
-� �
� �
� � �
� �
? „ �
aa,�� �;;u I
�''` � � E
���� � �
�
�
�-= �
,. �
� �
t�#�
�- � � � � �
�
�` � ;�= ..--� �---
f;x
�;�`",; �
�
�q
��a �� , � '"—" e--��r
���F � ��
;��� �, �`r� r
�X' ' � � . k , �
���"9 �p3 a r, �^��y� ��
--� '� � � ���""'���`����
� � � 1 �.w., � £�4;
�� -'Cs � � �
� ��� � �" � 4 �
� � o
. � :
d_�' �
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
{�
� .
; ,
� Index ---date--- --t.i.me-- Sra�nd_I�evei unit
1 22-22-2007 23:23:95 53.4 dB ����{ }�t3��
2 12-22-2007 23:23:96 55.5 d8 :��°�
3 12-22-'lOQ3 23:23:47 53.7 dB
9 12-"22-2007 23:23:98 53.2 dA
5 12-22-20Q7 23:23:49 52.6 dg �� �
6 12-22-2007 23:23:50 52.5 de � �
7 12-2.2-2007 23.23:51 53.1 dfl �� a
s i2-2z-2oo-r ��:a�:s2 �s.� as
� lz-az-aoo� 2�:z�:5s �n.a dB
i0 12-22-2007 23.23:59 55.9 dB
I1 1?.-22-2dti7 23:23:55 53.3 d$
1� 12-?_2-2fl�7 23:23:56 55.2 d8
13 12-22-2Q07 23:23:57 59. ? dB
19 11-22--2UQ7 23.23:58 55.1 dB
15 1"1-22-2D07 "13:23.59 a5.3 dB
16 12-22-2007 23:2�2:00 51.8 d9
17 12-22-2407 23:2�t:(}1 60.9 ds
18 i�-22-ZOQ"fi 23:24:02 ��1.� �B
19 12-22-20G7 23:24:Q3 53.� aB
20 12-22-2007 23:24:04 ��•2 ��
21 12-22-2G0? 23:24:05 �9.?_ dB
22 12-22-2d07 23:2�:Q6 57.1 dH
23 12-22-2D07 23:24:07 58.2 ��
24 12-22-2t7Q`7 ?_3;24:08 51.5 dB
25 12-22-2007 23:?.9:09 53.0 d8
2f 12-22-200? 23:24:1Q 55.0 dB
27 l2-?_2-2Q6'1 23;24:11 �3.` a�
28 12-22-2QCJ7 23:24:12 55.9 dB
29 12-22-20C17 2�:24:13 54.0 dB
3Q 12-22-2D07 23;24:14 51.� dB
31 12-2?-24�7 23:24:15 52•4 dB
32 12-22-2007 23:24:16 53.7 d�
33 12-22-20Qi 23:24:17 55.0 dB
34 12-22-2Q07 23:?.9;18 56.7 dB
35 12-22-2007 23:2A:19 5�.� dB
36 I2-22-?_Q07 23:29:Zd� 55.2 dB
37 12-7.2-20t�7 23:24:21 55.7 dB
38 12-22-2007 23:24:22 56.0 dB
39 12-22-2f7Q7 23:29:2.3 55.9 �8
40 12-22-2007 23:29:29 59.5 d�
41 12-2.2-20Q7 23:2_9:25 56.3 d�
42 12-22-2E3(�7 23:24:26 `�6.4 dE3
93 12-2?-?.pQ"7 23:29:27 59.2 d�
49 22-22-20Q7 23:24:28 68.0 �B
45 12-22-"l0(}"7 �3:�9:29 75.0 d$
4f 12-21-20t17 23:24:3Q 66.9 d8
97 12-22-2007 23:24:31 63.3 dB
46 12-22-20d7 23:29:32 57.2 dB
49 12-22-20Q7 23:24.33 59.8 d�
5Q 12-22-20Q7 23»2A:39 �7.3 dB
51 12-22-2�07 23:24:35 53.9 dS
52 12-22-2tJ07 23:2A:s6 58:7 dB
53 i2-22-2�fl7 23:29:3J 5�.� �
59 12-22-20Q7 23:24:38 53.2 d�
55 12-22-2n07 23:24:39 55.3 dF3
56 "12-22-20C}7 23:29:90 55.3 dB
57 12-22-2fJ07 23:29:41 59.3 d9
58 12-22-2007 23�2d_4? 54.9 df3
59 12-2�-20G7 �3:29:53 ��.5 d�
6t7 12-22-2C3Q7 2��;24.44 `f£s.2 dB
62 12-22-20Q7 23:29:95 57.$ tiB
6� 12-22-2007 23:29:4� 55.b dB
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNtNG COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
�
63 I2-22-20d7 23:24:97 53.9 dB
69 I2-'l�-2qOl 23:24:48 53.9 dB
65 12-22-2047 2�:24:49 56.3 d�
65 22-22-20Q"! 23:24:50 55.L dB
67 12-22-?.OQ7 23:29:51 54.9 d�
68 12-22-2�07 23:24:52 65.0 d8
59 12-22-2Q07 23:29:53 51.6 d�
70 12-27-2�07 23:7.4:59 52.0 dB
71 12-22-2007 23:24:55 53.2 dE
72 12-22-20Q7 23:L9;56 55.8 dB
73 12-22-2Qt}7 23:29:57 6C1.3 dB
79 12-22-2007 23:24:58 59.0 dB
75 1?_-2'1-20�7 23.24:59 55.1 dS
76 12-22-2407 23:`L�.Gq 51.9 dB
7�7 12-22-2007 23:25;O1 57.2 de
78 12-22-20Q7 'L3:2S:U`l 56.4 dB
79 12-22-2007 23:25:03 55.8 ci6
64 12-22-2007 23:25:p9 5fi.6 dB
81 22-2�-2007 23:25:05 5`,.5 dB
$2 1?_-?_2-?.007 23:25:06 59.:� �B
83 12-22-20p7 23:25:07 ��.� d�
84 12-22-7Q07 23:75:08 59.E d�
95 12-22-20Q7 23:25:09 58,1 dB
g6 12-22-200'7 23:25:14 57.9 a�
87 12-22-204� 23:25:11 56.3 �Et
88 12-22-2007 ?.3:25:12 57.5 dH
89 12-22-2Q47 23:25:13 56.9 dg
9q 12-22-2p07 23;25:14 55.2 df3
91 12-22-2007 23:25;15 56.9 dB
92 12-22-20Q7 23:25:1f� 55_5 dB
93 12-22-20t17 23:25:17 59.1 dR
99 12-22-2.b(�7 23:25:18 55.�i dB
95 12-22-20Q7 23:25:19 ��.0 ��
96 12-22-2q07 23:25:20 55.8 dB
97 12-22-20Q7 ?_3:25:21 55.8 d�
98 12-22-20Q7 23:25:22 ��.� d�
99 12-22-ZOC�7 23:25:�3 5H.4 c9B
Y00 12-22-2007 23:25:29 58.2 ��
101 12-22-2007 23:25:25 59.1 dS
1(72 12-22-20(37 23:25:26 fi4.4 di�
1Q3 12-22-2007 23:25:2�' 61.9 d�
144 I2-22-2�07 23:25:28 6Q.� �B
lU5 12-22-2Q07 23:25:29 65.1 dB
106 12-22-20t17 23:25:3fJ ��.1 �$
107 12-22-2Q07 23:25:31 �5.9 ��
10$ 12-22-2fJ47 23:75:32 56.2 d�
1C19 12-22-2067 23:25:33 55,5 ci.B
11C! 12-22-ZQ07 ?.3:25:39 �7.4 d�
111 12-C2-2007 23:25:35 f,C3.1 d�
112 12-22-2�G7 23:25:36 69."i dB
113 12-22-2007 23:25:37 72.4 d�
119 12-�2-2a4? 23:25:3#3 59.9 dH
21a 12-22-20n7 2�:25:39 71.0 ��
116 12-22-2t1b"7 23:25;�iC 67.4 dB
217 12-2?..-2007 23:25:41 72.9 dB
11�3 12-22-2�t37 23:25:92 66,0 dE
119 12-22-2JC?7 23.25:43 53."! dB
12Ct 12-22-20b7 23:25:9� 59.1 d8
122 12-22-2007 23:75:�15 ��.4 d$
aa2 iz-zz-�ao� 2�:2s:a� �5.a �a
3�3 az-��-�t�c�� a�:25;a� sz.s �e
129 12-22-2(?t17 23:25:9& 53.6 d8
125 12-22-2D07 23;25:99 58.7 d8
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
���
126 12-22-2007 23:25:50 5$.2 dg
� 127 12-22-2t�07 23:25:51 60.1 �B
128 12-22-2007 23:25:52 57.8 dB
129 12-22-2007 23:2�:53 55.0 dB
I34 12-22-2007 23:25:59 5�.� d�
131 12-22-20Q7 23:25:55 �5.� ��'
132 12-22-20Q7 23:25:55 ��.� �B
133 22-22-7Q07 23:25:57 ��.� d�
134 22-22-2007 23:25:58 53.8 ��
135 12-'1.7..-?_Ot7� 23:25:59 56.4 ciB
136 12-22-2007 23:26:Q0 5�.z ��
137 12-22-2007 23:26:01 57.Q dB
138 12-22-20Q7 23:2�r:02 57.� dB
139 12-22-2(107 23:26:Q3 58• � da
140 I2-22-2007 23:26:04 57.6 dB
141 12-22-2007 23:2ta:G5 57.5 �B
142 12-22-'LUQ7 23:26:06 y�.� d�
143 12-22-20Q7 23:?_6:Q7 55.8 dB
294 12-22-2007 2:i:26:08 b�.d �B
]95 22-22-2007 23:26:C19 `+9.0 dH
146 12-22-200� 23:26:IQ 66.2 dH
14"7 12-22-2007 23:2F:11 52.5 dB
146 i2-22-"LOQ7 23:26:12 ��.`� ���
199 1?.-22-2007 23:26:13 70.5 db
150 12-22-?Q07 23:26:1A 75.9 �a
l51 12-22-2007 23:26:15 6�.9 d�
152 12-22-2Q07 23:26:s6 61.4 d�
153 12-22-20Q7 23:26:17 57.8 dB
159 12-22-20(J7 23:26:18 5�.9 d�'
155 12-22-2007 23:26:19 54.6 ciB
156 12-2�-20Q'I 23:26:2t7 56.A dB
� 157 12-22-2Qb7 23:26:21 55.� �B
15� 12-22-2007 23:26:22 5'1.� ��
159 12-22-20tJ7 23:2b:23 5�.$ "��'
160 12-2?.-20Q7 23t26:24 59.9 dB
161 12-22-2(1(�7 23:25:25 55.1 dB
162 12-22-20b7 23:26:26 5�.� �a
lf>3 12-22-2bQ7 23:26;27 55.1 dB
169 1�-22-2007 23:26:28 a?.9 d�
165 12-22-2Q4? 23:26s29 54.1 dB
166 12-22-2Qp7 23:26:3t} 67..5 d8
167 12-22-20f57 23:25:31 5�•$ d�
16II 1.2-22-2007 23.26:32 58.9 dB
169 12-22-2067 23.2fi:33 5�.� ��
170 I2-22-20Q7 23:26:39 59. r d�
171 12-22-'l0i)7 23:26:35 ��-a ��
1"F2 12-22-2007 2�:26:3� 5%.6 dH
173 12-22-ZOU7 23:26:37 60-0 a�
1�°4 12-22-2007 23:2fi:38 55.9 d8
175 12-27.-2Q07 23:26:39 S"7.1 d8
176 12-22-2Q07 23.25:90 �,7.4 c!B
17"t 22-22-20U7 23:26:91 55.7 d8
17� 12-22-2t7A7 23.26c92 58.6 dB
179 12-22-2007 23:26:93 E;1-o �
1£i0 12-22-2UCD7 23:26s9�4 58.6 d6
181 12-22-2007 23:26:95 59.0 d8
182 12-22-2C3(77 23:26:96 62.6 �$
163 22-22-2�07 23:26:47 67.5 dH
18� 12-22-2007 23:2E,:9€I 71 .1 d$
I85 12-22-24G7 23:26:49 78.3 dB
IB�i 12-22-20Q7 23:26:5CJ 73.8 dB
187 12-22-2fl07 23:26:51 65.5 ��
188 12-22-2Q07 23:2.6:52 62.0 ��
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
°�
lf�� 12-22-20Q7 23:26:53 6C1.0 dB
190 12-22-20p7 23:26:54 61.1 dB
191 12-22-2007 23:26:55 59•6 dB
lg2 32-22-2Q07 23:26:56 �sT•� �B
193 12-?.2-2007 23:26:57 58.9 d�
199 12-22-2007 23:25:58 b3.£3 dB
195 12-22-20Q7 23:2b:59 6f�.7 dB
196 12-22-2QQ7 23:2'7:00 69.4 dB
197 12-22-2407 23:27:01 62.p dg
198 12-22-20t��1 2,�:27:02 �Q.2 ��
199 12-22-2f1Q7 23:27:03 ��.C) ��
200 12-22-2007 23:2'7:04 58.� dB
201 12-22.-?_QO`1 23:27:Q5 59.9 d�
2Q2 12-22-2007 23:27:06 61.� d�
203 12-22-2007 23:27:Q7 Ei9.8 ��
204 12-22-2t�07 13:2I:U8 58.0 ds
245 12-22-2�07 23:27:C19 59.8 dB
2Q6 12-2n2-20tJ7 23:27:10 55.5 d8
2V•1 1L�LL.��VIAI ��Y.4l.l� .!'J.O �13
206 12-22-?.007 23:27:1? 57.1 �a
2q9 12-22-2Q67 23:27:13 62.4 dH
21Q 12-22-2007 23:27:14 `��.� �g
2�� I?_-22-2007 2.3:27:15 56.5 dA
212 12-22-2007 23:27:15 55.8 dH
?.13 12-22-2Q�7 23:27:17 �9.2 �B
214 12-2'l-2QQ7 23:27:18 ��.`t �A
215 12-2?.-2007 23:27:19 57.C? ��
21b 12-22-2QQ7 2:i:27:20 58.i d9
217 12-'l2-�OQ7 23.27:Z1 55.9 dH
21$ 12-22-20�7 23:2'7:22 �3.5 �R
219 12-22-2007 23.��:23 6t�.5 dB
22(7 12-22-20C17 23:27:?.4 �i.� ��
221 12-22-2QQ7 23:2"7:25 59.8 dB
222 12-22-2007 23:27:26 5�.� d�
2?_3 12-22-2(7t�? 23:27:27 58.3 dB
229 12-22-2007 23:2?.2$ 59.4 dB
225 12-22-2007 23:27:29 59.0 ��
226 12-2?.-2G07 23:Z7:30 58.0 dB
227 12-22-29C77 23:27:31 62.0 ��
228 1?.-22-20f77 23;27:32 57.8 d8
229 I2-7.2-20Q7 23:27:33 56.�J da
23Q 12-27_-2U(�7 23:27:34 5Es.7 d�
231 12-22-20t7? 23:27:35 55,5 d$
232 12-?2-2QQ7 23:27:36 59.5 dB
233 12-22-2007 23t27:3? 59.3 dB
239 12-?_2-2t7{�7 23:2"7:38 6�i,3 dB
23a 12-22-2G0-� 23:27:39 �5.8 c1B
�3� 12-22-20p7 23:27:90 63.5 ciB
23�7 12-22-20U7 23:27:�11 52.9 dB
'13f3 12-22-20C3"1 23:27:92 57.4 d�
239 12-22-20(D7 23:?.�:43 55.2 dH
29U 1�-22-2407 23:27:44 67.1 d�
291 12-22 LC107 23:27:�5 54.5 dB
292 i2-22-20Q7 23:27:46 54.8 d8
'24 3 3 2-22-2.(7U i 23:27:9"? 65.8 d�
2gq 12-22-20q7 23:27;98 58.5 dB
2'45 12-22-2fl�?7 23:27:A4 57.2 ciB
296 12-22-2007 23:�7:5G �S•� �g
247 12-22-20Q7 23:27:51 72.7 dB
298 12-22-2007 23:27:52 62.3 dB
2d9 12-22-20b"7 23:27:53 �'�.1 `��
25Q I.2-22-20t�7 23:2?:59 6A.5 dB
251 7 2-22.-2Qt37 23:21:55 62.1 dB
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
� ,
252 22-22-200? 23:27:56 61.1 da
253 22-22-20Q7 23:27:57 59.8 d�
259 12-22-2007 23:27:59 49.4 d�3
255 12-22-2007 23:27:59 55.d d$
256 12-22-2QQ7 23:28:04 52.Fi t�B
257 12-22-2007 23:2�:Q1 �fl.� ��
25@ 12-2?_-2(?D'1 23:28:02 51.� �B
259 12-22-20b7 23:2$:03 59.4 dB
260 12-22-2007 23:28:04 52•9 d$
261 12-22-2007 23:2$:05 51.4 �a
262 12-22-2007 23:28:Q6 55.8 dB
263 12-22-20Q7 23:28:07 53.5 dB
264 12-22-7.007 23:2$:Q8 5�.-� d�
265 12-22-2C?0� 23:2£3:09 5�.� d�
266 12-22-2Q07 23:28:10 53.5 dB
267 12-22-2007 2;?:'18:11 53.9 dB
268 12-2?-2C?07 23:28:12 52.5 dB
?69 12-22-20�7 23:28:13 57.3 dE3
27� 12-22-?��0"t 23:28:19 5�.6 dB
271 12-22-2007 23:?.H:15 53.4 dEi
272 12-22-2nQ7 23:28:16 53.9 dB
273 12-22-2Q07 23.Zfl:17 �3.2 d8
?.74 12-22-200� 23:26:16 55.9 d8
275 12-22-2007 23:28;]9 55.8 c#F3
276 12-22-2C307 23:2E3:2C1 53.2 dB
277 12-?,2-2007 23:28c21 5?...? ¢�
278 12-22-20d7 Z3;28.22 56.f, dB
27� 12-22-20tJ7 23:2f3:23 55.2 �B
2$0 12-22-20Q7 23.�8:24 Sy.2 dB
281 12-22-2007 23:28:25 5'�.3 dH
282 12-22-20Q7 ?.3:28:26 56.1 d�
2£33 12-22-2007 23:?8:27 66.4 d�
289 42-22-2Q07 23:26:28 56.6 dB
l85 �2-22-2�0'7 23:2E#:24 5"1.2 dF3
286 12-22-2Q0? 23:28:3� 5J.9 d8
2€?1 12-2.2-200? 23:'18.31 5�."7 ��
288 12-22-200? 23:28:32 �p.c) ��
289 12-22-2t�07 23:7..8:33 57.7 dS
29{� 12-27.-?.C}0? 23:26:34 56.E+ d�
291 12-22-20(7� 23:28:35 59.9 dB
29? 12-22-20�7 23:2�:36 55.8 dB
29� 12-22-2QG7 23.28.37 56.9 d�
299 12-22-2Q07 23:28:3E3 57.k� d8
295 12-22-2Q07 23:2$:39 62.9 dII
296 12-22-24Q7 23:29:4Q Er"L.1 dki
297 12-?,2-2CiQ7 23:?$:Ai 62.9 d�
298 12-22--20Q� 23:2F5:92 59.8 dB
299 12-22-20p7 23:28:93 55,6 dB
300 12-22-2Q0-r 23:2$:�A `:��3.4 dEi
301 12-22-2Q07 23:28:45 ��•� �g
302 12-22-20Q7 23:28:�3f aF3.1 dB
303 12-22-2C707 23:28:A7 '�5.5 dB
3q4 12-?.2-20G7 23:28;48 60.9 d�
3fl5 12-22-2Jt17 23:28:�4g 55.5 ciB
3CI6 12-22-2C�47 23:2fl:50 aS.Q ct$
307 12-22-2�107 23:28;51 51.8 d8
308 12-22-2nb7 23_2�:52 57.4 ciB
3b9 I2-?_2--20Q7 ?_3:26:53 52»'/ dB
31G 12-22-2fJU"t 23�28:54 54.2 dB
311 12-?2-200"7 23:2�:55 55.7 dn
312 1?-2?-�f)(1't 23:?£3:5f, 5�1.Q d�
313 12-22-2C1a7 23:28:57 55.6 dB
319 12-22-2t307 23:28:58 54,1 d�
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
;�
;
�
315 12-22-2007 23:28:59 56.3 d9
326 12-22-2007 23:29:00 59.9 dS
31? 12-22-2007 23:29:01 58.3 dB
318 12-22-2Q07 23:29:02 55.8 �B
319 12-22-2047 23:29:03 56.Q dB
320 12-22-2007 23:29:09 55.6 d�
321 12-22-2Q47 23:29:05 59.9 dB
322 12-22-2QQ7 23:29:06 5�.� d$
323 12-22-20Q7 2.3:29:07 ��.� �B
329 12-22-20Ct7 7.3:29:08 ��.g ��
37.5 12-22-2007 2�:29:09 53.4 dB
326 12-27_-2Q47 23:29:10 ��.6 '��
327 12-22-2.Of17 23:29:11 S6.I dB
32$ 12-22-2U07 23:29:1"l ��.5 ��
329 12-22-2007 23:29:13 56.1 �
330 12-22-ZOUI 23:29:14 55.9 dB
331 12-22-20p7 23:29:15 58.3 �
332 k2-22-1007 23:29:16 ��.6 ��
333 12-22-200? 23.29:i7 56.3 d�
339 12-22-2007 23:29:1t3 55.5 dB
335 12-22-20q7 23:29:1'� 52.4 ��
336 12-22-21707 23:29W26 'a4.1 dB
337 12-22-2C107 23:29:21 59.4 dB
338 12-22-2007 23.29.22 �g.� d�
33�3 12-22-2d0� 23:29:23 �g.7 ��
340 72-22-20Q7 23:29:24 5�.3 dB
391 12-22-2007 23:29:25 55.0 dB
342 12-2.2-20Q7 23.29:26 56.6 dR
343 12-22-2UJ7 23:29:27 53.3 dB
349 12-22-�(30? 23:29:28 5A.6 dB
395 12-22-200"7 23.29:29 55.� d�
34S 12-22-2t�0) 23:29:3Q ��•-3 ��
347 12-2?-20(�7 23:23:31 ��.� d$
398 12-22-2t707 23:29:32 59.9 dB
349 12-22-20�7 23;29:33 ��.3 a�
350 12-22-20Q? 23:29:34 52.9 dB
351 12-22-2007 23:29:35 `��.� ��
352 17.-22-2007 23:29:36 54.3 dB
353 12-22-20Q? 23:29:37 5�.2 dB
359 i2-22-ZOf�7 23:29:38 `�4.1 de
355 12-22-2007 23:29:39 ��.i dB
356 12-22-20Q� 23:29:9(� ��.`� �
35� 12-22-2p07 23:29:A1 5�1.5 �
35f� 12-22-2007 2�:29:42 54.3 dS
359 12-22-2a07 23:29:4� 51.3 d�
�60 1.2-22-2qC77 23.29:44 55.6 ciB
361 12-22-2407 23:29:95 58.1 d�
362 12-22-2007 23:29:98 59.$ `�B
363 12-22-2007 23:29:4"7 58.2 dB
36A 12-22-2407 23:29:98 58.1 �a
365 12-22-200? 23:29:A9 60,7 dB
366 i2-22-2(l07 23:29:50 63.1 dB
357 12-22-2�0? 23:29:51 63.8 dB
36$ 12-22-2007 23:29:52. 57.3 dB
3b9 12-22-2C10; 23:29.53 56.5 �A
370 12-22-2007 23:29:59 �4.7 �B
37l 12-22-2007 23:29:55 `��.� �$
372 22-22-2t�07 23:29:56 5�.6 dB
�-r� iz-�2-�oo-r z�:z�:s� 3�.c as
374 12-22.-2t}Q7 23:29:58 51.9 dB
375 12-22-2Q07 23:�9:59 �6.5 dB
3'16 12-22-2007 23:30:04 55.3 �$
377 12-22-2Q07 23:3U:01 52.5 d8
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
37B 12-22-2QC17 23:30:02 52..7 d8
�79 12-22-20Q7 23:30:03 �1.8 `�B
3$0 12-22-2007 23:3C?:Q9 50.9 d6
381 12-7.2-2007 23:30:O�i 59.� dB
382 12-22-2p07 23:3G:06 51.8 d$
383 12-22-2007 23:30:07 53.9 d�
389 12-22-20p7 23:3q:08 5A.1 dB
385 12-22-2007 23:30:09 55.1 dB
386 12-22-2t707 23:30:10 5�.� d$
387 12-22-ZOU7 23:30:11 �2.� d�
368 12-22-2Q07 23:30:12 52.1 dB
389 12-22-20Q7 23:30:13 56.9 ds
390 12-22-2007 23:34:14 5a.g �B
341 12-22-'LQO�) 23:30:15 �'T.2 d�
392 12-22-200�J 23:3Q:16 56.3 dB
393 12-22-�Oi77 23:30:17 57.6 dB
399 12-22-20t77 23:30:18 �1.� �$
395 12-22-2007 23:30:19 Sj.g ��
396 i2-22-2007 23:3(�:20 52.3 dB
39l 12-22-20�7 23:30:21 53.7 dI3
398 12-22-2007 23:3b:22 53.� dB
399 12-22-29Q7 23:30:23 55.2 �$
400 12-22-2Q(?7 23:3�:29 52.3 de
901 22-22-2007 23:30c25 55.4 d8
402. 12-22-20t?7 23:3fl:26 53.5 �8
903 12-2'1-2�07 23:3Q:2? `�9.7 d�i
904 12-22-2pQ7 23:3C1:28 56.5 dB
4D5 12-22-2007 23:30:29 55.2 dB
�06 12-22-2�Q7 23:3Q:3(3 52.3 ci9
� 4C17 7�-27-?OQ'] 23:30:31 55.6 dB
408 12-22-2007 23:34:32 56.� d�'
403 12-22-2007 23:3Q:33 54.t1 dB
A10 12-22-2�Q7 23:30.39 52.� dB
911 7.2-?.2-2t70`1 23:30:35 63.9 dB
972 12-2?.-�007 23:3Q.36 57.8 ��
413 12-27-2007 23:30:37 59.9 ��
414 12-22-2Q07 23:3(i:38 58.1 d8
915 12-22-2t�07 23:3(3;39 52.4 dB
�` 916 12-22-20Q7 23:3�:40 59.(7 da
417 12-?.2-2�07 23:3C1:41 53.8 d8
41� 12-22-20Q� 2303(1:92 55.q d�
419 12-22-2007 23:30:43 5d.3 �
42Q 12-22-2Q07 23:3G:94 `i3."t dB
f 921 12-22-2Q07 23:30:95 53.b dB
9'12 12-22-2007 23:30:46 5�.� ��
423 12-22-2007 23:30:97 55.Q dB
424 I2-22-?.007 23:30:98 5�.2 d$
425 12-22-20p7 23:3Q:4�3 52.9 dB
426 12-22-20Q7 �3:39:50 �5•5 �B
427 22-22-2007 23:34:51 5U.1 dB
42� 12-22-20Q7 23:3Q:52 52.3 dB
929 12-22-20fl7 23:30:53 9g.� �$
430 12-22-2(}07 23:3U:a4 50.2 c38
931 12-22-20Q� 23:30:55 52.8 d�
A32 12-22-2�Q7 23:3'J:56 52.7 d8
433 12-22-?007 23:3�7:57 53.5 �g
434 12--22-2Q47 23:3�s58 54.0 dB
�335 12-22--2C�07 23:30:59 56.0 dB
436 12-22-2(Jt77 23:31:i30 53.U dB
437 12-22-2tlfl7 23:33:01 54.9 d�
43f� 12-22-2(3(7? 23:31:C�2 52.2 dE3
A39 12-22-2007 23:31:Q3 ��.� ��
99� 12-22-2007 23c31s�A 53.7 dB
MINUTES
PALM D[SERT PLANNING COMMISSION �XHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
�
� �
.�
�;' 941 12-22-2C1�7 23:31:4� �3.A dB
442 12-22-200'7 23:31.Ub 54•2 ��
443 12-22-2f107 23:31:07 53.3 dB
494 12-22-2QU7 23:33:08 55.5 d8
445 12-22-2007 23:31:09 53.0 d�
496 i2-22-2007 23:31:10 54.3 dB
497 12-22-2007 2�i:31:11 51.5 �
448 12-22-2007 23:31 :12 �4.8 �B
449 72-22-2Q07 23:31:13 52.6 d�
q50 12-22.-2007 23:31:14 52.3 dB
451 12-22-20Q7 23:31:15 52.3 dB
452 12-2Z.-2007 23:31:16 56.7 dS
953 12-22-2.�07 23:31:17 5Z.?. �g
459 12-22-2Q07 23:31:18 ��.4 ��
955 12-22-2U07 23:31;19 `�5.� ��
456 12-22-200T Z3:31:20 53.5 dB
457 12-22-200? 23:31:21 �1 .� ��
458 12-22-2007 23:31:22 `2.`� �B
459 12-22-2007 23:31:23 54.t� dS
960 12-22-2q47 'L3:3I:24 54 .0 dE3
462 1?.-22.-2407 23:31:25 SA.0 d�
962 12-'1..2-2C10? 23:31:2f� 5A.0 dB
463 12-22-2i707 23:31:2� 59.0 dB
464 12-22-2007 23:3I:2E 5'�.� ��
4t5 12-22-2G07 �3:�1:29 SA.�l cif3
96E, 12-22-200� 23.31:3Q 59.0 dB
9C7 12-22-2Q0? 23:31:31 59.0 ��
466 12-22-2Q07 23:31:32 SA.d dB
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
4 � :
w�"�"..•--- x i "',`f
� "�i"4 �l�2"s
`� 1 ° '�i yy', I t..,,;:^ ��� r .� �%�... '� r.
�.. � . 4.� „:�.�"�{�,;,-. t �r�i'�+G�� " � E'��:�p�i" �6rvs�. � "� za,
"� �
f�, . (t� �r
r� .� R itia �� � 1,�«�i l�«a,�a � - . ���ff�'Ta�e�'"'� ���Rk � �� �t i°,:t �r i f b. .-
�c.u�"»��„ � .� � � 't�,�e� ,.qt�°�'z� �, t t6E{� `r7 gy�'?> r ��.
""� � " " ���i� !� � r 3 .� � y'
� �zi B � �
�� . � �� �ag�4�y�tw����f��+i7 �� 4 �. `;:' �,i
*��, ' �a i�y� f { 5 [
�.. � "t ; ( . �' t 1� � i
t � �f���r �� ' � �
�'�� 'y`aw,�� ti ��}t '�t "�� �r �g �� c^ o- ,
�� �"t,M��f ���^������^�'`�A���� �"��'(�'��f� ������`��� 7��a r' �r i�z t ,
., � ��`�+°��r �3ii„�. � 1�� . 83r t r � P 7=e ,
s. �T� Y,��NfruM
:(t�t +pr
i�,� i� ����.,�>,�,���d�s1s. ,�.i,�t`., ,_�pt � ,si��
.,�, ,,� . ., �, , .. , p.,
. . , �� . � '�., . , , ,�
. rt�,.' a ..,:. ...
Y ,J'¢4�"-;,m�; dS�.Yi1"(a'h� YA ':. ' .. . .
tS�
� _��
� � ���
�� ✓J,�,,
. . _... � .. _.y` �',.
i i ��
i i
y t��E �� O Z7 �.' l ~ !
� � ` � � 1
� �-----: ------ _.,. _.r> U {
00 _.. - � �
. . l� "
tU �
__
-- , - 't �
- .�_—.
� - ; .
� �....____—— __�.._�
�„" i i � �
g--� C� C'�
�� _ --- � �e_ -- -- — -- � � Cj G�
�� � I
�N� j �
, : _.. __. � -- - --- �;
� � e - --- °{
- — �.
-- �
'at' I
3 r- � � i ' - � �►
� � t/
�. ,.,,
�f r E , ; , _.. _.._..__ _— --- � � _
�- — � Q � � �
N � ' � �
.... _.._.__ — ` � �
� __ . - ' -- � t3?
,� ' � a.` � * G Z _.1
� � ` , Y"�, � ' �
' t . .�__. �....n�. ,
� � ,�r— —
� � � � r_
I i
� � � _� � - - w � o� ; � ._
;� a -.►, � , ,
, ,
�( ,
_ ( . ,
'I�1� � � �- ; ,.n ; -,,,�=_ ._ _ _ __ v i' � .�-�" o
! � , `'J ' � ' �'4' � `' � ..-i '
.
r
� � �=� � E E
d._. �� I
i � I .. � L. 1..
91 � � , '... . _.�. �'�-- }�...... ._. � ' � � � .
. I � �
.:�. —"_"._'"_� � I , 3��..y. f�`+^���x I , �.
-� ' s d j
�3 � �°� •-�` . :�..,��� { _ _- _ Z
�
s„�
, � � ��
F {'-�".'�' �
' C9 i c `�-� . � ---�� ---- i _---;�
,J, . 'r � � � f� � �
�, � C , , "",
�j �
w� (�1, � � �� � � � ��
� ,��"
..._ . _.�. .__. j �-� t
t� i � __ - - } � '�
� rn: �
�
� I j __ 1, i � 1 � "�
� eH
� ►.�i ,n �p --- �...__ .�-. _ _. ; r � � � } `�"► �
�' ��,� V ' � —— —-- � .
�-+ � 3 � i R1 �:' �,..,,
�
�' .✓ � � r
�. sn r� c � � ;" � �
�
:;
� � , '�' � "' __ � � �
"� � — �.3 �
� � � � —� � — — - - �� � � �
� �7; a'a �...__1� i � g„'
� �. �', � � � '� O
} �,
,, —
�__
---. � C
� -C'� -� ' '> � � � :� ....7
�.—, � � - � � �- �� � �
,; -sc� � _ ri � �� �� 1 �
��
�
��� �, o i � -��-� r � � —�j . , �� � ,
, _
; ,�'� � � ~�" ; � '�� C'"�
o.. ; , i
� ;
. _. ..._- - m r
E - . - -
u� - .. -f 1 (� 1 � �
� �
o � � � �, . . � � �
� � 4j �"'.� ' �o � � ;{ E E
,i�. �� '$ -_' � ( � !° r'a '
� �
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
' �
1
�
E _ v_�. ..._._ . ___ .,w .,�._......,..,�_. , .,�..._ u�..___ .�.�..__ .,�.�
�
,�� _
� '� s � � �.
�,
r ' �.a^f,
��� ���.. � t— � � i f'`� , e'�^f
�G7r � �L� 1 G�
�: � � �i "s�" � ��
+� � p�` � ��'m '
" � ;" �^� �
��
` �� ' �
�. .
a � � �
{ fi. �
w� � �
` =,Ii:; _� �=- _ �
� � � � �
��a � �
�
�
� ,; .,,�>
.s � -.��
� ����� ,.�,
� �� �
�
z!; ," �,
�...
_,��. �
� � �
� � �
� �<� .�
�
� �
� , ,�i .�,i ,����- �
'#{"`, ..d ;�V� �
� '��r��� �ar--
5 �
�
�
a „� »
„
,��?j�� ,' �
r. . .
�4> �
� r
7 � .,,�- , ., _ .- .
.
� A . �
�
� �! ��
-�--�
�
� � � �
� � �.�, � u"� � �.,a �
i� ,��.?� �# � � r,—..
ti '���t ,^�,� �---
�
i tg�c�� �,
� � ,� K;.'�
j'` ���� �
��
` ��g�llNy`� � .p----
E`t �P�g.��^���;ts �y �
„$! i}�4�7��°i � � �
'i YT=€`s"T"�rS �"j T«..,.. „r�..x.� ,.,,. . .;y. ..
( ,�� —
� � ��
"'�7 3�.- �>
� Y ��� ;,� �. � ..�_•_•� � � �'
� �����` � �
,. �.;�„,, Cs�
p." ,..° ,,:.
,s�
a,
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
e -� 1
�
. ,
Index ---date--- --time-- Saund I,eve1 unit
1 p1-12-2C1b8 21:93:2E3 53.9 dB
2 fl1-12-2C708 2t :4'i:29 5fa.7 d�
3 Q2-12-2008 21:43:30 55.4 d�
4 �1-12-2C10� 21:43:31 55.8 �8
5 f11-12-�Q08 21:43:32 55.1 d�
6 O1-1�-2008 21:f�3:33 59.2 dB
7 O1-12-2008 21:93s39 54.2 d8
9 01-12-2008 21:43:35 52.9 dB
9 01-12-24(}8 21:93:35 52.6 dB
10 01-12-20�� 21:43:37 52.3 dB
li Oi-12-20Q8 21.43:38 52.6 dB
12 01-12-2�08 21:43:39 �n.h �S
13 01-12-2006 21:A3:40 52•2 �g
24 �1-12-2008 21:93:41 52.� d�
15 Q1-12-2QU8 21:43:42 52.0 d�
16 Oi-12-20Q8 21:43:93 `��.� �B
L7 01-12-2008 21:93:49 �9•5 dB
18 Q1-12-2008 21:43:95 52.9 dB
I9 U1-12-20fi78 21:93:46 5�•� �B
20 01-12-20QB 21:43:47 53.3 dB
21 01-12-20078 21:93:48 52.5 ciB
22 O1-72-20C19 ?_1:43:99 51.0 dB
23 01-12-20C18 21:43:5� 52.3 dS
2A 01-12-2(�(78 21:93:�1 �1.� ��
25 Q1-72-20G8 2i:93:52 53.2 dB
26 01-12-20p8 21:43:53 53•I �B
z7 a�-�z-�oae Zi:a�:�9 sz.e ��
28 01-12-20(76 21:43:55 51.7 dB
29 Q1-12 20�8 21s93:�a6 51.5 d8
3Cl Oi-12-2U(?� 2I s93:5� 5a.� ��
31 01-12-2008 21:93c5H 5Q."1 ��
32 01-12-2Q08 21:43:59 52.2 dB
33 Q1-12-"�()�8 21:44:00 52.9 dB
34 91-12-20�� 21:94:01 50.3 d�
35 01-12-2fl0$ 21:94:02 50.7 dB
36 01-12-2008 2] :94:fl3 48.£3 dB
37 O1-i2-200� 21aA4:09 98.6 dB
38 Oi-12-20f7� 2I:44:Qa i�0.9 dB
39 U1-12-2QQ8 21:44:Q6 `��.� ��
40 tJ1-12-2U(78 21:94:(l7 51.5 dB
41 01-12-2l�Q8 27 ;49:t38 52.2 d8
92 Q1-12-2t�C�6 21 :A9:09 �1.7 �a
43 01-12-200$ 21:+99:10 59,1 dB
44 C11-12-20Q8 21:49:11 52.0 ��
45 01-i�-ZQO£3 21 :A9:12 52.2 d8
96 f1I-12-2s�08 2I:44:13 51 .7 dB
9'7 O1-I2-2Q4$ 21:44:19 52.6 dH
48 t31-12-2CDC38 21:94;2S �0.7 dB
49 01-12-2Cs08 �'1:4�i:16 52.3 dS
50 Oi-12-20fl$ 21:94:17 53.8 dB
5I Oi-12-2008 23:44:1H 59.7 dS
52 DI-12-2Q�18 27:44:�9 53.1 d1�
53 O1-I?,-2DOE3 21:94:2€7 55.� dEi
5Q Oi-12-?C�QB 21:49:2i 5�.7 dB
55 qi-12-20t�8 23:�9:22 57.5 d�s
56 Q1-12-2�46 21:44:23 56.9 d�
57 01-12-2afl8 21:4A:29 56.0 d�
58 Q1-12-2QC70 21:�59;?5 55.3 d�
59 01-12-2Q06 21c94:26 SA.� d�
60 Q1-12-2Ut78 21:49:2"7 5�.6 dB
6] 01-12-20Q8 11:94:28 53.1 dB
62 QZ-12-20{l8 21:44:29 5�.� ��
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
}
63 01-12-2d08 21:44:30 a3.b dB
64 Oi-i?_-2t?d$ 21:49:31 51.8 dB
65 Oi-12-2Q08 27 :4d_32 51.5 dB
fi6 O1-I2-2008 21:44:33 51.2 da
6� O1-t?-200� 21:44:34 52.9 dB
5S 01-12-2d08 21:44:35 56.3 dB
69 01-12-2008 21:9�:36 51.5 �B
7Q 01-12-20Q$ 21:49:3"1 50.1 dB
71 01-12-20U& 21:99:3� 52.2 dB
72 01-12-2q08 21:99:39 52.n dB
?3 Oi-12-`1,Q08 21:99:40 a:3.6 d8
74 01-12-2Qf16 21:99:41 52.1 dB
75 Q1-12-2008 21:A9:92 57 .2 dB
76 01-12-20Q8 21:4Q:93 59.7 dB
77 Cli-12-20C18 21:99:44 53.7 dS
7f3 01-12-2t�08 21:A4:45 54.8 dB
79 Oi-12-2flQ8 25:95:46 54.� dH
90 01-12-2CJ08 2I:A4t97 53.8 dB
�1 01-12-2Qt78 21:44:�8 52.5 ciB
82 Qi-12-2008 21:44:49 �1.0 dH
83 Q1-12-2008 2I:49:50 5A.0 dB
8Q t)1-12-2008 2I:49:51 51.3 d�
f�5 01-12-?.0�8 21:49:52 50.8 ��
86 Qi-1�-20(38 21:44:53 5Q.3 dB
87 01-12-2QtJ8 21:49.59 49.5 dB
88 q1-12-2008 21:4�c5`� 52.1 dEi
89 �1-12-2008 21:A4:56 53.9 dB
90 01-12-20Q8 21:49:57 55.6 d�
91 01-12-2Qs76 21:49:58 57.5 dB
92 fli-12-20QE1 �1:99:5`� 54.i dB
93 01-12-20Q8 27:45:OQ 53.3 dB
94 4i-12-700t3 21 :�5:02 98. 7 dB
95 ai-i2-zoaa 21:95:02 97.7 dB
96 02-12-2008 21:�5:U3 4?.7 dB
97 02-12-2005 21:4�:04 46.9 dB
98 01-12-20Q$ 21:45:05 47.9 dB
99 01-12-20fli3 �1:45:46 49.5 dB
10� Oi-12-20C�8 22.n5.07 49.8 dB
101 Oi-12-2t�08 2I:45:(1B 50.8 dB
102 Q1-17.-2E�08 7_1:45:09 51.5 dB
203 QI-12-2C1CJi3 21:45:1�3 Ay.S dB
1�9 01-12-2008 21:�15:11 52-9 d�
l05 531-12-2Q0$ 21:45c12 49.9 dB
io6 a�-zz-xooe 2i:4�:is 51.2 �a
�0�1 01-��-zaoe �r:�s:�4 �i.7 aa
1t38 OI-12-2G908 21:45zi5 50.6 d8
Y05 Ql-1C-2�10II 21:95:46 51.6 ciE3
llfl (11-12-200f3 21:95:1'e 50.9 d.B
IIl 01-22-2fi1q8 21:45:I£� 50.5 d�
112 d1-12-2Uqt3 �'1:45:I9 51.1 dB
113 �1-12-200$ 21:45.20 52.0 d8
214 �11-12-2(708 21:95:21 5�i.5 d8
li5 �1-Ii-2�fJf� 21E95:22 59.� c!B
1�6 01-12-2�08 23.:95z23 �1.9 dB
117 �1-12-2.OQ8 21:A5:74 a0.7 dB
118 01-1?-2G08 21:45:?.5 SQ.6 dH
119 1?1-12-2008 21:95:2f 52.3 d8
12fi Oi-12-2[1Q8 21:9�:�7 49,3 dB
121 02-12-2008 21:45:28 49.9 dH
122 Oi-12-20fl6 21:45:2� 5Q.6 d8
323 01-12-2��E3 21:4a:30 94.4 d8
124 01-12.-2DOB 21:�15:�1 47.i1 d8
125 01-12-20q8 21:45:32 �98.8 dS
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
- }
�
126 01-12-2q08 21:45:33 48.5 dE3
127 01-12-2008 21:95:39 48.7 dH
12$ �1-1?-?_008 21:45:35 96. 2 dH
129 OI-I2-2C�Q8 21:Q5:36 46.5 dB
13b C�I-12-20Q8 �1:45:37 4�i.7 dB
131 f�1-12-2008 21:A5:38 47.3 dB
132 O1-12-2008 21:A5:39 97.7 dH
133 O1-12-2008 21:45:40 48.Q dB
139 01-12-20Q8 21:A5:41 97.5 dB
135 01-12-2008 21:95:42 46.9 dB
136 01-12-2008 21:45:43 97.2 dB
i37 Qi-12-2Q08 21:95:94 97• 1 c�$
138 01-12-20Q8 21:95:45 97.C1 dB
139 01-12-2008 21:95:46 97.7 dB
19t1 01-12-20Qd 21 :�5:4"! 97.2 dB
I9Z 01-12-24G1f3 21:95:98 49.9 d�
142 (11-12-2(7{38 ilc+15:49 97.6 dB
143 01-12-20�8 21:45:50 97.9 dB
199 01-12-2C1CJ8 27.:�5:51 A8.!� dB
195 01-2�-2U08 21;95:52 47•� �B
196 01-12-20p8 21.45:53 9�•� �a
].47 O1-12-2008 21:45:54 48.8 dH
148 fll-i2-2008 21:45:55 49.Q dB
199 01-12-200$ 21:A5:56 98.6 ��
150 fll-].2-2C1(78 21:45:57 A4."7 c��
151 01-1"1-20Q8 21:45:56 49.1 dB
152 01-12-20(18 2i:95:59 49.5 cta
253 01-12-?_Ot;8 22:46:00 99-0 dg
I59 01-12-2�08 21:46:U1 4"1.6 dB
155 02-12-24t78 21:96:Q'd 47.6 dB
156 01-12-20Q£i 21a46:03 9b.7 dH
157 OI-12-20q8 21:86sQ9 46.? elA
158 01-12-200£� 21:46:05 96.6 dB
153 01-12-2i708 21:96:Q6 96.9 dB
160 01-12-20t78 21:4F:0� 96.� d�
161 01-12-2008 21:46:4$ 47.] dB
162 O1-12.-2f70� 21:4Fi:Q9 4 �.:3 dI�
163 Q1-12-2008 ?2:96;1tJ 47.9 �B
164 01-12-2608 22:46:11 46.$ dB
165 01-12-2QC18 21:46:1� 9?•� ��
lb6 (31-12-2008 �1:45:I3 47.2 r1B
167 01-12-�a0f3 2] :46:19 98,1 dB
i6$ 01-12-2a0$ 21:86:15 47,5 d�i
169 01-12-�OdB 21:96:16 47-� �B
170 a1-12-2(f08 21:46:27 97.5 dB
171 01-12-2008 21:46:18 48.2 d8
I?2 Q2-12-2008 2I:96:19 47.7 t!B
i'J3 O1-12-20QH 21:96:2Q 48.0 dF3
279 Cl1-12-2tlOB 21.96:2? 4"?.�1 �IB
175 01-12-200$ 2i:96:22 98.I dB
1"76 01-12-20q8 21:46.23 98.5 dB
1?7 t31-12-2t70$ 21;46:?.A 4E�.`� d$
178 41-12-20013 22:9�i:25 98.3 d8
179 C71-12-2p08 22:46:2� 98.2 d8
2�� 01-I2-2.0�8 21:96;27 48.3 riB
181 Q1-I2-2006 21;96:233 48.5 dF3
182 Q1-12-2Q08 21:�d5:29 46.2 da
183 Cll-t2-2CIQ$ 2i:4Ei:3G 47.8 �B
189 01-22-24t3$ 21:96:31 47.:3 rf8
i85 02-12-2Qf18 21:46:32 46.0 dB
1£36 (ll-12 20�E3 21:4b:33 97.7 et8
1�7 Q1-12-2C�fl8 21:46:39 4f�.fl d8
i68 Q1-12-2d0€3 21:46t35 9$.1 �B
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
� - '�
189 01-12-200£3 21:96:36 97.5 dB
19b C�1-12-2�30$ 21:46:37 4E.6 dB
19i QI-7�-�(}0$ 21:46:38 9'7.9 d5
192 f71-12-2008 21:45:39 4f3.f7 d8
193 �1-17_-2008 21:96:9Q 4'7.� �B
154 01-12-2(�08 21:46.A1 97.6 dB
195 411-12-2C106 21:46:42 47.9 dB
196 01-12-200$ 21 :96:43 A$.� dE
197 01-12-2C1Q8 21:46:49 99.Q dB
19& Ci1-12-20(1$ 27.:46:95 46.9 dB
199 01-12-2Q08 21:46:46 48.7 dB
20� 01-12-2G08 21:96:97 47.?_ d$
2G11 Q2-1?-7_OQ8 21:46:99 �i7.3 d8
202 01-12-20Q8 21:96:49 48.9 �B
203 �1-12-2CiG�8 21:46:50 �g.9 ��
2Q9 01-12-2Q08 21:96:51 � �.� ��
205 01-12-2(I08 21:46:52 47.6 dH
2LY6 01-12-2008 27.:46:53 �s.`� d$
247 O1-12-ZOQ8 21:+16:�4 99.3 �&
20$ 01-12-ZOtJB 21:96:55 97.3 dA
2f39 01-1?.-2Q08 21:46:56 47.A d�
21fl 01-12-2008 21:46:57 47.1� ��
211 01-12-2008 21:46:5$ 4�.� ��
2I2 OI-17.-2008 21:4Ea:59 9�.`� �g
213 Q1-72-2Q08 21:47:qQ 4€�.2 dI3
214 01-12-2D08 21:4�:q1 4E3. 1 dB
215 01-32-20q8 2I:47;q2 47.6 dB
21£i �1-12-2E70t3 21:47:03 48.4 �B
217 01-12-20Q8 21:47:04 46.9 dB
21f3 01-12-2�(78 21:47:tJ5 4B.0 dB
219 01-22-2Q08 21:47:06 46.7 dB
220 C11-12-2QU8 21:97:07 47.9 dB
221 01-12-20Q6 21:97;Q6 �i`�-5 �$
222 Oi-i2-2008 21:97:p9 93.9 dB
223 �1-12-2(3£�8 21:4`7:10 50.2 dB
?24 01-7?-200f� 21:97:1T 52.2 ��
225 l�1-12-2008 21:4?:12 5�.7 dB
226 01-12-20�8 21:97:13 54.5 dB
227 01-12-2008 21:47:14 �8.9 d$
228 a1-12-2008 21:97:15 63.6 dB
22�3 tlI-12-200� 21:97:16 62.5 dB
230 Q1-12-20L78 2I:47:17 6D.� d�
231 01-12-2f�t18 21:47;13 59.0 �B
232 q1-17_-20C�8 21.47:19 60.6 d�
233 01�-32-20Q8 2i:97:2(l �i9.2 ��
23A O1.-12-2008 21:97:22 66.°� dB
235 01-12-20G�fs 21.91:2:d £�5,9 dB
236 OI-12-2�08 21:9�:2� 61.4 d9
237 Oi-1�-�i708 21;47:24 61,5 c98
238 01-1'1-2p08 21:97:25 64.8 ciB
239 01-12-2008 21:97:26 59.7 dB
24Q OI-12-ZpQ£s 2I:47:27 60.� d�
24: Q1-12-240F3 23:47:26 5C.5 d8
'l42 (11-12-2t708 21:9"7:29 5f.9 d8
243 01-12-2Q08 21:97;3C� 53.6 dB
249 01-12-200$ 21:47.31 53.6 dB
245 C11-12-2JQ8 �1:9�:32 51.9 dB
24b O1-12-20af3 21:97:33 A9.7 d8
247 01-12-2UOE 21;97:34 49.3 dB
249 01-12-2008 21:97.35 97.8 dB
299 01-12-20t1E3 21:47:36 47.b r3B
25f� �1-12-2008 21:4r:37 A?.f dF3
251 O1-I2-2008 21»47:3� 47.€3 ti8
miNurEs
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
t
a
, �
252 Q1-17_-2008 21.d7:39 ��•� d�
253 O1-12-2008 21:47:9Q 52.6 dA
?�4 01-12-2008 21:47:91 47.9 dB
255 01-12-2008 21:47:42 A7.6 dB
256 01-12-?.008 21:<17:93 ��. i ��
257 Oi-i2-7q�8 ?.1:4?:49 48.£s da
2a8 01-12-2008 22:47.95 99.6 +�B
259 fi1-12-20Q6 21 :97:46 50.2 ��
2bq Q1-12-?.C}08 21:97:47 59.5 dB
261 01-12-2408 21:47:4$ 56.6 t�g
262 01-12-2408 21:47:q9 S1.2 dS
2fi3 01-12-2f)b8 21:97:50 52.9 d�
264 b1-12-2QD8 21:47:51 59.a �B
265 01-12-2008 21:97:52 ��.0 ��
2bEa O1-I2-2008 21:47:53 53.2 d�
26a 01-12-2008 21:4j:�4 52.0 as
2b$ 01-12-20€78 21:A7:55 52.7 dB
269 01-12-'lUQ$ 2I:47:56 53.1 �B
27Q O1-12-20t18 21:9"�:57 53.2 d8
271 01-12-2008 21:97:58 51.1 dH
272 01-12-204Ei 21.:47:59 49.8 dB
273 O1-12-2(708 21:48:q0 5Q.3 d�
274 01-12-2008 21:4s�:q1 50.8 dB
275 Oi-12-ZQ08 21:98:02 52.9 dB
276 01-12.-2t�U8 21:98:Q3 50.9 �1�
277 01-12-2�08 21:Afl:04 99.7 dB
278 01-12-20Q8 21:48:t75 50,0 d�
279 Q1-12-20Q9 21:46:(�6 4�.4 dg
28D O1-12-20Q8 21:AB:0�7 49.9 dB
281 01-12-2QCJf3 21:48:C?£� 45.5 riR
282 03-12-20(J$ 21:9£3:09 98.4 r3B
283 01-1�-2008 21:48:1(a 98.6 dB
289 01-12-20�8 21:46:11 5(�.7 dB
285 C��-12-2008 21:48.12 50.1 dB
286 Q1-12-20Q8 2I:48:1� 53.0 dB
287 01-12-2008 21:48:14 AB.B d8
288 01-12-2408 21:4F3;15 53.3 �B
28� 01-1?.-2QOB 21:A$:16 47.4 dB
29Q O1-12-2008 22:98:17 54.0 dB
?91 Q1-I2-?.008 21348:18 54.8 d8
292 fl1-17.-?_b08 21:48:79 49,4 dB
�93 01-12-2008 22:48:20 50.2 ci6
299 Qi-12-2Q08 21:98:21 98.5 �$
295 07-12-20Q6 21:48:22 4E.6 dB
29b 01-12-2{�Q6 22:48:23 49.9 d�
297 (?1-12-2008 11 :4£3:ZA 4$.4 d�
298 Q1-12-ZUtI#� 21:98:�5 9$.9 d8
299 Q1-12-2008 21:48:26 9�.4 d�
30Ci 01-12-2008 2I:�18:27 5C1.5 dEi
301 Q1-12-2008 21:46:2$ 51.3 d8
302 QI-12-2tI0fis 21:48:?.4 52.3 ��
303 �1-i2-20U£� 21:46:3Cr A9.2 d�
3G9 01-22-20C�f3 2I:4B:31 48.3 d8
305 01-12-2U08 21:98;32 49.8 dB
�4� fl]-12-?.t?0$ 21 :48:33 49.5 d8
307 01-12-2(l08 21:48:3� 49.6 dB
3Q8 01-12-c"t?t78 21.48:3� 5p.5 c3B
3179 t�l-i2-2008 21:4$:36 50.q dH
31Ct t71-I2-2�}06 2I:48:37 47.$ dB
3Y1 U1-I2-2D(7� 2T:46:38 48.5 dB
312 C31-�2-2008 21:A8:39 4$.2 ciH
313 ai-li-2C��8 21:98:40 46.0 dB
379 01-17-2(1d�3 ?1;48:41 47.6 d8
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
. �
315 01-12-20Q� 21:4�:92 48.2 �
316 Q1-12-20Q8 21:98:43 46.? df3
317 b7-12-2008 L1:48:49 47.4 df�
�I$ Q1-12-2008 21:98:45 46.3 da
319 Oi-12-2Q08 21:48:96 47.3 dB
320 01-12-2008 ?.1:48:�7 48.6 dB
��i o�-i2-�aos 21:�s:a� ��.�1 aa
322 01-12-2008 21:48:49 �B.Q �B
323 01-12-2d0� 21:98:50 97.� dB
329 Oi-12-20Q8 2] :98:51 Q6. 3 dS
325 01-72-2008 21:98:52 97.5 d8
326 t71-12-2D(7$ 21:48:53 �6.6 dB
327 01-12-2a08 21.46:59 9$.6 dH
328 Q1-12-2008 21:48:55 4J•5 d�
329 ai-zz-a�oa '21:98:56 47.4 dB
330 01-12-2oos 2�:9a:5+ a7.� aa
331 01-12-2C108 2I:48:58 48.4 d8
332 01-12-2008 21:98:�9 49.7 dB
333 t71-]2-ZQ08 2i:45:00 49.5 dB
334 01-12-2fl08 21:49:q1 51.f: d�
335 O1-i2-2Q�8 21:49:02 SC�.� d�
336 01-12-2UU8 21:99:03 5�.3 ��
337 01-12-2Q08 21:45:t1� A9.� dB
338 Q1-12-20t�8 21:�4:05 52,5 ciB
339 Qi-12-2008 21:49:06 5�.7 ��
390 01-12-2Q08 21:99:0? 56•-`> ��
391 n1-12-2008 21:99:06 5a.a dB
342. D1-12-2008 21:99:C]9 51.4 dR
343 01-12-2t�08 21:99:10 99.d dB
399 01-12-20�J8 2i:49:11 50_? riB
��� oi-�z-2aae 2i:��:a2 �y.� ��
396 01-12-2C108 21:99:13 50.6 dB
347 b1-12-2b08 21:99;14 ¢$.� ��
348 Di-12-200B 21:49:?5 4�. t ��
399 01-12-20178 21:Q9:16 47.1 d�
350 fl1-22-2b08 21:49:17 47.4 d�
351 tll-I2-20C16 21:49:1£! 47.3 �
352 01-1?_-2008 21:9�3:19 9�.7 dB
353 ql-I2-2flq8 21:99:7ti ��.� d�
359 O1-12-7.008 21:49:21 4$.� ��
355 O1-]2-2008 21 :A9:22, 48.1 dB
356 41-12-2008 21:49:23 47.6 d�
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
x �'�
?
0 ...._.
. w
__,_ _..
,. . �� ._ � .... � � � .. �� -_
� � C i)
� � � � �y�
O�'.. Q� F'" ' t,1,1 ;
Q1 V� !
� [�/ '�
L--- __.____ ��
r - --
;� � �r�►, ��� � �
�',
o z:� �
o', XS
;N
1 V�'I � V�? �:
� �1 1�i �
,
c�� m .
'�., ����� � ��, E
§ ar .�
ip c:: ; i4
O' � c `.�
' � T', '�'� 'y
i I � Om, �
` � � � - ' ,...� ....�� �, l I } �'
� _— ,
--� �
p � � � 1 �.. � � � rn �
._. — --- � -
{ ! I 1 J
i'�I �J`'w ! ! , � �
t�� ��---_ _ ; � �
; �___ _— � � �
� _._
' � � Q ¢ i
r � �
��- � �� ` � .....� � - --� ' t Q � �
, � _ _ _._ ,
�� � � � � �
+, � , ,.
�, , _..
� �-`��� — - - - -------�
� __.. �__ _ �
� - I
� �_ , �r` � I
o': � � _ .. _ �- - - --�-- � � � �
� � -- , �; _l ' ' ' 1 � ;
'� � j � - � , �- --}-- 1 � - � r i r�
�' '~ � i.. I, � a � � I
,
I� � � : , i.._._ __ ._. _�,_ -- � J I
�v
��
r .
! � v' r � � ! = ��� �
, m.; _ _ w. .... = r
_ ,
.c ,_..._ - � ; ,
. . �
,�o �.� '
, � -�- �
..
c v, �
� , mI -- � � „ 1 r ,
� � __.__ , � ,
i= �. ,. _ ,�--
, ,, � � �� . ,,. - - � �
� � t
�
�- � � L
� � � � `� � ¢pI � - ,� ' Q , � � �.
V � N � i �
� � �
y, Ilj . . . , . , . ; ' Cy J l0 t0 .
i �
"i +i � o i � Q �C
,p, -_ � y� o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 � �
,�" i� �� � �� � � � � � �r cgi c�Li � � � �� �f�
, � �� _...
> � � �
i' � l � (p� � �t ( N
� � '�i O f � u, $ $
�:' � _ � ar ��i'� � 6l i rn � �C ��� � � �
� �
� .� `" _ �.. � � O,o � �y �,'
� a' � S� O � ` �' 1 � ♦ � • y�j •
; � '� � a t � aa � �. � v, Z ur �-
m I � � E � � '� :r o � cy aC cv
i
� C� 4
aC(� � +� � �J � � �-
�.' "'�= .�——__________ _ _._-�
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
:,�
<
� __.... .,... . ��...__ � ._. _.,���,._.._ �, ... _.._..____._____�� ._�m w_, ��_��.n�,._,_,
; !x< �^ � �
�` `�" ,4�., C � ;„.��� �
� L� � �; �
� � t"""� �' � @ ��..
� ^ k� �
� � � �� 1
.si ��, ��
t:
� �.r:'' ��
��; ; ;.'�; � � i
�A� � � � . . .. !
i �`' � n,; '� �� � � �� �
`�tr, � � � �
��
i-
� ���f � �
�„ i
� � '
� � � �����
�
�:�:`� *"-�
, s ��-_..
�
� �
n`�r � �Y"!
>* �
� ^� '
� � �
:a--o �
� � �
..�.-.,r�
a..+�°"� .� "� I
s�-s
� �
�
wr�
�
ar�s
�
r,";' �
�
�� � i I �
�����
,
, -�r
�� �. �_ . m . . �
��",;�r� �
�` �n Y j�N� �^ �, .�+ °,�t` � �
�� 4�i i tl ���a:. _w--..
�� i f v����� � �� �
� ` s`�„l�t��,h, .. � . �.r^^. � .
� 'SC��4; �
,:, �"I��!s�'`�� � c-`_a
1 I �ti���g.
N 6�
� ,�4��`,�'+ � �
��� ���s� � �
I .w....
��
j
�� ��: �, � � � �
� �'���'' � �""�_ '*�"". `� �
y� ;� V'.� �
.r...?�r^,,,
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
, P
Index ---date--- --time-- 5ound_Level unit
1 O1-12-2(108 22:50:90 50.6 dB
?_ 01-12-2008 21:50:91 51.3 dE
3 01-12-2008 21:50:92 51.b dB
9 01-12-2Q08 Z1:S�t:43 51.0 dS
5 Oi-12-20[}6 21:50:99 5t7.9 dB
6 O1-12-20C38 21 :5�:�J5 49.9 d8
7 p1-12-20C38 21:50:96 99.5 dB
8 Ol-I2-2048 21:5£�:97 99.3 dB
9 01-12-200$ 21:50:48 99.3 dB
10 01-12-2008 21:50:99 99.1 dB
11 d1-12-2008 21:5Q:50 49.0 d8
12 07.-12-20Ci8 21:5(?:51 �l�.l dB
13 Q1-12-2008 21:50:52 99.0 dB
I9 01-12-2008 21:50:53 �1�.� �B
15 01-12-2008 21:5():59 9�3.5 d�
16 01-12-'1008 21:50:55 49.£3 dB
17 q1-12-2Qf78 21:50:56 49.5 dB
18 01-12-20b8 21:50:57 99,2 dB
19 Ui-12-20C1$ ?.1:5U:58 99.1 ��3
20 (�1-12-2008 21:50:59 49.8 d�
21 Oi-12-2008 21:51:Ob 48.7 dB
22 QI-12-2008 21:51:01 98.4 dB
23 01-12-20Qfs 21:51:02 48.7 dB
29 01-12-2t}�fl ?1 :51:D3 qg.d d�
25 01-12-2008 21:51:Od �18.(t dB
26 O1-12-200$ 21:51:05 48.1 dB
27 Q1-12-2006 21:51:�6 98.2 dB
28 01-12-2QQ8 21:5I:(77 4£�.3 dB
29 O1-12-20078 2I:52:Q8 �I9.d di3
30 41-12-��Q8 21:51:t79 A9.6 dB
31 O1-12-2.001fi 21:53 :1C1 99.6 c��3
32 01-12-2�Q8 21t51.11 99.4 d�B
33 01-12-2008 21:51:I2 99.8 d�
34 01-12-20078 21:51:13 5i.a dB
35 01-12-2008 21:51:i4 50.7 dB
36 Ci1-12-2008 21:5i:15 50.4 d$
37 01-12-2008 21:51:I5 50.1 dH
38 t71-12-200� 21:51:17 49.b dB
39 [11-12-2008 21:51:18 49.4 �8
9Q 01-12-2008 21:51:19 9�.4 dB
41 Q1-12-2008 21:51:?0 49.9 d6
92 Q1-12-2C108 21.51 :21 �9.1 dB
43 01-12-2�03 21:52:22 49.1 dB
49 41-12-20Q8 21:5I:23 49.0 dF3
95 01-12-2Q08 21:51:24 A9.0 dB
Ab q1-12-2t108 �1:5?:25 49.0 dB
47 01-12-2QQ8 2I:51:26 49.b dB
4E� Q1-12-2�0�3 21:5t:27 46.9 dB
49 Oi-12-200£3 21:51:28 99.6 dB
50 t}1-12-2008 21:51:29 50.2 dB
51 02-12-2008 21:51:3� 50.7 dB
5? �D2-i2-26C?q 21;51:31 5Q.9 dB
�� oz-i2-aoae z� :�z:�z sa.� da
�� o�-xz-aaa� ��:s�:a�i sa.� ds
55 01-12-20t�8 �1 ;51 :39 5a.8 d�
5b �1-12-21�Q8 23:51:35 51.0 dB
57 01-12-20i�� 2I:51:35 51.4 d6
�e o1--i2-2oQs 21:s�:�� 5�.t as
59 Qi-12-20f�8 21:51:38 56.9 d8
60 01-12-?�?�?B 27 :5t:39 61 .d dH
61 �1-i?..-2Q3C38 21s51:40 60.5 d8
62 01-12-200A 21:51:44 58.4 dH
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
-
;;
a,
63 QI-12-20Q8 21:51:92 56.4 d$
69 O1-i2-2048 21:51.43 55.0 dB
fi5 01-12-2008 21:51:99 54.6 �B
66 Q1-12-2008 21:51:45 55.0 dB
67 01-22-2008 21:51:96 60.9 dB
68 O1-I2-2008 21.51:97 76.0 dB
69 Q1-12-20t18 21:51:98 6$.? d�
7Q 01-12-20t18 21:51:99 62.? dB
72 01-12-2008 21:51:50 54.4 d6
72 UI-12-2Q08 2i:5I:51 75.1 dB
73 C1-12-200Es 21:51:52 67.9 dB
74 01--12-2qq8 21:54:53 61.4 dB
75 Oi-12-2008 21:51:54 58.0 dB
76 01-12-2008 21:52:55 55."7 ��
7� Qi-12-20Q8 21:51:56 57.7 dB
7a Q1-12-20U8 21:51:57 55.6 d�
79 OI-12-2R08 21:52:58 54.�3 d$
8Q Q1-12-2008 21:51:54 53.1 d8
B1 (11-12-2f7aR 21:52:Q0 52.2 ��
$2 01-12-200$ 21:5�:01 51.3 d�
s� ai-i2-2aos zg:sz:oz so.� �a
84 Q1-1Z-2d�6 21:52:03 50.1"3 d6
85 �1-12-2Qt38 21:S2:t74 49.1 dFi
86 01-12-2t�08 21s52:05 �9.4 d8
87 01-12-26()8 21:52:06 49_1 dB
88 O1-12-2006 21:52:07 4ES.8 dB
89 Q1-12-2QOA 21:52:08 48.7 dB
�o o1-�z-zoaa z� .5�:ay ae.� as
91 01-12-2fJQ8 21:52:I0 48. 7 dB
92 01-12-2046 21:52:1i 48.E3 dA
93 p1-12-2Q06 21:52:12 49.1 ��
99 C)1-12-200II 21:52:13 4�.7 d8
95 01-12-20Q8 21:52:14 51.0 dB
96 Oi-12-2�t78 21:5?:15 55.9 dB
97 01-12-20Q8 21:52:i6 69.6 dB
9B 01-12-2008 21:52:17 67•9 d9
y9 L?1-12-2�tt)�3 21:52:18 6'1.. 3 d8
100 OI-12-2008 21:52:19 58.9 d�
101 Q1-12-2008 21:52:2Q 56.6 dE3
ib2 02-12-20q8 21:52:�1 59•'3 dB
103 41-12-2008 21:52.22 53.5 d8
1�4 �1-12-2008 21.5�:23 52.9 dB
lOS O1-I2-2C�C98 21:5?.�9 51.7 dB
l06 O1-12-2CJQ8 21:52:25 51.Q ��
107 fll-i2-200£� 21:52:26 50.5 tiB
1Q8 C11-12-2flC78 2I:52:27 50.1 dH
1C79 01-I2-i0t�E3 21;52:2E� 49.Es dB
11£� U1-12-20Q8 2.3:52;29 99.5 dB
lll Q1-12-2U4� 2'1.52:3(? 49.4 dB
112 01-12-200t3 27.:52;31 d9.6 dB
113 01-12-2008 21:52:32 4g.`� ��
114 Q7-12-2QQ8 21:52:33 ''�(�.9 d8
?15 Q1-12-244E3 21:52:39 52.Q dH
116 01-12-2t�09 21:52:35 51.� dB
117 O1-12-2t70� 21:52:36 51.6 dB
116 01-12-2f?0�3 21.52:37 51.6 dB
119 Q1-12-2Q08 2i:52:38 51 .1 dB
120 Q1-12-2QQ8 21:52:39 `��-� ��
i2i 01-12-2Q�9 21:52:40 50.5 d8
I22 01-I2-�00� 21:52:4I 5b.� dB
123 Q1-12-20Q8 21:52:42 5f�_1 dA
129 01-12-20G8 21:52.:43 99.8 c1B
12S 41-12-2048 2I:52:49 49.� dB
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMIS510N EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
�!
, . -•
126 01-12-2008 21.52:45 99•4 d$
127 OI-12-20(}8 21:52:96 99.2 �B
12$ 01-12-20(}8 21:52:47 49.0 dB
129 �1-12-2068 21:52:48 9�•8 dB
130 01-12-20b8 21:52:49 4E�.7 ��
331 Q1-12-2�08 21:52:50 9�.� ��
132 OI-12-20aF3 21:52:51 98.5 dB
l33 f�1-12-20Q8 21:52:52 48.5 d�
139 01-12-2Q08 21:52:53 �g.9 d�
135 01-12-'1.008 ?..1:52:54 48.5 dB
136 G1-12-2008 21;�2:55 4g•`� ��
137 01-12-2�09 2I:52:56 48.9 da
138 Q1-12-200£ 21:52.:�°1 9f?.6 dS
139 01-12-2008 21:52:58 4�.1 d�
140 01-12-2006 21:5"1:59 5p.3 d8
141 01-12-200� '11:�3:00 �0.� ��
142 Qi-12-2008 21:53:01 �1•d �
l43 oi-�7-zoaa 21:53:�2 53.3 ��
244 01-12-2008 ?.2:53:03 �2.� d8
195 01-12-2QQB 21:53:0�1 52.2 d8
146 O1-12-20D8 21:53:Q5 52.5 ciB
147 01-12-20U6 21:53:0� 51.1 dB
198 41-12-2da8 21:53:Q7 51.0 dII
199 01-12-20Q$ 21:53:0$ `,1 .� ��
15Q Q1-12-2008 21:53:49 51.2 d8
15? 01-12-2ti0� 21e53:20 50.7 dB
152 01-12-2t�08 21:5�:11 50.4 dt3
153 01-12-2009 21:53:12 50_3 dB
154 01-12-2008 2I:53:13 SQ.0 dB
155 01-12-2C1b8 21:53:�4 49.1i dB
156 DI-12-200� 21:53:15 49.2 d8
I57 p1-12-2t7(�£3 22:53:16 98.8 dB
156 01-12-2008 21 :53:1'7 98.6 d�
159 (}2-12-2b0E3 21:53:18 48.A dB
I6C1 ()1-11-2(}(�€3 21:53:2�3 98.2 d8
I61 �1-12-2fiiC3E3 21:53:�0 9$.1 dB
1f2 (�1-12-2410H �I:53:21 4�.9 dB
I63 f11-12-2Q08 �1.53:22 97.7 dB
164 01-12-2f1(7Ei 21:5�:23 97.� dB
165 Oi-12-2008 21:53:29 47.6 dA
16£ Q1-12-2008 21:53.25 4�.4 d6
1Fa7 O1-12-200� 21:5�:26 ��.3 d8
16f3 01-12-2t�OB 21:53:27 47.2 d6
165 G1-12-2008 21:53:2$ �7,1 d�
I70 Q1-12-2Ci0Q 21:53:2� 4"8-1 dE3
171 02-12-200E� 21:53:3Q 47.] dB
112 01-12-2C1Q8 21:53:31 47.1 dB
173 C�1-12-2008 21:53:32 47,i �B
1"79 �1-:2-20(J�? �1:53:33 47.1 dLi
175 01-12-2008 21:53:34 91.1 ��
176 OI-12-2QD8 21:53:35 47.0 dg
177 b1-12-2(l08 21 :53:35 97�a da
1?ffi CJi 12-2�?OE? 2i:53:3� ��.Q ��
179 Q1-12-2q08 21:53.3$ 97.6J dB
if3q (?I-22-2f1J9 21:53: �'� 9b.7 d'B
181 01-12-2qG8 2Ic53:40 97.1 dB
162 01-12-20t7B 21:53:91 97.b dB
if33 01-12-2Q0$ 21:53:42 47.4 dB
lfl4 Q2-12-2t�C18 21:53:A3 4?.� dB
185 (71-12-2008 23:53:44 47.Q dB
1.86 O1-12-2C}l78 71 :53:45 9�.t� d8
1�7 �1-12-2Q08 21:53:96 4E;.� dB
1F3A 01-12-2C}08 21:53.�E7 46.£3 d8
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JAhIUARY 15,2008
�.
. , �
189 02-12-2�(i8 21:53:98 4�.8 dB
19Q 03-12-2008 2?:53:93 ;6.7 dB
l91 QI-12-2008 21:93:5(1 9fi.5 �s
192 O1-12-2Q08 21:5�:51 96.9 dB
193 Q1-12-2008 21:53:52 9b.9 dg
199 al-i2-2Q(18 ?1:53:53 96.9 de
;95 01-12-20(�8 21 :53:59 �1�.� �B
196 02-22-2009 21:53:5y �7�.� �a
197 Oi-12-2008 21:53:56 46.4 dB
198 01-12-?00$ ?.1 :53:57 46.5 ��
199 Q1-12-2Q(78 21:53:5� 96.6 d�l
20Q 01-12-2Q08 21:53:59 4�•� �B
201 01-12-?.OQ$ 21:59:00 97.1 d9
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
4 f� � ���
, " :
�
,_.._ ___ . _�. �
M - _ . } ...._...-7� C711 � �
� r � 1��W � � 'O tY � F:,,-
` Q y� I ,
�� � . _b ._... � � , � H 1W
t11, �
aa LL'
E v
_ 1----
� ► '.�. : � '
;� � � �
O v�k O
O' � ��' �
��
E.1 � j
i'rj � <i 1;� l
��.O B , � tC ..�. �
.��, .._. y � . 'Q =�- � :
,� N'. � I . j � } � i ', .m.! J �..
�. I , 4 � I '�., � "Z'��° �
... . ti� ' ` � I �� O�I ���
� ^W„ '. : , �� : �.
ri � �
�:��. � �� f= ��,,. � � Q � v} d �
�+�
I•��' �� � I � J
, ' � � :
� �a�� � � � 5 � d a
, �� � ._.._
`� n. ti
r �. �
� ��� � , � ;
j+. � 1 l7 � ' � ; � ; , ' L—_.__-- �
, ..___a..,.__,.
�
�� G � .. . _ . ;_,_ . . � ��
......... e
t� � ` , � � ,�:
�_....... ___ _ ....___
1 �
�� � ...T.._._. . .,........_ I.�) .,. 1 � �� Fw
C Q ....�....
L � �V
'`'h, r
`*,Q� 1 U . �y1v^�1 _,. ..7 � '��' �� (
. � ��',� �� V ��' 7 j � � � �� � !
c .._... � '°'
I t �
G �
�.:T� J�-t �..� . . I ' ' I � .
j (� �Jy �
i�I �f'"`� ,"� } ,_� � , � } . ' � _ ?:: ..t i
I ��
� c � � 1 �� �f
� tv
� !,� ,� � � � ��, ; ;�__.� . �. �,_ � - � �
� � �C �' � � .
i c,. +� � �.,. ° I � { i
�
" i _", ' p ' �
i V � N t' , i � � o
� ��� � �� ` � > � �
� g �
`= ii 8 � ' ¢ a
f � __ i � o p o 0 o c o o c? o o �` � ':
�l' � � � � � S � $ � � � � �
,, � � -----
�
`.° { o! � � � I $ $
1 Ot � � N p �
('j]� � �A tA �N -
v __—I +"- � �y.- � � � � �� � 0 �� � C? . ; .
i Q? =s � Q
x
i > � Ll � Q'' ! II.' N ♦ t,u • u? �
a F..� � � 4U .A � LL �n �-` u� �
� � •C � (,� lZ � Cy tq y� � N � N
�� � �i � � �@ � � . � � w� O Q } �i
.. ._. . ....__ ,:.-�..�
_�' � �_______..__._. ��'----" � �..-. � . . :. :_... r ... .. . .
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
�
� .�
�
.��. __._f.._ :�... �� � �� .��.�._._...__ .,.�.n.m_��� n�.� �,
x �'�a`��;�_ � ( � , � "�_ �
' i
� �.' �
f� � �4 �
9 ��
� � �.
i ,�' � �� �
::,
�
�.., � � � ��
�
�i' � � � � �' � j
adk"': � . � . .j
� Q i
� t
�a I
�
� �
�°"+ �
i ��
r � �
t 4' �
��� i�'�
�"j."� �d{ � ''
'` �
t...3� .,,q.-
� � �
.s...+ �
� �,f>
�
� � �
r.�^y �
� �
'�,�;�. � .�.
�ri�; �
z�� ,"-.-
�;��e�
�
P� *� �
„� �
� . � �
��;; � � �'s � �
9 � N �
,„ � f
���,n � ��. �
3 '�rq t�'���.° � � '��'
�,; ' 1► r--�
---
� � �
�� I������ �� �
�;� �,3�,,; � .. i C�.�
�r�s ��„�C� -�s� � �:y,
�b
� """"°°"'" �,w.,•..
^�'
� rla��`�` � ►..r-°, � � �
��������, �
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
#
?nctex ---date--- --time-- Sound_Level unit
� 1 01-42-2008 21:50:40 50.f dB
2 01-12-2008 21z5(3:91 51.3 d&
3 01-12-2Q08 21:5t�:42 51.Q �B
d 01-12-2Qfl8 21:5(7:43 51.0 dB
5 01-12-2008 21:50:94 50.4 dB
6 01-12-2d06 21:50:45 49.9 dR
7 01-12-20578 21:50:96 49.5 dB
s ai-iz-2aoe 21:50:47 49.3 dB
9 41-12-20Q8 21:50:98 49.3 dB
2(7 01-12-2008 2I:5d:49 49. 1 dB
11 Q1-12-2�08 21:50:50 49,Q dB
i2 Q1-12-2Q06 2I:50:51 �3�. 1 dB
13 O1-12-2008 21:50:52 49.C? dB
19 O1-12-20(�8 21;5Q:53 99.0 dB
15 01-12-2008 21:5d:54 49.5 da
1Es Q1-12-2t;08 '11:5C3:55 99.8 dB
17 01-12-20a8 L1:50:56 49.5 dB
lE3 O1-12-20Ct6 21:50:57 99.2 dB
14 Oi-7"l-ZOUB 21:50:58 49.J- �B
20 QI-12-2QQ8 21:50:59 4t3.8 d8
21 01-12-2008 21:51:00 9£3.7 d$
2� O1-Z2-20Q8 ?_1:5I :01 9£�.9 dT�
23 01-12-20t)� 2I:5i:02 9$.2 dB
24 01-12-20U6 21:51.03 48.0 dB
25 01-12-200$ 21 :52:t7A 9f3.0 d€3
25 O1-12-2008 21:51:05 98.1 dB
27 01-12-2008 21:51:�l6 4H.2 dB
28 Q2-12-2008 21.51st�7 48.3 d8
29 01-12-2�06 21.51:08 49.A dR
30 Q1-12-20(38 21:51:Q9 49.Fi dH
31 01-12-2�J08 2I;51:IQ 49.K dB
32 01-12-2Q08 22;51:11 99.9 dB
33 b1-12-2C3(38 21:51:12 99.� d�
3�t 01-12-2(30$ 21:51:23 51.Q d8
35 O1-12-200E3 21:51:19 50.7 dB
36 01-22-200d �1:51:I5 50.4 d8
37 01-12-2008 21:51;1� 50.1 dB
38 p1-12-ZOC18 2I:51;1? 49.6 d8
35 01-12-2�08 21:51:I8 49.9 d6
9(J O1-12-2008 21:5I:15 49.9 dB
91 02-1"L-2C30$ 21:51:20 99.4 d8
92 U1-12-2008 22.51:21 ��.Z d�
43 Qi-12-2qOB 21.:5i:22 9'�.1 d8
44 C11-12-2t�Q8 2I:Sl :?3 49.4 dF3
45 Cl1-12-2�JCl8 2i:a1:24 49.t1 dH
46 Q1-i2-2QC�8 21:�1:25 49.0 dS
4"7 01-12-20Q$ 2I:51:25 49.C� dB
9E3 C71-12-2QQk3 2I:51 :27 48.9 dQ
Q9 01-12-2t�08 21:51:28 99.6 dB
5d 01-12-20q8 21:51:29 50.2 dS
52 01-12-2009 21.51:30 50.7 dB
52 01-32-2C7t?�3 21:5] :31 50.9 d�
53 fl1-12-200$ 21:51:32 5C1.7 dB
54 O1-12-2008 21:51:33 50.7 d8
55 01-12-2C7�8 21:51:39 50.$ dB
56 01-12-20(76 2i:51:3�, 5I.Q dB
ST O1-12-2b08 11:51:36 51.4 dB
58 Qi-12-2nt>Es 21;51:37 53.1 dk3
59 Q1-12-2QC�& 21;51:38 56.9 dH
60 Q1-12-2008 21:51:34 61.4 dB
�y os-lz-zooa a.l:st;ae, ��.s d�
b2 OI-12-2Ca06 21:5T:AI 58.4 dB
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
�
. ' �
63 01-12-2C�08 21:52:d'2 55.9 dB
� 64 (7i-12-2008 21:51.43 55.(7 dB
� 65 �1-12-2f108 21:51:99 54.6 ds
66 O1-i?_-2.Q48 21:51:95 55.0 d8
�7 01-12-2fJ�18 21:51:9b 60.� d6
69 01-12-2QC18 21:51:97 �6.Q dB
69 01-12-2008 21:51.:48 56."] dB
70 01-12-2008 21:51:9� 62.2 dB
71 01-12-2Q08 21:5i:50 69.4 dB
72 01-12-20Qt? 21.51:51 75.1 dB
73 t�1-22-20Q8 21:51:52 57.9 dB
74 01-12-2008 21:51:53 61.4 dB
75 tJ1-12-1c70£3 21.:51 :59 58.Ci dB
76 Q1-12-2d08 2I:Si:55 55•7 dH
77 Qi-12-2006 21:51:56 57. 7 dE�
�rs o�-i2-anos ai:�� :5r 55,� ��
73 01-12-2QQ$ 21:�1:58 54.9 d8
80 01-12-2�08 21:51:59 53.1 d�
Sl OI-12-20Q8 21:5?:00 52.2 dB
�i2 01-12-20U8 21:52:01 51.3 �B
a� o1-i2-�ooa zi:�z:o2 �o,� ��
en oi-iz-aaoe zi:sz:o� ao.o �s
a� oi-z2-zoae zi:��:e�� a9.� c�a
85 01-12-20Q8 21.52:05 9g•4 da
87 01-12-2008 21:52:C16 99.1 �B
88 01-12-2CS4�E3 21:52s 0? 48.A dB
84 01-12-2Q06 21:52:�8 98.7 ciB
90 01-12-20�i8 21:52:(19 48.6 dFi
91 01-12-2008 21:52:1(3 48."� d�
92 01-12-2UOFs 21:52:l1 4�.E dA
93 01-12-2Dd78 21:52:12 49.i dB
94 01-12-2008 21:5:Z:13 99.7 d8
45 01-1.2-20b8 21:52:14 51.C1 d�
96 0]-12-2008 21:52:15 55.9 d�
97 01-12-2008 23:52:16 69.6 dB
98 O1-12-2fi0fl 2I:52:17 67.9 d�
99 OI-I2-2t�08 21:52:18 62.3 dA
1Rq Q1-12-2008 21:52s19 58.9 d8
I01 01-1'1-2006 21:52:2Q 56.6 dB
102 01-12-2C?08 21.52:21 �9 •� ��
io� o1-�a-zooe zi:3l:zz :��.s ��
104 01-12-2Q08 21s52:23 `>�.� �g
I05 01-12-24(}8 21:5�.2� 51 .� dF�
lfl6 Qi-12-2t308 21:52:25 51 .U d8
107 01-12-2009 2i:52:26 50.5 dB
10$ t11-12-2i7Q8 21:52:2 t 50.1 dB
1(�4 01-12-2GC18 2�:5Zz28 4�.8 �
110 01-12-2U08 23 :52:2.9 49.5 d�
17.Z 01-17-2Q08 2i:52:3£7 49.9 d8
112 t71-12-2008 21:52:31 49.6 dB
133 01-12-2b08 21:52:32 49.9 dB
114 O1-12-2008 21:52:33 5Cl.d da
?15 Q1-12-2008 23:52:39 52.Q d�
I16 t71-12-2048 21:52:35 51.5 dB
I17 01-1�-2J08 21:52:3Ea 51.6 d8
21fi Q1-12-20�18 2I:52:37 51.6 dB
119 01-12-2f3�$ 21:52:38 51.1 d8
12fl O1-I2-24}0£� 21:52:39 50.8 dB
121 01-12-2C1�?8 21:57s90 50-5 ��
122 t71-22-2Q08 21:52:9i 5(1.9 dB
i2� oi-xa-z�o� zi:5a;�2 ��.� �B
12�3 tDI-12-2008 21:52:A3 99.8 dB
125 01-12-2008 21:52:d4 44-6 �B
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
" ��
126 01-12-2QOB 22:52:45 49•� d�
127 01-12-2Q08 21:52:96 99.2 ciB
128 tI1-12-2008 21:52:97 99.Q dB
129 01-12-20b8 21:52:98 98.8 dB
1.30 t�i-12-2pQ8 21:52:49 48.7 dH
231 Q1-12-2Q�8 21:52:50 �g.� �B
132 0l-12-2008 21:52:51 4�.5 dB
133 01-12-2008 21;52:52 48.5 �1�
139 qi-12-20b8 21:52:53 98•4 dB
135 01.-12-2C108 21:52:54 48.5 �B
136 d1-12-200B 21:52:55 46.5 dB
137 02-12-2008 21:52:56 48,4 de
138 01-12-2008 21:52:57 98•6 d�
139 01-12-20�JB 21:52:58 49. 1 dB
190 01-12-2008 21:52:59 �Q.� ��
191 01-12-2008 21:53:OU 50,6 dB
192 01-12-20C}8 21:53:C11 51.4 ��
143 02-12-2008 21:53:02 53.3 ��
194 Q1-I2-20t38 21 :53:(13 �2.9 dB
A45 01-12-2Q�8 21:53:09 52.2 d}3
196 O1-12-2.OU8 21:53:05 51•5 d8
147 �1-12-2bOt� 21:a3:06 51.1 dS
149 01-12-2Q08 21:53:0? 51.Q d8
149 01-12-2008 21:53:Q£3 51.4 dB
15� Oi-17_-20Q8 21:53:09 51.2 dB
151 b1-1�-2t708 21:53:10 �p•� ��
152 01-12-20f18 21:53:11 ���� d�
153 Qi-12-2Q08 21:53:12 50.3 �B
iS9 01-12-ZOQ8 21:53:13 50.0 d$
155 01-12-260fi 21:53:14 49.6 dB
156 O1-1�-2QC�8 21:53:15 99.2 ciB
157 01-12-�0(�R 21:53:16 98.8 dB
158 01-12-20Q6 2I:53:17 98.6 d�
159 01-12-2t108 21:53:18 A8.9 ��
16t� 01-12-2f1Q8 22:53:�9 �8.2 ci8
161 01-12-2f}f�8 21:53:2�1 A8.1 dB
162 Oi-12-2008 21:53:21 97.4 �$
163 Q1-12-2008 21:53:22 97.7 dB
164 �1-12-2008 21:53:23 97.7 dS
165 01-12-7.f��8 �1 :53.?4 47.6 cfe
165 01-32-2fl08 21:53:25 97.9 �B
7 67 O1-12-ZC10f� 21;53:26 97.3 d6
16$ O1-i2-2U08 21:53s27 4`7,2 dB
169 01-12-2008 21:53:28 47.1 d8
I7Q 01-12-2D0$ 21:53:29 4�.1 dB
171 U1-12-20q8 21:�3:30 97.i dB
1�2 U1-12-2Uti1�? 21:53t31 47.i dB
173 Q1-12-200$ 2I:53:32 47.1 dH
179 01-12-2Q��1 21 :�3:33 97.7 d8
175 A1-12-2C108 21:53:39 9'].1 dB
176 OY-22-200$ 21:53:35 97.� �B
177 QI-12-2b�8 23:53:36 A7.1 �$
��e oi-iz-aoo� ��;s�;s-� ��.o as
i79 a1-�2-�aos �i:��:�a a�.o aa
lEQ OY-12-2t�(78 21:53:3� 96.7 dA
181 01-1?.-2008 21:53:447 47.1 ��
182 OI-12-2t708 21:53:A1 47.0 d�
183 QI-12-�008 21:53:42 @�l,0 dS
1�34 t71-12-2048 21:53:43 47.0 dB
185 01-12-20Q8 21:53:A9 47.p d8
186 01-12-�008 21:53:45 47.�3 ��
1$7 i�1-12-20Ci� 21:53:�6 A6.9 dH
188 01-12-2Q0$ 21:53:47 96.8 �B
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
, � �.
189 01-12-2008 ?.1:53:4E 9�.$ �A
k 190 {11-12-2(�08 21:53:49 �1�.7 �B
I91 O1-i2-20Q8 21:53:50 46.5 dB
192 01-12-2008 ?1:53:51 ��.� �B
193 fJ1-12-2006 21:53:�2 96.4 dB
199 O1-T2-20Q8 21:53:53 4�•� ��
195 01-12-2Q08 21:53:59 96.5 dS
196 01-12-2Qq8 21:53:55 46.5 dB
197 p1-12-?_(306 21:53:56 96.9 dH
196 Oi-12-2008 21 :53:57 46.5 ��
199 01-12-2008 ?1:53:58 46.6 dB
2C10 01-1�-2008 21:53:59 96.8 dH
ao1 o�-lz-�oqg 21:34:�o a�a.i dB
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
_ �,�j�-
4 �
�
�- .� �
i � __ _ �
o I '� � �- � ►,�-
�� �� ��� � ; ��� � � ��
o� � � ;
E ' � +
._ � __—,
�� � : � �, r�
m� � ��
a :
_� � ,��
;� �
�T"' � rt� ,►
� ', ���� ; ,� _ t
, � ,� � ,
� �, r i
ro �
C] � _� �
1 �, 3: � j
� � ' � � —�_ � .��_. -' �� _.
' �
i � ',
,��, m .�,� �� Q
� �
` � � _ . - � �
t r-� � - - � -- �
� � �, . " t- . .
{
� '
�; r ; t___ __...�. ___ _.._... . - 1, � o
w (
;c 3� � `�., � � � R 2 .r
„.� , � � E � � ',,, � � �
j� -, � -' --- -�- �
6 s j _- c�--+ , � ,:,�;,� � �S � st �
� � ' �
,
a (�- ro �� � 1 1,. ':� ; # __.. ,� o �
• f� �,,, , .,� . , � � r. . ' � ' 2 '..
g:� ; � � � :...i ; ��,
o � i �
� ' .�..�................ _..._. G
� � �� � �� .._.� � �
J -� "�.. ,. ,
i�� ��. . . . _�.��- �� ---�-- � �I � � � ��
_�� �.._ � . 'I "'�� .. � �, I � �
. � � � � � . , . , __ ._� '�-�-' �� � �► {� ,�
1 �
� � � .
�
� .'' 6 ¢ " `" �
.4 � � < .E I Q �� �°
d '4.. ."+� . � �+f r... � � — � g
� � �-'� �' � ,y
,G�li � � �� ��. ' .___._ �...__ ^ ....__.� . j .0 `�' 4 �fi
, _..--- ..:: ,,�:g
't3 � � �- , � s� .� �
s`sq � , � �1 �, t
.- �
� CO T� � i�" �..� . _ _ - , ,.
- � �
__
! ._.. - ...._ .,.._ ._ � .� ' 'a
�' � � � � � �� a ���
�
� � � � ; � ; �" '
�� , , , .
� _ ..._ _ r
� ,� , � ; �
o v� � �'� �I �
�
� V � N > , �.� ,. S J .
` � , - �� � � > � � �
�;;
� v � � J' RO �i
--• y ; ., � Q d �,
"��� ti. � �� O Qf OJ � �O �t! < 4+i iV � b ,� ��:
� _�,.
W �
y LY_ _
+a � i -� r I � �
� �
~n � � O � ��� � � � � � �
C �''.: �� i fL � � 1�
r���. t� � � � d � e � � � �� L�j p � � O
� �
' y N Ca � � 1 I � N ♦ �ii + v`y ''
� ''� � m. � �.N 1 a,. .,�e (n � ,r� z ,r3 � .- .
"� pp CL � Ll�j I C4 � �+'� � �y N
c a, � cn E . E 4'► � � p �
i '� .°,� v�i c� �� >' �" '�
�
�
i�°z
�2
i�
� +
�"s�
_,;,
��
� �
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
�
r;
:;
_._ .,,.. . w. _,._ ..,_.��._....._�_._, _a�__��_ns__. _...�.�.�.�
..._.._
,A,�. .�:
„e ;
;� �� �.
z„� � x t_["`1 � ; 1""�. �"' �
� �-'�i t"`-+ •d'— ��I�� �.�r� R
�� � �„�- � �' �"� 4
f � ti � u j ;Y{{ �
r >,: t u:�^�,�
ar��
� ��'�,;� �� �
�
�>`; � � �.
,��_ � -� �
� ��
�' ��e � � —c�i ;
+�cs „�..►
�c
'�; �,� :� ..� �...��--y ' � i
F'i,
�°;'.
�
�
w. �
�
�
�
�
r: �.�-,
�;��A����� uc
� � �
� � �
�� �
� �, t--
� � , �
� #
;
...._.. �. �
;� , -
� �,, � � ,��.,
, �J �
,, e�
� �
i�r"3
r;,; ;,° a:�., �
� �
� � � � � � � �
�� �P go�t:;
;� ,�v..: � �
�` t �p"""^�+�
�
1 �E.�df C�''3� ;
; `�a�'Y �. . ,...�...
t
Ckr¢��
�frg �i���#�tii:�i$���i. , � � �.
� ��I�I���,�j, ���.. �� � .
��d
� � '� ��i . � ,�...,.. .. �� � � �.
i�� ";. � � . ,..
�� „�,� ,Gr„d_
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
'>�r
I�
Ind+�x ---c3ate--- --tim�-- Saund Level unit
1 01-12-20Q6 22:50:19 5�•� d$
2 Oi-12-2008 22:50:15 50.I dH
3 01-1"l.-2D08 22:50:16 53.0 dH
4 QI-12-2t70� 22.:5(}s17 51.3 dB
5 01-12-20Q8 22:50:I8 52.4 d8
6 01-22-Z(1t�8 22:5Q:i9 SI.S dB
7 tlI-12-20b8 22:50:20 55.1 dB
8 01-32-20Q8 22:50:21 ��.� ��
9 01-12-2008 22:5Q:7..?. 55.7 dfl
10 (?1-12-2flQ8 22:50:23 53.7 dB
11 O1-i2-2Qt}8 22:50:24 S3.g dg
12 01-12-2008 22;5{1:25 59.2 d8
a� ol-ia-2oas z2.�o:z� ��.� �s
i� oi-az-a�oe zz:50:27 5�.s d�
15 01-12-20U8 22:50:28 �j.� ��
16 01-12-2008 22:50:29 53.3 a�
17 QI-12-2QQ8 22:50:3(R 31.8 ��
18 O1-I2-2t708 22:5�:31 50.9 dB
19 01-12-2CJ�8 22;5U:32 a2•3 dB
20 01-12-2Q08 22:50:33 5C3.3 dH
21 t�l.-]'2-2UQ8 `12:5U:34 51.3 ��
22 o�-az-�ooa 22:50:35 53.7 ��
23 01-12-2q0E3 2i:5Q:36 51.3 df3
29 Q1-1.2-7ql�E� ?2:�C1:37 �1 .7 �B
25 01-12-2Q08 22:50:38 54•2 dB
26 O1-12-2Q08 22:54:3� 59.1 d�
z7 na-iz-aooa �z:�a:�o s�.� aa
z� o1-z�-aooa r�:s�:�7 c�,z .b d�
29 �1-12-20�8 22:St1:A2 53.1 �g
3Q Oi-12-20C18 22:5(�.43 57.7 d8
31 Ql-I2-2008 22:50:A9 52.6 d8
32 01-12-2bb8 22:50:45 53.? dH
33 01-12-z008 22:5f7:9C 53.8 dB
34 Oi-I2-20C19 22:5t�:97 `_:5,5 d8
35 01-12-2006 22:5Cl:98 55.9 d8
36 Oi-12-2t7Q8 22:5t�:49 56.9 dB
37 01-12-2008 22:5q:50 58.7 dB
36 01-12-2008 22:5Q:51 5�.4 dB
39 41-17.-20138 22:5Q:52 58.2 dS
40 C}1-12-2008 22s50:53 57.5 dB
91 O1-1.2-2Qt)� 22:5U:59 56.3 dB
42 O1-iZ-20(�8 22:50:55 ;`.4 dB
4� O1-12-200£3 22:s0:56 s�.? da
49 b1-12-20d8 22:5Q:57 �7.9 dB
95 Q1-12-2008 22:5t3:5Et 59.8 dB
46 Q1-12-2QOL� 22:5U:59 57.1 dS
A7 Q1-12-2008 22:51:flG 53.2 dB
48 OI-12-2f?98 22:5I:01 52,� d�
99 C1i-12-�C10� 22:51:�2 55.7 dB
50 01-12-2008 22:51:�3 S"1.7 dEi
51 01-12-2U0� 22:51:b4 56.1 dB
52 oz-i2-zoae zz:s� :o� s�.6 da
53 Q1-12-2008 22:51:L�6 56.3 dH
54 (d1-12-2bQ$ 22:`:1 :�7 53.8 dH
55 01-12-2(7U� 22:51:08 56.1 tiB
56 Oi-12-24fl9 22:51:f79 53.7 dB
5'"t �7-12-2U08 22:51:1b 55.9 d8
5$ 01-12-20q8 22:S1:i: 53.8 dB
59 01-12-2008 22s5I.17 52.5 dB
�a oz-��-�ac�� ��:�i:�� ���.�� ��
61 01-12-2008 22;51:19 53.3 dB
v
. 6?.. 01-12-2Q��3 22:51.:tc, 55.5 dB
.
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBI7 B JANUARY 15,2008
�
fa3 OI-12-�008 22:51 :16 56.7 dB
69 01-22-20b8 22:51:17 92.f3 d�
65 41-12-20fJ8 2Z:5�:1.8 59.9 dB
66 Q1-12-2008 22:51:19 57.3 dS
67 Q1-12-20�8 22:5I:20 58.1 dB
68 Oi-12-2b08 22:51:21 53.7 d8
69 `J1-12-2008 22:51�22 51.0 dB
7� 01-12-2p06 22:51.23 57.1 dB
71 Oi-12-200$ 22:S1.:29 52.3 dB
72 01-12-?.Q08 ?.?:51:?5 54.2 dF3
73 01-12-2d0E 22:51:26 ��.1 dB
7A 01-12-2008 22:51:27 58.3 dB
75 01-12-20(l8 22:51:28 55.1 dB
76 Q1-12-24Q8 22:51:29 S4."l d�
77 01-12-2008 22:51:30 52.7 dB
78 Oi-12-2008 22;51:31 55.1 ��
79 Q1-12-20p8 22:51:32 56.9 dB
80 U1-12-20Q� 22:51:33 SB.C) dB
�1 Q1-12-2008 22:51.:39 55.6 dB
82 D1-1Z-ZOQB 22:91:35 5�.1 d8
83 01-12-2008 22:51:36 53.� dB
8A 01-12-2U08 22:51:37 53.9 d�
�5 01-12-20�8 22:51:38 53.8 d8
66 01-12-200b 22:51 :39 59.2 d�
87 p1-12-2QU8 22:5] :90 58.6 d%
88 Q1-12-2U0£3 22:51:41 56.6 dB
89 01-12-2�06 22:51.42 55.7 dB
90 01--12-2QaB 22:51.:�13 a9.P dB
91 01-12-2n08 22:51:44 61.A d�
92 01-12-2008 22:51:4Ei 5$.9 d�
�33 01-12-2t7Q8 22:51:96 `�fi.5 dB
94 01-12-200� 22:51:47 61.1 ��
95 01-12-200fl 22:51:�E3 57.6 d�
96 t�1-12-2�08 22:5I:4'� �5.8 d6
97 (71-12-2a06 22:51:50 54.I dB
98 l31-12-2008 22:51:51 54.4 dB
�9 01-12-200$ 22:51:52 5-7.9 dB
100 Q1-12-20(18 22:51:53 61.2 �1�
101 01-12-24CJB 22:51:54 60.9 d�
102 Q1-12-200P 2?...51 :55 5�.� dg
103 �1-12-2�06 22;51.56 6C�.1 dH
l09 01-12-2f�0E3 22:51:57 57.3 ��
1t15 01-12-2008 22;51:58 60.9 df3
706 Q1-12-2008 22:51:59 59.5 d�
ao� oi-i�-zoos 2�:5a:aa ��.� as
zos ol-iz-zooa �z:�z:a� �a.9 as
1G9 03-1"l-2(3U8 22:52:U2 5�.0 dB
110 Cf1-12-2CT08 2?.:52:03 56.0 d8
111 01-12-2p0$ 22:52:04 53.2 d8
112 C71-1?.-2008 22:52:0� 53.q dF3
31.3 01-12-2008 22:52:Ub 54.3 dE3
i1� ai-iz-2ooe 2z:�z:�-� ��.� �g
31:� U1-12-20U8 22:52:C18 52.4 d8
116 Q1-12-2JQ8 22.52:09 51.9 �$
11� a1-12-2�lfJfl 22:5?:1C3 55.t� d�
118 01-12-20L�B 22:52sI1 54.Ei da
i19 Q1-12-20i?8 22:52:i2 51.8 d8
120 t1I-12-2Q08 22:52:1.3 50.1 dB
12I 01-12-2CJ08 22:�i2:34 52.8 dR
i2z oi-iz-�oo� z2:�z:�s s�.i aa
12� 01-22-2a0� 22:52:1fi 5�.3 c3B
129 Q1-i2-200fl 22:52:17 52.2 dB
_ I25 01-12-2(3Q8 22:52:1$ 51.7 ci$
.
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
3
126 �1-12-20Q8 22:52:19 54.2 d8
127 01-12-2Q0$ 22:52:2p 54.4 dB
128 t31-17_-2008 22:52:21 �2•� dB
129 01-1?_-2008 2?.s52:22 53.$ �$
13C2 �1-22-2�08 22:52:23 52.� �
131 01-12-2008 22;52:29 ��.� ��
132 01-12-2QOR 2?_:52:25 5I.3 d8
133 01-12-2008 22:52:26 53,9 dB
13A 01-12-20C18 22:5?.:27 5A.0 dF
135 Q1-I2-2008 22:52:28 53.4 �R
136 a1-12-20Q8 22:52:29 56.L dB
13? 01-12-?_OOE3 22:52:30 53.� d�
238 03-12-2008 ?.?:52:31 �4.$ ��
139 Oi-12-20(18 22:52:32 53. t dk�
140 01-12-2008 22:52:33 �?•� �B
191 01-12-2lJ08 'l?:5Z:�9 53.3 dB
142 t}1-12-20D8 22:52:35 53.d ��
193 01-12-2t��8 22:52:36 53.9 d�
144 Q1-12-2d06 2.2:52:37 55.3 dB
i4� ox-iz-zoae z�:sz:�� si.� aa
146 01-12-20DB 22:52:39 48.3 d$
147 (71-12-2(�08 22:52:90 SQ.B ��
198 01-12-200� 22:�2:41 �Q.€� d�
199 Q1-12-2008 22:52:�2 55.4 d8
154 �1-12-20C1f3 22;52:93 51.9 ��
151 q1-12-2dC�F3 22:52:95 49.6 dE3
152 01-12-2�09 22:57:95 53•t7 ��
153 Oi-12-2QQ8 ?.2:52:47 53.1 ��
154 t31-12-20q�i 22:52:47 57.9 dB
?55 O1-12-200$ 22:a2:46 55.2 riF3
156 C1i-12-2006 22:52:49 51.6 d�
157 Qi-1?,-2008 22:52:50 52..C1 dA
i58 a�-i2-2ao� 22:52:51 50.3 d�
]59 O1-12-2n08 22:57.:52 55.9 dA
16C� 01-12-2008 22:52:53 55.4 dB
162 o�-ia-2aoe 22:57.:54 51.3 ��
162 01-12-2C308 22c52s55 53.7 d8
163 01-12-2008 22:52:56 �p•7 �$
169 01-12-200fl 22:5�.57 `s3.5 dB
165 q1-12-2008 22:52:58 5"l.7 dB
I66 �k?-12-�OQB 22:52:59 55.1 dB
167 Ol-I?-2q08 22:53:00 51 .8 a$
168 Q1-12-2008 22:53:01 59.5 dB
169 03-12-?QQ8 22:53:Q2 59.� d�
1"7(� 01-12-2Q08 22:53:03 53.5 dY,
�71 01-12-?CAtJ$ 22.S3:OA 5?..6 dB
172 0].-12-2C�Q8 22:53:0� 53.9 ��
1't3 61-12-2Q08 22:53:�6 �5.3 dS
174 01-22-2C1Q8 22:53.{77 55.6 dB
175 O1-12-2G08 22:53:08 59.€� dB
176 QI-12-2i�Q£3 22:53:l79 58.b dB
17� Q1-12-20q8 22:53:1fl �6.2 dB
17Q p1-12-200$ 22:53:�1 55.9 dB
1y9 p1-12-2QQ8 22:53:12 56.8 ��
I8� D1-12-2C1Q8 22:53s13 5�,1 dB
181 Ol.-1�-2Q08 22:53;19 56.8 �1B
162 t�1-12-2008 22:53:15 52.3 dH
25� D1-12-2�708 22:53:16 54.2 dB
184 fl1-12-2t2118 2?:53:17 55.5 dB
185 01-12-2008 22.53:18 5a.3 dB
1$6 €J1-12-2t�0�i 22:5'i:lg 5f�.4 dH
1�7 01-12-2008 22:53:20 5?.2 dB
. 188 O1-I2-?_OOE3 22:53:21 53,9 dH
k
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
].89 02-12-24p8 22:53.2?. 54.3 dB
190 Q1-12-2Q08 2'L:53:23 55.:3 dH
191 07-7.2-2008 22:53:24 5�.� dp
192 41-22-2008 22:53:7.5 51.Q dB
193 01-12-2008 22:53:26 53.5 dB
194 O1-22-20�8 22:53:27 53.3 dA
145 01-12-200$ 22:53:28 54.4 d�
196 O1-12-2008 22:53:29 5�.� �B
197 01-12-2008 22:53:3Q 56.7 dB
198 a1-12-2006 22:53:31 55.9 �B
199 01-12-?dQ8 22:53:32 55.� dB
200 01-12-20Q8 22:53:33 5�•� �a
201 �2-12-20C}8 22:53:34 59.5 dB
2(l2 Q1-12-20q8 22:53:35 54.5 dB
2t33 Q1-12-20�8 22:53:36 54.5 d�
2{74 Q1-12-2QQ8 22:53:37 52.3 �$
2Q5 01-12-2008 22:53:38 53.5 dB
20b 01-12-2Uq£� 22:53:39 54.0 dB
207 fl1-12-20C18 ?2:53:4C} 56.1 ��
208 Oi-72-2008 22:53:41 SA.9 dB
209 01-12-20a8 22:53:92 55. 1 dg
210 01-12-2(71�8 22:53:93 5�.� ��
2I1 p1-12-20Q8 22:53:44 `�6.4 dB
2i2 01-22-2008 22:53:45 5H.7 d8
213 01-12-2008 22:53:46 �4.4 dB
2Y9 01-12-24C78 22:53:Q"7 53,9 d�
?15 01-12-2008 ?2:53:R8 52.2 �a
216 Ol-1?_-200�i 22:53:99 51.4 d�
217 01-12-20f18 22:53:5C3 52.6 d8
216 n1-12-24C7S 22:53.51 5`�.2 d�
219 02-12-20b$ 22:�3:52 53.9 c3B
220 Oi-12-20�1�3 22:53:53 51.9 d8
221 Q1-12-200� 22s53:54 52.7 dB
??.2 01-12-2008 22:�3:55 53.3 d$
223 01-12-2bQ8 22:53:5b 54."P d8
22A 01-12-2008 22:53:57 53.0 dB
225 UI-12-2t7�8 22:53:58 51.6 dB
226 01-12-2�08 22:53:59 63.5 ��
227 O1-12-2043 22:54:bC1 �1.� d�
278 O1-1.2-2048 22:54:Q1 52.9 d�
229 Oi-12-200$ 22:5A:Q� 72.5 dfl
23q 01-12-2008 22;59:03 51.3 �$
231 l?1-12-ZOCi8 22.5A:Q9 52.1 �B
232 01-12-2408 22:59:G5 49.9 �a
233 01-12-2U(}8 22;59:C}6 Sl.fi ��
239 Q1-12-2008 22:59:d7 99.9 dB
235 01-12-��C78 22:54:�7£� 58.5 dB
235 O1-I2-2�478 22:54;09 �f 7.€3 dE3
237 01-12-2t7C)S 22:54:T0 ���•� '��
238 01-12-200$ 22:54:I1 51.5 dB
239 01-12-2dL1$ 22:54:I2 50.4 dB
24L� C}I-12-2�08 22:54:13 72.5 d8
2�1 C71-12-20n8 22:54:14 98.0 dB
2q2 C31-12-2(3C18 22:59:15 99.5 ��
�
� .
�
r� .
���
�
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
���d��
� r
� I
�
"� � rn -
e� �� . , �.
�j g � � �' ' �
m� o a I �S
O, � � U � I
� �.��. ...�
'� �- , � r�:� � y �,
1 (�p� I � °� "3�
� S IL
� } a
� � i °n i€
� � ' € 4M 1fr
� p�� � � � ` � ��
� ��
.� � 'C L�� � �
�n �
� ....- J ��.
t Q �
t �i
C2. '� . . . . . �. . � O '
� . � � �k I '�. �i6 � �'', _ � � O � � ��.
N ��, s � .. { ��- I � � S J �
� "� �
N "-� � I } �
._ ....
' __ ( o .. _ _ � -� : {� ( �
� 1
,� � � � I � .�.�,„_.�:Wk- � i a a
r
� �
�
�
� � �
Q � , _ ._-.w._. ....,,._ �.
� �
� � � � � . � z
,. �� � ;
� , � - -_ _ _._--- _____.
J i � � . } �.. _ ,;�
� �
� -�—• � �. ` � �` r: �+
.c3' d'- �� � '
_ ,.� �rs �.
'- tC'� ... ...._�—. -- , - . .__.�'; , r: , ,
�� � �� � � '
,. (� _w.� c�,� .., �.� � � .
; � �: v+ �» .1 __..�._.___ .._�- r .. . .�-S-e.,, , � d l �
� ^ � .� . � � � "
� �. E
� � � �y,� � `J � 4 � �i
._ � -
. � Y � �4.. - ..�. � _ ......�. �... _.. . �
� '�Y � � � � N .°� �+.- ���, —__. .� � . _.._... . G ..,t � i
-
I
'L7,
} � � �
C_ ,� �
� zj l _ � . �'�.```_,_ -= ' - - ��__ _. _. _..� ,��t.7�
� �— _� � q
1, � +' , � -.u,r � . _
`P� p' �! � ' ' �°,''� . .> . _ . • }
{ .��s_; : - - � �
�� '��, o �v ! � � �� � � � i � 3
v � � � 7 . � � � �
a� x .._. —. � '�" t E � N
J �p !CI
r. �y —
` , m p a Q O o , Q p O O Q ci � li Q Q �
�� � � � � $� S `ti' �' �i .r r� �+ '��
ii
...�..._..__e__.._�
�" y �� � . .... . .
�� v+ � G7� � � � �
�° , i I
� } �
� �� � � � �
N �ff � N
s=, CY �,l .(/y ., ' tl� � ♦ 4�
tL ` ` � � � �N I � � �� � �?� � � p
ii � � Q ., ..� � t'� + d
p (( ' � � � ♦
1 � .�.� � � p Y� t, � �„� 12 (� tA �y y,� M �
�7
� °'' b�rn'' � P E'�'�' � r o O N �
a� .
J; �: �' � ci� � r' � r � `
i�" , _ . __ ._. ..
�---_ —--
�
__.___
,3 i ��'� .... . .. � . .... . ..
IT'i
97
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
, �
< ,,.a_
z �..��_....n���.,_�___. ��„.
,,.,�r..�..�...,�.�.�...._..�� T.,.,� .
.� .r....
� .__.. . .�._._ .,m— � ——� � � �
,
�� �'
>.
I�f ! � �"� a �^ r
''C'j" l'�"? �
� C'V � �""+ �
r--.. �t— u� �
jjjv
. . . . �w; �� . _... ... °�
��;, � � �J i
� 4 µ� ~� � � �
� � � � � � �� � 4
r �I�;-' � � ��
ti
� ,
. . . . a.�r—s (
� �� }
� � b �' �
�
� ���, � � "��,» i
y �"'^. �
� � � ��
�t„�.�:� +s? ��
��. �
.� y "o�y
a.�r"°a �„ �
"�-'-+' t�'i'S. .�r„,,.
.�i� L'?�,fY ,. � ..
�e.ev�"� � .
cvs
�
"'"""` � .
� �
. ,i ��, ,� �i ,�
Y', �
��� � '
v �
;���. . . �,"s`. � �
, p,p
�� �. �a . .�,;.,�
�. � � � r"�"''�,�. �
r•—�
i �
�
r
Il � p i` . 'C1'^f ''�..'A �.
., .,�„J'. �r.^`+,J
s�W��� k� �.. . . �_?
d
�i51�` Y� "
�y�{e� vs�'j. � ar�� �
r.�„ ,^Jp Gl:h '_^..." ..
� � � �
(; �1 ' c1� � �
� . . _._ . r,w�, �rr..�,.�
'w� . �. :.r.,.p . ��.
r
�� ''�i� . � � . �
t
� :: �� � """� ,",q�.". "� �
.
��` i �'¢�, � � � ,
�, , , �
� .4.i'..�.� . � .
��
r n.w.. .
t3
y�
?�
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
�
ti
Index ---date--- --time-- Sound_i,evel unit
1 41-12-2008 23:09:57 53.5 dB
2 Q1-12-2(�08 23:09:58 59.z dE�
3 Q1-12-2Q08 2�:C19:59 53.6 d�
4 OI-12-20d8 23:10:00 6�.y �H
5 01-12-2008 23:1[l:Ql 53.1 �B
6 Q1-12-2CJ08 23:10:42 5z.5 ciB
7 �1-12-2qd8 7.3s10:p3 59.6 dB
8 Cl1-12-20d8 23:10:49 5A.2 dB
9 tJ1-12-2C10$ 23:1(}:05 54.8 dB
iD 01-12-20C1$ 23:1t�:Q6 Ski.9 d8
il 01-2?-2008 23:10:Q7 ��.� ��
12 01-12-?.Ct08 23:10:Q6 56.� da
13 Oi-22-20(18 23:10:09 56,1 dB
14 01-12-2qQ8 23:1Q:10 55.9 dB
15 01-12-2Q08 23:10:11 55.0 d�
16 Oi-12-?_008 23:10:12 54.6 dB
27 01-12-20t78 23:1G:13 52.6 C��
18 01-11-2Ut78 23.1(�:14 53.4 dB
19 d1-12-20p8 23:1p: 15 55.4 cjD
20 01-12-2008 23:10:16 56.� dB
21 01-12-2d08 23:1D:17 56.�3 ��
22 Oi-12-20DF3 23:1�:28 53.1 d�
23 01-12-2D08 23:1b:I9 56.4 d�
24 Qi-12-2.008 23:1�i:2t� 56.9 riB
25 d1-12-20d8 23:10:21 55.3 dB
26 Q1-12-2�08 ?_3:1G1:22 5'7.9 dB
2? 01-12-2048 23:I0:23 53.7 ��
28 ql-1Z-2008 23:10:24 55.� rIB
29 01-12-2QQ$ 23:10:25 5�_9 riB
�+� 01-12-2Q�8 23:10:2� 54.9 c�B
31 01-12-2�1f�8 73:1(7:2"7 53.Q �B
32 01-22-2t108 23:10:28 55.5 dH
33 01-12-2(�0$ 23:1�:29 59.0 d$
34 61-32-20fl8 23:10:3Q �4•Q ��
35 01-12-2QQ8 23:10:31 55.8 dB
36 OT-12-ZC�QB 23:1f1:32 57.2 d�
37 01-1�-2008 23:1Q:33 52.6 dS
3� QI-12-2�08 23:10:34 55.9
39 Oi-12-2C�0� 23c10:35 55.9 dB
4t7 Ot-1?-?,JOS 23:1Q:36 56.9 dB
41 fl1-12-2t708 23;10:37 55.5 d�
92 Oi-12-2008 23:10:38 53.5
93 01-12-20bB 23:1�:39 �q.� �%
�9 41-12-2QQf3 23:2U:4� 54.3 d8
45 01-12-2008 23.IC�:41 �0.6 dB
A6 01-12-200£3 23:10:42 52 .5
47 OI-12-2008 23:1C7:43 53,3 d�
46 01-12-2C3C38 �3:3"�:A4 'i3.3 d13
49 01-12-20t38 23:10:45 53.9 dB
5Q Q1-12-2008 23:1Q:A6 53.� d8
51 Oi-12-2£�G8 23:1(7:97 55.3 d�
52 01-72-24{�8 23:1Q:48 56.3 ds
53 [}i-12-2C706 23:10:9'� 51.1 dB
59 p1-12-2t�OF3 23;1U:50 51.d d8
55 t71-12-20f18 23:1Q:51 52.9 dB
56 Q1-12-2t�C18 23:10:52 54.3 dB
57 01-12-ZQC}8 23:10:53 59.5 dB
58 f?i-12-2b0$ 23:10:54 51 .9 dB
59 �1-12-2008 23:1q:5� 56.7 ciB
60 01-12-2f�0$ 23_3C�:�6 52.8 d8
6i Q1-12-2008 23:1C1:57 52•5 dB
62 O1-12-2�10£3 23:1!}.5g 52.8 dB
MINUTES JANUARY 15,2008
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT E
a,
. ,
63 �1-12-2008 23:10:59 55.9 dB
b4 01-12-2Ct08 23:11.Q0 ��-`�
65 fli-12-20Q8 23:11:01 5Q.7 dB
66 Q1-12-2�4E3 23:11 :02 51..5 d6
6'7 p1-12-2008 'l`3:31:03 54.0 ��
68 01-12-2Q08 23:11:Q9 ��.� �e
�9 01-22-2048 23:11:Q5 58.6 dB
7t) 01-12-2008 23:11.C�6 56,6 �S
?I di-12-2008 23:11:07 52,5 dB
72 01-7.2-7.(10$ 23:11:0$ 52.8 dH
73 O1.-12-2006 23:i1:Q9 54.� da
74 01-12-"2008 23:11:10 55.Q ��
"15 oi-ia-2ao8 23:13 :11 5Z.1 dH
76 01-12-2006 23:I1:12 5�.� ��
77 01-12-2006 23:1i:13 52.4 �B
78 Q1-12-2008 23:11:t4 52.1 dg
79 02-12-2�D8 23;11:25 52.9 dH
80 01-1?_-2�a8 '13:i1:16 5�.3 d�'
81 03-12-?QC18 23:11:17 5�.6 dB
82 Q1-12-2CiU8 23:11:1$ 5`,i.5 dB
$3 d1-12-2008 23:11:19 $'�.3 ��
84 01-12-2008 23:11:2� 55.2 dfl
$5 {}1-12-2008 23:11:21 5�.� ��
86 �1-12-2{�(}8 23:T 1:22 54.1 dH
F37 01-12-2QQ$ 23: 11:23 5�.� ��
S8 01-12-24flII 23:I1:24 52.7 �B
99 Ol-I2-2008 2.3:11:25 52..7 d�
9t7 (31-12-2008 .'_3:11:26 53.1 ��
91 O1-12-2008 23:11:27 �-�.2 ��
92 C31-12-20C1$ 23:11:e$ 56.? dB
93 QI-12-2t1a8 2�:11:29 51.'7 d9
�� c�i-�z-zooa ��:��:�a �1.� ��
95 D1-12-2008 23:�1:�31 5'T.3 �H
96 01-1?_-20078 23:i7 :3?_ ��.g �a
97 Q1-1�-20Q$ 23:11:33 53.3 dB
98 01-12-20(l8 23:11:39 53.8 d�
99 01-12-?.0(l8 23:11.3� 5?.6
100 fl1-12-20(JE� ?3:11:3C� �3.5 dB
1Q1 01-12-?.C1Q8 23:11:3"7 53.8 d�
102 01-12-2008 23:11:3E3 52.0 ��
103 01-1?-2a08 23:1t:3�3 53.0 dB
10� Q1-12-2i�08 23:11:4Q s2•� ��
105 01-12-2�08 23:11:�11 6?..6
106 01-12-20n8 23:11:92 62.3 dB
1G7 01-12-2C1Q8 23.IJ :43 56.6
l0$ 01-12-2Q08 23:11:4A 53.-7 dB
�.Cr9 01-12-2006 23:11:45 �5•� dB
�1Q p1-12-2408 23:12:96 `��'� d�
111 01-'12-2008 23:3.1:47 ��-� d�
112 01-12-2Ct08 23:11:AE� 51.8 df3
:;` lI3 01-17.-200� 23:11:�#9 5I.3
� c�B
�� 114 {71-1�-2Q0& 23:11:5C� 55.7 dB
� 115 01-12-2b�� 23:11.51 53.5
� �� �
�
IIIIINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
_
�,
�
} _„ �_�,; ��.. �.m ,., , .. , � �� ��.W,
�,� a,.�...._, �_,�,
_ � � _ � �
3 -. ..._ '- _ ' ' �
��j _` .. . . . , . ..____..... . .. � � � . �- ---, � . -,,'. �
�t � � � �
��� �- �� �� � � � `� �
. .
�� a� � �����
� � � � �
E �
; ; � :
� , ___ _ --
! ,
ca' __ j I. �' ��-� o j
Q ' w� �,,, I j r, o
���
�' __ . ' ' � t�'n � �
� �,��„ ; � � 1► �T� �
�
�OI : � '� ' i lv ..' �, ;
� �� � �'� � � �� � � � �
s �N _ , � � �"' �C�a � �
� i j ' i� � � �
��, , I � �
-j— �
- , ,
i f i`
. �
� i
� ,...,�` �y ,,� ___.�._._.. _� j F_,_..,r__._�_._-- � � � � ',I
� �� � � � �� i � ,
., . • �
��¢ � .� i � ' � � � ' '� ��'� � rn 3 �
� . ..�..._.,. __�____ � p
t �r.' . ,
, C3� � �y I l = �
� r
,
,
' � ; , "" � i r � �
. : ._ __.. ___ or � �-
. , . < � �,
,
;>'( --.,.' �'~a ; O I .� 4
� � � � ��+....,,� �
' Q7 G� +�v� � . �- F j - Z j ';
i �i (i�T� ` ' `
� � � � � �
c� `�n I
�
o, �.. � _ _ - -
3 ; c � � . : ..�.,. , -- —+--
� �
r� �- � � --- __
, ,.. , -
,
, c�,,, s� , � �� C E
��� � ��� �� -��
�
—� ,� �
� _ � �
: , , �
� , -�� .�._�.._— - - _...___. , ; � �,.,,
;t� , � _;
� c�� — i � � v�
�: ,,, � � � "�,_� — t a E � ► a�►
, .
�� ,� -� � _ �- ��
;�� �� w � �� _ _ ' `� ��� � � _ ' � , '� - �
� .� w
. � , , � �
-r,.t ,� �� ,' ��. } , , �' � �
�
; u� i , � � � �
� ;.c�y , �-.:- — _ �— . � 'c =r �
i .
1'LS� � � �. � � �� � ,�
' � � � �
� � ��, ,� �7 � � : �- � �..__.- - --� � � ; �
r
Y�� �������_ �. �� � - - � _ _; ��
; : ,
� �� � � � � � � �
� _ = }
� . ,e ._ �_ - , ,
- _�. - � o �
o rn � �'' ,
� � � ' - ( � _ �
� � t
y � _ ___.._... a, ,
_ _ ��,;_,...j _ Q a � �
,
� � d �t � tis ca
s; � ! � � f Q �
�,, � � o [� o 0 0 �O o o r� o o '_ � ;
_HJ � o rn u�o Q � +d o o � � o
: i�_ �' +.. '� ,cn
v_.__._ �
� �
> � l
;�, , I i;p r � r--i ;,
�
� !O q�j �� ,� � �
� �
� '.,�� U) � � � � �, �' +cy ►ar� ry �
�,. �
�,, 1 � � � �
� � � ,�; ; � � p >
�+- � 'N i i � � � f0 N � E..`f. ¢ � Q o �
� ��� � � � � � ; � ♦ ��� ♦ �
. I �j � �1 � ' � A � 3C � ���. yA � Iln �
II � � � L]. � Q � Q � LL N ' Q �y
w ! � E � � rra C� � �
Ll �-� ?-
J _
� tK
t�..__� _..._._ � —___._ _ _ �
_
sa�r
•MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
, �
,
�
w
��, ._.�,�_�a._.�..__._.�__-___m.__.�,_
.�d._.F.� ___ �,�,. ��_��__��.__..__. ��.�_,�
,
�„�� ,� , C�i , C:�`� ,,o�,� �.,� � "� E
� ����` >. . l""� i � .. � 16.E�'S ��.j .
� .�a�'wM�.�x . . . �� .;� .
�u�� � �
�� � , � . . . . .
« �'���.� � � �
� �
�1 ��; � �
pN �� y� f� � � ��
� a"" �� � � t.�+.+""! �
�. t{,ti,.,S:. . .... . ... .. .
. . ... . e-�.t '��.
t*n�'+
�
� �
�
� � p,.
u�" p.
�� � ��'j .� � .
C-„3�r� �..,,..y
�,,.:_.. ..
«
�� , � � .:,,�,.� �,.,. ,�.... � .�.
� 'A`�"` ^4..,... . . .. . . �.,�'
-MP—� � �,_ �... I� �� �.. tY�'"Y
..�....:o � : .,�...
4..e""�, ,�,�✓ ��
� �
:`�
� ct- �
� ... ,� ,� .�. rk'"i
,.;a � � ear-�
�R.� �
�
µ @.: s"�
�., �
;, �
� �
���j � �
�a���M�;�� �
�;
G�;€
�
Mr _, � � � � � � � �
�;
` � e':::,�
� p � �
�x ���;� �
� ,���r s �--_�
�� � . --
"�!'[i CI' .!��;
7r�€:.'�.t} � � ��
�i� � �
�.,
_ ,�, -�� �
�
� ' � � � �i l
, ��,_ �f� � �
iUIINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
t�
r
Index ---date--- --time-- Sound I.aevel unit �
I q1-12-2QCa8 23:11:59 54.8 dB
Z 01-32-2008 23:12:d4 52.3 dB
3 qi-12-20f38 23:12:01 55.5 dB
4 OL-12-2008 23:12:02 52.9 cfB
5 01-12-200$ 23:i2:03 51.3 dB
6 01-12-2Qf�8 23:12:04 53.1 dB
7 01-12-2008 23:12:�5 51.8 dB
$ U1-12-2Qd8 23:12:06 59.7 dB
9 Q1-12-2008 23:12:07 53.6 dB
10 Cl1-12-20Q8 23.12:fl� 53.1 ciB
il 01-12-2008 2.3:22:09 55.3 d8
12 O1-i2-2008 23:12:1C� 52.4 d8
13 01-12-2008 23:1"L:11 5�1.� dB
14 O1-12-20Q8 23:I2:12 57.1 d8
15 01-12-2008 23:12:13 55.1 dB
16 01-12-2008 23:12:i4 51.5 df3
i7 O1-12-2008 23:12:15 53.7 dB
18 p1-12-20C3$ 23:12:I6 55.1 dB
19 Q1-12-20R8 23:12:2°7 57.2 dB
20 Q1-22-2Q0�3 23:1?_:IE 55.4 d�
�i oi-i�-�oae z�.iz:i� s7.a aa
22 Oi-12-2008 2?:12:20 5�.2 d8
23 O1-I2-2008 23.I2:21 56.2 df3
24 pl-7?-2Q0� 23;12:2� 59.7 ��
?_5 O1-Y2-�006 23:12:23 57.6 dB
26 O1-I2-2008 23s12:24 52.1 c�B
27 O1-I2-2008 23:12:25 59.1 dB
2$ O1-I2-20QB 23:12:26 58.1 dB
29 01-12-2q09 23:12:27 55.7 dB
30 bi-12-2Q48 23:12:28 55.0 dt�
31 b1-12-2�a8 23:12.29 55.2, dH
32 01-22-2QOB 23:12c30 57.b dB
33 01-12-2Q08 23:12:31 55.1 d8
39 �I-12-20E78 23:2�:32 �6.2 dH
35 O1-12-2008 23:I2:33 52.9 d8
36 Ql-I2-2C1n8 23:12:34 53.7 dB
37 01-22-2008 23:12:35 57.$ dB
38 Q1-12-20n$ 23:12:36 ;6.1 dB
39 �11-17.-2008 23:1?_:37 55.6 dB
90 01-12-2008 23:12:38 58.2 dH
A1 01-12-2�08 23:12:39 53.8 ciH
�i2 Oi-12-2008 23:12:9C8 `:,7.1 dB
93 01-12-20Q8 23:12:91 ti9 .7 cl�
44 Cl1-12-20Q8 23:32:42 55.7 dH
95 q1-12-20Q6 29:12:93 `�B.J dF3
4b p1-12-2008 23:11:99 ��.4 dE3
A7 01-12-2Q08 23:72:45 `�6.6 d8
4E Q1-12-2�JQ8 23:12:9E; 5,.5 d8
49 01-12-2008 23:17_:47 53.4 dB
SQ 01-12-2QQ8 23:12:48 53.3 �1�3
51 Oi-1?_-24?OE# 23:12:99 55.6 r�B
52 01-12-240E� 23:].2:5t} 5�.1 dEs
5� Ci1-12-:2Q08 23:12:51 5'?.2 dH
59 Cf1-12-2t}Q8 23:12:�a2 54.5 ciB
55 07-12-2�08 23:12:53 56.4 di3
56 01-12-20()8 �3:12:59 56.6 dB
57 01-12-2QC?$ 23:12:55 `�7.6 dB
5B 01-12-�q0$ 23:12:56 52.8 dB
59 02-I2-201?8 23:12:Si 55.5 dB
6t� 02-12-2CJQ8 ?3:12:5€i SS.O d8
61 01-12-?_�f3� 23:12:�� �2.9 �F3
62 Gl1-12-2t306 73:i3:60 57.9 dB
IVIINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
,
63 oi-i2-�aaa 2a:13:01 55.2 dB
6A Oi-12-2t108 23a13:02 55.9 d8
65 02-12-2Q08 23:13:03 55.4 dB
65 01-12-20d8 23:13t09 5�.9 da
67 Oi-I2-20Q8 23:13a05 Sfa.4 ctE3
68 01-12-ZQ08 23:13:06 61.5 dB
69 Q1-12-2008 23:13:ti7 f2.2 dB
7Q 01-12-2Q08 23:13:08 61.b d.B
71 p1-12-2008 23c13:09 62.0 dB
72 01-12-2008 23:13:10 58.0 d$
73 Oi-12-2QQ8 23:13:21 54.3 d�
79 01-I2-200$ 23:13:12 55.9 dB
75 01-12-2Q08 23:13:13 57.5 dH
76 01-12-2008 23:13:14 53.9 dk3
77 01-12-2008 23:13:I5 54.2 dS
7$ 01-1"1-2008 13:}.3:16 55.5 d�
79 02-12-20Q8 23:23:17 5�. 7 dB
80 Qi-12-2QOS 23:13:18 53.3 dH
81 pi-12-a008 23:13:19 55.6 dB
82 D1-1?_-2008 23:13:20 56.9 dEt
83 pl-I2-2046 23:13:21 5�.5 dH
B4 Ol-t2-2009 23:13:22 54.7 dS
85 01-12-2Q0$ 23:13:23 56.7 dI3
Q6 Q1-I2-2008 23:13:29 56.7 dI�
87 01-22-200� 23:13:25 �7.8 dH
88 QI-I2-2008 23:13:26 57.3 d6
89 01-12-2008 23:13:27 56.2 dB
90 01-12-20Q6 23:13z28 5A.2 dB
91 O1-I2-20Q8 23:13:29 54.6 dB
92 01-12-26p8 23:13:3q �6.5 �iB
93 01-12-20C1E 23:13:31 5$.8 d8
94 O1-12-20t18 23:1�:32 57.3 dB
95 01-12-2008 23:13:33 56.3 dB
g� ar-�a-�oaa z�:��:s� s�r.9 de
97 01-1�-2008 23:13:35 51.2 c��
9� p1-12-20n8 23:13:36 57.1 dB
99 O1-12-2006 23:13:37 59.8 dB
100 O1-12-2008 23:13:38 53.2 dB
1OI Q1-12-20�8 23:13:39 55.9 d�
IQ? 01-1?-2008 23:13:A0 52.Q dB
iO3 Q1-12-2�08 23:1"3.41 S7.A dH
109 DI-12-20(38 23:i3:42 52.0 d.8
105 Q1-12-2008 23:13:A� 55.0 d8
1Q5 U1-12-2008 23;13:99 50.J dB
107 Q1-12-20(}8 23:i:3:45 5I.2 d�
308 01-12-"l04$ 23:13:96 57.4 d6
1C9 Q1-12-2QG8 23:13:4`t �2.9 dB
i1Q Ol-I2-200$ 23:13:98 54.5 dB
ill O1-i2-zq(�8 23:1.3:49 55.1 dH
112 01-1?.-2008 23:13:54 53.2 dB
113 01-12-2008 �3:13:5] 54.1 dF3
�ia oi-�2-aaog 23:��:s2 �s.2 ae
ais aa-zz-�ooe zs:��:s� ��.� �s
116 01-12-2U08 23.13:59 �a6.8 d�
?77 Ctl.-12-2QOA 23:]3:55 51 .'� dB
118 Q1-12-20�8 23:I3;56 55.1 c!B
119 01-12-2Q48 23:13:57 55.9 d8
120 Q1-12-20Q8 23:13:5� 54.fi d8
121 01-12-2009 23:23:59 59_4 ci8
122 cJi-12-2008 23:1.4:(�fl 59.3 dB
123 OI-77-20C28 2i:14:tJ1 Ea0.8 dA
129 01-12-2008 23:1A.02 61.8 dB
125 �1-77.-2f7L18 23:14:Q3 61.3 d�
MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
I26 01-12-2f}08 23:19:04 b�.9 dH
127 b1-12-20p8 23:19:05 61.Q dE3
I28 Q1-12-2�06 23:19:�6 5�.6 df�
12� Oi-12-2l308 23:14:07 54.1 dB
130 OI-I2-2008 23:14:08 55.0 dB
131 01-12-2008 23:19:09 54.5 dB
232 bi-12-2Q0$ ?_3:14:i(1 58.9 dB
I33 Q1-12-2008 23:14:11 56.0 dB
I39 01-12-2008 23:1A:12 55.1 dB
135 01-1?-2UQ8 23:19.13 54.5 dB
236 Q1-12-2008 23:14:14 54.£3 dS
137 Q1-12-2Q08 23:19:15 54.1 dB
I38 01-1.2-2008 23:19:16 55.1 dB
139 n1-12-20U8 13:24:1"! 53.fi db
190 01-12-2008 23:14:18 56.4 dB
141 01-12-2008 23:14:19 55.4 dB
1�2 01-12-20�8 23:14:20 53.5 dB
143 01-12-2nU8 ?3:I4:21 59.5 dB
1Q9 01-12-2t708 23:3.4:22 54.6 dR
145 01-12-2R08 23:14:23 55.9 ciB
i46 p1-12-2Q08 23:14:24 59•0 dB
197 �1-12-2008 23:14:25 57.3 df�
lA9 U1-12-2Q08 23:19:26 58.1 dB
149 a1-12-2C30E1 7_3:19:27 S4•2 d8
150 01-12-2008 23:14:Z8 55.9 dB
252 pI-12-2008 ?3:14:29 5`�. ) d�
152 (f1-12-20Ctif 23:1A:3Q 53.1 dS
153 Q1-12-200f� 23:19_31 55.9 dB
159 01-12-2t�08 23:19:32 55.7 dB
155 O1-12-2008 ?3:14:33 54.5 ��
156 f�2-12-20Q8 23:1�:34 57.5 dB
757 (31-12-2t?Q8 23:14:3°i 56.0 di3
158 C11-12-��08 23:14:3b `�5.9 dB
159 b1-12-2f7C1$ 23c1A:37 55.7 dB
i�o a�-iz-zoo� z�:ia:�� sa.a aB
262 ��-12-2�08 23:29:39 51.7 dH
162 01-12-20�8 23:14:40 52.2 dB
163 C11-12-2008 23:19;41 55.5 dB
169 01-12-2008 23:14:92 ��.9 dB
165 p1-12-2C108 23:19:43 53.3 dB
165 Q1-12-?0(7E3 23:14:94 59.2 d8
167 O1-I2-2C}08 23:i9;95 55.2 dB
16E3 01-12-20G�3 23:14:46 53.9 d8
169 QI-12-?_008 23:14:97 52.9 dB
17p �1-12-2(308 23:14:48 �3.0 d�
171 OI-12-2f1Q8 23:1A:49 56.5 dB
172 01-12-ZOC6 23:14:50 59.1 dB
1"73 P1-12-2008 23:1d:51 56.9 dH
17A OI-12-2Q48 23:14:52 53.b dE3
175 01-12-2t708 23:19s53 56.5 dB
176 01-12-2008 23:19:54 55.Q dB
17"7 01-22-2008 23:19:55 62.2 dB
I�8 01-12-2t768 23:i9:56 `,6.0 dB
279 03-I2-2008 23:I9:57 55.4? dB
18a C�1-12-2(J(78 23:14:5£# 56.0 dB
i.81 01-12-2008 23:14:59 59.Q dB
182 01-12-2pQ8 23:t5:00 6I.5 dP
183 01-12-2b08 23:15:Q1 56.9 d�s
164 C11-12-2D08 23:15:02 55.3 dB
i85 Q1-12-2�0$ 23:25:03 59.9 dB
7B6 Oi-�?.-2t�08 23:15:04 53.C1 dB
187 A1-12-20a8 23:15.05 55.I d8
188 Q1-12-20Q8 23:15:06 48.9 dB
. MINUTES
PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT B JANUARY 15,2008
. +
18� 01-22-20Q8 23:15:07 99.0 dB
19Q 01-T2-20(l9 23:I5:08 50.1 �g
191 U1-12-?.008 7.3:75:Q9 48.1 ciB
192 fl1-12-2008 23:15:10 47.9 dB
393 01-12-2008 23:15:11 54.6 dB
19A 01-�12-2008 23:15:12 �9.3 d�
195 01-22-200f� 23:15:13 52.6 d9
� PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT C JANUARY 15,2008
Tiffan Windsor
From: Maureen Guinan [guinan@sbelawyers.com]
Received at Planning Commission meeting
Sent: Monday, January 14, 2008 4 58 PM Date:�r / o Cc156 N0. GvP 9G��s
Tiffan Windsor; Denise Roberge
Subject: FW: Augusta's Restaurant(From City) From;_ �e n�S e- 06 r9�
Attachments: augusta000.PDF
Just received and have not rev�ewed the following ema�l and attached report from Assistant City Attomey Hargreaves
Regards.
Maureen F. Guinan
Slovak Baron & Empey LLP
1800 E Tahquitz Canyon Way
Palm Springs, CA 92262
Phone: 760.322.2275 ext. 17
Fax: 760.322.2107
quinan(a�sbelawYers com
"NOTICE" This e-mail is confi0ential,intended only for the recipient(s)named above and may conlain informalion that is privilegetl,altomey work-product or
exempt from disClosure under applicable law. If you have received this message in error,or are not the named recipient(s),please immediately notify ihe sender
by return e-mail or by cauing(7601 322-2275.antl delete this message from your computer.
-----Original Message-----
From: Robert Hargreaves [mailto:Robert.Hargreaves@BBKLAW.COM]
Sent: Monday, ]anuary 14, 2008 4:49 PM
To: Maureen F. Guinan
Subjed: FW: Augusta's Restaurant
fv�
----Original Message-----
From: lay{aian@ci.palm-desert.ca.us [mailto:laylaian@ci.palm-desert.ca.us]
Sent: Monday, January 14, 2008 11:04 AM
To: David Erwin; Robert Hargreaves
Subject: Augusta's Restaurant
I3ob and Uave,
V6'e mcasured sound levels at Augusta's (unannc�unced) on Saturday night. The readin�s were remarkably closc
to �Sdh. Attached is the report from the Code Enforcement UI�Gcer.
�I�hey wcre also tryi►ig to install nc�v sound attenuating curtains that just arrived on Saturday, but did not have
them up at the time of our monitoring. With the curtains, it's cntircl�' possible that they� ���ill come in under JJ
db, which leaves us in 1he uncomfortable pc�sition of them arguing that thcy are compliant, and thc residents still
not being satistied. (Our statf belie��es that e��rn at >i db. thc� present a disturbance ior neighhors.)
We need to talk about how the present��tion will he madc at tomorro���s hearing.
i
.
�• PALM DESERT PLANNING COMMISSION EXHIBIT C JANUARY 15,2008
I,auri /�.
Lauri Aylaian
Director of Community vevelopment
Citv of Palm Uesert
73-510 Fred Waring Drivc
Palm Desert, CA 92260
760.346.0611 phone
76U776.6417 fax
�r i i i{�i i t a��*i�y+w 1�k i��v.: .+y'a�}}*��w k*i r� e .A M i� •+w�r��.# h'k x+�r w r w+k+a a}�k f t f+� �*f i#*#'k.v Y
litS CI3CUI.AR 23G i�:C"'?CE: To er.sure. ��o:r.�l.:�r.::e •+:i�_.. _ec���iremer.t:� -rr;t,osed �y the TRS,
W� _71_`J�T'i y0'.] L}:(J- di�y' � .J. `dY �_..':I C!'� :;O'�'d I'!(iC L"1 !.r;5 C:iT.T..l'71(::iL ��Of. lor :.r. �r,y
4t.`.achrnent; _s net !r:te�dec e� wr.i lt:er� tc �e ��e:, a�d c�ar:r.ct b^ �ised, fcr _;e
���.;_pose o; ;i; avoidir.c penal*..:es '.�:'.:er -,",e :r.t.ern::; '.�eve�a� C;;cie c� ;ii'
pror:�o:ing, r�arketi�g or reccrn;cenc'_r:g tc a::o:.�cr par'.y ar.�� t�ar;sa�:.ior. er r.iatT.er
�;idressed ir. this .:ommi:r.icat:cr. (or _:i ,.�.;� �t.r.a�:r.ier.;., .
J �.+.1.*�*x R+*#�x��# k i x.++x R x r a*k.��#�r+ �� .+* i ��++�'�a � � . w: �+M�F i f+� \ 1�++:��+ t.1�w+ r+i i*1�*x x+
�i#k h+�..*i i.�w*t*k R w++��T i+k}..:#t t x�r�..x� 1 M k�x R t i f#. .w Y x��+}k L a i t��f •M�'+• Y i+w���k t+i: .+
T.".i.s eT.ai_ anc any fi]es t�a'�sr�i�=ec •.�'_tY: i� may c'ont..r pr�vilc�qe<i o�
ctherwi_=.e con=icer:r.ial in'.or«a•_�on. 1= }:%l: uT2 ::ct ':�e irCcr.�c:d ~c�i��.er.t,
or bel.ic-`ve th�t y:�. r�ay rave receiv-:i t.;:is �.:;��r�unic::t :cr: i:i PLTor,
_F;�SB aCV`SE �f'12 SE''1GCZ� V:c Y@O_�� PT.r-. . rR:j C]@_('Z.P_ _�'�'.? 2("lc:_ . '+O:] YF.Ce=V@:.
♦+i+�x�**t�w w a � +x+ �k*4*! 4♦ R. .. i A . . . . � i � � ♦ • R�. . �i ♦ . .�. � r k i k k A a t w + .. �K k k#i x M i s.R ��w'x**�k r'n TM
�o virus fou�a '_n t}�.is '.nco:r�r.y :res:�-:;e.
C:iec Ked by AV� _r..e tdi='.or..
'dr:rsicr.: /.�.51E i Viru.=, f),:�aba:sP: 7h�. 1'>.:_/1223 - :te:ease Ua'_c: 1� ..3/2COH 8:23 °�i
No virus found in this outgoing message.
Checked by AVG Free Edition.
Version: 7.5.�16/Virus Database:269.19.2;'I?23-Release I)atc: U13!2Q08 8:23 PM
2