HomeMy WebLinkAboutMinutes - Art In Public Places (AIPP) Commission 10/20/2004CITY OF PALM DESERT
ART IN PUBLIC PLACES COMMISSION
MINUTES
October 20, 2004
CALL TO ORDER
Vice Chairman Bussing convened the meeting at 8:35 a.m.
ROLL CALL
Present:
Norma Bussing
Suzanne Greenberg
Kevin Grochau
Also Present:
Absent:
Joe Dickinson
Katherine Hough
Bob Kohn, Director of Special Programs
Richard Twedt, Public Arts Manager
Deborah Schwartz, Public Art Coordinator
Debbie Thompson, Recording Secretary
Kim Snyder, Guest
Richard Begola, Guest
John Westin, Guest
Maureen Thompson, Guest
Steve Morgan, Guest
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS
None
Minutes October 20. 2004
IV. CONSENT CALENDAR
Minutes of the regular meeting held on September 15, 2004.
Upon Motion by Commissioner Grochau and second by
Commissioner Greenberg, the Minutes of September 15, 2004, were
approved unanimously.
V. DISCUSSION ITEMS
A. ORAL REVIEW OF CITY COUNCIL ACTION
Mr. Twedt reported that the artwork by James Surls that was
proposed for the 2005/06 El Paseo Exhibition was not
approved by City Council. Mr. Twedt has been in contact
with Robert Menifee who is reviewing three other artworks to
replace the James Surls piece.
The two proposals for the Library mural were continued from
the Council meeting of October 14, to the meeting of
October 28, due to Councilmember Benson's absence.
Susan Evans offered to attend the Council meeting to
answer questions that Council may have about her proposal
for the mural.
VI. CONSENT ITEMS HELD OVER
None
VII. NEW BUSINESS
A. CONSIDERATION OF CREATING A TEMPORARY PUBLIC
ART PROGRAM
Mr. Twedt stated that he and Mr. Kohn have been thinking of
ways to accommodate emerging artists who have little or no
experience creating a public artwork. Mr. Twedt's idea for
the program would provide emerging artists the opportunity
to create a public artwork and experience the various
aspects of a public art project (i.e. working with city building
codes, permits and licensing requirements, the engineering
process, site selection, and consideration of pedestrian
traffic and accessibility). The program would provide a
platform for emerging artists to explore community issues
like recycling, landscape and geography, climatic conditions
2
Minutes
October 20. 2004
of the desert, etc. Some potential sites for artists to display
their work include empty storefronts on El Paseo where they
could do video installations, a projection on the McCallum
Theatre building, the Marks Center for the Arts at College of
the Desert, the median in front of Cal State San Bernardino
that has three or four palm trees from which art could be
suspended, and the Civic Center Park.
This program would expand upon the already popular El
Paseo Exhibition by placing more temporary artworks
throughout the City. A portion of the AIPP budget is
available for educational purposes. Mr. Twedt would
propose that this program be considered an educational
program, as is the docent program.
Each accepted artist would receive a design honorarium
(including engineering specifications) of $1,500.00 with a
$5,000.00 commission, if selected. The artists' work would
be displayed for a maximum of six months to which the artist
would be responsible for the removal of the art. Mr. Twedt
would offer assistance to the artist if he/she would be
interested in donating, recycling, or auctioning it off, etc. Mr.
Twedt stated he would treat it as a competition that will be
posted on the website for four months then have the
Commission review all entries and select six. This process
would take approximately a year and a half before a piece of
art is selected. He has titled the program "Embracing the
Desert". Mr. Twedt stated that a program like this would
elevate the awareness of art community wide.
Commissioner Greenberg stated that she visited the Midway
in San Diego that currently has a temporary exhibition of
sculptural trees made from recycled material. It was
suggested that City Council be taken on a bus tour to visit
other city's art projects.
It was moved by Commissioner Greenberg and
seconded by Commissioner Grochau that Staff proceed to
create a program for temporary art and take it to Council for
approval. Motion carried unanimously.
Mr. Twedt stated he talked to the staff at the Marriott Desert
Springs who are excited about the idea of using its water
areas (foyer area, in the lobby, and where the gondolas are)
for placement of temporary art.
91
Minutes
October 20. 2004.
B. CONSIDERATION OF A THEME FOR THE 2005 STUDENT
ART AND ESSAY CONTEST
Commissioner Grochau suggested that the theme coincide
with freedom due to the future Freedom Park. Recording
Secretary Thompson informed him that Freedom Park would
not be completed until early 2006, so it would be a good
theme for next year.
Commissioner Greenberg suggested the theme incorporate
the idea of community service (volunteering) or recycling.
It was moved by Commissioner Greenberg and
seconded by Commissioner Grochau that the theme for the
Contest focus on community involvement and that Staff can
determine the title for the Contest. Motion carried
unanimously.
C. CONSIDERATION OF ARTISTS TO BE INCLUDED IN THE
CITY OF PALM DESERT'S ARTIST SLIDE REGISTRY
The following artists were reviewed to be considered for the
City of Palm Desert's Artist Slide Registry. Romo Studios
and Chester Fields.
It was moved by Commissioner Grochau and seconded
by Commissioner Greenberg to include Romo Studios into the
Artist Slide Registry. Motion carried unanimously.
VIII. CONTINUED BUSINESS
None
IX. OLD BUSINESS
A. CONSIDERATION OF PURCHASING AN ARTWORK
FROM THE 2005/06 EL PASEO EXHIBITION
Mr. Twedt referred to the price lists included in the agenda
packet of the artwork for the 2003/04 and 2005/06 El Paseo
Exhibitions. Mr. Twedt reminded the Commission that
Mayor Spiegel initiated the consideration to purchase an
artwork from the current Exhibition to be placed in the Civic
Center Park. Mr. Twedt stated that the pieces he responds
to for the park are "Fat Happy" for a price of $16,000.00
each and "Cow" for a price of $65,000 both of which will be
H
Minutes
October 20. 2004
in the 2005/2006 El Paseo Exhibition. He added that those
two pieces are playful and are powder coated steel, which is
a sturdy material and finish for the park environment.
It was moved by Commissioner Greenberg and
seconded by Commissioner Grochau to suggest "Fat Happy"
and "Cow" to City Council for consideration of purchase to be
included in the City's art collection. Motion carried
unanimously.
X. PROJECT STATUS REPORTS
1. North Wing Gallery
Ms. Schwartz reported that the opening reception for the
Coachella, Valley Arts Alliance show was held on October
12, with approximately 60 people in attendance. There was
an article of the show in the Desert Sun. The next show will
include Helene Berman's paintings and J. Keith Stone's
masks. That show will open in December. She plans to
send out an RFP in January for the next season of
exhibitions.
2. Website
Ms. Schwartz stated that she is continuing to add entries into
the "other artist opportunities" section of the art Website.
3. Docent Program
Ms. Schwartz reported she has a tour scheduled today with
St. Margaret's Episcopal School, which may be postponed
due to rain. She has an El Paseo tour scheduled next week
with a class from College of the Desert.
The deadline for new docent applications closed on Monday
and she received eleven applications.
She has discussed a docent training exchange program with
the docent program manager at the Palm Springs Desert
Museum.
5
Minutes October 20. 2004
XI. REPORTS AND REMARKS
A. STAFF
Mr. Twedt reminded the Commission of the dedication for
Allen Root's entry sign at the corner of Washington Street
and Fred Waring Drive at 10:00 a.m. October 21.
Water Studio is behind with the installation of the balance of
the water feature signs for El Paseo. Mr. Twedt informed
Sean So that the signs need to be installed by November 7.
Donna Billick is planning to install the Baja Palapa mid
November.
Ms. Schwartz reported that she is planning a field trip for the
AIPP Commission to tour the San Diego Port.
Mr. Twedt stated that Mike Errante, Director of Public Works,
was instructed by two members of Council during the
Landscape Beautification Committee meeting to look at
some type of wall treatment for the wall at the corner of Fred
Waring and Cook. Mr. Twedt would like to suggest Donna
Billick and Arthur Gonzales to do elements of the Baja in
mosaic to coincide with the Baja Palapa that will be 3/4 mile
from the Baja Palapa. Mr. Twedt gave pictures of the
columns for the Baja Palapa to Mr. Errante. Ms. Schwartz
added that it could be a great opportunity for another
community workshop. Commissioner Grochau mentioned
that the homeowners association would need to be
contacted and would most likely want to be involved with the
decision of what will be placed on that wall.
Commissioner Greenberg discussed the idea of having an
art center in Palm Desert to hold art shows, classes, and
have artist participation. The building could be rented out for
shows and meetings. She added that there are eleven
different art groups in the Valley with a tremendous amount
of artists. Mr. Kohn stated that he and Mr. Twedt spoke to
Mrs. Gilligan about developing the art center. Mr. Kohn told
Mr. Twedt that he needs to create a plan and consider the
following. How would it be funded? Would it be City run or
its own separate non profit group with its own Board, budget,
insurance, etc? Mr. Twedt has been doing some research
0
Minutes October 20. 2004,
on empty buildings, which will be the largest expense. Mrs.
Gilligan approved the concept for further research.
Mr. Twedt reported that in the near future the City of Palm
Desert would be built out and the public art funds would be
depleted and the Commission needs to prepare for future
activity. It was suggested by Mr. Kohn that some of the
funding come from the recycling fund and the curriculum
could be described so 20 percent of the activities incorporate
recycling. Items like handmade papers from recycled paper,
working with kids on collage work with aluminum cans,
recycled steel or metal with welding, rubber, etc.
Commissioner Greenberg mentioned that every year the
Coachella Valley Watercolor Society has to pay a fee to rent
the Community Center for its juried art show. She added
that there are a lot of groups here that would pay to use the
facility for art shows.
Vice Chairman Bussing stated that she has been inquiring
about an art gallery in the Multi -Use Building that will be part
of the Entrada project and house the new Chamber of
Commerce. Mr. Twedt reported that Mrs. Gilligan asked him
to work with Donna Gomez of the Visitor Center to prepare a
show in ten months for the opening of the new Visitor
Information Center. He noted that in reviewing the blueprints
for the building there are no areas that are conducive for a
professional gallery, but art could be hung there. Vice
Chairman Bussing added that it would be desirable to be
able to display items other than just paintings. Mr. Kohn and
Mr. Twedt will further explore the idea and report back to the
Commission.
B. COMMISSION MEMBERS
• COMMISSION REPORTS
• LIAISON REPORTS
1. PLANNING COMMISSION — Sonia Campbell
No report.
XII. ADJOURNMENT
7
Minutes October 20. 2004
There being no further business, Vice Chair Bussing adjourned the.
meeting at 10:15 a.m.
Respectfully submitted,
DE —BIE L. THOMPSON
RECORDING SECRETARY