HomeMy WebLinkAboutMinutes - Sister Cities Committee 01/20/2005APPROVED MINUTES
PALM DESERT SISTER CITIES COMMITTEE
JANUARY 20, 2005 — 3:00 p.m.
ADMINISTRATIVE CONFERENCE ROOM
I. CALL TO ORDER
Chairman Talboys called the meeting to order at 3:00 p.m.
II. ROLL CALL
Members Present:
Patricia Bannon
Donna Jean Darby
Bill Harris
Rolf Hoehn
Nancy Jo McIntosh — Arrived approximately at 3:30 p.m.
John Marman — Arrived approximately at 4:00 p.m.
Rose Mary Ortega
Gilbert Slagel
Mark Talboys, Chairman
Staff/Others Present:
Donna Gomez, Visitor Center Manager
Terry Green, Ex-Officio Member
Sarah Healy, Ex-Officio Member
Briana Kirkwood, Ex-Officio Member
Ignacio Otero, Ex-Officio Member
O'Jay Vanegas, Ex-Officio Member
Lori Wimbish, Recording Secretary
III. ORAL COMMUNICATIONS
None.
IV. CONSENT CALENDAR
A. MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING HELD DECEMBER 16,
2004
Motion made by Gil Slagel to approve the December 16, 2004
meeting minutes, seconded by Patricia Bannon. Motion carried
APPROVED MINUTES
PALM DESERT SISTER CITIES COMMITTEE JANUARY 20, 2005
unanimously by a show of hands 7-0. Neither John Marman nor
Nancy Jo McIntosh was present during this motion.
V. NEW BUSINESS
A. CONSIDERATION OF DONATION OF A FLAT BED TRUCK TO
IXTAPA ZIHUATENEJO FOR RECYCLING COLLECTION
PROGRAM.
Donna Gomez reported that through the City's budget process they
would be replacing some of their vehicles. One of those vehicles is
a 1994 Chevy flatbed truck and it was thought that Ixtapa-
Zihuatanejo could utilize the truck for their Recycling Program. The
truck could be driven to the border, and received by a driver from
Ixtapa-Zihuatanejo, which would eliminate the cost of
transportation.
Terry Green asked if there was communication with Ixtapa-
Zihuatanejo regarding the truck and the transportation costs of
getting it there. Ms. Gomez said she wanted to bring the proposal
to the committee for consideration before contacting them.
Donna Jean Darby asked about insurance coverage. Ms. Gomez
said the City holds ownership of the truck and it is insured until it
crosses the border.
Rose Mary Ortega suggested that a photograph and a detailed
description of the truck be presented to Ixtapa-Zihuatanejo for their
consideration.
Mr. Talboys said the first step would be to ascertain whether they
want the vehicle.
Mr. Green expressed concern about what assurances the
committee would have regarding the vehicle being used for the
Recycling Program.
Motion made by Ms. Ortega to communicate the proposal to our
Sister City in Ixtapa-Zihuatanejo and then take the necessary steps
to begin the process, seconded by Rolf Hoehn. Motion carried
unanimously by a show of hands 7-0. Neither John Marman nor
Nancy Jo McIntosh was present during this motion.
2
APPROVED MINUTES
PALM DESERT SISTER CITIES COMMITTEE JANUARY 20, 2005
VI. CONTINUED BUSINESS
A. CONSIDERATION OF SCI ANNUAL FUND DONATION TOWARD
50TH ANNIVERSARY COMMUNITY PARTNERSHIP
Mr. Talboys received correspondence from Phyllis Warren -Briggs,
Director of Development for Sister Cities International, containing
detailed information about the 50th Anniversary Community
Partnership. He gave a brief presentation on that information. He
asked the committee to consider a contribution of $1,000, which
would entitle the committee to become a Community Partner.
Motion made by Ms. Darby to support the International Sister
Cities Project in the amount of $1,000 for 2004 - 2005, which would
be for the 2006 Conference, seconded by Mr. Hoehn. Motion
carried unanimously by a show of hands 7-0. Neither John
Marman nor Nancy Jo McIntosh was present during this motion.
VII. OLD BUSINESS
None
VIII. REPORTS AND REMARKS
A. CITY COUNCIL
Ms. Gomez reported that City Council approved the addition of four
new committee members increasing the recommendation of the
Sister Cities Committee by two members. Ms. Gomez added that
the City Council is currently reviewing the applications and believed
appointments would be made within the next two months.
Mr. Hoehn asked if the committee could make a recommendation
as to the number of members the committee would like City Council
to appoint. Mr. Talboys believed City Council would appoint two
individuals.
Ms. Ortega asked if there was anything in place that would provide
an opportunity for the committee to give input to the City Council
with regard to appointments.
Ms. Darby felt that input might be helpful, but did not want to
interfere with City Council's process.
3
APPROVED MINUTES
PALM DESERT SISTER CITIES COMMITTEE JANUARY 20, 2005
Ms. Gomez said she did not think there was a procedure in place,
and reminded the Committee that Mayor Crites had asked that
individual comments be directed to him.
Motion made by Mr. Hoehn to appoint a subcommittee to review
the applications being considered by City Council subject to Ms.
Gomez obtaining approval by the City Council, seconded by Ms.
Bannon. Motion carried by a show of hands 7-1. Ms. McIntosh
voted no. Mr. Marman was not present.
B. COMMITTEE CHAIR
Mr. Talboys reported that Mayor Crites sent a letter to the Mayor of
Gisborne inviting a delegation to visit Palm Desert, suggesting that
the visit coincide with the Golf Tournament.
Mr. Talboys reminded the committee about the Sister Cities Retreat
on February 4th from 8:45 a.m. to 4:45 p.m. at Club Intrawest.
Information regarding the retreat will be sent to committee
members. Mr. Talboys thanked Ms. Gomez for all her hard work
on the retreat.
Mr. Talboys shared with the committee an article from The Desert
Sun entitled, "City Seeks Unique Trade Union." The article is about
the City of Palm Springs and their overtures to China. Palm Desert
and Cathedral City were also mentioned in the article as being the
only two Valley cities that have associations with Sister Cities.
C. COMMITTEE MEMBERS
None.
D. SUBCOMMITTEE MEMBERS
Art, Culture & Education
1. Student Exchange
Ms. McIntosh reported on their meeting of January 19th. The
subcommittee reviewed forms from Sister Cities International
and other Sister Cities that have been involved in Student
Exchange programs. Once the forms are completed, they
will bring them back to the committee for review. The forms
will be given to Ms. Gomez to be reviewed for legal
purposes.
4
APPROVED MINUTES
PALM DESERT SISTER CITIES COMMITTEE JANUARY 20, 2005
Ms. McIntosh said the Student Exchange proposal was sent
to Gisborne. They acknowledged the correspondence, but
they did not give any indication as to their thoughts about the
proposal.
Mr. Vanegas and Ms. Darby requested that they be informed
about the meeting dates, as they would like to attend in the
future.
2. Artist in Residence
Ms. Darby said Ms. Gomez communicated with Gisborne
about the Aesthetic Education Program concept, but they did
not feel comfortable pursuing the concept at this time. They
talked about Kerry Fox, a photographic artist, and felt she
would be ideal for the Artist in Residence program.
Ms. Darby said the McCallum Theatre Education
Embassadors is forming a subcommittee to identify people
who would provide housing for the Aesthetic Education
Program.
Tourism & Economic Development
1. Golf Challenge
Mr. Talboys said the Golf Challenge is scheduled for April 8th
at Desert Willow. He and Ms. Gomez have continued to
meet with Ms. Bamber and her team at Club Intrawest. All
aspects of the event are progressing nicely. Ms. Gomez
said drafts of materials would be available next week.
2. Community Trip
Mr. Talboys reported that the Guitar Festival in Ixtapa-
Zihuatanejo is April 3 - 10. He also received confirmation of
the Sister Cities Conference in Ixtapa- Zihuatanejo and
those dates are June 1 - 5.
Mr. Talboys asked Pat Crawford to proceed with the
community trip. He anticipated having firm details and prices
at February's meeting. They are looking at a late April early
May departure.
Mr. Talboys reported that the subcommittee spoke in very
broad terms about a community day, and that the earliest
date might be in November.
5
APPROVED MINUTES
PALM DESERT SISTER CITIES COMMITTEE JANUARY 20, 2005
Humanitarian
1. Ladder Fire Truck
Mr. Otero reported that Dr. Cantu is waiting for one
additional legal document to be processed before the fire
truck can be delivered. He said everything should be in
order within the next couple of months.
Mr. Otero reported that the training program for Ixtapa-
Zihuatanejo's firemen is scheduled for March 18 - 27. The
Fire Department is sponsoring four firemen. He said another
trip is planned for August 16 — 23. They will be celebrating
the Day of the Fireman. Flyers were passed out to city staff
and they were hoping to have 50 to 75 people. The trip is
open to everyone.
Mr. Otero submitted a memo to Carlos Ortega's office
informing him of two ambulances that were surpluses. He
suggested to Mr. Ortega that they could be sent to Ixtapa-
Zihuatanejo.
A discussion ensued regarding the difficulty in getting parts
for the fire truck and ambulances once they are in Mexico.
Ms. Ortega suggested that the committee have budget
expenditure to cover those types of costs.
Mr. Otero passed out publications from Ixtapa-Zihuatanejo's
Fire Chief. The publication was the "Year in Review" from
the Presidente's Office.
Ms. Ortega gave a presentation on her trip to Ixtapa-
Zihuatanejo. She said there was interest in participating in
the Golf Tournament. The U.S/Mexico Sister Cities
Conference is scheduled for June 1 — 5. She said that the
Palm Desert Sister Cities collaboration was requested
through attendance and support during the event. They also
felt it would be an excellent time for the joint committee
meeting.
Discussion of ideas ensued as to what Ixtapa-Zihuatanejo
could do to make the conference a success.
Ms. Ortega also reported that Ixtapa-Zihuatanejo's Executive
Board would like to send an individual to meet with the Palm
Desert Sister Cities Committee. She would be representing
Ixtapa-Zihuatanejo's Sister Cities Committee as well as the
6
APPROVED MINUTES
PALM DESERT SISTER CITIES COMMITTEE JANUARY 20, 2005
Hotel Association, and the Convention and Visitor's Bureau.
Ixtapa-Zihuatanejo's committee would like the Palm Desert
Committee members to introduce her to various key
individuals and organizations in the community.
Mr. Hoehn was supportive of the above proposal. He felt it
would be beneficial to both committees.
Ms. Ortega translated a detailed report from Ixtapa-
Zihuatanejo's Sister Cities Committee regarding the donated
medical equipment, fire engine, and ambulance. Ms.
Ortega passed around photographs, publications, and
articles about the animal wildlife preserve. She was also
introduced to the Student Scholarship recipient, who was
very quiet, and appreciative of the scholarship.
She added that Ixtapa-Zihuatanejo requested from their city
a $25,000 budget for the 2005 fiscal year. She said they
believed that they would have a good chance of receiving
the money.
E. STAFF
1. U.S./Mexico Conference
Ms. Gomez reported that she sent additional information via
e-mail to the committee members regarding the U.S./Mexico
Conference. Three responses were received all indicating
that they were not interested in attending. Therefore, the
committee would pass on the conference this year.
2. Agua Caliente Cultural Museum exhibit
Ms. Gomez reported that a reception is scheduled for the
opening night of the exhibit, which will take place on
February 16th
Mr. Vanegas reported that transferring of the artwork would
be the 7th or 8th of February. He noted that the Museum's
Curator, Ginger Ridgway, would be attending the American
Anthropology Association's annual meeting in Tongo, North
Island, New Zealand in November.
Ms. Gomez reported that she received information from Aero
Mexico and they are offering the $345 rate to Sister Cities for
any trips related to Sister Cities to Ixtapa-Zihuatanejo.
7
APPROVED MINUTES
PALM DESERT SISTER CITIES COMMITTEE JANUARY 20, 2005
Ms. Gomez received an email from Rebecca Payne from the
Wildlife Animal Preserve thanking the Sister Cities
Committee for the donation of $750. She was very
appreciative.
Ms. Gomez mentioned that Elizabeth Williams, from the
Consulates Office in Ixtapa-Zihuatanejo, was very helpful
and very supportive of the Wildlife Animal Preserve. She
was also very happy that Sister Cities was helping out.
Ms. Ortega responded that the Wildlife Animal Preserve
already has the property, but they have not been moved.
Ms. Gomez passed around samples of the newly designed
letterhead and envelopes for Palm Desert Sister Cities
Committee. The committee responded favorably to the
design.
3. Raffle
Ms. Gomez said the committee raised over $2,500 on raffle
tickets. The money raised will go into the budget for the Fire
Department's training program of the firemen from Ixtapa-
Zihuatanejo. The winners were:
April Costello -
Pat Slagel -
IX. ADJOURNMENT
Bungalows Pacifico
Presidente Intercontinental
Chairman Talboys adjourned the meeting at 5:00 p.m., and then convened
to the Sister Cities Retreat at Club Intrawest on February 4, 2005 at 8:45
a.m., and then to the regular meeting on February 17, 2005 at 3:00 p.m.
Lori Wimbish, Recording Secretary
*Reminder: Our next meeting will be held February 17, 2005 at 3:00p.m.
8