HomeMy WebLinkAboutClaim #579 - G.E. Rall �� �"'"�
CITY OF PALM DESERT
COMMUNITY SERVICES DIVISION
CITY CLERK OPERATIONS
STAFF REPORT
REQUEST: CLAIM AGAINST THE CITY (#579� BY GREGG EDWARD RALL IN THE
AMOUNT OF $211,096.50
SUBMITTED BY: Rachelle Klassen, City Cferk
DATE: April 26, 2007
CONTENTS: I. Staff Report
II. Recommendations from Staff, Claims Adjuster
III. Claim No. 579
Recommendation:
By Minute Motion, reject the Claim and direct the City Clerk to so notify the
Claimant.
Background:
Based on a review of the subject Claim and the recommendation of the Claims Adjuster,
Risk Manager, City Attorney, and staff, it is recommended that the Claim be rejected.
Discussion of this item should be held in Closed Session pursuant to Government Code Section
54956.9(b), potential litigation.
;;
Submitted by: -�'" ;' 1 �
; �-
RA HELLE D. KL SS , CMC HEILA R. GILLIG , ASST. ITY MANAGER
CITY CLERK FOR COMMUNITY SERVI S/P.I.O.
Approved:
,
CITY COUNCIL ACTION:
APPROVED � DENIED
CARLOS L. O EGA RECSIVED OTHER
CITY MANAG R
NI�gTTNG DATE -a(� -D
rdk AY�S: enso -�� /�' ��' i Sai�ae( �//,
NC.?ES:_�cnG " , ...
Attachments (as noted) A���NZ�. ��n
A�3STAIN� ,�
`°?ERI1G'IED BY: r-
�'�r'��3'.���- �n File wit ity Clerk's Office
H.IWPdataIWPDOCSICLA/MS1579-reject staff report.wpd
�ti1:t;1�!','�D
i:iT Y C�.;F�� '� OFFtCE
P�".L� Dk�F_f; T, CA
?.00TAPR -4 AMII: 29
Apri] 2, 2007
TO: The City of Palm Desert
ATTENTION: Rachelle D.Klassen, City Clerk
RE: Claim : Rall vs. The City of Palm Desert
Claimant : Gregg Edward Rall
D/Event : 10/20/2006
Rec'd Y/Office : 3/19/2007
Our File : 5-1448740-PMQ
We have received and reviewed the above claim and request that you take the action indicated below:
CLAIM REJECTION: Send a standard rejection letter to the claimant.
Please provide us with a copy of the notice sent, as requested above. If you have any questions please
contact the undersigned.
Very truly yours,
CARL ARREN & COMPANY
Richar . Marque
cc: CJPIA w/enc.
Attn.: Executive Director
CARL WARREN & CO. co�rTo - E �
CLAIMS MANAGEMENT CLAIMS A.DJUSTERS
770 1'lacentia Avrnue,]'lacentia,CA 92870-G832 DATE y- y-�,�
Dl�,l.YO.►ios 251K0 Sanm Ana,Ca 92799-51 SO
Phone (714)572-52IX) •(AfN1)572-G9Q0•Fax (714)')G1-8131
Page 1 of 1
Klassen, Rachelle
From: Greenwood, Mark
Sent: Thursday, March 22, 2007 11:13 AM
To: K�assen, Rachelle
Subject: Claims No 578 and 579
Rather than make a recommendation on these claims, pertinent staff reports are attached.
Mark Greenwood, P.E.
Director of Public Works
City of Palm Desert
4/6/2007
CITY OF P �� � �1 DESERt
73—S�O FRED WARING DRIVE
,
PALM DESERT, CALIFORNU 92260-2578
��: �60 346—o6i�
Fnx: 76o 340-0574
info@pal m-deser�.org
TO: CJPIA (c/o CARL WARREN 8� CO.), CITY MANAGER, CITY ATTORNEY,
ACM FOR DEVELOPMENT SERVICES, DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC WORKS,
RISK MANAGER
FROM: CITY CLERK
DATE: MARCH 20, 2007
SUBJECT: CLAIM NO. 579`=CLAIM AGAINST THE CITY BY GREGG EDWARD RALL
IN THE AMOUNT OF $211,096.50
The attached Claim No. 579 is being transmitted to you for the.following:
❑ Information only.
or
� Review and recommendafiion:to the Claims Review Committee for any action
required by the City of Palm Desert.
We would appreciate your report, if requested, by April 20, 2007� for timely response to
the Claimant.
� 1 � 0�
v
RACHELLE D. KLASSEN, CMC `�
CITY CLERK Cl�
Y
Attachment (as noted)
�^��..�.�,w.
CITY OF PALM DESERT
ASSIGNED CLAIM N0.
CLAIM AGAINST THE CITY OF PALM DESERT
(For Damage(s) to Person(s) or Personal Pcoperty)
����, 3-i �f-o�
�l��l'la
Received by:
via: U.S. Mail Interoffice Mail Over-the-Counter
A CLAIM MUST BE FILED WITH THE CI Y CLERK OF THE CI Y OF PALM DESERT WITHIN SIX
MONTHS AFTER WHICH THE INCIDENT OR EVENT OCCURRED. BE SURE YOUR CLAIM LS
AGAINST THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, NO't ANOTHER PUBLIC ENTITY. WHERE SPACE LS
INSUFFICIENT, PLEASE USE ADDITIONAL PAPER AND IDEN'T�Y IIVFORMATION BY
PARAGRAPH NUMBER. COMPLETED CLAIMS MUST BE MAILED OR DELI1/ERED TO THE CITY
CLERK, CITY OF PALM DESERT, 73-510 FRED WARING DRIVE, PALM DESERT, CA 92260.
TO THE HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL, City of Palm Desert, California:
The undersigned respectfully submit(s) the following claim and information relative to damage(s) to
person(s) and/or personal property:
1. CLAIMANT INFORMATION:
NAME Gregg Edward Rall
ADDRESS � -
PHONE NO. G � DATE OF BIRTH:
SOCIAL SECURI�`Y NO. - ' • DRIVER'S LIC N E NO.
2. Name, telephone number and post office address to which claimant desires notices to be
sent, if other than above:
La� O f; G of Caron a. JohnG�n. & Hoddick LL.p
71-650 Sahara Road, Suite �k2
Rancho Miraue, CA 92270 (760) 773-4849
3. Occurrence or event from which the claim arises:
a. DATE: 10/2 0/0 6 b. TIM E: 6: 5 9 a.m. c. PLACE (exact and specific
,location Monterey Ave. at intersection with Saqewood Dr. , Citv of Palm
Desert, CA
d. How and under what circumstances did damage or injury occur? Specify the particular
occurrence, event, act or ommission you claim caused the injury or damage. (Use
additional paper if necessary.) Jeep vehicle driven by Barbara Gardner entered
intersection west through StQp sign on Saaewood Dr. , collided with
Cla?mant Greqg Rall, headed north on Monterey Ave on riotorcycle,
and collided with Joseph Funkev, also north on Monterey Ave. on
�#�r�ycle. See attached letter of re�esentation
e. What particular action by the City, or its employees, caused the alleged damage or
' injury? City of Palm Des�rt negligentiv designed owned o�erated,
maintained �llf� OY contrr�l 1 Pd h i ntarGPr++i nn nf MnntPrPy AVe 8t
Sagewood Dr.
Page 1 of 2
�5�r �
4. Give a general description of the indebtedness, obligation, injury, damage, oc loss incurred
so far as it may be known at the time of presentation of the claim. If there were no
injuries, state "no injuries": 'uries - avulsion fracture ri ht ankle,
�Prvical �� G� hLlQ�,,-:m�r���-a� Px�enses . pain/sufferinQ, pro erty amagP
,�-m m�tnrr���1 t�
5. Give the name(s) of the City employee(s) causing the damage or injury:
6. Name and address of any other person(s) injured:
r�QSE�1. F��nka= - - - --
7. Name and address of the owner of any damaged property:
�r�� F.Award Rall
.�oharh Fun� � .
8. Damages claimedGardner _
a. Amount claimed as of this date: $ 30 ,181. 50 medical. �8.000 loe, ;22,9]
b. Estimated amount of future costs: $ Fr�Ferty5d�ar.�aQe; $150, 000 pain/suffez
c. Total amount claimed:
d. Basis for computation of amounts claimed include copies o all bills, invoices,
estimates, etc.): Gpp atta�hed letter with breakdown.
9. Names and addresses of all witnesses, hospitals, doctors, etc.: See Attachments herewith
!0. Any additional information, including police reports, which might be helpful in considering
this claim: �e��e6 i'6ri.tirt atta^hP� , TM�'�� �a� �; � t c, F_r�pF�y dar.�aQe document;
Vf/ARNING:IT LS A CRIMINAL OFFEIVSE TO FILE A FALSE CLAIMI PENAL CODE 7�
INSURANCE CODE 556.1).
I have reail il» rnatters and statements made in the above claim, and I know the same to be true of
my own knowledge, except as to those matters stated upon information or belief as to such matters
I believe the same to be true. I certify under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is TRUE AND
CORRECT.
Signed this y of j'n�4� ,20 d"T , at )/(A .
� .
SIGNA L AIN NA UR O CLAIMAN
Office of the City Clerk, Palm Desert, California DOC. NO. DA?E FILED
Page 2 of 2
Anthony C.Caronna Law Offices Inland Empire Oflice
Paul J.Johnson CARONNA JOHNSON & HODDICK LLP 2068 Orange Tree Lane
Larry R. Hoddick > > Suite 215
ATTORNEYS AT' LAW/ CONSUMER ADVOCATES Redlands,CA 92374
REPLY TO (909)798-8180
71-650 Sahara Rd., Suite 2 Imnerial vauey Ot1`�
Rancho Mirage, California 92270 220 W. Main St.
TELEPHONE (760) 773-4849 Suite B
Brawley,CA 92227
FACSIMILE (760) 773-0849 (760)351-8851
ry ry
March 13, 2007 � �-�
= D..�
VIA CERTIFIED MAIL/ � ��m
RETURN RECEIPT REOUESTED � ��m
m
Z ���
�Op
City of Palm Desert c��
73-510 Fred Waring Drive � Dm
Palm Desert, CA 92260-2578
Re: Our Client: Gregg E. Rall
Date of Loss: September 15, 2006
Location: Ave 50 intersection at Jefferson St., City of La Quinta, County of
Riverside, California
Dear Gentlepersons:
Please be advised that the Law Offices of Caronna, Johnson &Hoddick, L.L.P. represents
the interests of Gregg E. Rall , • in
the presentation of Mr. Rall's claims for damages for personal injuries, physical pain and suffering,
emotional distress, loss of earnings, and property damage, as a result of a serious motor vehicle
accident which took place on October 20, 2006, at approximately 6:59 a.m., at the intersection of
Monterey Ave. and Sagewood Dr. in the City of Palm Desert, California.
At the time of the subject accident, Mr. Rall was driving his 2005 Harley Davidson
motorcycle in the#2 of 3 northbound lanes on Monterey Ave. approaching the intersection at
Sagewood Dr. To Mr. Ralls' immediate left, also headed northbound on Monterey Ave. was a
2003 Buell motorcycle driven by Joseph Funkey.
As the motorcycles approached the intersection at Sagewood Dr., a 2004 Jeep Cherokee
driven by Barbara Ann Gardner entered the intersection from the"Stop" sign controlling
westbound travel on Sagewood Ave. Ms. Gardner's entry into the intersection was a substantial
factor in causing a serious traf�"ic collision between Ms. Gazdner's Jeep, Mr. Rall's motorcycle, and
Mr. Funkey's motorcycle.
Our investigation of the subject traffic accident has revealed that the City of Palm Desert is
responsible for the negligent design, maintenance, management, and control of the subject
intersection and traffic control devices located at the subject intersection; and that the City of Palm
Desert had actual and/or constructive notice of a dangerous condition of public property, the 3
northbound and 2 southbound lanes of travel on Monterey Ave. separated by a single "Stop" sign
City of Palm Desert
March 13, 2007
Page 2
for westbound traffic on Sagewood Ave., where City of Palm Desert failed to install a traffic light
system located at the sub,ject intersection to adequate regulate motorists, which created a
reasonably foreseeable risk of the kind of incident which occurred, and which was a substantial
factor in causing harm to Gregg E. Rall.
Enclosed for your review is a copy of Traffic Collision Report#T06293008 prepared with
respect to this matter.
As a result of the subject accident, Gregg E. Rall sustained serious personal injuries
requiring hospitalization, together with continued and ongoing pain and suffering, and loss of
income.
Injuries and Treatment
As a result of the subject collision between Mr. Rall's motorcycle and Gardner's Jeep, Mr.
Rall was ejected from his motorcycle and crashed to the ground.
Paramedics arrived and transported Mr. Rall by ambulance to Desert Regional Medical
Center where Mr. Rall underwent extensive emergency examination for complaints of pain,
primarily centered azound the cervical spine, left elbow, and right ankle. Mr. Rall was provided
emergency treatment and released.
Cervical Spine•
Desert Medical Imaging MRI of the cervical spine dated 12/15/06 demonstrated:
C4-5: 3 mm central disc protrusion, uncinate arthropathy and mild degenerative changes
of facet joints manifesting as mild central spinal canal stenosis as well as mild/moderate right and
mild left neural foraminal encroachment.
CS-6: 4mm posterior disc protrusion resulting in moderate/severe central spinal canal
stenosis as well as moderate/severe right and severe left neural foraminal encroachment.
C6-7: Minimal right asymmetric posterior annular bulge, degenerative changes of the
facet joints and mild uncinate arthropathy resulting in mild left neural foraminal encroachment.
Right Ankle:
Desert Medical Imaging MRI of the right ankle dated 1/20/07 demonstrated:
Compazed with 11/1/06, there is some interval healing of the avulsion fracture involving
the talus posteromediallly at the attachment of the tibiotalar component of the deltoid ligament.
The fracture line remains identifiable, however, and is therefore not yet completely healed.
There is complete healing of the bone contusion involving the talaz head and neck medially.
There is resolution of ihe right ankle joint effusion and subtalar joint effusion.
Left Elbow•
Truly Open MRI Impression dated October 31, 2006 consisted of mild to moderate
subcutaneous soft tissue edema to the posterolateral aspect of the left elbow, suggesting post-
traumatic subcutaneous contusion/inflamrtiation. Mild edema noted over the medial left elbow.
No evidence of left elbow fracture.
City of Palm Desert
March 13, 2007
Page 3
Medical Special Damages Received to Date
Desert Regional Medical Center $23,241.64
Oasis Radiology Group $ 614.00
California Emergency Physicians $ 318.00
Yes I Can $ 64.41
Truly Open MRI $ 1,500.00
Desert Medical Imaging $ 3,808.00
Eisenhower Urgent Care Centers $ 291.00
Prescriptions $ 344.47
Current Total: $30,181.52
In addition to the above-mentioned providers, Mr. Rall has been examined and/or treated
by Dr. Robert F. Steinberg, M.D., Dr. Andrew R. Rothstein, D.P.M., and Hathaway Chiropractic,
whose billings and/or reports are yet to be received. Mr. Rall's prognosis remains guarded.
Loss of Earnines
Mr. Rall was employed by Golden Valley Products 49-570 Highway 111 Coachella, CA.
92236 (760) 391-5300 in sales, earning approximately$1,500.00 per week. Mr. Rall estimates a
loss of earnings of approximately$8,000.00 as a result of the injuries sustained in the subject
accident.
Property Damage
The 2005 Harley Davidson motorcycle owned and driven by Mr. Rall was "totalled"
following the incident, the actual cash value of the motorcycle plus sales tax, license fees, DMV
fees, at$22,915.34, less Mr. Rall's $500 insurance deductible.
Please contact the undersigned if you have any unanswered questions or require the
submission of additional information with respect to the claims presented on behalf of Gregg E.
Rall.
Very tnily yours,
CARONNA, JOHNSON & HODDICK, LLP
Attorneys at Law
By: �
Anth G Caronna, Esq.
Encls. (claim form; police report; medical billings, property damage documents)
_�....��.�.,
�AFFIC COLLISfON REPOR
55`.CARS Psgs 1 (Rev 1-03)OPI 061 � l d 6
�oaortaws K..e� Mr.�w crtr �uo�c�o�sneicr ►o�u�e�a�r NUMeeR
�� �� PAI.M DESERT DESERT
..�or Kaun M�� �r ReroRrw o�nncr �wT
T06293008
0 � RIVERSIDE 36C3-1 T-69
oauaan ooc�aueec o►c �a wr rewR a�ooJ nac• orriaR i.o.
• MOMEREY AVE. IOROR006 0639 3300 1802
� �r�crosr�aiwno� wr or wmc
• row wwr r►arooiw+s w: �ra�e
i FRIbAY X ro �o CPL DEVIIQNY
� X �+►�srcna.wmt sr��e�vr�ec #]780
: 3AC3EWOOD DR vu a( No 34 PHOTOS
� OIlN6l'f UCHt�E M#�ER iTATE CLAq NR W fMETY ep1Ar. VBl YEAR I�NKE/MOOEL I OOIOR LIC�E NM�lR iTA7!
CA C M O � P CHEROKEE ORY CA
a �rn�sr.aoot�,t�sn
BARBARA ANN GARDNER orweRs�we a a��u o��
s sr�eer�ooaets
�
o+M+�es�oa�cu �j�v+t�s
s crtr�a�e�a►
�
.� � � � ,�,f .�„�„n ,� ��W,��,�.�: o� o� ��
ire o.. r..
F t nea��eo�.ov[crs x wa��rr. ieerne ro rwnunu[
R no�na� w�u w�oNe ve�cx[ioeHnrirwnon►aa�sk
VM0.E T'�[ OIiCItI�E VMCLE QMMOE OMDE N QMMOlG AREA
NwIU110E CJ1R11�'4 /OLICY NlifJt lli2 1101� �IOR
MA X �KI011 IIOII-0VER
pR Oi TIIAVEI dl iTREEf 011 NUNVAY ���� G DDT
W SAOEWOOD DR 2S �.T T�� ��
r a�Nors uceec�weR a�� cws �ra a�e�r[au►. vet rwe w+��Mooe��oaat I��c�e K�eR rr��
' CA M P W 03 HARIEY D M/C YEL CA
u wwayARst.�roo�c.wn
. C3RFAO EDWARD RAI.L on►fu�s w� a w+e iu o�t
s sr�r�oo�ss
� . .
� �� a we�s o�enre�
� C7fY/iTATE/ZV
�
� asPotrtaN a ve�t oh owaes w: � �o�� �o�t
R aex »+r� erw ►�o��r wewKr w»�w� �uce RONS'POWIIJC}-(760�68-3100
I� Ow Yw
M /111011�! :�L 0!MlC�f /I0�!A/r. II!/Q 7�O IMRMT111E
Q qOhEN101E MM!li6M10�E VD�Ct.E1DHiiVICaTld1lR1�lA:
V6�CLE 7Y*E 0lfCRl�!V�CLE O�IM�IOf a��OE N DNMOED MfA
p�IIUVCE CIIRIU6t 1'OlIL1'MMOI l�f I�IOR
f�..uED �� X ROLL-0'11li!
DIR Of TRAVEL d/fTRlEf OR MOYMYAY N![D LMi � OOT /
N MONTEREY AVE. 30 �_T �� �,,�
11� CRMKi LICB4[►RAlEII iTATE CIARS AMt MO N1fETY EaM. VBl YEAR 1MKE/MOOn/OOLOII I UC�IfE!A�[R iTA7E
CA M p W 03 BUEIL EB9R BUJ CA
ai �w�[crresr.►�oo«.t�sn
� JOSEPHfVNKEY �M� ����
� sr�err�ooaets 7TMOTHYCARK�
r
�.,� n.�,��
� Cf►Y I iTAT!/M
� OIi�ON'TION Of tl�Cl!QI OI101Ri Or: OfFlCER DR111[R
� aoc wuR evfs �aR wEio�rt � ��� �� � RONS 7'OWINO-(760)568-3100
M ' naoR�eaw�cu�o�Eets No►��. ero�m wua�n�
et �moNe s�u�+ess na�e vo�c�t�oe�r�c�na�ra,Meea:
VMC{.E 7Yr[ OEfCR1�E YDfCIE DMI�OE ai�OE N 6�IIAMilD MEt
Ne{JIUIlC!G11tR!!R rOIICY lilwR� IIiC 1101! Iw10R
F��Q�T NOO MKI011 IIOII-0VER
pR p 711AVEL ON QTREET dt MO�MMY OEEO LMT � � �
N MONTEREY AVE. S� CAl-T TCM�C MCAOI �
lPAR6CilIM! dtrATCM NOTIAED MME 0111i RkNIlYYED
PAULSEN 1802 Ks � � O
��� � �o� .
..r.....x.,,.,.,,.
AFFIC COLLISION CODING��
5�+CARS Ppe2(Rev.1-03)OPI 061 P�2 d e
r oaw�oN�ro.o�r r�a� nrttz�ao� wcic• orr�e i.o. ra�e
ROpb 0639 3300 1802 T06293008
�� ow�ER�ooReu Hon�eo
IPERTY �'ES ❑Pb
MA(iE oESCe�or oNMae
s�►nnc;PosmoN SAFETY E�UIPMENT INATTENTION CODES
OCCUPANTS L-Alit BAG OEPLOYm MVC BICYCXE-HELMET
- A-NOPIE 9i VEFMCI.E M-AIR BAfi NQT DEPLOYED ORNER PA33ENOER A-CELL PFIOPE HMqFiELD
B-CELL PHONE FIANOBFRFF
8_IJNICNOWN N-OTFER V-NO X-NO C-EL.EGTRd�C EOINPARENi
C-LAP BELT U8W P-NQT REOUIRm W'� Y'� D•RADIO/CO
2 3 1-DRIVER 0•LAP BELT NOT U8� E.BMpq�IA
2 TO e-PA3SENOHtS E'��FIARNES8 U6ED CHILD RESTRAINT E�p FROM VEFIICLE F-EAT1Nff
5 6 �-sr�wcsN r� F-sr+ou��w�rcr�ss Nar us�o e-w vo�ae ueen �-��
e-►�.occ rnK ort ww a-uw�+ou�o�rw�ss uem a-r�ve►�ae nor us�o °�NOT�� ►+•�ww�s
H-LAP/BFIOULDER FIARNEBS NOT USED 1-FULLY F�C'fED I• PER�lEL HYGIET�
o-POSRION UNKNOWN S-IN VE►�CLE USE UNIQrOWN Z_PARTIALLY EJECfID
T 0-OT}IER J-PAS3tVE RESiRMlT UOED T-M VEMK�.E IMPROPER U9E �,�yN J- REAGYiO
K-P118.91VE RESTRAMi NOT U8� U-NOf�IN VETMCLE K-OTM�
�s�uwceo eaow Fou.owEe nr�w�roers�c�h s►+o�xn eE oc�+ee M rne wu�iu►rvE.
'"'"R"cau"'°"F"e'°'e �c c�o�xo�oev�us 1 2 3 sPccu�wfaawmo� 1 2 3 ""we""art n`Ece°"°
IfT I�MM(�l Of MRiV AT fMLT COlL1ilOM
vc sEcraN vbu� c��s � �a FuricnaaHc� � �aous w►T� � srcv�a
�� s carrRa.s r�r Fur+crar+w+c�� s cEu aF� w � areoeFFnr+o srR�aNr
on��o�a otiv�o� c co�rtRas oe9cu� c � �R��+ c ww o�no�o
D NO COMROLS PRESEM/FAGTOR' �( D CELL PIiONE NOT IN U8E D MAKING RqFfT TURN
dTF1ER h1AN DRNER' TYPE Of COlL1�lON E SCFIOOL 8US RELAT� E MAKMO LEFT TURN
UNKNOWM' A HEAD-ON F 76 FT MOT F MAKMrC�U TURN
s s+oe�w�►+� o ss Fr�R coMeo o s�c�ano
C REAR BD M M SLOWNG/STOPPNO
�T}�t (MARK 1 TO 4 RFJrI.�'7 D BR011D8�E 1 1 PASSMO OTHER VEFiK:LE
CLEAR E HR OBJEGT J J CNANCiINO LANES
CLOUOY f OVERTl1RNED K K PARKlI�KKi MANEl1VER
RAMM�I'3 O VEJ�CLE/P£DESTRIAN L L ENTERNrG TAAFFIC
SNOWN(i M QTHHt': M M O'T}IERUNSAFETJRIi�ICi
FOC3/VISBLRY Ff, N N %INCi INTO OPP031Nf3 LANE
OT}ER• MOTOR VEHK:LE MNOIVED WITH O O PARIC�
WIPD A NOf�.001Lt910N P � M19laNd0
UOMTINO S PEDE5iRbW C . G TRAVEUNf3 WROPKi WAY
DAYLIOHT x C OTHER MOTOR VEMMCLE OTHER AffOCIATlD FACTORf R OTHER':
DUBK•DAWN D MOTOR VEFNCLE ON OTHER ROAOWAY 1 2 3 (AAARK 1 TO 2 RBi1B)
DARK-STR�T Llf3FITS E PARKED MOTOR Vd#CLE A .e aeTa w�w� ueem Br[a
DARK-NO STREEi UOF�TS F TRMN �
avbc-srR�r uc►�rs NOT o e�crcx.E s K�10"'M°"� "'� Yts
R1MCT10NM�G' H ���; � i00RETY-ORUO
ROADWAY iURFACE C ve=eriowveu� aem 8
oRr i FucEn oe,iEcr: � 1 2 3 �,�K,�ro s rrvas�
y� D X X A w►D no'r BEEn Drtu�rc�o
saowr.icr � on�oexc.-r: e vmo�,oex�xr: s Neo•uNoeR w��
SL�PERY(1�100Y.OILY.ETC.) F INATTENT10fi': C F180-NO'T lINOER HFUIENCE`
ROADWAY CONDITION(8) O STOP i 00 7RAFFIC D HBO-IMFAIRMENT UNK►JOWPP
(MARK 7 TO 4 fT6dS7 PEDEST1tW1'i ACTIONS H EHiFRWO/LEJIVNK3 RAMP E UNOER ORl1G MIFLUENCE'
FIOLES.DffP RIJT'' A NO PEDESTRIANS!lVOIV� 1 PREVIOUS O011l.'iION F IINPAIRMENT-PFIYSICAL•
LOOSE MATERIAL ON ROADWAY' S CAO�SING N�I CR039WAUC J UNFAMIUAR WfTH ROAO O IMPAIRM@!i NOT KNOWH
08SiRUCTION ON ROAOWAY' AT I�IfERSECTION K DEFECTNE V@I.EOIIP.: CffED N NOT APPL1CA8lE
CdISTRl1CilON-R�AR ZOPIE C CROSSMO NI CROSSWAl1C•NOT B�'!,s 1 SIEEPY/FATIOUED
RE�UCED ROADWAY WIDTN AT�lTBtSECT10N �
ROOOED• D CR0391PKKi-NOT IN CROSSINALK L UNINVOLVED VENICLE
OT}IpC: E IN ROAD•NCLUOES 9NOlA.DER M ORF�N:
NO UPUISUAL OOI�DfT10NS F NOT Nl ROAD N NOME APPAREM
p APPROACFiINO/LEAVMG 9CEIOOL BUS O RUNAWAY VEFpCLE
�" FOR SKETCH DIAGRAM, SEE PAGE 4 � M'��""�
norwn w�rn
����.o+ ����
oF:au�oFw+n
IRED/WITNESSES / PASSENGER
i55 CARS Paae 3 R t-03 OPI °.c. 3 d e
7F CALLISION(MO. DAY YFJ�f� T1MEC2� NCIC• OFFICER IA
NUMBER
2006 0659 3300 1802 T06293008
st rtissoaai � � EXTENT OF INJURY('X�ONE) INJURED WAS(�X�ONEI � aur � s�rr
� �� EJEcf'ED
fATAL iEbEllL 0}►ER Nq►E COIiI/VQi �R P06. !Ap EQlIP.
wuer ruwr wutr oF nw oRNen �,us. reo. r�crttisr onu
❑ 33 M ❑ ❑ � ❑ � ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑ � 1 P W 1
/D.O.B./ADORESS T£LEPNONE
3C3 EDWARD RALJ.
tE0 ONLI�TRANSPORTED BY: TAKEN TO:
PARAMEDIC DESERT REGIONAL MEDL42.CENTER
2iaE MuuRiEs: ��p�HRUISES COMPL.AIIdT OF PAIN TREATED AND RELEASED.
VK:"i1M OF VqLEM CRIME N071FED
❑ 4� M ❑ o a o o ❑ o 0 03 1 P W �
,o.o a,,,� �
:PH FUNKEY
�ow�h rn�r�sPo��er: T�xew ro
p��j� DESERT RE(3IONAL MEDICAL CENfER
FaeE w,u�s:
SCRAPES,BRUISES BROKEN RIBS TREATED AND REI.EASED
vicr�oF v�T ca��nvrs�o
� 0 9 M a o o ❑ ❑ o ❑ a o
I D.O.B.!AODRESS ��p��E
AN N1CO1r4S BISBAS
RED Ot�1�TRANSPORTED BY: — -- TAKEN TO:
RIBE N�,RIRIEB:
VK.TM OF VIOLEKT CRIME NOTIFIED
2 0 �, M ❑ ❑ ❑ o 0 0 0 ❑ o
:/D.O.B./ADORESS �
.ERT C KOLBECK
Rm ONL1�TRAN9FORTED BY: •TAKEN TO�
�tBE NiA/RIE4:
VICTiM OF YIOLEPIT CRIME NOTIFlED
o ❑ o ❑ o 0 0 0 0 0
:/D.O.B I ADORESS ����
1RED ONLI�TRANSPORTF�BY: TAKEN TO:
:R6E INJURES:
VIGTIM OF VIOLEM CRIME NOT1FIEp
` o 0 o a o ❑ o 0 0 ❑
E/D.0.8./AOORESS ���E
1RED ONLI�TRIWSPORTED BY: TAKEN TO:
�tIBE NJURIES:
VIGTIAA OF VIOLEM CRM�NOTIFED
'ARERS NAME I.D.NUMBER Mq. DAY YEAR R I 3 NAME MO. DAY YEAR
PAULSEN �soZ io�2onoo6
F'i 1 � ��i��'
•STATE OF CALLFOItNIA
.SKETCH DIAGRAM
cxr sss p�Re 4ctt�� 8-9'� OPI 042 PAGE 4 OF 6
DATE OF INCIDENT TIME NCIC NUMBER OFFICER I.D. NUMBER
10/20/2006 0659 3300 1802 T06293008
ALL MEASUREMENTS ARE APPROXIAAATE AND NOT TO SCALE UNLESS STATED(SCALE=� )
� t
... i � � ; ;
� � �
F o �
, ;
r ' ' N 0 k,�1�
��D�..I�IZ�Y �—`�',l� i � I � �
. , �
� - -- ---�_ �, � ; � .
; ,� . .
� � ; � �
� � , :Q ,
---�--� -�-- . '.>-�-�-r,�---►.�-�� --r t I �--,�-13�
� ' ,
� � + � � � � �
f � -� ; : . �
' v- t
M � • �
4
V-'1. �—
v� � `''� ?r-y �
� -J �
1 '
� f
i f '
I
I , f
? I �
� i �
i
� � /r � 1 � '...~_�.- C,"' :
} , � , + , - _. . :a.. _
• : i . � '� '�,
� � l,r ; ; � ; ; ...
4 j i t (
�
i � �� i S
f ` � ' i
� ! �' ; �
i ; ! � ' ' I
� � i �
� •
i � . �
; ` ' t � , ;
; ,
� J 4
� + f � .
f ' � � i
� t
� { t
. � � `
1
PREPARED BY I.D.NUMBER DATE ER'S NAME DATE
R. PAULSEN 1802 10/20/2006 !�/
�fi � �i'� " �
STATE OF CAL�OItNIA
NARRATIVE/SUPPLEMENTAL PAGE 5 OF 6
CATE OF INCIDEN TIME NCIC NUMBER OFFICER I.D. NUMBER
10/20/2006 0659 3300 1802 T06293008
1 NOTIFICATION:
2 I received this minor-injury traffic-collision at 0701 hours. Responding from Monterey Ave. and
3 Magnesia Falls, I arrived at 0703 hours. All times, speeds and distances are approximate.
4 Measurements were made with a roll tape.
5
6 STATEMENTS:
7 D-1 (Gardner) Refer to Cpl. D. Devinny's supplemental report for Gardner's statemets.
8
9 D-2 (Rall) related he was north on Monterey in the # 1 or#2 lane, approaching Sagewood and
0 traveling about 50 —55 mph, While driving V-2 (Harley Davidson). Rall said the other motorcyclist,
1 D-3 (Funkey) was traveling on his left side. Rall told me he heard Funkey's motorcycte squeal his
2 brakes and realized that a car had pulled out in front of them. Rall said he also put on his brakes
3 and that he could not swerve #o #he left because Funkey was there. Ral! said he saw the car
4 continue to roll into the roadway and when it got halfway across Monterey and in front of him in his
�5 lane, he hit the car on its right side, fell and slid. Rall told me that immediately after he stopped
:6 sliding, he got up for a moment but then fell back down.
17
18 D-3 (Funkey) related he was north on Monterey Ave. in the# 1 lane approaching Sagewood at
19 about 60 mph while driving V-3 (BueN). Funkey said he was traveling just left of Rall and a bit
?0 ahead of his motorcycle. Funkey him and Rall were traveling about the same speed when `all of a
?1 sudden' he saw a car pull out from Sagewood in front of them. Funkey told me the car did not stop
?2 when it entered onto Monterey. Funkey said he just 'slammed' on his brakes and went down.
?3 Funkey told me he did not know if Rall's motorcycle had hit the car or not. Funkey cor�firmed that
?4 he did not collide with Rall prior to the car pulling out.
?5
?6 W-1 (Bisbas) related he was north on Monterey Ave. in the center lane approaching Sagewood
?7 and traveling about 35 mph. Bisbas said he was traveling behind the two motorcycles. Bisbas told
?8 me the motorcycles did not appear to be speeding and were traveling at a 'regulaP speed. He said
?9 the yellow bike was traveling next to and on the right side of the other one. Bisbas said he saw a
30 silver car pull out from Sagewood onto Monterey and then the car pulled out again farther and
31 onto Monterey. Bisbas told me he saw the yellow motorcycle hit the silver car and the other
32 motorcycle slid across the pavement. Bisbas added that the silver car was in the middle of the
33 road when it stopped.
34
35 W-3 (Kolbeck) related he was north on Monterey riding a motorcycle and behind both the Harley
36 Davidson and the Buell Motorcycles. Kolbeck said as he approached Sagewood, he saw the silver
37 car pulling out from Sagewood onto Monterey. Kolbeck told me he thought the car was intending
38 to make a left turn and when it entered Monterey, it continued and struck the Harley Davidson
39 causing the Harley Davidson to swerve into the other motorcycle —V-3 (Buell). Kolbeck said both
40 motorcycles went down and slid across the pavement.
41
42
PREPARED BY I.D.NUMBER DATE R ER'S NAME DATE
R. PAULSEN 1802 10/20/2006
�� � ����
STATE OF CALIFO�WIA
NARRATIVE/SUPPLEMENTAL PAGE 6 OF 6
CATE OF INCIDENT TIME NCIC NUMBER OFFICER I.D. NUMBER
10/20/2006 0659 3300 1802 T06293008
1 SUMMARY:
2 Both V-2 (Harley Davidson) and V-3 (Buell) were north on Monterey Ave. approaching Sagewood.
3 The Harley Davidson was in the# 2 lane and the Buell was in the# 3 lane. Both were traveling
4 about 50�0 mph. D-2 (Rall) was driving the Harley Davidson and D-3 (Funkey)was driving the
5 Buell. V-1 (Jeep) was west on Sagewood approaching Monterey at a slow speed and driven by D-
6 1 (Gardner).
7
8 As both motorcycles approached Sagewood, Gardner entered Montery Ave. from Sagewood in
9 the path of V-2 (Harley Davidson) causing D-2 (Ral!) to brake. The Harfey Davidson and V-1
10 (Jeep) collided in the #2 northbound lane of Monterey causing the Harley Davidson to veer to the
11 left, fall down and skid across the pavement. As the Buell approached, Funkey also braked and
12 swerved to the left in an attempt to avoid the Jeep. As a result, the Buell went down and slid on
13 the pavement
14
15 AREA OF IMPACT:
16 The area of impact was determined by statements, debris and vehicle damage as:
17 AOi # 1 (Harley Davidson vs. Jeep)
18 17 feet west of the east curb prolongation of Monterey and;
19 35 feet north of the south curb prolongation of Sagewood.
20
21 AOI #2 (Buell vs. Pavement)
22 22 feet west of the east curb prolongation of Monterey and;
23 29 feet north of the south curb prolongation of Sagewood.
24
25 CAUSE:
26 D-1 (Gardner) caused this co((ision by being in violation of 21802 (a) V.C. — Fail to Yield to
27 Oncoming Traffic While Entering Through Traffic.
28
29 RECOMMENDATIONS:
30 None.
PREPARED BY t.0.NUMBER DATE R �ER,'S NAME DATE
R. PAULSEN 1802 10/20/2006 %��%{//� �//ESd tS
�-w� � ����
� vi r
E.•REPeRED: 102006 INCIDENT R
— � INITIAL � SUPPLEMENTAL
RIVERSIDE COUNTY SHERIFF CAOJ30000
E MUY/EII 2 DATE/T1ME REPORTED �.DATE / T1ME ASSIGNED 1. DATE/ T1ME INV.START 6. DATElT1ME INV.TERM i. ACULT AR 7. JU V.ARR
T06293008
) EN D SEGTI N CRIME COUNTS 9 EDP COOF
-81 In'u Traffic Collision 1 18J4M
�FFENSES-CODE SECTION(Aaa a Ch�ny�to) CRIME COUNTS 11 EDP CADE
JFFENSES- ODE SECTiON�Adtl or Ch�np�to) CRIME
COUNTS t7. EDPCODE
OCATION OF OCCURRENCE 15 REP DISTR�CT 16 OCCURRED ON• DATE!TIME 17 OR BETYVEEN DA7E�TIME
itere /Sa ewood, Palm Desert 36G1 102006 0659
BUSINESS NAME �9 BUSINESS PMONE Y0 CASE STATUS/CIEARANCE
EXC
TIM -REPORTING PARTY -WITNESS -OTHER: �S��AtldlUon�l P�non�R�port
NVL 27 N (l�sl. vtt.M�0d1�) 2] SEII 21 PALE 25 Dpg
ti.�GE !1 MT �.Wi 1! FWR �p E�S 71 SKIM
:ESIOENCE ADDRESS CITV Z�P ]7 RES PHpNE
•USINESS ADORESS CITY
ZIP 35 BUS.PHONE
VVL ���• ��s�. � � A SEt �9 RACE 40 DOB �1 AGE �2 HT 1� WT ♦� NAIR IS.EYES r6 SKiN
ESIDEHCE ADDRESS CITY �E RES PHONE
ZIP
USiNESS ADDRESS CITY ZIP 50 BUS PHONE
iPECT: � Adult � Juvenile � Parde � Probation � S��AddAan�l P�nons Report � Arrested
�� 52 W1ME(lnt,Fust M�dAM) S1.SEl �q�� 55 Dp8 5t AGE S) Ni SA WIT 31 IMW 10 ETES KIN
MNER'S IICENSE NUMBER/ID NUMBER p StATE H SOGAL SECURITY NUMBER 65 MNi MUMSER 66 CU MUYlER
RESIDENCE ADDRESS CITY Z�P 61 RES PNONE
BUSINESS ADDRESS CITY ZIP 10 IUS PMONE
JUVENILE OISPOSITION• ❑OtMr Juria. ❑Juv Crt Prob �Wrthm Dept Dat�in�d Not D�t�in�d
�ANG DATA �3 CLOTHING DESCRIPTION
mg Name(s):
❑Member ❑Associate ❑Self Admit ❑Prior Knowledge
TATTOOS/SCARS
�F�c� Neek ❑R Arm �L.Arm ❑H�nCs❑Torso Baek O L�O�
IICLE: � REFER TO CHP 1s0 FORIM FOR STOLEN,RECOVERED,TOWED OR IMPOUNDED
�y�l5 LICENSE 7�. STATE 77 YEAR 7B. MAKE QO BODY S7YLE 01. REC.AUTO VALUE
A2 i
COIOR B3 VIN x BI OTHER IDENTIfIERS 65 O�SPO5ITION OF VEHICLE
EGtSTERED OWNER E) ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP E8. PMONE
� PROPERTY RErORT ATTACMED FOR BTOLEN,RECOVERBD,OR DAYAOBD PROrERTY
R71NG OFFICER OFF ID REVI£WED BY!DATE ENTERED BY I DA7E ENTEREO BY/DATE
Dan Devinny 1780 � O �C r06
ES T0 A�� APR SENT Apq CANCELED DOJ-NCIC ENT DOJ,NCIC CANC
, SWITRS , Paulsen r
.�..,.u� O . _ O i..
�
STATE OF CALIFORNlA
NARRATIVE/SUPPLEMENTAL PAGE S 1 oF S2
DATE OF INCIDENT TIME NCIC NUMBER OFFICER I.D. NUMBER
10/20/2006 0659 3300 1802 T - 06 293 008
1 SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT
2
3 PURPOSE:
4 The purpose of this supplemental report is to provide the following: 1) Notification, 2)
5 Statements, 3) Evidence.
6
7 NOTIFICATION:
8 I was advised of this injury traffic collision at about 0659 hours by Motor 71 (Deputy Rod
9 LaBrecque). I responded from Fred Waring and San Pablo and arrived on scene at about 0706
10 hours. When I arrived I observed a white female adult, later determined to be D-1 (Gardner)
11 standing in front of V-1 (Jeep). The vehicle was on Sagewood Drive, just east of the limit line with
12 Monterey facing west. I observed a fluid trail that led from V-1 westbound out into the number two
13 northbound lane of Monterey. At the end of the fluid trail in the number two lane was a skid mark
14 that began south of Sagewood. That skid continued north until the location of the fluid trail and
15 then veered to the left and continued north. Refer to photographs for further.
1fi
17 STATEMENTs:
18 D-1 (Gardner): The following is a summary of her statement to me. I asked D-1 if she was injured
19 and she told me she was not. I asked her if she moved her vehicle after the collision and she told
20 me she backed it up to the location it was now. I pointed to the AOI where I observed a skid mark
21 that deviated to the left and to where I observed a fluid trail that led from the AO! to V-9 and asked
22 D-1 if that is where she backed her vehicle from. D-1 told me that it was. I asked D-1 to tell me
23 what she remembered. D-1 told me she was preparing to make a right turn from Sagewood at
24 Monterey. D-1 told me she observed finro northbound motorcycles with one in the middle (number
25 2 lane) and the other in the far right lane (number 3 lane). D-1 told me she watched as the two
26 motorcycles collided into each other. D-1 told me after the two collided, "The force banged them
27 into me".
28
Z9 I asked D-1 to show me where she thought she was when she was looking at the two motorcycles
30 colliding. She walked to the area of the limit line for westbound Sagewood at Monterey. The
31 location she showed me was about ten feet north of the area of impact in the number two lane.
32 The location �r�e showed me was also north of where her vehicle was currently stopped. The
33 location where V-1 was currently stopped is directly east of the AOI. The fluid trail goes from the
34 AOI, east to V-1's location, which is south of where D-1 was describing as the location she was
35 when she observed the collision of the finro motorcycles.
36
37 I asked D-1 why she thought the two motorcycles collided and she told me, "I guess they were
38 startled there was a car here (me). I guess they thought I was going to pull out". D-1 told me she
39 also saw a group of motorcyclists a short distance behind where the two collided. D-1 estimated
�0 there were maybe ten motorcycles.
�1
�2
PREPARED BY I.D. NUMBER DATE R E DATE
D. DEVINNY 1780 10/20/2006 • S6T• � �6 0 0� v6
� STATE OF CALIFORNIA
NARRATIVE/SUPPLEMENTAL PAGE S 2 OF SZ
DATE OF INCIDENT TIME NCIC NUMBER OFFICER I.D. NUMBER
10/20/2006 0659 3300 1802 T- 06 293 008
1 EVIDENCE:
2 I took (34) digital photographs of the scene and vehicles. I saved those pictures onto a CD and
3 entered them����to evidence at the Palm Desert Sheriffs Station. I printed out a contact sheet of
4 the photos and they are in this report.
5
PREPAREO BY I.D NUMBER DATE REVIEWER'S NAME DAT
D. DEVINNY 1780 10/20/2006 /v � �p�
I INCIDENT REPORT I
'E PREPARSD• �02506 � INITIAL ❑ SUPPLEMENTAL
RNERSIDE COUNTY SHERIFF CA0330000
E NUMlER J DATE/TIMIE REodITED 7.QATE 7 TNE ASiW1ED �.DATE TI►E INV 6TART S DATE/TNE INV.TERM {AOu1 MR 7 Jw ARR
T06293008 102006 0659 102006 0701 102006 0701 102006 0954 0 0
�Hsea cooe secTroN wa a c�.�,o.w� caw� ��S c eoa ccoe
81 MINOR INJURY TRAFFIC COLLISION 1 18J4-M
FEHSES COOE SECTION(MO a Ctirp�b) CRME CAUNTS 1l EpP COOE
ftN6E6 COOE fECT�ON(Me ol Cn�np�b) COUNTb �!DP CODE
lCAT10N Of OCCURRENCE 1S.REP.DIST 1!OCCURRED ON• DATE/T1►IE 17.OR SETMEEIi QATE/i1ME
�NTEREY AVE. / SAGEWOOD, PALM DESERT 36G-1 FRIDAY 1020-6/0659
s.�ss►w�e ��eus�r�ss vMOHe 70 CASE STATub�CLEAqN10E
EXC
:TIM REPORTING PARTY -WITNESS - OTHER: ❑See Additional Persons Report
Jl t2/uME(uu.Fni.4�oa4 2�SE% 7� RACE M� 7.MT 2�WT 2�.MAi11 �0.EYE6 ]t SKMI
:SiDENCE ADONESS CITY Zlr 77 RE6 P�qlE
�smtsa�ooneu ci*Y ' W u eua w+ort
� n w�wE cu.i.Fm.µmu �sex �o w�ca so oos a�.�aE �Kr a wr u.w��t .s eres w s+w
:s�oer�ca.00�ss cm zr u Res.vnoHe
�SM+EssA00rtEss crtr SO.OUS wq►E
USPECT: � Adult � Juvenile ❑ Parole ❑ Probation � S�e Addrtian�l Penons Report ❑ ARRESTED
i5� St/MME(Lut.FnI.IMCO� S�SEX 54 RAC! SS DOE S�.AOE S7 MT S/WT S�.MArI !0.EYES N il(W
tNERS UCENSE NU►!ER i 10 MUMlER !7 iTATE N LOCIAI SECU1tITY M1M�ER 0.S MM NlA1�Ep pQ Gi NUMOEII
:&OEI/Cf AOOIIESS CRY Z1P 6/.RE810ENLE Rql�
ISiNESSA0011ES5 GT' Zp 70 EU3.VNO�E
JUVENILE �ISPOSITION: I 1.1uv Crt Prob, [)vMth�n�ept [ ] Ost�l��d (]Not O�ta�n�d
C�4NG DATA TATTOOS/SCARSMIARKS/CLOTHING DESCRIPTION
ig Name(s):
r"' �_..' "�. �
❑Member ❑Assodate ❑Sel�Admit ❑ Priot Knowbdge , � �
.�d J
TATTOOSrSCARSIMARKS
]F��rba� pR.� ❑L.nm, p r+�►►ds pro�o ps� ❑��s
HICLE: � REFER TO CHIP 180 FORM FOR STOLEN,RECOVERED.TOWED OR IMPOUNDED
VL 75 LiLENSE 75.STATE 77 VEAR 7�MI1KE 7Y.MODEL �0.SOOY ST'LE� t1 S N/RCV AUTO VKIJE
A2 i
JL011�COIOR q VIW� M.OTMER IDENTIFIERS 65 pISPOS1710N OF VEMICLE
:GISTERFDOVMlER q AOORE6S dT`I 6TA7E LP !�PHONE
�. DNA�OED PpOPERTY VALUE
❑ PROPERTY REPORT ATTACHED FOR STOLEN,RECOVEREO,OR DAMAGED PROPERTY s
RTiNG qFICE11 OFF ID R D OV�DATE EHTERED OY/DA7E ENTERED bY i W7E
PAULSEN 1802 f - .6
� p AVR CAMCELED DOiNC1C EHT RED pO.LHCIC
V.I.T.R.S. � 7 r � 102006/1320
r�4 '`<<� ' ��
—_. _ _.
INCIDENT REPORT C�`��
TE PREP�RED: ��2� RIVERiIDE COUNTY SMERIiF CA03f0000 �INITIAL O SU►�LEMENTAL
v . r i a � wv. i IIM. �. .A. ./V. A.
T06293008
rt .. �.w. u_ c �.
-81 Injury Traffic Collision 1 1 SJ4M
N _ w �AIM 11.
. �
� N t 1 1 N:
onterey/Sagewood Palm Desert 36G1 102006 0700
� � � � J M
EXC
�T1M-REPORTING PARTY-1MTNES3-OTHER: ❑Sse Aed�dorral Pisrson Report
�uR w:4�r� a �. . . . . . . N
hK !uk wt��ri . 1. . M .
u� • �
lSPECT: ❑Adu1t ❑JweNle ❑Parok ❑ProbaGon ❑SeeAddNion�IPenonRepoK ❑ARRE3TE0
• 1MA� 11Mt Al MMr� . .rl.. . � .r1N 1. N
L. � NW � L .W . iN
�A r..
y� �� h
�uvENt�E DiSPOSiTiON l 1��. f 1+��►� f 1 Mllu�D�t 1 I a�.� ( I►�D�uYw
GANG DATA TATTOOS / 8CARS ! CLOTHING DE3CRIPTION
�►`�anb(y:
❑Mert� �,Woc�.ts �SeN Admit ❑Prw�K�►awledpe
TATTOOS /SCARS/MARKS
�Fsce ❑Neck ❑R.Ann LArm❑H�nOs❑Torao ❑Back ❑Lep�
:HICLE: ❑REFER TO CHP 180 FORM FOR STOLEN,RECOVERED,TOWED OR IMPOUNDED
W� _ 11 . . A. . . L 1. 'A
' ��' • I/ . , , � w
f �1N .• f � -A .
p.
❑PROPERTY REPORT ATTACHED FOR STOLEN. RECOVERED,OR DAMAGE PROPERTY �
� �
. LaBrecque 3106 �
)7 , SWITRS , Dep. Paulsen �
,�+�m��l� t�'�V `1��{�
V
1TE O�CALIFORNIA
►RRATIVE/SUPPLEMENTAL
P 556 Rev. �-90 OPI 061 '
� � Page s
E UF iNCIGENT/OCCI'IIRENCE TIME(?�00J NCIC NUMBER OFFICER I.D.NUMBER NUMBER
' o�.�� ' g-� �� ,..3_� �a �3 � ,� C� ?'-�� .� ':~`' �� �''�
�E X� E TVPE SUN�EMENTA�('X"APPLICA
N�rntiv� �Collision RepoA ❑ BA Upd�te � F�tal ❑ Hit�nd Run Update
� Suppl�m�nUl ❑ Oth�r: ❑ Haurdous M�te�iab ❑ School Bus ❑ Other:
/iCOUNTY/JUDICIAL DISTH}C�.� . . • • • REPORTING D157RIC7BEAT CI7A7iON UMBER
4/��►1 Uf%F'!� . . . Y?. � • � J . - ' � ~�.a-
'ATIOWSU ECT ^ � STATE HIOHWAY RELATED
�Cn �i{' yi fl�e �`' � � aG Y':.^,. •�' � Y�s � No
��c'r,�C,�? '
��h � .�'�� .� C S P ` r- '�/�:S �r�Pf'. .�i;'%�;/'= —F ,t.,;•i-I' ' _ ' .. - .:z o�r-�� �^�v'.
i
j i1 ro r%,' :Y � . �7 rE f�. � �'it . !' .i-� i� � . l l �!.:::r-. �
� e� " ' �C .
r
�/+ r • /
l� rl r�J�� �����!` � .�� �� �;v �� r' �a> .'1r.s. .� J � � :. .f "'1^ Ga M � , s0t/ 1.l b�y.'t0
n n i 1 !t t� l(�' C v r.`,� � �� �� �, * , �.�,. � / �.. f- � t.-
�, ! � .C•.! r / � t. rr (' � � -
,S� c.,{ bc.t: p� � •7� � r•� ✓�' d• '7'�it� o �1•� c f�'�- e y e�/�' S ,��f • •s ;� �, f_. � %.C �.^
` r.o• � � ►"i ' i':. , 1�.. , O f �/c..0 .� r f E'/' /:.��.d-��. n i
� i ... . - � � • ^� - ��. 0 ! ! <t .��' x� � '" - .i '�t,• . '� -� '_ : � � , .+,
�'L 't - 7 / it � /1 t �' p�.[ 4 �•[ L! L� I' h :� .i . i r �{ /. i �.... . ., ,� a': , , ', �.
,,
�1�{, rtif r �' 1�t �..��r r/t� � . *' l !'.^ F � 7�r `�a • : • « •� , t� .
� �✓_•',�' :4.'.^y,
�i � _ . • . . • . .. ! . �. � . .
r .
� �. .,1. �� `� � �' ► { c :-. r � l �( �';►p O n w ;ti,� � r-,
' ' � !
,`,.� f r �'L � t- ; '� •.k •` ' 1: .:e !. J'f ! � '�/'..:• ,, .�.• i:f � � /� . n ;•• '
.. ,', . . '• '. ' _ /�'C--�- ' '( � i� � r. .�� �. ::t, arli �t,,.-• -s ._ r.
ti " ,�.� r • /��1.��/ .'� ..% �~ 'ai '1" ' ,• •. ; • `', �1• �� � •r �� ' 't �r�L r
, , , , � � . . . . � • r
�' `'� �; tt - •• /'� �: . ��i." � . - .. .,,, i
kS1�` 'i
y �.e
riOl)lil)1/Dd
'ARER'S NAME end i.D.NUMBER 3�y� � DATE � REVIE E DATE
�'• _ �=:�_ . .',�_- "° " ='� ,�/ /GD
Use pnvfous editlons until d�pl�t�d.
r-�'ai osP a es�a�