HomeMy WebLinkAboutC22300 Cook St. Drainage & Intersection Imprvmnt 505-03CITY OF PALM DESERT
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
STAFF REPORT
�.Z
REQUEST: Adopt the Mitigated Negative Declaration and Execute the Notice
of Determination for the Cook Street Drainage and Intersection
Improvement Project (505-03)
SUBMITTED BY: Mark Greenwood, P.E., Director of Public Works
DATE: June 12, 2008
CONTENTS: Vicinity Map (Exhibit 2)
Cook Street/Country Club Intersection (Exhibit 3A)
Cook Street/Hovely Lane Intersection (Exhibit 3B)
Notice of Determination
Mitigated Negative Declaration
Recommendation:
By Minute Motion, adopt the Mitigated Negative Declaration (MND) and
authorize the Director of Public Works to execute and file the Notice of
Determination (NOD) with the County Clerk and the Governor's Office of
Planning and Research for the Cook Street Drainage and Intersection and
Improvement Project (505-03).
Discussion:
On December 13, 2007, City Council approved an amendment to the contract with
Harris & Associates to prepare and process the environmental documentation for
drainage and intersection improvements at the Cook Street/Country Club Drive
intersection and the Cook Street/Hovley Lane East intersection as identified on attached
Exhibit 2, Local Vicinity Map. In summary, this project will include the construction of
drainage improvements that will eliminate the cross gutters and drainage issues at these
two intersections. The project will also include the reconfiguration and construction of
vehicle travel and turn lanes, raised medians, sidewalks, traffic signals and interconnect
at these two intersections as depicted on attached Exhibits 3A and 3B.
The Cook Street Drainage and Intersection Improvement Project will require the
acquisition of six sliver properties. The table below lists the parcels that are affected
and the approximate square footage of the acquisitions.
Adopt MND and Approval to File NOD for Cook Street Intersection Project
Page 2 of 2
June 12, 2008
PROPOSED RIGHT-OF-WAY ACQUISITION
ON PRIVATELY OWNED PARCELS
Location
Northwest corner of Cook Street and Country Club Drive
Southwest corner of Cook Street and Country Club Drive
Northwest corner of Cook Street and Hovley Lane
South side of Hovley Lane East, west of Cook Street
Southeast corner of Cook Street and Hovley Lane East
North of Hovley Lane East, east side of Cook Street
Parcel
Number(s)
620-370-011
620-370-012
624-310-003
624-040-034
624-290-001
632-060-033
632-410-035
Total
Approximate Area
of Take (sf)
590
3,430
6,990
3,495
495
1,930
146
17,076
The total project cost is estimated at $6.1 million, including environmental, design, right-
of-way acquisition, and construction. CVAG is committed to funding 50% of the project
costs. Due to the time required for the acquisition of the above -listed properties,
construction most likely would not begin until summer of 2010. The project will be
staged in order for construction to be completed by the fall.
BonTerra Consulting, a sub consultant to Harris & Associates, conducted an Initial
Study (IS) for the Cook Street Intersection Project pursuant to the California
Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). The IS and Notice of Availability(NOA)/Notice of
Intent (NOI) to adopt a Mitigated Negative Declaration (MND) was distributed to various
public agencies and organizations on March 19, 2008 to initiate a 30-day review period.
The City received two letters during the review period from Sunline Transit Agency and
the Riverside County Flood Control and Water Conservation District with minimal or no
comments, respectively.
Staff requests City Council adopt the MND and authorize the Director of Public Work t1.)
execute and file the NOD with the County Clerk and the Governor's Office of Planr inj
and Research for the Cook Street Drainage and Intersection and Improvement Project.
Fiscal Impact: None
Prepare By:
John Garcia,15.E.
Engineering Manager
Appr
Homer Croy
ACM for Deve
Carlos L. Ort • a
City Manager
ent Services
Depart niy/ nd:
Mark Greenvyood, P.E.
Director of Public Works
Paul Gibson
Finance Director
CD
Local Vicinity
Cook Street Drainage and Intersection Improvements
Exhibit 2
CM R:\Projects\Harris\J004\Graphics\Imprvmnts_0208\Ex2_LV_021508.pdf
Cook Street Improvements
at Hovely Lane
Cook Street Improvements
at Country Club Drive
Hovely
Country Club
CookCookPortolaWhitewater River
Whitewater River
§¨¦10
44thCookPortolaCountry Club
Frank Sinatra
El DoradoVarner
D:\Projects\Harris\J004\improvements_021408\Ex_LV_021508.mxd2,000 0 2,0001,000
Feet²
Improvements at Cook Street and Country Club Drive
Cook Street Drainage and Intersection Improvements
Exhibit 3A
CM R:\Projects\Harris\J004\Graphics\Imprvmnts_0208\Ex3a_imprvmnts_Country_Club_022608.pdfSidewalk Improvement Continues 840' fromCountry Club Dr IntersectionCook StCountry Club Dr
Lost River DrDe
s
e
r
t
F
a
ll
s
Dr
Cook StPipe Continues 1200' from
Cook St Intersection
D:\Projects\Harris\J004\improvements_021408\imprvmnts_Country_Club_021508.mxd150 0 15075
Feet²
Improvement Areas
Drainage Related Improvements
Roadway Related Improvements
Sidewalk Related Improvements
Source: Aerials Express, 2006
Improvements at Cook Street and Hovely Lane
Cook Street Drainage and Intersection Improvements
Exhibit 3B
CM R:\Projects\Harris\J004\Graphics\Imprvmnts_0208\Ex3b_imprvmnts_Hovely_021508.pdfCook StHovley Ln
BoardwalkBougainvillea Cir
Cook StHovley Ln
D:\Projects\Harris\J004\improvements_021408\imprvmnts_Hovley_021508.mxd150 0 15075
Feet²
Improvement Areas
Drainage Related Improvements
Roadway Related Improvements
Sidewalk Related Improvements
Source: Aerials Express, 2006
NOTICE OF DETERMINATION
To:
Office of Planning and Research
1400 Tenth Street, Room 121
Sacramento, CA 95814
From: City of Palm Desert
73-510 Fred Waring Drive
Palm Desert, CA 92260
(Lead Agency and Applicant)
Riverside County Clerk -Recorder
2720 Gateway Drive
P.O. Box 751
Riverside, CA 92502-0751
Subject: Filing of Notice of Determination in compliance with Section 21108 or 21152 of the Public Resources Code.
COOK STREET DRAINAGE AND INTERSECTION IMPROVEMENTS PROJECT
Project Title
SCH#: City of Palm Desert/John Garcia (760) 346-0611
STATE CLEARINGHOUSE NUMBER CONTACT PERSON AREA CODEJTELEPHONE/EXTENSION
(If submitted to Clearinghouse)
Project Location: The project site consists of the intersections of Cook Street at Country Club Drive
and Cook Street at Hovley Lane in the City of Palm Desert, Riverside County.
Latitude: 33.758036, Longitude: -116.356339 at Country Club Drive/Cook Street and Latitude:
33.747109, Longitude: -116.356262 at Hovely/Cook Street.
Project Description:
The Cook Street Drainage and Intersection Improvements Project would allow for the construction of
drainage improvements; reconfiguration of vehicle travel and turn lanes, raised medians, and sidewalks at
the intersection of Cook Street at Country Club Drive and the intersection of Cook Street at Hovley Lane;
and installation of signal interconnect (in -road signal traffic sensors) between 42nd Avenue and Frank
Sinatra Drive.
This is to advise that the
project on June 12, 2008
Date
above described project:
City of Palm Desert has approved the above described
0 Lead Agency 0 Responsible Agency
and has made the following determinations regarding the
1. The project (❑ will / ❑O will not) have a significant effect on the environment.
2. ❑ An Environmental Impact Report was prepared for this project pursuant to the provisions of CEQA.
O A Negative Declaration was prepared for this project pursuant to the provisions of CEQA.
3. Mitigation measures (I I were / ❑ were not) made a condition of approval of the project.
4. A statement of Overriding Considerations (❑ was / was not) adopted for this project.
5. Findings (LI were / O were not) made pursuant to the provisions of CEQA.
This is to certify that the Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration and record of project approval is
available to the General Public at:
City of Palm Desert City Hall, 73-510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert, California 92260
D to receive{] for filing and posting at OPR:
4
SIGNA (PUBLIC AGENCY)
Bo Chen
6/13/08 City Engineer
DATE TITLE
NOTICE OF DETERMINATION
To: Office of Planning and Research From: City of Palm Desert
1400 Tenth Street, Room 121 73-510 Fred Waring Drive
Sacramento, CA 95814 Palm Desert, CA 92260
(Lead Agency and Applicant)
Riverside County Clerk-Recorder
2720 Gateway Drive
P.O. Box 751
Riverside, CA 92502-0751
Subject: Filing of Notice of Determination in compliance with Section 21108 or 21152 of the Public Resources Code.
COOK STREET DRAINAGE AND INTERSECTION IMPROVEMENTS PROJECT
Project Title
SCH#: City of Palm Desert/John Garcia (760) 346-0611
STATE CLEARINGHOUSE NUMBER CONTACT PERSON AREA CODE/TELEPHONE/EXTENSION
(If submitted to Clearinghouse)
Project Location: The project site consists of the intersections of Cook Street at Country Club Drive
and Cook Street at Hovley Lane in the City of Palm Desert, Riverside County.
Latitude: 33.758036, Longitude: -116.356339 at Country Club Drive/Cook Street and Latitude:
33.747109, Longitude: -116.356262 at Hovely/Cook Street.
Project Description:
The Cook Street Drainage and Intersection Improvements Project would allow for the construction of
drainage improvements; reconfiguration of vehicle travel and turn lanes, raised medians, and sidewalks at
the intersection of Cook Street at Country Club Drive and the intersection of Cook Street at Hovley Lane;
and installation of signal interconnect (in-road signal traffic sensors) between 42nd Avenue and Frank
Sinatra Drive.
This is to advise that the City of Palm Desert has approved the above described
4 Lead Agency Responsible Agency
project on June 12, 2008 and has made the following determinations regarding the
Date
above described project:
1. The project ( will / 4 will not) have a significant effect on the environment.
2. An Environmental Impact Report was prepared for this project pursuant to the provisions of CEQA.
4 A Negative Declaration was prepared for this project pursuant to the provisions of CEQA.
3. Mitigation measures (4 were / were not) made a condition of approval of the project.
4. A statement of Overriding Considerations ( was / 4 was not) adopted for this project.
5. Findings ( were / 4 were not) made pursuant to the provisions of CEQA.
This is to certify that the Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration and record of project approval is
available to the General Public at:
City of Palm Desert City Hall, 73-510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert, California 92260
Date received for filing and posting at OPR:
SIGNATURE (PUBLIC AGENCY) DATE TITLE
�`�
��1 ��r �. i a � � s _, r,.: � � �
��������� ����. �' ���
���������
F�� T`HE ���I� �TI��T DR�I��.��
,�1L� I �TE����`���� -
I�Vt.PRC����hE�T� I�R�J��T
P�LAh �DE��R�', ��,L�FC�RNIA
Prepared for LCturi�Aylaipn
City of Fafm bese�
Palm Deserf C'suic C�r?ter
73-51� �red �'aring �rive
Palr� �es�rt, Ca[ifor�iq 9?250
Prepcared by �am 5t�ewart, Projec#I�a��tagerJEnvironmentql Servaces
BorTerra Cons�ltir��
151 Kal�us prive,$ui#e E-20Q
�osta Mesa,Cakifornia 92625
T: [7 i 4) 444-9199 F: (714] 444-959'9
wwvd.BonTerraConsulfiir�g.corn
fvlc�y 22,2d08
� �"
.. _
� � � suErir�r �
� NiEMORANDUM
May 21, 2008
To: City of Palm Desert From: Sam Stewart
Subject: Cook Street Drainage and Intersection Improvements — Responses to Comments
received on the Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration
The City of Palm Desert conducted an Initial Study (IS) for the Cook Street Drainage and
Intersection Improvements Project pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act(CEQA),
as amended (Public Resources Code, §21000 et seq.), and in accordance with the State CEQA
Guidelines (California Code of Regulations, Title 14, §15000 et seq.). In summary, the proposed
project involves the reconfiguration of vehicle travel and turn lanes, raised medians and
sidewalks, and the construction of drainage improvements at the intersection of Cook Street at
Country Club Drive and the intersection of Cook Street at Hovley Lane, and construction of
signal interconnect between 42nd Avenue and Frank Sinatra Drive.
Pursuant to Public Resources Code, Section 21080(c)(2), the City of Palm Desert determined
that a Mitigated Negative Declaration (MND) was the appropriate environmental document for
the project. Public Resources Code, Section 21091(f) and the CEQA Guidelines Section 15074
require that the lead agency must consider the MND and comments received before approving
the project. Specifically, Section 15074(b) states:
Prior to approving a project, the decisionmaking body of the lead agency shall consider
the proposed negative declaration or mitigated negative declaration together with any
comments received during the public review process. The decisionmaking body shall
adopt the proposed negative declaration or mitigated negative declaration only if it finds
on the basis of the whole record before it (including the initial study and any comments
received), that there is no substantial evidence that the project would have a significant
effect on the environment and that the negative declaration or mitigated negative
declaration reflects the lead agency's independentjudgment and analysis.
The Cook Street Drainage and Intersection Improvements IS and Notice of Availability
(NOA)/Notice of Intent (NOI) to Adopt an MND was distributed to various public agencies and
organizations on March 19, 2008. The review period ended on April 18, 2008, and the City of
Palm Desert received com ments for a period of 30 days.
The City of Palm Desert received two comment Ietters during the public review period. The first
letter received on April 1, 2008, from Sunline 90 Transit Agency acknowledges that they
received and reviewed the IS/MND. The letter also stated that SunLine is not requesting
inclusion of transit amenities and bus shelter as part of the proposed development. SunLine
stated that in the event that the proposed development should impact the bus stop and/or
service provided by SunLine, the City/developer would be required to contact SunLine 15 days
prior to beginning of construction. The City received the second letter on April 11, 2008, from
Riverside County Flood Control and Water Conservation District. This letter also acknowledges
that the Riverside County Flood Control and Water Conservation District received and reviewed
the IS/MND and has no comments.
151 Kalmus Drive,Suite E-200 Costa Mesa,CA 92626(714)444-9199(714J 444-9599 Fax
R:1Pmjecls\HamsW004\RTC Memo-052108.doc
Cook Street Drainage and Intersection lmprovements
ENVIRONMENTAL CHECKLIST FORM
SECTION 1 — INTRODUCTION
1. Project Title: Cook Street Drain�ge and Intersection Improvements
2. Lead Agency Name and Address: City of Palm Desert
73-510 Fred Waring Drive
Palm Desert, CA 92260
3. Contact Person and Phone Number: Planning Department
(760) 346-0611 ext. 483
4. Project Location: The project site consists of the intersections of Cook Street at Country
Club Drive and Cook Street at Hovley Lane in the City of Palm Desert, Riverside County.
The project site is located on the U.S. Geological Survey's (USGS) Myoma and La Quinta
7.5-minute California Quadrangles at Township 5 South and Range 6 East. Cook Street
forms the boundary between Sections 4, 9, and 16 to the west; and Sections 3, 10, and 15
to the east, on the above-mentioned quadrangles. The project site is presented in a regional
and local context in Exhibits 1 and 2, respectively. An aerial photograph depicting the project
site and identifying construction areas is provided in Exhibits 3A and 3B.
5. Project Sponsor's Name and Address: City of Palm Desert
73-510 Fred Waring Drive
Palm Desert, CA 92260
6. General Plan Designation: N/A
7. Zoning: N/A
8. Description of Project: The Cook Street Drainage and Intersection Improvements Project
(hereafter referred to as "the proposed projecY') would allow for the reconfiguration of
vehicle travel and turn lanes, raised medians and sidewalks, and the construction of
drainage improvements at the intersection of Cook Street at Country Club Drive and the
intersection of Cook Street at Hovley Lane, and construction of signal interconnect between
42nd Avenue and Frank Sinatra Drive. The conceptual design of the drainage and
intersection improvements is provided in Exhibits 4A and 4B.
Cook Street is a four-lane arterial within the City of Palm Desert. Country Club Drive is
designated as an arterial and Hovely Lane is designated as a thoroughfare in the Palm
Desert General Plan. Cook Street, Country Club Drive, and Hovely Lane are all currently
striped for two lanes in each direction with raised, landscaped medians and sidewalks. Cook
Street also has Class II bike lanes (i.e., striped on-road lane) in both directions of travel.
The improvements on Country Club Drive include installation of an 18-inch storm drain pipe,
a catch basin on the northwestern corner, and two catch basins on the northeastern corner
of the Cook Street intersection. The storm drain pipe would drain from these catch basins to
a proposed catch basin and existing 18-inch storm drain pipe at Desert Willow Drive
approximately 1,200 feet to the west. Storm water flows would be conveyed via the existing
18-inch storm drain pipe to an existing detention basin on the Marriott Golf Course
immediately to the south. The proposed 18-inch storm drain pipe would be installed in the
roadway contiguous to the south of the northern side curb and gutter on Country Club Drive.
R1Pro�eds\Hartis\J004115-030508.doc t DraR lnitial Study
WORKING DR4FT—NOT FOR PUBLIC DISTRIBUTIOtJ
� p u '�
�
�, �
�., 2 x �� �.y � � �+ �
� {.. ��( ,t� � � S � _ `Y
3 .F`t � �r�iy w u L
rwrzq .�`Y I}I � E
r t "�� � c
*4 �`�'' 'S JP ) t=' E
�, J `� t� K .� . � $.a U'
•.� Y.3`�k ".s a
, � 6 YeF„y�; : E
, ; � y°`, . � 3
4 ¢ f �� � �
��� �.Z ° , 3� S
p
� � E
3 n
r
v �
o-
s
/� F d
4v '
k jj
4 :
v: I} °
� �I in
� v;
�5�?� e
w �� �
„t, � .y '� �" � .�'i � "
' I,
, °
� m
�, � � �: , � � � ��
� t� �
� �. f��� � ,�� f
a, � , �
� a � ��
� o C g � ' � '� `�
t . � ' - , �:� � �
�.� •0 1° . t � ,a
� ` '' p`_ o ��5.',� �a'� P
s= r
..>� 5 J �; ' s
� } �� 3
h) 5 F
Y € k�+e �� �� �� � !
a q �.� �� �x� �<: £? �`•% f ,3^ f R
� IIN � t
OyF . m"v '3. '§ ^
T� 2 C � i
s,l y � " f � t a=g s �.
� L 4 �
` �, �`� `c. ��. E � � ' � ,
� � Y v
� s ''? � .. � ' r
€ ] $ F E
'} M1 £; d" (a���z" �"Y `�`'� yi ` .
�;y ,$.`,,, � 4 . 'z.. �.t}" �� `i p . 3 i{}� fv � .
91
+ ��t � . ' 4 :
�� x'ti� `�i f � S f� � �'�'Z.��g�'�.�"'�"#'e =a^^r;;. �.' �'"'r°
� � �f x-.Y ��,y� �., , �4 � '",
�r � <` `v.` �
:, z � : (I'.e � <. � �x 3 e - ..�.
� �
{5�� �
/ �
.d�'V�-n � �� E � `"fih 'vi i �3 N
,„+=��
�� � � 1 � } : � p �
m.
e
�� , li•����g P � + � �' "'�'vs � x � ' O
1
(� ' � L
X�.' �. F 4 t� �
�� 1
S i � s,'_ f U
o �
� l i.� �� � +, ; -,� �
.q 7.. p s ,p. � O
• � � � ''�c+ �
x - c �
`�.� �. a
' � � 0 m
�2''a,,i � ' i ? � ,` �t s �i-i � N
� n is t (�
9 �., .;,, , �, U m
„
�
� �` � � �� �� E - � � p o
�'' � °. �a � �o � �. - F' . tL$
� C N
� A �E � �_,`�� f'"----.: p �
; �; � � ��� � r� 4 � dl Y :�«
�,�'` � It � /, T � �� � U 3
V-
�.��.,.4,�: : h �� .°t .. f.%.s' . . , x . . ....,. ,
pxwBD5lL0 lti*3�BObKO fluawanwdwppp0l�sweryp�oalw�:Q
' j -,�a'n
. i -; � / ���'`�,
E_ � :
� ' � , 3�
+ �
( � � $
� . ( I � � � ' ., �
� t �� �
� - FmnkSina[m „� . , ,. � �
,......,�.._s�'^_^�..._._.�.>....,,e�^':�._.,.e,..,�,�..:... .......W..w,......:..._......,:,r...:...�^^ns ��:,:._ ..,.�_.. �
�. �
.._+` '"_"_,�`
� � � �,��� i . � � �( ��
, . ( _
a_ . � � , ,, , � �_� �
, �,
_�� � � E � �_.�._ � , , �t o�� � � .
, _.,
--_
__ ,
� � � �. � Ar �
, -
- � � � � (��, �_�. � � } ;_
' '�
� � , �
i � � � t � � , � ,_ w�I 1 ���.
, ! � � � � �o� r �� � ` � � � � �..1 �
s r = - �, . % �, a
� � �� _ � �(
_� �,. 1_ �,� �
� f , � t-
; ,,, � � �;� , ':,�
s
� � � r � '�
�
; k � � i � � � ��� ��� � ; � I � /� i �'?�_-_,
� � € Cook Street ImprovemeMs � �� . � ` �'� �i � i
�
i
f at Country Club Drive - � ` � ( �� � � �`
� ., r . � ir t � �
F S� � � �. . � . � �
� 1� , �. r � ( � r 1 �. � ;
r � I � � ; � ��� � r � � � ` � � � 1_,
G :" Coun[ryClub � L Coun[ryClub y� j
,,..:� _v✓.'-�;,r...�.._ a'..w.�,.: � c.».._.:'-.,... ^ _.-'..v.>-.�rs- ...urc.^s�.- s�,,, ..> ..1.�., n.�e�..
a ,�,w.F,_. ....,,.,,, � �..,..�,..�
� i ��
. �. . � , . i �,. - � , s _ .
--
i
� � .. � 'y � k F � � , �
q �r / � ,� � i `.
o� . ` r E . .� .. `�. i`� `
[ t �
a4� i � " �: ! Ft.. . i � � _ .J
F �
�
� I : �_. i � ��`. 4` m�� �". � 7 � .
S � ' I �` 7: o f i
i (
� •�� :� i � . IU�{ Y � �� -'l � r
'��, r , . . m= .
� �. i �, , �� a . f . . i
_ _ ..� ,t, � -� ` �; � � i
� ;� . �^ _ �_.� . _ � � ��.
�� . / ��,� � � _. _ 'l -,
�
�. �,-. � ;� � �" � � r ( � --� � t � ! � '��� �
,
� �
; , ,
i � �, � � I � ,,�`� �' __ � ( ` I
t . � � s _,_ HovelY � � f� ). /� `. i � i I 1 �
'�� , ._. � ,.. . _�_ < . . .. ,
1 � �
z � i
- , i ^.. *,i r I - i
� � �� ''.�' �. . _ ., �_
/ °
�
t � ' ��. ,
r i `
�
�� . � . i � Cook Street Im rovements ' � � � � �`� -�-'
. . P , � ...... , ._ _..
� ,,, � ,� i _ , . � . at Hovely Lane � � �
i
�
r � % s
!. � � i , A , i � ;.� . .
i '
� _ ,
� ;� �� f �t
% � � ; , . : � � �
� �� ` ` ` i � ��� _ i. ` i � ; ;'� � �
. , ,,. , ; � - � oA
s ' < 1 I � � � u� I .
... , . _.__.. : . . . .
.- . . � . . ..._ . .
r � '
„ _f:
� � � yt �
� ,
� :_ :� _ . i � � �`hiFy�, 1� ` ! G.� .
� . �c � ater,?.�;er'= — .
� � . .� � -s i t . � .� �
v { � - � _ '`� +, � � �
i �
� , � � �. � � � ,
a '. �� ',�� � �
�
.
� ' � � zr � � i � �
,
� � � �� ��
r � �
a , E r £� 1 4 . ..
I w 35.. aFlh
. v.� w ,.�, �w,.
�.m_, �w .,..�� .,.�,. ,__ _w �..� ._ _ �, _ �
. .�.,..�:�:--;
s i. ;� � � , �— _ �.
�: _ _ � _ ,
Local Vicinity Exhibit 2
Cook Street Drainage and Intersection Improvements
w�N y� �'
E ZA�a ��0�0 � 2,��� /��r��/ �I
v
s Feet CONSU Li1NG
cm zw�ya�w�m.uaoa�c�Pn¢svm�nm��azae�.z�v osisoe.par
� q.,� � � � �
�
�� � � �z y"d£�`�a.�e oa` �:. ��, � 7�'{ x k•
�.. f '�y�v � . u'�.z�yJ�}'�y Y` � : � J��g� �"' ,3�w
Q�
fl��� �� � � ` �{ � �
�'�f��;�'e"�.. "'o�w,vg,,�A��s�+�ej � � 4" i.��+.'� :�. ve1 .. '�.bi-K
y��
� S
N"i',..,? � ��� ��� rri
�-� � � ♦ mk� � �•d
f
��" ,' � s. �A aF�.-
� i
�� ,F` ✓�.n��3� ����,�,-,�;
. � v
�3
X � �� ��
�� � �����.���- �3�
��`- ywi"y� F
.,w �. � '���, � �y.`4 x
t �
: 4� �,�x���� �� ��3 �`�
�
� ^ � W �s�
� ���- S ..f � � �£
'�ry�„. 3€ � ,Jl 'T ` 4�}v. ¢� .f�.:�
� �b
� $
. � R'e ^'<XL'S�£r4Y .r
� *
i
� `� ��� � �"� " � 2�L
2
� �` � . -v� �d^S ,
S
'�.. ��rmr s� m �yF
���� � � 33��T
l � .1 .i-?'<'"'^„ry
�
o���� �y� � :.. < � �
B � �` m�" � .. � €s 4� �'``�
�[ S� ��� , � � ��;
; 3 � m ,..yIU gy A.� : . �3``� `�� c 'y�`��jp &'�- �2
' � ` � E t I F r 4 � -�v. � . �
Y f ��� � � : }.�* . ���F. .i � � .
} {�.' .a!yG f � `�� s � .c�;� �, � �
� � � �P
� 11 a
. ` r
• �
�� .. e 4 '§�'
�"^� M` G �;.� „L.vf
..� . ,. .. .�..: a, .... . �.0 �. ._
� � .. .;� -,. �,�€'�59�`_ �, :. � ..... � , • �
2
�=
:, �
v. . .. . ' � '.z ., '�' .,. ... r .
.. �,� �t,.�,„ ��a'i' ^.-.m`�'
�<-. .
,' v , ^. �i � .�^ , h
�
.. +' 3 ;' _u `
a ;v ,..... .:. . K s F �
��
�=i
Y
4�� � �
f
� �F?
� F' L G„�., �-.
��t�, � �. , � ,e
� � . ,��
� �
, s�
' . „ � . � ��,�:
r.
fi �
r
� .��.;.�. — -` �.� � .
� 3 �.
� � �
�I g� �? � ��� �:� ��..
? F ti �
�" ^,?``� � � '����'} ��������� � �' ��'`�;
Z �� { £������ ��� kj ����. £_ �� � ��k� ��,.
o �. .. f1-y?.�
� �` � � _� ,�� .
m 4 � � �
✓,
�.. t
o + y v
#
� ��?����..v�s��' .��� '�.�.' .<`�,�� �- - ^� . < ti$ � `
y � �.cF r���# .
g Improvement Areas
� � Drainage Related Improvements ,;, ��`-� �
y � � `
Y
e �� Roadway Related Improvements ���,
_ < �� '.�, `f.
� � Sidewalk Related Improvements �
� p��
� �'n�".w,,;�.�;`s� y . ,� g,°� ., Source:Aerials Express,2006
Improvements at Cook Street and Country Club Drive Exhibit 3A
Cook Street Drainage and Intersection Improvements
N
'"{°�E iso �s o iso .�nT—uP'�a1
� Feet c o N s u t r�H c
cn�aw��«ssuwmavoo<�c�on�=s�m���oxoe�..aa�mavm��coun�cwe ousoe.ua
� ,�� - e� �� � .�. �� » � � �:
`a � t� ' ,.t=%` g � :�` c-'��`�u., `�'x3 "
� `� �.`'�.,."��S $ , �'fi��a.^'�'.-rz. T z"� �',-
� �^
� *- ��'� � ;, � � :'�€���� ��� F
��- ,' za. �� :,`6 #` -
t �
��� ',�s "� '�{ �"ti Y 1
��� Y�� � � ��� �F %
�:.,� ,'3'e t- � # .�i.� k" ' m��wu.�
� � �
��;.' � ���e�✓� „ e e�`�
'�"�,- � �- , �.
t°.l � '�;� p..���„d<,. 3"..�r.YG � �, #� ✓ �b..
€ t�.;' e. Y' ;.T�. rv�-� .� .'«.'�'�` p a 3�` �:
�. "�" t � '�` g;�:� �� � ,rs
�'
`" ' � A" } "2�` � ' .F
��n,. �:��" `�'.-�� ,�' ��`��`� ���x �{�
t��' ��� �
� t��� .. v . -=;
.�s �' � ; � � . y �.
c „ � s ." �� �$ r�j �,"�� �rN �_`�� � < � �, `"a`Y�'
.. Y �� J�g�'��'� ` .
��
6 ce� S�
"r'�"'a � 1 } €'/F' t� r=k�,G= � `?`�
�,C. Y� �, `%NY v" �l',d.�?:4'' �[� s •
� K�°��'1 . t ✓�Y
A f
•� .:�.� � s� �����,.� �`� �.. �
F �
i . ��.. �.� �. . `�` �� �Yt �y
� '. �� ' �3� � �..�� "Y.. .
" � ^: "'g'a"'s�- �r.:+z+�'`..�' .s � `�' � �;s
l F �
� ��,, "� �`� �.�
� �� � �
�
g � d � n^ � .a,....� ..,�.� �� � i �C.
..%- .:.,. , � ,� � ,
' :F x . N `� �sa
...� .�. � � � � �
�
� .
r f.� p
.Y �v la��+r, �°u` �
�
�
� ���� � �
, a x� '9 � �` .,.
� `` �5��3 '<` , ,...
, .. -�, . � vN
,� �, ..n�..:.�. „_. .,,� . . � . . . .<.. x m-„>z ° '-. r . .
' .;r- � ..�.,..�.�
� �. �, �.��.�. . � . ....
:. ., ,.. ,.. .._, � . .... ... __�,.� ,. � . . . �.. „
. v . - " . _ . � .,�:
�
.�. , ... . . .- r a ,. i;..,t';
�' �` ,�, ' a� �e
s� � � �. r � �� a { y��n 3 �a y € '+n� u
9 . �-,.E � � G �� g � �-�"�`�'.d��jxa-�rx� .
� E - � y q � k ..
�:` z � �
'j '�
�� �
5. " ....�... ,....,... � . . '§�,�-
� �
��� . ;� � ; , � �
c af r
� � 1 . ��} .m' : Y�Y,#�.#k-�s� � �
� � c.
� 4 5
a ' ^ �
h �� � �
� r
_ � , :."�� . �-
a, ,
� �s.. .
�
� _� �� ��� � _. � ; r � � �`�"r�
r
z € � ., `�. „ � �� � � � � � �, , �
�
�.M
e' b � ,� 'F� �`&r�'
� �
` , � � $"A'=f �
i �� � � �� "'k F" �' � g � �.���-�;
� ImprovementAreas �. �'� ,� � " �-;.: �?...�-��
� � Drainage Related Improvements �
E , "��
� :�..�. _` ,, . � : � - :
�.
� � Roadway Related Improvements � 3 „ �
� .,� ., } .� s .;r
� � Sidewalk Related Improvements �; �. „ �,,.�
B - .. , Y. � , o- �; ' �. ..;
�x o . , � ��% Source:Aerials�press,2006
Improvements at Cook Street and Hovely Lane Exhibit 3B
Cook Street Drainage and Intersection Improvements
N
w�` 150 75 0 150 �V��T�
s Feet c o H s u i r� ry c
CMR\PmjoclSWomiVOWlG�apM1l¢1lmqvmn�s_0300�F 3b impvmnla_Hovoly 031508ptl1
�:�
� $_� � �
����� S � �
w °
��� :�;�� � . u�'
B � H
t5 f
� �� ��, o �
�� � ,
.� � :rt�,c�'��`;
� i `� �
SE �'�— t i —m �
��, p�"$t : �` ...
Y �y _y J
V -r� #Y '1 I 5'� � �
( w, � �
F- I
Jm'�� I '�i �� 6
I
� 1 �
�-- !R� � � .,
� ,I
O v 11R. r , _, � wrssi ru xc ia s ns 3xn xssm
I �. �.�.
b�x � RiV r li� I � m � �
�����{ � � � � �w �
�
s ; ;�; °� ,°�� ,
ts � s;�! � �"� � ' �� �
, �
a�w�� � ( �oj i� i� �' � ' I i
e�s I � '��� �£ . � �' � --i � � .�
� I t E� � {Ci . 4" � �-.,, � ��,
� , � —�=�� I i>' p � � ! .
I �... � F � I � li
1
1 -� � �f1
� Oc-m-1j I�' � I�W� i ( �� � I I
� i��:. � ��• � � �;
� ' � , !�, I
: I ' 'I�� 1 �..�d /�,.r .�L. 'i
} Y I��� ( � y�- .
0m�'�I ; �j � I �6
� =�.7 '��� � I'. � ��$ ` �� E � ...����
� i � � I
���,,�5 I � i � I e i` � !�� i., K.Tf �..
Fe "� ' i s r ,
a�yl � �,� � � , `i � �� � ��.
@8ps i � ' �� � �
5���"8 i I � i i ... i I � �A i ...
� � i h�� � � . �: �� � ' � �
It�, � r
i I
(,
O,�r* I i 1jf '��, I `� I I f 0. ' .
� �, I �, i
, � � , .� ,� � � � a �.:4�; >
.,, � ` ..i o
I ' , �� ��� � � , �
I I � �i i � �
� � > �
i �,, � � ,
�j� ; � x � � �
� „ � l P�p� 1��. I �
G� U ! I
�� (���� , � a�r ' ��� � �
m„T�vi , u � �, 3s 3. H�.m o
, �
� °�� ' � rt���° ; � �
i b
� � et� � � �au�se S 2
w _L � P 4 �kd N ¢
; _ � v E
I a� • o
o � :: �, I wrt W � N a
E � 9Yt343-F r� /.•'Y3A� � 0 O h
u� � � a�� y� � ° V �
� � i sl,i t, _ E � � g :
d o
¢ �..v Ip� j Y m � ,,�
� �.� .V: I, � i,''�, ( '� w � "�
- £ o °°
o _ > m e
o � �
h
o �
E �
U
�veaima�� ,�macv�.3;..w�.,o�wwn�uuv.:Nai.u.a
m ��L
� � � �j s
`n
9 �$'s
� x u�
x'
w
y•I � �
�
�— . F
�
�E� ��� � i'� rezi vss oc�3xs�s'3xn x�ivw �
f 4t�i {�' I 1 � � d�I �
i i i �
❑ ....�� � �I� �� rt i i � ''I I �n � �
.r ' � � I 6 � �,_��
� '�1 � '� ��� I „ s
� I � � � i�.'� �ii � i�
�'---i j�,J�,� �� , �i L� �
�i i Q i�'� .�..ar� �y � ^ S:�£
❑ � � i � i
o� i T;I i �,� I� �W ���� .
i
i �r
� ;.� ` II '`"��b.O+ i �, i ,
i
m .`i�� I fl I I 114�M..—.u�j � � I�.�
pi` � M _�
i--�� �� J F ��y f@!IyI .
yf yy� y�w 11i ,� >T
OW ��y <w—L� �ry
uW 0— ' um
Op. �I �� � i��_��k�� � o�
�� r r� �w_� �W
' ��� i ��� ` 1 „�",I .�::
�� i
r I x �
� �` i i�� � � � � � �-.
� O
I I � �� � 9
��. �
�' ���I i F- ji IY".",, � � �n. .
�� �� � �� ' (� , i � �'_.
�
p� I II I �i m � I I �� �
�� 1 �I�� - �� ��� �
i � 7� �'1
� d �� � ��w, ; �� ho � ,�
, I'o,,i-- ��..,,i' ��, �
o i � III=� i'� ""�j l �°I � I�
g ����!I II ,'�`� v�: � ��=� i i i'� I
� ., �
�si�ms inaie y,oer 33s 3xn x�ivry
� �
G
J
3Ntll Al3�OH 8 T
Q a �y$a�i�� J I U I ��9 � �F �� �e p m
a
g I
Is�l!���� ij g i�.� 5� �a = �
ILI; i � n 'pt 1 � n� `_ � E
-�;r- .�i�. ,.-. � - 32 b
.. I � �.,�.'.�""_r }--� _ _ c
+e.�'
�. �V�. �d �„ t �- '_ 4 I— - v �
= — � i i � � " ._
m i�a�.s �`��-_ L�K _ f nQoo o �
o a=•�s- �� e lj�' .e v , t,.j�. _ O c
E �'��' f ���. r z ^," � f, —' II � i - -, u � �
/ � i���' a �/ II I§ �o
� � aas��„��4��e u 3ii 'ah:� �' I' N a 6
� �'-n ��"�yi' ��I� n �IIp�n. §;ig � @ �
i
a� m
I� I ..,y�:� .s� � ,,.il�!� m o
� �^ 'Q` � ^3NY'1 Al3�OH ; d E
(J tU
C O � S
� 0 y �
� U
:areizo nwy avJ riR^['w^�a�vca"n�m��mac,�x.a
�
Cook Street Drainage and Intersection Improvements
At the intersection of Cook Street and Country Club Drive, Cook Street is proposed to be
widened by approximately 12 feet at its widest point primarily on the southwestern and
northwestern legs of the intersection. The intersection improvements include the widening of
Cook Street from approximately 460 feet north of the intersection to 900 feet south of the
intersection. The raised median on Cook Street would be reconfigured to allow for two
10-foot-wide dedicated left-turn lanes onto Country Club Drive in both directions of travel. A
13-foot-wide dedicated right-turn lane on the northwestern leg of the intersection would be
provided. The sidewalk on the western side of Cook Street would be widened from 10 to 12
feet from the intersection with Country Club Drive to approximately 840 feet to the south.
Implementation of the proposed project requires the acquisition of property on the northern
and southern sides of the intersection of Cook Street at Country Club Drive. A list of parcels
that would be impacted and the approximate square footage of the acquisition on each
parcel is provided in Table 1. Exhibits detailing the areas of acquisition are provided in
Appendix A.
TABLE 1
PROPOSED RIGHT-OF-WAY ACQUISITION
ON PRIVATELY OWNED PARCELS _
Parcel Approximate Area
Locafion Number(s) ofTake,(s�
Northwest corner of Cook Street and Country Club Drive 620-370-011 590
620-370-012 3,430
Southwest corner of Cook Street and Country Club Drive 624310-003 6,990
Northwest corner of Cook Street and Hovley Lane 624-040-034 3,495
South side of Hovley Lane west of Cook Street 624-290-001 495
Southeast corner of Cook Street and Hovley Lane 632-060-033 1,930
North of Hovley Lane, east side of Cook Street 632-410-035 146
� Total 17,076
Source: Harris&Associates
At the intersection of Cook Street and Hovley Lane, Cook Street would be widened by
approximately 12 feet at its widest point on the northwestern and southeastern legs of the
intersection and would extend past the intersection for approximately 335 feet to the north
and 230 feet to the south. The southeastern leg of the intersection would be widened to
allow for a 14-foot-wide right-turn lane, and a 4-foot-high retaining wall would be constructed
at this corner to support the existing above-grade landscaping associated with the
commercial land uses to the southeast. On Cook Street the intersection's existing raised
median would be reconfigured to allow for two 10-foot-wide dedicated left-turn lanes in both
directions of travel, and a 13-foot-wide dedicated right-turn lane would be provided on the
northwestern corner of the intersection. The sidewalk on the western side of Cook Street
would be widened from 10-to 12-feet. Proposed improvements would require the acquisition
of property on the northwestern and southwestern sides of the intersection of Cook Street at
Hovley Lane (Table 1). The proposed project also requires the installation of three 18-inch
storm drain pipes that would collect storm water from proposed catch basins located on the
northwestern and northeastern corners of the intersection and convey flows to a 36-inch
storm drain pipe that would be installed in the center of Cook Street from the northern side
of the intersection to approximately 280 feet south where it would connect with an existing
storm drain pipe that would convey flows to the Whitewater River Channel.
R1Pro�ects\HartisW004115-030508.tlac 2 braft Initial Study
WORKING DRAFT—NOT FOR PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
Cook Street Drainage and Intersection Improvements
On Hovley Lane, improvements include the widening of the southern side of the roadway by
approximately 6 feet and widening of the northern side by approximately 6 feet from the
intersection to approximately 500 feet to the west, and reconfiguration of the raised median
from the intersection to approximately 450 feet west and 300 feet east of the intersection to
allow for two 11-foot-wide left-turn lanes in both directions of travel.
Additional project features include the installation of new traffic signals, signal trigger
interconnect (in-road signal traffic sensors) from 42nd Avenue to Frank Sinatra Drive, and
roadway pavement rehabilitation and/or replacement. The storm water drainage
improvements would allow for the existing cross gutters (dips) at these intersections to be
eliminated. Dip removal would reduce the potential for vehicle "bottoming", thereby
improving traffic movement through the intersections, and enhancing tra�c safety. Raised
medians of adequate width would be vegetated with drought-tolerant landscaping that is
consistent with existing landscaped vegetation on Cook Street. To the extent feasible, the
proposed lane reconfiguration would occur within the existing curb-to-curb roadway.
Project construction is expected to begin approximately in May 2008 and completed by
November 2008. To _prevent traffic delays during project construction, improvements at
Country Club Drive would be completed in 5 stages and improvements at Hovley Lane
would be completed in 6 stages.
9. Surrounding Land Uses and Setting: As previously noted, Cook Street is a four-lane arterial
in the city. Country Club Drive is designated as an arterial and Hovely Lane is designated as
a thoroughfare in the Palm Desert General Plan. Cook Street is striped for two lanes in each
direction with Class ii bike lanes (i.e., striped on-road lane) and raised, landscaped medians
and sidewalks.
Surrounding land uses include single-family residential, general commercial, light industrial,
and professional office. At the intersection of Cook Street at Country Club Drive, there is
single-family residential development to the northeast, commercial and professional office
uses (including retail strip commercial and private business offices) to the southeast and
northwest, and the Marriott Desert Springs Golf Course) to the southwest. Light industrial
and private business offices are concentrated on both sides of Cook Street at the
intersection with Hovley Lane.
10. Other public agencies whose approval is required (e.g., permits, financing approval, or
participation agreement): None
R9ProjeclslHarns\J004115-030508.doc 3 D�afr lnitial Study
WORKING DRAFT—NOT FOR PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
Cook Street Drainage and Intersection Improvements
SECTION 2—ENVIRONMENTAL FACTORS POTENTIALLY AFFECTED
The environmental factors checked below would be potentially affected by this project, involving
at least one impact that is a "Potentially Significant ImpacY' as indicated by the checklist on the
following pages. "
� Aesthetics � Agricultural Resources � Air Quality
Biological Resources Cultural Resources � Geology/Soils
� Hazards& Hazardous � Hydrology/Water Quality � Land Use/Planning
Materials
� Mineral Resources � Noise � Population/Housing
� Public Services � Recreation � Transportation/Traffic
� Utilities/Service Systems � Mandatory Findings of Significance
SECTION 3—DETERMINATION_(To be completed by the Lead Agency.)
On the basis of this initial evaluation:
� i find that the proposed project COULD NOT have a significant effect on the
environment, and a NEGATIVE DECLARATION will be prepared.
I find that although the proposed project could have a significant effect on the
environment, there will not be a significant effect in this case because revisions in the
project have been made by or agreed to be the project proponent. A MITIGATED
NEGATIVE DECLARATION will be prepared.
� I find that the proposed project MAY have a significant effect on the environment, and an
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT is required.
� I find that the proposed project MAY have a "potentially significant impacY' or"potentially
signi6cant unless mitigated" impact on the environment, but at least one effect 1) has
been adequately analyzed in an earlier document pursuant to applicable legal standards,
and 2) has been addressed by mitigation measures based on the earlier analysis as
described on attached sheets. An ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT is required, but
it must analyze only the effects that remain to be addressed.
� i find that although the proposed project could have a significant effect on the
environment, because all potentially significant effects (a) have been analyzed
adequately in an earlier EIR or NEGATIVE DECLARATION pursuant to the applicable
standards, and (b) have been avoided or mitigated pursuant to that earlier EIR or
NEGATIVE DECLARATION, including revisions or mitigation measures that are
imposed upon the proposed project, nothing further is required.
Date Signature
For
R9Pmfects\Hams1J004V5-030508.tloc 4 Draft Initial Study
WORKING DR4FT—NOT FOR PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
Cook Street Drainage and lntersection Improvements
SECTION 4— ENVIRONMENTAL CHECKLIST FORM
This section includes the completed environmental checklist form. The checklist form is used to
assist in evaluating the potential environmental impacts of the proposed project. The checklist
form identifies potential project 'effects as follows: (1) Potentially Significant Impact;
(2) Potentially Significant Unless Mitigation lncorporated; (3) Less Than Significant Impact; and
(4) No Impact. The findings of impact identified in the checklist form are analyzed in detail in
Section 5— Environmental Evaluation. The analysis should meet the following requirements.
1) A brief explanation is required for all answers except "No ImpacY' answers that are adequately
supported by the information sources a lead agency cites in the parentheses following each
question. A "No ImpacY' answer is adequately supported if the referenced information sources
show that the impact simply does not apply to projects like the one involved (e.g., the project falls
outside a fault rupture zone). A "No ImpacP' answer should be explained where it is based on
project-specific factors as well as general standards (e.g., the project will not expose sensitive
receptors to pollutants, based on a project-specific screening analysis).
2) All answers must take account of the whole action involved, including off-site as well as on-site,
cumulative as well_as project-level, indirect as well as direct, and construction as well as
operational impacts.
3) Once the lead agency has determi�ed that a particular physical impact may occur, then the
checklist answers must indicate whether the impact is potentially significant, less than significant
with mitigation, or less than significant. "Pote�tially Significant ImpacY' is appropriate if there is
substantial evidence that an effect may be significant. If there are one or more "Potentially
Signifcant ImpacY'entries when the determination is made, an EIR is required.
4) "Negative Declaration: Less Than Significant With Mitigation Incorporated" applies where the
incorporation of mitigation measures has reduced an effect from "Potentially Significant ImpacY'to
a "Less than Significant Impact" The lead agency must describe the mitigatio� measures, and
briefly explain how they reduce the effect to a less than significant level (mitigation measures ,
from Section XVII, "Earlier Analysis," may be cross-referenced).
5) Earlier analyses may be used where, pursuant to the tiering, program EIR, or other CEQA
process, an effect has been adequately analyzed in an earlier EIR or negative declaration.
Section 15063(c)(3)(D). In this case, a brief discussion should identify the following:
a) Earlier Analysis Used. Identify and state where they are available for review.
. b) Impacts Adequately Addressed. Identify which effects from the above checklist were within
the scope of and adequately analyzed in an earlier document pursuant to applicable legal
standards, and state whether such effects were addressed by mitigation measures based on
the earlier analysis.
c) Mitigation Measures. For effects that are "Less than Significant with Mitigation Measures
Incorporated," describe the mitigation measures which were incorporated or refined from the
earlier document and the extent to which they address site-specific conditions for the project.
6) Lead agencies are encouraged to incorporate into the checklist references to information sources
for potential impacts (e.g., general plans, zoning ordinances). Reference to a previously prepared
or outside document should, where appropriate, include a reference to the page or pages where
the statement is substantiated.
7) Supporting Information Sources: A source list should be attached, and other sources used or
individuals contacted should be cited in the discussion.
R:Nmlec�s\Hams\J004\IS-030500.tloc 5 Draft Initial Study
WORKING DRAFT—NOT FOR PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
Cook Street Drainage and Intersection Improvements
8) This is oNy a suggested form, and lead agencies are free to use different formats; however, lead
agencies should normally address the questions from this checklist that are relevant to a projecPs
environmental effects in whatever format is selected.
9) The explanation of each issue should identify:
a) the significance criteria or threshold, if any, used to evaluate each question; and
b) the mitigation measure identified, if any, to reduce the impact to less than significance.
Potentiaily
Significan!
ENVIRONMENTALISSUES Potentially Unless LessThan
� Sfgnificant Mitigation Significant No
(See attachments for info�7tation sources) '�, Impact Incorporated Impact Impact��
L AESTHETICS. Would the projecf:
a) Have a substantial adverse effect on a scenic ❑ ❑ ❑ �
vista?
b) Substantially damage scenic resources, ❑ ❑ ❑ �
including, but not limited to, trees, rock
outcroppings, and historic buildings within a
state scenic highway?
c) Substantially degrade the existing visual ❑ ❑ ❑ �
character or quality of the site and its
surroundings?
d) Create a new source of substantial light or ❑ ❑ ❑ �
glare which would adversely affect day or
nighttime views in the area?
IL!AGRICULTURALRESOURCES. Would the project:
a) Convert Prime Farmland, Unique Farmland, or ❑ ❑ ❑ �1
Farmland of Statewide Importance (Farmland),
as shown on the maps prepared pursuant to
the Farmland Mapping and Monitoring
Program of the California Resources Agency,
to non-agricultural use?
b) Conflict with existing zoning for agricultural ❑ ❑ ❑ �
use, or a Williamson Act contract?
c) Involve other changes in the existing ❑ ❑ ❑ �
environment which, due to their location or
nature, could result in conversion of farmland,
to non-agricultural use?
III.AIR QUALIT'Y. Would the project: -
a) Conflict with or obstruct implementation of the ❑ ❑ ❑ d
applicable air quality plan?
b) Violate any air quality standard or contribute to ❑ ❑ ❑ �
an existing or projected air quality violation?
ft:\ProJacLs\HartisW004\IS-030508.Coc 6 Draff Initial Sfudy
WORKING DRAFf-NOT FOR PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
Cook StreetOrainage and Intersecfion Improvements
Potentialiy
Significant
ENVIRONMENTALISSUES PoteMially Unless �essThan I
� Significant Mitigation Significank No
.(See attachments for information sources} .. Impact Incorporated .Impact Impact��
c) Result in a cumulatively considerable net ❑ ❑ � ❑
increase of any criteria pollutant for which the
project region is non-attainment under an
applicable federal or state ambient air quality
standard (including releasing emissions which
exceed quantitative thresholds for ozone
precursors)?
d) Expose sensitive receptors to pollutant? ❑ ❑ � ❑
e) Create objectionable odors affecting a o o � ❑
substantial number of people?
IV. BIOLOGICAL RESOURCES. Would the project:
a) Have a substantial adverse effect, either ❑ d ❑ ❑
directly or through habitat modifications, on any
species identified as a candidate, sensitive, or
special status species in local or regional
plans, policies, or regulations, or by the
California Department of Fish and Game or
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service?
b) Have a substantial adverse effect on any ❑ ❑ ❑ �
riparian habitat or other sensitive natural
community identified in local or regional plans,
policies, regulations, or by the California
Department of Fish and Game or US Fish and
Wildlife Service?
c) Have a substantial adverse effect on federally o ❑ ❑ �
protected wetlands as defined by Section 404
of the Clean Water Act (including, but not
limited to, marsh, vernal pool, coastal, etc.)
Through direct removal, filling, hydrological
interruption, or other means?
d) Interfere substantially with the movement of ❑ ❑ ❑ �
any native resident or migratory fish or wildlife
species or with established native resident or
migratory wildlife corridors, or impede the use
of native wildlife nursery sites?
e) Conflict with any local policies or ordinances ❑ ❑ ❑ �
protecting biological resources, such as a tree
preservation policy or ordinance?
f) Conflict with the provisions of an adopted ❑ ❑ ❑ �
Habitat Conservation Plan, Natural Community
Conservation Plan, or other approved local,
regional, or state habitat conservation plan?
R:\Pro�acls\HaMsW004\IS-030508.tloc 7 Draft Initial Study
WORKING DR4FT—NOT FOR PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
Cook Street Drainage and Intersection Improvements
Potentially
Significant
ENVIRONMENTALISSUES Potentially unless �essThan
� Significant Mitigation Sfgniflcant No ��
(See attachmenfs for information sources) ', impact Incorporated Impact Impact
V.CULTURAL RESOURCES. Would the project:'I
a) Cause a substantial adverse change in the ❑ � ❑ ❑
significance of a historical resource as defined
in Section 15064.5?
b) Cause a substantial adverse change in the ❑ '� ❑ ❑
significance of an archaeological resource
pursuant to Section 15064.5?
c) Directly or indirectly destroy a unique ❑ �1 ❑ ❑
paleontological resource or site or unique
geologic feature?
d) Disturb any human remains, including those ❑ � ❑ ❑
interred outside of formal cemeteries?
VI'. GEOLOGIC PROBLEMS.'Wou/d the project: '
a) Expose people or structures to potential
substantial adverse effects, including the risk of
loss, injury, or death involving:
i) Rupture of a known earthquake fault, as ❑ ❑ � ❑
delineated on the most recent Alquist-Priolo
Earthquake Fault Zoning Map issued by the
State Geologist for the area or based on
other substantial evidence of a known
fault? Refer to Division of Mines and
Geology Special Publication 42.
ii) Strong seismic ground shaking. ❑ ❑ � ❑
iii) Seismic related ground failure, including ❑ ❑ � ❑
liquefaction.
iv) Landslides. ❑ ❑ J ❑
b) Result in substantial soil erosion or the loss of ❑ ❑ � ❑
topsoil?
c) Be located on a geologic unit or soil that is ❑ ❑ � ❑
unstable, or that would become unstable as a
result of the project, and potentially result in
on- or off-site landslide, lateral spreading,
subsidence, liquefaction or collapse?
d) Be located on expansive soil, as defined in ❑ o � ❑
Table 18-1-B of the Uniform Building Code
(1994), creating substantial risk to life or
property?
e) Have soils incapable of adequately supporting ❑ ❑ � ❑
the use of septic tanks or alternative waste
water disposal systems where sewers are not
available for the disposal of waste water?
R:\Pro�ec�slHartisW004\IS-030508.tloc 8 D�aR Initial Study
WORKING DRAFf—NOT FOR PUBIIC DISTRIBUTION
Cook Street Drainage and Intersection Improvements
Potentialiy
�Significant
ENVIRONMENTALISSUES Potentially Unless �essThan '
� Significant Mitigatlon SignificanE No �
(See attachments for information sources) I impact mcorporated lmpact Impact'
VII. HAZARDS. Would the project:
a) Create a significant hazard to the public or the ❑ ❑ ❑ d
environment through the routine transport, use,
or disposal of hazardous materials?
b) Create a significant hazard to the public or the ❑ ❑ ❑ �
environment through reasonably foreseeable
upset and accident conditions involving the
release of , hazardous materials into the
environment?
c) Emit hazardous emissions or handle ❑ ❑ ❑ �
hazardous or acutely hazardous materials,
substances, or waste within one-quarter mile of
an existing or proposed school? _
d) Be located on a site which is included on a list ❑ ❑ ❑ �
of hazardous materials sites compiled pursuant
to Government Code Section 65962.5 and, as
a result, would it create a significant hazard to
the public or the environment?
e) For a project located within an airport land use ❑ ❑ ❑ �
plan or, where such a plan has not been
adopted, within two miles of a public airport or
public use airport, would the project result in a
safety hazard for people residing or working in
the project area?
� For a project within the vicinity of a private ❑ ❑ ❑ �
airstrip, would the project result in a safety
hazard for people residing or working in the
project area?
g) Impair implementation of or physically interfere ❑ ❑ ❑ �
with an adopted emergency response plan or
emergency evacuation plan?
h) Expose people or structures to a significant risk ❑ ❑ o �
of loss, injury, or death involving wildland fires,
including where wildlands are adjacent to
urbanized areas or where residences are
intermixed with wildlands?
VIIL HYDROLOGY AND WATER QUALITY. Would the project:
a) Violate any water quality standards or waste ❑ ❑ o �
discharge requirements?
R:Wrojects\Hams1J004\IS-030508.doc 9 DraR Initial Study
WORKING DRAFT—NOT FOR PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
Cook Street Drainage and lntersection Improvements
Potentiaily
Significant
ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES Potentiauy uniess �essThan '
� Significant Mifigation Significanf No .
(See attachments for information sources} Impacf Incorporatea �:.Impact ImpacY
b) Substantially deplete groundwater supplies or ❑ ❑ ❑ �
interfere substantially with groundwater
recharge such that there would be a net deficit
in aquifer volume or a lowering of the local
groundwater table level (e.g., the production
rate of pre-existing nearby welis would drop to
a level which would not support existing land
uses or planned uses for which permits have
been granted)?
c) Substantially alter the existing drainage pattern ❑ ❑ ❑ �
of the site or area, including through the
alteration of the course of a stream or river, in
a manner which would result in substantial
erosion or siltation on-or off-site? -
d) Substantially alter the existing drainage pattern ❑ ❑ ❑ �
of the site or area, including through the
alteration of the course of a stream or river, or
substantially increase the rate or amount of
surface runoff in a manner which would result
in flooding on-or off-site?
e) Create or contribute runoff water which would ❑ ❑ � ❑
exceed the capacity of existing or planned
storm water drainage systems or provide
substantial additional sources of polluted
runoff?
f) Otherwise substa�tially degrade water quality? ❑ ❑ � ❑
g) Place housing within a 100-year flood hazard ❑ ❑ ❑ �
area as mapped on a federal Flood Hazard
Boundary or Flood Insurance Rate Map or
other flood hazard delineation map?
h) Place within a 100-year flood hazard area ❑ ❑ ❑ �
structures which would impede or redirect flood
flows?
i) Expose people or structures to a significant risk ❑ ❑ ❑ �
of loss, injury or death involving flooding,
including flooding as a result of the failure of a
levee or dam?
j) Inundation by seiche, tsunami, or mudflow? ❑ ❑ ❑ �
R:NroJecis\HamsW00d\IS-030508.tloc 10 Draft Initial Sfudy
WORKING DRAFT-NOT FOR PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
Cook Street Drainage and Intersection(mprovements
Potentialiy
��Signiftcant
ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES Potentially un�ess �essThan
' Significant Mifigation Significant No �
'(See attachments for information sources) ! Impact Incorporetea .Impact Impact�
IX. LAND USE AND PLANNING. Would the projecf:
a) Physically divide an established community? ❑ ❑ ❑ �
b) Conflict with any applicable land use plan, ❑ a ❑ �
policy, or regulation of an agency with
ju�isdiction over the project (including, but not
limited to the general plan, specific plan, local
coastal program, or zoning ordinance) adopted
for the purpose of avoiding or mitigating an
environmental effect?
c) Conflict with any applicable habitat ❑ ❑ ❑ �
conservation plan or natural community
conservation plan?
X: MINERAL RESOURCES. Woutd the'project:: '' '
a) Result in the loss of availability of a known ❑ ❑ ❑ �
mineral resource that would be of value to the
region and the residents of the state?
b) Result in the loss of availability of a locally- ❑ ❑ ❑ �1
important mineral resource recovery site
delineated on a local general plan, specific
plan or other land use plan?
XI. NOISE. Would the projecf'result in:
a) Exposure of persons to or generation of noise ❑ ❑ � ❑
levels in excess of standards established in the
local general plan or noise ordinance, or
applicable standards of other agencies?
b) Exposure of persons to or generation of ❑ ❑ � ❑
excessive ground borne vibration or ground
borne noise levels?
c) A substantial permanent increase in ambient ❑ ❑ � ❑
noise levels in the project vicinity above levels
existing without the project?
d) A substantial temporary or periodic increase in ❑ ❑ � ❑
ambient noise levels in the project vicinity
above levels existing without the project?
e) For a project located within an airport land use ❑ ❑ ❑ �
plan or, where such a plan has not been
adopted, within two miles of a public airport or
public use airport, would the project expose
people residing or working in the project area
to excessive noise levels?
f) For a project within the vicinity. of a private ❑ ❑ ❑ �
airstrip, would the project expose people
residing or working in the project area to
excessive noise levels?
R:\Pmjecls\Hams\J00411S-030508.tloc 11 Drak Inifial Study
WORKING DRAFT-NOT FOR PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
Cook Street Drainage and Intersection Improvements
Potentiaily
'�.Significant
ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES Potentiauy Unless �ess Than '
� Significant Mitigation Significant No '.
(See attachments for information sources) �mpact Incorporated Jmpact )mpact
XII. POPULATION APId HOUSING. Would the project:
a) Induce substantial population growth in an ❑ ❑ ❑ �
area, either directly (for example, by proposing
new homes and businesses) or indirectly (for
example, through extension of roads or other
infrastructure)?
b) Displace substantial numbers of existing ❑ ❑ ❑ �
housing, necessitating the construction of
replacement housing elsewhere?
c) Displace substantial numbers of people, ❑ ❑ ❑ �1
necessitating the construction of replacement
housing elsewhere?
XIII. PUBLIC SERVICES: Would the project: -
a) Result in substantial adverse physical impacts ❑ ❑ � ❑
associated with the provision of new or
physically altered governmental facilities, need
for new or physically altered governmental
facilities, the construction of which could cause
significant environmental impacts, in order to
maintain acceptable service ratios, response
times or other performance objectives for any
of the following public services:
i) Fire protection? ❑ ❑ � ❑
ii) Police protection? ❑ ❑ � ❑
iii) Schools? ❑ ❑ � o
iv) Parks? ❑ ❑ � ❑
v) Other public facilities? ❑ ❑ � ❑
XIV. RECREATION.'Wou/d the project:'
a) Increase the use of existing neighborhood and ❑ ❑ ❑ �
regional parks or other recreational facilities
such that substantial physical deterioration of
the facility would occur or be accelerated?
b) Include recreational facilities or require the ❑ ❑ ❑ �
construction or expansion of recreational
facilities which might have an adverse physical
effect on the environment?
XV. TRAFFIC AND TRANSPORTATION: Would the project:
a) Cause an increase in traffic which is ❑ ❑ ❑ �
substantial in relation to the existing tra�c load
and capacity of the street system (i.e., result in
a substantial increase in either the number of
vehicle trips, the volume to capacity ratio on
roads, or congestion at intersections)?
R:\ProjectslHams\J004\IS-030506.tloc 12 Draft Initial Study
WORKING DRAFT-NOT FOR PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
Cook StreetOrainage and Intersection Improvements
Potentiaily
�.Signifcant
ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES Potentially un�ess �ess Than
, ' Signifcant Mitigation Significant No
(See attacfiments for information sources) i impact Incorporeted lmpact Impact'
b) Exceed, either individually or cumulatively, a ❑ ❑ ❑ d
level of service standard established by the
county congestion management agency for
designated roads or highways?
c) Result in a change in air traffic patterns, ❑ ❑ ❑ �
including either an increase in tra�c levels or a
change in location that results in substantial
safety risks?
d) Substantially increase hazards due to a design ❑ a ❑ �
feature (e.g., sharp curves or dangerous
intersections) or incompatible uses (e.g., farm
equipment)?
e) Result in inadequate emergency access? ❑ ❑ � ❑ _
fl Result in inadequate parking capacity? ❑ ❑ o �
g) Conflict with adopted policies, plans, or ❑ ❑ ❑ �1
programs supporting alternative transportation
(e.g., bus turnouts, bicycle racks)?
XVI. UTILITIES AND SERVICE SYSTEMS. Would the project:
a) Exceed wastewater treatment requirements of ❑ ❑ ❑ d
the applicable Regional Water Quality Control
Board?
b) Require or result in the construction of new ❑ ❑ ❑ �
water or wastewater treatment facilities or
expansion of existing facilities, the construction
of which could cause significant environmental
effects?
c) Require or result in the construction of new ❑ ❑ ❑ �
storm water drainage facilities or expansion of
existing facilities, the construction of which
could cause significant environmental effects?
d) Have sufficient water supplies available to ❑ ❑ ❑ �
serve the project from existing entitlements
and resources, or are new or expanded
entitlements needed?
e) Result in a determination by the wastewater ❑ ❑ ❑ �
treatment provider which serves or may serve
the project that it has adequate capacity to
serve the projecYs projected demand in
addition to the provider's existing
commitments?
f) Be served by a landfill with sufficient permitted ❑ ❑ ❑ �
capacity to accommodate the projecYs solid
waste disposal needs?
R1PmJects\HartisW004VS-030508.tloc 13 � Draft Initial Study
WORKING DR4FT—NOT FOR PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
Cook Street Drainage and Intersection Improvements
Potentially
Significant
ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES Potenfially un�ess �ess7han
' Significant Mitigation SlgNflcant No �
(See attachments for information sources) i impact Incorporated Impact Impact
g) Comply with federal, state, and local statutes ❑ ❑ ❑ �
and regulations related to solid waste?
XVI. MANDATORY FINDINGS`OF SIGNIFICANCE. Would the project:
a. Have the potential to degrade the quality of the ❑ ❑ � ❑
environment, substantially reduce the habitat
of a fish or wildlife species, cause a fish or
wildlife population to drop below self-sustaining
levels, threaten to eliminate a plant or animal
community, reduce the number or restrict the
range of a rare or endangered plant or animal
or eliminate important examples of the major
periods of California history or prehistory?
b. Have impacts that are individually limited, but ❑ ❑ � ❑ -
cumulatively considerable? ("Cumulatively
considerable" means that the incremental
effects of a project are considerable when
viewed in connection with the effects of past
projects, the effects of other current projects,
and the effects of probable future projects.)
c. Have environmental effects which will cause ❑ ❑ � ❑
substantial adverse effects on human beings,
either directly or indirectly?
R:1Pmjecis\Hams\J004U5-030508.tloc 14 ' DraRlnitialStudy
WORKING DRAFT-NOT FOR PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
Cook Street D�ainage and Intersection Improvemenfs
SECTION 5—ENVIRONMENTAL EVALUATION
Substantiation and clarification for each checklist response is provided below. Included in each
discussion are mitigation measures, as appropriate, that are recommended for implementation
as part of the proposed project. �
I. AESTHETICS. Would the project:
a) Have a substantial adverse effect on a scenic vista?
b) Substantially damage scenic resources, including, but not limited to, trees, rock
outcroppings, and historic buildings within a state scenic highway?
c) Substantially degrade the existing visual character or quality of the site and its
surroundings?
d) Create a new source of substantial light or glare which would adversely affect day or
nighttime views in the area?
No Impact (Sections a, b, c & d). In its current condition, Cook Street is a major thoroughfare. -
However, it is designated as a major arterial and scenic roadway in the City of Palm Desert
General Plan. According to the City's General Plan Circulation Element, special setbacks and
landscaping standards are required for scenic roadways. The proposed project is required to
comply with these standards to ensure that scenic resources, including natural scenic beauty
and dramatic landforms, are visible from the roadway. Major scenic resources include the San
Jacinto, San Bernardino, and other mountain ranges surrounding and encompassing the City of
Palm Desert, as well as the desert floor. Cook Street is not designated as a State scenic
highway and the proposed project does not include structures that would impede views of or
from the project site. Therefore, the proposed project would neither substantially damage scenic
resources within a State scenic highway, nor would it disrupt existing views of the surrounding
environment to create a substantial adverse effect on a scenic vista.
The proposed project would occur primarily within existing roadway right-of-way and would not
substantially alter the visual character of the site and surroundings. As part of the proposed
project design, raised medians would be vegetated with drought-tolerant landscaping that is
consistent with existing landscaped vegetation on Cook Street. The proposed project
improvements would not result in a negative aesthetic effect on nearby residences or
automobiles and pedestrians traveling on the scenic roadway.
None of the proposed project or landscaping features would include reflective surfaces that
could create a source of glare. Street lighting potentially impacted by or relocated as a part of
the proposed project would be replaced with lighting that would be in compliance with City
Department of Public Works design standards and would be consistent with existing lighting on
Cook Street. In accordance with the City Municipal Code, street lighting would be fully shielded
to direct light directly onto the road surface and to prevent lighting spillover into adjacent
residences. Therefore, the replacement of street lighting would not be expected to impact
nighttime views of the area. No impacts are anticipated and no mitigation is required.
II. AGRICULTURAL RESOURCES. Would the project:
a) Convert Prime Farmland, Unique Farmland, or Farmland of Statewide Importance
(Farmland), as shown on the maps prepared pursuant to the Farmland Mapping and
Monitoring Program of the California Resources Agency, to non-agricultural use?
R:1Pmjects\Harzis\J004\I5030508.tloc 15 Oraft Initial Study
WORKING DRAFT—NOT FOR PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
Cook StreetOrainage and Infersection Improvements
b) Conflict with existing zoning for agricultural use, or a Williamson Act contract?
c) Involve other changes in the existing environment which, due to their location or
nature, could result in conversion of farmland, to non-agricultural use?
No Impact (Sections a, b, 8� c). The proposed project is not located on or in the vicinity of
property considered Prime Farmland, Unique Farmland, or Farmland of Statewide Importance
as mapped by the Farmland Mapping and Monitoring Program of the California Resources
Agency (NRCS 1979). Additionally, the proposed project would not conflict with existing zoning
or a Williamson Act Contract, nor would it result in conversion of farmland to non-agricultural
use. No impacts would occur and no mitigation is required.
III. AIR QUALITY. Would the project:
a) Conflict with or obstruct implementation of the applicable air quality plan?
b) Violate any air quality standard or contribute to an existing or projected air quality
violation?
c) Result in a cumulatively considerable net increase of any criteria pollutant for which _
the project region is non-attainment under tan applicable federal or state ambient air
quality standard (including releasing emissions which exceed quantitative thresholds
for ozone precursors)?
d) Expose sensitive receptors to pollutant?
e) Create objectionable odors affecting a substantial number of people?
No Impact (Sections a 8 b); Less Than Significant Impact (Sections c, d, & e). The
California Air Resources Board (CARB) divides the state into air basins which share similar
meteorological and topographical features. The City of Palm Desert is in the Coachella Valley, a
portion of the Salton Sea Air Basin (SSAB), which includes eastern Riverside and Imperial
counties. The SSAB's climate and topography, high winds, and fine sandy soils are conducive
to the formation of high concentrations of airborne particulate matter. Additionally, the
predominantly westerly winds transport pollutants from the adjacent South Coast Air Basin
(SCAB) into the SSAB.
The Riverside County portion of the SSAB is under the jurisdiction of the South Coast Air
Quality Management District (SCAQMD). The eastern Riverside County portion of the SSAB is
designated a non-attainment area for the following national ambient standards: ozone (03) and
fine particulate matter (PM). 03 is a colorless, odorless pollutant formed by a chemical reaction
between volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and oxides of nitrogen (NOx) in the presence of
sunlight. The primary sources of VOCs and NOx are mobile, including cars, trucks, buses, and
agricultural and construction equipment. PM is the term used for a mixture of solid particles and
liquid droplets found in the air. Coarse particles (all particles less than or equal to
10 micrometers in diameter, or PM10) derive from a variety of sources, including windblown
dust. Fuel combustion and resultant exhaust from diesel buses and trucks are primarily
responsible for fine particle (less than 2.5 microns in diameter, or PM2.5) levels.
Air quality modeling has shown that 03 in the Coachella Valley originates in the SCAB and is
transported into the SSAB by the predominantly westerly winds. The pollutant transport pathway
from the SCAB to the SSAB is through the Banning Pass to the Coachella Valley. Downwind of
the source region, exceedances occur' later in the day as the ozone cloud is transported
downwind. If the peak were locally generated, it would occur near mid-day and not in the late
R:�ProJecls\HartisW004\IS-030508.doc 16 DldR Initiel StUdy
WORKING DRAFT-NOT FOR PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
Cook Street Drainage and lntersection Improvements
afternoon or early evening. As a result, the SCAQMD is focusing on regulation of 03 in the
SCAB.
Between 1999 and 2001, the Coachella Valley exceeded the federal annual average PM10
national ambient air quality standards (NAAQS) numerous times. Because the Coachella Valley
was unable to demonstrate attainment of the NAAQS by the 2001 attainment year, the
SCAQMD prepared the 2002 Coachella Valley PM10 State Implemenfation Plan (CVSIP). The
CVSIP includes control program enhancements that meet the Most Stringent Measure (MSM)
requirements and a request for extension of the PM10 attainment date. Jurisdictions within the
Coachella Valley are required to adhere to the requirements outlined in the CVSIP, including
preparation of a Fugitive Dust Control Plan prior to issuance of grading permits for projects that
result in more than 5,000 square feet of soil disturbance.
A projecYs air quality impacts can be separated into short-term impacts from construction and
long-term permanent impacts from project operations. The proposed project is consistent with
the City General Plan Circulation Element and County's Master Plan of Arterial Highways; long-
term regional and local air quality impacts have been considered in their respective approved
environmental documentation.
Although the primary objective of the proposed roadway improvements is to alleviate congestion
on Cook Street and thereby improve traffic flow on the roadway, reduced congestion would also
reduce vehicle idling, which would have a slightly positive impact on air quality. Because the
proposed project itself does not increase the number of cars on the road, it is not considered a
tra�c-generating use. The air quality analysis therefore focuses on the short-term construction
impacts of the proposed project. Construction impacts include airborne dust from grading,
demolition, and dirt hauling, and gaseous emissions from heavy equipment, delivery and
dirt-hauling trucks, employee vehicles, and paints and coatings.
To determine whether emissions resulting from project-related construction are significant, the
SCAQMD recommends significance thresholds in its CEQA Air Quality Handbook. These
thresholds were applied to the proposed project in order to assure local and regional
consistency. Localized Significance Thresholds (LSTs) were not used for this analysis in
accordance with the direction of the City of Palm Desert given that the proposed project would
be phased in small increments to allow traffic lanes to remain open during construction and that
relatively minor improvements are proposed in proximity to residential land uses northeast of the
Country Club Drive intersection: The pollutants addressed by the SCAQMD thresholds include
carbon monoxide (CO), sulfur oxides (SOx), nitrogen oxides (NOx), particulate matter (PM10
and PM2.5), and reactive organic compounds (ROC). The daily thresholds for each of the
criteria pollutants are presented in Table 2.
TABLE 2
PROJECT EMISSIONS (MAXIMUM POUNDS/DAY)
CO �:�ROC TIOx PM70�� PMZS��.�
Grading/Excavation 52 10 47 8 2
Drainage/Utilities/Sub-Grade 49 10 46 8 2
Paving 21 3 21 1 0
Maximum Emissions 52 10 47 8 2
SCAQMD Daily Thresholds 550 75 100 150 55
Source:Road Construction Model Version 5.2
R:NrojectslHems\J004VS-030508.doc 17 � DraR Initial Study
WORKING DRAFT-NOT FOR PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
Cook Sfreet Drainage and Intersection Improvements
Table 2 also presents estimated project emissions. Grading/excavation, drainage/utilities/sub-
grade, and paving emissions were calculated using the Road Construction Model Version 5.2
developed by the Sacramento Metropolitan Air Quality Management District (SMAQMD)
(Appendix B). Additionally, PM2.5 emissions were calculated using the Final Methodology to
Calculafe PM2.5 and PM2.5 Thresholds developed by the SCAQMD. Construction emissions
were calculated for the following construction equipment assumptions:
• Grading/Excavation — one backhoe, one grader, one haul truck, one scraper, one water
truck, and one signal board.
o Drainage/Utilities/Subgrade — one compactor, one grader, one scraper, one signal
board, one water truck, and one trencher.
• Paving—one paver, paving equipment, one roller, and one signal board.
The air quality analysis assumes that no more than 1 acre of the project site would be disturbed
at any given time. Estimates of employee vehicle traffic and earth/debris export and import were
also included in the air quality modeling effort. Employee vehicle traffic would add a maximum of
26 vehicle trips/day based on an expected maximum of 13 construction employees on the _
busiest construction day. An estimated 1,500 cubic yards (cy) of debris (e.g., concrete and
asphalt) was assumed to be exported from the site during demolition which equates to two
disposal truck trips a day. The PM2.5 fraction used to determine emissions was the
"Construction and Demolition" subcategory and "Fugitive DusY' main category of the California
Emission Inventory Data and Reporting System (CEIDARS) PM profiles.
As identified on Table 2, project-related emission levels would not exceed SCAQMD's daily
thresholds and would result in a less than significant impact. No mitigation is required; however,
Standard Conditions of Approval 3-1 and 3-2 would apply to the proposed project and are
expected to reduce construction emissions from the project by approximately 68 percent.
Standard Conditions of Approval
SC 3-1 If the project is expected to result in soil disturbance of an area greater than or equal
to 5,000 square feet, the Project Contractor must submit a Dust Control Plan to the
City for approval in accordance with the Coachella Valley State Implementation Plan
(CVSIP). The Dust Control Plan must outline the measures that would be used to
control dust on the project site, including at least one of the Coachella Valley Best
Available Control Measures (CVBACM) for each dust source category as outlined in
Chapter 2 of the CVSIP.
SC 3-2 The City of Palm Desert will comply with South Coast Air Quality Management
District (SCAQMD) regulations, including Rule 402 (the Nuisance Rule) and Rule
403 (Fugitive Dust). To ensure that the project is in full compliance with both these
dust regulations and that there is no significant nuisance impact generated on the
project site, the Palm Desert City Engineer will be responsible for ensuring
compliance with these regulations throughout project implementation. Mandatory
measures set forth by these regulations include, but are not limited to, the following:
• Sweep any dirt tracked from the project site onto public streets no less than once
per day.
• Use particulate filters on all diesel equipment.
R:\Pmjects\Hams1J004\IS-030508.doc 18 DraR Initial Sfudy
WORKING DRAFT-NOT FOR PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
Cook StreetOrainage and Infersection Improvements
• Water exposed surfaces a minimum of two times daily. If fugitive dust appears to
be impacting adjacent residential land uses during times of high wind, additional
watering will be conducted and/or grading activities will be halted.
Cover all stockpiles of soil with tarps.
• Cover all trucks used to haul soil from the site with a tarp to reduce fugitive dust.
IV. BIOLOGICAL RESOURCES.Would the project:
a) Have a substantial adverse effect, either directly or through habitat modifications, on
any species identified as a candidate, sensitive, or special status species in local or
regional plans, policies, or regulations, or by the California Department of Fish and
Game or U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service?
b) Have a substantial adverse effect on any riparian habitat or other sensitive natural
community identified in local or regional plans, policies, regulations, or by the
California Department of Fish and Game or US Fish and Wildlife Service?
c) Have a substantial adverse effect on federally protected wetlands as defined by �
Section 404 of the Clean Water Act (including, but not limited to, marsh, vernal pool,
coastal, etc.) through direct removal, filling, hydrological interruption, or other
means?
d) Interfere substantially with the movement of any native resident or migratory fish or
wildlife species or with established native resident or migratory wildlife corridors, or
impede the use of native wildlife nursery sites?
e) Conflict with any local policies or ordinances protecting biological resources, such as
a tree preservation policy or ordinance?
� Conflict with the provisions of an adopted Habitat Conservation Plan, Natural
Community Conservation Plan, or other approved local, regional, or state habitat
conservation plan?
Potentially Significant Unless Mitigation Incorporated (Section a); No Impact (Sections b,
c, d, e, & t�. The following analysis is based on a Biological Resources Assessment prepared
by BonTerra Consulting on October 11, 2006. A follow-up visit to the project site by BonTerra
Consulting biologist Sam Stewart determined that conditions at the project site have not
changed since the original assessment was prepared. The full report is provided as Appendix C.
The project site includes existing public roads and public and private property adjacent to the
roadway alignment. Vegetation along the roads that may be removed by the proposed project
include smoke tree (Psorothamnus spinosa), oleander (Oleander sp.), and fan palm
(Washingtonia sp.). Adjacent vegetation that is not expected to be impacted by the proposed
project includes fig (Ficus sp.), gum (Eucalyptus sp.), and pine (Pinus sp.).
The majority of the project site provides very limited habitat for native wildlife species. The only
wildlife species observed in the vicinity of the project site that could potentially occur on the
project site include birds that may nest in ornamental vegetation. Bird species observed in the
vicinity of the project site include American kestrel (Falco sparverius), killdeer (Charadrius
vociferus), Anna's hummingbird (Calypte anna), black phoebe (Sayornis nigricans), common
raven (Corvus corax), verdin (Auriparus' flaviceps), northern mockingbird (Mimus polyglottos),
European starling (Sturnus vulgaris), common yellowthroat (Geothlypis trichas), song sparrow
(Melospiza melodia), and Brewer's blackbird (Euphagus cyanocephalus).
R9ProJacls\Hamis1J00d\IS-030508.doc 19 Draff Initial Study
WORKING DRAFT—NOT FOR PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
Cook Street Drainage and Intersection Improvemenfs
No special status habitats were observed on the project site. Plants or wildlife may be
considered to have "special status" due to declining populations, vulnerability to habitat change,
or restricted distributions. Certain special status species have been listed as Threatened or
Endangered under the California and/or Federal Endangered Species Acts (CESA and FESA,
respectively). No special status plant species are expected to occur due to lack of suitable
habitat and the developed nature of the project site. Additionally, �o Threatened or Endangered
species are expected to occur on the project site due to lack of suitable habitat and the
developed nature of the project site.
The project site is primarily existing roadway and is, therefore, not expected to function as a
wildlife movement corridor. The project improvements are not expected to impede wildlife
movement.
Trees on the project site have potential to be used for nesting by raptors. Regulations prohibit
activities that "take, possess, or destroy" any migratory bird or raptor nest or egg (Fish and
Game Code §§3503, 3503.5, and 3513). Therefore, if construction that is anticipated to impact
ornamental trees along the proposed project alignment is initiated during the raptor nesting
season (February 1 to June 30) a pre-construction raptor survey is recommended. This is not
expected to be a significant constraint on the proposed project.
Mitigation Measures
MM 4-1 If construction is scheduled to proceed beiween February 1 and July 30, no more
than seven days prior to the onset of construction activities that would impact trees
on the project site, a qualified Biologist will conduct a pre-construction nesting
raptor survey within the limits of project disturbance and in adjacent areas for the
presence of any active raptor nests.
If a raptor nest is found, the following restrictions on construction will be required
between February 1 and July 30 (or until nests are no longer active, as determined
by a qualified Biologist): (1) clearing limits will be established within a minimum of
500 feet in any direction from any occupied raptor nest exhibiting nesting activity
and (2) access and surveying will not be allowed within 100 feet of any raptor nest
exhibiting nesting activity, or as otherwise determined by a qualified Biologist. Any
encroachment into the 500/100-foot buffer area around the known nest is allowed
only if it is determined by a qualified Biologist that the proposed activity shall not
disturb the nest occupants.
V. CULTURAL RESOURCES. Would the project:
a) Cause a substantial adverse change in the significance of a historical resource as
defined in Section 15064.5?
b) Cause a substantial adverse change in the significance of an archaeological
resource pursuant to Section 15064.5?
c) Directly or indirectly destroy a unique paleontological resource or site or unique
geologic feature?
d) Disturb any human remains, including those interred outside of formal cemeteries?
Potentially Significant Unless Mitigation Incorporated (Sections a, b, c, & d). The following
section is based on a cultural resources records search conducted on August 31, 2006, by the
Eastern Information Center(EIC) at University of California, Riverside and a walk over survey of
the project site conducted by BonTerra Consulting on September 7, 2006.
R:\PmJects\Hams1J004\IS-030508.doc 20 DraR Initial Study
WORKING DRAFT—NOT FOR PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
Cook Sfreet D�ainage and Intersection Improvements
The EIC is the State-designated repository for records concerning archaeological and historical
resources in Riverside County. The records search provided information on known resources
and related studies within a one-mile radius of the proposed project alignment. The findings of
the records search, literature review, and survey are provided in Appendix D.
The EIC reported that at least 29 cultural resources investigations have previously 6een
conducted within a 1-mile radius of the project site. One of these studies, RI-3649 covers a
portion of Cook Street from Interstate 10 to Frank Sinatra Blvd (Chace 1994). The cited
investigation was negative for cultural resources.
The results of the records search indicate that 13 previously recorded cultural resources have
been recorded within a 1-mile radius of the project site, but are not located within or adjacent to
the project site. These represent archaeological and built environment resources. No
archaeological or built environment resources were previously recorded within the project site;
however, archaeological site CA-RIV-12698, a Late Prehistoric artifact scatter, was documented
approximately 1,000 feet from the Cook Street. None are located within or directly adjacent to
the project site.
A walk over survey of the project site was conducted on September 7, 2006, by BonTerra
Consulting. No previously recorded or unrecorded prehistoric or historic archaeological sites
were identified as a result of the survey. The project site has been previously disturbed by the
construction and maintenance of various paved roads, sidewalks and utility lines, as well as the
construction of the surrounding residential and commercial development. Visibility of native soils
on the project site was virtually non-existent given existing pavement over the established
streets. Visibility of adjacent areas was intermittent, with minor areas of exposure along the
street edge. No archaeological resources were observed in or adjacent to the project site. No
built-environment resources remain subsequent to development along both sides of the project
site.
The relative scarcity of recorded cultural resources sites in the vicinity of the project site
indicates that the potential for archaeological materials to be present is low. Because the project
site is located primarily within previously disturbed areas, the likelihood that cultural resources
may persist intact is substantially reduced. Mitigation Measures 5-1 and 5-2 are provided to
ensure that any potential impacts to resources are mitigated.
The results of the paleontological literature review indicate that the entire project corridor and a
one-mile radius around it are situated on deposits of Younger Quaternary Dune Sands/Alluvium
and Older Quaternary Deposits. The younger (Holocene) layers of the Quaternary Alluvium are
not expected to yield significant fossil resources. No fossils have been recovered from this
geologic unit in the vicinity of the project site. However, should undisturbed Older Quaternary
Deposits be present at depth or exposed during excavation, such sediments would have
undetermined paleontological sensitivity and may contain significant nonrenewable fossil
resources. Therefore, it is expected that earthmoving activities associated with project
construction would not likely result in a significant impact to paleontological resources.
Mitigation Measure 5-1 would further reduce the likelihood of impacts to paleontological
resources.
Mitigation Measures
MM 5-1 in the event that prehistoric or historic archaeological resources are encountered
during earthmoving activities, work in the immediate area of the find shall be
temporarily diverted or redirected to allow time to evaluate any exposed prehistoric
or historic material, including paleontological resources. Any recovered prehistoric
R:1Pro7ecls\HarzisW004\IS-030508.tloc 2'I DraR lnitial Sfudy
WORKING DRAFT—NOT FOR PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
Cook Sfreef Drainage and Infersection Improvements
or historic artifacts shall be catalogued by a qualified Archaeologist or
Paleontologist. For non-tribal resources, the City of Palm Desert would retain any
resources discovered during grading for display in public facilities or for educational
purposes following cataloguing.
MM 5-2 In accordance with Public Resources Code §5097.94, if human remains are found,
the Riverside County Coroner must be notified within 24 hours of the discovery. If
the Coroner determines that the remains are not recent, s/he will notify the Native
American Heritage Commission in Sacramento to determine the most likely
descendent for the area. The designated Native American representative will then
determine the reassignment of the human remains in consultation with the
Property Owner.
With implementation of the above mitigation measures, impacts are expected to be reduced to a
level of less than significant.
VI. GEOLOGIC PROBLEMS. Would the project:
a) Expose people or structures to potential substantial adverse effects, including the risk "
of loss, injury, or death involving:
i) Rupture of a known earthquake fault, as delineated on the most recent Alquist-
Priolo Earthquake Fault Zoning Map issued by the State Geologist for the area or
based on other substantial evidence of a known fault? Refer to Division of Mines
and Geology Special Publication 42.
ii) Strong seismic ground shaking.
iii) Seismic related ground failure, including liquefaction.
iv) Landslides.
b) Result in substantial soil erosion or the loss of topsoil?
c) Be located on a geologic unit or soil that is unstable, or that would become unstable
as a result of the project, and potentially result in on- or off-site landslide, lateral
spreading, subsidence, liquefaction or collapse?
d) Be located on expansive soil, as defined in Table 18-1-B of the Uniform Building
Code (1994), creating substantial risk to life or property?
e) Have soils incapable of adequately supporting the use of septic tanks or alternative
waste water disposal systems where sewers are not available for the disposal of
waste water?
Less Than Significant Impact (Sections a, b, c, d, & e). The project site is underlain by
Quaternary Alluvium (Qal), which is primarily distributed at the mouths of drainages in the Santa
Rosa Mountains and in the eastern portion of the Coachella Valley. These deposits may have
accumulated rapidly, without being saturated and may be subject to wind erosion or collapse
upon saturation (hydroconsolidation).
There are no known active or potentially active faults that traverse the project site. According to
the Palm Desert Planninq Area Map in the City of Palm Desert General Plan's Geotechnical
Element, the project site is not located in the Alquist-Priolo Earthquake Fault Zone. The closest
known active fault is the San Andreas Fault (right-lateral transform fault) which passes through
the northern portion of Palm Desert approximately 7.5 miles north of the site and extends for
more than 600 miles from the Salton Sea to Cape Mendocino and is capable of producing
R1ProjecislHams1J004\IS-030508.tloc 22 Drak Initial Study
WORKING DRAFT—NOT FOR PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
Cook Street Drainage and Intersection Improvements
magnitude 8.0 and potentially greater magnitude earthquakes. Another nearby active fault is the
San Jacinto Fault (right-lateral strike-slip fault) located approximately 20 miles southwest of the
site. it extends for approximately 175 miles and is capable of producing magnitude 6.5 to
7.5 earthquakes. This fault has historically produced Iarger earthquakes than any other fault in
California; however, it has not produced any particularly damaging quakes in recent history.
Located 45 miles southwest of the project site, the next closest major fault zone is the Elsinore
Fault, one of the largest but least active faults in southern California. It extends more than
140 miles in length and is capable of generating magnitude 6.5 to 7.5 earthquakes.
Given the City's proximity to the San Andreas and San Jacinto faults, the City has the potential
to experience extremely high seismically induced ground shaking. The effects of ground motion
on structures can be lessened to ensure structural seismic safety through the adherence of the
Uniform Building Code, California Building Code, and Unreinforced Masonry Law. No habitable
structures are proposed as a part of the project; therefore risks to people and private property
associated with the proposed project would be negligible.
Liquefaction is a seismic phenomenon in which loose, saturated, fine-grained granular soils
behave similarly to a fluid when subjected to high-intensity ground shaking. Liquefaction _
typically occurs where the groundwater table is within 50 feet of the ground surface. According
to the Liquefaction Susceptibility on the Palm Desert Plannina Area Mao in the City of Palm
Desert General Plan's Geotechnical Element, the project site is located in an area of low
liquefaction susceptibility and contains fine-grained sediments with a groundwater depth of
greater than 100 feet. Therefore, the proposed project would not be affected by liquefaction and
no mitigation is required.
Seiches refers to seismically induced oscillation or sloshing of water contained in reservoirs,
lakes, ponds, swimming pools, and other enclosed bodies of water. In the event of strong
ground shaking, the degree of damage to such small bodies of water in the City would likely be
minor. However, seiching could result in the failure of larger bodies of water (including water
tanks, retention basins, recharge basins, and other water storage structures) and could result in
the inundation of land and structures downgradient. The Colorado River Aqueduct extends
across the northerly boundary of the city, near the base of the Little San Bernardino Mountains
and is situated adjacent to segments of the San Andreas Fault. A surface rupturing earthquake
on one of these segments could damage the Aqueduct and release large volumes of water. The
proposed project consists of roadway improvements and would not be affected by nor result in
adverse effects from a seiche event.
According to the Seismicallv induced Rock Falls and Landslide Susceotibilitv Map in the
Geotechnical Element of the City General Plan, the project site is in an area of shallow
topographic gradient underlain by young unconsolidated sediments, with a "low to none"
susceptibility of being impacted by rock falls or.landslides. The topography of the project site is
flat and would not be substantially altered with implementation of the proposed project. No new
slope or bare areas would be created with implementation of the proposed project. Therefore,
the potential for landslides is considered negligible.
Wind erosion occurs on dry, sandy, finely granulated soils and involves the removal of soil from
one place in its deposition to another. In the Coachella Valley, the prevailing winds originate
from the San Gorgonio Pass to the west, and follow the central axis of the valley in a
southeasterly direction. Most of the developed portion of the city is highly susceptible to wind
erosion. According to the Wind Erosion Hazard Zones shown on the Palm Desert Planninq Area
Mao in the City of Palm Desert General Plan's Geotechnical Element, the project site is in a
Severe to Very Severe Wind Erosion Hazard area, which is exposed to erosive winds where
soils show distinct evidence of wind removal and/or accumulation in hummocks 24 to 48 inches
R:\Projec�s\Hartis1J004\IS-030508.tloc 23 Draft Initial Study
WORKING DRAFT-NOT FOR PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
Cook Street Drainage and/ntersection Improvements
in height. Increases in the amount of windblown sand in the city are related to episodic flooding
of the Whitewater River Floodplain and other major drainages to the west. The composition of
the Whitewater River floor consists of typically course sands, gravels, and cobble. However,
during major flood events, large quantities of sand and gravel are deposited on the river floor
and are exposed within the floodplains. The proposed roadway improvements would not be
expected to affect erosion or deposition on the project site or in the vicinity as the roadway is
currently developed. No impacts are anticipated.
According to the Seismically induced Settlement shown on the Palm Desert Planninq Area Map
in the City of Palm Desert General Plan's Geotechnical Element, the project site is in an area
with a high susceptibility to seismically induced settlement which is underlain by young,
unconsolidated deposits. Risks associated with land subsidence or soil expansion are
considered low due to the minimal amount of grading required for the project and the lack of
subsidence because construction would occur in the original alignment. Appropriate design
standards and standard engineering practices would be applied during construction of the
project. No significant impacts are anticipated.
VII. HAZARDS. Would t_he project:
a) Create a significant hazard to the public or the environment through the routine
transport, use, or disposal of hazardous materials?
b) Create a significant hazard to the public or the environment through reasonably
foreseeable upset and accident conditions involving the release of hazardous
materials into the environment?
c) Emit hazardous emissions or handle hazardous or acutely hazardous materials,
substances, or waste within one-quarter mile of an existing or proposed school?
d) Be located on a site which is included on a list of hazardous materials sites compiled
pursuant to Government Code Section 65962.5 and, as a result, would it create a
significant hazard to the public or the environment?
e) For a project located within an airport land use plan or, where such a plan has not
been adopted, within two miles of a public airport or public use airport, would the
project result in a safety hazard for people residing or working in the project area?
f) For a project within the vicinity of a private airstrip, would the project result in a safety
hazard for people residing or working in the project area?
g) Impair implementation of or physically interfere with an adopted emergency response
plan or emergency evacuation plan?
h) Expose people or structures to a significant risk of loss, injury or death involving
wildland fires, including where wildlands are adjacent to urbanized areas or where
residences are intermixed with wildlands?
No Impact (Sections a, b, c, d, e, f, g, � h). The proposed project is the improvement of an
existing City roadway and would not create a significant hazard to the public or the environment
through the routine transport, use, or disposal of hazardous materials or reasonably foreseeable
upset and accident conditions involving the release of hazardous materials into the
environment. Palm Desert High School is located more than one mile from the Hovley Lane
intersection at 43570 Phyllis Jackson Lane. However, as mentioned above, the proposed
project would not result in hazardous emissions or handle hazardous or acutely hazardous
materials, substances, or waste.
R:1Projec�slHams1J004\IS-030500.tloc 24 Draft lnitial Study
WORKING DRAFT-NOT FOR PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
Cook Street Drainage and lntersection Improvements
A Phase I hazardous materials/substances site records search was completed for the project
site and its immediate vicinity (EDR 2006). The records search is provided as Appendix E. Sites
were identified in the area that would be affected by the proposed project. Sites located in the
vicinity of the proposed project alignment include two leaking underground storage tanks (i.e.,
diesel and unleaded gasoline tank at a service station); an aboveground storage tank for waste
oil at a tool maintenance and repair shop; and a sewage treatment facility. None of these sites
are in the direct impact footprint of the proposed project and would not be directly or indirectly
affected by the proposed project.
The project site is not located within the boundaries of an airport land use plan nor is it within
two miles of a public airport or public use airport; therefore, the project would not result in a
safety hazard for people residing or working in the project area. The closest public use airport is
the Palm Springs International Airport approximately 10 miles to the west. A private airport is
located near the termination of Portola Avenue near Interstate 10. The Bermuda Dunes Airport
is used for approximately 25,000 flights annually. However, the orientation of the airport requires
flight paths to be east-west trending approximately 6 miles north of the project site. Therefore,
the proposed project would not result in a safety hazard for people residing or working in the
project area as a result of the private airstrip.
The City of Palm Desert has established a Multi-Hazard Functional Plan (MHFP) with planned
responses to natural and technological emergency situations. The MHFP includes emergency
response or evacuation plans that would be implemented during various emergency situations.
The Cove Communities Commission, comprised of various City officials from the cities of Palm
Desert, Rancho Mirage, and Indian Wells, is the decision-making entity for emergency and
related services issues with the contracted Riverside County Sheriff and Fire Departments.
Palm Desert's three fire stations (#33 at Town Center Drive and Highway 111, #71 at Portola
Avenue and Country Club Drive, and #67 at Mesa View Drive and Portola Avenue) share the
capacity of authority as a First Response Team. The agency responsible for the Hazardous
Response Plan (HRP) addressing hazardous and toxic materials is the County of Riverside
Health Hazardous Materials Division and/or the Regional Water Quality Control Board. The
proposed project would not be expected to impede the implementation of the MHFP or HRP as
it would allow through-tra�c during construction. Therefore, no impacts are anticipated and no
mitigation is required.
In addition, the project proposes roadway and drainage improvements and is surrounded by
urban development; therefore, the proposed project would not expose people or structures to a
significant risk of loss, injury, or death involving wildland fires, including where wildlands are
adjacent to urbanized areas or where residences are intermixed with wildlands. No mitigation is
required.
VIII. HYDROLOGY AND WATER QUALITY. Would the project
a) Violate any water quality standards or waste discharge requirements?
b) Substantially deplete groundwater supplies or interfere substantially with
groundwater recharge such that there would be a net deficit in aquifer volume or a
lowering of the local groundwater table level (e.g., the production rate of pre-existing
nearby wells would drop to a level which would not support existing land uses or
planned uses for which permits have been granted)?
c) Substantially alter the existing drainage pattern of the site or area, including through
the alteration of the course of a stream or river, in a manner which would result in
substantial erosion or siltation on- or off-site?
R9Proiects\HamsW004VS-o3o506.tloc 25 Drak Initial Study
WORKING DR4FT—NOT FOR PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
Cook Street Drainage and Intersection Improvements
d) Substantially alter the existing drainage pattern of the site or area, including through
the alteration of the course of a stream or river, or substantially increase the rate or
amount of surface runoff in a manner which would result in flooding on-or off-site?
e) Create or contribute runoff water which would exceed the capacity of existing or
planned storm water drainage systems or provide substantial additional sources of
polluted runoff?
fl Otherwise substantially degrade water quality?
g) Place housing within a 100-year flood hazard area as mapped on a federal Flood
Hazard Boundary or Flood Insurance Rate Map or other flood hazard delineation
map?
h) Place within a 100-year flood hazard area structures which would impede or redirect
flood flows?
i) Expose people or structures to a significant risk of loss, injury or death involving
flooding, including flooding as a result of the failure of a levee or dam?
j) Inundation by seiche, tsunami, or mudflow?
No Impact (Sections a, b, c, d, g, h, i, & j), Less Than Significant Impact (e & fl. The
Federal Clean Water Act establishes a framework for regulating potential water quality impacts
from construction activities through the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency's National
Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) program. Municipalities within the Coachella
Valley that conduct public improvement projects involving more than one acre of grading are
required to submit a Notice of Intent (NOI) to the State Water Resources Control Board
(SWRCB) to obtain coverage under the Areawide Urban Storm Water Runoff Permit (MS4) for
the Coachella Valley (Order No. 01-077). The Regional Water Quality Control Board (RWQCB)
oversees the implementation and enforcement of the MS4 permit. Because the project would
involve grading on no more than one acre at a time, the City would not be required to submit an
NOI to the SWRCB.
The Coachella Valley is underlain by several large subsurface aquifers, or sub-basins. The
Whitewater River Sub-basin encompasses 400 square miles and underlies the city and a
substantial portion of the valley floor; it is the largest groundwater repository for the Coachella
Valley. The Coachella Valley Water District (CVWD) provides domestic water services to Palm
Desert using wells that extract groundwater from the Whitewater River sub-basin. This sub-
basin is artificially recharged with imported Colorado River water carried via the Metropolitan
Water District Aqueduct. it is also recharged naturally with runoff from the San Jacinto, Santa
Rosa, and San Bernardino mountains. The proposed project would not result in a measurable
impact to groundwater supply or groundwater recharge.
The proposed project involves the installation of storm drain pipelines in Cook Street and on
Novley Lane. However, the proposed project would not measurably alter the drainage pattern in
the project area because storm water flows originating on the project site currently enter existing
catch basins that drain to existing storm drain pipes that flow to the Whitewater River Channel.
The drainage improvements would convey storm water generated on the project site and in the
immediate vicinity to the storm drain pipes more efficiently, which would reduce the potential for
on-site flooding.
The project would result in a negligible increase in impervious surface given that it is primarily
repaving areas that are currently paved with concrete or asphalt. Sections of raised medians
with natural soil and landscaping would be removed; however, new raised and landscaped
medians are also proposed in areas that are currently paved. Therefore, the proposed project
R:\ProJecLslHanis\J004V5-030508.tloc 26 Draft Initial Study
WORKING DRAFT-NOT FOR PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
Cook Street Drainage and lntersection Improvements
would not be expected to substantially increase the rate or amount of surface runoff in a manner
which would result in flooding on or off the site. The proposed project would not create or
contribute appreciable volumes of runoff water beyond the existing condition and would
therefore not result in flows that would exceed the existing or planned storm water drainage
system capacity nor would the project provide substantial additional sources of polluted runoff.
Construction activities such as grading, excavation, and trenching for site improvements would
result in disturbance of soils on the project site. Runoff from the project site during construction
could transport soils and sediments from these activities. Spills or leaks from heavy equipment
and machinery, staging areas, or building sites could also enter runoff. Typical pollutants could
include petroleum products and heavy metals from equipment and products such as paints and
solvents that could contain hazardous constituents. Short-term water quality impacts could
result if polluted runoff enters the Whitewater Channel (located 0.8-mile south of Hovley Lane)
and downstream receiving waters. Potential erosion, siltation, and other water quality impacts
during construction of the proposed project would be managed through the preparation of a
Storm Water Pollution Prevention Plan (SWPPP). This plan would be a joint effort between the
City and Contractor. The SWPPP would describe the measures or practices to control pollutants
during both the construction and post-construction phases of the project. An SWPPP typically
contains a list of target structural and non-structural best management practices (BMPs) which
would be used to control, prevent, or reduce pollution. BMPs that are most often used during
construction include gravel bags, temporary de-silting basins, and the timing of grading to avoid
the rainy season (November through April). The SWPPP would contain BMPs that address the
following areas during construction, as defined by the California Storm Water Best Management
Practice Handbook: internal erosion control, good housekeeping practices, waste containment,
minimization of disturbed areas, stabilization of disturbed areas, and controlling the perimeter of
the site. In addition to the requirements of the NPDES program, provisions of the Uniform
Building Code include elements that also require reduction of erosion and sedimentation
impacts. The Contractor's full compliance with applicable local, State, and federal water quality
standards would avoid water quality impacts.
The proposed project consists of roadway and drainage improvements; no housing is proposed.
Because no habitable structures would be placed within the 100-year flood hazard area and
because existing flows would not be redirected in a manner that could result in on-site or off-site
flooding, the proposed roadway improvements would not expose people or structures to a
significant risk of loss, injury, or death involving flooding. No significant impacts are anticipated
and no mitigation is required.
No large water bodies are located in the vicinity of the project site. Therefore, the proposed
project would not expose people or structures to a significant risk of loss, injury, or death
involving flooding as a result of the failure of a levee or dam, or inundation by seiche, tsunami,
or mudflow.
IX. LAND USE AND PLANNING. Would the project:
a) Physically divide an established community?
b) Conflict with any applicable land use plan, policy, or regulation of an agency with
jurisdiction over the project (including, but not limited to the general plan, specific
plan, local coastal program, or zoning ordinance) adopted for the purpose of
avoiding or mitigating an environmental effect?
c) Conflict with any applicable habitat conservation plan or natural community
conservation plan?
R:\PmjeclslHartis\J004\IS-030508.doc 27 . Drak Initial Study
WORKING DRAFT-NOT FOR PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
Cook Street Drainage and Intersection Improvements
No Impact (Sections a, b, & c.) The proposed project would allow for roadway improvement in
City-owned right-of-way with minimal take of private property (Table 1), including portions of
sidewalks and landscaped areas. These proposed acquisitions would not physically divide an
established community. The City is currently negotiating with private property owners to acquire
the right-of-way necessary to complete the project.
Cook Street is designated as an arterial in the Circulation Element of the City of Palm Desert
General Plan. Arterial street sections are described in the Circulation Element as having 3 traffic
lanes, a bikeway (either Class II on-street or Class I off-street), and 24-foot-wide parkways with
sidewalks in each direction of travel. The proposed project would widen the roadway to the
ultimate width consistent with the Circulation Element and would construct the roadways,
medians, and sidewalks in a manner consistent with the requirements of the General Plan and
Municipal Code.
No habitat conservation plans or natural community conservation plans currently apply to the
proposed project site. No impacts are anticipated and no mitigation is required.
X. MINERAL RESOURCES. Would the project:
a) Result in the loss of availability of a known mineral resource that would be of value to
the region and the residents of the state?
b) Result in the loss of availability of a locally-important mineral resource recovery site
delineated on a local general plan, specific plan, or other land use plan?
No Impact (Sections a & b). The Surface Mining and Reclamation Act of 1975 (SMARA)
mandated the initiation of mineral land classification by the State Geologist in order to help
identify and protect mineral resources in areas within the State subject to urban expansion or
other irreversible land uses which would preclude mineral extraction. SMARA also allows the
State Mining and Geology Board (SMGB) to designate lands containing mineral deposits of
regional or statewide significance in accordance with classification criteria set by the State
Geologist. The project site is located on land that is designated MRZ-3 on California Division of
Mines and Geology mineral resources maps, which indicate that this is an area which contains
mineral deposits, the significance of which cannot be evaluated from available data.
The proposed project would result in construction in an area that is developed in the existing
condition. Therefore, the roadway improvements would not cause additional land to be
precluded from future mineral extraction. Therefore, implementation of the proposed project
would not result in the loss of availability of a known mineral resource that would be of value to
the region and the residents of the state or in the loss of a locally important mineral resource
recovery site delineated on a local general plan, specific plan, or other land use. No impacts
would occur and no mitigation is required.
XI. NOISE. Would the project resuit in:
a) Exposure of persons to or generation of noise levels in excess of standards
established in the local general plan or noise ordinance, or applicable standards of
other agencies?
b) Exposure of persons to or generation of excessive ground borne vibration or ground
borne noise levels?
c) A substantial permanent increase in ambient noise levels in the project vicinity above
levels-existing without the project?
R:\PmjectslHarzisW004\IS030508.tloc 26 Draft lnitial Study
WORKING DRAFT—NOT FOR PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
Cook Street Drainage and/ntersection Improvements
d) A substantial temporary or periodic increase in ambient noise levels in the project
vicinity above levels existing without the project?
e) For a project located within an airport land use plan or, where such a plan has not
been adopted, within two miles of a public airport or public use airport, would the
project expose people residing or working in the project area to excessive noise
levels?
fl For a project within the vicinity of a private airstrip, would the project expose people
residing or working in the project area to excessive noise Ievels?
Less Than Significant Impact (Sections a, b, c, and d), No Impact (Sections e and t�.
Sound pressure measurements are expressed in decibels (dB). However, sound pressure level
alone is not a reliable indicator of loudness. In order to approximate the frequency response of
the human ear, a series of sound pressure level adjustments is applied to the sound measured.
The A-Weighting scale effectively approximates the frequency response of the average ear
when listening to most everyday sounds. Furthermore, the State Department of Aeronautics and
the California Commission on Housing and Community Development have adopted the
community noise equivalent level (CNEL) scale. The CNEL weighting scale weights the average
noise levels for the evening hours (7:00 PM to 10:00 PM) by increasing them by 5 dB, and
weights the late evening and morning hour noise levels (10:00 PM to 7:00 AM) by increasing
them by 10 dB. The A-Weighting and CNEL scales are described in Exhibit 5.
The City of Palm Desert's Noise Ordinance states that the 1-hour average noise level in
residential areas from a fixed (i.e., non-transportation) noise source may not exceed 55 dB(A)
during the day between the hours of 7:00 AM and 10:00 PM and 45 dB(A) in the evening
between the hours of 10:00 PM and 7:00 AM. If the ambient noise level exceeds the above
noise standards, the noise standard shall be the ambient noise level. Furthermore, Section
9.24.070 of the Municipal Code limits construction activities to the following days and hours at
certain times of year:
• Monday through Friday from 7:00 AM to 5:30 PM; Saturdays from 8:00 AM to 5:00 PM
(October 1st through April 30�h).
. Monday through Friday from 6:00 AM to 7:00 PM; Saturdays from 8:00 AM to 5:00 PM
(May 1st through September 30th)
• Construction is not permitted on Sundays or government holidays.
In the short-term, construction noise levels in the vicinity of the project are expected to fluctuate
depending on the particular type, number, and duration of use of various pieces of construction
equipment. The exposure of persons to the periodic increase in noise levels would be
short-term, and project construction is expected to comply with the City of Palm Desert's
Municipal Code requirements. Therefore, construction of the project is otherwise exempt from
the Noise Ordinance standards during the above-mentioned construction hours and would not
result in a significant impact on nearby residences.
Groundborne vibration is measured in terms of the velocity of the vibration oscillations. As with
noise, a logarithmic decibel scale (VdB) is used to quantify vibration intensity. When
groundborne vibration exceeds 72 to 80 VdB, it is usually perceived as annoying to building
occupants. The degree of annoyance is dependent upon individual sensitivity to vibration, and
the frequency of the vibration events. Typically, vibration levels must exceed 100 VdB before
building damage occurs.
R:\PmjecLslHams\J004\IS-030508.tloc 29 Draft Initial Study
WORKING DRAFT-NOT FOR PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
� u a � .
u'1 , � j o
�, I R
�1,
� M` mi
� � '
X � � "�
w �^ z w"
� O r
c�
_ _ $
e
� � � �
r K ;
� � �= N
?'c' 'x� O �'
__ q p
=` — ' W y
C
{� �� h i
_ 3 � � U
o`c o= Z �
' " W �
�� ' - Z j
- - V O
Y' ^ 5 � C 'L
- = M1 � _ � � � - E ;
x o °
y .� `v'' � .�l — n ry >
= ^ 2 ^ ._ — J
c 2 ,E j N
' f oi
� ` � � � �
� c _ c '
m _ �.� u Y _ �
q '_ �� :.0 _ y
� � v
�
v
,�''o = :
- t
`Av. Y0�' n:� i� �
Cs zY -^ � Q
%� �� �i m� �
� 'a X
�� i�.�
........fJ.,.........t ......,... p`.n��'• � ; �
Q ;
N y
W J
y y
� : ! i . . . . Z N
.. :� .. O
3 5 v "' '. 'T `c < ¢ G 2
s c C — x ' s _ ' � m O
- _ - x b - E �
o �
u •� �
� = ' - _ . , � :a ^ 3 v
..2„ _ ' n �' =• j Y � � :;� a ' ' `� N Q �
- '_ _ _° i # � �* `s � - } .� ' ``'c sS = y l,l
� �' € _ - _ s c _ � _ � = L (/1
� n y 5 - = _ ' � .o 0 0
2 = 's t _ 'a � � � `3 - J t M N G
^ _ y .+' � � ..� < — � Jl � �L � N
�` ' - ; � ' - - v � �
1 U ` ! U ,} N '. � � � G
L e1� �
� �y N N
�
L /y @
� V. U
�
O
�/ N
1 V (Q Q
QJ J �
� � m
N �
� � �
Z U N
iAresiou xa�soiyde�B�600fISWeHIsl�alo�dGO
Cook Street Drainage and l�tersection Improvemenfs
The primary vibratory source during the construction of the project would be jackhammers.
Typical jackhammers generate an approximate vibration level of 79 Vd6 at a distance of 25 feet.
Therefore, it is possible that vibration would be perceived by residents as a nuisance if jack
hammering occurs within about 22 to 56 feet of residences. However, project improvements do
not involve jack hammering within 55 feet of residences. Therefore, impacts are considered less
than significant due to the temporary nature of project construction, and because the vibration
levels would be well below the threshold of building damage.
The proposed project would not reduce the distance from the roadway to sensitive receptors in
the vicinity of the proposed improvements (i.e., residences northeast of the intersection of Cook
Street and Country Club Drive). The project would not remove existing barriers to noise and the
proposed drainage improvements would remove existing intersection dips, which would thereby
reduce vehicle noise typically associated braking, shock absorption, and acceleration.
Furthermore, road resurfacing/repaving would be expected to reduce tire noise on the roadway
by removing pot-holes and other surface irregularities. Long-term noise would not increase for
existing residential land uses and impacts are considered less than significant.
The proposed project is not located in an airport land use plan nor is it near a private airstrip.
Furthermore, the proposed project would not expose people to excessive noise levels
associated with airport uses. No impacts would occur.
Mitigation Measures
MM 11-1 Project construction shall comply with the City of Palm Desert Noise Ordinance.
All construction activities shall be limited to the following time constraints:
. Monday through Friday from 7:00 AM to 5:30 PM; Saturdays from 8:00 AM to
5:00 PM (October 1st through April 30'h).
• Monday through Friday from 6:00 AM to 7:00 PM; Saturdays from 8:00 AM to
5:00 PM (May 1st through September 30�").
. Construction is not permitted on Sundays or government holidays.
XII. POPULATION AND HOUSING. Would the project:
a) Induce substantial population growth in an area, either directly (for example, by
proposing new homes and businesses) or indirectly (for example, through extension
of roads or other infrastructure)?
b) Displace substantial numbers of existing housing, necessitating the construction of
replacement housing elsewhere?
c) Displace substantial numbers of people, necessitating the construction of
replacement housing elsewhere?
No Impact (Sections a, b, & c). The proposed project involves street improvements that do not
provide access to previously inaccessible areas, and would not, therefore, have growth-inducing
effects. The proposed project is in compliance with adopted traffic policies and forecasts and the
proposed roadway width would be considered consistent with the Circulation Element of the City
of Palm Desert General Plan and the CounN of Riverside Plan of Arterial Hiqhways (MPAH).
The proposed project would not result in direct or indirect population growth impacts that have
not already been analyzed and mitigated.
R1Pro�ects\Hams\J004\IS-030508.tloc $Q Draft Initial Study
WORKING DRAFT-NOT FOR PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
Cook Street Drainage and Intersection Improvements
The proposed project is a roadway improvement project. Land uses proximate to the project site
include residential uses; however, project implementation would not displace existing homes or
people. No mitigation is required.
XIII. PUBLIC SERVICES. Would the project:
a) Result in substantial adverse physical impacts associated with the provision of new
or physically altered governmental facilities, need for new or physically altered
governmental facilities, the construction of which could cause significant
environmental impacts, in order to maintain acceptable service ratios, response
times or other performance objectives for any of the following public services:
i) Fire protection?
ii) Police protection?
iii) Schools?
iv) Parks?
v) Other public facilities? _
Less Than Significant Impact (Section a). The proposed project is a street improvement
project and would not directly affect emergency police or fire services. Short-term traffic delays
may occur during construction. However, this short-term impact would not be considered
significant because the road would remain open during construction. Additionally, a Traffic
Control Plan would be prepared to address construction work hours, maintenance of pedestrian
facilities, and emergency vehicle access (See the Transportation and Traffic Section of this
Initial Study regarding the Traffic Control Plan). The proposed project would not affect any
schools or park facilities.
Local school buses use Cook Street as a travel route and may be delayed by construction
activities. As with other traffic in the area, the delays would not be substantial and construction
would be of a short duration. While the Desert Sands Unified School District (DSUSD) may
choose to re-route their school buses during the construction phase of this project as a result of
time constraints, this impact is temporary and would be considered less than significant.
Although impacts are expected to be less than significant, the following mitigation measure is
provided in order to reduce the nuisance impact of construction of the proposed project on
public services.
Mitigation Measures
MM 12-1 No less than four weeks prior to commencement of roadway demolition and
grading activities, the City of Palm Desert will provide notice to the County of
Riverside Fire Department, County of Riverside Sheriff's Department, and the
Desert Sands Unified School District indicating that they may experience delays
on the project roadway segment. Such notice will provide a schedule with the
expected duration of each construction task.
XIV. RECREATION. Would the project:
a) Increase the use of existing neighborhood and regional parks or other recreational
facilities such that substantial physical deterioration of the facility would occur or be
accelerated?
R9Projecls\HamsW004\IS-030508.tloc 31 Draft/nitial Study
WORKING DR4FT—NOT FOR PUBIIC DISTRIBUTION
Cook Street Drainage and Intersection Improvements
b) Include recreational facilities or require the construction or expansion of recreational
facilities which might have an adverse physical effect on the environment?
No Impact (Sections a & b). The proposed project would neither generate an increase in
population, nor would it increase tl5e demand for local or regional parks or other recreational
facilities. Furthermore, the proposed project does not include recreational facilities or require the
construction or expansion of any recreational facilities. No mitigation is required.
XV. TRAFFIC AND TRANSPORTATION. Would the project:
a) Cause an increase in tra�c which is substantial in relation to the existing tra�c load
and capacity of the street system (i.e., result in a substantial increase in either the
number of vehicle trips, the volume to capacity ratio on roads, or congestion at
intersections)?
b) Exceed, either individually or cumulatively, a level of service standard established by
the county congestion management agency for designated roads or highways?
c) Result in a change in air traffic patterns, including either an increase in traffic levels
or a change in location that results in substantial safety risks? �
d) Substantially increase hazards due to a design feature (e.g., sharp curves or
dangerous intersections) or incompatible uses (e.g., farm equipment)?
e) Result in inadequate emergency access?
f) Result in inadequate parking capacity?
g) Conflict with adopted policies, plans, or programs supporting alternative
transportation (e.g., bus turnouts, bicycle racks)?
No Impact (Sections a, b, c, d, f, and g), Less Than Significant Impact (Section e). Cook
Street is an existing north-south roadway designated as an "Arterial" (150-foot-wide right-of-
way) in the City of Palm Desert General Plan. Recent traffic counts on Cook Street documented
a daily traffic level of approximately 33,000 vehicle trips.
The primary objective of the proposed project is to provide intersection improvements at the
intersections of Cook Street at: Country Club Drive and at Hovley Lane. Portions of Cook Street
and Hovley Lane would be widened from their current configuration to their ultimate width.
Lanes would be widened but the current configuration would remain the same. The proposed
project is expected to improve traffic flow at the intersections. It would therefore be expected to
alleviate long-term traffic congestion on Cook Street. Therefore, the proposed project would be
expected to result in a minor reduction in tra�c volumes that could otherwise exceed the
capacity of the street system or Level of Service (LOS) standards established by Riverside
County and the City of Palm Desert.
To maintain traffic flow, project construction would be completed in several stages.
Improvements at Country Club Drive would be completed in 5 stages and improvements at
Hovley Lane would be completed in 6 stages. Traffic may be limited to one lane in each
direction during construction. Consequently, construction operations may result in traffic delays
on Cook Street and surrounding roads. Construction employee traffic would add up to 26 peak
hour trips per day. Construction vehicles (delivery and haul trucks) would add up to
approximately ten additional trips per day, The Contractor would submit a Traffic Control Plan to
the Public Works Department for review and approval (see SCA 15-1). This plan would address
construction hours, maintenance of pedestrian facilities and emergency vehicle measures, as
well as include measures to minimize potential traffic delays. The Traffic Control Plan would be
R:\PmJeclslHartisW004115-030508.tloc 32 Oraft Initial Study
WORKING OR4FT—NOT FOR PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
Cook StreetOrainage and/ntersecfion lmprovements
submitted and approved by the City prior to issuance of either grading or construction permits,
whichever occurs first. No further mitigation is required.
The proposed project site is located approximately two miles from the Bermuda Dunes Airport, a
general aviation facility which currerftly accommodates approximately 25,000 annual operations.
The project would allow for roadway and drainage improvements and would not affect air tra�c
patterns or levels. The current roadway configuration has no parking and none is proposed or
would be removed with project construction.
The roadway design does not contain any sharp curves. Furthermore, no land uses adjacent to
the proposed project site are incompatible with, nor would they become incompatible with one
another as a result of the proposed project.
The proposed project could result in constraints to local or regional emergency access. The
Traffic Control Plan would include specific measures for notifying emergency service providers
about roadway constraints during construction. The Traffic Control Plan would include specific
provisions relating to communications with the Desert Sands Unified School District about
construction-related roadway constraints.
Standard Conditions of Approval
SC 15-1 Prior to issuance of grading permits, the Construction Contractor must submit a
Traffic Control Plan to the Department of Public Works, which specifies (1) the
locations and dimensions of the construction work zone, staging areas, and
materials storage areas; (2) locations of construction signs, barricades and
delineators; (3) a schedule of road and/or lane closures; (4) a schedule of
construction work and subsequent traffic control duration; and (5) measures
designed to minimize tra�c delays and accommodate emergency vehicles.
XVI. UTILITIES AND SERVICE SYSTEMS. Would the project:
a) Exceed wastewater treatment requirements of the applicable Regional Water Quality
Control Board?
b) Require or result in the construction of new water or wastewater treatment facilities or
expansion of existing facilities, the construction of which could cause significant
environmental effects?
c) Require or result in the construction of new storm water drainage facilities or
expansion of existing facilities, the construction of which could cause significant
environmental effects?
d) Have sufficient water supplies available to serve the project from existing
entitlements and resources, or are new or expanded entitlements needed?
e) Result in a determination by the wastewater treatment provider which serves or may
serve the project that it has adequate capacity to serve the projecYs projected
demand in addition to the provider's existing commitments?
� Be served by a landfill with sufficient permitted capacity to accommodate the
projecYs solid waste disposal needs?
g) Comply with federal, state, and local statutes and regulations related to solid waste?
No Impact (Sections a, b, c, d, e, f, & g). The project proposes roadway and drainage
improvements and would not result in the need for new electrical or natural gas facilities,
R:Wm�ecis\HamsW004\IS-030508.tloc 33 Drak Initial Study
WORKING DRAFT—NOT FOR PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
Cook Street Drainage and lntersection Improvements
communication systems, local or regional water, or wastewater treatment and distribution
facilities, storm water drainage facilities, long-term water supplies, or long-term solid waste
services. In addition, it would not result in impacts that would exceed wastewater treatment
requirements. However, the relocation and extension of existing utilities and service systems
would be required. The utility relocations involving telephone, cable N, and water lines and
adjustments to Southern California Edison (SCE) vaults and/or power lines would be performed
by the individual utility companies. The coordination of the required relocation and extension of
facilities would be completed in advance between the appropriate Contractor and service
providers and agencies. The relocations of existing service systems as a result of the proposed
project would not result in additional impacts. No mitigation is required.
The Construction Contractor would be responsible for demolition and construction debris waste
disposal for the proposed project. Demolition and construction debris, including asphalt and
concrete from the existing roadway, would be recycled at the Granite Construction Company in
the City of Palm Desert. Additional, non-recyclable construction debris would be disposed of at
the Edom Hill Landfill or another operating landfill with sufficient permitted capacity to
accommodate the project's needs, including, but not limited to, the Badlands Landfill in the City
of Moreno. The proposed project would comply with federal, State, and local statutes and
regulations related to solid waste. No impacts are anticipated and no mitigation is required.
XVI. MANDATORY FINDINGS OF SIGNIFICANCE. Wouid the project:
a. Have the potential to degrade the quality of the environment, substantially reduce the
habitat of a fish or wildlife species, cause a fish or wildlife population to drop below
self-sustaining levels, threaten to eliminate a plant or animal community, reduce the
number or restrict the range of a rare or endangered plant or animal or eliminate
important examples of the major periods of California history or prehistory?
b. Have impacts that are individually limited, but cumulatively considerable?
("Cumulatively considerable" means that the incremental effects of a project are
considerable when viewed in connection with the effects of past projects, the effects
of other current projects, and the effects of probable future projects.)
c. Have environmental effects which will cause substantial adverse effects on human
beings, either directly or indirectly?
Less Than Significant (Sections a, b, 8� c). As identified in the Biological Resources
Section, the proposed project site is located in an urbanized area with vegetation consisting
primarily of ornamental plant species that provide low quality habitat for native wildlife species.
Project impacts would not substantially reduce fish or wildlife habitat; threaten to eliminate a
plant or animal community; or reduce the number or range of a rare or endangered plants or
animals.
As discussed in the Cultural Resources Section, the proposed project site is currently in a
developed condition and the potential for impacts to historic or prehistoric cultural resources
and/or paleontological resources is considered low due to the minimal grading and/or
excavation associated with the proposed project improvements. Furthermore, mitigation
provided would reduce the potential for impacts to historic or prehistoric resources to a level
considered less than significant.
As discussed in the Noise Section, the project would result in an increase in ambient noise
levels during construction. However, the project would comply with the City of Palm Desert
R:\Ptojecls\HarrislJ004\IS-03050B.tloc 34 Draft Inifial Study
WORKING DRAFT—NOT FOR PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
Cook Street Drainage and Infersection Improvements
Noise Ordinance during construction and long-term noise levels would not increase for
sensitive receptors upon project completion.
R:\Projecls\Hartis\J004\I5�030508.tloc 3S Draft Initial Study
WORKING DRAFT—NOT FOR PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
Cook Street Drainage and Intersecfion Improvemenfs
XVII. REFERENCES
California integrated Waste Management Board Solid Waste Information System (SWIS)
www.ciwmb.ca.gov/SW IS/.
City of Palm Desert. March 2004. Final General Plan.
City of Palm Desert. Municipal Code Title 25—Zoning: www.codemanage.com/palmdesert
CVAG Department of Finance. 2001. Regional Housing Needs Assessment.
Department of Mines and Geology. 2000. Seismic Hazards Maps.
Environmental Data Resources Inc. November 29, 2006. EDR Radius Map with Geocheck,
Portola Avenue Bridge, Palm Desert, CA 92260.
Newport Traffic Studies. February 9, 2006. Cook Street 24-Hour Traffic Volumes.
South Coast Air Quality Management District. 2006. Final Methodology to Calculate PM2.5 and -
PM2.5 Significance Thresholds.
Southern California Air Quality Management District. 1999. CEQA Handbook.
U.S. Department of Agriculture Natural Resources Conservation Service (NRCS). 1979. Soil
Survey of Riverside County, California, Coachella Valley Area.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (2000), Watershed Assessment Database
www.epa.gov/surf3/states/CA.
R:\Pro�ec�slHartisW004\IS-030508 Eoc 36 Draft Initial Study
WORKING DR4Ff-NOT FOR PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
APPENDIX A
RIGHT-OF-WAY ACQUISITION EXHIBITS
� N o
w
< g
� U �i^
N �pN
i-- o � a N�
Z2 �n � � gt
I �� II m � No �
� � � $�
Q j E
- - e �W `� ? � = �a
� W 3� �-l� B
� W�a g
W Z � � � O � � � � g
'� ? � aj � Q tt'`I � W W M � � � +,
� � X� Z F=�tt1 � �V' W�� ,Cy
� � W U Z l�M 2 li h G�
^ K � .. � ^ � C/2
M a � ¢N � ¢� O � � -
� p ¢ 30 ¢ 30 Q �
� � � I � I o
� a xoo Xoo ~ � ���
� O M O � � � �
Z o^0 I W �=O a = O �r^ ~ a � �
Q � Q�c�o Q�� = a o ���8
� � Q � � � � �� .
Z o � ��
N �. � W w
0 3 � � � �
W -�D'
� �� `� � w � � �
o"� o4 � �mo ❑
00~ U ��
� a� � a � `�' - - �
Q � � � �3 �I
� ; G (.s�) � �,o I
3 � .S9 F� ��o � � �
I �� �
c�O E (,l9) W� � Q
� � � I
X � ,LL N Q
w cr Q �Q � `- �
— Z vi
\ Q� � � — i � 2
�� Q ^Y �
�- °' �m� V W I :r
� � � � N JOQ (� O
� J � � a�x3 ^ `�
OV � a � �
U �
�
zm
�� , � o�P
�U� _ a � � � a�3
_- �¢ '��
�� wo m � �8�
_ �
� ��� : l i�am Y"�^ x � i�S
3 � I � W �
I
� i , �
�� � � Q
�� i. � I � �
� ! '; Lst) a>
,ss
L� m
� ! .L9 W � � �
� 3 i � � _ � � ����
z z � ' c� (� «f � ����
IFi� W : Z@I I � Rr � �C��
W
�
� N k� Q �q ��'tl
~ Z � � S
Z W (FiI � y
� FW X ci� _ _-1 C�
y)tn W �� 4
WW y Y � � �
� a a3 �3 � �
� � � �
� ao � �
I o a� G i- m h cW, a 1
'n � Il^ I w� o Q
N � / N ^ F ¢
a � Z m
� �
e � � � �� — __---I -- � � �
_ I � 3 � � � �
W Z
�yo, rc 33 � o�� wm
� / � � � ¢W3 Wb
> p� I o� �vWiW Z ..
o �>-
3 0� �`-' w�c�i 3
� am a� �ov� � .
C�O i ( Kj XO
�F RU �I-
� � � � R
W` K S � I Q2
\ �
� I
Z \
� �
' J �
�,
� �I
�
i
I
ti
ZW
i ?
� �
2�
I' ' Y �.W
Qa
� woa
� ' � �_�
O WC>W
� � Z �Km
�� �` I
u � i
Wd 6£:£0:: BOOZ/Ct/L 'bmP'A15 l!Q!4xa MOiI c:nlJ F�lunoJ\RWnop xG�4K3 M@J\(tPL500-L90)laanS Noo��Y>>a0 wlod��H
I
M
I F O
Q 5
� O y^
F- N ��
ZZ -W'� a �+�
}J V�II �e
¢� cn� °i� �t
V�1 � I ¢a �(y� � a g�
�s W � S �i
� � ' c� � Woa =
o I �
� '' ~m � �~� '� W �
cnm � � pw� � 3
a � w� � Z ��m �
x o� �- .+�
a� I �' aw=rn � �
c��r
� Li.l ¢ z �Ni y �, -
Z Q �
� Y
�
O
� �W � � Z \ Q ; �j_
U � $
�
OWW Q Q � � � _ ��•��
a X
o �� � � �' � ����
� � (,s�J � o � ��
�
�
� 3 .�5 �o
�n
Q C�o N t �99) c� - - �
� .99 �
�= 1
�
W� � Y ��' I
¢
3
W 3 C�
3 � �o � a,� �, � �' c� Q
N � I
� I �- � � � Z
�� a � � I � z ��� �
� �
k� ; � Y o � w� 3 Z �
w� � O v�'i W � � z
i� o� � °_ � _ ,- �
N o�..'.-C 3� a L_ _ _ _� N
r — -, :
�3
-- I �� v�
� �V J� �!--- 1l—
a 3� � —��
� W ¢
W� � � W� � /;
�Z am Ozm n
pQ �� � �w ¢ � ,
=J a �
I a� 3o
� N o
w
� a �
=V�j � 'g U v�i^
� O
� ��M � N ��
p� a y�
I � � � J� � ��
� W Q N II � � � $�
Q2� � � a j e
Op = a a
_ ��_�� _ � \ _ �
i �� �z c� X �
� �� =J J � �
� � � �
�
� � — � �
� �
w �- �� zW � " "
� �¢ Z �L Q �
� � �� O U ��'yT
� � � � � ? �S�
3
� � � ~ M Qa � � � f1��
x� x � o W3� = a � � -��
w� W�� Q a o woa C� � '���
o ��W � o � ��`
� W �� �o
Gsti) z � M Z � �m _,_,
.�
U
•JCJC � J�- J
�54) Q �"3 a
� ,£'9 0
�~ J 1 N
� S Q
�
� U' � Q �K W I O
I O � 03 \ � 1 a
o� o _ ` `� � �
Y �� �. _
� a� am - �
O � r,�'"��J
� m N
I � U v '� Q
�Qe �3 Q Q
�Q� zo tO � Q M � O ''
`� .. � i
I as�c, x� o v j W
i ��
� � � � N
� c� - - � —
� , � � M
N p
, � a _
I � I— `$ U v'�—
� ` I ¢�� N �m
� N
K Q
N
d' �
� OW^ �� $f o.0
�
N
I � aZ3 N�i � � � g�
� a0 � _ �a
o —
° w \ X �
� Gss) s W �I �
�.55) � J �-
-r..�
� W ,Z9 � � %�
I � p e� �, _
. � = y� ZZ � Q o
W � �� � � � �� � � ���
� �I ��� � '�W � � _ �
cn � � �o = �, o ����
� I N .. � � = c� � w ����
o �
�.�ti� , � o w �W � �,� �
� .sti Z z � �m �
i Gssa Q � �
�1¢
e W3
I a� ��, � 1�
�
Y
� �' a� cn � w 11
' 3 0� mZ � ¢ o v' Il
1 o v,�y � w � o � °0 1
in om� �� Z � ¢ _ —
� �� � ¢ `" � _ I
�U i X W O
W � v1 ^ iV
N � M
O �
� T � p I Q
1 � I ,—�i 3 � � � Q
� O i Z p � � p � � I�-'.
�� la" � �' � � 2
L�
I � WK w � I vJ
� � � > � �
� � I c� - - --� —
� I } � ~ N �
U � � _ _ �W - � Y�l �.� � Q �
v--� II rg' U 'h'�
� �O a ___— O� � N ��
� Vl S � I_----- � 'Q y c�
—�- x� a � � a� dS '��
�- G 3 „
�� � � � 8�
� � W� � w � ^ e
I- � - �� m € = �a
Z .. � �
c� � � c��- F- �'3
I �o�� ti3 ZZ � � �LJ �
�n�� cn >- =� X O
WU� WO Q1- �f-
�t_ 2 �'- -i-�
2 >'W �- � Q S�
.Z� � �o ¢� �
� F- � Ce]
.6£'� . '9 Q w�-a � � � -
titi .� �l °^' 3 �� w I� LL Q o
S9 � p � � � � \ O = ���
` Y v�i Z �� m J � � � � �
I -' W = a a ����
W W � O V w ���tl
a � 0 � � � ��~�
� � � a
a � � �
N ��
�o �
Q a � h a J�
J W c� Q �3 J
am a� 3
a� '
ac� p3 a� F j
�.� � 1
I
I � a� — ir) — �-- - - - -J=� _ _�
� � � s �
C� cO ^
� N —
� m � _ Q
�
U � J �3 � Q
� c� �-� ¢ � � � N
�L! � ' �3�3 2� � � "' N I O z
S� I x �' �W �_ " � �
p W W� w� 1 U
_ � �—� �
i I � c� - -�-- -
Q1 I �-- � I � N o
U � W _ _ �W � �il ''�� `O Q �
v— �� �'�' c� v�—
� v�i= � i_---- -- �� � a ��
—�- x� a t
I �+. � d1 � o
_ �— �� t� N
-- Op�j -/� w � gE
I � �, W�t W € S "�n'.
Z� T �
Z�� Z¢ � W Q3 � �
I i=m� �3 ZZ �� �LJ
X �� X� Q �y� O� `
W U W� �t- a= T -I-�
x �- w a�' �+
.z� � 3p Q� Q a�
� � �s rn
,s� . 's � W � a p Q � -
titi� 'l � 3 � � W W LL o
s's � � �' i � C� O �.,, 3 ��_
' Y v�i Z t=-� m J � � � ����
I '� W = a o ���g
J � o��
a � / a � o � ���LL
�"� N �o
a � � � +�
N ��
� rp �
Q { � � a ��-
J pW c� ¢ N 3 J
� J
am a� 3 i
�� WQ �� Z �
� � 0 3 a'� � I
o� X �
i a�
� �
� � _ �n _ �—_____�_� - -�
�
�
� � � �o r.
� � —�
� ¢� v — 'Q
I
U � � �3 � Q
C� �\ C� �-�¢ y � � N
W � ' �3� 3 z� � v �`' i� Z �
I O z
� � k � �W vFi= � I �
p '�' wo w� 1 U
� � - -'� - — �
i � �'
APPENDIX B
AIR QUALITY EMISSIONS CALCULATIOiV WORKSHEETS
E
m
m
N OI
C N
° " E
v v
y T N N N O h N y T N N N O N O
N N
p 9 O Q y o
> a � y
'rn o 'rn o
LL a � LL f d
� a �
m m
¢ n
(/1 N
N a O (7 t�J � C') � � y T O � � V il
N N
N 9 G y ry y O s
X � ` % y j
W '� W y
o � o d
� 3 a 3
a
`o `o
`m `m
a o _
� � w m .- m n E a N y� .t .- a a E
m � � m m �
a a � a o c
a � c rn � �c
- E � '� E �
o c = o c =
a � c f E `
E a � E
' '
N O N O
O 1� t0 r �- d V O O N d U
� V V N V �- � C A N N �- N W � C
V t7 � �� 'O N � �C
a � o m � o
_ E s v E t
O o w o �
N K H
Z O O Z O O
V N V N
N Iq
j� M N O� N m j �E j� � CJ N O n'J O j �E
q ln d� N N O �p � � N N �- N O) �p �
N N d N N d �
a io o' rn m a'
N c s � " � y
N m � O �°+ �
O
� V � 'm U � '�
N Q1 T O O O C� O 1N � � N T O N V N � � � �
m
; � 9 � o � y � 9 0 � y
> ,/� >
U� .L] O� (O � � � � K V, Y 0 fO N O N � K
� O � N E N O O N a N
0 p O O
o U � ;, � U � ` E
C N �
C A A A A A A 9 � /� � A A A A � �
� 1 �
C O d L d N � A N O N L N N � � N
� � } 0 .�. v'O m N � � T p �0 W o � N
N y N E � T � c N a�i � E ,c t v c
y `o 0
£ E u oi ¢` � r ° � E a � rn m � E o �
�o m
W N a m ° � m £ n p " N o ° j Q � y � "
C W "c a ° a � a w v � c W r a �n a � m .o a � c
O C � A y . y o 3 C c A � � o � x o 3
O ❑ N O A O N p
G uf � � a � o a F m o. E N u1 U � ,�'p ? C a m 'p d E w
� a u E c
� W � � O y N ` E N � C g � � N 1� N ~ `� 6 N �
C N 9 � � � C N � N � N W N 9 � � O � N E E N N
m c m = o o m �R m �' E d c m = - rn « � �o :; E
(� � r � % � n � z � F�- E o t � K � � m o E N m m
a � W � E � '- a � W � E � Z � � E o
� a a � c c E � o a m a ` c c E E � � d a
� O � N � N N O `G O O 3 N 1` q � q o �0
� a` C� i9 ❑ a E f- a F a` <9 !9 ❑ a � t°- a h°
m T C
p � 3
C 3 p
� � � . .
O �
ll j E y
m a y t
� L N jp
U � � d
� N
V � �
� � C �
6 �y �
;T2a
C � � �
�' � � N T
� U c a_
� H� m
a
p J�? oa3
� Q O
'-
_ �ry 2
O �� W w
2
�" �
��.: cz
V =,
w Q�
- �
y m C
� o
- a a
V N O
o d
O N R
� ` N
N �
a E o
o w m
`m = y u
c
o � 2 N � a
`� � N m c E
N � J U W a
N � N N s j N�
C m O � � � .t..
,� a a v v � � � � N L
O Ol
m o � (7 � y o � � E o
> 10 3 m v c � y m m m m � � u�i �
E E E v 'a � � '°
� z �° m` ` in 3 m w w w m m m r o�a�o
W � w m E .= �i ci .= ni ri �E m m �Z a. a.o `a
�
° «
T
a
" " a
� v a
w W
�p L N p N (p �- C N P O m N 'O
ry � O
- °o E
� U u
IG > m a
N N �
d U A
- � V
d O T � O �
�C a Q `n
O � = �
� o � � � d
L � U �u
y � o c
C � ,1°' a ` a.
O � � o �
.N N o
Vi °�' " o `+i �
0
C G 1] O �m N N y
G V N G c E � � N
W � ._ i 5 � d v q
C L a S V � W W T �
� y .'._". c .p �' � a w o `o
V �- � � '-" a E �' ° y >, '^
O ' - N ? 9 y � : A a a 4
� LL � C. Ip V
f�q ' � - ' � _ _ �= o m p d � 'd^
G � V c o y U
Q �, $ .� � ,a, � m 2 rn t ¢ y � �
a � _v E m
V C c j 9 � y � o o c w v Q � � � ' c
'a � K m o m ao'. z u H U . � � 'o � � o. a. m E
l6 a. �� o o � � m m m v $ K m � x `v � W E° �
O (0 o n _o = n o o 'o 'o' m ' 'o o � `0 'o 'o > .mc
�.' O z O :.. 5 a` U a` a` a` O a` �- � 3 m m a i-
N O O O O
o O O O O
� O O O O
O O O O
O O O O
O O O O
e
O O O O O N
o O O O O m m
� O O O O �
O O O O O h O O
O O O O � p o 0
O O O O 6
0
$ O O 0 O N O � 0 N
a O O O O � U ^ o 0
� O O O O �
c
O O O O O � O N % m m ry
p m v � � � m O � � Z m � o
U � V � O N N O � j
t d m �-
� U A
o' y
0
h
U
v
�
c o 0 0 0 0 0 0 ,y � in � o
.c �o �a o o n o
a a o o �i N �i � d A � o � o
`m
ai m � `m �
'o p' a io p' m
n U O
� U d c
� � � �
r o c' o
o� U � N
d K
v U
¢ td.�
D
`v m
n � y
° a ` c
- � o
O 'b •y
a' c� y
g p�, _ •E �
° C � W �',
m O �, @ OI .—��..
E V � C '^ d _
N ` m a m 7 . 9 E n
'� I�p a10i o in = v c � o
U '- �
rn O a i "' g _ a >''N H g >` 2
¢ c � : "; O 's '° !-^ m a c
sU � '�yf � � N a c a E w t0 a �
F �' o+ o� m c o = v w a a
c � c . � � � � � � y ?
o � �° 10 m' o � � � o m m £ o 0
z t9 c9 � a f- _ � E � > x w a h
N N n m f ` N N N
mf
O P N O O O O O O O O O O O€O O r O O O O O O
a o 0 o d d d d d d d d o elP�e a o � o � o � o
u � i
� v
m v
> v
� €
~ ~ Io v
� (
Q I() ^ (O O O N O N O N (O N N N Q N � O � O �- O
U � � N O Oi O Oi O Oi O O � ,0 . �.. U � O � O � O �
� j N
> > '
O �
m � Ja v
�
O � I '
d =
� �
N OjNiQiN.N�� % N O O � O � O e` O O ' V t � % t+l e` O r' O � O
� �I � � i Z O O O O O O O O O O .� Y fl`�� 2 (O � O � O � O
m i � � � i �
� i i � f�-
N �
F � 3 ( � � E v i �
m (
� I j i ` ! E o I
( i � � o n ( �
li, � � , e
I � m a i I I
� u
y � ,ty�M M (� O N N O h O N O 1p O O m �^. : (� 1p O O O O O O
x � O m `° o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 � ; O ^ o � o � o �
3 q � o � Q .. y o 0 0 0
> � � i
� , A )
O � : w y
q �
U � � � � 5
� �
� � � p O
o O E U d `
t ` E a t
� � U . � � . , m � 5 , �:
p o Z
�
5 LL � -
u
- N J °�
m C d
a O a d � � y m
_ � C y
" yyj oi U'� m ° � @ d C o, ° � l�
'o . 5 0
m � `m � c v i a a c 'N � m i a v
.o d o N v U c � y y°', y y U `� � _
{L U ' � = o K N o � �p o tll �
" � v m �' a J > 2� °� j n I1,J " D m `m �a u m
N £ � W � � a � � � � � m Y c � � a c� .� = m
> y �' m rn m a c fl o� t7 a O a 4 � V � s a v �' 'U2 � � u �
� c � � a � � 7 � rn �
� O 2@ �@ 'm � � 2 o m $ 'm o > o a F- � W a E a o a o � o
� (� c q (7 U' o a � � U, a V, a � a a a � � GI � � N 10 U, a U'� a � a
5 N a. E v o°�i a°1i a °i � m m m `m 'm „ m H 2 v �' a 1° : �' m -' ' '' ' ''
E � ; n o 0 0 o m d a a v a � 'c � � � = v a "' a " a '"
B 0 � a. E E E E � � o- � o. � o. " o. " � � � rn � m � o. � � � � "
Y 3 0` �a m m v m `o_ o ,o o. a a a n a n d � c A ° n �' n a n
`o `o `o `o � y c c y v ? D 'm a a a
m � � c m c m c �
� o 0 o d �E �E o' o o' o 'a `o 'o o `� 1° `� E o' o 'o `o o' o
3 E o` z z z z w w a ti a � a F a �- 9 � c� i� o w a � a � a ti
0 o c g o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
� o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o p a
� a o 0 0 0 o d o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o d d o 0 0 0 0 0
a �
c
'o
n
>. o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
p m o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o a
Z a o 0 0 o c o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
'o
n
� o � .- O o 0 o a o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
a o o U A o a o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
�
E o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o a o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
a a
�
a o
�
c
0
�'o c'�o U, � g g o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 -�
� y � o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o a o 0 0 0 0 o c o
� � a o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o c o 0 0 0 0 0
a a
c
'o o'
n n
�)!
� ` I d a
p V A E � o 'a
d � N �' t �' W c
m ! m 'a t�' � u o 'c d m
- v - L' w ` n
^ Q � oi � S ` °rn a 1= � E o '- m o
m c � 'o > >, b .9 a � 'v a .
❑ E i K `o A d K K '° c 'v. '° � � m d a,
� 1 � N � � � o' c 3 '�u. H ' �e a a x `m d � d � � a � � � � y �
� � m T m o 0 o N@ 2 0 � o L° o � � m' m o oi � L" � 'o a
.._I___ r m m o a o 0 0 o w LL c9 � O o a a � rn i'n in w r- r n _
a
� c'
� � � u m
`o '''^ � v' `-' E
m � � � � m = > `�,
c °� 4 u, � W
� °1 d u O d �
> r �t :
T a
U O 6 �,; .: f E o'
� � L Z a
� o _�;,�. �,
U c
n N
`� m O
C V N
c w •N _
a+ °' N -
N °� ^ � >
� 7 A m
� QG m � � � W `o
•+ `-
n � U 'm v E d E
o � � � Z
1 `m '� - c p_ -
� rn
m > c rn rn � 7 5 y
a+ 'a c � .o a �`n �
= a .� _ �jJ _v o
v � � � o` E 'a �
a LL N c c
_ y - � � p � d
> > c
a' � � � m � � O
� > i i `� a
_ _ _ _ o O n
rn 'm 'm y. �
ti 11 LL LL O U�
O T 0 O O O O O O O P O O 0 O N O O O � N O O O O n �
m m o 0 0 0 0 0 o m o o m o � o 0 o w N O O O O N O
� E O O O O C O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O
a a
�
0
K o 0 0 0 0 0 o n o 0 o M o o a m n o 0 0 o m a
O A � o 0 0 0 0 0 o c o 0 0 o c o 0 o rn m o 0 0 0
2 a 6 0 0 o d d d d d o o � o m o d o N N d d d d c � -
a �
c
0
0
a. o 0 0 0 0 o c o 0 0 0 o ry o 0 o m o 0 0 0 o m m
U a c o 0 0 0 0 0 o c4i o o in o m o 0 0 �o m o 0 0 o a
� N O O O O O O O (O O O V O OO O OO C (C � O O O O C
O
6
� TI� O O O O O O O O O N O m O p O Q N O O O O !O N
m m o 0 0 0 0 0 0 � o o m o 0 0 o m m o 0 0 0 � p
� � o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 �- o 0 0 o N o 0 0 oi o 0 0 0 0
o'
v a
; E � a
y n m y N W ..
m w F � s o � � E a
- '� t d 2 '"' a n n
g ' rn a r E m �- "o
`" o o a T 2 n 9 � Q o
� ` `� d � ft' m w 9 � w v d
v .� P' u F m o � o W `a m° � a' � c n
m s � � E c 3 u'�i H 'm � °' a x `m m � w �' � a `° u ° K n
i. " ` `o o 10 t0 2 0 " `o `0 0 � � m 'm 'o � rn � �v a m c
1- m m V U U U U O w t� (9 � O O a a K ri) ln N N I- f- E 3
0 0
m m
o `m
v E
> �
`o �
a �
E e
i n
.- .- o � � .-
a
U
C
7
O
N
E
z'
'm
d
c �
0 0
R d
q E
H d
w p
a
c
v
m
i�
0 0 0 o a o 0 0 0 0 o m o 0 0 0 0 o n � o 0 o m �
N O O O N O O O O O O N O O O O O O � O O C N p
a � O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O
9
O
6
% T O O S Q $ O O O O O A S O O O O O m n O O p � N O
Q N O O
Z � O O O T O O O O O O � O O O O O O N V O O O N V
C
O
n
p r o 0 o a o 0 0 0 0 o e o 0 0 0 0 o M o 0 o m n m
U N O O O � O O O O O O � O O O O O O 0 N O O O � � p
� O O O O O O O O O O N O O O O O O N M O O O M M
O
6
O O O m O O O O O O O O O O O O O m � O A N N
ON O O O O O O O O O O N O � O O p p O O A � p
E O C O N O O O O O O � O G O O O O m � O O O O
� 9
�
O
6
N d
N a � D W �
m
� � Q F � j O C H � 9
W � 6
� a F � E `� � ¢ p
m o' " o o' >. .� a a � 'v
v K � o � m o K° K 3 o W m � W m 9 a
� � `m m m c d
m ` u " �' c � m `v � ` a a S `a � � v m c a '° u " y m
U E N N Y N N � L N N O OI j � d N
F Gl Rl U U U U U ❑ W I�i f'J � O O p, p. R' N N � 41 F- r E �
N N
u N
N �
1 �
`o E
a �
E e
z a
N
N
J
O
N
E
m Z
D r
N j
m �
a d
� o
N a
a d
_ E
� v
a �
rn
N
C
q
O
o a o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o c o 0 0 o m m e o a o 0 0 o n o �
m o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o m m ry o a o 0 0 0 � o 0
� ? o 0 o d 6 0 0 0 0 0 o d d d d o d d d c d d 6
a 9
c
Qo 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o m m � o 0 0 0 o ry � H
� o a o a o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o ry a o m o 0 0 0 o N
Z a o 0 0 o d d d c d o d c d o n n v o N o 0 0 o n
a
c
p r o 0 o a o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o n o 0 0 0 0 0 � M �
V a o 0 o a o 0 0 0 o a o 0 0 o w � w o � o 0 0 o f o N
a00000000000000 > � � 0 � 0000
0
a
� m0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o M m m o � o 0 0 o m � �
o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o m n � o m o 0 0 o N d d
� � o o d d o 0 0 0 0 0 o d d d d o 6 c c c d o d
a
0
ri
; E � Q
�
in a t v w �
m 'v ti �' o o c m E
w
" ° ° O1 a � 2 n a o Q a o
_ � � O T � -
d' N
� � d N F � N � C "c U N al � (L v C � v N 6
p `w � rn x a t `m
m r d " E c 3 m d � �e a � x t > '> m � '° N t � � c y
>, ` ` `o o L° N 2 0 0 �° x m m o � a o
rn 9 m v o
H m m U U U U U O W LL U' � O O 2 a fL N 41 41 N F i-
N W
V N
= E
> v
`o E
a p,
E Q
i a
�
�
U
L
� �
6
O C
O
a �
�
Z c
� V
N `y
N
❑
O D
N
� O
� E
c w
g m
�0 O
a �-
� T
N V
� � m w w w m m m m w m m m m m m m m m m m m m
A 'o
m Z
❑
�
`o
� j ry in � m � m � rn N rn �n �n � m � �o rv '� m m m o
� � LL 1� I� V N I� In � Q V t0 Yl N Q d. N � 0 l N [Y y � �
- � o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 � o o m
a m �
0
L O J p
N a "
� a
� w
c
v
m .-. c
N d m
W L W
p� a N
O d v
¢ �
�A
H O
W
� m Z
ry x E
U C O
aN tn
�O j y` a O
� � 3 y N
M > O N pJ OI Q N W � N Q W m � ` W � � �y N (O a A m N W
N H
U � `o a o
= p � � o
V y
O �
- � U
V
O O T 4n
� C
> � Q
(J N
0 9
`m
ra m E
a V O
� N
L � m
C � �
M
` m '¢ A a
� A LL
° o o m
� a � m
a U
U S m d
Q x W
O 'a �j F-
W
d O a � W
S
t O E v y
� Q o }
° � E m r�n � n F
`o0 3 � .o' u E � m Z
;� q n m w < ` � .. ° > o W
m 'a � x v .., o N o L' d m C u m Q
'"'`" o W 1�- F2- E c � � m �' v a o. t Q
� K � @ a` m �' 2 5 � d n �O � w o � a 0
c E .� � ~ c o@ rn � U W � ~ ~ �" m a°�i c � `m � � n° O
a � @ v d ._ m w @ o� L' .c d `m v . U ..
'' v 3 L a S 2 d m � m rn a a m c N `0 � ,:° ,:,;a 10 �
'Q v o `o m m � � m � ,�' c m' 'm o 'o a `o rn a � m a d y rn Z
W W p] U U U U � U'� O O O a a fL 2' K K 4J UI i� N f �- � 0 41 W
,"..��..� Celebrofing
�mmxnm
C O N S U L T 1 N G '°9°-'c°6
An EnvlronmeNol Piann�ng/Rc�sclrca .
Monogemert!Corporotion ,
._� /, ,
�_`� December 1, 2006
Mr. Ehab Gerges ViA EMAIL AND MAIL
Harris &Associates egerges�harris-assoacom
750 "B" Street, Suite 1800
San Diego, California 92101
�� Subject: Biological Constraints Suroey for the Cook Street Restriping Project in
the City of Palm Desert, Riverside County, California
Dear Mr. Gerges:
This letter report presents the findings of a biologicai constraints survey for the
Cook Street project site (hereafter referred to as the project site) in the City of
Palm Desert, Riverside County, California (Exhibit 1). BonTerra Consulting Senior
Scientist Dr. Michael Robson conducted a general plant and wiidlife survey on
,�� ;- i' October 11, 2006. The purpose of the survey was to evaluate potential biological
,t ���� ��� constraints to development of the project site. Focused surveys for special status
1�--
__��--�� plant or wildlife species were not included in this survey effort. The California
Native Plant Society's (CNPS) Inventory of Rare and Endangered Vascular Plants
of California (CNPS 2006) and California Department of Fish and Game's (CDFG)
California Natural Diversity Database (CNDDB) (CDFG 2006) were reviewed prior
to the survey to identify special status plants, wildlife, and habitats known to occur
in the vicinity of the project site. Database searches included the U.S. Geological
{., . Survey (USGS) Myoma and La Quinta 7.5-minute quadrangles.
�!/�' /' PROJECT LOCATION
�f�.;,
The project invofves the restriping of lanes and shouiders along a three-mile
section of Cook Street between Fred Waring Drive and Frank Sinatra Drive
(Exhibit 2). The project site is located o� the USGS Myoma and La Quinta
I51 Kc,;m�,s D ��e 7•5-minute topographic quadrangle maps on portions of Township 5 South;
Range 6 East; Sections 3, 4, 9, 10, 15, and 16. Topography on the project site is
Su!i� E.200 relatively flat with a range in elevation from approximateiy 160 to 280 feet above
mean sea level. Cook Street crosses the Whitewater River just north of Fred
G.s!c Pd�eso Waring Drive. Surrounding land uses indude commercial, residential, and
ornamental. The project site is located within the proposed Coachella Valiey
Coi�Po�o r 92b26 Multipie Species Habitat Conservation Plan area.
� (71 n,� q44-9199 �
!' '�I 44%1-9j9� lax
�rr�.w_k;onie�rcccnsulhn�:_corc�
Mr. Ehab Gerges
December 1, 2006
Page 2
EXISTING CONDITIONS
Veqetation Tvqes and Other Areas
The project site consists of an existing roadway. Vegetation along the road that may be
impacted by the proposed project includes smoke tree (Psorothamnus spinosa), oleander
(Oleandersp.), and fan paim (Washingtonia sp.). Adjacent vegetation that is not expected to be
impacted by the proposed project includes Spanish needles (Palafoxia arida), plicate tiquilia
(Tiquilia plicata), broad-leaved cattail (Typha latifolia), puncture vine (Tribulus terrestris), fig
(Ficus sp.), gum (Eucalyptus sp.), and pine (Pinus sp.).
Wildlife Habitat
Given the developed nature of the project site and vicinity, there is limited habitat for native
wildlife species. The only reptile species observed in the vicinity of the project site was side-
blotched lizard (Uta staosburiana). Bird species observed in the vicinity of the project site _
inciude American kestrel (Faico sparverius), kilideer (Charadrius vociferus), Anna's
hummingbird (Calypte anna), black phoebe (Sayornis nigricans), common raven (Corvus corax),
verdin (Auriparus flaviceps), northern mockingbird (Mimus polyglottos), European starling
(Sturnus vulgaris), common yellowthroat (Geothlypis trichas), song sparrow (Melospiza
melodia), and Brewer's biackbird (Euphagus cyanocephalus). Mammal species observed in the
vicinity of the project site include desert cottontail (Sylvilagus audubonii). No fish or amphibian
species were observed in the vicinity of the project site.
Special Status Habitat
No Special status habitats were observed on the project site. The adjacent Whitewater River is
Iikely under the jurisdiction of U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) and/or CDFG. Regulatory
permits or agreements from these agencies would be required prior to the alteration of USACE
and CDFG jurisdictional areas.
Special Status Saecies
Plants or wildlife may be considered to have "special status" due to declining populations,
vulnerability to habitat change, or restricted distributions. Certain special status species have
been listed as Threatened or Endangered under state and/or federal Endangered Species Acts.
Special Status Plants
Several special status plant species are known to occur in the vicinity of the project site. One of
these species is federally and/or state-listed Threatened or Endangered species: Coachelia
Valley milk-vetch (Astragalus lentiginosus var. coachellae). This species is not expected to
occur on the project site due to lack of suitabie habitat.
Severai CNPS List 18 and �ist 2 species have been reported by the CNDDB in the vicinity of
the project site. These species may meet the criteria in Section 15380 of the California
Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), which states that if a species meets the definition of
Threatened or Endangered, it may be treated as such under CEQA. However, these species
are not expected to occur on the project site due to lack of suitable habitat.
Mr. Ehab Gerges
December 1, 2006
Page 3
CNPS List 3 and List 4 species are not considered constraints on development because
impacts on these species are typicaliy considered less than significant under CEQA. These
species are not expected to occur on the project site due to lack of suitable habitat.
Special Status Wildlife
Several special status wildiife species are known to occur in the vicinity of the project site. Two
federaily or state-listed Threatened or Endangered species are known to occur in the vicinity of
the project site: desert pupfish (Cyprinodon macularius) and Coachella Valley fringe-toed lizard
(Uma inornata). These species are not expected to occur on the project site due to lack of
suitabie habitat. Other species that may meet the criteria in Section 15380 of the CEQA are not
expected to occur on the project site due to lack of suitable habitat.
Otherlssues
Wildlife Movement -
The project site consists of an existing road and is, therefore, not expected to function as a
wildlife movement corridor. The project improvements are not expected to impede wildlife
movement through corridors crossing the project site, including the Whitewater River Crossing.
Migratory Bird Treaty Act
Ornamental plantings immediately adjacent to the project site have potential to support nesting
birds. The Migratory Bird Treaty Act (MBTA) prohibits activities that result in the direct take
(defined as the killing or possession) of a migratory bird or its eggs. Therefore, if construction
activities expected to impact nesting habitat (i.e., ornamental and/or native trees or shrubs) are
initiated during the nesting bird season (March 15 to September 15), a pre-construction survey .
is recommended. This is not expected to be a significant constraint on the proposed project.
Nesting Raptors
Trees immediately adjacent to the project site have potential to be used for nesting by raptors.
Regulations prohibit activities that "take, possess, or destroy" any raptor nest or egg (CDFG
Code 3503, 3503.5, and 3513). Therefore, if construction activities expected to impact nesting
habitat are initiated during the raptor nesting season (February 1 to June 30), a pre-construction
raptor survey is recommended. This is not expected to be a significant constraint on the
proposed project.
RECOMMENDATIONS
In order to reduce potential adverse effects on water quality in the adjacent Whitewater River, it
is recommended that the project contractor implement Best Management Practices required by
the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES, Environmental Protection
Agency), administered by the Regional Water Quality Control Board.
In order to avoid potential impacts on nesting birds, vegetation clearing activities on the project
site should occur outside the peak nesting season (February 1 to August 30). If vegetation
clearing occurs between March 15 and September 15, a Biological Monitor shouid conduct a
pre-construction survey of the project alignment to identify any active nesting locations.
Restrictions may be placed on construction activities in the vicinity of any active nest observed
until the nest is no longer active as determined by a qualified biologist.
Mr. Ehab Gerges
December 1, 2006
Page 4
A survey for active raptor nests is recommended seven days prior to commencement of any
construction activities during the raptor nesting season (February 1 to June 30). Restrictions
may be placed on construction activities in the vicinity of any active nest observed until the nest
is no longer active as determined by a qualified biologist. Typicaliy, a 300- to 500-foot buffer
zone is designated around a nest to allow construction to proceed while minimizing disturbance
to the active nest. Once the nest is no longer active, construction can proceed within the buffer
zone.
Please contact Samuel Stewart at (714) 444-9199 if you have questions or comments.
Sincerely,
BONTERRA O ULTI �
�:��ti , �
�< , �v ;�
,+�`l�f�" (��11i�'.'�Y� �.1. � {'� "(-0.' -
Sar�el C. �te� rt IV �-'Dr. Mike . Robsbn
Project Man�'ger Senior Sc�e'ntist
„
Attachments: Exhibits 1 and 2
RAPmjectW arrisV004\Constraintsd20106.dx �
REFERENCES
California Department of Fish and Game (CDFG) Natural Diversity Database. 2006. California
Natural Diversitv Database. Records of Occurrence for USGS Myoma and La Quinta
7.5-minute quadrangles. Sacramento, CA: CDFG, Natural Heritage Division.
California Native Plant Society (CNPS). 2006. Electronic Inventory of Rare and Endangered
Vascuiar Plants of California. Records of Occurrence for USGS Myoma and La Quinta
7.5-minute quadrangles. Sacramento, CA: CNPS. http://www.cnps.org(inventory.
���°�"'��a`.���..�.� '��������rt s; v �t�' �. .r �. �e ^ s w r=
.� y .r t^ x +` ,� .�,
,�^�„�°'�T` '�`� � , f r .�. . r,
��b� -`,��`�:^�y �K. : ��"r r , '*' .�'Y�"t'��� 1e ��" '�f* ., � r
� �.
H .� ,+ �������"� „ �
�.�,��^, G�s �,� � �` � �"�"s � � ��d�`�.'".a' f '
r""�'t .3,�.<� � -" . P�d"��� ,.. 3 3�3 r;�" ..i� m: �,� � � 4
,..�..,,Rpncncit�,� y�,,. ..�SxJ'���,� $` r-� .s ,�- ,� � k� s�.u` - ,' ;.
� d.
'�Cucamonga �= 7 r � �,� e x,,r�'-*r`�� � � � . ,:
:�tk-e;- �7 � � �^
30 ' d-�'�"` c`'�` � .w �. ;��a`���r„ " ,✓� " 3' r/---u•
- "?Ff.�' ,. 3"� ;: c�.� 5e � �e,�e ? �,,, e y�"6 .
atai(a . San Bernardmo � .a.r9��,;1� �r ..w ���,� �E`���'�����k�``���s �, : .: { .
OntaAa �••' r�.»��"`.��������.��� � �.,, ,�i J ' � a
: �` x �� r� ✓ §'�' :
� � YucalPa �� :3� „Fy '� � � �, sut ..z, c a d �.
�� " ed�antla §"x .�'��l�i ��a-z'..�'-�`�+��:�:' � " �"� �r�s F�,�� a E���
: Rrvers�de t . ` ,�, � i�= x.�f �..�ra�"�� � "� ;`�*��` '`r
5� a r = * .,zr i � ��,{ Ya-?-�"r"x i�`"Sr� �`�a�� .v w
�` „a '` ..��us :"u ¢�i��m ��i��''�� �'�'�� '��� `^rr�-� i
'a .� � -� � �� 6o r �'. "� � m � P :'.,E'� ..«.:, r�� t s.� ��
, ' •,--_._ \ : r
a ' ���'
�'�K Moreno Valley ' t �
� �
, � •�{ f � M � y v�'
�Corona ;�� La6e �.. � ;� � �, ,�c' � �'�'s t "'` �_
.8 � ' �e����
s
]9 + �
�� f("alrvw" Panls ,� �r ,� ' � ��� <'�s+ i�:`�T�' � �`
�Spe � f� r��'� �' tr' . f,� .el'�P �,���� � . �
� 3M �: ..d � Y, -�'� .. �3< '��,��� ,�""�,w
� � � �
' � .c �^�.+- f jY
� ` € �,�� s �' ..: � `x � �" r�� �
C!¢Y�I�tl .7'� f�`� rs�t � '� �„aA + �
}'78tl�btiet �, x� ` � � r `^'`rg' r � P�OfBCt ; � ..
� : E'o7tl9k; �..�� �, ,, . �� .` ` � `.�„` � ` LOCBtlOf1 p �� . ��.:
r e,
�
� � �-'"F ^'ssr�. ; CanYonL e "'r�' ' �± �4 t� ���,�..-.�> � � :s £ �d.`�
`� 7 -`�'' xt xx � F ee+.�. ' F �.�� `` `:r F
ancho r.'[" " "� ✓" �, i 't'�,� r �'�"6 �
ant!' .m.� 1 aFr 1 ae s � r ,.� � .f ?'�. � � � "...�E, G�.
iHa{ta �:. ` r ?` Lak� 9 �� , ,s " � 's;� ,�z � �,-h i a
t
�o��. � '� sr,�elnar4 ' �'" � >�v t -.fi� . 9� ihr,`� � °� ,.,a..�
� � "; '"�r" r . r � x --� ,,�.
r . � ° �`� �l � , � �;. � �:',
„ r°`�` y� ..�,g . ��' ` t ��"' " :.�b!� '� ,,,y .<:'i��`�'��.
, � `? #�j 'r U ,'�"�`�
tl ly �f h�.j � F , ��� „ �� ` � 2 0���� �.+� ✓'
an Juan � �" Temecula : `* � v:�f.�j `"'��``�
aplsGana � �.�,r �.. "a',�` '`f �'e„r d , .x% � ��� ���.�',� � � ,.
3� ���°���� �,�'� .� 'r�f'' �J �9 y rr � � x{e�� fi��p���fp ��'°'�,1�
� � � �
$ ,� t - ,� � . �^' ` s� `. v.r i�- :�x � > s �r .:'� a xa
� � � �
Clem s �7!U l' � V � i � �r�.r��x�z`�r$ ' a r ? ,e .+ `� A � ,,^
Petf4i€rt4n � .'� � �: ' �,
�+ �
�"� ��� 3�a � r f
��t � 'f���� „�`� f�� �,��� Y ��'. ^� , rt
`F� Y�f�F ����„ 1i��y.r/ y�c` , h �`/
a . F� � r� �b '�'lg '' � " t�`#'" r s' tr m�`''
� P� i
l ' s=1"` � �aY t`�,�,,, rs f �
� �.. `y :
,�, �' ; � t.� ����'� r .f'w�' a.`rT °{ ,
, � � a�` ,x`( ;�a ;-?�' ,ad f'r �_.
. .` . � . . � c �r
� . . .- ` � �" � � � ��
u
p �,i F` � ". � ;3"°yyCr a� J. � l�
�' s r ��.d
./6 .' ��+�y . i'"�. * . ��� N
I _ R'i� 3� : 1
� g i� t ��, ���r � � �j� F r��- l
r s �r , r .3�1r�r� =5 "� ,� ".
�r � *s� ` �;; "i P `k...�' �'
n
`a
m �+
g " ' j , s ,3`K ap�g"� J' �� r � `5'"':Kv'N � -
� PACfF7G � �z � v.s� s � ��.,a � �x��i � r�` r �
� i � � 1' �t { �. 3
i` OCE.4N ' .� . y=
.�^"�` � r� �.^' ,.� .
3 � '� � ������'`��� � �c �a1i �` �
e
.�`- �
� �a � ���� � � �
p r F � � . ts N,. .
r i � �=`� . �{ t .:d` �. � �
x.� ,, d� . � " �k .f ' � ,�
` # � � ;r-� 1 'n . ` � ''"�" ; '
. . . . � �.� � �'� <�. � ���� ���p� � .. . _ . � �' x� ��� �
rr � . , u?s,: ��.a� � �F e. `� . '��. �
Regional Location Exhibit 1
Cook Street Lane Realignment
N
w�E iO S O 1O ����
� Miles CONSU(i1NG
5 fl/Pryeds/Hems4000/GtaDhi¢IFi1 RL�140106�1
� R
L (� r
l \ �`\ \ �9 �. � � �14 ��\l l�( " 1�� •
—...r— 1___� �....,i...\ .. \a`— . .__.�%e �_V� a.e..4 ;` / .�?) �L,.._.._"Y`t:
`� �� \, `� � lti�� /�..� �.� °�v
. \ • ��.� \ ..,\ , 9 � � � � � !!
l •�.� � � A� A o . �"`"_ �a: N
�� � \ m 9 ( C?
.
. � g,
1� az .!\'\� � �\ �. -, 4 � '
,�,
�� , . �,\ � .,
, .�_
, _�,-� -. � ��� �., �� , �i
�.
. ,� � . , ,�
. � ,,�� : , �
. _ , , ,, ..e
, . , e� 1 �
' FronkSinuhuDr �1 1. c i 9 �
"'__— _ .:._ __ J n ' ..:..
'—". \. . � _ . .
{ di"y i- � I - �_ � � \ � ...._ �, i
k � � � A � V 1� � ' L L �.s
J " � ^ � `�.�� \ ,� \ �✓• �1� � o�
.� N 9 � 4 � I � •\ �\ o ��'� `
\
� a� Da 6`$ � , a � 3� � �' � � �., �_2
��"�" �p I a r�' y � '\.,\ � '� ( i i � ..._
;'l�P E A� ��y��..J��i �j,i, �' \l `\�ce�� �� _ l
p i c� .�,�-J � � � A �
�'"'�,, ,�p ���P,�"�� . " "�� C� ' --�, l � � ��. `�
t IW�:; r � . • - �� �,°,-�'�, v \ °=�"==�-��., -
� ` J \ \ � �.
.� 'dyA ��� �� 5��� o � � \..� ��
.,,�eI c\ �
;.43.. --_-,...,,_:�._��!^-~�-1\ `�,__9 4�\ io � 1t ; .
'. .. .A.s l
.
� ��
�-r-- �.�J -- -a--t — --- . _ _._.._ --- -� — -
������aa u �q � �� .
rc�� �
�,�,_�`,. .w+�. B (S o�� '.�� \ ,ykp� �� �C,' 11 ^v
/ '
,,,,x� t= f ., � � � �\ ) ZI
�d��€�s���.E'aa.. : �p C� . . .: _ J� _ i
r
� �� -; - ...... . .._—
�-!�>� ---T;� ..:_. _� r.
�, , ..
� _�7� Ql Y'� ' D �Qn ~�4,� � � C� 4
' �:� r o �P '—` ��
,. . u ,.` "'"�
�@ .. �i�+ � �� i����5 ����]+�}.,'�� � �1 .... b iV
i `a' '�..�
a
�.� * q] �
'i l t., F S d n }����l. C - .' ._
�„Y al { �
yn u �
'� ?3`" �.
+�t+r- wae� �� . �' a � '�..�-�.� r � r--ry 1 ��`. � ,
[ i� k "v. r"c,9.6 K`- ^ '�' 7 li l.��l.-^> G' ''14
� � �y"'' �u�i ro� . � x ��� � ',. v �C,� �� j���'
17
' �; , At � k �� �,�, s � � r— ,•
f ... � .� ��---�� � 4�"�i��i��a� �� J � �b fl
��„ i4� k,_�� w � �� . 6 �, A�/e h 1^ � �\� O -. 'r
" '.r §'��F, � � �. y . � ,E �, 7r
�IF'^ .. r .,.: � � :� $. ,� .. �:
� � �� �� :,�.s-M-�f . � . - '� i� . ..:.� � �� ,� S�S�.
�5$) � a i 1 .wou. Frcd Wnnng Dr :�� i � -
"e".� s r 3 1 .�'w � . �"�'� I -'�avx�� '�j ��
f .� v � 4� � :c, t ,� ;..
�a° ( � ; t � } a � �,f
�� � � ,� ,;�. . : ; r � G �s , � � ,
a� r, , w��
�i��� � . i�ia ��ojwi � � ���� �.4Z2 � � ,. ti �e3
u�.+ i, w�A:. uC�. 21
tJ �.n*.�.+. �� np r R y'�`c. � ..Ia e i�r i .�. ��,^x @ aa :� � w
+��ie �is N � E �...�+.,�sa� �. ��fGti1 � \� d . .
��-7.� _ � .r.. r1i- >. P I[�1:� Palm : "x i h,.S I ,�s� ' � �� .
`T,� �. 3 ��4i t ��` � �Deeert ^v 6✓ ^� :... ...'�`d a � T.� .��f � .�i
. • ,£--... ;� r����Z �i n iti�� " � ��d :�4 ; � � �i � ��� j°li � .
�z..a� � --��a� ' .I � ���f .�.a �C-� a^� , . ���4� �n:e c�
4� u 3� 1�* r����_wn` � .e,�-,_ . t � i s ...--c.'e . _..
�Pa�M�iE "F s`�--''--"��� �-,• , W li � �J,NYa�+i 'i"�'j �i� y+\�+� ��
2Q "4c�� 3j ��... -. �.�L..�..�.,:�' � Z� .., �cEr � �� ;. �� ��v � �tVA �
€ �., ,,(
\ �w.o 'vcE � �' ^., ,�s & S� �I
� Pro ect Location �-•"' ����; m q tf�;'��,,ti �)� ,�
� � Z �.�1z}� � . �Soumo°USGSCv(h�ea�u,iC�,ityyyoma F �
( n
.�.4. . __a -_ ,E�cE�� „��r ;� ) ��,r4,LaQuinm�and�Roncho�Miiage'(S�hLnuleQundrangle y
Local Vicinity Exhi6it 2
Cook Sfreet Lane Realignmenf
w�E R,000 1,000 0 2.OW ��
�Foet
�wwa�+
. � _
�' c� .�rs �� � rrr� �
An Environmental Planning/Resource
Management Corporatio� '
September 15, 2006
Mr. Ehab Gerges VIA FAX, E-MAIL, AND MAIL
Harris & Associates (619) 236-1179
750 "B" Street, Suite 1800
San Diego, California 92101
Subject: Phase I Cultural Resources Assessment for the Proposed Cook Street
Restriping Project, City of Palm Desert, Riverside County, California
Dear Mr. Gerges: _
Per your request, BonTerra Consulting has completed a Cultural Resources
Assessment of the Proposed Cook Street Restriping Project area (hereafter
referred to as the project). The results of the study are presented below. This letter
report was prepared in accordance with the California Environmental Quality Act
(CEQA) and conforms to the standards required by the California O�ce of Historic
Preservation (OHP).
INTRODUCTION
The proposed project area is located in the City of Palm Desert, Riverside. The
project involves restriping of lanes and shoulders along a three-mile section of
Cook Street between Fred Waring Drive and Frank Sinatra Drive. The City of Palm
Desert has determined that the project has the potential to affect cultural resources
that may be present at the road edge.
At the request of Harris & Associates, BonTerra Consulting completed a Cultural
Resources Assessment of the proposed project located within a three-mile section
of Cook Street in the City of Palm Desert between Fred Waring Drive and Frank
Sinatra Drive in Riverside County, California (Exhibit 1, Regional Location).
PROJECT DESCRIPTION
The proposed project is located on portions of Township 5 South; Range 6 East;
Sections 3, 4, 9, 10, 15, and 16 (San Bernardino Baseline and Meridian), as
indicated on the attached copy of the U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) 7.5-minute
151 Kalmus Drive Myoma and La Quinta topographic quadrangles (Exhibit 2, Local Vicinity).
Suite E-200 This study was conducted to identify any potentially significant cultural
(archaeological or historical) or paleontological (fossil) resources that might be
Costa Mesa adversely impacted by the project in accordance with CEQA. This report presents
the methods used to identify archaeological and historic resources in the project
California 92626 vicinity; any known and/or potential archaeological, historic, and paleontological
(714)444-9199 resources in the project area; the projecYs potential to adversely impact any
significant cultural or paleontological resources; and recommendations regarding
(714)444-9599 fax treatment of any project-related impacts.
�
Mr. Ehab Gerges
September 15, 2006
Page 2
BonTerra Consulting Cultural Resources Manager Brian Glenn prepared this assessment.
Mr. Glenn is a Registered Profes�ional Archaeologist, qualified under the Secretary of the
Interior's standards (Attachment A).
METHODOLOGY
Archaeological/Historical/Culturai Records Search
A cultural resources records search for the project area and a one-mile radius was conducted
by staff at the Eastern Information Center (EIC) on August 31, 2006 (Attachment B). The EIC is
the designated repository of the California Historical Resources Information System for records
concerning archaeological and historical resources and associated studies in Riverside County.
The records search provided data on known prehistoric and historic archaeological sites, built-
environment (constructed) resources, and previous studies within one mile of the project area.
Sources consulted at the EIC included archaeological site and artifact records, Archaeological
Determinations of Eligibility (DOE) listings, and the OHP's Historic Property Data File (HPDF).
The HPDF contains listings for the National Register of Historic Places (NRHP), California
Register of Historic Resources (CRHR), State Historical Landmarks (SHL), and California Points
of Historical Interest (PHI). The specific sources that were consulted at the EIC are listed below.
. National Register of Historic Places (NRHP), with updates to 2005
• California Register of Historical Resources (CRHR), 2005
. California Historic Resources inventory (CHRI), 2005
• CalifoPnia Historical Landmarks (CHL), with updates to 2005
• California Points of Historical interest (CPHI), 2005
. Archaeological Determinations of Eligibility, with updates to May 5, 2005
• Archaeological site records
• Maps depicting site locations
. Historic USGS Elsinore 30' Topographic Quadrangle of 1901
. Cultural resource studies and reports that cover areas within a one-mile radius of the
proposed project area
Archaeological Field Survey
An archaeological field survey of the proposed project corridor was conducted by Mr. Paul
Shattuck of BonTerra Consulting on September 6, 2006 (Exhibit 2). The survey included a
pedestrian survey of both sides of the corridor along Cook Street between Fred Waring Drive
and Frank Sinatra Drive. Visibility was poor over most of the corridor given the current level of
development. Inspection focused on areas of exposure adjacent to the Area of Potential Effects
(APE) in an effort to identify prehistoric or early historic material remains. In addition, the survey
was prepared to document historic period buildings, structures, and objects (i.e., those greater
than 50 years of age)within or adjacent to the APE.
A Garmin Geko 301 Global Positioning System (GPS) unit was utilized to accurately map any
resources encountered, and a Nikon Coolpix 5600 digital camera was used for general-purpose
and historic-building photography. Addresses and Assessor's Parcel Numbers (APN) of lots
along the project corridor were recorded and assessed for potential historic period structural
remains. Given the recent nature of the development of this area, the presence of historic
structures was determined unlikely.
Mr. Ehab Gerges
September 15, 2006
Page 3
Paleontological Resources Records Search
A paleontological resources records search and scientific literature review for the project area
was conducted on September 7, 2006, by Dr. Sam McLeod, Curator, Department of Vertebrate
Paleontology, Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County (NHMLAC; Attachment C).
Dr. Mc�eod is a qualified paleontologist with extensive experience in Riverside and San
Bernardino counties. The records search and literature review provided information on geologic
formations, known fossil types and localities, and any published studies within the project area
and in the general vicinity.
RESULTS
Archaeological/Historicai/Cultural Records Search
The results of the records search at the EIC indicate 29 cultural resources studies have been
conducted within a one-mile radius of the project area (Attachment B). One of these studies,
RI-3649 covers a portion of Cook Street, from Interstate 10 to Frank Sinatra Blvd (Chace 1994).
The survey was negative for cultural resources. A summary of the 22 studies is provided in
Table 1 below.
TABLE 1
PREVIOUS STUDIES CONDUCTED WITHIN ONE MILE OF THE PROJECT
'�� EIC Re ort No. `Author s 'and Year Co4era eR e'iof Stud�7Resources'�18entified
RI-0002 Ro ers 1953 � No acrea e surve ed,Overview stud onl
RI-0103 Drover&Nelson 1978 200 acres surve ed, 10 resources
RI-0161 Greenwood 1975 No acrea e surve ed,Overview stud onl
RI-0487 Swenson 1978 274 acres surve ed, 1 resource
RI-0494 Swenson 1978 27 acres surve ed,no resources
RI-0714 SRS 1979 460 acres surve ed, no resources
RI-0715 Keller 1998 460 acres surve ed, no resources
RI-1189 Tadlock&Tadlock 1978 434 acres surve ed, no resources
RI-1211 Warren et al. 1980 No acrea e surve ed,Overview stud onl
RI-1362 Swenson 1981 400 acres surve ed,no resources
RI-2063 White&Van Horn 1986 300 acres surve ed, resources
RI-2064 White&White 2000 600+acres surve ed,no resources
RI-2145 McCarth 1987 No acrea e surve ed, Overview stud onl
RI-2178 Neiditch 1987 34 acres surve ed,no resources
RI-2210 Undenvood et al. 1986 167 miles, 13 resources
RI-2282 Padon 1987 400 acres surve ed,no resources
RI-2658 White&Van Hom 1989 Evaluation re ort
RI-2765 Arkush 1990 9.5 miles surve ed,4 resources
RI-3245 Van Horn et al. 1990 No acrea e surve ed, Overview stud onl , 16 resources
RI-3489 Love et al. 1992 No acrea e surve ed, General Plan EIR
RI-3547 White&White 1992 100 acres surve ed,2 resources
RI3625 Ho an&Tan 1993 500acres surve ed, 1 resource
RI-3643 Mason 1992 50 acres surve ed, no resources
RI-3649* Chace 1994 1 mile surve ed, no resources
RI-3935 Drover 1995 20 acres surve ed, no resources
RI-4052 Love&Tan 1997 190 acres surve ed, no resources
RI-4240 Love et al. 1999 180 acres surve ed, no resources
RI-5418 Duke et al.2004 96 acres surve ed, 1 resource
RI-5877 Love et al.2000 No acrea e surve ed,Overview stud onl
`covers a ortion of lhe ro'ect area
�
Mr. Ehab Gerges
September 15, 2006
Page 4
A total of 13 previously recorded cultural resources have been identified within one mile of the
proposed project area. These represent a rather even mixture of archaeological or built-
environment resources. No archaeological resources were previously recorded within the
project corridor; however, archaeological site CA-RIV-12698, a Late Prehistoric artifact scatter,
was documented approximately 1,000 feet from of the APE.
No resources listed on or eligible for the NRHP or the CRHR are recorded within the APE. In
addition, no CHL or CPHI were identified within one mile of the proposed project site. The
current edition of the HPDF inaintained by the OHP does not list any historic resources or
properties within the boundaries of project area.
Various historic topographic quadrangles encompassing the APE (1904 Indio 30'; 1941 Toro
Peak and Edom 15'; and 1958/59 Palm Desert and 1000 Palms 15') indicate undeveloped
terrain with a rudimentary north-south road illustrated along the Section 15 and 16 section line
on the 1941 Toro Peak 15' quadrangle and a well in the southwest corner of Section 15 on the _
1959 Palm Desert 15' quadrangle; the 1941 road is not shown. The well is also shown on the
most recent 1959 (photo-revised 1980) 7.5' La Quinta quadrangle. Aerial imagery available
through Google Earth's Digital Globe (2006) indicates the corner is now fully developed as part
of a housing development.
Archaeological and Built-Environment Field Survey
The approximately three-mile project length consists of residential and commercial areas
developed continuously since the period subsequent to the 1980 photo-revision of the La Quinta
USGS 7.5' topographic quadrangle. No previously recorded or unrecorded prehistoric or historic
archaeological sites were identified as a result of the survey for the Cook Street restriping
project corridor APE conducted by BonTerra Consulting. The project area has been previously
disturbed by the construction and maintenance of various paved roads, sidewalks and utility
lines, as well as the construction of the existing residential and commercial development.
The surveys required approximately six hours to complete. Visibility of the project corridor was
virtually non-existent given existing pavement over the established streets. Visibility of adjacent
areas was intermittent at best, with minor areas of exposure along the street edge. No
archaeological resources were observed in or adjacent to the project corridor. No built-
environment resources remain subsequent to development along both sides of the APE.
Paleontological Resources Records Search
The results of the paleontological records search and literature review indicates two major
deposits within the project area: Younger Quaternary Dune Sands/Alluvium and Older
Quaternary Deposits. Younger Quaternary Dune Sands/Alluvium has low potential to yield fossil
resources and is assigned low paleontologic sensitivity. However, these deposits likely overlie
Older Quaternary Deposits present in the subsurface. Older Quaternary Deposits have high
potential to contain significant nonrenewable paleontologic resources and are assigned high
paleontologic sensitivity. Elsewhere throughout southern California, older Older Quaternary
Deposits have been reported to yield significant fossils of extinct animals from extinct the Ice
Age taxa including mammoths, mastodons, ground sloths, dire wolves, short-faced bears,
sabre-toothed cats, large and small horses, large and small camels, and bison. Review of the
Regional Paleontologic Locality Inventory (RPLI) at the NHMLAC indicates that no paleontologic
resource localities are recorded from within the proposed project corridor or from at least one
mile in any direction.
Mr. Ehab Gerges
September 15, 2006
Page 5
The results of the paleontological literature review indicate that the entire project area and the
one-mile radius are situated on d�posits of Younger Quaternary Dune Sands/Alluvium and
Older Quaternary Deposits. The younger (Holocene) layers of the Quaternary Alluvium are not
expected to yield significant fossil resources, and no fossils have been recovered from this
geologic unit in the vicinity of the proposed project. However, should undisturbed Older
Quaternary Deposits be present at depth or exposed during excavation, such sediments would
have undetermined paleontologic sensitivity in that they might have potential to contain
significant nonrenewable fossil resources.
CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMEPIDATIONS
The records search indicated that 29 studies have been conducted within one mile of the project
site and 13 cultural resources were identified as a result of these studies. One of the studies
(RI-3649, Chace 1994) terminates at the northern end of the current project APE. The historic
maps indicate the area remained, for the most part, undeveloped. Exceptions being a
rudimentary road illustrated on the 1941 map along the current Cook Street project APE, north
of what is now Fred Waring Road and a well on the northeast corner of Cook Street and Fred
Waring Road, which was first illustrated in 1959.
No archaeological sites, built environment, or potentially significant cultural resources were
identified within the proposed project corridor APE as a result of the field survey; however,
visibility was virtually non-existent across the bulk of the project corridor given existing
pavement and sidewalks. Prehistoric period resources are known within 1,000 feet of the project
corridor APE.
Based of archival research and field investigations, BonTerra Consulting concludes that the
proposed project has little potential to encounter buried archaeological resources within the
project corridor APE. Archaeological monitoring is not recommended.
If potentially significant archaeological evidence (e.g., stone artifacts, dark ashy soils, burned
rocks, old glass, metal, ceramic artifacts) becomes apparent during ground disturbances, work
in that location shall be diverted and a qualified archaeologist notified immediately to evaluate
the find. The significance of the resource shall be determined through evaluation according to
CEQA criteria. Should evaluation conclude that important cultural resources exist and will be
�egatively impacted by construction of the project, recommendations shall present mitigation
measures to necessary to lessen those impacts to a level of less than significant.
if human remains are discovered, the Riverside County Coroner's office must be notified
immediately under state law (California Health and Safety Code § 7050.5) and all activities in
the immediate area of the find must cease until appropriate and lawful measures have been
implemented. If the Coroner determines that the remains are Native American, the Coroner
shall contact the Native American Heritage Commission (NAHC) (California Public Resources
Code § 5097.98). The NAHC will designate a Most Likely Descendent who will make
recommendations concerning the disposition of the remains in consultation with the lead agency
and project archaeologist.
Analysis of the paleontological records search indicates excavation within the boundaries of the
proposed project has a potential to impact significant nonrenewable paleontological resources.
Excavation, should they be required, into undisturbed sediments of the Older Quaternary
Deposits will necessitate that a qualified vertebrate paleontologist develop a mitigation program
to include monitoring excavation activities that extend more than a few feet below the surface as
a protection against impacts to nonrenewable paleontological resources. The monitoring
Mr. Ehab Gerges
September 15, 2006
Page 6
program shall include recovery, preparation (to a point of identification), cataloguing of fossil
materials, and provisions for paleontological specimens recovered during mitigation to be
deposited in an accredited and permanent scientific institution for curation so as to be available
for further research. No paleontological monitoring is recommended for near-surface (less than
three feet) disturbance of the project corridor.
A preconstruction meeting shall be conducted in which the project paleontologist shall explain
procedures necessary to protect and safely remove potentially significant fossil materials for
study and curation. The methods employed during monitoring and/or recovery of fossil
specimens shall be documented in a report of findings.
Please contact me at (714)444-9199 if you have any questions regarding this assessment.
Sincerely,
BONTERRA CONSULTING "
� L-��z.-"'�„�.
-_-•_
Brian K. Glenn, M.A., RPA
Cultural Resources Manager
Exhibits 1 and 2
Attachment A: Professional Qualifications
Attachment B: Archaeological/Historical/Cultural Records Search
Attachment C: Paleontological Resources Records Search
R:\Prajec�s\HartisW004\Letter_Raport-091506.tloc
��` �'a��-�r,i',��� ���,���� rr� � � � r .T ta + w
r S,rraaYKr y'� .�' e �
� 'u�" p�" � . f
�t',�„"�<� . "+� '€� J r�� i�t ✓ N 18 � f, `�c ; `s+'�` x
���� ,�"2 �jt r r^ �r ,� f d �
..�"'.�'� „�,.f..;,�'�;,-" ��i"��t�i"`` �,r'� .vs+ y.�������'"�F�` .r�r -: .:x a .
e
-a` ,..C.,'� F�dfr�`� .. .� ��.; i',�e..f`i2"�"`�'rt' ,fi ` l�'v � �, '
�
r�r Hifncha � ...r3' r,„' .s a k�'�`3.%� v'f , v�-.. ;.;-�:, �� >
�� "Cucamon6a .:" 'i�t �.`�� � ?af`� JB r , '`�*".� : P< t r.
ao , � jr� z�`a.a _ : ��} ��� =�'� ' ;
. , #� .a*`� . ,z- y iW{n�2'���3 '^t# R
. : � , „v,_. � �'*" ;i#�. & 6 I
Rizlro San Bernerdmo R'�.°�„' ,, � "T �F"-�. +,�,.�z�"�"rp�-.,s, '`� s �+'" ''�r� i�� 1 �
, n �
� €t r „dj �'r��€��'� � .�.
� r " >� 3�
.3° l.! � . � � # '�'�✓� ,^�` ,rr^`��' p° f'>"�°
ontario ,,`-"'� '`�'a-�'�3�J,a,r��s�� ,u��,,,.,a�x �*"" � f ?` f ` �d;_'
_"_e, , . �.,� . . . 'st r'"v' rr.+ F
r, �l
� �Y , ,w° ,.0 ,�
Yuca( a
. Rodiandr � '� Q-"`�xa`�g�,cf*Y��-'`{� r.�� '� rr�r,...rr,.� r ��ps s��` '
ILveraide . � �.� ',s-rt�s �""#��`��3r��3-� .` � ��.��,�.;., ,� �
� � „r �. 3`.1 z ,� rf'"�l' ; S r .
'�,- � q, gf� k .TM����' "? "5`,ss?ff � �
G �`„� ""„' e�• ,#�' �,�. 1f S. �
a E
�„ µ
� <s ' - 6� . 3 ; a � f i
f \ z � ! G
Moreno Valley' �� � -�
� �� r � r
. rCorona a ,. I" , � � � • s,, ^� ' ,�'� � � �7 '�`R 1 ,, .,
".x' Lalv � .� g .: � � '"��. ���E *� 't�
� fi'at�€+ws :�', ,a .� � ='r ' .��
,A,° Perria � FY-� � z `� ` z�%�3 F•'
p f '",b` 3� w�s "°��ar c'*� v�`
�y ��� : , ��x' r,'� z � '� � '^:�.''��`�� :..�
t �
� �,y.�. � �, ;. y. # .. � I�F�����i`�' '`
CISV2i8a$`� �'� .t�.v �� '"� ���'"�_ , �� c
Nsrw�a� �,� x � � s,� ���x �.'��:�� Pro�ect � � �
F Fo«sG rc � � ; " �< ,:_� � : �� Location v �" ���
,
'`. r ���1�1a a�a�, Canon �e "� ..'�' ,��`a .9 P ,+ �£�. � rr� ,.w , 7.-.!
`x 5 > & Y Ytf � . �Y .. b w1`��'Ya"�'°�'�': � '�`:� "�� � .�-=�i, $'�.
' ,� ancha �.�, ; _ -% � r y.4�
. d�l[d �# . � .r'f 4 c`�"' ,%ri .F '.,n"" y�i
1 ,r l' „ �g . A :a .f C I"`��1" b i # J a
.3 rgants - � ,�i Leka C' . ��' r ,,�` `�+' „. ,}: k d `
f pn,�, . ,�i � � � � '
�Ioo�. .,... : � . 2` x }s
e7o,. + a szrFJsinwo ; � "`` .r.. � v+;, � � ,>-- i
x aF f� 'r r ?� F� �'"�� ; � .k` .�` � r .
� .r,r; < ^z`, e z'm ` � � ` "'�.f , ,�"�
y � ` < �'`. �,�
.; a .r .� r` , � xir
¢ + x. #3��xts . , „ f. tn. � ,� .r�;T �'�����
SanJuan � � `� �,r� xS`F"' �t : Temecula r i �"�� � . ,�''��r-*� '���€`p�-Fv-��, ���
ani.e.aiw r r��$„ �,` �3 ,. . � � � �r ,� .
.� z =� s r .,n r -�f "+'r' < �E
, �:�� f S`` ft ;T °�t'�' ^1.y"+ 9 a'X �a � `�"�,y°��`��d, '"€�C �-`.���'�$�.
,� ',. > �^ � .�u r €" e �p t2t'
$ o-1 2 fE
Clem a +C3II1P J' � t " : ,J` 1��,aA.r�^/ � '� � - �� '
� � P$nmeian ` x : : en � .--'�° � : `` .,-"� X
x 4� ; '� w � �«^`:/s r''. '` : <
a r � � r .a�`'` _ �,s.f'r t %yg%, e �`"p� a '� � � r f ..� � s � 1
f i� �+
�f ` -` < *�'�J � °t�x , r �/�"-.F ,_�Y � �4 �/'�r ,
x "r s ' r� �. (3rd 9 xt`. �' { ; . 3�
� � f � �;8 z t �-��' "'r� � ' �"w'l"�,"`
4. `� "`1F+�ra���Y��`''� "�'��•� £� 5��
3 ,y /5 �}' ` # j%'�'e� �`
Y 1 1 ��x;"f� 1 '�� � �(.�.Y�T.�
`�,<. � i� � ��,-, xF s
�=x` J ± { Y k.s�
� f e 9'�.i� : ; .
8 �; � ; ��r��..r $ € Y.X ✓ µ
:
w
�� �,
,} 4Y
� X
9. I � ,rt✓'y a' Y' L�� a r�. } h"4,
E r �k`, � &F7 .a a `-"' '� "
�o �� , �� ' � '� µ^�-r`� �` :� �.`���s
� � ? � �,�, '"°�fr.�'�'� x i �� €' # :r� � : $
� P A C 1 F t C '�. � ?�,,-. .u, .�` �s a"�-
x �, ;�, r �,..
E OGEAN � lY' �s .r � � �' ' � � .�a
� ���� . *� ��;.
� � � � � �� � � � �
a` .��` _ :f-s:� ,: � ^.z-.- „ �t p ..
� '� , r ,x°' s .� � ,N' , rr r � a v �
� r . � , � � �' .
u "f f #-"K r"f w, ��`� J k�' .+ t°,C`' r�: �,� � . a f,.
� � i 5 k �"`.;� �sA`a 3 x .+ � � � s
}x Y -::f f a"�i
9
. . . ,_ � . . _r. ..�„ . , .m,L...:�.s�� z,s. ._ , x_.. , =i�` d .. __ . '�:.:��� t,s��
Regional Location Exhibit 1
Cook Street Restriping Project
N �j �
wvE lO S O lO �^—��
� Miles CONSULTING
s
RJPmlecls/F1amsIJ00ElG2Phi�IF11_Rl_090)O6ptll
' � �L
� _ t �� `•,,� •, c,� - r . � �� )�-S�. c'� � �-� , ,.
._...�\ -_._.� .�•�.i �`\ \�-t- '__' .e ,." . _a,�. a,._"_ V I�ea-�j.:.r 1-
\ /
� �
�� � l ��l
•\.. . . . �.,� �� � I�
y
� � � �
\
\� \\\ \�� o�� �� �� (l L"'> -
� �,
. � �
�� \
30 32 � \\. ~ \ �\,. \\ �'`:) '_r'� `i $ .. o .
._��� ..��oo:. I `\ \\ � \ �"�, ' 6'�`W
�/� � � _��� �-� ' �.,
\ � .
� � �'\� � �� � __��
_ FrnnkSinatnDr � )
(� �, / \��\\\�\\ �\�� . _:. _
4 �� t�� I �'�. � � V � A � ' L L ,.
„ca ��..,il i � �'o�
") l>' 4 � f � � ��� �� \\ � �6�� �
# k I � � � '.�
. . � I 1.{. \ U Li�.
3 w +{M
L}'^�.�i. D�4�ry rJ. I 4 J� \\ .� \ `�\ �'��..
��r4 � �� '� `r�'y-i I\., n ,^ �� /�� ! I � l.� ��,..\ ...
�, ` J�• ,
. �
�t� � 'a1 p ✓ �J i._-✓ � � � .o � _ ��
' � �, �,��� . _� . i � a _` � � �-..
�< ,1,�g� '` K� - �� �` _,� �,� l � '�- ". -
��' � � `�----
' .,
: `.=b �� 5�-,5 ,� ;\� � \ \ �i �` —'l
8
� u �
3- � � �\.} ` 9 �� la /� � ll t
�. r 'no._.._. � I
-`:1 . .. • , �
� ti��.� .� \s s� � � � ..
-�v-��� '°�. -- '�,.- _ .---- - '— — - � -�, .- � - -----c ---- - � - --
Y rt' ' d '`b � � -
" �§ � - �a a . :�-.)�, � )1
�
� a. �. R f'_l��_ 9 : �J ' ]� �� � 11 +y
�
�'� t ", �S .
�� , � z1
_ ..„F� f r J4 .- p �
�"�������� i ' �d `� . "�.. "� ` �i i
.
d ".L<}c . a:.�C� „ — .... ._._. --
_ u° Q n�' D �� ' V �l
' " � � " � rry� `ti" � .�`�a§,� �
, 4 S .
} `v-r � - 7 ;�} g��y I�c.��uT��'m� . t ..... y `V
• -..
°���„� � y "+at�� ' h �g� i�' T�{ ���J' � t -' � _
d � _
� -�� s, ti i a '� r �, ,..�,.... � `�" '`�
wq. wair ��n�-t -� � r — '�,,�� �7
17': r i k ij'ir p rR$iFt, rt- ` 't-`` �'�"��..�p�-l��t�" C' •4 .Q ,��4 :.
c xl���fy`"� � s a'+ i �-�� � li � O �, ��.?��
�o� � � . � -' °` •` � � � p . '�
; � i I ; L..\ .�„:.'i �yhz�, � � , d u f
�6.�. � ��`+� il $` � Ws}��f� ���� \ `� yyr�-
� � f".A.. .,na.,sr•_, s��'. � ' � ° �`'�'�` � � t � ': i��,�.^.,.
tf7 - �� � � nl' . � � .wou. Fred War'ngDr �`�`.'�.,. ' i`� �'� }p Y�
t . . ����•=--•r+ � ._ I , . '^`=°�'a.'t� e pf -+"„^`---�C;�"r`�i yW
�.�„ 11�� I 3 �.�I: ` Well\'_` � v""nT/F9 \ l �
3 `
� ' ' g`S 3�� � ' � � �` �^`; d
� ,� f � � s ' > � ,
�;�'i� � r � ' �h. a(� ' � � ' ��" n ,, �� . , ,
,.� o w�� r � . ,:�, �� � �
�:wvE�.�`'"'w��.. �u ..�,� � 21 _ .. . 3
U q��'°�'� eF1 ff�� ° '..�� • e vsn 'd ' . �^N'aii� ° i Y•"�.
]R9' �'[q� 4J9 �✓ v � � - � � ..,.e,a. � -
:i� ,�+�y=���w �� r$ ...� ���t"i Palm ,�ry` " .� �'.,' . - +„�r��I' �I 4� :�b � �
� �" X � ! se ^. besert �y•i r t.,�m '",x �S � .�.'t�-"y ,q' � o
� r,�.._-:, ' r� . . �i rt 'ze,�-� ��,�r� . � u J �? 'a-�'�'l��t
�;�r ' �� �+„� ��-.�--�-;,���• �x,�����f"� ��'y �� 4� � ,'~��I�$w J,ii.rt a �
� t,. -rv�j �y.. � . .. . • 1.�. � W 11 ''f'P` A up� sr_ .,5�'y, `\ \ ,
41 f �.��� NY �� `Y 4�
�P811n�ert f'a -,-..s�rtc_ ,.. F "r
�'...' �)n ✓'.'' �' [xa.�s Fk �\� t\ 4LEPris�M"a✓+� ,., j .zr � �4�`4�
�,�y"`.r:�Eas�� b�e � "�. ', � � 1 ,C��� �I
Project Locatlon ,,,.�; Y, ���� m� (�"'�-,��,� 5a,,°
E1 �1�J) ��ourcc O6O8Celhed_rM1aICIty,M�omv ��
, , . —yx ^- �E�¢ � �/ � � ,�.�i��LoQmofn p"..d!RenehbMi@age75�Mioule4vid�angle��
yLocal Vicinity Exhibit 2
Caok Sfreef Reshaping Pmject .
"`�` z.000 �,aaa o z.oao '�'�'��
�Fea� � "
�,�.�
ATTACHMENT A
PROFESSIONAL QUALIFICATIONS
�¢��� BRIAN K. GLENN, M.A., RPA
C O N 5 U !T l N G CULTURAL RESOURCES MANAGER
M.A., Archaeology, University of California, Los Angeles, 1991
B.A., Anthropology, University of California, Santa Barbara, 1986
B.A., Geography, University of California, Santa Barbara, 1986
Brian Glenn specializes in Cultural Resource Management (CRM) under California
Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), and Iocal
regulations. During more than 20 years of professional experience, he has directed or
contributed to projects in many areas of southern California. He is skilled in a wide range of field
and administrative tasks fundamental to CRM and has written numerous technical reports. His
professional foci concern southern California's Campbell Tradition (circa 5000 B.P.), artifact
morphology as an indicator of function, environmental reconstruction through the analysis of fish
and shellfish remains, and the graphic display of data with emphases in exploratory data
analyses, computer aided drafting (CAD), and geographical information systems (GIS). Mr.
Glenn is a Registered Professional Archaeologist (RPA) qualified under Secretary of the
Interior's standards.
Representative Project Experience:
State Route 111 Widening Project, La Quinta. BonTerra Consulting supervised
preparation of Caltrans-approved cultural resources documents which included a Caltrans
Historical Resource Compliance Report and an Archaeological Survey Report which
included historic archives review, pedestrian survey, and Native American consultation.
Client: RBF Consulting, 2005
Black Bench Specific Plan, City of Banning, Riverside County. BonTerra Consulting
conducted a Phase I cultural resources assessment of the property which included historic
archives review, pedestrian survey, Native American consultation, and paleontological
literature review.
Client: SunCal Companies, 2005
National Register Evaluation of CA-RIV-2195. Surface collection, subsurface testing, and
reporting on four loci of archaeological site CA-RIV-2195 within the City of La Quinta,
Riverside County.
Client: Southern California Presbyterian Homes, Department of Housing and Urban
Development(HUD) and the City of La Quinta, 2002
Professional Experience:
BonTerra Consulting, Managing Archaeologist-2005 to Present
Pacific West Archaeology-1996 to 2005
Ogden Environmental & Energy Services-1991 to 1996
UCLA Institute of Archaeology-1988 to 1991
UC Santa Barbara Center for Archaeological Studies-1984 to 1988
Registrations, Certifications, and Affiliations:
Register of Professional Archaeologists (RPA, formerly SOPA), 1992
Society for California Archaeology (SCA)
San Diego County Archaeological Society (SDCAS) President, 1999
Various County and City Consultant Lists
ATTACHMENT B
ARCHAEOLOGICAL/HISTORICAUCULTURAL RECORDS SEARCH
EASTERN INFORMATTOM CENTER
�ALIFORNIA WISTORICAL RESOURCES �NFORMATION �YSTEM
Department of Anthropolog"y, University of California,Riverside,CA 92521-0418
(951) 627-5745- Fax (951)827-5409 -eickw@ucr.edu
Irryo,Mono,and Riverside Counties
August 31, 20Q6
RS #3792
Brian K. Glenn
BanTerra Consulting
151 Kalmus Drive, Suite E-200
Costa Mesa, CA 92626-7969
Re: Cultural Resource Records Search for the Harris J004 Cook Street Re-Striping
Project
Dear Mr. Glenn:
We received your request on August 30, 2006 fqr a cultura! resource records search
for the Harris 7004 Cook Street re-striping project located in Sectfon 33, T.4S, R.6E
and various sections of T.SS, R.6E, SBBM in the city of Palm Desert in Riverside
County. We have reviewed our site records, maps, and manuscripts against the
location map you provided.
Our records indicate that 22 cultural resource studies have been conducted within a
one-mile radius of your project area. One of these studies involved a portion of the
project area, and there are three adjacent to the project area. A copy of this report is
included for your reference. Seven additional studies provide overviews of cultural
resources in the general project vicfnity. All of these reports are listed on the
attachment entitled "Archeological Reports" and are availabie upon request at
15¢/page plus $30/hour. The KEYWORD sectfon of each citation lists fihe geographic
area, quad name, listing of trinomials (when identified), report number (n our
manuscript files (RI #}, and the number of pages per report.
No cultural resource properties are recorded within the boundaries ofthe project area.
Our records indicate that 13 properties have been recorded within a one-mile radius
of the project area. Copies of the records are included for your reference.
The above fnformation is reflected on the enclosed map. Areas that have been
surveyed are highlighted in yellow. Numbers marked in blue ink refer to the report
Brian K. Gienn
August 31, 2006
Page 2
number in our manuscript files(RI #). Cultural resource properties are marked in red;
numbers in biack refer to Trinomtal designations, those in green to Primary Number
designations. National Register properties are indlcated in Iight blue.
Additional sources of information consulted are identified below.
National Register of Historic Places: no listed properties are located
wlthin the boundaries of the project area.
OfFlce of Historic Preservation (OHP), Archaeologica{ Determinations of
Eligibility(ADOE): no listed properties ara located within the bounderies
of the project area.
Office of Historic Preservation (OHP), Directory of Properties in the
Historic Property Data File (HPD): no listed properties are located within
the boundaries of the project area.
Not all properties in the California Historical Resources
Information System are listed on the OHP ADOE and HPD.
The ADOE and HPD comprise lists of properties submitted to the
OHP for review.
Copies of the relevant portions of the 1904 USGS Indio 30', 1941 USGS
Toro Peak 15', 1959 USGS Paim Desert 15', 1941 USGS Edom 15', and
1958 USGS Thousand Palms 15` topographic maps are included for your
reference.
As the Information Center for Riverside County, it is necessary that we receive a copy
of all cultural resource reports and site information pertaining to this county in order
to maintain our map and manuscript files. Confldentlal information provided with this
records search regarding the location of cultural resources outside the boundaries of
your project area should not be included in reports addressing the project area.
Sincerely,
Step� Ostrich
Information OfFicer
Enclosures
___________________________________________________________________________________
� ARCAEOLOGICAL REPORTS NADS/Query �
� Printed: OS/31/2006 Page: 001 �
Document No. : 1080003 Unpublished Report .
ROGERS, MALCOLM S.
1953 MISCELLANEOUS FIELD NOTES - RIVERSIDE COUNTY. SAN DIEGO MUSUM OF MAN.
SUBMITTED TO N/A. UNPUSLISHED REPORT ON FILE AT UCR, EASTERN INFORMATION
CENTER, RIVERSIDE, CA 92521.
Last Update: 10/11/2005 Cataloged by: WOR-CA-04 on 09/19/1988
Keywords: RI-0002 {MF # 0003) (6) , 240 PP (7) , NO-ACREAGE SURVEYED - RECONNAISSANCE
STUDY (4) , AGUANGA 7.5' QUADRAbTGLE (4) , ALBERHILL 7.5' QUADRANGLE (41 , ARICA
MOUNTAINS 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , SACHELOR MTN 7.5' QUADRANGLH (4) , BEAUTY MTN 9.5'
QUADRANGLE (4) , BIG MP12IA MTNS 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4� , BLACKBURN CANYON 7.5'
QUADRP.NGLE (4) , BLYTHE Nfi 7.5' QUADANGLE (4) , CAENILLA MTN 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) ,
CATHBDRAL CITY 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , WTTONWOOD BASIN 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , �
COTTONWOOD SPRING 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , DESERT CENTER 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , DURMID
7.5' QUADRANGLS (4) , EAST DECEPTION CANYON 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , EAST OF RED
CANYON 7.5' QUPSJRANGLE {4) , EAST OF VICTORY PASS 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , FRINK NW
7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , HAYFIELD 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , HAYFIELD SPRING 7.5'
QUADRANGLE (4) , HEMET� 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , INDIAN COVE 7.5' QUADRF�7GLE (4) , KEYS
VIEW 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , LA QUINTA 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , LAKE ELSINORE 7.5' ,
QUADRANGLE (4) , LAKEVIEW 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , LITTLE MARIA MTNS 7.5' QUADRANGLE
(4) , MCCOY PEAK 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , MCCOY SPRING 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , MECCA 7.5'
QUADRANGLE (4) , MORTMAR 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , MYOMA 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , OROCOPIA
CANYON 7.5'QUADRANGLE (4) , PALEN LAKE 7.5' QUAARANGLE (4) , PALM SPRINGS 9.5'
QUADRANGLE (4) , PALM VIEW PEAK 9.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , PALO VERDE 7.5' QUADRANGLE
(4) , PECHANGA 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , PINTO WELLS 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , QIIEEN MTN
7.5' QIIADRANC>LE (4) , RANCAO MIRAGE 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) � RED CANYON 7.5'
QUADRANGLE (4) , RICE 7.5' QUADF2ANGLE (4) , RIPLEY 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , ROOSEVELT
MINE 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , SAGE 7.5' QUADRANGLfi (4) , SALTON 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) ,
SITTON PEAK 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , STYX 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , VAIL LAKE 7.5'
QUADRANGLE (4) , WHITE WATER 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , WILDOMAR 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) ,
WINCHESTER 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4)
Document No. : 1080L16 Unpublished Report
DROVER, CHRISTOPHER AND LEONPIZD N. NELSON
1976 THE COACHELLA VALLEY WATEA DISTRSCT FLOOD CONTROL ASSESSMENT: A CULTURAL
RESOURCE EVALUATION. Ai7TA0R(S) . SUBMITTED TO COUNTY. UNPUSLISIifiD REPORT ON
FILE AT UCR, EASTERN INFORMATION CENTER, RIVERSIDE, CA 92521.
Last Update: 12/O1/2003 � Cataloged by: WOR-CA-04 on 09/28/1988
Keywords: 200 ACRES SURVEYED (4} , 71 PP (7) , CA-RIV-1325 (9) , CA-RIV-1324 (8) ,
CA-RIV-1323 (8) , CA-RIV-1367 (8) , CA-RIV-1322 (8) , CA-RIV-1320 (8) , CA-RZV-1326
{8) , CA-RIV-1327 (6) , CA-RIV-1321 (8) , CA-RIV-6065 (8) , COACHELLA VALLEY (4) , LP
QUINTA 7.5' QUAD (4} , RI-0103 (MF #0091) (6) , RANCHO MIRAGE 7.5' QUAI} (4)
__-`--------------'----------"_---------------------------------------------
--------�-------------------'-'-----------------'----`------------------------
___________________________________________________________________________________
� ARCHEOLOGICP3, REPORTS NADB/Query �
� Printed: 08/31/2006 Page: 002 �
Document No. : 1080200 Unpublished Report
GREENWOOD, ROBERTA S.
1975 PALEONTOLOGICAL,ARCHAEOLOGICAL, HISTORICAL, AND CULTURFiL RESOURCES--WEST
COAST-MIDWEST PIPELINE PROJECT, LONG BEACH TO COLORADO RIVER. GREENWOOD AND
ASSOCIATES. SUBMITTED TO PRIVATE. UNPUBLISHED REPORT ON FILE AT UCR, EASTERN
INFORMATION CENTER, RIVERSIDE, CA 92521.
Last Update: 01/07/2004 Cataloged by: WOR-CA-04 on 10/Ol/1988
Keywords: RI-0161 (MF #0144) (6) , 38 PP (7) , NO ACREAGE SURVEYED--OVERVIEW OF
PROJECT AREA (4) , BEAi7MONT 7.5' QVADRANGLE (4) , BLYTHE 7-5' QUADRFfNGLE (4) ,
CP.SAZON 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , CATHEDRAL CITY 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , COTTONWOOD BASIN
7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) ,_ COTTONWOOD SPRING 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , DESERT CENTER 7.5'
QUADRANGLE (4) , DESERT HOT SPRINGS 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4J , EAST OF AZTEC MINES 7.5'
QUADRANGLE {4) , EL CASCO 7.5' QUADANGLE (4) , FORD DRY LAKE 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) ,
HAYFIELD 7.5' 4UADANGLE (4) , HAYFIELD SPRING 7.5' QUADRANGLfi (4) , AOPKINS WELL
7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , INDIO 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , LA QUZNTA 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) ,
MYOMA 7.5' QUADRANGLS (4) , PALM SPRINGS 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , RIPLEY 7.5'
QUADRANGLE (4) , ROOSEVELT MINE 7.5' QUAIJANGLE (4) , SIDEWINDER WELL 7.5'
QUADRANGLE (4) , SUNNYMEAD 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , THERMAL CI�,NYON 7.5' QUADRANGLE
{4) , WHITEWATER 7-5' QUAbRANGLB (4) , YUCAIPA 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4)
_"____'_'_"_'_""_""'_""""""_""'____"""_'_____""_""_"'__"_"'_
Document No. : 1080529 Unpublished Report
SWENSON, JAMES
1978 ARCHAEOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT OF THE PROPOSED DESERT AORIZONS COUNTRY CLUB,
INDIAN WELLS, RIVERSIDE COUNTY, CALIFORNIA. ARCHAEOLOGICAI, RESEARCH UNIT, U.C.
RIVERSIDE. SUBMITTED TO PRIVATE. UNPUBLISHED REPORT ON FILE AT UCR, EASTERN
INFORMATION CENTER, RIVERSIDE, CA 92521.
Last Update: O1/15/2004 Cataloged by: WOR-CA-04 on 10/18/1988
Keywords: 13 PP (7) , 274 ACRES SURVEYED (4) , CA-RIV-1315 i6) , COACfiELLA VALLEY (4) ,
LA QUINTA 7.5' QUAD (4) , RI-0487 (MF #0423) (6)
--"-'------'---------'--'-------'------------------------------'-'-'-------"----
Document No. : 1080535 Unpublished Report
SWENSON, SAMES D.
1978 ARCHAEOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT OF TENTATIVE 7.'RACT 12762, INDIAN WELLS RIVERSIDE
COUNPY, CALIFORNIA. ARCHAEOLOGICAL RESEARCH UNIT, U.C. RIVERSIDE. SUBMITTED TO
PRIVATE. UNPUBLISAED REPORT ON FILE AT UCR, EASTERN INFORMATION CENTER,
RIVERSIDE, CA 92521.
Last Update: O1/15/2004 � Cataloged by: WOR-CA-04 on 1Oj18/1988
Keywords: 29 ACRES SURVEYED (4) , 9 ?P (7} , COACHELLA VALi,EY (4) , So-1 4UINTA 7.5'
QUPD (4) , RI-6444 (MF #0427) (6) , NO RBSOURCES (8)
___________________________________________________________________________________
� ARCHEOLOGICAL REPORTS NADH/Query �
� Printed: 08/31/2006 Page: 003 �
Document No. : 1080764 Unpublished Report
SCIENTIFZC RESOURCE SURVEYS, INC.
1979 ARCHAEOLOGICAL SURVEY REPORT ON: THE PROPOSED MOBILE HOME SITE (460+ ACRES)
LOCATED IN THE MYOMA AREA OF THE COUNTY OF RIVERSIDE. AUTHOR(S) . SUBMITTED TO �
PRIVATE. UNPUBLISHED REPORT ON FILE AT UCR, EASTERN INFORMATION CENTER,
RIVERSIDE, CA 92521.
Last Update: 12/17/2003 Cataloged by: WOR-CA-04 on 11/02/1988
Keywords: 460 ACRES SURVEYED (4) , 7 PP i7) , COACHELLA VALLEY (4) , RI-0714 (MF
#0636) (6) , MYOMA 7.5' QUAD (4) , NO RESOURCES (8)
--------------------------'------------------------------—-----------------'--
Document No. : 1081334 Unpublished Report -
TADLOCK, JEAN AND W.L. TADLOCK
1978 ARCHAEOLOGICAL ELEMENT - ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT, IVEY RANCA, COACHELLA
VALLEY, RIVERSIDE COUNTY, CALIFORNIA. AUTHOR(S) . SUBMZTTED TO PRIVATE.
UNPUBLZSHED REPORT ON FILE AT UCR, EASTERN INFORMATION CENTER, RIVERSIDE, CA
92521.
Last Update: 01/13/2004 Cataloged by: WOR-CA-04 on 12/13/1958
Keywords: 434.49 ACRES SURVEYED (4) , 9 PP (7) , COACHELLA VALLEY (4) , RI-1189 (MF
#1167) (6) , MYOMA 7.5' QUAD (41 , NO RESOURCES (8)
"'____"'_'_"""'______"_"""'_'__'_'_"'_"__"'_____""""""""'"'_"_
Document No. : 1081359 Unpublished Report
WARREN, ELISABETH VON TILL, ROSERT H. CRABTREE, CbAUDE N. WARREN, MARTHA KNACK, AND
R. MCCARTY
1980 A CULTURAL RESOURCES OVERVIEW OF THE COLORADO DESERT PLANNING UNITS.
INSTITUTE FOR AMERICAN RESEARCH. SUBMITTED TO SURERU OF LAND MANAGEMENT.
CONTRACT NO. YA-512-CT-8-100. UNPUBLISHED REPORT ON FILE AT UCR, EASTERN
ZNFORMATION CENTER, RIVERSIDE, CA 92521.
Last Update: O1/13/2004 Cataloged by: WOR-CA-04 on 12/14/1988
Keywords: RI-1211 (MF #1192) (6} , 157 PP (7) , NO ACREAGE SURVEYED--OVERVIEW (4) ,
ARICA MTNS 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4} , pRLINGTON MINE 9.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , AUGUSTINE
PASS 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , BIG MAFtIA MTNS NE 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , BIG MARIA MTNS
NW 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , HIG MARIA MTNS SB 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , SIG MARIA MTNS SW
7.5' QUADRANGLPs (4) , BLYTHE NE 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , BUZZARD SPRING 7-5'
QUADRANGLE (4) , CATCLAW FLAT 7.5' QUADRPNGLE (4) , CATHEDRAL CITY 7.5' QUADPANGLE
(4) , CHUCKS3ALLA SPRING 7.5' QIIADRANGLE (4) , CLARK LAKE NE 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , .
COLLINS VALLEY 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , CORN SPRING 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , COTTOiIWOOD
BASIN 7.5' QUP.DRANGLE (4} , COXCOMB MTS 7.5' QUADRANGLE (9) , DESERT CENTEP. 7.5'
4UADR�INGLE (4) , EAST OF AZTEC MINE ?.5' QUADRPNGLfi (4) , FORD DRY LAKE 7.5'
QOADF.7i.YGLE (4) , GRANITE PP.SS 7.5' QUADRANGLS {4) , GROMMET 7.5' 4UADRrNGLE (4) ,
iiAYFTELD 7.5' QUADRPNGLE (4) , IiAYFISLD SPRING 7.5' QliADRANGLE (�t) , HOPKIDTS WELL
7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , INCA 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , LA QUSNTA 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4} ,
LITTLE CHUCI�WALLA MTNS 7.5' QUAOFlANGLE (41 , LITTLE MARIA MTNS 7.5' QCIADRPNGLE
(4) , MARTINEZ MTN '7.5' Qi7ADRANGLE (4} , MCCOY PEAK 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , MCCOY
SPRINGS 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , MCCOY WASH 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , MECCA 7.5'
QUADRANGLE (4) , MORONGO VALLEY 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , MORTMAR 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) ,
� OCOCOPIA CANYON 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , PALEN LAKE 7.5' QUADRPNGLE (4) , PALEN MTNS
�.S' QUADRANGLE (4) , PALEN PAS5 7.S' QUADRANGLE (4) , PILOT MTN 7.5' QUADRPNGLE
(4) , RABBIT PEAK 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4j , RANCHO MIRAGE 7.51 QUADRANGLE (4) , RED
CANYON 7.5' QUADRANGLE �4) , •RED CLOUD CANYON 7.S' QUADRANGLE (4) , RSCE 7.5'
QUADRANGLE (4) , ROCKHOUSE CANYON 7.5' QUADRPNGLE (4) , ROOSEyELT MINE 7.5'
QUADRANGLE (4) , SEVEN PALMS VALLEY 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , SIDEWINDER WELL 7.5'
QUADRANGLE (4) , STYX 7.5' QUADRANGLE (?) , THERMAL CANYON 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) ,
TORO PEAK 7.5' QUADRANGLE �4? , VIDAL 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , WASHINGTON WASH 7.5'
QUADRANGLE (4) , WEST BERDOO CANYON 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , WEST OF PALEN PASS 7.5'
QUADRANGLE (4) , WHITEWATER 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4)
___________________________________________________________________________________
� ARCHEOLOGICAL REPORTS NADB/Query �
( Printed: 08/31/2006 Page: 004 �
Document No. : 1081590 IInpublished Report
SWENSON, JAMES D.
1461 AN ARCHAEOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT OF THE PROPOSED DESERT FALLS COUNTRY CLUB SITE
IN COACHELLA VALLEY, RIVERSIDE COUNTY, CALIFORNIA. ARCHAEOLOGICAL RESEARCH
UNIT, U.C. RIVERSIDE. SUBMITTED TO PRIVATE. UNPUBLISHED REPORT ON FILE AT UCR,
EASTERN INFORMATION CENTER, RIVERSIDE, CA 92521.
Last Update: OI/20/2004 Cataloged by: WOR-CA-04 on 12/20/1988
Keywords: 18 PP (7) , 400 ACRES SURVEYED (41 , COACHELLA VALLEY (41 , RI-1362 (MF
#1414) (6) , MYOMA 7.5' QUAD (4) , NO RESOURCES (8)
-——---'-------------"----------"'------------------------------'-----------'-
Document No. : 1082498 Unpublished Report -
WHITE, LAURIE S., AND. DAVID M. VAN HORN
1986 ARCHAEOLOGICAL SURVEY REPORT: PROPOSED SITE OF THE INDIAN WELLS RESORT AND
CONVENTION CENTER: ARCHAEOLOGICAL ASSOCIATES, INC. SUBMITTED TO PRIVATE.
UNPUBLISHED REPORT ON FILE AT UCR, EASTERN INFORMATION CENTER, RIVERSIDE, CA
92501.
Last Update: 03/OS/2004 Cataloged by: WOR-CA-04 on 06/OS/1989
Keywords: 14 PP (7) , 300 ACRES SURVEYED (4) , COACHELLA VALLEY (4) , LA QUZNTA 7.5'
QUAD (4) , RI-2063 (MF #2262) (6) , YES RESOURCES (8)
---'-----'----------------------------------------------'-----'------'----
Document No. : 1082567 Unpublished Report
MCCARTHY, DANIEL F.
1987 CULTURAL RESOURCE IDENTIF2CATION AND RECOMMENDATIONS FOR THE NORTHERN
SPHERE SPECIFIC PLAN FOR THE CITY OF PALM DESfiRT, RIVERSIDE COUNTY, CALIFORNIA.
ARCHAEOLOGICAL RESEARCA UNIT, U.C. RIVERSIDE. SUBMITTED TO CITY OF PRLM DESERT.
CONTRACT NO. N/A. UNPUBLISHED REPORT ON FZLE AT UCR, EASTERN INFORMATION
CENTER, RIVERSIDE, CA 92501.
Last Update: 03/25/2004 Cataloged by: WOR-CA-04 on 06/10/1989
Keywords: RI-2145 (MF #2328) (6) , 17 PP (7) , OVERVIEW-NO ACREAGE SURVEYED (4) ,
COACHELLA VALLEY (4)
-----'-----"'------------------------'-------------'-------"-----"'------
Document No. : 1082605 UnpUblished Report
NEIDZTCH, BARRY R.
1967 AN ARCHAEOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT OF 34 ACRES OF LAND LOCATEO IN THE CITY OF
PALM DESERT, RIVER5IDE COUNTY, . CALIFORNIA. ARCHAEOLOGICAL RESEPI2CFI UNIT, U.C.
RIVERSIDE. SU3MITTSD TO PRIVATE. ifNPUBLISHED REPORT ON FILE AT UCR, :e1STSRN
iNFORMATION CENTER, RIVERSIDE, CA 92501.
Last Update: OS/27J2004 Cataloged by: WOR-CA-04 on 06/12/1989
Keywords: 34 ACRES SURVEYED {4) , 7 PP (7j , � COACHELLA VALLEY (4) , LA QUID7TA 7.5'
QUAD (4) , RI-2176 (MF #2364) (6) , MYOMA 9.5' QUAD (4) , NO RESOURCES (8)
�
___________________________________________________________________________________
� ARCHEOLOGICAL REPORTS NADB/Query �
� Printed: OB/31/2006 Page: 005 �
Document No. : 1082640 Unpublished Report
UNDERWOOD, S. , J. CLEI,AND, C.M. WOOD, AND R. APPLE
1986 PRELIMINARY CULTURAL RESOURCES SURVEY REPORT FOR TAE US TELECOM FIBER OPTIC
CABLE PROJECT, FROM SAN TIMOTEO CANYON TO SOCORRO, TEXAS: THE CALIFORNIA
SEGMENT. DAMES AND MOORE. SUBMITTED TO BUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT, DESERT
DISTRICT, RIVERSIDE. UNPUSLISHED REPORT ON EILE AT UCR, EASTERN INFORMATION
CENTfiR, RIVERSIDE, CA 92521.
Last Update: 02f23/2004 Cataloged by: WOR-CA-04 on 06/14/1989
Keywords: RS-2210 (MF #2396) (6) , 98 PP (7) , 167.5 MI X 25 M SURVEYED (4) , AZTEC
MINES 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , SEAUMONT 7.5' 4UADRANGLE (4) , BLYTHE 7.5' QUADRANGLE
(4) , CABAZON 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , CATHEDRAL CITY 7.5' QUADRPNGLE (4) , CORN SPRING
7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , COTTONWOOD BASIN 7.5' QUALJRANGLE (4) , COTTONWOOD SPRING 9.5' �
QUADRAP7GLE (4) , DESERT CENTER 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , DESERT HOT SPRING 7.5'
QUADRANGLE (4) , EL CASCO 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , HAYFIELD 7.5' QUADR.ANGLE (4) ,
HAYFIELD SPRING 7.5' 4UADRANGLE (4) , HOPKINS WELL 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , INDIO 7.5'
QUADRANGLE (4) , LA QUINTA 7.5' QUAI7RANGLE (4J , MYOMA 7.5' QUADRIINGLE (4) , PALM
SPRINGS 7.5' QUADRI\NGLE (4) , REDI,ANDS 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , RIPLEY 7.5' QUADRANGLE
"(4) , ROOSEVELT MINE 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , SIDEWINDER WELL 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) ,
SUNNYMEAD 7.5' QUADF2ANGLE (4) , THERMAL CANYON 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , WRITEWATER
7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) , 33-0053 (CA-RIV-53T) (8) , 33-0159 (CA-RIV-159) (8) , 33-0893
(CA-RIV-893) (9) , 33-1634 (CA-RIV-1634) (8) , 33-1767 (CA-RIV-1767) (B) , 33-1768
(CA-RIV-1768) (8) , 33-3075 (CA-RIV-3075T) (B) , 33-3076 (CA-RIV-3076T) (8) ,
33-3077 (CA-RIV-3077T} (8) , 33-12818 (8) , 33-12819 (8) , 33-12820 (8) , 33-12821
(8)
___'__"'_"'_'_""_""_'__""__'_"__"'_"_'_"__'_""'__"____"___"__"__'
Document No. : 1082719 Unpublished Report
PADON, BETH
1967 CULTURAL RESOURCE ASSESSMENT - CENTER POINTE PROJECT - RIVERSIDE COUNTY.
CULTURAL RESOURCE MANAGEMENT-LSA ASSOCZATES, INC. SUBMITTED TO PRIVATE.
UNPUBLISHED REPORT ON FILE AT UCR, EASTERN INFORMATION CBNTER, RIVERSIDE, CA
92501.
Last Update: 06/1'7/2004 Cataloged by: WOR-CA-04 on 06/16/1989
Keywords: 100 ACRES 5URVEYED (4) , 16 PP (7) , COACHELLA VALLEY (4) , RI-2282 (MF
#2475) (6) , MYOMA 7.5' QUAD (4) , NO RESOURCES (6}
—----------——------'-------------'-'----'-------------—'--------"---'-------
Document No. : 1083128 Unpublished Report
W"HITE, LAURIE, AND DAVID VAN HORN �
1989 ARCHAEOLOGICAL INVESTIGATIONS AT TAE CHAPIN ADOBE CITY OF INDIAN D7ELLS.
ARCHAEOLOGZCAL ASSOCIATSS, LTII. SUBMITTED TO PRIVATE. UNPUBLISFiED REPORT ON
rILE AT UCR, E�?STERN =NFORNATSON CENTER, P.IVERSIDE, CA 92501.
Last Vpdate: 07/O1/2004 Cataloged by: WOR-CA-04 on�. 08/27/1990
Keywords: RI-2658 (MF #2862) (6) , 52 PP (7) , NO ACREAGE S"JRVEYED (4) , COPCH^cLLA
VALLEY (4} , LA QUINTA 7,5' QIIA17 (4) , CA-RIV-3886H (8}
___________________________________________________________________________________
� ARCHEOLOGICAL REPORTS NADB/Query �
� Printed: 08/31/2006 Page: 006 �
--------------
➢ocument No. : 1083375 Unpublished Report
ARKUSA, BROOKE
1990 AN ARCHAEOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT OF TEiE PROPOSED MID-VALLEY STORMWATER CHANNEL
LOCATED IN THE COACHELLA VALLEY OF CENTRAL RIVERSIDE COUNTY, CALIFORNIA.
ARCHAEOLOGICAL RESEARCA UNIT. ST7BMITTED TO PRIVATE. CONTRACT NO. N/A.
UNPUBLISHED REPORT ON FILE AT UCR, EASTERN INFORMATION CENTER, RIVERSZDE, CA
92521.
Last Update: OB/06/2004 Cataloged by: WOR-CA-04 on 09/12/1990
Keywords: RI-2765 (MF #2969} (6) , 13 PP (7) , 9.5 MI X 100 FT SURVEYED (4) , INDIO
7.5' QUADRANGLS (4) , LA QVINTA 7.5' 4UADRANGLE (4) , MYOMA 7.5' QUADRANGLE (4) ,
COACFIELLA VALLEY (4)_, CA-RIV-3439-H (8) , CA-RZV-3440-H (8) , CA-RIV-3867 (8) ,
UCRARU #1066 (6)
"__"""__"_____"'_'_"_"_'"'_'_""""""'_'_"""_""'_""""'___'""'
Document No. : 1063836 Unpublished Report
VAN HORN, DAVID M. , LAURIE S. WHITE, AND ROBERT S. WIiITE
1990 CULTURAL RESOURCES SENSITIVITY OVERVIEW FOR THE COACAELLR VALLEY ENTERPRISE
ZONE. ARCHAEOLOGICAL ASSOCIATES, LTD. SUHMITTED TO COUNTY OF RIVERSIDE,
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AGENCY. UNPUBLISAED REPORT ON FILE AT UCR, EASTERN
INFORMATION CENTER, RIVERSIDE, CA 92521.
Last Update: 10/07/2004 Cataloged by: WRO-CA-04 on 07/11/1991�
Keywords: RI-3245 (MF #3477) (6) , 66 PP (7) , OVERVIEW + UPDATE RECORDED RESOURCES
(4) , INDIO 7.5' 4UAD (4) , LA QUINTA 9.5' QUAD (4) , MECCA 7.5' QUAD (4) , THERMAL
CANYON 7.5' QUAD (4) , VALERIE 7.5' QUAD (4) , COACHELLA VALLEY (4) , CA-RIV-135
(33-0135) (8) , CA-RIV-148 (33-0148) (8) , CA-RIV-676 (33-0676} (8) , CA-RIV-795
(33-0795) (8) , CA-RIV-1634 (33-1634) (B) , CA-RIV-1637 (33-1637) (8) , CA-RIV-2982
(33-2982) (8) , CA-RIV-2983 (33-2983) (6) , CA-RIV-2984 (33-2984) (8) , CA-RIV-2965
(33-2985) (8) , CA-RIV-2986 (33-2986) (6) , CA-RIV-2987 (33-2987) (6) , CA-RIV-3438H
(33-3438) (8)
-----------'---'------"--------------------------------'------'----'----------
Document No. : 1084160 Unpublished Report
LOVE, BRUCE, JOAN S. SCHNEIDER, GWYN ALCOCK, DAWN REID, KEVIN HALLARAN, AND TOM
TANG
1992 CULTURAL RESOURCES: LA QUINTA GENERAL YLAN EIR. ARCHAEOLOGICAL RESEARCH
UNIT, U.C. RIVERSIDE. SUBMITTED TO PRIVATE AN1J CITY OF LA QUINTA. UNPUHLISHr�D
REPORT ON FILE AT UCR, EASTERN INPORMATION CENTER, RIVERSIDE, CA 92521.
Last Update: 10/14/2004 Cataloged by: WRO-CA-04 on 06/O1/1992
Keywords: RI-3489 (MF #3747) (6) , 54 PP (7) , GENERAL PLAN EIR-NO ACREfiGE SURVSYED
(4) , COACHELLA VPZLEY (4) , UC'd7il2U #1159 (6)
___________________________________________________________________________________
� ARCHEOLOGICAL REPORTS NADB/Query �
� Printed: 08/31/2006 Page: 007 �
Document No. : 1084243 Unpublished Report
WHITE, ROBERT 5. RND LAURIE S. WHITE
1992 AN ARCHAEOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT OP PORTIONS OF THE AIGHWAY 111 CORRIDOR
SPESZFIC PLAN, CITY OF INDIAN WELLS, RIVERSIDE COUNTY. ARCHAEOLOGICAL
ASSOCIATES, LTD. SUBMITTED TO PRIVATE. UNPUBLISHfiD REPORT ON FILE AT UCR,
EASTERN INFORMATZON CENTER, RIVERSIDE, CA 92501.
Last Update: 10/14/2004 Cataloged by: WRO-CA-04 on 10/02/1992
Keywords: RI-3547 (MF #3811) (6) , 24 PP (7) , 100 ACRES St7RVEYED (4) , LA QUINTA 7.5
QUAD. (4) , COACAELLA VALLEY (4) , CA-RIV-0064 (8) , CA-RIV-2934 (8)
-----------'---—------------------'----------'----"'---------------------—--
Document No. : 1084363 Unpublished Report
HOGAN, MICHAEL AND TOM TANG
1993 ARCHAEOLOGICAL SURVfiY OF THE CARVER PROJECT LOCATED IN THE CITY OF PALM
DESERT, RIVERSIDE COUNTY, CA. ARCHAEOLOGICAL RESEARCH UNIT. SUBMITTED TO
PRIVATE. CONTRACT NO. ARU #1218. UNPUBLISHED REPORT ON FILE AT UCR, EASTERN
INFORMATZON CENTER, RIVERSIDE, CA 92501.
Last Update: 10/14/2004 Cataloged by: WRO-CA-04 on 07/O1/1993
Keywords: RI-3625 (MF #3912) (6) , 36 PP. (7) , 500 ACRES SURVEYED (4) , COACHELLA
VALLEY (4) , MYOMA 7.5' QUAD. (4) , CA-RIV-5080 (8)
"'_"_"""""'"""""'_""'__'___"___'___'_""'_"""'___"'_"""'_""
Document No. : 1084366 Unpublished Report
MASON, ROGER
1992 NEGATIVE ARCHAEOLOGICAL SURVEY REPORT, P.M. 46.5 - 47.3. DEPARTMENT OF
TRANSPORTATION. SUBMITTED TO DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION. UNPUBLISHED REPORT
ON FILE AT UCR, EASTERN INFORMATION CENTER, RZVERSIDE, CA 92501.
Last Update: 10/25/2004 Cataloged by: WRO-CA-04 on 07/06/1993
Keywords: RI-3643 (MF#3935) (6) , 5 PP. (9) , 50 ACRES SURVfiYED (4) , COACHELLA VALLEY
(4) , MYOMA 7.5' QUAD. (4) , NO CULTC7RAL RESOURCES (8)
------'------------------------------'-----'--------------------------'----
Document No. : 1084689 Unpublished Report
CHACE� PAUL
1994 A CULTtII2AL RESOUACES SURVEY FOR THE COOK STREET IMPROVEMENT PROJECT, CITY
OF PALM DESERT, RIVERSIDE COUNTY. TAE KEITH COMPANIES. SUBMITTED TO CITY OF
PALM DESERT. UNPTTBLISHED REPORT ON FILE AT UCR, EASTERN INFORMATION CENTER,
RZVERSIDE, CA 92501. �
Last Update: 10/i5/2004 Cataloged by: 47R0-CA-04 on Oi/19/1995
Keywords: RI-36a9 (MF #3950} (6} , 19 PP. (7) , 1 LINEAR MILE SIIRVEYED i4) , MYOMA
7.5' 4UAD I4) , COACHELLA VALLEY (4) , NO RESOURCHS (8)
___________________________________________________________________________________
� ARCHEOLOGICAL REPORTS � NRDB/Query �
� Printed: OB/31/2006 Page: 008 �
Document No. : 1084891 Unpublished Report
DROVER, CHRISTOPFiER
1995 ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT EVALUATZON: AN ARCHAEOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT OF THE
PARCEL 3 OF PARCEL MAP 27615, LA QUINTA, CALIFORNIA. AUTHOR. SUBMITTED TO
PRIVATE. UNPUBLISAED REPORT ON FILE AT EASTERN INFORMATZON CENTER, U.C.
RIVERSIDE, CA 92521.
Last Update: 10/27/2004 Cataloged by: WRO-CA-04 on 03/2'7/1996
Keywords: RI-3935 (MF #4310) (6) , 11 PP (7) , 20 ACRES SURVEYED (4) ; LA 4UINTA 7.5'
QUAD (4) , COACIiELLA VALLEY (4) , NO RESOURCES (8) , PM 27615 (6)
-------'---"---------—---------------------'-'-----------------------------'--
Document No. : 1085181 Unpublished Report '
LOVE, BRUCE, AND BAI "TOM" TANG
1997 CULTURAL RESOURCES REPORT CALIFORNZA STATE UNIVERSITY, SAN BERNARDINO
COACHELLA VALLEY CAMPUS CITY OF PALM DESERT RIVERSIDE COUNTY, CAI,IFORNZA. CRM
TECH. SUHMITTED TO PRIVATE. UNPUBLISHED REBORT ON FILE AT EASTERN INFORMATION
CENTER, U.C. RIVERSIDE, CA 92521.
Last Update: 11/O1/2004 Cataloged by: WRO-CA-04 on 04/27/1998
Reywords: RI-4052 (MF #4493) (6) , 19 PP (7) , 190 ACRES SURVEYED (4) , MiYOMA 7.5'
QUAD (4) , COACAELLA VALLEY (4) , NO RESOURCES (8) , CRM TECH JOB #289 (6)
---'--------'---------------------------------------------------------'------'-
Document No. : 1085344 Unpublished Report
KELLER, JEAN A.
1996 A PHASE I CULTURAL RESOURCES ASSESSMENT OF AMENDMENT TO SPECIFIC PLAN 151.
AUTHOR. SUBMITTED TO PRIVATE. CONTRACT NO. N/A. UNPUSLISAED REPORT ON FILE AT
EASTERN INFORMATION CENTER, U.C. RIVERSIDE, CA 92521. �
Last Update: 12/17/2003 Cataloged by: WRO-CA-04 on 10/27/1999
Keywords: RI-0715 (MF #0636) (6) , 32 PP (7) , 460 ACRES SURVEYED (4) , MYOMA 7.5'
QUAD (4) , NORTHERN PENSNSULA RANGES (4) , NO RESOURCES (B)
----------------------------------------------"-----------------------------
Document No. : 1085463 Unpublished Report
LOVE, BRUCE, BAI TOM TANG, AND MICHAEL AOGRN
Z999 HISTORICAL/ARCHAEOLOGICAZ, RESOURCES SURVEY REPORT: IVEY RANCA COUNTRY CLUB
NEAR THE COMMUNZTY OF THOUSAND PALMS, RIVERSIDE COUNTY, CALIFORNIA. CRM TECH.
SUBMITTED TO PRIVATE. CONTRACT NO. 422. UNPUBLISHED REPORT ON FILE AT EASTERN
INFORMATION CENTER, U.C. RIVERSIDE, CA 92521.
Last UpdaCe: il/03/2004 Cataloged by: FiRO-CP-04 on OB(22/2000
Key�aords: RZ-4240 (MF #�722) (51 , 22 PP f7) , 180 ACRES SURVEYED (4) , MYOMA 7.5�
QUAD (4) , COACHELLA VALLEY (41 , NO RESOURCnS (4) , CRM TECH CONTkACT #422 (6)
___________________________________________________________________________________
� ARCAfiOLOGICAL REPORTS NADB/4uery �
( Printed: 08/31/2006 Page: 009 �
Document No. : 1085531 Unpublished Report
WHITE, ROBERT S. AND LAURA S. WHITE
2000 A CULTURAL RESOURCES ASSESSMENT OF TFIE HERITAGE CLUB PROJECT SITE, 600+
ACRES LOCATED IP'Il�IEDIATELY NORTH OF TIiE INTERSECTION OF FRED WARING DRIVE .AND EL
DORADO DRIVE, INDIAN WELLS, RTVERSIDE COUNTY. ARCHAEOLOGICAL ASSOCIATES.
SUHMITTED TO PRIVATE. UNPUBLISHED REPORT ON FILE AT EASTERN ZNFORMATION CENTER,
U.C. RIVERSIDE, CA 92521.
Last Update: 03/08/2004 Cataloged by: WRO-CA-04 on 08/23/2000
Keywords: RI-2064 (MF #2262) (6) , 45 PP (7) , 600+ ACRES SURVEYSD (4) , LA QUINTA
7.5' QUAD (4) , COACFIELLA VALLEY (4) , NO RESOURCES (8)
--'--------------———---'----'------------------------—---------"-----——---
Document No. : 1086781 Unpul�lished Report
DUKE, CURT, NAT LAWSON, AND RIORDAN GOODWIN
2004 CULTURAL RESORUCE ASSESSMfiNT, XAVIER COLLEGE PREPAR�TORY HIGH SCHOOL, APNS:
653-290-002, -015, 653-300-�30, CITY OF TAOUSAND PALMS, RIVERSIDE COUNTY, CA.
LSA ASSOCIATfiS. SUBMITTED TO PRI. UNPtTBLISHED REPORT ON FILE AT EASTERN
INFORMATION CfiNTER, U.C. RIVERSIDE, CA 92521.
Last Update: 03/06/2006 Cataloged by: WRO-CA-04 on 03/06/2006
Keywords: RI-5418 (6) , 19 PP (7) , 96 ACRES SURVEYED (4) , MYOMA 7.5' QUAD (4) ,
33-13395 (8) , PROJECT NO. RMW430 (6)
-------------------—'-------------------------------------------------------— .
Document No. : 1087240 Ilnpuhlished Report
LOVE, BRUCE, BAI TANG, ANIJ MP.RIAM HOGAN
2000 CULT17RAL RESOURCES TECHNICAL REPORT, CITY OF PALM DESERT GENERAL PLAN. CRM
TECA. SUBMITTED TO PRI. UNPUBLISHED REPORT ON FILE AT EASTERN INFORMATION
CENTER, U.C. RIVERSIDE, CA 92521.
Last Update: OS/23/2006 Cataloged by: WRO-CA-04 on OB/23/2006
Keywords: RI-587'7 (6) , 31 PP (7) , 130 SQ MILES SURVEYED (4) , CATHEDRAL CITY 7.5'
QUAD (4) , EAST DECEPTION CANYON 7.5' QUAD (4) , LA QUINTA 7.5' QUAD (4) , MARTINEZ
MTN. 7.5' QUP1J (4) , MYOMA 75' 4UAD (4) , RANCHO MIRAC>E 7.5' QUAD (4J � SEVEN PALMS
VALLEY 7.5' QUAD (4) , TORO PEAK 7.5' QUAD (4) , NO RESOURCES (8} , CONTRACT #639
(6)
ATTACHMENT C
PALEONTOLOGICAL RESOURCES RECORDS SEARCH
����°�� ���c��°�
F" o f L o s R n g e 1 e s C�te n t y Vertebcate PaleontoJo�SecYiot�
' . r ` r d� i F�e Telephone:(273j 63-332$
f-, ,� �, FAY:(2131746-9431
900 Exposition Boulevard e Los Angeles,G1 90007 �! r l� j� i' j�(7 �'� r-;� e-mail:smcleodta;tduu.org
, �;,1� � ,�, ���,r;;,
'�il� :S�P � � zo��; �����
�y 4 �t 7 September 2006
— - _I
BonTeiTa Consultina
151 Kalmus Drive, Suite E-200
Costa Mesa, CA 92626-7969
P.ttn: Brian K. Gienn, Culturai kesources Manager
re: Paleontological Resources for the proposed Harris J004: Cook Street Re-striping Project,
Riverside County,project area
Dear Brian:
I have conducted a thorough search o£our Vertebrate Paleontology records for the
proposed Harris J004: Cook Street Re-striping Project, Riverside County, project area as outlined
on the sections of the Myoma and La Quinta USGS topographic quadrangle maps that you fased
to me on 5 September 2006. We do not have any vertebrate fossil localities that lie directly within
the project boundaries,nor do we have any localities neazby From the same or sunilar sedimentary
deposits as occur within the proposed project area.
From the level of geologic mapping available to me, it appeazs that the portion of the
proposed project area nortli of the Whitewater River wash has surficial deposits of yonnger
Quaternary dune sands and approximately the portion south of the Whitewater River wash has
surficial deposits of younger Quatemary Alluvium,the latter derived primarily as fan deposits
from tke:�ills To !ha s�uth. These deFosit�are unlik�!y tc centain sign±ficant vertebraYe!ossils, at
least in the uppermost layers, and we have no vertebrate fossif localities anywhere nearby from
these or similar deposits.
Grading of shallow excavations in the youn�er Quatemazy Dune Sands or AIluvium are
unlikely to encoun[er significant vettebrate fossils. Deeper excavations in the proposed project
area that extend down into older Quaternary deposits,however, may well encounter significant
vertebrate fossil remains similar to those from the famous Rancho La Brea asphalt deposits in Los
���eles or other"Ice Age"deposi[s found throughout southern Cafifornia. Any deep and
snbstantiul excavations Sn the proposed project area, fherefore, should be inanitored closely to
"...Io ins�-�ire �,vnr-der, discovery and r.s�nns;bl!ity
;or ot�r i'idiurul and <uitural wnrEd;."
yuickly and professionally recover any fossil remains discovered while not impeding development.
Any fossils recovered daring miti�ation sl�ould be deposited in an accredited and pennanent
scientific institution for the benefit of cu�rent and future generations.
This records seazch covers oniy the vertebrate paleontolo�y records of the Natural History
Museum of Los Angeles County. It is not intended to be a thorough paleontological survey of the
proposed project azea covering other institutional records, a literature survey, or any potential on-
site survey.
Sincerely,
�'{�wLese�'`"l � �i`( r a�� -
Samuel A. McLeod, Ph.D.
Vertebrate Paleontology
enclosure: invoice
EDR� Environmental
Data Resources Inc
E I2 ata Rpo
Corridor Study
Cook Street Restriping
Palm Desert, CA 92260
November 30, 2006
The Standard in
Inquiry number 01805628.1r Environmental Risk
Management Information
440 Wheelers Farms Road
Milford, Connecticut 06461
Nationwide Customer Service
Telephone: 1-800-352-0050
Fax: 1-800-231-6802
Internet: www.edrnet.com
Thank you for your business.
Please contact EDR at 1-800-352-0050
with any questions or comments.
Disclaimer-Copyright and Trademark Notice
This Report contains cedain information obtained from a variety of public and oiher sources reasonably available to Environmental Data
Resources, Inc.Il cannot be concluded from this Report that coverage information for lhe target and surrounding properties does not exist from
oihef SoufCes.NO WARRANTY EXPRESSED OR IMPLIE�,IS MA�E WHATSOEVER IN CONNECTION WITN THIS REPORT.ENVIRONMENTAL
DATA RESOURCES,INC.SPECIFICALLY DISCLAIMS THE MAKING OF ANY SUCH WARRANTIES,INCLUDING WITHOUT LIMITATION,
MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR USE OR PURPOSE.ALL RISK IS ASSUMED BY THE USER.IN NO EVENT SHALL
ENVIRONMENTAL DATA RESOURCES,INC.BE LIABLE TO ANYONE,WHETHER ARISING OUT OF ERRORS OR OMISSIONS,NEGLIGENCE,
ACCIDENT OR ANY OTHER CAUSE,FOR ANY LOSS OF DAMAGE,INCLUOING,WITHOUT LIMITATION,SPECIAL,INCIDENTAL,
CONSEQUENTIAL,OR EXEMPLARY DAMAGES.ANY LIABILITY ON THE PART OF ENVIRONMENTAL OATA RESOURCES,INC.IS STRICTLY
LIMITED TO A REFUND OF THE AMOUNT PAID FOR THIS REPORT.PufChaSBf BCCeptS this Report"AS IS".Any aflalySeS,eSGRlet@S,tBtirigS,
environmental risk levels or risk codes provided in this Report are provided for illuslrative purposes only,and are not intended lo provide,nor
should they be interpreted as providing any facts regarding,or prediction or forecast of,any environmental risk for any property.Only a Phase I
Environmental Site Assessmenl pertormed by an environme�tal professional can provide infortnation regarding the environmental risk for any
property.Additionally,the information provided in lhis Report is noi to be construed as legal advice.
Copyright 2006 by Environmental Data Resources,Inc.All rights reserved.Repmduction in any media or format,in whole
or in part,of any report or map of Environmental Data Resources,Inc.,or its affiliates,is prohibited withoui prior written permission.
EDR and ils logos(including Sanbom and Sanborn Map)are trademarks of Environmental Data Resources,Inc.or its affiliates.All other
trademarks used herein are the ro ert of their res eclive owners.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
A search of available environmental records was conducted by Environmental Data Resources, Inc.
(EDR).
TARGET PROPERTY INFORMATION
ADORESS
PALM DESERT,CA 92260 .
PALM DESERT,CA 92260
DATABASES WITH NO MAPPED SITES
No mapped sites were found in EDR's search of available ("reasonably ascertainable ") government
records withi�the requested search area for the following data6ases: -
FEDERAL RECORDS
NPL_________________________National Priority�ist
Proposed NPL______________Proposed National Priority List Sites
Delisted NPL_______________.National Priority List Deletions
NPL RECOVERY .Federal Superfund Liens
CERCLIS_____________________Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation,and Liability Information
System
CERC-NFRAP CERCLIS No Further Remedial Action Planned
CORRACTS__________________Corrective Action Report
RCRA-TSDP_________________ Resource Conservation and RecoveryAct Information
RCRA-LQG__________________ Resource Conservation and Recovery Act Information
ERNS________________________ Emergency Response Notifcation System
HMIRS Hazardous Materials Information Reporting System
US ENG CONTROLS________.Engineering Controls Sites List
US IN5T CONTROL________.Sites with Institutional Controls
DOD_________________________.Department of Defense Sites
FUDS________________________ Formerly Used Defense Sites
US BROWNFIELDS A Listing of Brownfelds Sites
CONSENL__________________.Superfund (CERCLA)Consent Decrees
ROD____________ Records Of Decision
UMTRA______________________ Uranium Mill Tailings Sites
ODI__________________________ Open Dump Inventory
TRIS Toxic Chemical Release Inventory System
TSCA Toxic Substances Control Act
FTTS_________________________FI FRA/TSCA Tracking System-FIFRA(Federal Insecticide,Fungicide,&
.Rodenticide Act)/TSCA(Toxic Substances Control Act)
SSTS________________________.Section 7Tracking Systems
ICIS__________________________ Integrated Compliance Information System
PADS______ PCB Activity Database System
MLTS________________________ Material Licensing Tracking System
MINES_______________________ MinesMasterindexFile
RAATS RCRA Administrative Action Tracking System
STATE AND LOCAL RECORDS
HIST Cal-Sites Historical Calsites Database
TC01805628.7r EXECUTIVESUMMARYI
EXECUTNE SUMNIARY
CA BOND EXP.PLAN_______ Bond Expenditure Plan
SCH_______________________.School Property Evaluation Program
Toxic Pits.___ Toxic Pits Cleanup Act Sites
SWFILF_____ Solid Waste Information System
WfNUDS/SWAT______________.Waste Management Unit Database
SLIC_________________________ Statewide SLIC Cases
HIST UST____________________ Hazardous Substance Storage Container Database
AST____________ AbovegroundPetroleumStorageTankFacilities
Notify 65 Proposition 65 Records
DEED________________________ Deed Restriction Listing
� VCP__________________________Voluntary Cleanup Program Properties
WIP_.______ Well Investigation Program Case List
CDL______________._._._.Clandestine Drug Labs
RESPONSE_________________State Response Sites
ENVIROSTOR______________.EnviroStor Database
TRIBAL RECORDS
INDIAN RESERV_____________Indian Reservations
INDIAN LUST Leaking Underground Storage Tanks on Indian Land
INDIAN UST__________________Underground Storage Tanks on Indian Land
EDR PROPRIETARY RECORDS
Manufactured Gas Plants___ EDR Proprietary Manufactured Gas Plants
SURROUNDING SITES:SEARCH RESULTS
Surrounding sites were identifed.
Page numbers and map identifcation numbers refer to the EDR Radius Map report where detailed data on
individual sites can be reviewed.
Sites listed in bold italics are in multiple databases.
Unmappable(orphan)sites are not considered in the foregoing analysis.
FEDERALRECOROS
RCRAInfo: RCRAInfo is EPA's comprehensive information system, providing access to data supporting
the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act(RCRA)of 1976 and the Hazardous and Solid Waste Amendments(HSWA)
of 1984. RCRAInfo replaces the data recording and reporting abilities of the Resource Conservation and
Recovery Information System(RCRIS).The database includes selective i�formation on sites which generate,
transport, store , treat and/or dispose of hazardous waste as defined by the Resource Conservation and
Recovery Act(RCRA).Conditionally exempt small quantity generators(CESQGs)generate less than 100 kg of
hazardous waste,or less than 1 kg of acutely hazardous waste per month.Small quantity generators(SQGs)
generate between 100 kg and 1,000 kg of hazardous waste per month Large quantity generators generate over
1,000 kilograms(kg)of hazardous waste,or over t kg of acutely hazardous waste per month.Transporters are
individuals or entities that move hazardous waste from the generator offsite to a facility that can recycle,
treat,store,or dispose of the waste.TSDFs treat,store,or dispose of the waste.
A review of the RCRA-SQG list,as provided by EDR,and dated 06/13/2006 has revealed that there are 5
RCRA-SQG sites within the searched area.
TC01805628.ir EXECUTIVESUMMARY2
' EXECUTIUE SUMMARY
Site - Address Map ID Page
CNARLES BIEHL 75 091 ST CHARLES PL N 2 9
EXCLUS/VE AUTO BODY 74872 VELIE WAY#7 5 13
PALM DESERT BODY&PAINT,lNC 74867 VELIE WY 5 14
JULES AUTO SERVICE 74841 AVE 42 5 15
VALLEYWIDE TOOL REPAIR 74 991 JONI DR UNIT 6 6 15
FINDS:The Facility Index System contains both facility information and"pointers"to other
sources of information that contain more detail.These include:RCRIS; Permit Compliance System(PCS);
Aerometric Information Retrieval System(AIRS); FATES(FIFRA[Federal Insecticide Fungicide Rodenticide Act]
and TSCA Enforcement System, FTTS[FIFRA/TSCA Tracking System]; CERCLIS; DOCKET(Enforcement Docket used to
manage and track information on civil judicial enforcement cases for all environmental statutes); Federal
Underground Injection Control(FURS); Federal Reporting Data System(FRDS);Surface Impoundments(SIA);TSCA
Chemicals in Commerce Information System (CICS); PADS; RCRA-J (medical waste transporters/disposers);TRIS;
and TSCA.The source of this database is the U.S. EPA/NTIS.
A review of the FINDS list, as provided by EDR, and dated 07/21/2006 has revealed that there are 6
FINDS sites within the searched area.
Site Address Map ID Page
CHARLES BIEHL 75 091 ST CHARLES PL N 2 9
EXCLUS/VE AUTO BODY 74872 VELIE WAY#7 5 13
PALM DESERT BODY&PAINT,lNC 74867 VELIE WY 5 14
JULES AUTO SERVICE 74841 AVE 42 5 15
VALLEYW/DE TOOL REPA/R 74 991 JONI DR UNIT 6 6 15
COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST 43-000 COOK ST 7 20
STATE AND LOCAL RECORDS
WDS:California Water Resources Control Board-Waste Discharge System.
A review of the CA WDS list,as provided by EDR,and dated 09/20l2006 has revealed that there is 1 CA
WDS site within the searched area.
Site Address Map ID Page
PALM DESERT WRP#10 00-008 43000 COOK ST 7 19
CORTESE: This database identifies public drinking water wells with detectable levels of
co�tamination, hazardous substance sites selected for remedial action, sites with k�own toxic material
identified through the abandoned site assessment program,sites with USTs having a reportable release and all
solid waste disposal facilities from which there is known migration. The source is the California
Environmental Protection Agency/Office of Emergency Information.
A review of the Cortese list, as provided by EDR, and dated 04/01/2001 has revealed that there are 2
Cortese sites within the searched area.
TC01805628.7r EXECUTIVESUMMARY3
` EXEGUTIVE SUMMARY
Site . Address Map ID Page
COLONYCABLEV/SION 41725COOKSTREET 3 11
CVWD-PALM DESERT 43000 COOK 7 16
SWRCY:A listing of recycling facilities in California.
A review of the SWRCY list, as provided by EDR, and dated 10/10/2006 has revealed that there is 1
SWRCY site within the searched area.
Site Address Map ID Page
TOMRA PACIFIC INC/RALPHS#27 74884 COUNTRY CLUB DR 1 8
LUST:The Leaking Underground Storage Tank Incident Reports contain an inventory of reported -
leaking underground storage tank incidents.The data come from the State Water Resources Control Board Leaking
Underground Storage Tank Information System.
A review of the LUST list, as provided by EDR, and dated 10/11/2006 has revealed that there are 4
LUST sites within the searched area.
Site Address Map ID Page
PALMER CABLE VISION 41725 COOK ST 3 9
COLONY CABLE V/SION 41725 COOK STREET 3 11
Facility Stalus:Case Cbsed
CVWD-PALM DESERT 43000 COOK 7 16
CVWD PALM DESERT 43000 COOK STREET 7 16
Facility Siatus:Case Closed
CA FID:The Facility Inventory Database contains active and inactive underground storage tank
locations.The source is the State Water Resource Control Board.
A review of the CA FID UST list,as provided by EDR,and dated 10/31/1994 has revealed that there are �
2 CA FID UST sites within the searched area.
Site Address Map ID Page
PALMER CABLE VISION 41725 COOK ST 3 9
COACHELLA VALLEYWATER DIST 43000 COOK ST 7 21
UST:The Underground Storage Tank database contains registered USTs. USTs are regulated under
Subtitle I of the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act(RCRA).The data come from the State Water Resources
Control Board's Hazardous Substance Storage Container Database.
A review of the UST list,as provided by EDR, and dated 10/11/2006 has revealed that there is 1 UST
TC01805628.tr EXECUTIVESl1MMARY4
' EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
site within the searched area.
Site Address MapID Page
CVWD 43000 COOK ST 7 18
SWEEPS:Statewide Environmental Evaluation and Planning System. This underground storage tank
listing was updated and maintained by a company contacted by the SWRCB in the early 1980's. The listing is no
longer updated or maintained. The local agency is the contact for more information on a site on the SWEEPS
list.
A review of the SWEEPS UST list,as provided by EDR,and dated 06/01/1994 has revealed that there are
2 SWEEPS UST sites within the searched area.
Site Address Map ID Page
PALMER CABLE VISION 41725 COOK ST 3 9
COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST 43000 COOK ST 7 21 "
CHMIRS:The California Hazardous Material Incident Report System contains information on reported -
hazardous material incidents, i.e., accidental releases or spilis. The source is the California O�ce of
Emergency Services.
A review of the CHMIRS list,as provided by EDR,and dated 12/31/2004 has revealed that there are 2
CHMIRS sites within the searched area.
Site Address Map ID Page
Not reported 43-000 COOK ST. 7 18
Not reported 75-000 GER.4LD FORD DR. 8 21
DRYCLEANERS:A list of drycleaner related facilities that have EPA ID numbers. These are facilities
with ceRain SIC codes: power laundries,family and commercial;garment pressing and cleaners'agents; linen
supply;coin-operated laundries and cleaning;drycleaning plants except rugs;carpet and upholster cleaning;
industrial launderers;laundry and garment services.
A review of the CLEANERS list,as provided by EDR,and dated 04/18/2005 has revealed that there are 3
CLEANERS sites within the searched area.
Site Address Map ID Page
PALM DESERT C&C CLEANERS INC 74924 COUNTRY CLUB DR S 1 3
C 8 C CLEANERS 74924 COUNTRY CLUB DR S 1 4
C&C CLEANERS 74-924 COUNTRY CLUB OR, 1 6
TC07805628.ir EXECUTIVESUMMARYS
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
HAZNET:The data is extracted from the copies of hazardous waste manifests received each year by
the DTSC. The annual volume of manifests is typically 700,000-1,000,000 annually,representing approximately
350,000-500,000 shipments. Data from non-California manifests&continuation sheets are�ot included at the
present time. Data are from the manifests submitted without correction,and therefore many contain some
invalid values for data elements such as generator ID,TSD ID,waste category,&disposal method.The source
is the Department of Toxic Substance Control is the agency
A review of the HAZNET list,as provided by EDR,and dated 12/31/2003 has revealed that there are 7
HAZNET sites within the searched area.
Site Address Map ID Page
C B C CLEANERS 74-924 COUNTRY CLUB DR, 1 6
COUNTRY CLUB ANIMAL CLINIC 74998 COUNTRY CLUB DR# 1 �8
PALMER CABLE VISION 41725 COOK ST . 3 9
JT MAINTANCE 74991 VELIE WAY#3 4 12
VALLEY WIDE TOOL REPAIR 42005 COOK ST#108 4 12
EXCLUSIVEAUTOBODY 74872VELIEWAY#7 5 13
Not reported _ 75-000 GERALD FORD DR. 8 2?
Emissions Inventory Data:Toxics and criteria pollutant emissions data collected by the ARB and local air pollution
agencies
A review of the EMI list,as provided by EDR,and dated 12/31/2004 has revealed that there are 2 EMI
sites within the searched area.
Site Address Map ID Page
JOHN'S FURNISHINGS,JOHN ORTEG 74-872 VELIE WAY#5 5 13
DESERT MAGIC,JOHN ISRAEL ETT 74-872 VELIE WY#5 5 14
TC01805628.ir EXECUTIVESUMMARY6
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Please refer to the end of the findings report for unmapped orphan sites due to poor or inadequate address information.
� TC07805628.ir EXECUTNESUMMARY7
118°R'OD" 116°l0'W"
� � .
� ¢ 1 � ��4h Y'�C�1 t ZjOf S]Jt'.1�.9
$ � a �8� � � �
RM4[SIINIP/.�fl Q �•� \ M61M1iPA0fl FMY1I61lNiMOP xA PVE�IIE:B
�' � �^ 4
1
� . � b
� a . � /
: �
P+ N
� m
° � �
m
m cs oe
' : � \
m W
a
.�. _c - N ' o'"_'°_g a— � ec� fr
; `a---��� 9 m \ . \ .
Q9 � � ~o c ~ a�' .. � GMEFiP '. H
y'�. 4- y a �.\r �y 0�{FOOII
4
y 4-� �
9
�E eL
,p,\tlqyP00 � ��y_ >
PG���
p M
. i ... $ ' Fop\ �yn ' \ Ofl M0.LYNOC
.��� _ �0 � // ��m
� µ e m�:'.. YMrtE11UqgEI
Q Q � q
o I $ /
fPP.IE $ �^ .. REONNFMP� .
(. \d .. ��� ,..
I � � PMfHJRS)�. � v� �. � �
& 11Ed0 $ew \ � $ H�. FUNMM49YPIIrG90fl �,. iS
� .. \ g �� � �' ; t Q
.. YIALANiANA `�� � �
.. \ , ze 'y: u
� " �IjFiS'PSc�§� �\� u c�`�� 3 �
�'�AMMMPF HOYlEYLNF \ OVERFIN �
�
�1 � � LEX44t1P �<CMNOE�
\ � /-� / m
� ( Ng i3-`- \ " q
� o CO,y�_ \ I�O.iVE 9PNOFVE p� � GOLOGAM�
��9 //� VEl'c'ffi1
r
t :
o �d `�43'W �. ��' \ M W e ..
n a �..
COM�., y. \ .M:q10P � �` o � e
�CIR .. 0 � r v "......_.-�, o ;�S
C�SIf((�y� �..�. P 41EPlE0Pm � ��� �
\ � a
—�-- �;� � ��
. e
a g
A6�: -. �:; m . m �„'_\
\ g ( m
� � $ e \
% � `�-��
� �1 � y R: �� �"�
� � \, �
e
�
m w
� � \, sw
[wnsr a m„ "`. ��.'. � �� < c W
vnFnnoon v[qe[ c* ' a
q6tFPOP � � �� p
ftUN`Y
\�� FPEOWLRMG�R
� �ko
rA @9 y4'�� � �f'PACO�'. � \
,1 � \
IPWFY / ChIf11NRWPV IiiU�fl: $ ,
��
IIPERVE Q
� �
� � � '
ii6°]2'W 116°30'00"
EDR DataMap�- Corridor Study
EOR'OEmiranmental �� �
DaGResaurceslnc Cook Street Restriping
-.
...::.5�..'...::
�d Liated 5itea O Waterways Q Water Pelm Deaert,CA
Q Earthquake Epicenters�Railroada �Supertund Sitee
(Richter5orgmatar) r� ContourLinee�FederalDODSites N
��Search Baundary o Ve tla
Roads ��P�Pelinee �Indian Reservationa 91A 1-.-{�—�
�MajorRoads M„'Powerlinee �10o-YrRoodZones 1-�' Sea/einMiles
�Fault Linea 0 National Watland Inventory
GppqMON06EORinceROOOT�IeI./azPd.Wrz005. OIBASBtB.tr��ANovOA
MAP FINDINGS SOMMARY
� Total
Database Plotted
FEDERALRECORDS
NPL 0
Proposed NPL 0
Delisted NPL 0 �
NPLRECOVERY 0
CERCLIS 0
CERC-NFRAP 0
CORRACTS 0
RCRA TSD 0
RCRA Lg.Quan. Gen. 0
RCRA Sm. Quan.Gen. 5
ERNS 0
HMIRS 0 _
US ENG CONTROLS 0
US INST CONTROL 0
DOD 0
FUDS 0
US BROWNFIELDS 0
CONSENT 0
ROD 0
UMTRA 0
ODI 0
TRIS 0
TSCA 0
FiTS 0
SSTS 0
ICIS 0
PADS 0
MLTS 0
MINES 0
FINDS 6
RAATS 0
STATE AND LOCAL RECORDS
Hist Cal-Sites 0
CA Bond Exp. Plan 0
SCH 0
Toxic Pits 0
State Landfill 0
CA WDS 1
WMUDS/SWAT 0
Cortese 2
SWRCY 1
LUST 4
CA FID UST 2
SLIC 0
UST 1
HIST UST 0
- TC01805628.1r Page 1 of24
MAP FINDWGS SUMMARY ;
, Total
Database Plotted
AST 0
SWEEPS UST 2
CHMIRS 2
Notify 65 0
DEED 0
VCP 0
DRYCLEANERS 3
WIP 0
CDL 0
RESPONSE 0
HAZNET 7
EMI 2
ENVIROSTOR 0
TRIBAL RECORDS -
INDIAN RESERV 0
INDIAN LUST 0
INDIAN UST 0
EDR PROPRIETARY RECORDS
Manufactured Gas Plants 0
NOTES:
Sites may be listed in more than one database
TC01805628.1 r Page 2 of 24
����MAP FINDINGS
Map ID
Direction EDR ID Number
Distance
Distance(ft.)Site �atabase(s) EPA ID Number
1 PALM DESERT C&C CLEANERS INC CLEANERS 5105807986
74924 COUNTRY CLUB DR STE 110 NIA
PALM DESERT,CA 92260
CLEANERS:
EPA Id: CAL000259949
NAICS Code: 81232
NAICS Description: Drycleaning and Laundry Services(except Coin-Operated)
SIC Code: 721'i
SIC�escription: Power Laundries,Family and Commercial
Create Date: 09/27/2002
Facility Active: Yes
Inactive Date: Not reported
Facility Addr2: Not reported
Mailing Name: Not reported
Mailing Address: 74924 COUNTRY CLUB DR STE 110
Mailing Address 2: Not reported
Mailing State: "CA -
Mailing Zip: 922600000
Region Code: 4
Owner Name: SOOK HEE LEE SIN
Owner Address: 74924 COUNTRY CLUB DR STE 110
Owner Address 2: Nol reported
Owner Telephone: 7607799277
Contacl Name: SOOK HEE LEE SIN/OWNER
�� Contact Address: 74924 COUNTRY CLUB DR STE 110
Contacl Address 2: Not reported
Contact Telephone: 7607799277
EPA Id: CAL000259949
NAICS Code: 81232
NAICS Description: Drycleaning and Laundry Services(except Coin-Operated)
SIC Code: 7212
SIC Description: Garment Pressing,and Agents for Laundries and Drycleaners .
Create Date: 09/27/2002
FacilityActive: Yes
Inactive Date: Not reported
Facility Addr2: Not reported
Mailing Name: Not reported
Mailing Address: 74924 COUNTRY CLUB DR STE 110
Mailing Address 2: Not reported
Mailing State: CA
Mailing Zip: 922600000
Region Code: 4
Owner Name: SOOK HEE LEE SIN
Owner Address: 74924 COUNTRY CLUB DR STE 110
Owner Address 2: Not reported
Ow�er Telephone: 7607799277
Contact Name; SOOK HEE LEE SINlOWNER
Contact Address: ]4924 COUNTRY CLUB DR STE 110
Contact Address 2: Not reported
Contact Telephone: 7607799277
EPA Id: CAL000259949
NAICS Code: 81232
NAICS Descriplion: Drycleaning and Laundry Services(except Coin-Operaled) �
SIC Code: 7216
SIC Description: Drycleaning Plants,�Except Rug Cleaning
Create Date: 09/27/2002
TC01805626.1 r Page 3 of 24
; MAP FIN�INGS
Map ID
Direction EDR ID Number
Distance
Distance(ft.)Site Database(s) EPA ID Num6er
PALM DESERT C&C CLEANERS INC (Continued) 5705807986
Facility Active: Yes
Inactive Date: Not reported
Facility Add2: Not reported
Mailing Name: Not reported
Mailing Address: 74924 COUNTRY CLUB DR STE 110
Mailing Address 2: Not reported
Mailing State: CA
Mailing Zip: 922600000
Region Code: 4
Owner Name: SOOK HEE LEE SIN
Owner Address: 74924 COUNTRY CLUB DR STE 1'10
Owner Address 2: Not reported
Owner Telephone: 7607799277
Contact Name: SOOK HEE LEE SIN/OWNER
Contact Address: 74924 COUNTRY CLUB DR STE 1'10
Contact Address 2: 'Not repoded -
Contact Telephone: 7607799277
EPA Id: CAL000259949
NAICS Code: 81232
NAICS Description: Drycleaning and Laundry Services(except Coin-Operated)
SIC Code: 7219
SIC Description: Laundry and Garmeni Services,NEC(except diaper service and clothing alteration and repair)
Create Date: 09/27/2002
Facility Active: Yes
Inactive Date: Not reported . ,
Facility Add2: Not reported
Mailing Name: Not reported
Mailing Address: 74924 COUNTRY CLUB DR STE 110 -
Mailing Address 2: Not reported
Mailing State: CA .
Mailing Zip: 922600000
Region Code: 4
Owner Name: SOOK HEE LEE SIN
Owner Address: 74924 COUNTRY CLUB DR STE 110
Owner Address 2: Not reported
Owner Telephone: 7607799277
Contaci Name: SOOK HEE LEE SIN/OWNER
Contad Address: 74924 COUNTRY CLUB DR STE 110 �.
Contact Address 2: Not reported
Contact Telephone: 7607799277
1 C&C CLEANERS CLEANERS 5105266651
74924 COUNTRY CLUB DR STE'I'10 N/A
PALM DESERT,CA 92260
CLEANERS:
EPA Id: CAL000181647
NAICS Code: 81232
NAICS Description: Orycleaning and Laundry Services(except Coin-Operated)
SIC Code: 7212
SIC Description: Gartnent Pressing,and Agents for Laundries and Drycleaners
Create�ate: O6/OB/1996 �
. Facility Acfive: No .
Inactive Date: 9/27/2002
FacilityAdd2: Notreported
. Mailing Name: Not reported
Mailing Address: 74924 COUNTRY CLUB DR STE t 10
TC01805628.1 r Page 4 of 24
?MAP FINDINGS
Map ID
Direclion EDR ID Number
Distance
Distance(ft.�Site Database(s) EPA ID Number
C&C CLEANERS (Continued) 5105266651
Mailing Address 2: Not repoded
Maili�g State: CA
Mailing Zip: 922600000
Region Code: 4
Owner Name: HONG LEE
Owner Address: 50-580 SPYGIASS HILL DR
Owner Address 2: Not reported
Owner Telephone: 7607778408
Contact Name: HONG LEE
Coniact Address: 74924 COUNTRY CLUB DR STE 110
Contact Address 2: Not reported
Coniact Telephone: 7607799277
EPA ld: CAL000181647
- NAICS Code: 8�232
NAICS Description: Drycleaning and Laundry Services(excepi Coin-Operated) -
SIC Code: 7216
SIC Description: Drycleaning Plants,Except Rug Cleaning
Create Date: 06/08/1998
FaciliryAclive: No
Inactive Date: 9/27/2002
Facility Addr2: Not reported
Mailing Name: Not reported
Mailing Address: 74924 COUNTRY CLUB DR STE 110
Mailing Address 2: Not reported
Mailing State: CA
Mailing Zip: 922600000
Region Code: 4
Owner Namer HONG LEE
OwnerAddress: 50-560 SPYGLASS HILL DR
OwnerAddress 2: Not reported
Owner Telephone: 7607778408 .
ConiactName: HONGLEE
Contact Address: 74924 COUNTRY CLUB DR STE 110
Contact Address 2: Not reported
Contact Telephone: 7607799277
EPA ld: CAL000181647
� NAICS Code: 81232
NAICS Descriplion: Drycleaning and Laundry Services(except Coin-Operated)
SIC Code: 7219 �
SIC Description: Laundry and Garment Services,NEC(except diaper service and cbthing alteration and repair)
Create Date: 06/08/1998
Facility Active: No
Inactive Date: 9/27/2002
Facility Add2: Noi reported
Mailing Name: Not reported
Mailing Address: 74924 COUNTRY CLUB DR STE 110
Mailing Address 2: Nol reported
Mailing Siate: CA
Mailing Zip: 922600000 .
Region Code: 4
Owner Name: HONG LEE
OwnerAddress: 50-580 SPYGLASS HILL DR
Owner Address 2: � Not repoAed
OwnerTelephone: 7607778408 �
Contact Name: HONG LEE
TC01805628.1 r Page 5 of 24
:���.MAP FINDINGS
Map ID
Direction EDR ID Number
Distance
Distance(flJSite Database(s) EPA ID Number
C&C CLEANERS (Continued) 5105266651
Contact Address: 74924 COUNTRY CLUB DR STE 110
Contact Address 2: Not reported
Contact Telephone: 7607799277
EPA Id: CAL000181647
NAICS Code: 81232
NAICS Descripiion: Drycleaning and laundry Services(except Coin-Operated)
SIC Code: 7211
SIC Description: Power Laundries,Family and Commercial
Create Date: O6/08/1998
Facility Active: No
Inactive Date: 9/27/2002
Facility Add2: Noi reported
Mailing Name: Not reported
Mailing Address: 74924 COUNTRY CWB DR STE 110
Mailing Address 2: 'Not reported -
Mailing State: CA
Mailing Zip: 922600000
Region Code: 4
Owner Name: HONG LEE
OwnerAddress: 50-580 SPYGLASS HI�L DR
Owner Address 2: Not reported .
� OwnerTelephone: 7607778406
Contact Name: HONG LEE
Contact Address: 74924 COUNTRY CLUB DR STE 110
Contact Address 2: Noi reported -
Contact Telephone: 7607799277
1 C&C CLEANERS HAZNET 5103953702
74-924 WUNTRY CLUB DR,#110 CLEANERS NIA
PALM DESERT,CA 92260
HAZNET:
Gepaid: CAL000173727
Contact: MOON RO
Telephone: 0000000000
Facility Add2: Not reported
Mailing Name: Not reported
Mailing Address: 74924 COUNTRY C�UB DR STE 110
Mailing City,St,Zip: PALM DESERT,CA 922601969
Gen County: Riverside
TSD EPA ID: CAD981397417
TSD County: Los Angeles
Waste Category: Halogenated solvenis(chloroform,methyl chloride,perchloroethyle�e,etc.)
Disposal Meihod: Recycler
Tons: .4792
Facility County: Riverside
Gepaid: CAL000173727
Contact: MOON RO
Telephone: 0000000000
Facility Add2: Not reported
MailingName: Notreported
Mailing Address: 74924 COUNTRY CLUB DR STE 110
Mailing City,St,Zip: PAIM DESERT,CA 922601969
Gen County: Riverside
TSD EPAID: CAD981397417
TSD County: Los Angeles
TC01805626.1 r Page 6 of 24
�'�. MAP FINDINGS �
Map ID
Direction EDR ID Number
Distance
Distance(ft.)Site Database(s) EPA ID Number
C&C CLEANERS (Continued) 5�03953702
Waste Category: Not repoded
Disposal Method: Recycler
Tons: .0000
Facility County: Riverside
Gepaid: CA�000173727
Contact: MOON RO
Telephone: 0000000000 �
Facility Add2: Not reported
Mailing Name: Not reported
Mailing Address: 74924 COUNTRY CLUB DR STE 110
Mailing City,St,Zip: PALM DESERT,CA 92260'1969
Gen County: Riverside
TSD EPA ID: CAD981397417
TSD Counly: Los Angeles
Waste Category: -Halogenated solvents(chloroform,methyl chbride,perchloroethylene,etc.) -
Disposal Method: Recycler
Tons: .0000
Faciliry County: Riverside
Gepaid: CAL000173727
Contact MOON RO
Telephone: 0000000000
Facility Add2: Not reported
- Mailing Name: Not reported
Mailing Address: 74924 COUNTRY CLUB DR STE 110
Mailing Ciry,St,Zip: PALM DESERT,CA 922601969 �
Gen County: Riverside
TSD EPAID: CAD981397417
TSD County: Los Angeles
Waste Category: Halogenated solvenis(chloroform,methyl chloride,perchloroelhylene,etcJ
Disposal Method: Recycler
Tons: .4214
Facility Counry: Riverside
�link fhic tir P�While viewing on your computer to access
-1 additional CA_HAZNET:record(s)in lhe EDR Site Report.
CLEANERS:
EPA Id: CAL000173727
NAICS Code: Not reported
NAICS Description: Not reported
SIC Code: Not reported
SIC Description: Not reported
Create Date: 07/13/1995
. FacilityActive: No
Inactive Date: 6/30/1999
Facility Add2: Not reported
Mailing Name: Not reported
Mailing Address: 74924 COUNTRY CLUB DR STE 110
Mailing Address 2: Not reported
Mailing State: CA
Mailing Zip: 922601969
Region Code: 4
Owner Name: MOON RO .
OwnerAddress: --
Owner Address 2: Not reported
TC01805628.1 r Page 7 of 24
���.MAP FINDINGS
Map ID
Direction EDR ID Number
Distance
Distance(ft.)Site Database(s) EPA ID Number
C&C CLEANERS (Continued) 5103953702
Owner Telephone: 00�0000000
Contact Name: MOON RO
Contact Address: INACTIVE PER VQ99-BMI
Contact Address 2: Not reported
Contact Telephone: 7607799277
1 COUNTRY CLUB ANIMAL CLINIC HAZNET 5103958719
74996 COUNTRY ClU6 DR#240 NIA
PALM DESERT,CA 92260
HAZNET:
Gepaid: CAL000147580
Contact: LILLIAN ROBERTS,DVM
Telephone: 0000000000
Facility Add2: Not reported
Mailing Name: Not reported
Maili�g Address: 74998 COUNTRY CLUB DR#240
Mailing City,St,Zip: PALM DESERT,CA 922600000
Gen Counry: Riverside
TSD EPA ID: CAD983604000
TSD County: San Bernardino
Waste Category: Photochemicals/photoprocessing waste
Disposal Method: Recycler
Tons: .2293
FaciftyCounly: Riverside
t TOMRA PACIFIC INC/RALPHS#27 SWRCY 5107138'112
74884 COUNTRY CLUB DR . N/q
PALM DESERT,CA 92260
SWRCY:
Certification Status: O
Facility Pho�e Number. (951)520-1700
Date facility became certified: 03/29/99
Date facilily began operating: OS/01/99
Date facility ceased operating: Still operating
Whether The Facility Is Grandfaihered: Not reported
Convenience Zone Where Faciltiy Located: 4359
Convenience Zone Where Faciltiy Located 2: 0
Convenience Zone Where Faciltiy Located 3: 0
Convenience Zone Where Faciltiy located 4: 0
Convenience Zone Where Faciltiy Located 5: 0
Convenience Zone Where Faciltiy Located 6: 0
Convenience Zone Where Faciltiy�ocated 7: 0
Aluminum Beverage Containers Redeemed: AL
Glass Beverage Containers Redeemed: GL
Plastic Beverage Containers Redeemed: PL
Other mat beverage containers redeemed: OB
Refilla6le Beverage Containers Redeemed: Not reported
TC01805628.1r Page 8 of 24
�:.'MAP FINDINGS
Map ID
Direction EDR ID Number
Distance
Distance(R.)Site Database(s) EPA ID Number
2 CHARLES BIEHL RCRA-SQG 1000818781
75 091 ST CHARLES PL NO G FINDS CAD983646936
PALM DESERT,CA 92260
RCRAInfo:
Owoer. CHARLES BIEHL
(619)341-0062
EPA ID: CAD983646936
Contack KAREN MORERA
(619)341-0062
Classifcation: Small Quantity Generator
TSOF Activities: Not reported
Violation Status:No violations found
FINDS:
Other Pertinent Envi�onmenlal Activity Identified at Site -
RCRAInfo is a�ational information system that supports the Resource
Conservation and Recovery Act(RCRA)program thmugh lhe tracking oF events and
activities related to facilities thal generale,transport,and treat,store,or
dispose of hazardous waste.RCRAInfo allows RCRA progrem staff to track the
notification,permit,compliance,and corrective action activities required
under RCRA.
3 PALMERCABLEVISION HAZNET S101589622
41725 COOK ST � LUST NIA
PALM DESERT,CA 92260 CA FID UST
SWEEPS UST
HAZNET:
Gepaid: CAL000209777
Contact: TOM MC KIMMEY
Telephone: 760340t312
FacilityAdd2: Notreported
Mailing Name: Not reported
Mailing Address: 41725 COOK ST
Mailing City,St,Zip: PALM DESERT,CA 922600000
Gen County: Riverside
TSD EPA ID: CAT000613927
TSD Couniy: Riverside
Waste Category: Aqueous soWtion with less than 10°/a total organic residues
Disposal Method: Transfer Station
Tons: 0.36
Facility County: Riverside
LUST:
Region: RIVERSIDE
Site Closed: Yes
Employee ID: 13
Facility ID: 93102
Case Type: Undefined
Status: 9
CA FID UST:
Facility ID: 33000182
TC01805628.1 r Page 9 of 24
.��..MAP FINDINGS
Map ID
Direction EDR ID Num6er
Distance
Distance(ft.)Site Database(s) EPA ID Number
PALMER CABLE VISION (Continued) S'101589822
Regulated By: UTNKA
Regulated Ip: Not reported
Cortese Code: Not reported
SIC Code: Not reported
Facility Phone: 6193401312 .
Mail To: Not reported
Mailing Address: 41725 COOK ST
Mailing Address 2: Not reported
Mailing City,St,Zip: PALM DESERT 92260
Contact Not reported
Contact Phone: Not reported
DUNs Number: Not reported
NPOES Number: Not reported
EPA ID: Not reported
Commenls: Not reported
Status: 'Active -
SWEEPS UST:
Status: A
Comp Number: 60
Number: 1
. Board Of Equalization: 44-017829
Ref Date: 11-17-92
Act Date: 11-17-92
Crealed Date: 11-21-88
Tank Status: A
Owner Tank Id: 000333 .
Swrcb Tank Id: 33-000-000060-000001
AcN Date: 11-17-92
Capacity: 5000
Tank Use: M.V.FUEL
Sig: P
Content REG UNLEA�ED �
Number Of Tanks: 2
Status: A
Comp Number: 60
Number: 1
Board Of Equalization: 44-017829
Ref Date: 11-17-92
Act Date: 11-17-92
Created Date: 11-2'I-88
Tank Status: A
Owner Tank Id: 000333
Swrcb Tank Id: 33-000-000060-000002
AcN Date: 11-17-92
Capacity: 550
Tank Use: M.V.FUEL
Stg: P
Content: DIESEL
Number Of Tanks: Not reported
TC01805628.1r Page 10 of 24
�;MAP FINDWGS
Map ID
Direction EDR ID Number
Distance
� Distance(R.)Site Database(s) EPA ID Num6er
3 COLONY CABLE VISION LUST S103820933
41725 COOK STREET Cortese N/A
PALM DESERT,CA 92260
LUST:
Region: STATE
Case Type: Soil only
Cross Street: Not reported
Enf Type: None Taken
Funding: Not reported
How Discovered: OM
How Stopped: Not reported
Leak Cause: UNK
LeakSource: UNK
Globalld: T0606501002
Stop Date: � 1993-01-05 00:00:00
Confrm Leak: 1993-02-09 00:00:00
Workplan: 1994-03-22 00:00:00 -
Prelim Assess: Not reported
Pollution Char: Not reported
Remed Plan: Not reported
Remed Action: Not reported
Monitoring: Not reported
Close Date: 1994-OB-02 00:00:00
Discover Date: 1993-01-27 00:00:00
Enforcement Dt: 1965-01-Ot OO:OO:OD
Release Date: 1993-02-09 00:00:00
Review Date: 1994-09-20 00:00:00
Enter Date: 1994-04-25 00:00:00
MTBE Date: Not repoded
GWQualifier: Notreported
Soil Qualifier: Not reported
Max MTBE GW ppb: Not reported �
Max MTBE Soil ppb: Not reported
County: 33
Org Name: Not reported
Reg Board: Colorado River Basin Region
Status: Case Closed
Chemical: Gasoline
Contact Person: Not reported
Responsible Party: COLONY CABLE VISION �
RP Address: 41725 COOK STREET,PALM DESERT,CA 92260 �
Interim: Not reported
Oversight Prgm: LUST
MTBE Class: '
MTBE Conc: 0
MTBE Fuel: 1
MTBE Tested: Site NOT Tested for MTBE.Includes Unknown and Not Analyzed.
Staff: RFL
Slaff Inilials: Not reported
Lead Agency: LocalAgency
Local Agency: 33000L
Hydr Basin#: COACHELLA VALLEY(7-
Benefcial: Notreported
Priority: Noi reported
Cleanup Fund Id: Not repoded
Work Suspended: Not reported
Local Case#: 93-102 �
Case Number: 7T2260013
TC01805628.tr Page 11 of 24
::MAP FINDINGS
Map ID
Direction EDR ID Number
Distance
Distance(H.)Site Dalabase(s) EPA ID Num6er
COLONY CABLE VISION (Continued) 5103820933
Qty Leaked: Not reported
Abate Method: Excavate and Dispose-remove contaminated soil and dispose in approved sile
Operator. TONY I.ICARDO
Water System Name:Noi reported
Well Name: Not reported
Distance To Lust: 0
Waste Discharge Global ID: Not reported
Waste Disch Assigned Name: Not reported
Summary: Not reported
LUST:
Region: 7
Lead Agency: Local Agency .
Siatus: 9-Case Closed
Case Num: 7T2260013
ID: 667
GloballD: � T0606501002
Case Worker. KO
Substance: Gasoline-Automotive
Cortese:
. Region: CORTESE
Facility Add2: 4�725 COOK STREET
4 JT MAINTANCE HAZNET 5105722256
74991 VELIE WAY#3 NIA
PALM DESERT,CA 92260
HAZNET:
Gepaid: CA1000006402
Contact DEACT PER VQ96
Telephone: --
Facility Add2: Not reported
Mailing Name: Not reported
Mailing Address: 74991 VELIE WAY#3
Mailing City,St,Zip: PALM DESERT,CA 922600000
Gen County: Riverside
TSD EPA ID: Not reported
TSD County: Los Angeles �
Waste Category: Unspecifed oil-containing waste
Disposal Method: Not reported
Tons: 0.45
Facility County: Noi reported
4 VALLEY WIDE TOOL REPAIR � HAZNET 5107149115
42005 COOK ST#108 NIA
PALM DESERT,CA 92211
HAZNET:
Gepaid: CAL000271561
Contacl: 6EORGE RAMIREZ/OWNER
Telephone: 7606749222 �
Faciliry Addr2: Not reported
Mailing Name: Not reported
Mailing Address: 42005 COOK ST#108
TC01805628.tr Paget2of24
�'MAP FINDINGS
Map ID
Direction � � EDR ID Number
Disiance
Distance(ft.�Site Database(s) EPA ID Number
VALLEYWIDETOOLREPAIR (Continued) 5107149N5
Mailing City,St,Zip: PALM DESERT,CA 92211
Gen County: Riverside
TSD EPA ID: CAT000613927
TSD Couniy: Riverside
Waste Category: Aqueous solution with less than 10%total organic residues
Disposal Method: Transfer Station
Tons: 0.08
Faciliry County: Riverside
5 JOHN'S FURNISHINGS,JOHN ORTEG EMI 5106833566
74-872 VELIE WAY#5 N/A
PALM DESERT,CA 922fi0 �
EMI:
Yeac 1990
Carbo�Monoxide Emissions Tons/Yr: 33
Air Basin: SS
Facility ID: 71916
Air District Name: SC
SIC Code: 2426
Air District Name: SOUTH COAST AQMD
Community Health Air Pollution Info System: Noi reported
Consolidated Emission Reporiing Rule: Not repoKed
� Total Organic Hydmcarbon Gases Tons/Yr: 1
Reactive Organic Gases TonslYr: 'I
Carbon Monoxide Emissions Tons/Yr: 0
NOX-Oxides of Nitrogen Tons/Yr: 0
SOX-Oxides of Sulphur Tons/Yr: 0
Particulate Malier Tons/Yr: 0
Part.Matter 10 Micrometers&Smllr Tons/Yr: 0
5 EXCLUSIVEAUTOBODY RCRA-SQG 1000293095
74872 VELIE WAY#7 FINDS CAD982520769
PALM DESERT,CA 92260 HAZNET
RCRAInfo:
Owner: STEVE HASTOR
(415)555-1212
EPA ID: CAD982520769
� Contack ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGER
(6'19)340-4855
Classification: Small Quantity Generetor
TSDF Activities: Nol reported
Violation Siatus:No violations found
FINDS:
Other Pertinent E�vironmental Activity Identified at Site
RCRAInfo is a national information system that supports the Resource
Conservation and Recovery Acl(RCR4)program lhrough the tracking of events and
activities relaled to facilities that generate,transport,and treat,store,or
dispose of hazardous waste.RCRAInfo allows RCRA program staff to track the
notification,permit,compliance,and correciive action activities required
under RCR4.
� TCO'I805626.7 r Page 13 of 24
'��.MAP FINDINGS
Map ID
Direction EDR ID Number
Distance
Distance(ft.)Site Database(s) EPA ID Number
EXCLUSIVE AUTO BODY (Continued) 1000293095
HAZNET:
Gepaid: CAL000041330
Contact: HASTOR STEVE �
Telephone: 0000000000
Facility Addr2: Not reported
MailingName: Notreported
Mailing Address: 74872 VELIE WAY
Mailing City,St,Zip: PALM DESERT,CA 922600000
Gen County: Riverside
TSD EPA ID: CAD008252405
TSD County: Los Angeles
Waste Category: Unspecified solveni mixture Waste
Disposal Melhod: Recycler
Tons: .2293
Facility County: .Riverside
5 DESERT MAGIC,JOHN ISRAEL E1T EMI S106829972
74•872 VELIE WY#5 N/A
PALM DESERT,CA 92260
EMI:
Year: 19,87
Car6on Monoxide Emissions Tons/Yr: 33
Air Basin: � SS
Facility ID: 47188
Air District Name: SC
SIC Code: 2511
Air District Name: SOUTH COAST AQMD
Communily Health Air Pollution Info System: Not reported
Consolidated Emission Reporting Rule: Not repoAed
Total Organic Hydrocarbon Gases To�slYr: .1
Reaclive Organic Gases Tons/Yr: 1
Carbon Monoxide Emissions Tons/Yr: 0
NOX-Oxides of Nitrogen Tons/Yr: 0 �
SOX-Oxides of Sulphur Tons/Yr: 0
Particulate Matter Tons/Yr. 0
Part.Matter 10 Micrometers&Smllr Tons/Yr: 0
5 PALM DESERT BODY 8.PAINT,INC RCRA-SQG 1000294113
74867 VELIE WY PINDS CA0981376809
PALM DESERT,CA 92260
RCRAInfo:
Owner: NOT REQUIRED
(415)555-1212
EPA ID: CAD981376809
Contact Not reported
Classification: Small Quantity Generator
TSDF Activities: Not reported
TC01605628.1 r Page 14 of 24
.�'.��MAP FINDINGS
Map ID
Direction EDR ID Number
Distance
�istance(fl.)Site Database(s) EPA ID Number
PALM DESERT BODY&PAINT,INC (Continued) 1000294113
Violation Status:No violations found
FINDS:
' Other PeAinent Environmental Activity Ideniifed at Site
RCRAInfo is a national information system that supports the Resource
Conservation a�d Recovery Act(RCR4)program through ihe tracking of events and
activities related to facilities lhat ge�erate,transpod,and treat,store,or
dispose of hazardous waste.RCRAInfo allows RCR4 program staff to track ihe
notification,permit,compliance,and corrective action activities required
under RCRA.
5 JULES AUTO SERVICE RCRA-SQG 1000819952
74841 AVE 42 FINDS CAU983659715
PALM DESERT,CA 92260
RCR41nfo:
Owner: JULIUS KNOBLAUCH
(619)346-0463
EPA ID: CAD983659715
Contact JULIUS KNOBLAUCH
(619)346-0463
Classification: Small Quantity Generator
TSDF Activities: Not reported
Violation Status:No violations found
FINDS:
Other Pertinent Environmental Activily Identified at Site
. RCRAInfo is a national informalion system that supports the Resource
Conservation and Recovery Act(RCRA)program through the tracking of events and
activities related to facilities that generate,transport,and treat,store,or
dispose of hazardous waste.RCRAInfo allows RCR4 program staff to track the
notification,permit,compliance,and corrective action activities required
under RCRA.
6 VALLEYWIDETOOLREPAIR RCRA•SQG 1001967529
74 991 JONI DR UNIT 6 FINDS CAR000070185
PALM DESERT,CA 92260
TC01805628.1 r Page 15 of 24
r�.MAP FINDINGS
Map ID
Direciion EDR I�Number
Distance
Distance(ft.�Site Database(s) EPA ID Number
VALLEYWIDETOOLREPAIR (Continued) 7007967529
RCRAInfo:
Owner: GEORGE RAMIREZ
(760)346-9452
EPA ID: CAR000070185
ContacC GEORGE RAMIREZ
(760)674-0669
Classification: Small Quantity Generator
TSDF Activities: Not reported
Violation Status:No violations found
FINDS:
Other Pedinent Environmental Activity Identified at Site
Califomia-Hazardous Waste Tracking System-Datamart
RCRAInfo is a national information system that supports the Resource
Conservation and Recovery Act(RCRA)program through the trecki�g of events and
activities related to facilities that generate,transport,and treat,store,or
dispose of hazardous waste.RCRAInfo allows RCR4 program staff to treck the
notiBcation,permit,compliance,and corrective action aciivities required
under RCR4.
7 CVWD-PALM DESERT LUST S103820850
43000 COOK Cortese NIA
PALM DESERT,CA 92260
LUST:
Region: RIVERSIDE
Site Closed: Yes
Employee ID: 7
Facility ID: 91162
Case Type: Soil only
Status: 9
Cortese:
Region: CORTESE
Facility Addr2: Not reported
7 CVWD PALM DESERT LUST U002167902
43000 COOK STREET N/A
PALM DESERT,CA
LUST:
Region: STATE
CaseType: Undefined
Cross Slreet: Not reported
Enf Type: None Taken '
Funding: Notreported
How Discovered: OM
How Stopped: Not reported
TC0�805628.1r Page�6of24
�'��. MAP FINDINGS
Map ID
�irection EDR ID Number
Distance
Distance(ft.�Site Database(s) EPA ID Number
CVWD PALM DESERT (Continued) U002167902
LeakCause: UNK
LeakSource: UNK
Global id: T0606500999
Stop Date: 1990-11-15 00:00:00
Confirm Leak: Not reported
Workplan: Not reported
Prelim Assess: Not reported
Pollution Char: Not reported
Remed Plan: Not reported
Remed Action: Not reported
Moniloring: Not reported
Close Date: 1992-07-'10 00:00:00
Discover Date: 1990-11-15 00:00:00
EnforcementDi: �965-Ot-0100:00:00
Release Date: 1991-03-04 00:00:00
Review Date: 1992-07-10 00:00:00 -
Enter Date: 1994-06-06 00:00:00
MTBE Date: Not reported
GW Qualifier: Not reported .
Soil Qualifier: Not reported
Max MTBE GW ppb: Noi reported
Max MTBE Soil ppb: Noi reported
Caunty: 33
Org Name: Not reported
Reg Board: Colorado River Basin Region
Status: Case Closed
Chemical: Diesel
Contact Person: Not repoded
Responsible Party: COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST
RP Address: 85820 COACHELLA NEIGHTS,COACHELLA,CA 92236
Interim: Not reported
Oversight Prgm: lUST
MTBE Class: '
MTBE Conc: 0
MTBE Fuel: 0 �
MTBE Tested: Not Required lo be Tested.
Staff: RFL
Staff Initials: Not reported
Lead Agency: LocalAgency
LocalAgency: 33000L
Hydr Basin#: COACHELLA VALLEY(7-
Beneficial: Not reported
Priority: Not reported
Cleanup Fund Id: Not reported
Work Suspended: Not reported
Local Case#: 91162
Case Number: 7T2260010
Qty Leaked: Not reported
Abate Method: Not reported
Operator: ERV RISLEY
Water System Name:Not reported
Well Name: Not reported
DistanceToWst 0
Waste Discharge Global ID: Not repoAed
Waste Disch Assigned Name: Not reported
Summary: Notreported �
TC01805628.1 r Page 17 of 24
r:MAP FINDINGS
Map ID
Direction EDR ID Number
Distance
Distance(ftJSite � Database(s) EPA ID Number
CVWD PALM DESERT (Continued) U002167902
LUST:
Region: 7
Lead Agency: Local Agency �
Siatus: 9-Case Closed
Case Num: 7T22600'10
ID: 686
GloballD: T0606500999
Case Worker: KO
Substance: Diesel fuel oil and additives
7 CVWD UST U003713197
43000 COOK ST NIA
PALM DESERT,CA 92211
UST:
Region: STATE
LocalAgency: 33000
Facility ID: 130
7 CHMIRS 5105883315
43-000 COOK ST. NIA
PALM DESERT,CA 92236
CHMIRS:
OES Incident Number: 02-1030
OES notification: 2/22/200202:14:43 PM
OES Date: Not reported
OES Time: Not reported .
Incident Date: Not reported
Date Completed: Not reported
� Property Use: Not reported
Agency Id Number: Not reported
Agency Incident Number: Not reported
Time Notified: Not reported
Time Completed: Not reported
Surrounding Area: Not reported
EstimatedTempereture: Notreported
Property Managemenl: Not reported
Special Studies 1: Not reported
Special Sludies 2: Not reported
Special Studies 3: Not reported
Special Studies 4: Not reported
Special Studies 5: Not repor[ed
Special Studies 6: Not reported
More Than Two Substances Involved?: Noi reported
Resp Agncy Personel#Of Decontaminated:Not reported
Responding Agency Personel#Of Injuries: Not reported
Responding Agency Personel#Of Fatalities:Not reported
Others Number Of Decontaminated: Not reported
Others Number Of Injuries: Not reported
Olhers Number Of Fatalilies: Not reported
Vehicle Make/year. Not reported
Vehicle License Numbec Not reported
Vehicle Staie: Not reported
Vehicle Id Number: Not reported
CA/DOT/PUC/ICC Number. Not reported
TC01805628.1 r Page 18 of 24
�".MAP FINDINGS
MapID
Direciion EDR ID Number
Distance
Distance(ft.)Site �atabase(s) EPA ID Num6er
(Continued) 5105883375
Company Name: Not reported
Repoding Officer Name/ID: Not reported
Report Date: Not reported
Comments: Not reported
Facilily Telephone: Not reported
Waterway Involved: No
Waterway: Not reported
Spill Site: Not reported
Cleanup By: Reporting Party
Containment Not reported
What Happened: Not reported
Type: Notreported
Measure: Not reported
Othec Notreported
Date/Time: Not reported
Year. 2002 "
Agency: Chowchilla Valley Water Dist.
Incident Dale: 2/22/200212:00:00 AM
Admin Agency: Riverside County Environmental Health �
Amount: Notreported �
Contained: Yes
Sile Type: TreatmenUSewage Facility
E Date: Not reported
Substance: Sewage
Quaniity Released: Not reported
BBLS: 0
Cups: 0
CUFT: 0
Gallons: 2637
Grams: 0
Pounds: 0
Liters 0
Ounces: 0
Pinls: 0
Quarts: 0
Sheen: 0
Tons: 0
Unknown: 0
Description: An overFlow at the head works at Water Reclamation Plant#10
Evacuaiions: 0
Number of Injuries: 0
Number of Fatalities: 0
7 PALM DESERT WRP#10 00•008 CA WDS 5102005547
� 43000 COOK ST N/A
PAI.M DESERT,CA 92260
CA WDS:
Facility ID: West Colorado River 330105012
Faciliry Type: Municipal/Domestic-Facility that treats sewage or a mixture of predominantly
sewage and other waste from districts,municipalities,communities,hospitals,
schools,and publicly or privately ow�ed systems(excluding individual
subsurface leaching systems disposing of less than 1,000 gallons per day).
Facility Status: Active-Any facility with a continuous or seasonal discharge that is under
Waste Discharge Requirements.
NPDES Num6er: Not reported
Subregion: 7
Facility Telephone: 7603982661
TC01805628.1 r Page 19 of 24
4 MAP FINDINGS
Map ID
Direction EDR ID Number
Distance
Distance(ft.)Site Database(s) EPA ID Number
PALM DESERT WRP#10 00-008 (Continued) 5102005547
Facility Contact: STEVE BIGLEY
Agency Name: COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST
Agency Address: PO BOX 1058
Agency City,St,Zip: COACHELLA 92236
Agency Contact: AIAN HARRELL
Agency Telephone: 7603982651
Agency Type: Special District Qncludes districts established wder general acts,sanitary
disiricts,water districts irrigaGon disUicts,etc.)
SIC Code: 4952
SIC Code 2: Not repoded
Primary Waste: Domestic Sewage
Primary Waste Type: �esignated/InFluent or Solid Wastes that pose a significant threat to water
quality because of their high concenlrations(E.G.,BOD,Hardness,TRF,
Chloride).'Manageable'hazardous wastes(E.G.,inorganic salts and heavy
metals)are included in this category.
SecondaryWaste: ' Notreported -
Secondary Waste Type:Not reported
Design Flow: 18
Baseline Flow: 17
Redamatio�: Producer-User:Reclamation requirements that have been issued to a producer of
reclaimed water who also uses the prod�ct.
POTW: The POTW Does not have an approved pretreaiment program.Some POTWs may have
local pretreatmeni programs that have not been approved by the regional board
and/or EPA.
Treat To Watec Major Threal to Water Quality.A violation could render unusable a ground water
or surtace water resource used as a significant drink water supply,require
closure of an area used for contact recreation,result in long-term deleterious
effects on shell fish spawning or growth areas of aquatic resources,or directly
expose the public lo toxic substances.
Complexity: Category A-Any major NPDES facility,any non-NP�ES facility(particularly
those with toxic wastes)that would be a major if discharge was made to surface
or ground waters,or any Class I disposal site.I�cludes any small-volume
complex facility(particularly those with toxicwastes)with numerous discharge
points,leak detection systems or ground water monitoring wells.
7 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST FINDS 1006837140
43-000 COOK ST 110013980344
PALM DESERT,CA 92260
FINDS:
Other Pertinent Environmental Activity Identifed at Site
The NEI(National Emissions Inventory)database contains information on
stalionary and mobile sources that emit criteria air pollulants and their
precursors,as well as hazardous air pollutants(HAPs).
TC01805628.1 r Page 20 of 24
:��MAP FINDWGS �
Map ID
Direction � EDR ID Number
Distance
Distance(ft.)Site Database(s) EPA ID Number
7 COACHELLA VALLEY WATER DIST CA FID UST 5701590190
43000 COOK ST SWEEPS UST NIA
PALM DESERT,CA 92260
CA FID UST:
Facility ID: 33006665
Regulated By: UTNKA
Regulated ID: Not reported
Codese Code: Not reported
SIC Code: Not reported
Facility Phone: 6193982651
Mail To: Not reported
Mailing Address: P O BOX 1058
Mailing Address 2: Not reported
Mailing City,St,Zip: PALM DESERT 92260
Contact: Not reported
Contact Phone: Not reported
DUNs Number. Not reported -
NPDES Number: Not reported
EPA ID: Not reported
, Commenis: Not reported
Status: Active
SWEEPS UST:
Status: A
CompNumber: 68589
Number: 4
Board Of Equalization: Not reported
Ref Date: 10-28-92
Act Date: 10-28-92
Created Date: 12-27-90
Tank Status: A
Owner Tank Id: Not reported
Swrcb Tank Id: 33-000-068589-000001
Actv Date: 10-28-92
Capacity: 280
Tank Use: M.V.FUEL
Stg: P
Conteni: DIESEL
Number Of Tanks: 1
8 HAZNET S'105886878
75-000 GERALD FORD DR. CHMIRS N/A
PALM DESERT,CA 92211
HAZNET:
Gepaid: CAC002561008
Contact: JOHN HOOVER
Telephone: 3039868011
Facility Add2: Not reported
Mailing Name: Not reported
Mailing Address: 75-000 GERALD FORD OR
Mailing City,St,Zip; INDIO,CA 92211
Gen County: Riverside
TSD EPAID: CAD028409019
TSD County: Riverside
Waste Category: Aqueous solution with less than 10%total organic residues
Disposal Method: Treatment,Tank
Tons: 1.6
TC01805628.tr Page21 of24
::MAP FINDINGS
Map ID
Direction EDR ID Number
Distance
Distance(8.)Site Database(s) EPA ID Number
(Continued) 5105886876
Facility County: Riverside
CHMIRS:
OES Incident Number: 02-6419
OES notification: 11/22/200207:34:57 PM
OES Date: Not reported
OES Time: Not reported
Incident Date: Not reported
Date Completed: Not reported
Property Use: Notreported
Agency Id Num6er: Not reported
Agency Incide�t Number: Not reported
Time Notified: Not reported
Time Completed: Not reported
Surrounding Area: . Not reported
Estimated TemperaWre: Not reported �
Property Management: Not reported
Special Studies 1: Not reported
Special Sludies 2: Not reported
Special Studies 3: Not reported
Special Studies 4: Not reported
Special Studies 5: Not reported
Special SWdies 6: Not reported
More Than Two Substances Involved?: Not reported
Resp Agncy Personel#Of Deconiaminated:Not reported
Responding Agency Personel#Of Injuries: Not reported
Responding Agency Personel#Of Fatalities:Not reported
Others Number Of Decontaminated: Not reported
Others Number Of Injuries: Not reported
Others Number Of Fatalities: Not reported
Vehicle Make/year: Not reported
Vehicle license Number: Not reported
Vehicle State: Not reported
Vehicle Id Number: Not repoAed
CA/DOT/PUGICC Number. Not reported
Company Name: Not reported
Reporting Officer Name/ID: Not repoded
Report�ate: Not reported
Comments: Not reported
Facility Telephone: Not reported
Waterway Involved: No
Waterway: Not reported
Spill Site: Not reported
Cleanup By: Responsible Party
Containment: Not reported
What Happened: Not reported
Type: Notreported
Measure: Notreported
Other. Not reported
Dateffime: Not reported
Year: 2002
Agency: Veeder Root
Incident Date: 11/22/200212:00:00 AM
Admin Agency: Riverside County Environmental Health
Amount: Not reported
Contained: Yes
Site Type: Service Siation
TC01805628.1r Page 22 of 24
i MAP FINDINGS
Map ID
Direciion EDR ID Number
Dislance
Distance(fl.)Sile Database(s) EPA ID Number
(Continued) 5105866878
E Date: Not reported
Substance: Gasoline
Quantity Released: Not reported
BBLS: 0
Cups: 0
CUFT: 0
Gallons: 0
Grams: 0
Pounds: 0
Liters: 0
Ounces: 24
Pints: 0
Quarts: 0
Sheen: 0
To�s: 0
Unknown: - 0 -
Description: Customer overtilled tank.
Evacuations: 0
Number of Injuries: 0
Number of Fatalities: 0
OES Incident Number: 03-3210
OES notification: 6/24/200305:32:37 PM
OES Date: Not repoded
OES Time: Not reported �
Incident Date: Not reported
Date Compieted: Not reported
Propedy Use: Not reported
Agency Id Number: Not reported
Agency Incident N�mber: Not reported
Time Nolified: Not reporied
Time Completed: Not reported
Surrounding Area: Not reported
Estimated Temperature: Not reported
PropeM1y Management Not reported
Special Studies 1: Not reported
Special Studies 2: Not reportetl
Special Studies 3: Not reported
Special Studies 4: Not reported
Special Studies 5: Not reported
Special Studies 6: Not reported
More Than Two Substances Involved?: Not reported
Resp Agncy Personel#Of Decontaminated:Not reported �
Responding Agency Personel#Of Injuries: Not reported
Responding Agency Personel#Of Fatalities:Not reportetl
Others Number Of Decontaminated: Not reported
Olhers Number Of Injuries: Not reported
Others Numher Of Fatalities: Not reported
Vehicle Make/year: Not reported
Vehicle License Number: Not reported
Vehicle State: Not reported
Vehicle Id Number: Not reported
CA/DOT/PUC/ICC Num6ec Not reported
CompanyName: Notreported
Reporting Offcer Name/ID: Not reported
Report Date: Not reported
Comments: Not reported
TC01805628.tr Page 23 of 24
'�.MAP FINDINGS
Map ID
Direction EDR ID Number
Distance
�istance(ft.)Site Database(s) EPA ID Number
(Continued) S105886878
Facility Telephone: Not reported
Watervvay Involved: No �
Watervvay: Not repoded
Spill Site: Not reported
Cleanup By: ConUactor
Containmeni; Not repoded
What Happened: Not reported
Type: Not reported
Measure: Not reported
Other: Not reported
Date/Time: Not reported
Year: 2003
Agency: VeederRoot
Incident Date: 6/24/200312:00:00 AM �
Admin Agency: Riverside County Environmental Health
Amount: ' Not reported -
Contained: Yes
Site Type: Service Station
E Date: Not reported
Substance: Gasoline
Quantity Released: Not reported
BBLS: 0
Cups: 0
CUFT: 0
Gallons: .75
Grams: 0
Pounds: 0
Liters: 0
Ounces: 0
Pints: 0
Quarts: 0
Sheen: 0
Tons: 0
Unknown: � 0
Description: Substance was released due to auto shut-off failing on dispensers 1 &13.
Evacuations: 0
Number of Injuries: 0
Number of Fatalities: 0
TC01605628.1 r Page 24 of 24
�
w �
�
�
W W W N
< a
�J U � W m �...
2
� vmi w vdi
� F" aJ U U U U �' W W W F' ' W y I- `F (j N
m W W Z Z Z W Z � W W W
� zN q� � � � � � zN � � � a � a zI� a r F zN Nz F w
N
Q U � > > > > Q j � � � � � Q f E E � N N N N N j � t~/1 E E E � Q Q J E E 3
O S � J J J J J = J J J U U U S W W W U � � � J � J 2 � W W W W S S J W W fn
� O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O � O � � � � � � � e- O O
f0 N t0 �O tO [O N t0 �O �O tO t0 �O 0 (O t0 t0 (O [O �O �O �O �O �O � (O �O
d N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N
N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N
N 0 O� O� O� O� O� OI O� m T O� O� m m m m m m m OI m m m m m m m m O) m m m rn O� m O�
O
N
m
N
a
�
N
N
� O
W m �
W
F N � K a � p
N F w m w F � n U
F � F
m F Q 6 W � FW- � _ � O F
Q � N i- 1- fn 4J f� f� f0 Q
� W W � � ln f/1 1=- Y Y Y Y �.O � � �
� > Y Y > Y > } N N u Y I Z O Q Q 6 Q } � S a "'
� � Q Q Q Q � � Q Q Q � � � ^ � " " Q � � •- •- •- LL LL � � 0 O O � U Z 3 � Q
� 3 � 3 3 � � 3 3 3 � � �r r� � � � � � �} �y �r r� o o � ¢ ¢ ¢ Z z a w w 3
a 2 � x S 2 S � 2 x 2 S S S S S � � � i � S S S S ¢ ¢ ¢ m m m m � p a > > �
Q o � oo m m o .- �n in � � y o m o �oo 0 0 � � o � opp � � m
V O N O T N m O N N N � N f0 O � �p 1� O N m fp N N N p� � m m Q W n N
N O f0 Sl N CJ O Yf Ct O O N tO 10 eJ W Q O� p � r � 0] A i W a1
t7 N t7 (7 l7 f7 (�l [7 (7 t7 {7 V N N l7 N N f�J V N l7 l7 f7 1� 1� I� �- f� ID t0 Q p
(n fD 1� 1` I� 1� I� 1� h 1� 1� 1� I� h I� 1� I� (` 1� h 1� 1� 1� I� 1� 1� I� I� V V Q V 1� I� I� 1�
� o Q U
� � (7 W F y
N � Q ~ W � < Q
� O � � W
� � w � W
a Q Q a ti � U' w � w
0 � NQ � K Q N mtn ui p O � ¢ Z � Q Fm W
a ¢ a � w a � � � � rtu� �- z wa Zz w m � p �
O ?i � N 2 Q O W Z N Z ZWQ Z W J � Z Z J J LL K W m J K O it
N J O D U # N U U � � Z .W.1 J J � O � LL O W u' Q J } Z Q �
F- E N tq Z Z U !n h' � F
w O m K F � Z � � Z O W � W W Z W U a F t J 2 2 ¢] t� Z J W Z �U Q 4' U'
amuwc� FdwUaQ � c� '= '= 5 � c� oN � cai ° � ca.iz �noz � v� wo ?
E � � ow � � � w � � v�i3 = 33w 3Z �' Oo � zc� c� Y � c� wow > c� a
m U Z � � W N N 0 W (q � � 6 � O y F, � O 2 2 W J W N � U Y N S y
z r o > E y o � � y � � w w 3 3 Z � 3 � � > � o N x �o x x 3 G u � '� g � �
�( W J F U J J F J W �. N � O � 1 O Q O W W U Q.' N m � N � J � J y W U � �
v W X S Q K K Q Q K Q S 7 p Z Z Q Z R K W a t� ¢ Q Q Q = X Q 6
f� m W U d Q Q d 0. Q d N N N tp � E fq (q f/J U N Q > ?i m ?i = � N � rtl � I- W E d
� � Vp Qp p VR f�0 N N f�0 m O tm0 ^ � n � 0 m m f�0 O�I N � N N n ry M n O�] N V � � In N
N m N N N N � Ir N N N N N N m Q N Ol [O r' t7 C�J W N O P N N m O�] N �A Cm'1 N p 1� O
Q � 1� N N N N V) I� N N b P C V W f7 e] c] tA V t7 N t7 1� W t7 (7 M t7 1� CJ O e� ct
Ol � O O O O 1n O N N N Cl N O� W (O N 1� I� m m O N Ol m (O ] T O fp P W t0 OI
a. l7 CO N N I(1 N iA (O fD (O (O f0 t0 f0 (O (O (O (O (O (7 M Cf CJ I� Cl (O t0 (O {7 C (O N (O
� O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O
W N � f� N N N (9 f� N lq N U! N N 4l N h N N � J J � � N � � N lq l� h ln N y Vl N l�
�
� i- F- i- r i- �- F- i- �- rr F FFrr �- �- � F Fr � rri- rr rrr rri- i- �'
J � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
� W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W W �
N Ul N Ul N t� t/1 N 41 N Gl N N (n l9 lq f� rn fq N N 4l 41 N t7 fq N f/1 N t7 l/1 N l9 f/1 f� K
� w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w w a
w o 0 0 0 0 0 0 o a o 0 0 o a o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o a o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o rn
x E E � � � � E � E � E � f E � E E � E � E E g E E � E g f E E E E E E �
� F �I J �l J J ..l J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J �l J
Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q
U U a 6 a a a a a a �. d a a a a a a 6 �. a a d d a a a a a a a a a a a a a a
ti ii�
���
C.: t�i �. ., [E .. ! ! .. 4':. . � � � _ . ..
� ����V����...I'� �������.�� �.,��
i ���L�i�. 1.��..Ji ���r.Jl�..�.
C V'�.+�� ��.L V�.r�� ��,��i A l LV� ���
INT�RSE�T�O�N �h�PR��E�h.E�TS
�'1����CT
Prepared for City of Palm Deserf
73-510 Fred Wc�ring Driv�
Palr� �es�rt,Cali#ornia 922�0
Prep�red by BonT�rra Consul$inc�
151 Kalmus D�€v�,5�ite E-20i�
Costa Mesa, Califarnia 92b26
�: [714) 4�449199 F: (71�4) 444-9�99
�v+nr�r.Ban��rraConsulting.carn
�1ay 24D8
Cook Street Drainage and Intersection Improvemen(s Project
COOK STREET DRAINAGE AND INTERSECTION IMPROVEMENTS PROJECT
MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM
Date: May 21, 2008
CEQA Action: Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration
Project Applicant: City of Palm Desert
Lead Agency: City of Palm Desert
Project Location and Description: The project site consists of the intersections of Cook Street
at Country Ciub Drive and Cook Street at Hovley Lane in the City of Palm Desert, Riverside
County.
The Cook Street Drainage and Intersection Improvements Project (hereafter referred to as the _
"ProjecY') allows for the construction of drainage improvements; reconfiguration of vehicle travel
and turn lanes, raised medians, and sidewalks at the intersection of Cook Street at Country
Club Drive and the intersection of Cook Street at Hovley Lane; and installation of signal
interconnect(in-road sig nal traffic sensors) between 42nd Avenue and Frank Sinatra Drive.
The drainage improvements at the Country Club Drive intersection include instailation of an
18-inch storm drain pipe, a catch basin on the northwestern corner, and two catch basins on the
northeastern corner. The storm drain pipe would drain from these catch basins to a proposed
catch basin and existing 18-inch storm drain pipe at Desert Willow Drive approximately
1,200 feet to the west. Installation of storm drains would eliminate cross gutters (dips) at the
intersection.
At the Cook Street and Country Club Drive intersection, Cook Street would be widened by
approximately 12 feet at its widest point primarily on the southwestern and northwestern
segments. Cook Street would be widened from approximately 460 feet north of the intersection
to 900 feet south of the intersection. The raised median would be reconfigured for two 10-foot-
wide dedicated left-turn Ianes onto Country Club Drive in both directions of travel. A 13-foot-
wide dedicated right-turn lane on the northwestern segment of the intersection would be
provided. The sidewalk on the western side of Cook Street would be widened from 10 to 12 feet
from the intersection with Country Club Drive to approximately 840 feet to the south. T he Project
requires the acquisition of property on the northern and southern sides of the intersection of
Cook Street at Country Club Drive. A list of parcels that would be impacted and the approximate
square footage of the acquisit ion on each parcel is identified on Table 1.
The drainage improvements at the Hovley Lane intersection include installation of 18-inch storm
drain pipes, a catch basin on the northwestern corner, and two catch 6asins on the northeastern
corner. The storm drain pipes would drain from these catch basins to a proposed to a proposed
36-inch storm drain pipe that would be installed in the center of Cook Street from the northern
side of the intersection to approximately 280 feet south where it would connect with an existing
storm drain pipe. Installation of storm drains would eliminate cross gutters (dips) at the
intersection.
Cook Street would be widened by approximately 12 feet at its widest point on the northwestern
and southeastern segm ents of the Hovley Lane intersection extending approxim ately 335 feet to
the north and 230 feet to the south. The southeastern segment of the intersection would be
widened for a 14-foot-wide right-turn lane, and a 4-foot-high retaining wall would be constructed
R:\PmjeclsU-lams\J0041MMRP�052108.doc 1 Mitigation Moniforing and Reporting Program
Cook Street Orainage and Infersection Improvemenfs Project
at this corner. The intersection's existing raised median would be reconfigured for two 10-foot-
wide dedicated left-turn lanes in both directions of travel, and a 13-foot-wide dedicated right-turn
lane on the northwestern corner of the intersection. The sidewalk on the western side of Cook
Street would be widened from 10• to 12 feet. The project would require the acquisition of
property on the northwestern and southwestern sides of the intersection of Cook Street at
Hovley Lane (Table 1).
TABLE 1
RIGHT-OF-WAY ACQUISITION ON PRIVATELY OWNED PARCELS
. . � � . � � � . � � Parcel' � . Approximate Area of
Location���� � � � � �� � � � � � � � Number(s)� � � Acquisition(s��
Northwest corner of Cook Sireet and Country Club Drive 620370-011 590
620-370-012 3,430
Southwest corner of Cook Street and Country Club 624310-003 6,990
Drive
Northwest corner of Cook Street and Hovley Lane 624-040-034 3,495
South side of Hovley Lane west of Cook Street 624-290-001 495 _
Southeast corner of Cook Street and Hovley Lane 632-060-033 1,930
North of Hovley Lane, east side of Cook Street 632-410-035 146
Total 17,076
Source:Harris&Associates,2008.
On Hovley Lane, improvements include the widening of the southern side of the roadway by
approximately 6 feet and widening of the northern side by approximately 6 feet from the
intersection to approximately 500 feet to the west, and reconfiguration of the raised median from
the intersection to approximately 450 feet west and 300 feet east of the intersection for two
11-foot-wide left-turn lanes in both directions of travel.
To prevent traffic delays during project construction, improvements at Country Club Drive would
be completed in five stages and improvements at Hovley Lane would be completed in six
stages.
Mitiaation Monitorinq and Reportinq Proqram
The California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) requires that all public agencies establish
monitoring and/or reporting procedures for mitigation measures (MMs) adopted as conditions of
approval in order to mitigate or avoid significant project impacts. Specifically, §21081.6(a)(1)
states:
The public agency shall adopt a reporting or monitoring program for the changes
made to the project or conditions of project approval, adopted in order to mitigate
or avoid significant effects on the environment. The reporting or monitoring
program shall be designed to ensure compliance during project im plementation.
CEQA Guidelines §15097 provides clarification of mitigation monitoring and reporting
requirements and guidance to local lead agencies on implementing strategies. The reporting or
monitoring program must be designed to ensure compliance during project implementation. The
City of Palm Desert (City) is the lead agency for the Project and is therefore respo�sible for
implementing the Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program (MMRP).
The MMRP contains the mitigation program that has been incorporated through preparation of
the Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration. Mitigation measures have been drafted to meet
RiProlecls\Hams\J004UAMRP-052108.tloc 2 Mitigafion Monitoring and Reporting Program
Cook Street Drainage and Intersection Improvements Projecl
the requirements of Public Resources Code §21081.6 as fully enforceable monitoring programs.
The MMRP defines the following for each m itigation measure:
1. Timeframe. In each case, a time for performance of the mitigation measure, or
review of evidence that mitigation has taken place, is provided. The performance
points selected are designed to ensure that impact-related components of project
implementation do not proceed without establishing that the mitigation is
implemented or assured.
2. Responsible Party. In each case, unless where otherwise indicated, the City, as
both lead agency and applicant, is the Responsible Party for implementing the
mitigation. The City will also monitor the performance and implementation of the
mitigation measures. To guarantee that the mitigation measure will not be
inadvertently overlooked, the supervising public official is the official who grants the
permit or authorization called for in the performance.
3. Definifion of Mitigation. In each case (except where a mitigation measure, such as
a geotechnical report, is a well-known procedure or term of art), the mitigation _
measure contains the criteria for mitigation, either in the form of adherence to certain
adopted regulations or identification of the steps to be taken in m itigation.
The numbering system corresponds with the numbering system used in the Initial
Study/Mitigated Declaration. The last column of the MMRP table will be used by the Compliance
Monitor to document when implementation of the measure has been completed. The ongoing
documentation and monitoring of mitigation compliance will be completed by the City. The
completed MMRP and supplemental documents will be kept on file at the City of Palm Desert
Planning Department.
R:\Projeds\HarnsW004\MMRP-052108.doc 3 Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program
u E
m m
a N o
y N d
c w a
d � '= c
� o 0
i '+.+ a
o N �
� a a
E �
� U y c
«, c
h R �
� � o
� �
Dc o
m -
°' o,
a . . _
� � m a�i g
� � �
� °� c r r
m Cc s O n� a�
z � O = � c � c
o Ui p, O �"m . m"m
(j � d � �c W �� W
Q�' Q�' m,..�`. m w
4 aU aU
� — � wm �o'� ino � � '�n� °' in ^� E `otl1 �'3 � owwaid a�
Z o " > > m .C � m .�.. � � ❑ � � c� _wco� .NT� 3a � nn :N
� � � � � nNo �;. o �'oaind� m�yaa��ia-16oa �aaciQ °v' '�= Y
� O - a�i `om=U� wa� „N $ Uc°�i �' amict '� rnm3 °� m E � wrn3
a a � `o �om >>�.nyU 3�?c�a � « c� o ��� nn'a � 16 � �,a�i o
W Q mc � �� � 3?��« a� � cwo� u�'i c °� c °� � a'� m;> a-
� " tUU = tm� �r EinZa� ao � 'wmr�noo ,t�, o a� � R � a� .G �° y � a
2 N O ~ U L 'C ~ "' N N � N U � .'C.. I- �L.. N Ul N rt+ r�+ > � L -O @ J� C m L � N
Q O N U (p�O O d �I � m � Ul —C N .-:� � �� � N pl O N � y� � �� � L...�-,
� " c> �n. cU � wma�o � 3E� � U!n �" "' m �� m = � °�' > N �om y om
? C iC d� � N U N O t0 L N Ol�� @ �!L � 3 �'N O U a N �C .J N � W O 'O'�
QQ O a� vvYa�`�� a� �c a`�i c� >�ar � `mmE�o ;� uCi d vi?c� `o a`�i > >
� y � y10 -�� m.�'cwa�Qa�i � ���°' om � Sm ��r �cuvi ''-- �o�.- c�i�3a �ny�
� � o - m w o 3 a m c t m c E >.v ti �r-o�c= °�r 'v y m N—v r m cYi L o
2 � « U �_ om> a m "�,-- �wa�o $ >, oi.mrn o
O R m N O N y U O 3 N O U � d � C M"�-C i0 0 p.v- C= V 0.— t-O 41 _ O_
� N i+ O N � � @ � �V U �n O O V� � C «V y d N� '.0 N'O� O � N N +�0
Z LL � d C Q�9 � 3 p� � � Y � C � N G m U � N E N a 0- N y l0 y'O d N N (0
Q C f0 � O �' QO�' O WLN_ � 0 � ,.. NdNC_ > > .t..
� in � �oEm°� � � ° ma°'i Uin�� a�i� ma�i > >'Nc v3i � � � ��� c�ir �jU��
¢ ❑ `_=oui �'n�Ea � o� c1Oi r � d� oao'iEa�i � � a�0i �
f� F-U mn�._ � mf. Em • • . . •
I� u
g �
�� �- N
�' M M
n' � �
� �
� �
0 0
U U
� �
iq N
Cl o O 4
C U U �
�C � Ol g
� C G �
� � � /
9 � �
?.�` U U E
G C
N N N 3
d � � o
= o O d
Q U U �
N �
C �
N
� N O
, m - a
o �, o,
Q = � c
E O — o
o N �
� Q �
� � a
` c
d O t0
_ U y c'
w
a � o
� p 'c
� �
�0 c
c o
O p�
. Ui . N �
L
� C m✓1 C m C S�
v O v O'� � O N
(n �` LA Eo0 E � E �n
o a 'yC'. m 16 � m m m o
L C L
U Q � c �Q m �Q Oa]
� C, o m�n, . m� �'a�i -
0 N � c:c o �"_ �''"--
� �, c m� c m � m
a
y aC7 m a�.U=' aC7
� U rn m v � — U a— >. c m a� N v m m c �.N N c c �n ^--o w" a) c � w ol
2 ` 'O ` NOIUVp =� �'TC O« NGY '- � « � O N ��w '..C-.�C N �(OC
� � y � `m `.crnm— ... � mo U � .Z` — m m � �o NOa� � Adm
� > r� �._ Qot � c�Ra— a.,s.. � ..� c Zc � m � aai � caawi o �ym
O o �o!gmmc vcdm� v� c ; °3 � .� ,Ja'€ 'n 9 � ;= Q a '� a � o
a � o �� � � ° � a� � �� � 9 ='' � � � � � N � '° �oY yLL ��
W .�. E � o-mu `oo° ui a w. 3EEcv wcm�� mcrn..
� 'O a � E�an �,LLom� ymocmE rna� ot � YYo �ymc .`
Q N p ti � '- C y N a 3 c � a> m c o w U m v c c n'" o Y� c E �n � 3�m `n
� y oct > � :c inr=oQ. � wov �vw�m � -= m o— �a 3 -- 00
2 C G (/1 N Ul«9 OX ���.�N (`m C.O U.G �r E O 0 L.O V W O� C�
Q Y O 01 � v G T Ul ;� d� O N OI O U.� j N G OI N N -O E y O. N N R O-0 v[p
2Vat�n o- t6omm� mmcEmU aaEiE.' �m €~ 3m = � osaw � w „s�„� `�m
� a�°i a"i3 � a� � mma��i � � 3 a � � d � � E . �a� .Jm � my 6N4=
0 v V cG s � 4j � � O " a a v N .0 C O �C 9 (0 �L C V T� � > ... � C D � C �
F_ w O '-' �°n� `" m _ my �,�0 3EU 'o � c « �.�c0 m� ya�'ia3co oa'� 6
Z L . d•u.0 N� �9 O r � � �N ry J O y w T . � G Y � -� O_ N_ J l0
O a3+ 16 C U— D ..�. >`_ U O O � C 9 N .� .- N� � C C O �C � 3 � T
�— �p C— U > C � O a � O l0 Cl= � d N .O
Zli � m 'o�c�`� EEa�rn�-o:°� m9� U� �Q � � `� a�io ` T« �� y �'�'-� � o ��
� � mooc" a`�iyoa`�ia`�im3 ovm,... � mvmca N � o._ w � m o� >,c
� •v�i � mLmo� � 'C' m5 � = o �'°�'�w �rmEc � mt o2 aoo � c mf.-'iE
a� t �— � o:°.coo— m m� � r� .- > mc�i'`my " �w000nw '° � cv °3
�` � � `ma16io $ '.N-c � mQ � � nci6i �r�oaKs�Zv�aQ �3 `—tin3m@vo wc�ima
I� u — —
g d � �
'o � �
a` � � �
�
� N w
C C p � C
O O O
R [0 � 2 � U
> > >
@ (0 O y'y
� X X y O_p C C o
C UI � � ` N U � � ¢
C N 'O -O TV- m �
p � C C � l0 O C pp �
F � N m O 'O « :`. C �
O m m � � � @ ? o
y � > � �' 'D �v,
� m m � N � E m E
rn rn c> c u� -0 3
✓i N
� �> �> � °' E> �C� -
o Z E� 0 6 a
U Om � m [0 (� c�im � � �
� �
� �
E N o
"> m a
e :� �
E c � C
o — o
c ++ 4
o G� �
� � @
w O �
� U � c
y,� G
D � O
m � O
m g
c o
O p,
:' � m a�i �
u' y c r r
o a ` a� n�
�c O � �
U � p C � c � c
U' °' 0 �'c c'�' -
O y � cw cw
� R m� `m�
y aU aU
� O y'O T tl) T(0 N N y 0 C N O � O T � C N N 0 'C T T L
Z o � c c m c d'-r � o E [h a o m N« w N a) m:�'
� � in � m m Q m= -� c �'�:- iri �� T � T�Y� 3s
O N 0 O '�' U � O � O �p N N O C � .... � N N
O .�. Ena`�iw o�� �.L « a� N� � a�. c �� m � m � �-�oc
m c� N T o �— Y c 5� � � � m > c�U m
W ^ 2 E-omo;=�� omn .c � o Qa ¢o tA E�� :n « m�.c �
R' Q � ca� � � °� o-o�o'g — � o � o 'n c of0 � a�icm�" �
W p E �-� c �0 �o a�3 y 3 Q� � � r:io ° ° � c'a� E A � n'0 w �c
p 3 0 �- �, ¢s a o�- n-C a a� c
Z3 �n c0c�i ro�= � om � nai = E � E� .� m � SA .«: cd;oo
Q,^ Y OiLT10 � UlQO �D � � 10 �0 � OM � OO� � OOfQN � U � OL
v � �O (A 3 N rT+ � C @� =� w C J� U @�Q (0 pj N � N C � 19 N O Q d
� V Oa�°i wo'f�-.� rn9a� � � R zOv '� omoE � i. Y '° ��._ nOT; o
,C � V l6 Y L C Q L N E LL w J LL O OJ C � �g� O �LL O O� Ul C
O V � N'� m . v.- m a�— � os.= -- � 3 _ ww oa>!� o
I� f/1 C C �9 C O C O!/1 N Ol TY OIN N N p ND qL9 "':_
O � O m� �o K 'E� o m� '�Z a o 9 N ` �(� c� o �p ��� v � �
a�+ l0 N v f0 C � d ...y 9� � R .L.- �� .'_-� j Ol� N �-�p �t� C U'O
m rn �_ � � N �c � U E� m v �-o
Cc ai ;7 �-o c�� Yn a v v-0 16 0 � y w m i�a m'° ° ' � � R � N� �y d
O c � .� R m m c y�� �� � �p �+ � c � c�� c � y 3 a �-°�o� a c �
ti � y�;oa''io �CocEon a�i �> in �a�ga � Uo� - o � � d-`�oaEaxi
¢ � " �.cZa.�c � o � o� �muo o„-'= o.>_ '° � �s
(� � �.°2axiu�it0oa�i `moo.o a�- m � • • . zoUU�vJEh «
� V
Sc O N
i
a � �
� �
0
� o �
2 3 T:=
c a 16 u
U y� �
OI - N 0 � �
C N N 'O p
�� m �i� N E
F = � O C m �
� U � C 7
U . d t � � E
� O x
� � U � � - U
d Q.- •- N � p v
'o o� � op v g`
Z U N a Z o-o rc
� E
m m
� N o
> m . a
o _ p�
E � � �
O - a
o N �
" °. a
y � G
d Q �
� U � c'
Y O
� O �
O
� �
N C
G �
� p�
m ` �' g
O
`" d c a'
o � '�
o S� p `o
U � p c a�i
� O
O a�ig ms
� � �`o
a o�
Z L'�soaovm �� v
N R � C �
� � NF-3 O N ��Q� O
uico � 'OE
O � E �oc� c �� m �a-°�oE
�
a a `m :o � m � c � l'n N c�i
n- �._
d
a. ,D � Q � n.-o m�� o-o � m
y.. C 'p._ U C N
0 3 � � N � (0 � N C N � �C r
Z � G N U Yn N C N v� m� E m
Q i.:r � ` @ � � N — � N
(� p '=' � � E '�C'A c mv `o �' .o i.
Z :p y � m J N v U-p c � m
V CR Nom� m�`- � � � '�o
Q V � O �O L p 1]'O � O U
~ d 0 N G r�j Ol N p G N� UI
C @ C � U
0 V 14 l0 U � v� � q O V a � �
�C d .°_, _ � �wo �n oa, >
N O t0 U � C N O � N
u- N'-- O! �� C U
d y N U.p E
p p�g � =oyo!° 2a�� c�i:� a�i
r y Y L U S 9 U E �
Q N C O O L U1 iU 0 y V ry �
Ve p aUU3� Eomm .- � a�
� U
� O �
d U
�
T
N p�
9 N 9
�� N
C � > Ol
O O �O
p� r d m U o
C C C
a � 'a A rc
'E y � � � �
F- ` `mm"- E
� �
r �� � �
V
R E
C U O O I
N �
V O- � VI
O O� �
A ,`o_ EaE Q
i- a-�o m o. �