The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutRes 2014-94 - T13008 - The SummitResolution No. 2014-94 \e s • cg • NO .74 :OD• 0 01 1 F 71 a :1 CUR YA7.M MUN N'VOYIY ■ ,.x m1 w. w A , ,� s a a • — F 1) - o !a 0 r w a S� to Qy� ,w.a ! •w. aY.a� �. m Nea R a s ; :. NORTH. va ai - PriTvE ... aC - _., r. Ift-- .. i — �ci. I x m 1 ��.9 JI).�1 4 —M 0.3,.. :I.., ea- '•t "4 1' WI w e. • o c co 30 >o CY C ;s uJra CO ` 4ra - i1 7 E ' a a. ,n >0 1 ill WM 111 6 W a.BNAOY DRIVE VIEW 61 a.M• •1� a.a Is a a.w 0 s _ s • Ass, N y 6 • 8 15. W • A # t a :e —'� 1,8 ro N. MA'AM, a 319V 1Atln - Resolution No. 2014-94 VALLEY QE,T u, IMOW/ HILLS WM 0 1: 8,860 VICINITY MAP GRASS GT GRA$$GT• MMTERM\ CIRN -'NESA_VIEWSDR Resolution No. 2014-94 // OP 0 SER LOI%'FR0R ca3 c0:08b, 'i#EODORA LN os4-wEvv-con I J GREENARIAR LN r4, ,- • 11011111 Nom 1♦ Aim rp 1 1 1 HOMESTEAD -RI' 1 1 1 1 1 L D SERT !E .p_ SUNDOWN LN SUN VALLEY LN MINIM J♦ MEN INDIAN HILLS WAY ROLLING KNOLL() EC au IC Inl Igh 3 �NYON DR ANDRS \ GE L --HEODORA LN O 7 0 0 0 r- 0 0 D' O A 1WES4—WSW-DR SPYGLASS LN "REASCAN DA 1 'OMEsTEAD-Rr S GLASS LN a 0 I 1 1 1 1 1 1 'fOMES•T•EA I I '_UJWA III RE H iI 1 B 1m A ANITA CIR � �-� A z3 Ea < 0 1.- a ALAN CIR mm DAVIS RD A 0 NO MIA H1210 The Summit Tract 13008 Accepted Dedications Exhibit A-1 ti WHITE DR MESA VI 4 r A QUAIL HOLLOW DR 0 A C GRARASS•C-T— ' 1 ' Z e f E mm *IR CARRIAGE TRI I I VICINITY MAP Resolution No. 2014-94 DESERT FLO E.?04, , ofi il:fou oo INDIAN HILLS WAY // 1 1 1 ' LOMESTEAD-RP 1 1 1 n 0 GREENBRIAR LN ROLLING I(NOLLOR cc . ANORE)5 SUNDOWN LN EDOORALN I 1 I cPNYON DR 1 SPYGLASSLN ANDSCANI \ 11 1 i I I IOMES•TEAD.R^ 2MESTEA LASS LN The Summit Tract 13008 Rejected Dedication Exhibit B-1 A m DAVIS RD ANITA CIR WHITE DR o ALAN CIR MESA VIEW DR QUAIL HOLLOW DR F MED —1:11 s E R E E wm 4611 CARRIAGE TRL VICINITY MAP Resolution No. 2014-94 i Resolution No. 2014-94 c 411 er:• e PY 8: -....�_ 41.W37•'eV 329 93 • 45 r,•14WW Iff GP a fir8P, ■i 0 Na . w a �i. o.- T S.1 ~ t Ni717`a4a \ji_ 514 Ne�11,�N 'W+1�,.ijf 19M0.7 , 11.11.10 11.11o. p. rvt l 5M to wlw v4[ f' - • —J 11 31 O r ias 2 iTt to reg Oqf to E -- eve sw t•• : rtM$17 j 40.211 '� 'NW i e ')L li r� lik ;^.31 1 = $ F,. g Off• S310N 9N11N3WAMOW , Resolution No. 2014-94 9 133HS 33S _ ILrn 1!1 44 a . __11X11N1. i1Lii_ Ve 9.1 C1 5 ' `a ■ P11•131 11700 IJ Rw•E ■ 71,114, t F/ove_q r0 �£Ms . 1•31' 111 lN.IOI NI 88 Sw t@: 'a1 Ili! Ln 8 s5F Q o1= o . pp fag,, lea -Nr1 al..= :•r 1s . Yi ■ SAT"—'14po X S F ` • j % -8 _. C C • --- 6 ■ 111174172. ._111<a 11 Q11.011 114 33 Vell ii 4 ie lip f :' IV O Ws? .Ia a • B ~ • kt'B OVAL ' era —.9y 1w r qq�� rw . 7"� ■ 1 _ qi rie'i •ewn ..0 7 � o__ � yyC7 = — RI 1 aFr: ' i NJL. £�3 0 o i. a f. y! 1 k SY 41 11 191.00 --- 112.9\ ■ •!1•311 O Ch NJ v , 4 N ' + • s1s-1a'elti T7 annseresc fi 23 r 8- 810888888888 U! R�USe7.1COi YOi3 .�. i.;;Kiltrt;>s*� • c{Yzr>.14gi•P. E.g'.014ggg. a sSaeeesSao E Ba6'Bm'B•s'Bsaa6 a n esseetza zelc % Y BRYr PYB:e•At :! -]!i C?Ydi'..Arta - zsenter...exaze B Resolution No. 2014-94 Iy 1w eithre x 1 Eiri A _E E a. it W 0 2 �. 4 h 4 1l f g • Ca•117 • 1.16 1 ; Fre •_23y yi I1i41.�.. O • 1”011.117 N.11 • 1•M'17 1 In V C0 • PI/'11Y RL8 ON• 1!)01,4 ' S 8 s r a: 8 41•a'U7 1+1.46 111 F 8 X' f: 8 }11� 17 40 • 1 "1ST Y a 1 ij w'7 .\I �114[ iS .� y -� aC i'-1nn le 4 •" H � rpj yn Z '� A ERY J�(Al n rA trim e.o s N, iO i _ k.�ao CD s i}'T ' a><C7EE FIi�Fs B n y G 8) 2, ; • 1•je••y % �K^C�Y61S144 `Il' Ili S[1 x222E51E2E2 i ^ %n W prvj 48N8S8E5li4IS II • 1'. "4 3' ze�x- Pt cn ccS srr3'i.�_r _ak cm • :nf!;_AA•-afa i C 9 ai a "Y;xYa's g • i•11.17 f 1U�_, 4 1 <_ U 01 y R v • rikart 11101 f E CJ1 Y �a SO• � SECSiIA •=3i�3: cc IP Pt f• • •14.•, -MN • Y. t �u 111� 3 __ - •„ _xesemb r OPAL xpFLIVE •� ww w Iw.R u >` r112:4 YCYS: DtF 4434488fl88888 8 rAx:__r=st: F. w V .I SJe Now) ey V aae.x. pste e=e�aaaic�a* ::4_xy_t.P.:44 4 1 ..e>{..gxacr'r �sGC�?SCE=e' J s X 3444.``,a�CB E aattaisa 11 3 •d. •J t1 4- ,��-,� �-,--�.,--�.�,�-�� ...�a,��,�- �,:. , _ �_� ��J ��d��a_ � � �i F� , , �� . ��`��!� �.�� ;�` CITY OF PALM D S��:�� 4�4, �: �° ,.r��= r` ...Y,...o...�_�.�,..�.�..�,...,�.w.. �; PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT STAFF REPORT REQUEST: ADOPT RESOLUTION 2014-94 ACCEPTING AND REJECTING CERTAIN OFFERS OF DEDICATION WITHIN THE MAP OF TRACT 13008 (THE SUMMIT) SUBMITTED BY: Mark Greenwood, P.E., Director of Public Works DATE: November 13, 2014 CONTENTS: Resolution Exhibits "A" and "A-1" Accepted Dedications Exhibits "B" and "B-1" Rejected Dedication Record Map Vicinity Map Recommendation Waive further reading and adopt Resolution No. 2014 - 94 accepting and rejecting certain offers of dedication within the map of Tract 13008 (The Summit). Backqround In March 2014, Public Works staff was contacted by a couple who are residents in The Summit area regarding the drainage channel and related easements in backyards in The Summit. Their claim and concern was that the unmaintained backyard channel near their property caused water from the severe August 2013 storm to enter their driveway and garage. They also want the City to maintain the channel in perpetuity because the recorded subdivision map for The Summit contains an offer of dedication to the City of Palm Desert of easements for storm drain purposes at the locations where the channel exists. Unfortunately, in the map of Tract 13008, which recorded in 1979, all offers of dedications to the City of Palm Desert for the streets and drainage easements were not specifically accepted or rejected by the City as required by the California Government Code, and there is no indication that the City accepted the easements by separate action or document at any time after the map recorded. The Director of Public Works visited the site and met the resident couple on July 9, 2014, and observed that much of the backyard channel has been significantly compromised by the homeowners through the installation of various landscape improvements and other obstructions. Significant debris was also seen in the channel such as garden clippings and trash. In the Resolution no. 2014-94 Staff Report Resolution Accepting and Rejecting Dedications on Tract 13008 Page 3 of 3 November 13, 2014 Director's opinion, there is very little chance of any flood damage to any home as the channel exists today, and there was no evidence of erosion that would have existed if water had flowed from the channel to the aforementioned couple's garage. The channel was most likely designed and installed to protect the homes that directly abut the channel, which was prior to the upstream development of the Canyons at Bighorn that adjoins the southerly boundary of The Summit. The Canyons at Bighorn project included a significant storm drain system that was designed to retain storm water on- site for a 100-year storm, and also provides protection to The Summit. For that reason, the Director's opinion is that The Summit channel is of very little use and unlikely to convey significant storm flows. Current and former Public Works staff have been consulted and only two occasions have been identified when City staff performed emergency storm response, damage assessment, and clean up in the 35 years that the backyard channel has been in existence. On the other hand, City crews have routinely maintained the streets in The Summit and the adjoining catch basins in the streets, and the downstream under sidewalk drains (for water draining off of the streets) since the streets were originally constructed. Because the channel provides only limited protection to the abutting homes, and no protection to other property, it provides no benefit to the public. The City Attorney has weighed in on this subject and concurs with the Director of Public Works that the backyard channel easement dedication should be rejected. Other reasons for the rejection are the difficulty in accessing the entire length of the channel due to its location in 22 separate backyards, the compromised nature of the facility due to property owner actions, and the additional manpower and time to routinely maintain this channel. Therefore, staff recommends that Council accept the dedication made in Tract 13008 of all streets, and four outlet easements for storm drain purposes over Lots 16, 25, 30, 131, and 153 as shown on said map; but reject the dedication of the eight-foot wide backyard easements to the City of Palm Desert for storm drain purposes. Also, as a matter of compromising with The Summit homeowners, staff recommends accepting the dedication of the two side yard easements for storm drain purposes shown over Lots 89 and 99 on said map. The easements are accessed easier because they adjoin public streets. Acceptance of the easements means that City crews will maintain the improvements within those easements on a regular schedule, in perpetuity, or until the City and The Summit agree that City maintenance will cease. Government Code Section 65402 requires, in part, that the Planning Commission report to City Council that the subject rejection conforms to the adopted General Plan. At their meeting of October 7, 2014, the Planning Commission, by minute motion, determined that the subject rejection does conform to the General Plan. Resolution No. 2014-94 Staff Report Resolution Accepting and Rejecting Dedications on Tract 13008 Page 3 of 3 November 13, 2014 At the City Council meeting of October 9, 2014, said Council adopted Resolution No. 2014-82 setting a public hearing for November 13, 2014, to consider accepting and rejecting certain offers of dedication within the map of Tract 13008. Staff requests that the attached Resolution be adopted for the subject acceptance and rejection of the map dedications as indicated therein. Fiscal Analvsis There is no fiscal impact associated with this action. Prepared By: Depart nt e : . a . Page Garner, L.S. Mark Gr e ood, P. ., Senior Engineer/City Surveyor Director of ublic Works Paul S. Gibson, Director of Finance Approval: hn M. Wohlmuth, City Manager PG/bl RESOLUTION NO. 2014- 94 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, ACCEPTING AND REJECTING CERTAIN OFFERS OF DEDICATION WITHIN THE MAP OF TRACT NO. 13008 (THE SUMMIT) M.B. 106/24-30, RIV. CO. REC., UNDER PROVISIONS OF DIVISION 9, PART 3, CHAPTER 3 OF THE STREETS AND HIGHWAYS CODE OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA. The City Council of the City of Palm Desert, California, does hereby DETERMINE, ORDER AND RESOLVE as follows: WHEREAS, the subject acceptance of dedication is made pursuant to California Government Code Section 66477.2, and the rejection of dedication is made pursuant to the requirements of the California Streets and Highways Code, Division 9, Part 3, Chapter 3; and WHEREAS, the City Council on the 9th day of October 2014 initiated proceedings to accept and reject certain offers of dedication more particularly described in Exhibits "A", "A-1" "B", and "B-1" attached hereto, and the City Council finds that said notices of such vacation were published and posted, as required by law; and WHEREAS, the City Council on the 13`h day of November 2014 held a public hearing as required by law, at which hearing all persons interested in or objecting to the proposed acceptance and rejection of said offers of dedication were heard, and said public hearing was duly and regufarly closed; and WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Palm Desert considered such matter and finds from the evidence submitted that the offer of dedication described in and shown on Exhibits "B" and "B-1", attached hereto and made a part hereof, are unnecessary for present or prospective public purposes, is private in nature and access thereto by City maintenance personnel is prohibitive and impractical. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, AS FOLLOWS: Section 1: That the offer of dedications described/listed and shown in attached Exhibits "A" and "A-1" are hereby accepted; and Section 2: That the offer of dedication described and shown in attached Exhibits "B" and "B-1" is hereby rejected; and RESOLUTION NO. 2014- 94 Section 3: That the City Clerk of the City of Palm Desert, California, shall cause a certified copy of this resolution and order to be recorded in the office of the County Recorder of Riverside County, California. PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the Palm Desert City Council held on this 13th day of November 2014 by the following vote, to wit: AYES: NOES: ABSENT: ABSTAIN: Van G. Tanner, Mayor ATTEST: RACHELLE D. KLASSEN, City Clerk City of Palm Desert, California Resolution No. 2014-94 EXHIBIT A Tract 13008 Accepted Dedications All highways and streets as shown on Tract 13008, as per map filed in Book 106. Pages 24-30 of Maps in the office of the County Recorder of Riverside County, Califomia. Spec�cally: Highway 74 (shown as Pines to Palms Highway) Homestead Road Crestview Drive Sundown lane Opal Drive (shown as Ocotillo Drive) Desert View Drive (shown as Skyview Lane) Sun Valley Lane Theodora Lane (shown as Rimview Lane) Summit View Drive Mesa View Drive Greenbriar Lane Valiey View Drive Spyglass Lane Olympic Drive North View Drive Shady View Drive Quail Hollow Drive And, The 8 feet wide easemeM foc storm drain purposes as shown over Lot 16 0�said map. The 15 feet wide easements for storm drain purposes as shown over Lots 25, 30, 131, and 153 of said map. The 14 feet wide easements for storm drain purposes as shown over Lots 89 and 99 of said map. Resolution No. 2014-94 EXHIBIT B Tract 13008 Rejected Dedication The 8 feet wide easement for storm drain purposes as shown over Lots 79, 80, 81, 82, 83, 84, 88, 89, 90, 91, 92, 93, 94, 95, 96, 97, 99, 100, 101, 102, 103 and 104 of Tract 13008 as per map filed in Book 106, Pages 24-30 of Maps in the office of the County Recorder of Riverside County, Califomia. RESOLUTION NO. 2014-82 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM DESERT, CALIFORNIA, INITIATING PROCEEDINGS TO ACCEPT AND REJECT CERTAIN OFFERS OF DEDICATION WITHIN THE MAP OF TRACT NO. 13008 (THE SUMMIT) M.B. 106/2430, RIV. CO. REC., UNDER PROVISIONS OF DIVISION 9, PART 3, CHAPTER 3 OF THE STREETS AND HIGHWAYS CODE OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA, AND FIXING A TIME AND PLACE FOR HEARING ALL PERSONS INTERESTED IN OR OBJECTING TO THE PROPOSED ACCEPTANCE AND REJECTION OF THE MAP DEDICATION The City Council of the City of Palm Desert, Califomia, does hereby DETERMINE, ORDER AND RESOLVE as follows: I. That it intends to, and by this resolution does, initiate proceedings under the provisions of Division 9, Part 3, Chapter 3 of the Streets and Highways Code, to accept the dedications as described/listed and shown in Exhibits A and A-1, and reject the dedication as described and shown in Exhibit B and B-1; and II, That the hour of 4:00 p.m. on the 13th day of November 2014 in the Council Chamber, 73-510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert, California, is hereby fixed as the time and place of hearing all persons interested in or objecting to the proposed acceptance and rejection of said map dedications; and III. That the City Clerk is hereby directed to publish a notice of said hearing in The Desert Sun, a newspaper of general circulation, circulated in the City of Palm Desert, California, twice, the first date of publication being two (2) weeks before the date of the hearing, and the City officials of the City of Palm Desert are hereby instructed to post notice of such map dedication rejections, as required by law, at least two (2) weeks before the day set for the hearing. PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the Palm Desert City Council held on this 9m day of October, 2014, by the following vote, to wit: AYES: BENSON, HARNIK, SPIEGEL, WEBER, and TANNER NOES: NONE ABSENT: NONE ABSTAIN: NONE Van G. Tanner, Mayor ATTEST: RACHELLE D. KLASSEN, City Clerk City of Palm Desert, California Sanchez, Gloria From: Moeller, Charlene <CMOELLER@palmspri.gannett.com> Sent: Thursday, October 16, 2014 1:50 PM To: Sanchez, Gloria Subjed: RE: legal Notice - Res 2014-82 PH 11/13/2014 - T13008 The Summit HI Gloria Ac.i rrcrivea anci will publish oi� ��atc�(s) r��yucstc�d. Charlene Moeller � Media Sales Legal Notice Coordinator The Desert Sun Media Group 750 N. Gene Autry Traii, Palm Springs, CA 92262 t 760.778.4578 � f 760.778.4731 legals .thedesertsun.com /dpwlegals@thedesertsun.com The Coachella Valley's#1 Source in News&Advertising! www.Desert5un.com � twitter ��` ,` � � ; facebook t��• : � �� :� This email and any files transmitted with it are confidential and intended for the individual to whom they are addressed. If you have received this email in error, please notify the sender and delete the message from your system From:�sanchez@citvofpalmdesert.or� [mailto:�sanchez@cityafpalmdesert.or�) Sent:Thursday,October 16, 2014 12:38 PM To: Email,TDS-Legals Cc: blon�man@citvofpalmdesert.or�; p�arner(c�citvofpalmdesert.org Subject: legal Notice- Res 2014-82 PH 11/13/2014-T13a08 The Summit Hi, Charlene! PLEASE PUBLISH THE FOLLOWING: NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING Resolution No. 201482 - Initiating Proceedings to Accept and Reject Certain Offers of Dedication Within the Map of Tract No. 13008 (The Summit) M.B. 106/2430, Riv. Co. Rec., Under Provisions of Division 9, Part 3, Chapter 3 of the Streets and Highways Code of the State of California, and Fixing a Time and Place for Hearing all Persons Interested in or Objectin to the Proposed Acceptance and Rejection of the Map Dedication. TWICE IN THE DESERT SUN Thursday, October 30, 2014 Thursday, November 6, 2014 This publication includes four(4) exhibits; the PDF has two. If you have any questions or require additional information, please call me. Thank you and enjoy the rest of your day; tomorrow FRIDAY!! i 1/VYe strongly oppose the Clty ot Pa1m De�t'�s proposad to abandon any of�it�s drainage eas�emerYts•in Tt�:3um�nit`d'e�v�eiopment Our et�tfre Summ�t drairrage systeri'�req�res the Cfty's 0��9�9�Y��inspection,maT�end nepalr expertise to en.sure our t�rrtinued he�tth and safeRy and ttre protectlon of ou�homes and i�milies. The City of Palm Desert shouid not foist its�legally mandat,�d maFRCenance and firrancial�sponsibilitles for the draii�age system orrto the Summit assoc'ration ur its Nomeowners. �. Name(s).....�v 6�.�.....�'�'�.�..� ......�........�........_........................... ................... . � Addr�ess:...�.g.� 7C).....N��'....L[.6.4�....��.:!�1.....�al.^..'!.....1L�}�.�:.......C.�..�Z..6..v........... � - - - - - - - - - - - --� - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - -- - - - - - - - - - -- _ , .._.. _ VWe str+ongly o�ose the�I af Palm De�ect's p�oposal to abandon any of fis drainage easements�The Swnn�it dea►eioPmer�t- Our eRtlre Summit drair�age system reqt�res the City's 0��9�'+e9�Y��•��o�sur+a otnr continued heattt►and sade�y and the protectlon of our homes arxi f�milies. The Ciry of Palm Desert should not foist its legally mandatsd mainter�ance and financial�sponsibilities for the drainage system orrto the Summit Association�or its homeowners. - ._ _ Name(s)...........�,l..RN�".r............�".(¢!�C!:'.�t:�....�C�.��7N............................................... �� G� �!�!�:................�t�?�.��.. ... ..�.7.....��..��U Address:.......��..t7..................�....�.... ...... �` - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - uwe sa�ongly o�pose ihe cny ot Palm neae�t�s pr+�o�l�o abanaon any of its arainage ea�emerrts in The Sinrunit de��efopme�rt. Our eMlre S�nmit draireage system recluires ihe City's o�n9�Y��P��.��e�tn en.sur�s our coritinued heatth and sa�e�ty and the protec�on of our homes and f�milfes. The City of Paim Deseit shouid not foist its legally mandabed matrtte�ance and financial respor�sibilities for the dralnage system oMo the Summit Association nr iis homeowners. -. . s. !... �._ ..i.`.._._.._._._._. ........................................................ � )--•• -... - ........ . �. �9 �:\��. ....�;.�:�...��...........�.....�.�.-..�-�.......:....... Address�,�►G,�� ................ ..-�-� V � 1/�str�nsh►ol�pase ifie qt�r art Palm uese�t�s p�ropo�tu abanaon any o�f i�s clrairmge easement,s in The Surrunit deMeloPment- Our erttire Summft c�rrac�e system requir�s the City's 0��9�Y��°��r�t°�ure our continued heatth and sadety and the proteetlon of our homes�d families. The City of Palm Desert st�ould not foist its legally mandat�ed mairne�nce and finaix�al tesponsibilities for the drafr�age system or�to the Summit Associatjon�r its Fromeowners. j . 1 / ��2 ��s�� Ns. C;�-.o7?/1?Gf-..... ..... . ..... . - ..... ............. ..... . ame( ) � l S�i��y c—�J �i.,- �a►�:.....��:.�.`�...:.�;1�............................ .........U.../...................... . . .......................................... r � - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - -- -- - -- - - - - - - - uwa atro�i„oppose u�s c�a,of Pai�oe�c's vropo�al tio ai�.don ar�►cf�s arai��sge eesemanb In'If�e�d�wia�pm��t. Oir erqirs Suronit�ainage system�+equh�es the C�Iry's orgd�9 r�f�r�edtied Y�{�ectlon.�ianoe and�epeir eecpatise b�eAs�oir cantirx+ed heelth ertd se�ety end the p�action of otu horries and�e�. The City of Paim Desert st�ould not toist its IegeOy rt�ar�dabed rt�irtter�noe�d finandal the d�ai�ge systern arto the Summit assocfatlon w its homernnrt�ecs. . � � � � �c��r`) _-�.�.'� �n,�c,� _....___�_._._..�-"�`�`�' �"`--� ,��:..�:�..3�.�'...._..��s�� e� �r��v� __....._......_......_..............._........................_......._...�........................... -QC'�1 v►� �eS�rt C' A `i Z Z b u _ _ _--- ✓ � _.- - - - -- - uwe strongly o�pose the c�t�r of Palm De�e�t�p�o�i to abandon any of fts drai�mge easements in The Sw�ur�it deNelopment. Our erttire S�xnmit drair�e system requires the Aty's on9a�9�9�Y scheduled in.specdon,malydenanoe and repeir e�cpertlse Uo ensure our continued h�and sa�erty and the protectlon af our homes and famtlies. The City of Palm Desert should not foist its legally mandaded mairrtenance and financ�al�esponsiblifties for tfie drainage system onto the Summft Assoc'rat�on ar its homeowners. . . � ` � � r�. �1�' �' �-� f '� - - ......... --. ..��......L�.... ..... N�,�S�.__...-�.�----------.._.�............_..._.._._...__...... ,l --�� - �/ � �c� S �(� S� l� �P�. . ... ��........ ................. Address:...��k.................................................y..........1............... � ...... ...... . 9�-a �� VVye stmpr�gty qppose the l:ity of Palm De�ert's ptoposal�o abartdort�y at its drair�age easements in The Sunxr�de�velopment. Our entire Summit dra�e system reqt�r+es the City's on9o+n9 r+eg�a►IY�eduled fispecijon,maint�enanoe and repeir ex�tise�ensur+s ot�r oontinued h�ith and sadety and the prnteCtlon of our homes�d f�mflies. The Gty of Palm Desert should not foist[ts legally manda�ed mairrtefrar�ce and finarxx:ial r+espor�ibil'�ies for the drainage system orrto the Summft t�' n�r its home�wners. •- ASs��IiL�'e-- -- _ a9 �4 N s 1... � . a►ne{ )••- ---- - ---..�...............................................».. �� 1 �. ��. �.1... .. ............................................. Address:.... ...........................•••-•-.....�... ..... .. ...... �.� . .l.. c�.�w� I��..s� / � , y o�2.�0 � � — -- -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - uvve�hr a�e�ne cx�„a��m ne�c��os��o�x�on ar�,►ar�s ar��e e�sements in The 8ummit deareioprrwnt Our entine Sixnmft�e systsm requlres the CitY's �9��9�9�Y scheduled inspectior�.mafrtt�ertanoe and rep�b'eocperti�e�o ensure our oorrtlnued heetth and s�eRyy and the pro�baction of our homes ar�d f�nilies. The City of Palm Desert should not foist its legalfy mandaRed rt�alntenance and fln�x�ai re5ponslbilittes for fhe drafnage system orrto the Summft Associ�tlon w its homeowners. " � - �� v�� Nams....... .......�`7��.............._---........_.......�!... . ..��... .... ..._.. e( ) �'..Il. ..._. �� S-��G ��"TI� � � � � �: .......................................................�.................�.. .�:�� .��:�.. �-� ) .� .�.... .... ., I�l�d� 7�� S ��v9�� -D �4��1�.� � ��,��l�t (,�� l� �� 1/��1� � �(�-�� - - - - - - - - -- -- - - - -- -- - -- - - - - - - - ��h►w��c�►o��r��r�n��r,� e�semenls tn The summ�de�eio��mant. our enn►e s�mm�drai�ge syscem reyuires tt�e c�ny�s 0��9►�9�Y��d�,mainbertevtce and rep�eb'eocpertise m ensure our oontinued heetth and safieRY and'the prabection vf our homes�d tamilles. The City of Palm Desert should not fo(st fts legalty mendaLed matrtte�rance and fi�ncial responsibilities for the drainage system orrto the Summit As�ociation Dr its homeowners. - ,;- '-1 , N�c ------ - - .�. .... '.�_...�...........,r�'4��s�.�..�....��!l'►�o�s� Address:.....�8�.�,��..��r�i�............................................................................................ /-�,�� .��r; ��. 9zz6a wve�y o�ose me cxrt�r of�nes�t�s��o�ao��y o�r t�arar� ease�nent�in The Sununit cle�relopmenk Our eMire S�unmit drainac�e system requires the C�►'s �9a�9�Y��.�and rep�ir e�cpert�e b�ensure our c�ntinued heetth and safety and the protectbn of our homes�d f�milfe.s. The City of Palm Desert should not foist its legally marxlabed malrtte�nce and firnarx�a!rasponsibilities for the drainage system orrto the Summit Association ar its Nomeovv�iers. �. N�S.............��.�.�Q.-.�-��....`�_�r.��.1.��._......C..�.�:..�.�;� I l � A��:...7.z..s.:�...�..............i... ...�.�..�1..�..�.�...............��.�............................. �'� �,, � Se�� 226 C� / � — — — -- - - - - - - - - uwe stno�gly oppose tne cXt�r of Paim oe�t's p�oposa�tio abanaon any o�f ns arairmge easements in The S�nnn�tt de�velopment. Our errOre S�xnmit�ge system requires the City's a��9�Y scheduled�ion,maurte�oe arxi repeir eo�ertise L�en,sure as corttinued he�tth and sa�ety and the protec�ion of our homes and temiifes. The City of Palm Desert should not foist its lec,�ally mar�da�bed mai�nce and flrranc�a!responsibillties for the dratnage system orrto the Summit Associatjon nr iis homeowne�s. �. . . Name(s .. . . ....................._.. ........ ..._. .�.. .. ... ..... ....... .. .. ... .-•----....... addr�ss:...�o..�.:^.lB....�...�..........��?�l-�:... .�,�...�..'I..Y.�.r............................................... �-� - — — — — -- -- - ��r�ao�u�e c�a��ne�rs�to�a�ao��y o�n�a�e ea�emerrts in The S�srudit de�reiopmer�t. Our entire Summft drai�ge system r�eq�res the City�s ��9�Y scheduled�pecBon.maint�enanoe and repa�r e�ert�e tn�sure our c�ontinued h�tth and s�fetY ar�d the Pr+at�c�on of our home.s and families. The Gity of Palm Desert sho�id not foist lts legally mandabed mai�r�e and financial r�Or��li�es for the drainage system orrto the Summft Association nr its homeowners. - // � . Name( ��G�:��cs.c.u�. ....�...� y�-•........................................•------- A��:.7��..�� .. .. ...............................��--.��.��...��.......... V We saongly o�pose ine cny o�f Pal,n oese�c`s propo�l tio abandon any o�f it�s cirat�ge e�emerrts in�n�e�ru�deti�etopmerrt. our eMina summit drair�age system r+equires the c�lty�s ongoih9 r�egt�artY s�eduled�pec�on.mair�t�enartoe and r�epeir��o en.sur+e our contlnued heatth and sa�e�tyy and the protectlon of our homes and f�milies. 'T'he City of Palm Desert should not foist its legaliy mandatsd mak�tenance and financia!r+esponsibilities for the drafnage system orrto the Summft Assoc'ratlon ar its homeowners. � Name(s). ._....�/.�' �IR.�...........��'.:�_.......�..�f`?��.�.1�7.�,,.111.......,�. . �,�Z' // / /� —/�� /� Address:..��l�(�.1...�,icv. ... 1.l.��......�.�.�.. .�/J.�1.. . .�!G�!p!��.L..l.•=•:..�,e��r�.� �� - - - - - - - - - - - �- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -�- - - - - - - - 1/Ylle strongly oppose tlfe G�rty of Palm De�rt's proposal t�abandon arty ot its drainage easemeMs fn The Summit de�r�elopment Our entire S�nmit�airrage system req�u�es the City's 0��9�9�1Y s�►eduled��pec�on.ma�tt+�e arxi r�ir eoq�ertFse�en,sure our oorttinued h�tth and saffety and the protec.�ion of our homes�d f�nilles. The C�ty of Palm Desert should not foist its legally manda�ted mairtte�rx;e and fir�arx�al�spor�sibilities for the drainage system onto the Summft Association�r its homeowners. � � �i��,.`''`'`� Name(s)....................�_........��..................._._..._..........._.........----------.........---................ Addt�ss:........ FzoieF'.ivcE�rcEx 7265/S1INDDGYNLN .............................................................................. PilLNI DPSERT,CA 922646SJ7 � - � .� � � � � _ � ' - � �. � � � ._. _. � - - � �.. _ � � 1/We 5�0�1�O�SB 1119 aly Of�lil�A�'L�S pIOpOS��D�IdO/f A�Iy O�f IfS[��Is'�B 60Se111efit'S II11�lA SUIIII�(�6N�O�t116Ift. �lJf�(1�(�$UIi11i1�G�'dill�B S�IS'�@Rl�UlI�6�1@�,�/'S ��9 re9��1Y scheduled inspection.mahr0enanoe and rep�ir expe�tise�o en.wre our c�rrantted he�tth and saffe�ty and the pr+�tection of aur homes�d famtlies. The City of Palm Desert stwuld not foist its legalty manda�ted malrtte�ance and firnanaal�sponsibiilties for the drafnage system orrto the Summit Associatfon vr its homeowners. � Name(s).... _... ... �......... . ......... -�_--_.----•-------------_..__�......................._......... f��- Address:.......1..�?.��.!...... ... ... ..... ..��...��TY..... .......... . .�:S?5� .�► . 9�(00 .� - VV1le strongly oppose fhe C�t�l o�f Palm Des�t`s propossd�o abandon an�l o�f its drairm9e e�semencs in Tt�e summ�deti�eiopme�. our entire summit drair�age systerr►requires tne caty�s 0��9�Y��Pectia►►.maf�t�nar�oe and re�ir eo�e�t�t�°�sure our oorttinued he�tth and sa�erty arid the protectfon of our homes and families. The City of Palm Desert should not foist its legally n��rxiaR�d mai�te�nce and financial�esponsibilities for the drai�age system orrto the Summft Associatfor,r�[�.s homeowners. � � � , � zT/L��'�, � Name(s). ...................._...._.._..._......................_._ ._..---.....-------..-.-----............ ................ O� / /��jF!i�;,;j„Y..�:�.'.�;. .........Y....-:.�.......` ._./................................ Address:.L-..�...��............f�.L. ..y.. ...... V � -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - UWe strongly oppose ttte Cit�/of Palm Des�t`s proposal to abandon any of i�s drainage e�semerYts in The Sunur�deMelopment. Our entire Summit drairrage system reqtBres the C�ity's o�n9�9�Y��Pe�.��"n ensure our continued heeith and sa�ety and the protiection of our hom�and iemilies. The City of Palm Desert stwuld not fast its fy mandaded mafrrte�nce and finarx�al�sponsibil'Ri�s for the drafriage system orrto the Summit ' n vr rts homeowners. . T / Ns._... _� .. . ._-------��............................................. ame( ) -�- ..� Dorothea Bisbas Addr�ess:.. �: �72650 Sundo CA 9 , , Dese , 2260 .................................................................................................. --� ', Palm G.`_ -- 1/vve str�orgly oppo�e ihe qty af Pslm De�t's proposal�o abandon any of its dratnage ea9emenCs in The Surrimit deMelopment. Our ertiGjre S�nmit�ge system re4ulre:s the City's ��9 re9�Y��.m��r�Lo ensure our oontinued heatth and safety and the protectlon of our homes and tamilles. The City of Palm Desert should not foist its legally mar�ated maintertance and financia!�sponsibilities for the drair�age system orrto the Summit A.Ssociatjon z��its home�wners. -. � . . N�cs��o�''e!�..w......�.. . ..r.a _.._ .�r.�.........................��....----.- . Addr�ess: .. .�!!.��....J`.`a':...... _..d.�_��.1.!�,.....-•--•--• !/YYe str�ongly o�ose ttfe Oriy of Palm Des�t's propoaal�o aVandon any of Ms drainage e�sements in The S�srunit deMefopmenk Our erttire Summit�'airrage system req�res the C�ty's 0��9�Y��.mairtt�er�anoe and r+epafr��ensur+a ots'cortdnued heatth and sa�erty and the prot�cdon aF ax homes and f�nilfes. The Ciry of Palm Desert should not foist its legally manda�ed mainte�nce and firrarx�al�sporuibil"�6ies for the drairnage system onto the S�mmit Associatior�ar ns homeowneis. " rv�s). ................. ....F...:',L:�'�E'.�....��1..�-�--...............�.._.................................. Add�:...::��.::..�-�t..l.............��.�....�:� ..... . ��r-e... ..�.�.��.:��.�... .... ........... ......... . .. --- �, �� - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - _ _ -.- - - - - - - - ��►��„��,�,��,�,�y�� e�neMs in�n�e S�mur�it deti�eiopm�nt. au ennre s�nmit d►alnage syst,em reqtdr�s tne c�ity�s 0��9�Y�duled�Spectfon,mairrte�noe and r�ir e�e�t�e L��sur+e our cartlnued heatth and s�ety and the protec�don ofi our homes and fami(ies. The City of Palm Desert should not foist its le�gally mandated mafnteriance and financial�esponsibilities for the drainage system orrto the Summit Association�r its homeowners, . N s.�l�:?:�:!�..� KaO�►Ai4 � �( )•--1• ....---...._.............._._..�............ ... ......:�,....�� Ada�:.�a6p"!......... .�:�......��.........��..��......�..�'��o � ...................... � _ � _ _ _ _ -- - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ��r a�P�e u�e c�ty of Pa�n nes�t�pro�osal�o a�anao�amr o�n$dra�age easemerns in The Swrunit deMelopn�ent Ota e�rttn4 S�mR d�ge system requres the G1tty's 0��9 re9�r1Y�eduled inspec0on,mam�mnoe�d repalr expertlse to ensure our c�rrtinued heatth and safety and the proteCttort of our hornes and famitfes. The City of Palm Desert should not foist its legally mandabed matrrtenance and firranc�al res�ibilitles for the drainage system onto the Summft A.ssociatjon or Its eowners.�� . Cy� Name(s). ...�.a.L��--=!------•�°r1r� �J 1 I�R S • �.......--------------------�---.....................------ Aadre�:......��.-��a...._..��R Tk�4�...v1�.W......�:...................................... ............................... 1/W@ S�I10�y OpE)OS@ 1f1@�.ty Of�f11�1'�8 pi'OpOSB��O�O�I a11y O��S(�'�Itc'Ig@ e�seme�,cs in�n�e sumr�veMelopmenc. our e�tine s�nmit dra�rage system requres the t�ty�s on9an9 r�g�ariY s�eduled i�ti�n.maintenartoe and r+�ah'e�tise m�sur+a aa oor�tinued he�tth and sadety and the probectlon of our homes�d tamilies. The City of Paim Desert should not foist its legally mandaLed mairYter�ance and firnarx�al r+aspor�sibilit�s for the drainage system orrto the Summit Assaciatjon nr its homeowrters. . ,/� S � /� ►�cs)---.J.�r r�'�.�. }....:....��1.11.�C.�bSS C�..................................................... JA ` , /, Address:..�.(��?�.....�v....v..�..e.�.��Y..�...... ...�,�..�H•.�L�J.'.��..:.1��.. r �—�t - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -�- - - - - - - - uvye straongly oppose u�e c�r ot Palm Des�t�propo�l to abanaon any af Its arainage e�semerrts�The Surr�mit detielopmenk Our e�rfire S'ummit drai�ge system requires the G1ity's ongoin9 r�g�ar1Y s�led fisp�ection,m�noe arxf re�ir e�q�ertl�e m en.st�r�e ota oontinued heefth and saacFe�y and the protectlon of our homes and families. The City of Palm Desert should not foist its legaliy rrrdndaded mainte�ance and firranc(al respor�sibilities for the drainage system o�o the Summit Association nr its homeowners. � . Name(s)----.,l.�...�'°�'��.�......�'��/�._.....�........�..�./�.-....................... �f�� /��C�'/� �/f/�^ �j��j �C.c-�.�c�� L� 2��!� Addr�ss:...�..........................................................................................................................,1...................� � - -- - - -- - - - -. _ — ._ � - - - - _. � _ � _ - -�- - - - - - - - I/We str�ongiY op�o�e ttfe City ofi Pal�n De�t's propo�al to aVando�arn/of ICs drairtage ea�ements in The Sisnmit deMelopmenk Our er�ire Summit d�r�age system r�e4uires the G1ty's 0��9�Y�uled�sPectlon.mak�tenanoe and r+sp�ir��ensure ots-�ontinued h�lth and safiety and the protectlon of our homes and tamilles. The City of Paim Desert should not foist its legalfy manda�ad mainte�ance and financ�ai�biiibies for the drainage sSrstem orrto the Summit r4ssoc'ration nr its homeowners. � tiG� G%� � Name(s. _......_............................. ............_.....................----..............................._.. Ad v��" � ��/ L�"�' �� `p�,tt �/�. � d�:...........................................................,�......1.............-.----....._....... ......... ..................... -� � �" �� _ � ��/� �,� �e�9h�oPP�e�e CfiY o�Palm Dese�t`s pt+u�o�al to abandon arYy o�f f�s drainage eesemerrts in Tt�e sisruHt aeMetopmen�. a,r enere summit�ge system requires the c�ty�s 0��9�9�Y scheduted'mspection,mafi�areoe and repelr e�ertise�enstue ota oorninued heefth and sa�ety and the pr+ntection aF ax homes�d families. The City of Palm Desert should not foist its legally mandabed mairtter�ance and finarx�al resporrslbilitles for the drainage system orrto the Summft iatjon nr its meowners. l ,/, � 74 ��k�� .. . � �� r,,amecS,.-.��(��...�..�..�:.��:!�.._..._.�..-.-......�.:�...._.�'!......�.:�.�:.�!�:..:..� Address:.�l�..�:.�.b......��.y..�►.e:�.4....:�lZ:4v".r-.��...��..�.�:�:�:r.� .r�......9�6� r-- �,.�` - - - - - - - - -- - - - -- _ _ - _ - - - - - - - - - - - -�- - - - - - - - 1/YYe sbr�ongly oppose the CKy of Pa�n De�t`s pnoposal�o abandon any o�iCs drair�age e�semerrts in The�deN�ebPmer�t. Our eMire Summit drair�e system re4t�res the Cit�r's o�n9�Y�+��.��d r�e�er�t�°e�ure our oorr�nued he�lth and saFety and the protectlon of au homes�d families. The(�ity of P�m Desert should not foist its legally�mairrtertance and finarxtial responsibilities for the drair�age system orrto the Summit Assaciation�r its homeowners. � �_�'j �- ��i�G.��1.•�-- -iC?'!2?�� /�'%? L� Name(s)._...... ... ....... . .... . ,�,��:....... ......�:.�.�.�....... � .�. .�.�............ ....................................... � � � _ ��►��►��,�,��,,,�� eesements in The s'�nrunit deMelopment. our e�ire s�unmit drakm�e system requres tt�e f�ty's a'��9�9�Y�edu�ed i�eciion.mairrt�nanoe and repa��to ensure our oontinued he�tth and saa�e�ty and the p�+ntec6ion of our homes�d famtUes. The City af Palm Desert shvuld not foist tts legally mandated mairrte�nce and flnan�al�esponsibilitles for the drainage system orrto the Summit association nr its home�wners. - � �� N�cS,��... . ._. ...�.... ...._...__.�..._.._-- -. -.--�_............... ��--� .JoI'I�? /�, Cvc:�� L ind� �, , Gca K Address:...Y�3.:z:s"�.....0 r:.�:�I....✓..��...,:l..r'!Ll.�'......�7�1.�...:SN!?�T. .n!��......................... I�c��n� 1�e Se r�t; G fl 9 2 Z 6 C� I/VYe str�ongly oppose ttfe City of Palm Desert's pt+opos��abar�don�r�y of its c�ainage easement�s in The�deMelopmenk Our errtire Siunmft drairrage system requir�s the C�ty's ongan9�g�ariY s�eduled fispeCtion,mair�enanoe and repeir e�ertlse b�ensur+a otx continued he�tth and saffety and the protectlon of our homes and families. The City of Palm Desert should not fast its legaliy manda�ed mainterrance and finar�cial respor�sibilitles for the drafnage system orrto the Summft Assoc'ration nr its homeowners. - Name(s)........................S.�?�c�x:a..W�a�.r�---.._....�.�.----------........................................................ Address:...4.�.:2,�A...Cr�s tu.i.ew-..F��e;...�s�m�-•DEs�er�'�"�A"�3'ZZfi'Q...................................• 0-__ -- - - - -- -- - -- - - -�- - - -- - - -- - uwe sa�o�ghr oppo�e tne c�t�r a�Pahn ues�t's pr�oposal to abanaon any o�f i�s arai�mge eesements in The S�untnit deMelopment Our eMire Summit c�e system reyuires the Cify's 0��9�Y�'��,m��oe arxi repair e�t)se to ensure our c�ntinued he�tth and sade�y and the p�fiectlon af ax homes . families. The City of Palm Desert should not foist Its le�gatfy marxiated maicrtenance and fi bilities for the draircage system onto the Summit Association vr tts homeowners. - ;i � , ,i/ � , ' , - Name(s)............. � � ..........................._.........._........._..............._...._----........................._.. r........... . � -� A��:....`�.,�...��.�..........��;��.��:..... .....�.�.�........�..�.........1�..::............�..:......... . �L?-6(� �` - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -�- - -- - - - - - ��shr oppose tne c�qr a�f Pahn De�t's pro�to abandon any o�f i�s arainage eas�nents 6�The Swnmit deMek�pmer�t. Oiu e�riire S�nmit�ge system r�e4uires the Caity's �9��9�9�►1Y schedu�ed ir�specijon,mairri+enanoe and�pair e�tise t+�ensvre our c�ontinued h�and safety and the protec6lon of our homes�d families. The City of Paim Desert should not foist its legal�y mandated maintenance and flnanc'raf r�espor}sibilities for the drair�age system onto the Summit Associatjon tir its homeowners. � � � Narne(s)---,;L�l��.....�....�... .�..�._�!�:�:................._........----•---•----•----------.................----....---..._.. ,e,��:...'z6��.......s�. . ��-.s..s......�:�.�...................�................................ �� e�9h/oPP�e fhe(�t�/of Palm Desert`s proposal�o abandon any af tts drainage e�sements in The S�srur�de�r�elopmenk Our entire Summft drainage system reqt�res the C�ty's �+'��9�9�Y��,�oe and repeb��t�ensure our continued h�tth and sa�eFty and the prot+ect�on of our homes and famflies. The City of Palm Desert should not fast Its legally manda�ed mairrtenance and financ�al�esponsibilities for the drainage system orrto the Summft/�Ssociation nr its homeowners. - � J�.'wo�rv�� Name(s)•-1(.��I�...��.._..................................................•--.........----- ��g�Q �� Address:.... .�-�,h.,.sj�.g,,0_.�,,,,�...........�..�:�:��........................................................................... �� Vyye s�r�pngly appose Ufe Cit�/of Palm Des�t`s proposal to aba�xfon any o�f!ts draine9e eeseme�s in Ths S�ur�it deMe�opment Ow e�rtire S�xnmft�e system�e4�res the City's 0��9 re9�Y��°��m�Oe and repeb'eocpe�t�e m ensure ota oorrtlnued heetth and sadety and the pr+ntectbn of our hornes and families. The City of Palm Desert should not foist[ts legatly mandabad maktter�ance and fi�a1�spor�sibilities for the drair�age system arrto the Summtt Association�its homeowners. � p �1,, ., J `� til.�.....S.f....JL).��.�....__.........................�................................. Name(S)•---�,�_y�� t ` ` � ` � � �� ..�.........V..�..�...�.��..r..�......... . .�. .. .............. .�...�..�.. ......... �� r�..... ...... .. Address �• .... 1 --,� - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -�- - - - - - - - uv��sh►a��cm,��o�rs�m�ao��„��a� ea�ements in The�nm�daMelopment. our�re Summit dr�age system requires the C�ity's 0��9�9�Y sct�eduled inspection,mair�oe and r+ep�lr eoq�tise m e�,sure our oontlnued h�tth and sa�erty and the protectlon of our homes and familie� The City of Palm Desert should not foist its legally marxlated mairttenance and financial�+esponsibilides for the drainage system orrto the Summft Association nr its homeowners. " �-- .�,�-�►� f f �-,,�o I�►�-r-�+�1,� Jo��s d� Piame(s)............................. ._..............._...�.- --......_...............--------.......----------............... �1r� �f/ / -�J � /� � O Address:....7 d �D� <�O 2i�1 `/� /� �� ...............................................................................:.. ........." ....�..................................._. -}- •�- i/YYe s�tror�gly oppose the Ctty o�f Palm Des�t's proposal t�abandon 2�ty of i�s drairsage e�semenf�in The S�nrur�it deuielopment. Our eMire Summft drairrage system requires tfie City's a'�goin9 re�a�1Y�heduled'mspecTia�,maint�enarioe and repeir e�pertlse�ensure otx oorttinued he�tth and sa�ety and the pr+otecrtion af our homes�cl families. The City of Palm Desert sttould not foist its legally manda�ed makYtenance and financial r�sponsibilities for the drairtage system orrto the Summft Associatjon w its homeowners. - N�cS,........��5.�....�..:._..��..�.�. ....�......�...........�-.--�----...:_.. � Address:...�a..-.�5�.........�.... ..... .��:�-......�-�:�-...........P�?-►�:.��-�- , � `� � (�7� 56�8 - �s3� �zzc�o � � uw��►o�n�c�,�r�,��o�.,ao�,�,,,�r n�a�� e�emer�ts fn The S�deMelopment. Our e�tre Summit dr�e system re4uir�es the Aty's a��9�Y�edWed'mspectlon,mair�oe and r+�aL'eapertise t�er�.sur+a ota oontint�ed he�tth and sa�ety and the protectbn af our horr�es and f�iifes. The City of P�m Desert should not foist its le�gatly manda�ed mainte�nce and financ�al r+esponsibilit.ies for the drainage system anto the Summfit Association nr its homeowners. �. 1 ' Name(s.�.... . l..�..�.�.. ::..,Z:1.vv!��n c.��1:..1................._......_.---........................... ) •.�. �.-...� Addr�ess:.........�.k-.�:!.��.'............. . � ��...---�d1).............`;.!J...C.?�.�l2 z��......... :�"� �` - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - uwe stnongly op�ose 1ne c�ih►o�f Pabn De�t`s pro�osal to aVanaon any o�f iCs arainage e�seme�s fn The�nn�de�r�ebpmenR. Our e�rtire S�anmit�irrage system requires the Cit�r's 0��9�9��Y sc�teduled inspection,mffinR�oe and rep�alr eocpertise�ensure ota continued he�tth and sa�eRy and the protectbn of our homes and families. The City of Palm Desert should not fast its legally martdaLed mairttenance arid finarx�al�sponsibillties for the drainage system orrto the Summit Assoc'ration nr its homeowners. � Name(s)...� ........... ... .__�. ...._.._................................................... s�iel.�� 0 Address:....�.R..I�Q......�.�./.}<.�.Q.7.Jl/.�....��........................................................................ uwe sa�o�gty opuose me cny ot Palm nes�t`s proposal�a abarxlon any a�f ns arairmge eagements in The Swrmnit deu�elopment Our er�tire Summft ckair�age system r+e4uir�s the C�ty's 0��9�9�Y scheduled'mspec6on,maint+enarx�e and repair e�tise�en.sure ax continued heatth and sacfety and the pr+nbac�on of our home�s and families. The City of Palm Desert should not foist its legalty mandabad mairtte�ance and fi�ancial�+espor�sibilities for the drainage system orrto the Summft Association nr its homeowners. � ` ' ' ._...��.�..._.�.�: � N�cs�:===:�. -------- ---- - ----------------....�---.__.---...-----------------..._.. �� .�.�." �..��.��.......�.�....�.�. %�.��.�..... `I�z � d ��:.... ..... ......... . .. ....... .. ._................................ � - - - - - - - - - - - - --- -- -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -�- - - - - - --- - uwe saor�ghr or�pose u�e c�cy ot Palm neserc�s pro�al to abarWon a�y of ns ara�nage easemen�s f�'ihe Swnn�aeN�elopmenr. au ennre summit�e system r+eq�res tne c�ty�s ��goin9►e9�arhi�ed�ed b�ec�on,m�r�rwe and repair eocpertlse t+�ensure our c�ntlnued he�tth and saa�ety and the protectlon af our hom�and famiiles. ll�e City of Palm Desert should not foist fts legaliy marxiated malnte�nce and financial resportsibil'dies for the drafnage systern onto the Summft A,ssociation�r its homeowners. OV� /y{O�+t�' 1�fm� �I�C��,�� J�0/�G�`GZtx.t�(.� ��G -6U,� Name($)........�...��:'S�:u�...�........."'....._».�....._._...._.......«........""......C'�'i..�...�.�.�:l�:'— A��s:........�zG�'7, .Iv�u �ac.,c.�:�.:...�.1.�....................... .... ...... .... ........... � ................................................ ��t�, �rsa.�r �: �� - - - - - - - - - - - . , - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -�- - - - - -.- - �� e�semerrts�The S�sr�de�relapment. Our errtire S�nmit�e system re4t�res the City's a'�goin9 reg�arlY�led�pec�tion.ma�anoe and rep�r eo�'tise�o ensure our ooritlnued h�tth and safaty and the pro�ection of our hornes and tamiliee. The City of Palm Desert should not foist its legally mandated mairtt�and financ�af respor�sibilitles for tfie drainage system orrto the Summft As.soc'ration�r its homeowners. �. Name(s).... ....... ..........................�------..._..__... .....�.---.......... ........---• -- --�- . Address:......�...�...U..�d .._.:.`:.........�l..l e`^�...... .. ...�,.�i.�.............. ...• .......---..... ....................... / UWe str�ngly oppose the City of Palm Desert's proposal�o abantlon any of its dratnage easemerrts in The Summit deveiopmertk Our entire Summit draimage syskem requires the C1ty's ongoing regutariy scheduled inspection,mair�t+enance and r�epair expertlse to ensure our c�rriinued health and safety and#he protection of our homes and families. The Cifiy of Palm Desert should not foist ifis fegally mandated maintenance and financiaf responsibilities for the drainage system orrto the Summit Association vr its homeowners. � Nam ............. ..........._....._...._._..._..._._.�.!`_"�_Uis ,�U.�iV�...../.�?�4!!!tOvh,6� Address:...... .G..,,�....��Dv..._..��.L....L.'.-:,.v�...�.,;..:.�.:...`.G.,.:'.��....`,'':,.,!, ,�`,,,��G/ .� -� _ �e�9h/q�pose the Clt�►afi Palm Des�t`s pr�al�o abandon aryy of l�s drai�ge essemerns in The S�nnm�deMebpment Our erttire S�nmit�a�age system requir�es the C1ity's o�n9�9�►�Y s�heduled b�spectior�.mahri�e and r�P�'ex�ert�e tn er�sure our oot�'bnt�ed heatth and sade�ty and the prntiectlon af our homes�d tamilies. The Caity of Palm Desert should not foist its leg�ly mandabed malrrte�arx:e and fina�ial n�por�sibiiities for the drainage system onto the Summit Association rn its homeowners. - �� O�.�s�,�,� N�cs�.--.---._.........�...........�......_.�...........�..�.........................._.---.._................................ a��:...��./....f.�....,...��'�,��„��.....•��.:.'.�........................................................... �� - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - V We str�on9h►opnose u�e c�ih►af Pahn D�s propasai t��anaor�any�it�s dra�r�age eeseme�rts in The�de�relopn�ent. Our e�re Stunmit dratr�ge system r+eqtires the C�ty's a�n9 r�la►1Y�heduled InspeCtion,R�r�oe��pert�se L��sur�s ot�r c�orttinued heanh and sa�edy and the protectlon of our homes and familfes. The City of Palm Desert shouid not foist its Iegal�Y manda�ted mairtt�and fin�rssportsibilit�es for the drafnage system orrto the Summit Elssociatjon w its homeowners. - n � . Name(s).............�.!�._..�.....t'�.1?�.l��...��.t�..:�."��..................._....................................... AddreS.s:......y:�.�.�.S.I.....�.��L4:�..��/�[:✓..1��.,�..P�:�'�:t..1��J 5�.�..2..?..c.�.�...�1.�:�................... �sa�y o�ose�ne cny a��ne�t�s�to�aori�y of�a�� e�eme�s�The swnnit detietopme�. our errtire surnmit drairrage system require5 the t�ty�s a►9��9�Y�eduled ins�ection.mah�noe and r�epelr ea�ertise tio ensure our continued heetth and sa�ety and the protectlor►o�f our homes�d famtlies. The Cily of Palm Desert should not foist its legally mandabed mai�rteriance and finandal�spon.sibilities for the drainage system orrto the Summit Association nr its homeowners. �. Name(s)...�o r�K H.....�....,5/LL P''1 q i�D+�LST}9 M-•................ Addr�ess:...7.2 Lv 9/ S P�G��q S S L fJ�.....Pq t'M "D a�-=7�T1...,.�..�......9��O O ................ .................................... .......................... .... �.�- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- _ _ . _ " UVYe str�on�y op�e�e�h►of Paim nesert`s pr�oposai�o ab�ndon am►o�f its drainage e�semerris in Tite S'u�r�it deti�ebpment Our erriire S�enmit�ge system reqtires the City's a�n9�'+a9�Y��°r'�maintenanoe and�ir expettise�ensure our c�ontinued heetth and saffe�y and the pro�ectlon of ax homes and famtiies. The City af Palm Desert should not foist tis legaliy mandaRed maicrt�and finarx�a!�or�ibilitles for the drainage system orrto the Summit Assoc'ration vr its homeowners• � - �l.�� AN N�cs�............�.��!...�.�...............�!....._....�.............�..z��.�..�. A��:.............�:.�.s�_1.....---....��-.y...t�:l:�t.�.....�,t�.�..�.��.,.....��..........�='...�.-�..� �` - - - - - - - - --- - -- - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - ,��,►�+��,��,��„�� s�c��. o��s�r��t�a�,�s 0��9�Y scheduled inspeciion,ma&�benarwe and r+e�-�ertise to ensure our oorrtinued heetth and sa�eFtyy and the protec�on af our homes�d tamilfes. The City of Palm Desert should not folst its legaly mandaLed mairrtenance and fl�responsibilities for the drainage system onto the Summit Assoc'ration�r its homeowr�s. " N s .:P!1:.'::�:`.:t ��?�l!n'� ... _....�._......................_...._...................._......----•--_.. a�( ) � ----•- Aadress:.��...�::..�./.....a�.t:l�.:�.e�� .1�..l��.��'h.:. ....'..`.e` `�-►,.../.��P�'`�. °��CC� �� !/VYe strongly oppose ttw Cit�/ofi Pafrr�Des�ert`s Proposal to abandoR anI►of its drainage e�seme�s in Ths Stsrun�de'Me�apmenk Otu entjre Summit drairn�e system requires the City's o�n9�Y��p�,�oe and repeir expertlse ta ensure our ooMinued heatth and safiety and the protectlan of our homes and familie�. The City of Palm Desert shoutd not foist its legally mandated mainte�arice and fir�nda!�+asponsibilities for tha drainage system orrto the Summit Associativn�r its Ftomeowners. . �� _.�. � 4 �p ] - ,,� t Name(s)....L��:�._....... �..JIJ.�..,.....�".�.. '�.�..�.Q.!.._............ . ...:l.:G�.X!!l r Address:..�:.�' �a-� �'l,b.r th � evJ �r� ....pcl..�i.r..�,....�:Q��......�.a a � n v � — -- - 1/VYe str'an$IY aPP�'e��ll�P��Desert's ptopOsal�o abandOn anY af its drain�9e e�seme�s M The 8�nrur�deMebl�'it Our e�re SummR�ainage sygtem ne4uire�the City's �►9��9 re9�Y��rr�oe and re�ir eocpert�e��ur�our c�orttinued haetth and sRfety and the pt+a�baction of cxsr hors�es and fsmilfes. The City of Palrn Desart should ctot foist t�s legaliy mandabed m�nt�and fl�cial�+espor�sibilities for the dra(rrage sys'tem orrto the Summit Association nr its homeowr�s. � . � . Name(s)................. (�.1,�.�`:...._..�:'�:'�'!:y'��............�.......------•----......................._..._ A�,�:.....''�.`.b\1�....�:x..�.��.�.�.��:�?....`:�:.:....�'..`�.�:�'�.��:��..�.`��:....`.�.�.:��.��. � - - - - - - - - - -- - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - -�- - - -- - - - - uv�re�,a�o�e u�e cx�,►or�n nes��o�,aon a�,►o�n�a�� es.sea�ents in The�de��eiopment. our eMfia swnmft dra�ge sys�t,ecn�eq�r�es the ctit}r's ongdn9�tY�edUled�spection.m�anoe artd repair expertise to ensure our oorrtinued heaith and sadety and the pmtec�don of our homes and i�milies. The City of Palm Desert should not foist its legally mar�daR�ed mafnt�and fl��esponsibilities for tt►e drainage system orrto the Summit Association�r its hom�o . �. �'-��L �� Name(�-��i� �`,2'Q....��U�51�,._...��r�ZA�L... .............��.►J�'..+�!,NOS � '7� SS/ �r'19��iv�.� �r°�. �,�v: �'.¢1_rn 7��-?�" ��4 9Z.�- �� Address:................................................................................. ..........................---.. J..............•---. J..................... ✓ — �A S�O�O�OS9 ti1A�y Of P8�1�1�S�OS��O 8b8flf�Ofl 8fly Of�Sr��fl8�@ easemerrts in"it�e Stsrunit de�r�elopmenc. our errbna summit arairrage syste�n req�r�es tne c�ity�s o�n9�9�Y��,mainbenarx�e and repeir eocpertise m ensure our continued heetth and safiety and the pr+ntectlon of our hom�and f�milies. The City af Palm Desert should not foist its legally manda�ed mainte�nce and financial�espor�sibilities for tfie drainage system orrto the Summft Assoc"ration�r Rs homeowners. . i , ' ^" I N s .. ..�..�..'��.�w1��s.......__---- --.... �=��......... �. �.... � �. . C.f � � �/�� D � � �'� , ,� Addr�ss:.......c.��..........� .........?. ........................................................��'..v:••••••.......... ..� . . �� - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - uwe sa�ongty oppose tne Clc�►of Pahn c)e�ert's propo�al tio abanaon any ot Ms arainage ea�ements in The Summit deMelopmenR. Our e�lre S�xnmft�sinage system r+equires the City's a��9�9�Y��.��d re�elr eoc�tlse t�ensure our continued health and sa�eRy and the protection af our homes and igmt8es. The City of Palm Desert should not foist its legally mandaRed mairrtenarx�and fl�ar�cial r+e�ponsibilities for the drainage system orrto the Summft Association�r its homeowners. �. Name(s,...../:.7�v�`'�'�f �+-r�� v✓� �p��c�....................._.. � �;�� ...�... ��G✓ � �C. ....... Address:.� ............ .. l/ ................... ........................................................ ..�.........�.J.......... � c� ,,� / � � � f�"�� / �i`b0 , C J .t --- - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - 1/YYe sbr�o�y oppose U�e City o�Palrn Des�t`s propo�sd�o abandon any of i�s drainage ea.4ements in The s'urrunit deMeiopmeac. our e�ere s�xnmit drairr�ge syscem requres tfie c�ity�s ongoin9 r+sg�da�s�eduled h�SPectfon.m�er�noe and r�r ex�ertlse to�sure our continued heetth and safie�ty and the protectbn of our homes and temilies. The City of Palm Desert should not foist fts legaily mandaLad majnte�nce and finand�r�bilities for the drainage system onto the Summit Assaciatfon vr tts homeowners. - � � Y Name(S). .. ............._.._.......�. ...._�.��_.._-/..__1�.��__.'__._._._...----- �J `�// C � . Addr�ess:....L..�.. ......... .��:�::4.l.`:... . ....... .................................................................... ,�a��- � , �� a � - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - uwe sao�ghr oppose u�e city of Palm oese�t�proposal to�anao�any o�f i�s drainage ease�nents in The�nu�deMelopment. Our ernire Summit drai�e system re4uires the Gity's ��9�Y scheduled inspection,n�ai�oe arxi repeir eocpertise�ensure our can4nued heaith and sa�ety and the protection of our homes and families. The City of Paim Desert should not foist its legally mandated maintenance and financial�bilities for the drair�age system ortto the Summit Assoc'ration ar its Fiomeowners. N h at �1 en — h�l►n h �t ��es�r�, Cl��---.��:...�� Namecs). ......................�!:�' . ......._..............��.._...�......._..�............�.... Q cJ Aad�:.�:�.�.�.�.�..J'h ad,�,...V:�..�!'.�....P��...��...C...�..��z.�i 1�............................ J � _ ". �e�shr a��e c�,►a��a�m�t��ro�o��o�x�on a�,►o�ns a�� easemeMs in The S�nr�mit deMelopme�rt. Our eMire Summit drair�age system r+e4ures the C�ity's 0��9 re9�Y�uled inspect�on.maint�enanoe and repeir eoc�tise��su�our oontinued he�tth and safiety and the pcobecHon of ou�homes and tamllles. The City of Palm Desert should not foist its IegaHy mandabed mairrte�nce and fl�l responsibillties for the drairrage system o�o the Summit Association�r fts homeowr�ers. �. • ' N�cS,....�-�r..'��...��..::.�:h��..�.....�-�.��..z`.�.......................................... A�►,a�:.��5�.►...sh��:�V�e�.......�.�._��................................................................................... � _. _ ��,�,�,►�,��„��►�� easements in The S�rurut deMelopme��t. Our eMfire Stunmi��e system requires the C�ity's 0��9�''�9�Y��,��t+�en.sure our catdnued heatth and sadety and the protectior►of ax hom�s and i�milfes. The City of Palm Desert should not foist its legally mandabed mairrteriance and flrranc.iat res�bil'fies for the drainage system or�to the Summit Associatlon nr its homeowners. . C� Namecs)-.------_._ .��..1!/_...._. ...... ............. ... .. .. .... ....---------.........�'...........:.... . � �� `.�Q... ........Y....�....�.�.:GL/.... .. ..................... . ...�� Address:...�.....��........ .. .... ......... . V - uwe sa+o�ty o�OSa me V�Ly o��m��OS�to�R�..��y o��W a��B e�me�in Tne s'ummic de�va�opmenr. ot.�ennre summit drair�age system requires the ctity's 0��9�Y��.mairttienanoe arx!re�air ettpertb�e ta ensur�ots'c�ortOnued heetth and sadety and the pnatec�ion of our homes�d tamilies. The City of Palm Desert should not foist ns legally mandated mairrtenance and finarx�l respor�sibilities for ifte drainage system oMo the Summft Association ar its homeowners. � _ / Name(s).................... ............._......_..........l��.J�R�2�.................................----........ Address:..��..�K�.�.�......`� t.t.Y�.��W h....�.�.'�..'.h.�.----•-��.." ese��......��!.:v`�� .�. ..� — �1e�on�►a�e tne Clh►of Patm De�t�propo�d to abando�any of tts arainage e�semenb in The S�snmit de��eiopment Our eMire Summit�e system reyuire5 the C1ity's a�n9�Y�1gd insPec�a►.msintienance and rspeir eo�ertise tn ensure our oontinued he�lth and sa�ety arxi the protectk�n of our homes and families. The Ctty of Palm Desert should not foist ILs IegaUy manclated maintenance and financial respor�sibilRies for the drainage system onto the Summft/�Sociation ar its homeowners. � Name{s)........_`�!.��'.%�:"f.�..!..:!..��.....--•---......._�............................................... Address:.7..a-.��o....x�;��'��-....� .l,a�,-„�f�;�'��.�...��ab " .,�- ........................ o-� - - - - - - - - - -. -- -- _ -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ��h►�e tne ae�r a��n ne�er��,o�to�,ao„�,►a�n�a�a�� easemer�s in Ths S�srpn�deMeiopmerrt, Our eMire Summit dr�e system r'e4ulres the C�r's n9ofn9►�9+�arly sc�ieduled ir�pecLion.mairrt�noe arxi repeir e�ert}se t�ensure our oor�nued he�tth and safety and the protec�on of our homes and farnilies. The City of Paim Desert should not foist its IegallY mandated mainte�ranoe and fi�ncia!respor�sibili�es ior the drainage system orrto the Summit Associatjon rn its homeowners. _ N�cs�. .--,�r��C.�r.�?�.��._..._..�� _/ � �.��' .........................._.. A�►,�5:......�'�.��...�..��.1...._-.-�...��.��1.......:1�`��..�..�. �.................................................... 1/YYe sinongty oppose U�e�t�l of Palm Desert�s p�oposaa tio a�ndon any a�f its drainage easernents i�t The Stnrn�deMelopmetrt. Our entire Swnmit�ainage system r+equ�res the Aty's ongoin9 negula►h��eduled i�ecbon,nr�6e�oe and repedor�e�o er�sure our c�orrtJnued heatth and sa�ety and the pr�bec,�Hon of au homes and famities. The City of Palm Desert should not foist its legalfy mandated masntenance and finanaal respon.sib�lides far the drainage system oMo the Summit Associatfon vr its homeowners. N�cs�. ._...._._..��'.....`I�.�.S_. .:Il��:'_��!5.----�....�°'�`��.._. �.!�S_._ Addr�ss:......�.�.��...5'�►� �� ...... �cz��. �r�t-�.��r::�.�:' ..._...._. ............... �................................. 2 � � � � - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- -- - _ ._ . _ _ _. _. .. _ uw�,��,o�os�u�e c�,►o��ne�e�t��o at�.�ao��n►ot�a� em�senneaits in The Stn�it d�elopm�e��. o�s e�re sisnmi�drairr�ge syscen+requMes the C�ty's ongdn9►�e9�a�iY�uled�spection.�and+�r�m ensiae oir oor�tinued he�tth and safety and the pmbec�ion of our har�es�d f�mtlies. The City af Palm Ueseri should not foist its�manda�ed rt�ntenanoe and fit�at�ities for the drain�ge system arrto the Summtt Assocladon�r its homeowners. �. Name(s�..��Q:V l 0.�.--.�� F U��T.�?'"......_....._............_..._....�.. Address:��..�.Q...��C?D��:�........��').......P�M.....A�.��. . '� R2��oD �_� — — -. vw��y o�m��r ot�+oe�c�a�m�,ao��►of ns a� easements tn'il+e s�rr�mit de�relopmenR. o�r e�ire s�rxnit dra�tiage system�e�ir�the C�ty's ongoin9 r�r1y sc.l�ded t�ect�on.m�te�noe ard rsPeir eq�ert�e bo e�tse otr cartinued health�d safety and the protection of ar hanes and lartdlfes The<Sty af Palm Dese[t should rrot foist its legatly m�ndemed rtreinRenance snd fi�erx�al r�po�ibfTAies for tt�e drainac�e system onto the SummR Associatlon ar its homeowners. �".P.a C-�/��i✓ =��,7� c,�---- �cs,.. ...,�'....�..,�'.._---.-----.-----------_..._..._.._.------------..._ .�_......_........---.—_._---._..... /��y�� V ��-/ ��/ • // Y �� J/V `� 11NVIW�I...�.. .�..�...r.....�.................�..........................r.....................................................................__....... ........... �l�/� �7��, �'f� wk.amv6�aoome�e W swe o.o.�c.o4o.+e�r�een mr a r�.�.r m�m.a�nrfi...��e�.�.�w Oira.rh.OumAda�e.raemRa�uz�q': ^9�+�•J I�RMfJwIM�wamms�oessi�s.m.ftrotiewmtr�co rwn.rrc�wMr lUwt+�awxmdarbmcadMdsTcChvvr.uvinywlrai MeC Rw Y.ply+viWbtl�Q sd bseY nyan�b IR Rs�e'-Y'-b�eNtf.+e C�a.M�AiNXtiliv�Akslo�wU�Ai. � / - � � f ,//r ��{�. "\._ �,�.,-.��c1_�1� . �_7�_F.�_i.._---(`-`-}�✓''?,l_�� ._�.f�tG`�.. ��f Z ��j };E�- �f)i C � �1 � �r�� i/We str+on9h►q�pose the�t�r of Pa6m Dese�t's paapo�at to ab�ndon any of its dra�age easemenfs in The Stsntnit cieanelopment. Our e�fne Swnmit c�rairx�e�ystem teqt,dr+es the(tity�s �90�9 ie9�'iY sc�ieduled mspectlon,nm�de�noe and�peir e�q�er�e�o er�sur+�our aonGr�ued heatt�and sa�e�tyy and the pr�Dsctlon of au tiomes ar�d iamgfes. The City of Palm Dese�rt shoutd not fotst its legatly mandabed tnairrtertanoe and fmanc�a!�bt7'�for fhe d�nage syst�n ar�to the Summit Assoc'ratiort ar iis homeawrx�rs. - _ �/� 1 ��e� �� Name(s)._ .._.................... ........................�...r ............ . .................. . Ada�s:....:7�:6.��.....S r,�.v�.��e-y...�c`�: ....��: .......�:?� .,.�...-�. � l°�� j- J`' .. ..�. ........... � U1 - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ---- ---- - - - - - - - - - - �e�9�Y oPPQse the�tit�►af Paim oes�t�pro�sal�o abarxion any o?its arah�age e�in Ths�nnmit de�reloprr�ent. Our eMire Summit�e system ne4uires the C1ty's 0��9�9�Y��d�sPe�on,mah�e�noe and repeir eapert�se Lo ensu�our c:onGnued he�ith and sa�ety and the probection of our homes an�d families. The City of Palm Desert should not foist its legally mandated maintenance and fir�ncial respor�ibilities for the drainage system orrto the Summit Associatlon nr its homeowners. - G�`�� 1� u� � ��'i� �� W� - fVame(s)- -----------------------------------------•---�--.....�_�...�............................................................. A��:..............��y3�%.....�.�.�%rlr��,w.--�� l i ��, C'��- 9'�a�v .......+....�.................................................... V We strongly oppo�e ihe qt�l of Palm Desert`s propasal�o aba�tdon any of its drainage easemerrts in The�deti�eiopme�rt. Our e�re Stxnmit drair�age system ne4�re:s the City's a��9�9�Y��P�.rtt�ri�anoe and repair e�ertise L�ensure our c�ntinued he�lth and sa�ety and the protiection af our home�s�d families. The City of Palm Desert should not foist its legally mandat,ed mairtterrance and fina�ia!�bilitles for the d�e system orrto the Summit Association nr its homeowners. � ` ��Ip � /7 ��w� � �i� G� (Va��/--�="•:5�`=C��»S�r�'�=tl..%� ..�.�........---- ----...._....................................... �/ ,�,��:..��:��...... .. . .. ..............�..:. .�:�..........`.:�....�.�............................... � � - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - ��►��►��,�„�� e�seme�s in�n�e S�,�ur�de�eiopme��. our e�re Surmm��ge sy�n r�quir�tne c�ty,�s o�n9�9�Y�du�ed ir�spe�tion.rr�ainDe�e and r�p�h eoq�tlse to ensure our c�orttinued heetth and sa�e�y and the pr+nbectlon of our homes and families. The City of Paim Desert should not foist tts legally mandabed mai�te�nce and fir�arx�al respor�sibilities for the drainac�e system orrto the Summft a,s�oc or�vr its homeownefs. - , - - --�-,��'��r n�cs�....:�.�r.rl.�.r.' ........... . ........._ - �:� Address�.o�tiS..��.._......�..�..�'-:.�''.�:��............................................................................ Klassen, Rachelle From: Stanley, Jane Sent: Friday, November 07, 2014 11:42 AM To: Klassen, Rachelle Subject: FW: Visit to the Summit drainage channels -----Original Message----- From: donna mandelstam [mailto:dm515@sbc�lobal.net] Sent: Friday, November 07, 2014 8:07 AM To: CityhallMail Subject:Visit to the Summit drainage channels 11/6/14 Hi Mayor Tanner, j We greatly appreciated your willingness to visit The Surrymit and to view the drainage channels in person. We also were willing to look at a possible compromise to present to the Board. Unfortunately,the compromise you suggested still involves the City's abandonment of its easements for the drainage channels. After you left we realized that this would leave the Summit with 22 private backyards over which we have absolutely no control. Even if the City did a "patrol" walk of the channels, whatever was found could not be enforced by the HOA. The abandonment of the easements strips the HOA all of its power with regard to the channels. Currently, if we have an obstacle in the channel, such as the foreclosure home's cuttings, we can cite them, and if they fail to act, we are able to clean it up ourselves (because it is a health and safety issue) and add it to the lien. If the City abandons the easements it leaves the homeowners with no protections whatsoever. The City has the staff, the knowledge, and the means to maintain these channels. When the obstacles are removed (and they will be) it really is not much of an addition to their current work in the Summit. Thanks again for your time.The Board and our Atty are confident that they have shown that Director Greenwood's Staff report that is the basis for this action is completely false. Letters and pictures prove that the channels do carry water, they did flood recently, water does come through the Bighorn holes and from the condos to the East, etc. The Board also said that they have never seen homeowners so galvanized around one issue: 61 protest yellow sheets, 10+ individual letters, and many pictures have been submitted. Please keep us protected, I know you want to do the right thing. Also, Director Greenwood was again misinformed when he stated that our Atty did not respond to the City's letters, she responded to both of them........1 will also call your number to make sure that you receive this message. Donna Mandelstam 760-565-7287 r.a �j ,Q �--1 D�� "'� =r r*� � rn�� cn�c._. r•� i ��m �OQ -� -rt ,. f�-*t � �h tn 1 Klassen, Rachelle From: Stanley, Jane Sent: Friday, November 07, 2014 11:41 AM To: Klassen, Rachelle; Tanner, Van; Harnik,Jan Subject: FW: Storm Channels From: C. Gerald King [mailto:cgking3Ca�yahoo.com] Sent: Friday, November 07, 2014 11:06 AM To: CityhallMail Cc: Aurora Sanchez Subject: Storm Channels Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council City of Palm Desert I own a residence at 48-601 Valley View Drive in the Summit development. We bought the home in 1997 and shortly after we moved in, we observed the storm channels weren't being very well maintained. But after a phone call to the city maintenance department, they quickly came, cleaned out the channels and have done a decent job of regular maintenance since. I am very disappointed to learn that the channels may not be maintained by the city in the future. Since the channels are an easement on my property for the city, I feel strongly they should continue to be maintained by the city. This is very important to me since we are only part time residents and depend on the city to see that large amounts of runoff don't inadvertently damage our property when we are not there. Respectfully, C Gerald King � � � �� o r�� < =r t*'t -.J �*1 aD� Nx..�.. m 3 aoU'r'*t -'�C�� C7� G3 A n � rn 1 Klassen, Rachelle From: Stanley,Jane Sent: Friday, November 07, 2014 11:41 AM To: Tanner, Van; Harnik,Jan; Greenwood, Mark; Klassen, Rachelle Subject: FW: Storm drains - Summit Neighborhood From: Laura [mailto:IbueermannCa�yahoo.com] Sent: Friday, November 07, 2014 11:26 AM To: CityhallMail Subject: Storm drains - Summit Neighborhood To the Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council City of Palm Desert I am writing regarding the status if the storm drain designed to direct run off for the benefit of all south Palm Desert residents. While it's clear that the issue of maintenance was a surprise to the City, the city appears to be relying on the fact that the drains are hidden from view running behind one small set of houses. This channel is part of the original water management plan. Out of sight should not mean "no longer our responsibility". Other storm drains, which are more visible in the city, are treated along with other public needs such as sidewalks. As we have been told over the years when attempting repairs & alterations to our homes, "ignorance of the regulations does not absolve the homeowner". Likewise, ignorance about the storm channels and years of neglect does not in any way absolve the City of its original obligation. That obligation was clearly the intent when the easement was originally required. The City is simply being arbitrary merely because we're now in a period of fiscal tightening. In fact, it makes many of the council decisions suspect. Is it simply expedient? Or did/does the Council actually fulfill its duties even if those requirements date back years before anyone's tenure? I would urge the Council to live up to the City's original demands a from the homeowners and its requirements by agreeing to include the channel in its maintenance plans. Laura& Brad Bueermann o .9� 48-770 North View DR Z �-� Palm Desert � _�� +C r f'ti` 760-836-3355 J rn�� 800/934-3303 x 2033 �'x-- � �N� -�ov _ � .. c-�-+, � �n � � 1