HomeMy WebLinkAboutRes 2014-94 T13008 The Summit ,��-,� �-,--�.,--�.�,�-�� ...�a,��,�-
�,:. , _ �_� �����J ��d��a_ �
� �i F� , , �� �. ��`��!� �.���� ;�`
CITY OF PALM D S����:�� 4�4, �: �° ,.r��= r` ...Y,...o...�_�.�,..�.�..�,...,�.w..
�;
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
STAFF REPORT
REQUEST: ADOPT RESOLUTION 2014-94 ACCEPTING AND
REJECTING CERTAIN OFFERS OF DEDICATION WITHIN THE
MAP OF TRACT 13008 (THE SUMMIT)
SUBMITTED BY: Mark Greenwood, P.E., Director of Public Works
DATE: November 13, 2014
CONTENTS: Resolution
Exhibits "A" and "A-1" Accepted Dedications
Exhibits "B" and "B-1" Rejected Dedication
Record Map
Vicinity Map
Recommendation
Waive further reading and adopt Resolution No. 2014 - 94 accepting
and rejecting certain offers of dedication within the map of Tract 13008
(The Summit).
Backqround
In March 2014, Public Works staff was contacted by a couple who are residents in The
Summit area regarding the drainage channel and related easements in backyards in
The Summit. Their claim and concern was that the unmaintained backyard channel
near their property caused water from the severe August 2013 storm to enter their
driveway and garage. They also want the City to maintain the channel in perpetuity
because the recorded subdivision map for The Summit contains an offer of dedication to
the City of Palm Desert of easements for storm drain purposes at the locations where
the channel exists.
Unfortunately, in the map of Tract 13008, which recorded in 1979, all offers of
dedications to the City of Palm Desert for the streets and drainage easements were not
specifically accepted or rejected by the City as required by the California Government
Code, and there is no indication that the City accepted the easements by separate
action or document at any time after the map recorded. The Director of Public Works
visited the site and met the resident couple on July 9, 2014, and observed that much of
the backyard channel has been significantly compromised by the homeowners through
the installation of various landscape improvements and other obstructions. Significant
debris was also seen in the channel such as garden clippings and trash. In the
Resolution no. 2014-94
Staff Report
Resolution Accepting and Rejecting Dedications on Tract 13008
Page 3 of 3
November 13, 2014
Director's opinion, there is very little chance of any flood damage to any home as the
channel exists today, and there was no evidence of erosion that would have existed if
water had flowed from the channel to the aforementioned couple's garage. The channel
was most likely designed and installed to protect the homes that directly abut the
channel, which was prior to the upstream development of the Canyons at Bighorn that
adjoins the southerly boundary of The Summit. The Canyons at Bighorn project
included a significant storm drain system that was designed to retain storm water on-
site for a 100-year storm, and also provides protection to The Summit. For that reason,
the Director's opinion is that The Summit channel is of very little use and unlikely to
convey significant storm flows.
Current and former Public Works staff have been consulted and only two occasions
have been identified when City staff performed emergency storm response, damage
assessment, and clean up in the 35 years that the backyard channel has been in
existence. On the other hand, City crews have routinely maintained the streets in The
Summit and the adjoining catch basins in the streets, and the downstream under
sidewalk drains (for water draining off of the streets) since the streets were originally
constructed.
Because the channel provides only limited protection to the abutting homes, and no
protection to other property, it provides no benefit to the public. The City Attorney has
weighed in on this subject and concurs with the Director of Public Works that the
backyard channel easement dedication should be rejected. Other reasons for the
rejection are the difficulty in accessing the entire length of the channel due to its location
in 22 separate backyards, the compromised nature of the facility due to property owner
actions, and the additional manpower and time to routinely maintain this channel.
Therefore, staff recommends that Council accept the dedication made in Tract 13008 of
all streets, and four outlet easements for storm drain purposes over Lots 16, 25, 30,
131, and 153 as shown on said map; but reject the dedication of the eight-foot wide
backyard easements to the City of Palm Desert for storm drain purposes. Also, as a
matter of compromising with The Summit homeowners, staff recommends accepting the
dedication of the two side yard easements for storm drain purposes shown over Lots 89
and 99 on said map. The easements are accessed easier because they adjoin public
streets. Acceptance of the easements means that City crews will maintain the
improvements within those easements on a regular schedule, in perpetuity, or until the
City and The Summit agree that City maintenance will cease.
Government Code Section 65402 requires, in part, that the Planning Commission report
to City Council that the subject rejection conforms to the adopted General Plan. At their
meeting of October 7, 2014, the Planning Commission, by minute motion, determined
that the subject rejection does conform to the General Plan.
Resolution No. 2014-94
Staff Report
Resolution Accepting and Rejecting Dedications on Tract 13008
Page 3 of 3
November 13, 2014
At the City Council meeting of October 9, 2014, said Council adopted Resolution No.
2014-82 setting a public hearing for November 13, 2014, to consider accepting and
rejecting certain offers of dedication within the map of Tract 13008.
Staff requests that the attached Resolution be adopted for the subject acceptance and
rejection of the map dedications as indicated therein.
Fiscal Analvsis
There is no fiscal impact associated with this action.
Prepared By: Depart nt e :
. a
. Page Garner, L.S. Mark Gr e ood, P. .,
Senior Engineer/City Surveyor Director of ublic Works
Paul S. Gibson, Director of Finance
Approval:
hn M. Wohlmuth, City Manager
PG/bl
RESOLUTION NO. 2014- 94
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM
DESERT, CALIFORNIA, ACCEPTING AND REJECTING CERTAIN
OFFERS OF DEDICATION WITHIN THE MAP OF TRACT NO. 13008
(THE SUMMIT) M.B. 106/24-30, RIV. CO. REC., UNDER PROVISIONS
OF DIVISION 9, PART 3, CHAPTER 3 OF THE STREETS AND
HIGHWAYS CODE OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA.
The City Council of the City of Palm Desert, California, does hereby
DETERMINE, ORDER AND RESOLVE as follows:
WHEREAS, the subject acceptance of dedication is made pursuant to California
Government Code Section 66477.2, and the rejection of dedication is made pursuant to
the requirements of the California Streets and Highways Code, Division 9, Part 3,
Chapter 3; and
WHEREAS, the City Council on the 9th day of October 2014 initiated proceedings
to accept and reject certain offers of dedication more particularly described in Exhibits
"A", "A-1" "B", and "B-1" attached hereto, and the City Council finds that said notices of
such vacation were published and posted, as required by law; and
WHEREAS, the City Council on the 13`h day of November 2014 held a public
hearing as required by law, at which hearing all persons interested in or objecting to the
proposed acceptance and rejection of said offers of dedication were heard, and said
public hearing was duly and regufarly closed; and
WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Palm Desert considered such matter
and finds from the evidence submitted that the offer of dedication described in and
shown on Exhibits "B" and "B-1", attached hereto and made a part hereof, are
unnecessary for present or prospective public purposes, is private in nature and access
thereto by City maintenance personnel is prohibitive and impractical.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY OF PALM DESERT,
CALIFORNIA, AS FOLLOWS:
Section 1: That the offer of dedications described/listed and shown in attached
Exhibits "A" and "A-1" are hereby accepted; and
Section 2: That the offer of dedication described and shown in attached
Exhibits "B" and "B-1" is hereby rejected; and
RESOLUTION NO. 2014- 94
Section 3: That the City Clerk of the City of Palm Desert, California, shall
cause a certified copy of this resolution and order to be recorded in the office of the
County Recorder of Riverside County, California.
PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the Palm Desert
City Council held on this 13th day of November 2014 by the following vote, to wit:
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
ABSTAIN:
Van G. Tanner, Mayor
ATTEST:
RACHELLE D. KLASSEN, City Clerk
City of Palm Desert, California
Resolution No. 2014-94
EXHIBIT A
Tract 13008
Accepted Dedications
All highways and streets as shown on Tract 13008, as per map filed in Book 106. Pages
24-30 of Maps in the office of the County Recorder of Riverside County, Califomia.
Spec�cally:
Highway 74 (shown as Pines to Palms Highway)
Homestead Road
Crestview Drive
Sundown lane
Opal Drive (shown as Ocotillo Drive)
Desert View Drive (shown as Skyview Lane)
Sun Valley Lane
Theodora Lane (shown as Rimview Lane)
Summit View Drive
Mesa View Drive
Greenbriar Lane
Valiey View Drive
Spyglass Lane
Olympic Drive
North View Drive
Shady View Drive
Quail Hollow Drive
And,
The 8 feet wide easemeM foc storm drain purposes as shown over Lot 16 0�said map.
The 15 feet wide easements for storm drain purposes as shown over Lots 25, 30, 131,
and 153 of said map.
The 14 feet wide easements for storm drain purposes as shown over Lots 89 and 99 of
said map.
Resolution No. 2014-94
EXHIBIT B
Tract 13008
Rejected Dedication
The 8 feet wide easement for storm drain purposes as shown over Lots 79, 80, 81, 82,
83, 84, 88, 89, 90, 91, 92, 93, 94, 95, 96, 97, 99, 100, 101, 102, 103 and 104 of Tract
13008 as per map filed in Book 106, Pages 24-30 of Maps in the office of the County
Recorder of Riverside County, Califomia.
RESOLUTION NO. 2014-82
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PALM
DESERT, CALIFORNIA, INITIATING PROCEEDINGS TO ACCEPT AND
REJECT CERTAIN OFFERS OF DEDICATION WITHIN THE MAP OF
TRACT NO. 13008 (THE SUMMIT) M.B. 106/2430, RIV. CO. REC.,
UNDER PROVISIONS OF DIVISION 9, PART 3, CHAPTER 3 OF THE
STREETS AND HIGHWAYS CODE OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA,
AND FIXING A TIME AND PLACE FOR HEARING ALL PERSONS
INTERESTED IN OR OBJECTING TO THE PROPOSED ACCEPTANCE
AND REJECTION OF THE MAP DEDICATION
The City Council of the City of Palm Desert, Califomia, does hereby
DETERMINE, ORDER AND RESOLVE as follows:
I.
That it intends to, and by this resolution does, initiate proceedings under the
provisions of Division 9, Part 3, Chapter 3 of the Streets and Highways Code, to accept
the dedications as described/listed and shown in Exhibits A and A-1, and reject the
dedication as described and shown in Exhibit B and B-1; and
II,
That the hour of 4:00 p.m. on the 13th day of November 2014 in the Council
Chamber, 73-510 Fred Waring Drive, Palm Desert, California, is hereby fixed as the
time and place of hearing all persons interested in or objecting to the proposed
acceptance and rejection of said map dedications; and
III.
That the City Clerk is hereby directed to publish a notice of said hearing in The
Desert Sun, a newspaper of general circulation, circulated in the City of Palm Desert,
California, twice, the first date of publication being two (2) weeks before the date of the
hearing, and the City officials of the City of Palm Desert are hereby instructed to post
notice of such map dedication rejections, as required by law, at least two (2) weeks
before the day set for the hearing.
PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the Palm Desert
City Council held on this 9m day of October, 2014, by the following vote, to wit:
AYES: BENSON, HARNIK, SPIEGEL, WEBER, and TANNER
NOES: NONE
ABSENT: NONE
ABSTAIN: NONE
Van G. Tanner, Mayor
ATTEST:
RACHELLE D. KLASSEN, City Clerk
City of Palm Desert, California
Sanchez, Gloria
From: Moeller, Charlene <CMOELLER@palmspri.gannett.com>
Sent: Thursday, October 16, 2014 1:50 PM
To: Sanchez, Gloria
Subjed: RE: legal Notice - Res 2014-82 PH 11/13/2014 - T13008 The Summit
HI Gloria
Ac.i rrcrivea anci will publish oi� ��atc�(s) r��yucstc�d.
Charlene Moeller � Media Sales Legal Notice Coordinator
The Desert Sun Media Group
750 N. Gene Autry Traii, Palm Springs, CA 92262
t 760.778.4578 � f 760.778.4731
legals .thedesertsun.com /dpwlegals@thedesertsun.com
The Coachella Valley's#1 Source in News&Advertising!
www.Desert5un.com � twitter ��` ,` � � ; facebook t���• : � �� ��:�
This email and any files transmitted with it are confidential and intended for the individual to whom they
are addressed. If you have received this email in error, please notify the sender and delete the message
from your system
From:�sanchez@citvofpalmdesert.or� [mailto:�sanchez@cityafpalmdesert.or�)
Sent:Thursday,October 16, 2014 12:38 PM
To: Email,TDS-Legals
Cc: blon�man@citvofpalmdesert.or�; p�arner(c�citvofpalmdesert.org
Subject: legal Notice- Res 2014-82 PH 11/13/2014-T13a08 The Summit
Hi, Charlene!
PLEASE PUBLISH THE FOLLOWING:
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
Resolution No. 201482 - Initiating Proceedings to Accept and Reject Certain Offers of Dedication
Within the Map of Tract No. 13008 (The Summit) M.B. 106/2430, Riv. Co. Rec., Under Provisions of
Division 9, Part 3, Chapter 3 of the Streets and Highways Code of the State of California, and Fixing a
Time and Place for Hearing all Persons Interested in or Objectin to the Proposed Acceptance and
Rejection of the Map Dedication.
TWICE IN THE DESERT SUN
Thursday, October 30, 2014
Thursday, November 6, 2014
This publication includes four(4) exhibits; the PDF has two. If you have any questions or require
additional information, please call me.
Thank you and enjoy the rest of your day; tomorrow FRIDAY!!
i
1/VYe strongly oppose the Clty ot Pa1m De�t'�s proposad to abandon any of�it�s drainage
eas�emerYts•in Tt�:3um�nit`d'e�v�eiopment Our et�tfre Summ�t drairrage systeri'�req�res the Cfty's
0��9�9�Y��inspection,maT�end nepalr expertise to en.sure our t�rrtinued
he�tth and safeRy and ttre protectlon of ou�homes and i�milies. The City of Palm Desert shouid not
foist its�legally mandat,�d maFRCenance and firrancial�sponsibilitles for the draii�age system orrto the
Summit assoc'ration ur its Nomeowners. �.
Name(s).....�v 6�.�.....�'�'�.�..� ......�........�........_........................... ................... .
�
Addr�ess:...�.g.� 7C).....N���'....L[.6.4�....��.:!�1.....�al.^..'!.....1L�}�.�:.......C.�..�Z..6..v...........
� - - - - - - - - - - - --� - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - -- - - - - - - - - - -- _ , .._.. _
VWe str+ongly o�ose the�I af Palm De�ect's p�oposal to abandon any of fis drainage
easements�The Swnn�it dea►eioPmer�t- Our eRtlre Summit drair�age system reqt�res the City's
0��9�'+e9�Y�����•������o�sur+a otnr continued
heattt►and sade�y and the protectlon of our homes arxi f�milies. The Ciry of Palm Desert should not
foist its legally mandatsd mainter�ance and financial�sponsibilities for the drainage system orrto the
Summit Association�or its homeowners. -
._ _
Name(s)...........�,l..RN�".r............�".(¢!�C!:'.�t:�....�C�.��7N...............................................
�� � G� �!�!�:................�t�?�.��.. ... ..�.7.....��..����U
Address:.......��..t7..................�....�.... ......
�` - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
uwe sa�ongly o�pose ihe cny ot Palm neae�t�s pr+�o�l�o abanaon any of its arainage
ea�emerrts in The Sinrunit de��efopme�rt. Our eMlre S�nmit draireage system recluires ihe City's
o�n9�Y����P��.�������e�tn en.sur�s our coritinued
heatth and sa�e�ty and the protec�on of our homes and f�milfes. The City of Paim Deseit shouid not
foist its legally mandabed matrtte�ance and financial respor�sibilities for the dralnage system oMo the
Summit Association nr iis homeowners. -.
.
s. !... �._ ..i.`.._._.._._._._. ........................................................
� )--•• -... - ........
. �. �9 �:\��. ....�;.�:�...��...........�.....�.�.-..�-�.......:.......
Address�,�►G,�� ................ ..-�-�
V �
1/�str�nsh►ol�pase ifie qt�r art Palm uese�t�s p�ropo�tu abanaon any o�f i�s clrairmge
easement,s in The Surrunit deMeloPment- Our erttire Summft c�rrac�e system requir�s the City's
0��9�Y����°�����r�t°�ure our continued
heatth and sadety and the proteetlon of our homes�d families. The City of Palm Desert st�ould not
foist its legally mandat�ed mairne�nce and finaix�al tesponsibilities for the drafr�age system or�to the
Summit Associatjon�r its Fromeowners. j .
1
/ ���2 ��s���
Ns. C;�-.o7?/1?Gf-..... ..... . ..... . - ..... ............. ..... .
ame( ) �
l S�i��y c—�J �i.,-
�a►�:.....��:.�.`�...:.�;1�............................ .........U.../...................... . . ..........................................
r
� - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - -- -- - -- - - - - - - -
uwa atro�i„oppose u�s c�a,of Pai�oe�c's vropo�al tio ai�.don ar�►cf�s arai��sge
eesemanb In'If�e�d�wia�pm��t. Oir erqirs Suronit�ainage system�+equh�es the C�Iry's
orgd�9 r�f�r�edtied Y�{�ectlon.�ianoe and�epeir eecpatise b�eAs�oir cantirx+ed
heelth ertd se�ety end the p�action of otu horries and�e�. The City of Paim Desert st�ould not
toist its IegeOy rt�ar�dabed rt�irtter�noe�d finandal the d�ai�ge systern arto the
Summit assocfatlon w its homernnrt�ecs. .
� � � �
�c��r`) _-�.�.'� �n,�c,� _....___�_._._..�-"�`�`�' �"`--�
,��:..�:�..3�.�'...._..��s�� �e� �r��v�
__....._......_......_..............._........................_......._...�...........................
-QC'�1 v►� �eS�rt C' A `i Z Z b u
_ _
_---
✓ � _.- - - - -- -
uwe strongly o�pose the c�t�r of Palm De�e�t�p�o�i to abandon any of fts drai�mge
easements in The Sw�ur�it deNelopment. Our erttire S�xnmit drair�e system requires the Aty's
on9a�9�9�Y scheduled in.specdon,malydenanoe and repeir e�cpertlse Uo ensure our continued
h�and sa�erty and the protectlon af our homes and famtlies. The City of Palm Desert should not
foist its legally mandaded mairrtenance and financ�al�esponsiblifties for tfie drainage system onto the
Summft Assoc'rat�on ar its homeowners. .
. � ` � �
r�. �1�' �' �-� f '� - - .........
--. ..��......L�.... .....
N�,�S�.__...-�.�----------.._.�............_..._.._._...__...... ,l --�� �
- �/ � �c�
S �(� S� l� �P�. . ... ���........ .................
Address:...��k.................................................y..........1............... � ...... ......
. 9�-a ��
VVye stmpr�gty qppose the l:ity of Palm De�ert's ptoposal�o abartdort�y at its drair�age
easements in The Sunxr�de�velopment. Our entire Summit dra�e system reqt�r+es the City's
on9o+n9 r+eg�a►IY�eduled fispecijon,maint�enanoe and repeir ex�tise�ensur+s ot�r oontinued
h�ith and sadety and the prnteCtlon of our homes�d f�mflies. The Gty of Palm Desert should not
foist[ts legally manda�ed mairrtefrar�ce and finarxx:ial r+espor�ibil'�ies for the drainage system orrto the
Summft t�' n�r its home�wners. •-
ASs���IiL�'e-- -- _
a9 �4
N s 1... � .
a►ne{ )••- ---- - ---..�...............................................»..
���� ��1 �. ��. �.1... .. .............................................
Address:.... ...........................•••-•-.....�... ..... .. ...... �.� . .l..
c�.�w� I��..s� / � , y o�2.�0 �
� — -- -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- -
uvve�hr a�e�ne cx�„a��m ne�c���os��o�x�on ar�,►ar�s ar��e
e�sements in The 8ummit deareioprrwnt Our entine Sixnmft�e systsm requlres the CitY's
�9��9�9�Y scheduled inspectior�.mafrtt�ertanoe and rep�b'eocperti�e�o ensure our oorrtlnued
heetth and s�eRyy and the pro�baction of our homes ar�d f�nilies. The City of Palm Desert should not
foist its legalfy mandaRed rt�alntenance and fln�x�ai re5ponslbilittes for fhe drafnage system orrto the
Summft Associ�tlon w its homeowners. "
� - �� �v�� �
Nams....... .......�`7��.............._---........_.......�!... . ..���... .... ..._..
e( ) �'..Il. ..._.
����
S-��G ���"TI� � � � �
�: .......................................................�.................�.. .�:�� .��:�.. �-�
)
.� .�.... .... .,
I�l�d� 7�� S ��v9�� -D �4���1�.�
� ���,��l�t (,�� ��� l� �� �1/���1� � �(�-����
�� - - - - - - - - -- -- - - - -- -- - -- - - - - - - -
��h►w��c�►o���r�����r�n��r,�
e�semenls tn The summ�de�eio��mant. our enn►e s�mm�drai�ge syscem reyuires tt�e c�ny�s
0��9►�9�Y��d�,mainbertevtce and rep�eb'eocpertise m ensure our oontinued
heetth and safieRY and'the prabection vf our homes�d tamilles. The City of Palm Desert should not
fo(st fts legalty mendaLed matrtte�rance and fi�ncial responsibilities for the drainage system orrto the
Summit As�ociation Dr its homeowners. -
,;- '-1 ,
N�c ------ - - .�. .... '.�_...�...........,r�'4��s�.�..�....���!l'►�o�s�
Address:.....�8�.�,��..���r�i�............................................................................................
/-�,��� .���r; ��. 9zz6a
wve�y o�ose me cxrt�r of�nes�t�s��o�ao��y o�r t�arar�
ease�nent�in The Sununit cle�relopmenk Our eMire S�unmit drainac�e system requires the C�►'s
�9a�9�Y���.�and rep�ir e�cpert�e b�ensure our c�ntinued
heetth and safety and the protectbn of our homes�d f�milfe.s. The City of Palm Desert should not
foist its legally marxlabed malrtte�nce and firnarx�a!rasponsibilities for the drainage system orrto the
Summit Association ar its Nomeovv�iers. �.
N�S.............�����.�.�Q.-.�-��....`�_�r.��.1.��._......C..�.�:..�.�;� I l
�
A��:...7.z..s.:�...�..............i... ...�.�..�1..�..�.�...............��.�.............................
�'� �,, � Se�� � � � � 226 C�
/
� — — — -- - - - - - - - -
uwe stno�gly oppose tne cXt�r of Paim oe�t's p�oposa�tio abanaon any o�f ns arairmge
easements in The S�nnn�tt de�velopment. Our errOre S�xnmit�ge system requires the City's
a��9�Y scheduled�ion,maurte�oe arxi repeir eo�ertise L�en,sure as corttinued
he�tth and sa�ety and the protec�ion of our homes and temiifes. The City of Palm Desert should not
foist its lec,�ally mar�da�bed mai�nce and flrranc�a!responsibillties for the dratnage system orrto the
Summit Associatjon nr iis homeowne�s. �.
.
.
Name(s .. . . ....................._.. ........ ..._. .�.. .. ... ..... ....... .. .. ... .-•----.......
addr�ss:...�o..�.:^.lB....�...�..........������?�l-�:... .�,�...�..'I..Y.�.r...............................................
�-� - — — — — -- -- -
��r�ao�u�e c�a��ne�rs�to�a�ao��y o�n�a�e
ea�emerrts in The S�srudit de�reiopmer�t. Our entire Summft drai�ge system r�eq�res the City�s
���9�Y scheduled�pecBon.maint�enanoe and repa�r e�ert�e tn�sure our c�ontinued
h�tth and s�fetY ar�d the Pr+at�c�on of our home.s and families. The Gity of Palm Desert sho�id not
foist lts legally mandabed mai�r�e and financial r�Or��li�es for the drainage system orrto the
Summft Association nr its homeowners. -
// � .
Name( ��G�:��cs.c.u�. ....�...� y�-•........................................•-------
A��:.7����..�� .. .. ...............................����--.��.��...���..........
V We saongly o�pose ine cny o�f Pal,n oese�c`s propo�l tio abandon any o�f it�s cirat�ge
e�emerrts in�n�e�ru�deti�etopmerrt. our eMina summit drair�age system r+equires the c�lty�s
ongoih9 r�egt�artY s�eduled�pec�on.mair�t�enartoe and r�epeir��o en.sur+e our contlnued
heatth and sa�e�tyy and the protectlon of our homes and f�milies. 'T'he City of Palm Desert should not
foist its legaliy mandatsd mak�tenance and financia!r+esponsibilities for the drafnage system orrto the
Summft Assoc'ratlon ar its homeowners. �
Name(s). ._....�/.�' �IR.�...........��'.:�_.......�..�f`?��.�.1�7.�,,.111.......,�. . �,�Z'
// / /� —/�� /�
Address:..��l�(�.1...�,icv. ... 1.l.��......�.�.�.. .�/J.�1.. . .�!G�!p!��.L..l.•=•:..�,e��r�.�
��
� - - - - - - - - - - - �- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -�- - - - - - - -
1/Ylle strongly oppose tlfe G�rty of Palm De�rt's proposal t�abandon arty ot its drainage
easemeMs fn The Summit de�r�elopment Our entire S�nmit�airrage system req�u�es the City's
0��9�9�1Y s�►eduled��pec�on.ma�tt+�e arxi r�ir eoq�ertFse�en,sure our oorttinued
h�tth and saffety and the protec.�ion of our homes�d f�nilles. The C�ty of Palm Desert should not
foist its legally manda�ted mairtte�rx;e and fir�arx�al�spor�sibilities for the drainage system onto the
Summft Association�r its homeowners. �
� �i��,.`''`'`�
Name(s)....................�_........��..................._._..._..........._.........----------.........---................
Addt�ss:........ FzoieF'.ivcE�rcEx
7265/S1INDDGYNLN ..............................................................................
PilLNI DPSERT,CA 922646SJ7
� - � .� � � � � _ � ' - � �. � � � ._. _. � - - � �.. _ � �
1/We 5�0�1�O�SB 1119 aly Of�lil�A�'L�S pIOpOS��D�IdO/f A�Iy O�f IfS[��Is'�B
60Se111efit'S II11�lA SUIIII�(�6N�O�t116Ift. �lJf�(1�(�$UIi11i1�G�'dill�B S�IS'�@Rl�UlI�6�1@�,�/'S
���9 re9��1Y scheduled inspection.mahr0enanoe and rep�ir expe�tise�o en.wre our c�rrantted
he�tth and saffe�ty and the pr+�tection of aur homes�d famtlies. The City of Palm Desert stwuld not
foist its legalty manda�ted malrtte�ance and firnanaal�sponsibiilties for the drafnage system orrto the
Summit Associatfon vr its homeowners. �
Name(s).... _... ... �......... . ......... -�_--_.----•-------------_..__�......................._.........
f��-
Address:.......1..�?.��.!...... ... ... ..... ..��...����TY..... .......... . .�:S?5�
.�►
. 9�(00
.� -
VV1le strongly oppose fhe C�t�l o�f Palm Des�t`s propossd�o abandon an�l o�f its drairm9e
e�semencs in Tt�e summ�deti�eiopme�. our entire summit drair�age systerr►requires tne caty�s
0��9�Y���Pectia►►.maf�t�nar�oe and re�ir eo�e�t�t�°�sure our oorttinued
he�tth and sa�erty arid the protectfon of our homes and families. The City of Palm Desert should not
foist its legally n��rxiaR�d mai�te�nce and financial�esponsibilities for the drai�age system orrto the
Summft Associatfor,r�[�.s homeowners. �
� � , � zT/L��'�, �
Name(s). ...................._...._.._..._......................_._ ._..---.....-------..-.-----............ ................
O� / /��jF!i�;,;j„Y..�:�.'.�;. .........Y....-:.�.......` ._./................................
Address:.L-..�...��............f�.L. ..y.. ......
V � -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - -
UWe strongly oppose ttte Cit�/of Palm Des�t`s proposal to abandon any of i�s drainage
e�semerYts in The Sunur�deMelopment. Our entire Summit drairrage system reqtBres the C�ity's
o�n9�9�Y���Pe�.������"n ensure our continued
heeith and sa�ety and the protiection of our hom�and iemilies. The City of Palm Desert stwuld not
fast its fy mandaded mafrrte�nce and finarx�al�sponsibil'Ri�s for the drafriage system orrto the
Summit ' n vr rts homeowners. .
T
/
Ns._... _� .. . ._-------��.............................................
ame( ) -�- ..�
Dorothea Bisbas
Addr�ess:.. �: �72650 Sundo CA 9
, , Dese , 2260 ..................................................................................................
--� ', Palm
G.`_ --
1/vve str�orgly oppo�e ihe qty af Pslm De�t's proposal�o abandon any of its dratnage
ea9emenCs in The Surrimit deMelopment. Our ertiGjre S�nmit�ge system re4ulre:s the City's
��9 re9�Y���.m����r�Lo ensure our oontinued
heatth and safety and the protectlon of our homes and tamilles. The City of Palm Desert should not
foist its legally mar�ated maintertance and financia!�sponsibilities for the drair�age system orrto the
Summit A.Ssociatjon z��its home�wners. -.
� . .
N�cs��o�''e!�..w......�.. . ..r.a _.._ .�r.�.........................��....----.-
.
Addr�ess: .. .�!!.���....J`.`a':...... _..d.�_���.1.!�,.....-•--•--•
!/YYe str�ongly o�ose ttfe Oriy of Palm Des�t's propoaal�o aVandon any of Ms drainage
e�sements in The S�srunit deMefopmenk Our erttire Summit�'airrage system req�res the C�ty's
0��9�Y����.mairtt�er�anoe and r+epafr��ensur+a ots'cortdnued
heatth and sa�erty and the prot�cdon aF ax homes and f�nilfes. The Ciry of Palm Desert should not
foist its legally manda�ed mainte�nce and firrarx�al�sporuibil"�6ies for the drairnage system onto the
S�mmit Associatior�ar ns homeowneis. "
rv�s). ................. ....F...:',L:�'�E'.�....��1..�-�--...............�.._..................................
Add�:...::��.::..�-�t..l.............��.�....�:� ..... . ��r-e... ..�.�.��.:��.�...
.... ........... ......... . .. --- �, ���
� - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - _ _ -.- - - - - - - -
��►���„��,�,���,�,�y���
e�neMs in�n�e S�mur�it deti�eiopm�nt. au ennre s�nmit d►alnage syst,em reqtdr�s tne c�ity�s
0��9�Y�duled�Spectfon,mairrte�noe and r�ir e�e�t�e L��sur+e our cartlnued
heatth and s�ety and the protec�don ofi our homes and fami(ies. The City of Palm Desert should not
foist its le�gally mandated mafnteriance and financial�esponsibilities for the drainage system orrto the
Summit Association�r its homeowners, .
N s.�l�:?:�:!�..� KaO�►Ai4 �
�( )•--1• ....---...._.............._._..�............ ... ......:�,....��
Ada�:.�a6p"!......... .�:�......���.........��..���......�..�'��o
�
......................
� _ � _ _ _ _ -- - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
��r a�P�e u�e c�ty of Pa�n nes�t�pro�osal�o a�anao�amr o�n$dra�age
easemerns in The Swrunit deMelopn�ent Ota e�rttn4 S�mR d�ge system requres the G1tty's
0��9 re9�r1Y�eduled inspec0on,mam�mnoe�d repalr expertlse to ensure our c�rrtinued
heatth and safety and the proteCttort of our hornes and famitfes. The City of Palm Desert should not
foist its legally mandabed matrrtenance and firranc�al res�ibilitles for the drainage system onto the
Summft A.ssociatjon or Its eowners.�� .
Cy�
Name(s). ...�.a.L���--=!------•�°r1r� �J 1 I�R S
• �.......--------------------�---.....................------
Aadre�:......��.-��a...._..��R Tk�4�...v1�.W......�:......................................
...............................
1/W@ S�I10�y OpE)OS@ 1f1@�.ty Of�f11�1'�8 pi'OpOSB��O�O�I a11y O��S(�'�Itc'Ig@
e�seme�,cs in�n�e sumr�veMelopmenc. our e�tine s�nmit dra�rage system requres the t�ty�s
on9an9 r�g�ariY s�eduled i�ti�n.maintenartoe and r+�ah'e�tise m�sur+a aa oor�tinued
he�tth and sadety and the probectlon of our homes�d tamilies. The City of Paim Desert should not
foist its legally mandaLed mairYter�ance and firnarx�al r+aspor�sibilit�s for the drainage system orrto the
Summit Assaciatjon nr its homeowrters. .
,/� S � /�
►�cs)---.J.�r r�'�.�. }....:....��1.11.�C.�bSS C�.....................................................
JA ` , /,
Address:..�.(��?�.....�v....v..�..e.�.���Y..�...... ...�,�..�H•.�L�J.'.����..:.1��..
r
�—�t - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -�- - - - - - - -
uvye straongly oppose u�e c�r ot Palm Des�t�propo�l to abanaon any af Its arainage
e�semerrts�The Surr�mit detielopmenk Our e�rfire S'ummit drai�ge system requires the G1ity's
ongoin9 r�g�ar1Y s�led fisp�ection,m�noe arxf re�ir e�q�ertl�e m en.st�r�e ota oontinued
heefth and saacFe�y and the protectlon of our homes and families. The City of Palm Desert should not
foist its legaliy rrrdndaded mainte�ance and firranc(al respor�sibilities for the drainage system o�o the
Summit Association nr its homeowners. �
.
Name(s)----.,l.�...�'°�'��.�......�'��/�._.....�........�..�./�.-.......................
�f�� /���C�'/� �/f/�^ �j���j �C.c-�.�c��� L� 2��!�
Addr�ss:...�..........................................................................................................................,1...................�
� - -- - - -- - - - -. _ — ._ � - - - - _. � _ � _ - -�- - - - - - - -
I/We str�ongiY op�o�e ttfe City ofi Pal�n De�t's propo�al to aVando�arn/of ICs drairtage
ea�ements in The Sisnmit deMelopmenk Our er�ire Summit d�r�age system r�e4uires the G1ty's
0��9�Y�uled�sPectlon.mak�tenanoe and r+sp�ir��ensure ots-�ontinued
h�lth and safiety and the protectlon of our homes and tamilles. The City of Paim Desert should not
foist its legalfy manda�ad mainte�ance and financ�ai�biiibies for the drainage sSrstem orrto the
Summit r4ssoc'ration nr its homeowners. �
tiG� G%� �
Name(s. _......_............................. ............_.....................----..............................._..
Ad v��" � ��/ L�"�' �� �`p�,tt �/�. �
d�:...........................................................,�......1.............-.----....._....... ......... .....................
-�
� �" ��� _ �
��/� �,�
�e�9h�oPP�e�e CfiY o�Palm Dese�t`s pt+u�o�al to abandon arYy o�f f�s drainage
eesemerrts in Tt�e sisruHt aeMetopmen�. a,r enere summit�ge system requires the c�ty�s
0��9�9�Y scheduted'mspection,mafi�areoe and repelr e�ertise�enstue ota oorninued
heefth and sa�ety and the pr+ntection aF ax homes�d families. The City of Palm Desert should not
foist its legally mandabed mairtter�ance and finarx�al resporrslbilitles for the drainage system orrto the
Summft iatjon nr its meowners. l ,/, �
74 ��k��
��.. . � ��� � �
r,,amecS,.-.��(���...�..�..�:.��:!�.._..._.�..-.-......�.:�...._.�'!......�.:�.�:.�!�:..:..�
Address:.�l�..�:.�.b......��.y..�►.e:�.4....:�lZ:4v".r-.��...����..�.�:�:�:r.� .r�......9�6�
r--
�,.�` - - - - - - - - -- - - - -- _ _ - _ - - - - - - - - - - - -�- - - - - - - -
1/YYe sbr�ongly oppose the CKy of Pa�n De�t`s pnoposal�o abandon any o�iCs drair�age
e�semerrts in The�deN�ebPmer�t. Our eMire Summit drair�e system re4t�res the Cit�r's
o�n9�Y�+��.�����d r�e�er�t�°e�ure our oorr�nued
he�lth and saFety and the protectlon of au homes�d families. The(�ity of P�m Desert should not
foist its legally�mairrtertance and finarxtial responsibilities for the drair�age system orrto the
Summit Assaciation�r its homeowners. �
�_�'j �- ��i�G.��1.•�-- -iC?'!2?�� /�'%? L�
Name(s)._...... ... ....... . .... .
,�,��:....... ......�:.�.�.�....... � .�. .�.�............ .......................................
� �
� _
��►���►������,�,��,,,���
eesements in The s'�nrunit deMelopment. our e�ire s�unmit drakm�e system requres tt�e f�ty's
a'��9�9�Y�edu�ed i�eciion.mairrt�nanoe and repa��to ensure our oontinued
he�tth and saa�e�ty and the p�+ntec6ion of our homes�d famtUes. The City af Palm Desert shvuld not
foist tts legally mandated mairrte�nce and flnan�al�esponsibilitles for the drainage system orrto the
Summit association nr its home�wners. -
� ��� � �
N�cS,���... . ._. ...�.... ...._...__.�..._.._-- -. -.--�_............... ���--�
.JoI'I�? /�, Cvc:�� L ind� �, , Gca K
Address:...Y�3.:z:s"�.....0 r:.�:�I....✓..���...,:l..r'!Ll.�'......�7�1.�...:SN!?�T. .n!��.........................
I�c��n� 1�e Se r�t; G fl 9 2 Z 6 C�
I/VYe str�ongly oppose ttfe City of Palm Desert's pt+opos��abar�don�r�y of its c�ainage
easement�s in The�deMelopmenk Our errtire Siunmft drairrage system requir�s the C�ty's
ongan9�g�ariY s�eduled fispeCtion,mair�enanoe and repeir e�ertlse b�ensur+a otx continued
he�tth and saffety and the protectlon of our homes and families. The City of Palm Desert should not
fast its legaliy manda�ed mainterrance and finar�cial respor�sibilitles for the drafnage system orrto the
Summft Assoc'ration nr its homeowners. -
Name(s)........................S.�?�c�x:a..W�a�.r�---.._....�.�.----------........................................................
Address:...4.�.:2,�A...Cr�s tu.i.ew-..F����e;...�s�m�-•DEs�er�'�"�A"�3'ZZfi'Q...................................•
0-__ -- - - - -- -- - -- - - -�- - - -- - - -- -
uwe sa�o�ghr oppo�e tne c�t�r a�Pahn ues�t's pr�oposal to abanaon any o�f i�s arai�mge
eesements in The S�untnit deMelopment Our eMire Summit c�e system reyuires the Cify's
0��9�Y�'����,m��oe arxi repair e�t)se to ensure our c�ntinued
he�tth and sade�y and the p�fiectlon af ax homes . families. The City of Palm Desert should not
foist Its le�gatfy marxiated maicrtenance and fi bilities for the draircage system onto the
Summit Association vr tts homeowners. -
;i � ,
,i/
� , ' , -
Name(s)............. � � ..........................._.........._........._..............._...._----........................._..
r...........
.
� -�
A��:....`�.,�...���.�..........��;��.��:..... .....�.�.�........�..�.........1�..::............�..:.........
. �L?-6(�
�` - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -�- - -- - - - - -
��shr oppose tne c�qr a�f Pahn De�t's pro�to abandon any o�f i�s arainage
eas�nents 6�The Swnmit deMek�pmer�t. Oiu e�riire S�nmit�ge system r�e4uires the Caity's
�9��9�9�►1Y schedu�ed ir�specijon,mairri+enanoe and�pair e�tise t+�ensvre our c�ontinued
h�and safety and the protec6lon of our homes�d families. The City of Paim Desert should not
foist its legal�y mandated maintenance and flnanc'raf r�espor}sibilities for the drair�age system onto the
Summit Associatjon tir its homeowners. �
� �
Narne(s)---,;L�l��.....�....�... .�..�._�!�:�:................._........----•---•----•----------.................----....---..._..
,e,��:...'z6��.......s�. . ��-.s..s......�:�.�...................�................................
��
�e�9h/oPP�e fhe(�t�/of Palm Desert`s proposal�o abandon any af tts drainage
e�sements in The S�srur�de�r�elopmenk Our entire Summft drainage system reqt�res the C�ty's
�+'��9�9�Y�����,�oe and repeb��t�ensure our continued
h�tth and sa�eFty and the prot+ect�on of our homes and famflies. The City of Palm Desert should not
fast Its legally manda�ed mairrtenance and financ�al�esponsibilities for the drainage system orrto the
Summft/�Ssociation nr its homeowners. -
� J�.'wo�rv�� �
Name(s)•-1(.���I�...��.._..................................................•--.........-----
��g�Q ��� � �
Address:.... .�-�,h.,.sj�.g,,0_.�,,,,�...........�..�:�:��...........................................................................
���
Vyye s�r�pngly appose Ufe Cit�/of Palm Des�t`s proposal to aba�xfon any o�f!ts draine9e
eeseme�s in Ths S�ur�it deMe�opment Ow e�rtire S�xnmft�e system�e4�res the City's
0��9 re9�Y���°��m�Oe and repeb'eocpe�t�e m ensure ota oorrtlnued
heetth and sadety and the pr+ntectbn of our hornes and families. The City of Palm Desert should not
foist[ts legatly mandabad maktter�ance and fi�a1�spor�sibilities for the drair�age system arrto the
Summtt Association�its homeowners. �
p �1,, ., J `�
til.�.....S.f....JL).���.�....__.........................�.................................
Name(S)•---�,�_y���
t `
` � ` � � ���
�..�.........V..�..�...�.��..r..�......... . .�. ..
.............. .�...�..�.. ......... �� r�..... ...... ..
Address �• ....
1
--,� - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -�- - - - - - - -
uv��sh►a��cm,��o�rs�m�ao��„��a�
ea�ements in The�nm�daMelopment. our�re Summit dr�age system requires the C�ity's
0��9�9�Y sct�eduled inspection,mair�oe and r+ep�lr eoq�tise m e�,sure our oontlnued
h�tth and sa�erty and the protectlon of our homes and familie� The City of Palm Desert should not
foist its legally marxlated mairttenance and financial�+esponsibilides for the drainage system orrto the
Summft Association nr its homeowners. "
�--
.�,�-�►� f f �-,,�o I�►�-r-�+�1,� Jo��s d�
Piame(s)............................. ._..............._...�.- --......_...............--------.......----------...............
�1r� �f/ / -�J � /� � O
Address:....7 d �D� <�O 2i�1 `/� /� �� �
...............................................................................:.. ........." ....�..................................._.
-}- •�-
i/YYe s�tror�gly oppose the Ctty o�f Palm Des�t's proposal t�abandon 2�ty of i�s drairsage
e�semenf�in The S�nrur�it deuielopment. Our eMire Summft drairrage system requires tfie City's
a'�goin9 re�a�1Y�heduled'mspecTia�,maint�enarioe and repeir e�pertlse�ensure otx oorttinued
he�tth and sa�ety and the pr+otecrtion af our homes�cl families. The City of Palm Desert sttould not
foist its legally manda�ed makYtenance and financial r�sponsibilities for the drairtage system orrto the
Summft Associatjon w its homeowners. -
N�cS,........���5.�....�..:._..���..�.�. ....�......�...........�-.--�----...:_..
�
Address:...�a..-.�5�.........�.... ..... .��:�-......�-�:�-...........P�?-►�:.���-�- , �
`� �
(�7� 56�8 - �s3� �zzc�o
�
�
uw��►o�n�c�,�r�,���o�.,ao�,�,,,�r n�a��
e�emer�ts fn The S�deMelopment. Our e�tre Summit dr�e system re4uir�es the Aty's
a��9�Y�edWed'mspectlon,mair�oe and r+�aL'eapertise t�er�.sur+a ota oontint�ed
he�tth and sa�ety and the protectbn af our horr�es and f�iifes. The City of P�m Desert should not
foist its le�gatly manda�ed mainte�nce and financ�al r+esponsibilit.ies for the drainage system anto the
Summfit Association nr its homeowners. �.
1 '
Name(s.�.... . l..�..�.�.. ::..,Z:1.vv!��n c.��1:..1................._......_.---...........................
) •.�. �.-...�
Addr�ess:.........�.k-.�:!.��.'............. . � ���...---�d1).............`;.!J...C.?�.�l2 z���.........
:�"�
�` - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
uwe stnongly op�ose 1ne c�ih►o�f Pabn De�t`s pro�osal to aVanaon any o�f iCs arainage
e�seme�s fn The�nn�de�r�ebpmenR. Our e�rtire S�anmit�irrage system requires the Cit�r's
0��9�9��Y sc�teduled inspection,mffinR�oe and rep�alr eocpertise�ensure ota continued
he�tth and sa�eRy and the protectbn of our homes and families. The City of Palm Desert should not
fast its legally martdaLed mairttenance arid finarx�al�sponsibillties for the drainage system orrto the
Summit Assoc'ration nr its homeowners. �
Name(s)...� ........... ... .__�. ...._.._...................................................
s�iel.��
0
Address:....�.R..I�Q......�.�./.}<.�.Q.7.Jl/.�....��........................................................................
uwe sa�o�gty opuose me cny ot Palm nes�t`s proposal�a abarxlon any a�f ns arairmge
eagements in The Swrmnit deu�elopment Our er�tire Summft ckair�age system r+e4uir�s the C�ty's
0��9�9�Y scheduled'mspec6on,maint+enarx�e and repair e�tise�en.sure ax continued
heatth and sacfety and the pr+nbac�on of our home�s and families. The City of Palm Desert should not
foist its legalty mandabad mairtte�ance and fi�ancial�+espor�sibilities for the drainage system orrto the
Summft Association nr its homeowners. �
` ' ' ._...��.�..._.�.�: �
N�cs�:===:�. -------- ---- - ----------------....�---.__.---...-----------------..._..
�� �.�.�." �..��.��.......�.�....�.�. %�.��.�..... `I�z � d
��:.... ..... ......... . .. ....... .. ._................................
� - - - - - - - - - - - - --- -- -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -�- - - - - - --- -
uwe saor�ghr or�pose u�e c�cy ot Palm neserc�s pro�al to abarWon a�y of ns ara�nage
easemen�s f�'ihe Swnn�aeN�elopmenr. au ennre summit�e system r+eq�res tne c�ty�s
��goin9►e9�arhi�ed�ed b�ec�on,m�r�rwe and repair eocpertlse t+�ensure our c�ntlnued
he�tth and saa�ety and the protectlon af our hom�and famiiles. ll�e City of Palm Desert should not
foist fts legaliy marxiated malnte�nce and financial resportsibil'dies for the drafnage systern onto the
Summft A,ssociation�r its homeowners. OV�
/y{O�+t�' 1�fm� �I�C���,��
J�0/�G�`GZtx.t�(.� ��G -6U,�
Name($)........�...��:'S�:u�...�........."'....._».�....._._...._.......«........""......C'�'i..�...�.�.�:l�:'—
A��s:........�zG�'7, .Iv�u �ac.,c.�:�.:...�.1.�.......................
.... ...... .... ........... � ................................................
��t�, �rsa.�r �: ��
� - - - - - - - - - - - . , - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -�- - - - - -.- -
���������������
e�semerrts�The S�sr�de�relapment. Our errtire S�nmit�e system re4t�res the City's
a'�goin9 reg�arlY�led�pec�tion.ma�anoe and rep�r eo�'tise�o ensure our ooritlnued
h�tth and safaty and the pro�ection of our hornes and tamiliee. The City of Palm Desert should not
foist its legally mandated mairtt�and financ�af respor�sibilitles for tfie drainage system orrto the
Summft As.soc'ration�r its homeowners. �.
Name(s).... ....... ..........................�------..._..__... .....�.---.......... ........---• --
--�-
.
Address:......�...�...U..�d .._.:.`:.........�l..l e`^�...... .. ...�,.�i.�.............. ...• .......---..... .......................
/
UWe str�ngly oppose the City of Palm Desert's proposal�o abantlon any of its dratnage
easemerrts in The Summit deveiopmertk Our entire Summit draimage syskem requires the C1ty's
ongoing regutariy scheduled inspection,mair�t+enance and r�epair expertlse to ensure our c�rriinued
health and safety and#he protection of our homes and families. The Cifiy of Palm Desert should not
foist ifis fegally mandated maintenance and financiaf responsibilities for the drainage system orrto the
Summit Association vr its homeowners. �
Nam ............. ..........._....._...._._..._..._._.�.!`_"�_Uis ,�U.�iV�...../.�?�4!!!tOvh,6�
Address:...... .G..,,�....���Dv..._..��.L....L.'.-:,.v�...�.,;..:.�.:...`.G.,.:'.���....`,'':,.,!, ,�`,,,���G/
.� -� _
�e�9h/q�pose the Clt�►afi Palm Des�t`s pr�al�o abandon aryy of l�s drai�ge
essemerns in The S�nnm�deMebpment Our erttire S�nmit�a�age system requir�es the C1ity's
o�n9�9�►�Y s�heduled b�spectior�.mahri�e and r�P�'ex�ert�e tn er�sure our oot�'bnt�ed
heatth and sade�ty and the prntiectlon af our homes�d tamilies. The Caity of Palm Desert should not
foist its leg�ly mandabed malrrte�arx:e and fina�ial n�por�sibiiities for the drainage system onto the
Summit Association rn its homeowners. -
�� O�.�s�,�,�
N�cs�.--.---._.........�...........�......_.�...........�..�.........................._.---.._................................
a��:...��./....f.�....,...��'�,��„��.....•��.:.'.�...........................................................
�� - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - -
V We str�on9h►opnose u�e c�ih►af Pahn D�s propasai t��anaor�any�it�s dra�r�age
eeseme�rts in The�de�relopn�ent. Our e�re Stunmit dratr�ge system r+eqtires the C�ty's
a�n9 r�la►1Y�heduled InspeCtion,R�r�oe���pert�se L��sur�s ot�r c�orttinued
heanh and sa�edy and the protectlon of our homes and familfes. The City of Palm Desert shouid not
foist its Iegal�Y manda�ted mairtt�and fin�rssportsibilit�es for the drafnage system orrto the
Summit Elssociatjon w its homeowners. -
n � .
Name(s).............�.!�._..�.....t'�.1?�.l��...��.t�..:�."��..................._.......................................
AddreS.s:......y:�.�.�.S.I.....�.��L4:�..��/�[:✓..1��.,�..P�:�'�:t..1��J 5�.�..2..?..c.�.�...�1.�:�...................
�sa�y o�ose�ne cny a��ne�t�s�to�aori�y of�a��
e�eme�s�The swnnit detietopme�. our errtire surnmit drairrage system require5 the t�ty�s
a►9��9�Y�eduled ins�ection.mah�noe and r�epelr ea�ertise tio ensure our continued
heetth and sa�ety and the protectlor►o�f our homes�d famtlies. The Cily of Palm Desert should not
foist its legally mandabed mai�rteriance and finandal�spon.sibilities for the drainage system orrto the
Summit Association nr its homeowners. �.
Name(s)...�o r�K H.....�....,5/LL P''1 q i�D+�LST}9 M-•................
Addr�ess:...7.2 Lv 9/ S P�G��q S S L fJ�.....Pq t'M "D a�-=7�T1...,.�..�......9��O O
................ .................................... .......................... ....
�.�- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- _ _ . _
" UVYe str�on�y op�e�e�h►of Paim nesert`s pr�oposai�o ab�ndon am►o�f its drainage
e�semerris in Tite S'u�r�it deti�ebpment Our erriire S�enmit�ge system reqtires the City's
a�n9�'+a9�Y���°r'�maintenanoe and�ir expettise�ensure our c�ontinued
heetth and saffe�y and the pro�ectlon of ax homes and famtiies. The City af Palm Desert should not
foist tis legaliy mandaRed maicrt�and finarx�a!�or�ibilitles for the drainage system orrto the
Summit Assoc'ration vr its homeowners• �
- �l.�� �AN
N�cs�............�.���!...�.�...............�!....._....�.............�..z���.�..�.
A��:.............�:.�.s�_1.....---....��-.y...t�:l:�t.�.....�,t�.�..�.��.,.....��..........�='...�.-�..�
�` - - - - - - - - --- - -- - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - -
,��,►�+��,������,��„����
���s�c��. o���s�r������t�a�,�s
0��9�Y scheduled inspeciion,ma&�benarwe and r+e�-�ertise to ensure our oorrtinued
heetth and sa�eFtyy and the protec�on af our homes�d tamilfes. The City of Palm Desert should not
folst its legaly mandaLed mairrtenance and fl�responsibilities for the drainage system onto the
Summit Assoc'ration�r its homeowr�s. "
N s .:P!1:.'::�:`.:t ��?�l!n'� ... _....�._......................_...._...................._......----•--_..
a�( ) � ----•-
Aadress:.��...�::..�./.....a�.t:l�.:�.e��� .1�..l��.��'h.:. ....'..`.e` `�-►,.../.��P�'`�. °��CC�
�� �
!/VYe strongly oppose ttw Cit�/ofi Pafrr�Des�ert`s Proposal to abandoR anI►of its drainage
e�seme�s in Ths Stsrun�de'Me�apmenk Otu entjre Summit drairn�e system requires the City's
o�n9�Y���p�,�oe and repeir expertlse ta ensure our ooMinued
heatth and safiety and the protectlan of our homes and familie�. The City of Palm Desert shoutd not
foist its legally mandated mainte�arice and fir�nda!�+asponsibilities for tha drainage system orrto the
Summit Associativn�r its Ftomeowners. .
�� ��
_.�. �
4 �p ] - ,,� t
Name(s)....L��:�._....... �..JIJ.�..,.....�".�.. '�.�..�.Q.!.._............ . ...:l.:G�.X!!l
r
Address:..�:.�' �a-� �'l,b.r th � evJ �r� ....pcl..�i.r..�,....�:Q��......�.a a � n
v � — -- -
1/VYe str'an$IY aPP�'e��ll�P��Desert's ptopOsal�o abandOn anY af its drain�9e
e�seme�s M The 8�nrur�deMebl�'it Our e�re SummR�ainage sygtem ne4uire�the City's
�►9��9 re9�Y����rr�oe and re�ir eocpert�e��ur�our c�orttinued
haetth and sRfety and the pt+a�baction of cxsr hors�es and fsmilfes. The City of Palrn Desart should ctot
foist t�s legaliy mandabed m�nt�and fl�cial�+espor�sibilities for the dra(rrage sys'tem orrto the
Summit Association nr its homeowr�s. �
. � .
Name(s)................. (�.1,�.�`:...._..�:'�:'�'!:y'��............�.......------•----......................._..._
A�,�:.....''�.`.b\1�....�:x..�.��.�.�.��:�?....`:�:.:....�'..`�.�:�'�.����:���..�.`��:....`.�.�.:���.��.
� - - - - - - - - - -- - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - -�- - - -- - - - -
uv�re�,a�o�e u�e cx�,►or�n nes����o�,aon a�,►o�n�a��
es.sea�ents in The�de��eiopment. our eMfia swnmft dra�ge sys�t,ecn�eq�r�es the ctit}r's
ongdn9�tY�edUled�spection.m�anoe artd repair expertise to ensure our oorrtinued
heaith and sadety and the pmtec�don of our homes and i�milies. The City of Palm Desert should not
foist its legally mar�daR�ed mafnt�and fl��esponsibilities for tt►e drainage system orrto the
Summit Association�r its hom�o . �.
�'-����L
�������
Name(�-��i� �`,2'Q....��U�51�,._...��r�ZA�L... .............���.►J�'..+�!,NOS
�
'7� SS/ �r'19��iv�.� �r°�. �,�v: �'.¢1_rn 7��-?�" ��4 9Z.�- ���
Address:................................................................................. ..........................---..
J..............•---. J.....................
✓ —
�A S�O�O�OS9 ti1A�y Of P8�1�1�S�OS��O 8b8flf�Ofl 8fly Of�Sr��fl8�@
easemerrts in"it�e Stsrunit de�r�elopmenc. our errbna summit arairrage syste�n req�r�es tne c�ity�s
o�n9�9�Y�����,mainbenarx�e and repeir eocpertise m ensure our continued
heetth and safiety and the pr+ntectlon of our hom�and f�milies. The City af Palm Desert should not
foist its legally manda�ed mainte�nce and financial�espor�sibilities for tfie drainage system orrto the
Summft Assoc"ration�r Rs homeowners. .
i
,
' ^" I
N s .. ..�..�..'���.�w1����s.......__---- --.... �=��......... �. �....
� �. .
C.f � � �/�� D � � �'� , ,�
Addr�ss:.......c.���..........� .........?. ........................................................���'..v:••••••..........
..� . .
�� - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - -
uwe sa�ongty oppose tne Clc�►of Pahn c)e�ert's propo�al tio abanaon any ot Ms arainage
ea�ements in The Summit deMelopmenR. Our e�lre S�xnmft�sinage system r+equires the City's
a��9�9�Y���.��d re�elr eoc�tlse t�ensure our continued
health and sa�eRy and the protection af our homes and igmt8es. The City of Palm Desert should not
foist its legally mandaRed mairrtenarx�and fl�ar�cial r+e�ponsibilities for the drainage system orrto the
Summft Association�r its homeowners. �.
Name(s,...../:.7�v�`'�'�f �+-r�� �v✓� �p��c�....................._..
� �;�� ...�... ��G✓ � �C. .......
Address:.� ............ .. l/ ................... ........................................................
..�.........�.J..........
� c� ,,� /
� � � f�"�� � / �i`b0
, C
J .t --- - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - -
1/YYe sbr�o�y oppose U�e City o�Palrn Des�t`s propo�sd�o abandon any of i�s drainage
ea.4ements in The s'urrunit deMeiopmeac. our e�ere s�xnmit drairr�ge syscem requres tfie c�ity�s
ongoin9 r+sg�da�s�eduled h�SPectfon.m�er�noe and r�r ex�ertlse to�sure our continued
heetth and safie�ty and the protectbn of our homes and temilies. The City of Palm Desert should not
foist fts legaily mandaLad majnte�nce and finand�r�bilities for the drainage system onto the
Summit Assaciatfon vr tts homeowners. -
� � Y
Name(S). .. ............._.._.......�. ...._�.�����_.._-/..__1�.��__.'__._._._...-----
�J `�// C � .
Addr�ess:....L..�.. ......... .���:�::4.l.`:... . ....... ....................................................................
,�a��- � , �� �� ��a
� - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
uwe sao�ghr oppose u�e city of Palm oese�t�proposal to�anao�any o�f i�s drainage
ease�nents in The�nu�deMelopment. Our ernire Summit drai�e system re4uires the Gity's
���9�Y scheduled inspection,n�ai�oe arxi repeir eocpertise�ensure our can4nued
heaith and sa�ety and the protection of our homes and families. The City of Paim Desert should not
foist its legally mandated maintenance and financial�bilities for the drair�age system ortto the
Summit Assoc'ration ar its Fiomeowners.
N h at �1 en — h�l►n h �t ��es�r�, Cl��---.��:...��
Namecs). ......................�!:�' . ......._..............��.._...�......._..�............�.... Q
cJ
Aad�:.�:�.�.�.�.�..J'h ad,�,...V:�..�!'.�....P��...���...C...�..��z.�i 1�............................
J � _ ".
�e�shr a��e c�,►a��a�m�t��ro�o��o�x�on a�,►o�ns a��
easemeMs in The S�nr�mit deMelopme�rt. Our eMire Summit drair�age system r+e4ures the C�ity's
0��9 re9�Y�uled inspect�on.maint�enanoe and repeir eoc�tise��su�our oontinued
he�tth and safiety and the pcobecHon of ou�homes and tamllles. The City of Palm Desert should not
foist its IegaHy mandabed mairrte�nce and fl�l responsibillties for the drairrage system o�o the
Summit Association�r fts homeowr�ers. �.
• '
N�cS,....�-�r..'��...���..::.�:h��..�.....�-�.��..z`.�..........................................
A�►,a�:.��5�.►...sh��:�V�e�.......�.�._��...................................................................................
� _. _
��,�,�,►�,��„�������►����
easements in The S�rurut deMelopme��t. Our eMfire Stunmi��e system requires the C�ity's
0��9�''�9�Y����,�����t+�en.sure our catdnued
heatth and sadety and the protectior►of ax hom�s and i�milfes. The City of Palm Desert should not
foist its legally mandabed mairrteriance and flrranc.iat res�bil'fies for the drainage system or�to the
Summit Associatlon nr its homeowners. .
C�
Namecs)-.------_._ .��..1!/_...._. ...... ............. ... .. .. .... ....---------.........�'...........:....
. �
�� ��� � �
� �`.�Q... ........Y....�....�.�.:GL/.... .. ..................... . ...����
Address:...�.....���........ .. .... ......... .
V -
uwe sa+o�ty o�OSa me V�Ly o��m��OS�to�R�..��y o��W a��B
e�me�in Tne s'ummic de�va�opmenr. ot.�ennre summit drair�age system requires the ctity's
0��9�Y��.mairttienanoe arx!re�air ettpertb�e ta ensur�ots'c�ortOnued
heetth and sadety and the pnatec�ion of our homes�d tamilies. The City of Palm Desert should not
foist ns legally mandated mairrtenance and finarx�l respor�sibilities for ifte drainage system oMo the
Summft Association ar its homeowners. �
_ /
Name(s).................... ............._......_..........l��.J�R�2�.................................----........
Address:..��..�K�.�.�......`� t.t.Y�.��W h....�.�.'�..'.h.�.----•-���.." ese����......��!.:v`��
.�.
..� —
�1e�on�►a�e tne Clh►of Patm De�t�propo�d to abando�any of tts arainage
e�semenb in The S�snmit de��eiopment Our eMire Summit�e system reyuire5 the C1ity's
a�n9�Y�1gd insPec�a►.msintienance and rspeir eo�ertise tn ensure our oontinued
he�lth and sa�ety arxi the protectk�n of our homes and families. The Ctty of Palm Desert should not
foist ILs IegaUy manclated maintenance and financial respor�sibilRies for the drainage system onto the
Summft/�Sociation ar its homeowners. �
Name{s)........_`�!.���'.%�:"f.�..!..:!..��.....--•---......._�...............................................
Address:.7..a-.��o....x�;��'��-....� .l,a�,-„�f�;�'��.�...��ab "
.,�- ........................
o-� - - - - - - - - - -. -- -- _ -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
��h►�e tne ae�r a��n ne�er���,o�to�,ao„�,►a�n�a�a��
easemer�s in Ths S�srpn�deMeiopmerrt, Our eMire Summit dr�e system r'e4ulres the C�r's
n9ofn9►�9+�arly sc�ieduled ir�pecLion.mairrt�noe arxi repeir e�ert}se t�ensure our oor�nued
he�tth and safety and the protec�on of our homes and farnilies. The City of Paim Desert should not
foist its IegallY mandated mainte�ranoe and fi�ncia!respor�sibili�es ior the drainage system orrto the
Summit Associatjon rn its homeowners. _
N�cs�. .--,�r���C.�r.�?�.��._..._..�� _/ � �.��' .........................._..
A�►,�5:......�'�.��...�..��.1...._-.-�...��.��1.......:1�`��..�..�.
�....................................................
1/YYe sinongty oppose U�e�t�l of Palm Desert�s p�oposaa tio a�ndon any a�f its drainage
easernents i�t The Stnrn�deMelopmetrt. Our entire Swnmit�ainage system r+equ�res the Aty's
ongoin9 negula►h��eduled i�ecbon,nr�6e�oe and repedor�e�o er�sure our c�orrtJnued
heatth and sa�ety and the pr�bec,�Hon of au homes and famities. The City of Palm Desert should not
foist its legalfy mandated masntenance and finanaal respon.sib�lides far the drainage system oMo the
Summit Associatfon vr its homeowners.
N�cs�. ._...._._..��'.....`I�.�.S_. .:Il��:'_��!5.----�....�°'�`��.._. �.!�S_._
Addr�ss:......�.�.���...5'�►� ��� �...... �cz��. �r�t-�.��r::�.�:'
..._...._. ............... �................................. 2 �
� �
� - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- -- - _ ._ . _ _ _. _. .. _
uw�,��,o�os�u�e c�,►o��ne�e�t���o at�.�ao��n►ot�a�
em�senneaits in The Stn�it d�elopm�e��. o�s e�re sisnmi�drairr�ge syscen+requMes the C�ty's
ongdn9►�e9�a�iY�uled�spection.�and+�r�m ensiae oir oor�tinued
he�tth and safety and the pmbec�ion of our har�es�d f�mtlies. The City af Palm Ueseri should not
foist its�manda�ed rt�ntenanoe and fit�at�ities for the drain�ge system arrto the
Summtt Assocladon�r its homeowners. �.
Name(s�..��Q:V l 0.�.--.�� �F U��T.�?'"......_....._............_..._....�..
Address:���..�.Q...��C?D��:�........��').......P�M.....A�.��.
. '� R2��oD
�_� — — -.
vw��y o�m��r ot�+oe�c�a�m�,ao��►of ns a�
easements tn'il+e s�rr�mit de�relopmenR. o�r e�ire s�rxnit dra�tiage system�e�ir�the C�ty's
ongoin9 r�r1y sc.l�ded t�ect�on.m�te�noe ard rsPeir eq�ert�e bo e�tse otr cartinued
health�d safety and the protection of ar hanes and lartdlfes The<Sty af Palm Dese[t should rrot
foist its legatly m�ndemed rtreinRenance snd fi�erx�al r�po�ibfTAies for tt�e drainac�e system onto the
SummR Associatlon ar its homeowners.
�".P.a C-�/��i✓ =��,7� c,�----
�cs,.. ...,�'....�..,�'.._---.-----.-----------_..._..._.._.------------..._ .�_......_........---.—_._---._.....
/��y�� �V ���-/ ��/ • // Y ��� ��J/V `�
11NVIW�I...�.. .�..�...r.....�.................�..........................r.....................................................................__.......
...........
�l�/� �7���, �'f�
wk.amv6�aoome�e W swe o.o.�c.o4o.+e�r�een mr a r�.�.r
m�m.a�nrfi...��e�.�.�w Oira.rh.OumAda�e.raemRa�uz�q':
^9�+�•J I�RMfJwIM�wamms�oessi�s.m.ftrotiewmtr�co
rwn.rrc�wMr lUwt+�awxmdarbmcadMdsTcChvvr.uvinywlrai
MeC Rw Y.ply+viWbtl�Q sd bseY nyan�b IR Rs�e'-Y'-b�eNtf.+e
C�a.M�AiNXtiliv�Akslo�wU�Ai. �
/ - � � f
,//r ��{�. "\._
�,�.,-.���c1_�1� .
�_7�_F.�_i.._---(`-`-}�✓''?,l_�� ._�.f�tG`�..
��f Z ��j };E�- �f)i C �
�1
� �r�� ��
i/We str+on9h►q�pose the�t�r of Pa6m Dese�t's paapo�at to ab�ndon any of its dra�age
easemenfs in The Stsntnit cieanelopment. Our e�fne Swnmit c�rairx�e�ystem teqt,dr+es the(tity�s
�90�9 ie9�'iY sc�ieduled mspectlon,nm�de�noe and�peir e�q�er�e�o er�sur+�our aonGr�ued
heatt�and sa�e�tyy and the pr�Dsctlon of au tiomes ar�d iamgfes. The City of Palm Dese�rt shoutd not
fotst its legatly mandabed tnairrtertanoe and fmanc�a!�bt7'�for fhe d�nage syst�n ar�to the
Summit Assoc'ratiort ar iis homeawrx�rs. -
_ �/� 1
��e� ������� �
Name(s)._ .._.................... ........................�...r ............ . .................. .
Ada�s:....:7�:6.��.....S r,�.v�.��e-y...�c`�: ....��: .......�:?� .,.�...-�. � l°��
j- J`' .. ..�. ...........
�
U1 - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ---- ---- - - - - - - - - - -
�e�9�Y oPPQse the�tit�►af Paim oes�t�pro�sal�o abarxion any o?its arah�age
e�in Ths�nnmit de�reloprr�ent. Our eMire Summit�e system ne4uires the C1ty's
0��9�9�Y���d�sPe�on,mah�e�noe and repeir eapert�se Lo ensu�our c:onGnued
he�ith and sa�ety and the probection of our homes an�d families. The City of Palm Desert should not
foist its legally mandated maintenance and fir�ncial respor�ibilities for the drainage system orrto the
Summit Associatlon nr its homeowners. -
G�`�� 1� u� � ��'i� �� W� -
fVame(s)- -----------------------------------------•---�--.....�_�...�.............................................................
A��:..............��y3�%.....�.�.�%rlr���,w.--��� �� l i ��, C'��- 9'�a�v
.......+....�....................................................
V We strongly oppo�e ihe qt�l of Palm Desert`s propasal�o aba�tdon any of its drainage
easemerrts in The�deti�eiopme�rt. Our e�re Stxnmit drair�age system ne4�re:s the City's
a��9�9�Y���P�.rtt�ri�anoe and repair e�ertise L�ensure our c�ntinued
he�lth and sa�ety and the protiection af our home�s�d families. The City of Palm Desert should not
foist its legally mandat,ed mairtterrance and fina�ia!�bilitles for the d�e system orrto the
Summit Association nr its homeowners. �
` ��Ip � /7 ��w� � �i� G�
(Va��/--�="•:5�`=C��»S�r�'�=tl..%� ..�.�........---- ----...._.......................................
�/
,�,��:..��:���...... .. . .. ..............�..:. .�:�..........`.:�....�.�...............................
�
� - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - -
��►���►������,�„���
e�seme�s in�n�e S�,�ur�de�eiopme��. our e�re Surmm��ge sy�n r�quir�tne c�ty,�s
o�n9�9�Y�du�ed ir�spe�tion.rr�ainDe�e and r�p�h eoq�tlse to ensure our c�orttinued
heetth and sa�e�y and the pr+nbectlon of our homes and families. The City of Paim Desert should not
foist tts legally mandabed mai�te�nce and fir�arx�al respor�sibilities for the drainac�e system orrto the
Summft a,s�oc or�vr its homeownefs. -
,
- - --�-,�����'����r
n�cs�....:�.�r.rl.�.r.' ........... . ........._ - �:�
Address�.o�tiS..��.._......�..�..�'-:.�''.�:��............................................................................
Klassen, Rachelle
From: Stanley, Jane
Sent: Friday, November 07, 2014 11:42 AM
To: Klassen, Rachelle
Subject: FW: Visit to the Summit drainage channels
-----Original Message-----
From: donna mandelstam [mailto:dm515@sbc�lobal.net]
Sent: Friday, November 07, 2014 8:07 AM
To: CityhallMail
Subject:Visit to the Summit drainage channels
11/6/14
Hi Mayor Tanner, j
We greatly appreciated your willingness to visit The Surrymit and to view the drainage channels in person. We also were
willing to look at a possible compromise to present to the Board. Unfortunately,the compromise you suggested still
involves the City's abandonment of its easements for the drainage channels. After you left we realized that this would
leave the Summit with 22 private backyards over which we have absolutely no control. Even if the City did a "patrol"
walk of the channels, whatever was found could not be enforced by the HOA. The abandonment of the easements strips
the HOA all of its power with regard to the channels. Currently, if we have an obstacle in the channel, such as the
foreclosure home's cuttings, we can cite them, and if they fail to act, we are able to clean it up ourselves (because it is a
health and safety issue) and add it to the lien.
If the City abandons the easements it leaves the homeowners with no protections whatsoever. The City has the staff,
the knowledge, and the means to maintain these channels. When the obstacles are removed (and they will be) it really
is not much of an addition to their current work in the Summit.
Thanks again for your time.The Board and our Atty are confident that they have shown that Director Greenwood's Staff
report that is the basis for this action is completely false. Letters and pictures prove that the channels do carry water,
they did flood recently, water does come through the Bighorn holes and from the condos to the East, etc. The Board
also said that they have never seen homeowners so galvanized around one issue: 61 protest yellow sheets, 10+
individual letters, and many pictures have been submitted. Please keep us protected, I know you want to do the right
thing. Also, Director Greenwood was again misinformed when he stated that our Atty did not respond to the City's
letters, she responded to both of them........1 will also call your number to make sure that you receive this message.
Donna Mandelstam
760-565-7287
r.a �j
,Q �--1
D��
� ���
"'� =r r*�
� rn��
cn�c._.
r•�
i ��m
�OQ
-� -rt
,. f�-*t
� �h
tn
1
Klassen, Rachelle
From: Stanley, Jane
Sent: Friday, November 07, 2014 11:41 AM
To: Klassen, Rachelle; Tanner, Van; Harnik,Jan
Subject: FW: Storm Channels
From: C. Gerald King [mailto:cgking3Ca�yahoo.com]
Sent: Friday, November 07, 2014 11:06 AM
To: CityhallMail
Cc: Aurora Sanchez
Subject: Storm Channels
Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council
City of Palm Desert
I own a residence at 48-601 Valley View Drive in the Summit development. We bought the home in
1997 and shortly after we moved in, we observed the storm channels weren't being very well
maintained. But after a phone call to the city maintenance department, they quickly came, cleaned
out the channels and have done a decent job of regular maintenance since.
I am very disappointed to learn that the channels may not be maintained by the city in the future.
Since the channels are an easement on my property for the city, I feel strongly they should continue
to be maintained by the city.
This is very important to me since we are only part time residents and depend on the city to see that
large amounts of runoff don't inadvertently damage our property when we are not there.
Respectfully,
C Gerald King
� �
� ��
��
o r��
< =r t*'t
-.J �*1 aD�
Nx..�..
m
3 aoU'r'*t
-'�C��
C7�
G3 A n
� rn
1
Klassen, Rachelle
From: Stanley,Jane
Sent: Friday, November 07, 2014 11:41 AM
To: Tanner, Van; Harnik,Jan; Greenwood, Mark; Klassen, Rachelle
Subject: FW: Storm drains - Summit Neighborhood
From: Laura [mailto:IbueermannCa�yahoo.com]
Sent: Friday, November 07, 2014 11:26 AM
To: CityhallMail
Subject: Storm drains - Summit Neighborhood
To the Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council City of Palm Desert
I am writing regarding the status if the storm drain designed to direct run off for the benefit of all south Palm
Desert residents.
While it's clear that the issue of maintenance was a surprise to the City, the city appears to be relying on the
fact that the drains are hidden from view running behind one small set of houses. This channel is part of the
original water management plan. Out of sight should not mean "no longer our responsibility". Other storm
drains, which are more visible in the city, are treated along with other public needs such as sidewalks.
As we have been told over the years when attempting repairs & alterations to our homes, "ignorance of the
regulations does not absolve the homeowner". Likewise, ignorance about the storm channels and years of
neglect does not in any way absolve the City of its original obligation. That obligation was clearly the intent
when the easement was originally required.
The City is simply being arbitrary merely because we're now in a period of fiscal tightening. In fact, it makes
many of the council decisions suspect. Is it simply expedient? Or did/does the Council actually fulfill its duties
even if those requirements date back years before anyone's tenure?
I would urge the Council to live up to the City's original demands a from the homeowners and its requirements
by agreeing to include the channel in its maintenance plans.
Laura& Brad Bueermann o .9�
48-770 North View DR Z �-�
Palm Desert � _��
+C r f'ti`
760-836-3355 J rn��
800/934-3303 x 2033 �'x--
� �N�
-�ov
_ �
.. c-�-+,
� �n
� �
1
Resolution No. 2014-94
\e
s
• cg
• NO .74
:OD•
0
01
1
F
71
a :1
CUR YA7.M MUN N'VOYIY
■ ,.x m1 w. w A ,
,� s a a
• —
F
1) - o !a 0
r
w a S� to
Qy� ,w.a ! •w. aY.a� �. m
Nea R a s
; :. NORTH. va ai - PriTvE ... aC - _., r. Ift-- .. i
— �ci. I x m
1 ��.9 JI).�1 4 —M 0.3,.. :I.., ea- '•t
"4
1'
WI w
e.
•
o c
co
30 >o
CY
C
;s
uJra
CO
` 4ra
- i1 7 E ' a a.
,n >0 1
ill WM 111
6 W a.BNAOY DRIVE
VIEW
61
a.M• •1� a.a Is
a
a.w
0
s _ s
• Ass, N
y 6
•
8
15.
W • A
# t
a
:e —'�
1,8 ro N.
MA'AM,
a
319V 1Atln
-
Resolution No. 2014-94
VALLEY
QE,T u,
IMOW/ HILLS WM
0
1: 8,860
VICINITY MAP
GRASS GT GRA$$GT• MMTERM\
CIRN
-'NESA_VIEWSDR
Resolution No. 2014-94
//
OP
0 SER LOI%'FR0R
ca3
c0:08b,
'i#EODORA LN
os4-wEvv-con
I J
GREENARIAR LN
r4, ,- •
11011111
Nom
1♦
Aim rp
1 1 1
HOMESTEAD -RI'
1 1 1 1 1
L
D SERT !E
.p_
SUNDOWN LN
SUN VALLEY LN
MINIM
J♦
MEN
INDIAN HILLS WAY
ROLLING KNOLL()
EC
au IC
Inl
Igh
3
�NYON DR
ANDRS \
GE L
--HEODORA LN
O
7
0
0
0
r-
0
0
D'
O
A
1WES4—WSW-DR
SPYGLASS LN
"REASCAN
DA
1
'OMEsTEAD-Rr
S GLASS LN
a
0
I 1 1 1
1 1 1
'fOMES•T•EA
I I '_UJWA
III RE H
iI 1 B
1m
A
ANITA CIR � �-�
A z3 Ea
<
0
1.- a
ALAN CIR mm
DAVIS RD
A
0
NO MIA H1210
The Summit
Tract 13008
Accepted Dedications
Exhibit A-1
ti
WHITE DR
MESA VI
4
r
A
QUAIL HOLLOW DR
0
A
C
GRARASS•C-T—
' 1 '
Z e f
E
mm
*IR
CARRIAGE TRI
I I
VICINITY MAP
Resolution No. 2014-94
DESERT FLO E.?04,
,
ofi
il:fou
oo
INDIAN HILLS WAY
//
1 1 1
' LOMESTEAD-RP
1 1 1
n
0
GREENBRIAR LN
ROLLING I(NOLLOR
cc
.
ANORE)5
SUNDOWN LN
EDOORALN
I 1 I
cPNYON DR
1
SPYGLASSLN
ANDSCANI
\ 11
1 i I I
IOMES•TEAD.R^ 2MESTEA
LASS LN
The Summit
Tract 13008
Rejected Dedication
Exhibit B-1
A
m
DAVIS RD
ANITA CIR
WHITE DR
o
ALAN CIR
MESA VIEW DR
QUAIL HOLLOW DR
F
MED
—1:11 s
E
R E
E
wm
4611
CARRIAGE TRL
VICINITY MAP
Resolution No. 2014-94
i
Resolution No. 2014-94
c
411
er:• e
PY 8:
-....�_ 41.W37•'eV 329 93 •
45
r,•14WW Iff GP a
fir8P, ■i
0 Na . w a �i. o.- T
S.1 ~ t Ni717`a4a \ji_
514 Ne�11,�N 'W+1�,.ijf
19M0.7 , 11.11.10
11.11o. p. rvt l 5M to wlw v4[ f'
-
•
—J
11
31 O r ias
2
iTt
to
reg
Oqf
to
E
--
eve sw t••
: rtM$17 j 40.211
'� 'NW
i e ')L
li r� lik ;^.31
1 =
$ F,. g
Off•
S310N 9N11N3WAMOW
,
Resolution No. 2014-94
9 133HS 33S
_ ILrn 1!1 44 a
. __11X11N1. i1Lii_
Ve
9.1
C1
5 ' `a
■ P11•131 11700 IJ
Rw•E
■
71,114,
t F/ove_q r0
�£Ms
. 1•31' 111 lN.IOI NI
88 Sw t@:
'a1 Ili!
Ln 8 s5F Q o1=
o . pp
fag,, lea
-Nr1 al..=
:•r 1s
. Yi
■ SAT"—'14po X S F `
• j %
-8 _. C C • --- 6
■ 111174172. ._111<a
11 Q11.011 114 33
Vell
ii
4 ie lip f :' IV
O Ws? .Ia a
• B ~
• kt'B OVAL ' era —.9y 1w r
qq�� rw . 7"� ■ 1 _
qi rie'i •ewn ..0 7
� o__ � yyC7 = —
RI 1 aFr: '
i NJL.
£�3 0 o i. a
f.
y!
1 k SY 41 11
191.00 --- 112.9\
■ •!1•311
O
Ch
NJ
v ,
4 N
' + • s1s-1a'elti T7
annseresc fi
23 r 8- 810888888888
U! R�USe7.1COi YOi3 .�.
i.;;Kiltrt;>s*�
• c{Yzr>.14gi•P.
E.g'.014ggg.
a sSaeeesSao E
Ba6'Bm'B•s'Bsaa6 a
n
esseetza zelc %
Y BRYr PYB:e•At :!
-]!i C?Ydi'..Arta -
zsenter...exaze B
Resolution No. 2014-94
Iy 1w
eithre x
1 Eiri
A
_E E a.
it W
0
2
�.
4 h 4
1l
f g • Ca•117 • 1.16
1
; Fre
•_23y yi I1i41.�..
O
• 1”011.117 N.11
• 1•M'17 1 In
V
C0
• PI/'11Y
RL8
ON•
1!)01,4
' S
8
s r
a:
8
41•a'U7 1+1.46
111
F 8
X' f:
8
}11� 17
40
• 1 "1ST
Y
a
1
ij
w'7
.\I
�114[ iS .� y -� aC
i'-1nn
le
4 •" H � rpj yn Z '� A
ERY J�(Al n
rA trim
e.o s
N, iO i
_ k.�ao
CD
s i}'T ' a><C7EE FIi�Fs B n y G
8) 2, ; • 1•je••y % �K^C�Y61S144 `Il'
Ili S[1 x222E51E2E2 i ^ %n W
prvj 48N8S8E5li4IS II • 1'. "4
3'
ze�x- Pt
cn ccS srr3'i.�_r _ak
cm
•
:nf!;_AA•-afa
i C 9 ai a "Y;xYa's g
• i•11.17 f 1U�_,
4
1 <_
U
01 y R v
• rikart 11101
f E CJ1
Y �a SO• � SECSiIA •=3i�3:
cc
IP Pt
f• • •14.•, -MN • Y.
t �u 111�
3 __ - •„ _xesemb r OPAL xpFLIVE
•� ww w Iw.R
u >`
r112:4
YCYS: DtF
4434488fl88888 8
rAx:__r=st: F.
w
V
.I SJe
Now) ey
V
aae.x. pste
e=e�aaaic�a*
::4_xy_t.P.:44 4
1
..e>{..gxacr'r
�sGC�?SCE=e'
J s X 3444.``,a�CB E
aattaisa
11
3
•d.
•J t1 4-
Resolution No. 2014-94
L\ 1
• ,.y'UW In.••
OD ▪ „ -
•
tr
Mr !SY Y'
lg i I
ggd J
i I
10
1
oo
I
1 •l I14L
A b
': :l4CF-47' S7 Y44an4SSYM"'_!Y • !: JJ
AR 00 J
4qe n4g4-042 plia:.;91 .11.:1a1-An . e = : 4z.
it
EfOtop£a_e:saastilESEEEEE iq= I
4;:gtx
Ma gn8x 7i8a88xx11x1r1tAssii=iiisii 5 .. �+gf I
Vw
.x _nCmSniCxCam.xcx_e »xma3te k R ii. arc-ii:+
'•'.Y^iC�>; y4 ..
gig: i= co
g.ga'si::keexis_cia'ss:ax:ei4iaa f Iv
a
C•1.Mtlr 77 'IL Yw es • *1 14.l L7
`4
re .0 .:1.w •..may 1wf1....1=stay •
sta. ..a.. ',elms
L-YOQ ` . 1.4.47 111.01
__—.._ _�7 .� LY.LL . I•M'N31 O
$ y = 8 1
tp gC o0
CD.ei i o0
•a -
111
. •1 417
°" x:.....,.. VALLEY VIEW
•1, WO
9
rn
• S 44
Um. a.1•� e
• Nn'11Y ln-O. ;,
ID
. D
• nt
ag
alrl_q lya_
s t
• 1.14 e!
..
J
•
nc
{€ j
Pa
s
74
•i�4
S
to w �. i 4.014
J .
o d
:if cc y ▪ co
J 4-V J Ch
,
r1 ^ 0 11
11 •.
..ea
Oh.+
1111 I ,� DRIVE n 1z
N • rat11Y
11.10 It.a I ! O r.l!
a
'
OD
i
Ta+d771 1'7-
J
IA
SEE SHEET G
IX3!
t tt
l
a
gyro
44/
1vAa +vs
a
0
Resolution No. 2014-94
1t MwISY I.r.a 0
r
II a.co II N I
J ,
lu
rWIY'Q..1 �
1
o = .b
�T' 1
.y ■ rein ism
A-.
Vi
x �s — .�
s.
—t.11•fl'H1 �
p IF
I ° cf+
a O f
ay is
sis 4, ▪ ■ rwtr, a
,CO g x 613 w CO
fn f
—►a vapor, .. •. o
.441.12
No(r14 VIEW ra•o+'
—
� k --S 6*Ai"Uua
k.
s
CO
W
c0
I.w.01.-
rn
SEE SHEET 5
�--" "'w'
vl
"" O.a t1 w VW.
•Y DRIVE
. _-iClClfi _. V. faa • • .
s""
N
• Iowa•� i i m • y
-.
. MIMISI ,$ �• L I/.r .. .:..
w.w �, ...•• D g e
eras
1 w. 1 a eras ,/ ,'t m 4 A
N17�illw1011 5'1
15 <a
• w'w1 "' �
4n i. \•" . '1 OD `C
1 •=; 1nf Z
1.10' °yt 4• o y 0 Q$
P _ fy yj/,.
N'i '•:P k
a �
V ''``
_ J 01, t
r:gam.
V
1 I^�, i•1
V
�1
L
vto 4
O f
�
*rn
4
43. f:
74r
V
r
.L3314$ 33S
.
ill
— dp,
If
w.lt s
r.r ON IV fg1 jai
a W _ IN, Fla Ce. W S' _ _
ri
dd
li
V kV 9H.6PY VIEW �,a1 PR we ttNt. av
tti
-7t
I.
CO
CO
0
ii
4
x,
s-a, j.sS4.41 r
2t
l Iry•ol�
w.a
1rwM1
•1113
L Y
flit
rap
SP GN FY-, (Iq DO
C 5I_•
f g IIIPP"'
Cr, i coNi i b O tlJ!� 1
a is
a il
ail>3 m
a
,•a•r1
1
i4seseg=1h 9
�Y9i:�zSa3YC?2 CP:4 ;', � i
,saE'svEVo3'reat0000 (E 8
$B$BR7t$,$8S88E88C(3$ 0
GGNaaoop.-oe M,zospA6t Al
't'sa.ec«aa-�ataaa:sa s
abi'a'sas«sera«ass's:e 1
a.�
20
RECEIVED
11/13/2014 C'PALM DE5ER��CA �
2014 MOY I 2 AM 9� 5 I
I-�onorable 1Vlayor Tanner and City Council Members:
We are asking you to reject the City's proposal to abandon its drainage
easements for the four concrete drainage channels in the Summit.
If this proposal passes, The Summit HOA will be stripped of any and all
author�ty it has over the four drainage channels. They will revert back to
22 separate concrete areas averaging 800 square feet in 22 different
private backyards and the CC&Rs will not apply. The City's proposal
literally eliminates any oversight or control of a vital part of our
interconnected Summit drainage system.
Let's talk about what will actually happen to the 22 homeowners who
back up to the four drainage channels if the City of 1'a1m l�esert is
allowed to abandon those easements. This is an outrageously
impractical and dangerous notion. A drainage system is by definition
there to protect the lives and property of the people it serves. No one's
safety should be placed in jeopardy by taking a piece of the Summit
�rainage system and forcing nonprofessionals to monitor i�, clean it ,
maintain and repair it.
1 . All of these homes have tract maps that clearly show that the City of
Palm Desert is responsibie for these easements and for the ongoing
maintenance of the Summit drainage system. They see the City Public
Works crew ciea.ning dra.ins at the street every two months. This creates
a reasonable expectation that the City is cleaning and maintaining the
entire drainage system, not just skipping part of it. Whenever there was
an emergency, the City was called and sent their crew to clean the
channels.
2. Most of these homeowners are here only as part time vacationers.
They are not even present to monitor debris that may have stopped
behind their property after a storm. Some occupants are renters who turn
over frequently. Many are senior citizens. Out of the blue, they would
be as�ked to care for their portion of a concrete drainage channel some
sections of which are cracked and leaking already. Would you want to
live on any of these channels?
3. Some backyards have short walls or no wa11s abutting the drainage
channel behind their homes. If their neighbor's debris blocks the
channel, they will be flooded. Other homes have 6 ft walls with
landscaping on top of the walls . Those homeowners don't even see the
dra.inage channels and they don't have access to them. It is neither safe
nor practical to assume they will fulfill this responsibility.
4. All of these homeowners pay the same homeowner association fees
and city taxes but will be treated differently than the rest of the Summit
homeowners. A new and unexpected and undeserved financial burden
will be foisted upon them.
5. If two homes of equal value are for sale in the Summit and one is on
a drainage channel and the owner needs to explain to every prospective
buyer that the home comes with an obligation to maintain a portion of a
concrete drainage ditch, which home will sell first? Which home has
been de facto devalued by the City's abandonment of it's responsibility?
6. �['here is an abundance of law regarding ea.sements. The City's failure
to regularly maintain only the four drainage channels and one other drain
while regularly maintaining the rest of the Summit drainage system
(without notification to the Summit that it was doing so} violated the
rights of the homeowners in the Summit and placed them in danger.
The City attempted via its Staff Report to say that the drainage channels
carried no water, had no further use, had little chance of flooding, and
did not carry water that entered from Bighorn. Every one of these
statements is false according to the attached letters and pictures from
various Summit homeowners whose properties back up to the drainage
channels. Homeowners have verified that the channels carry water, and
serve a purpose and that water enters from Bighorn. The City's failure to
maintain a drain and drainage channel caused one home to be flooded at
48721 North View Dr in the heavy rainstorm of August 2013. Also
atta.ched is a letter from a witness to that flooding and the flooding of the
garage of the home next door. No one wants a repeat of that. We all
want to be safe. The City needs to fulfill its legal obligations and not try
to use a 35 yea.r old clerical error (failure to note each easement as
"accepted") to sidestep their responsibility.
The atta.ched letters and pictures are in addition to the 65 yellow protest
responses from Summit homeowners opposing the City's
recommendation to abandon its drainage channel easements. The City
has the expertise, the staff, and the equipment and they are already on
site in the Summit every two months. The small number of fences, etc
will be removed and it will be easy to walk the full length of the
channels to clean them. Please take the outpouring of homeowner
protests seriously and reject the City's recommendation.
�-..
< <
,_-- ,._ ;,� ,,
//� ,,��_ � � -,
��.�w._ / �'"J �, i I P //��
/ / p•"s-i/'� , ( 1 •� � V
t '..._ .�-'� -. , \ � . � . , .:' � �
, �, J V � �,�
Donna and Bill Mandelstam � ',
October 10,2014
My name is Alan Kaplan of Alan Kaplan Pooi Service in Paim Desert. I have serviced and maintained pools in
The Sumrriit development for the last 30 years.
t maintained the pool at 48721 North Vew Dr for Rasvan Buhescu and his wife for several years before they
moved out of the area in Feb of 20�4. The prope►ty is now in foreclosure.
I was present when the clogged C'rty of Palm Desert drainage channei behind their home and the City inlet drain
on the City easements on their property overflowed in the big rainstam of August 2013. I saw water pour
through the backyard from the City drainage chan�el dov�m the steps and irtto the Buhescu living room. I aiso
saw the water run through their yard and down hill through their side yard irrto the garage of the Mande(stam
residence at 7269'1 Spyglass Ln. I saw the Mandelstams shoveling mud out of the driveway and cleaning water
out of the garage with brooms. I cleaned the mud out of the Buhescu pool,drained the poof and cleaned the
pool decking following the storm_
Mr Buhescu contacted Flood Tech company to clean up after the flooding but he did not hire them because the
estimate was too high.
t also mai�ain other poots on Spygiass Ln and Valley Vew that back up to the drainage channels.
Over the years I have seen water enter the channei from Bighom through the 10 f�oles in the Summit perimeter
wall behind 4872i North Vew Dr whenever there is a heavy rairrstorm. The holes are almost directly behind the
pool that I maintain and water still comes through them and goes into the channel and the drain when we have
significant rainstorms_
I have also scen City mairrter�ance crews clean up the channels periodicalty over the years. I saw them clean the
drainage channets several fimes in the 1980's and the 1990's but not in recent years
Alan Kaplan
..l.!��v.r.�..-��/�7':�.:-":`:
760=2y9-5809
Subject: Re: City of Palm Desert's proposal to abandon their drainage channel easements
From: C. Gerald King (cgking3@yahoo.com)
To: dm515@sbcglobal.net;
Date: Tuesday, October 28, 20141:05 PM
Donna & Bill,
Water does run in the channel on the backside of my property at 48-601 Valley View Dr. In last years
heavy rain, the channel would not handle all the water and the area where that channel drains in to the
large channel on the North side of the property washed out. Not being there at that time of the year, I
don't know if the area washed out was caused by the city not maintaining the channel at the back of
the property or that the channel was not sufficient to handle all the water caused by the flood
conditions in August 2013.
When we first moved in in 1998, it appeared the city was not keeping the channeis clear, and after
considerable rain that winter, my wife called the city, they quickly came and cleaned both channels
and have done an adequate job since except maybe for the back channel last year.
The channel on the west side of my property drains a lot of runoff from the condominium complex
west of ine as does the large channel on the north side.
I personally believe it is irresponsible for the city of Palm Desert not to maintain these channels and
their entry into the city's storm drain system.
Please let me know if I can be of further help. I regret we won't be in Palm Desert at the time of the
meeting.
Gerald King
360-681-8747
SubJect: Re: Ciiy of Palm Desert plans to abandon Summit drainage channels
From: Kathy Bjork (kbjo67@yahoo.com)
To: dm515@sbcglobal.net;
Date: Sunday, October 19, 2014 222 PM
Donna,
I have attached a letter for Paim Desert along with photographs of our drainage hole.
I hope this helps. Let me know how this complaint progresses.
Kathy Bjork
October 19, 2014
City of Palm Desert:
Palm Desert is a city to be proud of. This is due, in part, to the excellent care
from the maintenance crews that work to see that the vegetation is trimmed, the
streets are paved and the public areas kept free of clutter.
When we moved to the desert many years ago we chose to buy a home in Palm
Desert. We were attracted by its neat appearance, parks and
shopping, the lack of contention among the city council and willingness to listen
to citizen concerns. My husband and I have been residents since 1977 and have
resided in our current home in The Summit since1986.
When we bought our house it had a cement drainage channel that ran the length
of our backyard at the top of our embankment. We were told it was part of a flood
control easement owned by the city and they would be responsible for its
maintenance. In the twenty-eight years we have lived here we recall only two
instances where we saw evidence that someone from the city had cleaned the
channel, and this was in the late 1980's.
We, ourselves, have worked to keep the area clean of leaves, mud and other
debris that accumulates in the channe{. This has been quite an investment of our
time and effort, especially since our property is the highest point and apex to#he
channel.
To add to our labors, Big Horn Development dug a hole in our fence, authorized
by�the city, to let water and debris drain from their neighborhood. Every time
there is even a moderate amount of rain, or when they water extensively, we are
left with a muddy mess next to the hole. We were told the opening would be
upgraded; we were even shown drawings of a structure that would be instailed to
help channel the water. This has never been built.
It is disturbing that Palm Desert has not lived up to their responsibility. They were
quick to grant an expensive development permission to drill a hole in our wall to
permit water and mud to flow from their property into our yard_ Yet they do not
appear to care how it affects the homeowners whose yard it broaches.
I offer my support to the homeowners in The Summit who have brought their
concerns about this problem to the City.
Kathy Bjork HYPERLINK "mailto:kbjo67@yahoo.com" 'V'���`;-���?,�_�:`�:���:����
72631 Spyglass Lane
Palm Desert
DrFArtece oPt„nineE behAnd het-Me-7e 0
Nor h View Dr In recent moderate raEnstom in September 2014
Dragnage channel b Ind hornhornes on spyglass Ln 6n recent mdei° e ralna orr - :pter 20.Lt
Print
3/8/14, 3:55 PM
Subject: Photo from Mar 8, 2014
From: Donna Mande!stem (dm515@idoud.com)
To: hi11925@stxglobal.net;
Date: Saturday, March 8, 2014 3:40 PM
about:blank
Page 1 of 1
L
E
CD
a
1C
m�
CO
CO
CU
Q5
0
E
on
ic
ma
25
CD
t
a
z
74;41,-
co
a)
a)
o
o.
la
c
o
a)
W
c
g
= r
Qicera
�t�C�iY�D
C I T Y C L E R K'S ,��l�RS & FREEDMAN, L.L.P.
PALM D�SER
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
201� NOV I 2 PM b' 2�3100 COOK STREET, SUITE 202 mail@hoalaw.com
DAVIO M.PETERS PALM DESERT, CA 92211
KEENAN A.PARKER wwW.h08/eW.CO�r1
JAMES R.McCORMiCK JR.
STEPHEN M.KIRKLAND
CHRISTINA M.BAINE DeJARDIN Tel: (760) 773-4483 ENCINITAS OFFICE
Fax: (760) 773-0919
JOHANNA R.DELEIS5EGUES 191 CALLE MAGOALENA,STE. 220
TRACY M. FULLER LINKOWSKI ENCINITAS,CA 92024
GHANT W.HAMOR Tel: (760J 438-3441
MICKEY JEW ' Fex:17B01 436-3442
KYLE E.LAKIN
LAURIE F.MASOTTO QRANGE COUNTY OFFICE
LAURIE S.POOLE
ZACHARY R.SMITH 120 VANTiS,STE.300
ALISO VIEJO,CA 92856
Tei:t9491 390-2977
SIMON J.FREEDMAN(RET► Fex: (949)335-8044
November 12,2014
Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council
City of Palm Desert
73510 Fred Waring Drive
Palm Desert,California 9226U-2578
Regazding: Palm Desert Summit Homeowners Associatian/Offer of Dedication of Storm Drain
Channel Easements
Our File No. 2203
Dear Hoaorable Mayor and Members of the City of Palm Desert City Council:
The Law Firm of Peters & Freedman, L.L.P., represents the Palm Desert Summit Homeowners
Association ("Association"). The purpose of this letter is to respectfully request that the City
Couc�cil("City")expressly accept the offer of dedication of easements made im retation to the storm
drain channels located within the community.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
The Association is a 154 home community that is sandwiched between Highway 74 and the Big
Horn development. The beautiful single family homes in this development are currently listing for
just under$1 M.
When the Association was built in approximately 1978, the City placed various conditions of
approval on the development. Specifically,the City required storm drain channels/easements along
certain residential lots to accommodate drainage in the community. Standard Condition 7 states that
all dedicated land and/or easements required by the approval sha11 be granted to the City of Palm
Desert without cost to the City. Special Condition 6 states that the applicant must provide acceptable
easements to accommodate drainage from Sectian D& H onto the property. Special Condition 7
states that single easements shall be apptied between lots,where appropriate.
These Special Conditions appear in the resolutions of both the Palm Desert Planning Commission
and Palm Desert City Council. Copies of the resolutions are attached as Exhibit"A." The required
easements appear on Tract Map 13008, which was approved and accepted by the City. A copy of
Mayor and City of Palm Desert City Council Members
November 12,2014
Page 2
Tract Map 13008 is attached as Exhibit"B."
In August 2013,the City of Palm Desert experienced what has been characterized as a 100-1 SO-yeaz
storm. Torrents of water rushed through the storm drain channe2s in the Association,taking debris
and vegetation with it. At least one home adjacent to the storm drain channet was unfortunately
impacted by the storm and sustained damage. This home is located at 48721 North View Drive. The
gazage of the neighboring home at 72691 Spyglass Lane was also flooded as a result.
After the August 2013 storm,the issue of maintaining the storm drain channels took center stage.
When the Association and other homeowners approached the City regazding its obligations,the City
attempted to disclaim these easements by saying that it never accepted them. This determination is
not supported by the facts or the law.
THE CITY HAS ALREADY ACCEPTED THE OFFER OF DEDICATION
'The question of whether the City should accept the offer of dedication of the channel easements is
moot.City Staffappears to assert that because the City did not formally accept the offer of dedication
at the time that the Tract Map was approved, it can now abandon the offer 35 years later. This
azgument is based upon the City's own failure to adhere to Government Code Section 66440 to
certify its acceptance on the Tract Map.
By requiring the easements as Conditions of Approval for the community,the City clearly intended
to accept the offer of dedication. Further, the City approved and accepted the Tract Map itself,
which identifies the easements reserved to the City. In light of its true intention to accept the offer
of dedication,it is disingenuous for the City to attempt to rely on a technical oversight it created to
abandon its obligations to its constituents.
More importantly, however, the City accepted the offer of dedication by performing regulaz
maintenance of the channels. California case law holds that a municipality may imply consent to a
dedication by exercising dominion over the azea in question. See, Tischauser v. Newport Beach
(1964) 225 Ca1.App.2d 138, 145. Because the City has maintained the channels over the past
severai years,it has already accepted the offer of dedication. Even if the City"expressly"rejects the
offer of dedication,a homeowner could still assert that the City has already accepted the offer. The
safest and simplest way forwazd for the City is to expressly accept the offer.
In support of this conclusion,we have attached copies of the City's maintenance logs establishing
regular maintenance of portions of the easement. See,Exhibit"C." Unfortunately,the eazliest entry
on the logs that we could identify was in 2009. In the lifespan of a roughly 35-yeaz old project,the
City's logs aze not complete. Fortunately, the Association does have correspondence from
homeowners in the community�rming that the City has performed regular maintenance of the
channels going back much further than 2009. True and correct copies of correspondence from
homeowners and a pool vendor who works within the community corroborating this regular
maintenance are attached as E�chibit"D."
As the owner of the easements,the City is required to maintain them. See,Reirlsch v. Ciry of Los
Angeles(1996)243 Cal.App.2d 737,747. It cannot now disclaim the easements and its obligations.
Mayor and City of Palm Desert City Council Members
November 12, 2014
Page 3
FACTUAL INACCURACIES IN CITY STAFF REPORT
To support its recommendation to abandon the offer of dedication of the easements,City Staff has
asserted that"there is very little chance of any flood damage to any home" and that"The Summit
channel is of very little use and unlikely to convey significant storm flows." Staff has also asserted
that because the"channel provides only limited protection to the abutting homes,and no pratection
to other property,it provides no benefit to the public."
Unfortunately,Staff is inconect on all counts.As stated above,two homes at the Association were
damaged in 2013 when water flowed from the storm drain channel onto the Lots and into the
residence and neighboring gazage. 'The neighboring home that was damaged is not even adjacent
to the storm drain chan.nel. The channels do,in fact,provide an important function of draining away
irrigatian from other homes,storm water and runoff from the neighboring Big Horn Development.
There are sizable holes drilled in the boundary wall separating the Association from Big Horn that
allow water that is not redirected on the Big Horn property to flow into the channels. Photos of the
channels evidencing water flow and the holes in the wall are attached as Exhibit"E.". In addition,
correspondence from homeowners carroborating the water flow aze attached as E�ibit"F."
City Staffhas also asserted that the channels pravide no benefit tv the public. It is not cleaz how the
City is defining the term "public." Presumably, the few hundred residents of the Association
constitute some portion of the "public." Further, since the City has apparentiy permitted the Big
Horn development to divert its overflow water into these channels,the channels benefit more than
simply the Association and its residents but instead makc up a system of water flow designed and/or
approved by the City to expressly benefit the"public"
It would be unrealistic and frankly impossible to justify any project undertaken by the City if it had
to serve or somehow provide a benefit to the entire population of Palm Desert. Further,the City's
own maintenance records demonstrate that the City has performed drainage maintenance in several
other locations that realistically service only a subset of the public. It makes no sense that the City
would have required the easements in the first place if it believed that the channels did not serve a
public interest.
If nothing else,the City has a vested self-interest in maintaining the channels. While the City has
offered to accept certain portions of the channels,primarily the outlet drains,it does not make sense
to reject the balance of the channels.All of the debris that collects in the channels will flow into the
outlets until the inlets become so clogged that the water enters the residential lots. If enaugh debris
collects in the outlets or flows from the residential lots,there could be standing water on the streets
that the City maintains. The City's maintenance logs do reference a number of standing water items.
As any asphalt company will attest, standing water is the biggest enemy of asphalt.
City Staff also stated that there have only been two occasions that have been identified when City
Staff performed emergency storm response and clean up. T'his is,again,incorrect. According to the
City's maintenance logs, portions of channels have been regulazly maintained since 2012.
Homeowners and a pool vendor who works in the community have also conoborated that the City
has regularly maintained the channels. Please refer to Exhibits"C"and"D."
Mayor and City of Palm Desert City Council Members
November 12,2014
Page 4
City Staff also indicated that some homeowners have installed improvements or otherwise altered
the channels such that it would be difficult for the City to access the entire length of the channets.
While the City has the ability to take action to remove the improvements,in the spirit of cooperation,
the Association would be wilting to work with the City to require the homeowners to rernove any
obstacles in the channels in the event that the City expressly accepts the dedication of easements.
We respectfully request that the City expressly accept the offer of dedication of all easements within
the Association for the storm drain channels and maintain them on a going forwazd basis. Thank you
for your due consideration of this issue.
Very truly yours,
PETERS&.FREEDMAN, L.L.P.
Ctirir�ina Baine�e�ar�n
CBD\cmb
cc: Board of Directors
G:122�2203\CBDU.etters\la city councii re channels.wpd
E�.HIBIT "A"
PLANNING C011I[ISSION AS30Lt7TION NO. 418
A RE30LUTION OF THS PLANNING CO!l11I33ION OF THE
CITY OF FALY DESBRT, CALIFOAIQIA, AECOHi1ENDING
APPROVAL TO THB CITY COUNCIL OF A TLNTATIV$ TBACT
11AP TO C�tEATE A 161 LOT 3INGLE-FAl1ILY SUSDIVISION.
�' CA8E N0. TT I3U08 ,
1PHEREd3, the Planning Comtaission of the City oi PQZm Desert,
California, did on the 31st day of October, 1978, hold a duly noticed
PubZic Hearing, to consider a request by COVE CONBTRpCTION COMPANY for
approval oP a Tentative Tract Map to create 161 single-ismily residc�tial
V lots on approxi.matelq 64.4 acres withia the R-2 12,000 (Single-family
reeideatial, mia. I2,000 sq. ft. lot area) and A-1 12,000, 9.P. {33ngle-
family residential, min. 12,000 sq. ft. lot area, Scenic Preservation
Overlay) zones generally located east of Highaap 74, sout6 of Homestead
Road, more particularly deacribed as:
APN 631-02-8, APN 631-03-1, 2, 3, APN 631-09-13, 14,
APN 631-11-1, 2, 3, 5, 7, 8, 9, 14, & 15
WIiE&EA3, said application has complied with the requirements
of the "City oP Palm Deaert Environmental QualfLy Proc�dure fiesolution
No. 78-32," in that the Director oP Environmental Services has deterroined
that thie pro,�ect aill aot have a aignificant efPect on the environment
and no furt6er documentation will be required; and,
�
&HEREAS, at said Public Hearing, upon hearing and considering
all testimony and arguments, if any, of all persons deairing to be heard,
said Planning Commiseion did tind the 2ollowing tacts and reasone to
exiat to reco�nend approval oY the Tentative Tract Map:
1. Tde sub�eet Tentative I�ap does aubstaatially compiq with
Chapter 26 of the Citp of Palm Desert Municipal Code, and
t6e State of Caliiornia Subdivieion Nap Act, as amended,
2. The aub�ect Tentative Nap does comply with the adopted
"" General Plan aad the Palm Desert Zoning Ordinance.
3. The aite is physically suitable for the type oP develop-
ment proposed.
4. The deaiga oP the subdivision and t6e proposed improve-
ments are not likelp to cause subetantlal environmental
damage or serfous health probiems.
NOM, THEREFORE, 8E IT RESOLVED by the Planning Coasmisslon of
` the City ot Palm Desert, as iolloWs:
1. That the above recitations are true and correct and consti-
tute the fiadings of the Co�isaion in this case;
2. That it does hereby require Lhat the ap�licant pay a #ee
in an amoant determined under the Ordinance provisions in order to comply
with Article 26.15 of the City's Subdivision Ordinance reqarding the
public facilitiea requirement;
3. That it does hereby recommend approval to the City Council
of the City of Palm Desert the above described Tentative l�ap No. 13008
for the reaeoas set forth in this Resolution and subject to the attached
conditions.
�..
L�r
PLANNING COMHI3$ION
RE90LUTION NO. 419 pa$e �
PA88�. gppROVED, and ADOPTED at a regu2ar meetiag of the Falm
Desert Planning Coannission, he2d on thia 31et day af October, 1878, �
by t6e #ollowing vote, to wit:
AYTsS: Berkeq, Fleshman, Ke21y, Kryder, 3nyder
��S� None
AB3ENT: None �
AB3TAIN: None �
� r1.(.Q,. � .
F R LY, Chairman
�
���..b�-^v
PAOL A, I 3, Secretarq
/ke
�
•,,,/►
�
rnl
�
PLANNING COIQ[I33ION
BESOLUTION N0. 419 Fage Three
CONDITIONS OF AppROVAL
`,. CABS N0. TT 13008
3tandard Conditions:
i. The developsnent of the praperty described herein shall be eub�ect
to the restrictions and limitations set fortL herein Which are ia
addition to ell municipal ordinances and State and Federai statutes
r,,, nom in force, or whfch 6ereafter roay be in force.
2. Full public improvementa including traific safety lighting as
required bq Ordinance and the Director of Public Works, shall be
installed in accordance with City Standards.
3. The tract ahall be subjecS to the payment ot drainage and signali-
zation feea as required by the Citq of Palm Desert.
4. The CC&R's for this deve2opmeat shall be submitted to t6e Director
oi Public Wor&s for review and approval prior to the issuance of
aap building permits. Prior to recordation oP the iinal subdivision
map, the applicant shall submit to the Director o4 Public Norks:
�r+
a. The docwnent to convey title.
b. Covenants and restrictiona to be recorded.
c. Hanagement and maintenance agre�ent to be entered into with
the owners of the units of the pra�ect,
5, Tmprovement plans for water and sewex� sqstem shall meet the require-
meats oi the respective serviae districts.
6. Area shall be annexed to appropriate Improvement Districts having
furisdiction over the eub�ect area,
�
7. All dedicated land and/or easements required by this approval shall
be granted to the City of Pslm Desert, wfthaut cost to the City and
free o! all liens and eacumbrances.
8. All on-site utilities, including cable TP, shall be placed under-
ground attd shall be completeip concealed from view except certaln
appurtenances as may be approved by the Director oY Eavironmental
Services.
`, 9. Complete plans and �pecifications ahall 6e submitted as required hy
Ordinance to the Director of Public Works for checking and approval
beiore co¢struction oi anq improvements is comnenced. The sub-
divider sltall submit '�as-built" plans prior to acceptance of the
subdivision improvements by the Clty.
10. In order to maiutain reasonable Lire protection during the construc-
tion period, the subdivider shall maintain passable vehicular access
to all buildinge. An adequate number oi fire hydrants with the re-
qu3red fire Plows shall be instalied as recommended by the Fire
Adarsha 1.
11. All requirements of the City Fire Marshal sha12 be met as part of the
developmept oP this tract per the attached letter dated October 23,
197$.
�
12. Drainage shall 4e subject to approval of the Director of Public Warks.
Applicant shall provide engineered data as requested.
13. The total number of lots shall be limited to 161 with a minimum area
of 12,000 sq. ft.
\r
14. The applicant shall have tmelve (12) months irom the date of the
approval or conditional approval of the tentative map for filing
oP the Yinal map unless aa extension of time of up to eighteen
(18) mont6s is granted by a Resolution of the City Council.
15. Applicant shall pay a fee in an amount determined under the drdinance
provisions in order to comply with Article 26.15 of the City's Sub-
division Ordinance regarding the public facilities requirement.
PLANNING COIdItI88ION
RTsSOLUTION N0. 419 Page Four
SpeCial Conditione:
1. Engineeriag caicalst3ons shall be eubmitted for all drainage
�tructures to substantiate the desl�n of the proposed open �
concrete channels.
2. The developer shall be respoasible for 3mprovements af oif-site
streets to upgrade their water carrying deaign, includiag the
inatallation of cross-gutters aqd swales, as required by the
Director of Public Aorks.
r
3. The deve2oper sha;l make a coatribution according to the �
signalizatloa Ordinance o1 t6e City oi Palm Desert in the amount
of $8,050.00.
4. The tract shall be bouaded bq a eix (6) foot high masopry wall,
as required by the Director of Bnvironmental Services. Said wall
shall be ot decorative character ad�acent to public streets.
5. Propoaed improvements, as expressed in Exhibit B, shall be in-
stalled ae part of the subdivisioa improvements.
6. App23cant to pronide acceptable easements to aecomodate draiasge
from 3ection D &c H oato the propertq.
9. Single easements shall be applied between lots, where appropriate. �
S. Mesa View ahall be Pully improved as part of the first phase.
a
�
�
>
�
�
�
PLANNING C�IIS3ION
RE30LUTION NO. 419 Page Five
�
°�►—��f; P,tVEP51L`E CdUNTY
�•r� } • FiREDEPARTMENT
.srJ� ��. IN C40PfRAT10N MfTM rl/E
� ('tiUVTY�:ig:
CALIFOpN111 OEPARrMENT OF FORHSTRY
e�rsxs�ris�;r.a`. pAWD L.FLAKE
� COUNTY FIRE WAFOEN
�� •�� ]IO MESt SAM JACMTO STREET
PERRIS.CAIIFORNIA 92370
T£I,EPMONE 171�1 65l•)7a3
Octooer 23, 197d
![z. Pau1 A. Nilliams
Dlrector of �viro�ental 3ervices
City of Palm besert
47-275 Prickly pear Lane
Palm Deeert, CA 92260 Re; Case No. '1"1' 13008
`" Dear Nr. Ylilliame:
Ae in the past, we requeat tbat approvai of thie tract be postpoaed untii aucG
time tqat the Ironwood Fire 3tation ie conatructed and oysrating. In tt�e event
the project ie approved ttie followit�{ are the fire proEectioa requlre�menta,
1. Inatall a water aystem capabla oY daliverl.c� 15IX3 (iPe2 fire Plon from aciy fire
tLydrant for a two hour duration ia eddition to domestic supp�q. The compu-
tacion shall be based upon s minimum of 20 psi reaiduai opersting preasure
in the aupply main fron +�hich the Piow ia meseured at the t}me of ineaeurement.
�" 2. Iaetail Rivereide County auper fise t�ydranta located at eacb atreet inter-
section (s) but not greater than 5p0 Yeet apart in a�qq direetion.
A. t:xLerior eurface of t�ydrent oarrela sud heade ohn7.1 be paiated cqrome
yellow, aztd the tope and naszle caye shall be paiuxtod green.
B. Curbe shall be painted red 15 feet in either directioa from each bydrant.
3. Prior tv recordation of the fina], mep, the developer shftll lurttish the originui
� and three (3) copLes of the Aater a�yat� plan to the Fire Harahal for review.
4. The Mater system plan ahall be si,gnca by a registered civil eagineer azid ap-
proved Dy the waLet� company, with the tollowing certiSicatinn: "I certiPy
thet the design oY the water ayatem in Tra�t 90. 13008 ie in accordance with
the requiremente preecribed Dy the Fire msrapai.^ Upon approval, the uriginay
plan will De recurned to the developer.
Yery LruLy yours�
DAVZD L. Ff,AKE
,Pire Chi.ef �
/ �/� / "
' �cz uj�;'{
... �_ r c,l�•{-:
.� ' David J. Ortegel
Fire Marehal
xld
�
r- •
Minutes
Pal� Deaert Flanniag Commission
October 31, 2978 Page Four
VI. PUBLIC HEARINGS (Coat. )
E. Case No. TT 13323 (Cont.)
Coaunissioner 3apder asked iY the Conditions of Approval on
the Development Plan would applp to this case. Yr. Crump noted
that thep wou1Q as indicated in Standard Condition No. 12.
On a motion by Commisaioaer Berkey, seconded bq Commiesioaer
Kryder, the C�iesion approved the Case by Planning Coc�ission Re- +�+r�
solution No. 418; carried unanimously (5-0).
F. Caee No. TT 13008 - COVE CON3TRUCTION CO., Applicant
8equest ior approval of s Tentative Tract Hay to
create 161 aingle-fami2y residential Iot$ on approxi-
mately 84.4 acres within the R-1 12,000 and R-1 22,000,
- 3.P. (Siagle-tamilq residential, min. 12,000 sq. ft.
lot area, 9cenic Preservation Overlay) zones generally
lacated ea.st oi Bighmaq 74, south of Homestead Road.
Yr. Nilliams reviewed the case and the Condltians o4 Approval.
He also aoted the concerna [lOt@d �A the previons related casea.
Commieaioner Snyder asked about DAesa View. Commissioner Berkey
asked if Conditioa No. 2 mae suYiicient. And, Chairman Kelly asked
it lot sizes met the requirements of the zoaing designation. 1dr.
Williama replied to these c�nceras that Condition No. 1 and 2 se�n
to cover the coacerns and that aome of the 2ots are larger and the
size on the emaller onea can be ad,�uated. Comnissioner Berkey
asked about the atatus oi the tire atatiott. 1(r. Nilliama stated �
that the City has the lsnd and the fire station should be under
conatruction by the end of the year.
Chairman Selly declared the Public Aearing open and asked i7
the applicant wiehed to apeak at this time.
ED ARIGHT, Pres. ot Cove Construction, atated that
he ieele that the drainege problems can be haadled
and that he agrees with the ataft's recommendations.
Chairman Kelly aeked if there was anqoue wishiag to speak in
FAVOR or OPPOSITION to the pro,ject.
ROSE FREELANDER, 48485 Praire Dr., noted her concern
with the drainage oa liesa View and Praire.
�r. Williama noted tLat Yesa View will be double width and
part oi it wili have a 16 foot median. He also noted that there wi21
be improvementa to the curbing so that the watar won't flow oato qards.
ltr. Mright aoted that the additional width o! the
street will allow for more water to be carried.
Chairman Kelly declared the Public Hearing closed and asked �
for the pleasure oP the Coamisaion.
Co�nisaioaer Kryder noted his concern with the drainage but
stated that the conditions shouid take care oi t4at.
Corrnnisaioner Fleshmaa atated tha.t cross guttera will not
haodle the situation on Homestead.
Idr. Beebe stated that moat of the atorm drains are short and
that the City will maintain them as the streets are public.
Commissioner Fleshtnan asked the applicant if he would provide
drainage easement on Section A, and he auggested that he make the
easement through one property instead oi two.
r •
Yiautes
Palm Desert Planniag Coo�ission
October 31, 1978 Page Ffve
VI. PUBLIC HEARINGS (Coat.)
F. Caee No. TT 13008 (Caat.)
br. Wright atated that there would be an easement.
Commissioner Fleshman also suggested that on Condition No.
4 the worda "decorative where appropriate" should be added.
+�.
ftr. 81111ame stgted that the stafP felt that cul-de-sscs were
better than a loop street.
Commiseioner 3nyder noted 6is concern with the western end oP
Homestesd not being a water carrying street. He stated tHat the
applicant ehould work with I[r. Beebe to solve these problema.
Yr. Wr3ght stated that the iirst pro�ect would create
• leas water.
Commiasioner Snyder stated that his concern 19 Lhe water that
could come domn and hit Homestead.
Co�nissioner �les6man asked iP street C could be turued and
dxain the otLer way.
�lr. Wright stated that this thought would also hold
true for streets H, C, & D, but Ocotillo would have
to be raised which would block the view of residents.
Commisaioner Fleahman asked that Seetion B be reatudied. Mr.
�Yright stated that he wou2d be glad to do this.
�"' Chairmaa Kelly noted her agreement with the conditions as pro-
posed aad aoted her confidence in ilr. Beebe to handle the probl�s.
1[r. Beebe aoted that the Commission ia approving a parcel map
not the hqdrology map as presented and that he doea not Want to make
a generalized statement.
Co�nissioner Fleahman stated that ltesa View should be 3mproved
as part of the Pirst phase, becauae of the fire station.
To cover the ahove poiats, the following conditions were
added�to the Special Conditiona:
Add to Conditioa No. 4 - Said wall sha21 be of decorative
character ad�acent to public streets.
New Condltion No. 5 - Proposed improvements, as expressed
in Eac6ibit B, aBall be iastalled as part oi t6e subdivision
improvements.
New Condition No. 6 - Applicant to provide acceptable ease-
ments to accomodate drainage trom Section D & H onto the pro-
perty.
;� :Iew Condition No. 7 - Single easements shall be applled be-
tween lots, where appropriate.
New Condition No. 8 - Nesa Viea shall be fully improved as
part of the first phase.
On a motion by Commissioner 3ayder, seconded by Coromissiooer
Fleshman, the Commission approved the case, with the additional condi-
t3ons, by Planning Commission Resolutioa No. 419; carried unanimously
(5-0).
RESOLUTION N0. 78-145
A RES�LUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL Of THE CITY OF PALM DESERT,
CAIIFORNIA, APPROVItlf A TEMTATIVE TRACT MAP TO CREATE A 161
LOT SINr,�f.-fAMiLY SUBDIYISIQN.
CASE N0. TT 13008
WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Palm Desert, California,
did, �n the 30th day of Nov�nber, 1478, hold a duty noticed Public Hearinq
to consider a request by COVE CONSTRUCTiQN C�lPANY for approval of a Tentatfve
7ract Map to create 161 sinqle-family residential lots on approximatety 64.4
acres within the R-1 12.000 (Sinqle-family resldentiai. min. 12,000 sq. ft.
1ot area) and R-] 12,000, S.P. (Single-famity residential, min.12.000 sq. ft.
lot area, Scenic Preservation Overlay) zones qenerally located east of
Hiqhway 74, sauth of Hanestead Road, more particularly described as:
APN 631-02-8, APN 631-03-1, 2, 3, APN 631-04-13, 14,
APN b31-11-1. 2, 3, 5, 7, 8, 9, 14, 6 15
tdHEREAS, said application has complied with the requirements of the
"City of Palm Desert Environmental �uality Procedure Resolution No. 78-32."
in that the Director of Environmental Services has determined that this project
wil] not have a significant effect on the environment and no further documentation
wiil be required; and,
WHEREAS, at said Public Hearioq, uoon hearfnq and considerinn a11
testimony and arquments, if any, of all �ersons desirinq to be heard, said City
Councit did f;nd the followinq facts and reasons to exist to recommend avproval
of the Tentative Tract Map:
t. The subject Tentative Man does substantially comp7y with Chaoter 26
of the City of Pa1m flesert Municipal Code, and the State of
� California 5ubdivision Mao Act, as amended.
2. The subject Tentative Map does comply with the adopted �eneral P1an
and the Palm Desert Zoninq Ordinance.
3. The site is physical)y suitable for the type of deve]opment �r000sed.
4. The desiqn of the subdivision and the proposed impravements are not
likely to cause substantial envirornnental damaqe or serious health
problems.
NOW, TNEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVEO by the City Council of the City of
Palm aesert, California, as follows:
1. That the above recitations are true and correct and constitu=e th�
findinqs of the City Council in this case;
2. That it does hereby require that the appticant pay a fee in an
amount determined under the Ordinance provisions in order to comnly
with Articte 26.15 of the City's Subdivision Ordinance renardina the
oublic facitities requirement;
3. That it does here6y approve the abave described Tentative Mao No.
. 13008 for the reasons set forth in this Resolution and subject to the
� attached condiLions: -
PASSED, APPROVED, a�d AOOPTEQ at a reaular meetinq of the palm OeserL,
California, City Council, held on this 30th day of November, 1978, by tMe
followinq vote, to wit:
!�
AYES: Brush, �IcPherson, Newbrander, Wilsbn � ullins
NOES: None
ASSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None �
1 �
• EDN RO D. MU LINS, MA R or
ATTFST: � � �/ ���5 . McPHERSON, MAYOR PRQ-TENPORE
, ,/ -f�{.e�'-.�,rC�-�c_,�����
� � SHEILA R. �ILLI�P.N CI7Y ��f.�K--
CITY Qf PAtt�t DES�Q�', CAL1 6R�!IA
_._ .. .. ..._ .._. .. _._
. t �
RESOLL'TIO:i NO. 78-145 ~ Page �ro "�- . � �
CONDITIO�S OF APPR04AL �
� CAS£ Nd. TT 13003
Standard Conditions:
• 1. The developr�ent of the property descrfbed herein shall be subJect
to the restrictions and limitations set forth herein whlch are in
addition to all municipal ordinances and State and Federal statutes
aow in force, or which hereafter may be in force.
2. Fu21 public improvements including traftic safety lighting as
xequired by Ordiaance and the Director o2 Public t9orks, shall be
'installed in accordaace with Citq Standards.
3. The tract shAll be subsect to the payment of drainage and signali-
zation lees as required bq the City o! Palm Desert.
4. The CC&it's Por this developmeat shall be submitted to the Director �
of Bublic {9orks for review and approval prior to the issuance o2
any building permits. Prior to recordation ot the iinal subdivision
map, the applicant shall submit to the Director of Public norks:
a. The documeat to convey title.
b. Coreaants and restrictions to be recorded.
c; Mana.gement and maintenance agreement to be entered into aith
the ouners oY the units oi the pro�ect.
5. Improrement plans for water and sewer system sha.11 meet the require- "
ments of the respective service districts.
� 6. Area shall be annexed to appropriate Improvement Districts having
jurisdictian over the subject area.
l7. All dedicated land and/or easemeats required by this approval shall
) be granted to the City of Palm Desert, without cost to the City and
Pree of all liens and encumbrances.
8. All oA-site utilities, including cable TV, shall De placed under-
ground and shall be completely concealed from view except certain
appurtenances as may be approved by the Director of Environmental
, Servfces.
•9. Complete plans and specifications shall be submitted as required by
Ordinance to the Director of Public SYorks for checking and approval
before construction of any improvements is commenced. The sub-
divider shall submit "as-built" plans prior to accept�nce of the
subdivislon imprarements by the City.
20. In order to maintain reasonable fire protection during the construc-
_ tion period, the subdirider shall maintain passahle vehicular aacess
to all buildings. An adequate number of fire hyc2rants with the re-
quired fire flows shall be installed as recommended by the Fire
Marshal.
11. All requirements of the City Fire Llarshal shall be met as part of the
development of this tract per the att¢ched letter dated October 23,
� 1978.
12. Drainage shall be subject to approval of Lhe Director�of Public CVorks.
• Applicant shall provide engineered data as requested.
I3. The totul number of lots shall be limited to 161 with a minimum area
of 12,000 sq, ft.
14. The applicant sh�ll have twelce (12) months Prom the date of the
approval or conditional approval of• the tentative m3p• for tiling
oi the final map uniess an estension of time of up to eighteen
(18) months fs granted by a Resolution of the City Council.
15. Applicant shall pap a fee in an amount determined under the Ordinance
.prorisions in order to comply with Article 26.15 of the City's Sub-
diyision Ordinance regarding the public facilities reqvirement. '
. � .- � � r r .
RESOLL"f IO,T N0. 73-I45 Page Faur
� .
i rw—��• p.IVE?510E CCUHTY
1 I�' rr
��� .l. -s".. �,7�4:; fIP.E DEPAP.TMENT
�'� ' IN COOPERATION W1TM TNfi
' ��'COI.'\'7Y�'•:''�4j..
��q,,1�� ' " '�';K�_: CA�.Ii01�N1A OlPA117M[NT OF FppESTRV '
. Rtrt•x»rifi..;r..., Dnvi�L.FLAXE
� COUNTY ftRE WAFO£N �t0 wEST S�N J�CENTO S7REET
, —� PERRIS, CALIPORNiA 9237�1
• ._...-
. TEIE�'NONE (71�1 637•)1S�
October 23, ly7d
Mr. Paui A. 4lillia�a •
Director of r,'hvironmeaLal Servicea
Cieq of Pala Desert
47-275 Pr±�k1y Pear Leae
Ptla Desert, CA 92250 Re: Caee No. T'P li�d
Dear �:r. Williaas:
Ae in the past, we request that app:oval of tais tract be nostpoaed until such
tias thaL the Ironwood Fire Stati�a is co:struated azsd ope:ating. In tne eve.:t
the pro�ect ia approved the fallo��i.iyg a^e the fire prnteetion reouireceats.
1. Install e r+eter system capaole of de;iveri:.g 15Q0 GP'.1 fire flow from any fire
ty�cr2nt for s two tiour dtsation ia a3diti3on to donestic aupp�. The aoey�-
ta:ivn shall be baaed upon a ei�:ac of 20 pai resi3ual opersl:.^g pressure
in the auYply main �ro� which the :_o�� ia measur�d gt tihe time of ine•�s•„��c�t. '
�1 2. Ir.stall Riversi3e County aupe: Yire h;/dransa located at eech stseeL i^.ter- �
1 sectioa {a) but aot greater t�aa 500 Yeet agart in a^.y direction.
A. Exterior surface of t�ydrant tsrre'_s ana hea3s shall be peiated chrooe
yellow� and the tops sn3 noza:e caos shell be pelntrea grsen.
B. Curbs shall be paintad rPd 15 ;eet i^. eicner directian Pro� each h;;nreat.
3. Priar to recordatioa oi tha fi�al map, the developer shall tur_is� tee or:_3ir_�� _
' a:.d ttree (3) copies of tce wa.er systej plan to tae Fire �4s=saal for re•r_aw. �
4. She water system plan scall be si�:.ed o;{ a registere3 civil er�gi�eer a.-�� ap- 1
proved oy tae watier conp9uy, with tne followi.*� certiificatinn: "I car�i:y '
tc.a� Lhe deaign oY tiae wa:,er systea :n :ra�t do. 13008 is in acccraanca w_ta
zhe requ+r;ants pre�cribe3 by tne Fire Karsaal." Upon aporaval, tce or:3ira1
plan •rrill be retura�d to the developer.
Verf truly yours, '
DAYID L. FLARE
,Fire C�ief
• -. , . . �CG-L��-�t� �.�- . I
. i�
� l+ - Da'r1d J. Ortegel •
Fire 96arshal
_._..via - - :..:-..- �
�
RLSOLUTION N0. 78-145 Page Three
5�ecial Conditions:
1. Engineering calculations shall be submitted Sor all drainage
structures to substantiate the design of the proposed open
concrete channels.
2. The developer shall be responsible #or improvemeets of off-site
streets to upgxade tbeir �ater carryfng design, inciuding the
installation oP cross-gutters and swales, as required by the
Airector oP Public Works.
3. The developer shall make a contribution according to the signali-
zation Ordinance of the City oF Palm Desert in the amount of $S,Q50.00.
4. The tract shall be bounded by a six (6) �oot high masonry wall,
as required by the Director of Environmental Services. Said wa12
shall be of decorative character adjacent to public sLreets. _
5. Proposed improvements, as expressed in Exhibit B, shall be installe
as part of the subdivision improvements, except sidewalks shall be
provided on both sides of �esa View Drive.
6. ApplicanL to provide acceptable easemedts to accommodate draina�e
from Section D & H onto the property.
?. Single easemeets shall be applied between lots, where appropriaLe.
8. uesa View Drive shall be Pully improved as part of the Pirst phase.
I
�
EXHIBIT "B"
�
�i: � 3t_� :: t i
� _ ci� _;:^� =�M:F `}�; �3j� �6�d
• ��y '#s�� ; :? �
aaF I
� � ` �f' _=rf�' �i ���° `':i r_ �� 91 �
..,. �� x
`�5 �s �� -'=�`a . g � �:;�� =
� _ � ;: „ ._=; .. ._ , � :,;� ;
h � _' '�T_.. � `s�=�_ � : '` ` _ '' _i.��, i
_ �g ��. ' , ;�:! -
'�'.;:� � � � _ ' 'k��
� � ,�°=�n i�«' ' ' . a r"_t , � �ds�
� � a ,'�ei�� � ���'��� .c.i �; " �t�
�;�� . : +_a � . �a;x»K� �c '� _. � z �ita
�I:.;._ € � � ;r•: =t�;;�� ��� , - ��� g -�
.:� � a .`I � i ~� �
's S� Y � ��
rx .�„i : 'aa x� ;ayi � a . �=
SR�` _ �6�7I .1�= : : " �
..FlB - .:iS_. zS� �+ ��«
,. �rs� _ "aF^3i : _��� � a " � ° �
:u�sr�� - __:��,; ; , � a e € � "s r
� p % • 1� R�P
. • � t` i�•
..��� is� y �! •" �: ��€ I
g� 3�� ; �, 6= � _ ; _ a: : - ,. , �;-
=t. - >s, ; , ,a��� W� _; � 'L� r I
'=�=.� #�� '� _ �!�.�5 '��� � �' �x �' :I �:
� - . ��� � ,:�p^ r: = ru"aa"a
i �¢�Yry~ . i �=_#"' !, ' ���.� raC.� � ;�..• t ,; -� .;e.
b =¢f�'�= __ �?� �; - ;i:�' 'Y�g�� Yi.:► f �, `-S �
r-. ��„
; � � :,'� : . = - .
�i � �ig���� �t- ��;r:s � . : rT��= - €�:o����"� $�:' �` ra�
� _ . • °- . _3ip'-j� ~' =�tl�� i' � � �'�
O�� �: *�����:� �Qj��'1^ __ °Y3rS'€��° ����!'. �C�a !� ��W
�•- �' "� _ a_.�i�z •a_ � a. _ , �
: s:3:.�: � -. gr#5�� _ �r�� �s=5 n- e��i�:� a e •r�a
� � � : -s :� .. ' ��as - ! -s��tc.��s s�V. �a,�= .. R'�
M y �_��c�= • _ ':_�� :�. s '''-'=_3s�t;x��:�=��: =��' _ ��i
��— � ea� . :reY��: � -r; ��=' ==,.o, ���
Q ��Y r� � s, ��'� . Y:���$ g@�^�r� f `.Cc �
}..� i Y��- � d'_ �.� ` �i��"l� '�2 � �ff� _ � d
��Ug�O ` L�.'3��� ' - E: es. p67Y�'����i�����w ,i �• - ��
, �� =�� # :f��t` �= r e� l�.s �Fi.�p g.�'..1�� ` w�
�2Q ,; }: *�E3S�}; � _ ��'s �r� _ ,�:�' " rx��"g'g �:.��.i�X=a•.qs- � : _
����� = _4« 2 «.i� 6E_�tE�S�"S�:r���+g:���.8 `„ E ~ •
��f,,,.�«� : �'�_
F, M
2 �ix3 � � ..
,
_r �: �� • �a " , � -
_��� � = as - .,; ': '-Q �;:i'" a# 'I xgaE
, ; "-J •}� _ _ '; - = R{� �:a``• .� ���:i
� r - 3 _ �: € . :s - Et�i
. .�a . . ,__ �� __ � :r,yy.� _ - = c '+�;` s
F7 ;, ' - . " � .7. � .p •� 1`L=i t
Q '� (I' " jf j �I•� ,;:� }�� ZI ai .
a :q • 'F7'VI:; ' '_ �i - \ i.� ' . �' -� !� •i�� �
��:i}�- . =�� #� �=� -_ = _ .. _ _ :���� �fF: ���r E :;� f-_
s=,::.-.- .-af _ - - �- : - : r=s;�• '�'_� 'k�
=:�.' - �:�i - .�� - , � ,� _ �, = ;r ��=1' �- '�F�IC ,. �;t',�=x� ����,r
--- 'C� r � - --- �� .., __ z:
_ :3c _ <�k j� _ � �.;� �� - i•�5 -'z:�,'t. �I ;� ��'�`��;3� ���L�f
:I� - �a�� �JS � 'rr �Y_}� � �� _ � ''• '� �� :� �`�=Ol� ��
��T_ t�. 'V � �I'� � -) �I ' -�� .���• fgl � ���
#Kii�`S 5" F�:A'X . .. •-. �- Y: '! i ' i�3'i:' . �i�
. _ ._-. * . _'s
_._.-----� -- -�.•.-'---�---�-•+'.�---
_' q
^'��.���Z�i �
� ^ � # ' �° a:
' _ �-�
�f
� y a ��e ��.y�C
Q
� t
a - �.� � :� �� .�`����g }�
� ��"' �}���� ��'�4�°= r
i
�
f 1 � ��'�
F� � i��F`i M � ��� ��g
�`� ' ��a���e� ti
..00 a
' ��
s�
r� ' -i:
�� �
_
�� -_.�t•.__ ....,�,,�----�
_�__
1 F r •��` �;� ^
'�Y; � �s 3
�� g;; �� �� •
� a
��d� ��° � �a �
� � tiw<«.».ws....o�.•... : c
dib i r.Np watn.
���,�.��f�----,�,�c�"� �E ! ! ! # A ■ ae ee ��
g i� q � � :� 8C! / • 's � 1F i
� " �� 2 R � � � � 33 d � !
p i �� a
=i1 7 ;i�� N Y t oM�a ii.� U , ! � s , �s!
� � � « � r • r s � � � , . .,.w.�. � ,� ��°
1
> +• •.Cw'7tFn"'� . 7=
� 3 � • . � � s r t . ' � ! � t � t� �� ' ;lIG
� D�a i � � ■ �"� � • • � ! ! ! ! � � y,i'�� J ftl�
' � �{ M • i � —_ —
r� � 6 �i�� S. I . p ; � R • t � • ■ .u��y�� �w.�w � R�y
��' =�
�� , n � i � �.�.�� i t
p ? _ • s p • S� �i �Fr
�'�� i d e s R � 'r a� �sy , �
�jio1� � ''� ,� � s �� � � �� ��7 � 1
��� ��� r = � ►� w � � Lit�i�l� �iY • _`���
�: �~vR � � '+ R R !�/J��f „�� ,J �� �et��
a�� �tr _�r, _ �_aa_��se_�C y� `�1�•
F.,,,o bq —�ewr---- . ' ..n u�.w�
� � ; � •� :�
� �
: ��� : +� N � ,� ..
��a; �E,� ��E � � � `_'� � � yt ���
��� ;��s � ��� � - �t ��
t= 3��'.�1 ' ; . ° z�' e :e°!
��� y-��b� ,"�, � ;� �; qT s: r.,sw �
P?d� e��'F�a ��t �S� aY,�t cv �e'al ti f
��� �� }���
s i
'��� ea:i ea� t ��
tllie
S,� s;-i g
��� e2CiE }
::;i �
—`_ `� � j 1 `
50 - . .41�if1 MdG.K•IN--— �
«P/ M�Oi.14��� �O L� } � � �
..— 'dOLui _� 1�OL�1' '_' � � .1t iLi '� "� ; � ! 7
'�•<r.<c •c,es, + �y�, a i� Q � `' d
•`.4 = •o R� —� . �'�'�• ` �'�s
� fa:� a,�
`''� �€
►}}�
. .,f
--�7Z�
� x�M r.+u�. r—
n
� c " � �� �
� � Y'! �� � M � M
W N �� ��]� '
� �ir���7i� t ,
�q�1 • 4
� � � � . ��.� 011' � ��
���aaaa�.��a , -- � �' �K-�—�-�-��
. ��aa�...ia��� ��^ ' :l �.
���������� � � N• �
� � ��� " � -
�azasesssaaax
� l:��i='�a�� �I �'`�
�r ���p��3���� N
� �
� � �
� ��i�i70ai��� �� a �~ N '
M'�
$ ������������ ��
�
�_..�......��eev �f ; ^� �
� �1 ti N
N � F
�3 � a , �
�f W ��' � ti � 1 �
2 a � �e �� � �
Q �� ���� ��y qH N 1 �[,�i� - �
K/�, i e ^
^� i � a� � N u'!
r i��� }� � �` b
O�a : t
� � � b ���s ._ �'
� ]: M M�.11.�. 4� N.
O i
N��� � �/ N
� � � � \ 1/'J •
� � � �
��U��'� r �
�� ��4 � � � � .q�
l Q y
����$Q4 f R �� M'�i� a rn� ar`trd'
Y�
� �
�, E'..a„� � � ��, 'P t
pt �y�,, a �
2 E} .a i �i • ..
�1�"'� E � s, ' !f
� � K �
9 k
g �°':��, � � � `/— �\
..\ p ' M�� � ��� A
�� 1'�`� �� � �+ �
� �"� nv" (y� a1L�eis ��` "'� � �
�� ��Mdq9 � �
�r �H 6wT S �
���..j w�r,�p��
'J A �' ..
� �c�1 s�,.a�, f
�� �� .
x� �''�+'4::.�,, - w
xx
g_a � � �
1 t+� ```�\
Z �O
r
�
� _..r p I�f
� � �� iN
n9
�_- � M � p � �
^ � � � �
� 9I.�C�Q I1 � MM
� niva�p T- �wr-ii�—'�-- �
� ( ( �� �N1A S��p . . r�K� m
� a 111��C11������ r � 1 �
-. f
�,��'s��f���1; .Q°i� � �
� � - �
I �
# ::l�i���1ii �� �
� t��������� , �� ,�
�AJfAlIM1�1111;AA � � �
�i�i��±����l� � � � � Z
�#9i�7 i�i�i� 1 ,
i��i��a���l� � � g ,
������������ � � � �
> �
�a�,�,..:.pa� , e
�
a ����3:�a�� � �z�F
�� ��3������ � � o �.
�'� �~ q������l� � R�P C N �
� � i f` a.q ) I v
� `M `k a _rk_. 7 , �
W �i�Li����� f s tR
�2 � �.. ..w�.��'.t� Y�'f � 1� s i �
��� '�, � b F t
� ��� � d � � � �
� � � 4 � N f �
T�q y� �
� , � � �
��� � l io A�
�i�a .a� �'^�r'n, MYMII
� a �
�2 ��� ' '�a' R � �^
��� �v� �� / � �` �
,� �--•�°� �� _ br /� �
a � w x
r
�2+Y� Jt�'�aU�' ~ <
� -; »
�i� � � r �� �i
� '`�` � �
� � � N �•
o. ^1�`�� �
� � ` '
�,. ��\
� •�a
� �` � . �
� • � �
� � �
�••- � p p. �K 6tL � • F�s
Y ,n , i
� Yr� ��J�`�o �
�. p .
I �
v Z .
�"f aj s��v10l s�N� � � �,.
y� b�`��.svM . d {�
� � �
1�� �ol� `"•�,,:, r �
7 V�� ' �� � E'
- � aa� �'. � C
C D •���� i � �
��_tii
.
-- �
� � --�-��
y� �r S�1 �� 1
O �
� tl W �
N � 8 S 19iM�, af$ ��K �
�
W w�« b
--�'� "�r r' t�
•; Y � D E�
� ,�
` f
�o �o N v�i " L
�"� ��+ � �I 1�
• i
�� � A �A1 _ '4 ; Ma ��
� e 8 ��n A�,�►vn—m:aa,�i;--• f
� «»
� r
—� 1 .
�T � � � o� I
�r � I
m a�o a°Oo� E I � �+ n-� .
„ ..�wz J�� �.�� � 1 1 �r,et�..r_ --
,� — — --
� � � � YId�1� � M'Nt iN.11M� `�
— �__•_^ -- iYNwMI�1IJ�Wsf1YM��!
4 $ � � �� ...,�,r'«"'�"".'r""a "�'.1'$
�� ' � � � ��a"3 � �'� �
Z� d � �
��o, k ,a � i�l �,�Z3��ii�'�'���3�oa�o���y�:�s���
� #! � � »» �.�Y�'� � �.9�1�7ai.Q���S�:��i���r iiK�i
� * �� � � ��a-#�—;- q t
p9� ��N�� ` � ;-M x y ` �� � � 1 iiiiiiZ��aa�.k.�k�l�ii�li�1
r� � � € z � � �� �����������������k��e�������•
�x � ti� Wr,� � �"'^'�� ��Sa9tOEOlt!l�C�19f\�POi
S �p _'
8 � 7 � t'11 � �
l�t��"„� �
ap I � �
a��8��* � � �{Q , � ��
y� �
R ,aM� � ' a� Y
Z �<:� �ru a'" -�-- I � R��i [s ..
~ ��� M MR �1
� � �e�
� z `: . .i
�� oo �
.,. � .4
, , � r �
P � � � e
a � � �
� s � m i �i ��
�� � ti � � �
(x *i '.., ±� o.f,� �� �'�r'! �'� �.
pfP , I q. � � `�A 1 .t ' ��.q�s'y' `
�'/ t I - ¢ PJ � —�
~ rr " N` � d Y n�at �::.r.�. m�s �..�s.w..- �
� S'� : A � '�y ms �-� �Yn
` y f
$ '"�� a ���
�cti,ha�,'�`w a�s� � � �i
SfNy � $ .��;-
� �#��
--�,,,�--�—
— � .,
� ����593�3�D»'_'�i�a"3
� i�9��03�9��i����9:��!
--�z� !iiiiii:i�������#i:i
� � �������������������
u �- •••'•-'�seee:¢Ye�e
A
� H�if� LNAMI� 1��
1 r N ry N f�v N
7 Q
S T'
.oa n� � � �
1 �� _ � y�
� u a IJ
�� ���
k o�. ��—iAtYQ ^��MitA iQ�'M6 7t
�
�
�.[ � � m � t1 `v � '* `.`r� �
C R! _' � ++ r' %� "—' n
. �
N �
$ I � �i� ' N
R$ � 5 � m
�tt � g �; +
R r M ^ ^
;' �� � w
� � � ^ w
y .' .� �
W��' �� �` ! � _� ����
� �§b � ' _ gr�r?�---,� '„°`-.+a' -�''„,: ,pw a � �a "'"
� � g�X � ` �� ��
— � R � r ,. "
� , � � R�� � } �A�
'� � � ^ �— M i
p � � rt � '� I
�OV��p�� ,w ^r � � •r Y�� — _.
Q j�� Fu I� � � `
��•a��"'.,�. � �, h�� � ; .,�,.u...,-.
� �i �
a „ .�,. � �• �
� �—•��� � .�,,, ` � � � ------i .
� � � � ' �
z �_ � °� �� ` � '
2 i r � i va ,n �
���e m ^ h � �'i i �' � f R�
•r.� > �, , i i - �
�� ma � � �
�y b � � f
�t I t( u.a�� '��1C �I � k� rn o[
i� .
Y h ��
t 6 �� �
�
� •i� ^ �n .o e� P `I �
�� in v> � �� � �'I
� ,b� , _ �� � �
� '
.���,� L a ' a♦ oJ
,d! � ♦� �
i.
��y�� � ��� � !i�
�.��fJ � �s�# 6 la�HB aas � � �
v p�R
ao
� -- —
a
� '
�
�
n "�'�7Z�
�
�a�S�'�g��=
# '��9ai���i
x 1 i7i:s::��
� ��������
,_ ..,._
...r IINf� VIi411
� � �
OI �
�'V • fV N � r N .—. ^ �
i� ;
� k
, �
' s � .,►{,,,, .��usd• �,p
�"g •�, —��A�T'T 3111110 MiM A4VNbb�— —
D�a b _... a�o � �
� �
� � � � 3 � ^ � = ^ _� �
�� � � o!
�- t� �
��V���b �
'�tiQ��� J�� I r'm ►Nx.�
�����4t � �
�~ ' � {/�
� �,qHS � �I O � � � � O�
? �i��` AS R � � � r
� � � � €
� � . � � ; ,, _ �__
�--=�,�d � _ ' --�:-----�
s b b niv �wivoN'« -- �
m
; � v
W Y� � I v
N �� � � o p ^ o �
R
�� 1 •' •
� $ i._s '
� •Wt { y �yy�yp� A'M u1.MN a N
� ( � �yypwW��N�1�WIMW�MT/!.\�
U I ;
�� i �
��� i �
�r o.� .
��e � t
oa
EXHIBIT "C"
E�►HIBIT "D"
Christina Baine Dejardin
Subject: RE:The Summit Storm Drain Maintenance-adjacent to 48521 Olympic Drive
From: Mary Ann Anderson [maiito:marvannandersonCa�me.00m]
Sent: October 14 14 4:02 PM
To: Wendy Zumwalt
Cc:Anderson Mary Ann;Ande�son Terry
Subject:The Summit Storm Drain Maintenance-adjacent to 48521 Olympic Drive
Hi Wendy,
I've sent a short note to the City of Palm Desert asking that they not "abandon" us and our storm drain
maintenance. We have one of those storm drains on the entire East Side of our property. There are several trees
(on our neighbors side)which of caurse shed into the drain.Additionally,the entire Olympic Drive-seven
homes- send irrigation water and debris several times a day down the cul-de-sac street into the storm drain
creating smelly black sludge and standing water. I have cleaned out the drain myself-taking sacks and sacks of
stuff out and putting it in the garbage. I tried using a hose to clean what remained but when that failed the city
sent some public workers right over and cleaned the drain.They told me to "never" attempt to hose it down
again or I wauld be fined. The public workers were very professional,prompt;taking less than half an hour to
clean the entire drain, and repea.ted the process one day without even being called. I was very impressed with
their work. l'm saddened and fivstrated to think that I'd have to take on the task of keeping that awful black
water and dirt cleaned up. (Last winter the sludge was so thick the water wouldn't drain through at all.)
Thank you for whatever assistance you can give and I will try and attend the City Council's meeting.
Mary Ann Anderson
maryannanderson me.com
48521 Olympic Drive, Paim Desert, CA 92260
760-895-5082 cell
760-895-4442 home
i
Christina Baine Dejardin
Subject: RE:Storm Channels
From: C. Geraid King �maiRo:cakinq3Cc�yahoo.com]
Sent: November 071411:06 AM
To: g�.yhallCa�c' of��lmdesert.or�
Cc:Aurora Sanchez
Subject: Storm Channeis
Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council
City of Palm Desert
I own a residence at 48-601 Valley View Drive in the Summit development. We bought the home in
1997 and shortly after we moved in, we observed the storm channels weren't being very well
maintained. But after a phone call ta#he city maintenance department, they quickly came, cleaned
out the channels and have done a decent job of regular maintenance since.
1 am very disappointed to learn that the channels may not be maintained by the city in the future.
Since the channels are an easement on my property for the city, 1 feel strongly they should continue
to be maintained by the city.
This is very important to me since we are only part time residents and depend on the city tv see that
large amounts of runoff don't inadve�tently damage our property when we are not there.
Respectfully,
C Gerald King
i
EXHIBIT "E"
EXHIBIT "F"
Oc�ober 10,2bf4 � . .
Myi tmme is At�rt Kap�ri+a�Al�t K�t Pnol S�ir:e in p�m L�. I ttavo�searvic�d end maintait�t Roois in
77ie S�rtrr�E d�r�loprrner�f�tt�taat s0 y�s�rs.
i n'�irrta�ted'the poo!8t�$7'2�t North Yie�n►iAr for Ha�v�n�u and t'�is w�e iur a�at Ye�"s I�o�e they.
ntoved out ofthe area in Feb��f4. The �
pr�partjr i�no�v 3n fcx�clo�.,�.
1 wa�ptoe,Sent wtteC�the�dlogged(�i[Y a�P�n Qes9rt dradrtage d�amet betlind'then'hOme arid the C�ty ir�c�rt
on the�jr ee�ne�otti the�pnoperty �oe�'Howred irt the�ig r�r�Omt vf Augt�t 2U�13. 1 a�v wa�r pot+�'
th�1#he backy�d'frozn the t�i.y dr�age d'�aei clowrt the st�eps a�'td irr��e� liuing rt�am. 1 af�o
s�w tt�e waber rtm th�gh tl�eir yerd ar�ri cia�n i�ttr�t,�tt f�telr sGde yar+d ir�bo'!ha�e rif t�e Mpn�m
ree�noe�728g1 Spy�i.n. [sgw�e M�r�alstmms�roov�eGng mud twE of the���w,�r
9ar�e v�h�. !de�ned the m��d aet a#the�ctiescu pool,�ed the pod�d clesned t#�e
D��S��sno�m.
Nk��t�Fbod Tecfi c.�mp�y to c�1 up�er the flooc�rrg but he c�d not!�e t�tent b6c���e
estlmate w$s t+�oo higt�.
i al�a�in oth�'poo�s on�ilr snd Veltey View fhat baadt c��o the�e ct�els.
O+rer fhe y�e�rs 1#�v�e�w�t ec��a c�x�'ircm 8i�horn#�h tt�e 10 t�ole�in ttie Swrnnit Pe�te�s�
v�rali beh�nd 4872i Trlortl'e lAeNr Dr whene�thera ts a tieavy ra�Lprr1R. Tt�e troie�s ere�c�r+�y b��rul the
���'�t��them az�d goe�irt#o tt�e c�7el and U7�c�a�n w�r1 we t�ne �
!henre�so seen t�.y m�cxae�rs caeen tm the ct�at�'�e�s�arer�e yea�s. 1�tn►�n ctean the
drau�ge d�emels�eyer�}ttmes in t�e 1�'s and tha 199(Ts but rtot�r�oerrt y�er�
�#Captan �
..���...����; .
76(}:2�$-5609
Christina Baine Dejardin
SubJect: RE:The Summit Storm Drain Maintenance-adjacent to 48521 Olympic Drive
From: Mary Ann Anderson �mailto:mervannanderson(a�me.coml
Sent: Octol�r 14 14 4:02 PM
To: Wendy Zumwalt
Cc:Anderson Mary Ann; Mderson Terry
Subject:The 5ummit Storm Drain Maintenance-adjacent to 4852101ympic D�ive
Hi Wendy,
I've sent a short note to the City of Palm Desert asking that they not "abandon" us and our storm drain
maintenance. We have one of those storm drains on the entire East Side of our property. There are several trees
(on our neighbors side)wiuch of course shed into the drain. Additionally,the entire Olympic Drive-seven
homes-send irrigation water and debris several times a day down the cul-de-sac street into the storm drain
creating smelly black sludge and standing water. I have cleaned out the drain myse3f-taking sacks and sacks of
stuff out and putting it in the garbage. I tried using a hose to clean what remained but when that failed the city
sent some public workers right over and cleaned the drain.They t�ld me to "never" attempt to hose it down
again or I would be fined. The public workers were very professional, prompt;taking less than half an hour to
clean the entire drain,and repeated the process one da.y without even being called. I was very impressed with
their work. I'm saddened and frustrated to think that I'd have to take on the task of keeping that awful black
water and dirt cleaned up. (Last winter the sludge was so thick the water wouldn't drain through at all.)
Thank you for whatever assistance you can give and I will try and attend the City Council"s meeting.
Mary Ann Anderson
maryannanderson(a�me.com
48521 Olympic Drive, Palm Desert, CA 92260
760-895-5082 cell
760-895-4442 home
�
�ctober 19, 2014
C+ty vf Palm Desert:
Palm Desert is a aty to be proud of. This is due, in part, to the exoellent care
from the maintenance crews that work to see#hat the vegetafion is trimmed, the
streets are paved and the public areas kept free of dutter.
When we moved to ti�desert marry years ago we chose to buy a home in Paim
Desert We were attracbed by its neat appearance, parks and
shopping, the lack of contention amor�the city councit and willingness to listen
to citizen concems. My husband and I have been residerrts since 1977 and have
resided in our current home in The Summit since1986.
When we bought our house it had a cement drainage channel that ran the length
of our backyard at the top of our embankmen#. We were told it was part of a flood
control easement owned by the city and they would be responsibte for its
maintenance. In the twenty-eight years we trave lived here we r�al!only two
instanves where we saw evidence that someone from the c�iy had cleaned the
channel, and this was in the la#e 1980's.
� We, ourselves, have worked to keep the area cleari of leaves, mud and other
debris that accumutates in the channel. This has been quite an investment af our
fime and effort, espeaally sinoe our propertjr is the higl�est point and apex to the
channel.
Tv add to our labors, Big Hom Deveiopment dug a hole in our fence, authorized
by-the aty, to let water and debris drain from their neighborhood. Every time
there is even a moderate amourn af rain, or when they water extens�vety, we are
le�t with a muddy mess next to the hote. We were totd the opening woufd be
upgraded;we were even shown drawings of a structure that wouW be instalied to
help channel the water.This has never been buiit.
It is disturbing that Paim Desert has not lived up to their responsibility. They were
quidc to grarrt an e�ensive developmerrt permission to drili a hote in our wait to
permit water and mud to flow from their property into our yard. Yet they do not
appear to care how it af�ects the homeowners whose yard it broaches.
I offer my support to the homeowners in The Summit who have brought their
conaems a�ut this problem to the City.
Kathy Bjork HYPERLINK "maiito:kbjo67C�3yahoo.com" kbjo67@vahoo.com
72631 Spyglass Lane
Palm Desert
r'� ` •
f ' ' �I/ ' -�, ..•
- Ga7NYRY' Gwf oWvi
�' I � � '
�� I _ ' I X
� • • �
��
:� -__C-��i-..�i_ _ ':. ..
�I� � � �� � � -- .,�;��-
,;�_..,�._.____-- . � ,- . r.. , .� .
� ,
..�',� . � - PM 13 33 .
';\ IY�NM�t
''�! �.� • 131 MP Y
.!+ . •�...�_,�` $
'.i� i •`.5j. •• �
' �-,.�.._.�„-- j' _ .__ - -~ �,
:._;;; ; ,�, �.--.:.. _ �.-
, =o.-- . ;_�L ¢� ` oo«■.
�'^ � ,� wur
JI '__'c_"_ I"fOSL, .��7� ��_ I .
�.•__-'�` - ���pa{T'�' 1 - • .f . - - { ` _ �
' 1� 1 o e i � • `
CYP %'�\ �j: .�., {.. � .• ,� 1- -
f�''7a� � !i� j �,. 12ounc ar r � --
_ � w . r �rr[a�nn , �• ���
. .�. ;
.
� �
!i IOIG �� i - � . ,,.,—.^-,r l i+ .._� � �"' �_^ — =
.
.- .......�....
, : ..�. " ' .;�..... .':... ._„ '-= -
. ;� ;..'j �,:. =I_..•y.._ ;'• L -; .� � . pM� _ �_. , !.
;�' F � c _.; : � il
'I` PM I �? 'x��LLJ •� / J ',��^ ^ . '� ! � ,�
IB �� � �� ..y:;. �i �I
_ ��. —:ri. j _ 1 �
. �I � �U: J •::I.�i�.. NM1:^.npM }Y�.y/•�• '��
:. 4uY � -,i.l� 1
� ..,., �• � L� Y r� . �
; ' � _,=:.� _ �� ,:��.�� �. .,i.�.:..:.�' L�
I _ - _ : � :,✓_,....,. _ .. - .
Y" :�+ i ,'t r'��.~��+: i.
--� , - . . ._. ,?�'�w,�_ ri _ � l�"' ^ __ __ _ .� �_
. . . :: ';:. ;-, : _:,,' ...... . �--^ ;:.:. ,.�.
I . ' '�• 1 :.� � :c..�' ' -_ - r�_-- i
. :+ � y'"�,� ,��t� -�`, 1
� . . TT133Z\\' _ _,_ � - . �
i . . ._� �•`�_ �-..__..�•. .... ', : ;_. ,,� �
� �._,�. .-----��� �T,..�. �
_1 k �. r'�-:` �N<<
;-e .=-�' •9° �
i----�--:._: ,� ��-,:��- �.F�` ._ _�'•'. 5'r' I '
� : . � --- / -isf•����` �r 't a ' '
� -- - IZ!NF , ,�, _ ,�� ?
: � , _. •.., /�
- -�r-� /• .�__•-•� /
� . � . ._' i! - �_::::� ':... �...,:t,-:>ej�� i
' . " _'� �k - - t .� �' ;.. I
'�'i7� «:._...�y-,�� .6'
COP o7�.77 - -- ..:��'+....�c:'c..�..T=...-.;.r.�. �.x J/
!�{O MF i' ' ...•..�•'�''� '��M ' �
i j,, _ �i1� �A��..;�''�»...r. J�l `' i
�!%4 � ��3DOd %-"��/` ;
�I � r� �' .� �\•.:� � :i , � :I:
.ti �_ti �.t ;.
i
� !` "� �� • �:�,L' �ti! � �Is
..:s.nt^':' ... �(�
�,;
�-- '.'^'^�Z�` � �
� �
"_ . �ryC. f14�y' 4\ . .
' `j�+��` ..�e" �� `�� �'�'�
/ j
EVERY TWO MONTH
. � DRAIN �HANNEL MAINTENANCE SCHEDULE
Equipment�tools required: Truck No. 79 or 04, Shovels, brooms, hedge trimmers (in some iocations),
wheel barrel. You will need to use the water truck in some locations.
Month: ��ZO��
Locations Date Com leted Time R uired Crew
Mesa View
48-601 Valley View / '" Z -/ - S
Olympic&Spyglass _- �i . � , l
Siiver S ur Ranch
At the cal-de-sack on Feather Trail east
of Silver S urt Trail �� '"��"/� � �� 5�",�- �
Silver Spu�before the round about both p o� n o f ex�sT
sides of the center median "------
At the cal-de-sack on Broken Arrow �6 _�� f/� � Zd �5 ��
Trail east of Siiver S ur
Buckboard W/of Portofa S/side two
Drains /O -ZD 'J`� • Z-5 5�s �-
Portola
Haystack channel on Portola W/side -�p.. � � S �,�Q ��
Portola�Uof Haystack(weekty) � _Zp - : � rr � �--
Candlewaod East of EI Toro Peak Q - Z p -�l , s
N/of Ha stac k
Channel between Amber 8�Ambrosia /� -LD �� . ZQ
Desert Holy& Blazing Star Drain on the �� _Z�,�� Z�— �,S ��
corner.
At the cai-de-sack on Willow Street east �� _�� ,l / � S 5 ���
of Desert Lil �T
e cal- e-sack on Goldflawer east /� _ZO _�,� , /S-- SS r���
of Desert Lil at the end of the i
At the cal-de-sack on Salt Cedar east �Q _zD l� Z S
of Desert Li ss -�--�/'�
At the cal-de-sack on Tamarisk Road
East of Desert Lil �� z� ��� i �-� .SS �-�
73-840 Flagstone at the cul-d�-sac. -----
45-390 Garden Sqdare - � �_ �,
San Pabb at Coco's restaurant S/side �
I ofHihwd 111 IU `Zl ' � � � � � • �
Purslane Drainage Channel ,� . �_�r
Pain#ers Path
Painters Path & Edgehill N/W comer � � •
Painters Path S/of Fred Waring (Ci�cuit r
C' ( C LI-� 1,� 1 � �� S�
� F.Waring 8� PaintersPath N/E corner two i � ,�
drains. � v L! -( L _ /�,") •
Park View
43-83t Joshua Road . U � Z� �� _
��� EVERY TWO MONTH
DRAIN CHANNEL AA/�iN NANCE SCHEDULE
Equipme�8�tools required:Truck No. 79 or 04, Shoveis, brooms, hedge trimmers(in some locations),
wheel barrel. You will need to use the water truck in some locations.
Month: vc.�s 2�ti
J"
Locations Date Com leted Time R uired C�.eyy
Mesa View
48-601 Valley View � �
Oiympic 8� Spyglass . 3 ;� ,� „ v.�,n �
Silver S ur Ranch
At the cal-de-sack on Feather Trail east
of Silver S urt Traii 3 � � . � S r►� � f,�
r before the r
sid - �
A e cal-de-sack on Bro en Arrow '
Trail east of Silver S ur I3 j �t , ��� �^ �,� ��'
Buckboard W/of Po�tola S/side tw o
Drains '1 3 � � J'� . � .�.-.? �
Portola
Haystack channel on Porkola W/side 3! � 3 ' '�
Portola N/of Haystack(weekly) � ��'�
Candlewood East of EI Toro Peak �-- 3/ i , Z t7 M•� t
N/of Ha stack
Channel between Amber�Ambrosia �3 / • � O r�r:� �,
Desert Holy& Blazing Star Drain on the
comer. �l ! ! `` , ,3 � .r,r . `� �•
At the cal-de-sack on Willow Street east
of Desert VI g�/ /�f � �- , s --rp
- - -__ _.. _ ��� �.��-i-�— - -
t t e cal-de-sack on Goldflowe�east � / /� I �5.
of Dese�t Li at the end of the i e ��
At the cal-de-sack on Salt Cedar east � � /,/ ' �v ���
of Desert Li 7
At the cal-de-saC1c pn Tamarisk Road � / c � ��
East of Desert Lil g// /r� J �
73-840 Flagstone at the cul-rlec-sac.
45-39aGerd�r-Sqr�are r,� _ ,�
San Pab(o at Coco's restaurant S/side � T
of Hi hwa 111 � � `� ' 1`� , /,S .1 P��
Purslane Drainage Channel _ _ S �
Painters Path
Painte�s Pa#h� Edgehil! (V/W corner - - � , �5--
Painters Path S/of Fred Waring (Circuit £
Ci � 'y' �� � J� -►�� �
F.Waring & PaintersPath N/E comer two
drains. � ' � r�� ► �D � £..,J �'�,
Park V�ew
43-831 Joshua Road � � s � / . 3i� �
�
- EVERY 7W0 MONTH
DRAIN CHANNEL MAINTENAN � SCHEDULE
Equipment&tools required: Truck No. 79 or 04, Shovels, brooms, hedge trimmers (in some Ivcations),
wheel barrel. You will need to use the water truck in some locations.
Mortth• o
locatfons Dats Com leted Time R uired C�ew
Mesa View
48-601 Valiey View 3 � ��
Olympic& Spyglass �3 . 30
�-�— .�-
Silver S ur Ranch
At the cal-de-sack on Feather Trail east
of Silver S urt Trail �/� - 2� r Td �
Silver Spur before the round about both
en er me � �� ���5 Nc�7 �(� .� �' 1c�`e F�o� �,5�
At the cal-de-sack on Broken Arrow
Trail east of Sifver ur j $ .,�4 r T-F ��
8uckboard W/of Portola S/side two
Drains � �' ,� �-r.d.�-�
POrtOla
Haystack channel on Portola W/side .� ��.-
Portola Wof Ha stack(weekly) . --�
N/of Ha stack
Channel between Amber&Ambrosia - � . 3v �
Desert Holy&Blazing Star Drain on the ` v
corner. glg , ZU �-r,��
At the cal-de-sack on Willow Street east
of Desert UI .� 1•O ,�4• rt
��he��an Goldflower easf --
of Desert Lil at the end of the i s"�q ,Z� �.�
At the cal-de-sack on Salt Gedar east
of Desert Lil g � . .�� ,�� ��
At the cal-de-sack on Tamarisk Road
East of Desert Lil 5 - • �U �r �
73-840 Flagstone at the cul-dec-sac.
45-390 Garden Square — �„ J
San Pablo at Coco's restaurarrt S/side
of Hi hwa 111 �• 4 ,2d �•�- ,fi �
Painters Path
Painters Paih& Edgehill N/VN corner /p
Painters Path S/of Fred Waring (Circuit
Ci , �. ��,, �� X- ;
F.Waring& PaintersPath N/E corner two
drains. ���!l.3 Z'� £ �� � �.:�
; --�--------—Park View�----.___._ _---- ------- — ---�- --
�.... __�.__...__.------
� 43-831 Joshua Road � iG—_.- .--- --.�-- __. - --- -- -_-- _-
i �v .� ��----
"'-"' EVERY TWO MONTH
DRAtN CHANNEL MAINTENANCE SCHEDULE
Equipment S tools required: Truck No. 79 0�04, Shovels, brooms, hedge trimmers(in some tocations),
wheet barrei. You will need to use the water truck in some tocations.
Month• ., o��
Locations Date Com leted Time R uired Crew
Mesa View
48-601 Vatley View -Z - t� ` �
Olympic&Spyglass
Sjlver S ur Ranch
At the cal-de-sadc on Feather Traii east �--� S S
of Sitver S urt Trai! ' Z-� l�
Silver Spur before the round about both
sides of the center median
At the cal-de-sadc on Broken Arrow
Trail east of Sifver S r
Budcboard W/of Portola S/side fin►o
Dra+ns
Portola
Haystack channel on Portola WJside 1 13 �S �' -5
Portola W/of Haystack(weekly� 2�
N/of Ha stack
Channei betw�een Amber 8 Ambrosia 1 "'% S
Desert Holy& Blazing Star Drain on the
corner.
At the cal-d�sadc on Wilbw Street east
of Desert Lil
_ .. _....-- ---- - .. _ _ ._
At the cal-de-sadc on Goldflower east � .� �
of Desert Lil at the end of the '
At the cal-de-sadc on SaR Cedar east
of Desert Lil
At the cal-d�sadc on Tamarisk Road
East of Desert Lily .___ ---
73�40 Flagstotte at the cut-dec-sac. -
45-390 Garden Squace -- �_
San Pablo at Coco's restaurar�t S/a�de
of H' hwa 111
Calle De Los Cam � sinos
Two drains so+uth of Thrush . W/side � L- � �Z S 5
Painters Pa'�h ._
Pa+r�ters Path 8 Edgehill N/W comer � - Z � � �' �_ ��-- S �
Pairiters Path S/of Fred Waring (Circuit
City) -�--.
F.Waring S Painters Path N/E comer two � :�
drains. � -'-� �
EVERY TWO MONTH
DRAIN CHANNEL MAINTENANCE SCHEDULE
Equipment 8�tools required: Truck No. 79 or 04, Shovels, brooms, hedge trimmers (in some locations),
wheel barrel. You will need to use the water truck in some locations.
Month: October 30 2012
Locations Date Com leted Time R utred Crew
M@Se Vi@W �'-�=-�- —
48-601 Valley View �U � 3�� , 5'S ss- -
Olympic 8� Spyglass l a .� c'� . � s'S - �'z--
Silver S ur Ranch -- - -�—
At the cal-de-sack on Feather Trail east
of Silver S urt Trail %r� --'3� �' SS �_
Silver Spur befo�e the round about both
sides of the center median —� ---
At the cal-de-sack on Broken Arrow
Trail east of Silver S ur �� t.� T-� SS /�_..
Buckboard W/af Portola S/side two
Drains �- 3 v ,r� Ss ,/�'`-�
Portola
Haystack channel on Portola W/side �; � S�.S
Portola N/of Haystack (weekly) ,i ,�..5'
N/of Ha stack
Channel between Amber 8�Ambrasia % Y} j v �
Desert Holy 8� Blazing Star Drain on the �
comer. - � �' -.5 �5S �Z.—�
At the cal-de-sadc on Willow Street east �' r�, /
of Desert Lil "U 3J , S S S '`v
At the cal-de-sack on Goldflowe�east
of Desert Li( at the end of the i e � - i � �s
At the cal-de-sack on Salt Cedar east �� 7 , t � �
of Desert Lil ?/ f L S � �c_.
At the cal-de-sack on Tamarisk Road ,
East of Desert Lil l�' � 3 �� � `� '�--��
73-840 Ftagstone at the cul-dec-sac. � r��
45-390 Garden Square � � � f -� �- 5
San Pablo at Coco's restaurant S/side
of Hi hwa 111 ' �J >S '�Z--
Painters Path
Painters Path & Edgehill N/VU corner - �
Painters Path S/of Fred Waring (Circuit -
Ci �',�. ' �� ��1 ;�L.-,
. F.Waring 8 PaintersPath NIE corner two , ; � „ �; �i
�drains. � � " ! _—.___t... � � �
...__.r. ......_ .._ _ - ---�------- �--- --
-- . .---------��--a—---------------- -- --
Park View
43-831 Joshua Road ��; ' •n �
a � -. � t' «F}�,t � bx� r� �'� �� � ti x� � y.i
' 't �, e t u �.. ;.. x `�"�, ax'^u."* s s: t� eCP � xw.a x;h 2�,'`u�a``f����"".'� °�'���L�'
,.��(,t+ { s,�!��} , 1 P; y` � S'F'sr� p .4 y x�+� rte+'�S w ���'w ,
� ���'y+"n7P s ���°M�t 1 .:W,b, ^9^� y �� �^�l� ' �y u 2� '`��> .t°��M�. '�"�y;�„*n4'�r$.
h✓,, '�" ;�a r9'`1t f� ?' . �-,�... �. Y� S � d�• w(,�r . .k '� t t,�Y c �j `�
t�. .�"1 " 1 k ,-0 "� ` .'" °. At ,�. ��y • ,r F, Y .'�.�
�.. �.
Y. ..- . � ;� ,.i-_ . . - I��....
, .. . .. . :.., '... ,.. ... . ' .:..,. . p i. li., ..'..
ff ^ , _ .. .. _
t
�
MONTHLY
CATCH BASINS/DYRWHLLS
MAINTENANCE SCFiED�I LE
i This schedule requires the ditch witch for maintenance
Month: y
ILocation _ Date Com leted Time Re . Crew
Fred Warin Locations
t. 43-820 Wildflower,ciean outside the wall �y � I
at the ed e of the white water channel I —� � r /`� , f � �,c/
. Drains along Fred Waring from San
Pascual to San Pablo north side �� �, ( `y 1�,�r � �` ���
Drains off of ACacia and San Luis.
3. Drains along San Pablo from F.Waring to M. - /
Falls � �I I� ��✓� .��? �iV
4. Drains/Drywe{Is at the Civic Center, Rec. t � �
Center arkin lot and satellite ard � '�r �V .�j � ��✓
5. florine&Erin Drain on Corn ' < < ^
,�x-.
6. Buttonwood&Gazania on Corner 2. -�
: F.Waring between Monterey San Luis Rey
s/side �'—�y- '� / Tj���i�/
8. F.Warin &Alaska two drains a �l ; y �� _�v
9. F.Warin &Elkhorn � - �.. � fj�,;
10. F.Warin &Califprnia " •-.� � /� � s'S .��c
11. Goleta b the vacant lot ,
Na stack Locations ��
12, Slazin Star arain ___ i . , '
13.N/end of Olympic Dr clean out inlet 8 under
sidewalk drain that�ces to Mesa View � �� %' ' ; :k ,.rr. , /�
__.v -- --- - --- - --,�----�--�
Portola Ave Locations � ,
14. 43-620 Carmel Circle � � .�'f{� R�I :+ r °; ���a�-7---
15�West of 43-620 Carmei Circle � y► �%f�`�L� a • � �-�
16. F'almiila Circle& rsene S/west corner `.y= �_ , ;
74-383 M rsin 'j � � � ti
P.D. Countr Club Locations A
17. 77-455 W omi • . S J�
�. �—'—�-- ---------
19.42-845 Warner �J (j(2^%(1 �� ;,- �
L ��. - -- -----
21. Edinborou h E/o Warner N/side • 20- ���'
.California&Tennessee N/E corner
2 . Cali�ornia at New York N/west side _ _�� �_ _
r24. Ave, of the States at Washmgton S& N side _ _
' �---�v ._ --�
—.�_
77-010 KentuCky Ave. ----- ------- - -- � � -Z- � -- - --• — t -
43-510 Tennessee Ave. � �
ti;�;�s�.� ; . 3 �- ,s� � , Y �r��b,.,� L�.
G�1�T0^, 10�`L/ �1 ���•�-'�1G. �'ZS ��+ • `��' ���C4/�1s,.
�
MONTHLY
CATCH BASINS/DYRWEI.LS
MAINTENA�fCE SCHEDULE
Th(s schedule requtres the ditch wttch for matntenance
Month• -' 2O1
Locatlon Date Com leted Time R . C�ew
Fred Warin Locations
a Y' ►�� ��� C- l�- � u
1. 43-820 Wiidflower,clean outside the wall
at the ed of the white water channel 6-� �• (� �, � s z� �
2. Drains along Fred Waring from San
Pascual to San Pablo north side
Drains off of Acacia and San Luis.
3. Drains along San Pablo from F.Waring to M.
Falls � - Z d-l� f ,S'� �
4. Drains/Drywe►is at the Civic Center, Rec.
Center a�kin lot and satellite ard � ' � •��j � , � ,
5. Florine&Erin Drain on Comer. � 3
6. Buttonwood 8�Gazania on Comer o S �
7. F.Waring beiween Monterey&San Luis Rey
S/side
8. F.Wari 8 Alaska twa drains � �� 5�, �
9. F. Warin &Elkhorn • / � .
i0. F. Warin &Calffornia _ �•� .
11. Goleta b the vacant lot . ,
2 ,
Ha stack Locations
12. Blazin Star drain ,
13.N/end of Olympic Dr clean out inlet�unde�-- --� - - — -- - -
sidewalk drain that oes to Mesa View. �-Z y-/Y � ,�
v �� � N �� - �6 � :�a
Portola Ave Locations
14. 43-620 Carrnel Circfe
15. West of 43-620 Carmel Circle
16. Pafmitla Circie& M rsene, S/west corner , � "
74-383 rsin �_ `J_
P.D. Countr Ciub Locations
17. 77-455 W omin
18. 42-365 Warner ...__
19.42-845 Warner �---`i _.� ,--�
20.43-325 Warner _ 2� . � l v
21. Edinborou h E/o Warner Wside o -�li,n- � j
22. Califomia&Tennessee N/E comer � � �2y -
23.Cal'rfomia at New Yo�c Wwest side
24. Ave. of the States at Washin ton S& N side �
25.77-286 Missouri&Califomia on California �________ .,
77-010 Kentuck Ave. -�-3 � � � Str �
43-510 Tennessee Ave. - �r • � _
y 3�� 7f�,`-'c sfs<�Na ��d�► �,-t I -r�t � ��; ��N�.
� `.`��. . ,
c�.'caud���'�i�'��� ""is""�'`i���4a'£;aa�zxtwAa�k'��,a;a�'.^fr.
��
�
t
MONTHLY �
CATCH BASINS!DYRWELlS
MAINTENANCE SCHEDULE
This schedule requires the ditch wltch for mairrtenance
Month: �. ,� .
Lacation Date Com leted Tlme R . Crew
Fred Warin Locations
� � , � •Z� • �� 2- a�-- ��
1. 43-820 Wilclflower, ciean outside the waft
at the ed e of the white water channel bA• b'�• �� 1 � 5
2. Drains along Fred Waring from San ps . ,y . �a,
Pascual to San Pablo north side :1 .= Z.�U - � �P
o cacia and n u�s. '��
3. Drains along San Pablo from F.Waring to M.
Falls 0�• ti2 1'� t • � C�f
4. Drains/Drywelts at the Chric Center, Rec.
Center arkin lot and sateUite ard �A- 2 •t -s.• o �FT � +�Z-
5. Florine&Erin Drain on Comer. o . . p -T
6. Buttonwood&Gazania on Corner --- ._.----- .-
7. F.Waring between Monterey&San Luis Rey
S/side o;• �'�• �k �•o
8. F.Warin &Alaska two drains oq . � • � . o F�
9. F.Wari & Elkhorn o . a FT
10. F.Warin &California 0�1• LS • t • v Ft � J
11. Goteta the vacant lot o . o. P Z
1• l -,�
Ha tac Locations
12. Blazin Star drain o • � �..
13.N/end of Olymp�c Dr clean out inlet&under
sidewalk drain that oes to Mesa View. '�'���" �'` `-''r�
3•oo vJ o . � t• o FT` ,Q
Portola Ave Locations
14_ 43-620 Carmel Circle . .s-
15. West of 43-620 Carmel Circte �'___ �_� _
��16_Palmdla Circle 8.Myrsene,S/west comer____ _
74-383 Myrsin _-- �`-----------j---------�--•_--- ----
P.D. Count Club Locations
17. 77-455 W omin -----___ 1 p,
18.42-365 Warner ._----
19.42-845 Wamer ��____.__� _______._.
20.43-325 Warner O • o� • 1•c� a Z d J?
21. Edinborou h E/o Warner N/side o .o . ,o #
22. Califomia&Tennessee N/E comer . , ,
23. Cafifornia at New York Wwest side ►�-i �
24. Ave. of the States af Washin on S& N side �,
5.77-286 Missouri BCaI"rfomia on Califomia v� � � ta �I ����c�• �.
— ---- - --� �
F 77-010 Ke�tucky Ave_._.__ _ ��__- -- --.--� e� �—+ �:�_-- --`'--�� S-s--.�
a3-510 Tennessee Ave. ' � �Z� . -
_..---- -- ... ---- �- � I �• � _ � L:,-� r i�.
— --- �� —.
� °
;�
� s��� � �• ,
�ot�►+�r
CATCH BASINS!DYRWELLS
MAlNTENANCE SCHEDULE
This schedule requires the ditch wltch for maintenance
lonth: o.,
Locatlon Date Gom leted Time Crew
Fred Warin Locations
r �.• � - s ._ -� ----
r�.� t .�..� -� -i- s �
1. 43-820 Wildflower,clean outside the wall
at the ed e of the white water channel C� 7. . � � FT Ets
2. Drairts along Fred Waring from San
Pascual to San Pablo north side � �,. � - �
3. Drains along San Pabb from F.Waring to M.
Falfs �''J -7• - t � - f F� r�
4. DrainslDryweNs at the C+vic Center, Rec.
Center arkin bt and sateilite ard o'S- zG - (�c 1 - $"' � �,E�
5. Florine& Erin Drain on Corner. b, z • �
6. Buttonwood&Gazania on Corner s . _ � ,J
7. F.Waring between Monterey 8 San Luis Rey �
S/side ' -� � �. ; , ' � ' � ;i�-
8. F.Warin &Alaska two drains � .� - Z
9. F.Warin &Eikham
1Q. F.Warin &California o
11. Goleta b the vacant lot o • � .� -� ,�.
t?. • - f�f w al o 'S "i .J .
Ha stack Locations
12. Blazin Star draun 3 ��' 4 v L-
13.N/end of Olympic D�clsan out inlet&under ����
� sidewatk drain that s to Mesa View. 7�'U��
, t4tN :t ^�t � -.:� 0 2 v fi�' ►4
Portola Ave Locations
14. 43-620 Carme!Circle - /- , 5 � ��
15. West of 43-620 Carmel Circie � � �y •- ,�-� � �
� 16. Pafmilla Circle&Myrsene, S/west comer � +�� ��er,�( L �, ,; u ��,� �- �•
74-383 M rsin - - — ---- `- - --
P.D. Count Club Locations —� i � � �~ � ��
--.�._------- �--.--,
17. 77-455 W omin ` f / S 1 i � „-`
18.42-365 Wamer vi� �NG.��- X ,S T -----`�
19.42-845 Warner -� d��''�rt. ��5 i --
20. 43-325 Wamer � /-J y ,
� d�
21. Edinborou h FJo Wamer Wside ,� - '- ;5 - E �_
22. California&Tennessee WE corner � a ..
� 23. California at New York N/west side ��� i � -
I_24. Ave.of the States ai Washin on S& N side ------------- ----- ,._
�25.77-286 Missouri&Califomia on Cal'rfornia -
:. 77-010 Kentuc�Ave. -- _-_--- - ---- - - �:-� � v �
j a3-510 Tennessee Ave.__ _ ! _ ___� „��v�_{ � S� �`
�7-245 Cal'rfomia Ave. -- -�- ----�- + ----- -
. l__.
- C 5" W kti't rC. —_----- - -----`f (-/�— --- �--• --���.F. v`--- �•-
_j
4
MONTHLY
CATCH BASINS/DYRWELLS
MAINTENANCE SCHEDULE
This schedule requires the ditch witch #or maintenance
ittt: �:�.
Location Date Com leted Time Re . Crew
Fred Warin Locations � �-
s�c?A..p c c act�-�- - ?� �� y • t3 r�W�.__
. 43-820 Wildflower, clean outside the wa I
at the ed e of the white water channel � � \� 0
F i • it-
_'. Drains afong Fred Waring from San
Pascual to San Pablo north side 1 •���-�� 1 •5" . 2.
3. Qrains along San Pabto from F.Waring to M.
Fails ` z • �$• I 1. s-� �-. ��,
4. Drains/prywelis at Ehe Civic Center, Rec.
Center arkin lot and sateilite ard 'L• �H• �`1 �• � T • ��
5. Fiorine& Erin Drain on Comer. • �q,• t� � o . Z
6. Buttonwood &Gazania on Comer ------ --- ---�._ _._.
7. F.Waring between Monterey&San Luis Rey Z Z�. ��
S/side 1- S �t . ��
8. F.Warin 8 Alaska two drains �' � � � , �
9. F.Warin &Eikhorn y,. � . �,q � F.�, _ �
10. F.Warin &Calrfornia , � , p �,� , �
1 t. Goleta b the vacant lot - _ � -; ,.�. , ,- �-R: •
��A�w . vl ' / � , �.
Naystack Locations
12. Blazin Star drain __ -Zq - ; .o �T �� •
13.N/end of Olymptc Dr Gean out inlet&under �
s�dewatk drain that goes to Mesa View. "� - �� -
---�3•oo �n,c,-t R� -�— - - -_,- i > .�--
.. �--_..
Portola Ave Locations
^1� 43-620 Carmet Circle +----� ��__ Z . 2�i 1•; ��O _ �T JR•
'� WPst of 43-62U Carmel Circle _ ; �. Z� �,n ��_ �_ � ��
'E�. F�a�n��r�a r�r��;e Fk Myrsene S�west comer -- ---- • --
'-i {}3:� M\rrS1'� .- _..._._.�_._..._ .- _' ._. _ .�_�____�-.._-'
�
P.D. Country Club Locations � � � �T -- � `"�—`
77-455 W rioming ., - - _ , �----.
2-365 Warner � _ ` r ' '�
-845 Wamer f �� � � _
z25 Warne� ' -- .w,J..__ �__.�_ �_ _�-- _
�borough E/o Warner N/side � � �' '�---�
�nia&Tennessee N/E corner �'� , • �-�--� --�'`--- - �
i
�ia at New York N/west side - y � - �,`- '"�
�he States at Wash.in�ton_5& N side,_ - - �.�`—"-"'
Fsso.ir&Cal�rarnia o���;alifornia T ' _ _
^Kv Ave. �---_�__...__._.__�
,�,. _ � .. " .. _ -_ ----•- "
` � - ....._ _w_.,__---.
MONTHLY
CATCH BASINS!DYpWELLS
MAINTENANCE SCHEDULE
This schedufe requires the ditch witch for maintenance
Month: �a�, r ���.
,
Location Date Com leted Time Re . Crew
Fred Warin Locations
t. 43-820 Wildflower, clean outside the wall 1 /J �J -- � �
at the ed e of the white water channel I ��7 �/ � � � r �
2. Drains aiong Fred Waring from San / �� /� / � ��. �T-
Pascual to San Pablo north side �
3. �rains along San Pablo from F.Waring to M. , { - .,-
Falls . � 7 3 /�l l, t � �,`� �. -�1
4. Drains�'Drywelis at the Civic Center, Rec. 1 � •� .
Center arkin !pt and satellite rd i L-� �� �- .S �� { t`f
5. Florine 8�EriR Drain on Corner. ; � -!/ -- � � -
6. Buttonwood&Gazania on Corner �----- �.._-
7. F.Waring between Monterey&San Luis Rey /` �� / �, O f��-.r-
S/side t
8. F.Warin &Alaska two drains �,� , • � �
9. F.War' & Elkhorn /- - j=
10. F.Warin &California � .-i, .� �� Ft
11. Goleta b the vacant lot , �, •� ? � -
°�{Mt S M� •c� t� -
N stack Locations
. 12. B�azin Star drain ti6 � S
13.N/end of Olympic Dr clean out inlet& under
siciewalk drain that oes to Mesa View. � -- --
- -���w���� _ T S
Portola Ave Locations
_____--_-------- - �--�---------------t-----
� �3-62t!C�rmel C�rcle --�=---`'-----+--_><; ._.-�---=--`-¢.i�.w.
. W�,st �t a3-62�Car�z�e! C�rcle - - --- - ' -�.. _-+- -. � . _i_=,�.�.s�__..�
_•,�:r:,ai�3 :;rr:la g �J1y�SE•�!e= j .r.PSt •:,n�,�r — .—-
= 383 h1�r4ir. � : '
�.D. Country_Gtub Locations �
'�455 Wyoming 1
365 Warner --"V------- -'--1�-''----__..._ �_- __�_ _ � .�.�_
j45 Warner -- ------�--_-----------j�-=---- ---;.--- _.—_- -- ..
?5 Warner u" t Z -- — - _ �----,
�orough Elo Warner N/side � u• �rY 4 s �
�ia 8�Tennessee N/E comer � ,`. �-
�at New York N:west side � ��—�^t�_ _� _�.�__ _,�� � - �Z
..___. -- -- - --.. .___..._;.. . _ -r-
^ �tates at vVash�ngton ��, N s�dc : _
- --- -•- • . . • -- --�_ . - -
'�� +^ ��:al+fnmia on CaGfornia
�! '�v r. L •
_ : .Y� _�_ _`__ _. '..-.
r�1/l: ~ 1 _ _ - � �.
M.,
. ��. ,�,�:., k �.., '''m :�z. ��,. 7�� ''����'}�` �'�' + � #F-• �p� t r�
t yi �m �" �� ��"k 7A r"'t��it i���i'�w i �wP�� �. �: k� Mw�" at�Ye;��.
y w "�"Y
�,�r�'r1���r'r x � � �y h ,M r �, :3�•y �'��rs�,?�k�`'�i�`�y'�,�
},�{ ` ��. y� t �r�, ..rh".-4' a:� o- '�a+x
.�
� p 1 ,,� ,�pG F> � „ � � � ��
, � , r .�
_ - . , ' �'
>� '
, <ke. .,,. .. . � . . _ . .. ,L�. � . .. k .. 4Y: , �„ , s ., � � m , .i. . M .
"f`
r
R�n
/ �y
�, MONTHLY
CATCH BASINS/DYRWELLS
MAIN7ENANCE SCHEDULE
This schedule requires the ditch witch for maintenance
, �Month: ��. ,►•..
Location Date Com leted Tlme H . Crew
Fred Warin Locations
1. 43-820 Wildflower,clean outside the wali �Z /b �3 �- O -rn� �-�-
� at the ed e of the white water channel V r
�g 2. Drains afong Fred Waring from San
Pascual to San Pabio north side O 1 � �+3� i�4 (• s FT' d �'
3. Drains along San Pablo from F.Waring to M. ���7 �3 � �S _�i� �
Fails �
� 4. Drains/Drywells at the Civic Center, Rec. . -�y�'
Center rkin lot and sate�lite rd �� �� �J z � `� r� ~ T
5. Florine&Erin Drain on Corner. / ?' /
6_ Buttonwood 8�Gazania an Comer
7. F.Waring between Monterey&San Luis Rey
S/side o i • a-y- �<� 1� 5 '� �' ''r'
,
8. F.Warin 8�Alaska two drains Ns - "1 ` �c � -� �
9. F.Wari �Elkhorn J Z / . 4
10. F.Wari 8�Catifomia �� , U j �.
11. Goleta the vaCant tot f , C;�
1- �- � t• ,'Sa
Ha stac Loca ions ._._
12. Biazin Stardrain ��g� - . rf;�f f T
1 . r cTean out intet&under � �
sidewatk drain that ces to Mesa V'�ew. `
— II,�J��� UN i—j •
Portola Ave Locations
14. 43-620 Carmel Circle •30 � "T
15. West of 43-620 Carmel Circle - Z_- � 3d
16. PalmiNa Circle & rsene, S/west comer �i v�-= M
74383 rsin ----._ ------
P.D. Count Ciub Locations
17. 77-455 W min / Z 3 / . ,s'
18.42-365 Wamer _----- -----
19.42-845 Wamer ---
20. 43-325 Wamer - -- -------
21. Edinborou h FJo Wamer Niside - - o
22. Califomia 8 Tennessee N/E comer 2 -3D•I (7 �" r
23. California at New York N/west side - Z - �' ��"
24. Ave.of the States at Washin on S&N side � ��Y ��—�"-
25.77-286 Missouri$California on California � - O F
' 77-010 I<entuck Ave. 3 2 � "
43-510 Tennessee Rve. Z•3D �' �. •C? . ��
77-245 Calffornia Ave. �' �� -' �---
�3-0o w iz 23 ,3 i � - c r�
i r
f 1 � f b,y j e"s^ m ';fi
r� �:
. � . . . .. �ia, , .,
�/-/►� 7 / )
1 •� ~'L� ��• �` �r �v:iCl/ /�-� �
a f
`� v1 1
• l `� ��'lft�('' F. �P�?f oi�l�j� 1
y Z -Lf S Sr k r�f�;n..T��„ c }��� �-•�' •rNF�5�� � .
. � Iw- .� .��F�� � � �faz
MONTHLY �/.�
CATCN BASINS/DYRWELLS
MAINTENANCE SCHEDULE
This schedule requlres the ditch w�tch for maintenance
i Nio7nth: 1Je��M e��
Location Date Cam leted Ttme R . Crew
Fred Warin Locations
t. 43-820 Wildflower,ciean outside the wall > � � �
� at the ed e of ine white water channe� �� /Z /� / �C' f" T
I 2. Drains along Fred Waring from San
Pascual to San Pabio north side 1ti 15 � t� � - � FT � ��
3. Drains abng San Pablo from F.Waring to M.
Fails /f %3 /3 � � ��� �' �
� I 4. Drains/Drywelis at the Civic Center, Rec. // �� /j / �- � �f r�
;. Center arkin lot and sateliite ard /
5. Florine&Erin Drain on Corner. - Z - 3 ; �
� 6. 8uitonwooc!&Gazania on Comer / £�'-
� Slside Waring between Monterey&San Luis Rey `} �6 ,� ' J J� � `,r,
8. F.Warin &Alaska iwo drains i'- � �� '
_ 9. F.Warin &ENchorn � ', p �'
10. F.Wari &Cafifornia 1 • ' •� •o
11. Goteta b the vacant lot � � �
Ha stack Locations
12. Slazin Star drain � ii
13.Wend of Olympic Dr clean ou�inlet&under
sidewatk drain fhat oes to Mesa Vievv. w.�7f � �%'�< e ` �
Portola Ave Locations
14. 43-620 Carmel Gircle t -�z��_ � '� �
15. West of 43-620 Carmei Circle .___ ti z� c'S _ 3v ? �
1 6. P a l m i l l a C i r c l e 8� My r s e n e, S/w e s t c o r n e r ��' �---- - �
74-383 Myrsin —i-----+�-- r-- ---_.�._
P.D. Coun�Club Locations
17. 77-455 Wyoming � '� ; S �
!8. 42-365 Warner T� • - �
(9.42-845 Wamer
:0.43-325 Wamer -Z��•- >�, _ / { -
1. Edinborough E/o Warner N/side / z�,_/ �- . �s ��"�`�
2. Califomia&Tennessee NIE corner �-� • ��_ -i.O_
3. Califomia at New York N/west side ��._�_�r c, � . __ ���� ��-�
—� ' �T----
�.Ave. of the States at Washington S&N side ��,• � _ ..____ 1 • --,� _ �
�J7-286 Missouri&California on California � �i t -r-._
-010 Kentu�Ave. , _� _ ��, ;'i,Y�.ti _ —
•510 Tennessee Ave. �� �'T'
�2.45 Caf�fornia Ave . �q, %
...�
►�.- . k-���•,.,, -'- n, .r � ,r J:-� ,? _ c�t- * �..
le+r��d�kN,�R K >,y.,A+, e-as.;:u,, .. ::.-� . ..- .
MOHrt+�r
CATCH BASiNS!DYRWELLS
M/UNTENANCE SCNEDULE
Thls schedule requires the dltch witch for malntenancs
�Month:�
Locativn Date Com ieted Time Re . Crew
Fred Warin Locations
1. 43-82�Wilciflower,dean outside the walt
at the of the white water channel ��3 .� � p �����
2. Drains along Fred Waring from San �
Pascual to San Pabb north side �0 � �� f � ��
Faflsrains along San Pablo from F. Waring to M. �, � � �+-
� � �� ����
4. Drains/Drywells at the Civic CeMer, Rec. T
Center arktn lot and satelqte ard f� � l,� z•� J � � �T
5. Florine 8�Erin Drain on Corner. . p
6. 8uttonwood&Gazania on Corner �------
7. F.Waring beMreen Monterey d�San Luis Rey
S/side �Q� � /. �� d � �'"� ��
8. F.Warin 8�Alaska two dr2�ins 7 '�"
9. F.Warin 8 Elkhorn . p
10. F.Wari &California p i . p
11. Galeta b the vacant lot '
Ha stack Locations
12. Blazi Star drain E' r"
13.Nlend of Ofympic Dr dean out inlet 8�under
sidewalk drain thai �s to Mesa View.
Portola Ave Locations ,
14. 43-620 Carmel Circle O � Z
15. West of 43-620 Carmel Circfe �?�__ Z--
16. Palmilfa Circle S Myrsene, S✓west comer _ ��� � ---�
-— ---- -
� 74-383MYrSin --I----- ----- .--•-� - - -••-+-- - --•
P.D. Country Club Locatlons
17. 77-455 W om i ~ ��y_�--- . � ���'G�,1 Z
18.42-365 Warner �v �r�,�,p �--- —
19. 42-845 Wamer �7t�1�'�J - i ^
20. 43-325 Warner � / C £
1. Edinborau h E/o Wamer Wside jo ��—
'.Califomia&Tennessee WE comer ' O /v ' _
California at New York Wwest side G• r ��
Ave. of the States at Washin on S&N side , - -� ----- --�
�-286 Miss��ri&California on Califomia _ %'.�="� ��! _ _ _ _�`�
-� ----- --- ------— --- -�—- �
'�ashington St. Locations � _. _ _ , '
-- ---�- ;
. ,. .�� .; .� , � . .,,, �, .:
... ,. . ..., :.. r.; . .
p+� ,
N �
•
.,..... w., . ,. ....,.,.- • .., . . -
. .—... a.. .,.� . r... .�.�:-.� ..._..., >...�. .w,. ,n.w:.: .. ..� ^ .� e
. � , . , '�Y,•'�.,�`4.v „ Ty�,, ..
�•��
MONTHLY
CATCH BASINS!DYRWEL�S
MAINTENANCE SCHEDULE
This schedule requlres the ditch witch for maintenance
Month: e��a�ri►3�-
Location Date Com leted Time R . Crew
� Fred Warin Locations
1. 43-820 Wildflower, clean outside the wall
at the ed e of the white water channel s f 3 2•� f ��
2. Drains along Fred Waring from San C��,r��T� _
Pascual to San Pablo north side '"'-
3. Drains along San Pablo from F.Waring to M. � . � -
Falis `/ '� /3 � C 7��'� /^T
4. Drains/Dryweils at the Civic Center,Rec. ,
� Center rkin lot and satellite ard �� `%�j �� � ��' f-^�
5. Florine&Erin Drain on Comer. �/ /� : C� �'
6. Buttonwood&Gazania on Corner � � 3 , ZO �' F
7. F.Waring between Monterey&San Luis Rey
S/side /� /�j Z. U � ��
8. F.Wari &Alaska two drains � .�S � . r
9. F.Warin &Elkhorn io � ,i, �" '
10. F.Warin &Califomia Z , p �
; 11. Goleta b the vacant lot ` �
� e �.,. /z j. D �-
� Ha stack Locations �
12. Blazi Star drain iD /Z.. t �
t 3.N/end of Olympic Dr clean out inlet&under
sidewalk dcair�tbat oes to 11�sa-t�Pew. � // C�- . �� ,T���-
Portofa Ave Locations
14. 43-620 Carmel Circle 9 �Z :• • 3�' £ 7
15. west of a3-s2o Carme�Circ►e __ ; �� , 3C .�J� � - 1- ,
16. Palmilla Circle& M rsene, S/west corner �. ;,,� �� -- -- �—
74-383 rsin k:�-'y �,�t�� „ — ._.....
P.D. Count Ctub Locations �
17. 77-455 W amin � /� �3 . �
18.42-365 Wamer ____ —
19. 42-845 Wamer _----
20. 43-325 Warner � -
21. Edinborou h EJo Wamer N/side i6 i S"
22. Califomia&Tennessee N/E comer �"
23.Cal'rfomia at New York N/west side �
24. Ave.of the States at Washi on S 8 N side --�""
?5.77-286 Missouri&California on Califomia G ___-- ,_.
7-010 Kentucky Ave. � --� � ��� �—
13-510 Tennessee Ave. � r , ! ,7 i t , ,
7-245 Calitornia Ave. -.. - --� , ��-- - �-�� -- .
f �-- , `� .��: , .
��--G( � ('lil,l, j�r t,v� r� �Z��1: �,U ��
��v l�C /l �� ��'� �IZG�I3 l'� � � �
� /
�,,
.,. :, �
;..
.�
,
, �
'�`�d ,�� �rr , _, < �.p, ,- � ..� ._e. .... .. . ... .� , .. . .,� m..,. .�M., �,_ � _ .a�
� ��„��, _
�
- E � MON7HLY
,F `� CATCH BASINS/DYAWELLS
'� MAINTENANCE SCHEDULE
This schedule requtres the ditch witch for rnalntenancs
� Monttt: ��,,,�- �
Location Date Com leted Time R . Crew
Fred Warin Locations
1. 43-820 Wildtlower,dean outside the wafl / �- ,,
at the ed e of the white water channel � ( � /.3 . �� ���� � Z
2. Drains along Fred Waring from San �.� _
Pascua!ta San Rablo narth side �' ��5 ` �r����
3. Drains along San Pabto from F.Waring to M. �� � �3 , ,c�i 5 `�C. � Z
Falts
4. Drains/Drywelts at the Civic Center, Rec. / � ' �
Center arkin !ot ar�satel{ite ard � � �3 I � �?r � �
5. Florine&Erin Drain on Comer. 3 Z
6. Buttonwood 8 Gazania on Comer •, � Z
7. F.Waring between Monterey&San Luis Rey
S/side
8. F.Wari &Alaska two drains �
9. F.Warin &Eifchom ;
10. F.Warin &Califomia
11. Goleta b the vacant lot J , �c
Ha stack Locationa
12. Blazin Star drain , �
13.N/end of Olympic Or clean out inlet&ur►der �
sidewalk drain that oes .�ssa Y�ew+�. U S� �! -- ___-- �
Portala Ave Locations t�`
14. 43-620 Carts�el Circfe .3 o E
15. West of 43-620 Carmel Circle �_S`/3 _3a �'��'
16. Palmiila Circle& rsene S/west corner �.t�������> --�• --
74383 NlYrsin � ------- '^ - _
P.D. Coun�Ctub Locations Y
7-� ,�CC ( 'r !
�7. !/'TTJ W m� ��'� � J l�G f
i8. 42- Wamer -- --- '°�
19.42-845 Wamer 4� .�—
20. 43-325 Warner �- -1 �' j
21. Edinbor h E/o Warner Wsida '' - �t 1 �tis - � � Z
22. Califomia&Tennessee WE comer 4;'- ►5 -) 3 �� Z
,��„w
23.Calffomia at New York N/west side SC - S' � Z � h s "(' � �j�
24.Ave. of the States ai Washin on S& N side !� ti� � - `
25?7-286 Missouri&Califomia on CaNfornia Y.c � � : �;_
l Z • ��i�� (�CcfrtG✓ "C�!_• — .------- ' --L—i7.s .._ _!_.1 _ : s��
�Wa�shin on St. Locatlans � ^�
�__ �__ _ _ .L___ -.__._�--- -- _ __l._. __ . jj„
Nc.1�� `-K �.u-S� � Lt7�.5���1 5��� i�o v.r �l i L ��� � �ll. (�-�. G F ��1
tf
�
.�,
MONTHLY
CATCH BASINS/DYRWELLS
MAINTENANCE SCHED�ILE
This schedule requires the ditch witch tor ma(ntenance
Month: " �� ,
Locatlon Date Com feted T(me Re . Crew
Fred Warin Locations
t. 43-820 Wildflower, clean outside the wall
at the ed e of the white water channel � - � ��\3 � N�1 � �� � t i
2. Diains atong Fred Waring irom San .,. � , -, .
Pascua!to San Pablo nath side � � � � • � ff < �� - � �
3. Drains along San Pablo from F. Waring to M. �
r
Falis ���I c. � ' ' ,
4. Drains/Dryweifs at the Civic Center, Rec. ' ^�
Center arkin lot and satel(ite ard 1' 1 �t� S•
5. Florine�Erin Drain on Corner. �. �
6. 8uttanwood 8�Gazania on Corner r�� £ . ._______�
7. F.Waring between Monterey&San Luis Rey
sis�ae ��/9�3 Z.�•�s -Tr-' � FT
8. F. Warin 8�Alaska two drains ' y � " c �
9. F.Warin 8�Elkhorn � � •
�0. F.Warin &Califomia -
11. Goleta b the vacant lot -. . ,
Ha stack Locattons
12. Blazin Star drain 7 - ;��-.'y - -;�, : i ;: � � -
- 13.N/end ot Olympic Dr ciean vut�nlet 8�under , , r, ,
sidewalk dra9n that oes to Mesa View. • - � � �� • ,
�c e w t,w 'l • 2 � 4".` �
Portola Ave Lacations
. ----------__--_— ---
___ ___. _ ___._
� 14. 43-620 Carmel Circle �- �' ` ; �_ _ ;�' � , £ � _i_
_ ...__.-- — -- --�-- - � � - -- +-�-;-��_� '------ -- -
t 5 West of 43-620 Carmel Circls t __ �� _ _ ` :� �_ 1 ,_ r � �
�� palmdfa C�rcfe 8 Myrsenp S;west.�omer }- � : F
'4 383 MY�sin �
P.D. Country Club Locations �
1? " a55 W omm ' -
.--------
� Y__._� . _ . . .
i_18. 42-365 Warner _.______ _ �
19. 42-84 Wamer � -- - . .
20. 43-325 Warne� --- - --- -- - ._._- ----- �-- - -- �
21. Edinborou h E/o Warner N/side �- �'- j.�j � —� • ���-�-'
�
22. Cal'rforn+a &Tennessee N/E corner � - ---- -- � __ �
23. California at New York N/west side � � �
�24 Ave. of the States at Washinclton S&_N side _ .�t2�,��� ___ �-, � ' '"
ZS 77-286 Missour 9�Cal�f�rn�a on �af�fornia � �=..,�y�
�• �y. 1_�G. s...L,.'�'.'�S G.C. - � --K- �~ -- � r� � -•---'-- -47- ��, -
Washington St Locations � �
_ ; ' , , _ ►
� �i � � � � � .. t`:T ` � � �I ►' T
, .4� ,. p�..—>.
�,..te� . 4 .'p. . . . . , . .
F lr��—�
MONTHLY
CATCH BASINS/[3YRWELLS
MAINTENANCE SCHEpULE
This schedule requires the ditch witch for maintenance
Month: .-'`;ti r, . �
Location Date Com leted Time R . Crew
Fred Warin Locations
t. 4.3-820 Wildflower, dean outside the wall
at the e of the white water channel � ; - , - � ' ��
2. Drains along Fred Waring from San
j Pascua!to San Pablo north side � �'�' � � j,
3. Drains atong San Pablo from F,Waring to M.
� �alls . ' . , � -
�,
4. Drains/Drywelts at the Civic Center, Rec. r � . �
Center in lot and sateilite ard '
5. Florine&Erin Drain on Corner. ? - .�.
6. Buttonwood&Gazania on Corner ' : ;
7. F.Waring between Monterey 8�San luis Rey . . ,
S/side � ►
8. F.Warin &Alaska two drains ' • , -
9. F.Warin &Elkflarn • . ; n ,-
10. F.Warin & Califamia -' �
11. Goleta b the vacant lot ' . - � ' -
j , . .
Ha stack Locations
t 2. Blazin Star drain - - �
13.N/e�of Olympic Dr ciean out inlet S under
s'tdewaik drain that oes to Mesa�ew. � ' � -
Portola Ave Locations
14. 43-620 Carmet Circle
15. West oi 43-620 Carme!Circle •
16. Palmilia Cirde& M sene, S/west comer � �
74-383 M rsin � -� -�----- -
P.D. Countr Ciub Locations
i 7. 77-455 W omin J �
18.42-365 Wamer � • • •
19.42-845 Warner �
20. 43-325 Wamer
�..—.—.
21. Edinborou h E/o Warner N/side S y3 .� �'
22. Catifornia&Tennessee N/E corner �
23. Calffornia at New York Wwest side •�
4. Ave. of the States at Washington S& N side • � �
7z-286 Missouri&Cal'rfornia an California �,�k �1..� �.��t_+,t _ S
. Karlsas � missouri
� Washin tan St. Locations
���lt� l��ltc,�� � ? � 3 J �-� f �
. . . . . .. .. . . 5.r kY�'A 9:s S &s&�„�����'ra'� d�-,�,,,�
� d��, , .. ... . . �� . . �� � .
2�L . + _ _'
MONTHLY
CATCH BASINS/OYRWELlS
MWNTENANGE SCHEDULE
This schedule requires the ditch witch tor mainte�ance
Nlonth• �4.� y
' ��
Location Date Com leted Time R . Crew
Fred Warin Locations
1. 43-820 Wildflower, dean outside the wall
at the ed e of the white water channei t'"a.'(" �
2. Drains along Fred Waring from San �
Pascual to San Pablo nvrth side
3. Drains atong San Pablo from F.Waring to M. �,( :�
FaNs _ /'/ S , � �✓.-�f�
4. Drains/Drywells at the Civic Center, Rec.
Center rkin lot and satellite ard ' � �?- - ' � ) �,. `, �
5. Florine&Erin Drain on Corner. - �-;2,y- , ; ,4 Z
6. Buttonwood 8�Gazania an Corner L-
7. F.Waring between Monterey& San Luis Rey
S/sicte
8. F.Warin &Alaska two drains ,-�./ -s
9. F.Warin 8� Elkhorn •�- �• ! �� ��-��_
10. F.Warin &Califomia .'��.- �_� �r-
11. Goleta b the vacant(ot N _
!
Ha stack Locations
12. Blazin Star drain - �„ , �
� 13.N/end of Olyrx��ic Dr clean out intet& under f
sidewalk drain that oes to Mesa View. " 2 --1 • s C i(/ L
Portola Ave Locations �
14. 43-620 Carmel Cirde � ',t '' •
15. West af�3-620 Carmet Circle — - —`
16. Palmilla Circle&M rsene, S/west corner - ��
74-383 Myrsin
P.D. Count Club Locations � � �� �
17. 77-455 W omin �-� , {rz
42-365 Warner . -�__.
9 42-845 Warner •----�
20. 43-325 Warner ► n � , p i,
2y. Edinborou h E/o Warner Wside ",;�A • � �,
22. Catifamia&7ennessee N/E comer� '' � K, � - ; �
23. Californ'ra at New York N/west side f • . ; ��.� ,
24. Ave. of the States at Washington S& N side_ _. � .
. 25.77-286 Missouri&California on Cal'rfarnia `� ' - - - —`—
r26. Kansas � �, �►r�a _ � '� N � �._ AZ. \/ ---
�
Washington St. Locations � � � � �
�__--
4 + �.�
�f� I /� " �C . C �j �ji
r
� S
Page 1 of 2
Cit�r of Palm Desert
/--:' \ Serviae Request
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
73-5l�Frod Waring Drive
Palm De�CA g2260
� 760-346-0611
� �� � " �ce.�
Y � �` CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION
PrinGed on 10/ZO/2014
Street Maintenance(Pubik)-Nnisance Water/Standing Water/Gutber Drainage()
� Reyuest Acid;es:; �� Citizer,.:;r;nt,��? If,;�arrt�K�trr;rr
Street Info: The Summit Citizen Name: Ryan Gayter
�Y/Zip CitY.�P� --
���� Greenbriar,VaNey View,
Spygiass,North V'�ew,QuaN
Hollow,Shady View,etc...the
streefs south of Mesa View.
� -.• , .. � t r.i;_>� UtC"51i5;?Il�f3(filr't�Ot7 �f'UVI(�2Q f?V;.}�YZf'.1�7'-
is it presenting an no
immedtate danger to
the pub�c7:
.� Staff Request Admin
Request ID: 252563 Priolity: Normal
Reeelved/Entered: 12/28/2010 4:57:23 PM
Target Complete Date: 3/31/2011 Siatus: Cflmp�eted
Actua!Canplete Date: 3/29/2011 Color
ReA��uroe: Taken Rag:
by[Ryan Gayler]
HOW:Staff(S)
Original Asslgned Staff: Gaugush,Cora
Qurent A�Igned Staff: Gailarclo,F..r�(See kctions Log for detafls)
',� Staff;ClGzen Action:.og
I
ncriau rn+�v DATE BY whoM
Staf�Adion:Cabch bastn and under sideHralk drain 29 MAR 2011 �pp
deaning in that area was dune 2-2&11 to 3-2-ii. li:ii
5tai'f Actlon:StaGis was dtanged from'Open'to 29 MAR 2011 �q�,�,qRpp
'Completed' 11:10
Actual Complete Dabe was changed irom'empty'to
'03/29/2011'
Staff Action:Mark Greenwood has reassigned this 29 MAR 2011 MGREENWO00
Reque.st tn Ed Gallardo on 3/29/2011 7:55:49 AM.Reason 07:55
for Reasslgnment:Please confirm this work is c.omplete and
dose the CRM..An EmaO has been sent to Ed Galiarclo at
egallardo@cilyofpalmdesert.org.
Staif Action:Target Compfe6e Date yvas changed f�om 3 FE8 2011 �{�pNp�
'1/11/2011'to'03/31/2D11'. R�n:Cnritractor w���do 12:06
thlos woric,He is expecDed tp start yn Fe�ary 201 L
AZAMARRIPA
http://palmdesert-cim.civicasoft.Co�t/admin/ArintRecluest.asr►�nnP�r��i—�S�c�� Y A M n,..... .
I
. �
Page 2 of 2
9taff Actbn:Stadis was changed from'Reoeived'Uo 3 JAN 2011
�Open�
09:22
�Acqon:Carlos Hemandez has rea�slgned this 3)AN 201I CHQtNANDEZ
�1�b�Aaron Zamarripa on 1/3/20116:32:47 06:32
AM.Reason for Reassignment:Schedule for comptetlon.An
Emall has been sent to Aaron Zamanipn at
azamarrlpa�dtyafPalmdesert.org.
�'�O^'C°�Ga�9�h has r�ssigned this Request to 30 DEC 2010 CGAUGUSH
Carios Hemandez on 12/30/2010 8:49:07 AM,Rea�n for pg;4g
Reassignment:.An EmaB h�been sent to Carlos
Hernandez at chemandeza�cityafpalmdesert,org.
Sbtf Adion:Carbs,Thls Is tt�e area east of May 74 and 30 DEC 2010 CGALIGt1SH
south of Mesa View.Thank you. pg:qg
Sbff AltadtmeM 2:v1Pw ttachmrant
��
Staff Attachment 3:Vfew Attachmr+nt
0 - -
Staff Attathment 4:111�w A�
n
http://paimdesert-crm.civicasoft.com/admin/printRequest.asp;h�questid=252563 �nnnr�n�a
� ,:x
�� ;�, i�,,
_ � �h, f
, , �5,
ik � r1rr1
M' ' +M' �1F�61 1 ' �
�. r r
'_ �� .
' �`a ' 'h+
� ����t ' .�'(y{�' .
C� i .�i��' �� ' 4
5 1' rr,�ucv'i�+ k y@�ri
S .' `,iL j{,.� � . �'1 �,.�..
� ,, ��' �,r
r 7 t
N •p}��� �
� a� � ���d x ��a
`
� r. V� k.�1 ` � .
Sh �y����P^
,���� ��p�q,'�i��.re�,`-. �,' �.1
.� rr'� �: � }'
. r�
���
P
l�
,� � r 1 fl
� 4 �
3
� � p�
�A
[ ,'���` �,G
.� �� '�.,:�i ✓
1 4
lt', <��d�� � .
, �J�� 71
{#i.: } '
���rtir
k}�y' ,e
:. f .'� 3 i;t �'
� �g��r 7 ;
'�'
y � -"�r
? ° -
i �ji�a= �`Q rnr
���pl��7n�;
d�� �
P Y
�M, �
`!. ��
�Y�
j ik i°�� � _ tt''.
�f�'� ' ,,.,�.
�,�t �d '� �ri " �'�y
���� �
,�:i7T k ��„��* ��
W.� :,�
, r�, .. ���.1' ""`^.
i.
�f,� . 1 ^'i^� �-1y..'
�+' 1
a a .. �d . :������ `4g+'�`��".
'v;'�' �.�t��.r�r'r. � y��Xy� '��, S�, r,�.1kf.
, � �_ �•.
4'v ,.r -.a i' , .'�r t�"'.
q�p�� �riti ��;'� , r. � 'k � �.� �_.
�' + � � �'"t.�i'.5��,..���.
� �� ti � ��'- �':
i 4 �� t�*��
�,: ��"�
� �� ��� �� '�l�:
,. .
,� �,��,�:. ;
� ' '� "�
�' � �, �; a'' , r�}.;', � '`.� �; .
tr � •`r' �4 . � '.`"���.�
'� i t tt�.� '���F .
f { �C �� � �� � ' , �
A ; z��:•l: �
�, _ , _ . � �,
r � `Py,`�
`a'�.a �i �,A�.. � y •�±!";�2 ..j'
�i
'ma:e,i; 1� � �� � +� k��'..
F �
�"+4�r,..
�""*...,.�. � ,
� �.
�*,^`'',*� , .;:
����
.,�� �is��� �
;`� �� �>;
�^"",�'�"" � " �',.�,,' � t+
�1 �
� � ��
��� b�� �� �k
�� � �
�,�fi, ,�,�° �
M�^qp
���,, �
. ;: �
�. �,e.� ,�s
i�� ,
; ���;�,
'�� ,� �:�
�,,�•�" �,a
�r.
x ,
i �1 :
�� ��,'
�'T hti•� �� ���
� ��`� C �^ ,.iYi � J'��
.j. J�� � �' ,
�
� y �g¢ ,
� ''� l a�4}"
,'4 �� ��, f� �'�
�;� r.,:� :� .A��`r
a, ��� ..��f"1M
y,.
�.;� .�, ��F:-
Me�,�
bW,p�,,�, .
2'
..,�,,:'.a r:
'� .rw�..h�,
�� �
,V" ,� ^'�Y.y=:,'�
s,g..
r
p}ri�`k,.
;�:
� . , {� _ .
� r�°`� i+��.�1'��1�: _ + �,� „�,�`�,tr iQ-�� .M�,,� C"` •• -.o� _
.� �a.�re�c, `a.�F-�"F;�". ,& �X ""j��yl:r.� ��� �+
'' kh'�"� �� ,' �.��,. ,' ��`� ^.��� c ��r t i
�',� ��. a � � �, a � • ,
4 �..-��, w r ./r_. � �=( , . 7
't ,�a,� :� "` ��p�'� �- + �i�'.M ;r� .�'" � . �
. ,, ,�' �y } ..�� �n� p���, S .a',� t � �" � '� �s� ;''I� c �~
t , ���P y
i�j" ���� � ,•+•'a.'�c � '� �'� �j ",,��1*a: +` r �'
q •A .^�,� � '� tg'yr' � � , .
� �y °
7`� �� � ?�Ti� � n M �� F 5 'c?k"4+'°T.Ar . Ej... - ��
�:i � .d '�'� pi'f yj,, 1 �� � `1. k,' + q � i
�� t� .. + � 2b� w � � - ' :. ^7'a�.k .�! ��� �i/ _..
' --�.�i' .w:Y � �"� ,p ` ,�y •r ��t,,}v y,� � . f
y`�;N ��� '��.� � � r dr4��e� �7+`�� ,� e 3�i � � �,�
,� "�
N � �
���� �Y�
«,r,w �
p �,.
i ��'�,��.�, �,� K� `*�`; "�3��W��a � �a,,�� �
� . ..
».. �v @ « b '� � 1� � �W. .
-,q� x ,�� "� r adt.�" ��` 1k � ° �:4.' ' :�
' ,�,��,''��t. � � 3, ,c�r• .
"�+, � ',.�,�°� °� `"�'�, �,
��`� �, at�:.��,�,,,� c;� � :�
i� �'�� �m ����� J°i�k � y,¢:'�{'' �Y'�A ��
� I � i;-:,�0� �,^,. '
` ��
n e
I
i �,.. ,,,�
. � rr � �.�4 j h,�y� �F.�. ,��.. ,k, .�i•,
;r �r
r ��-�. ;: , t • ,
"�, � � ,r'_ �'� ,..,G� _ - - �
�'�,'F �,�J�� �+ . "h ,� �"'`'d e``� s r;;A' tc� �
��,�p°�. Af t M1 ,� x�' �:. �� �(� � 4' i+re,'�..` � t
�� ,.'� �%' x`� � � � ���{�+t
;� � e `� fi�� y. r i�j �,C� � , �� �
��" ,�: �{ Y s, �s,�w j, °�
� f 4 0�' A'�j F1� �
k, � �� � 1y��M� i k: t
� # x �, ` F �yP )e{f�� +t t �f�Pn`' 4
� ;� '�� t� ` (.y� ;�Y ���� �Y����
,� � r�l'r SII � 1 t ' �y�j �'�" lar ' �f�;1
�4���� a,,, �, ,� � r ,� i ��` .;, ` ';j,j ���',r���
,
� � � � � � f , �,�i-! ��� +�}+�i a�'�. .i
�,�a�� ` i p I '� ' '�';y� �� � $.'� r�t�9 i, i
'wa � t ''�' ����P� �� �� �� IYI
,�4���'�� ; � � � '1 {r, , ' tal.
� �� ��, �;a; ���� ���� �;��� ( y��,,.� ��j ,t,` ,
' � �' r. .� tY� `� � . , f� ,
.� � ��� �� , ��� � Jr �� � ti: , -
�' � ,� �, + ,''i
� � ,�
�� ��.w���.��kY ,`i 4� (y/ , r� _
. �
� > , �' � �� ���� � ' w _.
��- � ���' �9 `:� t � �-��'� ;e° .�.. � t�, r h, •
i .,, "�`� , �, ����rw d '��`v�`a i �`' ° � ��"�" 1 -
�. _�! � , r� :, ,�v ��� �,�,�� �,�: .e'" ��'� �
,� � �. � , ��
��^`'� �"'%�'`�'., � � ��x � ,� � , , �� ,�",,� �. ,"J �,
,
1 , �,' � '�*,,,�;3:. � "�"" � 9-' �. � '�
� `' �} 'q�,,� � ,�� ; x �`.# ��' �� ..1!
„ d. �
, , , ,
p�, �x k t.
w � :
.,f �� �l `.� °�.7`f�� y,6. �� �^�� .*, � �$ .
�
6 �t . °°�� � � . 1 , .
� ��;' � �� � A " , ,
� � ,� �� r ��
�� a�. :4 t��.&" �'�,; k� ���� ��"�'�� � _..��g� •h J �
�` �1�7 Saif+ P�'�~r " }%y�' wY'Y et f ��� �� �,�. '�I!C� � f
_ �
r �
fi� �� " �. �, . �� �� .. � � '
�' , . .
' ,�# � �� � �1.,...y�p . ��" . e
�
,�'. � .� r�,,� �� ��� "';�, _ _� � ` ",
�� ` � � ]��,
� .s �e. , �i
.11 F yt ���y���..i .. �., 4.1�� � ^Ma . - '�Faw. J �� �'Y+, ,
7
' Page 1 of 2
„�. , City of Palm Desert
Yu,v�3
r..� � sa�R�,�� �21� ��0 ��'1
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT � �
73-510 Fred Waring Drive �� ���
Palm Deser�CA 92260
760-346-0611 �jj�`�„ �(P/J.
� ,,; F� " � .'. ;;:
CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION
PH�ted on 10/21/20i4
�tr+eet Malntenance(Publk)-Nuisanoe Weber/9tsndinp Water/Gutt�er DraleageQ
�'y F:,E'.C�1iP.5t:A�i�C(:5� � {";i(�t.'�f,;:iril,elE.t i.lif�if(1,�-�:�,"��.
Street info: Narth Vtew Drive Citizen Name: ]anna Meinhold
��Y/aP Phonel/Phone2: 760-341-0683/na
Cro�Street Mesa Vfew Drive City,Zip: --
Deta�Ls Storm drafns bcated tn front of
homes in The Summit at 48-
550 Nortfi Vfew Drive and 48-
551 North ViE.w Drive.
> ���.;;�uE�s� r���ta�l_ ihzen�
Request De�crip�ion: Reaident dabns that the
sborm drair�s have palm
tnees growning�drem and
aerosol�dumped inaide
cauBing poor drairn�ye.
Is It presentlng an no
irnme�abe dariger 6a
the publk7:
� Staf�Request Admin
Request ID: ?55187 Ptiorily: Normal
Rec�ved/EnGer�Bd: 8/16/2013 10:31:48 AM
Target CompleOe Dabe: 8/30/2013 �S: �p�
Actual Complebe DaGe: 8/21/2013 ��
Request Source: Taken by[Donna Evans] Fiag:
HOW:Staff(S)
�n9�►��9�ed Sbff: Gaugust►,Cora
Cum�t flss[gned 5taff: Reye5,Qavid(See Ati^tiorts LOg for detalls)
� Staff/Citizert Actlon Log
ACTION TAKEN pAg BY WHOM
Staff Actton:Task completed by Jesse P and A�l Z 21 AUG 2013 DREYES
13:57
StaH Acdon:Status was changed fram�Iteceived'to 21 AUG 2013 pREYES
'Completed' Z3:55
Actual Corrtpkte DaOe was changed frpm'p,rriptjr�t�p
'08/21J2013'
9Feff Acdon:Carlos Hernandez has rea�igned this ZU pUC,2013 CHERNANDEZ
Request bo David Reyes on 8/20/20i3 l:19:15 PM.Reason 13:19
for Reassignment:Schedule to have this dr�n deaned,
�:1/palmdesert-CITI].C1VICA,SOft.CO?YI�A(�III1T1/UY1T1�8pi1CT:f.acn`�tprntPetiri=7551 ft7 �n/��r►n�e
' " - Page 2 of 2
U�ank you.An Emafl tws been�nt to David Reyes at
dre1�Yo��mdesert.org.
���%C���a�9���sslgned thFs Request 6� 20 AUG 2013 CGAUGUSH
Carbs Hemandez on 8/20/2013 1:15:17 PM.Re�on for 13:15
Reassi9nment: Please schedule for maintenanoe.Thank
you.M Emafl has been serrt to Cxrbs Hemandez at
chernandez�dtyofpalmde.9ert.org.
Staff Acdon:Ph�os atbched of totation.Debris in storm 20 AUG 2013 CGAUGUSH
drain lnlet inhibldng draina�. 13:14
Stai�At�chment 2:View Attachment
0
StaPF Attachment 3:Vtew Attachment
0
Staff Attachment 4:View Attachment
U
StafF Attachment 5:View Atmchment
0
StdfF Attachment 6:Vi w Ae�c � n
0
http://palmdesert-crm.civicasoft.co�m/admin/printRequest.asp?requestid=255187 �nn�r�n�a
r �
Page t of 2
, City of Pslm Deae�#
,l \ Service Request
~ PUBLIC WGRKS DEPARTMENT
' 73-510 Fred Waring Drive
Palm Desert,CA 92260
�°° 760-346-0611
�� p g � � ��
`` f ' �� �� ' CONRDENTIAL INFORMATION
Printed on 10/20/2014
Street Malntenance(Publlc)-NWsanoe Wabar/9tanding Waber/Qutber DrainageQ
�� Re'Quest Atldress ��� �.pYizen C.ontai.t tnformaYoon
Street Info: 48550 N.View Dr C�izen Name: Gary Wiggins
Aty/Z{p Phonel/Phone2: 760-341-7268/nd
Details in front of above address C�Y.�A� --
� GIS Ir�Po � � i<cyut:st Getaifs (Ir�format�o�� provitled by Gti:eni
Request Destription: 9trom draie needs deanUq
I Is tt presenqng an no
irnmedfate dan�x to
the publtc7:
eD Sta�f Request Adrnin
Request ID: 250864 Prbrity: Mormal
Reoefved/Entered: !0/12/200911:56:32 AM Status: Completed
Target Compfete Date: 10/26/2009
Adual Complete Da6e: IO/23/2009 ��
Request Souroe: Taken Flag:
by[]odl Orton]
HOW:Staff(S)
Original A�signed StafF Gaugush.Cora
Current As�ned Staff: Zamarripa,Aaron{Sea Actions Log for ae(ai(s)
� St�ff/Gtizen Action Log
� ACTION TAl�N �T� BY WHOM
�aff Action:This request was assigned to)oe Rosas& 23 OCT 2009 MZAMUDIO
Frank Duran ft was oomplebed on 10-21-09,thank You. iZ:24
�Adion:Status was cfianged from'Received'bo 23 OC'f 2009 MZAMtIDIO
'�mP��� 12:23
AcQiai Compl�e Qate was changed from'empty to
'10/23/2009'
Staf'f Actjon:Carlos Hemandez has reasstgned thls 14 OCT 2009 CHERNANDEZ
Request to Aarnn ZamaMpa on SO/14/2009 7:4438 07:44
AM.Reason for Reassign�nt:Schedule this for Geaning.
the phot shows a bcaqon In the wrong address.The drain
at the 48-550 Is further north.The draln In the phobD Is not
a draln its an outlet whlch tbe inlet Is somewhere behind
the homes which we do ot maintaln.There is a dratn infront
of 48-550 that needs some cleaning a the�uth end of ths
storm droin,some minor trash..An Email has been sent to
Aa�Zamarrlpa at azamaRipa�c►tyofpalmdesert.org.
SKAfIGKT
http://palmdesert-crm.civicasoft.com/admi.n/printRequest.asp?requestid=2So864 10/20/�n1 a
. �
Page 2 of 2
Staff Adion:Spencer'Knlght has reasslgned this Request 13 OCl'2009
to Carlos Hemandez on 10/13/2009 3:30:00 PM.R�eason for 15:31
Reassignment:Carbs:Ls this the Ctty's to maintain?.M
FrnaU has been 9ent to Carbs Hemandez at
chernandez�cilyofpalmdesert.org.
Smff Ilctlon:Randy Chavez has rea�igned thls Request to 13 OGT 2009 RpiAVEZ
Spencer Knight on 10/13/2009 2:49:29 PM.Reason for 14:50
Reassignment:Spenoer,I've endose a picture for the area.
Sorry I got Mgger happy..An Emall has been sent to
Spencer Knlght at sknight�dtyofpalmdesert.org.
5�ff Action:Spenoer,we don't n�aintain anytfiing in the 13 OCT 2009 RCHA1/EZ
vidnity. 14:49
StaPf Atlachment 2:Vlew Attachment
�)
�1lctlon:Spencer,we donY maintain anyt?�tng In the 13 OCT 2009 RCFIAVEZ
vidnity. 14:49
Stafi Attachment 3:yiew Attachmer►t
�)
Staff Action:Spencer,we don't maintain anything in tfie 13 OGT 2009 RCHAVEL
vidnity. 14:48
Stdff Attachment 4:View Attarhment
�)
5taff Adbn:Spencer,we dont maintain anytfiing in the 13 OCT 2009 RCFIAVQ
vidnitY� 14:48 �
Sta(f Attachment 5:V�Attachment
�)
Stal"f Adbn:Sper�cer Kntght has reassigned tlifs Request 13 OCT 2009 SIQVIGfif
ta Randy Chavez on 10/13/2009 8:21:54 AM.Reason for 08:22
R�sigameM:Randy:Please�ke a bok at thhe sborm
drain at tlie above adchess,�ke a picture,and let me
knaw..An EntaH has be�sent to Randy Chav�ez at
rrhavez�cityofpatmdesert.cxg.
91sR A�tion:Cora Gaugt�sh has farwarded ttds.Rsquest to 12 OCT 2009 CGO�lK�1SH
Spencer Knight on 10/12/200911:56:32 AM.Reason for 11:57
Forvvarding:I wIN be out of the offbe ur�i Monday,Ocbober
19,2009..An EmaN has been sertt On Spe�toer Knlght at
skni9ht�c3lYofpalmdeselt.org.
I
http://palmdesert-cmi.civicasoft.com/admin/printRequestasp?requestid�50864 10/20/2U14
I
. . .
�. �
i � 1 �.t �i � fi '.��/� ' , ' 6
�E �, n
i' . �����
+�`� � '� �� r�� •;,,�,� J,� �r
�.. , �. 'I+ ' ��,p���!'��. �ti` , �'� �e
�: � ��,�� ,�tit � t ;_�( r"'�.� `,��- �
a ' �
.:� sr s. _ { � tk.�}' _t r �'3�o ` ;d
� l
s� T �r .�A� � M r �,�- ryy��` •,�(.
�.`"�� �` � ' � �j/ +°' �
'1,���� _� 0 r,f p 1. . l�:. l �'t( A'
I�'� � L��� , ���,' .�'� .)"`: }is'�(� � ��) F�
.. t'. I ��t fh�, t}r.�.`�� �;i'
_ •b j . �''�,�i^`s 9 r �'�,
�� A� j�� � }1 =�' � ��� i'�9
rr � 1 � ( �
� x ` �`
r, ,� � '1 .� a s
4 1 + � � yf ���� n
� A' 1 �r o �. .
� � � �°�� � 1 � 'F
� �Y �'
s � �� '�+ ...� ~ � .. . ' �r'"'�'., .;�
r.
;Mtk' , � � . , ..
`+p rl�..�..` � i. � . .. . S pP,.
� �� �
, " � �� „
� ..i
l � •
_`'d:
� ��.;'�'., ' . �.�y"
! ✓,,. ,;'.
,� .
� r� t. ��� ..� .f
Y � ,sn' �� ' � •� �
.R {q,�
s � �5
;� .7 � r 't,Y� .
^1��w �_ ��I�� �� I� I I I . „;..t:
I�
��� �I ;
�° '/
r
i
� .
� . .
, , r.i ,
v
�
.
�
,.. ' .... 1. . .
.._ ...._-_._ .y .:
.._._.__...._ . .
�'. . t 5i:
' ��� � �� �� � .
�
� �
' f�A���� ' ,la , ��'., ,
1
. i� ��'�,,�i��.T�,p�� �,is� � . .
�' � 7� �i �
�rr�, �
�
,+ t4� y,, � . ��� y� ,:
t � �+YriL°tR � � �
� �ti ����., , ��
;.; �<,� � i-
� ,�,. , ��.� ��
�` i f �
,°
! ,�'�F �"' �w'�
�: V � � �
���' ,�r,�
. ,
. ,
i, �, y �,..
��; �y � �,
� ���s,` j ,7
i ����:t� a .
� ���� '�r,� > '�" ���
F�F � �ri f '
y �`k'[ �r+
.I!{{�,.� �A�r��� k .
y�ni i t�#�, d..
h1}'}� i� n
. ��'���� t t�•�K�
� �. � 1
M�i
�1 �,�l� �
a�. ��,G `,��
� �t i i
�a� , ai�,�.�� '�>�v
i�,v
�' - t�;
.1,'��d"�'` . .
I
� , Page 1 of 2
.� City of Palm De�ert
%.:' \ Serviae Request
'�� PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
73-510 Fred Waring Drive
Paim Desert,Cp 92260
I R a��. � . .r�.
760-346-0511
CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION
PHnted on 10/20/2014
Street MaiMenance(Publk)-Nulsance Wabet/9tanding Wabar/Gutter Drainagen
� �
�����c:�Lip e , ;i:;<; � 'lc.��.. ,:�l;:s� „i .r{;_ ..�,
Street Info: 48550&48551 North View qtlzen Narr�e; )anna
ah'��p Phonei/Phone2: 76a341-0683/na
Qoss St►�eet Mesa View CItY.�p: --
Detalls Storm drains are lacated at
above address.
� �
Request Descriptlan: 9torm drains has pla�
9rowing out of them.
, Ls it presenting an no
immediate danger to
the publk?:
�0 Staff Rec9uest Admin
Request ID: 255805 Priority: Nonhal
Reaetved/Entered: 4/4/201410:41:13 AM
Target Complebe Date: 4/18/2014 S�' ��
AcYual Complete Date: Coior
Request Souroe: T�ioen by[,]o�prp�� �'
FiOW:Telephone(P?
Original Assigned StafF: Gaugush,Cora
(.Lrrent A�igned Steff: Gauq�;str,Cora�See Actiass Log far d�aiis;
� 5taff/Cifitze^Atti�n L.og
AiCTION TAKE7d � 8Y WHOM
Staf'l Actlan:Status was changed from'ReoeMed'W 17 MR 2014 CGAi1Gl1SH
,���,
11;18
�Actlon:Mark Grpenwood F�s r�fqned this 9 APR 2014 MGREHVWppD
�q�est to Cora�au9usF►on 4/9/2014 3:52:35 PM,Reason 15:52
for Rea�ignment:.M Emaf!has been serrt to Cora
Gaugush at cgaugush�dtyofpalmdeserGorg.
Staff Adion:Ma�1c,See photos taken by Mike Brown this 9 APR 2014 CGAUGUSH
moming,April 9,2014.Thank you,Cora ii:15
Stafl Aitathmenk 2:View Attac.hment
0
Stafl`Attathme.�t 3:View Attachment
d
5taff Action:Cora Gauqush t�as�ned tl�Fs Request to 8 APR 2014 CGAUGUSH
Maric Gr�eetsavood on 4/8/2p14 4:43:46 PM.Renson for 16;43
Reassfg�menr Mark,Please advt�e.Thank you,Cora.An
ht�:/lpalmdesert-cim.civicasoft.cnm/admin/printR�qu�t.asp;hequestid=255$OS I0/2o/�n�a
,. Page 1 of 1
. � . ,� _
-:,-
�.. �
.. .,' . ,, �
� . �.
., �,,
�' � i '�
��� r +�k•
C� rod� � .�"�dr' .. �Y � j � R �, f y}1.
.q . ... _. - .. ...
• . + ,
� � � 1)'��'{�BY���n ��. ���y,�, ..
. 4:M . � � d,�"7F
.f
1� rA�`.. 4 .
�l�6' �. •� ';� �::, i'
r' � . , , �'� "�` �
�;. .
, �
�*F
''.'�Y '���� •�' ..�_. ��a� 't"ly,�} ," .
11.4 T {� t .
.� � ' 11.� a; �A�}�4}��9�, .
."�.] ��1 }f11,�T'gG'�
.����t.h
� t.i f:r
�\
\ �\
\`` \
,
� \
y ' r
y,.
�.
',.
�ftPJ�I����-CID1•C1ViC850ft.00?1]ICiVirA/1nr.la�minhinhf�.t, .,�..rn.�..Lrr._��.,� _ _ ._ .
':� • �
K�
`b
�.T�
H,, - .
� II ; .I. � �. ,� �a # 1 '��.
fi �
��' �:17+: i
1 a`+.i� '��,
..,y..�� ,.f?.. .�..w
'j.
tr.:.-� .F�.
� $a
P "w,'"a'�"r �iF H t r'� .
r�y ,: k �Xi��
.�w� �, �„ �t���� �` ���`�Vti��p¢#�:��i � A
,' ,: i(}
� . � ��
4 ! jH �i.
��'�� �- �� f, ?.
�" r 1
��� � '�tl
%k; � �"E`r#'�n � c ��t
�., , y ,
,t •h• .�',�.� .
J�r � � �I
�. ',. . ..� , .;••
i. .�. "�' �� ...�.H yl . .
. ��, �.� 'M�.4, ..�SkN+t� .... . t . "
�' 41j .rro � '.�+�.� . . ,w}� . �1� l�*' •"
,� � ,�i�. � � 1 i
A ;.,�� �,
�r'.' ��, � � .gk a�Yti�.
-,� f �,� .� ,+s� � ,� . ' �i
� . . r� i . . � �r ��;.
�. . � � � 1,.
�����"��: � �, - ,� r.;� ',
. .}i. ^�A i�, ,�'� �
' �:7 " . • ' � "\ R�'�: ' M;��,
� � � { ,� '+n;.v-._ ....+...�� jH
� �' ti +r
�1 '.��.�• y� �.. � 1 Z\` � .�� ���,� ./'
° '}��1 �
,��. r "' � �., � � � f,� , .
�:,,'. s '_; `r' 'C' „-.�y �'! �� � ''y��u ��. ! , '���'"
� �/ �. �f � � ..�- "�. 1� �F.
�• �r.- �*� .. � .y. .+� . ..... �
'r, r t,� .1 , . •
� � �: u � - � �� � � �� � :�
. .. . .� ..�.. 1 Pr^:. .. .
". .' .... 4 . , -" �
. � I�'.y. �d``�� �54M . V Y
e �'r
� �"�.�� '""� ,�' �- .,r i���..'.����t.` s� � ;�r �
>, .
aµ1:, '' w'"�y' �� 4.���� � � x��` � tbra���i�«i�wpy'�ws""'y � � t #��
r
her 4 �
� .` r�^� .� 'Y . 1.�q'�1�p . ''a:iu.7rh,yy��, � �`+
`+� � M. � 1 �t�� �x � a .�` ir�� ���'` ����y,r,a'` �'. a `}��� �
" ��+ � ,{ ; � .'��F^Pru .r. kq � 'r �i. �.�, � .S°a'! � �4 ' '� c,
`� �>'�" "�•.,,�` .k �'�i,4 r Y i �� t.� j �� : ��'`'.h N,�w r "�
' ' t �a ��� . y �� �� t ,�� � •�5
� .....�` f7R�,' w��'��,'��1 '•j� r'"p`%��� �.. ' � � �i.i` , ' ,; ��
, � �,. � �,�, t �t+' ,�.
�i•. a , '+3E.k. ' ♦ � '� ��`���'�. �a 'R q, �;, �,`a. ��r��`��'.!q h .. :�a a�x.�s
� �`'�"�.'���' �`F ��' x �i �s� .A�'.., :�y.. ��,�t`°�r x¢{� '�.� ��h �,�. °,. �f �;,� � . a'�w .
d �` 4 7'� �i �+ 4' °7,Sp� q`�,U.1 y . ��4� f.
W � f ;il '�a �
�.�. �"�'}�' �` �i��j �... � N� �5.� �'� �a. �`x} �` � .. } ' .,
�'��..'��' �!� �d�'R,� *� en r, t � � vi L : �
�,^��,�' ,�r p ,�"� ,y: " +a ����,� � a�� , ���
ur-�._ ,y y,"�G, ,� � w �r r a '�€'�� `#s� '� r'� t � � �' ~�.� ' cr
�► � .RL'�'� ��, /��d. p � y� � �y�W�}, � � y � � '�"�w
, '
Y'� �`�'.� i' t P' i �z� 1�l{`+ � ��^d�y�� . i , � ��t � . *+(�
,�:: �� `'�+sr '�� i "";, � " 4 T�.�j�,�� t�
,� ,r ,� t ry �, '_ * r.�,
u� . y� •_•• ,'Yk R . � k�' � � Ay'. � •1 ' � . . .. ���
����*1 ���. �A � "W j,vt ���,1 �� ;' �'", '�
`L�k�'� �' �;�" ". �(� *.""�i����.. .. � � � . '.
� ' �C :a. �`' �? �u4
..M .�y�1. .. � . '{ ����p �'74 ' Y{. �,� � ' ``1� ;
i:� � n Fy+"-fA �b1•� . � Y �'!' 7 ��t�• � .
� � , �h ��� . �a � , 1
� :_ '�{x �� � 4�• �h f � . . .. . .
� �. liri L M,'��' . � d ( .�,. ' ..
.@ � '�'y,:t �.�y�.+ihwrM�r . w.« r a1R� �" 1� ��� � , �'r
i o� �
�°r" '�{ �' �,. ,�'��5��;�r *i�" ��
�7 � �r
. � ?t��c _ � •� Y� � . +t �i 4� m
..�`�` � �.�^T.'� , " ' � k �� t��� `� � S.� � D��.�4 1` A
h� .._.:. .1tlr}3 �'� h'6 i€,s. � c
� � �� � �S d�r" i ��t� s 1.t���'��`'� •i � ��a 4 y � � � ,��.
r+� � ;#���'` `r� �•.x y �'��``�,k��.� ��+ ,j� �` i' .;
t� .. �+
',, �"'� x �,' , 1 �" ` ' .
�?' ::• , � .`;�•'� ^�
s, : �' � f `="Fi�; . �i �• �`.'' � ;�,`� '`' � , ,
� 1 � ,., `y ti , �
. . f �,
� a�k";'� s^.. . .. ! �ql .� )tead\�+'�.L 1 �` . ��'� �'
...� 1 ,.t� , � ,. .:,` ��
. . ,: �.�'�: �'� �. `tiy � ka�••�wV� ti b �{w'��..` '.
� .,. �' �'" J � 4 ,r �' �`'�t"' ^' ' .� t �w
!. . . �. � � �,r1 � Y.
,'�� �. J�' .�i �' i a ' � .,! �.
r
T , � � � tr . . _ v�:� . ` �y� � t ._ T�':
� •`' •
�', �t.
• . ..,, ._..�. � . , �! � � 4� . • ., • .r.' � . . �..
" J � �� \ �,' ` \ � .:
-.-';p"' ' ..�;� .. .. . .. � ` .
:.. � f p: T i ' � , * 1 � 1 �1. '� �� �jA
` `
�� � . . �t'yry,l t ♦ . . \ 1t( \ 1 �`M\` i+�. �.
` � s�•w. �-•.. ..,y�. ���. � °y'"�wt :�;. .� ':� �- �.',�,� +��i ti �j� ,1` �'i Y ,;��� +Y
'�rr _ � � a PUD�C. F � �{ Y . �.1j ' t .�, -.. ♦.n•.
i• �,y.F`L ls �"�4 °"«'C:• y ,i ( '' '� * ,; ti � ` , , , i5 ,F''
i i � M1 �
� �y t� t ...`t •'+ F 13 � ' ` � � 4;�.
t t ''w . ., 4 vx'e �3 ��y � L�•i
i� �' ��� ; i� �M`;�� P� y�4„�„4.4� �� � �«y� � � �y . 'Y , t X.
� t' •s�B�+iM o-: � �'. ��s���°,�� t� °�j ti n { • �ti u .� � � ?y a
..: :�� ����' �� . A�t 4nFy� s�� `: L k 4�-���. n�w�� � � .r'� ' ,�.
�',+5,.i �. y ���.� �{�q�:� a t fi `LFq � `y� � �, � 4.�'��:
t . � ]°� b�'�.� T 4�Y M,�1�'���,.}�,, i � ♦� �•,
!� Ct h�Yor 't +,{y�*k'i y,l�"L+ , 1
{.1 \ � � �q.�fr d��L �� M! t t y Y:
.�' ..� � t J � �A W Y �� � ` �� h } ' � \
w �� � i y��+y s3k i�,, Ir �'wF °:� d" ,�� 'v ;�.;1 t -:l
._...r.. � .'•�� , � ; 1� '.l `r''�'t r�� ly� � ,���' � '"j� �� �,�Y t � :�� �
' �� �� ,,��� � � �{r��y�+ 1ro � � �� '��' ' e 1 •� ,�v,,•.
��� �_.. - .�. � .
/R� � � •.'. v...t t, 4= . � { h y w y.
� �, 1 ��n t� � � \
_ .� [� ' ..,�� 1dt�'. �s't ti�T�r�.�.. �f�" ..
e�� ' ' '� .` . .t,� .; ��y ae ,a. 3 '!� . �3 . ,. ,+�
�` t'r£ �.� y •`'1���� .� . aw{fi;�. r .4,� �� t � ' , ��2 ��,� �
Ii �4 S'�if � ���9 9��' �*� ' � .�' �'7 .`.. `6` � �' • ' - , i.
,g* '.«,� ,��. , r \� �1� �`1 i�� � `.� � .
*� +� ,, :'. '.y� .+' ^}'r�+ta' .;� � `* • .
v�� �. �,, � v,F; tr,� , ` , ' . ' ' ' ,
. IF�� � t , t , t,i �, . ' .. ' � .
i� j, `1 =t, ♦,'� , .
• ',r� , .,, :, � :•� x � i. , .
`4V€+V• �t 1.��� � ..�a4 .yr��``\\w. � y'. . _ ` ' .
:.�?�' .4 tfYf..i A W' �y�.,'+ 1 ...\:! v4,`�:. ' . . ,
8 �y,' '.',����i t �� 1�, �,4 l .. . .
�
y�,�� '� �
t' ' � 4 ti.��ll'at" � id i "" i,L ,�' . ` ,
�� � �" �a,�$-�ti��,`�;, �t,��;���` �; � � . t � . ��. �
�,• 4 �'���"' ni., r ir� .» •.` .
�4 - ,'�' w �. ,,+`� r*y "t 4 '' r :
��S � t .�$ ,°'R
,�, Y� ,�r .'��ry�� � , � . -�� � x � ' u � J� �'.
��4* . �"'i� ,,J1t; �'��x'� - ;d� '�,s.
, r
�
.
, "
i�, t .y �, '� ..M f �' �,,,....." : � ,[V�"f
��' �'1"� �IP� �� '� �,� d%`, v,
� � a� ���r',^i��y�s e..' '+,I�' �� •�� ���f � ��°:f .,
��'� ��N!�E)^� 5t �. ,., � � ��<r ����� �!t ��' 'r�
d:;�^ �g A. �t .
��r� ~'A rd�t,,.� A ."~� � � ,.._ �^ f, m� �� x�
''yy x .s
k�����;, r y ki t� ,M^ ' � 4i"� �' �'r'Pw i �,,��?'
a , ad� �1 S��MA,�r - � � ,� ,v' ��'� '��� ° ;4 �. i..
ow'4 � p
i a 4 ,q .�1�. � : ' � /1 `�Y� �t ,��.r. x� �,.
� ��� �r . r l� " � �� F �rsp�
� ��
PK ��. d i . � - �'�.��W .�; . y�y,
_^"�.���w� � � a, ��. .�`':� y ,,;
�,?^'' °• ' .�'''
h� � � ��
. ,�,- � �, � � F ,�_ r
r �tn��. , > r. �f .
,� a t�"��,, • � Y �� , "� `�+�:ri' " �,�, s-
�+'�i, !?:. �� yt. ,�1��i .. r� .
.�.a�, . +y�,c,. � � � � 4',�.. # � � • .. � .
.� nY 1 r +� T
f�'�; �'M1�� �..�Zi'M". ��i.� '.�� �:�Yi �� , � . . ��
y� ��yy b; � � �. ,
��,Fi' 2V�7'n� �'4',j� � � �`��� C+ ', ��1 , , � ' '� w
w n M`��'��.. Y�` k �
�P� ,� � � ,�,�C 4 �,F; ��� �
Ai . � •}j�, , ;* �'6 r A r d; .
,`� , t,, , ., ti1�, ��. �,� y � �+.�
�; ' � �`t �a �) •xx�.�'
�j� • a.;�'t`~�w;'' �.'� � wf � �
, .
. �x"a� �AE �u�#��.� '� . ' �x , 3+.,nP. � � .. ..
�� . �,
�„��'�+� F x¢�t�� �F� , ' . ' _ . �� �,� 'akw"
��� u �1,r. . �. . ' �, . � 'i', . � �:�� f
��sA� , w.M �..�. . . ' . �...�"'-�` {�' .
f � ��� . � f �t
��'��k�e� � � .s- '�M�.. .�;..�.L-,
; � ^:
p���;� ' �� ' �' �i - T '.
� ��,i �TM' �, '� �
�� � �., �. �, ��. , ._� � _ � i _.'�
1�, _ � ;� � d�. "`"`' ��� � �. �L.
9'�� ' ,5°k� � ,�nr'i �;� �'?• x '�"^ r�y� ''��,
t .. �Myy4
�' '' � �` � � ''� f � � ��.,-
. . , � .. ` ; h��`���io'�,. ���+'�y .�.+.w 1 .
. �`� , - .� � i
Y°� ��
� , �� � r` ���
�� r��,�74c4�Yriip�,,,�' •:�[:�,
. � ��
' ,, 1•
�_ ����`� ��� A`:
i
�: �y C l�. i i �� �-. �� 'fe. �,
� d �;�T "�°�� � �,�d� �,��^s�,°'jM1��„�th °� `��, ,�.�.r i � —
� � �4� t : � ���e�i��'� '�,� rvay� _, �, ��
3 A p � ,
�'b�'., t�i �`�,�ns,w��A ��`,��V���j9'�b'm��' �t�,;, �y�� . Y
��d� �
�� . ., �� 1' � . . ��I �'��
� \
��, _ ,
K .
, � �
�
� � - r�: '�i"' � ,,�,�`" t
�� ��`� �' ,�,�, �,� .� � ,�t
� �(':�' ������
,..
� � ��. . �� �� ,� �: .A
;�' '.�' ` � r.; ' �r �
'��. � s �, : , -
. .
, ��a . . . �: .� �, � . ,�� ,�� � � . � • �,
: .
, . , ,
,��, �: ,;�'�"'• ;� , � � , , , r '�
" .�.
, , :
. � � ,. _� �. � � „..,
'• �, � � � ; ,,
� „ �r ,f. r-
;< .,� � � � ' : �a
��c _ � ��+�'�'YY . . . M ,— �� � � � .
���' �,� ��?��� '�� „p....
�
'1 � M
:;5, � :.� oir-{ !k.'.
*;E..«�. —� /
r.�;� �ya",
'�rn r ��r • � ,dtl ���T,�� �� r
�• � � r i µ IR � ..
. F
r�M s� �s�M'' �� � +;1,'- ��.'4t �t �
Y� � � t ��` I���'I , ,q� �
'+ly�. �+" d� � .� � �.�I �
�,^ ��, ��; � ;� � �`; � � �,,�� M1.� �,,���' � ,�`
.� f ' ,�� �.�� �i , �.a-
'�� ky Fr Y�,,:.:
,, .�.
1 �
�� �� i�
.,�1► � .+�� �p � ' � �
� �
. �
�� � �-: �, �, ���_ i 1 �° -�'a
a
' t�� ay^i� ��»:'� ' ��I�� �� "` �, l�� ,�,�,�'�: r � , ,�
� �' � ,��� M ���-�, I � � � �.
I �i'� "xr ���� i �� �:��v. -i
� a. }� r� f �{ a�'.' �t'.:i
q `1.� °� +�r.�
� �,��1� �^ , k �� 9 q� � qy
�_„'�f s ,.�
� ` "
, �.�
,t�P , y� ;
,.,;
• � � x ��� �,
. .� .� . �
�. ., ,
. , � �'� �
r "��'� ' �� b� �
. , , ,
R � � ,� , , . �
� �t . �
� � n' . �
.
,�� � , � �,� �� '�� �r
� � �� � � ,�, �n�,'� �!
.., � �.� � r �� .�,
i � �i� ..{y� u ,_ .
r ^ � `�, �w�l�, ' Y ,,,� . � � �� « ':���
,��� � � +
k'
A'f��X ' � � � .' j� I�' `' ��
� �� �*' .�4,r {�i�, r, . .
� ��' �f � �.� �� i5 d
I T r. , . P �'1F*�� .� • 5 �'�"� �� , ���.
�l4
�� . . �! .' 4. � M� �•� �t ;��V Y ,I �I ��I
�tarry�,, ,: * ��w, '�,
�. . �VYMW�� ' � � '°` x <.'
r�R��. � �{ � ,.iJFc ���k' ,p., � k
Y - Y '� r �� ,`� �:_�
H
� � � ' � �- ��i��� �, �� �=�".,� ' :s
+:� � � � �; �" .
� �� ��� ��'�.
"' ' ► •'`� ,.
'�d,I�IM?F•'.11' �V A : .. Il�e yF 't1; ��
;I ;�.
� ��,A' �1r .� n.,�ti�
�.� �Y'. ,.�!. s wi y� .
'� . � + .`.
P
' �� �s "� j'•Y"���4�. ^w.�
�� r ��.
+ � � `'�'� �
�y a i� .� 4 . �.
��_ "r . 1'i1 '�3 a ' ' t
� ' «
�' � �� ,��.- a rt
a �
� i.. � a
� -� ��� � `y� mk_" •: ,�r� ��'
� ��" � 4� �ryy�,°�,'��. fi '� ,�f '��
„
^' �'. ��h �.�
,
, , . .
; '
#� '-'. 4 �'�. ' �� `' � �� �
4�y� � yl , .� � .�' ,�-' ..�� ° � ,:..... .^� . .i � � ,��
r -
a�',;'. '� � 3�'1�4" .r'
+ ���r� - �4�1 f£��y� � � �f���1�.
k . �.
I �
� . C,u � � �
� T a +A �'.{ 9�P k t° .��, $ � �:._ i
�P L � '1
.��
h. I .t �uA k y ��• T .� � ..
,. �i �� � �� � � ���� '�`;'� � ' ,; a�p, ��� � �
` "' . �. �
�,�'� � •�' � ��
��� .� �.
��` � ��.F �� k � � ,�
, a ,. , ,� . �
''� �'��' *°y" �r� , � ; � - �� k �
� �'� � �� .
.
�;
r
� � ,
�� � t���� ^� �,� ,� �-,„���' �
� �
t+Sx���� � � � � `�' ' ����i�l��..
�� `d, .� � . � � � _v'� � � p��,��`,`,.
'.'�A.
�.:',.
� , � ,•,�" k. ',�y . �+�
.t . .. . . .. . � .. _ . . .
;yi
q—'u.� ' . I . �
,. � .�,,.. . ..,. . . ,,.�
;.,�� f�P � Nd�� k i RCf�,���{ � �, � � A�� (1 �-�Yw "�s �' M �d . �'��.
'y�"i R�t� `��6�� �n-.� �" 'a -,�y � a. pt� 1"1� �o�'r ;i,� r .
�r�' 4�����,�ri � ,v� ".� �r ��� �` '-��
� � ��t� �. �;,s�g ir a. � � f y � �Y gf +a . . jf .� �
_
� _
:.�,�"sn�v.."S�'.�. , �6 ..+�� f .,t,J'�,��s f.w �� .-}'� v .�� + , ` $i i �� .
b _
.:
, c
. ak ��r' � '��Y�' A x , �.� � „.� ,_ • ^� .� �. , ,. -! .da,,� �
� ,, � r �^�,
_ ��°..�.�.
. .. ... . . fa.i��L���, �.y b. I t�,�, .
. _��: .. . .;� � .� � .� V FF,
. .. . � . . . .. . . �,`
.. � . . . . . . . . .'..' .
.. � � .. . . . . . :.i
� ,
� .:. ...� . �., '.
. .. , . . : ..,.. . .. � '>. ' ' .��� ,��:
'.�
.:
a
. � . . .. . . � � .k:� ' �F
, �yElc�°
'�� � � � ti1
R,� �
at
a; �?;i� �
' .. � . ., . f:.
, s' ' ?
t
r�
A,
#,_
� �����,4im� . v:
e
�Y '.; i � i r +af:
„�trT»` *a �i � � u i�'� �� `�� ��� '�
'f�� �R� �:� ��. "� „ ����t . .`�;- ,.
� � �f . .p�• � �,_
+ 5 �1
"«,�.� Y.�� 4 �rr
�.��`.i. ' ,�. .
�
r.
�� � .,*r4.. '45 8r���� � . ..
�� i ". �},� . j , - .. � . �i# . . . �4 YI
..,� , � . - . �. . � �f�
�W ►
1.
' / ,
/ �
,I t ��
; . �
� ;_ . .� .. � � . .
� �r�,: � ,� �,;�"';��
� �.,. , + y,, �r �
� ��
.�t ' � �'',1R:.1..
• ti �r
. j .
- � ai` �� ',� �W -,v ---
�, , � � �e
�.� �r ,�� '���:
�'� °l"� .� ��1 W .�� <rY;� .
e , ,F,j��,��"Y��`- �� �,�a
�1 �� �'�F�p,,•
"`Y�`1�
f��'d,.;.�P�. `s.�... ..� �?t -.K �����
�i;��J�,.���!t.e�4 . j�,� �1 �^' �`�p�..... .t,�w.b�J
„� r� �4.� �� ^£i,
. �i" ro t��#' . y�.y��n�, :.,u, . .,
� k d�"�-tT .. .�����y��'� ; , '`�"
�, '� +�'',x,�' ,�'�fi^i�,��� �� �,f,�
'P�1}e, �r .,�}�1�y�..'�'�t A�y�4 ��"ey '• � � .
� � w�� ��,, k Mdrroa�"�Ir�: . ... :
., ' .., r � .��.` .� "
p.
�.. f��. r� �s� � {�, �'
'19" �.. �
`r . ,�..Y �F
s._ � - �' % ; � +�' - �`�r' t
. ., ..�f.." ., `r Y+ �+,"' .
nt
�.��;.�. ,��. �., ",. � � - M
. sr�,ya �� , a- " an � . '
3f' _q�x �'V ' iw"'� �.
A'.'. �"':: � n , �
� �' , � �,k �� �,
� �`�r �'t�M�tw"i . �j� Y? � � �.�'�,;,+�5+''
�"%k�C �'�'-�� � p4 :�p��!� � ��! w� +a1�'6'�
I�y �.. "✓.� l^' .. !.b.l'\ 4.����...:;
. �.'w �w +f:�+r "F� . '�'���, ,� � g'.;;�
. , � �'a.' ���M � , ..
k
.!�. . �a �4��' �' w ��Y,-
PA a
- � '�` �'������3'f,a��,«a+k' .
� ,ri� s ,� +c-_.�� �: ��;.
...p ��� .�'.,�.
.. vru ���� ��� .:yr ��*sy� e.�
`Y, � � . : ��� $� .
�.n � 'i���iC�k�1��p �r r � Y.t w.��7�* �^
,
�. p�i
t�: + �; �i� �
�F I - .. �� �Y;�"�n'� �c,� �u"�'�.,� . �� .. . ., .
w,
x .1��,.::: ' � � .:.. g r��..�`i� ' , ^ +,.
� �'��,�}{ '`' �''i.. � . � � W'r�°� d '-'7�', '�°` �� � `` .
' � .
;.. y �;• r�'p�� . .' x„�" �� {y . . �+M ,. ,,.p. . .
u y F ./
,A s y ,�y�
� M S T. ��"�. �.� If� !�"1 ... g wI
'�'` ' ,� t "�' ' �` � i ' , .
, � ,,p!
,y��.� )pn ; �.:.shw yeyn� k � V� ,ky'"'� 77 a ' M�..f.� J°�� y'y*el��.� •
;
I�'+'� '�.. ty � � ✓�'�^'�i��d �:s '� �r .. Y '..., . '"'�"ya�t.' :; wt V�+�2�.�. �` 4kr,�..�•,!��.
r
„y .�y r'ai ro',." t , `i. ; �"'�'t�'� `h p�K ,� � 'x
�i -.�4 �; �;.1 �s.�,�a j . � �` �`; '�
, ��r�,�,. .
� �� � � �� ,
��. .
{ �r� '"' �;���' � �j �"T,,�e �� . f
`eAb . '�ti�+_r r �� ak � �;,s � .
♦ �« .'y�� :,�R�y,
���� P��y� ry �� ��4 Zt�•� �� y:. �..� ��`" �: � o ,
g `h ✓4 t�.+Y' „ � N ^''... � I ���� � �� � �r�
.
�q� �+'�+•�,'.n �M, �. �� ¢^ � �� ,
• ..
� <�Jf' ', .:, P � ,at::1.'
� � �� .� � �. Y, ��. a 1 �,... ix �Y.
,�'�"�� .� ' � � � �`4M� Y�_ yIY � i+
�,ii �.j ! .:.��� C ."�'a #:.
m`
��:.. -rt��� . wv. _ T' �
�`�,n � A� � ' ' _ "'� 3. "'.
: . �
-f�� �* �,
�as
>. � ;�
�- ,��"" � � ; � „ .�.� - �:�
„ , ,
�: - ` �� �� I -
.
` � �'.4 �,�� ,w' .S. A4J�+ .:k..F, n�`p«n N
F �. . .. .... .. . .. e�.
�
+x � � : �
K ��y `,n`'ny����� y lG " ��' �+a ,�[ �,� W+e ¢ � ��N.�gY ��.'�w,�.
r�._'�. �;.' _ �#1� '�` '�.�+�f'§�g J+p� ���aLL��.'�r-'" ':. r,� �f��
� I I
� s� ,��.,• ,'��,�,'� �_ � �-
�` �l.�h,� �.� �l �;
"'jG°°: *, 3�,;,�� ' � I
� �I' r p.., E,{�pp�.�µ��� �� la
"� �,�r�� r � e w "'�'`��,� y ,� �' &
.._�. �d .__ a' �. . ....Zw�t.�t.., ., ....'9t�' .. ..« . . .l�
L4
,,, ��,��;� �.. .� ,� :�'�' ��,
,
�:, ... . .,,
�. . �w. �. �'�"�.'!�,
Ya �� *�' x'�i• ..Lp y,�. �� .... .
q 'S �'� t ����i'`'Tt�"
��.y
���,�yt,�'�� V. np�r< �.q6.
'�,.�w � *t '+'171. ��.:;,�( � � .
f���� �' �� ��y Y �' p� .,�
,i°� �.;���-�,�,' ,�J� y�
*'=a �R "a. it/'F� 5'�A�� "'i[ . +. .
r, ;i
� *�. �"<�� �. '9�.,�►� - y � ::�,
� . . .,% r�n ,, . ��r,' ""'�t' L ,':
}sj *.n;� , . �+ yc+,� �� �;i.
.�;�,� ' �'�i .a�' �;,��yh
f��,. �T�
a�����fp �"�
p� , 1 a 1F R'.+�' + +. ���i^�'En y,lY�'
�k-�. i.., ,g n� �� ` .,'�
,p ! �
.. , ���•... �1s'h` �'"r A� I��+�! yJ.i
y.... �� �' '�` �"� �'
'''�' r��+ik"►�'�i�.. �
"k +,.,
. r;*^ N.. '�`' :��,�L,-;y.
a
- fi
. � � ` '� �„ r �� � �,� .:y .
�
ti�
�������(� �y��.i4 � - ` � � �� � �.
1���'A yi:. ..k" � � �,''. �! #...
� ]YL !
I ��}��• � ,.. .. � �" , h ..
� ._ .
tic i a . � r � � .,
yy�, � � �� t. .. y�"' � �y� .y�., .,
` �, 'J.'Y' 'e� a M �� �,�,.. �wl. 1 . '�
�,�� ,. �. . "�a' '.�� ���1� e ��` -�,i'"' *�w ^c" •,5r, .,tA!
a .
�- .. ,, . �. .r.�� �' �,:.y'�F
���,��4ya '�, �' ,. �.y�' '�i.��. t a :�'� � .i °�+ ..
. s� �
. ,�, ~?iq"'.r� �� ''�i�� R�� °.y�, �,..s,�.�� � kb:N 4'p ' .r+�' �;_`i
N
. �,"�,;�'"t���r `3.a.t�. ��'�. �@'�a�.?,� y, rry�►", , ;. �"O�a,.,�.�� �.}4' � :
!' I� �
s '* � � ' � ,�y '� ia
�. .�_.�„q • �'�7G.....���`µ� 5 " +�dw ` �{w?���r4r^. �' y�`� � + .�.
=."�If � � �°_µr "ii{ �.
"�roP� �` a} +w# ,1 � �� S'� 'Vi +,�v ..t � �ipigg e� . ,, r"��..
��� � + J ?� ,�.,�•. � �'F 4��� ���z���
.. .�''�:. r,.i��'���,�� -yw�� �� �'s',-
� � �� ��� �� � �
�
Y k
, rw � . .,,�w ,
.� 'a ��u_� � .
.�� .. � ���� . 'y .
k
r., . r . ' . r .
. . �Rc 5:�� :,c a �� �a , �.. '.��.�. ��_Y�.
� �a. �,
.a �Y (y�DM - '� g �M',{.
� � n�'
1 .. a ."� K� y ^.��{� ��`' 4���,,.
, � +.. K���W� ti,� yr� v,��� � i..-.. '� 5 .
�'�. .�+�tm'h � 4� � ���v: �;Ma.,y_ :: 1�� �'` r ,-
���g�n. ,.�� � � F 1 '�4`� M�j,'C�. T� � ���.i�A" ��� � wiM ��, ��'�?�'
.� 'yJ`�"'�Y '�' �*J`ft � 4`k ;;
_'�� .�,;.� � r° +a � �i� � } �;" �`
, �,M° ^ s �,�.F,� r'� rcy� ,� ��.,,; ,
� ��, �.,.
;� �;, ti.AJ
4 ,y� 1��j � �
.�� rr+a� ��.� ..�r`�',�A..��.y�,'`�' , r�� � t��y��..,a�V� �
�
�e�c ` � ' �S u 't�.
Y*,
� �.
���, - � ,�`���eis� v,r.,- �"
�� :�% °�.�" '�, �`"Y� e�, F�`.� i u.
y��r "n r :/
� ��r\. ' �. � �� c
' ����'.. � �; ,xt
�x;i , �� . ., �cc
. - . ., '9,;'„�' .�:Iw�µ� � ..�, .rj` �` � ag�. �r� �M
+w;�- � �+,1� � �
'" � '
� .
� r_
w ..+. . + � �" ! �
��� . . �w.' � . -a��� .. � �.g.:.� r�. .,�
,'4' T .�i;'� � :� .�
F
��r
t+'
��. �`�� "�?"` �r ,.
r+ra�•. .�.
`�^,���w R ��"� �,,�+�+� ��� § $ ' � �°'M�'x
�Y,.< ..::5 'f1L{�y:...���i, t �,�P2� Y r � '�'i� i k v�. . .i.., .
-06M
�,.. ( ' 4��„'�'FydFe r k�.���"�•F .,��i�? . ^ �� �.;
� � � ;r� ��� e�" i,-
� � � ��' ���
r¢, �; .
F7'S• ¢� "4 „p��''(, •F! ity;eP�}� .
�"e.� HVF !.h' 15� "M''...
.i� k�"� ��>.;'��T ..i� �'�.: 'y r
... 4'. �Y��V��. �r!��,Y� w �.� � �� ���. y
a '" �' � . � � �, . � . �r
� '�° �t:: - ��. .�x° � '�4�;
�, '
N : �-.� : � �;;,^ ,�,�,Y.�,;�
F��
-.�, ,..
Pt �
... ,�� � V3� � .a� ��'��
.��, �. �o ♦,��
4�� „ 'Sl'"� �e', ;.
� y �., �:�� :
e�, F.. � �n z���
„ ... i •�.� e+. . �,�•y� �'.
�� �.�5� f ° _
� �Y � �
� �� - '�f.y� • ,M!'::Y�
���.i: c�^`� Yn'i
. '��". �a. ;,. � �
.. . �u+ ;,..
; .
i .�.. .- �"� .. ^t.
`t� . ' ' � . . . . . "
. ` ...�- . „������ , .. .. ' ,�f�.: ...
* b �t �''
� � . � . � ,�ih . . § .
�.. - -
G
�r, �� r �'�. `..�,.
t ,.r`�t�.�F ,�[�y .,.
' � . y���� �4 Y� ,
' ��''� .- ���..
i�
���'- ��� Fa{s� fi� J� t �+�"y �x� ��!`!!
�y . �u^ �,�.v4 . S ry L�" ��M �
� �p.. r y��,� .dr�'%,x 't �',� �'�� , y.n+
;'�9u ;�"" ..' . " y` N� d ;��. fi 1
p+��r:,� . +�+s !�'•: � � ��' �,'"° '� �� t�
h� ..' %v... ���. "f." y '"S�.: Y.♦ �u ,� . ' . . .
.�� ' �'"" � �. , : � ,� 9'v ; �� �-.�1' +� t,
r .a A;,� �
.�:�^, ...'�,��, 'i. *^ r i ♦ �� � �Mr,��; 4,. �y �.. w�p �. 1
,�,M�.. � � �� N� ...r.�".'(��"� �.���£`�\ �' �� t' � .
' f4 '` 3�R �r.
` ���ti^r �*. .. ����p- y�'$ . �r ,��,�' � .. �,�ok ",
;� '�l� ... 4 �,�p k" fY.'�'' 1 b�k:.�� :„y y�,.sf d
'«;��� I
4q
.�� 'Ah�n ' V� A��.. �'+'ri4h1�M,zsC �� p�'`�t'�y 3 . , �
�, rt ...,� ,,. ��,��',.'*w "�w..;.,�, ..`,. �� �� * `,�y �f ��� .��r�� � i �
P R
i n ,�.,,`1. � ...iik ' M��.. S!F . '.�y` . .. �. '�,
��xY�'� 4���� . .. � !v1 d w . ,� 3 '�45�.
�r`;% » �_rl�` � "�.�, ,*� ,t`�r. '"'���� 1 a
., "'� ,' �e y Y+��'7'� ,� .� i�� ^4�`� � �, �, ,,�� '
,. .� .
� �+.,. + . x .� j��� � �,��.A �r ��:. . �tr .
: ��� .!,�,"�'.�y, '$?x�.• � • r`.,.�, . .'M� .1'�«. 'xn k,�hr. .
!�� ���' � �• . �"-��y�a�wy v�'4 w 'Y�.r��m�` � � . . "' �� .
� X � ,
' Y s� .;z ♦ ;'J�l�.. r4,>y��'v`' f� �• 4 ..
. �'�Y���.� � '�'�'q.� ��{y 9.����, . � ' �'t'�'.�MI:��t1W"
T '� � � 4 iVr'��'� ` - � ��� ' *'iwe ~�
, ' d _
e� ",{,�,:��A'�.. �'y' �+K � ��tY'.,�x.' "`-y��:,
) �F �
�{" J2 ����//��,,�.q ' ! p �
r'Y'�:iL �,' .. ��� 14" '� ; '.t ,�ry .`�'"'..r n.
l^
��t W $,�. *. k •��.
°� � y � ,M, *�'X ^�p r,r§ '"
�' .f ih�� , �i�^..M-Y`'� �� M ., �
� . '�1�.w���T�r°� �ti'�� .�`� _� ..
�y 4
� � ��� � a
' ,'r �,;' �a"'t�` � � ;,
�,. #�-� � �,���,,�'�_ � �
a ��� r�1°A` a"`,��'» 1 �i �++'�' � „� ,�'Iy���'�" � A��
"y7►a�]`, A ; '" �t4 �.fn! t , ,;1� '� ,Mr:�"���wrsp��� � . .. ..� �� '.�
j hM i �'� � A i�R's' ���'. 1`",'"y
���}„� �k1�����'� � ��y �5'_ k- �;s
.
_ � =� �
b � �
�e,';# ..L J'���� �� r��w,.
, �""4"'�� #^ 'hh,� vw�4�"i„"yci^''��i�''r a ,� . .... . y p 1 ;�.
.. ,. . `-•,w,�p P �, .��I��y�y " ' . � ..
� S� �,�� � ^ � ����n . u'����k '�+ �y�1b'�,
,�' v+�w..7h e,� L"",�Y, 1.,�,
�,. �� �
;�`��� n.�"'t,� .. '' a;'.�.' •� ., �1�',
,... �y 1, 4 K�'` '�., o e s � "_� • 'k t rti�
n
y y�ll� .. �, � � - y�
�. FY1�/ �s� f�d'1 "*t �},� ..a l�. ���H:..,
*fr� w.' T� �, �� ��; Mr�� .. �'K yA_' ,
.;*Y.��i4'' Ai '� . .�.° '. . , . I,b.L.
,<.
r S' .. . �'.'M 4�..: 7i�,t�'��`�, . .
�
. . - '� , ;� � . �+��� ',' .. . . �.
r • .. y
h, .. y
.
. _ yw
:. � ,,;�y ... � - a'..�, .
k k`i
�, i- � 1 �� `.:� ,
- .� �`,� � Y�� ��n� �u �� r� � �.... '� � . , � .
4�p �. � ,�y��� ��� 1r. -
, i� . Y.� •�r,. �6� yp { ( ��*�A�A" ��y.�ryNN �.
.fiG;�,�"�RR'`.h �q+'��� �4, r4.� �,�R} �, � �' �- ' .. .
�I, �, �+Z4�'� :�Y MK�s� �.,P. *� ��� n ..�.: �� ���:i
`r}+��y N � i � l�b c � � .. �"* ,r � �� �
�.
� .;��� �,, 11P*!ro� v� . � � r�. k ���� {Py�'.v
` k� :,�� � � � . 1 �
� t�vM �. � � , k.. �� }t Y 5.��."
� '�r++ �~ n , ����„S�r, ,,�a� +•?` ' , ,n.,�.. . � 'd'�4e , '..
� , . � ��y _ .. �¢
r " , y
�y,;y ` va . �,}.,'���./��'
�v R�{ pn R � tcvKf'^�'»I �� � F 5' ��c .
•}�:�^ � -. ` R�1�e.�� ����� ���.•� X P {d
� �' �7
� �
s �y,
��,.� .H '� �'�,�^ �'�°r� r�at��:�iN'k� r �.a���� �. . r �''T '� �
.�;
�
�
.4 � r.. t .: � .C�� . ..,. �,,. ;� ". ,
_ }� ' ���' � �. .��� 4 i.K�� nt�ti ��:' . .9�' . .
�'�� �t�',�d� w ..n,f `�4�t d �. ✓,4 . .
'� ��; . �, . ' e`�f ��y ' � � a ,�*, . . . .
+�t' s�f$
� i w�� '�` R!^� "��t i ' � ..� �. _ � ..
,� �ra���� ���
4� � y.�. `� 1k .� '�� �y.. r
� � � � ~�d �� /Nf� � r � ' � �
�" x �y �
���� .
, ,�( yM,�M� �1fT�� �I\ �q � � �.'f �
�i t � w x � .. Y : 1�
v"'�v n t�� . `�� �yi!`� �^'�� � s, . v .=.=G�' � .
.i�,i/ ��� r� � • . $� ty.�' i..1����' '�i.� �Y�����f�, " � . �
.. .
. ,
.
�
.
, +
< - . ,.. .. .� . .
- _ �� ..��'.. _ .u.._.... ±� . _ . ....__ �f� .._ __._�� _ 5� • ,