HomeMy WebLinkAboutHOUSG CMSN - 11/15/06CITY OF PALM DESERT
HOUSING COMMISSION
MINUTES
November 15, 2006
I. CALL TO ORDER
Chairman Jane Turner convened the meeting at 3:30 p.m.
II. ROLL CALL
Present: Members Absent:
Jane Turner
Verna Smith
Linda Ward
Also Present:
Carlos Ortega, Executive Director
Justin McCarthy, ACM for Redevelopment
Dave Yrigoyen, Director of Redevelopment/Housing
Janet Moore, Housing Authority Administrator
James Conway, Project Coordinator
Patty Leon, Recording Secretary
Guest(s):
Teresa Vakili, RPM Company
Lauri Aylaian, Redevelopment Manager
III. ORAL COMMUNICATIONS
IV. CONSENT CALENDAR
Leo Sullivan
Larry Saindon
A. MINUTES of the Regular Housing Commission meeting of September 15, 2006
and October 11, 2006
Approval of the September and October minutes were continued to the
next Housing Commission meeting.
Housing Commission
Minutes NOVEMBER 15, 2006
V. REPORTS AND REMARKS
A. COMMISSION REPORTS
B. SUMMARY OF CITY COUNCIL AND REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY
AGENDA ITEMS RELATED TO HOUSING, AND SUMMARY OF CITY
COUNCIL, HOUSING AUTHORITY, REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY
ACTIONS
An update was provided to the Housing Commission for review.
Janet Moore summarized the report and explained the joint consideration
item requiring approval by both the Redevelopment Agency and the City
of Palm Desert for the sale of the ninety-three (93) single-family homes
located in the Falcon Crest Development.
Linda Ward inquired if Liberty Landscape's contract would provide
services to the properties nearing completion.
Mrs. Moore responded that Liberty Landscape provides a price per
property. The amount on the contract is inclusive of all properties. In the
event a property is added, Liberty will provide a bid for that property and
the contract will be amended.
C. RPM MONTHLY STATUS REPORTS
The Monthly Status Report for September was reviewed by the
Commission.
D. REPORT #1 - MONTHLY OCCUPANCY AND AVERAGE RENT
STATEMENT
Report # 1 for September was reviewed by the Commission.
Janet Moore referenced the report's new format, depicting the inclusion of
Candlewood, La Rocca Villas and Palm Village Apartments. She noted
that Palm Village and La Rocca Villas were added in order to include the
appropriate figures once the properties are completed.
E. REPORT #2 — MONTHLY NET OPERATING INCOME STATEMENTS
Report #2 for September was reviewed by the Commission.
G:\RDA\Patty Leon\Housing Commission\Minutes\2006\11-15-06 .doc
Housing Commission
Minutes NOVEMBER 15, 2006
F. HOUSING AUTHORITY PROPERTIES UPDATE (JAMES)
An update on the Housing Authority properties was provided to the
Commission.
James Conway summarized the update and distributed pictures of the
construction progress at California Villas, stating that seven of the nine
contained buildings are currently being prepared for the color application.
Mr. Conway also noted that staff is currently working with the architect to
expedite the civil engineer process of Phase B with regard to the site
improvements such as the landscaping, walkways, and parking lots.
Jane Turner referenced the pictures and asked if the air conditioning units
located on the front porch of the apartments would be removed. Mr.
Conway replied that, as part of the initial renovation project, the property
was assessed to implement central air but was determined not practical
since the roofs are very low pitch, allowing minimal spacing for the
ducting. It was noted that some of the tenants have expressed a
preference with the existing units.
Upon question of Candlewood Apartments renovation plans, Mr. Conway
stated that there will be several changes made to the property such as the
reconfiguration of the pool, fencing, pool deck, and entry gates.
VI. NEW BUSINESS
A. RPM Agreement for Property Management Services
Janet Moore reviewed the staff report stating that the request is to
forward a recommendation to the Council to enter into an agreement
with RPM Company and authorize the Executive Director to finalize
the Agreement. She mentioned that the Agreement did not change
substantially with the exception of updating the legal aspect clauses
from laws that have changed.
Carlos Ortega advised the Commission on the importance of
expressing their opinion regarding the performance of RPM
Company. He stated that the Commission's recommendations are
forwarded to the City Council for review in making their decision.
Action: Motion was made by Verna Smith and seconded by Linda
3
G:\RDA\Patty Lcon\Housing Commission\Minutes\2006\l 1-15-06 .doc
Housing Commission
Minutes
NOVEMBER 15, 2006
Ward to forward a recommendation to the Palm Desert
Housing Authority Board to enter into a contract with RPM
Company to provide property management services to the
Housing Authority properties.
VII. CONTINUED BUSINESS
VIII. INFORMATIONAL ITEMS
A. HOUSING AUTHORITY NEWSLETTER (November)
Newsletters were reviewed by the Commission.
The annual Thanksgiving luncheon that is put on by the staff of Catalina
Gardens was discussed. There were 38 dinners served which included tenants
from Pueblos and Candlewood who were very pleased with this event.
B. AGENCY HOME IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM UPDATE
An update on the Home Improvement Program and guidelines were provided to
the Commission for review.
James Conway reviewed the update.
Janet Moore summarized the Home Improvement guidelines provided to the
Commission for review. She noted that the program comprehensively clarifies
the guidelines and procedures that are currently in place but also considers the
maximum grant amounts available, which are significantly low compared to the
market. One important component added is the Lead -Based Paint & Asbestos
Abatement, which is a requirement by state law in areas of rehabilitation. Mrs.
Moore also mentioned the conflicts surrounding the waiting period currently
available once per household in a three-year period and noted that the
proposed Emergency Grant will have no waiting period.
Commission expressed that the information provided was very informative.
C. PALM VILLAGE APARTMENTS
An update on Palm Village Apartments was provided to the Commission as well
as updated pictures of the construction phase.
Lauri Aylaian summarized the work progress at Palm Village Apartments. She
4
G:\RDA\Patty Lcon\Housing Commission\Minutes\2006\I 1-15-06 .doc
Housing Commission
Minutes NOVEMBER 15, 2006
mentioned the difficulties surrounding the sub -contractors and stated she
anticipated completion of the project by the end of this year. She further noted
that staff has spent a significant amount of time with legal counsel to determine
different strategies regarding the balance of the unfinished work but found that
the alternatives discussed were not within the approval time -frames allowed.
Staff will continue to work with the existing contractor.
D. CATALINA GARDENS COMMUNITY ROOM
An update on the Community Room was provided to the Commission.
Lauri Aylaian reiterated that the Contractor was terminated due to performance.
Three separate contracts have been awarded to complete the exterior portion of
the property with minimal work required on the interior. Completion of the project
is anticipated late January of 2007.
Upon question, Mrs. Aylaian clarified the work that was delayed due to the City's
Ordinance purchasing guidelines. She stated that the guidelines have two
different interpretations that address the Public Works Department and the
Redevelopment Agency, which has a more conservative description in definition
than Public Works. After careful consideration to the procedures, the Finance
Department was able to support and authorize the contractual services which
allowed the project to move forward.
E. Phase II 20 Acre Site Update:
1) Falcon Crest
2) La Rocca Villas
An update of Falcon Crest and La Rocca Villas were provided to the
Commission for review.
Dave Yrigoyen reported that the project is now 95% complete on the framing for
the first phase of the single-family homes at Falcon Crest. Twenty-nine homes
are schedule to be completed in March and available to qualified buyers to
purchase them. The model homes are slightly delayed due to minor changes
with interior design selections.
Janet Moore reported that once the model homes are completed, a tour will be
scheduled for Commissioners to preview the models prior to the grand opening.
F Estonia Protocol
It was informed by Carlos Ortega that the Pubic Utilities Commission (PUC)
awarded a grant of $14 million dollars to the City of Palm Desert with the
5
G:\RDA\Patty Lcon\Housing Commission\Minutcs\2006\I 1-15-06 .doc
Housing Commission
Minutes NOVEMBER 15, 2006
condition that the City implements an ordinance that would set higher standards
beyond the normal current standards. The ordinance received approvals by both
the PUC and the California Energy Commission and will be forwarded to the
City Council for adoption at their December meeting. The grant will be in
addition to the existing program currently implemented and funded by Southern
California Edison and Redevelopment Housing monies to assist low and
moderate -income families.
Upon question of how this program will affect new construction, Mr. Ortega
stated that there will be additional requirements with regard to new construction
and the implementations of energy efficiencies such as air conditioners,
insulations, and photovoltaic panels. Additionally, the City will offer incentives to
existing homeowners interested in replacing inefficient items such as AC units
with energy efficient qualified items as well as offer photovoltaic panels to
properties with swimming pools.
Discussion ensued with the recognition of this program in terms of publicity. Mr.
Ortega stated that once the Program is approved, besides the publicity by form
of news, notifications will be sent to all residents of Palm Desert. The new
department created, Department of Energy Services Conservation, will be
working closely with Southern California Edison and the Gas Company to bring
forth the contractors.
At this time, Jane Tuner inquired if there has been any interest in the vacancies
of new members. Janet Moore stated that the City Clerk has not received any
applications. She noted that staff has furthered the outreach with respect to our
tenants as well as continuing to actively seek applications from the community.
Linda Ward mentioned she would be happy to volunteer her services of seeking
tenants from our properties as she has previously done with the agreement of
Teresa Vakili.
IX. ADJOURNMENT
With members of the Housing Commission concurrence Chairman Jane Turner
adjourned the meeting at 4:10 p.m. The next meeting will be held on December 13,
J
PATTY LEON, f EORDING SECRETARY
G:\RDA\Patty Leon\Housing Commission\Minutes\2006\I 1-15-06 .doc