The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About2010 Master Professional Svcs Consultant's List CITY OF PALM DESERT / PALM DESERT REDEVELOPMENT AGEN Y / PALM DESERT HOUSING AUTHORITY STAFF REPORT REQUEST: APPROVE THE 2010 CONSULTANTS' MASTER LIST OF QUALIFIED PROFESSIONAL SERVICES CONSULTANTS FOR SERVICES VALUED AT LESS THAN $25,000 SUBMITTED BY: Martin Alvarez, Redevelopment Manager DATE: December 10, 2009 CONTENTS: 2010 Consultants' List Recommendation By Minute Motion: 1. Approve the 2010 Master Consultants' List appended to this report; 2. Authorize staff to negotiate agreements and contract amendments with the qualified consultants for up to $25,000, and authorize the City Manager/Executive Director to execute same; and 3. Approve the proceedings for selection and award of contracts as set forth in this report authorized by Section 3.32.090 of the Palm Desert Municipal Code. Executive Summary Approval of the staff recommendation will approve the 2010 Consultants' List and streamline the process for retaining consultants to perform under contracts valued at less than $25,000. The processes for consultant selection and contract approval for contracts valued at more than $25,000 will remain unchanged. Background Retention of architects, engineers, appraisers, construction managers, and other consultants who perform professional services is not done through bidding. In accordance with State public contract code and City ordinance, consultants are selected on the basis of experience, qualifications, and costs. This results in a cumbersome two- step process wherein a shortlist of consultants is developed by consideration of qualifications, and then a cost proposal is requested from the best-qualified firm. If an Staff Report Approval of 2010 Consultants' Master List/Granting Exception to Bidding Requirements December 10, 2009 Page 2 of 3 agreement cannot be negotiated with this firm, negotiations are terminated and a cost proposal is requested from the second-ranked firm. When professional services are required for small projects or limited-scope issues, the selection of a consultant can take almost as long as it takes to actually do the work. Consequently, Agency and City staff have teamed together to prepare a list of consultants who have been evaluated and determined to be qualified to perform professional services work for the City, Agency and Housing Authority. This list was developed based upon consideration of: • Qualifications of the firms and their key personnel; • Expressed interest in working for the City; • Quality of work (if any) previously performed for the City or Agency; • References from other governmental agencies; and • Reasonableness of rates. Approval of this list of qualified consultants will complete the first of the two steps required to procure professional services. The next step will be accomplished on a case-by-case basis as the need arises. After identifying a particular need, staff will select a firm from the master list and request that the firm submit a cost proposal for performing the required work. Consideration will be given to the amount of work given to each consultant, so that no single firm is selected for all work of a particular type. Once staff has negotiated an agreement, it will be presented to the City Manager/Executive Director for approval and execution. Contract amendments, if any, that do not bring the total amended contract value above $25,000 will also be reviewed and, if acceptable, approved by the City Manager/Executive Director. Any contract amendment that would bring the cumulative contract value to over $25,000 will be brought to the City Council/Agency Board for consideration. 2010 Consultant List Review Staff has reviewed the qualifications and performance of consulting firms found on the 2009 Consultant List and has revised it accordingly. Firms deemed to be qualified are considered qualified for three years, unless there are changes in key personnel or the firm performs substandard work. In either case, it will be removed from the list of qualified consultants until or unless it resolves these issues and is approved at a future date by the City Council/Agency Board. A team of City/Agency staff reviewed over 100 new consultant applications for consideration on the 2010 Consultants' List. The team reviewed each firm's qualifications and experience, and the new pre-qualified consultants have been incorporated in the attached 2010 Master Consultant List. G:\rda\Consultant Lists\For 2010 List\Staff Report 12-10-09.doc Staff Report Approval of 2010 Consultants' Master List/Granting Exception to Bidding Requirements December 10, 2009 Page 3 of 3 Therefore, staff recommends that the City/Agency Board/Housing Authority approve the attached 2010 Consultants' Master List and authorize the City Manager/Executive Director to execute contracts and amendments with named qualified consultants for professional services not exceeding $25,000. Fiscal Analysis There is no fiscal impact associated with this request. Submitted By: ,..,.....„—./. / / 7 ' 2 M in Alvarez, Rede elopment Manager /Jan Moore, Director of Housing Department Head: / 1 - . , Ju ' cCarthy, AC ••r Red-velopment CITY COUNCIL ACTION APPROVED V DENIED 0 RECEIVED OTHER Paul S. Gibson, Director of Finance MEETING DATE id-/O' -L i AYES:L �D() Picusun1�iEIIi, .4o ep1 gi0er-i NOES: j / y Approval: ABSENT: hkki1r' ABSTAIN: on r. C---� VERIFIED BY: k - 1 f C' ,—.1 Original on File with City Clerk's Office Jo ohlmuth C' y nager/Executive Director fO Fb Vl '6i BY RDA ( -o) Le BY HOUSG AUTH (5-0) ON l - t c - 0 9 ON /0 -0 VERIFIED BY Rk)i<tr. VERIFIED BY: kbildii J Original on file with City Clerk's Office Original on file with City Clerk's Office G:\rda\Consultant Lists\For 2010 List\Staff Report 12-10-09.doc 0 m 0 r+ a, m fa a v c 2 c o c o c O ++ 0 + 0 +, c O u co — O two O to O — O to +-+ 0 "a 0 "0 O ." — 0 10 O — 0_ O 0 O t2 1— Z; O tZ 0 > , 0 31 _ (7 a) 1— 0 u +; O 0 > — U _O (I 2 U + 0 0 > oil; VI — LL H Y O N I— C 3 E H Y - C.J N \ U C C) - GO U b4 \ N C i U GA \ a) ,a) a) GO \ N +-, J +., to U 2, 0 GA > CO •C C U _cO C +., to U E > GO > (G U _c (G c Q i� (d V - C +-+ Y w U •y a) co — C C +,, a U — C U \ C) UfL6 in tz a) f6 , > COC a) co as C N . 0 > -0 0 = >, to . > (L6 ccoo c _ oCA H \ u 2 GCA v ' w a H to Ga U 1 H c '> to c +_ 2 2 U L H ra ra > c GA rT, i , , d N tt3 +., i i i J c +, O C y,, i . i d a.,, U 0 tG J GO c cc 0 as GA DO 110 GA t3A GA CC C C C1013.0110 C , C U (- 0 to GA OCO GO GA C C N Co C 7 CCCCCC c H +., }, \ to 'L O U L 7L 'L L 'L 'L C 0 .L L .L L 0 E U U L L L L E O GA L N U C O N Cl) a) a) Cl) a) a) Q +, U Cl) a) a) 0 y C •- c c Cl) C) Cl) Cl) C ++ C ++ 0 C U t/3 +'' W C C C C C C U C C C a) .L �_ j N y - C C c C 0L aJ C a) •OO N Y C & GA GA GA GA GA GA i O tG GA t3A GA � m > 0 C C v) OA w) GA .s > 5- C L (Lo O O c C C c C c to L L C C c 0 i- C U O 0 0 C C c c c o O w F- a U U w w w w w w tl a H w w w to Q w Q U U U w w w w w a s to W U U U U U V Q N H In J -0 1- U Z v ra L Q m CO H a) H = cn a)n a) O c0 c 2 N CO cs) +O O 0 0 a)Z o U a U 0 %i 0 N 0 r+ 0 N 17, N N Li a) U C U a L +, L a) C a) In o E c to � % LAL a) tw = +J on c Y to 0 (0 W = 'V ,-i C to on u 0 oN al C C i N 'E)VI.+= +� 0 > — o - = Q \ e Q 0 _ W CO > 7 ' 7 - >- ' / — ) Cu / 5 < ƒ c • / ° & c c co u — E E \ a E o ± , ƒ — ° @ 5 ' T e o - 2 u on to o u _ \ \ % CU % / 7 = g CO til > on on 7 2 y > © 7 c = 2 $ c 5 c & � = t u e C C Q o u co u . . / u ° 2 2 § ' § » 3 CT (0 c - t ° = d § % / [ 2 CO � .E e % [ f 2 = ƒ § 5 k y / / $ k » % I c m m ._ g / _ m / £ c u CO u e , , , / _ c . CO CO m - c • , . CO 3 m / _ ƒ CO ƒ E / m _ m 2 2 % k 2 0 / / / / E E _ 0 ° W O c ' E E c c u t t / c. _c t 47, / ' ' g / f / 2 2 R 0 ° •- t \ \ G \ \ • m \ 0) c 0 0 VI / c 0 . ._ C C / . . .e .� . � •5 ' e 5 0 e _ . . . 0 0 o G 0) o o 0 c c c C _ c c coC co 0- G) u CU u C C C C u u u u o_ ( / CO 0 0 E CO CO C2 cc 5 3 u 0 0 r NI k ro § 'C LA 0 $ § vs - \ t -0.0 j a) _ 3 § g e k 0 CO kOA \ z vs ( CU k 0 C % U _ c m CO e In LW / tILI C C a) # ƒ co Z « / ƒ ƒ 3 12 2 < E « < < < < a 0 M O m N m to OD (1 C V.' C CO t 7, L • O II:) a) O Z .>_ i `� - O ra - C.) O C0. co l7 to a1 O- > Q- .- a a1 c _ U 00 O V 3' :U U C C •O Cc+O C C D U H •+� LL "O 3 aJ m a O O a) '� H (O g \ c C U a0 m 0 •° v w °- w u CA as c[ c — }, C U •N to E C N ra C OD O co > ca +, c aJ u c Y L c "a -a v) au ai Q - - O c L c 0 > a 'O aJ _ V H ;a •3 co N cc) '5 ° a) a ., CO i +° U VI t^ N E D co ao Ca J E c4 c ca 'N c E L , c Ni to C to N v — a o ° c c c t t 0 C , a) a) a a) vi a) � C a) c c o O D U .c O +, •- u 2 +J o E o 0- ra E ao L E g .N o t •E > aL-+ +L, a) aJ U +� .• Q U ,O O > a fa O .E 2 O Cl) C C C aJ L L• _ L L _ _ Cl)aJ a ro c "O c C •ED En Q U U LJ• L• 'p U Cl > 'a as O- > C CA •> Q' > as L• fa aJ O O c C L• L• LV CD L L a"' C a) a1 a c - C C E -a L 0 a cc V U w w Q Q Q a a Q w cc cc Q w a w w Q 0 W QQ Q Q < Q Q Q Q < Q Q 4 U V U U U U U U U U U N I- N J co H ccu O Q O CC i CD ns a) C J COtn OL '6 C a Y N (6 . Q N co c a) m co E 0 E 0 0 0 co v ra co v co m 0 U U COm rn V) CC N a ( -J a U O a1 O N co C Cl) E c O L .> c w U > a 0 0Y a 0 a) U Q N U •L = co O , 2 U a) N _o U N 4-, - v, 3 7 aU CD C E _ •U ,C Y L y O L O O fa 14- > u 0 E 0 co O C Q O �i c 0 U O -6 >., c N W c a) U U CD C C a i i C 7 a Q a1 .'^.. Q a1 aJ U Lc0 •C E L co -� Z c }' L 0 2 W ra C7 a aJ 1°., co •� Q V X co L L Y CO j WW L >• >' — U0 I- C Z +� U Q 0 a) Y aJ O •;a E w U in CO H Q C v_ `~ Q ra L co > > N 0 0 'L 7 co ra C _ ca Q Q co co oo co U U U U cU C7 0 m su 00 co C c / § a) 0) z — 0 / . c 5 0 . ¥ \ 2 k 0 \ \ k : CU v \ 7 ) 0 > 2 § 3 7 Q '> f / f v O 3 ¥ O 0 H •E / K / § e t m t c U in § — t m a / CU C u J VI 5 _ .> c c u = 0 © .> c u 2 t CL C- 0 e g CD CO _1 J CO \ •• a u ' ° @ ? - 3 f F u ° § 7 = 0 0 > # E c a 5 e _ 0 -0 c ƒ .£ — -0 CO cw L e k \ \ \ 2 E Q c E. e . E c c - u u Q 7 c 0 . — _ ._ , , , — a) co ! I - - , . , , a � • c , , 0 _I , 0 lm m _ m 2 g m m m m m m c CL _ m , m _, . E 7 c c 7 = _ 0 0 . c 7 C c c c / 2 , = F c c c c = = » C \ \ a � 0 u \ Q § \ \ \ \ 0 u OA § \ 2 0 \ 2 3 e < > u _ 3 u e t ® 7 $ « u e t > u t c c c = 0) e zE c c c C = m o a. 5 •- C C a) a) C CV C C ®VI . .O . . 2 . / . C ' .00 .e .e . 1- as t e e 'er y � ' y U / U 3 3 3 3 2 0_ v) e > E 2 2 ° / G Z k > > > 2 3 fl C 2 2 $ Z C ƒ / E / % \ U 2 G E G / 2 f / 0 \ \ U % e 0 m 0 IJI to m 00 Q. c .7 c 7 o tic, m 0 +-I c U U C •— 0 N 0 i — "O la CO co O a) > \ F• = N O > — 3 0A Vf Q > 0 N v +`°+ - v a) C m a - H Y -o 73 LL{A N a c - OA U 4-+ a1 +, U (0 aJ \ to co c0 aJ c gE CO •u on v 00- - � 0 o 0A c 15 \ 0A •> 2 c aco LS caA C v ro v o +_ t� 0 a +_ aco •.3 aco .o v H co o o +° o a W J Cr IV -0 co OA 00 CD OA C -0 C 0 co C to m v) N J 00 00 00 C Ni , N C N CC \ , \ f6 'cc C C C CO aJ , N \ i c C C a \ v, \ c \ ' -O U _,n aJ < C L V, aJ a) a) al � i C • U a� °cA v a1 aJ a C >� •U °cA c C aJ a •L — a� w CD a) a) a) U .-' .-+ w U -C 4 O •C •'= C C C O� C aJ C C OL c +' vi o _cV1 C N •C •C C C U ''o cry C V)0 a .0 •C •6 O o O .c aa u .0 • OD C •t]A C C �° c CO (6 Q Q a a U U w w w w a U U U a C7 a — a a w w w w a cn II- a w a a a W i- U U U . a) as tto Z a) L 00 I- -O co -0 0 2 .- -O 0_ +' 0 Q- co ca) '' co c a) L a) C N co Z coaJ o c E 0 0 U v v > co m o 0 V 0 I I- 2 L- 0 2 a: a U 0 a-1 0 N 0 0 N N 0A J c . U (c6 C U c a) a 0 > 2 a) co c f0 C 7 U c, ++ ON U vi v C7 C NI 0 03 W 0 U a) i "p - C O .., a L a c o o ,,, X 0_ IA c 0. N N 0 v Z in 0 a) OC C a C p Yo V) a) LL +' L. co v, O O co ++ c Z v cC C �_ z (V v CID u° N Q CO C .-•� - •> a to vi roo D o O z m CO CO a) av a) a) -o 0o U U U U 0 0 0 0 0 0 U' 0 m 0 v LID 03 0- 2 C L OL 0 U c •+, a) C _ co 0 z •> U L O U O — U a) - F- vOi U } - U O > C L Ua+ > ILL)V LL C 3 E a) ~ u ~ U a) a) U {A a) C la a) a) — on to N 4, +J (a U a) •O dA a) 0 aJ (a •U iE U U G CN W ate'' f0 a) V U C U U N U v' N fB ' > 06 co C = E 'O (6 N > > L C c L •- 2 aco U 0 a F- f6 '> ao 2c a) w e U 0 ra cC ° CD o _ 1 I , . a 0 Co cc , = . , a c •+� c w w CC CC D \ m O c oco acA aco ucA c c ns N N ocn aco 00c +6 E0. C i L i L O U b.aa) c Q c c i L N a) a) a) a) a) +, }, ° • a0) L) O aa)) a°1) aa)) Q., a) a) Cl) Cl) U U '' +' 2 in C +-+ aw..+ C C C C C a) a) > C C C C o '> Y C 'O C C to 'Ea 'Ea Ea Ea Eo 0- . L Q- OA U O ad4 OA i C f0 fa O O O O C C C C C , i 7 Q- C LO C C C Q w a a Q U U U w w w w w a v) Q w Q U w w w W U U U U U U Q N I— V) J I- 0 Z ID Q C I— rua, C _ co c v .L vl } Q Z it C c 0 c j `^ a) L) v, > F-O u 0 0 N 0 0 0 " vl ✓ -. C c CD C E D H C C O0 U J w a u o oZ w o J U >' Q C On C } O CW U p vi 'i — G a) Q E 013 ( Q J Z E v' c ', c IV L ao Y of 0 > Q C ,n of U > Cl) Q w c W w 0 Q E O o Z 0A _ U 0 ro U U N -- v, ro D a) au 2 2 v - m 0 0 0 0 0 0 l7 0 m 0 a, 00 to a t t _c0.0 Ea U U U C O UA "a Z > U O YO O C '� UQ — U O a) o a) a) _ m 1_ U C LL •> .> ••U (0 OYA oYA CO o 2 o UU i C u N in , UA Y U 7 H- I— a) C — U -co _ _ E c to •> on > (o C co O C -p N co co c co > 110 c •L CO ,n Q O co 'CC C > •E c vE +, > II^^0 = co a Ca) co v, C cu V • 0 0 R > L C �..� V •> C •> Y W G L •C C U Q� C +•+ , , d ate+ U a (6 Q) , , ate-, U 0 ate, U — C }, , , 0 O (o N Y >. O (o 110 CA hA C CC C C 1]A oA C C U C 0 -0 O (o oA OA m v N J cc C 2 C C C Q) c al Q C C Q) C Q) — Q) C L (0 C C , L , _o Q) _ u U E 'L •L •L E O C 2 _O L 'L E o E U E 0 ,n u u •E 'L 'L u a oA = E (o 7 O � 4) Q) 0) c �-•+ Y N v O c •+•' C 47, C +J w 7 O Q) Q) O u C Q) Q C •L L L w Q) L Q) O u a U > Q) a O U O {n O U \ +L+ 4., w dJ 4-, 'C Y O Y o o C C C L Q) Vf Q) Q) ,C C L Q) L L Q) VI Vf • C VI L Vf O O O COA C o C - co s_ a) C C CD- C 0U C 5 Q O O O OA cGO L `" C u (o C U U U w w w w _ n a CC w w w ._ w Q w H U UU w w Q 2 Cl_ Q a w W I- U U U U U U U U U Q U N I— I', CU Z i C ONA CCQ) CD C Lc) as al as t13 J a) z Q C 'p C ut L oA p 0 u Q O t� aJ RI E (o Q) (0 E 5 Z c E c L E c co 0 u a m cm a) u cm a) a cn Q 0 0 N C 0 C 0 O o Q N L U J t c u Q) ro U j U_ c a.) O C U N %• oa) Q L (0 C co J cu Y o 3 U OL N >. V) C o L (� (o C C 4., •C E N 4-, C co 0U U `o 3 C 0 o0 GA co- E d p ., L ' +� E Y > J Z E 0 H N C U L i "a C Q) C C N CU N Q C wco Vf O O E Y C Q) _, Q) VI oH tn W Y N a t CO >- °C° (C6 (0 j o Z Q) L CY U L .i+ w (o U u U) 4-4 > 1 U 4-, a) ,o 7 'a CO in w w w w w w w w w U 0 m 0 00 v m 0) a C 2 _c O 0 O }' U ''' C CUC Z i C •> U 0 .5 U co- 0 = 0 U O Q Q 0U > a- O CA — U *' 0 0 •> O V fa a) U C LL U 5 i LL ro V 7 i-+ a 3 E v u ~ 3 E v U 0) ti0 a) a) - on tin a) +� C 4- a) a) — DO OD a) +� CC g CO O U ° , 0n > - co O co 0 C > h0 > — _DO C U t C - d \ C °�° U 0 d '> V N C �� a I COA d CC oOn OD y 0 0 p CO oho on on o: o 0 co DO 00o 00 ado D f on _ _ c c •L 'C L 0 VI VI U ,U •- 'C .0 .0 'L 0 G L VI U U ' 'L 'L L 'L 'L G VI a) a) U w w 0 C a) Cl) a) a) •,_, Q p w 7 7 -' a) a) a) a) aJ , v) U < a) a) ++ u \ \ . w a) a) Cl) a) U U > . tit; +- w Cl) Cl) Cl) a) a) U L C VI C C VI VI C C C C a) vj a) a) in ut �, ,C C C C C a) a) C (L0 000 'En0 RI +, a,a' CU O O O ti CCA 0A 0 0 Q- (a O O ++ O O O C C 0O 0 0 O i_ a w w w H 1— i- U U U w w w w = a a vI H U U U w w w w w d Q LLJ H < 4 � U U U U U U U N I- v, J C Cl) U Z 'Es00 i L Q C a) i a) H a) ro C Cl) 'L '' a) VI J C -O L -O o_ a) H a) 0 73 a) •N N 0 O 0 Zit ; c ; coTo t6 V N cc d d 0 d 0 a-I 0 N 0 <-1 0 N J H C co C U O U f6 C i Q — O E aj a U on U a 0 y., a, C H �+ vi ,.. Cl) U N i 2 C c a) o L a) Q VI O co v L Q O J Z La) •}, U C U L N c H O co L W w aO, LJ 'O (n = d z L •C 0 W O ,• E O a; w \ c Z o?S +' Q p O C io of t a) of E a) CD COL L Lro UL LL LL LL U. LL LL U. C7 0 m 0 rn v no (0 ro a c 00 c t t 00 +-' 0 C 0 u u u C C +' dA 'O 4'o 4-' 00 -0 Z •> U CO C •� p +�CIO L 0 O O '� CO 0 — C) -o O ^ la m O O CU C7 C7 C7 m c '> O Q .� — ate+ -o Q 'O +, VU Li. C •� m Vf U C — 00 — 00 00 CD v1 •. f0 U i C Op a) 3 (00 U v`�; u v, u ' C 00 CD LL a) I— ...._ Y v 3 E n7 ° to 0° H c ~ 'c ~ •c ~ > c •�a to a) a) — 0.0 Ca 0, c +' a) Cl) = a .O +� +.+ Cam, +-• C5 i.' v W - ♦.' fn '> 00 > f0 c u t o c > 00 '5 oA c c u a) fa a) f0 Cl) f0 v '> � '3 C 4 a) _ c a) a) as m c g a) +-, 2 +' 2 44' 2 00 a, m = O U 'fo i `~ U f6 cc C 'vf E c'6 0 O O C cc cco E 0 f0 > L f0 m C Q) N > a) .O v N L a) — a) — a) — 'O A 0.0 a) +, 2 °=o 0 p a IL ca u CA m +_ 2 •3 '- a,0 H C7 '> C7 '> l7 ra '> += c c o0 io i i i i d Cl) f0 J C ++ CO f0 i , 0 i '0 i +r V 3 — C f0 +' C '+ C C C m _o C C as O oC0 00•C 00•C 00•C 00C C� N E C o fcc0 C OCA C CCD C C a) C f0 2 fcc0 QCC) U U L L L C •L O C L u u ._ O U G 'L L O 'L O_ 'L O U U U •� G C 7 3 +'. a) a) a Cl) a) 0 7 O +' +' +' a) v +' a) 'Y a) c '}' ci, 7 O ,,, }, c +' y LU C C C C C Vf u N a-' ++ Ill a) p a) C c a) c a) C 0L a) Y vv, v, L. Q) _" V1 Vf > o o O 000 On- 'GCD 'C0n 0CA t0 O O O O ui OL d_O OCiD V) •_ Cl- 0CA C Q• L O O O OL C () U U w W W w w a a to U U U J a w W w w w t. Q U U U a w W Q � U U U UU U U U N H N J I— Z U, U) Q Cb. C Cl) v) JL OD 1- I+ Qa.) 0 Q a) N a a) p 0 Z VI E E O E > C aJ aJ co 0 U a (n co as a 2 aR. oc L 0 LI N 0 0 0 N v, J VI C fU 7 C O U Y ttO N C Li .L U U 0 —C a) C Y Q a) (0 f0 00 C +' C u 00 7 O o W L C v, v, N C v1 N Q C 0 Q Li Z C u C U Li O C VI °c° C O Cro - N w - C.-.) ` a) Y c W aJ C a Z 0 0 N Q' O C u V1 U w O O O O Y C v M = m a v a) a) - a.) m u C7 C7 C7 C7 C7 OD (9 6 0 m 0 00 C •/ J on c o u o u / % — 0 C / . I . z & > 2 = ' 2 & » 2 Op _ G 0 = g - = G •\ Q . \ 0 k : /r / g ' 0 7 e G c@ a / — u @ = t •5 £ 3 b > y 2 ( U # ' c e > a) E m a) ® \ E E e / f / E e / / 2 a) 7 ' m = & w c u m e » u - m G co Ln 5 _ E c m 7 co 2 m t 9 m m u 2 y 9 m 2 c u e 2 < ƒ @ .o a) @ Q .= u ° ) C@ — F u 2 a' u 2 U _ $ E Q I ° m Q E _ , '> ) c . E _ as as e c E E cc § , .> _ c : I ƒ \ R I \ Q / / ¥ / R : I G e f ¥ \ \ : I / U co\ e f $Zi \ f f / § % ' § � \ / E i ' / / / / § % / / / E / E i ' \ u u U 2 \ . — - - 0 I u u \ ' — — o > 2 » . . - - ' 0 2 ® o = o = a \ \ — o 0 = = C \ \ — 0 a \ \ \ • 0 u d t > 6 3 a) a) a) U » > a) a) a) t t 4 3 a) a) Cl) t t > u o > c c c Cl) e ® c C c a) e c = c CU Cl) o / c •• * c . .� . 0 . c c @ . . .a 0— . c c . . .c .c \ .0 f 0 0 = o o c c c = 0 0 o c c c o o 0 c c = _ u u a v) u u u u = e vI u u 0 u e / � o_ u u u u u 3 v) e 111 < U U U U U V) V) = w Z � ® � 0 no a)" t d CU / 0 o c Z E O E E © 0 u 2 2 2 2 1- 0 0 IN ) ra o o LiC - C = Z2 C \ / U \ VI E k g ra w 2 $ # 7iis ) Z U - £ 3 ƒ 2 u L. t 2 g / : I = to 0 M O '-I v 00 co LL O c OL C 0 44 0 a) a) _ 0 0VI as Z I- o0 C O C7 C7 v O 73 Q = 10 — o a) - > Oo Q .j - U_ U_ co I. d4A U c LO C U •5 .5 N 5 V L.L C U a) co U -co (> L U LL C ~ C ~ 3 E O F-- Y , , U C a) V V1 +, +, a) C a .v a) - of) \ N +J 4-, C J +•' a — oA qp \ Cl) +, QN Y 03 0 f�6 5 CC6 U — C i U a) 92 rra as O a) V — C •c U U N Ua�i a0i ^ a�i `Un > co m C E t -0 0 f 0 aoa Ei �. ' c v -3 W '> L9 > "C t +�' bCA U H f6 00 bA fai N (O C C c0 7 — , d c0 c0 , U c U co a) co — C •+, , d c0 f6 +, �, .on N O �, 0 Li Ga —I m 0 0 c0 C o C C (C6 0 a) a) cu \ CO m (O C C C C C to CO C c0 • 'C O C C 'L O +-' }' U U .- C C C L L O E d on u o .0 'L 'L •L •L L N Y a) }' a Q U L i N a) a) Cl) a 4, +, U C CJ U C +•, a) L N a) a) a) a) a) u ? C a) C a) �= '^ += N N . C C C C a) a O U OL Q .O •C a) ••= •• C C C C C O a) ++ Q .a Q U c0 U O O O Ea •Ea •a El) O O 7 cc .0 co N co .5 o O O •G •IV (10 •C C � .� .0 3 L— — LC — - CL Q U U U LJJ LJJ LC L U d d Ln F— LL C7 2 d d_ Q U U LJJ LJJ L U L LI LJJ d Ln LLI U < Q O Ln a)U — a6 oo N dA Ly • O a) Li o C C C CL LL a) a) O C c , C a N — T +- Z C C L m C N Co f0 N LLJ -C C "O -03 U 0 W U uJ C L N C Z a) C X to a) Q +., U N 7C3 a) J i OA }+ .++ ro M a a uJ a) O O O CO 2 2 2 2 2 I 2 0 m 0 N .-1 N t0 OD C d u t▪o CO U L ._ +O-+ 0U CO — — +O+ Z O aJ i > •> 0) vs p a O — U — — U C V > , > I. o° Q > — +, 0fl :--- > 0 Q COtuj C C U C C> > C +. U U u ' CoL U ' a) v' c) a) LL .E ~ — aJ 3 E a , 3 E ~ L (n avi + v c CO u on a) v - o aa) +� .v a, +� +J c LA (n S N m O_ o — VI a • c u > o > U t c > CO ca C O O v 4- '5 -a w - c a s }>. 2 o° iU n f6 ago Z 2 '> u Do c — E O co a) , 7 op I , d° — N , , a C U ' J 4 N C7 a° v J cc o° m '( oc° oc° }c-, .a O (a 0.0 oc° oc° ccca m o4:7, c CIO c( ' a)C cu cu 0 +J 'L O +•' •L +•' 0 'L L L U •U • 47, E 'L L 'L C U .0 0 •L G L E d D a) .0 aJ Q a) O O a) aJ L L .N a) a) aJ U L L U y vs U >. CO .L yI Y C a) !_' 0 c a= ,L C C +., N N — C C C cu N a C N aJ L O -o C ar ED C C .U° . i .> +, Q C L � Q' U CO CCD i a-+ •C C° cLa O O O C .0 •C .I- O O C C OL 3 C — 0 Q w '- Q a w Q = w w 0 0 0 U w w w a U U — w a N w 2 m W I- 2 < < < < Q Q Q Q < < I-- Q U U U U U U U U U U N H N J Z 00 C O U v O vs •_ U O a) CI0 E a) -o C - 'a a) O- O ca L V1 N 'L fa w (a (J_ 2C a) E +�•+ Q E 'a C O O > > to n3 c 0 co ca aJ na V u u `- 0, cn a 0 J U a cc N 0 1-1 N C O . u a) Q v( C o2S 4E' c Li � O 0 C E 6 0 N 00 L u -a u C a, +' C L C u co 0 gC L °) U y 00 0 C 0 Q L u 0 C C 0(13 N O i +•, Jam.0 co a••� VI h aJ U 0]° L U fa J O C O C i Q 'i Le' c6 O o.-+ • a) U u C 0 •� NO UY6 in C C - U vNi IO8 W 'a- •U C a° on Q O i CO C vl vs or) L Q O J +•1 a) fa +a) L Y d Z (i p UO a aa) .O Q ro Ln C N C (a .1:7_ E C vvsi C .� To 3 W 'Ts > (a o2f 2 c Z N E (a N co Q v) C w of u V1 a) C E Q C C t° o=C 2 2 < C Y Li_ 12 H 2 O O 6 o 15 eta ro f = 2 TD . c C g t £ z \ / 7 U 0 � o o _ - O f _ f k I- 0 % ' ' o a - / s o 2 « O t eG . ' co U. u 5 4c 5 / ± f § § ± / v) / e v) « u u m = & • m e e u m $ E u = > m ,> n3 _ C RS u U - CO / o ft k \ \ \ . ( % E c § 0. -0 ./ C \ C ƒ \ c $ / \ \ / / - c \ / / / R 0 a \ I \ GO / GO / I m m e GO m 3 § \ 0.0013110C 0 x E m GO m E E E 5 E 5 g § E g � ' ( 3 § E o ° ° c 5 \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ / M ' � \ \ , I 0 / / $ \ \ \ e u a) u m e o m e u 3 a) e e t _ > 7 u 3 > & a) u C C C c = C C C C c c = v C C C C C .0 . . . . . c c .G . . .\ _ " 0 C (73 _ � . . 3 C C 3 C C C C C 3 \ 3 \ C C 3 0 < $ ƒ ƒ ƒ 3 3 3 UJ < U U U U U 0 IA (A I— c 0 a) 2 to -J s- a, a ° j t c \ C \ Z c E E O ( O u 2 2 2 2 \ 0 I-i 0 N 0 -4 0 - t - C •\ � § \ ro ) — , / / \ C 0 \ 0 .- L., j CO in / E • - a k _ k k 0.0 U 0 \ Z d CO 0 G CO k \ VI a z a I al z CL 0_ 0 CU v u G u o u in E \ D \ \ \ ƒ a) . & 6 0 m 0 v N 41 0.0 00 a E in 00 L C C O I✓ cl. ' O 0 O on O on -0 - O N Z C U Q C v) 0o0 5 U i N i C 'a "O C �_ co C - U_ 6 0 0 Q O v_ c u in Co -- CO c� ' a) c •o m a) 5 ' a) — (13 v •o •E F- " o u �c 3 E 3 E U LL v a) _ oa) Ton u c 5 u a, a) = n +, a) a) no on ++ a u on (0 {N .> '5 •5 > Co •L o c }, C c C > o 7 00 C > to(0 O C u c c Y cCo O u , 4 a) a) Co U — — +-' u Y V U E E O C 00 c cc C — '- E .- O C i fO o .-1 cc cc I I •� '(o cu aJ L E E °C to Ion -a E to >_ co a) � a) Co U > 00 00 U 0 w 2 d N to on 00 4-' 2 C 'O 00 .t U 0 d f- 00 5 C 5 d i- N .- .- C - m (6 C I I I I Co m I 11 I I 4., M _ }I CIOV c (O f0 •f6 (O on 00 00 d0 OA 00 00 COc CO Co C (9 M C c C C CO C C C C c 3 E • c cc E cc _ '._ O 'L o 'L L U U -• -.+ L a) L 'a) 0) 'L 'a) C G U U 'n O G 7 0 a) a) a) a) a) aJ a) U u O of N a) a) a) a) a) a) a) i i +� +' >_ L a) aJ a) a) u U al U a) a) u +L., w w c c c C c cCL1 C u U r.., a, w a) a) VV; C C C C a) a) C Cl..) C C C C C C C C C aJ a) of Vf C O O O OCO F.0 OCO on 0C.0 OCO 000 O O C C O O L O O En 00 00 ap �- Oa C 00 a 0U U U U w w w w w w w a a U U U - a U U w w w w a _ w _ w w I- Q U U U U U U 1- 1/1 I— VI J I- Z 0 Q C J a) O a) E •c O O on C (a C V1 Co Co (0 C C n3 Z U Q C t t L p U (n n 0 U U O 0 0 N 0 0 N c H c V V N C C N C c C U U Y Vf > U 6 N Vf 0 0 N 000 U 4., 0 C CO C LU O L L U v u 0 J C Co C �.. 0 c Z C H LLJ U 0 c 0 Q ... W a) p w l7 Co o Z t U > > E u u < O O c m nCo Y O 0 0 7 12 m 2 Y Y Y Y Y 0 m 0 v MD m a on C V C Cl.)C La — a-, Z U IS in O _ 7 > 00 a) O — -0 m CO ) C 0 > > Q U u_ 'E .V (O O.A C C � > C CO vs U \ U C U N a) C -0 CO U O 'E I— ?> _ E c , , !A V1 a) - to a-+ a C v c cv a) a) — J +J +. a) • u +cr CO (a V) \ '> > co C 'C3 O. O a) ca 7 0 CO op m V \ a a) D CO }' C s Q t Cl) • uas O +� c C dA CS v 0 u Q °C > E co -a -, co a) _ LU U aa)) taosL. CO CO c a) a) Q °' = Co `CO c U 0 op cu rn C u l7 •> o b _ c c C 01 > cco co C� > CU d4 — , , CO J CO a) U a t0 C C 4 4 O C C i J U OU U cc O to OA CA CC E , -I = on — 0 cc O O co CCR J co Cv ) a1 C C ,, U •L •L G O L L, 'L O a"' >` .C) U • , tu, O V V a) O VI L W a)„„ c)„, u > ate+ Q a� Q v ++ ++ w w • C 67 u W a {/� '(LO •c C N .Ea .OA .O "6 i U - OA C" U i o. C C V, N CCD .O •p CO co V 0 00 i' Q- a) O O C C L a) 7 L CO C L CO L O O O 0 L L a) a) L u c Q- Q U U w w a Cc cn Q a w Q a a U U U U a a a c cc Q Q w Q CU I—< U U U < < U U U U < U LA F- V, V) OA J C L Q Z V) a, V, 4-, cu C L a) C 0 L OA V1 0 CO c E a' a) E C Z H aC „ coL O V U m p v l7 CO CO O U O I-I O N 0 0 N 0 U ,� C E J N c c a) f 6 0 C a! •U o a U i N 0� U - CJ C J +•, V, J d C Q U. � 0 1- C �- a vi te) E -C �— 0., 0 f0 C •+., C]. co • OA f0 -c co- E o '^ c c 0 ° CW C -p = •J a) c0 — c O vs Y G L J CD if)C a) C 0.0 v, Q J 00 CI O V) NC O ? >O L i v '3n C COC N W C N O L CO co C p O "O c Z w ai N Q E E - U t o u N U V O 0 -o -o C C C C C C 3 c 00RI CO Y CO J J CO CO J CO J Rs J -I J J 0 0 m 0 La v to Op a C a. O a L 0ao co U O U + _cL C L U U , C a a 7- CO ++ 3 pop 'a Ov Z > ° a ° 5 U i .++ C 7 Op a a — v a O L = m C 1- > ' •- 7 >. > c O N > — — 7 ' -0 tip Q U +, c apCO v, C u , aci u 0 U u 0 ? , C E v > (0 C aco co a _ E a cu c U 'J '> CIO '> ° Le) aUi O '> >_ co • acp U co aci (o c ai on m v (0 v C — v v o t cc c U — - Y c� E U ° cc c E W a C cn u y 2 Op U m '> p •> ''' 2 to U 0 Cl H (a •> aao c C > - 2 Oap N C - ' a U ' ' +° U Op = a U ca w = •+, ca oC 3 dA - 'co' Op Op -- v, op c ° CO 00 00 ti4 Op CIO -- c -� O CO - , c m 'v CO C C a C av c o +° 'O E c_ C C_ c_ C C c- 0 ' •+, U G U U E L •L O L E O . U U L L 'L L 'L 0 C L +•+ vs U U +.+ 0 it L L W a Cl)CI) U ut aa) 0 U — + + W a a a) a) a) U U >' °� L . . u) U c6 a) .+a' .2 .Vf N C C a 'a C L a (0 Vf Vf C C C C C a a a 0 V1 V1 4_, .a L C2 t '- C C U' a Op °- C OA > O •L C C N to to •Op Op Op Q- O L u C C V1 O Q- ° U O O O C C V U a)1 O C CO O O C C C C C c L O L 1- O O O L C1 L L U U U w w c m w w c Q U U U w w w w w Ci V•f Q Q U U U CL Q Ci Q c W Q U U U U U U U U U I- III H N J 0 1_' C 0 Op C Z U •C a Q (a •u Q. (a a a ,n _ ut a i E L co 20 N CO LL fp CO C C C C E Z c c a C > 3 > ° (o u VI V1 Z v, L L L U 0 a-4 0 N U 4-, CO _ 4-, Z O Lil Q C 0 C U O 06 0 r+ 06 ,' cN 0 (L U L O C VV) re O a) cca U 0C1 Op CI_ Q '^ C L C 0 a +' c (o Y Cl) C +,, W IA' V) Op f6 C L CO CO V1 0 +, N W b4 aO U a) U O 0 C C = O0 +)) W +' Op •i U of C «�. Q E C• .0 C >- ° 0 (o Q Z c a 00 = j c Y IA 03 0 Y06 O w 0- N Y 06 W Z a t10 U O C -a o O. Z Cco u O 0 -§ C 'L L 0N LL @ LrlE ,V CC -0 C CO (o (o U a m J o O J U 0 m 0 r, 1-1 t OD OA n C .0 03 E OL C - a ,, c o \ o 0 z > U o < > u aoi a°. o F- ' O - v1 0A \ +, O > OA OA in - - cc) > - U Q LL '> 2 c - > C LC. U +, 2 .> ro +, D U > a U a \ U O d U•_ 3 a \ Y H U c H -- U O N a - OA C U c u C a - OA N 7", cla a-' U +' J a) +' co in on > fo C O J v1 "3 •L ..... OA > Co C _C co C a ro .0 C 4- Q `° u •c a •- \ OA Q- +, c c c u •c Y U 2 \ a o 2 ,. - U a p u C r 5 '[L1 c v oo a \ v a o- co ' •> " c _ aa, D a - c ? c a \ 2 °cA v 0 bp u '- - c w 2 cLo 2 ocA v o a co - '>_ •E Cw m L7 > •- u `o on v1 fo Cl) 0 7 to i r to C r i i a. y, U O co J +' UtV3 O r n- +, C Co cup OA C CC N Cn 7) OA OA O co OA OA 00 OA C N C , C OA •- N OD OA C C C \ I a C C 0 - E c c c C a) c \ ca N a C c L \ .0 C CD 0 •L 'L +•' 0 'L 'L •L 'L 'L 'L L L L 'L O +, a s C on U L a s n. 7 +' a a a a C •+O- on - O C •ra - a '+O- °cA a s }, U L �' a a U Q •c a 0 a a L w a a a a o U U > O U a U +, 'i= c c U U C V1 ,C C a •C L 'L O c Ca a•, C L a •C a a) L C C a) C C a U.-- C O c OL co (tf i +-' c a O O En Oc0 cF. En C c r •O 7 C c c CO RI C C OL 4t- U U w w cc a a Q - w w Q U U w w w w w - tl a cn w it w - l7 a w w a H w 4 Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q U U U U U U U U U U U N I•-• N J a 0.0 > Z v1 CIA i U .....� Q C Cl) 2 N C co 2 J O a p- a 7 O L > D CL C N L U E v L Z a O E Ca �CO > CU O U 0 JO C CI- CO CI- CO CC CU H - m U m U 0 0 N U O o 0 L N a J a) C co U ro O N a aJ 4-4 `_°U °cA _ LI CO v _ 1 0 > c:,U a a U Li Li c U _ C v1 c cn ° 0 co a LIJOA c CIA - --- 2 Q "O L •i co C OA CO Q c + C L a + Z o Z Q a tI) �° •to- ccr) C c c c - W d C a Q C 0 U U O C o 2 o a w U L w U O i VI 4J CO U < CC N H > ++ ro m 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 z z % 6 0 m 0 CO v m ra o O c O O — 0 � y Z c > U > U L °v o 0 O N - U O Q = 'j U = U — H +, >, > i 0 N > — a-, O N > oA U cam) N U C ....... L C rts V V U L a+ > U _ > C LT- U f0 N C 0 = 3 c v H u 3 E v f— _ v 3 U cn U a) — U + +� •41 V1 C .� a) oA ap t CO > o0D > U to C > QN _ C Y iC V yr a) a) fa O — c U G a) a) U > QJ J 7- fly 00 Q f6 > fa L C ro a) C co C I > fr6 L C — C .0 >cc > U v C7 `L° Z: 2 U 0 a 1— (o L QA C 4-' 2 tg C) 8 F- f 5'> oa C +' U Q) I CO y d4 - C 1 1 1 1 a CO J c '+, I 1 I }` (D J b4 cC Q0 C C 0 QA GO on GO oA OC C i Lc O fo QA QO GO w C ca oa a) 7 +'' (O .- C C c C C fc6 fa C C C C C c N �-+ C .c C 0 C U U ••L •L •L •L •L - G L U (u •L •L L L O G L U L a) .� c a) U c c a) a) v a) CU 0 7 0 '+, a a) a) a) ,.,, +, O a) a) U a a) 0 U — N Y a) a) a) a) a) a U >. L L N a) a) a) a) U U >� L a) C C N C L fa N N C_ C C_ C C N a) U !�/) 1�/) • ,C_ C_ C_ C_ a) a) a) VI C_ '� ,-CD L .� '> .L C C oa •f]: Fo 'Ea L •o L C C N aD ,aQ •� •a Q- •O L c aA C (C C C L a) 0 O C C C C C ro L 7 O 0 O C C C C L 7 0 C L i..� d L L I— < 0 U L L L L L CL d cn U U U L L L L a N U L LLI ~ U < . co a) Q C 0 U I— ro 0 0 N N U co • CI cc v VIa, Sao 22 Z L O 0 0 U _ a kJ '-I O N N 0 00 0 Z N (a = J C Q us = 3 0 COC y_ O 0 U Y U 41 C = U C O (ca v NN U o IL co • - C o W ., 0 N vi 11 1-C N U U a) U a ` CO+, a) C Z C ro U Y 0 ro W1/1 a) N U = VI 4-4 L VI CC v a c Z C7 a) N ro oU L L ,Ls (� co 0.) a) 0 E 'C m Z Z Z Z Z 0 / U m 01 1-1 o ro C / • v0 Z > = 0 ¥ / CU o = 0 0 — O -0 0 _ ° kru r 7 > , R 0.im \ s OD : u Cr 0 2 7 2 t LA- co G \_ c C j f / _ E e E -. % 0 = e � � , c c t 2 aj = 2 u - m a) » u U : » = C 0 ea 1 > DC ? u c > m .> co u / m t '> •� o c c J c - ' ° ƒ c / e f 7 u c c ƒ 0- bA c % § CoDO U — ' CIO u RS , > E m > c ' u = # G c O e t : I E e c e > \ % ; = g « E c „ 2 _ ._ , , co — � •- . , , 3 g co 0 — 2 R o u / 2 0 c 0 / e 0 0tb E E § / 2 of) / / •E § f \ 0 % e E E cc NJ , E / t \ k — — U £ ƒ — - - - 0 t CI R / 2 2 E 2 e t / E a rn / ui CU � U / / / § § § ( \ t « / 0 / 3 C > A 0 « c $ » § E ® c c u = c c c C o _ m ° g \ c c ® . . c c ® .e . . . 0 • f c a) 2 0 ru co -0 2 ' t c u o > C 0 0 0 c c 0 0 0 = c c o ® t a) m v a) _ C0 2 u c 2 u U U Lu Cl- 0 0 0 Lu w Lu 3 0- « U Q « CG = Lu « « u 2 0- L < U U < < U < < U in v) Z / - u « % ) o \ 0 k co E CO § 0 0 C VI 0 = f = E u E « 0 E E co 2 \ 2 = 2 \ 0 %—i 0 m ru .c k CO cs / U 7 \ - d 0 0 \ C - ,cr\2 E a7. k EC0O 0 E § 0 \ C U 0 \ - 2 — C 2- § 2 / § \ 2 0 _ U ® u •_ m u _ z ® G ' - aj U \ 3 0 ' u 2 / \ 2 ƒ j Z Z CO \ C O - $ 3 e e ._ , 2 0 0 0 0 > Co ƒ 0 .0-- 0 m 0 0 N N tto d C Co 2C i a.., 0 O 0 •y Z aco ) U i on po _ -0 0 C F- a0 aJ in 00 a .> UC D U Li_ C U > a -0 CU m LL a) C a) 3 a) 1— .� V1 a) C U Co C cC .� O = \ a) a-+ +, a) a) C IA a 0 vi vi O +, > co .., U _c C C a a O Co +' °Co ut aao }, v) a) C U U a) a a) CO Co E co on co w — '� C E •N E a) U c = C •E a) a U 0 V) H f6 ago G c c OA U(13 al '= ix) 0 '5 U ce = • a co O co Co —i Cr CO 7) N CO C` • La 00 a0 CIO a0 a0 C 2 C J J , • a) i _ C C •C C C m a) Co a) Q a)U C a) Q v, 7 a) a) a) a) a) ca a) v • a) C a C O 0 u +, Co u ni a o oo 'c aCo 'c 'c 'o 'o a u o Q n. Q a Q a Q U w w w w w a Q n. Q Q a W Q U • C Co a E 0 U 2 o a o CC N Co vY J V1 C U () co a) U +� C 7 L — C (.3 Q U i C V a) a) Cl) aC-o 0 C v, a UC Co CO 0 " V) 0 U z. •� C co U a) NI 013 vi C O C } LLI V O_ N Q c CO C i C C , G a) L UD C .0 _ �, 'ut Q C J O Q Q L Q N 0?� in 41 in in- J U U } C Q ca c Z o L N a0 CO In N a 0 a, 2 D a) = , W a) C O 4., 3 °CO 0 0- a O c Z y a v? C C -a Jo 0 0 N to Co ' a) 0 . 2 C C > n 0 a) i i N Co co CO Co CO a CL 0. CL CC C: CC CC CC CC 6 0 m 0 (-4 a) to fC d 2 C L 8 C 4-' 0 U O 'O C � } a) Z > U i v U A > U 0 Q = l7 a) '^ '- O 0 N U +-, O C `� _ O U _O C _ a i C LL f6 U N D > > LL co U > U i N \ L 1- -aU \ L U -0 LL N 3 E a, - — c , v 3 a) H . c a) GA c ........ N +J Co + \ • = GA \ . C Co N \ a) '5 to > CO c • COU_ L C > > Co U C 0 J < >' co a) co U C •.Y U "- U 2 —. Cl) a) (� — c Y () a) °c'a �..� \ U Q H C > •Co 4- L co c Q cc , > 'f c E .� a)co GCA -a 5 GA U a VI H f6 — > Gin c `L° GA U a H f° CUMCO ° O u C GA co c •+C-, I , I , , — +f°,, r 1 o m CO °n = •--, , , . , a m J = a) o o J O f° GA GA GO GA GO GA C v N C , .O r6 GA dA GO °A CO C , O OC N U o ' ° •Y c C C c c C a) C \ as v, o ;° c C C C C fS° ,,, a) �, \ +-, C +••� U U 'C 'L 'L L 'L 'L E O G L t U — 'L •L •L •L •L L L CO CToon f6 N L L (A a) a) a) a) a) a) c •}, c �, ? 0 L a) N GU) N N ? Co (}'n Q .0 u _ a) Cl) Cl) Cl) a) Cl) U U W N W W Co }' w C C C C C C OL Cl) C a) a) f° N }, C C C C C a) L C _ Y C C _ 'L U C C N •GA GA •GA .� •GA on •> Q' C 'O > .L C cn b4 .a M .E GA 'O i 0 CO (° L co C (G a) L O O O C C C C C C C L O a) O O C C C C C L 7 c Cl) Co �°C a) < - Cl) N c nC v E O co o a z U N L C CU CO O U � CI _0 J CD IS o 11) 0 inc., 1 in 8 >.. Q LL W N N C pp a.' R U f° �n G C C C _o J fC Z +_.+ +_a Q "a C VI O O +., u U :° N C C C J Ln LLI U vZ U w LL 0 (A LL W CO U LL ra D m 0 a) Cl) W 0 m O N N N 00 to _0 d O C CL O V C 0 \ C .--.. a.) • 0 -0 O — U > — -0 -- l7 I— in 00 fl — > — 0. 2 O — vi 4-+ LL a o it U a U ° 3 o o F- vf a) CoO a) `" a) Oon o0 CI) N N ,� ° a) .O — OOA a) +� a) d +J ga — o Q co O U C > on t C -O •L Co O- > > — Co t C Cr 00 Co co \ co >- co _ C •Y = a) a) co — U a) 000 C co U VU co 0 c U a) C_ C V .� Co '6 co > fC6 a) C W c a�� U _� O •.� "a c 00 C > C C C C U CL F- co — c U d 00 O v i - •— i CL Co C +co+ 00 U CO 0 CO O J o0 on tip 04 C J to tip C 2 E o0 00 J co 00 00 0A C co C . , Q , C C C C Co y ��,, C C c� _O Q. C C Co E C cc Co N O C C 4, ,-, t 'W .L •L •i •L 2 L- U U 'C 'L c 7 — O 'L 'L *' U . i i i 2 \ E o O U 0A U d U a) a) a) a) �,, 0 7 O a) a) � co .� a) a) a) N O N a) a) a) �,, 00 — . a) C a a) O a) a) a) U >- . i a) a) U -O U > O a) {L, w a) a) a) U C O U U �= C +E fo +E C C C C O a H i C C Cl) i C O C C C C C a) 00 s_ a) C)- U i c'Cl) i 0 to C 0 7 O O 000 •00 O .E O 0A 000 U O O 'dA 00 000 0 CO C in vi Q a Q Q Q w w w w CL v) U U w w a Q w Cr C w Q U U w w w a w W Q U U U U U U U U V U in I— N J Z ,0,, ,�+ Z a) C U < a co ) — av'i v a C a) CO° E co D 0 :a :a Q To C a) c a `^ E a v Coin = " c U Co _c Z > > C a, C 0 o Ps c.7 a �n (7 co cn 0 U 0 11 N 0 -1 U o C 11 J L a) C! N —C Y U Cj C U C v) = C co C C ,CI) O CL V1 .o co 17) U -4 Vf C Q •N rto a) Co U c'�..) U CO o a) U i O N E O- 0 C C CI) i Q o O 0 L L U 2 a) V1 O 00 0 C O N WW Q Q U a) co C a) co N G O O C > tiA • a) U c = Q �, C a) o Lin Z N U CD +� N V) Co V) L V C C 0 3 Q o CCo 00 O W C C C C o cc w C 2 o co a3 C 0 C a)cl) C 'C Z J J w U a) J 0 C i ea D C7 2 U Co 0 >- to cCco CO OU v Ca o` - fY N N to to N O m 0 m N w On on oA re a_C C •_ Y. } OL _C MS C N O of o C a") p j U O N C Z a) L c a) Q a) 0 0 C7 — C7 , O = 0 — f- > 7 pp _ y O > OA — on m Q a) Co C cp U C LL () ++ > C U U of i d V a) C> f2 i C Y 3 Co n `L° `i' a) C ai U :� ,v aa) - OOn ate) 4-, U v Qu .0 0 ° >. m ° on a>) CO a>i Coil° > c U Co v an Q v u J 4:1 O ' t U •Co C fY V) O CC C (� .� U E C Cn cc 7 E v o J °1 m ,�o an ,.71 v -, C •+, r , a v co m .on = i C a, O C c o v) Co a) a) CCo C ° •Q as Cn Co Co C Co a) Co C L d U 'L Q t L .0 U U •L O U U •L •L L 0 2 +., GI U L a) U a) O o0 U C U = U cA L dA a) 7 7 ++ a) a) a) }, +� V L 3 a) a) 'L a) V > C a) Q a) L + O C a) U L L W Cl) a) a) U U +O+ 0 a) C O C a) co a1 C Vf ' N Q Q 'L ++ C a) vyf ruf +, .0 C C a) a) t C ti C 4-', w C O. •O z i co i O Co O +' 7 .0 Q O O O C 17.0 C CC Ea Q OL L +' 0 Cn W 2 J W = Q V) I- Q f1 Q 0 0 = Q W U U U W W W d Q - U W W a 4 4 4 x 4 4 4 a 4 4 4 U U U I- U U U U U U U N VI co J L I - Q Q a v U u ra _ v a 0L C C C a) U L n c CU 0 fa �O Co a) 'a L LL V.) Q E m c -, C Co O a) > a) Z v) onUn L •> raLa O co 0 U JO a ._ ro Q to a U 0 al 0 N U C a) = L) O +•' c O +J N 0 U op n C C C S" ++ = C U oA U Cl) C = a of N Q c a) Vo2S N a) 0_ v J I c C N C C a) v ro 'i C L L _> O o •C a) LL W a) a1 L ++ of L a) Y 2 a) a) COn en Q 0 C C 4 E C > L U o2S Cdn U Z 'n > 4... O L U w a) ro v) V {a I- LA _ LE Q L C a+ OD W C C N In To i CCO La) +' V c Z 0 c L L Q C C t Co W 0 N + }'' co E O O O a cc 7. m in v) v) v) v) N V) Lr) VI v) v) 0 m 0 a N a) m OA 00 d V) N V) ++ oOA (0 00 O cR 0 U O 0 iO A "O U 0A -0 U O rp ., - - 0 Oa0.C a — U "a O Um 7 — Q CO v+ c U CO eA U m •no >_ c > ••— D a, c a m ao 3 C al 3 E a\i I- - , E v a u. Y C v) a) a) __ U C a1 .0 v a) �_ U a) a) - OA \ a.+ 4 a) - N +-' co v1 , '> 00 '7 o C c v, -0 Q C v, '> 0o 'a co '> a0 > CD U CO C OA > L C Q 00 a1 03 m O- O a) L C m O OD a1 M CO Q- a) CO CU -_ C 2 a) (o U - U N \ _I C OC C vl •'vi E Y ro N ••- C cc C , v) cc C , '� E CO '> C E o,o ✓ Y to c avo c 'S C C ago u 6 H > O0A 2 O0A u co aao ro 'E - = C OD E co co N co E '3 - OA a0 - COC - d ro ,, O m C -' VI E C �, E J E m La CO V1 'N la CO co OA OA ti4 U C O ro ti4 OA C C N 0 COE a) o ccM C n , O , co E v ro 411 E C C C C cC� E C C 0 \ �., U U U G a"' U a"' U U U •U 'L L 'L 0 G U . L L to O O O of L , E a O a H U L 7 O N a) a1 a +., .,, 3 N a1 a1 4_, C C y.., L L UJ .0 0 U > ++ , L. W L .O +L., aL.+ W a) a) a) U U .1L+ w a1 a1 U O U, can a) v) a) v' of C V) C C C a1 a1 of C C O L C U C C v a) w• 'p a) -a U w U C C V, m a) C C in OA OA on O- 'p C v) 'pA 'pA '� '> C L 00 O LJJ L > a1 L w s- O O O L }' O O O C C C L O O C C L CM Q U U U .- -; a. '- Q J Q U U U L7 = U U U w w w a U U w w a w a W I- < <Q H U U Ca) U U U U H I- V) J Z O In OA Q N C C ra ro a) s- E c 5 C 0 -a n 'v CLa V 0.) •� N v) Zco_C " o aL) E as C E v, co C > CD Q a 0 U 0 0 N 0 -1 N U J C CO .0 U M co C N O ini a) cc J U OZ o 0 J U 0 — V C NJ - 01 a1 Y C i C vz L Cro Y 4 �•, L } J 0_ Z a) U a) C CD to c ro a1 }' OA E > H v) L O L_ 0 N NJ L C L a1 Ur 'II Z CO Z Q O Q ro m u p cc '47, H Q U a1 a1 -° m v) v) v) I— I— H I— 0 0 m 0 LP) N a) LIO d Q 0 0 0 2 O 0 a+ 0 +' _ 0 co Z U c , > > U L >_ U 'I-' O = -0 0 O 0 - U "0 O U —0 O _. > O +r Q a) Y > a+ 00 Q _ > > ++ 00 Q .> Q U L.L (j > a C D C V C W > U C O U > V - U CO "O a) ' a " U ' a \ U U. 3 a u ' U F c E 3 E a H , �, 3 E a, 1' u V1 a - OA C +., co a ,a a) = OA +. ' a = OA to a C a-+ H •> > co CCo c 0 C +R, U —J cc > to > co U c '> on > ro c U C 0 C < cU — E U ccc CO 4 ascc cU = Y U �, a 0 , > s. lL0 c _ i cR R > La E Q R > fL6 CO C E 'p Z. C U D a R U N H 'E G 4-, 2 by U 0 H on m .. 2 ' U D a H R U OD (C9 , , , a +J a R a.' , a-+ 0 C C i.+ , , , R oA — a.., , , , , a a co J la R OQ oA oA OA C cc C C on C N O -O O CO OA CIA OA C O Q O co cc oA OA oA OA Cc C , R E c c c c a , cCR = c_ a, +, :° .Y E c_ c_ c_ fc6 , :° +, E c_ c_ c_ c_ c_ , cR U E G Q 'c E U U U 'c 'L 'c G L U u .- 'c 'c 'i 'C 'C , G L 7 +'' a a) a) a) C c ., U a C c = 7 o N a) a) a a.., a o 7 a) a a a a < a, O i III a a Cl.) a O Q 0 0 a O - a, w a) a) a) U .` +L.+ w a a a) a) a U >_ +' C C C C L '1 a, i= c L C N N Vf a.,, C C C a R of Vf a.., C C C C C Y a a) O O C G GO oA C R .O L to •C -R c c O O on on ocO O a O O O OA oA OA oA OA p U U w w w w w a a i- w w a U U U U w w w a Q U U U w w w w w a a v) W I— < < <Q I— U U U < U N I— V) J I— Z i CO Q aI', CO a J a 2 c p aZA Z It E Ln c a) O COL vs O U a U a C2 O ei O N 17) a-, CO U O o N -1 sn o Q W vs O N L 7 a O C U J as o L = U o O W C' C C 3 (U Q oA MO G U C C v, Q Y J 3 Z V` OCA O N c N a) Y C — 0I- OD vs UJ W a-+ co 'O C C Z Q a N Q LU U H a) a a) 0 Wns CO I— I— I— I— I— v i.D 0 m 0 N N OD ILO cc, _0 C E N 4••+ 2OA C L L CO +••+ a U C 0 U 0 L_ O OA 0 U �O+ OO D 'O + ��+ �� c) C U U 0 c of +�+ p 0 0 aJ Z - — -0 > a) m OCA 0 N a) Cl) C7 - Q vi l7 N C7 3 > 00 2 — O O v) >- �, • H • OA Q CO U \ OA CO *' C Cl) r0 U OVA CO C LL UCO V m U v CO E ••0 H -O .0 0- ..., 1-- Li 3 3 a i Y _ OA E , N — c a) V) Cl) a) +, OA U C C N }, C 4-, a- a) a) .,-' a) C C u d a J u +r U II) •> •> C CO 'L co +., C CO 'C C C v '> OA C 0. O U .0 >, a) OA CO Y CO v _CO a) a) — U .o Cl) a) on a) 0 " c c v)i m •> _ cti o •• OA O .� to CU w c"n f6 '> 'c OO)A OOD ° CU c u `�° C7 > '5 l7 '> c '- •- co , , , , a V CO CO = = c CO a) to 21 ' m U +-, 0 ' C� '� OA COc OA OA OD ti4 OA OA -- E c c m O c J '( cc OD O , OA -- c N ti4 m '� rO rO rO c C C c c c C O CO f° ' ( — cr6 ' N C O p v, c c c O \ ,c c ' a) U U 's:. 'L 'L 'i 'i •i p U U U U G V 'L U t L. 'L 0 0 E OO L 0 4-' 0 3 O a) a) a) a) a) a) 7 O U a) d O a) •a., +: C C a) i., aJ L s- i A v v a) a) a, a, U o U U �; U 4. t Q a) 0 — >- a) U U O • a) U �, o ,'if -. LA ,C_ C_ C C C C_ a) •LLi a) a) vv a) O_ •C u i CO N C a) a) L C C a) i C C a) OA OA OA Ern OO 'a 0- • o 'p U C c '0 U CO i OA i i 'OA Q- Q- '> c 'OA Q- U a) O O C C C C C C C c UJ L L L. O O L L — CO C w a) 7 C c C vs vs C CO C C — C U U w w w w w w w — -I a Cl- Q U U a Q C7 Cl- W Q ut w - - w a w - Q W Q In- VI U U U U V U U U V U F- Vf O coN C N H Z in a OD I— 0 0 O > i O aJ CO OA I_ O 0_p c a) c h N co p Y O co vE Z CO COa a '> O CO > O as 0 V O ill VI > 2 v) 2 a U O '-I O N U J U J U C aj C — > rO COC N O 0 0 - N CO •pA CO = - C U N 0 w C c U U L U ,O C a) U an > �,, C U 7 as on — u a) 06 O +' C vi i C O N Y 0 C 8 a o vs CO O O E H C - U >- of C 0 0 aJ a) ON @ > •� i OZS N o W U' O7j N O C O 04 to N w a, Q cv Vi O LO oCD to _, Z O Q- c 'En O CO Q C Vf > p C C '+, — J a) of Q '� Vf CO U (13 w O a) vv)i Q N W d VI X O C ? -a r0 0 Z Q c V) +, c rO O 0 rz rD U N ••3 c i 12 m H I— I-0 H H H H 0 0 0 O m n N W v, O c _c L Do C 0 U 0 C 0 O is +' p OA C . p in z > U i O c > 7 U° L 0 v, — U -0 O O O — U — N — m N O 0 = '_ C7 of vi CI UY O — U U + > DO - v CO Y V c C L.L U ++ > a) C C.) N > > C DO a 7 to U L \ N U O aj Ln 9 c 'O CO L LL 171 �, a) F- u — , v 3 E u — ' to a) E - L GE0 , �— v a) a) — a in '> a) '> to c u _c o c ;a > D o C > a° '5 a° c C C U �- to c Y a) to a) c — U 2 a) >' w to m c o a) u Q. °C m � > Es L to c s E -O co > c _ E Q- -a 'N E as coo 2 o° v a a H co '> aa)b.o c 2 iU to '> a tLa C 2 °c° '- ' a H tiA — c •}c-, , , a U ca J — c i a U m s° 2 — c ;� m E c ocn O ca c OA oc° OOD DO -- C , c 0 to tiA -- C 0 , O E to o° s° ;.� E c rcca m c3 c c C U 0 L 'L 'L L 'L 0 C L O V ,V 'L 'L O C L L U U47' •E O V C L L L a 0 0 a) a) aJ a) a) '4, +, O U 7 7 a) a) '+, +, a O 7 7 ut •+, • 4_, v a) >j TO. ,V, , w C C C C C a) v a of v, ,C C a) a) ca a) v, ut . a) L .a) C C c a1 O O O 'OA 'OA 'tl° Q 0 7 L O O tTo 'OA .O 3 O O O w o .a '0° t cc ta Q U V U W w w W W a to H U U w w = a Q to U U U C —i a w w l7 W � V V V U Q V N I— V) J 0 H C Z i pp D v, Q a) . t`o a) to a) L c a) a) O_ L ao p .— N a) Q inL E ccE a Z lc co —as cco O O U a oc a to -J 0 ei 0 N 0 0 fV U C J C C a) U E c Q) U — Do c v, o is a) +' 0 to c --I„I 0 V N O U C O o Cw 0 C 0 U G d4 pop a6 oc° i C Q _ }+ L C IA N N O > 0 a = NJ0 LL C Z C U to L a) 0as U ,a > -/a > > >co 6 0 m w 0 co N v to OO ra N +••, O C ..COL C COL of C v C O Z c 7 .> U O v) > U i Q — a0 U O C07 — U 0a" OA -0 0 a, a) c — L F m U aJ L U a — coL U — p E _ N , a) V1 N a) a) On p a) +J c +-, +•� \ .O aJ OA On N +J u C Vf '> '> OO on '� > N yr U _c (o p C C > On > (o C U L C v) co 5 aJ v c C m U _ C ( U }, a) ,CI) L c U _ •c Y U a) c CO V co co , , > .CC CCco L (o C = N Q (D , > ccoo R as C 1- -p — 0 L._ c U c}n H f6 '> go' o°1A `L° U a F— f6 oap c c c :r +� a U L.CC(1) CO CO aA — c •}, a (0 w '3 •OD p Ertl p p (o (o OA DJ) bp On on -- C C O .Q p (o 00 On On OA On C CO, .U' �+ U -' ry E E C c c c c c �° fO o CO .c E ,c c c c C (o ,n en a) io+� +, +� '+� c cc c _ U U U U L 'L 'L 'L 'L p C G U U L 'L L 'L 'L C L V U 7 7 3 7 tg 171 v v a, v v 7 7 *' a) a, aJ v Cl) O u , L L L L . w w aJ aJ aJ a) a) U a U U a +•, +,, w a) aJ a) CI) CD U >s �, +� 0 IA 0 0 0 0 Y .0 C C_ C_ C a) U' a) aJ to of +, .0 C C C C aJ a) •- o Q 'L p C C C C v8 U OO On OO On OO O- L p 'p 'i C C Vf OO 'on .OA .00 .00 'p vt a0+ O O O O O O C C C C C (o L L aJ O O O C C C C C L 3 i O U U U U U U w w w w w c a a a Q U U U w w w w w a (n Q C7 S Q W Q U U U U I- Vf H V) J I- Z i U C (o a) cc a) _ t a) a) Z E 0 C C Q - CO LL L L 0 '-I 0 N 0 0 N J C ro vl 0 O U J U C Li 0 OA — C 0 C — 0 •_ V) N v L.- C N O W C CU on U u. p c 2 •- Q 0.0 C 0 Z p w Q U V1 Q. OJ p Q ro ... W O N o c inU 0.) a) a)rz i m 0 m 0 Cr) N U OD ao ra d YO d 0 u i+ a) Z C 'j U Q Co 0 O 0 Q V m U vC U Co c� aw) No >_ U LL >j 3 C — .E U (o — 73. ~ , p N Cl) .0 •a1 O 00 U U p 00 3 Q) d Y +J V to) Q > > 00 _co •L U n3 C +J U t 00 to C U 0 J co O O mi C - U O U Y z ` U C U O on U O >� > Co > R U U U (o �L' a, C -O - 'O a) '6 J -0C ' ' i ' i i i i d m V fo J CO i 3 p 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 C 00 m cu C C C C C cc C C C p cC C 4' U U U L l- 'L C 'C L L L C O O G L 'L 46 C) U 3 3 3 a) a) a) a) a) a) a) a) a) y '}' a-+ O ,_ a) a) U 0) L L L U U U a) a) a) U U a) U U U >" U U L - V) V) 0 C C C C C C C C C U a) U > c ,C Q, U C C C 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 p' Q' 0 L 00 U Co L O O O C C C C C C C C C N N L 3 C C i- L Q U U U w w W w w w w W w a cn ii w Q C7 W Q U U U U I- VI H N J 0 f- C Z =p Q L CCI MI Co -J 4- E a M U U 'a) m U co VIE Co c 00 0 cn - Q V) 0 0 N 0 0 N U N C r° '- 0 3 U Cu, a) O 4-' u v) C U UL C V Q 0 > .--1 0 a) U_ U 0 O N C V E (o O CU U („) U to 'n Q C C .I'.' E LI 2 p0 Co O n) C C a) a) Y N W iZ 0 _ W C C C c ro u0 '6 -O -O = ra17 0 m 0 0 m a ao do oA . _o C v, Y oA ° a C a,c ,�0 V o c0 a Z ,, L)) Q 4 N c aa) 0 0 O m C.) -0 > 0 c C La o c - — C7 H ' ' 0 = Q — S? 3 oA • > — Q _ 5_ tin C C LL Crxi 7 C m, C 7 U V U V�f V a) s ca L m L) 7 a m 1— Li' E a " as H 3 a oA , 3 F Y c _ N a) a) oA U C oA j C +, +, a) u .0 +, ,� j aUi U + goA a0 CD •L CD C +, 0 0 C C -o in '> (D c c > +, t a) f6 ro ro C +, r U 4= }, a) a) C OD a 0- 0 a s U U a., 2 c c - '- U a '� o c ra E E co c cc N 'N E - o V co cm > L v co +, L v a) a) +� -o >, '_n a) U c+n C ,n '> 2 G U L c - } • c c w a cn H � u c c a = — o f c — 1 i s , V O 0 oA oA OD 0.0 OD OD oA C = CC C C E m L 't•, E c op OD OD CID -- C_ C C C C C C CU crb cca Q , Y a) 0 cc� m C C C C C U U 'L 'L 'L 'L L L 'L E (o c C C 0 — U Q U G U 'L 'L 'L 'L 0 7 3 a a a a a a a) C •L +., a•, a = L • +, O a a a a L L v a a a a a a o }, a U 0 > +., +L.+ .0 D U Y a a) a) a .0 N •C C C C C_ C •_ C_ L_ ‘n In a s a V) L w .a of •C C C C a C C •pA 'Go •to 'WI .00 •a0 oA > -0 i '0 '0 -0 u C +a, u• p CO on oCA oA oA Q O 0 C C C C C C C C CD L L a U U w w w w w w w w _ a n. 11 oC < U _ CI- U w w w w E LU U U U U Q H H N J a) I- oA Z C f6 J E Q a) a V') t CO N .c E U +, it co ra Z co C v� O c a cc U V V Q O '-I O N 0 0 N N 45 4-1 a C C O C C LU Li O ---- OD a C U .n • 5 J O N O 0 on 5 O LU U .L = ?` `n a 0 u' Q a) U Z Y 2 •oC-0 ti4 C _ Y WY LUY va va Z 'Cr) 0U OD L v° N C 0 -- V1 C 7 m Y N C7 CITY OF PALM DESERT / PALM DESERT REDEVELOPMENT AGEN Y / PALM DESERT HOUSING AUTHORITY STAFF REPORT REQUEST: APPROVE THE 2010 CONSULTANTS' MASTER LIST OF QUALIFIED PROFESSIONAL SERVICES CONSULTANTS FOR SERVICES VALUED AT LESS THAN $25,000 SUBMITTED BY: Martin Alvarez, Redevelopment Manager DATE: December 10, 2009 CONTENTS: 2010 Consultants' List Recommendation By Minute Motion: 1. Approve the 2010 Master Consultants' List appended to this report; 2. Authorize staff to negotiate agreements and contract amendments with the qualified consultants for up to $25,000, and authorize the City Manager/Executive Director to execute same; and 3. Approve the proceedings for selection and award of contracts as set forth in this report authorized by Section 3.32.090 of the Palm Desert Municipal Code. Executive Summary Approval of the staff recommendation will approve the 2010 Consultants' List and streamline the process for retaining consultants to perform under contracts valued at less than $25,000. The processes for consultant selection and contract approval for contracts valued at more than $25,000 will remain unchanged. Background Retention of architects, engineers, appraisers, construction managers, and other consultants who perform professional services is not done through bidding. In accordance with State public contract code and City ordinance, consultants are selected on the basis of experience, qualifications, and costs. This results in a cumbersome two- step process wherein a shortlist of consultants is developed by consideration of qualifications, and then a cost proposal is requested from the best-qualified firm. If an